Petitioners‘ Demonstratives
`
`Apple lnc., et aI.,
`Petitioners
`
`V.
`
`Global Touch Solutions, LLC,
`Patent Owner
`
`lPR2015-01171
`
`(u 5
`
`. Patent No
`
`. 7,994,726 B2)*
`
`|PR2015—01172
`
`(us.
`
`Patent No
`
`. 7,498,749 B2)**
`
`lPR2015-01603
`
`(U S
`
`. Patent No
`
`. 7,498,749 B2)***
`
`lPR2015-01173 (U.S.
`
`Patent No
`
`. 7,329,970 B2)**
`
`lPR2015-01174 (U.S.
`
`Patent No
`
`. 7,781,980 B2)*
`
`|PR2015-01175 (U.S.
`
`Patent No
`
`. 8,288,952 B2)*
`
`August 3, 2016
`
`* Petitioners Apple lnc.; Motorola Mobility, LLC
`
`** Petitioners Apple lnc.; Motorola Mobility, LLC; Toshiba America Information Systems, Inc.
`
`*** Petitioners Apple lnc.; Toshiba America information Systems, Inc.
`
`Page 1 of 117
`
`TAIS and Apple Exhibit 1045
`
`TAIS and Apple v. Global Touch
`IPR2015-01603
`
`
`
`Apple lnc., et aI.,
`Petitioners
`
`V.
`
`Global Touch Solutions, LLC,
`Patent Owner
`
`lPR2015-01171
`
`(u 5
`
`. Patent No
`
`. 7,994,726 B2)*
`
`|PR2015—01172
`
`(us.
`
`Patent No
`
`. 7,498,749 B2)**
`
`lPR2015-01603
`
`(U S
`
`. Patent No
`
`. 7,498,749 B2)***
`
`lPR2015-01173 (U.S.
`
`Patent No
`
`. 7,329,970 B2)**
`
`lPR2015-01174 (U.S.
`
`Patent No
`
`. 7,781,980 B2)*
`
`|PR2015-01175 (U.S.
`
`Patent No
`
`. 8,288,952 B2)*
`
`August 3, 2016
`
`* Petitioners Apple lnc.; Motorola Mobility, LLC
`
`** Petitioners Apple lnc.; Motorola Mobility, LLC; Toshiba America Information Systems, Inc.
`
`*** Petitioners Apple lnc.; Toshiba America information Systems, Inc.
`
`Page 1 of 117
`
`TAIS and Apple Exhibit 1045
`
`TAIS and Apple v. Global Touch
`IPR2015-01603
`
`
`
`Petitioners‘ Demonstratives
`
`Overview
`
`ll. Brief Overview of the Prior Art References
`
`III‘. Undisputed Issues
`
`W. Purported Deficiencies Raised By Patent Owner
`
`Page 2 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`I. Brief Overview of the Patents
`
`The Patents Are Directed To Portable Electronic
`
`Devices With Touch Sensors And Exhaustible Power Sources
`
`(10) Patent No.:
`(45) Date of Patent:
`
`US 7,994,726 B2
`*Aug. 9, 2011
`A n~.é.4—.4~_.‘,—\_ .
`p v--—-
`____ “‘
`saw » jj *
`
`’
`
`’
`
`(54)
`
`INTELLIGENT USER INTERFACE
`INCLUDINGA TOUCH SENSOR DEVICE
`.,_;—_¢-.-._/\_y.¢ I‘- _
`
`I (22) Filed:
`
`‘
`
`E
`—_.
`_
`_r— I —;—§,_- .0 0
`
`Aug. 12, 2010
`
`F
`
`Ex. I001 ('726 Patent)
`
`.»—..,-_’___ I‘ ., p...-
`
`'|I'||.,l.!.!.!.!|||||
`
`:f"S"‘°{"'f°'f'
`W) mluxuuvuulmlnaa
`lV:IlCIl:A‘lwtIl1.\lfiBVKK
`17.‘i
`IIIICV NMJAMVMIM,
`my Anon 4‘“MI‘—1M[‘,1‘N
`
`mm
`on nu-«sun.-n_s.¢.n
`lI\l\s.Y'l\JC|k:4Il‘1.Vl\4R.
`um» new In mu-
`&!%n$H§I‘Ijfi§Cy.
`""-""‘
`
`'-“'
`
`~-—
`ngpu.su-.Apu:-.u-..u..-
`M, W‘, nmu.‘
`
`:‘ _,,:":;;"§**'* ,3
`'
`* "P
`uunmr\nmuIInum\
`1 ana
`m«-
`
`ll
`
`ms;
`
`nsrnnunnmu
`.,,‘,,,,n\,,,,,..,
`h_, .13“,
`
`""N‘ N-W’ *"“""
`“°-"
`m_nnIu-..-n.v_m—.|lhrunpr no-
`-3-:
`
`u-u........,,._.
`LI: IILZQILIA I
`Iain-ulpyyhsnin '
`
`~
`
`7.
`
`\
`
`»»-«—- -:1?’
`
`~l"'|"‘|
`"Vi
`-mun um.
`g T|l§—1-Ifl-nxfiuunpthude
`Iflunhlvflulfikfiluccésnnulahtfifln
`mummy.
`,-—.n..-.mu-yuan‘-
`-
`V-C-I-I‘-'
`aha.-at-y.-an-.El~a.up-sun than
`.
`us.-u.a..un....un.u.-.pm.c.
`_
`_I-~I~__-_-_"-‘-r“_;‘
`_
`-N:
`.
`mums
`-magnum-an-nun.
`_ H an-u.u...mum.4-u.-—.us-=-1.-e
`mn(.uI¢,.-g.o- I-3-a.-lu.u-u_-mu
`mm-naIm.v-M am.--a...-.._.s~.o..
