`
`PMC Exhibit 2024
`
`Apple v. PMC
`|PR2016-01520
`
`Page 1
`
`PMC Exhibit 2024
`Apple v. PMC
`IPR2016-01520
`Page 1
`
`

`

`
`
`mm EH1
`Founelcl ln 'lfi‘i'll'el. 21’. No.5-
`
`lar
`Ience
`
`MWMWmo-uozine
`
`
`
`HIGHLIGHTS New personal computers—now the big guns have arrived
`IBMJ Xerox, and olhars me at last detonate the smell-om peer op:
`lesion. PAGE 53
`
`0F
`
`. top-eeorst reoe to develop beam weapons
`.
`1mg ISSUE Hlaaile killers .
`hair or pertiole-hsam guns in orbit oould blast-targets tme miles away. PAGE 'l'E
`
`New age for alrshlps? Workhorse center-blimp:
`Heli—Stel. to be used for hug: lifting may bring dir_|fi'ibis: oul of limbo. PAGE 12
`
`Faster than bullets or rockets: electromagnetic launchers
`No longer a dream. space-ego alinqa can fire ohiaotsst five times. rl'fls sponge. EAQEjE
`
`All-out energy audits—how the pros soot hast leaks
`l'.'l."I‘
`II--:-.
`Ilr': 1
`
`
`
`CD'H'EFI PHOTO B‘I" JOHN KEA‘HNE
`
`53
`
`.
`
`PE arm
`HUME-mm saunas
`Net-r osreonsl comm-Ito‘s—
`nowtlte '
`one have arrived. ..
`For the 'M's: a decade
`BE
`ofuonder In home electronlu. .
`“11:
`Build a home
`More chem nsls. oiun'l'rneil'nfihicsim '-W
`The cornan record revolution: dl lDd
`
`New aoftwera makes your
`men I
`u
`rich
`.
`1
`High-resolution T'lnl'mwida-sctesn.
`metal-deer ole-lure: .
`.
`. . .
`.
`.
`.
`.
`
`. me
`
`HEEULIH FEATLI‘IEE
`.z
`FEWIIILDIBE...+________.
`Albernata—anargu ens-were .
`. _ .
`.
`. 1
`Datreltr
`1B
`
`
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`Recreation nil-Undue .
`fifi
`PS-What'anstn'a
`T1
`Wordless workehoE .
`.
`.
`.
`.
`.
`.
`.
`. .. 121
`5hoptalk.... _
`_ _ _
`_
`_ _
`.
`_
`.
`.
`. .423
`
`
`ENEH-G‘I' PEWE
`
`.
`.
`EnergyI real for eunloss dime-s .
`Insulating tore for meme walks.
`Allaout enetmr audits
`an
`.
`—how the pros spot heel leeks. .
`Windlantt'e firetanrout. .
`.
`.
`.
`. .. 111
`Insulating I.IIrell walleye—energy
`.ll'r'il'l swith s emulorleolr. . . 118
`
`
`H-DIIIE AND ‘fflD
`Lecimm home; solarium kitchen .
`'1'.” “FEM!
`.-
`Announcing the sixth snnue
`Ffi-‘APA Flmoo Pro'eol. Contest
`
`. 112
`"‘23
`
`. 132
`
`
`
`12
`1-!
`
`mills All! WEI-“WES
`
`Tahimwaligmnam..........1H
`flange-ale imp I.|J.'Z'!.i.'|.'|fl. _-
`.-
`-
`1;:
`Router egg figrg; an: m
`121
`
`Willow smear
`B4
`I’lu edb-us................
`NASA. remotely Elle-ted vehicle. .
`. H
`
`..efeh .Pee-sin BB . . . . . . . . . _ . .
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`What's new in photogrepl‘n'. .
`.
`.
`.
`8?
`flit-timed Him... - . ._. .---..._ .Ifll
`What's new in home improvement
`Bill
`I” .
`.
`an
`il'ihet'e newI [or your oer. _ .
`91
`
`.
`
`. _ .
`
`.
`
`WWW“
`fill-m
`diesel
`forG amld-eieaosra........_
`J
`Marc-MW steering-«Mme! air bag.
`1E!
`F5 oar test.- three little wagons
`for small femlllee .
`.
`.
`.
`.
`.
`.
`.
`.
`.
`.
`. .
`32
`
`Mflifl'flfif_flm9fi -
`-
`-
`.
`.
`.
`45
`Beemeral't‘s LNG car .
`.
`.
`.
`.
`.
`.
`Turbo cutie uase oomputar—
`
`
`
`
`
`GmflflliedJiH_ieifi3L¢_._Lr--- - - - L439
`Suoeses at last for 10-year-old
`etretifiad—oharge engine? .
`.
`.
`.
`Transmission shll’u like an
`automatic. but “use fuel .
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`32
`
`92
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`NEW me ANDmm
`TIr
`Double I:|u_t'[ from I duel cassette .
`:9
`Light-tensan themestst .
`.
`. .
`.
`._ .
`WM
`www.mnme 4%
`
`NEW TEGI-IHDLDG‘I"
`
`Nuolser magnetic resorts-toe .
`New aga for airahi s?
`.
`.
`.
`.
`1I'llurrurhl'unurea em- Iimg .
`The rniaalle killers .
`. . too-secret
`race to dwelog beam mgone .
`Faster than bullets or I'DBIEIE:
`ulecoomagnetie launchers .
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`Ii
`
`3'2
`
`T5
`
`1'13
`
`ens-maul. orrlces see mourn Mlnui. New York, hm. snot 3
`Publlehed filtr'l'lhlr h- TIMES HIHHDH Momma. I'LL 3W “HE-fin MPH-Ii.- NW 'I'Dri. N-T- 1W1?
`lone should he
`EIH'IHII. Inlbllflllfifl I'IIJI'I'I-
`[troy
`Ill
`roan
`h
`sue end at“!!! 'I'o
`H. 'l'.. and mllioni rI'IIiH
`SUMIP'I'I'OH SEMI'IGE.
`em.- filer-d be
`lent lo Boulder. Colo...
`ld'JI'III Elwyn-w our: m
`her sum. "Emma. in: nurse or was:er mu at 111- en.
`Mlere‘hll'm.
`Dent. Binnie
`Ponder Sue-es Suhaorlpllon Department, Bouhler Colo. m2. In U._5.
`_
`lemlilrn soles-1s are Hi1le Irom lJ-nlwrl
`Marleen
`.Pmn arbor. Merl. some AMER‘I'IEIHG emcee. New York:
`_Cain-do em‘l elsewhere. one
`
`r
`l'..hnol.rllrllfl$.'fl1reo'rm
`end boom-1e one veer $133an 524.”. than sire-SHIP: l|1
`:12-fl3-131h DIEM“: 1.x” W- “J M l M. Whll
`Ti.
`MIrJ'I. Elm!
`Ma. 11901:]. Tfl. 312-683-3091: emu
`: we rs. warm-new. qua-511:. 'r-II.
`Nineteen: L“ J"!
`Don
`“Ml.- IITHI to W n. m If m. -
`-
`ill-5.31. _Subse_nptiorr or ore proensamr'eflronlfleiflr. Ffl'rpllefiI
`H IP-ei'le met own: see-u fill-nir- b.-
`holes
`1555. More! Indian-Joiner!!!
`l-ea:
`are lmEL Tel. '21!-
`. B
`r. Dale. m For dunno oi aileron Ill-oi- nlohl «Him
`Mr
`ill
`plfl I“ huh glam-rd m “queue. Perm.- Houo III'H‘l nettle-e.
`[aer
`Inn. "1 nuhh reamed.
`E El 1551 by 11mm. errior MeguIn-el.
`ol and
`and eequ Form 353“ III II". NIH-ll UWWHfl-flfcm m-
`FTII'H
`lrl LIE—A.
`
`Hot-mean: I551 | 1'
`PMC Exhibit 2024
`
`Apple v. PMC
`|PR2016-01520
`
`Page 2
`
`PMC Exhibit 2024
`Apple v. PMC
`IPR2016-01520
`Page 2
`
`

`

`P5 SPECMLm
`BETHM
`
`High-
`resolution TV
`— here come wide-screen
`crystal—clear pictures
`
`
`
`New video components
`speed TV systems that
`match 35-mm-film fidelity
`
`By JOHN FREE
`
`Wmlinmxfl. [1.0.
`For nevus] days. (mugs of lawn-
`nmlx- dficlrls. politician-5. and jnur‘
`must: cmmdml imo n clutched room
`It CBS’II afiim hm. We'd mm to
`View I run. onetime «Mention ol'vz'it
`ww.WIewguing¢nabuw
`wu.‘ (235': Jmeph Hubert}.
`flue-
`pm‘rdenl of engineering develop
`mu. tnld my group. “in. n crimhinn-
`film If Mgh-renlutinn TV. m
`warniwisdevmnWJndenhenced-
`exile:- W."
`[ruling the rum hour I watched a
`variety ol' emailing TV images film:
`had main-w firmly—mun than
`five time. an:de nf televisiml pic.
`hunt you m: an mum-emigre“ home
`reneiwru. The highwlolutinri pi:-
`turea. a den]!
`match fur sham
`[new Era-mm all
`. were shown on
`spa-uni "Gimme-rm" divert-view
`are main lush-mu Wain-rum TV.
`Other equipment “and hf CHEr such
`as mmlecmnic encoding circuit-
`and a Snow-built digital video retard—
`er. may have a key rule-In improved
`Mum duliwring chit. new type of
`TV tn you during the nasal
`Actually. mulled high-definition
`TV PHIJT‘VJ has been aniinhil: fur
`dnoedtirtui‘l use in medical school:
`am! basil-acne awliculium [or a Few
`men. But It has been limited to lit-r-
`mmmr'mnu using nnly um and
`TV mar-rim Mir. mural
`videotape machine: capable “murd-
`kng HDTV were unveiled. A: : reuult.
`mum-mod director: may awn pm
`“I | rerun» some:
`
`huh-rewlumn TV in wart In preda-
`HIE marina. err-d lam-firm nerwnrh
`will um it. In 01mm II".- qunlity u‘
`mnrhrd presuming.
`CBShuntillnnMJIen-mmnfmpnr
`muting HBW. It. and ulher broadcast-
`m require trunnmisalm charm-alt: to
`gel these super-fidelity pictures into
`your home. For muons dflailed be.
`luw‘ high-rheoluliun 1’? can‘t lie rur-
`riod finally an rugulru' TV dunno]:—
`aaul no one plan: In clin today's
`lunch“! TV Warninghlnudcndw
`swim N13?- rNat‘roml Tcleuinion
`Standards Cmilteei femur-11.
`But HDTV can lie thiamine-1] into
`hem by dived-Medan Mullins.
`CBS is telling nlfirinln that iI'I vital to
`reserve HDTV frequencies m a new
`rim or utellites slated for launch
`wiihin a few war-u.
`Mm pilots. better [:1an
`Hair do” HUN diff}! technicllly
`Emu Itillrllrd TV"? SW NTSC
`nets. functioning perfectly. can dire
`lain}? (83 HIM 525I huriml sun
`inns creel-ed all ukflmn balm: paint
`'n' piflurels by «weevil-lg back and
`I'm}: war picture-lube Morph-m.
`Each horili Han line can resolve.
`ne display, ‘38 Ila-punt: pictm elm.
`menu. tallied [fuels 1n NISC pith
`Lure can dinghy 2MB“ pin-ll.
`in practice. new beta equipped with
`Milled ml: llltm "'9. Aug. TN
`alum only about 330 horiaontal ele-
`mull: mt elder m average only
`Ill-nut 25f} picture element» per scan
`line. By central. nlthouqh em fim
`mind-arid! have been In. a Liza-line
`HDTV pirlure might mntain ml
`curler but eunu- Ilve Him-sun may pi:-
`els lone million! mated with an
`ideal 2mm mega. Each one or the
`highwunluu'nn sunning lie-antenna!
`mm image detail, and tub in 1mm
`
`beam urflw mdn-nemn- picture Far-
`mt. A: a result. highmunlutian TV
`mquim more frequency space. or
`handwrith typically. 30 NH: “mm:
`1.2 Jill-E: for slandnrtl NTSC 1“.
`"The N'l’fii‘ system It» given us
`very goo-i aervm din-i. n: the List 2.5 In
`30 mm." said Flahorty. "but we are
`main; it tn its maximum :- picture-
`[it LII-gar lmi tamer." A durum-Im-
`than made l'JIiI my apparent. Two
`«mum were rel: up in an adjmme
`mom umloulu'llg I; fired. One will a
`ntlle-uf-tlle-axt (2135 camera in dis-
`plmr ulnmiard 535MB: TV per‘mu.
