`Patent 7,772,209
`
`
`UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`__________________
`
`BEFORE THE PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`__________________
`
`SANDOZ INC.,
`APOTEX INC., and APOTEX CORP.,
`EMCURE PHARMACEUTICALS LTD.,
`HERITAGE PHARMA LABS INC.,
`HERITAGE PHARMACEUTICALS INC.,
`GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS, INC., USA,
`GLENMARK HOLDING SA,
`GLENMARK PHARMACEUTICALS, LTD., MYLAN LABORATORIES
`LIMITED, TEVA PHARMACEUTICALS,
`FRESENIUS KABI USA, LLC and WOCKHARDT BIO AG
`Petitioners,
`
`v.
`
`ELI LILLY & COMPANY,
`Patent Owner.
`__________________
`
`Case No: IPR2016-003181
`Patent No. 7,772,209
`__________________
`
`
`
`PATENT OWNER’S OBJECTIONS TO SUPPLEMENTAL EVIDENCE
`
`
`
`
`
`
`1 Cases IPR2016-01429, IPR2016-01393, and IPR2016-01340 have been joined
`
`with the instant proceeding.
`
`
`
`
`
`Case IPR 2016-00318
`Patent 7,772,209
`Patent Owner Eli Lilly & Company (“Lilly”) hereby objects pursuant to 37
`
`
`
`C.F.R. § 42.64(b)(1) and the Federal Rules of Evidence (“FRE”) to the
`
`admissibility of certain purported supplemental evidence served by Petitioner
`
`Sandoz Inc. on January 17, 2017 in connection with its Petition for Inter Partes
`
`Review. The exhibits objected to, and grounds for Lilly’s objections, are listed
`
`below. Lilly also objects to Petitioner’s reliance on or citations to any objected
`
`evidence in its papers.
`
`Some of the exhibits served by Sandoz Inc. on January 17, 2017 were
`
`introduced at depositions in this proceeding, and Lilly objected to certain of those
`
`exhibits at the depositions as required by 37 C.F.R. § 42.64(a). Nothing contained
`
`herein shall be deemed to withdraw any of Lilly’s objections to deposition
`
`evidence or the requirement that evidence to cure those objections must have been
`
`provided during the deposition, see id.
`
`I.
`
`IDENTIFICATION OF CHALLENGED EVIDENCE AND GROUNDS
`FOR OBJECTIONS
`A. Exhibit 1064
`Lilly objects to Exhibit 1064 under FRE 802 because it is inadmissible
`
`hearsay, specifically trial testimony from Dr. Bruce Chabner in a different
`
`proceeding, Eli Lilly v. Teva Parenteral Meds., Inc. et al., 1:10-cv-01376-TWP-
`
`DKL (S.D. Ind.). Lilly further objects to Exhibit 1064 as incomplete as it does not
`
`include Dr. Chabner’s direct or re-direct testimony. It therefore should be
`
`
`
`2
`
`
`
`Case IPR 2016-00318
`Patent 7,772,209
`excluded under FRE 106, 401, 402, and 403. Lilly also objects to Exhibit 1064
`
`under FRE 402 and 403 because it is irrelevant and its probative value is
`
`substantially outweighed by the danger of wasting time and needlessly presenting
`
`cumulative evidence in this compressed proceeding.
`
`Exhibit 1065
`
`B.
`Lilly objects to Exhibit 1065 under FRE 402 and 403 because it is irrelevant
`
`and its probative value is substantially outweighed by the danger of wasting time in
`
`this compressed proceeding. Exhibit 1065 was published in 2004 and, therefore,
`
`bears no relevance to what the person of ordinary skill in the art would have known
`
`by the relevant date. Therefore, Exhibit 1065 should be excluded under FRE 402
`
`and 403.
`
`C. Exhibit 1073
`Lilly objects to Exhibit 1073 under FRE 802 because it is inadmissible
`
`hearsay, specifically deposition testimony from Dr. Bruce Chabner in a different
`
`proceeding, Eli Lilly v. Teva Parenteral Meds., Inc. et al., 1:10-cv-01376-TWP-
`
`DKL (S.D. Ind.). Lilly also objects to Exhibit 1073 under FRE 402 and 403
`
`because it is irrelevant and its probative value is substantially outweighed by the
`
`danger of wasting time and needlessly presenting cumulative evidence in this
`
`compressed proceeding.
`
`
`
`3
`
`
`
`Case IPR 2016-00318
`Patent 7,772,209
`Lilly also objects to Exhibit 1073 because it contains hundreds of pages of
`
`extraneous materials that appear to be other exhibits in this proceeding, are not
`
`related to Exhibit 1073, and should not be included in the same exhibit with Dr.
`
`Chabner’s deposition testimony from Eli Lilly v. Teva Parenteral Meds., Inc. et al.,
`
`1:10-cv-01376-TWP-DKL (S.D. Ind.), even were that deposition testimony
`
`otherwise admissible. Lilly incorporates by reference herein any objections it has
`
`made to those other materials and reserves the right to interpose objections based
`
`on the use, if any, to which the extraneous materials in Exhibit 1073 may be put.
`
`D. Exhibit 1130
`Lilly objects to Exhibit 1130 under FRE 802 because it is inadmissible
`
`hearsay, specifically deposition testimony from Dr. Steven Zeisel in a different
`
`proceeding, Eli Lilly v. Teva Parenteral Meds., Inc. et al., 1:10-cv-01376-TWP-
`
`DKL (S.D. Ind.). Lilly also objects to Exhibit 1130 under FRE 402 and 403
`
`because it is irrelevant and its probative value is substantially outweighed by the
`
`danger of wasting time and needlessly presenting cumulative evidence in this
`
`compressed proceeding.
`
`Exhibit 1131
`
`E.
`Lilly objects to Exhibit 1131 under FRE 802 because it is inadmissible
`
`hearsay, specifically trial testimony from Dr. Steven Zeisel in a different
`
`proceeding, Eli Lilly v. Teva Parenteral Meds., Inc. et al., 1:10-cv-01376-TWP-
`
`
`
`4
`
`
`
`Case IPR 2016-00318
`Patent 7,772,209
`DKL (S.D. Ind.). Lilly also objects to Exhibit 1131 under FRE 402 and 403
`
`because it is irrelevant and its probative value is substantially outweighed by the
`
`danger of wasting time and needlessly presenting cumulative evidence in this
`
`compressed proceeding.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`/David M. Krinsky/
`David M. Krinsky
`Reg. No. 72,339
`Back-up Counsel for
`Patent Owner
`
`Williams & Connolly LLP
`725 Twelfth Street, N.W.
`Washington, D.C. 20005
`202-434-5338 (Telephone)
`202-434-5029 (Facsimile)
`dkrinsky@wc.com
`
`
`
`5
`
`
`Date: January 24, 2017
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Case IPR 2016-00318
`Patent 7,772,209
`
`CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
`(37 C.F.R. § 42.6(e))
`
`The undersigned hereby certifies that the foregoing document was served on
`
`
`
`January 24, 2017 by delivering a copy via electronic mail on the following
`
`attorneys of record for the Petitioner:
`
`Ralph J. Gabric
`Reg. No. 34,167
`rgabric@brinksgilson.com
`
`Joshua H. James
`Reg. No. 72,568
`jjames@brinksgilson.com
`
`Brinks Gilson & Lione
`455 Cityfront Plaza Drive
`Suite 3600 NBC Tower
`Chicago, IL 60611-5599
`T: 312-321-4200; F: 312-321-4299
`
`Bryan T. Richardson, Ph.D.
`Reg. No. 70,572
`brichardson@brinksgilson.com
`
`Brinks Gilson & Lione
`4721 Emperor Blvd.
`Suite 220
`Durham, NC 27703-8580
`T: 919-998-5700; F: 919-998-5701
`
`Counsel for Sandoz Inc.
`
`John D. Polivick
`Reg. No. 57,926
`jpolivick@rmmslegal.com
`
`William A. Rakoczy
`
`
`
`Laura Lydigsen
`Pro hac vice
`llydigsen@brinksgilson.com
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Deanne M. Mazzochi
`Reg. No. 50,158
`dmazzochi@rmmslegal.com
`
`Patrick C. Kilgore
`
`
`
`
`
`Pro hac vice to be filed
`wrakoczy@rmmslegal.com
`
`Rakoczy Molino Mazzochi Siwik LLP
`6 West Hubbard Street, Suite 500
`Chicago, IL
`P: 312-527-2157/F: 312-527-4205
`
`Attorneys for Apotex Inc. and Apotex
`Corp.
`
`Thomas J. Parker
`Reg. No. 42,062
`thomas.parker@alston.com
`
`Alston & Bird LLP
`90 Park Avenue, 15th Floor
`New York, NY 10016
`P: 212-210-9529/F: 212-210-9444
`
`Counsel for Mylan Laboratories Limited
`
`Gerard A. Haddad
`Reg. No. 41,811
`GHaddad@BlankRome.com
`
`Blank Rome LLP
`The Chrysler Building
`405 Lexington Ave.
`New York, NY 10174
`P: 212-885-5135/F: 917-591-6921
`
`Counsel for Glenmark Pharmaceuticals
`Inc., USA, Glenmark Holding SA, and
`Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Ltd.
`
`Paul M. Zagar
`Reg. No. 52,392
`PZagar@BlankRome.com
`
`
`
`
`Case IPR 2016-00318
`Patent 7,772,209
`
`Reg. No. 69,131
`pkilgore@rmmslegal.com
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Blank Rome LLP
`The Chrysler Building
`405 Lexington Ave.
`New York, NY 10174
`P: 212-885-5290/F: 917-332-3063
`
`Counsel for Emcure Pharmaceuticals
`Ltd., Heritage Pharma Labs Inc., and
`Heritage Pharmaceuticals Inc.
`
`Patrick A. Doody
`Reg. No. 35,022
`patrick.doody@pillsburylaw.com
`
`Pillsbury Winthrop Shaw Pittman LLP
`1650 Tysons Boulevard
`McLean, VA 22102
`P: 703-770-7755/F: 703-770-7901
`
`Counsel for Wockhardt Bio AG
`
`Gary J. Speier
`Reg. No. 45,458
`gspeier@carlsoncaspers.com
`
`Carlson, Caspers, Vandenburgh,
`Lindquist & Schuman
`225 South Sixth Street, Suite 4200
`Minneapolis, MN 55402
`P: 612-436-9600
`F: 612-436-9605
`
`Cynthia Lambert Hardman
`Reg. No. 53,179
`chardman@goodwinprocter.com
`
`Goodwin Procter LLP
`The New York Times Building
`620 Eighth Avenue
`New York, NY 10018-1405
`
`
`
`Case IPR 2016-00318
`Patent 7,772,209
`
`
`Bryan P. Collins
`Reg. No. 43,560
`bryan.collins@pillsburylaw.com
`
`
`
`Mark D. Schuman
`Reg. No. 31,197
`mschuman@carlsoncaspers.com
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Case IPR 2016-00318
`Patent 7,772,209
`
`/David M. Krinsky/
`David M. Krinsky
`Reg. No. 72,339
`Back-up Counsel
`for Patent Owner
`
`
`
`P: 212-813-8800
`F: 212-355-3333
`
`Attorneys for Teva Pharmaceuticals
`USA, Inc. and Fresenius Kabi USA,
`LLC
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Date: January 24, 2017
`
`
`
`
`
`