`Mylan et al. v. AstraZeneca
`IPR2015-01340
`
`
`
`Commercial Success Expert Witness Experience
`
`For the Brand
`
`Against the Brand
`
`orexo A3 and orexo us’ inc”
`v. Actavis Elizabeth LLC.
`_
`,
`_
`— United States District Court for
`The DISH,-Ci of Deiqwore
`
`Horizon Pharma AG and
`Jagotec AG v. Watson
`
`Laboratories, Inc., - Florida,
`
`Actavis Pharma, lnc., Andrx
`
`Corporation and ACiClViS, inc.
`— United States District Court for
`the District of New Jersey
`
`Coalition for Affordable Drugs
`‘'1' “C V" C‘."”"°
`Technologies, Ltd.
`_
`— United States Patent and
`Trademark Office Before the
`
`Patent Trial and Appeal
`Board
`
`Amneal Pharmaceuticals, LLC
`
`v. Endo Pharmaceuticals, inc.
`
`— United States Patent and
`Trademark Office Before the
`Patent THC” Cmd Appeal
`Board
`
`
`
`
`
`II'||'nI.III'..II1‘b-fill" PH.‘-I ‘Il.I31"|-13 L\'l".'|R\l.!1'IFI-'\i
`Iirwluflfiunuuluhdrdnpua-j.nmnmnu
`|r.\t..1w.-nun -I urn-mug. HI In.-suing-In-—n-nu
`
`u
`
`-
`
`C
`
`mu puns.-um. mu-nan-.h<v:»a.v(Aa-n-n-.¢u.<-..
`Wlnw-Id MIII -I-h-orlnlv-Imrli I.I-Ill-lnfl-I|:.1-I land: I
`incl .1.«.-.-nu-sluuuuunpg-pt.-.—u-L--an»--u.-c-u-.
`
`uuumnvu mi al hapuldrn-nu n"_.
`ii1p—u..—m:-vu-Inna-Ihuum-q
`rum 1.:-uni-.u Mun
`
`n—-sunny-lid-m ua.-at-panama \'!.$In|I DI1‘iIfll'~II=|flIfl
`u.«n;.a...au.. .nn.a.u..un.v\.-I.I¢4\I-!.«:.uu...n.-pu...|nn
`._-....._n -—IiI-plan um-nun. ....a¢.uu.m. gag
`muanun mqn. n..u.a-.. ll\ul\'!A n--Inn no-up-and
`I4--n amid:-viii!!!-urn:-I-Ifllu-tin-ruin-nun and shunt
`umm|.tI|.uan:I|I..-|'.1.uHu:dhu'_'
`'-
`'LJ
`nu-mu-p.. u-umaumn-unuuuuhuannuqandnpum.
`Iulnl |l‘l\-I Inlcthhn I.'|-uulw ll cr-I-II-inns:-1: I-I‘ -uni-Hm:
`pun-uni:-an-nan. nqlilinnr :1. u
`l1Fl'¢||lI.l1I'l'-I$1|JI—=flI*"lFU-QUHIL-‘lb-‘*|II'|'|“'KI‘
`in-on-nu-an ni r-a-Lu-nu uliulhfll \'i.1rI-r nuan--alums.
`mqrs H
`T mum I:rM'lIuN\T
`.
`gaugugrnuan-uganun,:°'.uFpmp-pa-n.q.In|uu(i9|:'.i\1(A
`-u.-nuummhdn--uutunm-ndu-Iaplnnhnungp
`mum-nIm1nnu-mm u-uulnaauhul--rLaIl1—Inlx n-I4
`Pdqfiunlnauunnnuw--udur-run-u-nu-tin-at-uuunn
`kc-«I--can->¢uHI'1-rn|I'r14-“lanai-Imodhhu-1'I'!1InuI41
`paw-15:-anllutru-w-|.n-a>t|iI\4!---ml IILI LU:
`‘I-un-oII\l.'5l'[l'I'l'l'| um-1131: um Tll'l'\fii.unuua mum-
`uu In :IHI:.l-t Hum Iamvu-slain ;-g-,-;,nugr.u:rg-1.1
`TIN-l'(i'IH"I'l‘I.R('I1I3‘ViT——.—..—
`.
`1m..,,¢1:|I-Hi Inulcfiuun u;.lvq:m-aw; lmh-ggcufi
`nu.11'z~wm§a.mm-unggu.-_u—_
`neg...-uu1..qmu:.IIrM+u~.,.u::-q-udu.h .;_* in
`I'll’!-“I!'EllHl'I'1F|‘-fl—AlIJ'.\I
`-\—;.1-u-I--in-Iu..-in-Ilueu-bu-uupunjul-n-gnl I.
`o
`we.-unur4.rrr\1uu=v-«:1-narnasuauantu-u.uu..nuuIan
`ma
`In-u-nulls
`
`t
`
`m'«..I rm runny:-1-I-A-Im.Iw mun
`Inn-n. .\ .-Wu--1: no
`— 1"IIflI' ‘I1 KIRK |_\II!'*nJIl'ni'
`\.'.r_-\ 1. n.Jaquu.I».I pup-n.I-N :1 rwauuluu -in-and an
`Ian-1 I-HI-n II:-It-IIrI-‘M mu--~uIvuu-nc in-nuld -q-mun «mm-.'
`.n.nuunmu'Inu- Immlw-Iarlnnul -sump n _g go
`$1:-fluu.nu -nun tum-mun Id up I mhonunnnuuu nu
`Jdaunn |.¢nn..in-u. :‘ .‘|
`1]..-u|1I'ln1I-mind:|'U.InInI»nh-lulunudlnncnnlnu-1: -v -.
`HIM‘ ISII »|II\II5\.IQI'I.l'I'IIi\
`llual-m-rl-hill--we‘-2 ' ‘I’ II? -I Iluwdnh Iawrwllw -I
`I‘I|r-- -«tn-damn -om-mulnuunruu .-raw-nnr-u-I
`J1uI-;nhI|- Euad 'I'Il|.I llu-u|munM1dun-urh.."uuIn¢dnIu
`'\-'HlIF=u- -A Innlll Ii
`l
`-sum In-J I---J--I-I->-m mum-|“'1I£1 W-K-n-J1-r-1-«In-Ih
`E ' q hla mau-an-nnl1’.u g-nuul.-1uInu-u.u.nvu.hu-u
`H1-II |u'-I(Tl'I-ulnnnuh-nu-nu uuunn--In .1.‘
`.'.In
`T |‘.|I:|9IM5l.l-UR‘-hA.‘Vm!I‘lIl.\4'.lJli
`Idda. -.,.,...¢;n,'¢_..
`Tl|'|'ITR.\l'\'I'I¢ iI'I|'|'i
`unm on! a mu Ina-auuunm «mm 1:; —II:_uLn.n
`nnpmlcnn cunhmn an.-unlvru-.r|..m¢5H.r_\ 43
`\um.|u.s.;\um.u A|1Im.\
`
`I-'ir'\I'I"\-Mil“-J"I|'\"-""""‘!'-"
`I ilrrva-nlnn----wvmpd
`p.u...uI_- B1-Iuflllnu-I ||u.H'J'.A ..
`rf-1-um--nu hui-no--I1-I-mun Jml-«um-.1-.un:|-:.Lw
`In nunjunnphn —JI|--u|uunuuln.um1i-vnnIhvrIU|Iu.mnu-I-
`II-'l.I.I‘l1.t-:'IIIflrol\NIlS'IJu1uu'« I n.\1'Ir_\1\'
`1 unit lllII\I‘I-\Nhl'|i|1il:
`3H-6-Iq-Dalila-urC\rud.1I4uo-nun
`II-fiI_l"|'|-i'l¢t'|FI'I'DI'l.|U|lII'L\
`l Ill-4-dun-gu -H..aIu-nun llgqqu,
`I: In-muun ml 1-.
`Ill!-wit-A-1
`! l3Il'l|l-i|. l!H5.M'||vII"lfi-'I'|l-IT!“
`nu.-.qu.uugu
`llhillllllrl-‘I|'
`Ila-nun-nlnirh-1|!
`IIIflII!|n,'lu
`Ih-p ‘run. and. Inn! |lluu'nu|
`WITHIN‘-hfl-GI’
`I I I)-an Ununa-n-mnlu,-nnmlu-u I
`'II -1 may l"|'l‘1M-I
`
`IIIHWIHPIIIW
`ll(II\II ll-HI-$IMIl'I'I.I.Ii\'
`I I I-"nun-II-H-I l'-i -M M1 |Iw|lI\-»-rII4i|-Iilluric I
`|‘DIIIlIlII|I+!
`I: I filnulllflilbrl
`l1:'Hu-In-I-mun-u
`I I-lI'hJH-ll ll'lIl‘HI l.\IIJI'I'Il\-Ioillh
`{:.1
`I I !.I‘.'VI'|la|.l‘II||l' lI1l!‘fl-
`IIAIII-Ilflll AL.ll'I'Il-l'l.l'I'.\‘
`I Ii-I-I.'\uI'|'ln| \'II| |'I.I|
`|I"I II?“
`IIJL.-n-u-autumn:-nulnunlwunlnlilm
`I: Ir.-mum.-... um .m—uu r. mum-o-nu Illlldul
`I1ln\a-vnu indent‘-palnltuu-snug
`IaI1l'IIIIll.h'I1IIl.1.
`I I Iluuuunnuu Ilh.n-In
`H1
`.‘I\1Iuniu-Jlluuolhlddlhlhll
`' | '4II|.I---9-ullh Illa--vu-
`IA :I.-autumn tum;
`ll |'IIIu|
`I'I\'I'I.\¥ I1-H 1IIPP9
`I. used I-at-l upwnmu
`It Kilt H'l'I'l
`l'Uh‘l'l‘fl.1l.fl, Afilll-I.L'IflhI.|
`If rH'&.\1I Ill’-‘H-fl.l.'lId |‘h‘Ifil.hI'|lfl
`9...-a....I-g-u...
`‘Cu I'\"H.I-H II|'l\'|
`‘tun-mu alumna-uInIA-at--Iljluuhuululliullnilii
`I-‘IILL i’|l.E‘.5("RlBl.VG INFIJIM-l‘I1DN
`
`fiallrmul ID SSMSH
`
`
`
`HIlI'lI|I:I ID: 312%‘:
`
`bum-mumgn1uau—-m-,nx-um lcnpuzllig
`disc!-am: K.UMB.|(.'IL.l'£L NJ!
`ll yuwlun IIIJIHIIIIH; Ilnlhdupr
`-Inna! Ifi |ul\uz||Jl.Iuhn.nnuIhu:nII'nAhn.I.:‘I nfiw m-lulu
`:[u'|-Qua}-nsallpln-(vuhn'¢-uunwu.-nn.la|qr|sI1LIeulI\|¢efl Imdni
`
`nnu1.t|L;_|~.__I1_ _ _
`_r_|I
`mm !\rrI'umII1 upumurlnn-r known:
`I] Ian-an u nuupmd
`TIIuIj'Ilrd.iu>tInnncI(I'IlI]I.:'I.T}J'. XI. I5-I «. 1!
`
`l'm.|-nnl pl" £a-1i.mr- Haimmm um I
`vuurnrn B“ ha-
`Muuuullamslquaulruauiwhwhhlh \‘.‘.
`-I1
`Piufimmm In ll- HI-ilhw I-dd-III
`I-I II1l|III3ri-lIal- Id-1-In III
`I.In.:h.nn.I|dnI.LmIu mama pagan.-n_.1.aa.-us...-nquq
`III»:--gdyrunuu In :91-uni nan: nnauumlr on puns. stand will
`uugirpuu I:-I-wnl
`up
`|ILII:fin
`llkn mu] Mlh an IHIII
`-as-svur-p*1= v
`-:|||'-wphwll w maul» a I-mt alum -Ida: n-uh:
`unmtnua-: I-1' mun. my 1': run-mi
`II» nnmnanw IN ml: ur
`
`M-I--Hmnn: c‘
`-.I:
`H1:-rum-nuIIII1~IM'.-w-r J-'--1-tn |r']\ n-II»--u mm! man How
`c--urn: nn|_nnu«=IuaInunnulu~Ai|-ughpnnhnnhoplueaurlllaulnd
`nlanlhu.-:1:--dm-Ilrmtlu n1!-In uf-cIInIauI-up:-vnustrrllp rgnnwnu.
`min In nnpilyl-m-. dwI.uJ-an. -I. sufndnunu in mnl1|.un-r In
`nulaun huh: «I -ulanlluldl PI-nu-I1-r I-1c-nun-rlitlmi-|Iil.1'lF.!
`DER. mm M: mun L-mafia-I mm mm: I‘||'I||I|I1lIr M-minwull
`an-avunum and wall: IJlcI'nuneI¢=InII-u|Ib.urdLI-but-_ ii, :._I.
`|-_2|
`.Ir»inAbn..5.nev-nu!-lbaldlqlclllllqullnransqzvuinluphitm
`mm; l)fl\'l Inluhmn L>I1-In an: |u-Hcuulnc I-I-uarclrjxl
`p-I-n-Ldnuaamnu--ml |rappwpuI= |§.HI
`lihcnnnrrunfiur tumuur ‘Io uulnnn mlau at Irnmnn-ulu
`H-I: Ilfiunlul will I(fl.'I|E.I'|I:ll.‘I'?.'[ KI: fl any ~fl‘IElrI.hhhl.|: M
`AlI‘\'l:Iitlt1L.IIt£CHfi5T
`Mu:-I nI.1IIrIIIrpuI1Iflln »P'$ M1-unblr-In-II Wall-wlhur-a
`nlhuh-H-Ilfifluz nil nu: mmnlh Inn at ill:-I4 lull: in
`Plliflfillnr-IIII:-Ilwunmnuuna-ur H
`mm na-cu-rn-m-mun. -.\---tnwmwnlmii -nrdlalu
`nlnlnca-annual; mu nup|IuH-nenduIh|lu1InIu=|“u-
`raw-H-3 "Ir! I-Ian-an Lrrw-M-Mrnlnm-n. v¢.hn»Jn1n.ILL>
`nubwncluutnr-um-anal ||.\_'I'bou'u¢I|1l-udw pfird-Iufld
`Huh mdunam.-uni uwbfili lluhulluuu III mu
`II-Iulnplc-an-lniludttflluuulnllllldltfllinllflllal
`nu-A-I-lira-mm-nI:..U
`lIII'II'l"| '“"9|-C"-liMI'|"EI5t ItI'W'I'III3Q\|lfililI.‘fl"'H'!l
`uIILI&flNnTMd1ZFflnbflK
`
`Mimi |H'9‘I'-Eo\II'|'E|fi'I
`L-auflmnnmm M1 may :1 mm Imhulfuu Illulullfl
`MIT IA
`i1IIfl'lM.Ifl-
`Ifluuu
`-Lmflnm
`_
`.
`'
`nutuunn--Lm n a~¢.:sn.-qnuu-u-um-M‘-1*‘ T_*J
`L‘-dam mp -dim'—ud' In Ind‘ I-hi-u -dun: nip 1-ifiq
`Inuounnwnnl-mvm|n|nIuI'llunu1I-lull I|1.':'l
`
`Ia: nurutllr Il_'.lII:I_..¢L‘I'|‘L'DIiI
`hkuolnu-Mulnn-nun-Iunlnnnnuluuuumlazfl
`
`ux.-mmransu rm’.-u nun.-u.' B‘FI'I|1.|l.lfll.fi
`rln-4-rl-Illa:-.u Initinudnlull-r|-IIIIII-III:-hulhtnx
`qhr-upq hr L;I)$fl|I.'I.\"J‘l-.x|‘r_
`RtIMll.l1l.i'll'!I|-nnuhhhnflouuduunhulyh-rfl-rflruunulo-L
`tilt-It-IIrh.l'-uritdlr
`Dl|IbH'—\- UUIIBIIE fill
`'W.I|ISI.'|'.I'.'n.- L|lTl"MIfil.n|.l‘!I
`-*'-1IlfN-a-'I*-II-1i--I-'!Bv--r|"i|-=I"--=--u-
`lzrflrucluhvubr-um--|hb—I‘IIriurt2h§II. I'h-rblc
`hruunaruwflnufinon-inumcpixfihilnlillelnudcnhd
`I-nIar.Iup-in-.uu—nnuIa-pun-L-an-uauqnauu
`hIfIflDl.d‘_1_l
`mun: t-id: noun. #1». mlinmp iinrnl.