`The («her was a IJZISullne model
`made for Japan's puhl ic hmdmting
`mrpumtierl lNI-“D.
`-
`The 525-1ine mine-m piyed its '
`mmalfikm [Injection 1“ Iron
`u! with a nix—firm diurnal mm {and
`to regular W studio mammal. 11:9
`NHK Hm earners sent its pridurwe
`to a Natasha-hull; wide-format
`qunn TV Ind widelrrmtt muni-
`m In: calm“ pérturui.
`Pictum Hi I hwl of {rail were
`impressive an the 5254i“: Elna: laid
`smaller mu nitrite. But mntruted with
`{he mull-clear imueum the HWV
`sorta. the limitations of M90 platter-ea
`Wm diam-lie. Training hath cum.
`cmu an the street helm’prud‘umd even
`sharpen-mum“. I could read [incline
`places and alher vehicle Lelterin m1
`HIM? main than. were u impaled
`II:
`on fill-line mime.
`Why do “1653‘s secs have a equemh
`per-cure ratio fem Imam-Ilia and three
`high? "II we: clans-m lot very simple
`ms." sail! Walnut}. "Firm. I1 I“!
`all we could die lucluwlosiullvl. and
`i1 1th: the my film: were made.“ he
`said.
`liemrihing the 1946': mm-
`dlmrne-T'lr‘ formal.
`an HDTV system unveiled by Surly
`(‘muum'
`
`
`
`._d_'......
`
`PMC3685199
`
`PMC Exhibit 2024
`
`Apple v. PMC
`|PR2016-01520
`
`Page 3
`
`PMC Exhibit 2024
`Apple v. PMC
`IPR2016-01520
`Page 3
`
`

`

`
`
`
`Sway 1.11511“ picture Mm“ [fill warm a gunman 525:1“ uinw.
`
`Wide-stun hlgn-rcmlntlun manna: :ll'h'f'LM'Jzii‘ tv .‘SHK. m-d
`‘.‘.J‘.5I, shin has JiI-Ircr- ragga-ml grow. 5 3 asap-rt 'J’I-ZI. F'ha:
`rmdr 01.:c.'.-.-e-'l|-I:Ina| 2mm.» mash.
`Inks" 0N": r-‘e much z'r-a
`mm“, and ‘JHK mm a .'-
`_--.
`|.< h!.‘y'“-.'I}'1u'fr.‘jg|fl:‘ syst‘nr
`Plum-(tinn W dupe-rad L's, Hun-Jim: a1 :3? 1mch exh-tfl. rn
`umcfln lh': Mfr-net IJLkswfl.;:|'1.vc!l.a'u:
`'
`lib: cnrmnmcr-z- 'ncdel:
`tnlsnlar: " -'l
`.. .- r-r-n .s 3'}
`Image-i. hnm TV :amnre
`
`
`
`PMC Exhibit 2024
`
`Apple v. PMC
`|PR2016-01520
`
`Page 4
`
`PMC Exhibit 2024
`Apple v. PMC
`IPR2016-01520
`Page 4
`
`

`

`hull. spring can show pictures in stan-
`dard lull format. the extra-wide Clos-
`W W. or an inmmdinta
`gloom width. The lllgmlomn
`mu! tho CBS:er lad. a
`5:3 piflun-upecl: min. In ofiditinn to
`letting you one molt or all nfthe pi:-
`tme from wide-om movies. outing
`clone to album militant-En HDTV
`imam common mom or the usual
`mm of am sumo.
`Digital «mutilation
`Winning up in lumbar CBS onion
`wunspoeinlutpeul'tideoupemocd-
`er amplified by Sonyjuut IL: I!!!“
`nurlior. Hill Connolly. managing di-
`rect-n- nldmulogmunt. For the CBS-TV
`Minot-i, palm unotlu-r noun-assure
`don-ammunition “B losers today are
`sonar-ll: armed t at digital
`teth-
`nlqooo an the proper way to man!
`this HDTV iltl'onnotioo and Mt
`it." In ilan IFS. Howl: '73}.
