throbber
OPTICAL
`ENGINEERING
`
`December 2003
`Volume 42 Number 12
`ISSN 0091-3286
`
`SPIE-
`The International
`Society for
`Optical Engineering
`
`I
`
`OE letters
`Acousto-Opticol Tunable Filters
`Diffractive Optics
`Optical Clack Generation
`Optical logic Generation
`Optical Switches
`Waveguide Gratings
`Wavelength Monitors
`
`I Featuring Papers on
`Automated Visual Inspection
`Crock Measurement
`Digital Holography
`Fiber Amplifiers
`Fiber Bragg Gratings
`Fiber Dispersion
`Image Reconstruction
`Image Restoration
`Infrared Beomsplitters
`Infrared Detectors
`Infrared-to-Visible Converters
`Interferometry
`loser Heat T reoting
`liquid Crystals on Silicon
`Motion Blur
`Optical Encryption
`Optical Sensors
`PLZT Thin Films
`Polarizers
`Position Estimation
`Profilometry
`Radiometric Calibration
`Time-of-Flight Range Finders
`Ultraviolet losers
`X-Ray Optics
`
`This resource is also available
`ontheWWW.
`Use MadCat to launch.
`
`Energetiq Ex. 2021, page 1 - IPR2015-01277
`
`

`
`OPTICAL
`ENGINEERING
`
`Donald C. 0' Shea
`Editor
`
`Editor
`Donald C. O'Shea
`Georgia Institute of Technology
`School of Physics
`Atlanta, Georgia 30332-0430
`4041894-3992 • Fax 404/894-9958
`E-mail doshea@prism.gatech.edu
`
`Editorial Board
`James Bilbro
`NASA Marshall Space Flight Ctr.
`Optical fabrication &: testing, coherent lidar
`
`Luc R. Bissonnette
`Defence Research Establishment Valcartier
`Lidar, curosol scattering
`
`Casimer DeCusatis
`IBM Corporation
`Fiber optics
`
`Ronald G. Driggers
`Army Research Lab.
`Infrared systems and radiometry
`
`Touradj Ebrahimi
`Swiss Federal Institute of Technology EPFL
`Image/video processing and coding
`
`G. Groot Gregory
`Lambda Research Corp.
`Interferometry
`
`Jiirgen Jahns
`University of Hagen, Germany
`Optical interconnects, micro-optics
`
`F~sKajzar
`CEA Saclay
`Nonlinear optics
`
`Ali Khounsary
`Argonne National Lab.
`X-ray optics, high-heat-load optics
`
`Raymond K. Kostuk
`University of Arizona
`Holographic materials, processes, and systems
`
`H. Angus Macleod
`Thin Film tenter
`Thin film technology
`
`Dennis W. Prather
`University of Delaware
`Physical optics
`
`Gregory J. Quarles
`VLOC
`Lasers
`
`Jennifer C. Ricklin
`Army Research Laboratory
`Atnwspheric optics
`
`Giancarlo C. Righini
`IROE. National Research Council
`Integrated optics
`
`Jannick P. Rolland
`School of Optics and CREOL at UCF
`Optical system design
`
`Rajpal S. Sirohi
`Indian Inst. of Technology Madras
`Interferometry
`
`Bryan D. Stone
`Optical Research Associates
`Lens design
`
`Andrew G. Tescher
`Compression Science Corporation, Inc.
`Image compression, image &: signal processing,
`video technologies
`
`Totnaliz R. Wolinski
`Warsaw University of Technology
`Optical fiber sensors and liquid crystals
`
`Jiangying Zhou
`Summus Ltd.
`Image analysis, pattern recognition and
`computer vision
`
`Managing Editor
`Karolyn Labes
`P. 0. Bo!t.lO
`BellinaJ!am, Washington 98227-0010
`3601676-3290 • Fu 3601647-1445
`E-mail joumals@spie.org
`
`Editerlal Staff
`Monica Crabtree
`Rita J. Davis
`Michelle Luff
`Aune Munger
`
`Publisher
`Eugene G. Arthurs, Executive Dir"ilctor
`Eric Pepper, Director of Publications
`
`Mailing:
`8PIE
`P.O. Box 10
`Bellingham, Washington 98227-0010
`
`Shipping:
`SPIE
`1000 20th Street
`Bellingham, Washington 98225
`360/676-3290 • Fax 360/647-1445
`E-mail joumals@spie.org
`
`Copyright e 2003, The Society ot Phofo.Opdeal
`Instrumentation EJIIIDeers. Copying of material
`in this journal for internal or personal use, or the
`internal or personal use of specific clients, beyond
`the fair use provisions granted by the U.S. Copy(cid:173)
`right Law is authorized by SPIE subject tu payment
`of copying fees. The Transactional Reporting Ser(cid:173)
`vice base fee for this journal is $15.00 per article
`(or portion thereof), which should be paid directly
`to the Copyright Clearance Center (CCC), 222
`Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923. Other copy(cid:173)
`ing for republication, resale, advertiting or promo(cid:173)
`tion, or any form uf systematic or multiple repro(cid:173)
`duenon of any material in this journal is pnlbibited
`~ wi1b. permission in wriling from the pub(cid:173)
`lisller. The CCC fee eode for this journal is 0091·
`3286Al3J$l5.00.
`Edif,Qrial. Send manuscripts and technical corre(cid:173)
`spontfence to SPIE. Papers and reviews published
`in ()ptical Engineering reftect tbe opiniotl. of the
`llllthor(s); ittc!Usion of andes and advertise·
`ments does oot necessarily ~titute endotse·
`ment by the editor5 or by SPIE.
`SPIE MealbeniUp. Aanual membetsbip dues in(cid:173)
`clude a choice¢' ~ Sooiety's four peer~ed
`joutJliJ.s. 2003 ~ @ues: $95; $45 letirecl;
`$40 Student. For I'QORI infmDation. C0U18Ct SPIE
`M~ 5eniGes at 3601676-3290, Fa: 3CiOI
`647-1445, e-mail: memllenhip@spie.org. CIJ8IIp
`or Address. Send old and new address to SPIE
`~-
`· . ·
`C1f11i«11 ~ (IBSN 0091·1216} (USPS
`4S0.970) is publisbeci ~ by . . ~ of
`~· lallfNMt'lli® ·~ 1000
`~ ·. w ~..,. ···-~-.;.....
`lOdlSt.. - - ~---~
`&.nuat ~· pritos: ·,u. .... ~·$550
`N. America. $61S OlllsUJcl K ~ ~
`'postate paid lit ~'W'l ,..,.,... at ad(cid:173)
`di\ionai Illlli1iJig o.rtc. • .., nr t tb Sea4 - - .
`dlal1les to ~ ~,. -
`-
`St.,
`Bellingham. WA 98225.
`Primed in the Vm.t'Sflt1es oa·~:,.,_.
`CCIIIId;alia.J~ . .lliili-:aE a-.
`prodt Pill*~.~.~ aeptS
`ta&-deduetible ~-~-support
`of its efforts .~ and to advance
`knowledae in
`ailCS oproe~ 8llPlied
`.
`science and ~· With special emphasis on
`educalion, SPIE amwally awards scholarships and
`publishes a gUide to opl:ics progrtlliiJ in colleges and
`universities an:IU8d the world. The Society has es(cid:173)
`tablished a fuad to support student travel to SPIE
`symposia and is facilitating donations of technical
`publications to educational institutions and libraries
`without access to this literature. For information on
`how you can contribute or participate in a deferred..
`giving program. please contact Sharon Kirkpalrick,
`SPIE Headquarters, P.O. Box 10, Bellingham, WA
`98227..()()10, 3601676-3290, Fax 360/647-1445,
`E-mail shsronk@spie.org.
`
`Energetiq Ex. 2021, page 2 - IPR2015-01277
`
`

`
`Optical pumping of the XeF(C-+A) and iodine
`1.315-pm lasers by a compact surface
`discharge system
`
`B. A. Knecht*
`R. D. Frasert
`D. J. Wheeler*
`C. J. Zietklewlczl
`A. A. Senln, MEMBER SPIE
`L. D. Mlkheevll
`V.S.Zuevll
`J. G. Eden
`University of Illinois
`Department of Electrical and Computer
`Engineering
`Laboratory for Optical Physics and
`Engineering
`Urbana, Illinois 61801
`
`Abstract. Details are provided regarding the design, construction, and
`performance of a compact ( ""0.6-m2 footprint), single-channel surface
`discharge system and its application to optically pumping the XeF( C
`-+A) and iodine atomic lasers in the blue-green ( =480 nm) and near
`infrared (1.315 }LITI), respectively. The system has a gain (active) length
`of ""50 em, and triggering the discharge requires no high-voltage or
`high-current switches. Measurements of the velocity of the photodisso(cid:173)
`ciation bleaching wave and the small-signal gain of the XeF(C-.A) sys(cid:173)
`tem are described. At 488 nm, the gain coefficient r was found to be
`... 0.3% cm- 1 , a value comparable to those reported previously for sys(cid:173)
`tems dissipating considerably higher power per unit length. Single-pulse
`energies >50 mJ from the XeF(C-.A) laser (-485 nm) and >0.7 Jon
`the 5p 2P112-+5p 2P312 transition of atomic iodine at 1.315 ,urn have been
`obtained with nonoptimized resonator output couplings (5% and 10%,
`respectively). The rate of erosion of the dielectric surface has been mea(cid:173)
`sured to be ... 0.1 to 0.3 ¢Tl/shot for a glass ceramic dielectric, and the
`performance of two electrical configurations for the ballasting pins
`(feedthrough and V) is compared. c 2003 Society of Photo-Optic81 tnstrtJmenta(cid:173)
`tion Engineers.
`[001: 10.111711.1624849]
`
`Subject terms: lasers; visible; optical pumping: surface discharge.
`
`Paper 030139 received Mar. 24, 2003; revised manuscript received Jun. 9, 2003;
`accepted for publication Jun. 10, 2003.
`
`Introduction
`1
`The surface discharge, an electric discharge at the interface
`of a gas and a solid dielectric, was first reported by G. C.
`Lichtenberg in 1777. Over the past three decades, renewed
`interest in surface discharges has been driven by potential
`applications in materials processing, 1 surface cleaning, 2•3
`waste remediation, and optical pumping of lasers by
`photodissociation,4- 6 all of which require intense sources
`of ultraviolet (UV) or vacuum ultraviolet (VUV) radiation.
`Excitation of lasers by a surface discharge is particularly
`attractive because of the ability of the optical source to
`produce quasi-blackbody radiation having a characteristic
`temperature above 3 X l<f K and to do so with a relatively
`simple system amenable to repetitively pulsed operation. In
`1975, Beverly5 proposed pumping the iodine photodisso(cid:173)
`ciation laser (5p 2P 112-+5p 2P312 ;A= 1.315 ~m) with a sur(cid:173)
`face discharge and subsequently measured efficiencies ap(cid:173)
`proaching 10% and 3% for the conversion of electrical
`
`*Present address: 662N 300W, Lebanon, IN 46052.
`tPresent address: Realized Technologies Inc., 1530 Barclay Blvd., Buffalo
`Grove, IL 60089.
`*Present address: National Center for Sueercomputing Applications
`(NCSA), University of Illinois, 605 E. Springfield, Champaign, lL 61820.
`'Present address: Melles Griot, 2605 Trade Center Avenue, Longmont,
`C080503.
`lpennanent address: P. N. Lebedev Physical Institute, Moscow, Russian
`Federation.
`
`power to optical radiation in the 250- to 290-nm and 170-
`to 210-nm spectral regions, respectively.7 Studies have also
`shown surface discharges to be effective sources of extreme
`ultraviolet (XUV; hw-10 to 70 eV) photons,3 and charac(cid:173)
`teristic radiation temperatures of ( 1 to 2) X 104 K are at(cid:173)
`tainable for specific energy loadings of the plasma of l to
`4 J cm- 2 (Ref. 5). In 1979, Belotserkovets et al. 8 demon(cid:173)
`strated lasing from atomic iodine when the molecular pre(cid:173)
`cursor, C3F7 I, was photolyzed by a surface discharge.
`Since that time, a variety of atomic and molecular lasers
`initiated or pumped entirely by a surface discharge have
`been demonstrated,4•9 but much of the effort has been di(cid:173)
`rected toward the XeF photodissociation laser, 10•11 partly
`because of the breadth of the absorption spectrum of the
`parent molecule, XeF2 • The other factors providing impe(cid:173)
`tus for the efforts on XeF are the two laser transitions that
`are available (B-+X and C-+A) as well as the large satu(cid:173)
`ration intensity of the C-+ A band in particular. 12 The latter,
`-400 kW cm- 2,
`is a direct reflection of both the C-A
`stimulated emission cross section (-9x 10- 18 cm2) and
`the e-state radiative lifetime (93±5 ns). 13
`In a series of papers published between 1984 and the
`early 1990s (Refs. 14 to 17), Kashnikov, Zuev and co(cid:173)
`workers reported the characteristics of a sequence of
`surface-discharge-pumped XeF laser systems producing as
`much as 174 J on the B-+ X transition of the molecule in
`
`3612 Opt. Eng. 42(12) 3612-3621 (December 2003) 0091-3286/20031$15.00 © 2003 Society of Photo-Optical Instrumentation Engineers
`
`Energetiq Ex. 2021, page 3 - IPR2015-01277
`
`

`
`Knecht et al.: Optical pumping ...
`
`the UV at 351 nm and up to 117 J in the blue-green ( C
`-+A transition, ). .... 485 nm). Consisting of individual dis(cid:173)
`charge sections, each typically 8 to 12 em in length and
`having a dedicated capacitor and high-voltage switch, these
`optical sources had active lengths ranging from 70 to 190
`em. The first system, reported by Kashnikov et al., 14 com(cid:173)
`prised eight discharge sections in a single-channel design
`and yielded a brightness temperature of = 3 X 104 K. By
`increasing the gain length to 190 em ( 16 discharge sec(cid:173)
`tions), raising the number of discharge channels to three,
`and with careful attention given to the current rise time and
`the purity of the XeF2 vapor, the Russian group subse(cid:173)
`quently produced single-pulse energies that are, to this day,
`unsurpassed for a primary coherent source in the visible. 17
`Despite the impressive characteristics of these lasers, in(cid:173)
`cluding the ability to operate at a pulse repetition frequency
`of 1 Hz, the system was quite large, and the dedication of a
`capacitor and high current switch to each discharge section
`introduced significant timing jitter ( <0.25 JJ-S). Further(cid:173)
`more, in low-impedance circuits of this type, switches con(cid:173)
`sume substantial energies and adversely affect the complex(cid:173)
`ity and lifetime of the system.
`In the mid-1990s, we reported the design and prelimi(cid:173)
`nary operation of a compact surface discharge system that
`successfully pumF.: the XeF(C-+A) and iodine photodis(cid:173)
`sociation Iasers. 1 •19 A more detailed account of the design
`and operation of this system and an alternative structure for
`the surface discharge ignition electrodes are presented here.
`Having an active length of '"'"50 em, this surface discharge
`system requires no high-voltage (or high-current) switches,
`which has the beneficial result of lowering the firing jitter
`as well as the equivalent series inductance for the system.
`Careful attention given to the design and layout of the de(cid:173)
`vice and the power generator has resulted in a rugged sys(cid:173)
`tem having a compact footprint ( .... 0.6 m2) and an overall
`size comparable to that of a commercial excimer laser. The
`small-signal gain on the C-+ A transition of XeF has been
`measured to be 0.3% em- 1 at 488 nm, a value virtually
`identical to those reported for surface discharge systems of
`considerably higher power loadings.
`This paper is organized as follows. Section 2 describes
`in detail the design of the electrical system and laser head
`for the device. Two approaches to igniting the surface dis(cid:173)
`charge, surface feedthrough (in-line) and V configurations,
`are presented and compared. The experimental results on
`the XeF(C-+A), XeF(B-+X), and atomic iodine (1.315
`JJ-m) lasers are discussed in Sec. 3, and Sec. 4 summarizes
`the conclusions of this study.
`
`2 Surface Discharge System: Design and
`Performance
`
`2.1 Background
`Previous designs of surface discharge systems can be
`broadly classified into two groups. The first are those in
`which the discharge occurs on a dielectric surface such as
`polyethylene, Teflon, or a ceramic9•14- 17 and the distanced
`between consecutive electrodes ranges from several centi(cid:173)
`meters to beyond 10 em. The practical upper limit on the
`discharge gap is dictated by the breakdown voltage for a
`given surface and the spatial instability of the discharge,
`
`Fig. 1 Schematic diagram of the feedthrough (in-line) electrical con(cid:173)
`figuration for igniting and sustaining a surface discharge. The Mo
`pins are ballasted capacitively and resistively, and the charging volt(cid:173)
`age is typically 30 kV. The dielectric surfaces explored to date are
`machinable glass ceramic, BN, and Al20 3 and SiC-coated surfaces.
`
`which rises dramatically with increasing d. If no accommo(cid:173)
`dations are made for triggering the discharge or preionizing
`the gap, charging voltages of ;;::: 15-30 kV are required,
`even for small gaps (d=2-3 em), to obtain an adequate
`radiation temperature. Systems with long gain lengths, such
`as the devices of Refs. 14 -17, having active lengths of
`0. 7-1.9 m, rely on discharge sections operated in tandem.
`Each section, typically 8-12 em in length, requires lO kV
`when the entire discharge is triggered by a 50-kV pulse
`applied to a cable lying beneath the dielectric surface. The
`device of Ref. 16, for example, had a gain length of 1.9 m
`as a result of 16 individual discharge sections, each 12 em
`in length.
`The second general category of devices relies on dis(cid:173)
`charges produced on the surface of ferrite rods or slabs.
`Producing a stable, intense surface discharge with these
`materials requires forming a channel in the ferrite, either by
`exploding a wire on its surface20 or by micrornachining a
`narrow channel (""' 150 JJ-m) by laser ablation. 21 Such de(cid:173)
`vices typically involve rods tens of centimeters in length
`(76 em in Ref. 20) and driven by a capacitor charged to 40
`to 50 kV. To summarize, realizing in a surface discharge
`system the gain lengths normally required for high-power
`laser operation (tens of centimeters} requires a means for
`spatially confining the discharge. Long path lengths can be
`obtained with ferrites once a channel has been established
`on the surface, or shorter discharge sections ( ... 10 em) can
`be combined in tandem to yield active lengths beyond 1
`20-24
`m.
`
`2.2 Electrical Design: Power Generator and
`Discharge Ignition Configurations
`The approach adopted for the experiments reported here
`offers a novel and robust scheme for establishing surface
`discharges over paths of arbitrary length and to do so with(cid:173)
`out the need to switch each section independently. In fact,
`no high-current or high-voltage switches are used at all.
`Rather, the discharge functions as its own switch.
`A schematic diagram of the first electrode configuration
`investigated is shown in Fig. 1. The key elements of this
`surface discharge device are: a ceramic substrate that runs
`parallel to the discharge axis, a main electrode at each end,
`and a series of intermediate electrodes between the main
`electrodes which divide the discharge path into segments.
`The critical feature of this design is the latter-a series of
`resistively and capacitively-ballasted molybdenum pins,
`which serve to both establish and stabilize the surface dis-
`
`Optical Engineering, Vol. 42 No. 12. December 2003 3613
`
`Energetiq Ex. 2021, page 4 - IPR2015-01277
`
`

`
`Knecht et al.: Optical pumping ...
`
`Fig. 3 Photograph of the surface discharge. The path length is
`48.5 em.
`
`waveform, recorded by a modified Rogowski coil for a
`charging voltage on the capacitor bank of 30 kV, is repre(cid:173)
`sentative of those observed throughout these experiments
`and shows that the current reaches its peak value of
`"""46 kA in =4 J.LS. The maximum current observed to date
`is >50 kA. Notice that the current waveform is essentially
`critically damped. indicating that the impedance of the ca(cid:173)
`pacitor bank nearly matches that of the surface discharge.
`This is a result of efforts from the earliest designs t<} mini(cid:173)
`mize the inductance of the power generator and laser head.
`Consequently, > 80% of the 2.5 kJ stored in the capacitor
`bank (for \-'= 30 kV) is deposited in the surface discharge
`in the first half cycle of the current waveform. For a power
`pulse having a temporal width of 5 J.LS (FWHM). this en(cid:173)
`ergy dissipation corresponds to a power deposition per unit
`length of discharge of ""'8 MW em-· 1 •
`The low overall inductance of the capacitor bank and
`electrical connections to the HV and ground electrodes
`manifested itself in an unusual way during the testing of
`this system. Early versions of the laser employed standard
`wire to connect the ballast circuitry to the intermediate
`electrodes. To facilitate the rapid assembly of the laser
`head, the wire was later replaced by short springs, but ex(cid:173)
`perience showed that it was necessary to carefully limit the
`number of turns in the coils. Otherwise, the inductive volt(cid:173)
`age drop produced across the spring resulted in arcing and
`severe damage to the coil and associated components.