`I-m-Iq,
`-—u|u-nu. nu --punk -an-bur mun
`uuueu-upon-.-—n-.-cu-uh-.n.|-up-«J-u..,.....|
`uh-&nl|imlh|uht,‘_|_h
`l'I'I(hI-Ihlun-fl':II|l.flu|'IflIu-K¢'|‘.|-HI.-l.'b'l.I Hind
`h-glhfiiulrflli-I_IiuI-u||ulrI_4._d,LI_r
`I,'|IIl.'.1. IIDN! A,\‘|‘.I Flu;
`m)Ml1|IH\'.r1 1|;'J|..ur.nnumn.n-guugngn nugqnlj-|p=11rIuII-—|
`tHl'Nlnhiin~( null:-nunnI.nhu¢|—d; uu1||;n|:.tnn|Inlf|ulIhnkd
`anu=a.u:uupm,.Iguu-g=nwuIwshJn-man;::.1n9uu:.
`.a.JLu.-n-=u.=am.ro.n.muuaqnaI-1a:tJvuIHIu:u:nh-nmqrans
`-
`..1,
`1Inm.nn...t1 2
`:1-1.:h:pm1amnr'mn1mdmna.h.huxm.uuuhoa:I |_u
`Iiun-I11-tn-in-uin:-puuunun-Ilalzzncan-r.:l|u:uuuuu.u_|_L ‘JI
`lIIH.'lriE.L¥'D.:\l]'\lI.Nl'|l'I.\lIIFI
`.I.'nnnuI:;-Insdnnln -Iflllzivu-Idlhnl r.' "
`uuuunmuunqq an-=r-....:....h..uun'm.n.s n1nIIl|l
`lhnnqufitmmghufluuflknman-luhahin |2__|r
`Uluiaumllllhnlnlzulrifliuunuhllllflmlnulllmll
`Il.'|:nI1nbI.hdnn ._- [I
`'iIIIl|bI-\ I-IN: Knwm-h 1'1-l.~rl'JI\I* 1.'..."
`Luann: nnqupumau-u‘. m :3 nq-mun u-pa-an nu. |A1nu
`null: nlntnunrmlo nui umunuq hum.-nu-an-Isl n.'. :. ‘ ‘.-
`llluvl.-'I IlIk.1’I'|l.‘IlH'\(-111!
`hllrflt
`1|q-uugh-I.n.|lIInqn-:r.«|n|a+II.|¢|Id|..I:.JJ\n.u--I -.
`*-uma¢|-r4mIrII'numII-vrnu<II|'mu-on-I—-m:-rI--
`HDIIE-mII|vIn|'ll0II|nv-IL-IlImlI.Ie\nnuJ-14w;-.:I
`l'l'I'5‘IIrU‘HI( Alli“
`Ilcnnl .q_—.. .n
`Iluvcruv-«mu w-u1l|-u—u§nn--uu$nh n.
`Mnfifilflll-n.g|nEh‘u|.l-khan": sun ‘.1!
`lflfllll-Bl!
`Iin-on M u an-u hlIInnunl.m1-v muuqu mg
`I301-tlhn uh!-li-nr IL: .|nllnmu I- KIlHn1lIl<L.YflL XII II
`uu¢l|Il| III
`
`|Iu.I.‘1l'o'nn nu nu n-‘rum-u
`
`1......
`u
`.. vm.p....u-.9...-mn....Lmo.u:g
`HI h F-l1lI.'W‘l fiflhhlibflfl iNI"IIi|h1_'lIfi ififll
`I24!-Hllil W: an n. ml mmum ..
`-q-rrnn -n'I
`lalffliflfl
`...um.u.a..I an Inn} u-an-an L... um: _I n...n..u
`
`I'|'I.I. lIiHIl3l.\l¢'1‘|¥DI.\(lI.'l'l'|‘I:K|2Wl-'I.‘i'I‘I-‘
`VI IIHING: Lil"lIl M fills
`I I'll!!! +\IIII\n.u'III\u-1
`lllmunl-uh-{It
`8lIH~\|fl..\'|I'l-1l|MF‘hII-«\FIl‘
`2| Inn..-n-aunt-nu
`Zilh-up \.h-an-nun uunhu-n.-ruin I-and In-qt 'n'F1.v\-I-1
`Iulfluhrl
`.‘ u-nuiur-an I. no -an uni:-4|:-H-and-iuIuuIl| um-Malum
`rill!-fill
`J nuuu mum nu-mw.~um\
`I r1>\1'I..u!.'nu' nutm-
`S I-|I.1ll?U!aJ.'|v3 I"IIIl'.\1'lIl\I
`‘I last: M-l-r
`|JH|n1InIu
`
`PT!-!3fi1FIII?lfI|1
`
`SJ Anuuaulllflififikn
`uaunu-uvdlupuuiuumu
`.I!\'1hu|IuII|.I'IInIlIIIm
`Iuhml huh!
`
`I I-his
`::='-»-*......:w............%..................-........,.~~*
`‘H
`.
`.L .
`
`I I8
`
`In-r
`
`:.:::.=~=v.'.-.-.'w.'..':.'.a....-
`
`
`
`Doctor Discussion Guide
`
`..
`
`...- _n.._.n.
`
`..
`
`_ T
`
`j j
`
`j
`
`T _
`
`__T_
`
`
`
`THE rnrormauhn is intended In: its cousuarrers only
`
`U za
`orig y
`
`Parlltaplmg .n
`IheFI12'lh'
`um and Immi-
`Snwnn Prunrn
`
`Get ready for your doctor appointment-
`ynur input is important.
`'4':--«:nI-g, i-.-.1 lvlilfill-IE5 .-5 :u. in-mu.-r:r-~I L-an -1i rum; .1 I1-$IZu$k'.F-'-II'|Tt|1I'Duf-1rrC[f-I
`T953-_v|h2: go; :11 d‘.-3151'.‘ [T 5 l:=_3|rI!'1|
`lilo‘. : tits‘. !nI pJ.I Ask your iluclnr rl
`IIHIEQYEI. 1151 [-9 the -u;.~.r r);tl-Tr lrrr Km
`
`Haw DNGLYZA has bu-rr shown to hqlp
`
`
`
`
`
`
`ONGLYZA has been tested in multiple clinical studies including thousands of
`nmwrdmw adult patients with type 2 diabetes. in all of these studies, ONGLYZA in addition
`"*'°"““=""‘°-"""“‘°*
`to diet and exercise has been shown to lower A10. Your results may vary.
`next doctor visit.
`
`
`
`
`PTX—2272 at 1
`
`
`
`What is ONGLYZA?
`|Ir'L-I nu‘-:I-on:-.1320
`
`‘ "
`
`" '
`
`|£I5t“.(-l'.-lw'_‘|' I.I..c-J‘ 'mi'eI ..-.g-:|l.In. a.;1'- -
`or l‘.I.'|be|.'. 'A.=:-.'aI.u:la.=.i.=. I.nL'rr::sefl lair! ... l: .'r.r D|lH.‘d l.'-' urlnrl
`-.1I l.:'-:In'I'
`-I K-II have 3 *II,*~:rLi1.r-1:2 cl getting |;arIr.'I5a-’r'..': A-|u5+= lalun; DN|a'1TI'Ji.
`
`||l':|.‘.91||T|Ei“.Il| IJI HIE |..:III'.'e:'I§ |lIE'I
`Who should nnt take DHGLYZA?
`|IL't- ur 1HJIInl ml‘?-\'.di!'p
`'||nI'r I-‘II luil '.N£v||II-i :31 iii: Tau:
`-IL Ir-pIeCII'II1: Sl.“l|'.'-.|‘.- :l|'I-I gll. |'P3r.5|||'rF'-'. ran -'|l.li|i|' 1--1|I \I|H5|J'IJ. .L=\fl
`'DNC'.‘!£|"~ I‘ WI; .r=-: ="|L.-lglc I:-:I is-‘Ir lI'-
`-.w.iIi-wm: nr !rrP:1'.'IIrI; w-I|III,'_ ::-1 the 'l_|.|l|
`I‘-n!"a. ':-.521
`-1r.i'.n;_ 1|.m!:;,_ r--'
`|'.-'-=i||'.[
`:.‘ \‘lm l'.a..Ir=. ’l'-4.-sr-. :11'.1|'a.'rr-i
`:TU|'l-‘i7riIiT|E UN Gl‘l'I-in and :bfliflcHL'»1Irdid'.T|=l will INN
`Ruse see flripmfanfiafaeylafonwzlah-nonpagu I
`Stick here Jar fll'm':a-hon &m'da.1mi cinch my lnr Ml firunbm lnlamamn
`PTX-22}"2PaQa1ufB
`
`
`
`l
`
`