`Connolly Elfilliflld that will: ton»
`volitional TV. voltage in propofliunuJ
`to hit-inmost. The brig-hie: the mm
`or. any given point on tho mo. the
`lonlm the voltage. Since the woman
`is analogous to what‘s on the man.
`it‘s callatl out Molnar sly-nun.
`'1']!!- mini lag-m llnu smoothing
`quit; fifiuont." Cmoolhr mid. Th:
`voltage generated In: tho usth is
`constantly In
`or measured by
`digital atrium.
`[lid these samples
`in than flaith a battery number Elo—
`m and onion! uptown-ting its inton-
`fily. Thin Indoniqno for and: pin! out
`Eh: noon lino: "quires (amid-crib},
`mom bandwidth. or hollow upen-
`Irom. for storage and transmission
`While this inmbondVidth nonun-
`mm o a ordain, mm «flow: on
`undo! way to sluilil tht Mum?
`W needed for mom: TV.
`“Dneofthethin mandala
`reduce the nurnh'u' a hill lho‘nnry ill;-
`its] om Io duel-rib: a picture."
`Connolly said. He minnow on arms
`"law-arm mWa."n UPS or! lion-in:
`on monimm Running his finger
`momma linoonzho “the
`Itlpllind that it curried nhout
`IED
`blank pixel-.91” 200 blue. 1nd I59
`“kWh Mingle! l‘
`swun- o
`l roouoncflmv
`Iran: with analog TV because we
`mmnlt awry one 01‘ those things
`will! the whole bandwidth.” Connolly
`“kl. With digital Incl-minnow. though.
`I: single hrid' lipid an be ell-mam!
`that tells the digital circuit: in the
`mower lo moo 150 binds pixels.
`This coding of the digital slim].
`Inquiring pot-hays only a flaw doom
`hits inn-mo all lamina: oi wpetltiw:
`signals, ml.- tho ran: at which bill.
`most In trnnmitlml—nlm bandwidth
`Inquirnlnnaln. Similar fibrous-redun-
`
`ml mu sciatic:
`
`lion coding an atom“: the on NM
`and 115} block plush for on. ‘31!!!" who
`lino.
`John Rani of tilt (:35 “Mon
`ConwrlStlmfiord. Coon.) Mm:-
`od n CBS 4:1 hit-nto-lodmfion :1:-
`mm with on analog videotape Inn-
`clfiou. an own flab-Roe loo: pane-m
`drawn on Milan was email luv a
`digitally mead signal thll. rewind
`only as mohimmllinn kimono soo-
`olui install! of lho 144 monolithic;
`I'm no: orig-inn! digital sampling.
`"Th'u is 11 our; simple Immune»
`reduction huhmqu o." Rani “ill. ‘11-...-
`cirtuila can libean In.- helll in the
`film at your land. Thin luadl up to
`line that will: moron-mole: cm
`cum mud: blather Int-cote mluflloma
`can in “blend.”
`"Failaufl
`these lull-Hallo I'lan
`solid/mm. HTYW will not be boon-donn-
`ahlc." added F'lohuml. ll: hopes to fit
`disitnih- mud high-molmiou
`TV inlnn normal nrnnuly non-om! TV
`chunll. "limit work In. yet
`Ill be
`done." he aid. "hot you cu: one we've
`schism! a 1:; Manson in beta Fairly
`wail. tmomtttm: a monthly equal
`quality Melton.“
`Tho: out-pnflarn yiclurc [ “or lull
`marl: nnisc hm non-led flu Emmi]
`indicating ml: all do: image won get-
`ting through. For this demonstration.
`n moo-moi 4.2-Mflz, SIS-line WISE! sig-
`nal Income 3 Ill-mmnhibfiec. digital
`signal the: m compound into a.- 23-
`mnanUII-e. Iillflll- Burl that rh'gital
`fill-lino signal would :9ng sis-out
`Eon: Win-human on your 11' na. An
`HDTV signal, even hem it's digital-
`ly would. require: about (in.
`Pouring martin
`Why, i‘l'dig'iml ending oo’o 1‘? sign}
`up on mac]: morn inequality:
`n1.
`isn't high-mole TV
`morn fusible with analog signals?
`l‘figh-lflqwmr noise is m moon.
`Noise. which can spill] Moduli T'l'
`imam Momma HDTV.
`Connolly marrow! soother ul-
`rntogoofoigiml TV hylirunlwwin.
`I m-lim mlog-Iignll pooh"! 04' I
`fruit bowl from Lope. Then he Illnul'ld
`lit: some picture It'll." it hm! bun Tb
`more 10 limo» xmfi-manfion
`unpar. The mouse In: mud. loll. of
`now. and color value; “In: alumni.
`For limo-damn. about fluo- gonna-
`u‘om- Hi the limit. he said.
`But memo that follow!!! from mills-
`and «no motiods-gonontion digi-
`lully oodncl lapel mad umlternd
`from 111: originals. Cmnlly tom-
`parod analog upan In puuxins
`water [mm one ulna In: others: Some
`rotor sticks to each film; romping.
`similarly. ml» parla- ol' the aria-inn!
`signal with onoh aluminium
`
`1}]le limit. by contrast. on
`«that the mm or llama of
`palm on tape.
`'l'lwy sun-in mus-
`mlu'mn. and taping much bell“. and
`ConnolleI oomde tho digital tech-
`niqoo-topwring with: from all. In
`film. The will: I'digilnl him! not
`Ill-1'0
`wholly-d.
`CB minmwmtmprmdwith
`Sony‘s new digital rut-colder "In just
`man your:
`thoro'u hon o 50:!
`imWnt in tho ability tojnm hit:
`intonamal‘l mu. of
`.' lid Flllfll'b
`1y. '1": won: from under one million
`fblltll mm inch to 40 million.
`We
`need o 3:!
`moment our
`that In room-ll Idigiutl HUN.”
`EBB also promoted an N'I‘SC winke-
`Iap-u undo with stereo sound at. a lion-
`:Ldy Centa- conoert HDTV moonli-
`tflbthEMBmtobflm
`the realism ol'uridmmn mold“ and
`othrr mom in“ your homo. Dur-
`ing the llamrutrolion of I. Hm
`operatic aria. repented switching l:-
`lweun stereo- nnd. mumpth mules
`mule sterw‘a advantages olnriou.
`HDTV allows Imam-lot color. too. a
`More International high-minnow
`Wound mi will mom: provide vio-
`id Inna: that can‘t ho obtain“ with
`NTSC mlor Inn‘th Mormon.
`HDTV printout m he would
`withluminaooel'
`' mainland color
`signals aegunkd. mogul TV lig-
`nals have wmhinecl thou—diuutruu
`hr plum fidelity—to achieve oom-
`pntlhllity hotwoon bludt-aod-wldlo
`mm! color mom“.
`You my first unmount- HDTV not
`mnTV meionrbuld'
`In}!!! nun
`thoqu movin- m.
`3‘ might
`lune Ila prototype HDTV goal- within
`3 year lhr Hollywooo ornamth mi:
`[1181 would he 1:0de to film. Vid-
`molt): dim Montana in mono
`rrq.‘ and finilui'lity.
`1.11. I djfinrml. application. CBS
`plans to no: HDTV in about [line
`your: to coll-Into standard broom lo.
`HDT'U' tones woulo maul unreal wo-
`tlumnm mbnlquos, such no 5mm
`(filmmflhl and morning without
`picture aluminum. balm mur-
`alno to flour N'I‘BC nooni‘lrlfl.
`Alan. cablch and how trim
`and tops myhflingmtnmin
`the 1963'; You would Iliad I .Ipnlill
`waiver or ninja. but Ind! man
`could Immune “ammonium” -
`lot-or!- pmbluns of brilliant
`.
`“Tho mlquouuon to whether dmla
`some to be available to the mom}
`pohllonrwiut‘lmitwfll humming
`only Eartha ridmphilowith the money
`be buy all then ancilllriuf aid Flu
`I'm-fly. Getting Wilda-hm] HDTV Lntn
`hunk“ channels. he nnid. “dam
`on the still ol'tiue onsinnorm' smu-
`nilor to make it lit.“
`III
`
`" PMéééSEfifil
`
`PMC Exhibit 2024
`
`Apple v. PMC
`|PR2016-01520
`
`Page 5
`
`PMC Exhibit 2024
`Apple v. PMC
`IPR2016-01520
`Page 5
`
`