throbber
Ranbaxy Ex. 1009
`IPR Petition - USP 9,050,302
`
`

`
`
`
`LE3 JUUR NAL CANAIDIEN DE.
`
`S(;‘.[E:‘N.
`
`
`1:5 NEE: R151.-C§¥(3EQi.7F.‘~§
`
`Effects of Nocturnal GLamma-Hydxwxybutyrate on
`Sleep/g Waking Pattemg in Narc0lepsy—Catap1&:xy
`
`¥U)Gl7,R §:'fROU('1ii§{'§(.}N mid ;‘u§(")E'-2_'|"IT:"-.<'1I'[1
`
`fix-1.»-‘°.?,\/II‘.I.\...>’».1~’.
`
`,0<..>:’t*-
`(Ymrinzmzv; 4«F“~/z<2::r‘
`§_T,i§M3VI;‘\R\":
`5 qt" s‘,’m=*_;_a;‘mzfcfny ;,.>r:r~
`'
`:sr)lm‘ mm:
`
`
`’ >’?1fz.‘L;"-W? M ;=:rl:’erm wé!/2‘
`‘
`.
`
`~<*;1r:‘§,.<Jfe.x1‘ f3*'fz‘%r“s? ;'.*_.~2.:"I' mt " 7~!(?
`.:'af‘£'.W“);‘z‘-“/’J:‘s.4flf2>:'{rm')r~{!.a\F‘!i‘flv w;;
`‘
`:.::a*2:m2:,:-!r1'.:im.»u‘.5mi,__w"c::<*
`(C:‘BI{].
`
`
`

`;w‘:«":
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`i?'€'E"R(}[)L’(‘,?‘I'1£)?\‘
`
`rs? 111::
`pi-1LhO§{€iI1CS§:~1
`T115:
`
`dajwixnu dmx
`new zmzj
`sl_es]~.« emfl.C§«:.~e
`m nar«;:<:l¢rp‘sj»; and emf’
`the m,:xi1im:w,v
`s3»'m[3£u:ns.' mi cazapiaxz
`hypmag
`
`
`E1aE§u:i11;i£im“1.~3.
`am!
`Sltic‘) para!‘
`mmxizx pawn» uzlciarsimmi
`Iht’ d
`emu z:p;;1c:m3 m Faiistili imxn im1"c~;~,:.~;mi
`
`pi
`..~su.rc fin siccgn m’ im‘ :1ub~cu:upu—
`
`Imus m
`A}: at
`um;x;;rcL<1.e<i {isms
`clurérlg iéw sErcp;’\»:;tk§r1g :,:}=u‘;(;a
`Ixm’
`i$m.s;<;~. 1‘msc;:1s, <;m1tm1 ncw:m.s; systcxn
`.:x‘timniz1.nr.<; am! nihw I:yp«::; M Slczsp
`s1113;m:..ssi:1g, m¢:e::iH::z~:ti<irz‘1s
`I‘:-‘kw Emmi
`u.~4(~‘:d m cnmrol ms mam c>41z5.t;n:":,~:
`
`{7.:—m_rm1::. W?‘ Der:/1:2mI
`:31 31., 389%).
`Iiitlr. ix»
`lu2:.1wr:,, h(>\*.’€\’m‘, ahmn h,c,m»'
`:<sc..tcE*1 %n<:e'c:asv:.<§
`p€Li:»‘~:1zt‘(3 «lemmas. In
`rcccllé t;:t;1:‘>a.,
`inv‘c:stigm<:rs; haw pm
`Exlcreasxzwgg uttsanfiom, m the :x,c2cmm.f~:l
`2
`scstmxia, which so D{iI&'H..Et!.\L§C8]l'\
`a
`;;"mmncm cmnplzzim.
`én
`this ‘m;
`L
`{E);m'ac':]3;,
`I934; Zzarconc.
`1.7’
`I)cn1c:1l
`rt! 21]‘. E‘)"¥€~),
`‘ifiing modem
`gm1y2sm'1n'a(ngmpmc {Still qwss,
`it hm;
`mmn 5l'I:;m-‘I1 rm: 1“t3f$U€'.».‘_~o mgln
`iixicxxxiymci iyy :‘t1w:r.:m;:me111d pe2"§uds
`mi‘ m.a:1§x<.-.é"=Lc1z1c.w’*‘s,
`is ca typiuail {callus <32’
`n2.m:c:s.§cpay-caiapficxjg
`{Re:chtsc!19z§”
`ca 31,, 106:2; Bmughmn.;1m'l }v1:mr:E21
`I976; M"2ntp1aée::irm;’m]., Us . wcél
`:93; Emixzg;1h:'mrn1a2]3ri"t .un
`:,c:<;$,mgi1§
`
`a§L*L“gi %s.: Mien rt’-ciaaucci §n I<_31;He.iu1';1 ’
`:1
`
`
`{Rm:cl1I5c31aI"f:3I1 at 521.,
`I”? 3; Mammal ‘
`. it
`GT,
`L11‘,
`i‘,'}'75.3’
`é‘\»4e1x“_z‘xz:hI§«’. CTm'1.x;m aim!
`
`$t~£3*&‘V-EQEYEQK in pr ma),
`:1
`in
`:1r1:m‘i(—-.
`f]th¢;!:*
`:)Emc:'.'\r;:%i<3I1s;
`
`Va 2313' M" s0tt.i:1g,s. f1;m.‘2aI;m 31134 "‘
`an
`iIR1}?CirI‘IE:tlt mm for
`nm“t1:1’11a2I
`4;3‘ys».'s<_m1r1%;1
`311;
`that Lir;“v=‘c:§e1m:11m1r 05" Ehz:
`Elln .. .. 5~1ic3(tp
`.,‘§:m§1i::H'
`11:2
`iémwr:
`.
`c:h:§u':ac€,c:ris;tic
`_.,uh p21t'§:2nt.:<
`Iv»
`L
`;nrcnd1,a-uaaci by :ut<:re»:% H wrp
`Emmi‘
`3-5m‘
`e;k;;:mm%x:,
`an'an*1pr5
`(fumes.
`i‘,?>mz:1 made:
`{C3
`:'&tah§Esh
`9:3 minum
`(l.\.T:‘xmkudnn
`amii Dsmcm,
`19'
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`F1~Lfll{LiAl~2"‘r‘
`
`I§3f,"sf.§— -— 2?‘;
`
`.<!c:y;",fr:s¢;=“ ;w“l:"
`!».5e>(r']1 (md R’
`~
`()5 ;,J..’'<);;€,>!E}.;’£I‘
`, mi‘fIz_-21
`4')!‘
`
`Em?“ téflfc‘
`
`_
`
`
`
`I'tm—'
`
`rJI(Ic1('!w; eff
`, mm’
`:'<.‘es Mm! 4.’u_s5-
`; =r'rrgJir.w:.e‘
`>:Lu;um::’_‘.-'zmgrr
`‘
`'
`
`of mmw1‘§,1.>Vw.~r5;’/mu.
`I mix’; mm’
`
`
`
`,or:z‘rf2.'):(:5i:m°.'
`§er'J'.'
`dz:?=E'»‘€‘,Y
`cf!"
`
`v:'urzms3q~ rg,2"’(r‘_rm—? m 3::
`,
`>
`
`511*
`(Fm .*i:m7.!§'€‘r'
`’
`.
`ff? !}f.‘« ’§lN’c’.\‘.
`w:u‘er'
`
`if _a'frqra wax n*c;tzza‘aci In
`m’*.~‘ mic! !'n:':"cIm¢'
`.-lam’ _f}‘z.figr.v:w:!«'“x.f.
`174:‘
`
`_wmi:.e4.’an'i;c.
`
`c.’.=‘+71.::‘r:¢: mm‘: :
`ans:
`R[~_"s*.1
`.«:a>2ft:.rt:!w's‘
`M’. Le mmrwze 61' {N25 9.‘
`.§\'7I?U??
`
`
`
`
`fie
`F? rm: m:,»:'m_ w‘qzw:;«:.s'
`,'.>«.*rm’u,m‘
`}e:_:i.'e'«
`
`m'a’.~‘ ¢f.~'m'm*
`6'! M 9',m’
`*
`. n.~m’:'i
`
`
`.,n).m= ;w':.:fm.1g<>1~‘:s:
`,/1:; nzkmm ~r’£:.ru,n:::a /ax
`
`m;7:’.<m"r»'~. ml.’ We mm 1*e5m’:4:';’ 1!: wt um:
`2‘:!u.w ::"crcw‘=.$‘
`rimrmtw‘
`:16 m:.r2.rm—'££‘.
`'
`!::;a»‘¢wir,vmt-t‘
`c?{
`dZ2::;r<=*.
`m,z2—
`Izfzmw an '!f¢7.5I‘t“.§n.