`A-m----cu r-on-«unto...-———
`nnv-xun--q-—mn.mw-un:uun-
`-
`litfivlwnst
`Ju1.—.6nu-A-gt-an
`
`IISIICA usm us’:-4|
`
`‘1
`
`l
`
`III]
`//
`
`Ialnlocmn
`
`Vina‘
`E1511
`~nhrr..unI v.(Ifid‘lnnas¢A:-U:
`nnaoismvh
`smuwornpaou
`
`See, e.g., lPR20lS—O1171 Pet. at 4
`
`Page 3 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`I. Brief Overview of the Patents
`
`The Patents Are Directed To Portable Electronic
`
`Devices With Touch Sensors And Exhaustible Power Sources
`
`’726 Patent
`
`(57)
`
`ABSTRACT
`
`The present invention, according to a preferred embodiment,
`is directed to portable electronic devices which operate on
`exhaustible power sources, for example, batteries.
`
`[PR2015-01171 Ex. 1001 (’726 Patent). Abstract
`
`IPRZOIS-01171 Ex. 1001 (’726 Patent). Fig. 1
`
`1PR2015-01171 Ex. 1001 (’726 Patent). Fig. 12
`
`See, e.g,, lPR20lS—Ol171 Pet. at 5-6, 29
`
`Page 4 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`I. Brief Overview of the Patents
`
`The Patents Are Directed To Portable Electronic
`
`Devices With Touch Sensors And Exhaustible Power Sources
`
`|PR201S-01171 Ex. 1001
`
`.n...._,
`
`.
`
`|PR2015-01172,
`|PR2015-01603 Ex. 1001
`j
`‘:."""“‘
`cup.
`
`(10) Patent No.:
`(45) Dlte orrmm:
`._ _
`'
`
`US 7,994,726 B2
`‘Aug. 9. 2011
`
`‘_,_._._ ‘_,
`’
`
`lPR2015-01173 Ex. 1001
`T
`"
`
`(10) Patent No.:
`(as) Date of Patent:
`
`US 7,498,749 B2
`‘Mar. 3, 2009
`
`719 '
`
`A
`
`(10) Patent No.:
`(45) Date of Patent:
`
`Feb. 12. 2008
`
`|PR2015-01174 Ex. 1001
`-5'
`K1-,1».-an
`Ian-.9
`- —-
`
`(10) Patent No.:
`(45) Date of Patent:
`
`US 7,781,980 B2
`‘Aug, 24, 20l0
`
`lPR2015-01175 Ex. 1001
`T
`—-=.‘._.__,
`
`(10) Patent No.:
`as) Date of Patent:
`
`US 8,288,952 B2
`‘Oct. 16, 2012
`
`See, e.g., lPR201S—O1171 Pet. at 1; lPR201S—O1172 Pet. at 1; lPR2015-01173 Pet. at 1; IPRZOIS-01174 Pet. at 1; lPR201S—01175 Pet. at 1; |PR2015—016;O3 Pet. at 1
`
`Page 5 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`I. Brief Overview of the Patents
`
`The Patents Are Directed To Portable Electronic
`
`Devices With Touch Sensors And Exhaustible Power Sources
`
`Us 6,249,089
`V
`
`us 6,621,225
`
`V
`
`US 6,650,066
`
`V
`
`U5 5,952,034
`
`V
`
`US 7,336,037
`
`Continuation-in-part
`
`us 6,984,900
`
`US 7,084,531
`
`(Io) Patent No.:
`(45) Date of Patent:
`
`US 7,329,970 B2
`Feb. 12, 2008
`..____
`
`V
`
`V
`
`Us 7,443,101
`
`V
`
`US 7,498,749 B2
`(10) Patent No.:
`‘Mar. 3. 2009
`(45) Date of Patent:
`————_~~»-.-~.. 1,~
`
`(10) Patent No;
`(45) Date of Patent:
`
`US 7,781,980 B2
`‘Aug. 24, 2010
`
`_____._._,V,_. \_ ~,_,_
`
`US 7,994,726 B2
`(10) Pnlenl No.:
`‘Aug. 9, 2011
`(45) Date of Patent:
`»« -—-~~
`—
`——-fr '~
`(I0) Pntent No.:
`US 8,288,952 B2
`(45) Date of Patent:
`“Oct. 16. 20l2
`
`o
`
`I Continuation
`
`Continuation-in-part
`
`See, e.g., lPR20lS—O1171 Pet. at 1;lPR201S—O1172 Pet. at 1; 19122015-01173 Pet. at 1; lPR201S—O1174 Pet. at 1; lPR2015{)117S Pet. at 1; lPR201S—O1603 Pet. at 1
`
`Page 6 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners’ Demonstratives
`
`I. Brief Overview of the Patents
`
`The Patents Are Directed To Portable Electronic
`
`Devices With Touch Sensors And Exhaustible Power Sources
`
`’726 Patent Claim 1
`
`1. A method for controlling a product comprising a power
`source, or a connection for a power source, and an energy
`consuming load, said method including the step of providing
`an electronic module comprising an electronic circuit includ-
`ing a microchip and a touch sensor forming part of a user
`interface, said microchip adapted to control the activation of
`a visible indication in response to an activation signal
`received from the user interface while operation of the load is
`
`IPR2015-01171 Ex. 1001 (’726 Patent). Claim 1
`% 4-.4.._...\
`_mo-j-—7*‘—*"/‘—v-"—f? 4~_+
`__
`_d_,.«\_.-—..;o
`
`See, e.g., |PR201S—O1171 Pet. at 28-36
`
`Page 7 of 117
`
`
`
`Brief Overview of the Patents
`
`Ill‘. Undisputed Issues
`
`«IV; Purported Deficiencies Raised By Patent Owner
`
`Page 8 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`ll. Brief Overview of the Prior Art References
`
`.
`
`%
`
`The Prior Art References
`
`BATTERY PACK WITH CAPACITY AND
`l’RE-REMOVAI. INDICATORS
`
`[751
`
`Inventors:F Milpitas. cum; Robert J.
