VtkcnuBwurvq/iqx! !
`682.383.8933!
`!
`
`!
`!
`
`!
`!
`
`!
`!
`
`!!!!!!Rcrgt!22!
`!
`!
`!!!!Gpvgtgf<!Lwn{!34-!3125!
`
`!
`!
`
`!
`
`!
`
`WPKVGF!UVCVGU!RCVGPV!CPF!VTCFGOCTM!QHHKEG!
`aaaaaaaaaaaa!
`!
`DGHQTG!VJG!RCVGPV!VTKCN!CPF!CRRGCN!DQCTF!
`aaaaaaaaaaaa!
`
`GK\Q!EQTRQTCVKQP-!
`Rgvkvkqpgt-!
`!
`x/!
`!
`DCTEQ!P/X/-!
`Rcvgpv!Qypgt/!
`
`! !
`
`Ecug!KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!TG54-818!G!
`
`! !
`
`Dghqtg!MCN[CP!M/!FGUJRCPFG-!LCOGU!D/!CTRKP-!cpf!!
`FCXKF!E/!OeMQPG-!Administrative Patent Judges/!
`
`GUJRCPFG-!Administrative Patent Judge/!
`
`FGEKUKQP!
`Kpuvkvwvkqp!qh!Inter Partes Tgxkgy!
`37 C.F.R. § 42.108!
`
`!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!2
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`! F
`
`!
`
`
`682.383.8933!
`!
`
`!
`!
`
`!
`!
`
`!
`!
`
`!!!!!!Rcrgt!22!
`!
`!
`!!!!Gpvgtgf<!Lwn{!34-!3125!
`
`!
`!
`
`!
`
`!
`
`WPKVGF!UVCVGU!RCVGPV!CPF!VTCFGOCTM!QHHKEG!
`aaaaaaaaaaaa!
`!
`DGHQTG!VJG!RCVGPV!VTKCN!CPF!CRRGCN!DQCTF!
`aaaaaaaaaaaa!
`
`GK\Q!EQTRQTCVKQP-!
`Rgvkvkqpgt-!
`!
`x/!
`!
`DCTEQ!P/X/-!
`Rcvgpv!Qypgt/!
`
`! !
`
`Ecug!KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!TG54-818!G!
`
`! !
`
`Dghqtg!MCN[CP!M/!FGUJRCPFG-!LCOGU!D/!CTRKP-!cpf!!
`FCXKF!E/!OeMQPG-!Administrative Patent Judges/!
`
`GUJRCPFG-!Administrative Patent Judge/!
`
`FGEKUKQP!
`Kpuvkvwvkqp!qh!Inter Partes Tgxkgy!
`37 C.F.R. § 42.108!
`
`!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!2
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`! F
`
`!
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`
`K/
`
`KPVTQFWEVKQP!
`
`Gk|q!Eqtrqtcvkqp!)Rgvkvkqpgt*!hkngf!c!eqttgevgf!Rgvkvkqp!tgswguvkpi!
`cp!inter partes!tgxkgy!qh!enckou!47-!57-!65-!75-!76-!88.8;-!;4-!;5-!212.215-!
`
`cpf!218!qh!Rcvgpv!Pq/!WU!TG54-818!G!)Gz/!2112=!vjg!818!rcvgpv*/!!
`
`Rcrgt!5!)Rgv/*/!!Dcteq!P/X/!)Rcvgpv!Qypgt*!vkogn{!hkngf!c!Rtgnkokpct{!
`
`Tgurqpug/!!Rcrgt!;!)Rtgnko/!Tgur/*/!!Yg!jcxg!lwtkufkevkqp!wpfgt!46!W/U/E/!
`
`'!425/!!!
`Vjg!uvcpfctf!hqt!kpuvkvwvkpi!cp!inter partes!tgxkgy!ku!ugv!hqtvj!kp!
`
`46!W/U/E/!'!425)c*-!yjkej!rtqxkfgu!cu!hqnnqyu<!
`
`VJTGUJQNFVjg!Fktgevqt!oc{!pqv!cwvjqtk|g!cp!kpvgt!rctvgu!
`tgxkgy! vq! dg! kpuvkvwvgf! wpnguu! vjg! Fktgevqt! fgvgtokpgu! vjcv! vjg!
`kphqtocvkqp! rtgugpvgf! kp! vjg! rgvkvkqp! hkngf! wpfgt! ugevkqp! 422!
`cpf! cp{! tgurqpug! hkngf! wpfgt! ugevkqp! 424! ujqyu! vjcv! vjgtg! ku! c!
`tgcuqpcdng! nkmgnkjqqf! vjcv! vjg! rgvkvkqpgt! yqwnf! rtgxckn! ykvj!
`tgurgev!vq!cv!ngcuv!2!qh!vjg!enckou!ejcnngpigf!kp!vjg!rgvkvkqp/!
`
`Wrqp!eqpukfgtcvkqp!qh!vjg!Rgvkvkqp!cpf!vjg!Rtgnkokpct{!Tgurqpug-!yg!
`
`fgvgtokpg!vjcv!vjg!kphqtocvkqp!rtgugpvgf!d{!Rgvkvkqpgt!jcu!guvcdnkujgf!vjcv!
`
`vjgtg!ku!c!tgcuqpcdng!nkmgnkjqqf!vjcv!Rgvkvkqpgt!yqwnf!rtgxckn!kp!ujqykpi!vjg!
`wprcvgpvcdknkv{!qh!enckou!212.215/!!Ceeqtfkpin{-!yg!kpuvkvwvg!cp!inter partes!
`
`tgxkgy!qh!vjgug!enckou/!!Yg!jcxg!cnuq!fgvgtokpgf!vjcv!vjg!kphqtocvkqp!
`
`rtgugpvgf!d{!Rgvkvkqpgt!jcu!pqv!guvcdnkujgf!vjcv!vjgtg!ku!c!tgcuqpcdng!
`
`nkmgnkjqqf!vjcv!Rgvkvkqpgt!yqwnf!rtgxckn!kp!ujqykpi!vjg!wprcvgpvcdknkv{!qh!
`
`enckou!47-!57-!65-!75-!76-!88.8;-!;4-!;5-!cpf!218!qh!vjg!818!rcvgpv/!!
`Ceeqtfkpin{-!yg!fq!pqv!kpuvkvwvg!cp!inter partes!tgxkgy!qh!vjqug!enckou/!
`
`3!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!3
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`
`A. Related Proceedings
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt!kpfkecvgu!vjcv!vjg!818!rcvgpv!ku!vjg!uwdlgev!qh!c!Hgfgtcn!
`!
`fkuvtkev!eqwtv!ecug<!Barco, N.V. et al. v. Eizo Nanao Corp.-!22.ex.11369!
`
`)P/F/!Ic*/!!Rgv/!2/!!!
`Cffkvkqpcnn{-!vjg!818!rcvgpv!ku!vjg!uwdlgev!qh Inter Partes!
`Tggzcokpcvkqp!Pq/!;60113-158!cpf!ycu!vjg!uwdlgev!qh!Ex Parte!
`Tggzcokpcvkqp!Pq/!;10131-148!)vjg!148!Tggzco/*/2!!Rgv/!2/!!!
`B. The ’707 Patent
`
`Vjg!818!rcvgpv!ku!fktgevgf!vq!c!u{uvgo!cpf!ogvjqf!hqt!pqkug!tgfwevkqp!
`
`kp!ogfkecn!kocigu!dgkpi!xkgygf!qp!fkurnc{!u{uvgou/!!Gz/!2112-!5<25.27/!!
`
`Uekgpvkhke!uvwfkgu!kpfkecvg!vjcv!gxgp!c!unkijv!kpetgcug!qh!pqkug!kp!ogfkecn!
`
`kocigu!ecp!jcxg!c!ukipkhkecpv!pgicvkxg!korcev!qp!vjg!ceewtce{!cpf!swcnkv{!qh!
`ogfkecn!fkcipquku/!!Id.!cv!2<41.44/!!Ceeqtfkpin{-!vjg!818!rcvgpv!rtqxkfgu!c!
`
`pqkug!tgfwevkqp!u{uvgo!cpf!ogvjqf!vjcv!cfftguugu!pqp.wpkhqtokv{!qh!rkzgn!
`dgjcxkqt!rtgugpv!kp!ocvtkz.cfftguugf!gngevtqpke!fkurnc{!fgxkegu/!!Id.!cv!5<47.
`
`52/!!!
`
`Vjg!818!rcvgpv!kpenwfgu!c!tcpig!qh!godqfkogpvu-!kpenwfkpi!c!xkukqp!
`
`ogcuwtgogpv!u{uvgo!!c!ugv.wr!hqt!cwvqocvgf-!gngevtqpke!xkukqp!qh!
`kpfkxkfwcn!rkzgnu!qh!c!ocvtkz.cfftguugf!fkurnc{/!!Id.!cv!7<21.28/!!Vjg!xkukqp!
`
`ogcuwtgogpv!u{uvgo!kpenwfgu!cp!kocig!ecrvwtkpi!fgxkeg-!c!oqxgogpv!
`fgxkeg!hqt!oqxkpi!vjg!kocig!ecrvwtkpi!fgxkeg-!cpf0qt!c!fkurnc{/!!Id.!cv!7<28.
`
`!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
`
`2!Vjg!Qhhkeg!kuuwgf!c!tgzgzcokpcvkqp!egtvkhkecvg-!Tggzcokpcvkqp!Egtvkhkecvg!
`Pq/!WU!TG54-818!E2!)vjg!818!E2!egtvkhkecvg*-!qp!Octej!42-!3125/!
`
`4!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!4
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`
`31/!!Gcej!qh!vjg!godqfkogpvu!tgcejgu!vjg!ucog!tguwnv!qh!qwvrwvvkpi!cp!
`gngevtqpke!kocig!qh!rkzgnu/!!Id.!cv!7<31.34/!!]C_!rtqeguu!ku!twp!vq!gzvtcev!
`rkzgn!ejctcevgtk|cvkqp!fcvc!htqo!vjg!gngevtqpke!kocig/!!Id.!cv!8<5.8/!!
`
`Cniqtkvjou!ctg!wugf!vq!cuukip!c!nwokpcpeg!xcnwg!vq!gcej!rkzgn-!yjgtg!vjg!
`
`cniqtkvjo!kpenwfgu!c!hktuv!vcum!qh!kfgpvkh{kpi!c!nqecvkqp!qh!gcej!qh!vjg!ocvtkz!
`
`fkurnc{!rkzgnu!cpf!tgncvkpi!vjg!rkzgnu!vq!vjg!rkzgnu!qh!vjg!gngevtqpke!kocig-!
`
`cpf!c!ugeqpf!vcum!qh!ecnewncvkpi!cpf!cuukipkpi!qpg!nkijv.qwvrwv!xcnwg!hqt!
`gcej!rkzgn/!!Id.!cv!8<9.24-!9<63.65/!!C!vguv!kocig!oc{!dg!igpgtcvgf!d{!ftkxkpi!
`
`gcej!qh!vjg!rkzgnu!ykvj!vjg!ucog!ftkxg!ukipcn!qt!ftkxg!ngxgn-!cpf!vjg!nkijv.
`qwvrwv!qh!gcej!rkzgn!ecp!dg!ecnewncvgf!htqo!vjg!vguv!kocig/!!Id.!cv!;<36.4;/!!
`
`Vjg!pgzv!vcum!qh!vjg!cniqtkvjo!ku!vq!fghkpg!c!ftkxg!hwpevkqp-!vjgtgd{!
`
`rtqxkfkpi!c!eqttgevkqp!rtkpekrng!vq!igpgtcvg!c!tgswktgf!nkijv.qwvrwv!tgurqpug!
`
`ewtxg!hqt!cp!kpfkxkfwcn!rkzgn!cpf-!vjwu-!gswcnk|kpi!vjg!tgurqpug!qh!cnn!qh!vjg!
`rkzgnu!kp!c!fkurnc{/!!Id.!cv!21<3;.53/!!!
`
`Cp!gzcorng!qh!gswcnk|kpi!vjg!dgjcxkqt!qh!vjg!rkzgnu!ku!knnwuvtcvgf!kp!
`
`Hkiwtg!21!cu!hqnnqyu<!
`
`!
`
`5!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!5
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`
`Hkiwtg!21!knnwuvtcvgu!vjcv!rkzgnu!ykvj!ewtxgu!C!!E!ctg!gswcnk|gf!vq!vjcv!qh!
`ewtxg!F/!!Id. cv!23<4.6/!!C!urgekhke!vtcpuhgt!ewtxg!hqt!gcej!rkzgn!oc{!dg!wugf!
`
`vq!eqorgpucvg!vjg!dgjcxkqt!qh!gcej!rkzgnu!ejctcevgtkuvke!nwokpcpeg!
`
`tgurqpug-!vjgtgd{!oqfkh{kpi!qt!ewtkpi!cp{!wpgswcn!nwokpcpeg!dgjcxkqt!qxgt!
`c!fkurnc{!ctgc/!!Id.!cv!23<2;.39/!!
`C. Illustrative Claims
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt!ejcnngpigu!enckou!47-!57-!65-!75-!76-!88.8;-!;4-!;5-!212.
`
`215-!cpf!218!qh!vjg!818!rcvgpv/!!Rgv/!33.56/!!Uwdugswgpv!vq!vjg!hknkpi!qh!vjg!
`
`Rgvkvkqp-!c!Tggzcokpcvkqp!Egtvkhkecvg!kuuwgf!kp!vjg!148!Tggzco/-!ecpegnnkpi!
`
`uqog!qh!vjg!enckou!ejcnngpigf!kp!vjg!Rgvkvkqp!cpf!cogpfkpi!qvjgtu/!!
`See!Gz/!3116/!!Kpfgrgpfgpv!encko!47!ycu!eqphktogf/!!Id.!cv!3/!!Encko!212-!
`
`yjkej!fgrgpfgf!htqo!kpfgrgpfgpv!encko!211-!pqy!ku!ytkvvgp!kp!kpfgrgpfgpv!
`hqto!vq!kpenwfg!cnn!qh!vjg!nkokvcvkqpu!qh!ecpegnngf!encko!211/!!Id.!!Encko!75-!
`yjkej!fgrgpfgf!htqo!encko!73-!pqy!fgrgpfu!htqo!cancelled!encko!;5-!
`
`yjkej!fgrgpfgf!rtgxkqwun{!htqo!encko!73/!!Encko!57!fgrgpfu!htqo!
`
`kpfgrgpfgpv!encko!52/!!Encko!65!fgrgpfu!htqo!kpfgrgpfgpv!encko!64/!!
`
`Encko!76!ku!fkuenckogf-!cpf!enckou!88.8;!cpf!;4!ctg!ecpegnngf/!!Enckou!213.
`
`215!fgrgpf-!fktgevn{!qt!kpfktgevn{-!htqo!kpfgrgpfgpv!encko!212/!!Encko!218!
`
`fgrgpfu!htqo!kpfgrgpfgpv!encko!216/!!!
`
`Enckou!47-!75-!212-!cpf!218!ctg!knnwuvtcvkxg!qh!vjg!tgockpkpi-!
`
`ejcnngpigf!enckou!cpf!ctg!tgrtqfwegf!dgnqy<!
`
`47/!!C!ogvjqf!qh!kocig!rtqeguukpi-!uckf!ogvjqf!eqortkukpi<!!
`!
`hqt!gcej!qh!c!rnwtcnkv{!qh!rkzgnu!qh!c!fkurnc{-!qdvckpkpi!c!
`ogcuwtg!qh!c!nkijv.qwvrwv!tgurqpug!qh!cv!ngcuv!c!rqtvkqp!qh!vjg!
`rkzgn!cv!gcej!qh!c!rnwtcnkv{!qh!ftkxkpi!ngxgnu=!!!
`
`6!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!6
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`
`oqfkh{kpi!c!ocr!qh!vjg!fkurnc{!vjcv!ku!dcugf!qp!vjg!
`!
`qdvckpgf!ogcuwtgu-!uckf!oqfkh{kpi!kpenwfkpi-!ykvj!tgurgev!vq!c!
`ocipkvwfg!qh!c!eqorqpgpv!jcxkpi!c!urcvkcn!rgtkqf!dgvyggp!qpg!
`cpf!hkhv{!oknnkogvgtu-!fgetgcukpi!c!ocipkvwfg!qh!c!eqorqpgpv!
`jcxkpi!c!urcvkcn!rgtkqf!nguu!vjcp!qpg!oknnkogvgt!cpf!fgetgcukpi!
`c!ocipkvwfg!qh!c!eqorqpgpv!jcxkpi!c!urcvkcn!rgtkqf!itgcvgt!vjcp!
`hkhv{!oknnkogvgtu=!cpf!!
`!
`dcugf!qp!vjg!oqfkhkgf!ocr!cpf!cp!kocig!ukipcn!vjcv!
`tgrtgugpvu!cv!ngcuv!qpg!rj{ukecn!cpf!vcpikdng!qdlgev-!qdvckpkpi!c!
`fkurnc{!ukipcn!vjcv!ku!eqphkiwtgf!vq!ecwug!vjg!fkurnc{!vq!fgrkev!
`vjg!cv!ngcuv!qpg!rj{ukecn!cpf!vcpikdng!qdlgev/!
`
`! 7
`
`5/! Vjg!kocig!rtqeguukpi!crrctcvwu!qh!encko!;5-!yjgtgkp!vjg!
`fguktgf!pqp.wpkhqto!nkijv.qwvrwv!tgurqpug!eqortkugu!c!nqygt!
`fgitgg!qh!pqp.wpkhqtokv{!hqt!rkzgnu!uwduvcpvkcnn{!cv!c!egpvgt!qh!
`vjg!fkurnc{!vjcp!hqt!rkzgnu!uwduvcpvkcnn{!cv!gfigu!qh!vjg!fkurnc{/!
`
`! 2
`
`12/! Cp!kocig!rtqeguukpi!crrctcvwu!eqortkukpi<!
`cp!cttc{!qh!nqike!gngogpvu!eqphkiwtgf!vq!igpgtcvg!c!
`fkurnc{!ukipcn!dcugf!qp!c!ocr!cpf!cp!kocig!ukipcn!vjcv!
`tgrtgugpvu!cv!ngcuv!qpg!rj{ukecn!cpf!vcpikdng!qdlgev!
`yjgtgkp!vjg!fkurnc{!ukipcn!ku!eqphkiwtgf!vq!ecwug!c!
`fkurnc{!vq!fgrkev!c!fkurnc{!kocig!qh!vjg!cv!ngcuv!qpg!rj{ukecn!
`cpf!vcpikdng!qdlgev-!cpf!!
`yjgtgkp!vjg!ocr!eqortkugu!eqttgevkqp!fcvc!eqphkiwtgf!vq!
`eqttgev!hqt!rkzgn!pqp.wpkhqtokv{!qpn{!yjgp!vjg!rkzgn!pqp.
`wpkhqtokv{!ku!qwvukfg!qh!c!vqngtcpeg!ngxgn-!cpf!!
`!
`yjgtgkp!vjg!vqngtcpeg!ngxgn!xctkgu!coqpi!rkzgnu!qh!vjg!
`fkurnc{/!
`
`! 2
`
`18/! Vjg!kocig!rtqeguukpi!crrctcvwu!ceeqtfkpi!vq!encko!216-!
`yjgtgkp!vjg!ocr!eqortkugu!eqttgevkqp!fcvc!hqt!c!hktuv!rkzgn!kp!
`vjg!fkurnc{!dcugf!kp!rctv!qp!c!nkijv.qwvrwv!tgurqpug!qh!cv!ngcuv!
`qpg!rkzgn!kp!vjg!fkurnc{!cflcegpv!vq!vjg!hktuv!rkzgn!vjcv!jcu!c!
`fgitgg!qh!pqp.wpkhqtokv{!itgcvgt!vjcp!c!rtgfgvgtokpgf!
`vjtgujqnf/!
`
`7!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!7
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`
`D.
`
`References Relied Upon By Petitioner!
`
`!
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt!tgnkgu!wrqp!vjg!hqnnqykpi!tghgtgpegu<!
`Exhibit No.
`References
`
`2113!
`
`2114!
`
`2115!
`
`2116!
`
`2117!
`
`2118!
`
`2119!
`
`211;!
`
`Rcvgpv!Pq/!WU!8-338-62;!D2!)Mcycug*!
`
`Rcvgpv!Rwdnkecvkqp!Pq/!WU!311601123932!C2!)Mcpck*!
`
`Rcvgpv!Rwdnkecvkqp!Pq/!WU!3116011;48;9!C2!)Mcocfc*!
`
`Rcvgpv!Pq/!WU!6-46;-453!)Pcmck*!
`
`Rcvgpv!Rwdnkecvkqp!Pq/!WU!311601134;97!C2!)Ok|wmqujk*!
`
`Rcvgpv!Pq/!WU!8-161-185!D2!)Mq{coc*!
`
`Rcvgpv!Pq/!WU!7-382-936!D2!)Itggpg*!
`
`Rcvgpv!Pq/!WU!7-8;2-677!D2!)Mwtcvqok*!
`
`8!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!8
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`
`E. Asserted Grounds of Unpatentability
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt!cuugtvu!itqwpfu!qh!wprcvgpvcdknkv{!hqt!enckou!47-!57-!65-!75-!
`
`76-!88.8;-!;4-!;5-!212.215-!cpf!218!qh!vjg!818!rcvgpv!wpfgt!46!W/U/E/!
`''!213!cpf!214-!cu!hqnnqyu!)see!Rgv/!33.56*<!
`
`Reference(s)
`
`Mcycug!cpf!Mcpck!
`
`Mcocfc!
`
`Pcmck!
`
`Pcmck!cpf!Ok|wmqujk!
`
`Pcmck!cpf!Mq{coc!
`
`Itggpg!cpf!Mcocfc!
`
`Itggpg!
`
`Itggpg!cpf!Mwtcvqok!
`
`Basis
`
`'!214)c*!
`
`'!213)g*!
`
`'!213)d*!
`
`'!214)c*!
`
`'!214)c*!
`
`'!214)c*!
`
`'!213)d*!
`
`'!214)c*!
`
`Claims
`Challenged
`47-!57-!cpf!65!
`
`75!cpf!76!
`
`88.8;!cpf!;5!
`
`;4!
`
`;5!
`
`212.215!
`
`218!
`
`218!
`
`KK/ CPCN[UKU!
`A. Claim Construction
`Kp!cp!inter!partes!tgxkgy-!encko!vgtou!kp!cp!wpgzrktgf!rcvgpv!ctg!
`
`kpvgtrtgvgf!ceeqtfkpi!vq!vjgkt!dtqcfguv!tgcuqpcdng!eqpuvtwevkqp!kp!nkijv!qh!vjg!
`
`urgekhkecvkqp!qh!vjg!rcvgpv!kp!yjkej!vjg{!crrgct/!!48!E/H/T/!'!53/211)d*=!
`
`Qhhkeg!Rcvgpv!Vtkcn!Rtcevkeg!Iwkfg-!88!Hgf/!Tgi/!59-867-!59-877!)Cwi/!25-!
`
`3123*/!!Encko!vgtou!ctg!ikxgp!vjgkt!qtfkpct{!cpf!ewuvqoct{!ogcpkpi-!cu!
`
`yqwnf!dg!wpfgtuvqqf!d{!qpg!qh!qtfkpct{!umknn!kp!vjg!ctv!kp!vjg!eqpvgzv!qh!vjg!
`gpvktg!fkuenquwtg/!!In re Translogic Tech., Inc.-!615!H/4f!235;-!2368!
`
`)Hgf/!Ekt/!3118*/!!C!encko!vgto!yknn!pqv!dg!ikxgp!kvu!qtfkpct{!cpf!ewuvqoct{!
`
`ogcpkpi-!jqygxgt-!yjgp!cp!kpxgpvqt!cevu!cu!jku!qt!jgt!qyp!ngzkeqitcrjgt-!
`9!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!9
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`
`fghkpkpi!vjg!vgto!kp!vjg!urgekhkecvkqp!ykvj!tgcuqpcdng!enctkv{-!fgnkdgtcvgpguu-!
`cpf!rtgekukqp/!!Renishaw PLC v. Marposs Societa’ per Azioni-!269!H/4f!
`
`2354-!235;!)Hgf/!Ekt/!2;;9*/!!!
`
`Pgkvjgt!Rgvkvkqpgt!pqt!Rcvgpv!Qypgt!rtqrqugu!vjg!eqpuvtwevkqp!qh!cp{!
`
`encko!vgtou/!!Ceeqtfkpin{-!cnn!vgtou!ctg!ikxgp!vjgkt!qtfkpct{!cpf!ewuvqoct{!
`
`ogcpkpi!eqpukuvgpv!ykvj!vjg!Urgekhkecvkqp/!!!
`B. Timeliness of Petition
`
`Rcvgpv!Qypgt!eqpvgpfu!vjcv!vjg!Rgvkvkqp!ku!vkog.dcttgf!wpfgt!Ugevkqp!
`
`426)d*!dgecwug!vjg!Rgvkvkqp!ycu!hkngf!oqtg!vjcp!qpg!{gct!chvgt!vjg!fcvg!qp!
`
`yjkej!Rgvkvkqpgt!ycu!ugtxgf!c!eqornckpv!cnngikpi!kphtkpigogpv!qh!vjg!rcvgpv/!!
`
`Rtgnko/!Tgur/!3.26/!!Rcvgpv!Qypgt!urgekhkecnn{!ctiwgu!vjcv!kv!ugtxgf!c!
`
`eqornckpv!cnngikpi!kphtkpigogpv!qh!Rcvgpv!Pq/!WU!8-74;-95;!D3!)vjg!"95;!
`rcvgpv*!wrqp!Rgvkvkqpgt!qp!Qevqdgt!8-!3122/!!Id.!cv!3=!see!Gz/!3113/!!
`
`Uwdugswgpv!vq!vjku!ugtxkeg-!vjg!"95;!rcvgpv!ycu!tgkuuwgf!qp!Qevqdgt!3-!3123-!
`
`cu!vjg!"818!rcvgpv/!!Rtgnko/!Tgur/!3/!!Vjg!kpuvcpv!Rgvkvkqp!ycu!hkngf!qp!
`
`Lcpwct{!28-!3125-!oqtg!vjcp!vyq!{gctu!chvgt!vjg!fcvg!qh!ugtxkeg!qh!vjg!
`eqornckpv/!!Id.!!Ceeqtfkpin{-!Rcvgpv!Qypgt!ctiwgu!vjcv!vjg!Rgvkvkqp!ku!
`wpvkogn{!wpfgt!Ugevkqp!426)d*/!!Id.!cv!3.26/!!!
`
`Yg!ctg!pqv!rgtuwcfgf!d{!Rcvgpv!Qypgtu!ctiwogpvu/!!Ugevkqpu!362!
`
`cpf!363!uvcvg-!tgurgevkxgn{-!vjcv!]y_jgpgxgt!cp{!rcvgpv!ku-!vjtqwij!gttqt-!
`
`fggogf!yjqnn{!qt!rctvn{!kpqrgtcvkxg!qt!kpxcnkf-!/!/!/!vjg!Fktgevqt!ujcnn-!qp!vjg!
`surrender of such patent /!/!/!-!tgkuuwg!vjg!rcvgpv!hqt!vjg!kpxgpvkqp!fkuenqugf!
`kp!vjg!qtkikpcn!rcvgpv!cpf!]v_jg!surrender of the original patent ujcnn!vcmg!
`
`ghhgev!wrqp!vjg!kuuwg!qh!vjg!tgkuuwgf!rcvgpv/!!46!W/U/E/!©©!362-!363!
`
`;!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!;
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`
`)gorjcuku!cffgf*/!!Vjg!pgy!tgkuuwg!rcvgpv!ku!c!fkuvkpev!rtqrgtv{!tkijv!vjcv!
`fqgu!pqv!ukorn{!tgrnceg!cp!qtkikpcn!rcvgpv!nunc pro tunc/!!Intel Corp. v.
`Negotiated Data Solutions, Inc.-!814!H/4f!2471-!2475!)Hgf/!Ekt/!3123*!
`)ekvkpi!Spectronics Corp. v. H.B. Fuller Co.-!;51!H/3f!742-!748.49!)Hgf/!Ekt/!
`
`2;;2**/!!46!W/U/E/!'!426)d*!tgekvgu!vjcv!
`
`]c_p! kpvgt! rctvgu! tgxkgy! oc{! pqv! dg! kpuvkvwvgf! kh! vjg! rgvkvkqp!
`tgswguvkpi! vjg! rtqeggfkpi! ku! hkngf! oqtg! vjcp! 2! {gct! chvgt! vjg!
`fcvg! qp! yjkej! vjg! rgvkvkqpgt-! tgcn! rctv{! qh! kpvgtguv-! qt! rtkx{! qh!
`vjg! rgvkvkqpgt! ku! ugtxgf! ykvj! c! eqornckpv! cnngikpi! kphtkpigogpv!
`of the patent )gorjcuku!cffgf*/!
`
`Jgtg-!Rcvgpv!Qypgt!ugtxgf!wrqp!Rgvkvkqpgt!c!eqornckpv!cnngikpi!
`kphtkpigogpv!qh!vjg!"95;!rcvgpv/!!See!Gz/!3113/!!Vjg!tgkuuwcpeg!qh!vjg!"95;!
`rcvgpv!cu!vjg!"818!rcvgpv!fkf!pqv!continue!vjg!"95;!rcvgpv-!dwv!tcvjgt!tguwnvgf!
`kp!vjg!surrender!qh!vjg!"95;!rcvgpv!cpf!vjg!issuance!qh!c!pgy!rcvgpv-!vjg!"818!
`
`rcvgpv/!!Rcvgpv!Qypgt!ugtxgf!Rgvkvkqpgt!ykvj!cp!cogpfgf!eqornckpv!cnngikpi!
`kphtkpigogpv!qh!vjg!"818!rcvgpv!qp!Lcpwct{!28-!3124/!!See!Gz/!3115/!!Vjg!
`
`Dqctf!ceeqtfgf!vjg!kpuvcpv!Rgvkvkqp!c!hknkpi!fcvg!qh!Lcpwct{!28-!3125/!!
`See Rcrgt!4/!!Ceeqtfkpin{-!Ugevkqp!426)d*!ku!pqv!crrnkecdng!jgtg!dgecwug!vjg!
`
`Rgvkvkqp!ycu!pqv!hkngf!oqtg!vjcp!qpg!{gct!chvgt!Rgvkvkqpgt!ycu!ugtxgf!ykvj!vjg!
`amended!eqornckpv!hktuv!cnngikpi!kphtkpigogpv!qh!vjg!"818!rcvgpv/!!!
`
`Yg!cnuq!ctg!wprgtuwcfgf!d{!Rcvgpv!Qypgtu!ctiwogpv!vjcv!vjg!enckou!
`
`qh!vjg!"95;!rcvgpv!ctg!uwduvcpvkcnn{!kfgpvkecn!vq!vjg!enckou!qh!vjg!"818!rcvgpv-!
`
`cpf-!vjgtghqtg-!wpfgt!Ugevkqp!363-!vjg!"95;!rcvgpv!ku!vjg!ucog!cu!vjg!
`
`"818!rcvgpv!hqt!vjg!rwtrqugu!qh!Ugevkqp!426)d*/!!Rtgnko/!Tgur/!7.9-!23.25/!!
`
`Ugevkqp!426)d*!tgswktgu!vjcv!vjg!rgvkvkqpgt!/!/!/!ku!ugtxgf!ykvj!c!eqornckpv!
`
`21!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!21
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`cnngikpi!kphtkpigogpv!qh!the patent/!!46!W/U/E/!©!426)d*!)gorjcuku!cffgf*/!!
`
`Vjcv!ku-!Ugevkqp!426)d*!ku!eqpegtpgf!ykvj!cnngikpi!kphtkpigogpv!qh!c!rcvgpv!
`igpgtcnn{-!cpf!pqv!urgekhke!enckou/!!Id.!!!!!
`
`Ceeqtfkpin{-!yg!ctg!pqv!rgtuwcfgf!d{!Rcvgpv!Qypgtu!ctiwogpv!cpf!
`
`fgvgtokpg!vjcv!vjg!Rgvkvkqp!ucvkuhkgu!Ugevkqp!426)d*/!!!
`C. Claims 36, 46, and 54 – Obviousness over Kawase and Kanai
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt!eqpvgpfu!vjcv!enckou!47-!57-!cpf!65!ctg!wprcvgpvcdng!wpfgt!
`
`46!W/U/E/!'!214)c*!cu!qdxkqwu!qxgt!Mcycug!cpf!Mcpck/!!Rgv/!33.41/!
`1. Kawase (Ex. 1002)
`
`!
`
`Mcycug!vgcejgu!c!ogvjqf!qh!ftkxkpi!c!fkurnc{!rcpgn!vjcv!eqttgevu!
`
`nwokpcpeg!xctkcvkqp!vjcv!ctkugu!cu!c!tguwnv!qh!ejcpig!qxgt!vkog/!!Gz/!2113-!
`
`2<9.26/!!Vjg!ogvjqf!kpenwfgu!vjg!uvgr!qh!ejcpikpi!c!nwokpcpeg!ugvvkpi!
`tghgtgpeg!xcnwg!ykvj!vjg!gncrukpi!qh!vkog/!!Id/!cv!6<27.29/!!Vjg!tgpgycn!
`
`kpvgtxcnu!ctg!ejcpigf!kp!ceeqtfcpeg!ykvj!vjg!ejctcevgtkuvkeu!qh!nwokpcpeg!
`fgitcfcvkqp/!!Id.!cv!6<2;.32/!!C!eqttgevkqp!qrgtcvkqp-!yjkej!kpenwfgu!vjg!
`
`ftkxkpi!qh!rkzgn!cpf!ecrvwtkpi!qh!nwokpcpeg!kphqtocvkqp-!ku!ecttkgf!qwv!
`ykvjkp!c!rgtkqf!pqv!chhgevkpi!xkfgq!ukipcn!qwvrwv/!!Id.!cv!6<38.3;/!!Itg{!uecng!
`vjgp!ku!tgcnk|gf/!!Id.!cv!6<42.48/!!Vjg!ftkxkpi!ogvjqf!ku!knnwuvtcvgf!kp!
`
`Hkiwtg!2-!tgrtqfwegf!dgnqy<!
`
`!
`
`22!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!22
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`
`!
`
`!
`
`Hkiwtg!2!knnwuvtcvgu!vjg!hnqy!qh!kprwvvgf!xkfgq!ukipcnu/!!Gz/!2113-!
`
`21<2;/!!Xkfgq!fgeqfgt!2!ugrctcvgu!cp!kprwv!eqorqukvg!xkfgq!ukipcn!kpvq!cp!
`TID!nwokpcpeg!ukipcn!cpf!jqtk|qpvcn!cpf!xgtvkecn!ukipcnu/!!Id.!cv!21<33.35/!!
`
`Vjg!TID!nwokpcpeg!ukipcn!ku!eqpxgtvgf!vq!c!fkikvcn!ukipcn!d{!C0F!
`eqpxgtvgt!4/!!Id.!cv!21<34.36/!!Eqpvtqnngt!3!tgegkxgu!vjg!jqtk|qpvcn!cpf!
`
`xgtvkecn!ukipcnu!htqo!xkfgq!fgeqfgt!2!cpf!igpgtcvgu!vkokpi!ukipcnu!vjcv!ctg!
`u{pejtqpk|gf!ykvj!vjg!jqtk|qpvcn!cpf!xgtvkecn!ukipcnu/!!Id.!cv!21<36.39/!
`
`Eqttgevkqp!ektewkv!23!wugu!c!xcnwg!tgncvgf!vq!nwokpcpeg!kp!qtfgt!vq!
`uwrrtguu!xctkcvkqp!kp!nwokpcpeg!dgvyggp!rkzgnu/!!Id.!cv!21<39.42/!!Hqt!c!
`
`fkurnc{!rcpgn!wukpi!gngevtqp.gokvvkpi!gngogpvu-!rjqurjqtu!cpf!cp!cpqfg!
`
`gngevtqfg!ctg!fkurqugf!qp!c!uwthceg!qrrqukpi!vjg!gngevtqp.gokvvkpi!gngogpvu-!
`
`cpf!vjg!ewttgpv!gokvvgf!htqo!gcej!rkzgn!ku!fgvgtokpgf!d{!ogcuwtkpi!vjg!
`coqwpv!qh!ewttgpv!hnqykpi!vq!vjg!cpqfg!gngevtqfg/!!Id.!cv!21<44.53/!!Kp!
`
`cffkvkqp-!vjg!ftkxkpi!ewttgpv!ukipcn!htqo!ukipcn!ftkxgt!8!ku!c!fgvgevgf!ftkxkpi!
`ukipcn!crrnkgf!vq!vjg!fkurnc{!rcpgn/!!Id.!cv!21<52.54/!!Gkvjgt!qh!vjgug!xcnwgu!
`
`23!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!23
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`
`oc{!dg!wugf!hqt!gttqt!eqttgevkqp/!!Gz/!2113-!21<54.55/!!Eqttgevkqp!xcnwg!
`
`ctkvjogvke!wpkv!7!rgthqtou!eqorctkuqp!qrgtcvkqpu!dgvyggp!xcnwgu!tgncvgf!vq!
`
`ogcuwtgf!nwokpcpeg!xcnwgu!cpf!vctigv!nwokpcpeg!xcnwgu!cpf!uvqtgu!vjg!
`fkhhgtgpegu!cu!eqttgevkqp!xcnwgu!kp!ogoqt{!6/!!Id.!cv!21<55.5;/!!Eqttgevqt!5!
`tgvtkgxgu!vjgug!xcnwgu!htqo!ogoqt{!6!cpf!rgthqtou!vjg!eqttgevkqp/!!Id.!cv!
`
`21<61.65/!
`2. Kanai (Ex. 1003)
`
`Mcpck!vgcejgu!c!ogvjqf!qh!eqttgevkpi!nwokpcpeg!wpgxgppguu!qh!c!
`
`fkurnc{!fgxkeg/!!Gz/!2114!‚!4/!!Vjg!fkurnc{!fgxkeg-!yjkej!kpenwfgu!c!
`
`eqttgevkqp!wpkv!cpf!c!rnwtcnkv{!qh!fkurnc{!gngogpvu-!rgthqtou!c!eqttgevkqp!qp!
`
`kprwv!ukipcnu!dghqtg!qwvrwvvkpi!vjg!ukipcnu!vq!tgurgevkxg!fkurnc{!gngogpvu/!!
`Id/!‚!21/!!
`
`Igpgtcnn{-!vjg!eqttgevkqp!ogvjqf!tgfwegu!qt!fgngvgu!uqog!htgswgpe{!
`
`eqorqpgpvu!htqo!coqpi!htgswgpe{!eqorqpgpvu!qh!nwokpcpeg!wpgxgppguu!
`kp!qtfgt!vq!mggr!vjg!wpgxgppguu!htqo!gcukn{!dgkpi!xkgygf/!!Id.!‚!32/!!Kp!
`
`ugngevkpi!vjg!htgswgpe{!eqorqpgpvu!vq!dg!tgfwegf!qt!fgngvgf-!vjg!ogvjqf!
`
`ugngevu!eqorqpgpvu!qh!jkijgt!htgswgpe{!vjcp!cv!ngcuv!qpg!qh!vjg!eqorqpgpvu!
`
`vq!dg!ockpvckpgf-!qt!ugngevu!eqorqpgpvu!qh!c!jkijgt!htgswgpe{!vjcp!c!
`rtgfgvgtokpgf!htgswgpe{/!!Id.!!
`
`Nwokpcpeg!wpgxgppguu!oc{!dg!ogcuwtgf!d{!ftkxkpi!kpfkxkfwcn!
`
`fkurnc{!gngogpvu!qp!vjg!dcuku!qh!kprwv!ukipcnu!jcxkpi!vjg!ucog!xcnwg!
`kpfkecvkxg!qh!c!rtgfgvgtokpgf!nwokpcpeg/!!Id.!‚!33/!!Ogcuwtgf!nwokpcpeg!
`
`fcvc!ku!ugpv!vq!c!eqttgevkqp!xcnwg!igpgtcvkpi!rctv!vjcv!ecnewncvgu!eqttgevkqp!
`xcnwgu/!!Id.!‚!75/!!Vjg!fkurnc{!fgxkeg!cnuq!ecnewncvgu!c!nwokpcpeg!vctigv!xcnwg!
`
`24!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!24
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`
`hqt!vjg!fkurnc{!gngogpv-!yjkej!ku!vjg!nwokpcpeg!qh!c!egtvckp!fkurnc{!gngogpv!
`
`vjcv!ku!qdvckpcdng!yjgp!nwokpcpeg!wpgxgppguu!ku!gnkokpcvgf!d{!kfgcn!
`
`eqttgevkqp!htgg!qh!eqttgevkqp!gttqt/!!Gz/!2114!¸!87/!!Gcej!htgswgpe{!
`
`eqorqpgpv!qh!vjg!nwokpcpeg!vctigv!xcnwgu!ku!pqv!itgcvgt!vjcp!vjg!nwokpcpeg!
`wpgxgppguu!fkuetkokpcvkqp!vjtgujqnf/!!Id.!‚!93/!!Vjg!eqttgevkqp!xcnwgu!ctg!
`
`ecnewncvgf!d{!fkxkfkpi!vjg!nwokpcpeg!vctigv!xcnwgu!d{!vjg!ogcuwtgf!
`nwokpcpeg!fcvc/!!Id.!‚‚!96-!212/!!Vjg!ecnewncvgf!eqttgevkqp!xcnwgu!vjgp!ctg!
`
`uvqtgf!kp!c!vcdng!cpf!wugf!d{!c!ownvkrnkgt!vq!ownvkrn{!vjg!kocig!fcvc!d{!vjg!
`
`eqttgevkqp!xcnwg-!yjkej!vjgp!qwvrwvu!kocig!fcvc!tgrtgugpvcvkxg!qh!eqttgevgf!
`nwokpcpeg!wpgxgppguu/!!Id.!‚‚!97-!214/!
`
`3. Analysis
`
`Vjg!gxkfgpeg!ugv!hqtvj!d{!Rgvkvkqpgt!ku!kpuwhhkekgpv!vq!rgtuwcfg!wu!vjcv!
`
`vjgtg!ku!c!tgcuqpcdng!nkmgnkjqqf!vjcv!Rgvkvkqpgt!yknn!rtgxckn!kp!ujqykpi!vjcv!
`
`enckou!47-!57-!cpf!65!ctg!wprcvgpvcdng!wpfgt!46!W/U/E/!'!214!cu!qdxkqwu!
`
`qxgt!Mcycug!cpf!Mcpck/!!Rgv/!33.41/!!Urgekhkecnn{-!yg!ctg!pqv!rgtuwcfgf!d{!
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt!vjcv!vjg!eqodkpcvkqp!qh!Mcycug!cpf!Mcpck!vgcejgu!qt!uwiiguvu!cnn!
`
`qh!vjg!nkokvcvkqpu!qh!enckou!47-!57-!cpf!65/!
`
`Kpfgrgpfgpv!encko!47!tgekvgu!c!ogvjqf!qh!kocig!rtqeguukpi!vjcv!
`
`eqortkugu!hqt!gcej!qh!c!rnwtcnkv{!qh!rkzgnu!qh!c!fkurnc{-!qdvckpkpi!c!ogcuwtg!
`
`qh!c!nkijv.qwvrwv!tgurqpug!qh!cv!ngcuv!c!rqtvkqp!qh!vjg!rkzgn!cv!gcej!qh!c!
`
`rnwtcnkv{!qh!ftkxkpi!ngxgnu/!!Kpfgrgpfgpv!enckou!52!cpf!64-!htqo!yjkej!
`
`enckou!57!cpf!65!fgrgpf-!tgurgevkxgn{-!tgekvg!ukoknct!nkokvcvkqpu/!!Rgvkvkqpgt!
`
`eqpvgpfu!vjcv!Mcycug!fguetkdgu!vjcv!nwokpcpeg!kphqtocvkqp!htqo!cnn!vjg!
`
`rkzgnu!ku!ecrvwtgf!d{!vjg!nwokpcpeg!ecrvwtkpi!ogcpu!cpf!ku!eqorctgf!ykvj!
`
`25!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!25
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`
`]c_!vctigv!nwokpcpeg/!!Rgv/!33.34!)ekvkpi!Gz/!2113-!28<42.45*/!!Rgvkvkqpgt!
`
`hwtvjgt!eqpvgpfu!vjcv!Mcycug!fguetkdgu!vjcv-!]y_jgp!vjgtg!ku!c!fgxkcvkqp!
`
`htqo!vjg!vctigv!nwokpcpeg-!ftkxkpi!xqnvcig!ku!ejcpigf!cpf!nwokpcpeg!ku!
`
`ogcuwtgf!cickp!wpvkn!c!xqnvcig!xcnwg!vjcv!eqpxgtigu!vq!vjg!vctigv!nwokpcpeg!
`ku!fgvgtokpgf/!!Id.!)ekvkpi!Gz/!2113-!28<45.52*/!!Ceeqtfkpin{-!Rgvkvkqpgt!
`
`eqpvgpfu!vjcv!Mcycug!fguetkdgu!vjku!nkokvcvkqp/!!!
`
`Encko!47!hwtvjgt!tgekvgu!
`
`oqfkh{kpi! c! ocr! qh! vjg! fkurnc{! vjcv! ku! dcugf! qp! vjg! qdvckpgf!
`ogcuwtgu-! uckf! oqfkh{kpi!
`kpenwfkpi-! ykvj! tgurgev!
`vq! c!
`ocipkvwfg!qh!c!eqorqpgpv!jcxkpi!c!urcvkcn!rgtkqf!dgvyggp!qpg!
`cpf! hkhv{! oknnkogvgtu-! fgetgcukpi! c! ocipkvwfg! qh! c! eqorqpgpv!
`jcxkpi!c!urcvkcn!rgtkqf!nguu!vjcp!qpg!oknnkogvgt!cpf!fgetgcukpi!
`c!ocipkvwfg!qh!c!eqorqpgpv!jcxkpi!c!urcvkcn!rgtkqf!itgcvgt!vjcp!
`hkhv{!oknnkogvgtu/!
`
`Enckou!57!cpf!65!tgekvg!ukoknct!nkokvcvkqpu/!!Rgvkvkqpgt!cempqyngfigu!vjcv!
`
`Mcycug!fqgu!pqv!fkuenqug!fgetgcukpi!c!ocipkvwfg!qh!eqorqpgpvu!jcxkpi!c!
`
`urcvkcn!rgtkqf!nguu!vjcp!qpg!oknnkogvgt!cpf!itgcvgt!vjcp!hkhv{!oknnkogvgtu/!!
`Id/!!Rgvkvkqpgt!eqpvgpfu!vjcv!Mcpck!fguetkdgu!c!uvgr!qh!tgfwekpi!
`
`rtgfgvgtokpgf!jkij!htgswgpe{!eqorqpgpvu!cpf!tgfwekpi!rtgfgvgtokpgf!nqy!
`
`htgswgpe{!eqorqpgpvu!htqo!coqpi!htgswgpe{!eqorqpgpvu!qh!urcvkcn!
`htgswgpe{!fcvc/!!Id/!)ekvkpi!Gz/!2114!‚‚!25-!27*/!!Mcpck!fkuenqugu!
`
`urgekhkecnn{!vjcv!jkij.htgswgpe{!]wpgxgppguu_!ku!crrtqzkocvgn{!eqorngvgn{!
`
`gnkokpcvgf!cpf!nqy.htgswgpe{!wpgxgppguu!ku!tgfwegf!vq!c!pginkikdng!fgitgg/!!
`
`Gz/!2114!‚!99/!!!
`
`!
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt!cempqyngfigu!vjcv!Mcpck!hcknu!vq!gzrnkekvn{!fkuenqug!vjg!
`
`urgekhke!urcvkcn!rgtkqfu!qh!qpg!cpf!hkhv{!oknnkogvgtu/!!Rgv/!41/!!Rgvkvkqpgt!
`
`26!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!26
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`
`ctiwgu-!jqygxgt-!vjcv!urcvkcn!rgtkqfu!dgnqy!qpg!oknnkogvgt!cpf!cdqxg!hkhv{!
`
`oknnkogvgtu!ctg!kp!ceeqtfcpeg!ykvj!jwocp!rgtegrvwcn!nkokvcvkqpu-!cpf-!
`
`dgecwug!Mcpck!fkuenqugu!tgfwekpi!qt!gnkokpcvkpi!eqorqpgpvu!ceeqtfkpi!vq!
`
`jwocp!rgtegrvwcn!nkokvcvkqpu-!vjg!urcvkcn!rgtkqfu!qh!qpg!cpf!hkhv{!oknnkogvgtu!
`yqwnf!jcxg!dggp!qdxkqwu!vq!qpg!qh!qtfkpct{!umknn!kp!vjg!ctv/!!Id.!!Rgvkvkqpgt!
`
`ctiwgu!vjcv!qpg!qh!qtfkpct{!umknn!kp!vjg!ctv!yqwnf!jcxg!dggp!oqvkxcvgf!vq!
`
`oqfkh{!vjg!u{uvgo!qh!Mcycug!ykvj!Mcpcku!vgcejkpi!qh!tgfwekpi!qt!
`
`gnkokpcvkpi!htgswgpe{!eqorqpgpvu!qwvukfg!qh!c!rcuucig!tgikqp!dgecwug!
`
`Mcpck!vgcejgu!vjcv!vjku!tgfwegu!wpgxgppguu!cpf!kortqxgu!kocig!swcnkv{/!!
`Id.!)ekvkpi!Gz/!2114!‚‚!98-!99*/!!!
`
`!
`
`Yg!ctg!pqv!rgtuwcfgf!d{!Rgvkvkqpgt/!!Rgvkvkqpgt!jcu!pqv!rtqxkfgf!
`
`gxkfgpeg!vq!uwrrqtv!vjg!ctiwogpv!vjcv!fgetgcukpi!vjg!ocipkvwfg!qh!c!
`
`eqorqpgpv!ykvj!c!urcvkcn!rgtkqf!dgnqy!qpg!oknnkogvgt!cpf!fgetgcukpi!vjg!
`
`ocipkvwfg!qh!c!eqorqpgpv!cdqxg!hkhv{!oknnkogvgtu!yqwnf!jcxg!dggp!qdxkqwu!
`
`vq!c!rgtuqp!ykvj!qtfkpct{!umknn!kp!vjg!ctv/!!Rgvkvkqpgt!cnuq!fqgu!pqv!rtqxkfg!
`
`uwhhkekgpv!gxkfgpeg!vq!uwrrqtv!vjg!ctiwogpv!vjcv!urcvkcn!rgtkqfu!dgnqy!qpg!
`
`oknnkogvgt!cpf!cdqxg!hkhv{!oknnkogvgtu!ctg!kp!ceeqtfcpeg!ykvj!jwocp!
`
`rgtegrvwcn!nkokvcvkqpu/!!Cnvjqwij!dcuke!mpqyngfig!cxckncdng!vq!c!rgtuqp!ykvj!
`
`qtfkpct{!umknn!kp!vjg!ctv!oc{!rtqxkfg!c!tgcuqp!vq!eqodkpg!gngogpvu!kp!rtkqt!
`ctv-!kv!fqgu!pqv!guvcdnkuj!vjg!rtgugpeg!qh!vjg!gngogpv!kvugnh/!!See!K/S HIMPP
`v. Hear-Wear Techs., LLC-!862!H/4f!2473-!2476.2477!)Hgf/!Ekt/!3125*/
`
`Igpgtcn!eqpenwukqpu!cdqwv!yjcv!ku!dcuke!mpqyngfig!ctg!pqv!c!uwduvkvwvg!hqt!
`fqewogpvct{!gxkfgpeg!hqt!fguetkdkpi!eqtg!hcev!hkpfkpi/!!Id. Jgtg-!yg!ctg!pqv!
`
`27!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!27
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`
`rgtuwcfgf!d{!Rgvkvkqpgt!vjcv!uwej!nkokvcvkqpu!yqwnf!jcxg!dggp!qdxkqwu!vq!c!
`
`rgtuqp!ykvj!qtfkpct{!umknn!kp!vjg!ctv/!!!
`
`!
`
`Hwtvjgtoqtg-!yg!ctg!rgtuwcfgf!d{!Rcvgpv!Qypgt!vjcv!Mcpck!fqgu!pqv!
`
`fguetkdg!gzrnkekvn{!fgetgcukpi!vjg!ocipkvwfg!qh!c!eqorqpgpv!jcxkpi!c!urcvkcn!
`
`rgtkqf!dgnqy!c!urgekhkgf!xcnwg!cpf!fgetgcukpi!vjg!ocipkvwfg!qh!c!eqorqpgpv!
`
`jcxkpi!c!urcvkcn!rgtkqf!cdqxg!c!urgekhkgf!xcnwg/!!Rtgnko/!Tgur/!28.33/!!
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt!ctiwgu!vjcv!Mcpck!fkuenqugu!vjcv!crrn{kpi!eqttgevkqp!rtqeguukpi!
`
`crrtqzkocvgn{!eqorngvgn{!gnkokpcvgu!vjg!jkij.htgswgpe{!wpgxgppguu!cpf!
`
`tgfwegu!vjg!nqy.htgswgpe{!wpgxgppguu!vq!c!pginkikdng!fgitgg/!!Rgv/!34!
`
`)ekvkpi!Gz/!2114!‚!99*/!!Hkiwtgu!9D!cpf!9F-!tgrtqfwegf!dgnqy-!knnwuvtcvg!vjg!
`
`gnkokpcvkqp!qh!jkij.htgswgpe{!cpf!nqy.htgswgpe{!wpgxgppguu<!
`
`!
`
`Hkiwtg!9D!knnwuvtcvgu!nwokpcpeg!wpgxgppguu!hqt!rkzgnu-!cpf!Hkiwtg!9F!
`
`knnwuvtcvgu!vjg!eqttgevkqp!qh!vjg!wpgxgppguu!qh!rkzgnu/!!Gz/!2114!‚‚!98.99/!!
`
`Yg!ctg!pqv!rgtuwcfgf-!jqygxgt-!vjcv!vjg!ocipkvwfgu!qh!dqvj!jkij.htgswgpe{!
`cpf!nqy.htgswgpe{!xcnwgu-!kp!Hkiwtg!9D-!ctg!decreased!kp!qtfgt!vq!rtqxkfg!
`
`vjg!eqttgevkqp!xcnwgu!kp!Hkiwtg!9F/!!!
`
`!
`
`Ceeqtfkpin{-!Rgvkvkqpgt!jcu!pqv!ujqyp!c!tgcuqpcdng!nkmgnkjqqf!qh!
`
`rtgxcknkpi!kp!ujqykpi!vjcv!enckou!47-!57-!cpf!65!qh!vjg!818!rcvgpv!yqwnf!
`
`jcxg!dggp!qdxkqwu!qxgt!Mcycug!cpf!Mcpck/!
`
`28!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!28
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`
`D. Claim 64 – Anticipation by Kamada
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt!eqpvgpfu!vjcv!encko!75!ku!wprcvgpvcdng!wpfgt!46!W/U/E/!
`
`'!213)g*!cu!cpvkekrcvgf!d{!Mcocfc/!!Rgv/!41.43/!!Qtkikpcn!encko!75!fgrgpfgf!
`htqo!encko!73/!!See Gz/!2112-!47<27.2;/!!Encko!75-!cu!cogpfgf!d{!vjg!
`818!E2!egtvkhkecvg-!pqy!fgrgpfu!htqo!cancelled!encko!;5/!!Gz/!3116-!2<43.
`
`47/!!Rgvkvkqpgt!qpn{!rtgugpvu!ctiwogpvu!fktgevgf!vq!qtkikpcn!encko!75-!cu!
`
`fgrgpfkpi!htqo!encko!73-!cpf!fqgu!pqv!rtgugpv!cp{!ctiwogpvu!cu!vq!vjg!
`nkokvcvkqpu!tgekvgf!d{!cancelled!encko!;5/!!Rgv/!41.43/!!Rgvkvkqpgt!dgctu!vjg!
`
`dwtfgp!qh!ujqykpi!vjcv!Mcocfc!fkuenqugu!vjg!nkokvcvkqpu!qh!fgrgpfgpv!
`
`encko!75!cpf!vjg!enckou!htqo!yjkej!encko!75!fgrgpfu-!fktgevn{!qt!kpfktgevn{/!!
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt!jcu!pqv!rtqxkfgf!uwhhkekgpv!gxkfgpeg!vq!fgoqpuvtcvg!vjcv!Mcocfc!
`
`fkuenqugu!vjg!nkokvcvkqpu!75!cu!fgrgpfkpi!htqo!encko!;5/!!Ceeqtfkpin{-!
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt!jcu!pqv!guvcdnkujgf!vjcv!vjgtg!ku!c!tgcuqpcdng!nkmgnkjqqf!vjcv!
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt!yqwnf!rtgxckn!kp!ujqykpi!vjg!wprcvgpvcdknkv{!qh!encko!75!cu!
`
`cpvkekrcvgf!d{!Mcocfc/!!!
`E. Claims 101-104 – Obvious over Greene and Kamada
`
`Rgvkvkqpgt!eqpvgpfu!vjcv!enckou!212.215!ctg!wprcvgpvcdng!wpfgt!
`
`46!W/U/E/!'!214!cu!qdxkqwu!qxgt!Itggpg!cpf!Mcocfc/!!Rgv/!49.53/!!Qtkikpcn!
`
`encko!212!fgrgpfgf!htqo!encko!211/!!Gz/!2112-!49<44.45/!!Encko!212-!cu!
`
`cogpfgf!d{!vjg!818!E2!egtvkhkecvg-!kpenwfgu!vjg!ucog!nkokvcvkqpu!cu!qtkikpcn!
`
`encko!212-!dwv!ku!ytkvvgp!kp!kpfgrgpfgpv!hqto!vq!kpeqtrqtcvg!vjg!nkokvcvkqpu!
`qh!kvu!qtkikpcn!dcug!encko-!kpfgrgpfgpv!encko!211/!!Gz/!3116-!3<66.4<3=!see
`also Gz/!2112-!49<33.45/!!Cu!uwej-!qtkikpcn!encko!212!cpf!cogpfgf!encko!
`
`212!ctg!kfgpvkecn!kp!ueqrg/!!Cnvjqwij!Rgvkvkqpgt!cpf!Rcvgpv!Qypgt!qpn{!jcxg!
`
`29!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!29
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`
`rtgugpvgf!ctiwogpvu!fktgevgf!vq!qtkikpcn!encko!212-!yg!hkpf!vjcv!vjg!ucog!
`
`ctiwogpvu!crrn{!vq!cogpfgf!encko!212!dgecwug!vjg!ueqrg!qh!qtkikpcn!encko!
`
`212!cpf!vjcv!qh!cogpfgf!encko!212!ctg!kfgpvkecn/!!Ceeqtfkpin{-!qwt!cpcn{uku!
`
`jgtg!ku!qh!cogpfgf!encko!212/!!!!!
`1. Greene (Ex. 1008)
`
`Itggpg!vgcejgu!ogvjqfu!hqt!eqttgevkpi!urcvkcn!pqp.wpkhqtokvkgu!kp!vjg!
`
`dtkijvpguu!qh!gngevtqpke!fkurnc{u/!!Gz/!2119-!2<9.24/!!Itggpg!fguetkdgu!
`
`ugxgtcn!ogvjqfu!hqt!mggrkpi!c!tguwnvcpv!nwokpcpeg!uwduvcpvkcnn{!eqpuvcpv!
`wukpi!cevkxg!eqpvtqn!ogcpu/!!Id. cv!9<56.58/!!Vjg!eqttgevkqp!ogvjqfu!
`
`kpeqtrqtcvg!vjg!ogcuwtgogpv!qh!dtkijvpguu!ejctcevgtkuvkeu!qh!vjg!fkurnc{!cpf!
`ecp!dg!crrnkgf!vq!ugngevgf!rkzgnu!qt!cnn!qh!vjg!rkzgnu/!!Id.!cv!5<45.47/!!Vjg!
`
`ogcuwtgf!fcvc!ku!uvqtgf!cpf!vjgp!ugngevkxgn{!tgvtkgxgf!fwtkpi!vjg!qrgtcvkqp!
`
`qh!vjg!fkurnc{!cpf!wugf!vq!uecng!cpf0qt!kpvgtrqncvg!ftkxg!ukipcnu!kp!tgcn.vkog/!!
`Id.!cv!5<4;.55/!!Eqttgevkqpu!ctg!ocfg!ykvj!tgurgev!vq!c!ejqugp!tghgtgpeg!
`
`u{uvgo!uwej!vjcv!cp{!tgockpkpi!itcfwcn!cpf!cdtwrv!dtkijvpguu!pqp.
`
`wpkhqtokvkgu!qxgt!vjg!ugngevgf!rkzgnu!hcnn!dgnqy!vjg!jwocp!g{gu!fgvgevcdng!
`nwokpcpeg!vjtgujqnf!wpfgt!kpvgpfgf!xkgykpi!eqpfkvkqpu/!!Id.!cv!5<62.66/!!Vjg!
`
`nwokpcpeg!eqttgevkqp!ogvjqf!ku!knnwuvtcvgf!kp!Hkiwtg!5-!tgrtqfwegf!dgnqy<!!!!!
`
`2;!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!2;
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`
`!
`
`Hkiwtg!5!ku!c!dnqem!fkcitco!qh!vjg!nwokpcpeg!eqttgevkqp!ogvjqf-!
`
`yjkej!kpenwfgu!fcvc!kprwv-!nwokpcpeg!uecngt0cffgt!67-!egpvtcn!tcpfqo!ceeguu!
`
`ogoqt{!65-!fkurnc{!eqpvtqnngt!63-!tqy!ftkxgtu!63c-!cpf!eqnwop!ftkxgtu!63d/!!
`
`Gz/!2119-!21<59.69/!!Nwokpcpeg!uecngt0cffgt!67!tgegkxgu!fcvc!kprwv-!uwej!cu!
`
`xkfgq!fcvc-!cpf!tgeqorwvgu!vjg!eqnqt!eqqtfkpcvgu!qh!vjg!tgegkxgf!fcvc!kprwv!
`dcugf!qp!nwokpcpeg!tcvkqu!uvqtgf!kp!egpvtcn!tcpfqo!ceeguu!ogoqt{!65/!!Id.!cv!
`
`21<64.69/!!Cu!c!tguwnv!qh!vjku!tgeqorwvkpi-!vjg!eqnqt!eqqtfkpcvgu!ctg!
`pqtocnk|gf!hqt!vjg!kpvgpfgf!nkijv!fkurnc{/!!Id.!cv!21<6;.72/!!Vjgp-!fkurnc{!
`
`eqpvtqnngt!63-!yjkej!ku!qrgtcvkxgn{!eqppgevgf!vq!tqy!ftkxgtu!63c!cpf!eqnwop!
`ftkxgtu!63d-!tgegkxgu!vjg!pqtocnk|gf!fcvc/!!Id.!cv!21<64.67/!!C!oqfkhkgf!rkzgn!
`uvtgco!vjgp!ku!qwvrwv!vq!ftkxgtu!63c!cpf!63d/!!Id. cv!22<9.22/!!!!
`2. Kamada (Ex. 1004)
`
`Mcocfc!vgcejgu!c!fkurnc{!eqttgevkqp!ektewkv!cpf!c!fkurnc{!crrctcvwu!
`
`vjcv!eqttgev!wpgxgp!kocig!crrgctcpeg!ecwugf!d{!vjg!fkurnc{!crrctcvwu/!!
`
`Gz/!2115!‚!3/!!Mcocfc!fguetkdgu!c!ogoqt{!vjcv!uvqtgu!hktuv!fcvc!kpfkecvkxg!qh!
`
`uk|g!cpf!rqukvkqp!qh!c!tgevcpiwnct!tgikqp!qp!vjg!fkurnc{!uetggp!cpf!ugeqpf!
`
`31!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!31
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`
`fcvc!kpfkecvkxg!qh!itc{!ngxgn!ejcpigu!kp!c!uwttqwpfkpi!tgikqp!ctqwpf!vjg!
`
`tgevcpiwnct!tgikqp!kp!cp!kuqogvtke!ocppgt!ykvj!tgurgev!vq!c!jqtk|qpvcn!cpf!
`xgtvkecn!fktgevkqp/!!Id/!‚!2;/!!Cp!kocig!rtqeguukpi!wpkv!cflwuvu!itc{!ngxgn!qh!
`kocig!fcvc!kp!tgurqpug!vq!vjg!hktuv!fcvc!cpf!ugeqpf!fcvc/!!Id.!!Vjg!kocig!
`
`rtqeguukpi!crrctcvwu!ku!knnwuvtcvgf!kp!Hkiwtg!2-!tgrtqfwegf!dgnqy<!
`
`!
`
`Hkiwtg!2!ku!c!fkcitco!qh!vjg!nkswkf!et{uvcn!fkurnc{!crrctcvwu!vjcv!
`
`kpenwfgu!kocig!rtqeguukpi!crrctcvwu!22-!ogoqt{!23-!ukipcn!uqwteg!24-!cpf!
`
`nkswkf!et{uvcn!fkurnc{!rcpgn!25/!!Gz/!2115!‚‚!52.53/!!Ukipcn!uqwteg!24!
`
`uwrrnkgu!kocig!fcvc!ukipcnu!hqt!fkurnc{!qp!nkswkf!et{uvcn!fkurnc{!rcpgn!25/!!
`Id. ‚!53/!!Kocig!rtqeguukpi!crrctcvwu!22!eqttgevu!vjg!kocig!fcvc!ukipcnu!
`
`dcugf!qp!eqttgevkqp!fcvc!uvqtgf!d{!ogoqt{!23!cpf!uwrrnkgu!vjg!eqttgevgf!
`kocig!fcvc!ukipcnu!vq!nkswkf!et{uvcn!fkurnc{!rcpgn!25/!!Id.!
`
`Cp!ctgc!vq!dg!eqttgevgf!ku!urgekhkgf!d{!vyq!rqkpvu!eqttgurqpfkpi!vq!vjg!
`vqr!nghv!eqtpgt!cpf!vjg!dqvvqo!tkijv!eqtpgt!qh!c!tgevcpiwnct!tgikqp/!!Id.!‚!56/!!
`
`Eqpuvcpv!eqttgevkqp!xcnwg!m-!yjkej!eqttgurqpfu!vq!cp!coqwpv!qh!ujkhv!d{!
`yjkej!c!itc{!ngxgn!ku!ejcpigf-!ku!crrnkgf!vq!vjg!tgevcpiwnct!tgikqp/!!Id.!!
`
`Eqpuvcpv!eqttgevkqp!xcnwg!m!ku!fgetgcugf!itcfwcnn{!kp!c!tgikqp!uwttqwpfkpi!
`
`vjg!tgevcpiwnct!tgikqp-!yjgtg!vjg!uwttqwpfkpi!tgikqp!jcu!c!urgekhkgf!ykfvj!
`32!
`
`Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE!Gzjkdkv!3113-!Rcig!32
`Vjg!Enqtqz!Eqorcp{!x/!Cwvq.Mcru-!NNE-!Ecug!Pq/!KRT3127.11932
`
`
`
`KRT3125.11469!
`Rcvgpv!WU!TG54-818!G!
`!
`uwttqwpfkpi!vjg!tgevcpiwnct!tgikqp/!!Id.!!Vjwu-!vjg!eqttgevkqp!xcnwg!ku!m!cv!vjg!
`
`gfig!qh!vjg!tgevcpiwnct!tgikqp!cpf!fgetgcugu!vq!|gtq!cv!vjg!gfig!qh!vjg!
`uwttqwpfkpi!tgikqp/!!Id.!
`3. Analysis
`
`Vjg!gxkfgpeg!ugv!hqtvj!d{!Rgvkvkqpgt!rgtuwcfgu!wu!vjcv!vjgtg!ku!c!
`
`tgcuqpcdng!nkmgnkjqqf!qh!kvu!rtgxcknkpi!kp!
Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.
After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.
Accept $ Charge
Still Working On It
This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.
Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.
A few More Minutes ... Still Working
It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.
Thank you for your continued patience.
This document could not be displayed.
We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.
Your account does not support viewing this document.
You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.
Your account does not support viewing this document.
Set your membership
status to view this document.
With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll
get a whole lot more, including:
- Up-to-date information for this case.
- Email alerts whenever there is an update.
- Full text search for other cases.
- Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.
One Moment Please
The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.
Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.
Your document is on its way!
If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.
Sealed Document
We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.
If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.
Access Government Site
