UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`__________________
`
`BEFORE THE PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`___________________
`
`ERICSSON INC. AND TELEFONAKTIEBOLAGET
`LM ERICSSON (“Ericsson”),
`Petitioner
`
`v.
`
`INTELLECTUAL VENTURES II LLC (“IV”),
`Patent Owner
`___________________
`
`Patent 7,787,431
`
`DECLARATION OF RANDALL C. SCHWARTZ
`
`ERIC-1008
`Ericsson v. IV
`Page 1 of 54
`
`

`
`I, Randall C. Schwartz, do hereby make the following Declaration pursuant
`
`to 28 U.S.C. § 1746:
`
`1.
`
`I am making this declaration at the request of Ericsson Inc. and
`
`Telefonaktiebolaget LM Ericsson (collectively “Ericsson”).
`
`2.
`
`I am the Founder and Principle Consultant of Wireless 20/20
`
`Consulting Group LLC, where I have been employed since 2005. I have worked
`
`as an electrical engineer since about 1983, and more specifically worked in the
`
`wireless field since 1992.
`
`I hold both an undergraduate and a graduate
`
`engineering degree from Dartmouth College.
`
`3.
`
`From 2003 to 2005, I served as Strategic Planning Manager at Intel
`
`Corp. In this capacity, and among other responsibilities, I led Intel’s 802.16
`
`standards effort. In connection with this work, I attended and participated in the
`
`IEEE 802.16 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access Standards, where I
`
`analyzed contributions of others in order to further the development of the IEEE
`
`802.16 standards.
`
`4.
`
`The IEEE 802.16 Working Group is a public forum for collaboration
`
`and development of ideas among interested parties to develop standards and
`
`recommended practices to support the development and deployment of broadband
`
`Wireless Metropolitan Area Networks.
`
`1
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 2 of 54
`
`

`
`5.
`
`The IEEE 802.16 Working Group organized meetings periodically in
`
`conjunction with other IEEE 802 groups. As a matter of general practice, the IEEE
`
`802.16 Working Group meetings that were organized were open to members and
`
`the general public. The IEEE 802.16 Working Group had a website, i.e.,
`
`www.WirelessMAN.org, which could be viewed by members of the working
`
`group, IEEE members, or any other interested member of the general public.
`
`Information, agendas, and announcements about upcoming IEEE 802.16 Working
`
`Group meetings were posted on this website. For each IEEE 802.16 Working
`
`Group meeting (also called a “Session”), an attendance list was maintained to keep
`
`track of attendees for membership and credit purposes.
`
`6.
`
`As a matter of general practice, documents and contributions were
`
`submitted before or during the IEEE 802.16 Working Group meetings. During the
`
`IEEE 802.16 Working Group meetings, each of the submitted documents and
`
`contributions was discussed, and when required, action was taken to determine the
`
`acceptance or viability of the contribution to the standard.
`
`7.
`
`Due to the high volume of documents and contributions submitted,
`
`physical “paper” copies were not handed out during IEEE 802.16 Working Group
`
`meetings. Rather, the documents and contributions were made electronically
`
`available for download to attendees of the IEEE 802.16 Working Group meetings
`
`by way of the IEEE 802.16 website. The documents and contributions were not
`
`2
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 3 of 54
`
`

`
`subject to any confidentiality and could be freely disseminated by attendees to
`
`other interested persons of skill that had not attended the meetings. Because the
`
`documents and contributions were provided electronically, they were easier to
`
`share with interested colleagues or other interested persons – in fact, the IEEE
`
`802.16 Working Group encouraged disseminating the submitted documents and
`
`contributions to further the development of the standard.
`
`8.
`
`Also, during and after the IEEE 802.16 Working Group meetings, the
`
`submitted documents were publically accessible on the IEEE 802.16 website.
`
`Active members of the work groups were encouraged to review the documents
`
`before and during the 802.16 Working Group meetings. Any interested members
`
`of the general public could also freely access and download submitted documents
`
`and contributions without restrictions on dissemination, in real time similar to the
`
`access afforded the actual attendees of the work sessions.
`
`9.
`
`As a matter of general practice, after each IEEE 802.16 Working
`
`Group meeting, a Session Report that included Session Minutes and session
`
`documents was created by the Chair and posted on the IEEE 802.16 website, to
`
`memorialize the specific meeting. These are also available on the 802.16 website
`
`for the general public to review. These were generally available within a week of
`
`the completion of each Working Group Session meeting.
`
`3
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 4 of 54
`
`

`
`10.
`
`I was employed by Intel Corp. on March 15-18 of 2004, when the
`
`IEEE 802.16 Working Group held the Session #30 meeting at the Hilton in the
`
`Walt Disney World Resort, in Lake Buena Vista (Orlando), Florida, USA. The
`
`Session #30 IEEE 802.16 Working Group meeting was held in conjunction with
`
`the IEEE 802 Plenary Session.
`
`11.
`
`For the March 2004 Session #30 meeting, announcements were posted
`
`on the IEEE website that included information about the date and location of the
`
`meeting. Attached as Appendix A is the IEEE WirelessMAN 802.16 website
`
`snapshot from the WaybackMachine that evidences that at least as of February 7,
`
`2004, the Session #30 meeting date and location information was announced
`
`publicly. I obtained Appendix A by first accessing the WaybackMachine page, at
`
`http://archive.org/web/ , next performing a search for www.wirelessman.org ,
`
`opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink for the year “2004,” next clicking on the
`
`hyperlink for February 7, then downloading and printing the resulting webpage.
`
`12. Also, attached as Appendix B is a copy of the Session #28 Report
`
`dated November 18, 2003, evidencing that the Session #30 IEEE 802.16 Working
`
`Group meeting was publicly announced in that report. Specifically, Session #28
`
`Report includes a section entitled “Future Mattings” which announces that the
`
`“IEEE 802.16's Session #30 will take place in Orlando, FL, USA on 15-18 March
`
`2004 in conjunction with the IEEE 802 Plenary Session.” I obtained Appendix B
`
`4
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 5 of 54
`
`

`
`by first accessing the IEEE 802.16 reports page, at
`
`http://www.ieee802.org/16/meetings/reports.html , next opening (or clicking on)
`
`the hyperlink labeled “Report” in the same row as “#28,” then downloading and
`
`printing the resulting webpage.
`
`13.
`
`I attended the March 2004 Session #30 IEEE 802.16 Working Group
`
`meeting on behalf of Intel Corp., as evidenced by Appendix C, which provides the
`
`list of meeting attendees. I obtained Appendix C by first accessing the IEEE
`
`802.16 reports page, at http://www.ieee802.org/16/meetings/reports.html , next
`
`opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink labeled “#30,” opening (or clicking on) the
`
`hyperlink labeled “attendance list,” and then downloading and printing the
`
`resulting webpage.
`
`14.
`
`IEEE 802.16 Working Group meeting attendees generally included
`
`IEEE 802.16 members as well as individuals of the general public who were
`
`interested in the subjects of the papers being discussed. Appendix C evidences that
`
`222 individuals signed up for the Session #30 IEEE 802.16 Working Group
`
`meeting, of which 180 were granted participation credit. Participation credit was
`
`granted to those attending six of the eight session intervals, provided that
`
`registration fees were paid.
`
`15. As already noted, as a matter of general practice, copies of meeting
`
`documents and contributions were made available electronically to attendees and
`
`5
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 6 of 54
`
`

`
`the general public on the IEEE website before and during the meeting, without a
`
`password or restrictions. The IEEE 802.16 Task Group d Document list, identified
`
`as Appendix D, includes an electronic index which indicates that, among other
`
`documents, document “IEEE C802.16d-04/19” entitled “A New Frame Structure
`
`for Scalable OFDMA Systems” by Inseok Hwang, Jaehee Cho, Sanghoon, Sung
`
`Hun Huh, Soon Young Yoon, Panyuh Joo, and Jaeweon Cho was submitted on
`
`March 11, 2004 (ERIC-1005) and document “IEEE C802.16d-04/36r2” entitled
`
`“Additional Preamble Definitions for 802.166 OFDM-256” by Adam Kerr and
`
`Paul Petrus submitted on March 17, 2004 (ERIC-1009). These documents were
`
`made publicly available before or during the Session #30 meeting. I obtained
`
`Appendix D by first accessing the IEEE 802.16 reports page, at
`
`http://www.ieee802.org/16/meetings/reports.html , next opening (or clicking on)
`
`the hyperlink labeled “#30,” opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink labeled
`
`“document list,” opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink labeled “Task Group d
`
`Documents,” and then downloading and printing the resulting webpage.
`
`16. As already noted, as a matter of general practice, the IEEE did not
`
`place any restrictions on dissemination of submitted documents. Consistent with
`
`this are the cover pages of the IEEE C802.16d-04/19 document (ERIC-1005) and
`
`the IEEE C802.16d-04/36r2 document (ERIC-1009) both of which include a
`
`“Release” clause granting an irrevocable license to the IEEE to disseminate the
`
`6
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 7 of 54
`
`

`
`material contained in the contribution and to make the contribution public. I
`
`obtained IEEE C802.16d-04/19 (ERIC-1005) by first accessing the IEEE 802.16
`
`reports page, at http://www.ieee802.org/16/meetings/reports.html , next opening
`
`(or clicking on) the hyperlink labeled “#30,” opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink
`
`labeled “document list,” opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink labeled “Task
`
`Group d Documents,” opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink labeled “IEEE
`
`C802.16d-04/19,” and then downloading and printing the resulting document. I
`
`obtained IEEE C802.16d-04/36r2 (ERIC-1009) by first accessing the IEEE 802.16
`
`reports page, at http://www.ieee802.org/16/meetings/reports.html , next opening
`
`(or clicking on) the hyperlink labeled “#30,” opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink
`
`labeled “document list,” opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink labeled “Task
`
`Group d Documents,” opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink labeled “IEEE
`
`C802.16d-04/36r2,” and then downloading and printing the resulting document.
`
`17. Attached as Appendix E is a copy of the March 19, 2004, Task Group
`
`d (TGd) session minutes, which were created by the TGd Chair. The Session #30
`
`TGd Minutes at pages 2-3 indicate that both document IEEE C802.16d-04/19
`
`(ERIC-1005) and document IEEE C802.16d-04/36r2 (ERIC-1009), were discussed
`
`during the Session #30 IEEE 802.16 Working Group meeting. I obtained
`
`Appendix E by first by first accessing the IEEE 802.16 reports page, at
`
`http://www.ieee802.org/16/meetings/reports.html , next opening (or clicking on)
`
`7
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 8 of 54
`
`

`
`the hyperlink labeled “#30,” opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink labeled
`
`“document list,” opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink labeled “Task Group d
`
`Documents,” next opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink labeled “IEEE 802.16d-
`
`04/03” of the “Task Group d: Session #30 Minutes” and then downloading and
`
`printing the resulting webpage.
`
`18.
`
`The Session #30 TGd Minutes (Appendix E) at page 3 also indicate
`
`that the IEEE C802.16d-04/19 document (ERIC-1005) was withdrawn. Frequently,
`
`documents are submitted for review and discussion at the meeting and thereafter,
`
`during the meeting, withdrawn from consideration for inclusion in the standard. It
`
`was general practice to stamp the word “WITHDRAWN” on the front cover of a
`
`withdrawn document, but to not modify its contents before reposting the
`
`withdrawn document on the IEEE website. In contrast, regarding documents that
`
`were modified, it was general practice to include for each revision a number and a
`
`date. To illustrate by way of example, referring back to Appendix D, the IEEE
`
`C802.16d-04/36r2 document (ERIC-1009) underwent two revisions and the
`
`posting indicates the following: “IEEE C802.16d-04/36r2 (Rev. 1: 04/03/17; Rev. :
`
`04/03/13)).”
`
`19. As noted above, it was general practice to for the Chair to create a
`
`Session Report and post it on the IEEE 802.16 website, to memorialize the specific
`
`meeting. In connection with the Session #30 IEEE 802.16 Working Group
`
`8
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 9 of 54
`
`

`
`meeting, on March 30, 2004, the Chair created and posted a Session #30 Report,
`
`attached to this declaration as Appendix F. The Session #30 Report provides a
`
`hyperlink to the “Session #30 document list” that “includes references to over 170
`
`session documents,” including the IEEE C802.16d-04/19 document (ERIC-1005)
`
`and the IEEE C802.16d-04/36r2 document (ERIC-1009). I obtained Appendix F
`
`by first accessing the IEEE 802.16 reports page, at
`
`http://www.ieee802.org/16/meetings/reports.html , next opening (or clicking on)
`
`the hyperlink labeled “Report” in the same row as “#30,” then downloading and
`
`printing the resulting webpage.
`
`20. Also, attached as Appendix G is the IEEE WirelessMAN 802.16
`
`website snapshot from the WaybackMachine, which evidences that at least as of
`
`April 2, 2004, the Session #30 Report was available on the IEEE website for
`
`download by the general public. I obtained Appendix G by first accessing the
`
`WaybackMachine page, at http://archive.org/web/ , next performing a search for
`
`www.wirelessman.org, opening (or clicking on) the hyperlink for the year “2004,”
`
`next clicking on the hyperlink for April 2, then downloading and printing the
`
`resulting webpage.
`
`9
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 10 of 54
`
`

`
`
`
`I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct.
`
`
`
`
`
`Executed on July 31, 2015
`
`
`
`
`
`Randall Schwartz
`
`10
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 11 of 54
`
`

`
`
`
`
`
`APPENDIX A
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 12 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 13 of 54
`
`

`
`
`
`
`
`APPENDIX B
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 14 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 15 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 16 of 54
`
`

`
`
`
`
`
`APPENDIX C
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 17 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 18 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 19 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 20 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 21 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 22 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 23 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 24 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 25 of 54
`
`

`
`
`
`
`
`APPENDIX D
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 26 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 27 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 28 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 29 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 30 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 31 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 32 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 33 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 34 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 35 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 36 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 37 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 38 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 39 of 54
`
`

`
`
`
`
`
`APPENDIX E
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 40 of 54
`
`

`
`IEEE
`802.16 Session #30
`15 – 18 March, 2004
`Orlando, FL
`
`
`Page 1 of 7
`
`
`Task Group d (TGd) Chair
`TGd minutes
`19 Mar 2004
`
`Approval
`Discussion
`
`X
`
`
`
`Information
`
`X
`
`
`
`
`Source:
`Title:
`Date:
`Document for:
`
`
`
`Agenda item:
`
`Minutes
`
`Registered Contributions _________________________________________________________________________ 1
`Session #30 Schedule____________________________________________________________________________ 3
`Monday March 15, 2004 _________________________________________________________________________ 4
`Review of Comments; 80216-03_11______________________________________________________________ 4
`Tuesday March 16, 2004 _________________________________________________________________________ 4
`Review of Comments; 80216-03_11______________________________________________________________ 4
`Wednesday March 17, 2004_______________________________________________________________________ 5
`Review of Comments; 80216-03_11______________________________________________________________ 5
`Thursday March 18, 2004 ________________________________________________________________________ 6
`Deferred comments___________________________________________________________________________ 6
`
`Registered Contributions
`The following is a list of registered contributions to TGd as of the publication of these minutes.
`•
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/56 - Accepted Resolution of comments 42, 68, 146, and 436 (Bob Nelson, 04/03/18)
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/55 - Resolution of Comments 167-170 (Bob Nelson, 04/03/18)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/54r1 (Rev. 0: 04/03/18) - Clarification of procedure of creation of service flows (Vladimir
`Yanover, 04/03/18)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/53 - Updates to Block Turbo Coding for OFDMA (Brian Banister, 04/03/17)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/52 - Analysis of end-of-burst degradation in the OFDM UL PHY under mobile conditions
`(Ran Yaniv and Tal Kaitz, 04/03/15)
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 41 of 54
`
`

`
`Page 2
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/51r1 AAS enhancements for 1x Scalable PHY - (John Liebetreu, Dale Branlund, Lalit
`Kotecha, Mike Webb, 04/03/15)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/50r3 (Rev. 2: 04/03/18; Rev. 1: 04/03/15; Rev. 0: 04/03/13) - OFDMA PHY
`Enhancements for better mobility performance (John Liebetreu, et al., 04/03/18)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/47r1 (Rev. 0: 04/03/13) - OFDMA PHY Enhancements for Ranging (John Liebetreu, et al.,
`04/03/15)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/45r1 (Rev. 0: 04/03/13) - OFDMA PHY AAS Enhancements (Panyuh Joo, et al., 04/03/15)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/44r1 (Rev. 0: 04/03/13) - OFDMA PHY Enhancements using Hybrid ARQ (John
`Liebetreu, et al., 04/03/15)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/43 - SS De-Registration (Phillip Barber and Ken Stanwood, 04/03/13)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/42r1 (Rev. 0: 04/03/13) - REVd Sponsor Ballot Comment Addendum (Robert Nelson,
`04/03/18)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/41r2 (Rev. 1: 04/03/17; Rev. : 04/03/13) - WirelessMAN-SCa Support for AAS (Brian
`Eidson and Robert Nelson, 04/03/18)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/40 - Supplement for comments from Yigal Leiba (Yigal Leiba, 04/03/13)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/39 - Support of Negotiated Capabilities and QoS Parameters (Vladimir Yanover, Tal Kaitz,
`Eyal Verbin, 04/03/13)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/38r3 (Rev. 2: 04/03/18; Rev. 1: 04/03/13; Rev. 0: 04/03/13; slides: 04/03/18) - AAS
`enhancements for OFDMA PHY (Dale Branlund, Adam Kerr, Lalit Kotecha, John Liebetreu, Paul Petrus,
`Mike Webb, 04/03/18)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/37r2 (Rev. 1: 04/03/16; Rev. : 04/03/13; slides: 04/03/17) - Unique Randomizer
`Initialization for Interference Management in 802.16 OFDM PHY (Adam Kerr, Paul Petrus, 04/03/18)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/36r2 (Rev. 1: 04/03/17; Rev. : 04/03/13) - Additional Preamble Definitions for 802.16d
`OFDM-256 (Adam Kerr, Paul Petrus, 04/03/17)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/35r1 (Rev. 0: 04/03/12; slides: 04/03/17) - Channel Estimation and feedback report for
`OFDM AAS (Tal Kaitz, Naftali Chayat, Vladimir Yanover, Radu Selea, Bogdan Franovici, Adam Kerr, Paul
`Petrus, Hassan Yaghoobi, Atul Salvekar, Raja Banerjea, 04/03/17)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/34r1 (Rev. 0: 04/03/12) - Improved Stack Diagram (David Johnston, 04/03/13)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/33r1 (Rev. 0: 04/03/12) - Proposal for a new PDU concatenation scheme to facilitate MAC
`PDU separation under error conditions (Sunny Chang, Bonggee Song, Taein Hyon, Yunsang Park, 04/03/15)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/32r1 (Rev. 0: 04/03/12) - Terminal Assisted QoS support (Yunsang Park, Panyuh Joo,
`Changhoi Koo, 04/03/15)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/31r1 (Rev. 0: 04/03/12) - BPSK Modulation for IEEE 802.16 WirelessMAN OFDM (Atul
`Salvekar, Hassan Yaghoobi, Vladimir Yanover, 04/03/14)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/30 (slides: 04/03/18) - Spectrum sharing in License Exempt bands - protocol proposal
`(Marianna Goldhammer, 04/03/12)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/29r1 (Rev. 0: 04/03/12; slides: 04/03/16) - Maps Format in AAS (Vladimir Yanover,
`Naftali Chayat, Tal Kaitz, Paul Petrus, Adam Kerr, John Liebetreu, Hassan Yaghoobi, Atul Salvekar, Raja
`Banarjea, Bogdan Franovici, Martin Lysejko, and David Castelow, 04/03/16)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/28 - Changes to UL-MAP ordering in OFDM-256 PHY (David A Castelow, 04/03/12)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/27 - Change in definition of Service Classes (Vladimir Yanover, 04/03/11)
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 42 of 54
`
`

`
`Page 3
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/26r3 (Rev. 2: 04/03/17; Rev. 1: 04/03/16; Rev. 0: 04/03/11; slides: 04/03/17) - Changes to
`Focused Contention in OFDM-256 Mode (David A. Castelow, Naftali Chayat, Tal Kaitz, Adam Kerr,
`04/03/18)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/25 (withdrawn) - The uplink subchannelization preamble with lower PAPR (Panyuh Joo,
`Cho Sijun, Hai Wang, FengMing Cao, 04/03/11)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/24 (withdrawn) - Uplink control channels (JeonTae Oh, Seungjoo Maeng, Soonyoung
`Yoon, Jaeho Jeon, Youngbin Chang, Chiwoo Lim, 04/03/11)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/23 (withdrawn) - New FEC structure suitable for CTC and mobile Cellular Operation of
`802.16 OFDMA (Jaehee Cho, Soonyoung Yoon, Panyuh Joo, Jaeweon Cho, 04/03/11)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/22 (withdrawn) - Support for 4-Antenna Space-Time Processing (Wonil Roh, SeungJoo
`Maeng, Jaeho Jeon, Panyuh Joo, 04/03/11)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/21 (withdrawn) - OFDMA ranging (Jaehawk Lee, Jaeweon Cho, Sijun Cho, 04/03/11)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/20 (withdrawn) - OFDMA subcarrier allocations (Jeong-Heon Kim, Youngbin Chang,
`Chiwoo Lim, 04/03/11)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/19 (withdrawn) - A New Frame Structure for Scalable OFDMA Systems (Inseok Hwang,
`Jaehee Cho, Sanghoon, Sung Hun Huh, Soon Young Yoon, Panyuh Joo, Jaeweon Cho, 04/03/11)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/18 (withdrawn) - System Parameters for IEEE 802.16d (Jaeho Jeon, Soonyoung Yoon,
`Seungjoo Maeng, Jiho Jang, Sijun, Cho, Youngbin Chang, 04/03/11)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/17r2 (Rev. 1: 04/03/17; Rev. : 04/03/12) - Clarification of optional features (Vladimir
`Yanover, 04/03/18)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/16r3 (Rev. 2: 04/03/16; Rev. 1: 04/03/16; Rev. 0: 04/03/12) - Extended IE format for
`concurrent transmission of bursts (Christian Hoymann and Paul Piggin, 04/03/17)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/15 - Transmission Convergence Sublayer to the OFDM PHY (Lei Wang, 04/03/12)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/14 - Updated OFDM Frame Structure Diagrams (Lei Wang, 04/03/12)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/13r1 (Rev. 0: 04/02/27) - Updates to Block Turbo Coding for OFDM (Brian Banister,
`04/03/16)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-04/12 - Proposal on DL preamble change for 802.16 OFDM (Bogdan Franovici, Lingjie Li,
`04/02/08)
`
`IEEE C802.16d-03/76r3 - MAC and PHY MIB for WirelessMAN and WirelessHUMAN BS and SS (Joey
`Chou, Russ Reynolds, Alex Raji, Vladimir Yanover, Shlomi Eini, Radu Selea, 04/03/12)
`
`Session #30 Schedule
`All meetings are held in the Enchantment E & F.
`Subject (number of
`Monday
`sessions)
`TGd sessions (9)
`
`
`
`15:45-19:00
`
`
`
`Tuesday
`
`Wednesday
`
`Thursday
`
`8:00-12:00
`
`13:15-18:00
`
`19:00-22:00
`
`8:00-12:00
`
`13:30-18:00
`
`20:00-23:00
`
`10:15-12:00
`
`13:15-21:00
`
`
`
`802.16 WG Plenary (2)
`
`13:00-15:25
`
`
`
`
`
`21:00-02:00
`
`
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 43 of 54
`
`

`
`Page 4
`
`Monday March 15, 2004
`Session convened at 16:00 hr.
`
`Commentary database 80216-04_11 formed the basis for coment resolution for the Sponsor Ballot.
`
`Comments marked as editorial will be reviewed by the TGd Chair and Editor, Editorial comments classified as Editorial
`and “non-Editorial”. A list of the Editorial comments will be posted, the TG will be instructed to review these
`comments and be prepared to resolve them in a single motion during the last TGd session on Thursday March 18.
`
`Any/all OFDMA 1x comments will be discussed during a joint TGd TGe session Thursday morning.
`
`The issue of any/all 2GHz lower bound comments will be discussed with Working Group chair for an opinion if this
`notion can be accepted. Any/all such comments will be addressed by a single resolution.
`
`Review of Comments; 80216-03_11
`•
`4
`Deferred for discussion with WG Chair: 2GHz lower bound.
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`6
`
`Deferred to Thursday am joint TGd / TGe session.
`
`32 No concensus, In favour – 15, opposed – 12, fails; comment rejected.
`
`34 No concensus, In favour – 26, opposed – 0; passes, comment accepted.
`
`63 Deferred to allow Eyal to develop text.
`
`Monday session recessed at 22:00 hr.
`
`Tuesday March 16, 2004
`Tuesday session convened at 8:00 hr.
`
`Review of Comments; 80216-03_11
`•
`4
`Resolved.
`
`Decision: the “non-Editorial” editorial comments will be address first.
`•
`
`61 Deferred for review and resolution by Wednesday am; Vladimir, Eyal, others.
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`68 Deferred; Bob Nelson to determine the most suitable location for the noted section.
`
`106 Deferred; Eyal to provide text by Wednesday am.
`
`272 Deferred; David Castelow to provide specific text.
`
`349 Deferred; so members attending TGe can comment.
`
`436 Deferred; Bob Nelson to provide specific text.
`
`“Non-Editorial” comments resolved. Continue with remainder of comments.
`•
`
`10 Deferred; to joint session.
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`36 Deferred; DL not present.
`
`37 Deferred; Jon Labs to provide specific text.
`
`42 Deferred; Vladimir, Lei Wang, Don Leimer, & Bob Nelson to provide specific text.
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 44 of 54
`
`

`
`48 No concensus; Contribution C80216d-04_39 split into two. Part 1: In favour – 27, opposed – 0, part 1
`accepted. Part 2: In favour – 10, opposed – 9, fails, part 2 rejected.
`
`61 Deferred; DL to provide RFC number for IPv6 reference.
`
`Page 5
`
`79 Deferred; related to comment 278.
`
`86 Deferred; presenter in TGe.
`
`99 Deferred; related to comment 251.
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`Tuesday session recessed at 22:00 hr.
`
`Wednesday March 17, 2004
`Session convened at 8:00 hr.
`
`Review of Comments; 80216-03_11
`•
`137 Deferred; after lunch break.
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`86 Resolved; No concensus; In favour – 7, opposed – 19, fails, comment rejected.
`
`150 Deferred; Bob Nelson and Vladimir to discuss.
`
`165 Deferred; Jon Labs to provide specific text.
`
`167 Deferred; Don Leimer, Raja Banerjea, and Lei Wang can discuss and resolve.
`
`194 No concensus; In favour – 11, opposed – 9, fails, comment rejected.
`
`200 Deferred; Vladimir, Raja, et al to discuss and provide specific text.
`
`235 Deferred; Bob Nelson to redo C802.16d-04_41r1 to reflect results of discussion.
`
`251 Resolved; No concensus; In favour – 41, opposed – 1, passes. (related to 99)
`
`99 Resolved.
`
`252 No concensus; Straw poll; In favour – 25, opposed – 16. Deferred; Naftali to propose specific text.
`
`253 No concensus; agreement to split comment resolution. To split; In favour – 38, opposed – 1, contribution
`C802.16d-04_31 split. Part 1, In favour – 41, opposed – 0, part 1 passes. Part 2, In favour – 32, opposed – 12,
`part 2 fails.
`
`273 No concensus; agreement is to split comment resolution. Part 1, In favour – 25, opposed – 0, passes. Part
`2, In favour – 5, opposed – 18, fails.
`
`303 No concensus; In favour – 8, opposed – 18; fails, comment rejected.
`
`314 No concensus; In favour – 16, opposed – 13, fails, comment rejected.
`
`327 No concenssu, straw poll, in favour – 28, opposed – 6.
`
`332 Deferred to Thursday.
`
`341 Deferred to Thursday.
`
`342 Deferred to Thursday.
`
`358 Deferred; Yossi needs to be here.
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 45 of 54
`
`

`
`Page 6
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`367 Deferred to Thursday joint session.
`
`372 No concensus, In favour – 8, opposed 8, fails; comment rejected.
`
`422 No concensus, In favour – 18, opposed 15, fails, comment rejected.
`
`Session recessed at 23:20 hr
`
`Thursday March 18, 2004
`Thursday joint TGd/TGe session convened at 8:00 hr.
`•
`
`329 Contributor withdrew this and other related comments from TGd and requested TGe chair to re-open a
`TGe comment. 339. in order to accept the contents of these comments. TGe chair agreed to do this.
`Contribution related to this comment is “C802_16REVd-04_47r1”.
`
`Contributions that are “Technical Binding”
`•
`
`457 Deferred.
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`458 No concensus. In favour – 4, opposed 18, comment rejected.
`
`459 No concensus. In favour – 10, opposed - 11, comment rejected.
`
`460 No concensus. In favour – 14, opposed – 13, comment rejected.
`
`Editorial comments address in single vote immediately after the lunch break.
`
`Motion to accept all Editorial comments as identified by the TGd Chair and Editor, and included in uploaded file
`“Editorial comments.txt”. Bob Nelso/ 2nd Lei Wang. Editorial comments; approved by unanimous voice vote. Editor
`instructed to accept all editorial comments identified in the editorial comment list provided in the TGd temporary
`upload directory.
`•
`
`263 Deferred to allow review of 5 (?)
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`268 Deferred to allow revision of C80216d-04/37r1.
`
`271 No concensus; In favour – 17, opposed – 2, comment accepted.
`
`276 No concensus; In favour – 20, opposed – 8, comment rejected.
`
`278 No concensus; In favour – 9, opposed –7, comment rejected.
`
`317 No concensus; In favour – 7, opposed –8, comment rejected.
`
`208 Resoved.
`
`318, 319, 320 Deferred; waiting for specific text.
`
`322 No concensus; In favour – 12, opposed – 17, comment rejected.
`
`380 Deferred. Ken and David to provide specific text.
`
`440 No concensus; In favour –17, opposed – 8, comment rejected.
`
`Deferred comments
`•
`010 Rejected. Related to comments 341, 342, and 346, which are also rejected.
`
`•
`
`•
`
`150 No concensus, In favour – 32, opposed – 8, passes.
`
`257 No concensus, In favour – 52, opposed – 3, passes.
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 46 of 54
`
`

`
`Page 7
`
`All deferred comments resolved.
`
`Minutes of session #29 were reviewed and approved.
`
`
`
`This concluded the comment resolution part of the current Task Group d session.
`
`Motion – to put forward the following motion to the working Group “To accept IEEE 802.16-04/11r1 as the resolutions
`in the Sponsor Ballot of P802.16-REVd/D3, develop Draft P802.16-REVd/D4 based on those resolutions, and initiate
`Recirculation” David T./ 2nd Zion H. Approved by unanimous voice vote.
`
`Motion – to put forward the following motion to the working group “To request conditional approval from the LMSC
`EC to forward P802.16-REVd to RevCom”. Shawn T. / 2nd David J. Motion passes by unanimous voice vote.
`Bob N. / 2nd Jon L. – “To adjourn the Task Group d meeting for this session”.
` Motion passes by unanimous voice vote.
`
`Session recessed at 21:15 hr.
`
`Database was revised during the closing plenary. IEEE 802.16-04/11r2 is made available but can’t be uploaded to
`‘mercury’ due to equipment problems. This verion will be uploaded next week on the main IEEE server, TGd directory.
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 47 of 54
`
`

`
`
`
`
`
`APPENDIX F
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 48 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 49 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 50 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 51 of 54
`
`

`
`
`
`
`
`APPENDIX G
`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 52 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 53 of 54
`
`

`
`ERIC-1008
`Page 54 of 54