`ra
`n, Cedar Rlpick, Iowa
`
`Assignee:
`
`owa
`
`Cedar Rapids,
`
`romuu: wonx STATION-TYPE DATA
`coujcnon svsnnu
`
`[75]
`
`Inventors: Arvin D. D-nielso-L Solon: Dar-Id R-
`Schultz. Cedar Rapids. hour of Iowa:
`Denis Sllva. San Jose. Cami; Darrell
`L. Bootwrlght. Cedar Rapids. Iowa:
`Rldlcy G. Austin. Lisbon. Iowa;
`Daniel E. All. Cedar Rapids. Iowa:
`Steve Darren I-‘rlcnll. Fenom:
`‘ Milpitas. both or Calif.
`j‘_’____ ___;.4—;_.——
`
`[54] BATTERY PACK AND A MEIHOD FOR
`MONITORING REMAINING CAPACITY or
`A BATTERY PACK
`
`I76]
`
`Inventor: Roland Rnthmann. Raitreisenweg 3.
`3.35375 Neufnhm, Germany
`
`‘
`\
`
`The smart battery device of the present invention. referred
`to as 21‘ Battery Operating System (DBOS).
`is
`
`
`See, e.g., lPR201S—O1171 Pet. at 4; lPR201S01172 Pet. at 4; lPR201S—O1173 Pet. at 4; lPR201S4J1174 Pet. at 4; |PR201S-01175 Pet. at 4; |PR20154J1603 Pet. at 5
`
`Page 9 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`ll. Brief Overview of the Prior Art References
`
`Beard ’290 Patent Discloses A Battery Pack And Terminal
`
`Beard ’290 Patent
`
`See, €.g.,
`
`|PR2015—D1171 Pet. at 11, 31; !PR2015-01172 Pet. at 10, 26,‘ IPRZOIS-01173 Pet. at 11, 29,’ |PR201S—D1174 Pet. at 11, 30;
`|PR201SvO1175 Pet. at 10, 29; !PR20l5~Ol603 Pet. at 13, 33
`
`Page 10 of 117
`
`IPR20l5-01171 Ex. 1005 (Beard). Fig. 8
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`ll. Brief Overview of the Prior Art References
`
`Beard ’290 Patent Discloses A Battery Pack And Terminal
`
`Beard ’290 Patent
`
`Beard ’290 Patent
`
`The battery pack 103 comprises an LCD display 111 that,
`upon re uest,
`rovides an indication of current battery
`ca acit .
`
`with “E" and “F” designating “empty" and “full", respec-
`tively.
`
`IPR2015-01171 Ex. 1005 (Beard) at 9:16-33 I
`-j—.—‘.-;;4_-_A"__
`I O---
`
`See, &‘.g.,
`
`|PR2015—D1171 Pet. at 12-13; lPR2015~D1l72 Pet. at 11-12; lPR2015~01173 PE-t. at 12-13: lPR2015~01l74 Pet. at 12-137
`|PR201S~O1175 Pet. at 11~l2; lPR201S~Ol603 Pet. at 14—15
`
`Page 11 of 117
`
`FIG. 8
`
`lPR2015-01171 Ex. 1005 (Beard). Fig. 8
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`Ii. Brief Overview of the Prior Art References
`
`Beard ’290 Patent Discloses A Battery Pack And Terminal
`
`Beard ’290 Patent
`
`See, €.g.,
`
`|PR2015~D1171 Pet. at 17, 31,’ iPR2015-01172 Pet. at 19, 26,’ iPR20l5-01173 Pet. at 17, 29,’ lPR20l5—01174 Pet. at 17, 30;
`|PR2015—Ol175 Pet. at 16, 29; iPR20l5—Ol603 Pet. at 18, 33
`
`Page 12 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`ll. Brief Overview of the Prior Art References
`
`Beard ’290 Patent Discloses A Battery Pack And Terminal
`
`Beard ’290 Patent
`
`Beard ’290 Patent
`
`When the device 303 is operational, the processor 351
`periodically communicates to the battery pack 301 to
`retrieve The processor 351
`uses such information along with information regarding the
`peak, typical and minimum loadin characteristics of the
`
`device 303 to estimate the achievable with the presently installed
`
`attery pack.
`
`IPR2015-01171 Ex. 1005 (Beard) at 12:59-65
`.__,}___l,§ _ _;-p-.-.
`
`Instead of (or in addition) displaying:l
`;i_ .:..;_«_,u,;..
`:_,»,,»_i_
`the control circuit
`|
`223 interacts with the display 225 to deliver the i
`‘to the operator.
`IPEOIS-01171 Ex. 1005 (Beard) at 11:45-48
`
`IPRZOIS-01171 Ex. 1005 (Beard). Fig. 11
`
`See, e.g.,
`
`|PR2015—D1171 Pet. at 17, 31, Rep. at 15: |PR201S»O1172 Pet. at 19, 26, Rep. at 19; lPR201S-01173 Pet. at 17, 29, Rep. at 11;
`|PR201S~O1174 Pet. at 17, 30, Rep. at 15; |PR20l5—O117S Pet. at 16,29, Rep. at 17; lPR201S—01603 Pet. at 18, 33, Rep. at 20
`
`Page 13 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`ll. Brief Overview of the Prior Art References
`
`Beard ’290 Patent Discloses A Battery Pack And Terminal
`
`Beard ’290 Patent
`
`i
`
`Beard ’290 Patent
`
`Abattery pack 201 provides an operator with an
`indication of battery capacity whether or not it is inserted
`into a portable electronic device 203.
`
`lPR20l5-01171. Ex. 1005 (Beard) at 11:10-12
`
`When fully inserted, the battery pack
`contacts 241. 243 and 245 engage the corresponding con-
`tacts 251, 253 and 255, and. if suflicient power is available,
`the device 203 may enter a fully operational state when the
`operator so desires.