`i’..’m* .mn.*r;ve,u”c*Isv.“v ::;HZ.I’it-
`a:,‘.v”c
`:7.’ msmse a (W e;-*!r'.rc"‘}’iL‘:m‘u mm‘ mm:
`c£u=‘.n§r'£g{t’.‘s 1;vi'Nv.w.:'.'.< Jr u::*'.r,r';~_xigyfmrgirfuna . t’ N":-‘
`
`(I was ms’
`r:_,»':,r:mr.~‘frz}»1v
`.r!::=
`lr'F5*e?rJ“::‘.I1<‘r" nu
`fin‘:
`.\§I'r,'(r‘J'4’.’:‘fa*.l)."P'IX rs
`wm: Qzzm.n» aim;
`mflaqr’ rm! my —
`v zmm; m.v'.~.rfn’.azr.*»
`
`.
`_
`Is‘:
`3‘
`;W‘»§¢;".‘l't!,*l1’,s
`, mzrmzr
`f.’
`~
`."!qu.n‘,s* N we"
`u’r;.sz:;‘,w.5' F/eivw‘
`4:16 gm‘; mfg‘
`.s'.!i..rm:!cm:.-z
`
`
`
`
`
`z‘Irn*?—
`
`
`
`i;':m.r'x mm 63 is
`..
`‘,1
`zmnn « m—'r:.rzr N ,—
`
`
`(IS~’W'”
`.
`5 W .e"c=ur
`._wur:t..wm’ 1:»-‘_A.»v(:;mw‘
`
`
`.mi1‘r:7I5’-,E:rmmm.
`‘
`(,r;,:;1.*”r’ia?'
`a1"r.<
`u(s{*(;rrfi£’ 57 NF’ Ei7f’)E|i’l'v'!_Jf‘é§e."‘
`(‘<’{'.’
`(‘I
`
`x'rr:m~z:a'
`'
`arr W25‘ azz:gr.rzeme:Iv’r‘>rs du
`’
`xmmm-'1s" mu rim mzciim‘
`:‘.:°rzr8: E@'w.W2»
`r‘!?r:‘€iL‘fidffcsu!'<‘3‘Jl1.§{5(fzJL‘,\‘
`{Em m‘cr:‘a"m'
`.3 en‘ 4} 6?
`Jr
`f!"/miss-r.»'e>' «fit
`‘:.wmm'f ;"L’c ;.~m.u'cwrI
`
`
`
`
`flu W'h‘],.’.$ I7¢‘J:‘!:{."il4”‘ .:':f§!:x* rs
`‘
`' «Jr: wrrm-.v '1’).
`6’!
`;,!.w awe‘
`(ii
`'
`n"§.:'
`.m1r.z'r“
`»' Mei
`
`
`mmrmd! {Mi 1
`5:’/??3‘?»Vi%'T'5'P?'}<_'f‘,§ <1:
`€5-
`«.Jm:
`;:w‘rir>n’:»'~,s
`:;*u.w' cm? H
`,
`5
`'
`«fr
`§u:«:.!Iw:
`*
`1.4’:
`.w.>z.;>zr‘m‘il.
`
`
`
`fRl~{z1‘I_}
`
`as
`
`#1:-*'
`
`.'.v‘f.e'r'rx‘rrzz«:*'z?1
`
`
`
`
`
`in‘
`
`v:‘
`
`
`
` '
`
`i‘,ixé£1Ii« of
`. ("::;s:z:1.a.
`
`

`
`...r>1,s‘:A::.:m»;x.«/..‘u&rA.'n.*
`
`V.-a ~
`
`TH E C,'.~\N.~’kI>{fi.N .I(,}1fR;"v’#*\I, DY NELE IM‘)lf_3(.'iIC.»"<.I, E\'(‘,IE{NC.‘E..‘§
`
`41.2% 1*: $33.61;}. All :sI“::;>v.=e:d n';mem'.~:.cvcrz1§
`01151:: R Wsrf ghee}; }.1:::*im§s duri.n;_.r_
`
`the a"<;:cmdir1g-3
`inc:
`0:?” tbs f“:_:m't.w:x1
`
`gmticrttzs was-1
`:“immly dc:.hi!’mm;<_I by
`their ilimss zmxf mm Staci mat h<:1:n;E‘i§—u¢i
`!'I"11.iLth fmm the eazalxzdzxui
`:rmh‘:1m:t.a
`;:.mn‘ni1*.im1_ smIn.alm'1E.s aim! ;_:1”n%.E(§t%;wrLw«~
`waml rncd utéma. H:‘.E"m‘e:. sT«f;at'Ei21g{fiHB.
`:11} pm:x>Ԥc:n:s; tmznirmzxi
`fm‘ na1'm1ep»:x‘}»=
`
`was LHv_!1iifl1N3d
`for
`:1!
`Ieem two
`
`‘Hie
`;3r«:*:—tI'iaI
`smncm in-
`ciudeai a hifi§1OT‘);' and péwsimfi c~:~;a1mi~
`n:1'{i«:,m.
`i‘:e113ata1<?a;;in=;:3\
`rcnah
`and
`hepam:
`as ushesi X-ray,
`¥-‘.(.,7G.
`II‘
`V
`#2., and M ME’! and 2:
`’m1i:-i ps§.'«;'hc;«
`logical asS:':SS{"x1e':1t.
`:"c‘:peaLeC1 subgectivc
`
`smmnt
`mt" Slekiflitléifis
`uwing Lhe
`‘céianfmfl. S‘|<.\cpi:1«'c:»'s; Seals (I-‘ludzées ct
`
`mm L
`“A
`f)», pupi.1,Eu::'1e::ry in
`L)s.i2m'a
`s;t‘1n'Ii«:-a and b;-:s<;tEi'mi pu1y3oz'e':augm-
`phict cwmlinga. :‘M“i_c1‘H1vJti§‘1w:?&L§gm.§v<:
`zmd punréy mia,u'1ta11j: m:.t1.m.:
`as!’ 211:
`smdy was ma1::»E:1inmi,
`i:1f"nr1‘:mcl Mid
`,»,'ig11cd mmcm was 0bmi:w.nE {mm cmh
`paéicnt.
`The §'m1yr<m1‘1nm_g1':4}'=E1ic:— 1'eua.a1‘diz§g;s
`in tin‘:
`flu:-m':3 pztliczms;
`(NIL?)
`‘Mitre
`mmie w'sth p<M"I_;abf»€
`«'1 cm rm} ?v’Ic':di§mg
`n:cord~::'s;
`tf(.)>;§.m‘d
`E.!C’l;T'E.1":CEii
`}:1.str*u-
`amen:
`(‘nrzzguaram Ihée gmmiated pa»
`ti-an:
`n1(miwriam in
`ihsfiér mnrnxai
`em~'imnm;:1n anfi at time: Llsztaiacmitic
`leveks. The am»--.m.:m..» 5.156433
`'»h’€i‘{‘.
`(14-
`
`;-’'~.» L;-A5,
`a atombimd hur'L;:mm11-
`
`vermai
`rm-uIwgm"z*1: ami
`it sxsbmcmai
`EMU.
`‘!‘wcnL»-max"
`imurs. of dam.
`ccauld bxc :*s:.ce_u‘clre.cI an on: reguéur C7129
`cassette.
`In [lac Tm"m'1m .~.;lm‘Em&;.
`zinc:
`pmirms (N —‘?‘j wcrc t1=;,vs;3i§m imsci and
`aim:
`t‘£!Cs?I'<'3il3L_.',.'_~:
`r.3bt‘;,:i:1c;i ML%'x a (3ms:,a
`model 73E} ;m1‘yg,::1pl1, Nmv:
`z:'eF Hie‘
`p2,1tirsnt:~:
`lmcé l1§:;i_m"ics ml"
`m‘
`
`
`in=;c~::‘asc
`;~;mw%r
`‘E
`.m1g;;e?~'.fiw of 3100;:
`
`:‘:wm:1, am? mi. mvnpmm u:asfwcm:aI1§~
`m;<:§m;1c‘:«;i
`ix?
`thaa
`'I‘cmm1w jxmdiefisz
`in
`wlmtll
`&2..11‘fia:ienI mxmher C-f r'::r:me.,i%11;:
`chzmncia mfldtt
`it pa
`.\ bk: tr: mn.I1iw':‘
`1m:s‘:*.1 mud {.hm’i1CiC z‘ pimmm.
`(Tem-
`t‘mm'ms
`48.
`lumr
`)’<3«SC?E‘6Hi‘L,}z.~3
`<:-I
`tit:
`3;¢;3p;waé<ing.; pzmerns -.w:re <f)lLm"x%ncx3
`in mi patictratg £2: the pm-ff} 11.8 baselixm
`rs2:t'itac,§ zmd atami
`£§£g‘diI1
`z~'.@'1e4'
`Ln
`1::
`nigizis cm the dmg, Utuinig :11»: 48
`imm‘ mmmo [;}ib0I"éllL}1‘}‘
`:'::r:uz'dmg:,:’«'..
`tin:
`;:»;11.icn:3
`W¢.Tf"L7
`¥S§lCL}UI'i1;£L’~€.1
`I2‘
`x‘s':m21i:'1
`in bed exccgal
`muals mat“!
`t:oe1thrm:m l3rc:1k.~:e.
`‘*5 grtz {I€}~§5*
`.:*m iniéini !.5 gm :0
`ml.) c.1«,i:x“(* of {f§H'B 'w;I.~’; vgiwn m‘:|Hj»—'
`5%?
`b:.:d$im.:~: gzmd fu13mwe.l
`313:’ mu as‘ aw
`
`
`
`
`
`mmal slcuep ;-md £9 ;~;tm,ij»; {he effirct mi‘
`
`' ma. the s§;n'x;at:_::"ns of the ;om;,%izim1.
`'l:;:;a.c§1écw: %§1i.:s
`lazm: uscsi :‘m«;L111“1ml
`-of
`_;ga1r117‘:e1—fi1yL!I:,mybu1yra:c
`((%I'~ll:‘3“l. a cutztml $}1m't:a;%h;z.in imtj,» zsuéd‘
`
`{E)n§1cm—-
`L8‘; 211.,
`§"~}‘.r(>) WELI1 E1j_«pn10m;
`
`mupcrrtiu’ (i_.;»:hc2n'i!t
`l¥;’(M}‘
`‘s-W cfimsc
`Glfli
`3f1L¥i;'rE‘i1,ESl£
`it
`]’}é;1.'1
`lw;:z1 ?\'}1Q‘.’W1
`in
`{3l"1‘itI‘1‘I<,¥§.L‘
`1303.11 RIZM mm ~:%n‘we‘-w'»~1w
`Mac}:
`(P»~1::xI1a:i;4L;
`;.z1.,
`I9'3*'?}
`in
`r.:nm1‘;1sl to (.)1“«;HnfH“§' hy}3axn‘::ic;%5 which
`xzwfiw a:1|3;3rt§§.~;tl‘w.~,§c seltmp stafe.a“{K;1lws
`4,11 31..
`I‘.-U0}. GHR aim pmses.:mE an
`aclditirivnad :n:a;}m:' mwantagss rwm HW-
`msmr.-ui ?1y§1f'1flI iEf5i
`:1: mai animal zmxdics
`Emd {zx§Ee¢fl m dL::1mz1:1tJ'ei2.Lr ihe: dv2w:§n;.1~
`ment
`of mE:r.3nc—e me me
`<,Jmg“s:
`h}¢';m:,:iic t:H\€a:t!:é
`\r.r:r,1"1 p:'()i<imgC:ii
`1.3:‘:
`{V%Ck€:l'5;.
`19%}.
`{<3
`Lx~czas.m
`Ew.-*2:
`1&2 date, we
`in 21
`m1s'cca'—::;mc p;mc:m: with QHB.
`pruiérzxixxzxry c:>21m1m1is;:z~umn cmmrm
`mg
`:3
`pziiiemts
`(‘Br:,mghum and
`5»-hx:13c1sa%4, W?(i_'J and in a m1ng;2.=mim1
`artiuslc dumiéing rm: Mimcnl éi..‘ij,.’1“\’!L'{."> of
`Wm ;:x:?:tima1.~,z
`iIzlCE*.1dm‘1
`in thus. paw-mt
`rc»pvz::H
`tf_Bnn.:ghmn
`zmd
`;‘v‘1ELE’I"st?'1£°¢]Izr?,
`1‘$"?0), we have :~,huw1'1
`that QUE
`m*1m'1«:e:d§§: %c1:3g'7I'(:«w.=;
`n<3c*t,11m1z_1§
`sleep
`and I%mL ruig‘:a1mm"c+;. hsnaE1tzx:imttic):n3,
`
`ans} ;1itau1<;~; mt’
`E.
`_
`iz». vanish,
`Dnrir;
`the day, giressum E'<:t-r sleep
`
`bBL‘<,)I1‘;:“.fi less impctratmt and czatap
`ms eittacks b<:::c«me mime: and lass
`
`fi'1‘ctw::1k:+;“nL in :1:
`p‘).E1f§2",17}1‘~f‘x‘iI‘iUk.iE1}‘é”!sH
`rs)-=n1p1:a::ms oi
`the di>‘r‘«*:‘dSE xlkszxgwpear"
`when smal§ rapealud daiiy énnses of
`stimulanrs am:
`in cz:sz:’1hm;ulm1
`
`wish UHB at nigiiy
`mix. we hm.-
`dew.-Yulugycai 5,0111: §‘u:"t.msa:ir
`‘
`géxm-:1.
`sun mwc. Ihcm bccn gm};
`guts aim:
`
`‘ um. and p:v.§i:::'1Lx% g<.:1m';1E§y fmd mix
`m:;~mm:m 21m<.:11 {no-1'-is
`;?n"x1&1{£~fl“«|L¥ than
`sh-3
`u$\.1.‘il «mmbi11z.stitm cf ::tin'm1.':mts:
`zmgi
`tricfxrgiic -mticivprcmziwz‘ cirtsgx ha
`um papa:-r, WE‘
`fmvzga: on tin: uf'€"L‘#:LtErs'
`{sf
`('3 H I? upmn the x‘&:c:m‘c1e:1l glut]; /‘wiakmg
`§1.attLé%'m (3? mar ;1:«:tEc:n4.sap
`
`m‘1“1L:~.": :5 Am ;wsfI’H(3s:n;~,+
`
`Fru1ric:~:::"z cm‘? the: 1€1g:«a';ie:'1:s[c>u:1u:l-
`my mm.
`2
`;tm:i
`H},
`for
`ts:z':§n1§<:ai
`1‘C£
`
`
`;rms‘,a, wh»./ms: hism '
`; am awn»
`
`:11;mzcd m mm 5:»
`imss
`H‘:§301‘1
`{limugmon and M.;:m1s;1:—:k, §E:}’::‘:)\}h mw
`had ;t—.u11'1p.l:.ttu siudicw mi" their ;E»H1<mr
`sEm:p»wa1ki1‘xg pzmu:
`: Tl1m= mmeis;t~:d
`
`mi
`.x'«'.‘s::m
`nm.Ec.sa
`*1
`Imzlziiazs
`
`1:-€w,=m:1“:
`the
`.,7 ['_mu::m
`4”
`
`(fifan-s}<:m;%m:. 197:?) or 7% hum {M\‘sr’a:iL/.,m:».'w,
`at 2%..
`¥€)7»:1)« “€l:i§«‘s"
`in um'L'x1aE5.:Lxb‘_ic<;tx.
`Ira {ha c<’zzLImL: mf {hast
`coxp<;*1‘i<11z:nm
`which hm-:2
`inmivcd thc sazstsaimxi
`imgm::m:«.tiu~:i M
`;:m1§:sor1‘111‘«::~
`gmg:l1'u.: pawsrm icécslmcei
`to th.-;u:;sr
`immd in
`rae1s’wl@;;1sj«>*
`hem:
`rza;:m1J§°‘
`czmcrgcd.
`Sl~:.-up
`o—n.°;ct
`E~‘.F.M pxzyimcis
`and c.2ttm*
`zrleerxifikm ztinm as?‘ dis
`‘
`‘
`ciutcai xlcvg-'p¥ sua:l‘1ens.' multiph ::g'.m-<:]:_~; :
` .8»
`5<,,m";L]1cci “il3t>;‘1“:1‘1m(.§i;.:tI.: »1c;:t].a" (Hart
`Fcm2.i1":—1
`zxmrl
`E_..;'
`19765:},
`:c_p’;'»e;—‘11‘<:d
`within at
`f<:\x= Imnr
`5 Sumgh the fuéi
`
`Clétnxcal :»'§.~1-c4§'m1mct W55 nm-‘arr efiicitcd. ii
`1:: mnc:,m»1I*:?e3 that
`this;
`tnight
`hzwa?
`m‘.c11r1"€d
`|'1z2«:1
`it
`bszcn pcmihle 1::
`cm1:‘im.m zhescz studies fur 1s;zngcr:mu:.~;.
`Inéeedm the clinical and pofi,y:mm:m-
`grazmic gvmw-:*.rns
`emf‘ mxrcéaiepsge mm
`dewckop
`en
`p;=nlm1s:gi«3;L]
`L:m1di1mrs:'
`such as Sinflflfi ‘apnea: whmz em: t;»‘;)if“ie:§
`by
`cm‘c»ni:*
`sleep
`€‘:'agrw::1t,:aiicm
`
`c('iui]lez:x%mtL1lt
`er.
`1%..
`I976).
`lepsy also £1;)§Jt1é'tl‘b 10 d(3'VL§v;){J pn':l"t:rcn~~
`mum m m_m:r
`iznciivitixxzilx in wtmm
`sfieep
`£5
`chroni-caally
`cf13~;r‘LipU:£.§.
`{M
`c.K541nph:, in shift vm;'k¢‘:1"s ur in m:rs.-as
`and (lC::;1c3|‘s who must kccp it'rr:gnla'F
`hmsrs in the cmirsrc of their <lm:'m.~;
`(BI'm:ghtcm,
`19131).
`in
`50‘~7_‘*"'“
`01
`€c§in,;m:h%::
`Q:-uses: M ImI'a:u1eps_ ..
`
`pk’Z5£}’ :3 hm;
`<1f'_.~¢:wera Heep dL:{9ri‘va—
`Timn
`ear
`mi‘
`firm-5m1m'
`alarm E1abi:s
`}}1‘tiC€3[‘3E-d aha nnstztt nf'tI1e.c}§sw.&ae. reftezx
`by rmmy }w'(,1t:lZ'5a {Mit_s::he3l and lfierrmnz,
`W(é?'€: Br«::ugE1t<.m
`(3hamcm., I9?ffl.
`M(:1;’:':m«-‘:51’,
`in ttstaxblfigsl
`’d mxrc<:<§eptic:s
`the c0_ndiI:i»r:3n
`s:E1az‘actcrVi~ti.»3a}§3v* ht-
`c01‘2‘z:2s umlsuaiigz r;1£t'f'i:-mt
`{£3 cmmué
`whcn Ilium ia any dis:mp1im1 of ma:
`siccgufxriaking rhj;t!m1s buys shift v.-m'l~;,
`jet iug, hr pnm slwsp l1ub§t:~ ilimugixtcmz,
`E’9”r‘i; Zzm:om; 5.975;
`finmnglltcm and
`(}["léit1lJTl1_.; E9?'(i3.
`1¥1:3re;~.1'¢“a1“c
`Aétlmugh c\r'i£1£".:1mé
`that [1:"v:m‘:€l§I1‘;_1_
`aucmxzruz-2] ::,l:1:.:p v:!iS[ll!‘~
`hmicib TT‘l:l}’ muvv gm én'1;wm't,zm1 mla in
`flit: garieeis m”
`the mn¢.1isicm and
`
`ivnziiesacé
`.‘¢m'fiL:?
`;,mI_§1m's hasw
`aludctd
`£f1rdit1.i}t“}-’
`11}./»‘pmm;cs as mm
`thcix‘
`t.re:ai:m~::n1\:
`{l.);n1%.¢l:2.V
`1934; Zarc<:>rn:2,
`E‘~)'x‘3}. zhr: majm‘ ihcwmcfmic appmac-h
`
`has;
`:3
`in suppress
`the glajmme
`.5yI11p-t(3l".t’§S
`siccxp;ma<:1<smzd<1mxw-
`imess with xtinn:kmm;; smct a:2i:a;w§r:.:>:y
`{and mEmr
`|{£‘i.f\«’1~basea;i
`.’«1‘L}:X1§1¢1x'f.<’
`sy:21;m3tns) will’:
`t§“iu3~“clic or MAC)
`§:1t1H1~iu:w1'_g= :‘+.nt.idcg3I“c::s:m1s.
`*3»-‘it mammi Lu ::11E(:II§1j?L to kw;
`am:
`~.5{3nIii1lJ‘1l_\_:“ and :lm'at.ic;:;:1 mi’ mau-
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`~
`
`l“E.BR1,i2\_IH’ 18!?’-if!
`

`S
`(ff!/i mm’ S[E‘(';JLV"iQ«’(.»{,I€y’
`
`i~‘;:m:*r:';.s‘ in ‘*s*4:z1*c“<.'HW—‘V‘:
`
`

`
`
`
`i.J;*I J00 R:‘\%7.M_, C/\N:’3.IJEEi;‘$ 'lV)‘|~T§ SCIJT;
` ?*«‘E','Il_‘,', ROL(_‘)(_‘rE(}L§
`
`
`
`3
`
`‘N13
`:s:§a:up wuss mo LEc;m:§(,.vpL::i.
`night
`ealmimmi
`the E‘1l,lRTk!)>‘EJ‘ of pm’iud.'.s 02'
`Sit“.’C{'>,
`he
`tirzcimn‘
`E‘~2‘RI:E_M, RJ;iM. or
`mmhin;1t§am; m” the twm, whaigzh wen:
`.~:cpen':a,wr.1
`fmm one mmthcar by mm:
`mm 01“ man? rnf<-‘.E1'%wr‘ «MT, xmmfullzcss
`or
`at
`*
`1.
`f7’s?i.p-t}I1«:f§§ng,: upon the.-ir
`
`cglumzi Eh i%1u:s¢ !hE)CZl1I“‘f"I,f\lr€3EE}’)})!Cf:‘i('§dF.
`w.:rc'-.pLztiz1i.cvi1,w: C‘»ilt3§_:(Pfj;£“f:iI F5 min or
`I6-31“) mm. .3i~<15 mm. 45-(>{\? min.
`
`thaw M min, In :~;,ddi1i<)n.
`and
`we .'Ii’1:’:21Sl2I"L‘£i
`the E”rm|,Lae,1:r;3s‘ M stage
`shifts out wt‘
`2,
`3 mus‘
`4
`m‘3llL‘n‘:[iV‘t:§§x‘ (Lu... mu Q1“ ;\$??Z1.;..—:’v1 5:‘Ee:r:p_i
`and mm 0?" REM
`'Il‘1cmxmE_}crof
`
`
`slm"t,s out M" 111:: fmxmn‘ xxw; flip!" 56:}
`pm’ H10 min uf Hm? M11“; M
`Z 3
`am’! 4 paw’ zaiglm and um. mi‘ the lunar
`gin-:31“ E00 [mu n1‘ R1"
`zilwp par ni_gm.
`Dmimwz tfm (3:13:
`a: pmr:iL.m.<; M‘ aha
`
`s‘cc«)r’:‘Kir‘:_s,ga sleep ‘Y
`;|m"1l3‘s:3d Tm‘ ilw
`..
`1,
`duration ¢':E".~zt;i:_sz;::€
`?!.=1, RE1VI,a:1L%
`MT; and Ihc rm 31 aEr2c:H_i:I1:t.~a 1m§=.z(ié mg
`
`am! rzxchzcitaijg. 31215::
`E w 'c: Uzfliféllatc}
`w-.
`as zilwve. ’I“he21w1fl>e:w:1; ciafnixnu sleep
`perimia V.-ms aim d<:tcermir1ed. A sleep
`permd was defmed 21:4 an episcacict. of
`:'e«:o:*ded
`-ep Cami-.m1inzg at
`laws: 3
`mm of statgcs 31. 3, 210:‘ P. M s;iee:g1.».e:nd
`pm.:<:d<:<£ and I'tsiimvcd ésy at East 15
`min
`m:kr:1"::Inc.«;~s
`uz‘ mg:
`I
`fdnm's::u:53}. 'I“m:s<:
`}3r:3'iu(1:»' W'£'31‘t':
`ammi iniazzn 3 grmaps, must: 421‘ 3145-
`min, Hf" =‘!(w»~t3=O min amcfi of’m-;v-r:1L}1;m {>1
`mm LTii1‘T"L?8j3=£L‘A1‘xL”I'$§_!,
`{:7
`the
`kmgL:r
`
`1I1r.*_;1.:sum5; of
`cm";
`“1H(‘l:~:t{5«;§
`::icc.\p at
`aligghi.
`Emnrs §ms42:l§:1e
`In {ms _[Il2:1}N:‘l‘, Ema
`
`pc“,z«?:v‘§~k0I]‘I1nf3§1l‘é’§}1§']5LT alum 1'0!‘ 6;
`t}?2
`}‘.va—
`timt
`mmparea‘l £0 <_i;1tax:21f\I€s" 7 to H3
`ni§_;h15 on GH E1‘€:”.éIn‘3fIH.
`"I§"!1:,: (‘Emit M
`each paiicxzt. Eh
`em}: M" the mm 24
`hour periods lJNt‘}.r:.' amt after GHH
`irmimxazat were £i'u’(tz‘£i§;K;f£‘§
`lw:1Lz_m2 mm-
`pzmmni. The two zaitesal Stmjr;-m E mat
`mras zippflix;-4!
`to c;::c§1 x/wI:1h3::, zmlsass
`mhmwisc _~sm1<:d.
`
`
`
`EH";
`
`
`
`i.‘7l..I'S
`
`"f‘h«:: dalz.-1 miwtaxitmci §j§i§12g a:%1.E'1m' the
`
`;m1‘E:mln* cnttgfiszimrwl m‘ Hm Lnmmstc
`ingm1i::*x1*.
`1:‘ec:n:*diI‘1g
`*‘*hrzia;;L..w.<; w-cw
`szinnilm". The wmgai‘ cf
`Lzrwt
`\\';:.*; m
`the: :‘~iIw;:g: p;,«:t.r,c:r11.~;
`‘»~\»hi>::h
`/m‘t‘«:! V]‘i1.“*;[
`
`balm’:
`mzsez.
`3:1
`smgtn. H29
`immtr'm*n r:'::;~.c>§~<i3:1g.a usgtlexlhs :~'h0"Wfi.*I('f
`an
`yamiod
`of’ marezt
`in less
`.~msi.:—.1iz:@:i
`
`wzxkfulnuszg amtéi
`;<[cm;a mzset,
`xx;
`,u:h
`wan.’
`them Inlimvzsai ;x:!wrtE§,-' by
`REM
`
`
`
`FFl3RiAl,«5;R‘r’ EEFRQ ~ 25
`
`tissfismii as 111:: rims: {mm
`fizltastlcy Wm;
`°I<‘.kT.i;‘p «.1m»:*.1. to aim fiuisi x:c_mtimmu.~: 3 m"
`mam: mm Bf‘ iiiigifl 3 M‘ 4 .<;i»:°.<3p" REM
`sleep iatmwcy want dktfilmti
`the sinus
`rmm Elm «mam eat" 3 01‘ more min in
`Lhtrzxtiun of
`sfitzzgc
`1:; me
`fiirgt
`mnti.m:cnm; 3 m mme min of REM
`siccp.
`{if REM sieep mcxxrrcci be~f‘o;*r:
`1?, its lam-r1<:.y ‘WZi?x'iir3[E—Y’IT1ii1f3d bfs-’
`measmimg rim iH“iL81‘V‘éll Emmczan liza-
`bcg;:E:‘mi1“n_z of the 3 s:s:v:m:cu1‘u‘»«'«2 min at‘
`RTSZV.-i
`and the
`gavreccmimg
`3
`«:0n:aL‘:.*z11i\2c min -:3!“ w21§m;:i"*.;l11c—as,
`I'1['.1"v‘I
`d«:.miry ratfczva in 221.; pa-:'<.:cnta.gc mi’:
`iiI'1inE—c;m»;}1s
`r:<‘zm;1ining «me or num:
`:'2api1,l
`v§.=c
`t1‘1Cwr:n19m:~'. Tin: milms
`»:3Evtai1'2:~:d fur‘ mch RPM pc»s*i:csd “mm:
`;'m1'n1:'1Ei:~w:(i
`fm"
`iis cmrminn 2~.rnԤ an
`.':w-sragr:— \-;~1lue far catch mE"‘;hc I?0CH1‘i‘l1.‘;iI!
`and d1im'na§
`z‘ttcw<?ing m‘,r'md.s'. was
`detrzrrnimtd.
`
`Two filrimtr pa1‘2un‘ztm‘s §m’nivi11g,
`Rl7E\»‘I Flaep were dcrfi-.;:d in QFCJCF m
`
`m .u';Lu"c
`the degreat M REM slaep
`fa gnaentatmn. ‘Thezxe \m:':1'«e R}*'.?x~I sleep
`e§t‘iciem,ir:s with arm without a;:21g=:' 2.
`Le, mhzcr ;'3'.1‘.§<:I‘1“L\.' ofdefin1’t<: .~l«:».a:~pL Fm‘
`each R BN1 $:1~::€g1= pssrissnaf, the mmbrsr wt"
`rzpmttm bsstv.-'um the: éim urd r.}1e§z1§: 40
`E«‘.L7M sficcp L':peui1 ml that pmiod
`mm dm.Cr':‘Iait‘Ic<i.
`Ilula ’sm.s dcskgnaxtcxi
`t?1c“mtz43 R ETx=1.e!m:pp<:s‘i0d th1mLion1",
`i’$m%s1t1:s'e“. at" f:':1g1m:z‘;f.1tiu11,
`ii imiludmj
`£‘,jm.'3ChS mt" w:I1kcfzz!ne.<;:4. stazga E. MT’
`
`and, at
`r.i1*’"
`Sznga 2. REM sleep
`£%§’(‘ir*iEtn¢':y wfthmit stsmg 2 1'¢7!1.:m to the
`pe1"cent.£1,§u': of the REM szlmyw gm-ind
`duration mrmistitlg M RPM s%::.(:.p
`a-pwclxg
`(FT1,1j§. R¥iM sleep §ffi+3ififflL:}’
`mcmdmg stage 2 z‘<:§"m'.»' to the pemrew
`tage 0%“ {ha REM :3h:‘:é;*J pmind cl1..:rmi0n
`CL]]’!i‘~‘i§t§ng atsf egmchs 0%’ REM sleep m‘
`of sfiagrt 2 sieegs,
`sf dcfinitc
`‘I”hc txm REM sfcep cf cizzmry ‘»r‘&iE‘LIf.‘3:¥
`»~.=::rc n:n';nmhw.r:a:i é."«;1;"r:zach R11 M slew.»
`|:m:1'imL and an m.<cs“u1E. m—=c1‘mg:_1<;: mean
`value for cm}: of the rmcLuz‘1‘m1 Eilid
`diumai
`rm:-carding pcxrimjs
`wiza-
`tairmi.
`In this smdy.
`:1
`|?;}%‘M ezlczcp
`cpmfh E1.‘i3;'l
`La:
`‘fine a‘e;:mm1»:n.l
`irmn t.h«::
`cmzzct ;»1'v::v;:L‘*.c.ii:ig REM :~;1s:e:p cpawh by
`.<u1ms{ I5 mm In ha: suimwi .'-L»; met M :1
`svcgmmiic.‘
`!{i'V7‘\=%
`SlL”{?]T1
`p=:m'rd. The
`rmmhzrr
`("cf R NI
`:«:p
`pm“ir,mls pm"
`nighé. zmcii [Fair ~17}-‘4;I]¢ cim'z1€Em“;.
`i.c:.k the:
`time (‘mm the cvnsnst nfloncr RT:'.M .<E<:<:;a
`;‘:e:rim§ tn tlm OHSCE. n? the mzxzt‘ gwrimj,
`wen: ;m:c')
`(ti-i§(»§1i!:\‘t€1{iA
`A z‘:‘1ez2HL::‘e
`Tm"
`nf m»mm‘J'
`
`cic1m":'n.ining the
`f‘:‘:17;§_tI’1t3111;3;t_i«a1r uf
`
`;*‘ur1%1m' LO gm m 1.5 gen Him 9 d1::‘Eng:
`mar nig¥1twith :%.r1y :1mj<.>:' :m*mrm1‘11g, éf‘
`m<.ax‘:: tham
`Bleura had pmsezd fmm
`téw §3I't’J‘v'jOl1S dam. Wlrit p2‘.(I€II1YF& wtsrx:
`mqlkéfcd to 3”-cc!
`fulif,-'
`€‘t_lr;‘I'?: and dear
`headed h:‘:fm"e making thee? maxi muse.
`‘”!‘h4:
`‘
`“a:im;’mf‘(iE-{Rsfiwn1'mtico2?'Ié::c£
`
` pa 5 B... 1*
`in ma n is ahmlt 2,5 ln>L1:;»
`Mk at
`313‘,
`1‘}"§‘.7),
`‘M‘1i£:!1 u(;~1*n‘i::‘+pr;md:s e;\lc,m§}}:
`Lu mm of its <ic.Lc<t£::l3lvc g'7e:'e:a.c~a1a:<:iI'1 the:
`b[:Jm,l {I*[a:m»..I'a ct .24E.,
`.¥‘:J{%=$%.).
`In I‘1::m
`3x;.11ic:nErs, 1wc:;»or U‘1:'I$t,‘d£3S!:?.» were givnia
`Q;-§f}1 néght i1'E .=,1«;;icami wish m11'<*rbge.cL§x.‘::
`uf nlzmxizlixlingg
`c0ntimIm,1,s :1 r1ight‘;~a
`53526:}:
`pmsfifjlav. G}?Bwam:‘1<:\.»'cr'gé"vcr1
`
`within um Ema
`cat‘ the :ax":tjcip.<a,...-:§
`liznc M the mcmnim:
`;1\A¢:r1.L:c':m11g;r
`in
`mailer I0 swim! h€'.12gy:,wcx'
`<2ffi:*.CIs, Hm
`Lara! quaamitg-‘ giwsrx fizich night r:1ngcd
`tmz1‘z 3.795 gain to €135 gsm, C0n‘«::3p::m.dv
`ing-,
`:9
`ewcruge ;':eméem.
`f?O~5‘€t}:Z€‘. of
`am 530 nagfkg.
`
`"lhe poifi.-‘SiJIflI‘1c.3\gI'éiphiLi datzz were
`6}‘
`
`as‘w.i
`zu; omirag, Lu
`i.r‘2ie:'na:.1imwJ
`r.ritcri,u
`[li;c=':Insc}:z1{I'1:n
`and
`}-'L2d»~.-a
`16368} and sL:m’Cc;'§ using 46)
`cpmcm as
`wv,lca:fuIm‘5s. stage: 1, 2., 3, 4 and REM
`:~5h"c;':.
`{_!1J,l1:~‘ n:m«:m:mt mm: (?v‘I"I‘. 2,41,
`«::;:mtEa.s
`u‘zt>s;L‘:zt'm'l
`?>\r 111m»'-nncna igni-
`iaaclx flu‘ cmsr f*">(_ M mm duration
`with g):c;v§n:::x mm‘ emc“C€:;‘diI‘.g cpmhs
`rmmlgmairlgg sictzrp 1‘tst11:tI"ns:}. Théff nigh!
`mud d;74,‘f§i:n:c“. pm‘iim"a‘+ nfflle rmmrstiinxgsz
`v»»'m':*. mm11_vscd mp:u:’;m:]},/. Tm: §‘m“n1m"
`was m‘bim1rily defirxeci as
`ilw Lima‘
`
`l§>»:'.~t\x~‘«sc~n thrs ea
`of night
`tn the
`mm‘
`0?
`{ha
`finial
`awaf-m2i:1g;
`for
`b1‘e£I}:lmI. Sleep sjuxaifig Ehvi Iétmamiden‘
`uf the .34 imnrc v.-M scored as yw;
`
`Lhc. d.&i}."i§!1'1€
`[37
`.
`Y Md 2). ‘fihetizmxof
`siccp nsarm mu. take1m;<tl1:“ EJ:‘ginI1§r”I:g
`:71” [hrs fiE’.SiCmHitll10l,i%£ 10 min <11" R15 M
`en“ mi. Nifliml siuup, r:.xc‘[u.<§w; of gtaigze
`I, wt-an ::;)r‘1‘«c:,s‘;‘:v¢)x1m;dlmh::p;1{i=;:mS’:;
`.~mbjr3::ti\—‘¢: a1pp1ms.a1l uf‘ swap <:z1m:t rm-
`
`Ihif nighi as _“L“4i1{'t3Lf am téau ?51~i§5« 1'urz.1a.~.;
`?‘~}ir1c-:1 1‘M,"r 1‘}.>rm:.i3 bc:<'ftin1«: ctreistcci in 511:"
`l;:1€mr:m‘:ry
`s;z.1:.u2i::.a:,
`l1i11l"“ cmxlci mic be
`«:.wm1i1hs§‘mc'i in HR“ pfll'HI§C!lk‘—S1§,1I%(Ii(:r:.H10‘
`EE1{L‘,l":£.‘}.“ Wm:
`lwzilrim<*a
`In rsierasgga mm-izt
`w:;m mu; (iL‘£_m'rI1i:1c*.c!. §*”nz' cgtzmh 1“cL:(m'I«
`‘tug perimi. Imctnmml (Ind n‘im‘1‘ml, wxr
`
`cm xxizmzci Elm t«iz~§;z! ,si::t:min1e& im*,I:.n;i—
`ingg
`am‘!
`sxa:§Lad~;:n:,§
`51:13:11
`1
`(whiarh,
`e:c:t«rrc&lt:»f:nd:: to c1rrm.v5i:a 55. mud‘ rrxnst
`;mLhm"s mg:-cc. min:
`to:
`;:cLuau! deep).
`~{;T<?>m:sp0nding mctmml sleep effi»
`::ir5.nc:i$s rc:fm.* to the pea‘-cm-:11;zgvs ofthaz,
`pzmwric-n of tlm I‘s3CCBf(Hi1};S cmmsmeci
`aha: mlrcwlm amp pawxrns. EJc;L21~;lvs¢p
`
`
`
`b'mr4,L' fa Mn 3; 1-\"’(:rm>.=W;
`
`

`
`«.~4.-.x.m~.w
`
`‘|...m:un-~
`
`_¢x,>¢w.1*nlx-n< tux «.
`
`.,».. "..,K.,-0
`
`...v.r.\,...........»......,»m>.¢..».wmM».mmmmw_mmmmw_m..V%,..vy
`
`THE (T.~\>£e*\ DIAN .lfiISRNAL OF" T~F}°:;13‘R€)L0(}ECAL S(.7I.l._lN£ZES
`
` [ii
`
`1&5, éllustrates the f;'cqu-int mvamkmzingé; «céurang
`1 —» A $8 mam r:m1Iiuumz>;. baseline recomimg in an Iypiirazl i%:§1I}f~;9i'{i13%‘ifiti_‘1 ;mtir;nz_\
`Fr'g*u.!'€
`nocmmal siiccu nwnétipte. s§e,epm1sc:t REM prc:1’és.:Li:y.
`€1Eagnient.'11it'm <31‘ REM ,sE«:¢p. and mim‘ fcatmm ca? slam» in n-a$cuIep3}«*—uaitiplasxjg
`
`
`(note: in Figa.
`I a11L’§‘31he w1’Lica[a:u.<:1:x4lic&1te
`stage; mu! :l1c§m1‘iz«;>:1m1zx,.
`'5 :lxv:tiznc:i:m~m1::*x, REM gécepis slmwn as a émrmmtzz!
`whéic mar at um lcwzi 01’ satgzgc E, and x1m\mé1:mI by 3:11am 11'i:1I1g.E<:5 aitmvc the :m::tp
`lim-K. Timc: ;l.4.?h) hoxzw m imtEr.
`l:¢_.;u:'r:.<.' was
`
`E{):fM}»l1:€)-('3 pmj.
`
`15
`{
`
`X\
`
` E
`
`mwfimjfiflig
`A 4R~»hm=_:.r re-:m‘L‘1i11gnfihmaxunm pa11%.m11 nu-dzxysx 9 am’! Hi m'1mcmr:z:1i xi”§I~§H Timm M :u1mi1:i«qm1Lia|| am m'21s-mi Edy ua*a‘-aux»; btrfixm’
`l*“;‘g;:n,~ 2
`in nézmhcia’ M rma§.1Ir%1d1
`the Emrimratial axis. Th-1:’ §igL,n"é;= iIIusmm'.!_~; the ::1a:t'vH::L<‘.v;i mx1iin1ut_'; of Imsztmlml
`i3.E,7..;‘»=1 sleep,
`that 4.{¢:r;I'c:.4..,x'u
`:auvako_t1irxg:e, and the rcmmtmn nt"&a1§,'tin1:= slzzcp {siuzsapittt1hem1bjcrms; E2:w.ir1g rc:m;:'mm;i quimiy in the hmp’xm‘: lnhm;-amry while risn UHH)»
`
`“
`
`M‘ “ F]':§3R‘-I531“?! Wm
`
`(EH3 mm’ .‘%’a’z—%c;J_<’as-'az.?u':rg; {’atIew1..\ in V”&JY¥fr(((LJl(’:’1€“1§“>’%,’
`
`

`
`
`
`LE IOU R?‘M. I. CT/M‘£M'3§T:1‘f‘€lI)ES S(IiF7..?‘J(TF,S NEEIRU§.(,)f}}Ql§ES
`
`
`
`TA 1} 1.11’.
`
`I
`
`F” f_.i.iI13’w2 5‘
`
`
`s:_::e.r~'m1:‘ Sir:
`
`_/ H*’:1e“<:‘n__z; f’rJ!Iw"m
`
`Busrlim;
`
`3 55.5
`
`
`
`
`
`
`“»‘?’.(i
`404 9 J.
`35% I
`-+; 5530.5
`(12.4
`5%.}
`4‘7.§%
`Zfvfx
`f8(Ik.f% ; 72.9
`82.9
`2.<3.=3
`93.3
`34.5
`I55 me
`$15.]
`1.6
`?'5.0
`4L4
`431)
`IM9 i 4€.},?§
`!{u.7' i 6.!
`_* 1.3
`4’ 2743.?‘
`SM} 1‘ 37.?
`
`I1
`
`
`
`
`
`13 :3
`
`
`
`
`
`F91
`'~;1w:;1 {min}. incl,
`‘Twat’:
`
`{‘1"n.it1L.
`Si
`"]“m‘.a%
`
`Dém, ml wakef‘ume%s {min}
`
`Sizzgg.
`1 mm)
`5-9! gr 2 mm)
`Stag-.L=. 3 9 ~H1r;i1:}
`Stage RPM (mmfi
`Mmvmnmlet ii ;
`'2
`"
`Slmtp :31
`us.
`{
`3,
`Sleep v:5‘!'§r;.
`$3
`mm)
`Daétzx mien
`REM lz1%.c11s:y {::E11§2‘.:]
`
`'
`
`'
`
`
`
`‘. 2;;
`
`ct dL:rat3nn(mir1}
`asp effic. i
`_
`incl.
`M sixaep eflc. ~(,.,,§.
`c.—:m;S.
`:a'hé2"Ls Ewzn :\ RE
`200 mm ?~3I{E:?v1
`Sixifh,
`‘£."t‘11 R.EM.fIU€H1“Li:: REM
`Filmzp 1'mgg:';z:I11;'—1tmc1
`"
`5 min Um.)
`rain ifnmj
`# min {nan}
`:1t1.f2f} min {no..f:
`,
`£3} 111§11i’:1u.:!
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`.025
`
`.(L|(}5
`.01
`
`
`
`l"E¥3RI..7AR‘n" 1‘)V§if)« 3.?
`
`‘l',r“\ }‘il..§? 2
`
`P"/"fZ~m:‘.s L9,? {EH}? rm U:")}‘F§I‘J'!E.‘ }3’¢'~ V
`
`
`Ilnn-lhw
`
`
`
`
`
` .
`
`173}
`,
`§<i€M + mu
`m 3% 2.5
`
`
`
`i
`
`‘M. (3
`36.?
`Q 20. 9
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`‘Imad séeep (mm). inci,
`Tnial sleep e'm;n_).
`
`fhaggv:
`E {min}
`Stzzgc 2 (min)
`Stage 3 6* 4 {:'mE7a)
`St;!gc— RF;l‘v.4 (tum)
`s"~'1(EW.5§’I"!l3§‘\{ §iE‘I1C% {min}
`R F‘/I c$t':‘z:»\iz;.'
`
`}-:f*.w1 w:"p a
`u
`
`Emmi my. “:aE:.:n:;: 1:
`‘
`'
`N13. [¢mgr;::* “sleep prsrmxis
`.‘?£E~45 mm
`‘#6
`if; mm
`
`
`
`}‘ifN_':z_aj;5m;r‘.'
`
`Nr:mcJfz1N‘;‘
`
`

`
`
`
`-s.~ Hm!-\»"
`
`TH E (.721!
`
`D {A N M) U R A L 0 F §‘«’Ki.H R0 Lflfi E CI.»-‘X L 1*&(§‘.E‘F. ‘
`
`mmmi <»wt‘z2'11:1s1;ntiu':11 Wm mH":11m:r
`
`than 11'1a1i::i;n§cILre§,
`itllil the g11'<;r»=;::1<;:«: U?
`:_:4,m;;mn§t;.:z:II
`'.-m=.m:a1cxs mi’ mm.-;<"‘ ma‘.
`l"c,.wm.!mg:«2. whE«;'h -:."w swam‘
`if‘: Ulits
`c.m1dit.im1 «fiiis5i"si§<:1-M1, W76;
`\=’{1_a__":u?,
`
`l€}”.?(i},
`\=.—w: HEY»
`I-:am,:_"‘V pr-atscnt.
`l.iE< ‘c Mimi" iE“1R'CS.§f,ZZ1t0t‘S .~::n":hl321t"~
`
`e‘.nr:,—3*‘:
`réera mid
`t;~m~y
`{WT?(%} mm”
`:\mmp&;n.~;;r and :,‘esi[c%;a;::.Lm (§%3’7Z%). WC:
`\«~“c*.t'A5r
`iIT‘apl‘{?S%L‘.U by 1h»: rm—11"1«.a:d ciéss-mi-»
`mim: and i'mgu1wr::aiic3:1 mi" zm«.:m1'm:'2
`{am} diLL1‘mal} sfwgfi \-Lhiath we‘: imam}.
`it“:
`nus‘ paiéenl-;<‘
`1~:M;xr{3Er2gs.
`In
`a:id'zIicm m {‘:*«:;;s..xL-.r1L sh-cg) gxnset REM
`»5!L3s}3 gvcriucls, HICM‘ xwrc I1L.ElI"é€.‘l'L3LE.ki
`
`qmchs.
`LJK ”‘ét'1t=:1'z‘mtc£iM::
`31
`9”
`>;in1u1§.zmcm::~.a f‘::z1\r_,zz'e:«: nf $:.ngrr i’. and
`[GI M slamgs), znzlltflpic bricfm x§s::;1~ ihxgvv
`nzcms
`sun!
`pn;::1m1g;v:éa;i pcrimlw; with
`)‘1}iB1if{‘
`‘§'r3:m11:'E:s; M »elm;;f« mm x»':s‘im:.%‘711§«
`1'1-.233 9290;) zmd its suhcmnp¢:mc,:nt% ap-
`f,H?&H‘:;‘—(‘] m }EZi‘.~w‘.?
`hi-?C('..\‘mf;”
`a;fi:»;.u;tI'x::i§
`m‘<.'mr1c1 the?: 24 hours and R363 h;—“u'rir:tI“.a
`b»:tm‘ccn !;}::::.;:1 and \.x=a§<,ef11tncss tn hm":
`been breacll-:=d.
`sgxenmlifiaid heath» by
`the cthmnic <l::yr.in1<: eiswnvz-:it2es;~a am
`that
`xx”
`7:13 zmarcxwssa during p«.aly«~
`graphi.‘
`iiy x11<)mM1z‘r:d
`Rl:T.‘v1
`:!c::1.L
`es;Jecia§t}; at sleep DTESCL
`€63»
`GHQ tm1d<‘:d ms reverse t¥f‘:s:J$“u
`Hi
`tune
`it _m*m]11<;'.e-xi
`imt1'ezs.=;:::1uammlL<%-
`amm and re~i11':cgj_§rméLw:
`at-E“ sivscp ami
`man::m?z1gi;v :ym1u1“:1"m1i.I..-gd .~;h':x'::J with
`Em:
`1mL:mrsm§
`;;m~m¢
`Ezugh dmc
`Lmmcd
`31:0 3E1mu:‘;3uzmd 01".aI¢:cp EVE
`ahmn xhr: sauna him; cwéél nig‘m.
`In
`czmzix
`l—hi.”駀
`1:n;:‘im1.‘~, REM 5106'?"
`ustmilg 0<:<:um:d at s§<;:vcpn>sasctz‘1m,i ‘was;
`f~;w}1%:.>w»;::{
`E13‘
`21 pericacl of xeimv ‘J.~&W£.‘3
`slutty»
`(Fig.
`3}.
`.—’»‘sl:b1::1:gy,}1
`the
`Ir?»
`Imrnm1é1.:1[imI
`sryf night
`rektmp ~:lm~;t'1‘:’
`was
`the-n3~f0:'e
`nm cmmwlrzae,
`t?.E1Ch
`|m~3rriad of (E n1;;1— inn_h1u:*1'i .~§lé."f:‘|1. E{\¥R~_'iSe‘$€d
`:23?" saieep v.~h%u11 Wm. more mrnt.im.mLI:s.
`3'1:wi;'1g;
`Ilcsww -;m=e:l<;t;1ing;s and fe\Vr»'%‘
`
`
`
`stag.
`Shif"tx~ Tlrc.
`el1§«:c1ix=e
`"
`sznlezm.
`Qf pemasms m1 mcL’£i::aui<:>ru
`xv-as
`[11:11
`they were t.I‘3.11j;‘é1S§t¥E{3(i§.11‘%ng cg-.as:h sum
`hoax
`
`1;":
`thrcz:
`«if[’{1g~§fiC
`ed
`:~ia:L:—p
`p~:1'iod amt diafi
`rm: cx,pm'iez'1ct‘
`“W45-~
`1:glnI"
`s1 mr:s
`«cnf
`rT1i;K«':d
`ZHV3
`\mP;vci”L1l1‘1::.H:L 1\Et1::w11g,i1 me [maxi L‘3ut"?2-
`iéo:1 pm‘
`of :1«;.u;tL1nmE w;c;‘1i
`\*«‘2151 W“
`§§'1L‘.1”C£1:a‘Lfd by (NIB, she c',irL1§_,’5 a1w;1L11‘"
`ml aE':E:;:ts dial alwr H“1€;‘. dm;:u_im1 xmai
`
`<_»ra_;{n.1"m=,:'xté<*r:2 <1? cm}. Emu:
`:
`tap,
`"I“\}‘:“!"€
`mm signuafimmt.
`(l£3€fi‘£‘z.H<3
`3::
`1111:: d\.m‘:.~
`Lian <1? Emth RE M 5123;: ems‘! %;§.(1\w W51“?
`
`
`
`
`
`s§r:c:p period 4f,\}*3’%g‘ 1). §’avL%:::1twuw-Masai
`M lmtrm tmicfcci m cl};§ft, E‘m1‘1: w':x‘ia;c{‘mi»»
`
`En amé um wf blm" I»~3 mi§:1:w:1’Ea:ds
`i{fZTe'\«I elem 0:" .~smg;::
`1
`fm‘ b(:Wt1‘£}T
`mi"
`mémzlzzss m‘
`:;\-11:":
`t1[m.L*m mi’
`t}1i{11}{£3hi.k
`bcfmc f?zxlEi1‘1;; ium 21 r’c:m1,«:uEi:l:L1n::J sk;c:p
`pcctréml 0fz.1§ 19:15: H) min; am! {£16}:
`l3S‘t]{§H§}—’ than had rnuch §€1E"1}'_.{LfI‘(3I
`¢.Tw’i,‘1“u
`nmmaé
`§?.Y,M sleep
`'i'lu;a
`RH‘\~*1 3159;) §.'m%m1ie< n‘::cn:"dm.1 in ‘aha:
`c)m.1*,aatémn emmixss
`’\K*‘i,‘l‘€:
`thm. mg.~m1—
`ezzaraziy mrzgss" Khan in thz‘
`itmatimt
`stuciies: ((jh;'
`:»‘quup:;:c
`:1
`i§‘F.(}(A}f‘¥)
`(IMl1e1' REM
`m:":;?w1rc3 did new
`uhffcs"
`sig'z2if'ic;:n1Ijs~‘ beiwman tbs: Wm
`h'1}mmr:na"is:.~;.
`kmsauiérac
`|3re~f_i}~H3
`Thu: xmcturnal
`1‘ucm‘*diz1g.%:(Table I) :«
`€H'r‘4;‘I'.i£;1i]MlI'IiE_)L‘.I‘
`oi" §‘¢:uurc.s when ::c:<z'm::«am‘.c.§
`to ;‘}LllT:é-
`lxsh-2:1 dam (‘MiIizu11.ss; 1:1 211.. 1¥J‘7£), and
`c»r:»1:1m;1';ca% Linc
`fimiiugég of utlicrs for
`mm mm;§tim1 (R<;cl1tsct‘1af1E:11 «:11 3.1..
`
`E962; Tig;':I“m‘m>:~F‘a:I‘1“:::ifa am? 3,;/3%‘:
`19745;
`Mmmtphinil‘
`at
`.13.,
`l€»'f‘?'§?{I".
`T‘.mt<<¢:
`im~.1w:lm*i cam: my i*I‘%r£:ct slwp came":
`RPM pcrimis.
`fmc;_=;e1’:t
`:a\«':«1ks:rxiz‘u;§;
`and permds; M‘ w1miv=::l}g pn'\[011ged
`\x;:11c:e?f2.2]r1c.~.'s;,
`law
`:‘:t"f'i::.é:::1«:ieF..
`zmd f':mt;:_1:::1t smge shifts.
`in shut).
`‘sight.
`slcsp was
`c.12nI'e1rt.m'izccl
`h}:
`n';a;rE<€:<§
`fmg:'11€:a1tmic:«m w1zia:h x=az:.9 mm
`t'§rfl<:ctr:d
`in our
`1n=::21:',¢L3:‘r;:s
`551’:-c3wu‘I5
`t'rm§v.1ent
`-shat“:
`F5 mire ct»:
`per§e;u:i£. Qt“ sleep and mw REM sleep
`cfficiunciuzs {with and without Sm
`2}.
`MIL‘
`(‘;a—;y:$1’m slcesp :naas;m'z:s befurc.
`CEHB amt sJi“v“::I} i11“l‘2fl*el<:
`Pig,
`3 slmws
`a 1mm‘ pm.—C}I~IB :2;-.a;m"::?':11g
`in .1
`I:_\;‘pii_E2iE pa.§.icnl.
`é;i1W;w'1if‘Ec,';—‘u'1l,1j;
`CINE {f_T's1L\>[L" 1, Mg.
`im'.me1.\:.<:d HM? C1x.::'e1.%.iun U4‘
`:mctm'n;’:
`
`sJm\—-'w;1w.—: sleep 21%. L112; u,\1}_3»:T1'1.‘ ‘ Maui
`
`L
`§z1r:x's:e"¢s:t¥ct
`am:
`s:h’~::p
`5:!
`iciaxncg’
`mazmmss, mm d«;'::‘1'c: «ed zhzsé nmnzhté"
`of xlccpv purimfis;
`imzax than I5 min in
`dumt‘icm. TEN: mm} mmytxnt of REIN‘
`
`szléeep vzls Lxncrftanged,
`ha,
`£1 hwznnn:
`less
`fmgmentedk
`indiamtxrcl
`by
`si:g.;I1i:"ice112ik).:’ fmvcsr 51:13:12 :9E1if‘Es om cw‘
`
`§H-'i?'s-I slccp urd ‘My an ismreiras , in tin»:
`RIETM slam «2f‘!“w.is;m:_y‘ UHB §igmiI‘i
`uzilmiy
`hmh the Ezmsmrg.-* L3
`Rlih»-‘I ,si::cp mad the d»:milj;oHl1::rezpin.
`cyc nmvc1nc.r‘1t.s thc:1m«:1w?s‘ Hzr:
`that‘
`mm: dam cgfifibk‘:
`L2)
`iliahmlcagi
`zmwturm-xi GHB F*;:SElH*$d in ax
`::igr:ifi~
`mun dccz‘-cmac in nu: d1.mM§c.m czvf 5;mt‘:I
`¢§§\mmE sfiour wmc sicrsp mcé RIUVI
`sEs:¢:p.
`?%£:;ag«c
`I
`pa¢.1:r:rr1.»;,
`Ium
`imsrcsm-2:3 (mm«sigr1if1::zs.ml}{)m Bififil-iillfinth
`
`mi this. emhuugh the mags! salucp time:
`
`ifi11céL:c§:1‘1g
`I p;‘1m:m ’ uf" dmw.t;L«
`dil3’iI3g the ca}:
`1'c11min:e:Li aw
`
`L“i‘1El3'1jJi;'3(.L ;2::1u:-‘:1 slam {m~;c]1,aiin.L. sizlgn:
`
`2) Wm. dL:cz'::z “'
`5! mm the:
`§:1("}%»iv:!1,L;zI
`tiiLj}>“3iI‘é§L* .~Qwp gn —H¢,)i§.s‘ hmsmmt ::i'1mt.u:‘.
`
`Tm: c_w-mall? i7Liik‘].('Il‘ sxfrm M the c:.Ex‘u_:y”
`fhcn, was 14.2 i_s_r;pmw; the c:c):::im:it§»-' 01"
`tmcrmmai gslccp ;1I'1«:!
`to 1"cr(!1Ir:,e:
`itwg
`pm'inr,i:~: nf‘c.iafcE1iIm*. S1E,?€3[) and dim'nz1l
`flaw xxcma" amii RE5T\—=1$icr:p‘ fF3:1hjc~.c:.1ivc:~
`Ex’, {ha ('iz‘witn1<: tmcyp xms ;_wa‘ca,*i\.v'c~:E as
`heirtg
`§:'np:3m_tiw,
`H1‘z;<zl.ljw.
`a:Et§1mag1*e t_}1~:‘I'r:
`:hut {EH8 mm [3r:;1u;I1,n;e
`htbhavioral
`23'1i‘iL_l1§.'lx:‘~$E’;?LIi£1-Elia‘
`
`in a‘e;1:s.: (€;.md..m:11aik aft
`pctit ma} epifiep ‘
`25%., T97?) émd in LT£'1l.5 1S:‘mz1<;? M.
`11%.,
`E97£'::),
`rm 1.1-;a1t:nti;gE1}-*
`cpziuptuguni-2;
`£Ll'_{Li c1i3<;i1:~ne'gc.s wz::"c §?I’C?~$C1’EL gm thcsc
`‘».ft3i":~:‘ g:uxc'ai«):ng.u:c.§
`r'<:c:-.>rd%ng:; an in lancr
`f01Emv»1.1;:> n:c.m"a§Eng;s;._ and my sliuiml
`5:;~,ir~_1rs:g; haw: (H:Li‘11I"f‘¢3("1.
`
`is c"~’ic§crw=::
`
`'}~ and
`2ear.nziEar 10
`
`DKS(
`
`
`
`@1133?
`
`The’: t:Iin§e:aI am {Z90}).’SOI3W1<‘rg1"é&11hiC
`
`Ct zmgus pmiflacewfl by (EH3 dmrim: the
`"MU day ncrimi
`f:3¢Ilmw:Vd
`1p;:u‘z11h:1
`
`ca-m‘:=,<;:‘ Ci%néca.11§~f,
`pm:
`.m1sI§:
`ff‘
`ymrtué {Bmughmn and ‘Ft-iitrmlak
`E9?9), there was mhzction both in H ‘"
`aiitiration of «:1aj,,»2;,é:m': sltrep mud m the:
`i:1«:ide~:acr¢~ and imensily M cumpiccxéc
`
`swat.“ _, md, Ci)}'T€S§]L)IidilE}§U)U1§E,t1lt:
`Llaytimc pmmtma ml
`J;;ua§g;g:‘;1p11ic RS-
`wr‘ding;~; s}mvw-42:}
`zictznaxi iota] sitxzp
`
`time, amd
`Lime Ln slow‘ xx-‘zsvc sfixscp
`and in R‘I33‘\:i slcugn, ;‘3uh_icsti'vc vclrcmwiyv»
`2:m3s_,
`h(3Vv'%L‘7’\.’L:‘1",
`:'tm11in1md
`in bx‘
`£1
`§%l'E1]‘iI€11IL H \s»'&:"»’s‘ef1£:.C1s3c“l
`'st“1tl"w:1m:k M
`
`ax I1}; "g;nif"i<:a:‘1! (1:”x€l1}LjE-
`in d;1_\~‘Ii:nc mngze
`1‘ 51mm, which in fact: wm *«'(3I'K1M\‘h&li
`h1,c:n'6:m:~:s,“:.
`(l'h*awsirwm.»s
`\‘.—i:l!~L
`.wh.~1+:-
`
`q1wn:Ej,r irrmnwvrzed with mm? —phem~
`«‘imr:.’§ 3\’ig?'nt sluup Wm‘; mzrcei ed
`being (ié.:4:3pv.=.'1“ and Mm r’:S%Ht3§$.
`‘I‘%1:3:“c:
`
`Wm‘
`lass; uf z1iglmnar
`and
`aihzc,ins;=1~
`um
`a,iH1m1,g1h ¢i]1‘:{dlI1il‘.§,§.,
`fin a Immss
`
`
`ce;m1mL1<:-:1. Ci,
`'5-
`g::lc:_. 1:11. mwmnm'.
`pc:»:ad§:V1gI-3’.
`aha:
`2:
`iaimc‘: pmtim: oi
`the t’c':c(u~;i§:1gs sham-d that siecp u.-‘:15
`corasmfiicmtcti mmlm1,gm'pc.r:mis,tl1crc
`wen:
`ikvwir
`smgrg:
`shifts mini
`ssfcmn,
`p2.3r2i{::1!m“1jg: REM slow, wax:
`imsrc
`i11

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket