`IPR 2016-01261
`U.S. Patent No. 8,457,113
`
`
`
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`_____________________
`
`BEFORE THE PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`_____________________
`
`
`Bright House Networks, LLC,
`WideOpenWest Finance, LLC,
`Knology of Florida, Inc.
`Birch Communications, Inc.,
`Petitioners
`v.
`
`Focal IP, LLC,
`Patent Owner
`
`_____________________
`
`Case No. IPR2016-01261
`U.S. Patent No. 8,457,113
`
`
`
`Before SALLY C. MEDLEY, JONI Y. CHANG, and BARBARA A. PARVIS,
`ADMINISTRATIVE PATENT JUDGES.
`
`PETITIONERS’ RESPONSIVE LISTING OF SUPPORT SHOWING
`REPLY ARGUMENTS ARE PROPER
`
`
`
`
`
`DM2\8016587.2
`
`
`
`
`
`Pursuant to the Board’s Order (Paper No. 40), Petitioners provide the
`
`following citations to the record to show that statements made in the Petitioners’
`
`Reply were (1) first raised in the Petition, and/or (2) raised in response to
`
`arguments and statements made by Patent Owner in the Patent Owner’s Response
`
`(“P.O. Resp.”) and its expert in his declaration (“Bates Dec.”). For the Board’s
`
`convenience, Petitioners have repeated Patent Owner’s assertions of new
`
`argument/evidence using the same numbering as Patent Owner, followed by
`
`Petitioners’ support by citation to the record to show that all arguments constitute a
`
`proper reply:
`
`(1) Petitioners’ Support: P.O. Resp., 38:8-46:15, 56:18-20, 57:5-10; Bates Dec.,
`
`¶¶67-75, 90-91; Pet., 33:17-20, 34:6-9, 34:12-16, 35:12-18, 50:12-51:5.
`
`(2) Petitioners’ Support: P.O. Resp., 47:1-9; 48:1-53:4; Bates Dec., ¶¶79-85; Pet.,
`
`40:18-23, 18:16-22, 26:19-27 (FIG. 4 (68)).
`
`(3) Petitioners’ Support: P.O. Resp., 38:8-46:15, 47:1-9; 48:1-53:4, 56:18-20, 57:5-
`
`10; Bates Dec., ¶¶67-75, 79-85, 90-91; Pet., 33:17-20, 34:12-16, 35:12-18,
`
`50:12-51:5, 26:13-17; 40:18-23, 18:16-22, 26:19-27 (FIG. 4 (68)).
`
`(4) Petitioners’ Support: Pet., 34:6-9, 34:12-16, 33:17-20, 35:12-18, 50:12-51:5,
`
`26:13-17; P.O. Resp., 38:8-39:19, 53:5-59:5, 56:18-20, 57:5-10; Bates Dec.,
`
`¶¶67-69, 86-93.
`
`
`
`
`
`1
`
`
`
`(5) Petitioners’ Support: P.O. Resp. 53:5-59:5; Bates Dec. ¶¶86-93; EX1060,
`
`356:9-357:8; Pet., 28:5-9, 34:6-9, 34:12-16, 59:12-17.
`
`(6) Petitioners’ Support: P.O. Resp., 43:1-44:16, 55:3-55:17, 58:3-59:5, 38:8-39:19,
`
`56:18-20, 57:5-10; Bates Dec., ¶¶73-75; 87-89, 92-93, 45, 90-91; EX1059,
`
`22:23-23:8; 26:7-15; Pet., 28:1-3, 34:6-9, 34:12-16, 35:12-18, 50:12-51:5.
`
`(7) Petitioners’ Support: P.O. Resp., 30:16-38:5, 42:5-44:16, 56:18-20, 57:5-10;
`
`Bates Dec., ¶¶61-66, 73-75, 90-91; Pet. 34:6-9, 34:12-16, 35:12-18, 50:12-51:5.
`
`(8) Petitioners’ Support: P.O. Resp. 38:8-46:15, 53:5-59:5; Bates Dec., ¶¶67-75,
`
`86-93; EX1059, 201:22-202:11, 205:15-206:16, 211:21-213:14.
`
`(9) Petitioners’ Support: P.O. Resp., 38:8-39:19, 45:9-46:15, Bates Dec., ¶¶45, 67-
`
`69, 77-78; Pet., 16:1-4, 36:14-20.
`
`(10) Petitioners’ Support: P.O. Resp., 38:8-39:19, 45:9-46:15, Bates Dec., ¶¶45,
`
`67-69, 77-78; Pet., 16:1-4, 22:15-18, 36:14-20.
`
`(11) Petitioners’ Support: P.O. Resp., 61:15-62:11; Bates Dec., ¶98; Pet., 16:1-
`
`19, 24:7-26:8, 36:14-20, 38:9-12, 38:18-39:11.
`
`(12) Petitioners’ Support: P.O. Resp., 47:1-9; 48:1-53:4; Bates Dec., ¶¶79-85;
`
`Pet., 40:18-23, 18:16-22, 26:19-27 (FIG. 4 (68)).
`
`(13) Petitioners’ Support: P.O. Resp., 50:7-8, 51:9-11, Bates Dec., ¶¶80, 82;
`
`EX1059, 155:13-158:11.
`
`(14) Petitioners’ Support: see (1), (4), (6)-(8), (9)-(10) above.
`
`
`DM2\8016587.2
`
`2
`
`
`
`
`
`Dated: July 21, 2017
`
`
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`By: /Patrick D. McPherson/
`Patrick D. McPherson
`USPTO Reg. No. 46,255
`Duane Morris LLP
`505 9th Street NW, Suite 1000
`Washington, D.C. 20004
`LEAD COUNSEL FOR
`PETITIONERS
`
`
`DM2\8016587.2
`
`1
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ON PATENT OWNER
`UNDER 37 C.F.R. § 42.6(e)
`
`Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. § 42.6(e), the undersigned certifies that on the 21st
`
`day of July 2017, a complete and entire copy of this Responsive Listing of Support
`
`Showing Reply Arguments Are Proper was provided via the Patent Trial and
`
`Appeal Board End to End (PTAB E2E) System as well as delivering a copy via
`
`email on the following counsel for Patent Owner at:
`
`Brent N. Bumgardner
`brent@nelbum.com
`PAL-IPR@nelbum.com
`
`John Murphy
`murphy@nelbum.com
`
`NELSON BUMGARDNER, P.C.
`3131 W. 7th Street, Suite 300
`Fort Worth, Texas 76107
`
`Dated July 21, 2017
`
`LEAD COUNSEL FOR PETITIONERS
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`By: /Patrick D. McPherson/
`Patrick D. McPherson
`USPTO Reg. No. 46,255
`Duane Morris LLP
`505 9th Street NW, Suite 1000
`Washington, D.C. 20004
`
`