`
`IPRZOIS-01171. Ex. 1005 (Beard) at 11:67-12:4
`
`IPRZOIS-01171 Ex. 1005 (Beard). Fig. 11
`
`See, 6‘.g.,
`
`|PR2015—D1171 Pet. at 12, 30; {PR2015-01172 Pet. at 11, 25; lPR2015-01173 Pet. at 12, 3O;lPR2O154O1174 Pet. at 12, 30.‘
`|PR201S—O1175 Pet. at 11, 28; lPR2015—Ol603 Pet. at 14, 33
`
`Page 14 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`ll. Brief Overview of the Prior Art References
`
`Danielson ’728 Patent Discloses More Detail About The Terminal
`
`Danielson "I28 Patent
`
`IPR20l5-01 171 Ex. 1007 (Danielson). Fig. 1
`
`See, e.g., lPRZO1S—Ol171 Pet. at 17; IPR201S-01173 Pet. at 17; lPR201S—O1174 Pet. at 17; |PR2015—O117‘3 Pet. at 16; |PR20l5—O1603 Pet. at 17
`
`Page 15 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`ll. Brief Overview of the Prior Art References
`
`Rathmann ’869 Patent Discloses The Duracell Battery Operating System
`
`Rathmann ’869 Patent
`
`The smart batte
`
`to as 8 is
`
`device of the resent invention, referred
`
`initially described in the following overview
`
`IPR20l5-01171 Ex. 1006 (Rathmann) at 5:48-58
`
`Sec’, 8.9.,
`
`|PR2015~D1l71 Pet.at16,'IPR2015-01172 Pet. at 16; |PR2015-01173 Pet. at 16; |PR2015-01174 Pet. at 16,’ lF‘R2015{Jll75 Pet. at 15;
`|PR2015—O1603 Pet. at 16
`
`Page 16 of 117
`
`
`
`I. Brief Overview of the Patents
`
`K,
`
`II. Brief Overview of the Prior Art References
`
`W. Purported Deficiencies Raised By Patent Owner
`
`Page 17 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners‘ Demonstratives
`
`Ill. Undisputed Issues
`
`No Dispute Re Prior Art Priority Dates
`
`No dispute Beard ’29O is prior art under at least
`
`35 U.S.C. § 102(e)
`
`No dispute Rathmann is prior art under at least
`
`35 u.s.c. § 102(e)
`
`No dispute Danielson is prior art under at least
`35 U.S.C. §§ 102(a) and 102(e)
`
`See, e.g.,
`
`|PR2015—O1l71 Pet. at 11, 14, 17; IPR
`|PR201Sv01174 Pet. at 11, 14, 17; |PR'
`
`5-
`5—
`
`72 Pet. at 10, 13; |PR2015~O1603 Pet. at 13, 1S,17;lPR2015—O1173 Pet. at 11,14, 17,’
`75 Pet. at10, 13, 16
`
`Page 18 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`Ill. Undisputed Issues
`
`Unrebutted Testimony Re Motivation To Combine
`
`Morley Patent Owner's Expert
`I
`
`Beard, Petitioners’ Expert
`
`Vlll. MOTIVATIONS T0 COMBINE THE PRIOR ART
`
`Motivation to Comblne Beard with Rathmann
`
`95-
` "°°°“5° b°‘h P3‘°“'5 "° ‘fi"’°‘°d
`to the same problcrn—enabling the user of a portable, battery-pack to readily
`
`detennine the current state of battery charge. A POSITA would have looked to
`both complementary disclosures to obtain advantages when combined, as further
`
`discussed below. See. e.g.. Beard at 2:29-3]
`*
`*
`
`(“Thus, there lies a need for the
`*
`
`Motivation to Combine Beard and Rathmann with Danielson
`
`10°
` Baird and Rathmann disclose the hardware,
`
`software. and operation of intelligent battery packs with capacity indicators. but do
`
`not describe in detail the host products that use these intelligent battery packs, or
`
`how the host products may interact with the battery packs.
`
`IPR20l5-01171 Ex. 1003 (Beard Decl.) at 111195. 103
`
`See, e.g.,
`
`|PR201SvOl603 Pet. at 21—28
`|PR2015~0l171 Pet. at 1928; |PR2015—O117Z Pet. at 17-22; |PR2015—01173 Pet, at 1927; |PR201S—O1l74 Pet. at 1927: |PRZO15—D1175 Pet. at 17-26;
`
`19
`
`Page 19 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners‘ Demonstratives
`
`Overview
`
`I. Brief Overview of the Patents
`
`ll. Brief Overview of the Prior Art References
`
`{.
`
`V
`
`IIIT. Undisputed Issues
`
`Page 20 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners’ Demonstratives
`
`IV. Purported Deficiencies
`
`IV. Purported Deficiencies Raised By Patent Owner
`
`(1) Beard In View Of Rathmann Does Not Disclose
`The Claimed "Energy Consuming Load” (’726, ’749, ’952, ’980)
`
`(2) Beard And Rathmann In View Of Danielson Does Not Disclose
`Microchip Control Of Both The "Energy Consuming Load” And The Indicator (’970)
`
`(3) Beard In View Of Rathmann Does Not Disclose
`Deactivation Of A "Function” In Addition To The Visible Indicator (All Patents)
`
`(4) Beard In View Of Rathmann Does Not Disclose
`A Different Activation Signal For The Function (’726, ’952, ’970)
`
`(5) Beard In View Of Rathmann Does Not Disclose
`A Power Source Enclosed In The Product Housing (’726, ’952, ’980)
`
`(6) Beard And Rathmann In View Of Danielson Does Not Disclose
`A Touch Sensor And On/Off Switch In The Same User Interface (’726, ’980)
`
`(7) Beard In View Of Rathmann Does Not Disclose
`The Claimed "Location |ndicator” (’970)
`
`(8) Beard In View Of Rathmann Does Not Disclose
`Activation Of A Visible Indication Without Activating Load (’980)
`
`Page 21 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners’ Demonstratives
`
`IV. Purported Deficiencies
`
`IV. Purported Deficiencies Raised By Patent Owner
`
`Argument
`
`’749 Patent
`'726 Patent
`|PR2015-01171 IPR2015—01172
`
`’749 Patent
`IPR2015-01603
`
`'97O Patent
`IPR2015-01173
`
`’980 Patent
`IPR2015-01174
`
`'952 Patent
`lPR2015-01175
`
`Beard In View Of Rathmann Does Not
`
`Disclose The Claimed "Energy
`Consuming Load"
`
`Beard And Rathmann In View Of
`
`Danielson Does Not Disclose Microchip
`Control Of Both The "Energy Consuming
`Load" And The Indicator
`
`Beard In View Of Rathmann Does Not
`Disclose Deactivation Of A "Function"
`In Addition To The Visible Indicator
`
`Beard In View Of Rathmann Does Not
`
`Disclose A Different Activation Signal For
`The Function
`
`Beard In View Of Rathmann Does Not
`Disclose A Power Source Enclosed In The
`
`Product Housing
`
`Beard And Rathmann In View Of
`Danielson Does Not Disclose A Touch
`
`Sensor And On/Off Switch In The Same
`User Interface
`
`Beard In View Of Rathmann Does Not
`Disclose The Claimed "Location
`Indicator”
`
`Beard In View Of Rathmann Does Not
`Disclose Activation Of A Visible
`
`Indication Without Activating Load
`
`Page 22 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners‘ Demonstratives
`
`IV. Purported Deficiencies
`
`Patent Owner's Consistent Errors
`
`Patent Owner impermissibly reads limitations from
`embodiments in the specification into the claims
`
`Patent Owner misreads the claim language to
`add new limitations not required by the claims
`
`Patent Owner misreads the plain disclosure of
`the prior art
`
`See, e.g.,
`
`|PR2015—O1
`|PR201S 01
`
`Rep.
`Rep,
`
`>10, 13-15, 1825,‘ [PRZO15~O1
`~10, 13-19, 20~22; lPRZO15~O1
`
`Rep.
`Rep.
`
`-12, 14-20; |PR2015—O1173 Rep. at 5-15; |PR2015—O1174 Rep. at 2-10, 13-24;
`~12, 14—21
`
`Page 23 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners’ Demonstratives
`
`IV. Purported Deficiencies
`
`IV. Purported Deficiencies Raised By Patent Owner
`
`Page 24 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`Claims Require "Energy Consuming Load”
`
`’726 Patent Claim 1
`
`1. A method for controlling a product comprisin a ower
`
`source, or a connection for a power source, and“
`‘said method including the step ofproviding
`an electronic module comprising an electronic circuit includ-
`ing a microchip and a touch sensor forming part of a user
`interface, said microchip adapted to control the activation of
`a visible indication in response to an activation signal
`received from the user interface while operation ofthe load is
`unafiected.
`
`,_;_¢—-.4-4-J~‘.:-—’x;.___’%__§
`
`mo
`
`lPR2015—0l171 Ex. 1001 (’726 Patent). Claim 1
`
`See, €.g.,
`
`|PR2015—O1l71 Pet. at 28, Rep. at 3,‘
`|PR201S~O1l75 Pet. at 27, Rep. at 3
`
`Page 25 of 117
`
`|PR2015—O1172 Pet. at 23, Rep. at 3,‘
`
`|PR2015-D1603 Pet. at 31, Rep. at 3; lPR2015-01174 Pet. at 29, Rep. at 3;
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`Plain Meaning Of "Energy Consuming Load” Undisputed
`
`Beard, Petitioners’ Expert
`
`1 16. A POSITA would have understood this plain and ordinary meaning to
`
`be “any part of the product that consumes energy when the product is used.” The
`
`’726 patent uses the term “energy consuming load” consistently with this plain and
`
`ordinary meaning.
`
`IPR2015-01171 Ex. 1003 (Beard Decl.) at 11116
`
`Morley, Patent Owner's Expert
`
`A. Okay. So I believe that something could be
`
`an
`
`energy—consurning
`
`load whether ,
`
`in
`
`general, whether
`
`it's under control of
`
`a
`
`micro or not. If it's a load and it consumes
`
`energy,
`
`it's
`
`an
`
`energy-consuming
`
`load,
`
`generically speaking, yes.
`
`IPR20l5-01171 Ex. 1036 (Morley Microsoft Tr.) at 10221-5
`
`See, e.g.,
`
`lPR2015»O1171 Pet. at 8, Rep. at 34; |PR201S»O1172 Pet. at 9, Rep. at 4; |PR201S-01173 Pet. at 9; |PR2015-01174 Pet. at 8, Rep. at 3-4;
`lPR20lS—0l17S Pet. at 8, Rep. at 4,‘ |PR20l5-01603 Pet. at 10, Rep. at 4
`
`Page 26 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`IV. (1)
`
`P0 Argues Petitioners’ Construction Is Improperly Broad
`
`P0’s Response
`
`Petitioners and Petitioners‘ expert (Paul Beard) point to "any of the
`
`exemplary energy consuming components depicted in device 203 in Figure I 1" of
`
`Beard for an alleged teaching of the claimed load. Paper 3 at p. 31, and Ex. I003
`
`IPR2015-01171 Paper 14 (PO Resp.) at 25
`
`See, e.g., lPR201S—O1171 Resp. at 25; lPR201S—O1172 Resp. at 12; lPR201S—01174 Resp. at 23; |PR2D1S—O117S Resp. at 31; iPR20l5—O1603 Resp. at 12
`
`Page 27 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`Patent Owner Admits That Beard ’29O Discloses
`
`“Energy Consuming Load” Under Plain And Ordinary Meaning
`
`Morley, Patent Owner's Expert
`
`Q. So if the board does not adopt your
`
`consuming
`energy
`construction of
`load, but it views
`it as energy
`consuming component of the device ,
`
`Beard would disclose
`
`that
`
`claim
`
`1:i_mitation, correct?
`
`A. Yes.
`
`Be‘"d'29° Patent
`
`T
`
`$88, e.g.,
`
`IPR20l5-0ll7l Ex, 1005 (Beard) at Fig. 11
`|PR2015—01l71 Rep. at 10-11; IPRZOIS-01172 Rep. at 12-13; ~|PR2015~O1l74 Rep. at 10-11; lPR20l5-01175 Rep. at 10-12,‘
`|PR2015~Ol603 Rep. at 1213
`
`Page 28 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`P0’s Proposed Construction Should Be Rejected
`
`Petitioner's
`Proposed Construction
`
`Patent Owner's
`Proposed Construction
`
`“Energy Consuming
`Load”
`
`plain meaning;
`
`("any part of the product
`that consumes energy
`when the product is used”)
`
`"an energy—consuming
`component that receives
`power from the power
`source under the control
`of the microchip”
`
`The issue is whether the specification
`
`disclaims or deviates from the plain and ordinary meaning
`
`See, €.g.,
`
`|PR2015—D1171 Pet. at 8, Resp. at 20,‘ |PR2015~O1l72 Pet. at 9, Resp. at 12; |PR2015—O1173 Pet. at 9; IPR2015—Oll74 Pet. at 8, Resp. at 20;
`|PR201SvOl175 Pet. at 8, Resp. at 31; |PR201S~01603 Pet. at 10, Resp. at 11
`
`Page 29 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`Board Declined To Construe "Energy Consuming Load”
`
`1.
`
`“energy consuming load”
`
`The term “energy consuming load" is used in challenged independent claims
`
`IPR2015-01 171 Paper 3 (Petition) at 8
`
`Institution Decision
`
`Petitioner proposes constructions for “energy consuming load” and
`
`“mains.” Pet. 8-10. For purposes of this decision, we determine that only
`
`“mains” requires express construction.
`
`IPR20l5-01171 Paper No. 8 (Inst. Dec.) at 4
`
`See, e.g.,
`
`|PR2015—01171 Pet. at 8, Inst. Dec. at 4; |PR2015—O1172 Pet. at 9, Inst. Dec. at 4; lPR201S—O1173 Pet. at 9, Inst. Dec. at S;
`|PR201S—O1174 Pet. at 8, Inst. Dec. at 5; |PR201S—O117S Pet. at 8, Inst. Dec. at 4-5; |PR201S—O1603 Pet. at 10, Inst. Dec. at 5
`
`Page 30 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`IV. (1)
`
`Claims Do Not Require Microchip To Control Power To The Load
`
`’726 Patent, Claim 1
`
`1. A method for controlling a product comprisin a wet
`source, or a connection for a power source, andfl
`‘ said method including the step ofproviding ‘
`an electronic module comprising an electronic circuit includ-
`’
`and a touch sensor forming part of a user
`
`in response to an activation signal
`received from the user interface while operation ofthe load is
`unafiected.
`
`IPR20l5-01171 Ex. [00] C726 Patent). Claim 1
`.§2—~
`._.o~,—\g_’_%‘_;— F‘-‘*9-’
`
`The claims do not require microchip to control power to the load
`
`See, €'.g.,
`
`|PR2015-D1171 Pet. at 28, Rep. at 3,‘
`|PR201S~Oll75 Pet. at 27, Rep. at 3
`
`Page 31 of 117
`
`|PR2015—O1l72 Pet. at 23, Rep. at 3,‘ lPR2015-D1603 Pet. at 31, Rep. at 3; lPR2015-01174 Pet. at 29, Rep. at 3;
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`IV. (1)
`
`Claims Do Not Require Microchip To Control Power To The Load
`
`Morley, Patent Owner's Expert
`
`Q. There's nothing in the language of claim 1
`
`that
`
`requires the energy consuming’
`
`load to
`
`receive
`
`power
`
`under
`
`the
`
`control
`
`of
`
`the
`
`microchip, is there?
`
`THE WITNESS: There is no specific mention of
`
`controlling that.
`
`lPR20l5-01171 E); 1035 (Mofley Tr.) at 9122-9317 (objection omitted)
`
`See, e.g., lPR201S—Ol171 Rep. at 3; |PR20l5—01172 Rep. at 3; IPR20lS—O1603 Rep. at 3; lPR201S»Oll74 Rep. at 3; |PR2015—O117S Rep. at 3
`
`Page 32 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners’ Demonstratives
`
`Features Found In Every Embodiment
`Should Still Not Be Read Into The Claims
`
`PO’s Response
`
`Every single embodiment disclosed in the ‘726 Patent includes such a
`
`microchip—controlled switch that manages conducting of current to the load. See.
`
`e.g.. Ex. I001 at 3:61-66. 6:66-7:4. 7:17-31. 8:56-63. 9:4-12. and FIGS. 1-7. 8A-
`
`8B. and 9-17.
`
`IPRZOIS-01171 Paper 14 (PO Resp.) at 19
`
`Thorner:
`
`!‘>"‘E “It is not enough for a patentee to simply disclose a single
`
`embodiment or use a word in the same manner
`
`1n all
`
`embodlments, the patentee must ‘Clearly express an intent’ to
`redetlne the term.”
`
`Thomer v. Sony ComputerEnter1ainmentAmerica LLC. 669 F.3d 1362. 1365 (2012)
`
`;
`
`See, e.g., |PR201S—01171 Rep. at 6-7; lPR2015—O1172 Rep. at 5-5; lPR2015—O1603 Rep. at 5-5; |PR201S—01174 Rep. at 5-7; lPR201501175 Rep. at 6-7
`
`Page 33 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`PO Attempts To Limit Claims To Specific Embodiments
`
`PO’s Response
`
`Nm-y.jaisc~oswa-nu»-726 mm
`
`microchip—contmlled switch that manages conducting of current to the load using a
`
`man-machine interface (MMI) device (e.g.. touch sensor) that itself does not
`
`conduct the current to the load. d FIGS. I-7. 8A-
`
`[PR2015-01171 Paper 14 (PO Resp.) at 16
`
`SUMMARY ‘OF THE INVENTIOIR
`
`there is provided a microchip controlled switch to manage 1
`both the current conducting functions and the MMI fiinctions \
`in an electronic device, such as a flashlight, on a low current \
`basis i.e. without the MMI device having to conduct or switch N
`high current.
`
`IPRZOIS-01171 Ex.100l ('726 Patent) at 3:61-66 I
`4-&é.——§o~4;§‘.~f._
`;x4—«—--
`
`1) No mention
`nor definition
`
`of "energy
`consuming |oad”
`
`2) Does not
`
`say microchip
`
`controls power
`to load
`
`See, e.g., lPR20l5—O1171 Rep. at 4-5; lPR2015—O1172 Rep. at 6; |PR201S—O1603 Rep. at 6; lPR201S—O1174 Rep. at 4-5; lPR201S—O117S Rep. at S
`
`Page 34 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`'726 Patent Summary Of The Invention
`
`According to a still further embodiment
`IPR20l5-01171 Ex.l001 ('726 Patent) at 5:6
`:-
`anisu.-at-— 4....
`O
`
`fl.
`
`‘
`
`an:
`
`uau-uu-anzua-1-:~
`S
`
`>o‘¢ri—uM
`
`According to one embodiment
`lPR2015-01171 Ex.l00l ('726 Patent) at 3:61
`
`p-.—.-n
`
`mun
`.-u—..n-‘nun:
`--a..:..n—.. n.
`
`.:
`u ncuuu.-m U-nahnullvu.
`u--an-».un- .n.uuuu.qs.a-\-u.
`5.-—......n_q»..4u.a..‘.n_a..
`tunmu
`
`paw
`
`.».. «
`
`.
`
`nu ».
`
`.4 ‘ojlfifi-J
`
`__
`
`~—, -—
`
`um-u~ux...u«
`
`1 Accordingto anotherembodiment
`
`IPR20l5—0ll7l Ex 1001 C726 Patent) at 4:47
`__...-_—-.po}}.-___..,_
`__A—~..
`
`See, e.g., lPR201S—Ol171 Rep. at 4-5; IPR20l5—O1172 Rep. at 6; |PR201S—O1603 Rep. at 6; lPR201S—O1174 Rep. at 4-5; lPR201S—O117S Rep. at S
`
`Page 35 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners’ Demonstratives
`
`PO’s Support Does Not Describe
`Microchip Control Of Power To The Load
`
`PO’s Response
`
`Thus, unlike conventional MM] switches that directly connect a power
`
`source to a load, central to the invention of the ‘726 Patent is its explicit distinction
`
`over this conventional configuration by virtue of providing a low-current MMI
`
`switch that does not itself conduct cunent to the load:
`
`It is important to recognize, however, that it is control
`
`circuit 20] which activates current switch 202 upon
`
`acting on an input from MM] switch I02. Unlike
`
`heretofore known prior art devices. activating switch I02
`
`does not conduct cun'ent to load 105, but is only a
`
`command input mechanism which can. according to the
`
`invention. operate on very low current.
`
`This passage
`
`does not require
`
`the microchip to
`
`control power
`
`to the load
`
`M‘ at 732349‘
`
`1PR20l5-01171 Paper 14 (PO Resp.) at 18
`
`See, e.g., |PR201S—01171 Rep. at 5; lPR201S—01174 Rep. at 5; lPR20154)117S Rep. at 6
`
`Page 36 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners’ Demonstratives
`
`PO’s Support Describes Exemplary Embodiment In Fig.2
`
`’726 Patent
`
`’726 Patent
`
`,
`
`l
`
`FIG. 2 is a block diagram of a microchip for use in asso-
`ciation with a push button or sliding input activation/deacth
`vation switch according to one embodiment ofthe invention;
`IpR2015_01171 EXJO01 (.726 Patent) at 525759
`.1
`.
`_ AF’..-
`.
`- _‘
`‘-/.-..
`_
`_
`
`.
`
`.
`_
`Th|s [5 not the
`
`"vefy ch a fa ctef"
`
`of the invention
`
`"line structure and operational parameters ofsuch a micro-
`chip 103 are explained in greater detail below with respect to
`FIG. 2. As shown in FIG. I, power is supplied to microchip
`1015 by power source 101. Wlien
`operator activates input
`switch 102 to the “on“ position it represents a command
`which is communicatcxi to microchip 103. Input means 102
`requires very low current in preferred embodiments. In one
`embodiment of the invention. microchip control/reset means
`201 simply allows the current switch 202 to pass current
`provided from power source 101 to load 105 in an unimpeded
`manner when the MMI switch 102 is acti\3:qgd,_ ;ip§l__ip_qq_e__ ’
`.e2ii~'.t.t1.'i.*.1l.u.>‘.l1.1i.ii1it.illi1I2iii1i1tiuiis.t:12l:*iI2sa1:1t is important '0:
`irecognizc, however, that it is control circuit 201 which acti-:
`Evates current switch 202 upon acting on an input from MMI: ‘
`:switch 102. Unlike heretofore known prior art devices. acti-E
`Ivating switch 102 does not conduct current to load 105, but is:
`:only a command input mechanism which can, according to; p
`I
`.
`.
`I
`IIIIIII
`:the invention, operate on very low current-7-‘or examp e.
`'a'c'<:'o'rH'iEi§,' T6 't'h'c' ix'1x75r'ii'it')hf 1b'u'c ' 'si':h'st')F 'i'n"put or carbon
`coated membrane type switch devices are preferred.
`IPRZOIS-01171 Ex.lO01 (’726 Patent) at 7:12-31
`._
`-.
`-.,, _._
`
`See, e.g., |PR201S—01171 Rep. at 5; lPR2015—O1174 Rep. at 5; lPR201S—O1175 Rep. at 6
`
`Page 37 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners’ Demonstratives
`
`P0’s Expert Testimony Should Be Given No Weight
`
`.
`
`what
`
`I
`
`think the patent
`
`teaches is an energy consuming load is a load
`
`whose
`
`power
`
`supply
`
`is
`
`controlled by
`
`the
`
`microchip.
`
`So
`
`there has
`
`to Ibe
`
`a
`
`switch in
`
`series
`
`between
`
`the
`
`power
`
`supply,
`
`or
`
`exhaustible power supply if it's a battery --
`
`there's the switch that is controlled by the
`microchip,
`\ and
`then
`there's
`the
`load
`downstream so that in order for power to come
`from the power source and get to the load, it
`
`has
`
`to
`
`go
`
`through
`
`that
`
`switch
`
`that
`
`is
`
`controlled by the microchip.
`
`IPR2015-01171 Ex. 1035. "Morley Tr." at 88:4-19
`
`see, e.g., |PR201S—O1171 Rep. at 5-6; |PR2015—01172 Rep. at 7; |PR2015—01603 Rep. at 7; |PR2015—O1174 Rep. at 5; |PR201S—0117S Rep. at 6
`
`Page 38 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`Applying P0’s Construction Consistently Would
`Add A Microchip To Claims That Do Not Require One
`
`Claim requires a microchip:
`
`Claim DOES NOT require a microchip:
`
`’726 Patent
`
`’749 Patent (sibling of the ’726 Patent)
`
`2l.Amethodofimplementingauserimerl'aceforaprod-
`l.Amethodforcontrollingapr0ductcomprisingapower
`uct comprising connections for a power supply and at last
`source. or a connection for a power source. aid an‘
`‘ said method including the step ofpmviding one— using at last a touch sensoruser
`an electronic module comprising an electronic circuit includ-
`interfiice switch and a visible indicator. wherein the method
`ing a microchip and a touch sensor forming part of a user
`includes the Steps Of:
`interface, said microchip adapted to contml the activation of
`(a) activating the indimtor in response to a user interface
`a visible indication in response to an activation signal
`Switch activation signal:
`received from the user interface while operation ofthe load is
`(b) activating the indicator when the load is not activated by
`unaflected.
`the user.
`
`lPR2015-0l 171 Ex. 1001 (’726 Patent). Claim 1
`;4—__—__-
`_
`
`(C) perfotmins an automatic delayed deactitmiofl OT 3
`firnction that Wm activated in response to an activation
`signal received via the user interface switch.
`
`[PR20l5-01171 Ex. 1041 ('749 Patent). Claim 21
`J&-v'*"““"
`
`Applying P0’s construction to this
`
`claim would add a microchip that is
`
`nowhere in the claim language
`
`See, e.g., lPR201S—Ol171 Rep. at 10; lPR2015—O1172 Rep. at 3; lPR2015—Ol603 Rep. at 3; |PR2015—O1174 Rep. at 10; lPR201S—0117S Rep. at 10
`
`Page 39 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`When Patentee Wished To Include A Requirement That
`The Microchip Control Power To The Load, It Did So
`
`’726 Patent
`
`’970 Patent (CIP sibling of the ’726 Patent)
`
`1. A method for controlling a product comprising a power
`source, or a connection for a power source. and an
`‘ said method including the step of prov:
`an electronic module comprising an electronic circuit includ-
`ing—and a touch sensor forming part of a user
`interface, said microchip adapted to control the activation of
`a visible indiaatiar in response to an activation signal
`received from the user interface while operation ofthe load is
`unaffected.
`
`IPR20l5-01171 Ex. 1001 (’726 Patent). Claim 1
`j,
`g.-____.,
`,.,__j
`
`52. A method of operating a product which includes a
`visible luminous indicator, an—and a
`power source for powering the load. the method including
`the steps of operating a user interface switch. that is a touch
`sarsor type switch which is not a serial link in a circuit from
`thepowersourcetotheloadtopowertheload.tocontrolthe
`operation of‘using the microchip to control the
`connection ofthepowersourceto theloadandtheactivation
`of the indicator. and to activate the indicator to show a last
`one of the following when the load is not activatect a
`condition of the product. an activation of the switch, and a
`power level of the power source
`
`lPR20l5-01171 Ex. 1037 ('970 Patent). Claim 52
`4——.—-4*""“’
`
`See, e.g., lPR20lS—O1171 Rep. at7—8; |PR2015—O1172 Rep. at 9-10; ll-‘R201S—01603 Rep. at 9-10; IPR201S—O1174 Rep. at 7-8; lPR2015—O117S Rep. at 3
`
`Page 40 of 117
`
`
`
`Petitioners' Demonstratives
`
`PO’s Construction Contradicts Controlling Law
`
`’726 Patent
`
`’970 Patent (CIP sibling of the ’726 Patent)
`
`1. A method for controlling a product comprising a power
`source, or a connection for a power source. and an
`‘ said method including the step of prov:
`an electronic module comprising an electronic circuit includ-
`ing :1 microchip and :3 touch sens-‘-r fr-rsnin<_.z part ol‘ 2 user
`
`52. A method of operating a [roduct which includes a
`visible luminous indicator, an—and a
`power source for powering the load. the method including
`the steps of operating a user interface switch. that is a touch
`sensor tvpe w. itch which ix‘ not a serial link in .1 circuit {mm
`
`In re Rambus Inc.:
`
`same
`“[U]nless otherwise compelled the
`claim term in the same patent or related patents
`carries the same construed meaning.”
`
`In re Rambus Inc.. 694 F.3d 42. 48 (Fed. Cir. 2012) (internal quotations and alterat
Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.
After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.
Accept $ Charge
Still Working On It
This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.
Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.
A few More Minutes ... Still Working
It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.
Thank you for your continued patience.
This document could not be displayed.
We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.
Your account does not support viewing this document.
You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.
Your account does not support viewing this document.
Set your membership
status to view this document.
With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll
get a whole lot more, including:
- Up-to-date information for this case.
- Email alerts whenever there is an update.
- Full text search for other cases.
- Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.
One Moment Please
The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.
Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.
Your document is on its way!
If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.
Sealed Document
We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.
If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.
Access Government Site
