IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
`FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
`TYLER DIVISION
`
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`
`
`Civil Action No. 6:15-CV-618-JRG-JDL
`LEAD CASE
`
`
`
`JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
`
`
`Civil Action No. 6:15-cv-00639-JRG-JDL
`CONSOLIDATED CASE
`
`
`
`JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
`
`CHRIMAR SYSTEMS, INC., D/B/A CMS
`TECHNOLOGIES AND CHRIMAR
`HOLDING COMPANY, LLC,
` Plaintiffs,
`v.
`
`ADTRAN, INC.,
` Defendant.
`
`CHRIMAR SYSTEMS, INC., D/B/A CMS
`TECHNOLOGIES AND CHRIMAR
`HOLDING COMPANY, LLC,
` Plaintiffs,
`v.
`
`DELL INC. AND AEROHIVE
`NETWORKS, INC.,
` Defendants.
`
`
`
`DEFENDANT DELL INC.’S EXHIBIT LIST
`
`Pursuant to the Court’s Docket Control Order entered in this case, Defendant Dell Inc.
`
`(hereinafter, “Dell”) respectfully submits the Exhibit List attached hereto as Appendix A for
`
`identification of documents Dell expects to offer and may offer at trial. Dell’s Witness List and
`
`Deposition Designations are being served separately. Dell reserves the right to supplement this
`
`Exhibit List.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`-1-
`
`

`
`October 24, 2016
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`By: /s/ Gilbert A. Greene
`Gilbert A. Greene
`State Bar No. 24045976
`Paul D. Trahan
`State Bar No. 24003075
`James G. Warriner
`State Bar No. 24070813
`Stephanie N. DeBrow
`State Bar No. 24074119
`NORTON ROSE FULBRIGHT US LLP
`98 San Jacinto Boulevard, Suite 1100
`Austin, TX 78701
`Tel: 512.474.5201
`Fax: 512.536.4598
`bert.greene@nortonrosefulbright.com
`paul.trahan@nortonrosefulbright.com
`jim.warriner@nortonrosefulbright.com
`stephanie.debrow@nortonrosefulbright.com
`
`Dan D. Davison
`State Bar No. 05590900
`NORTON ROSE FULBRIGHT US LLP
`2200 Ross Ave., Suite 3600
`Dallas, TX 75201
`Tel: 214.855.8000
`Fax: 214.855.8200
`dan.davison@nortonrosefulbright.com
`
`Deron R. Dacus
`THE DACUS FIRM, P.C.
`821 ESE Loop 323, Suite 430
`Tyler, Texas 75701
`Tel: (903) 705-1117
`Fax: (903) 705-1117
`ddacus@dacusfirm.com
`
`COUNSEL for DEFENDANT DELL, INC.
`
`
`
`
`
`-2-
`
`

`
`CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
`
`I certify that this document and all attachments thereto were served via email to
`
`Plaintiffs’ counsel of record on October 24, 2016.
`
`/s/ Gilbert A. Greene
`Gilbert Greene
`
`
`
`-3-
`
`

`
`APPENDIX A
`
`APPENDIX A
`
`

`
`Offered
`
`Objection
`
`Admitted
`
`Date
`
`Witness
`
`DTX No.
`DTX-1
`DTX-2
`DTX-3
`DTX-4
`DTX-5
`DTX-6
`DTX-7
`DTX-8
`DTX-9
`DTX-10
`DTX-11
`DTX-12
`DTX-13
`
`DTX-14
`DTX-15
`DTX-16
`DTX-17
`DTX-18
`DTX-19
`DTX-20
`DTX-21
`DTX-22
`DTX-23
`
`DTX-24
`DTX-25
`DTX-26
`DTX-27
`
`DTX-28
`
`DTX-29
`DTX-30
`
`DTX-31
`
`DTX-32
`DTX-33
`
`DTX-34
`DTX-35
`
`Description
`Aruba 100 Series Access Points Data Sheet
`Aruba 103 Series Access Points Data Sheet
`Aruba AP-103H Hospitality Access Point Data Sheet
`Aruba 110 Series Access Points Data Sheet
`Aruba AP-175 Access Point Data Sheet
`Aruba 200 Series Access Points Data Sheet
`Aruba AP-205H Hospitality Access Point Data Sheet
`Aruba 210 Series Access Points Data Sheet
`Aruba 220 Series Access Points Data Sheet
`Aruba 270 Series Outdoor Access Points Data Sheet
`BCM5910X/BCM591X1 Data Sheet
`BCM5910X/BCM591X1 Programmer's Reference Guide
`BCM5910X Integrated IEEE 802.3at PoE PSE Controllers
`BCM59101/BCM59103 Power Management/Multiple Power
`Source Management
`BCM59101B Data Sheet
`BCM59101 Data Sheet
`BCM59103B High-Power PSE Design Guidelines
`BCM59103 Product Brief
`BCM59111 Data Sheet
`BCM59111 Data Sheet
`BCM59111 Programmer's Reference Guide
`BCM59121 Data Sheet
`BCM59121 Programmer's Reference Guide
`Average ASP/port for BCM59101, BCM59103, BCM59111,
`BCM59121
`Nortel Networks Proposed Digital DTE Detection Circuit
`Nortel Networks DTE End Demo
`802.3af DTE Power via MDI Task Force Presentation
`July 2000 Minutes for IEEE 802.3 CSMA/CD Meeting,
`07/10/2000
`"Resistive" Signature and Detection Protocol Summary and Overall
`Feasibility Presentation, dated November 2000
`DTE Power via MDI - 5 Criteria
`
`IDLE PAIR Discovery Process presentation, dated March 2000
`Preliminary Simulation Results for Diode Discovery Process
`presentation by HP dated March 2000
`Update on Diode Discovery Process dated May 2000
`Common Mode and Differential Mode Discovery Techniques dated
`May 2000
`Consensus Proposal from HP dated May 2000
`
`Defendant Dell Inc.'s Exhibit List
`
`Beginning Bates
`Aruba-DellSub_00000003
`Aruba-DellSub_00000012
`Aruba-DellSub_00000020
`Aruba-DellSub_00000026
`Aruba-DellSub_00000069
`Aruba-DellSub_00000075
`Aruba-DellSub_00000082
`Aruba-DellSub_00000089
`Aruba-DellSub_00000096
`Aruba-DellSub_00000103
`BRCM0001
`BRCM0050
`BRCM0126
`
`End Bates
`Aruba-DellSub_00000009
`Aruba-DellSub_00000017
`Aruba-DellSub_00000025
`Aruba-DellSub_00000032
`Aruba-DellSub_00000072
`Aruba-DellSub_00000081
`Aruba-DellSub_00000088
`Aruba-DellSub_00000095
`Aruba-DellSub_00000102
`Aruba-DellSub_00000108
`BRCM0021
`BRCM0125
`BRCM0177
`
`BRCM0190
`BRCM0254
`BRCM0303
`BRCM0306
`BRCM0331
`BRCM0333
`BRCM0391
`BRCM0393
`BRCM0514
`BRCM0568
`
`BRCM0689
`CARLSON0001
`CARLSON0002
`CARLSON0003
`
`BRCM0253
`BRCM0302
`BRCM0304
`BRCM0330
`BRCM0332
`BRCM0390
`BRCM0392
`BRCM0513
`BRCM0567
`BRCM0688
`
`BRCM0689
`CARLSON0001
`CARLSON0002
`CARLSON0028
`
`CARLSON0029
`
`CARLSON0042
`
`CARLSON0043
`CARLSON0092
`
`CARLSON0091
`CARLSON0093
`
`CARLSON0094
`
`CARLSON0104
`
`CARLSON0105
`CARLSON0118
`
`CARLSON0142
`CARLSON0157
`
`CARLSON0117
`CARLSON0141
`
`CARLSON0156
`CARLSON0167
`
`DTX-36
`
`IEEE 802.3af Task Force Minutes LaJolla dated July 11-12, 2000
`
`CARLSON0168
`
`CARLSON0171
`
`DTX-37
`DTX-38
`DTX-39
`DTX-40
`DTX-41
`
`Coupled Diode Discovery Protocols and Prototypes dated July 2000 CARLSON0172
`Discovery Method Evaluation, Cisco
`CARLSON0186
`Diode Discovery Process Economic Feasibility
`CARLSON0192
`Diode Discovery Process Lab Testing Results
`CARLSON0205
`Analysis and Implementation of Coupled Diode Detection
`CARLSON0239
`
`CARLSON0185
`CARLSON0191
`CARLSON0204
`CARLSON0238
`CARLSON0277
`
`1 of 44
`
`

`
`DTX No.
`
`Description
`
`Beginning Bates
`
`End Bates
`
`Offered
`
`Objection
`
`Admitted
`
`Date
`
`Witness
`
`Defendant Dell Inc.'s Exhibit List
`
`DTX-42
`
`DTX-43
`
`DTX-44
`
`DTX-45
`DTX-46
`
`DTX-47
`DTX-48
`
`DTX-49
`DTX-50
`DTX-51
`
`DTX-52
`
`DTX-53
`DTX-54
`
`DTX-55
`DTX-56
`
`DTX-57
`DTX-58
`DTX-59
`DTX-60
`
`DTX-61
`DTX-62
`DTX-63
`
`DTX-64
`DTX-65
`DTX-66
`DTX-67
`DTX-68
`DTX-69
`DTX-70
`DTX-71
`DTX-72
`DTX-73
`
`DTX-74
`DTX-75
`DTX-76
`DTX-77
`
`Diode Discovery Some Hazard Matrix Tests dated April 9, 2000
`White Paper on the subject of the AC coupled diode discovery
`method dated July 2000
`IEEE Criteria for Evaluating Detection Schemes dated October 9,
`2000
`
`CARLSON0278
`
`CARLSON0284
`
`CARLSON0285
`
`CARLSON0305
`
`CARLSON0306
`
`CARLSON0314
`
`Comparative CISPR22 Class B Telecom-Port Conducted Emissions
`for the Resistive Prototype and Coupled Diode Prototype
`802.3af Plug Fest Results dated November 2000
`
`Nov. 2000 Stewart Presentation for IEEE Meeting, 11/01/2000
`Detection Methods - Reliability Analysis
`Resistive Signature and Detection Protocol Summary and Overall
`Feasibility dated November 2000
`Coupled Diode Discovery It Works dated November 2000
`Discovery, will it affect AM radio? Dated November 2000
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power Meeting Minutes in Tampa Florida
`November 2000
`Economic Feasibility of supporting power on both pair sets in the
`DTE
`DTE Detection Revisited dated May 25, 2000
`Technical Feasibility of Sending Common Mode Power on the
`Signal Pairs
`DC Power Discovery Algorithm by Phil Holland
`Diode Discovery Process Power Level Detection by Robert Muir
`from Intel
`Power Classification for the PD by Roger Karam
`July 1999 IEEE Meeting Minutes, 07/07/1999
`July 1999 IEEE Meeting Agenda, 07/30/1999
`Proposed Objectives for the DTE Power via the MDI SG October 1,
`1999
`Sept. 1999 IEEE Meeting Minutes, 09/30/1999
`Sept. 1999 Index for IEEE Meeting Materials, 09/30/1999
`
`Sept. 1999 802.3af Project Authorization Request, 11/11/1999
`Nov. 1999 Index for IEEE Meeting Materials, 11/09/1999
`Nov. 1999 IEEE Meeting Minutes, 11/09/1999
`Nov. 1999 IEEE Meeting Agenda, 11/09/1999
`Jan. 2000 Index for IEEE Meeting Materials ,01/20/2000
`Jan. 2000 IEEE Meeting Minutes, 01/20/2000
`Jan. 2000 IEEE Meeting Agenda, 01/20/2000
`Mar. 2000 Index for IEEE Meeting Materials, 03/07/2000
`Mar. 2000 IEEE Meeting Minutes, 03/07/2000
`Mar. 2000 IEEE Meeting Agenda, 03/07/2000
`
`Mar. 2000 Glaser Presentation for IEEE Meeting, 03/01/2000
`May 2000 Index for IEEE Meeting Materials, 05/24/2000
`May 2000 IEEE Meeting Minutes, 05/24/2000
`May 2000 IEEE Meeting Agenda, 05/04/2000
`
`CARLSON0315
`CARLSON0324
`
`CARLSON0332
`CARLSON0341
`
`CARLSON0364
`CARLSON0413
`CARLSON0436
`
`CARLSON0323
`CARLSON0331
`
`CARLSON0340
`CARLSON0363
`
`CARLSON0412
`CARLSON0435
`CARLSON0440
`
`CARLSON0441
`
`CARLSON0448
`
`CARLSON0449
`CARLSON0456
`
`CARLSON0464
`CARLSON0557
`
`CARLSON0576
`CARLSON0602
`CARLSON0607
`CARLSON0611
`
`CARLSON0624
`CARLSON0626
`CARLSON0633
`
`CARLSON0634
`CARLSON0637
`CARLSON0639
`CARLSON0643
`CARLSON0657
`CARLSON0659
`CARLSON0664
`CARLSON0681
`CARLSON0683
`CARLSON0688
`
`CARLSON0714
`CARLSON0717
`CARLSON0719
`CARLSON0727
`
`CARLSON0455
`CARLSON0463
`
`CARLSON0556
`CARLSON0575
`
`CARLSON0601
`CARLSON0605
`CARLSON0610
`CARLSON0623
`
`CARLSON0625
`CARLSON0632
`CARLSON0633
`
`CARLSON0636
`CARLSON0638
`CARLSON0639
`CARLSON0656
`CARLSON0658
`CARLSON0663
`CARLSON0680
`CARLSON0682
`CARLSON0687
`CARLSON0713
`
`CARLSON0716
`CARLSON0718
`CARLSON0726
`CARLSON0750
`
`2 of 44
`
`

`
`DTX No.
`
`Description
`
`Beginning Bates
`
`End Bates
`
`Offered
`
`Objection
`
`Admitted
`
`Date
`
`Witness
`
`Defendant Dell Inc.'s Exhibit List
`
`DTX-78
`
`DTX-79
`
`DTX-80
`
`DTX-81
`DTX-82
`
`Detection and Signature Protocol by Lucent dated April 18, 2000
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power via MDI Task Force July 2000 Plenary
`Work Meeting July 11-12, 2000 La Jolla, CA
`Power, Detection and Discovery over the Existing Ethernet Wiring
`by CMS Technologies, July 2000
`
`CARLSON0751
`
`CARLSON0758
`
`CARLSON0759
`
`CARLSON0761
`
`CARLSON0762
`
`CARLSON0769
`
`Attendance Sheet for IEEE Meetings in La Jolla, CA in July 2000
`IEEE 802.3af Task Force Minutes, La Jolla
`
`CARLSON0770
`CARLSON0778
`
`CARLSON0777
`CARLSON0781
`
`DTX-83
`
`July 2000 Leonowich Presentation for IEEE Meeting, 07/11/2000
`
`CARLSON0782
`
`CARLSON0793
`
`DTX-84
`
`DTX-85
`
`DTX-86
`
`DTX-87
`
`DTX-88
`
`DTX-89
`
`DTX-90
`
`DTX-91
`
`DTX-92
`
`DTX-93
`
`DTX-94
`
`DTX-95
`
`DTX-96
`
`DTX-97
`
`DTX-98
`
`DTX-99
`
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power via MDI Task Force September 2000
`Interim Meeting September 12-14, 2000 New Orleans, LA
`Minutes of the Power via the MDI Task Force New Orleans, LA
`September 12-13, 2000
`Welcome to the September 2000 Interim Meeting of the 802.3af
`DTE Power via MDI Task Force, New Orleans, LA by Steve
`Carlson dated September 12-13, 2000
`
`CARLSON0794
`
`CARLSON0796
`
`CARLSON0797
`
`CARLSON0807
`
`CARLSON0808
`
`CARLSON0833
`
`"Resistive + Diodes" Signature and Detection Protocol Summary
`and Overall Feasibility by Avaya and Lucent, dated September 2000 CARLSON0834
`
`CARLSON0874
`
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power via MDI Task Force November 2000
`Plenary Week meeting, November 7-8, 2000, Tampa, FL
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power Meeting Minutes in Tampa Florida
`November 2000
`Welcome to the November 2000 Plenary Meeting of the 802.3af
`DTE Power via MDI Task Force, Tampa, FL by Steve Carlson
`dated November 6-9, 2000
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power via MDI Resistive Signature and
`Detection Protocol Follow-up by Robert Leonowich dated July 11,
`2000
`AC Coupled Diode Discovery 25 Pair CAT-5 Cable Test Results by
`Rick Brooks dated November 2000
`
`CARLSON0875
`
`CARLSON0877
`
`CARLSON0878
`
`CARLSON0885
`
`CARLSON0886
`
`CARLSON0909
`
`CARLSON0910
`
`CARLSON0921
`
`CARLSON0922
`
`CARLSON0948
`
`Lucent/Avaya Resistive Prototype Conducted, Radiated Emissions
`ESD and Hipot by Rick Brooks, dated November 2000
`Nortel Coupled Diode Discovery Prototype Radiated Emissions by
`Rick Brooks dated November 2000
`Resistor Signature Analysis by Dieter Knollman dated November
`2000
`"Resistance Detection" Tolerance Allocation and Test Limits by
`Dieter Knollman and Don Stewart dated November 2000
`
`CARLSON0949
`
`CARLSON0959
`
`CARLSON0960
`
`CARLSON0968
`
`CARLSON0969
`
`CARLSON1038
`
`CARLSON1039
`
`CARLSON1042
`
`Diode Discovery Process Signal Pair Test Results by Robert Muir
`AC Coupled Diode Discovery Conducted Emissions by Rick
`Brooks dated November 2000
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power via MDI Task Force January 2001
`Interim Meeting January 8-9, 2001 Irvine, CA
`
`CARLSON1043
`
`CARLSON1073
`
`CARLSON1074
`
`CARLSON1223
`
`CARLSON1224
`
`CARLSON1225
`
`3 of 44
`
`

`
`DTX No.
`
`Description
`
`Beginning Bates
`
`End Bates
`
`Offered
`
`Objection
`
`Admitted
`
`Date
`
`Witness
`
`Defendant Dell Inc.'s Exhibit List
`
`DTX-100
`
`DTX-101
`
`DTX-102
`DTX-103
`
`DTX-104
`
`DTX-105
`DTX-106
`
`DTX-107
`
`DTX-108
`DTX-109
`
`DTX-110
`
`DTX-111
`
`DTX-112
`
`DTX-113
`
`DTX-114
`
`DTX-115
`
`DTX-116
`
`DTX-117
`DTX-118
`
`DTX-119
`
`DTX-120
`
`IEEE 802.3af Task Force Minutes, Irvine, CA January 8-9, 2001
`Welcome to the January 2001 Interim Meeting of the 802.3af DTE
`Power via MDI Task Force, Irvine, CA
`dated January 8-9, 2001
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power via MDI Task Force March 2001 Plenary
`Week meeting, March 13-14, 2001, Hilton Head, SC
`Minutes for IEEE 802.3af meeting March 14-15, 2001
`Welcome to the March 2001 Plenary Meeting of the 802.3af DTE
`Power via MDI Task Force, Hilton Head Island, SC dated March 12-
`15, 2001
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power via MDI Task Force May 2001 Interim
`Meeting May 23-25, 2001 St. Louis, MO
`Minutes on 802.3af Task Force Meeting
`
`CARLSON1226
`
`CARLSON1230
`
`CARLSON1231
`
`CARLSON1253
`
`CARLSON1254
`CARLSON1256
`
`CARLSON1255
`CARLSON1259
`
`CARLSON1260
`
`CARLSON1278
`
`CARLSON1279
`CARLSON1281
`
`CARLSON1280
`CARLSON1283
`
`Welcome to the May 2001 Interim Meeting of the 802.3af DTE
`Power via MDI Task Force St. Louis, MO dated May 23-25, 2001 CARLSON1284
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power via MDI Task Force July 2001 Plenary
`Week meeting July 10-12, 2001 Portland, OR
`Minutes for 802.3af Portland, OR July 2001
`Welcome to the July 2001 Plenary Meeting of the 802.3af DTE
`Power via MDI Task Force Portland, OR by Steve Carlson dated
`July 9-12, 2001
`
`CARLSON1303
`CARLSON1305
`
`CARLSON1311
`
`CARLSON1302
`
`CARLSON1304
`CARLSON1310
`
`CARLSON1328
`
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power via MDI Task Force September 2001
`Interim Meeting September 24-26, 2001 Portsmouth, NH
`September 2001 IEEE 802.3af Interim Meeting Minutes,
`Portsmouth, NH
`Welcome to the September 2001 Interim Meeting of the 802.3af
`DTE Power via MDI Task Force, Portsmouth, NH by Steve Carlson
`dated September 24-26, 2001
`
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power via MDI Task Force November 2001
`Plenary Week meeting November 13-15, 2001 Austin, TX
`Minutes for the IEEE 802.3af Plenary meeting - Austin, TX (Nov.
`12-15, 2001)
`Welcome to the November 2001 Plenary Meeting of the 802.3af
`DTE Power via MDI Task Force Austin, TX by Steve Carlson dated
`November 12-15, 2001
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power via MDI Task Force March 2002 Plenary
`Week Meeting March 10-14, 2002 St. Louis, MO
`IEEE 802.3af Minutes dated March 12, 2002
`Welcome to the March 2002 Interim Meeting of the 802.3af DTE
`Power via MDI Task Force St. Louis, MO by Steve Carlson dated
`March 11-15, 2002
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power via MDI Task Force May 2002 Interim
`Meeting May 13-15, 2002, Las Vegas, NV
`
`CARLSON1329
`
`CARLSON1329
`
`CARLSON1330
`
`CARLSON1338
`
`CARLSON1339
`
`CARLSON1351
`
`CARLSON1352
`
`CARLSON1352
`
`CARLSON1353
`
`CARLSON1357
`
`CARLSON1358
`
`CARLSON1372
`
`CARLSON1374
`CARLSON1375
`
`CARLSON1374
`CARLSON1381
`
`CARLSON1382
`
`CARLSON1396
`
`CARLSON1397
`
`CARLSON1398
`
`4 of 44
`
`

`
`DTX No.
`
`Description
`
`Beginning Bates
`
`End Bates
`
`Offered
`
`Objection
`
`Admitted
`
`Date
`
`Witness
`
`Defendant Dell Inc.'s Exhibit List
`
`DTX-121
`
`DTX-122
`
`DTX-123
`
`DTX-124
`
`IEEE 802.3af Minutes dated May 13-15, 2002
`Welcome to the May 2002 Interim Meeting of the 802.3af DTE
`Power via MDI Task Force Las Vegas, NV by Steve Carlson dated
`May 13-15, 2002
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power via MDI Task Force July 2002 Plenary
`Meeting July 9-11, 2002 Vancouver, BC, Canada
`Minutes of the 802.3af working group for the July plenary meeting
`held in Vancouver, BC, Canada July 8-11, 2002
`
`CARLSON1399
`
`CARLSON1410
`
`CARLSON1411
`
`CARLSON1428
`
`CARLSON1429
`
`CARLSON1429
`
`CARLSON1430
`
`CARLSON1433
`
`DTX-125
`
`DTX-126
`
`DTX-127
`
`DTX-128
`
`DTX-129
`DTX-130
`
`DTX-131
`
`DTX-132
`
`DTX-133
`
`DTX-134
`
`DTX-135
`DTX-136
`
`DTX-137
`
`802.3af Task Force Data Terminal Equipment (DTE) Power via
`Media Dependant Interface (MDI) dated July 8-11, 2002
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power via MDI Task Force August 2002
`Interim meeting, August 19-21, 2002 Chelmsford, MA
`Meeting Minutes P802.3af August 19-21, 2002 Interim Meeting -
`Chelmsford, MA
`Welcome to the August 2002 Interim Meeting of the 802.3af DTE
`Power via MDI Task Force Chelmsford, MA by Steve Carlson
`dated August 19-21, 2002
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power via MDI Task Force Octobe 2002
`Interim meeting October 1-3, 2002 New Orleans, LA
`Meeting Minutes 802.3af September 2002
`Welcome to the September 2002 Interim Meeting of the 802.3af
`DTE Power via MDI Task Force New Orleans, LA by Steve
`Carlson dated October 1-3, 2002
`
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power via MDI Task Force November 2002
`Plemnary week meeting November 12-14, 2002 Kauai, HI
`
`Meeting Minutes of IEEE 802.3af November 2, 2002 Kauai, HI
`Welcome to the November 2002 Plenary Meeting of the 802.3af
`DTE Power via MDI Task Force Kauai, HI by Steve Carlson dated
`November 11-15, 2002
`
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power via MDI Task Force January 2003
`Interim meeting January 7-9, 2003 Vancouver, BC, Canada
`802.3af meeting minutes Vancouver, BC January 7-9, 2003
`Welcome to the January 2003 Plenary Meeting of the 802.3af DTE
`Power via MDI Task Force Vancouver, BC by Steve Carlson dated
`January 6-10, 2003
`
`CARLSON1434
`
`CARLSON1440
`
`CARLSON1441
`
`CARLSON1441
`
`CARLSON1442
`
`CARLSON1442
`
`CARLSON1443
`
`CARLSON1458
`
`CARLSON1459
`CARLSON1460
`
`CARLSON1459
`CARLSON1466
`
`CARLSON1467
`
`CARLSON1485
`
`CARLSON1486
`
`CARLSON1486
`
`CARLSON1487
`
`CARLSON1490
`
`CARLSON1491
`
`CARLSON1512
`
`CARLSON1513
`CARLSON1514
`
`CARLSON1513
`CARLSON1516
`
`CARLSON1517
`
`CARLSON1537
`
`5 of 44
`
`

`
`DTX No.
`
`Description
`
`Beginning Bates
`
`End Bates
`
`Offered
`
`Objection
`
`Admitted
`
`Date
`
`Witness
`
`Defendant Dell Inc.'s Exhibit List
`
`IEEE 802.3af DTE Power via MDI Task Force March 2003
`Plenary week meeting March 11-13, 2003 DFW Airport, TX
`P802.3 TF Session Minutes - March 2003 Plenary meeting
`Welcome to the March 2003 Plenary Meeting of the 802.3af DTE
`Power via MDI Task Force Runway 27R, DFW Airport, TX by
`Steve Carlson dated March 10-14, 2003
`PoE-Plus Study Group Minutes dated January 26, 2005
`
`CARLSON1538
`CARLSON1539
`
`CARLSON1538
`CARLSON1540
`
`CARLSON1541
`CARLSON1563
`
`CARLSON1561
`CARLSON1569
`
`Power over Ethernet Plus 802.3 Study Group Agenda and General
`Information by Mike McCormack dated January 26-27, 2005
`Power over the DTE, A simple low- cost proposal, Daniel Dove
`(HP), Jan. 2000
`
`CARLSON1570
`
`CARLSON1593
`
`CARLSON1594
`
`CARLSON1599
`
`DTX-138
`DTX-139
`
`DTX-140
`DTX-141
`
`DTX-142
`
`DTX-143
`
`DTX-144
`
`DTX-145
`
`DTX-146
`
`DTX-147
`
`DTX-148
`
`DTX-149
`
`DTX-150
`DTX-151
`DTX-152
`DTX-153
`DTX-154
`DTX-155
`DTX-156
`DTX-157
`DTX-158
`DTX-159
`DTX-160
`DTX-161
`DTX-162
`DTX-163
`DTX-164
`DTX-165
`DTX-166
`DTX-167
`DTX-168
`
`DTX-169
`DTX-170
`
`CARLSON1637
`
`CARLSON1643
`
`CARLSON1659
`
`CARLSON1660
`
`Coupled Diode Discovery Protocols and Prototypes dated July 2000 CARLSON1600
`DTE Power via MDI Detection
`Scheme, Joint Proposal by Broadcom
`& Level One, Sept. 28, 1999
`Power over the MDI, Howard Frazier, Karl Nakamura, Roger
`Karam (Cisco), January 2000
`Power over the Ethernet Plus Study Group January 26-27, 2005
`Vancouver, BC, Canada
`Classification of the 802.3 Connection January 24-28, 2005 by
`CMS
`An AC Method for Load Disconnect Detection "Current Pulse" by
`Thong Huynh - Austin, TX November 2001
`Power over Ethernet on the Cisco Catalyst 4500E Series Platform
`Data Sheet dated Novemebr 23, 2015
`U.S. Patent No. 2,822,519
`U.S. Patent No. 3,983,338
`U.S. Patent No. 5,121,482
`U.S. Patent No. 5,200,686
`U.S. Patent No. 5,404,544
`U.S. Patent No. 5,406,260
`U.S. Patent No. 5,568,525
`U.S. Patent No. 5,991,885
`U.S. Patent No. 6,115,468
`U.S. Patent No. 6,134,666
`U.S. Patent No. 6,218,930
`U.S. Patent No. 4,633,217
`U.S. Patent No. 4,733,389
`U.S. Patent No. 4,816,703
`U.S. Patent No. 5,162,672
`U.S. Patent No. 5,451,923
`U.S. Patent No. 5,994,998
`U.S. Patent No. 6,175,556
`AMD Am79C971 PCnetTM –FAST Single-chip Full-duplex
`10/100 Mbps Ethernet Controller for PCI Local Bus (available at
`least by May 1996)
`AM79C972 PCnetTM-FAST+ Hardware User's Manual
`
`CARLSON1674
`
`CARLSON1714
`Chrimar_DefsII0000001
`Chrimar_DefsII0000008
`Chrimar_DefsII0000042
`Chrimar_DefsII0000047
`Chrimar_DefsII0000089
`Chrimar_DefsII0000100
`Chrimar_DefsII0000141
`Chrimar_DefsII0000246
`Chrimar_DefsII0000265
`Chrimar_DefsII0000273
`Chrimar_DefsII0000281
`Chrimar_DefsII0000320
`Chrimar_DefsII0000335
`Chrimar_DefsII0000344
`Chrimar_DefsII0000374
`Chrimar_DefsII0000403
`Chrimar_DefsII0000511
`Chrimar_DefsII0000554
`
`Chrimar_DefsII0000938
`Chrimar_DefsII0001200
`
`CARLSON1613
`
`CARLSON1642
`
`CARLSON1657
`
`CARLSON1659
`
`CARLSON1666
`
`CARLSON1713
`
`CARLSON1729
`Chrimar_DefsII0000007
`Chrimar_DefsII0000015
`Chrimar_DefsII0000046
`Chrimar_DefsII0000051
`Chrimar_DefsII0000099
`Chrimar_DefsII0000107
`Chrimar_DefsII0000151
`Chrimar_DefsII0000264
`Chrimar_DefsII0000272
`Chrimar_DefsII0000280
`Chrimar_DefsII0000290
`Chrimar_DefsII0000330
`Chrimar_DefsII0000343
`Chrimar_DefsII0000348
`Chrimar_DefsII0000381
`Chrimar_DefsII0000421
`Chrimar_DefsII0000523
`Chrimar_DefsII0000561
`
`Chrimar_DefsII0001199
`Chrimar_DefsII0001213
`
`6 of 44
`
`

`
`Defendant Dell Inc.'s Exhibit List
`
`Beginning Bates
`
`End Bates
`
`Offered
`
`Objection
`
`Admitted
`
`Date
`
`Witness
`
`Chrimar_DefsII0001847
`
`Chrimar_DefsII0002160
`
`Chrimar_DefsII0002161
`
`Chrimar_DefsII0002251
`
`Chrimar_DefsII0002260
`
`Chrimar_DefsII0002552
`
`Chrimar_DefsII0002557
`Chrimar_DefsII0002623
`
`Chrimar_DefsII0002622
`Chrimar_DefsII0003037
`
`Chrimar_DefsII0003253
`
`Chrimar_DefsII0003279
`
`CMS000001
`
`CMS000005
`
`DTX No.
`
`DTX-171
`
`DTX-172
`
`DTX-173
`
`DTX-174
`DTX-175
`
`DTX-176
`
`DTX-177
`
`DTX-178
`DTX-179
`DTX-180
`
`DTX-181
`DTX-182
`DTX-183
`DTX-184
`DTX-185
`
`DTX-186
`
`DTX-187
`
`DTX-188
`
`DTX-189
`DTX-190
`
`DTX-191
`
`DTX-192
`
`DTX-193
`
`Description
`Digital Semiconductor 21143
`PCI/Card Bus 10/100-Mb/s Ethernet LAN Controller (available at
`least by December 1997)
`DP83840A 10100 Mb/s Ethernet Physical Layer, Technical Data
`Sheet, Literature Number: SNL2006A (March 1997)
`IEEE Standard 802.3-1993 Edition, Part 3: Carrier Sense Multiple
`Access with Collision Detection (CSMA/CD) Access Method and
`Physical Layer Specifications
`IEEE Std. 802.3i-1990, System Considerations for
`Multisegment 10 Mb/s Baseband Networks (Section 13) and
`Twisted-Pair Medium Attachment Unit (MAU) and Baseband
`Medium, Type 10BASE-T (Section 14), 1990.
`ANSI/IEEE Std. 802.3u-1995
`ThunderLANTM TNETE100PM PCI EthernetTM Controller with
`Power Management Single-Chip 10 BASE-T with MII for 100
`BASE-T/100VG- AnyLAN (available at least by
`October 1996)
`
`Assignment of U.S. Patent No. 6,650,622 , PCT Application and
`Provisional Application to Chrimar dated September 1999
`Provisional Patent Application, USSN 60/081,279, Network
`System for Uniquely identifying and tracking electronic equipment,
`dated Apr. 10, 1998
`U.S. Patent No. 6,650,622 Prosecution History
`U.S. Patent No. 8,155,012 Prosecution History
`WO/1999/053627 (PCT/US1999/007846 publication on October
`21, 1999)
`U.S. Patent No. 8,155,012
`Schematic: CMS Stick, dated Aug. 13, 1998
`8/13/98 American Broadband, Inc. Schematics re CMS Stick
`CMS EtherLockID Brochure
`CMS Network & Asset Control, dated 1999
`Solutions
`Letter from C. Boenke to M. Cummings Re: quotation for
`development of two printed circuit electronic assemblies, dated
`Mar. 17, 1998
`Letter from C. Boenke to M. Cummings Re: enclosed schematic of
`the system outlined, dated Mar. 6, 1998
`Letter from C. Boenke to C. Mahaney Re: CMS 485 protocol
`definition, dated Nov. 24, 1998
`Schematic: ELID Board, dated Sep. 21, 1998
`Settlement Agreement with Neteon Technologies Inc., April 8,
`2009
`Patent License Agreement between Cisco and Chrimar, dated Aug.
`19, 2005
`Letter of Assurance from Rader, Fishman & Grauer to IEEE, dated
`10/10/2001
`
`CMS000006
`CMS000027
`CMS000706
`
`CMS001408
`CMS001503
`CMS001560
`CMS001561
`CMS001606
`
`CMS001612
`
`CMS001821
`
`CMS001823
`
`CMS001829
`CMS001835
`
`CMS001922
`
`CMS001978
`
`CMS002008
`
`CMS000026
`CMS000365
`CMS001407
`
`CMS001493
`CMS001541
`CMS001560
`CMS001561
`CMS001607
`
`CMS001635
`
`CMS001822
`
`CMS001825
`
`CMS001831
`CMS001835
`
`CMS001929
`
`CMS001995
`
`CMS002008
`
`CMS002009
`
`7 of 44
`
`DTX-194
`
`Letter of assurance from Glenn Forbis to IEEE dated Dec. 3, 2001 CMS002009
`
`

`
`Defendant Dell Inc.'s Exhibit List
`
`DTX No.
`
`DTX-195
`
`DTX-196
`
`DTX-197
`
`DTX-198
`
`DTX-199
`
`DTX-200
`
`DTX-201
`
`DTX-202
`
`DTX-203
`DTX-204
`DTX-205
`
`DTX-206
`
`DTX-207
`
`DTX-208
`
`DTX-209
`
`DTX-210
`DTX-211
`DTX-212
`DTX-213
`
`DTX-214
`
`DTX-215
`
`DTX-216
`
`DTX-217
`
`DTX-218
`
`DTX-219
`
`Description
`Letter from G. Schivley to IEEE (D. Scozzafava), dated Oct. 25,
`2000 re: Etherlock and '260 patent
`Letter from G. Thompson to J. Austermann dated Oct. 12, 2001 re:
`802.3af standard
`Posting by G. Thompson to 802.3af committee re: potential legal
`action by CMS
`
`Power over Ethernet Interoperability book by Sanjaya Maniktala
`Letter from C. Boenke to M. Cummings dated March 11, 1998 re:
`EtherID
`March 18, 1998 American Broadband, Inc. Invoice 10981 to CMS
`Technologies, Inc. stamped PAST DUE
`February 10th, 1998 letter from Clyde Boenke to Marshall B.
`Cummings re: project phases
`
`Beginning Bates
`
`CMS002051
`
`CMS002053
`
`CMS002055
`
`CMS002065
`
`CMS002519
`
`CMS002535
`
`CMS002551
`
`Correspondence from American Broadband, Inc. to CMS
`Technologies regarding circuit boards, April 13, 1998 - July 2, 1998 CMS002562
`
`Correspondence from Clyde Boenke to Phoenix Engineering
`Design, Inc. regarding CMS 485 protocol, November 24, 1998
`Draft CMS ELID Module Code July 3, 1998
`Schematic: CMS Stick, dated Aug. 13, 1998
`Correspondence between CMS and American Broadband regarding
`circuit boards, May 28, 1998 - July 24, 1998
`
`CMS002564
`CMS002572
`CMS002626
`
`CMS002635
`
`Letter to M. Cummings from C. Boenke and attached Schematics
`for CMS Technologies Hardware, dated March - May, 1998
`Letter and Schematics from C. Boenke to M. Cummings Re: update
`on circuitry for the ELID, dated May 4, 1998
`IEEE 802.3at presentation from PowerDsine, An Extended
`Classification Proposal: Proposal #1, Nov. 2005
`
`CMS002652
`
`CMS002740
`
`CMS002792
`
`IEEE 802.3 Standard, 2008
`IEEE 802.3af-2003 standard
`IEEE 802.3at-2009 standard
`AMX DXLink Multi-Format Transmiter Module brochure
`Cisco Whitepaper, Power over Ethernet: Cisco Inline Power and
`IEEE 802.3af, 2004
`Multi-bit Identification Scheme using Existing Ethernet Data Lines
`presentation by CMS, dated Jan. 24-28, 2005
`
`CMS006253
`CMS012307
`CMS012440
`CMS013051
`
`CMS013080
`
`CMS014800
`
`CMS014958
`
`Manufacturing Specification Protection Board Test, May 18, 1999 CMS014847
`Schematic: CMS Technologies Protection Module Slave Top Level,
`dated Jun. 10, 1998
`Letter from C. Boenke to M. Cummings Re: diode switches to
`disable Ethernet signals in the Protection Module, dated Jun. 1,
`1999
`Schematics: CMS Technologies Protection Module, Dated May -
`August 1998
`
`CMS014975
`
`CMS015014
`
`Offered
`
`Objection
`
`Admitted
`
`Date
`
`Witness
`
`End Bates
`
`CMS002052
`
`CMS002053
`
`CMS002058
`
`CMS002511
`
`CMS002528
`
`CMS002539
`
`CMS002553
`
`CMS002563
`
`CMS002567
`CMS002598
`CMS002634
`
`CMS002651
`
`CMS002695
`
`CMS002752
`
`CMS002817
`
`CMS007042
`CMS012439
`CMS012580
`CMS013057
`
`CMS013092
`
`CMS014806
`
`CMS014871
`
`CMS014974
`
`CMS015013
`
`CMS015031
`
`8 of 44
`
`

`
`Offered
`
`Objection
`
`Admitted
`
`Date
`
`Witness
`
`Defendant Dell Inc.'s Exhibit List
`
`DTX No.
`
`DTX-220
`
`DTX-221
`
`DTX-222
`
`DTX-223
`
`DTX-224
`
`DTX-225
`
`DTX-226
`
`DTX-227
`DTX-228
`
`DTX-229
`
`DTX-230
`
`DTX-231
`DTX-232
`
`DTX-233
`DTX-234
`
`DTX-235
`DTX-236
`DTX-237
`
`DTX-238
`
`DTX-239
`
`DTX-240
`
`DTX-241
`
`DTX-242
`
`DTX-243
`DTX-244
`
`DTX-245
`
`DTX-246
`
`DTX-247
`
`Description
`Letter from C. Boenke to M. Cummings Re: Chapter 23 of the
`IEEE 802.3, dated Aug. 24, 1998
`Letters from C. Boenke to M. Cummings re: component prices,
`dated July - August 1998, plus schematics and layouts
`Letter to C. Boenke from M. Cummings Re: Ganged jacks, dated
`Jul. 21, 1998, plus data sheets and schematics
`Inventor declaration for '250 patent re-examination, dated June 14,
`2010
`Assignment Nunc Pro Tunc from C. Boenke to Chrimar, dated Feb.
`3, 2015
`Assignment Nunc Pro Tunc from C. Boenke to Chrimar, dated
`January 29, 2015
`Assignment Nunc Pro Tunc from D. Boenke to Chrimar, dated
`February 4, 2015
`Assignment Nunc Pro Tunc from R. Alford to Chrimar, dated
`January 28, 2015
`U.S. Patent No. 7,457,250
`Alford declaration exhibit 19 '250 patent re-examination, dated June
`8, 2010
`Inventor declaration for '250 patent re-examination, dated June 14,
`2010, plus patent application
`License Agreement between Hubbell and Chrimar dated September
`10, 2004
`IEEE 802.3af attendee list, La Jolla, July 11-12, 2000
`Power, Detection and Discovery over the Existing Ethernet Wiring
`by CMS, July 11-12, 2000
`Letter of Assurance for Essential Patents, 12/3/2001
`Letter of Assurance from Rader, Fishman & Grauer to IEEE, dated
`10/10/2001
`U.S. Patent No. 6,650,622
`Austermann ITC declaration, dated Oct. 28, 2011
`Minutes of the Power via the MDI Task Force Interim Meeting,
`May 24-25, Ottawa, Canada
`
`IEEE 802.3af Task Force Minutes, La Jolla, July 11-12, 2000
`802.3af DTE Power via MDI Task Force Meeting presentation,
`dated July 11-12, 2000
`Power, Detection and Discovery over the Existing Ethernet Wiring
`by CMS, July 11-12, 2000
`Letter from G. Schivley to IEEE (D. Scozzafava), dated Oct. 25,
`2000
`December 5, 2000 IEEE-SA Standards Board Patent Committee
`(PatCom) Meeting Approved Minutes
`Austermann Notes on PatCom Meeting
`Email from J. Siemon to J. Austermann re: IEEE Patent policies,
`dated Sept. 19, 2001
`Letter of Assurance from Rader, Fishman & Grauer to IEEE, dated
`October 10, 2001
`Letter from G. Thompson to J. Austermann dated Oct. 12, 2001 re:
`802.3af standard
`
`Beginning Bates
`
`CMS015032
`
`CMS015038
`
`CMS015053
`
`CMS015062
`
`CMS015205
`
`CMS015209
`
`CMS015211
`
`CMS015213
`CMS015254
`
`CMS015363
`
`CMS015375
`
`CMS015995
`CMS016027
`
`CMS016029
`CMS016037
`
`CMS016038
`CMS016450
`CMS016567
`
`CMS016576
`
`CMS016584
`
`CMS016588
`
`CMS016614
`
`CMS016622
`
`CMS016624
`CMS016628
`
`CMS016630
`
`CMS016633
`
`CMS016636
`
`End Bates
`
`CMS015032
`
`CMS015052
`
`CMS015061
`
`CMS015066
`
`CMS015206
`
`CMS015210
`
`CMS015212
`
`CMS015214
`CMS015295
`
`CMS015366
`
`CMS015423
`
`CMS016006
`CMS016028
`
`CMS016036
`CMS016037
`
`CMS016038
`CMS016475
`CMS016572
`
`CMS016583
`
`CMS016587
`
`CMS016613
`
`CMS016621
`
`CMS016623
`
`CMS016627
`CMS016629
`
`CMS016632
`
`CMS016635
`
`CMS016638
`
`9 of 44
`
`

`
`Defendant Dell Inc.'s Exhibit List
`
`DTX No.
`
`DTX-248
`
`DTX-249
`
`DTX-250
`
`DTX-251
`
`DTX-252
`DTX-253
`DTX-254
`
`DTX-255
`
`DTX-256
`
`DTX-257
`DTX-258
`DTX-259
`
`DTX-260
`
`DTX-261
`DTX-262
`DTX-263
`
`DTX-264
`
`DTX-265
`
`DTX-266
`
`DTX-267
`
`DTX-268
`
`DTX-269
`DTX-270
`
`DTX-271
`
`DTX-272
`DTX-273
`DTX-274
`DTX-275
`
`DTX-276
`DTX-277
`
`Description
`Multi-bit Identification Scheme using Existing Ethernet Data Lines
`presentation by CMS, dated Jan. 24-28, 2005
`E-mail thread between Austermann and C. Cullin (Cisco) re ID
`CLASS, dated March - April 2001
`Emails between James Alford, Mike Benkarski, and Aubrey Downs
`dated January 6-7, 2005
`Emails between Mike McCormack, Austermann, and Udi Naamani
`dated December 2004 - January 2005
`
`Beginning Bates
`
`CMS016639
`
`CMS016646
`
`CMS016653
`
`CMS016655
`
`Business Update, CMS Technologies, dated January - March 2006 CMS016660
`Notes from J. Austermann re: IEEE Letters of Assurance
`CMS016662
`CMS product sales history, 1999 - 2011
`CMS016693
`CMS's corrected objections and responses to ITC's 2nd set of
`ROGs, dated May 9, 2012
`E-mails between Randy Below, Udi Naamani, and Austermann re
`CMS dated April - July 2001
`Emails between Mike McCormack and Austermann, dated
`December 2004 - January 2005 re: IEEE presentation
`Business registration, dated March 7, 2011
`Business registration, dated December 21, 2011
`
`CMS016771
`
`CMS016807
`
`CMS016809
`CMS016819
`CMS016820
`
`Email asking invoice for James Alford, dated February 17, 2011
`License agreement between Chrimar Systems and Chrimar Holding,
`dated Sept. 23, 2011
`Chrimar proxy statement for September 2011 meeting
`30(b)(6) deposition notice to CMS, dated June 3, 2009
`Summary judgment order invalidating claims of '260 patent in
`Chrimar v. Cisco
`Letter from J. Whitt (Apple) to G. Forbis re: '260 patent license
`offer, dated July 16, 2007
`E-mail from A. Peterman (Dell) to G. Forbis re: license offer, dated
`Oct. 21, 2005
`Letter from D. Jakopin (Meru) to C. Taylor re: '260 patent license
`offer, dated Jan. 18, 2008
`Letter from J. Silverio (Motorola) to C. Taylor re: '260 patent
`license offer, dated Dec. 21, 2007
`Patent License Agreement between Cisco and Chrimar, dated Aug.
`19, 2005
`IEEE-SA Standards Board Bylaws, dated 2001
`IEEE-SA Standards Board Operations Manual 2001 (approved
`December 2000)
`E-mail from A. Ward to J. Aflord re Year-End Financials dated
`January 8, 2009
`Table of CMS notice letters
`CMS business plan for 1998 - 2002, dated Jan. 16, 1998
`CMS Technologies Fact Sheet
`Inventor declaration for '250 patent re-examination, dated June 14,
`2010, plus patent application
`IEEE subpoena in Chrimar v. Foundry, dated Feb. 20, 2009
`
`CMS016828
`
`CMS016829
`CMS016837
`CMS017841
`
`CMS017886
`
`C