throbber
Stuart J. Lipoff
`
`Mr. Lipoff is a consultant with a practice in TIME (telecommunications, information technology,
`media, electronics, and ebusiness). He draws upon his 40+ years of experience in a wide variety
`of technologies and industries to assist clients with knowledge based consulting services involving
`complex business decisions. Clients turn to him for his unique ability to combine a deep
`understanding of industry dynamics with his equal depth in the underlying technologies. Because
`he is at home in either the board room or the laboratory, the services he provides range from top
`line revenue enhancement to operations and capital efficiency improvement working across all
`levels of the client organization. His clients include component suppliers, equipment
`manufacturers, service providers, and those who make equity and debt investments in technology
`ventures. Typical assignments involve product development assistance, technology assessments,
`M&A corporate development, visioning the future, strategic planning, strategic business
`development support, competitive product positioning, change management, and overall business
`decision support.
`
`He has assisted clients evaluate product development plans and apply technologies in activities
`ranging from conceptual studies to detailed development and implementation of products,
`services, and strategies. Mr Lipoff has industry expertise in several high volume manufacturing
`operations in electronics, electromechanical, and related industries. He has assisted clients in
`strategic planning, managing their technology, improving the product development process,
`managing complex external procurements, and resolving problems in design, procurement, and
`manufacturing.
`
`Mr. Lipoff was employed 25 years by Arthur D Little, Inc (ADL) as VP and Director of
`Communications, Information Technology, and Electronics (CIE); 4 years by Bell & Howell
`Communications Company as a Section Manager, and 3 years by Motorola's Communications
`Division as a Project Engineer. At ADL he was responsible for the firm's global CIE practice.
`Under his leadership this CIE practice was the fastest growing and most profitable operation in
`the company growing at 30%/year and accounting for 25% of the net profit of the firm with less
`than 1% of the staff headcount. At both Bell & Howell and Motorola, he had project design
`responsibility for portable wireless communications and paging products.
`
`Stuart Lipoff has Bachelor's Degrees in Electrical Engineering and in Engineering Physics, both
`from Lehigh University. He also has received a Masters Degree in Electrical Engineering from
`Northeastern University, and a MBA degree from Suffolk University.
`
`Mr. Lipoff is a fellow of the IEEE Consumer Electronics, Communications, Computer, Circuits,
`and Vehicular Technology groups. He is an elected member of the IEEE Consumer Electronics
`Society National Administration Committee, and was the Boston Chapter Chairman of the IEEE
`Vehicular Technology Society. He served as 1996-7 President of the IEEE Consumer Electronics
`Society and is now Chairman of the Consumer Electronics Society Technical Activities and
`Standards Committee. He has also chaired the search committee for Sony supported Mazura
`Ibuka Award in consumer electronics. As Vice President and Standards Group Chairman of the
`Association of Computer Users, he served as the ACU representative to The ANSI X3
`Standards group. For the Federal Communications Commission's Citizens advisory committee on
`CB radio (PURAC), he served as Chairman of the task group on user rule compliance. He has
`been elected to membership in the Society of Cable Television Engineers (SCTE), The
`Association of Computing Machinery (ACM) , and The Society of Motion Picture and
`Television Engineers (SMPTE).
`
`Ex. 1003
`
`Page 1 of 11
`
`PETITIONER'S EXHIBIT 1003
`
`

