throbber
1958
`
`Morton and Pietenpol: The Technological Impact of Transistors
`
`955
`
`The frequency-production index can be expressed in
`dimensionless form and is then the number of oscilla-
`tions at the alpha cutoff frequency of the highest fre-
`quency transistor during the average time required to
`produce a transistor in the U.S.A. In dimensionless form
`IfP is 2X101" cycles per unit. This measures the sim-
`plicity of the transistor compared to man.
`Since transistor production depends on years and
`men, I have used in Table I the well established ratio' of
`70 between them in predicting frequency from volume
`and frequency-production index. The production esti-
`mates are based on conventional methods of estimating
`growth.
`
`2 This number will be recognized as 3 (10) in the customary score
`system.
`
`No business essay is complete without a reference to
`money. Assuming that the cost per unit varies as
`P,-0.3 , my estimate of average transistor prices for
`1958, 1959, and 1960, is $1.80, $1.40, and $1.20. The
`corresponding sales volumes are $125, $210, and $300
`million.
`In closing this essay, I should like to acknowledge the
`assistance that has made it possible to carry out the ex-
`tensive research involved. The significant data pub-
`lished by the Electrical Industries Association3 has been
`essential. Special thanks are due to the encouragement
`and assistance of my friends at Bell Telephone Labo-
`ratories; without it, the completion of the investigation
`would have been difficult.
`3 Wall St. J., p. 11; October 14, 1957.
`
`The Technological Impact of Transistors *
`J. A. MORTONt, FELLOW, IRE, AND W. J. PIETENPOLt, MEMBER, IRE
`
`Summary-During the past ten years the transistor has invaded
`every phase of the electronics industry. Its important features are
`its high efficiency at low power levels, its reliability, and its potential
`low cost.
`Presented here are the major milestones and problems which
`were overcome and led to devices that cover a broad field of elec-
`tronic technology, and to the growth of a new industry.
`
`E LECTRONICS is an increasingly important part
`of modern technology. It merits this distinction
`because it pervades our economy as water does a
`sponge. Since electronics has to do with the high speed
`transmission and processing of information, it becomes
`a wonderful extension of man's mind.
`Electronics has the potential of affecting every aspect
`of our modern industrial world through communication,
`entertainment, transportation, power, manufacturing,
`and business. If we can measure the transistor's effect in
`expanding the breadth and versatility of electronics, by
`imaginative implication, we can define its impact on the
`whole of modern technology.
`The bulk of present day electronics has to do mostly
`with the transmission of information. In some 45 years
`it has grown from the original deForest vacuum triode
`and modulation theory to the fifth largest American
`industry comprised largely of consumer, military, and
`industrial transmission functions.
`
`* Original manuscript received by the IRE, March 5, 1958.
`t Bell Telephone Labs., Inc., Murray Hill, N. J.
`
`For some time now, through applications of informa-
`tion and switching theory to functions such as pulse-
`code modulation, memory, and logic, electronic man has
`known how in principle to extend greatly his visual,
`tactile, and mental abilities to the digital transmission
`and processing of all kinds of information. However,
`all these functions suffer from what has been called "the
`tyranny of numbers." Such systems, because of their
`complex digital nature, require hundreds, thousands,
`and sometimes tens of thousands of electron devices.
`The large amount of power used inefficiently and the
`high cost of reliability of the electron tube have pre-
`vented these expansions of electronics in all but a few
`cases where the high cost could be tolerated, even though
`not desired.
`This is where the transistor comes in. The really
`important aspects of the transistor are its very high-
`power efficiency at low-power levels and its potential
`reliability. Because of its relatively simple mechanical
`features, it is potentially low cost-another basic re-
`quirement of "the tyranny of numbers."
`So the story of the transistor to date has really been
`the struggle to realize these potentialities of high
`performance with high reliability and low cost. Let us
`take a quick look at the major milestones and problems
`that have been passed leading to today's transistor
`technology.
`To measure the present and future stature of tran-
`sistor electronics, we will glance at a few of the many
`system functions which transistors are now performing
`
`Sony Corp. v. Raytheon Co.
`IPR2016-00209
`
`Raytheon2013-0001
`
`

`
`956
`
`PROCEEDINGS OF THE IRE
`
`June
`
`or are committed to do. These examples cannot be
`inclusive-there are too many. Many of them will be
`drawn from the Bell System since the facts are more
`readily available to the authors. But some military,
`consumer, and rindustrial applications must be men
`tioned.
`
`HISTORY
`The era from the announcement of the invention of
`the point-contact transistor in mid 1948 until mid 1951
`can be likened to early childhood. In this era, key items
`in advancing the device technology and research under-
`standing came through the development of pulling
`and zone-melting methods for growing single crystals
`of germanium of unprecedented purity and uniformity.
`Work by the inventors of the transistor and their
`colleagues during this era, resulted in improved theoreti-
`cal understanding and physical realization of the junc-
`transistor with greatly improved performance.
`tion
`Fabrication of junction diodes, triodes, and photo
`transistors was accomplished by both growing and
`alloying techniques. The micropower, high gain, and
`low noise predicted for such devices was proved.
`From mid 1951 to mid 1952, a period reminiscent of
`adolescence was experienced. Gains in performance en-
`couraged further applications. However, as for an
`adolescent youngster, so too for the transistor, from
`day to day we were impressed with new performance
`possibilities-yet, at the same time, new reliability dif-
`ficulties were brought to light.
`These reliability problems were shown to be surface
`dependent, research and development programs on sur-
`face physics and reliability were initiated throughout
`the industry. This heralded the "young manhood"
`period of 1952 to mid 1955.
`During this period, larger responsibilities and defi-
`nite commitments were undertaken. For example, point
`transistors went to work in an operator tone-dialing
`trial in October of 1952. The first over-the-counter sales
`of alloy and grown-junction-transistor hearing aids took
`place around the end of 1952. A few years later no manu-
`facturer produced tube hearing aids.
`In March, 1953, point-contact phototransistors and
`transistors were employed in the card translator portion
`of direct distance-dialing equipment. In a reliability
`study over 100 million transistor hours of operation
`were attained in this application with an indicated
`failure rate of less than 0.04 per cent per 1000 hours.
`TRADIC, the first transistorized military computer,
`was demonstrated in January, 1954, and later in the
`same year, the first all-transistor personal radio became
`available in time for the Christmas market.
`Other equipment developed during this era included
`the first all-transistor industrial computer, and tran-
`sistorized telephone sets for the hard of hearing and for
`use in noisy locations. Transistorized rural carrier and
`line concentrator tests were successfully undertaken.
`On the military side, digital data transmission and
`
`processing systems, computers, and missile-conitrol sys-
`tems relied wholly or in part on transistoors for their
`successful development and trial.
`This sudden expansion in applications called foi a
`wide variety of types of transistors. Techniques for
`germanium were pushed to their limits. Gerrnarniuni
`crystals of almost perfect physical and chemical proper
`ties were developed to improve manufacturing yields.
`Diodes, triodes, tetrodes, and power units of a wide
`variety were developed and put into manufacture. Sili-
`con entered the field as an alloy-junctioni diode of greatly
`improved properties; silicon became an important bread
`and butter business.
`Gains in understanding of the surface effects in
`reliability were put to work successfully in the form of
`improved surface treatment and capsulation techniques
`Reliability surpassed that of all but the best telephonie
`tubes. In fact, one hearing aid transistor manufacturer
`complained bitterly and frequently over the disap-
`pearance of his replacement business.
`Where then did transistor electronics stand n'ear the
`end of this era of early manhood?
`The wide variety of applications called for a stagger
`ing range of characteristics. Point, grown, alloy, and
`surface-barrier techniques on germanium and silicon
`were close to their capability limits. Each structure and
`technique had serious limitations. Transistor designers
`and manufacturers were forced to develop a large num-
`ber of compromise designs-about 200. The resulting
`manufacturer's nightmare inhibited large-scale eco-
`nomical manufacturing of any one prototype. This was
`reflected in still high costs, from $2.00 to $45.00 per
`transistor.
`Meantime, research people were busy pushing ahead
`the frontiers of understanding of materials, structures,
`and techniques. Toward the end of this era they made a
`triple breakthrough of such magnitude that it started
`a new era-the "Era of Maturity." This work demon-
`strated the possibility of removing most of the limita-
`tions which forced design compromises to a multiplicity
`of types.
`By proving the feasibility of purifying silicon to
`transistor requirements, by solving the problems of
`solid-state diffusion as a technique, and by devising the
`diffused-base structure, they demonstrated the possi-
`bility of making diffused silicon transistors with cutoff
`frequencies of 50-100 mc, 5 to 10 times faster than the
`older germanium transistors while at the same time
`retaining the silicon advantages of high power, tempera
`ture, and efficiency. Application of similar structures
`and techniques to germanium pushed the frequency
`frontier into the low-microwave region.
`The magnitude of these research accomplishments
`dictated a re-evaluation of most transistor develop-
`ment-application programs starting 'in mid 1955. It was
`realized that further refinements of growing, alloying,
`and surface barrier technriques were possible but only at
`large development and manufacturing costs. IHowever,
`
`Raytheon2013-0002
`
`

`
`1958
`
`Morton and Pietenpol: The Technological Impact of Transistors
`
`957
`
`-I
`
`'--
`
`DIFFUSED SILiCON POWER
`ALLOY GERMANIUM POWER
`
`luu
`
`'10
`
`n
`
`_
`
`_
`
`_
`
`_
`
`I _
`DIFFUSED BASE SILICON
`
`_
`
`_
`
`POINT CONTACT, GROWN & ALLOY GERMANIUM
`DIFFUSED' BASE GERMANIUd
`
`z z 0
`
`ai
`
`fr
`
`the dramatic demonstrations of potentiality of these
`new diffusion techniques, based as they were on more
`complete scientific understanding, clearly showed that
`maximum effort should be devoted to their develop-
`ment. The eventual economies of a single prototype
`diffusion technique and diffused structure, with heavy
`emphasis on silicon, were the :goals.
`
`PRESENT STATUS
`Where then has this diffusion breakthrough brought
`us today? Either in, or just entering, production are
`the following diffused devices:
`1) Silicon-power rectifiers ranging from 0.5 ampere
`up to 100 amperes which will handle reverse break-
`down voltages up to several hundreds of volts.
`2) Silicon-voltage limiters with closely controlled break-
`down voltages ranging from 4.2 volts up to 200
`volts.
`3) Diffused-base silicon transistors with frequency
`cutoffs in the 50-100-mc range. As switching tran-
`sistors they will provide 10-mc switching rates
`with attendant power dissipation up to one-quarter
`watt.
`4) Diffused-base germanium transistors with fre-
`quency cutoffs as high as 1000 mc. One code of this
`prototype designed as an oscillator has a minimum
`rating of 50 mw output power at 250 mc. Other
`codes designed for very high speed switching pro-
`vide switching rates as high as 50-100 mc.
`Today the circuit designer has at his command a
`broad range of structures and characteristics. These
`new devices in combination with improved versions of
`the older structures greatly extend the range of per-
`formance formerly possible. It is not possible here to
`compare all of their electrical characteristics, but it is
`helpful to show in Fig. 1 the frequency range as a func-
`tion of power dissipation covered by presently available
`types. The frequencies plotted are the grounded-base-
`alpha cutoff frequencies for each prototype. For video
`or broad-band amplifiers, the useable range would be
`somewhat below the cutoff frequency depending upon
`the mode of application. However, for oscillators, useful
`power outputs can be achieved to well above the fre-
`quency cutoff.
`The availability of such complete performance range
`from present semiconductor devices has profoundly
`affected the kinds and numbers of system applica-
`tions.
`In transmission systems, pulse-code modulation car-
`rier, personal radio paging, and VHF communications
`are depending upon diffused germanium devices. Al-
`though transistors have not yet found their way into
`commercial television receivers, laboratory develop-
`mnents indicate this to be highly probable with attendant
`savings in size, power, and maintenance costs.
`In power systems, the new diffused silicon rectifiers,
`voltage regulators, and lightning protectors are essential
`
`.0; ____ 1 _
`10 KC
`
`I _._A
`
`100 KC
`
`MC
`FREQUENCY
`Fig. 1-The curves indicate the power-frequency spectrum
`covered by various prototypes of transistor structures.
`
`IOMC
`
`IOOMC
`
`IOOOMC
`
`components for success. By applying diffusion to cheap
`silicon, it has been possible to design a much smaller
`and better telephone click reducer than the copper-
`oxide unit now in use for many years but dependent
`upon an uncertain supply of unique copper.
`In electronic switching, computers, and digital data
`processing, the new diffused diodes and triodes are
`greatly extending the speeds and reliability while at
`the same time greatly reducing the size and power
`required for such large and complex machines.
`In the military area too this new line of devices is
`gaining acceptance in computers, missile systems, servo-
`systems, fuses, radar, communications, and power sup-
`plies. In fact, diffused germanium transistors are now
`circling the earth in the EXPLORER and VANGUARD
`satellites.
`All in all today's variety of old and new transistors
`are finding their way into a staggering variety of tube
`and nontube replacement equipment. To round out the
`list with a few more, there should be mentioned bin-
`aural hearing aids, portable radios, phonographs and
`dictating machines, auto radios and fuel-injection sys-
`tems, portable cameras, paging receivers and instru-
`ments, machine-tool controls, clocks and watches, toys,
`and even a guidance system for a chicken feeding cart.
`As of this date, there are approximately seventy
`domestic and foreign manufacturers of transistors and
`related diodes. Production figures abroad are not avail-
`able but it is known that essentially every major West-
`ern nation, as well as Japan, is very active. It is believed,
`however, that they are somewhat behind the United
`States in application and production. We have no
`authoritative technical information on Russia's status
`but Pravda assures us that Russia is well in the fore-
`front--as usual?
`
`NEW DESIGNS
`In the laboratory stage there are a number of new
`designs which will extend the range of electrical per-
`formance of the devices presently in manufacture. One,
`which is now entering production, is the four-region
`
`Raytheon2013-0003
`
`

`
`958
`
`PROCEEDINGS OF THE IRE
`
`June
`
`BILLION
`
`100
`MILLION
`
`U)
`
`z
`
`LL
`In
`10
`
`z 1
`
`0
`MILLION
`
`MlILLION
`
`100
`THOUSAND
`
`YEARS
`Fig. 2-The solid portions of the curves indicate the number of units
`sold in the United States by the year. The dotted portions of the
`curves represent estimates.
`
`be designed for operation at frequencies as high as, or
`possibly higher than, those possible with advanced de-
`signed vacuum tube and traveling wave structures with
`properties competitive in many ways.
`
`GROWTH OF AN INDUSTRY
`The growth of the transistor from its birth in 1948
`to its present maturity has been rapid indeed. With the
`critical need for electronic components in today's world
`and with the many advantages offered by transistors,
`it is not surprising that such a revolution has occurred.
`The management of nearly every major electronic
`laboratory has directed teams of their most competent
`research and development people toward the design of
`these semiconductor devices.
`Through the years, meetings and symposia have
`been held for scientists to exchange information on the
`most recent technology developments. By concerted
`effort, many of the basic problems associated with
`semiconductor devices have been solved; today, tran
`sistors are being used in many industrial and military
`systems, particularly where low power, small size,
`and high reliability pay off. In the United States the
`sale of transistors alone has risen from a level of essen
`tially nothing in 1952 to 29 million units in 1957s Fore-
`casters predict that these sales will go to over 250 million
`units by 1965. If one adds to this the sale of semiconduc-
`tor diodes, it is predicted that combined sales will reach
`600 million by 1965. (See Fig. 2.) In 1957, the dollar
`volume of transistors and semiconductor diode sales
`
`p-n-p-n silicon switching diode. The electrical character-
`istics of this device are similar to those of a cold-cathode
`gas tube. However, the silicon device requires a great
`deal less power and can operate at speeds one thousand
`times faster than the gas tube Thousands of these
`diodes will be used in the switching network of all-elec-
`tronic telephone systems. Other major applications
`will doubtless be found in military and commercial
`digital computers.
`It is interesting to note that this small device requires
`precise control of almost every bulk and surface proper-
`ty known to semiconductors. It is necessary to control
`accurately the density of impurities throughout the
`bulk material, the width of the various layers, and the
`density of the imperfections in the bulk material, which
`in turn controls the lifetime of minority carriers. It is
`necessary to control not only the density of these imper-
`fections, but also the type of imperfections (the energy
`level within the forbidden gap). On the surface one
`must control and add impurities in such a rnanner that
`the density and type of surface states are within reason-
`ably narrow limits. The surface must be carefully
`cleaned and oxidized so that the device will be electrical-
`ly stable over long periods of time. In addition, the
`atmosphere around the device must be controlled so
`that there are no ions present to alter the electrical
`properties of the diode. Recent technological develop-
`ments have made possible such precise control of each
`of these properties.
`With the ever-advancing speeds of electronic com-
`puters go requirements for faster and faster computing
`diodes. By a controlled reduction of carrier lifetime,
`minority carrier storage and recovery times have beeii
`reduced to less than 2 m,isec. These designs, which are
`ready for pilot manufacture, will extend the speed of
`computer diodes by a factor of 10
`New diffused transistor structures are being made in
`the laboratory by reducing the thickness of the base
`layer and by reducing electrode spacing and cross
`sectional area. In this way the frequency range of
`germanium and silicon transistors can be extended
`another factor of 10 over that of present designs. It is
`expected that diffused germanium transistors will soon
`be made which will oscillate at frequencies as high as
`10,000 mc per second.
`For some time it has been known that a variable
`reactance can serve as an amplifier, but it
`is only
`recently that this principle has been put to practical
`microwave use. The dependence of the capacitance of a
`p-n junction upon the voltage across it makes possible
`a rapidly variable capacitance, when an appropriate
`high-frequency voltage drive is used. Furthermore,
`theory predicts that this device should have extremely
`low noise. In actuality, an amplifier of exploratory design
`has a measured gain of 15 db at a frequency of approxi-
`mately 6000 mc per second and a measured noise
`figure of 4.5 db. In this case the driver was a 12-kmc
`reflex klystron. It now seems possible that amplifiers can
`
`Raytheon2013-0004
`
`

`
`1958
`
`Jenny: The Status of Transistor Research in Compound Semiconductors
`
`959
`
`was 69 million dollars and 103 million dollars, respec-
`tively. By 1965, it is expected that the dollar volume of
`semiconductor sales will exceed that of the older electron
`tube. A further indication of the growth can be seen by
`the fact that the Joint Electron Tube Engineering Coun-
`cil had issued 600 transistor and 1300 diode industry
`codes by the end of 1957.
`During its short ten years of life, the transistor,
`through its inherent low-power requirements, small size,
`and high reliability has permeated the entire electronics
`industry. It has already captured large sections,of the
`
`market. With materials, structures, and techniques
`presently in the laboratory and currently in manu-
`facture, the transistor will play an increasingly impor-
`tant part in modern electronic technology.
`By basic scientific contributions and imaginative in-
`ventions, scientists and engineers have laid the founda-
`tion on which is being built a truly great technological
`industry. It may well be that the extension to man's
`mind, that transistor electronics makes possible, will
`yet have a greater impact on society than the nuclear
`extension of man's muscle.
`
`The Status of Transistor Research in
`Compound Semiconductors*
`DIETRICH A. JENNYt, MEMBER, IRE
`
`Summary-New semiconductors capable of competing with ger-
`manium and silicon in transistor applications must be looked for
`among the compound semiconductors, and more specifically among
`the III-V and IV-IV compounds. Gallium arsenide and indium phos-
`phide are the most promising all-round materials for high-frequency
`as well as high-temperature performance. Indium antimonide and
`indium arsenide may be of interest for extremely high-frequency
`transistors operating at low temperatures, The aluminum com-
`pounds, gallium phosphide and silicon carbide, are potentially useful
`for very high operating temperatures at the cost of high-frequency
`performance. Some of the unusual properties of the compound semi-
`conductors have led to novel methods of junction preparation and
`new junction structures, such as the surface-diffusion and the wide-
`gap junction. Bipolar and unipolar surface-diffusion transistors have
`been demonstrated in indium phosphide, and the wide-gap emitter
`principle for high injection efficiency has been experimentally verified
`in gallium arsenide transistors. Electron lifetimes in these two com-
`pound semiconductors are estimated from the transistor results.
`
`INTRODUCTION
`Kl_HE ADVENT of the germanium transistor in
`1948, and the silicon transistor shortly thereafter,
`raised the inevitable question whether there are
`other semiconductors capable of exhibiting transistor
`action. Research in this direction was primarily stimu-
`lated by the hope of finding a semiconductor with su-
`perior properties for transistor applications. A glance at
`the periodic table and the electrical properties of the
`elements shows immediately that such a material would
`scarcely be found among the elemental semiconductors,
`except possibly diamond which has some obvious dis-
`advantages. Therefore, the search for a competitor to
`* Original manuscript received by the IRE, April 10, 1958. The
`work reported in this paper was supported in part by the U. S. Air
`Force, Wright Air Dev. Center, Dayton Ohio.
`t RCA Labs., Princeton, N. J.
`
`germanium and silicon in the transistor field was con-
`centrated on the compound semiconductors.
`Compound semicoaductors, in contrast to the elemen-
`tal semiconductors, are true chemical compounds of two
`or more elements with characteristic stoichiometric
`compositions. Representatives of this vast class of semi-
`conductors are found throughout the entire range of
`chemical compounds from the simple binaries to the
`most complex organic structures. The elemental semi-
`conductors, such as a-tin, tellurium, selenium, ger-
`manium, and silicon are, in effect, only special cases of
`the compounds. Although by far the major systematic
`research efforts, both theoretical and experimental,
`have heretofore been concentrated on germanium and
`silicon, the compounds have played an important role in
`semiconductor research from the beginning. In fact,
`the earliest evidence for a conduction mechanism differ-
`ent from that in metals was Faraday's observation of a
`negative temperature coefficient of the resistivity in the
`compound, silver sulfide, in 1833. Rectification at a con-
`tact between dissimilar materials was discovered by
`Braun with pyrites and galena, and almost simultane-
`ously by Schuster with "tarnished" copper, or copper
`oxide, in 1874. Silicon carbide and lead sulfide attained
`some importance as detectors in the early radio days,
`but they were soon displaced by the vacuum tube.
`Copper oxide has been one of the most important solid
`rectifier materials to this day, particularly in power ap-
`plications. The practical importance of these compounds
`stimulated some early fundamental research, but, due
`to the lack of a satisfactory model of semiconduction,
`little significant information was gained. In 1931, after
`quantum mechanics had come into its own, Wilson laid
`
`Raytheon2013-0005

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket