IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
`FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
`TYLER DIVISION
`
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`
`
`Civil Action No. 6:15-CV-618-JRG-JDL
`LEAD CASE
`
`
`
`JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
`
`
`Civil Action No. 6:15-cv-00639-JRG-JDL
`CONSOLIDATED CASE
`
`
`
`JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
`
`CHRIMAR SYSTEMS, INC., D/B/A CMS
`TECHNOLOGIES AND CHRIMAR
`HOLDING COMPANY, LLC,
` Plaintiffs,
`v.
`
`ADTRAN, INC.,
` Defendant.
`
`CHRIMAR SYSTEMS, INC., D/B/A CMS
`TECHNOLOGIES AND CHRIMAR
`HOLDING COMPANY, LLC,
` Plaintiffs,
`v.
`
`DELL INC. AND AEROHIVE
`NETWORKS, INC.,
` Defendants.
`
`
`
`DEFENDANT DELL INC.’S OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS’ EXHIBIT LIST
`
`Pursuant to the Court’s Docket Control Order entered in this case, Defendant Dell Inc.
`
`(hereinafter, “Dell”) respectfully submits its objections to Plaintiffs’ Exhibit List attached hereto
`
`as Appendix A. Dell reserves the right to supplement these objections.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`-1-
`
`Chrimar Systems, Inc.
`Exhibit 2093-1
`IPR2016-00574 USPN 8,902,760
`
`

`
`November 7, 2016
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`By: /s/ Gilbert A. Greene
`Gilbert A. Greene
`State Bar No. 24045976
`Paul D. Trahan
`State Bar No. 24003075
`James G. Warriner
`State Bar No. 24070813
`Stephanie N. DeBrow
`State Bar No. 24074119
`NORTON ROSE FULBRIGHT US LLP
`98 San Jacinto Boulevard, Suite 1100
`Austin, TX 78701
`Tel: 512.474.5201
`Fax: 512.536.4598
`bert.greene@nortonrosefulbright.com
`paul.trahan@nortonrosefulbright.com
`jim.warriner@nortonrosefulbright.com
`stephanie.debrow@nortonrosefulbright.com
`
`Dan D. Davison
`State Bar No. 05590900
`NORTON ROSE FULBRIGHT US LLP
`2200 Ross Ave., Suite 3600
`Dallas, TX 75201
`Tel: 214.855.8000
`Fax: 214.855.8200
`dan.davison@nortonrosefulbright.com
`
`Deron R. Dacus
`THE DACUS FIRM, P.C.
`821 ESE Loop 323, Suite 430
`Tyler, Texas 75701
`Tel: (903) 705-1117
`Fax: (903) 705-1117
`ddacus@dacusfirm.com
`
`COUNSEL for DEFENDANT DELL, INC.
`
`
`
`
`
`-2-
`
`Chrimar Systems, Inc.
`Exhibit 2093-2
`IPR2016-00574 USPN 8,902,760
`
`

`
`CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
`
`I certify that this document and all attachments thereto were served via email to
`
`Plaintiffs’ counsel of record on November 7, 2016.
`
`/s/ Gilbert A. Greene
`Gilbert Greene
`
`
`
`-3-
`
`Chrimar Systems, Inc.
`Exhibit 2093-3
`IPR2016-00574 USPN 8,902,760
`
`

`
`APPENDIX A
`
`Chrimar Systems, Inc.
`Exhibit 2093-4
`IPR2016-00574 USPN 8,902,760
`
`

`
`PLTF. EXH. NO. DESCRIPTION
`
`BEG. BATES NO. or
`DEPO EX. NO.
`
`END BATES NO.
`
`Dell Inc.'s Objections to Plaintiffs' Exhibit List
`
`Discovery
`
`Defendants' Discovery Responses and Initial Disclosures
`
`PTX-001
`PTX-002
`PTX-003
`PTX-004
`PTX-005
`PTX-006
`PTX-007
`PTX-008
`PTX-009
`PTX-010
`
`PTX-011
`
`PTX-012
`
`PTX-013
`
`PTX-014
`PTX-015
`
`United States Patent No. 8,155,012 B2
`United States Patent No. 8,942,107 B2
`United States Patent No. 8,902,760 B2
`United States Patent No. 9,019,838 B2
`Provisional Application for U.S. Patent 60/081,279
`United States Patent No. 5,406,260
`United States Patent No. 7,457,250
`IEEE 802.3af-2003, June 18, 2003
`IEEE 802.3af-2009, October 30, 2009
`Letter from G. Schively to Marshall Cummings, January 23,
`1998
`Letter from Clyde Boenke to Marshall Cummings, February 10,
`1998
`Letter from Clyde Boenke to Marshall Cummings, March 6,
`1998
`Letter from Clyde Boenke to Marshall Cummings, March 11,
`1998
`Letter C. Boenke to M. Cummings, March 17, 1998
`Handwritten notes, March 13, 1998
`
`CMS000006
`CMS016442
`
`CMS125157
`CMS012440
`CMS297929
`
`CMS002551
`CMS001823
`CMS116584
`CMS002519
`CMS111637
`BOENKE-00054
`CMS001821
`CMS002739
`
`CMS000026
`CMS016449
`
`CMS125288
`CMS012580
`CMS297930
`
`CMS002552
`CMS001825
`CMS116586
`CMS002528
`CMS111646
`BOENKE-00056
`CMS001822
`CMS002739
`
`PTX-016
`
`CMS IWATCH, Schematic
`
`Boenke-0000010
`
`Boenke-0000011
`
`PTX-017
`PTX-018
`PTX-019
`PTX-020
`
`PTX-021
`
`PTX-023
`
`PTX-024
`PTX-025
`PTX-026
`PTX-027
`
`PTX-028
`
`EtherLock II (Physical Exhibit)
`ELID/NIC stick (Physical Exhibit)
`Demonstration PC (Physical Exhibit)
`"CMS Technologies, Arbor Partners Announce Financing,
`Advisory Relationship," Press Release, January 26, 1998
`Confidential Information and Inventions Agreement by and
`between CMS Technologies and Clyde Boenke, February 3,
`1998
`Secrecy and Invention Agreement by and between CMS
`Technologies and Wisne Design/Pico Engineering, April 13,
`1998
`Letter from Clyde Boenke to Marshall Cummings, April 15,
`1998
`Email from John Austermann to Peter Gray, April 18, 1998
`Email from John Austermann, April 23, 1998
`CMS Technologies Sales Order Number SO- 11277, August 18,
`1998
`"CMS Technologies Introduces First Solution to Fill Inventory
`GAP in Asset Management," Press Release, 11/1/1998
`
`CMS227271
`
`CMS088025
`
`CMS002562
`CMS116587
`
`CMS002678
`CMS298004
`CMS297990
`CMS284915
`
`CMS227272
`
`CMS088026
`
`CMS002562
`CMS116587
`
`CMS002678
`CMS298008
`CMS297994
`CMS284915
`
`CMS116593
`
`CMS116594
`
`1 of 59
`
`DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS
`As to the discovery responses and initial disclosures of other defendants, Dell makes the
`following objections: R, P, F, H, IP
`
`As to its own discovery responses Dell maintains the objections lodged in the discovery
`responses themselves. Additionally, to the extent this single
`entry encompasses documents cited in Dell's discovery responses, Dell objects to this
`entry as compound and reserves all objections to the underlying documents pending a
`specific identification of such documents by Plaintiffs.
`
`R, P, H, F, AU
`The document bearing Bates numbers BOENKE-0000010-11 does not match the
`description of this exhibit provided by Chrimar. As a result, Dell is unable to specifically
`identify and review this exhibit. Dell reserves all objections pending specific
`identification of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`R, P
`R, P
`R, P
`R, P, H, F
`
`R, P, H, F
`
`R, P, H, F
`
`R, P, H
`R, P, H, F
`
`R, P, H, F
`
`Chrimar Systems, Inc.
`Exhibit 2093-5
`IPR2016-00574 USPN 8,902,760
`
`

`
`PLTF. EXH. NO. DESCRIPTION
`Letter from Glenn Forbis to Secretary of IEEE-SA Standards
`Board Patent Committee, October 10, 2001
`Settlement and License Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, LLC, and Aastra USA Inc., September 29, 2014
`License and Settlement Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems,
`Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, and Avaya Inc., July 12, 2012
`Confidential License and Settlement Agreement by and among
`Chrimar Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar
`Holding Company, LLC, and Advanced Network Devices, Inc.,
`December 23, 2015
`Confidential Settlement Agreement by and between D-Link
`Systems, Inc. and Chrimar Systems, Inc. d/b/a CMS
`Technologies, April 16, 2010
`License and Settlement Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, LLC, and D-Link Systems, Inc., April 16, 2010
`License and Settlement Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, LLC, and Extreme Networks, Inc., July 16, 2013
`License Agreement by and between Chrimar Systems, Inc., d/b/a
`CMS Technologies and Hubbell Premise Wiring, September 10,
`2004
`License Agreement by and among Chrimar Systems, Inc., d/b/a
`CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding Company, LLC, and
`Keyscan, Inc., October 20, 2015
`License Agreement by and between Chrimar Systems, Inc. and
`Chrimar Holding Company, LLC, March 6, 2015
`License Agreement by and between Chrimar Systems, Inc., and
`Chrimar Holding Company, LLC, April 23, 2013
`License Agreement by and between Chrimar Systems, Inc., and
`Chrimar Holding Company, LLC, September 23, 2011
`License Agreement by and between Chrimar Systems, Inc., d/b/a
`Chrimar Technologies and Waters Network Systems, LLC,
`February 26, 2009
`License Agreement by and between Chrimar Systems, Inc., d/b/a
`Chrimar Technologies, and Neteon Technologies Inc., April 8,
`2009
`License Agreement by and between D-Link Systems, Inc. and
`Chrimar Systems, Inc. d/b/a CMS Technologies, April 16, 2010 CMS281177
`License and Settlement Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, LLC, and Biamp Systems Corporation, January 28,
`2016
`License and Settlement Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, LLC, and IPitomy Communications LLC, March 3,
`2016
`License and Settlement Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, LLC, and Leviton Manufacturing Company, Inc.,
`October 27, 2015
`
`CMS015067
`
`CMS001869
`
`CMS089470
`
`CMS001893
`DKS00068932
`
`CMS031337
`
`CMS001902
`
`CMS059706
`
`CMS064240
`
`CMS048480
`
`CMS089508
`
`CMS016829
`
`CMS089676
`
`CMS059877
`
`CMS098135
`
`CMS098149
`
`CMS064253
`
`PTX-029
`
`PTX-030
`
`PTX-031
`
`PTX-032
`
`PTX-033
`
`PTX-034
`
`PTX-035
`
`PTX-036
`
`PTX-037
`
`PTX-038
`
`PTX-039
`
`PTX-040
`
`PTX-041
`
`PTX-042
`
`PTX-043
`
`PTX-044
`
`PTX-045
`
`PTX-046
`
`BEG. BATES NO. or
`DEPO EX. NO.
`CMS002008
`
`Dell Inc.'s Objections to Plaintiffs' Exhibit List
`
`END BATES NO.
`
`DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS
`
`CMS002008
`
`CMS015084
`
`CMS001882
`
`CMS089483
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`CMS001901 DKS00068970
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`CMS031375
`
`CMS001921
`
`CMS059717
`
`CMS064252
`
`CMS048487
`
`CMS089516
`
`CMS016836
`
`CMS089683
`
`CMS059884
`
`CMS281191
`
`CMS098148
`
`CMS098161
`
`CMS064265
`
`2 of 59
`
`Chrimar Systems, Inc.
`Exhibit 2093-6
`IPR2016-00574 USPN 8,902,760
`
`

`
`PLTF. EXH. NO. DESCRIPTION
`
`BEG. BATES NO. or
`DEPO EX. NO.
`
`END BATES NO.
`
`DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS
`
`Dell Inc.'s Objections to Plaintiffs' Exhibit List
`
`PTX-047
`
`PTX-048
`
`PTX-049
`
`PTX-050
`
`PTX-051
`
`PTX-052
`
`PTX-053
`
`PTX-054
`
`PTX-055
`
`PTX-056
`
`PTX-057
`
`PTX-058
`
`PTX-059
`
`PTX-060
`
`PTX-061
`
`PTX-062
`
`Nonexclusive Patent License Agreement by and between
`Network-1 Security Solutions, Inc. and Allied Telesis, Inc.,
`February 7, 2013
`Nonexclusive Patent License Agreement by and between
`Network-1 Security Solutions, Inc. and Motorola Solutions, Inc.,
`March 30, 2012
`Nonexclusive Patent License Agreement by and between
`Network-1 Security Solutions, Inc. and Transition Networks,
`Inc., March 29, 2012
`Nonexclusive Patent License Agreement by and between
`Network-1 Technologies, Inc. and Huawei Technologies Co.,
`Ltd., July 6, 2015
`Patent License Agreement by and between Network-1 Security
`Solutions, Inc. and BRG Precision Products, Inc., December 31,
`2008
`Patent License Agreement by and between Network-1 Security
`Solutions, Inc. and Buffalo Technology (USA), Inc., December
`31, 2008
`
`Patent License Agreement by and between Network-1 Security
`Solutions, Inc. and SEH Technology, Inc., December 31, 2008
`
`License Agreement by and among Chrimar Systems, Inc., d/b/a
`CMS Technologies, Microsemi Corp Analog Mixed Signal
`Group Ltd, PowerDsine Inc., and Microsemi Corporation,
`February 5, 2010
`License Agreement by and among Chrimar Systems, Inc., d/b/a
`CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding Company, LLC,
`Microsemi Corp Analog Mixed Signal Group Ltd, PowerDsine
`Inc., and Microsemi Corporation, March 6, 2015
`Confidential Settlement Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Microsemi Corp Analog
`Mixed Signal Group Ltd, PowerDsine Inc., and Microsemi
`Corporation, February 5, 2010
`Settlement Agreement and Amendment to License Agreement by
`and between Chrimar Systems, Inc., d/b/a Chrimar Technologies
`and Neteon Technologies Inc., January 18, 2016
`
`Settlement Agreement and Nonexclusive Patent License
`Agreement by and between Network-1 Security Solutions, Inc.
`and NETGEAR Inc., May 22, 2009
`Settlement Agreement by and among Chrimar Systems, Inc.,
`d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding Company, LLC, and
`NetMedia, Inc., September 18, 2015
`
`Settlement Agreement by and between Network-1 Security
`Solutions, Inc. and Allied Telesis, Inc., February 7, 2013
`
`Settlement Agreement by and between Network-1 Security
`Solutions, Inc. and PowerDsine, Inc., November 16, 2005
`
`Settlement and License Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., Chrimar Holding Company, LLC, and
`Grandstream Networks, Inc., January 15, 2015
`
`NETWORK000123
`
`NETWORK000136
`
`This document has not been produced or otherwise provided to Dell. Accordingly, Dell
`reserves all objections pending provision of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`NETWORK000011
`
`NETWORK000022
`
`This document has not been produced or otherwise provided to Dell. Accordingly, Dell
`reserves all objections pending provision of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`NETWORK000001
`
`NETWORK000010
`
`This document has not been produced or otherwise provided to Dell. Accordingly, Dell
`reserves all objections pending provision of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`NETWORK000023
`
`NETWORK0000031
`
`This document has not been produced or otherwise provided to Dell. Accordingly, Dell
`reserves all objections pending provision of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`NETWORK000043
`
`NETWORK000052
`
`This document has not been produced or otherwise provided to Dell. Accordingly, Dell
`reserves all objections pending provision of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`CMS097545
`
`CMS097556
`
`R, P, H
`
`NETWORK000032
`
`NETWORK000042
`
`This document has not been produced or otherwise provided to Dell. Accordingly, Dell
`reserves all objections pending provision of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`CMS001930
`
`CMS001942
`
`CMS089588
`
`CMS089603
`
`CMS001951
`
`CMS001977
`
`CMS098130
`
`CMS098134
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`NETWORK000104
`
`NETWORK000122
`
`This document has not been produced or otherwise provided to Dell. Accordingly, Dell
`reserves all objections pending provision of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`CMS064266
`
`CMS064272
`
`NETWORK000137
`
`NETWORK000143
`
`This document has not been produced or otherwise provided to Dell. Accordingly, Dell
`reserves all objections pending provision of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`NETWORK000053
`
`NETWORK000075
`
`This document has not been produced or otherwise provided to Dell. Accordingly, Dell
`reserves all objections pending provision of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`CMS015237
`
`CMS015253
`
`R, P, H
`
`3 of 59
`
`Chrimar Systems, Inc.
`Exhibit 2093-7
`IPR2016-00574 USPN 8,902,760
`
`

`
`PLTF. EXH. NO. DESCRIPTION
`
`BEG. BATES NO. or
`DEPO EX. NO.
`
`END BATES NO.
`
`DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS
`
`Dell Inc.'s Objections to Plaintiffs' Exhibit List
`
`PTX-063
`
`PTX-064
`
`PTX-065
`
`PTX-066
`
`PTX-067
`
`PTX-068
`
`PTX-069
`
`PTX-070
`
`PTX-071
`
`PTX-072
`
`PTX-073
`
`PTX-074
`
`PTX-075
`
`PTX-076
`
`Settlement and License Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, LLC, and Allied Telesis, Inc., March 25, 2016
`
`Settlement and License Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, LLC, and Belkin International, Inc., March 30, 2016
`Settlement and License Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, LLC, and Korenix USA Corporation, December 21,
`2015
`Settlement and License Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, LLC, and Phihong USA Corporation, March 30, 2016
`Settlement and License Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, LLC, and Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd., December
`29, 2004
`Settlement and License Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, LLC, and StarTech.com USA LLP, December 22,
`2015
`Settlement and License Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems,
`Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, LLC, and Transition Networks, Inc., November 20,
`2015
`Settlement and License Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, LLC, and Tycon Systems Inc., October 22, 2015
`Settlement and License Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, LLC, Buffalo Americas, Inc., and Buffalo, Inc., April
`20, 2016
`Settlement and License Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, LLC, Edimax Computer Company d/b/a Edimax
`Technology Co., Edimax Technology Co. Limited, and
`Comtrend Corporation, January 7, 2016
`Settlement and License Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, LLC, MOXA Americas Inc., and MOXA Inc., March
`23, 2016
`Settlement and License Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, LLC, POWERDSINE Inc., and Microsemi
`Corporation., March 6, 2015
`
`CMS102318
`
`CMS102330
`
`CMS102331
`
`CMS102351
`
`CMS064312
`
`CMS064324
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`CMS281215
`
`CMS281226
`
`R, P, H, F
`
`CMS062614
`
`CMS062633
`
`CMS064325
`
`CMS064337
`
`CMS064284
`
`CMS064296
`
`CMS064273
`
`CMS064283
`
`CMS285670
`
`CMS285681
`
`CMS089289
`
`CMS089302
`
`CMS102286
`
`CMS102298
`
`CMS031657
`
`CMS031672
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H
`
`Settlement and License Agreement by and among Network-1
`Technologies, Inc. and ALE USA Inc., July 7, 2016
`
`ALE0208148
`
`ALE0208179
`
`This document has not been produced or otherwise provided to Dell. Accordingly, Dell
`reserves all objections pending provision of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`Settlement and License Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, LLC, Belden, Inc., GarrettCom Inc., and Hirschmann
`Automation and Control, Inc., August 29, 2016
`
`CMS321113
`
`CMS321125
`
`R, P, H
`
`4 of 59
`
`Chrimar Systems, Inc.
`Exhibit 2093-8
`IPR2016-00574 USPN 8,902,760
`
`

`
`PLTF. EXH. NO. DESCRIPTION
`Settlement and License Agreement by and among Chrimar
`Systems, Inc., d/b/a CMS Technologies, Chrimar Holding
`Company, LLC and WatchGuard Technologies, Inc., September
`13, 2016
`
`PTX-077
`
`Dell Inc.'s Objections to Plaintiffs' Exhibit List
`
`BEG. BATES NO. or
`DEPO EX. NO.
`
`END BATES NO.
`
`DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS
`
`CMS325131
`
`CMS325148
`
`R, P, H
`
`This document lacks a Bates number or other identifier sufficient to permit Dell to
`specifically identify and review the document. Dell reserves all objections pending
`identification of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`PTX-078
`
`PTX-079
`PTX-080
`PTX-081
`PTX-082
`PTX-083
`PTX-084
`PTX-085
`PTX-086
`PTX-087
`PTX-088
`
`PTX-089
`PTX-090
`PTX-091
`PTX-092
`PTX-093
`PTX-094
`
`2000 IEEE-SA Standards Bylaws, 10/1999
`2001 IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylaws, 12/2000
`2002 IEEE-SA Standards Bylaws, 1/2002
`IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylaws, 2/2003
`IEEE-SA Standards Bylaws, 1/2005
`IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylaws, 04/2007
`IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual, 12/2000
`IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual, 12/2002
`IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual, 1/2004
`IEEE-SA Standards Board Meeting Minutes, IEEE Operations
`Center Piscataway, NJ, 3/30/2006
`Minutes of the Power via the MDI Task Force, New Orleans,
`LA, September 12-23
`IEEE-SA Patent Policy, July 17, 2001
`IEEE-SA PatCom Comments, September 12, 2006
`IEEE-SASB Patent Committee, “Pre-PAR Intellectual Property
`Management," September 25, 2007
`Patent Policy Tutorial, March 1, 2016
`"Standards Management and Texas Instruments,"
`Standardization News, December 1997
`
`IEEE_CHRI_00000856
`IEEE_CHRI_00000136
`IEEE_CHRI_00000557
`IEEE_CHRI_00000223
`IEEE_CHRI_00000672
`IEEE_CHRI_00000080
`IEEE_CHRI_00000994
`IEEE_CHRI_00000421
`IEEE_CHRI_00000698
`IEEE_CHRI_00001309
`
`IEEE_CHRI_00000872
`IEEE_CHRI_00000151
`IEEE_CHRI_00000572
`IEEE_CHRI_00000237
`IEEE_CHRI_00000694
`IEEE_CHRI_00000097
`IEEE_CHRI_00001031
`IEEE_CHRI_00000438
`IEEE_CHRI_00000736
`IEEE_CHRI_00001315
`
`CMS184884
`CMS091373
`CMS297078
`CMS297109
`CMS297146
`CMS311672
`
`CMS184894
`CMS091377
`CMS297108
`CMS297119
`CMS297183
`CMS311682
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H, F
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H, F, AU
`
`PTX-095
`
`Letter from Kevin Smith to David Ringle, June 18, 2003
`
`ALE0053103
`
`ALE0053103
`
`This document has not been produced or otherwise provided to Dell. Accordingly, Dell
`reserves all objections pending provision of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`PTX-096
`
`PTX-097
`PTX-098
`PTX-099
`PTX-100
`
`PTX-101
`
`PTX-102
`
`PTX-103
`
`PTX-104
`
`PTX-105
`
`Letter of Assurance for Essential Patents, 3Com Corporation,
`March 7, 2005
`
`ALE0053098
`
`ALE0053099
`
`This document has not been produced or otherwise provided to Dell. Accordingly, Dell
`reserves all objections pending provision of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`Email chain of PoEplus list group, October 7, 2004
`Email chain of PoEplus list group, March 24, 2005
`Email chain of PoEplus list group, November 3, 2005
`Power over Ethernet Plus 802.3 Study Group Agenda and
`General Information, M. McCormack (3Com Corporation)
`P802.3at Task Force DTE Power via the MDI Enhancements
`Agenda and General Information, Michael McCormack, January
`10-12, 2006
`
`M. McCormack Depo Ex. 3
`M. McCormack Depo Ex. 4
`M. McCormack Depo Ex. 5
`M. McCormack Depo Ex. 6
`
`M. McCormack Depo Ex. 7
`
`IEEE-SA Records of IEEE Standards-Related Patent Letters of
`Assurance for IEEE Standard 802.3 and Amendments – 802.3.1 M. McCormack Depo Ex. 9
`
`Email chain between Michael McCormack and John
`Austermann, September 6, 2006
`Email from Michael McCormack to PoEplus members, July 19,
`2005
`
`M. McCormack Depo Ex. 12
`
`M. McCormack Depo Ex. 13
`
`5 of 59
`
`R, P, H
`R, P, H
`R, P, H
`H, F
`
`R, P, H, MIS
`
`This document lacks a Bates number or other identifier sufficient to permit Dell to
`specifically identify and review the document. Dell reserves all objections pending
`identification of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`This document lacks a Bates number or other identifier sufficient to permit Dell to
`specifically identify and review the document, as there is no Exhibit 9 to Mr.
`McCormack's deposition in this case. Accordingly, Dell reserves all objections pending
`specific idenfication of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`R, P, H, AU
`
`R, P, H
`
`Chrimar Systems, Inc.
`Exhibit 2093-9
`IPR2016-00574 USPN 8,902,760
`
`

`
`PLTF. EXH. NO. DESCRIPTION
`PTX-106
`Email chain of PoE plus list group, July 28, 2005
`PTX-107
`Email chain of PoE plus list group, September 6, 2005
`IEEE Standards Association Antitrust and Competition Policy,
`PTX-108
`March 22, 2007
`IEEE 802.3 & Subgroups - Attendance Sheet, La Jolla,
`California, July 2000
`Email chain between Michael McCormack and Ron Bose,
`September 6, 2005
`Email from Judy Gorman to John Austermann, June 23, 2000
`
`PTX-110
`PTX-111
`
`PTX-109
`
`J. Austermann Presentation at La Jolla
`
`Email Chain, August 2001
`Letter from Greg Schively to Denise Scozzafava, 10/25/2000
`Letter from Denise Scozzafava to Greg Schively, 11/14/2000
`Letter G. Forbis to IEEE-SA Secretary, 10/10/2001
`Letter from Geoff Thompson to John Austermann, October 12,
`2001
`"Investigation of Sensing for DTE Power via MDI," Jennifer
`Rasimas, Stephen Jackson, Nortel Networks, IEEE Proposal,
`January 20, 2000
`Approved Minutes of IEEE-SA Standards Board PatCom
`Meeting, 12/5/2000
`
`Dell Inc.'s Objections to Plaintiffs' Exhibit List
`
`END BATES NO.
`
`BEG. BATES NO. or
`DEPO EX. NO.
`M. McCormack Depo Ex. 14
`M. McCormack Depo Ex. 15
`M. McCormack Depo Ex 16
`
`M. McCormack Depo Ex. 18
`
`DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS
`R, P, H
`R, P, H
`R, P, H
`
`TI-0000079
`CMS089723
`
`CMS089889
`
`CMS015108
`CMS089728
`CMS089730
`CMS016633
`CMS016636
`
`TI-0000079
`CMS089723
`
`CMS089896
`
`CMS015110
`CMS089729
`CMS089730
`CMS016635
`CMS016638
`
`AMXII-0015906
`
`AMXII-0015912
`
`CMS089686
`
`CMS089689
`
`R, P, H, I
`
`R, P, H
`
`This document has not been produced or otherwise provided to Dell. Accordingly, Dell
`reserves all objections pending provision of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`PTX-112
`
`PTX-113
`PTX-114
`PTX-115
`PTX-116
`PTX-117
`
`PTX-118
`
`PTX-119
`
`PTX-120
`
`PTX-121
`
`PTX-122
`
`PTX-123
`
`PTX-124
`
`PTX-125
`
`PTX-126
`
`PTX-127
`
`PTX-128
`
`PTX-129
`
`IEEE 802.3af Task Force Minutes, LaJolla, CA, 7/11-12/2000
`
`ALE0046301
`
`ALE0046304
`
`This document has not been produced or otherwise provided to Dell. Accordingly, Dell
`reserves all objections pending provision of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`Letter of Assurance for Essential Patents, December 3, 2001
`"Classification of the 802.3 Connection, Multi-bit Identification
`Scheme Using Existing Ethernet Data Lines," CMS
`Technologies, 1/24-28/2005
`"PoE Plus -- IEEE 802.3at Extended Classification Using Ping-
`Pong Scheme," Texas Instruments, 1/10/2005
`Letter from Ben C. Johnson to Donald S. Clark, April 17, 2002 CMS091308
`
`CMS016037
`
`CMS089708
`
`CMS089690
`
`IEEE 802, "Welcome to IEEE 802 Newcomer Orientation," July
`7, 2015
`
`A. Petrick Depo Ex. 9 from
`6:15-cv-163
`
`IEEE-SA Standards Patent Committee (PatCom) Minutes, Hyatt
`Regency, Atlanta, Georgia, 3/18/2005
`
`A. Petrick Depo Ex. 16 from
`6:15-cv-163
`
`CMS016037
`
`CMS089714
`
`CMS089707
`
`CMS091314
`
`R, P, H, F, AU
`
`R, P, H, F, AU
`The document marked at Ex. 9 from Mr. Petrick's deposition in Case No. 6-15-CV-00163
`is a presentation entitled "Welcome to the July 2000 Plenary Meeting of the 802.3af
`DTE Power via MDI Task Force" (CMS324453), which does not match the description
`Chrimar has included for this Exhibit. As a result, Dell is unable to specifically identify
`and review this exhibit. Dell reserves all objections pending specific identification of
`the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`The document marked at Ex. 16 from Mr. Petrick's deposition in Case No. 6-15-CV-
`00163 is the 2001 IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual (IEEE_CHR00000576),
`which does not match the description Chrimar has included for this Exhibit. As a result,
`Dell is unable to specifically identify and review this exhibit. Dell reserves all objections
`pending specific identification of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`U.S. Patent No. 5,712,870
`
`IEEE 802.3af Task Force Minutes, LaJolla, July 11 12, 2000
`New Participation Orientation Slides, IEEE 802.11, Al Petrick,
`January 2005
`
`Petrick Ex 4 from 6:15-cv-
`163
`Petrick Ex 10 from 6:15-cv-
`163
`Petrick Ex 3 from 6:15-cv-
`163
`
`R, P, H
`
`R, P, H, AU
`
`6 of 59
`
`Chrimar Systems, Inc.
`Exhibit 2093-10
`IPR2016-00574 USPN 8,902,760
`
`

`
`PLTF. EXH. NO. DESCRIPTION
`IEEE-SA Records of IEEE Standards-Related Patent Letters of
`Assurance for IEEE Standards 802.11 and Amendments
`IEEE Standards Style Manual, May 2000
`
`PTX-131
`
`PTX-130
`
`PTX-132
`PTX-133
`
`IEEE Standards Style Manual, January 2005
`U.S. Patent No. 6,546,494
`
`PTX-134
`
`"DTE Power via MDI — 5 Criteria"
`
`Dell Inc.'s Objections to Plaintiffs' Exhibit List
`
`BEG. BATES NO. or
`DEPO EX. NO.
`CMS297670
`Petrick Ex 19 from 6:15-cv-
`163
`Petrick Ex 20 from 6:15-cv-
`163
`CMS321103
`
`Carlson Ex 2 from 6:15-cv-
`163
`
`END BATES NO.
`
`DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS
`
`CMS297717
`
`CMS321112
`
`R, P, H, AU
`
`R, P, H, AU
`R, P
`
`Although the deposition transcript referenced by Chrimar has been produced at
`CMS314969, the exhibits to that deposition are neither identified by Bates number in
`nor attached to the transcript. Thus, this document has not been identified in a way
`that permits Dell to locate and review the document. Accordingly, Dell reserves all
`objections pending specific identification of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`PTX-135
`PTX-136
`
`Minutes of July 1999 IEEE 802.3 CFI
`IEEE 802.3 Working Group Attendance Sheet
`
`CMS014019
`CMS101312
`
`CMS014029
`CMS101319
`
`R, P, H, F
`
`PTX-137
`
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power Meeting Minutes, Tampa, Florida,
`November 7, 2000
`
`Carlson Ex 6 from 6:15-cv-
`163
`
`PTX-138
`
`PTX-139
`
`PTX-140
`
`PTX-141
`
`Email from Steve Carlson to John Austermann regarding DTE
`Power Presentation, June 25, 2000
`Email from Steve Carlson to John Austermann regarding CMS
`Presentation for 802.3af, July 5, 2000
`Email from Geoff Thompson to stds-802-3-
`pwrviamdi@xxxxxxxx regarding Legal action, April 27, 2001
`
`CMS062467
`
`CMS089719
`
`CMS089724
`
`CMS062468
`
`CMS089720
`
`CMS089727
`
`PTX-142
`
`Email from R. Brooks "Detecting a PD disconnection event"
`
`Carlson Ex 12 from 6:15-cv-
`163
`
`PTX-143
`
`Email from Y. Darshan "Detecting a PD disconnection event"
`
`Carlson Ex 13 from 6:15-cv-
`163
`
`PTX-144
`
`Email from N. Stapleton "Detecting a PD disconnection event"
`
`Carlson Ex 14 from 6:15-cv-
`163
`
`Although the deposition transcript referenced by Chrimar has been produced at
`CMS314969, the exhibits to that deposition are neither identified by Bates number in
`nor attached to the transcript. Thus, this document has not been identified in a way
`that permits Dell to locate and review the document. Accordingly, Dell reserves all
`objections pending specific identification of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`This document lacks a Bates number or other identifier sufficient to permit Dell to
`specifically identify and review the document. Dell reserves all objections pending
`identification of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`Although the deposition transcript referenced by Chrimar has been produced at
`CMS314969, the exhibits to that deposition are neither identified by Bates number in
`nor attached to the transcript. Thus, this document has not been identified in a way
`that permits Dell to locate and review the document. Accordingly, Dell reserves all
`objections pending specific identification of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`Although the deposition transcript referenced by Chrimar has been produced at
`CMS314969, the exhibits to that deposition are neither identified by Bates number in
`nor attached to the transcript. Thus, this document has not been identified in a way
`that permits Dell to locate and review the document. Accordingly, Dell reserves all
`objections pending specific identification of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`Although the deposition transcript referenced by Chrimar has been produced at
`CMS314969, the exhibits to that deposition are neither identified by Bates number in
`nor attached to the transcript. Thus, this document has not been identified in a way
`that permits Dell to locate and review the document. Accordingly, Dell reserves all
`objections pending specific identification of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`7 of 59
`
`Chrimar Systems, Inc.
`Exhibit 2093-11
`IPR2016-00574 USPN 8,902,760
`
`

`
`PLTF. EXH. NO. DESCRIPTION
`
`BEG. BATES NO. or
`DEPO EX. NO.
`
`END BATES NO.
`
`DEFENDANTS' OBJECTIONS
`
`Dell Inc.'s Objections to Plaintiffs' Exhibit List
`
`PTX-145
`
`Email from G. Thompson "Detecting a PD disconnection event" Carlson Ex 15 from 6:15-cv-
`163
`
`PTX-146
`
`802.3af Task Force Welcome Slides, July 2001
`
`Carlson Ex 16 from 6:15-cv-
`163
`
`Email from Steve Carlson to John Austermann regarding DTE
`Power Presentation, June 25, 2000
`Email from Steve Carlson to John Austermann regarding CMS
`Presentation for 802.3af, July 5, 2000
`Email from Matt McKinney to Michael McCormack, et al., Re:
`LTC PoE+ Contributed Article, August 31, 2009
`
`CMS059759
`
`CMS089719
`
`TI-0073678-683
`
`Although the deposition transcript referenced by Chrimar has been produced at
`CMS314969, the exhibits to that deposition are neither identified by Bates number in
`nor attached to the transcript. Thus, this document has not been identified in a way
`that permits Dell to locate and review the document. Accordingly, Dell reserves all
`objections pending specific identification of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`Although the deposition transcript referenced by Chrimar has been produced at
`CMS314969, the exhibits to that deposition are neither identified by Bates number in
`nor attached to the transcript. Thus, this document has not been identified in a way
`that permits Dell to locate and review the document. Accordingly, Dell reserves all
`objections pending specific identification of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`R, P, H
`This document lacks a Bates number or other identifier sufficient to permit Dell to
`specifically identify and review the document. Dell reserves all objections pending
`identification of the document to Dell by Chrimar.
`
`R, P, H, F, AU
`
`R, P, H, F
`
`CMS059760
`
`CMS089720
`
`CMS325055
`
`CMS289943
`
`CMS289901
`
`PTX-147
`
`PTX-148
`
`PTX-149
`
`PTX-150
`
`PTX-151
`
`PTX-152
`
`PTX-153
`
`PTX-154
`
`PTX-155
`
`PTX-156
`
`PTX-157
`
`PTX-158
`
`PTX-159
`
`PTX-160
`
`CMS325054
`
`CMS289936
`
`CMS289880
`
`"Power-over-Ethernet Ports Exceed One in Five Shipments,
`According to Dell'Oro Group," Press Release, November 19,
`2007
`"3Com Solutions: Power over Ethernet," 3Com White Paper,
`2007.
`"Designing a Low-Cost IEEE 802.3af PD (Powered Device)
`Front-end," PowerDsine White Paper, February 12, 2004.
`"Gartner Says Worldwide Ethernet Switches Revenue
`Grew 24 Percent in 2004," Gartner press release,
`February 24, 2005
`(http://www.gartner.com/newsroom/id/492108).
`"Licensing," Network-1 website (http://www.network-
`1.com/portfolio/IP licensing.htm)
`"Reviews - Power over Ethernet switches group test " Personal
`Computer World, November 1, 2005
`“Senior VP Charlie Giancarlo Discusses How Power over
`Ethernet in Cisco Catalyst Intelligent Switches Brings New
`Levels of Network Convergence,” Cisco newsroom, February 17,
`2004
`Case Study: Purdue University, Microsemi website
`(http://www.microsemi.com/document-
`porta