`

`Stuart J. Lipoff
`
`Stuart Lipoff holds a FCC General Radiotelephone License and a Certificate in Data Processing
`(CDP) from the ACM supported Institute for the Certification of Computing Professionals
`(ICCP). He is a registered professional engineer (by examination) in The Commonwealth of
`Massachusetts.
`
`Mr. Lipoff holds seven USA patents and has published articles in Electronics Design,
`Microwaves, EDN, The Proceedings of the Frequency Control Symposium, Optical Spectra, and
`numerous IEEE publications. He has presented papers at many IEEE and other meetings. In the
`fall of 2000, he served as general program chair for The IEEE Vehicular Technology Conference
`on advanced wireless communications technology. He has organized sessions at The
`International Conference on Consumer Electronics and was the 1984 program chairman. He
`conducted an eight week IEEE sponsored short course on Fiber Optics Systems Design. In 1984,
`he was awarded IEEE's Centennial Medal and in 2000 IEEE's Millennium Metal.
`
`He is was member of the USA advisory board to the National Science Museum of Israel and has
`presented a short course on international product development strategies as a faculty member of
`Technion Institute of Management in Israel. He also served as a board member of The Massachusetts
`Future Problem Solving Program.
`
`Mr Lipoff is internationally recognized as an authority and opinion leader in new economy
`related businesses and technology. Citations supporting his recognition can be found on his web
`site at http://www.lipoff.org .
`
`Some examples of projects he has performed in the broadcasting, cable TV, computer products,
`consumer electronics, media, telecommunications, and wireless communications sectors include:
`
`• For Next Generation Network Architecture llc (NGNA llc) consortium of Comcast, Cox, and
`Time-Warner; he managed the project that produced a five year planning horizon vision for
`the services and technology the cable industry will seek to deploy. The services and vision
`were then mapped to overall architectures impacting network elements in the back office,
`head-end, outside plant, and customer premises and documented in next generation network
`recommendations. The project involved coordination with over fifty senior technical staff in
`the three cable MSO sponsors as well as interactions with over 100 suppliers of systems,
`software, and products to the cable industry. The recommendations and findings were wide
`ranging including, for example: software defined downloadable conditional access (CA)
`systems, migration of the outside plant from low to mid split, bridging from network CA to
`in-home network digital rights management systems (DRM), and migration from 1way to
`2way digital TV.
`
`• For a cable operator I am supporting exploration of alternative means to provide competitive
`public network wireless services to existing cable and new customers. The project involves
`exploring 3rd and 4th generation wireless air-interface technologies and developing models
`that integrate capital expenditures forecasts with operating profits to develop financial
`performance perspectives of alternatives. A unique aspect of this project includes developing
`technology forecasts and estimates of subscriber equipment capable of supporting video and
`multimedia content delivery to handsets.
`
`Page 2 of 11
`
`PETITIONER'S EXHIBIT 1003
`
`

`

`Stuart J. Lipoff
`
`• For the venture capital arm of The UN's World Bank (IFC), we supported the evaluation of
`an investment opportunity in a China based cellphone contract engineering and design firm.
`As a part of this project, he met with leading cellphone original design manufacturers
`(ODMs) and contract manufacturers in China to develop technology, feature, and volume
`forecasts for next generation cellphones.
`
`• Analysis and recommendations in a study funded by CableLabs which led to today's hybrid-
`fiber coax architecture widely deployed worldwide for delivering broadband multimedia
`services to the home. The project involved developing forecasts of technology trends in
`parallel with projecting the business applications. Detailed proforma financial models were
`developed to make the cost/benefit of deploying this technology visible to the cable industry,
`and strategies were developed and recommended to the industry.
`
`• Leadership of the project which developed the series of DOCSIS specifications for high
`speed residential cable modems. The scope of work included developing a roadmap and
`strategic framework for evolving the business from simple high speed internet services to
`multimedia broadband services combining voice, data, and secure electronic content delivery.
`This project was performed under contract to the MCNS consortium of cable TV operators
`representing 85% of the subscriber base in North America and has since been adopted by the
`United Nations as a global telecommunications standard.
`• For Tele2 (a pan European cellular and wireline telephone company), he supported their
`efforts to procure an advanced cordless telephone from contract manufacturers in China
`(PRC). This involved development of detailed technical specifications, coordination of a
`request for information, (RFI), and evaluation of the responses.
`• For Millicom International (a cellular provider in several developing nations), he studied
`capital spending and developed best practice benchmarks. The work products were then
`employed in forward planning and to develop strategies for improvement of their financial
`performance. The project involved the collection of data from over 25 systems in 12
`countries and developing capital efficiency metrics that were normalized to the specific
`geographic and demographic specifics of each system. The project not only provided a
`measure of present and historical capital efficiency but also provided a management system
`to be employed for the future.
`• For the banks providing financing to The Iridium Mobile Satellite Service, he served as a
`technical advisor and assisted in developing the contracts between the banks and Motorola in
`which Motorola secured the loan. As a technical advisor, he had extensive day-to-day
`interactions with Motorola's manufacturing and product design organization. The
`interactions included examination of the manufacturing cost, methods, and processes of
`Motorola's Subscriber Products Group cellfones, pagers, and related portable wireless data
`communications devices.
`• For Sony USA, he supported a feasibility analysis of a planned investment by Sony into a
`wireless PCS carrier in the USA. This involved the development of alternative business
`models, financial analysis, and technical analysis in order to determine financial attractiveness
`and risk of proceeding with the venture.
`• For Samsung Electronics Global Marketing, he developed a strategic framework for a line of
`portable and personal multimedia products to be introduced in The USA. The project
`
`Page 3 of 11
`
`PETITIONER'S EXHIBIT 1003
`
`

`

`Stuart J. Lipoff
`
`included developing a common theme for a set of products that ranged from cellphones, MP3
`music players, electronic books, PDAs, to hand-held games. One the common theme was
`developed, product features and capabilities were detailed and market adoption models were
`developed to forecast demand.
`• For Korea Mobile Telephone, he supported the project that developed a strategic plan to
`position KMT relative to Korea Telecom.
`
`• For Symbol Technology, a manufacturer of hand-held industrial computing products, he co-
`developed the protocol for a wireless local area network that was the basis for the current
`IEEE 802.11 wireless LAN standard. Latter he worked with this same client to selected voice
`over internet protocol (VoIP) codecs and algorithms that support the client's current product
`offering cordless industrial voice telephony over a quality of service (QoS) managed wireless
`IP network.
`
`• Leadership of the project for CableLabs that studied the technology and economics of
`wireless personal communications technology. This project is highlighted in the history of
`CableLabs in their website as one of the significant accomplishments of The Labs. The
`project included the selection of CDMA technologies and the development of strategies to
`compete with incumbent cellular carriers. This effort led to the formation of a consortium
`between Sprint and the cable MSOs that has evolved into the present Sprint PCS business.
`• Co-inventor of the Commercial Free™ technology widely licensed to major consumer
`electronics manufacturers and incorporated in nearly all high end video tape recorders
`(VCRs), personal digital video recorders (PVRs), and new released DVD video recorders.
`The technology employs artificial intelligence techniques to automatically recognize
`commercial segments and remove them upon the playback of time shifted recorded video
`program material.
`• For Rockwell Semiconductor, he supported a major project to identify and explore
`diversification opportunities beyond their current line of fax modems and compression chips.
`The project identified opportunities in wireless communications, broadband enterprise
`networks, and video signal processing. After identification of the opportunities, market
`forecasts were developed, competitors identified, and an analysis of the attractiveness versus
`fit with Rockwell was performed to support a request for board approval of diversification
`plans.
`• For Cambridge Silicon Radio (UK), he worked with the client to develop a prioritized list of
`applications for their Bluetooth component offerings. The project mapped applications into
`specific target customers and based upon an analysis that considered the market needs with
`CSR's capabilities, a prioritized roadmap of products was developed to steer the R&D
`portfolio.
`• TCE markets cordless telephones in the USA under the GE Brand Name. The introduction
`of cost and size reduced imported products had an unexpected and immediate negative impact
`on market share. he was retained to develop modifications to the existing product to size
`reduce the existing product by reworking the existing inventory as well as develop a next
`generation product for new production. The project involved a combination of industrial
`design, antenna design, modification of the impedance matching electronics for the new
`antenna, and re-qualification of device under FCC regulations as a low power unlicensed
`(cid:3)
`
`Page 4 of 11
`
`PETITIONER'S EXHIBIT 1003
`
`

`

`Stuart J. Lipoff
`
`communications device. The large telescoping antenna was replaced with a center loaded size
`reduced flexible antenna. An additional printed circuit board was designed and fabricated to
`tune and match the new antenna to the existing cordphone transceiver. Additional
`modifications to the transmitter involving component changes were developed to increase the
`transmitter power to overcome the additional loss in the loaded antenna. Manufacturing
`process sheets were designed and implemented in the factory to support the rework of the
`existing inventory. Engineering change orders were prepared for a new product design that
`included the changes on a single unified printed circuit board.
`• For the flash memory global marketing group of Samsung, he led a project that explored the
`opportunities for flash member in the emerging group of personal multimedia devices. These
`PMM devices ranged from PDAs, MP3 players, electronic books, to enhanced cellphones.
`The project developed visions and roadmaps for the rollout of these products and then
`translated this to the specific flash memory needs. A key aspect of the project was to
`determine the digital rights management and intelligence needs of the flash memory as content
`storage media. The analysis drove the Samsung developments and led to their participation in
`the SD flash consortium.
`• For TRW, he participated in an assignment which reviewed all their non-classified military
`and defense technology to identify commercial applications. A number of systems
`applications in security for wireless communications and antifraud were developed which
`became the basis for successful spin-off operations. In addition, this project examined their
`GaAs design and production capabilities. The project resulted in foundry business for the
`GaAs fab in large volume consumer applications for direct to home satellite TV receivers.
`• For a corporate cross sector event organized by Motorola Corporate for all their divisions, he
`prepared presentations on the visions of the future in each of the major sectors in which
`Motorola has an interest. The presentations included: consumer electronics, medical,
`automotive, industrial electronics, and communications. The presentations provided a basis
`for the cross sector teams to engage in long term planning for each division.
`• For a manufacturer of hand-held industrial computing products, he co-developed the protocol
`for a wireless local area network that was the basis for the current IEEE 802.11 wireless LAN
`standard. Latter he worked with this same client to selected voice over internet protocol
`(VoIP) codecs and algorithms that support the client's current product offering cordless
`industrial voice telephony over a quality of service (QoS) managed wireless IP network.
`• For a large multinational cellular service provider he performed a review of their capital
`efficiency. The project involved the collection of data from over 25 systems in 12 countries
`and developing capital efficiency metrics that were normalized to the specific geographic and
`demographic specifics of each system. The project not only provided a measure of present
`and historical capital efficiency but also provided a management system to be employed for
`the future.
`
`Page 5 of 11
`
`PETITIONER'S EXHIBIT 1003
`
`

`

`Stuart J. Lipoff
`
`• Whistler is generally known as a large volume manufacturer of radar detectors sold to
`consumers to avoid speeding violations. He was retained to develop a new recreational
`marine product called Brite Buoy. This product was a two part battery powered system
`consisting of a floating radio receiver that operates a flashing lamp and a handheld coded radio
`transmitter operating at 900MHz that activates the lamp. The product was designed to allow
`a boat owner to find their mooring in the evening. He designed the unit to make maximum use
`of the existing radar receiver IF section in order to allow the benefits of large volume purchase
`of common components as well as reduce risk and time to market. He designed and
`developed a SAW Filter stabilized transmitter incorporating low cost modulators used in
`garage door openers. The unit was design for manufacture using the clients existing high
`volume automated surface mount assembly lines.
`• For Bell&Howell, he led the team that developed a digital radio paging product employing
`thick film hybrid RF and custom baseband integrated circuits. The project was designed for
`high volume manufacture using in-house production systems.
`
`Page 6 of 11
`
`PETITIONER'S EXHIBIT 1003
`
`

`

`Stuart J. Lipoff
`Litigation Support Projects as a Disclosed Expert
`Current as of January 2015
`
`• Provided expert report and testified at ITC hearing as technical expert, retained by
`Samsung in the case captioned below:
`The United States International Trade Commission
`Investigation No. 337-TA-882
`In the Matter of CERTAIN DIGITAL MEDIA DEVICES, INCLUDING
`TELEVISIONS, BLU-RAY DISC PLAYERS, HOME THEATER SYSTEMS,
`TABLETS AND MOBILE PHONES, COMPONENTS THEREOF AND
`ASSOCIATED SOFTWARE
`Complainants: Black Hills Media, LLC
`Respondents: Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd.
`
`• Provided expert reports and deposition testimony on invalidity and rebuttal to
`infringement, retained by Comcast et al as a technical expert in the case captioned below:
`The United States District Court, Eastern District of Texas, Marshall Division
`Civil Action No. 2:11-CV-30 (DF)
`In the Matter of United States Patent Number 5,563,883
`Plaintiffs: C-Cation Technologies, LLC
`Defendants: Comcast Corporation, Charter Communications, Inc., cequel
`Communications, LLC dba Suddenlink Communications, Cable One, Inc.,
`Almega Cable Inc., Longview Cable Television Company, Inc., and Kilgore
`Video, Inc
`
`• Provided expert reports on invalidity and rebuttal to infringement, retained by Apple in
`the case captioned below:
`The United States District Court, Eastern District of Texas, Tyler Division
`Civil Action No. 6:10-cv-74-LED-JDL
`In the Matter of Certain Digital Set-Top Boxes Components Thereof
`Plaintiffs: Smartphone Technologies LLC
`Defendants: LG Electronics Inc, LG Electronics USA, Inc, Apple Inc, and AT&T
`Mobility LLC
`
`• Provided expert report and presented tutorial at ITC hearing as technical expert,
`retained by Apple in the case captioned below:
`The United States International Trade Commission
`Investigation No. 337-TA-808
`In the Matter of Certain Electronic Devices with Communication Capabilities,
`Components Thereof, and Related Software
`Complainants: HTC Corporation
`Respondents: Apple Inc
`
`Page 1
`
`Page 7 of 11
`
`PETITIONER'S EXHIBIT 1003
`
`

`

`Stuart J. Lipoff
`Litigation Support Projects as a Disclosed Expert
`Current as of January 2015
`
`• Provided expert report and testified at ITC hearing as technical expert, retained by
`Cablevision in the case captioned below:
`The United States International Trade Commission
`Investigation No. 337-TA-712
`In the Matter of Certain Digital Set-Top Boxes Components Thereof
`Complainants: Verizon Services Corporation and Verizon Communications Inc.
`Respondents: Cablevision Systems Corporation
`
`Provided declarations as a technical expert, retained by Comcast in the case captioned
`below:
`
`The United States District Court for the Eastern District of Viginia, Norfolk
`Division
`Civil Action No. 2:11 CV 103 RAJ/TEM
`Plaintiffs: Bear Creek Technologies, Inc
`Defendants: Comcast Corporation et al
`
`• Provided declarations and expert report as technical expert, retained by Active Video in
`the case captioned below:
`The United States District Court for The Eastern District of Virginia, Norfolk
`Division
`Civil Action No. 2:10-cv-248 RAJ/FBS
`Plaintiffs: Active Video Networks Inc
`Defendants: Verizon Communications Inc., Verizon Services Corp.
`Verizon Virginia Inc. and Verizon South Inc.
`
`• Provided expert report and deposition testimony as a technical and industry expert,
`retained by eleven member joint defense group in the case captioned below:
`The United States District Court for The District of Maryland, Southern Division
`Civil Action No.8:07-cv-03012-AW (D.Md.)
`Plaintiffs: Technology Patents LLC
`Defendants: Deutsche Telekom AG et al: AT&T Mobility LLC, Microsoft
`Corporation, Yahoo! Inc., Sprint Nextel Corporation, Motorola, Inc., Palm, Inc.,
`Samsung Electronics Co., LTD., Samsung Telecommunications America LLP,
`LG Electronics Mobilecomm U.S.A., Inc., Helio, LLC, Clickatell (PTY) LTD.,
`Cellco Partnership (d/b/a Verizon Wireless), and T-Mobile USA, Inc.)
`
`• Provided declarations as a technical expert, retained by BigBand Networks in the case
`captioned below:
`
`Page 2
`
`Page 8 of 11
`
`PETITIONER'S EXHIBIT 1003
`
`

`

`Stuart J. Lipoff
`Litigation Support Projects as a Disclosed Expert
`Current as of January 2015
`
`The United States District Court for The District of Delaware
`Civil Action No. 07-351 (JJF)
`Plaintiffs: BigBand Networks, Inc.
`Defendants: Imagine Communications, Inc.
`
`• Provided declarations as a technical expert, retained by Romek Figa in the case
`captioned below:
`The United States District Court for The District of Massachusetts
`Civil Action No. 08-cv-10304-NG
`Plaintiffs: Romek Figa d/b/a Abraham & Son
`Defendants: Apple Inc
`
`• Provided declarations as a technical and industry expert, retained by ODS Technologies
`in the case captioned below:
`The United States District Court Central District of California, Western Division
`Civil Action No. CV 07-03265 DDP (RCx)
`Plaintiffs: ODS Technologies, L.P., d/b/a TVG Network, and ODS Properties, Inc
`Defendants: Magna Entertainment Corporation; HRTV, LLC., ; and Xpressbet,
`Inc
`
`• Provided expert report and declarations as a technical and industry expert, retained by
`Motorola in the case captioned below:
`The United States District Court for the District of Delaware
`Civil Action No. 07-752-GMS
`Plaintiffs and Counter-Defendants: Motorola, Inc., ET AL
`Defendants and Counter-Plaintiffs: Rembrandt Technologies, LP, ET AL
`
`• Provided expert report and deposition testimony as a technical and industry expert,
`retained by Amino Communications in the case captioned below:
`The United States District Court, Central District of California
`Civil Action No. CV-07-1829
`Plaintiffs: Amino Communications, LLC
`Defendants: Guest-Tek Interactive Entertainment, LTD, Guest-Tek Inc, and
`DOES 1 through 10
`
`• Provided expert report and deposition testimony as a liability industry expert, retained
`by JTMD and Ascion in the case captioned below:
`The United States District Court, District of Massachusetts
`Civil Action No. 07-CV-10207-RGS
`Plaintiffs: L& P Property Management Company and Legget & Platt Incorporated
`Defendant: JTMD, LLC d/b/a Reverie, and Ascion, LLC
`
`• Provided deposition testimony as an liability expert, retained by National
`Semiconductor in the case captioned below:
`
`Page 3
`
`Page 9 of 11
`
`PETITIONER'S EXHIBIT 1003
`
`

`

`Stuart J. Lipoff
`Litigation Support Projects as a Disclosed Expert
`Current as of January 2015
`
`The Superior Court of California, County of Santa Clara
`Civil Action No. 1 -02-CV8 1 0872
`Plaintiff: Itech Group, Inc.
`Defendant: National Semiconductor Corporation
`
`• Provided expert report, deposition, and trial testimony as a liability technical expert,
`retained by Charter Communications in the case captioned below:
`The United States District Court, Eastern District of Texas, Marshall Division
`Civil Action No. 2-05-CV-436
`Plaintiff: Hybrid Patents Incorporated
`Defendant: Charter Communications, Inc.
`
`• Provided expert report and deposition testimony as a liability industry expert, retained
`by Lutron in the case captioned below:
`The United States District Court, District of Utah
`Case No. 2:03-CV-00488TC
`Plaintiff-Counter defendant: Vantage Controls, Inc.
`Defendant-Counter plaintiff: Lutron Electronics Co., Inc.
`
`• Provided expert report and trial and deposition testimony as a liability industry expert,
`retained by Telewizja Polska in the case captioned below:
`The United States District Court, Illinois, Eastern Division
`Civil Action No. 02-C-3293
`Plaintiffs: Telewizja Polska USA
`Defendant: EchoStar SateIlite
`• Provided expert report and deposition testimony as a liability technical expert, retained
`by Broadcom in the case captioned below:
`The United States District Court, Eastern District of Texas, Sherman Division
`Civil Action No. 4:03CV159
`Plaintiffs: Broadcom Corporation
`Defendant: Microtune (Texas), L.P.
`
`• Provided expert report, deposition testimony and trial testimony as a damages expert,
`retained by IPPV and MAAST in the case captioned below:
`The United States District Court For the District of Delaware
`Civil Action No. 99-577-RRM
`Plaintiffs: IPPV Enterprises, LLC and MAAST, Inc.
`Defendant: EchoStar Communications Corp
`
`• Provide expert report and deposition testimony as a damages expert, retained by the
`TVJCOM in the case captioned below:
`The United States District Court For the Middle District of Florida.
`Case No. 3:OO-CV-1045-5-2 1 A
`Plaintiffs: TVJCOM International, Inc.
`
`Page 4
`
`Page 10 of 11
`
`PETITIONER'S EXHIBIT 1003
`
`

`

`Stuart J. Lipoff
`Litigation Support Projects as a Disclosed Expert
`Current as of January 2015
`
`Defendants: Mediaone of Greater Florida, Inc., Canal Plus Technologies, S.A.,
`Canal Plus U.S. Technologies, Inc., and Societe Europeene de Controle D'Acces
`
`• Provided expert report and deposition testimony as a liability expert, retained by Sony
`in the case captioned below:
`The United States District Court for the Eastern District of New York
`Civil Action No. 92-01 28-ARR (Consolidated), Civil Action No. 91 -5056-ARR
`Plaintiffs: Loral Fairchild Corporation
`Defendants: Sony Company of Japan, LTD.
`
`• Provided expert report and deposition testimony as a liability expert, retained by
`General Instrument in the case captioned below:
`The United States District Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania
`General Instrument Corporation v. Scientific-Atlanta, Inc.
`Civil Action No. 91 -6923
`Plaintiffs: General Instrument Corporation
`Defendants: Scientific-Atlanta, Inc.
`
`Page 5
`
`Page 11 of 11
`
`PETITIONER'S EXHIBIT 1003
`
`

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket