US009l 1690832
`
`(12) Umted States Patent
`Fallon
`
`not Patent No.:
`(451 Date of Patent:
`
`US 9,116,908 B2
`*Aug. 25, 2015
`
`(54) SYSTEM AND METHODS FOR
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`
`ACCELERATED DATA STORAGE .rL‘\'D
`RETRIEVAL
`
`1
`U.S. lATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`(71 i Applicatlt: Realtime nm 1.1.(:, Arntonk. NY (115:
`('72)
`Inventor:
`James J. Fallon. Armonk, NY ("US")
`
`):’;;;;;k;t;‘,$‘ ""
`lcnnllm-led)
`
`lb-"31’ A:;saig11ee: Realtlme Data I.l.C, .’\rmo11.l~:. NY HIS}
`
`FOREIGN P'A‘T]'?’NT DOCUMI-ENTS
`
`( * ) Notice:
`
`Subject to any disclaimer. the term ofthis
`patent is extended or ad_it.t5tcd under 35
`u.s.c‘. l54(l:1}by 0 days.
`
`'
`
`(31
`
`T
`_
`(C-'0""n"°d)
`
`_
`
`This patent is subject to a ttznninal dis-
`Clmmcrl
`[21 ) APPL Na: 1413039276
`
`{'22}
`
`piled:
`
`_[.m_ 12‘ 20”
`
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`Rt.-z1|tin1e's Response in Opposition to the Defendants‘ Joint Objec-
`tions to Report and Recotruncndation of Magi-snate ltcgarding
`Manon for Partial S11irLma.1'y Judgment oi Invalidity for Indefinite-
`
`ness. in R'£'(tt'.r."me Dam. U.-t" dXb.{w1’.’t'0 \-1 Par.-ketcer. .’1:r'. e.rr11'.. Civil
`Action No. 6:lJS—t:v—[Ji}l4e1—l.El}; US. District Court for the Eastern
`
`[65].
`
`Prior Puh[icafi(m Data
`
`District of Texas. dated Jul. 2?. 2009. 15 pages.
`
`us 201sxo012507 A1
`
`Jan. 3. 2015
`
`‘-C°”““"“d)
`
`((13)
`
`Related U-5- APP“'=3“l"fl Data
`(7ontinLi.ation olapplicatiott No.
`1 lfS53.4l9. filed on
`01:1. 26, 2006, now Pal. No. 8,756.332, Wl'llCl1 its a
`continuation of application No.
`l0f628.':"95. filed on
`Jul. 23, 2003, now Pat. No. 1130.913, which is a
`continuation of application No. 09f266.3'9-4. Filed on
`Mar. 11. 1999. now Pat. No. 6.601 .104.
`
`(51 ,1
`
`Int. Cl.
`(206)? 15/16
`Gllfif-' 17,30
`
`(200601 ]
`(300501)
`(C.mn.mnod.]
`
`(52) U.S. ( TI.
`(‘P{‘
`
`(:'06F I 7/30.l5j' (2013.01); (:'06F 1 7/303 7!
`(201 101 }; mi“, 59/n4{2o]3_()1)-_
`{comimlecu
`
`[581 Field of Classification Search
`7(l9a’23L 247
`USPC
`See application file for complete search history.
`
`Pr1'1r1ar_1-E.\'o1r11'm:r — Philip B Tran
`‘[741]
`-‘I''‘'‘’'''‘''‘‘’.'''; “J3""""t 9" Fl’"1'’ _ Sterner Kesslerv G'5'ld*""‘ei3-l
`‘St 1”“ Pd-"I-'( ‘
`
`.
`“B5TR"( T
`(573
`Systems and methods for providing accelerated data storage
`and retrieval utilizing lossless data compression and decom-
`prcssion. A data storage accelerator includes one or :1 pluralit_v
`ofhigh speed data cottlprcssion cncoclcrs that are configured
`to compress data. The compressed data is subsequently stored
`in a target meinory or other storage device whose input data
`storage lJ€t]](.l‘\r_\?l(Zlll]
`is lrtwer than the original input data stream
`lJt:111t:lwIt.l|.lt. bum larly, at data retrieval accelerator Lnclttdcs one
`ora plurality ofhjgt speed data decompression decoders that
`are configured to decompress data at a rate equivalent to or
`faster than the input data stream from the target 1'I.ier11or_v or
`storage device. The deconipresscd data is tl'1e_11 output at rate
`data that is greater than the output rate lrom the target
`memory or data storage device.
`
`30 ('.laims_. 20 Drawing Sheets
`
`E
`txvann-in-tn. —.11I'a
`-ace:-nun;
`
`I
`
`\_
`
`i
`
`_ was
`_/flax--Z¥x_
`< "3.-'.‘.1.£..'°"' )4‘ '3$"7_1."‘.‘.'.'l'
`“$26.01
`?
`nu
`
`In
`
`_"""""""' i
`1
`11:1--nr.~a1lI-1.5h1_,
`era
`
`Oracle 1001
`
`Oracle 1001
`
` Ei
`Hfaau mu
`I! (/aazuumaeauu
`an
`/’
`'
`\__r_,,_, .,
`
`‘Y, .....
`
`‘
`
`l |
`
`

`
`US 9,116,908 B2
`Page 2
`
`(511
`
`(52)
`
`Int. Cl.
`HIHN 92804
`HWL 29/06
`Ht!-1N 19/1 76
`HMN 19/15
`1'l04‘N 19/H5
`H0-1fN 19/152
`H1)-IN 5/781’
`H0-JN 5/8-1!
`HUJN 5/85
`H0-JN 5X90?
`H04N 9/82
`U.S. Cl.
`(TPC
`
`(200001 1
`(200001 1
`(201401 1
`(2014.01 1
`(201401 1
`(201401 1
`(200001 1
`(200001 )
`(200001 1
`(200001 1
`(200001 1
`
`H0->I.’V 9/111042 (201301 )1 H0-1N I9/115
`(£014.01):IIIWNI9/I5[2014.011;Hfl4N
`I9/]52(2014.01): HIMNI9/I76(2014.01'];
`H0-IN5/781' (2013.01); H04N 5/843 (2013.01):
`H04N 5/85 (201301 )1: H04N 5/907 12013.01)‘.
`H0-iN 9.41227 (2013.01)
`
`(55)
`
`References Cited
`
`U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`4.021 .702
`4.032.093
`4.054.951
`4. 1 27.5 1 0
`4.302.775
`4.325.085
`4.300.040
`4.300.410
`4.394.774
`4.404.050
`4.494. 100
`4.499.499
`4.574.351
`4.593.324
`4.020.029
`4.040.001
`4.002. 150
`4.70 1.745
`4.729.020
`4.730.340
`4745.5 59
`4.740.030
`4.750. 135
`4.754.351
`4.004.959
`4.0 13.040
`4.014.740
`4.002. 107
`4.000.150 1
`4070.41 5
`4.072.009
`4.070.541
`4.000.012
`4.090.202
`4.097.717
`4.900.991
`4.900.995
`4.929.940
`4.953.324
`4.950.000
`4.905.075
`4.900.990
`5.003.307
`5.010.009
`5.027.370
`5.020.922
`5.045.040
`5.045.052
`5.040.027
`5.049.001
`5.079.030
`
`3F*>>>i»‘*2D"FF*>Ia‘*3>>29->39->IP>>>-}F*>>>>29->>>Iiv3>>>'>>>I$*3*>>P>>>LD3Ir)";*I>>
`
`5.-' 1977
`6.’ 1977
`10.-' 197 7
`1 1- 197 S
`I 11' 1981
`4' 1982
`1 l." 1982
`5.-' 1983
`7.1 1983
`8'' 1984
`17 1985
`25 1985
`3! 1986
`63' 1986
`127' 1986
`2*‘ 1987
`7.-' 1987
`101' 1987
`3.1‘ 1988
`3.11988
`57' 1988
`5.-' 1988
`6.’ 1988
`6: 1988
`2: 1989
`31' 1989
`31‘ 1989
`8.4 1989
`9.! 1989
`91’ 1989
`I 07' 1989
`1 0.-" 1989
`1}‘ 1989
`12.-" 1989
`1.’ 1990
`31" 1990
`3.-’ 1990
`5.-" 1990
`91 1990
`9." 1990
`107' 1990
`1 1991
`3.51991
`5.-' 1991
`6: 199 1
`7.-' 199 I
`91 1991
`91' 1991
`94' 1991
`9-' 1991
`1 ' 1992
`
`H0e1'm'.1:1g
`Moran
`Jackson at al.
`Coy at 01.
`Widcrgrcn cl :1].
`Ciocrch
`Wo11'n11'1 1:1 :11.
`Crilt1:1c1' :21 111.
`Wixlcrgrcn 01 :11.
`E11sL1m.11
`Laugdon. Jr. :1 al.
`Brickrrlan el 111
`Dang e1 :1].
`O1:11c11bo cl al.
`Hauck
`Bledsoc
`Malhes 1:1 111.
`Wulerworth
`Schaphorst a1 a1.
`Mm:('risken
`Willis 0121.1.
`[-'1'iedm11.11 01 111.
`Boilen
`Wrighl
`Mnknnsi at :11.
`Fulalcl
`Miller at 111.
`Copeland. [II
`DuL:1c at 111.
`Van Maren or a].
`Tsu1£1y11I11z1 el 8.1.
`Slnrer
`Dinan :1 a1.
`L111:0bcrl cl 0.1.
`Hamilton ct al.
`1311110 at al.
`Swanson
`O'Brien 1:: al.
`Henmmm
`Aalue el al.
`[1011 el :1].
`O'Brien
`Whiting el :11.
`Whiting ei al.
`Friedrrlan el 31.
`Huang
`1"'a0c01J1.1:1
`Mitchel] cl 0.1.
`’1'aa.t'f0 el al.
`Gibson cl 111'.
`Golin
`
`5.091.782
`5 .097.261
`5.103.306
`5.109.226
`5.109.433
`5. I 09.45 1
`.5. l 1 3.522
`5. 1 1 5.309
`5.121.342
`5. 1 26.7 39
`5. I 28.963
`5.132.992
`5. I46.221
`5.150.430
`5. 1 55,484
`5 . 1 59.336
`5.167.034
`5. 17 5.543
`5.179.651
`5. I 87.793
`5 . 1 91.43 1
`5,204.7 56
`5.3.09.2 20
`5.2 1 2.742
`5.326.] 76
`5.327.893
`5.23 1 .492
`5.23 7.460
`5.2 37.675
`5.343.341 1
`5.243.348
`5,247,638
`5.247.646
`5.149.053
`5.363.168
`5.267.333
`5.370.832
`5.3 80.600
`5..'!87,4 20
`5.2 89.580
`5.293.379
`5.293.576
`5.307.497
`5.309.555
`5.3 19.6 82
`5.33 1,425
`5.34 I .440
`5.347.600
`5.353. 1 32
`5,3 54,3 1 5
`5.355.498
`5.3.57.6 14
`5,367,629
`5.3 73.390
`5.3 74.9 16
`5.3 79.0 36
`5.3 79,757
`5.381.145
`5.3 89.922
`5.394534
`5.396.228
`5.400.401
`5,403.6 39
`5.406.278
`5,406.2 79
`5.410.671
`5.4 12,384
`5.4 14.8 50
`5.4 20.6 39
`5.4 34.9 83
`5.4370 20
`5.45".‘-!..'! 87
`5.4 54.0 79
`5.454.107
`5.455.576
`5,455.51 78
`5.455 .6 80
`5.461.679
`5.463.390
`
`>35-.’-P3‘-Sh->>3=-3*3*D‘->LP}FF'.i='3=->5LP}>3-3>>*3'P}>>->353’>1}>3->373’>3“>3‘->3*}FF-13>>3‘->.1*11i*}>}>>.1*3>F?->>}.>3='>->}.7*3='.?P'3>>F>?>Ii>
`
`2-’ 1 992
`3:’ 1 992
`491992
`451992
`4- 1992
`41' 1992
`S: 1992
`551.992
`641992
`61’ 1992
`7-' 1 99.1
`71' 1992
`91" I 992
`971992
`1 0." 1 .992
`1 0'1 992
`l 1 5 1 992
`1 21" 1 99.1
`I "1 993
`2:‘ 1 993
`341993
`451993
`5! 1993
`591993
`7.-' 1 993
`7.11993
`7.’ 1993
`8-' 1993
`851993
`9.’ 1993
`971993
`971993
`9.51993
`91' 1993
`1 1 -"1 993
`l 1
`1 993
`1 2.1 1993
`1 " 1 994
`21' 1994
`351994
`391994
`351994
`1 994
`57' 1994
`61" 1 994
`7-‘ 1994
`891994
`91 1994
`1 04' 1 994
`1 0:’ 1 994
`1 0-‘ 1 994
`I 07' 1 994
`1 1 .’ 1 994
`I 2-' I 994
`l 21’ 1 994
`1 ('1 995
`1
`1 995
`1
`1 995
`21" l 995
`21' 1995
`3.11995
`331995
`451995
`4-' 1995
`41' 1995
`4- 1995
`51' 1995
`551995
`591995
`7-’ 1 995
`7.51995
`9.51995
`971995
`9.11995
`1011995
`1 1.1-‘ 1 995
`1 1.1.’ 1 995
`I 01 I 995
`1 0-’ 1995
`
`Krausc el al.
`La1:1gd0n.Jr.c1 al.
`W-:i1na.11 er a]
`Ma1:Luan. Jr. 01 al.
`N111-m1bI.t~'.1111
`A0110 {:1 11.1.
`D1l'I‘W1(1(1.1-E. Jr. 01 9.1.
`I1a.ng
`Szymborski
`W1:1il'i1'1g 01:11
`Akagiri
`Y1111 at al.
`W'11ilir1g. el :11.
`C110
`C11a.rr1ber5. [V
`Rabin el 11.].
`M.'1cI_c11n. Jr. 1:101.
`1.3.1117“.
`Ta.-1f‘I'r.- 01 9|.
`Keith el :11.
`llascgawa ct 11.1.
`Chcvion 1:1 :11.
`l[iya.n:1a el al.
`Nomlilc el al.
`Weslzrway at 211.
`E11
`Dangi at 11.1.
`Miller 121 :1].
`I1a.n.11o1'1. Jr.
`Seroussi et :11.
`Jackson
`U'13riE1'1 el al.
`Uslerlund al :1].
`Iain
`Toms et 11].
`A000
`Balknnski 01 a1.
`V110 Mare-11 01111.
`B.11.rrel1
`1.11111‘ e1 1711.
`Carr
`Mihm. .lr. et al.
`Feigcnbatlm 11:1 01.
`Akins cl 0.].
`Clark
`07.010" 01 :1].
`E1111 «:1 111.
`13.110310}! (:1 :11
`Katsuma
`A1'msLr0ng
`Pravirlu el al.
`Pallisam at 0].
`C1111 at £11.
`I.t‘.1up-71 E1 :11.
`C1111
`Storcr
`Iliyaunn cl :1].
`Allen at 0.1.
`Se-roussi at al.
`Ktllakowski at 21.1.
`Ga.ra.h1'
`Wasilew-ski at 0.1.
`139101111 1:1 111.
`Graybill 01 al.
`Anderson at 11].
`Elgiunal el al.
`Chang at 111.
`Whiting
`Perkins
`‘[000 1:1‘ :11.
`Wells 01 £11.
`Diceuco et al.
`Roper et al.
`Lehman 131 a].
`Clark. 1] et al.
`Bhandari
`Shin
`N1;-l‘n1i1e at :11
`W]1il'i1'1g 01 :11.
`
`

`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`
`U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`5.-167.037
`5.471.206
`5.475.333
`5.479.537
`5.479.633
`5.433.470
`5.436.326
`5.433.364
`5.433.365
`5.495.244
`5.504.342
`5.506.344
`5.506.372
`5.506.944
`5.521.940
`5.523.623
`5.530.345
`5.533.051
`5.535.311
`5.535.356
`5.535.369
`5.537.653
`5.539.365
`5.542.031
`5.544.290
`5.546.395
`5.546.475
`5.553.160
`5.557.551
`5.557.663
`5.557.749
`5.561.421
`5.561.324
`5.563.961
`5.574.952
`5.574.953
`5.576.953
`5.577.243
`5.531.715
`5.533.500
`5.536264
`5.536.235
`5.590.306
`5.596.674
`5.593.333
`5.604.324
`5.606.706
`5.610.657
`5.611.024
`5.612.733
`5.613.069
`5.615.017
`5.615.237
`5.619.995
`5.621.320
`5.623.623
`5.623.701
`5.627.534
`5.627.995
`5.629.732
`5.630.092
`5.635.632
`5.635.932
`5.633.493
`5.640.153
`5.642.506
`5.649.032
`5.652.795
`5.652.357
`5.652.917
`5.654.703
`5.655.133
`5.666.560
`5.663.737
`5.671.355
`
`3-‘-'.a‘-*la‘*>Sb5>>>>>-fi;1=v>:3v>3'~21=~>29>>>>29-}D>>>ib>>iB*>>>>29fi3*>§>29>2D->3*>>3P>2D-2>F*>>39'>2D-?>>>39>2D->3*>3*39fi>>
`
`111995
`11 1995
`12-1995
`12-1995
`12-1995
`1.1996
`1--1996
`171996
`1..-1996
`2-1996
`4.1996
`4..-1996
`471996
`471996
`571996
`6..-1996
`6-1996
`7-1996
`71996
`7-1996
`7-1996
`7-1996
`7'1996
`71996
`31996
`3.- 1996
`31996
`971996
`971996
`971996
`971996
`10.-1996
`10.-1996
`1071996
`1171996
`1171996
`11 1996
`111996
`12-1996
`12-1996
`12-1996
`12-1996
`12-1996
`1 1997
`11997
`2-1997
`2-1997
`371997
`371997
`371997
`371997
`371997
`371997
`4..-1997
`471997
`471997
`4..-1997
`571997
`571997
`571997
`571997
`6..-1997
`671997
`6.1997
`671997
`671997
`71997
`71997
`7 1997
`7'1997
`3.-1997
`3.-1997
`971997
`971997
`97’ I99?
`
`Chu
`Allen et 3|.
`Ganhish at 21].
`Campbell 1:1 :11.
`Wells El. 31].
`A1112 at a].
`Remillanl
`Cole
`Seroussi el II].
`Jelzlng 13! 3|.
`Gentile
`Ran
`Mahler
`Gentile
`Lime et al.
`Park et :11.
`Hiall at 21].
`James
`Zi1nmer1'1'1aL1:1
`KJ111 et nl.
`Wells et al .
`Bakke cl 3.].
`Gentile
`Douglass at £11.
`GE-rllile
`Sharma cl‘ al.
`Belle cl 3.].
`Dawson
`Crafl
`Firmly
`NI:Il'1'is
`Smith at al.
`Carreiro er a].
`Rynde1'11:11111 et nl.
`Brady et 3|.
`Rusl el al.
`Hugentoblel’
`Cl1£uT1bers. IV
`\7'e1'in3ky et al.
`Allen el 3|.
`Belknap at 111.
`llas|:11.1.1:1 et 31.
`Wz1.la.nabe El :l.I.
`Bhandari el al.
`Van Maren el 3].
`Chui at 0].
`’l‘a.l1c3.m0t0 131 3.1.
`Zl:1a.1:1g
`Campbell cl‘ 3|.
`Stone
`Walker
`Clmi
`Fu et nl.
`Lohedzinslci
`Ryn1:le1'11:11111 ct nl.
`Kim 1:1 111.
`Bakke El Al.
`C‘I;J.l’l
`Miller El 3|.
`Moslmwilz ct 3.].
`Carreiro er a].
`Fay el al.
`Shinagawa el 71].
`Tyler el al.
`Ul;..1ya111£1 61 111.
`Lee
`Burl at 0|.
`Dillon (:1 al.
`Sl1i.1n01i el 0].
`Mailpin at 3|.
`Clark. ll
`Kjkjnis
`Moertl el .1].
`[let
`Collins
`
`US 9,116,908 B2
`Page 3
`
`5.67 1 .3 39
`5.671.413
`5.673.370
`5.675.333
`5.675.739
`5 .6 36.9 16
`5.693.] 59
`5.694.619
`5.696.927
`5.703.793
`5.70351 1
`5.7 15.477
`5.7 17.393
`5.7 17.394
`5.719.362
`5.721.953
`5.724.475
`5.729.223
`5.740.395
`5.742.773
`5.743.122
`5.743.904
`5.757.352
`5.764.774
`5.765.027
`5.767.393
`5.763.445
`5.763.525
`5 .77 1 .340
`5 .7 74.7 1 5
`5.77341 1
`5 .73 1 .767
`5.734.572
`5 .7 34.63 1
`5.737.437
`5.794.229
`5.796.364
`5.799. 1 1 0
`5.305.334
`5.305.932
`5.307.036
`5.303.660
`5.309.176
`5.309.299
`5.309.337
`5.3 1 2. 1 95
`5.312.739
`5.3 12.3 33
`5.313.363
`5.3 13.369
`5 .3 1 3.5 30
`5.3 19.2 15
`5.322.731
`5.325.424
`5.325.330
`5.332.037
`5.332.126
`5.332.443
`5.335.733
`5.336.003
`5.333.321
`5.333.927
`5.333.996
`5.339.100
`5.341.979
`5.347.762
`5.350.565
`5 .3 56.797
`5.361.324
`5.361.920
`5.364.342
`5.364.673
`5.367.167
`5.367.602
`5.370.036
`5.370.037
`5.372.530
`5 .3 74.907
`5 .33 1 . 104
`
`I5‘-J*>‘.1*3>b->33-33'3*3*}Pl1*.l='>>>>>LP-3P>'3*?>>>}FF-‘.i>Ib’?*3=-P}}.7=->3*3='}}bi‘->J*J>IF-2331??-fl‘->.IP3*>>~??-3=->.Il*3>}>=-I?-.3‘-331.1333‘Pie}-3>3*J*3*3>-3*}-3*
`
`9-" | 997
`97' I 997
`97' | 997
`Illa‘ l 997
`I [J7 I 997
`| I.
`I 997
`I
`|- I997
`12" | 997
`I2.’ l 997
`l 2-’ | 997
`l -" | 998
`3' I 998
`2" I998
`27' I998
`2-' I998
`231998
`3-’ | 998
`37' | 998
`431998
`‘I.-" I 998
`5-’ | 998
`59' | 998
`5?" | 998
`E17’ | 998
`IS.’ I 998
`5*" I 998
`571998
`631998
`57' | 998
`fif l 998
`75 I 998
`7-" | 998
`7"’ I 998
`7." I993
`7-’ |998
`Sr" | 998
`851998
`87' I 998
`‘.17’ I 998
`9.-" I 998
`97' | 998
`9' I998
`9-" | 998
`97' l 998
`97' | 998
`‘.17’ I 998
`9.-" I 998
`9." | 998
`Ill." | 998
`IU.’ | 998
`NJ" I 998
`I 07' I 998
`l II! I 998
`I 07' I998
`ll].-' | 998
`l l "1998
`l | ' |998
`|
`I I998
`I
`|- I 998
`I I.‘ | 998
`l l7"l 998
`l I-' | 998
`| I 3 I998
`l | ' I998
`| l. | 998
`13- I998
`12-" | 998
`l7"l 999
`I-' | 999
`l -' | 999
`|-" I 999
`|."' I 999
`271999
`2! [999
`351999
`271999
`2-’ | 999
`3’ I 999
`37’ | 999
`
`Salihu
`Sl1ip1n1111 et 11].
`Laney
`Beursier cf 11].
`Ishii el Ell.
`Baltlunulsky
`Sharul
`Kenna
`MacDonald el 3].
`Wise el al.
`Gandhi El. 3].
`Kikinis
`Nakana el al.
`Schwm-1'2 61 :11.
`Lee el al.
`Ki.kini3
`Kirsten
`Framaszek at al.
`Wells 61 111.
`B|r1l'I1fie|t.|—B1‘uw11 cl :1].
`Shinagawa el 3].
`II11a.1:1g e1‘ 3|.
`Jericevic et al.
`Liu
`Wang el al.
`Ufi1|'l0 131 111.
`Tmeller cl 3].
`Kralowelz at al.
`Nakazatn er .1].
`Madany el al.
`DeM¢-735 61 al.
`lnnue at Zll.
`Rostaker el :11.
`Mac
`llasllimolo er 0|.
`French et 3|.
`Call0J10.11
`Israels:-11 at 111.
`McKinley el al.
`I\'awasl1ima el al.
`Lo3L|e1:1
`Sekine ct nl.
`Yajimu
`(‘loutier el 3].
`Hsu1n:1J-1 3.‘-‘I ul.
`Z|'lB.l'Ig
`mmmfi
`R30
`Langley
`Withers
`Canfield el al.
`Dobson et :11.
`Wells el :11.
`Cemfield at al.
`Kopf
`Park
`'l':1.na|cz1
`K.0IE3r{Ik El :1].
`Blumer 13-1 :11.
`Sadeh
`Malsubara et 3|.
`(jillorl
`deCa.r1nu
`Wegener
`Schulhofel al.
`Czmfield el al.
`W'1gl1L111zm
`Kawauchi
`R3111 el :11.
`Meat! et 31.
`Knjiya el al.
`Riddle
`Dee-ring
`Za.1:1di et al.
`1-"1':1.n35zek :1 nl.
`Chan
`l)urr1yI:1 at al.
`Crafi
`Alc:1]:1a.11e
`
`

`
`156}
`
`References Cited
`
`U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`5.883.975
`5.884.269
`5.886.655
`5.887. I 65
`5.889.915 I
`5.892.847
`5.90 I .278
`5.907.801
`5.909.557
`5.909.559
`5.9 I 5.079
`5.9 I 7.438
`5.9 I 8.068
`5.9 18.225
`5.920.326
`5.923.860
`5.930.3 58
`5.936.6 I 6
`5.938.737
`5.943.692
`5.945.933
`5.9-19.3 55
`5.949.968
`5.95 I .623
`5.955.976
`5.956.490
`5.960.465
`5.964.842
`5.968.149
`5.969.927
`5.9 73.630
`5.97-1.2 35
`5.974.387
`5.974.-'-I71
`5.978.483
`5.982.3 60
`5.982.723
`5.982.937
`5.987.022
`5.987.432
`5.987.590
`5.990.884
`5.99 I .5 1 5
`5.996.033
`6.000.009
`6.002.-'-I I 1
`6.003. I I 5
`6.008.743
`6.009.491
`6.0 I
`I .90]
`6.014.694
`6.02 I .433
`6.033.755
`6.026.2 I '1‘
`6.028.725
`6.031.939
`6.032. 148
`6.032. I 97
`6.038.346
`6.0 57.790
`6.0 58.4 59
`6.06 I .398
`6.061.473
`6.070. I 79
`6.073.233
`6.07531 70
`6.078.958
`6.09 I .777
`6.092.123
`6.094.634
`6.097.520
`6.097.845
`6.098. I I 4
`6. I 04.389
`6.I 05. I30
`
`3*3'9}Sb3*>>>i>)->LD>>>)'~)v}29>>>>2F-fi}>>P>73’fi>>>>->3>}>>>>29->3*>>39>2D-23F*>>>>29-?>>ibbib)"->}>Lb39§b>>
`
`3.51999
`3.3 I999
`37' 1999
`3." I999
`3: I999
`-T1999
`531999
`5.31999
`671999
`631999
`6.3 I999
`6: 1999
`6.31999
`6.3 1999
`731999
`751999
`7-‘ 1999
`831999
`8.31999
`831999
`83 1999
`931999
`931999
`9.3 1999
`93 I999
`9.31999
`931999
`10.3 I999
`10: I999
`10.31999
`10.31999
`10.3 I999
`10.31999
`10.11999
`1 I3 1999
`1 171999
`I I: 1999
`1 1.31999
`I I.’I999
`1 1.: 1999
`1 1- 1999
`1 1-‘ I999
`11 1999
`1 I 1999
`11-‘ 1999
`121999
`1231999
`12.-‘I999
`1231999
`172000
`I.-'2000
`211000
`232000
`2: 2000
`212000
`232000
`21.1000
`2.32000
`332000
`532000
`5.32000
`5- 2000
`5.52000
`5.32000
`6.32000
`6.32000
`6.32000
`73 2000
`7f2000
`7.-‘.2000
`8"2000
`8.32000
`832000
`8.32000
`8-32000
`
`Na.1'it11 at 111.
`C‘.cl1ic1' er :1].
`Rust
`Martel :71 III.
`Dclbbek
`Johnson
`Ku.rih:1.r:1 el :11.
`Albert el 71].
`Helker 61 EL].
`80
`VoncI.r1.Ln. Jr. at al.
`Antla
`Slmfe
`White at al.
`Rentselaler el al.
`Ulnxig
`Ran
`Turhurg, J1‘. el 71].
`Srrlallcomb el al.
`Marbcrg
`Kalkstein
`Panamlssis
`C}B1‘ltiIe
`RE'yna.r el :11.
`Heath
`Buchholz el al.
`Admns
`Packard
`Jzlquelle L71 ill.
`Schinuer 1:1 :11.
`Healh
`Ntlnally el 81.
`Kageyatna
`B6-It
`Thmnpson. 11'. 1:1‘ al
`Wu el 11.].
`Kmn:I1£I.ni
`Accad
`Geiger et a1.
`Z1.1s1na.11 er al.
`Wing 50
`Dolunn 131' 111.
`Fall at :11.
`(‘hiI.1—Ha6
`Brady
`Dye
`Spear el al.
`.Ia1.1I.1etIc
`Roppel 61 :11.
`Kirsten
`Aha:-oui 1.‘I al.
`Payne
`Casse11:na.n
`Adiletra
`BlumenaJ1.1
`Gilbert at :11.
`Wilkes
`F!-irdwell 61 111.
`Ralnnkar
`[gntn et al.
`Owen el :11.
`Saloh ct al.
`Chen et al.
`Crafl
`I-(maker 61 III.
`LitL1c cl :1].
`I:IcI'1cita 1:1 111.
`Guetz et al.
`8160116 61 111.
`‘1'z1I1agi E1. 211.
`Kadnier
`N3 61 21.1.
`McDonald er :1].
`Ando
`Wu 61:11.
`
`US 9,116,908 B2
`Page -'1
`
`6. 1 1 5.284
`6. 1 28.4 1 2
`6.134.631
`6.141.653
`6.145.626
`6. 145.666
`6. 166.241
`6.176.667
`6.1 76.647
`6.176.649
`6. 172.936
`6. 173.381
`6. I 75.650
`6. 1 75.8 56
`6.182.125
`6.1 85.625
`6.185.659
`6. 162,682
`6.192.155
`6. 195.624
`6.195.125
`6.195.391
`6.195.465
`6.198.842
`6. 198.856
`6.268.273
`6.2 15.904
`6.216.157
`6.2 19.7 54
`6.222.886
`6.225.922
`6.226.667
`6.226.740
`6.236.223
`6.237.054
`6.243.829
`6.255.264
`6.257.693
`6.272.] 78
`6.272.627
`6.272.628
`6.282.64 1
`6.285.458
`6.298.468
`6308.31 1
`6.369.424
`6.3 16.563
`6.3 1 7.7 14
`6.317.818
`6.336.622
`6.333.745
`6.336.] 53
`6.345.367
`6.356.586
`6.356.937
`6.374.353
`6.388.584
`6.362.567
`6.464.931
`6.421.387
`6.434.168
`6.434.695
`6.442.659
`6.449.658
`6.449.682
`6.452.662
`6.452.933
`6.459.429
`6.463.509
`6.487.646
`6.489.902
`6.565.236
`6.5 1 3. I 13
`6.527.162
`6.526.174
`6.529.633
`6.53 2, 1 21
`6.536.438
`6.539.456 B2
`
`9-32 000
`I 03.2 000
`I 042 000
`I033 000
`I 1 1000
`I
`I 2000
`I 3001
`I 32 00 I
`I .2 00I
`172001.
`I -3200 I
`132 00 I
`I -"-200 I
`1'32 001
`I 32 001
`2-32 00I
`32001
`23200 I
`35200]
`2-’: 001
`3.32 001
`27.2 001
`2-32 00I
`342 001.
`33200 I
`332 00 I
`43200 I
`4-32 001
`43:’. 001
`4-32 00I
`57 300 I
`5.3200 I
`5266 1
`5.3200 I
`532 001
`032 001
`032 00I
`71.2 00 I
`83200 I
`332 001
`333 001.
`3-03.00 I
`9-32 001
`I 032 00I
`I 072 00 I
`I 03200 I
`I 072001
`1 1.2001
`I I - 3.001
`I. 23200 I
`I 23200 I
`I 3002
`4332001
`332 002
`332 002
`432 002
`532 00:!
`5.32002
`1572 002
`75.2001
`3.32002
`372002
`353.002
`9-33 00;?
`9.32002
`932002
`932001
`I 033 002
`1052002
`I 11"."! 002
`1232002
`132003
`172 003
`232 003
`-.I.3:’.0'03
`3132003
`3.32003
`3.32003
`332003
`
`Parzych
`Satoh
`Jennings. II.[
`Saukl-mnen
`Barnclt
`Dye
`Shin1i7.u
`V1:1:1IczLt1'zLrr1:Ln 61 :11.
`Dye
`So
`}(ILTL'I.9.IC.I
`Dye
`SindI1I.1 el al.
`Riddle
`Boralla at a].
`Tan et .111.
`Milillo c1 81.
`MurizL11y el :11
`Fan
`Fallon
`Udagawa el al.
`Ilancock at al
`Zandi et :11.
`Yet)
`I'3a.I'1t1:111
`Dye el ELI.
`I.8.\3fl.IIEE
`\3i8hwa.|:1aLI1 el 711.
`Bell 61 :11.
`Yogeshwar
`I5I1‘.)l1()11
`M11J1.hEws at E11.
`38-1
`0Ia.rig,
`Freilng. J1‘.
`Chan
`Seba.<1Li6.|:1
`Miller 61 n1.
`Nieweglcrwski at 3].
`Mann
`Aguilar er :1].
`Christensen
`Yada
`Park
`Carmichae-I at al.
`Fallon
`H6: at :1].
`Del C.'1sli1I6 et 71.1.
`Zwiegincew cl 6].
`Sclmcfer
`SI1imm11uJ‘21 e1 :11.
`Izuu1id:1 1:1 :11.
`Heath
`Geblcr el al.
`Monrvillc et :1].
`Settsu et a1.
`Durward et .11.
`53111011
`Chen et RI.
`Rhee
`Kari
`ljsfahani at a].
`BIu111ena1I
`I_21fe 1:1 :11.
`Tn-orinns
`Mouzin
`Du [Held at 21.1.
`I)ec1"u1g
`T€Dll"|3.l1 elal
`Lipasli
`Healh
`Knbnla
`Knbnyashi
`Dye el 9.].
`Gmflhgnino
`F.:1swzI.I' El 11.].
`R1181 1:1 111.
`I.ecl2':1'us at :I.I.
`Slewalt
`
`

`
`US 9,116,908 B2
`Page 5
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`
`U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`6.542.644
`6.577.254
`6.590.609
`6.597.812
`6.601.104
`6.604.040
`6.604.158
`6.606.040
`6.606.413
`6.609.223
`6.618.728
`6.624.761
`6.633.244
`6.633.968
`6.650.261
`6.661.839
`6.661.845
`6.704.340
`6.708.220
`6.711.709
`6.717.534
`6.723.225
`6.731.814
`6.735.195
`6.745.282
`6.748.457
`6.756.922
`6.768.749
`6.792.151
`6.810.434
`6.813.689
`6.819.271
`6.822.589
`6.856.651
`6.862.278
`6.879.266
`6.885.316
`6.885.319
`6.888.893
`6.909.383
`6.909.745
`6.938.073
`6.944.740
`6.952.409
`6.959.110
`6.959.359
`6.963.608
`6.990.247
`6.993.597
`7.007.099
`7.024.460
`7.050.639
`7.054.493
`7.069.342
`7.089.391
`7.102.544
`7.127.518
`7.129.860
`7.130.913
`7.161.506
`7.181.608
`7.190.284
`7.245.636
`7.319.667
`7.321.937
`Rl:'/10.092
`7.327.287
`7.330.912
`7.352.300
`7.358.867
`7.376.772
`7.378.992
`7.386.046
`7.395.345
`7.400.274
`
`B1
`B2
`B 1
`B 1
`B1
`B2
`B1
`B2
`B1
`B l
`B 1
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B1
`B 1
`B2
`B1
`B1
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B1
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B1
`B 1
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B1
`B2
`B1
`B1
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B1
`B1
`B2
`B2
`B 1
`B1
`B1
`B2
`B2
`B1
`B2
`B1
`B2
`B1
`B2
`B 1
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B 1
`B 1
`B1
`B2
`1:]
`B2
`B1
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B2
`B2
`
`42003
`612003
`7 2003
`7.12003
`7.12003
`8-‘ 2003
`812003
`812003
`8.12003
`812003
`912003
`9.12003
`1012003
`1012003
`1 1.12003
`1212003
`1212003
`32004
`3.12004
`3: 2004
`42004
`4.-'2004
`5.12004
`5.12004
`6.12004
`6.12004
`6.12004
`7.12004
`9.12004
`1012004
`1 1.12004
`1 1.12004
`1 1.12004
`212005
`3.12005
`4.12005
`412005
`4.12005
`5.-12005
`6.12005
`6.12005
`812005
`912005
`1012005
`10.12005
`10.12005
`1 152005
`1» 2006
`1.12006
`212006
`412006
`5.12006
`5.12006
`612006
`8-‘ 2006
`912006
`1012006
`10.12006
`10.12006
`1 2007
`2: 2007
`3- 2007
`712007
`1 2008
`l- 2008
`22008
`2.12008
`212008
`4.12008
`4.: 2008
`5.12008
`5.12008
`6.12008
`7' 2008
`72008
`
`Salon
`Rasmussen
`Ki1at.l.e at .11.
`Fallon el :11.
`Fallon
`Kawasaki et al.
`Fallon
`Abclat
`Zei neh
`Wolfgang
`Rail
`Fallon
`Avery
`Zwioginccw or al.
`Nelson el al.
`lshida at al.
`1-leralll
`Nnlawadi at al
`Ulin
`York
`Yoko:-;o
`Schops
`Zack el al.
`Mehla
`Ukmln all n].
`Fallon ct al.
`Ossia
`Uslcr cl al.
`Barnes el al.
`Mnlhujn1nuraswall1y el al.
`Baxlar. F11
`Geiger at al.
`Dye el al.
`310.311
`Chang or al.
`Dye el al.
`Muhring
`Geiger at :11.
`Li et al.
`Shokrollahi et al.
`PM at 111.
`Mcndhckar cl al.
`Abali el al.
`Jolih:
`Danskin El a].
`Suzuki :31 al.
`Wu
`Schwartz
`Nakagawa el al.
`Donali el ill.
`Kooprnas‘
`Ba.I'nt:s at 211.
`Schwartz
`Bioderman
`Geiger ot al.
`Lin
`Vange E1. al
`Alvnxez. ll
`Fallon
`Fallon
`Fallon at al.
`Dye cl nl.
`Hans ei nl.
`Biederman
`Fallon
`Rang
`Martinian at 111.
`Fox or al.
`Fallon
`Fallon
`Fallon
`Fallon
`Fallon en a].
`Fallon
`Fallon el IL1.
`
`7.415.530 132
`7.417.568 B2
`7.548.657 132
`7.552.069 B2
`7.565.441 B2
`7.711.938 B2
`7.714.747 B2
`7.777.651 132
`8.004.431 B2
`8.054.879 132
`8.073.047 B2
`8.090.936 B2
`8.1 12.619 B2
`8.275.897 B2
`8.502.707 132
`8.504.710 B2
`8.553.759 1:12
`8.643.513 B2
`8.692.695 B2
`8.717.203 B2
`8.717.204 132
`8.719.438 132
`8.723.701 B2
`8.742.958 132
`8.756.332 B2
`8.867.610 B2
`8.880.862 B2
`8.929.442 132
`8.933.825 132
`8.934.535 132
`9.054.728 B2
`200110019630 A1
`2001.-'0U3l092 .41
`200 1.10032 1.28 Al
`200110047473 Al
`200110052038 Al
`200110054131 .41
`200210037035 A1
`2002100693-54 Al
`3002.-'0l'.|7824l Al
`200210080871 Al
`200210097172 Al
`200210101367 Al
`200210104891 Al
`2002.-'0l'.‘.6755 .1\l
`200210169950 AI
`3002.-'0l9l692 Al
`200310030575 Al
`2003101134905 Al
`200310058873 Al
`2003101184238 Al
`2003.-"0090397 Al
`200310142874 Al
`200310191876 Al
`200410042 506 Al
`200410056783 Al
`200410073710 Al
`200410073746 Al
`200610015650 Al
`20061111811-‘141 Al
`200610181442 Al
`200610184687 Al
`200610190644 Al
`200610195601 Al
`200710043939 «'-\1
`200710050514 Al
`200710050515 Al
`200710067483 .1\l
`200710083746 Al
`200710096954 Al
`20070109154 Al
`200710109155 A1
`200710109156 Al
`200710174209 Al
`200810232457 Al
`2110910125698 Al
`200910154545 A1
`200910287839 A1
`201010011012 Al
`
`812008 Fallon
`812008 Fallon el al.
`62009 Dcavcn
`612009 KC]1L‘1:fi
`712009 Rornanik al :1].
`512010 Wise el al.
`5-"2010 Fallon
`812010 Fallon clal.
`812011 Rseznlk
`1112011 Fallon ctal.
`12.12011 Fallon el al.
`112012 Fallon et al.
`2.12012 Fallon el al.
`912012 Fallon
`852013 Fallon
`812013 Fallon
`1012013 Fallon clal.
`212014 Fallon
`4-"2014 Fallon at al.
`5.12014 Fallon
`512014 Fallon el al.
`512014 Fallon
`5-‘"2014 Fallon B131.
`6.2014 Fallon ctal.
`612014 Fallon ......................... .. 709-2.31
`1012014 Fallon et al.
`1 1.12014 Fallon El al.
`112015 Fallon 01 al.
`112015 Fallon
`1.-‘"2015 Fallon I:-:1 al.
`612015 Fallon
`912001
`Johnson
`1012001 Keck el :11.
`1012001 Kepecs
`1 112001 Fallon
`1212001 Fallon ctal.
`1212001 Al\'aro'z. 11 1:1 al.
`312002 Singh
`612002 Fallon El al.
`612002 Vidal :21 a].
`6-"2002 Fallon cl" a1.
`712002 Fallon
`8-‘"2002 Geiger cl al.
`812002 Otto
`912002
`1.1 et al.
`11.12002 Esfallani el al.
`1212002 Fallon el al.
`212003 Frachlcnhcrg el :11.
`212003 Anton cl :1].
`312003 Geiger (:1 al.
`5.12003
`1'lkada el al.
`552003 Raslnnssen
`712003 khwartzr
`1012003 Fallon
`312004 Fallon ctal.
`312004 Fallon
`41200-4 Fallon
`412004 Fallon
`112006 Fallon
`812006 Fallon
`812006 Fallon
`812006 Fallon
`8-"2006 Fallon
`852006 Fallon
`2.12007 Fallon el al.
`32007 Fallon
`312007 Fallon
`312007 Fallon
`4.-"2007 Fallon ctal.
`512007 l3oldl el al.
`552007 Fallon
`5-"2007 Fallon
`552007 Fallon
`7-"2007 Fallon
`912008 Fallon el al.
`5.-"2009 Dye
`6.12009 Fallon el al_
`1 112009 Fallon at al.
`l'20l0 Rawson
`
`

`
`US 9,116,908 B2
`Page 6
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`
`U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
`
`2010f031t3114 A1
`2010r'0318fi84 A1
`10 10: 03327110 At
`2111 150037626 Al
`20Il.'0l99243 AI
`201190211883-'3 A1
`2011"0231-542 A1
`2011-"0235697 A1
`21111-"(BS5559 Al
`20120194362 Al
`20l2.'0239'921 Al
`I1I.I|4:'0022098 AI
`2014311022099 A1
`201410022100 A1
`201470023135 A1
`201450028430 A1
`201410105270 Al
`20l4.u'0|05271 Al
`2015."(J(J090S1 Al
`201501113132 A]
`
`122010 liallon eta].
`1292010 l"allon
`12-20 I 0 Fallon
`2.-"201 I Fallon
`35201 1 Fallon et 211.
`Sr 201 1 Fallon
`972011 Fallon et :11.
`9.12011
`1-‘allon et at.
`I [:20] I Fallon
`El-22012 Fallon et al.
`{H2012 Fallon
`1.-".2014 Fallon
`[I201-1 Fallon et al.
`1.»'2014 Fallon et at.
`1.2014 1-'al1on et 50.
`l.-‘"2014 Fallon et Ell.
`4.-"2014 Fallon et al.
`432014 Fallon et :11.
`1.32015
`l"allon
`201 5 Fallon
`
`l"OR1EICiN PA'l'17.N'1" I)OC‘IJMI.1N'1"S
`
`E1’
`E1’
`F1’
`El’
`L1’
`EP
`E1’
`Fl’
`GB
`JP
`JP
`.11’
`JP
`WO
`W0
`WO
`W0
`WO
`WO
`WO
`WO
`WO
`W0
`WO
`W0
`
`0 135098
`0283798
`040.5572
`0493130
`0587437
`0595406
`0718751
`0 928 070 Al
`21152025
`04-24168]
`6051989
`9188009
`11149376
`WU 9414273
`W0 9429f'i5'2
`WO 9.502873
`W0 95-529437 Al
`WO 9748212
`WO9839699 A2
`W0 9908186
`WO003fi5 74 Al
`WO 0lt0.5764'2
`W0 01.r'057659
`W0 011153772
`W0 (12»'3959l
`
`651986
`9.‘ I 988
`11991
`7:‘ I 992
`31994
`551994
`fir'199fi
`7-‘"1999
`131986
`8.31992
`2.51994
`7I1997
`6519959
`6:199-4
`12.‘ I994
`1.31995
`1151995
`12.-"1997
`9319915
`2-’ 1 999
`fiI20tI11
`8.72001
`S:"20tJl
`S.-'20Ul
`552002
`
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`
`Reply to Reallirue-‘s Response to Blue Coat Defendants’ Uhjections
`to Report and Recommendation of United States Magistrate J1Idge
`Regarding Motion for Partial Stlmtnary Judgment of tnvalidity for
`lndefiniteness Entered Jtm. 23-. 2009. in Reairiflle Data, JCLC at/‘Jig.’
`{X0 V. I*‘ncil'e'te'et"_ hie. ht 0.1.. Civil Action No. 5:03-i:v—00I44—1.ED;
`U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Texas. Jul. 31. 2009. 3
`
`lfilitltime Data’s Stir-Reply in Opposition to the Defendants‘ Joint
`Objections to Repon and Recommendation ofMagi stmte Regarding
`Motion for Partial SlItTll11iI.I'y Judgment of Invalidity for Indefinite-
`ness. in Keatrfme thin. LLC -:J‘a’t'Jv'¢1.f1Z’t'() v. P¢2ci'ceteer; Inc. er 111.. Civil
`Action No. 6:08-cv-00144-LED; U.S. District‘ Conn‘ for the Eastern
`District of Texas. dated Aug. 3. 2009. 3 pages.
`“A-T [Financial Offers Manipulation. Redistrilrution of Ticker 11]".
`Inside Market Data. vol. 4 No. 14. Sep. 5. 1989.
`1 page.
`“Add—on Options for the Xpres.sFiles".
`Intelligent Compression
`Tee ltnologies.
`h1lp:!7weh.z|.|‘c11ive.orgi'web.' 199 805 1811534 18.-"
`icteompress.comfoptions X,htm1. 1998. 2 pages.
`Andrews et al.. "A Me
`-Removed Variation of Weighted Universztl
`Vector Quantivation for lmage Coding”. lEF.Fi. 1993. pp. 302-309.
`Assorted Claims Chan‘ for U.S. Pat. No. 6.624.761. Rentrfare Dara.
`LLC DXBJL-1' [X0 v. (‘.’lfl:' Grorrp fr1r:.. or at‘.
`. 6:09-cv-327-LED-JDL.
`
`6:10-ev-246-LED-.lDI_. United States District Court‘ for the Eastern
`District oFTexas Tyler Division. Oct. 19. 2011.1, 4 pages.
`Assorted Claims Chart for U.S. Pat. No. 7.161.500. Reaitirne Dara.
`Lt.C' DIEM Lift) v.
`(.'.:'l»fl_" Group i’rrc., or o:'.. 6:09-cv-327-]_1iD-.l'DL.
`United States District Court for the Eastern District ot"1'exa.s '1'yler
`Division. Oct. 19. 2010, 5 pages.
`Assorted Claims Chan for U.S. Pat. No. 7.400.274. Ra-al‘i‘t‘;iie Dam.
`LLC‘D2’B./A IXO v. CME Gmiip 1m:.. er of.
`. 6:09-cv-327-LED-JDL.
`6:10-ev-246-LED-JDL. United States District‘ Court‘ for the Eastern
`DisIJ‘ict o1'Texas Tyler 1)i\'isiorl. Oct. 19. 2011.1. 6 pages.
`Asserted Claims Chart for 1.1.3. Pat. No. 7.417.563. Reaitiflle Data.
`7.1. ("DxBri~t IXO v. (‘ME Group 1'm:.. er of.
`. 6:09-cv-327-L1_"D-JDL.
`6:10-cv-246-L1.-".D-JDL. United States District Court for the Eastern
`Distrie ofTe:~¢as Tyler Division. Oct. 19.2010. 13 pages.
`AssertedC1tLirn5 Chan for U.S. Pat. No. 7.714.747. Remlitme Dam.
`LLC'D/BM LYC? V. CME Gmiip Im‘.. at at. . 6:09-ev-327-LED-.|'DL.
`6:10-ev-246-LED-.lDI_. United States District‘ Court‘ for the Eastern
`District DrTt!X3J5 Tyler Division, Oct. 19. 2011.1. 19 pages.
`Barton. Rich. S4511’ Comfllock Network Character Set Definition.
`19.2 [(12 Network. Version 1.7.0. Feb. 10. 1995. 29 pages.
`Beech. W. A.. ct al .. “AK .25 Link Access Protocol for Amateur Packet
`Radio." Version 2.25. Revision: Jul. 1998. 143 pages.
`Bormann. Carsten. "Providing integrated Services over Low-bitrato
`Links." Nehvork Working Group Request‘ for Comments: 2689. Cat-
`egory". 1nfi:I1111a.tiona.1. Rep. 1999. 14 pages.
`CoI11Stoc1t Services PZlJT1p111EL N1eGraw—1-1il1 Financial Services
`Company. purportedly published by .lu1. 19. 1995. 6 pages.
`Cormack. Gordon V. “Data Compression on a Database Syste ".
`Colnmllnieations of the ACM. vol. 28. No. 12. Dee. 1985. pp. 13315-
`1342.
`Danskin. John Moflatt. "Compressing the K Graphics Protocol: A
`Dissenation Presented to the Iiaeult of Princeton Llniversity in Can-
`didacy 11J]'11’1E DegreeofDoi:tor of1’hilosophy." Jan. 1995, 147 pages.
`"Data Networks and Open System ColnmI.Lrtica.tions." lnliilrmation
`"technology Abstract Syntax Notation (.1ne[ASN. 1) Specification
`01' Basic Notation. International Telecoimntlnicntion Union. ITU-T
`Teleooiurnuniczninn Stanttanliwation Se4:torc-1' ITU 3.680. Jul. I994.
`Defendants‘ Inval idily Contentions. Reat'r‘t'm£* Dara, U.-C D/BM IXO
`V. (ME Group Inc, er :21.
`. 6:09-cv-327-LED-JDL. fi:10-cv-24fi-
`LED-JDL. United States District Cotut for the Eastern District of
`Texas Tyler Division. Out. 19. 2010. 1*} pages.
`Degermark, Mikael. "lT’ 1-leader Compression". Network Working
`Ciroup Request for Comments: 2507. Category: Standards Traclc.
`Feb. 1999. 47 pages.
`Developer's Guide, Version 1.0.2. SELF Comfitock. Feb. 15. 1994.
`186 pages.
`Dotnanslci. Dr. Bernie. “All the news you can eat. Department: Dr.
`Br-:mie’s Digeslions and Dig,ressions".. Demand Tex:l'tno1ogy’s
`Capacity Mnnageinent Review. vol. 25. No.
`'1. Jul. 199?. pp. 24.
`18-22.
`Eflios. Michelle and Phil ipA. C.’hcn.I. "Weighted Universal Tl'£l.TI.S1lJF1l'1
`Coding: Iiniversal Image Coniprossion with the I<.arhiu1en~l.oeve
`Transform“. IEEE. 1995. pp. 61-64.
`Engan. Mathias. "I1-" Ileader Compression over 1-"PP". Network
`Working Group Request for Coinrnents: 2509. Category: 2509. Feb.
`1999. 10 pages.
`Exhibit" A.
`Invalidity Claim Chans A1-A45 for U.S. Pat". No.
`6.624.761. Reairime Dara. L-EC DEB/A LYO v. (‘ME Group hi.-».. er
`Ga‘.
`. 6:09—cv—327—1.F.1)-JD]... 6:l0—cv—245—1.F.'D-.lTJ1.. United States
`District CoI.u't for the Eastern District ot"1'exas Tyler Division. Oct‘.
`19. 2010. 616 pages.
`Exhibit
`1-3.
`lnvalidity Clailn Cha.I1s 131-1345 For 1.i.S. Pat. No.
`7.151.506. Reaftirrie Darn. LLC D2’B.»fd [X0 v. C‘ME Group Inc. cf
`of.
`. 6:09-cv-2-27-1_ED-.lDL. 6:10-ev-246-LED-JDL. United States
`District Court for I.l1e Eastern District o1'Texas Tyler Division. Oct.
`19.2010. [513 pages.
`Exhibit C. Lnvalidity Claim Clilarts C1-C7. C9-C31. C33-C45 for
`U.S. Pat. No. 7.400.274. Reatftrrte Data, LLFD/Eris {Xi} v. {THE
`Ginny: far.-., er al.
`. 6:09—ev—327—1.FD~.1D1.. 6: l0—ev—3-16—I.F.lJ-JDI..
`United States District Court for the Eastern District of't‘exas Tyler
`Division. Oct. 19. 2010. 1528 pages.
`
`

`
`US 9,116,908 B2
`Page 7
`
`(56)
`
`References Cited
`
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`
`Exhibit D. Invalidity Claim CI]a.t1s D1-D7. D9-D45 for l.I.S. Pat. No.
`7.417.568. Reoitinte Dattz. LLC DEB‘/it £.3t'C) v. C‘M.L' Group Jim. at
`at‘.
`. 6:lJ9—cv—3I£7—I.FD—JDI.. tS:l0~cv—24fi~l.F.D—.TDI.. United States
`District Court for the Eastern District of Texas Tyler Division. Oct.
`19. 2010. 2453 pages.
`I.-'.'<hibit E. Invalidity Claim Chants I31-I37. E9. Ell. El}-E15. LEI’?-
`F._'lI.l. E.'l2—l-7.45 for U.S Pat. No.
`'i‘.TI4.74T, Reattinte Data. LII’
`.033".-’I IXO V. C'M'E Group i'm:.. 9.’ GI. , 6:(I9—c\« -327—I.F.IJ—JTJI_. 6: II}-
`cv-246-LIED-JDL. United States District Court for the llaatetn Dis-
`trict ot"I'exas Tyler Division. Oct. 19. El"! ID. 33 I2 pages.
`Greene. Tirn. “sqtteetce your ‘1\'etlin]Ls”. i'1IElWt)l'lCVVUl‘l(l. vol. I4. No.
`28. Jul. 14. 1991'. pp. I and 56.
`Ilelck. Cht'istopherJ.. "I:LncapsuIate(| 'I'ieket". Ver I.l'J."JttI. I4. 1993.
`22 pages.
`"I-IigI1~perI'orrnartce schernzt—sp-ecilic compression for X1911. data for-
`Inats." XMI_—Xpress: Prodttet Utrerview. Intelligent Cotnpression
`Technologies.
`I1rtp:.".twelJ.a.t'c hiVe.org. vt.rcIt»"2 DU 208 I 8002 535r'W\l’W.
`ictcompress.con:tt'prodttcts _xmlxprcss. 200]. 2 pages.
`1*-II’I.33 I-Isu. William H. and Amy E. .?.w:Lrii.-o. "Atttornatic Synthesis
`of C|I'Ifl1]JI'|-‘S$It.1I'l Techniques for Heterogeneous Files." Sollw:I.re—
`Practice and l:'.Kperienee. vol. 25 t 10). Oct. 1995. pp. 1097-] I 16.
`"lCT's XML-Xprcss". Intelligent Compression Technologies. Dec.
`2000. 5 pages.
`II.igl1-
`"I.n.t'ormation processing sy