`Although the primary purpose of the Mo pins is to en(cid:173)
`able the rapid formation of a surface discharge over a path
`of arbitrary length with a moderate voltage. the pin an-ay
`also serves to confine the discharge, thereby improving the
`shot-to-shot reproducibility with respect to previous surface
`discharge devices. Figure 3 is a photograph of the surface
`discharge viewed normal to the surface. Minor deviations
`from a straight path are evident, and the overall length of
`the surface discharge is 48.5 em.
`
`2.3 Laser Head: In-Line and V Configurations
`Side, frontal, and end-on views of the laser head with the
`in-line ballast pin array configuration described in the last
`section are illustrated schematically in Fig. 4. Each Mo pin
`was inserted into a cylindrical hole in the dielectric material
`and was mounted so that its tip was flush with the surface
`of the dielectric. For most of the experiments reported here.
`MACOR machinable ceramic served as the dielectric ma(cid:173)
`terial, but preliminary tests with pyrolytic boron nitride.
`alumina, and SiC-coated surfaces were also conducted. Be(cid:173)
`cause of its chemical stability in the presence of fluorine,
`Kynar® was the material from which the laser head was
`machined. The lower plate (not shown in Fig. 4) sealing the
`laser head was fabricated from a polycarbonate or alumi(cid:173)
`num. As noted earlier. both the main electrodes and the
`intermediate (pin) electrodes enter the laser head through
`the top and traverse the ceramic dielectric. The seal around
`the main electrodes consisted of a Kynar fitting having a
`
`Fig. 2 Oscillogram of the surface discharge current for a charging
`voltage of =30 kV. The horizontal (temporal) scale is 2 ,u.s/div, and
`the vertical scale is 20 kA/div.
`
`charge. All of the pins in the linear array were isolated from
`de ground by a !0-MO resistor and a 450-pF doorknob
`capacitor. For the first pin (trigger electrode), however, the
`capacitor was connected in series with the secondary of an
`air-core autotransformer, to which the trigger pulse was ap(cid:173)
`plied. The separation between the pins in the array, except
`that between the high-voltage (HV) and trigger electrodes
`was set at 12.7 mm (1/2 in.) to ensure that breakdown be(cid:173)
`tween two adjacent pins occurred at or below 30 kV when
`the gas pressure in the laser chamber was I atm. The gap
`between the HV electrode (left side, Fig. l) and the trigger
`electrode was set to 28 mm (designed to hold off 30 kV).
`Consequently. when the full supply voltage was impressed
`across the entire array (HV electrode to ground), break(cid:173)
`down does not occur in the absence of a trigger pulse.
`However, when a - 15 to - 18-k V trigger pulse is applied
`to the transformer primary, the voltage appearing on the
`firl't pin (trigger electrode) is -50 kV, and breakdown oc(cid:173)
`curs in the HV-electrode-trigger-electrode gap. As current
`begins to flow in this gap, the voltage at the trigger elec(cid:173)
`trode rises rapidly to a value slightly above 30 k V, owing to
`peaking effects. Since the second pin in the array is still at
`ground potential, the gap between the trigger electrode (pin
`I) and pin 2 now self-breaks. The remaining gaps in the
`array follow in quick succession, and within 5 J.LS of the
`application of the trigger pulse. a surface discharge is es(cid:173)
`tablished along the entire length of the array. A major ad(cid:173)
`vantage of this design is that the individual gaps are not
`triggered independently and, consequently, the firing jitter
`(with respect to the command trigger) is low. Furthermore.
`although negative trigger pulses were normally employed
`in the experiments described here, the use of an autotrans(cid:173)
`former reduces the sensitivity of the system to the polarity
`of the trigger (because of ringing in the secondary of the
`transformer), resulting i.n improved reliability and stability.
`Little of the energy stored in the capacitor bank (5.6 J-tF
`cf. Fig. l) is expended in forming the discharge, but the
`establishment of the surface discharge presents a low(cid:173)
`impedance path to ground. It is at this point that C 0 delivers
`virtually all of its stored energy to the discharge, resulting
`in rapid heating of the plasma and the generation of intense
`blackbody radiation. It should be mentioned that once the
`discharge is established, negligible current flows through
`the ballasting pins, which are etfectively decoupled from
`ground.
`Figure 2 is an oscillogram of the discharge current. ob(cid:173)
`tained with I atm of air in the laser head and a machinable
`glass ceramic (MACOR) serving as the dielectric. The
`
`3614 Optical Engineering. Vol. 42 No. 12, December 2003
`
`Energetiq Ex. 2021, page 5 - IPR2015-01277
`
`

`
`Knecht et al.: Optical pumping ...
`
`IH
`
`~I
`
`Fig. 4 Drawings (to scale) of the laser head, showing side (top),
`front (lower left), and end-on views of the Mo pin array, the HV and
`ground feedthroughs (at the left and right sides of the side and fron(cid:173)
`tal drawings, respectively), and the dielectric itself. For clarity, the
`lower plate of the laser head has been removed.
`
`tube boss seal on one end and a Swagelok®-compatible
`seal on the other. Both of the main electrodes themselves
`were machined from molybdenum (chosen for the purpose
`of minimizing material ablation per shot) and attached to an
`aluminum shaft that provided direct electrical contact to the
`capacitor bank. A detailed diagram of the main electrode
`feedthrough is provided in Fig. 5. Denoted C0 in Fig. 1, the
`capacitor bank comprises 44low-inductance (equivalent se(cid:173)
`ries inductance ""'50 nH) capacitors having a rated voltage
`of 40 kV and connected in paralleL The entire bank is
`mounted in an AI and polycarbonate enclosure that is quite
`compact. When fully assembled, the capacitor bank and
`laser head together have a footprint of only 0.6 m2 ( 150
`X -40 cm2), comparable to that for a commercially avail(cid:173)
`able excimer laser.
`The major drawback of the in-line intermediate elec(cid:173)
`trode design is the failure mode. Particulates formed by the
`discharge tend to become lodged around the electrodes and
`gradually migrate into the cylindrical cavities in the ce(cid:173)
`ramic substrate. Consisting of ablated ceramic material and
`ash produced when the plasma comes in contact with Ky(cid:173)
`nar, the particulates are weakly conductive. The result is an
`alternate discharge path between the main electrodes and
`the ground plane on the exterior of the laser head, a path
`that is no less favorable (from an electrical perspective)
`than the one intended. The diversion of current into this
`auxiliary channel produces strong heating of the intermedi(cid:173)
`ate electrode insulating sleeve and the surrounding ceramic,
`often resulting in damage to both the ceramic and the laser
`head. Periodic cleaning of the laser-head surfaces amelio(cid:173)
`rates this problem, and installing a closed-loop gas recircu(cid:173)
`lation system to trap particulates should largely eliminate it.
`Nevertheless, in an effort to bypass this difficulty
`through electrode design, a second electrode configuration,
`known as the V, was designed and demonstrated. End-on
`and frontal views of the V configuration are illustrated in
`Fig. 6. One asset of this design is that, by bringing the
`intermediate electrodes to the dielectric surface at an ob-
`
`Aluminum oonductor
`
`Kynar 1i:ecldlroucll
`
`TctlonslecM:
`
`Fig. 5 Diagram (to scale) of the main electrode feedthrough, show(cid:173)
`ing end-on (left) and side views of the assembly.
`
`Fig. 6 Front (upper panel) and end-on (lower panel) views of the V
`configuration for the intermediate electrodes (molybdenum pins). A
`portion of the main electrode assembly and the bottom plate for the
`laser head have, for clarity, been removed. Note that the upper and
`lower panels are not drawn to the same scale.
`
`lique angle and from alternating sides of the laser chamber,
`the fabrication and installation complexities associated with
`introducing electrodes through the dielectric are eliminated,
`and replacing the dielectric is greatly simplified. Further(cid:173)
`more, the distance between the electrode shanks on a given
`side of the laser chamber is maximized. Although this ap(cid:173)
`proach eliminated the damaging misfires experienced with
`the in-line configuration, particulates deposited on the laser
`chamber wall caused occasional flashover between the in(cid:173)
`termediate electrodes. Our experience is that this drawback
`can be rectified by periodic cleaning and, presumably, a
`particulate trapping system.
`Most of the experimental results presented in Sec. 3 for
`the XeF(C-*A) and iodine 1.3-pm lasers were obtained
`with the in-line and V configurations, respectively.
`
`2.4 Erosion of the Dielectric Surface
`A critical parameter determining the ultimate utility of op(cid:173)
`tically pumping atomic or molecular lasers with surface
`discharges is the lifetime of the dielectric surface itself. For
`this reason, several measurements of the surface erosion
`rate were made with the system operating at full power (2.5
`kJ stored, V= 30 kV). Figure 7 is a profile of the surface of
`a machinable glass ceramic (MACOR) dielectric, recorded
`with a microstylus (Dektak) after more than 500 shots of
`the system on the same surface. Representative of other
`profiles obtained during these tests, the data of Fig. 7 show
`the nearly symmetrical channel to have a peak depth of
`=50 pm and a FWHM of -0.8 em. Thus, the average
`erosion rate is :50.1 p.m/shot. Other tests confirm the re(cid:173)
`sults of Fig. 7. Specifically, for a MACOR dielectric, which
`has a nominal composition25 of -46% Si02 , 16% Al20 3 ,
`and 17% MgO, the measured erosion rates ranged from
`0.06 to 0.3 p.m shot- 1, and varied by < 60% along the dis(cid:173)
`charge path (i.e., axially). The data suggest that the erosion
`rate is largest for the first few tens of shots on a new di(cid:173)
`electric surface but quickly falls to :50.1 p.mshot- 1 there(cid:173)
`after. Preliminary tests with alumina (Al20 3) and SiC(cid:173)
`coated surfaces indicate that they will exhibit erosion rates
`
`Optical Engineering, Vol. 42 No. 12, December 2003 3615
`
`Energetiq Ex. 2021, page 6 - IPR2015-01277
`
`

`
`Knecht et al.: Optical pumping ...
`
`2cml
`~l
`
`J
`
`Fig. 7 Microstylus (Dektak) profile of a machinable glass ceramic
`dielectric surface after more than 500 shots of the laser system at
`full power. The FWHM of the eroded trench is -o.s em.
`
`approximately an order of magnitude smaller than these
`values, which will be required for an acceptable lifetime
`(>lOS shots for a single dielectric).
`
`2.5 Repetitively Pulsed Operation
`Although this system has been operated almost exclusively
`in the single-shot mode, it was designed and constructed so
`as to be capable of operation at pulse repetition frequencies
`(PRFs) of 1 to 5Hz. The issues that affect repetitive opera(cid:173)
`tion include rapid recharging of the capacitor bank, reliable
`holdoff and triggering characteristics, the continuous intro(cid:173)
`duction or recovery of laser fuel, clearing debris and par(cid:173)
`ticulates from the optical path and (as discussed earlier)
`electrode and dielectric surfaces, and maximizing the life of
`high-stress components. With respect to the former, the HV
`power supplies first used with this system · to charge the
`capacitor bank were a 30-kV, 10-mA system and, subse(cid:173)
`quently, an ALE model 152 L supply, rated at 40 kV and
`1.5 kJ s-t. The latter supply permitted recharging of the
`bank in less than 10 s, but introduced electrical transients
`that compromised the holdoff characteristics of the power
`generator and triggering circuitry. More recently, replacing
`the earlier power supplies with an ALE model 830 L unit
`( 40 k V, 8 kJ s- 1) has allowed for the capacitor bank, stor(cid:173)
`ing up to 4.5 kJ (for V=40 kV), to be charged in < 1 s. It
`should also be mentioned that the capacitors in the bank
`were rated conservatively. They were designed to operate
`up to 100 Hz and, largely because of the small degree of
`current reversal to which the capacitors are subjected dur(cid:173)
`ing each shot, have an expected survival of 90% after 108
`shots. Furthermore, tests indicate that prefiring of the sys(cid:173)
`tem is minimal for PRFs .eo; 5 Hz.
`A longitudinal flow system was also designed that al(cid:173)
`lows for replacing the gas mixture between shots. Although
`this subsystem has not as yet been tested, it provides for the
`removal of the fragments of the laser fuel molecular pre-
`
`3616 Optical Engineering, Vol. 42 No. 12, December 2003
`
`cursors and reconstitution of the gas mixture. For PRFs
`above ..., 5 Hz, transverse flow of the gas mixture will be
`required. In this regard, the laser head was designed to
`accommodate an array of gas flow ports, dispersed along
`the length of the surface discharge on both sides of the
`chamber, thereby allowing for gas flow along the coordi(cid:173)
`nate perpendicular to the axes of both the laser itself and
`the ballasting pins (cf. F

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket