`Receipt date: 12/24/2013
`Application Number
`90013106 ~ GAU: 3992
`
`
`Filing Date
`INFORMATION DISCLOSURE First Named Inventer|Byron Hourmand
`
`
`STATEMENT BY APPLICANT
`An Unit
`|
`
`( Not for submission under 37 CFR 1.99)
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Examiner Name
`Attorney Docket Number
`
`| 5796183RX
`
`
`
`HLADY, A.M., "A touch sensitive X-Y position encoder for computer input," Proceedings of the Fall,Jgine@On .
`Conference, November 18-20, 1969, pp. 545-551.
`93
`
`SASAKI, L., et al., "A Touch-Sensitive Input Device,”Intespaiie al Computer Music Conference Proceedings,
`
`November 1981, pp. 293-296.
`
`6
`
`CASIO, AT-550 Advertisement, published in Popular Science by On The Run, February 1984, p.-129.
`
`
`
`CASIO, "Module No. 320," AT-550 Owner's Manual, at least as early as December 1984, 14 pages.
`
`
`
`SMITH, $.D., et al., "Bit-slice microprocessorsin h.f. digital communications," The Radiog0 geefElectronic Engineer, Vol.
`
`51, No. 6, June 1981, pp. 299-301.
`
`A
`
`BOIE, R.A., "Capacitive Impedance Readout Tactile Image Sensor,"" Bssbeedings of the IEEE International Conference
`on Robotics and Automation, Vol. 1, March 1984, pp. 370-372. ge
`
`THOMPSON,C., "Clive Thompson on The BreakjprOugh Myth,” Wired Magazine, http:/Avww.wired.com/
`magazine/201 1/07/st_thompson_breakthrough? August 2011, 3 pages.
`
`"Innovation in Information Techpefogy," National Research Council of the National Academies, Computer Science and
`Telecommunications Boarg/Bivision on Engineering and Physical Sciences, http://www.nap.edu/catalog/10785.html,
`2003, 85 pages.
`
`i
`
`
`
`BUXTON, W., et al., "Large Displays in Automotive Design," IEEE Computer Graphics and Applications, July/August
`2000, pp. 68-75.
`
`EFS Web 2.1.17
`
`Page 251 of 1714
`
`SAMSUNG EXHIBIT 1006 (Part 2 of 8)
`
`Page 251 of 1714
`
`
`
`SAMSUNG EXHIBIT 1006 (Part 2 of 8)
`
`

`

`
`
`(Not for submission under 37 CFR 1.99)
`
`Examiner Name
`
`Attorney Docket Number
`
`[5796183Rx
`
`
`
`
`
`Receipt date: 12/24/2013
`
`
`Application Number
`90013106 - GAU: 3992
`
`Filing Date
`INFORMATION DISCLOSURE First Named Inventor|Byron Hourmand
`
`
`STATEMENT BY APPLICANT
`Ant Unit
`|
`
`
`
`
`
`
`BUXTON, W., "Lexical and Pragmatic Considerations of Input Structures," ACM SIGGRAPH Computer Graphigs, Vol.
`17, No. 1, January 1983, pp. 31-37.
`
`7
`
`
`
`18
`
`BETTS, P., et al., "Light Beam Matrix Input Terminal," IBM Technical Disclosure Bulletin, Octobeg’1966, pp. 493-494.
`
`19
`
`20
`
`21
`
`22
`
`23
`
`BUXTON, B., "Multi-Touch Systems that | Have Known and Loved," downloaded from¥ittp://www.billbuxton.com/
`multitouchOverviewhtml, January 12, 2007, 27 pages.
`
`HEROT, C.F., et al., “One-Point Touch Input of Vector Information for Computer Displays," Proceedings of the 5th
`Annual Conference on Computer Graphics and Interactive Techniques,
`fugust 23-25, 1978, pp. 710-716.
`
`WOLFELD, J.A., "Real Time Control of a Robot Tacticle Sensor, University of Pennslyvania, Department of Computer
`& Information Science, Technical Reports (CIS}, Master Thesis; http://repository.upenn.edu/cis reports/678, August
`1981, 68 pages.
`
`LEWIS, J.R., "Reaping the Benefits of Modern Usabj¥ty Evaluation: The Simon Story," Advances in Applied
`Ergonomics: Proceedings of the 1st International
`@onference on Applied Ergonomics, ICAE May 21-24, 1996, pp.
`752-755.
`
`Philosophy of User-Computer Interface Design," Proceecings of the SIGCHI
`NAKATANI, L.H., et al., "Soft Machines#A
`Conference on Human Factors in Cogiputing Systems, December 1983, Chicago, pp. 19-23.
`
`RUBINE, D.H., "The Automgfic Recognition of Gestures,” Carnegie Mellon University, Master Thesis, CMU-
`24
`CS-91-202, December, 1941, 285 pages.
`
`
`25
`
`26
`
`7
`
`KURTENBACH,;.P., "The Design and Evaluation of Marking Menus,” University of Toronto, Graduate Department of
`Computer Scigfice, Master Thesis, May 1993, 201 pages.
`
`HORKINS, D., "The Design and Implementation of Pie Menus,” originally published in Dr. Dobb's Journal, December
`1
`, lead coverstory, user interface issue, reproduced at wvww.DenHopkins.com, & pages.
`
`BUXTON, B., "The Long Nose of Innovation," Bloomberg Businessweek, Innovation & Design, January 2, 2008, 3
`pages, downloaded from: http:/Awww.businessweek.com/stories/2008-01 -02/the-long-nose-of-innovationbusinessweek-
`business-news-stock-market-and-financialadvice.
`
`EFS Web2.1.17
`
`Page 252 of 1714
`
`Page 252 of 1714
`
`

`

`
`Receipt date: 12/24/2013
`Application Number
`90013106 - GAU: 3992
`
`
`Filing Date
`INFORMATION DISCLOSURE First Named Inventor|Byron Hourmand
`
`
`STATEMENT BY APPLICANT |.
`|
`
`
`
`
`Examiner Name
`
`Attorney Docket Number
`
`| 5796183RX
`
`(Not for submission under 37 CFR 1.99)
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`BUXTON, B., "The Mad Dash Toward Touch Technology," Bloomberg Businessweek, Innovation & Design, Octobg»*
`
`|
`21, 2009, 3 pages, downloaded from: http:/Avww.businessweek.com/innovate/content/oct2009/id2009102162 9
`28
`him.
`‘
`
`
`29
`
`“The Sensor Frame Graphic Manipulator," NASA PhaseII Final Report, NASA-CR-194243,Madly8, 1992, 28 pages.
`
`30
`
`31
`
`32
`
`33
`
`34
`
`
`IZADI, S., et al., "ThinSight: A Thin Form-FactorInteractive Surface Techn sqy," Communications of the ACM,
`Research Highlights, Vol. 52, No. 12, December 2009, pp. 90-98.
`
`KRUEGER,M.W., et al., "VIDEOPLACE- An Artificial Reatfify,” Proceedings of the SIGCHI Conference on Human
`Factors in Computing Systems, April 1985, pp. 35-40
`
`BROWN,E., et al., "Windows on Tabletsgg 4AMeans of Achieving Virtual Input Devices," Proceedings of the IFIP
`TC13 Third International Conference g#*Human-ComputerInteraction, August 27-31, 1990, in D. Diaper, et al. {Eds},
`Human-ComputerInteraction - INyeBACT ‘90, Amsterdam: Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. (North Holland}, 11
`pages.
`6
`
`"A MultiTouch Thre
`fsimensional Touch-Sensitive Tablet," http:/Avww.youtube..com/watch?v=ArrusSCxUiA,
`
`November 18, 2089, 1 page.
`
`'Gééio AT-550 Touch Screen Calculator Watch (1984)," http:/Avww.youtube.com/watch?v=UhVAsqhfhqU, May 24,
`
`#2012, 1 page.
`
`|
`
`Ol
`
`Ol
`
`Ol
`
`Ol
`
`oO
`
`If you wish to add additional non-patentliterature documentcitation information please click the Add buttan Add
`EXAMINER SIGNATURE
`Examiner Signature Date Considered ‘Henry Tran/(02/20/2014)
`
`
`
`
`
`*EXAMINER: Initial if reference considered, whethercr notcitation is in conformance with MPEP 609. Draw line through a
`citation if not in conformance and not considered.
`Include copy of this form with next communication to applicant.
`
`2 Enter office that issued the document, by the two-letter code (WIPO
`1 See Kind Codes of USPTO Patent Documents at www.USPTO.GOV or MPEP 901.04.
`Standard ST.3). 3 For Japanese patent documents,the indication of the year of the reign of the Emperor must precede the serial number of the patent document.
`4 Kind of documentby the appropriate symbols as indicated on the document under WIPO Standard ST.16 if possible.
`5 Applicant is to place a check mark hereif]
`English language translation is attached.
`
`EFS Web2.1.17
`
`Page 253 of 1714
`
`Page 253 of 1714
`
`

`

`
`Receipt date: 12/24/2013
`
`Application Number 90013106 - GAU: 3992
`Filing Date
`INFORMATION DISCLOSURE First Named Inventor|Byron Hourmand
`
`
`STATEMENT BY APPLICANT | .
`Art Unit
`
`(Not for submission under 37 CFR 1.99)
`
`Examiner Name
`
` Attorney Docket Number
`
`
`
`
`
`| 5796183RX
`
`Please see 37 CFR 1.97 and 1.98 to makethe appropriate selection(s}:
`
`CERTIFICATION STATEMENT
`
`[_]
`
`That each item of information contained in the information disclosure statement was first cited in any communication
`from a foreign patent office in a counterpart foreign application not more than three months prior to thefiling of the
`information disclosure statement. See 37 CFR 1.97(e)(1).
`
`OR
`
`That no item of information contained in the information disclosure statement was cited in a cammunication from a
`
`foreign patent office in a counterpart foreign application, and, to the knowledge of the person signing the certification
`after making reasonable inquiry, no item of information contained in the information disclosure statement was known to
`anyindividual designated in 37 CFR 1.56(c) more than three months prior to the filing of the information disclosure
`statement. See 37 CFR 1.97(e)(2).
`
`[]
`
`
`
`[_] See attached certification statement.
`[_] The fee set forth in 37 CFR 1.17 (p) has been submitted herewith.
`[x] Acertification statementis not submitted herewith.
`
`SIGNATURE
`A signature of the applicant or representative is required in accordance with CFR 1.33, 10.18. Please see CFR 1.4(d} for the
`form of the signature.
`
`Name/Print
`
`37,793
`
`Registration Number
`
`This collection of information is required by 37 CFR 1.97 and 1.98. The information is required to obtain or retain a benefit by the
`public whichis to file (and by the USPTO to process) an application. Confidentiality is governed by 35 U.S.C. 122 and 37 CFR
`1.14. This collection is estimated to take 1 hour to complete, including gathering, preparing and submitting the completed
`application form to the USPTO. Time will vary depending upon the individual case. Any comments on the amountof time you
`require to complete this form and/or suggestions for reducing this burden, should be sent to the Chief Information Officer, U.S.
`Patent and Trademark Office, U.S. Department of Commerce, P.O. Box 1450, Alexandria, VA 22313-1450. DO NOT SEND
`FEES OR COMPLETED FORMS TO THIS ADDRESS. SEND TO: Commissionerfor Patents, P.O. Box 1450, Alexandria,
`VA 22313-1450.
`
`EFS Web2.1.17
`
`Page 254 of 1714
`
`Page 254 of 1714
`
`

`

`Receipt date: 12/24/2013
`
`90013106 - GAU: 3992
`
`Privacy Act Statement
`
`The Privacy Act of 1974 (P.L. 93-579) requires that you be given certain information in connection with your submission of the
`attached form related to a patent application or patent. Accordingly, pursuant to the requirements of the Act, please be advised
`that:
`(1} the general authority for the collection of this information is 35 U.S.C. 2(b)(2); (2) furnishing of the information solicited
`is voluntary; and (3) the principal purpose for which the information is used by the U.S. Patent and Trademark Cffice is to
`process and/or examine your submission related to a patent application or patent.
`If you do not furnish the requested
`information, the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office may not be able to process and/or examine your submission, which may
`result in termination of proceedings or abandonmentof the application or expiration of the patent.
`
`The information provided by you in this form will be subject to the following routine uses:
`
`1.
`
`The information on this form will be treated confidentially to the extent allowed under the Freedom of Information Act
`(5 U.S.C. 552} and the Privacy Act (5 U.S.C. 552a). Records from this system of records may be disclosed to the
`Departmentof Justice to determine whether the Freedom of Information Act requires disclosure of these record s.
`
`A record from this system of records may be disclosed, as a routine use, in the course of presenting evidence toa
`court, magistrate, or administrative tribunal, including disclosures to opposing counsel in the course of settlement
`negotiations.
`
`A record in this system of records may be disclosed, as a routine use, to a Member of Congress submitting a
`request involving an individual, to whom the record pertains, when the individual has requested assistance from the
`Memberwith respect to the subject matter of the record.
`
`A record in this system of records may be disclosed, as a routine use, to a contractor of the Agency having need for
`the information in order to perform a contract. Recipients of information shall be required to comply with the
`requirements of the Privacy Act of 1974, as amended, pursuant to 5 U.S.C. 552a(m).
`
`A record related to an International Application filed under the Patent Cooperation Treaty in this system of records
`may be disclosed, as a routine use, to the International Bureau of the World Intellectual Property Organization, pursuant
`to the Patent Cooperation Treaty.
`
`A record in this system of records may be disclosed, as a routine use, to another federal agency for purposes of
`National Security review (35 U.S.C. 181) and for review pursuant to the Atomic Energy Act (42 U.S.C. 218(c)).
`
`A record from this system of records may be disclosed, as a routine use, to the Administrator, General Services, or
`his/her designee, during an inspection of records conducted by GSA aspart of that agency's responsibility to
`recommend improvements in records managementpractices and programs, under authority of 44 U.S.C. 2904 and
`2906. Such disclosure shall be made in accordance with the GSA regulations governing inspection of records for this
`purpose, and any other relevant(i.e., GSA or Commerce) directive. Such disclosure shall not be used to make
`determinations aboutindividuals.
`
`A record fram this system of records may be disclosed, as a routine use, to the public after either publication of
`the application pursuant to 35 U.S.C. 122(b) or issuance of a patent pursuant to 35 U.S.C. 151. Further, a record
`may be disclosed, subject to the limitations of 37 CFR 1.14, as a routine use, to the public if the record was filed in
`an application which became abandoned or in which the proceedings were terminated and which application is
`referenced by either a published application, an application open ta public inspections or an issued patent.
`
`
`
`
`
`A record from this system of records may be disclosed, as a routine use, to a Federal, State, or local law
`enforcement agency, if the USPTO becomes awareof a violation or potential violation of law or regulation.
`
`
`
`EFS Web 2.1.17
`
`Page 255 of 1714
`
`Page 255 of 1714
`
`

`

`witgationSearch Report CRU 3999
`
`
`
`
`TO: Henry Tran
`Location: CRU
`Art Unit: 3992
`Date: 01/27/2014
`
`From: Shanette Brown
`Location: CRU 3999
`MDE 05D10
`Phone: (571) 272-6632
`Shanett.Brown@uspto.gov
`
`
`
` a (0e5
`
`Patent ClassSubclassDescription
`5,796,183 307 Lie
`ORE, Ltd, AIK/AQuantumRescarch|
`
`Ltd v. Nartron
`
`Corpor:
`
`litigation on this patent.
`
`Sources:
`1) I performed a KeyCite Search in Westlaw, which retrieves all history on the patent including any
`litigation.
`
`r
`
`‘US-DIS-
`
`Number
`re:06cv1777
`
`2) I performed a search on the patent in Lexis CourtLink for any open dockets or closed cases.
`
`3) I performed a search in Lexis in the Federal Courts and Administrative Materials databases for any cases
`found.
`
`4) | performed a search in Lexis in the IP Journal and Periodicals database for any articles on the patent.
`
`5) I performed a search in Lexis in the news databasesfor any articles about the patent or any articles about
`
`Page 256 of 1714
`
`Page 256 of 1714
`
`

`

`Page | of 5
`
`Westlaw Delivery SummaryReport for BROWN,SHANETTE L
`
`Date/Time of Request:
`Client Identifier:
`Database:
`Citation Text:
`Service:
`Lines:
`Documents:
`
`Images:
`
`Sunday, January 26, 2014 14:47 Central
`SB
`KEYCITE-HIST
`US PAT 3796183
`KeyCite
`369
`1
`
`0
`
`The material accompanying this summary is subject to copyright. Usage is governed by contract with Thomson Reuters,
`Westandtheir affiliates.
`
`http://web2.westlaw.com/print/printstream.aspx?mt=287&prft=HTMLE&pbc=BC6E23F9,,,.
`Page 257 of 1714
`
`1/26/2014
`
`Page 257 of 1714
`
`

`

`Page 2 of 5
`
`
`
`KEYCITE
`
`Date of Printing: Jan 26, 2014
`
`€S US PAT 5796183 CAPACITIVE RESPONSIVE ELECTRONIC SWITCHING CIRCUIT, Assignce:
`Nartron Corporation (Aug 18, 1998)
`
`History
`
`Direct History
`
`=>
`
`i CAPACTTIVE RESPONSIVE ELECTRONIC SWITCHING CIRCUIT, US PAT 5796183,
`1998 WL 1463338 (U.S. PTO Utility Aug 18, 1998)
`
`Patent Family
`2 CAPACITIVE REACTION ELECTRONIC SWITCH FOR ZERO FORCE APPLICATION
`CONTAINS OSCILLATOR SUPPLYING FREQUENCY OF 50 KHZ OR HIGHER, AND
`INPUT TOUCH TERMINAL, Derwent World Patents Legal 1997-394976+
`
`Assignments
`3 Action: ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST (SEE DOCUMENT FOR DETAILS).
`Numberof Pages: 002, (DATE RECORDED: Aug 17, 2012)
`4 Action: ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST (SEE DOCUMENT FOR DETAILS).
`Number of Pages: 002, (DATE RECORDED:Aug 17, 2012)
`3 Action: ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORSINTEREST (SEE DOCUMENT FOR DETAILS).
`Number of Pages: 011, (DATE RECORDED: Dec 22, 2009)
`6 ASSIGNEE(S): NARTRON CORPORATION, (DATE RECORDED:Feb 04, 1997)
`7 Assignee(s): NARTRON CORPORATION, (DATE RECORDED: Jan 31, 1996)
`
`Patent Status Files
`
`.. Re-Examination Certificate, (OG DATE: May07, 2013)
`.. Request for Re-Examination, (OG DATE: Oct 02, 2012)
`.. Certificate of Correction, (OQG DATE: Nov01, 2011)
`.. Certificate of Correction, (OG DATE: May 11, 1999)
`
`Docket Summaries
`
`12 NARTRON CORPORATION ET AL v. HOURMAND,(W.D.MICH. Jul 20, 2010) (NO.
`1:10CV00691), (28 USC 1338 PATENT INFRINGEMENT)
`13 "QRG, LTD. v. NARTRON CORPORATION", (M.D.PA. Sep 12, 2006) (NO. 1:06CV01777),
`(28 USC 2201 DECLARATORY JUDGEMENT)
`
`© 2014 Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved.
`
`http://web2.westlaw.com/print/printstream.aspx?mt=287&prft=HTMLE&pbc=BC6E23F9,,,.
`Page 258 of 1714
`
`1/26/2014
`
`Page 258 of 1714
`
`

`

`Page 3 of 5
`
`14 "NARTRON CORPv. GEN ELEC, ET AD", (F.D.MICH. Dec 24, 2003) (NO. 2:03CV75 169)
`
`Litigation Alert
`15 Derwent LitAlert P2010-30-63 (Jul 20, 2010) Action Taken: complaint for PATENT
`INFRINGEMENT
`
`16 Derwent LitAlert P2007-35-68 (Sep 12, 2006) Action Taken: A complaint was filed
`17 Derwent LitAlert P2007-02-10 (Apr 13, 2006) Action Taken: Order of court - Ordered that
`motion to dismiss by defendantis denied. Further ordered that the case is to be transferred to the
`USDistrict Court for the Middle Dist of Pennsylvania
`
`Prior Art (Coverage Begins 1976)
`18 CAPACITIVE PRESS CONTROL ACTUATION SYS'TEM, US PAT5235217Assignee: ISB
`Lid., (U.S. PTO Uulity 1993)
`19 CAPACITIVE SENSOR CONTROL SYSTEM, US PAT 4323829Assignee: Fish, Barry M.,
`(U.S. PTO Utility 1982)
`20 CAPACITY RESPONSIVE CONTROL CIRCUIT, US PAT 4831279Assignee: Nartron
`Corporation, (U.S. PTO Utility 1989)
`21 CAPACITY RESPONSIVE KEYBOARD,US PAT 5087825Assignce: Nartron Corporation,
`(U.S. PTO Utility 1992)
`22 CHARGE SENSITIVE SWITCH, US PAT 4159473 Assignee: Johnson-I_.azare CanadaJ imited,
`(U.S. PTO Utility 1979)
`23 CONTROL-SAFE CAPACITIVE SWITCH, US PAT 5233231 Assignee: Pepperl + Fuchs, Inc.,
`(U.S. PTO Utility 1993)
`24 DC TOUCH CONTROL SWITCH CIRCUIT, US PAT 4758735Assignee: Nartron Corporation,
`(U.S. PTO Utility 1988)
`25 DISCRIMINATING CONTACT SENSOR,US PAT 3911215Assignee: ELOGRAPHICS, INC.,
`(U.S. PTO Utility 1975)
`26 DISPLAY DEVICE HAVING UNPA'TTERNED ‘TOUCH DETECTION, US PAT
`4476463 Assignee: Interaction Systems, Inc., (U.S. PTO Uuility 1984)
`27 ELECTROGRAPHIC SENSOR FOR DETERMINING PLANAR COORDINATES, US PAT
`3798370Assignee: ELOGRAPHICS, INC., (U.S. PTO Utility 1974)
`28 ELECTRONIC SWITCH ARRANGEMENTS, US PAT 3651391 Assignee: BLACK $#amp;amp;
`DECKER INC., (U.S. PTO Utility 1972)
`29 ELECTRONIC WATCH WITH TOUCH-SENSITIVE KEYS, US PAT 4257117Assignee:
`LUbauches S.A., (U.S. PTO Utility 1981)
`30 ELECTRONICALT.Y ACTUATED ELECTRIC SWITCH, US PAT 4213061 (U.S. PTO Utility
`1980)
`31 HAND SANITIZING STATION, US PAT 4942631 Assignee: Barry Robertson; Rosa, Rudy,
`(U.S. PTO Utility 1990)
`32 INDUCTION COOK-TOP WITH IMPROVED TOUCH CONTROL, US PAT 4308443Assignee:
`
`&
`
`ee
`
`&
`
`&
`
`<=
`
`Re
`
`=
`
`<
`
`ces
`
`&
`
`eS
`
`&
`
`s
`
`&
`
`© 2014 Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved.
`
`http://web2.westlaw.com/print/printstream.aspx?mt=287&prft=HTMLE&pbc=BC6E23F9,,,.
`Page 259 of 1714
`
`1/26/2014
`
`Page 259 of 1714
`
`

`

`Page 4 of 5
`
`OO
`
`eeoo%950%0EB©0%8&MF
`
`Rangaire Corporation, (U.S. PTO Utility 1981)
`33 KEYBOARD SWITCH, US PAT 4503294Assignee: Nippon Mektron Ltd., (U.S. PTO Utility
`1985)
`34 LAMP RESPONSIVE TO THE HUMAN TOUCH UPON A LIVING PLANT AND CONTROL
`SYSTEM THEREFOR, US PAT 4152629 (U.S. PTO Utility 1979)
`35 LUCENT ELECTROGRAPHIC SENSOR FOR DETERMINING PLANAR COORDINATES,
`US PAT 4071689Assignee: Elographics, Incorporated, (U.S. PTO Utility 1978)
`36 MULTI-WAY SWITCH SYSTEM HAVING PLURAL REMOTE TOUCH PADS, US PAT
`5066898 Assignee: Delat Systems, Incorporated, (U.S. PO Utility 1991)
`37 NONPLANAR TRANSPARENT ELECTROGRAPHIC SENSOR, US PAT 42208 15Assignee:
`Elographics, Inc., (U.S. PTO Utility 1980)
`38 PERSONAL-CARE APPARATUS COMPRISING A CAPACITIVE ON/OFF SWITCH, US
`PAT 5453644Assignee: U.S. Philips Corporation, (U.S. PTO Utility 1995)
`39 PROXIMITY ACTUATED POWER CONTROL VARIABLE AS TO SENSE AND
`MAGNITUDE,US PAT 3984757 (U.S. PTO Utility 1976)
`40 PROXIMITY CONTROLLED POWER SWITCHING CIRCUIT, US PAT 4246533 (U.S. PTO
`Utility 1981)
`4} PROXIMITY PAD WITH CONTROLLED ILLUMINATION,US PAT 4016453 (U.S. PTO
`Utility 1977)
`42 PROXIMITY SWITCHING SYSTEM, US PAT 4031408 (U.S. PTO Utility 1977)
`43 SELT' TIMING SWITCII, US PAT 3965465 (U.S. PTO Utility 1976)
`44 SINGLE-FILECTRODE CAPACITANCF, TOUCHPAD SENSOR SYSTEMS, US PAT
`4237421 Assignee: General Electric Company, (U.S. PTO Utility 1980)
`45 TOUCH ACTIVATED AC, FULL WAVE, TWO WIRE SWITCHES, US PAT
`3549909 Assignee: HALI.7,BARKAN INSTRUMENTS, INC., (U.S. PTO Utility 1970)
`46 TOUCH-CONTROL ADAPTER FOR ELECTRIC LAMPS, US PAT 4211959Assignee: Westek
`Corporation, (U.S. PTO Utility 1980)
`47 TOUCH CONTROL FOR ELECTRICAL APPARATUS, US PAT 3641410Assignee: BLACK
`$#amp;amp; DECKER INC., (U.S. PTO Utility 1972)
`48 TOUCH CONTROL SWITCH, US PAT 4289972 (U.S. PTO Utility 1981)
`49 TOUCH CONTROL SWITCH, US PAT 4264831 (U.S. PTO Utility 1981)
`30 TOUCH CONTROL SWITCH, US PAT 4210822 (U.S. PTO Utility 1980)
`31 TOUCH CONTROL SWITCH CIRCUIT, US PAT 4731548 Assignee: Nartron Corporation,
`(U.S. PTO Utility 1988)
`32 TOUCH CONTROL SYSTEM, US PAT 5572205Assignee: Donnelly Technology,Inc., (U.S.
`PTO Utility 1996)
`53 TOUCH CONTROLLED DISPLAY DEVICE, US PAT 4910504Assignee: Touch Display
`Systems AB, (U.S. PTO Utility 1990)
`34 TOUCH CONTROLLED ELECTRIC LIGIIT SOCKET WITT] INGI CURRENT
`TOLERANCE, US PAT5208516 (U.S. PTO Utility 1993)
`
`
`
`
`
`© 2014 Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved.
`
`http://web2.westlaw.com/print/printstream.aspx?mt=287&prft=HTMLE&pbc=BC6E23F9,,,.
`Page 260 of 1714
`
`1/26/2014
`
`Page 260 of 1714
`
`

`

`Page 5 of 5
`
`
`
`55 TOUCH LAMP, LATCHING AC SOLID STATE TOUCH SWITCH USABLE WITH SUCH
`LAMP, AND CIRCUITS FOR THE SAME, US PAT 3899713Assignee: HALL?BARKAN
`INSTRUMENTS, INC., (U.S. PTO Utility 1975)
`36 TOUCH OVERLAY FOR IMPROVED TOUCH SENSTTIVITY, US PAT 5386219Assignee:
`International Business Machines Corp., (U.S. PTO Utility 1995)
`37 TOUCH RESPONSIVE POWER CONTROL SYSTEM,US PAT 4939382 (U.S. PTO Utility
`1990)
`58 TOUCH-RESPONSIVE SOCKET, US PAT 4101805Assignee: Destron,Inc., (U.S. PTO Utility
`1978)
`59 TOUCH SENSITIVE CONTROL PANEL, US PAT 5012124 (U.S. PTO Ubility 1991)
`60 TOUCH SENSITIVE ELECTRIC SWITCH, US PAT 4289980 (U.S. PTO Utility 1981)
`61 TOUCH SENSITIVE ELECTRONIC SWITCH, US PAT 3879618 Assignee: MAGIC DOT,
`INC., (U.S. PTO Utility 1975)
`62 TOUCH SENSITIVE POWER CONTROT. CIRCUIT, US PAT 3666988Assignee: ROBERT FE
`BELLIS, (U.S. PTO Utility 1972)
`63 TOUCH SENSITIVE POWER CONTROL SYSTEM, US PAT 3919596Assignee: BELLIS
`ROBERT ELLIOTT, (U.S. PTO Utility 1975)
`64 TOUCH SENSITIVE SWITCH, US PAT 4360737Assignee: Leviton Manufacturing Co., Inc.,
`(U.S. PTO Utility 1982)
`65 TOUCH SWITCH CIRCUITS, US PAT 4119864Assignee: RCA Corporation, (U.S. PTO Utility
`1978)
`66 TOUCH SWITCH DEVICE, US PAT 4352141 Assignee: Starcote Limited, (U.S. PTO Utility
`1982)
`67 TOUCH TERMINAL WITH RELIABLE PAD SELECTION, US PAT 4374381 Assignee:
`Interaction Systems, Inc., (U.S. PTO Utility 1983)
`
`%“
`
`a68%he©8
`
`8%
`
`© 2014 Thomson Reuters. All rights reserved.
`
`http://web2.westlaw.com/print/printstream.aspx?mt=287&prft=HTMLE&pbc=BC6E23F9,,,.
`Page 261 of 1714
`
`1/26/2014
`
`Page 261 of 1714
`
`

`

`LexisNexis CourtLink - Show Docket
`
`Page 1 of 2
`
`"SASSERAAAARTHAS
`
`US District Court Civil Docket
`
`
`
`1:10cv691
`
`Nariron Corporation et aiv. Hourmand
`
`This case was retrieved from the court on Sunday, January 26, 2014
`Tatesteteiceteetecateecatecateacetateataataateataaaaaaaaaaateateaaacaaaacaaetnaaaaacaaaaaaaacaaaanicaaetnaeeeaetnaeaeabateeee
`
`Nature of sult: Patent (830)
`
`%:07/20/ 2010
`
`9: Judge Robert Holmes Bell
`
`
`:: Patent Infringement i: Federal Question
`
`; CLOSED
`$: 09/08/2010
`tute: 28:1338
`x8: None
`
`s: Patent
`
`t: $0
`
`Litiganis
`
`Atlorneys
`
`Robert C.J. Tuttle
`ATTORNEYTO BE NOTICED
`Brooks Kushman PC
`1000 Town Ctr., 22nd FI.
`Southfield , Ml 48075-1238
`USA
`(248) 358-4400
`Fax: (248) 358-3351
`Email: Rtuttle@brookskushman.Com
`
`Robert C.J. Tuttle
`ATTORNEYTO BE NOTICED
`Brooks Kushman PC
`1000 Town Ctr., 22nd FI.
`Southfield , Ml 48075-1238
`USA
`(248) 358-4400
`Fax: (248) 358-3351
`Email: Rtuttle@brookskushman.Com
`
`Nartron Corporation
`Plaintiff
`
`Uusi, Lle
`Plaintiff
`
`Byron Hourmand
`Defendant
`
`Date
`
`07/20/2010
`
`#
`
`1
`
`Proceeding Taxt
`
`Source
`
`COMPLAINT against Byron Hourmand filed by Nartron Corporation, UUSI,
`LLC (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B, # 3 Exhibit C, # 4 Exhibit
`D, # 5 Exhibit E, # 6 Exhibit F, # 7 Exhibit G, # 8 Exhibit H, # 9 Exhibit I,
`# 10 Exhibit J, # 11 Exhibit K, # 12 Civil Cover Sheet)(rmw) (Entered:
`07/21/2010)
`
`https://courtlinklexisnexis.com/ControlSupport/UserControls/ShowDocket.aspx?Key=151.... 1/26/2014
`Page 262 of 1714
`
`Page 262 of 1714
`
`

`

`LexisNexis CourtLink - Show Docket
`
`Page 2 of 2
`
`07/20/2010
`
`07/20/2010
`
`07/20/2010
`
`07/20/2010
`
`07/21/2010
`
`08/16/2010
`
`08/16/2010
`
`09/01/2010
`
`in the amount of $350.00, receipt number GRO20949; for filing
`RECEIPT:
`fees (rmw) (Entered: 07/21/2010)
`
`SUMMONS ISSUED as to defendant Byron Hourmand (rmw) (Entered:
`07/21/2010)
`
`CORPORATE DISCLOSURE STATEMENT by Nartron Corporation (rmw)
`(Entered: 07/21/2010)
`
`CORPORATE DISCLOSURE STATEMENT by UUSI, LLC (rmw) (Entered:
`07/21/2010)
`REPORTfrom the Clerk, WDMI, to the Director of the U.S. Patent and
`Trademark Office on the filing of a PATENT ACTION (rmw) (Entered:
`07/21/2010)
`
`SUMMONS returned executed; Byron Hourmand served on 8/4/2010,
`answer due 8/25/2010 (Brandenburg, Robert) (Entered: 08/16/2010)
`
`SUMMONS returned executed; Byron Hourmand served on 7/27/2010,
`answer due 8/25/2010 (Brandenburg, Robert) (Entered: 08/16/2010)
`
`UNOPPOSED MOTION to approve consent judgment by plaintiffs Nartron
`Corporation, UUSI, LLC; (Tuttle, Robert) (Entered: 09/01/2010)
`
`09/08/2010
`
`ORDER granting 7 motion to approve consent judgment ; signed by Judge
`Robert Holmes Bell (Judge Robert Holmes Bell, keb) (Entered:
`09/08/2010)
`REPORTfrom the Clerk, WDMI, to the Director of the U.S. Patent and
`Trademark Office on the determination of a PATENT ACTION (gjf)
`(Entered: 09/09/2010)
`WWWWWWWWWWWTTT
`
`09/09/2010
`
`Copyright © 2014 LexisNexis CourtLink, Inc. All rights reserved.
`*** THIS DATA IS FOR INFORMATIONAL PURPOSES ONLY ***
`
`https://courtlinklexisnexis.com/ControlSupport/UserControls/ShowDocket.aspx?Key=151.... 1/26/2014
`Page 263 of 1714
`
`Page 263 of 1714
`
`

`

`LexisNexis CourtLink - Show Docket
`
`Page 1 of 9
`
`REESE
`
`US District Court Civil Docket
`
`
`
`Qrg, Lid., A/ K/ A Quantum Research Group, Lid. v. Nartron Corporation
`
`This case was retrieved from the court on Sunday, January 26, 2014
`JBihbbhbhhhhnhhnhhnhhnhnhhnhhnhnhnhhnhhnhnhahhnhhnhhnhahhohhnbhnbahhnhhnbhabenbthhithhahehnbthhithhnbhnbtbhithhhbhnbthhithhhihnbthhthhnihnbthhihhnihnbthhthhhibnbibhnhhhibnbihhihhhihnbthhnhhnihnbthhnhhhibntthhthhbihntthhbhhbihnbihhihhbihnieeehnihet
`
`
`
`
`
`t: Patent (830)
`e: Declaratory Judgement
` {: None
`U.S. District Court, Western
`District of PA, 2:06-CV-500
`ion: Federal Question
`
`
`
`: CLOSED
`11/28/2007
`28:2201
`§: Both
`
`18: $0
`ys: Patent
`
`Litigants
`
`Attorneys
`
`Qrg, Ltd.
`a/k/a Quantum Research Group, Ltd.
`Plaintiff
`
`Andrew E. Falsetti
`LEAD ATTORNEY; ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
`[Term: 10/23/2007]
`Reed Smith LLP
`435 Sixth Avenue
`
`Pittsburgh , PA 15219
`USA
`412-288-3844
`Email: Afalsetti@reedsmith.Com
`
`Clay P. Hughes
`LEAD ATTORNEY; ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
`Reed Smith
`435 Sixth Avenue
`Pittsburgh , PA 15219
`USA
`412.288.3008
`
`Email: Chughes@reedsmith.Com
`
`Gene A. Tabachnick
`LEAD ATTORNEY; ATTORNEYTO BE NOTICED
`Reed Smith LLP
`435 Sixth Avenue
`
`Pittsburgh , PA 15219
`USA
`412-288-3258
`Email: Gtabachnick@reedsmith.Com
`
`Robert B. Hoffman
`
`https://courtlinklexisnexis.com/ControlSupport/UserControls/ShowDocket.aspx?Key=151.... 1/26/2014
`Page 264 of 1714
`
`Page 264 of 1714
`
`

`

`LexisNexis CourtLink - Show Docket
`
`Page 2 of 9
`
`Nartron Corporation
`Defendant
`
`Nartron Corporation
`Counterclaim Plaintiff
`
`LEAD ATTORNEY; ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
`Eckert Seamans Cherin & Mellott, LLC
`213 Market Street, 8th Floor
`Harrisburg , PA 17101
`USA
`(717) 237-7182
`Email: Rnoffman@eckertseamans.Com
`
`Mark D. Chuey
`LEAD ATTORNEY; ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
`Brooks Kushman P.C.
`1000 Town Center 22nd Floor
`Southfield , Ml 48075-1238
`USA
`248-358-4400
`
`Email: Mchuey@brookskushman.Com
`
`Mark A. Grace
`LEAD ATTORNEY; ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
`Cohen & Grigsby PC
`11 Stanwix Street 15th Floor
`Pittsburgh , PA 15222-1319
`USA
`412-297-4900
`
`Email: Mgrace@cohenlaw.Com
`
`Robert C.J. Tuttle
`LEAD ATTORNEY; ATTORNEYTO BE NOTICED
`Brooks Kushman P.C.
`1000 Town Center 22nd Floor
`Southfield , Ml 48075-1238
`USA
`248-358-4400
`Email: Rtutthke@brookskushman.Com
`
`Thomas C. Wettach
`LEAD ATTORNEY; ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
`Cohen & Grigsby, PC
`11 Stanwix Street 15th Floor
`Pittsburgh , PA 15222
`USA
`412-297-4900
`Email: Twettach@cohenlaw.Com
`
`Jill L. Bradley
`ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
`Cohen & Grigsby, P.C.
`625 Liberty Avenue
`Pittsburgh , PA 15222-3152
`USA
`412-297-4707
`
`Email: Joradley@cohenlaw.Com
`
`Mark D. Chuey
`LEAD ATTORNEY; ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
`Brooks Kushman P.C.
`1000 Town Center 22nd Floor
`Southfield , Ml 48075-1238
`USA
`
`https://courtlinklexisnexis.com/ControlSupport/UserControls/ShowDocket.aspx?Key=151.... 1/26/2014
`Page 265 of 1714
`
`Page 265 of 1714
`
`

`

`LexisNexis CourtLink - Show Docket
`
`Page 3 of 9
`
`248-358-4400
`
`Email: Mchuey@brookskushman.Com
`
`Mark A. Grace
`LEAD ATTORNEY; ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
`Cohen & Grigsby PC
`11 Stanwix Street 15th Floor
`
`Pittsburgh , PA 15222-1319
`USA
`412-297-4900
`
`Email: Mgrace@cohenlaw.Com
`
`Robert C.J. Tuttle
`LEAD ATTORNEY; ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
`Brooks Kushman P.C.
`1000 Town Center 22nd Floor
`Southfield , Ml 48075-1238
`USA
`248-358-4400
`Email: Rtuttle@brookskushman.Com
`
`Thomas C. Wettach
`LEAD ATTORNEY; ATTORNEYTO BE NOTICED
`Cohen & Grigsby, PC
`11 Stanwix Street 15th Floor
`
`Pittsburgh , PA 15222
`USA
`412-297-4900
`Email: Twettach@cohenlaw.Com
`
`Jill L. Bradley
`ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
`
`Cohen & Grigsby, P.C.
`625 Liberty Avenue
`Pittsburgh , PA 15222-3152
`USA
`412-297-4707
`
`Email: Joradley@cohenlaw.Com
`
`Andrew E. Falsetti
`LEAD ATTORNEY; ATTORNEYTO BE NOTICED
`[ Term: 10/23/2007]
`Reed Smith LLP
`435 Sixth Avenue
`Pittsburgh , PA 15219
`USA
`412-288-3844
`Email: Afalsetti@reedsmith.cCom
`
`Clay P. Hughes
`LEAD ATTORNEY; ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
`Reed Smith
`435 Sixth Avenue
`Pittsburgh , PA 15219
`USA
`412.288.3008
`
`Email: Chughes@reedsmith.Com
`
`Gene A. Tabachnick
`LEAD ATTORNEY; ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
`
`Qrg, Ltd.
`Counterclaim Defendant
`
`https://courtlinklexisnexis.com/ControlSupport/UserControls/ShowDocket.aspx?Key=151.... 1/26/2014
`Page 266 of 1714
`
`Page 266 of 1714
`
`

`

`LexisNexis CourtLink - Show Docket
`
`Page 4 of 9
`
`Reed Smith LLP
`435 Sixth Avenue
`
`Pittsburgh , PA 15219
`USA
`412-288-3258
`Email: Gtabachnick@reedsmith.Com
`
`Robert B. Hoffman
`LEAD ATTORNEY; ATTORNEYTO BE NOTICED
`Eckert Seamans Cherin & Mellott, LLC
`213 Market Street, 8th Floor
`Harrisburg , PA 17101
`USA
`(717) 237-7182
`Email: Rnoffman@eckertseamans.Com
`
`Proceading Text
`
`Source
`
`Case transferred in from District of Western District of Pennsylvania; Case
`Number 2:06-CV-500. Original file with documents numbered 1-17,
`certified copy of transfer order and docket sheet received., filed by QRG,
`LTD.. (Attachments: # 1 Civil Cover Sheet # 2 Receipt# 3 Doc. 2-
`Disclosure Statement# 4 Doc. 3- Summons# 5 Doc. 4- Motion to
`
`Dismiss# 6 Proposed Order to Motion to Dismiss# 7 Doc. 5- Brief in
`Support to Motion to Dismiss# 8 Exhibit A# 9 Exhibit B# 10 Exhibit C# 11
`Doc. 6- Notice of Appearance by Thomas C. Wettach# 12 Doc. 7- Notice;
`Response to Motion to Dismiss# 13 Doc. 8- Motion for Discovery# 14
`Proposed Order for Motion for Discovery# 15 Exhibit 1# 16 Exhibit 2# 17
`Exhibit 3# 18 Exhibit 4# 19 Exhibit 64 20 Exhibit 7# 21 Exhibit 8# 22
`Exhibit 94 23 Exhibit 5 (Motion for Discovery)# 24 Doc. 9-
`Notice: Response to Motion for Discovery# 25 Doc. 10- Brief in Opp. to
`Motion for Discovery# 26 Exhibit A (Brief in Opp. to Discovery)# 27
`Exhibit B (Brief in Opp. to Discovery)# 28 Exhibit C (Brief in Opp. for
`Discovery)# 29 Exhibit D- (Brief in Opp. to Discovery)# 30 Doc. 11- Order
`Granting Motion for Discovery# 31 Doc. 12- Brief in Opp. to Motion to
`Dismiss# 32 Exhibit A (Brief in Opp. to Motion to Dismiss)# 33 Exhibit B
`(Brief in Opp. to Motion to Dismiss)# 34 Exhibit C (Brief in Opp. to Motion
`o Dismiss)# 35 Declaration of Richard T. Ting# 36 Declaration of Andrew
`E. Falsetti# 37 Declaration of Harald Philipp# 38 Declaration of Chris
`Bede# 39 Doc. 3 - Motion for Leave to File a Brief in Reply# 40 Exhibit A
`(Motion to File Brief in Reply)# 41 Doc. 14- Response to Motion for Leave
`to File a Brief in Reply# 42 Supplemental Declaration of Richard Ting# 43
`Doc. 15-Order Granting Motion to File Brief in Reply# 44 Doc. 16- Brief in
`Reply# 45 Exhibit A (Brief in Reply)# 46 Doc. 17- Order Denying Motion