UNITED STATES DISTRICT OOIITI'
`DISTRICT OF NEW JERSEY
`
`K
`
`NEI'2PI-mE, "In.
`PIa'nfiIf,
`
`U.
`EBAY, "53., SKYPE 'I'E'JHI'IDLWIES, 81%.,
`SKYPE, IIIKL, a’ld JOI-N DUES 1—10,
`Defianda’fls.
`
`Sammy 10, 211i?
`111 pm.
`Vailme 2
`
`Vllecflpetl deposilim afSl-IAIIE MA'ITAWAY,
`mmhnoflte, Men by PIai'IIiIfs,
`dflflBrilieIl KeyDriue, IIa'rI', FkII'iIh,
`More Kali Ann Wilis, a Reg'stenxl
`
`Repflterall mPuflic lifl'l'nand
`furmeStakadFk‘xilh.
`
`A P P E A R A N c E &
`IIIII'ILIJAIIIS 8. CONNOLLY, LLP
`Annmew for Phiiiit
`725 TweIIII'I Skeet, N_W_
`Waflliighn [)c ZDIIIS
`BY: NICHOLAS .I. BOYLE. E80. and
`KEVIN HARDY, E90.
`and—
`EIJJOT ROTHSTEIN, ESCL, In—I‘Kmse mm, IDT.
`
`IREI_L&MAIIEI_LA, LLP
`AmnmewforiheDefemmIs
`1000 Avenue (111198135
`Su'teQm
`LusAngeIeaCA 9006?
`BY: ALANHENRICH,ESQ_
`
`IN DEX
`Culiirlued Eminfim by Mr. Heinrich
`ExamilafinnbyMLBuer
`
`—
`
`180
`
`Hanoi-hmM
`
`:0
`
`10
`11
`12
`13
`
`14
`15
`16
`
`17
`
`111
`
`19
`
`NEBHEB
`
`-L
`
`10
`11
`12
`13
`14
`
`15
`16
`17
`111
`19
`
`NEBNEB
`
`178
`
`.-
`
`1|]
`11
`
`12
`13
`
`14
`
`15
`1B
`1?
`1B
`
`EEBBEBE
`
`Iflfi-‘JQLfl-th-I
`—|—|—|—h—hbun-ID
`
`15
`
`179
`
`Maltaway, Shane v. 2 9I10I2007 9:00:00 AM
`181)
`
`E X H I B I T S
`[ESCRIPTIGII
`My Exl‘itil 4 fl!"
`Iderllificdhn, US Plant
`6,108,704.}
`
`PAGE
`1110
`
`[Mammy Exl‘l'til 5 fl!"
`23 mm, US Pate“
`6,108,704 h'Btory, Bates Ms.
`SKYPE—NZP m1!) Ihmug'l 290904.}
`
`1111]
`
`[Mdta‘lray Exl‘l'til 6 fix
`Idenlificdhn, US Pdent
`6,131,121.}
`
`214
`
`[WBfimTfix
`lderlIiIimIiurLSou'ceCode,
`Bakessh'rpadCBSBBfi—BBSJ—m‘ned
`
`250
`
`[mum Exl‘l'tilsfw
`Idenlificdiln, Mmmsm
`businsa devehfl'mrl, Bates stair]!!!
`CBS 54—56.]—retai’led
`
`2'68
`
`181
`
`[This Blhebag'nn'ngoqume 1}
`WMMMMMMM
`mumnmumm
`mmulmiaua}
`THE VIDEOGRAPHER: Wealemihe mm.
`CONTINUED EXAMINATION
`BYMRHEIIIRICH:
`
`Q. Welmmebaclt, Mr. mm.
`A. mm“.
`0. lmgnhgmnmsfmmmlmrfll
`mmdasmyEmbfltmuliaUSPateran.
`B,108,?04;aflrmamgnighshwymml
`minimatedasEmibilNo.5,Michisflefle
`historyfur US Pm"! No. 6,113,704, and min I'Ie
`Bans mmlnls SKYPE—NZ‘P "10 mm 290904.
`MR.BOYLF_' Dnyulhaueuxiies?
`THEIMTIIESS: lmtowkmflbekxel
`camehem.
`
`MRI-EIIRICH: ldnrrmreamoffl‘e
`mmmlddmbfluumiea
`MR.BOYLF_' Egflpoi'llm.
`BYMR.HEIIIRICH:
`
`Q. SofiMstarIirgwifl‘lmeTMpatai,
`EmisaUnhdStatespataimatmaremmadas
`minVHMrun?
`
`Ebay_Ne12Phone
`
`Page 173— 181
`
`Page 1 of 29
`
`LG Electronics Exhibit 1011
`
`

`

`182
`
`Maltaway, Shane v. 2 91012007 9:00:00 AM
`184
`
`A Solsays.
`Q. Dnyulrewgizemsasmemm
`Wammmnmasmemiwem?
`A lseenwme. llsafi'Poiltlnmin
`WWI."
`
`0. Nldymreuimdlhispmllh
`mmfixymrdeposifim?
`A lfimldnyeah.
`0. Mnemh'fliarmmmemfled
`n'fllhrafflispflml‘?
`EBOYLE Ohiecfim,vag.le.
`TI'EWITNEE Tommflflrmnfla
`
`WMJH
`BYNIlI'EINRICH:
`
`lluuldliietocalymrmlnfl‘e
`Q.
`flefisttxynm,wewillgohackhlte?04pahfll
`inafewn'im BllifyaumuldhlmmPage
`mmuhmmmsanmmm
`mm
`
`hparlimlewwlflltemIMmynur
`Mmmmmmmmma
`Mmmmflmmmhfl‘em
`mm.
`Doyulreungizefl'lisasaduflaafim
`Mynumbmitedhfl'eufltedstatesfitem
`
`Olfiue?
`A No.
`
`Q. WelLlefllumbPagemTa. Daynu
`mnmmfimmmmmm?
`A Yes. Thaleilis.
`
`Q. Dnymmuemyremnmdwflflflm
`signdlfisdmmelfl?
`A NnYuIMH'eiflmmizedl Mn,
`ldim‘lreumrizel
`Q. Nubymsigranlmwumdedarhg
`Malldlhemishllifidechafimm
`
`dywromhmhflgemdegmdfl'fldl
`mmmflemiflmflimmdlnliefare
`
`beiwedmbemmflflllufl‘erj‘me
`mmmmflewimlhelmmmgeflflwilml
`uses-Emismdlheikemmimlew
`filealdirplisunment?
`InllBOYLE lunsgnhgmobiedmlhe
`mmflflifllimmflm
`TI'EWITNEE mmfllelast
`Wheresafi'lmmdwamafl
`statenIeanadehHehamM'mdl
`mya'gml Snumlbelievedfl‘ern
`tobelme.
`
`mm-mlmm-th-L
`8200283333333n:a
`mm-qmm-hwn-L
`NEEINEBEE-fiaaififiia
`
`{HG-‘nlelLfl-th-I
`dad—sad...-Hamburg-La
`
`1B
`
`lflfi-dafimhuN-I
`d—hd—L—h—h—h—hHamburg-La
`
`1B
`
`BYMR.HEI|I?ICH:
`
`Q. Snusig’lulmis,mededflafim,ym
`whifledflislnfl‘euitedstflesPaterlOflite
`
`WWIWMMMW
`A. W89.
`0. Solmldlltekldlectmrafierfinn
`tollemidpa'agaph—
`A W3.
`0. —w1myuurelermlhemnuepfimofme
`Wwflwm. Dnymseelml‘?
`A. Yeah.
`
`Q. WMimmwhjafimfier
`unremreferrhgmmere?
`A ldnn'llum. Matalewetalingabwl?
`Ywmmuflmmm
`Q. Solwilflahrqmmdmisisflun
`mefilehismryuf—
`A. TI‘I'spflanL
`Q. —flle'?04pflnt
`MR.BOYLF_' Tubefa'rJulhauegiumlim
`severalfunfleflmarflynuaeaflmgfim
`abmrlunesinyepageinlhenidfledfl'fl.
`MR. I-EIIRICH: l'mask'lu ama
`dmmmmwmmme
`pataflnlfice.
`
`MR.BOYLF_' ‘l'hatishfl‘en'iddleafa
`
`Muffins.
`THEVb‘IThESS:Ilseemsh1.|emme, No.3.
`BYMR.HEIII?IICH:
`
`0. Okay. Snfl‘fllwaslheinmfimalhjed
`mailerfl'flmmrefeningk)?
`MR.BOYLF_' Washedmdmma‘l.
`THEVHTMESS: Ynu meanmatmisis
`
`mm?
`BYMR.HEIII?IICH:
`
`0. Yes. matwuaremrighinyulr
`mummufim
`A Ilsafifflterammberofmksofme
`methinmfimwhjedmfierfm
`misismnrermyreferflngmflepohmmfl
`lntenflmmflpatertmchmfinglnysz
`Pam! NI). 6,1m,?04, ifdl unhis HES mater,
`mmfllmtodealuflmmeumtafldfllifipatat
`Q. Snuwldyuumcphhmmhmrm
`Wm—
`A- REN—
`O. —flmflniwufiuewbiwmisaf
`0113mm
`MR.BOYLF_' Washedmdmma‘l.
`THE WITNESS: Welthapderrlmrlaf
`
`1B
`
`185
`
`Ebay_Ne12Phone
`
`Page 182- 185
`
`Page 2 of 29
`
`

`

`186
`
`Maltaway, Shane v. 2 91012007 9:00:00 AM
`188
`
`Whrhelf. I'mMapaHnmrley,
`mdaflingn'etogiueymmhtenxetafim
`is—mhm,ynumreadflmselfafl
`mmmmmmmmm
`mdlhewnmsedmis—medairsufflis
`patentalamaleynuaslhgmtogiuewu
`rnyup'liunafi?
`BYNRI'EINRICH:
`
`0. mummmmm
`n'fllhrisoffl‘empmll?
`A Yes,hanmerfll10,000—fuot
`unflemtafl'llgyed'l.
`Q.
`ledynupleaseeaqfinfl'flmme?
`A lllilruxlilhyw.
`'Abstl'act Apnii—m-poifllm
`plum. mmmafldm
`WWUanME-ha
`mmmimmm
`mmmhmm
`'Afirstpnirl—m-lnilllmplm
`inmstephshrighadammmcfivelP
`Mdasetofpmhgmismm
`unimsflusmmpeclmmelmnetfl,
`umsmifilgamewfiunaflstpmcessirgunlm
`ammmmmmmemlmm
`
`afflesemndflncessirgurflaflretievemelP
`Mflmemfluflfiunflndmmhg
`unmafinnmrhmmflnmm
`afaposivemlilestaflsdmemupmcessing
`unlforesflfliihhgamifl-h—pnfl
`mmrmnicafimslhk:
`
`Andldmireeflhl‘eaflalyfllrfl'ler,“
`Misfi‘egistolmispatat
`Q. Dnymmuemyunflemtmdhgdmatme
`inmfiuealhjedmfierisdmemm
`www.mjmfl‘eabstmdaffln
`patent?
`A Wel,mael'tailly. Aamlh’mjls
`MJTWJISEJGD.
`Q. Cwldynuteln'elfatymrmmhg
`isufli‘eiwerliuewbiwmrdmem
`patelfllifluflreaaigmnmmmatismu‘epage
`hale?
`
`A lramexph'nedflfllmywhynurflior
`immaflmmifimstomasmhmme
`mafimmmmatimmfliHEm
`used.
`
`Trisispstbasicalymmewmara—
`Mfimmmmmmmdarfln
`
`n'efllxlobgieshwvedinesuiishhgfl'fl
`
`mm-mlmm-th-L
`8200283333333n:a
`mm-qmm-hwn-L
`NEEINEBEE-fiaaififiia
`
`{HG-‘nlelLfl-th-I
`—|—|—|—h—h—|LH-th-LD
`
`1B
`1?
`1B
`
`lflfi-dafimhuN-I
`d—hd—L—h—h—h—hHamburg-La
`
`1B
`
`pnii—m-poillmecfinnmmglamedinn
`www.mismlymflis. Stephysmp.
`Nndilfemflflnlmatllflvedreadymldm
`Q. Wel,ldim‘lafl(ymlam.flllem
`militirnnm'ng.
`A. Mmmmkisbasnllyamilhfim
`ofevenflhigleukedamnmfarmismnhg,
`BMW-IBM-
`Q. mm—HI,MMmmme
`claim.WMdm'lmmaboltatdim1_
`A. Michis?
`
`Q. WhichismPagem.
`A. $9. Chim1. Okay.
`Q. Altlifynuumlldjustreajmflto
`wiser.
`A. any.
`0. AmwumiMrdchimfl
`MR.BOYLF_' mwhmrabgfl
`mndusim.
`THEWITIESS: Amllmiwumr.
`
`manymnmbym‘ywrdemifim
`afi'nlentul‘! lsflfl'epel'sunlmoimlemais
`Mmeumueivesdl? Wale
`wutalingamul?
`
`EWMR.HEIIRJCH:
`
`Q. Lemmrtulhwmpfinn. Didyuu
`mmofcla'mfi
`
`MR.BOYLF_' Objedim. Cdlsforalegal
`mndusim.
`
`THEVHTMESS: lnmerald'npflt.
`no. lmldhauemsaymatelelmjflmm
`saidmmywkrm—wumuwflhman
`ideafurmtablishiumemflmmit'way
`mmMm,we5tartedadlfllyme
`mmllusingu‘ePOPmisMHis
`emlxldied 'll 1, Ital implementafiun.
`Myarmihrfimflnreaflarwmlflm
`beetlJnulIlmABumsiunswimGlerndfl'fl
`firemmemafiermatynum,mnfly—
`mmumwmmmmm
`
`erndlispreflythmskn,auwremim
`nemtoberealire.
`
`thammyuqulmfim,amlme
`mneeiuerafi? Ashrasmem
`
`Mm,m_ Amllheumueivenf
`litemlyavniuemerleMBsystemmat
`doespoilllnmill? llauldffluetosayyes.
`Myumhimlimhfiaywkrm,
`
`18?
`
`1.
`
`Ebay_Ne12Phone
`
`Page 186- 189
`
`Page 3 of 29
`
`

`

`Wmswihelemperfinmm
`1
`2 mmmmmmm
`3
`nmnecfimsewices. mmatis,wululaw,
`4
`mathlmrrrymm.kilmllaslm
`5
`g‘veymune.
`B
`BYNRHEINRICH:
`T
`0. Soismereapafiwhrelemenlnf
`B
`dain1li‘atymmdi’edn'etoa1dsaymlmxl
`9 mnhhxtedmflispa'fiwhremmdchinfl
`10
`IRBOYLE Ohiecfim,cal5knralagal
`11
`0mm.
`12
`THEWITNESE Wel,dlolcla'm1l
`13 www.mmmIm—I
`14
`luuldsaylhemnuepfimofhwmget—me
`15
`mnceflimaffl'emedinnsewiuemuessin
`16
`chim1wasGlelln'sbmmhes-AHMJ
`1?
`Memideaammmgetmeminm
`19
`pu'It'
`19
`mmmmmalmnmmtedm
`20
`armchgflmtmnmcfimsewizepnrtimd
`21
`chim1. Mallinal,ddm1pleuymum
`22 mmmmmammm
`23
`mnnecfimviaamncfimsenmrasakmhp
`24
`mechanism.
`25
`MdagdaneliaBIHme-imm
`
`ulmataswell,mdilr.,ywkrm,firfl
`1
`errbotiment
`2
`BY MR. HEINRICH:
`3
`Q. Snwushbdflflmmh
`4
`5 winning [hem sandal: pollinn at cla'm 1.
`B
`Mdlceqningmehammda'mtm
`T
`parfiwla'elermismmdmsaymatm
`B mmintenmdamchg?
`9
`EBOYLE Tl'isiseamfiyu‘esam
`10
`mesfinn. Ashedmdmmed.
`11
`THEWITNESE lqmlamedme
`12
`mesfinn.
`13
`BYNIlHEINRICH:
`14
`Q.
`lglesslmdlydun'lundetstmdmr
`15 mnllen.
`16
`Winnmliulanm‘atelemeflsm
`1? midywsayflntymmmimto?
`19
`IllBOYLE Saneubjecim.
`19
`THEWITNESE ‘erydnlflywpnflmleach
`20
`elerrlernamlllilltellm
`21
`BYNIlHEINRICH:
`22
`Q.
`'Wemdnmat
`23
`A Okay.
`24
`Q. Sndidwumnmnemmeumaepfimd
`25 unmmmdemrhmsmifigtomema
`
`190
`
`Maltaway, Shane v. 2 9111012007 9:00:00 AM
`192
`
`netwrltprmwladdlessrecewedwmefirst
`1
`2 pmmmmmmMm
`3 mm
`4
`MR.BOYLF_' Otiadimvaguga'ldcdls
`5
`lnralegalumcushn.
`6
`THEVHTIESS: You hdenn'lmwM‘al
`T
`ynua'eafierhem. llriilamedymr
`B
`quesliun.
`9
`lmchfl1desaibesflnpm
`1|]
`establishmapniri—bmhlmcfim
`11 mnemmfimmmMHEme
`12
`nukesalinuryhrmelPMdme
`13
`aher,mdmenunaereeeived,mkesaminm
`14
`pth
`15
`mmmlmuflyuujmenl
`1B
`fistnluelmmhesauflmawayd
`1T
`doingmepoinmmhfinmymiu' Hence,
`1B
`MPOP3medlaismfieremncfimsenmr.
`19
`Subsequunmfl‘HIMemsnnmm
`2|]
`NumemsdisummmeIemMI
`21 mummmmmmm
`22
`mynmaflmbeuuseaflsfime
`23
`marinarflwenflynemmmrmism.
`24
`Snwflmhat said, llauld tellyuulhat
`25
`unmiginlumueivenflhemcfim
`
`191
`
`193
`
`1 mmmmemmmmmn
`2 Mmmmmflmm
`3 m irplemmtafimsuere moaned by
`4
`Glemancll.
`5
`BY MR. HEIIRJCH:
`6
`Q. Whydnn'lynutfltealmkaldainfl]? If
`T wumldreadmattomsel.
`8
`a. any.
`9
`Q. Amyuuminyentnrdchimm?
`1|]
`MR.BOYLF_' mwhmram
`11
`cundusim.
`12
`THEVHTIESS: LinywkrmJgJessl
`13
`mmmaay,ymkrm,inmis—lis
`14
`surlafrmlli-parL Okay? Becamelhefirst
`15
`parlrehateschjm1halay,atahlisring
`1B
`apdmmpoinflrmlghamncfimsenmr,
`1T
`mumyuIamde-diulilpohBABmd
`1B
`c,mu1reh1aammmmm
`19
`ammmlheerrbofledhmeuser
`2|]
`interface. mmatbeirgu‘ecmyml'm
`21
`“mum our;
`22
`BYMR.HEIIRJCH:
`23
`Q.
`lfyulunMMMmdainnmdmad
`24 mattomsel.
`25
`a. any. Okay.
`
`Ebay_Ne12Phone
`
`Page 190—193
`
`Page 4 of 29
`
`

`

`194
`
`Maltaway, Shane v. 2 91012007 9:00:00 AM
`196
`
`Q. Newman'lweflurafda‘mifl?
`“1m Sa'neutiecim.
`TI‘EWITNEfii ChinSQperh'nsln
`maintainilgmen'apnrlmwleflflt
`associatesme ideliiierul a “theme cienl
`
`toilstmchisamncfim
`servinepmcm
`llissorlofmlgoes—wflntsm
`khdalmiumatmeummcfimsewimmo
`mrmlhimlemmtedJmflmme.
`Buzuseflntisflflwuaedflngymam
`mam. millennium!!!"
`g'vernelheleldm
`Snatfl‘eafloffl‘edameldha‘ueh
`say,m,miiwasparluf6|em‘si1ihl,wu
`
`mm,mereradmbe—acmmy,letme
`mhkmflmisasmfl. Letn'eretwmd
`
`my.
`Mamlrflvetotellynum‘flismy
`inalim_NIdflisgnhgmbebofl1.llill
`www.mmlewedmmhg
`dtelmiivesmlhePOPwverafllfihga
`pruprietalyumrecfimmmisisan
`www.mmmmammmm
`
`Iheidenlifiera'ldmeledress.
`
`Snlmldmmsayfl'flGlerna'ldl
`Winwrdmm‘nmm,said,m,
`Iele—misismwmaregommm
`todnl. Snlmldsaymiwuh.
`BYNIlI'EINRICH:
`
`Q. mmmmmummm
`mumflmflnmwminlfim
`wuwmlniuedchimfl?
`
`TI‘EWITNEE Nmeflfllhmatl
`
`rneanjlis—lfisisike—mmflflll
`mumatmldaweryqulmfimas
`to—astoeridenceasmmoumneivedflar
`
`3mm. ldm'llllma'lyofllat
`BYNIlI'EINRICH:
`
`Q. Didymdawpnintlrieflmm
`sayfljustcamwwimaliflyideafmiteflin
`ammwalabnotemnKurmme
`Ital?
`
`A Ndmammfippatbll—aflgmted
`flgtfl—lwasismadapateltsolismm
`blflllismncepldrrfl'rfinhgalonhptflfleis,
`rmsonymsaymtnflmm. lmemj'sanatnflws
`fling
`
`mm-mlmm-th-L
`8200283333333n:a
`mm-qmm-hwn-L
`NEEINEBEE-fiaaififiia
`
`{HG-‘nlelLfl-th-I
`Baaaaaaaazan:a
`
`lflfi-dafimhuN-I
`dd—hd—h—h—hmmth-La
`
`1T
`
`‘l'l'lefmtmatlehmmkrm,mn
`it) implementafinn i1 Iris pannigm, i1 Iris
`specificmpimmismaIMiluime,afl
`mmmmepateflclefltmflmiswe
`mapateflilflfllmgard.
`Bllmeoveldlumcegxotwume
`"limplmemmbemneedymrmalreed
`idafliertolilkfllnymrpl’lmmrrberuamr
`mmwmememreismmenfier,
`ghemeapmmterldatedmlmatgmback
`mmghanfimiy.
`So this isjust a1 implementafinn is
`m—inmiswplicdimiiwmnsunique.
`Q. waefamiiwwimmeummw
`mahfiflfiamfimmmmwfl-
`a. nismmmmm
`mm. karmeeaLmHeisatablemr
`mm‘ng. Youlmal.
`Q. Solhecurmptofalmlnpualeis
`basicdlyjismesamumcqtreganlesstf
`Iratpa'fiwhrdahmmsmbehmem
`tableniml?
`a. Amulptableisabnhptabla
`Q. flanesnimmmm
`mterrlofu‘elmluphhleisniyn?
`
`A. “MLHIatislfmmflmique,
`mwghmdmmmcafimflisimhedh
`Ywhm,flnmwofalmlnptable.
`m,hmbemarwm,mflifywareamglto
`mmmmwanm—mmjm
`pmmmm.mukav.wuaeuimh
`maregard.
`lmlmlflliflamcjveywm
`mnpleofiu‘empofmyheaddmhgsfl'flae
`omsammmmmmmm
`becausemeyaespecifiwyauimtouiqm
`WM.mmlu-Ikrm.lluuldgiueflln
`will. Billfl'l'rltngulfmrmsaying.
`Q. Sommilklmfaclflflluneaffl'e
`mnletershlhelonhptflflehwlnbelP
`andmmmatmademrimenfinnmmnw
`
`MR.BOYLF_' Wmmrizes
`histafinnmr.
`THEVHTIESS: Mn,rmgninglnlellyw
`mmmhunmlimm
`unmlemweimm. ThePOTS
`mmrmmwapMHmka
`lonhptdfle. chall411,nget
`inforrrafim,mmnupi1akmkmwle,
`
`195
`
`197
`
`Ebay_Ne12Phone
`
`Page 194 — 197
`
`Page 5 of 29
`
`

`

`198
`
`Maltaway, Shane v. 2 91012007 9:00:00 AM
`200
`
`mmemmdMMmmm
`mrpMIEflurrbeL 0hr?
`m,flereisapaluligmshillum
`mfrnmPOTStnvduemerlPinmflwu
`mmdnalonkmbecamemepmnenurmeris
`mm. umifimmmlm
`dynanicalyaseimedmmemleor
`lmmmmwwmmdflfl
`mmiflmmiaemerlflflebnlup
`Mshocura'ldIKflanqifim Semis“
`mimeparlafl mmmmmm
`MingwmlPaddImatelqmmemmher
`equinhntasqmosedMsomaherpamters
`Edmmmmmmflis
`mic-lion.
`Snl'mmmepaterlmniHsawuis
`mdsa'dJedUfisisamhlewplimimtf
`mwmflahblemsm,
`mdglantedusmepatent Becameilis
`mimhmhspwificwpicafim.
`Ohemhgmyuwldhemcjmusme
`patent?
`BYNIlI'EINRICH:
`
`Q. Hemldhauen'afleamisfleniflfl?
`)1 mm.
`
`0. deyulflliflflfllisuflmly?
`
`TI‘EWITNEE Wellhaueharmrm
`llmhdldmhlmh’mhmmm
`pageshemhfllcmlellymtarleimLym
`“.mareholmgatmpwmsdmfl
`rere,wuhluw,imisisallolfl'le
`mmmmmmmum
`
`examhermmmmispatatsayhgcm
`mkmmmflimmhnfllfish
`Hathawaynrexphhflisjmalotaffim
`Ient'lmlfispmllintermd
`mimmmnmmmewrimn
`
`Snflisnfllllewrflfllhgl‘en‘afleared
`middecis'mmenfllonksllehema
`geatdealnlfimebefomhemaderisduishn;
`fence, mummsimflldhembaflydid nu
`Mamisue.
`BYNIlI'EINRICH:
`
`Q. Weremimnhedhu‘emmnunicafinm
`bemNetfinflmdlhepataioflimduingfl‘e
`mmmemmfi
`A mmminmmmmmis
`MmuehiledBnmhbsitobmmewrpalml
`Murrummdatmatimcune, I believe Glenn
`
`mm-mlmm-th-L
`8200283333333n:a
`mm-qmm-hwn-L
`NEEINEBEE-fiaaififiia
`
`{HG-‘nlelLfl-th-I
`Baaaaaaaazan:a
`
`lflfi-dafimhuN-I
`
`—h—h—|N-LD
`
`13
`
`immmmfirstsuhdaflaflusedmis
`mmmmmmdflemfi,m
`InhirajBnmhbsiJsatdmmwimBnmafll
`saili'HeIeisfl‘edesim.‘ IMMfllem
`wilBruDe.
`
`MR.BOYLF_' l'mjlfitgui'lgtorfinflm
`caufinn fmm eaflier about umversafims win
`
`yourammey.
`THEVHTIESS: Chum.
`ldidgnoverwimrimmeamnelflsnflm
`desigqurh'lnmnfikedetennmasln
`mmmhmemmmmmme
`patent. matingmlum.
`EWMR.HEIIRJCH:
`
`Q. Wemynuhmedwbsanflflyinjay,
`refiewigmtoflnpdmlulfice?
`a.
`ldm'lbeimm,wlerfl'mmafi:eBm
`camaflfltedton'eaflaflnedmemesfilnmdl
`pmbdfirashefllim.
`Q. Dowulecalspaifiwmeasling
`mthmmflnmm
`MR.BOYLF_' rmgnighcalinnyulagah
`Himmtoafiunfly—cieflmmmm
`THEWITIESS: Yeahmflliu—lwfl
`recdlspecificn-uhns. lnlearletel
`
`wufl'flfl'leremocmsiufiflmtecamafl
`said,’1—i,Sln\e,lhauegflmquesfimsfur
`wurere. Cmynurebn'eml?‘
`MJuukrmeldmmrimm
`lunldexphhandlefilhhisdunfinmdn
`mmmmmmmflemem
`BYMRHEIIRJCH:
`
`lwmldiheywtomimmedeaxipfim
`Q.
`hmmmteflhiefly.
`Myquesfimfurwuiswfflhermereis
`mydisdmehu‘empatemuusingmme
`
`MR.BOYLF_' mmbedeanwuwairim
`Inmadlheerlieuig?
`MR. I—EIIRJCH: mthereuiemdl
`weanlin—
`MR.BOYLEIdun1mwM|ereyulale
`n'akilgmatreprmntafinnfmm. Dammit
`himm—
`
`MR. I-EIIRICH: me rim-alimony.
`THEVHTIESS: Aleuiequisn‘lapemsd. A
`Wisrrmofascm_ FHushgismrplete
`detailedread.
`
`lhmnotdmeampletedfiailedmad.
`Snifynuraveasecfiminm‘fimare
`
`199
`
`201
`
`Ebay_Ne12Phone
`
`Page 198-201
`
`Page 6 of 29
`
`

`

`relenhgk), lmldamecmeflifwu
`would pnintiluu.
`BYNRHEINRICH:
`
`0. WelLleimebadlplihaprelimm
`quesliun.
`Siting here rightm, alewu awarenf
`anypassageurdscbelminme'mdpataiflu
`Hksammmmmwngmmemcfim
`ms?
`
`mm-mlmm-th-L
`
`.5.-U'I-h-
`
`IRBOYLE Almmentafiue.
`.5.-in
`TIEWITNESE Imam rmjust
`.- N
`sayinglmldplemmeflfllfl‘ereissnme
`.- w Wagehhereufllsafianmnecfimm
`mmaamwflemwa
`listimtedswtemnrasetafnultifle
`m Immispst—mmd
`90mm.
`YMMmemfinndlhefimemdgupe
`mmglheremseeilmfimmelsays
`“Misting mum'lywpnflmeh
`adrediunmmmilseeilunfitl
`eucflylhalelis.
`BYNIlHEINRICH:
`
`—|—|—|—|@fl'nlai
`NEEENEE
`
`Q. UVellemlmitflsaysmaLml
`can'lpoi'ltymmawpassage. Ellirwuare
`
`meofapassageJdikeymtopdntmem
`Ital.
`
`A llfllmllyulmllwdm'lyuutel
`MMIWIMTMMMWr
`syshrn?
`Q. fmaflingfl‘equafimflmlflm
`asked. Snimmminmmapassagehmfln
`“mudswsamcfimmmayust
`asastamlahmsysternorlishimtedsmn.
`A Wheredmflsaymd?
`Q.
`rmaflingynu.
`EBOYLE Cmnselor,yuua'earguhg
`Iiflllhavlnesaafl—
`IIIHENRICH: fmaflthgfl'equafim.
`EBOYLE —fl'|emles|imisjlm
`inuwermd Infair. Emerywcalspmdywr
`depusitimfimemflhgfurhinlmeadlfisur
`mmmmafldmflmm. llis
`inpmper.
`BYNIlI-EINRICH:
`
`Q. Pleasetfltemfime, Mr. mm.
`Ill BOYLE Justin Index]; I‘B'Baflt'ng
`mmreadfl‘eelfiepahnt
`THEWITNESE Hum.
`
`EBOYLE FmPageL
`
`mm-qmm-hwn-L
`dd—hd—h—h—h
`CIUIhUN-hfi
`
`—h—h—|93"!
`RENEE!
`
`DEE
`
`Maltaway, Shane v. 2 91012007 9:00:00 AM
`204
`
`{HG-‘nlelLfl-th-I
`Baaaaaaaazan:a
`
`lflfi-dafimhuN-I
`
`—h—h—|N-LD
`
`13
`
`THEWTIESS: Well,yml|lw,lis
`interesfirngamseimlmkal—fl'e
`fistfllhglseeismPageMmdmn
`mm1ammlsm'memncfim
`serverZfiifludesapmuesmrjfimerfar
`gmtirrleshnmaflmemywchasa
`damusmrirgf
`‘I'I'Ienilsafi,'FanIIrrple,err|ailflaTlet
`lPaddIessesdbgged-incdlshanexenflaw
`enlmdi'rflt'
`
`SnbasimllyMamsayilg.hrm
`unmmnmruwlflbea—nmbea
`SparkfimmrnraSpalkZflpmnrhun
`SI.In,fflUigaca*alCPlJ,andrurligUNDL
`"aim alimer, had drive, lined drive,
`
`dmwumaflmflinfi,
`dmmmmmmfimefl
`fluwldbeaPOPserver. lmealngiU'ng
`mmmbemmflm
`Weltereisinm. ESQ—let's
`shtdafi Orjuststarlalxijrdalfly
`afexphmfimlefssta‘tatmeerrbodmfl
`dmummmm
`mm.mumnmmber10isplmflxlas
`
`Wait ‘l'l'lefmclimsrquentedby
`MMMMMNMhMde
`eimersha'edordeaicahadme,mmm
`bulnntliritedmmmmeof
`exemlingmesofime.
`Oarlynlifliuimmmmrs. ll
`mhnmmmszdeamwlhe
`mmmmm
`hemmbeprmidedwameflmmmr
`ammdmflm
`llsaysynum hauemuliple manners.
`BY MR. HEIIRICH:
`
`l5 Iris referring specificdlytome
`0.
`mm
`
`ldnn'llum. lraven'tgnnebadtmme
`a.
`album. I mam, I anjm read'ng this.
`0. Ymmfwlfiegplmmmflme
`d'ayams.
`MR.BOYLF_' Isfl'lereamesfiunperflrg?
`THEVHTIESS: Well,rm5fill1yingm
`mrfisflfimmmm‘jmu
`m—
`
`MR.BOYLF_' Bunrmaflinghimjsmerea
`
`Ebay_Ne12Phone
`
`Page 202-205
`
`Page 7 of 29
`
`

`

`mmmm?
`IRHENRICH: llismvsamequafimhe's
`sfilufinghmmjshepstsaid.
`IIlBOYLE Cmyulreajmfl‘e
`mesfiun?
`(“mummmemuatedmrfimmmad
`hackwmerepnmrasalxwemuedj
`TI'EWITNEE 'l'hisanhaIretoreaj
`it Lefsseeifilisalfl‘ebegi‘nhgl‘ere.
`lca'ltfmmmykmlmg—kmkhgmer
`mistingldm'tseemefldmfl‘e
`mnecfimmasbehgmuflum,mm
`Mme. flisjmtmhgmismmzfim
`serverhfl'ewmleaffl‘eemlmflmem.
`Snfldmn'limptyumunly,mdml
`finmfllatlmmtnfldmflsaymfl
`mimmmune. Solmstomaplwy
`ma].
`BYNIlI'EINRICH:
`
`Q. ‘l'reeaamplematisgjmusesaeinge
`
`A WelJeah. Italiamasiglepl’me.
`Tmphxmdoesflflln'emflfleisnotmmflnn
`”Whitman? “isms-true.
`Q. Amlalyjuksammueflmme
`
`MMacallerafladlee?
`A Sodlflmalea‘ehmmmm
`
`mmm,hmisfletSpeakpmlun?
`Q. Letmejlst—
`EBOYLE [Xlflirlm'lflh'samiwem
`Ywamstflfilghdnflaga‘n.
`Yuumfinish.
`
`TIEWITNESE lmmmlhenrrue
`
`Arlifllmemhgicmrynuragml
`sayingweljlereismlymeummcfim
`mmhfismflmlmdm
`tosayflmismlyllnminmis
`patentfl‘ecalera'ldlhecallee. Hamlin!
`Mm?
`BYNIlI'EINRICH:
`
`rmjuslasligllemesfinn.
`Q.
`A Wel,l'rn awaingynurmesfinn.
`lcalurlygobyflflmeuuulddechm
`mund'aglamsmddedumlmmmeim
`MUELHIBlican'Hiflhmis
`doummmereflsammmmedimmr
`eadshormfiienmnecfimselwsnfiyexist,’
`surlaf'rrpiesmrnellasleflqaenmdflcmbe
`anymidlwayfl'flyulfllt Wismdlget
`
`mm-mlmm-th-L
`8200283333333n:a
`mm-qmm-hwn-L
`NEEINEBEE-fiaaififiia
`
`Maltaway, Shane v. 2 91012007 9:00:00 AM
`2118
`
`{HG-‘nlelLfl-th-I
`Baaaaaaaazan:a
`
`lflfi-dafimhuN-I
`d—hd—L—h—h—h—hHamburg-La
`
`1B
`
`frumiL
`
`Q. Daesfl'leflflpata‘ldisdnsemflirflnf
`maneuveremncfimsewermldhm
`apareflmncfimsewer?
`MR.BOYLF_'
`l'mmmr. Hulda". Wham
`hairstparldmeqlesfim? IMnissed
`lim_The'Tdeabnt Wasthereamlllng
`WM?
`
`MRJ—EIIRICH: llis'nanuesfimmat
`ynui'ltenuated.
`Snumjlflasklagah
`BYMRHEIIRJCH:
`
`Q. Duesflme'i'fl-Ipataidisdnseaw
`unfigllafimliHEmmncfimsewerhasa
`mimnecfimselm
`A. TremisnoJlispatemmnm
`descfibe NHSpeak'smachiachlre. Then“;
`mmmmm.
`Q. Duesmispatemmmmtsm
`seweramfltecumasofWZSm1m
`MR.BOYLF_' Otieclimuague.
`THEVHTIESS: Trispaiml'sdahad
`Augustm,21m,andflisexpiciiya
`pain—tumulntemmlpatelt ltis
`notauxtMmsewerarNett-‘Jpeflsewer
`
`arctitechlrepatat Snmifiisln'llgvery
`spedficastolmlflsda'msare.
`EWMR.HEIIRICH:
`
`Q. Mhemtelmsmhgfl'mJlas
`Mmhflnflmmmm.
`1995—
`
`A. any.
`0. —ifilhe¢htemmchmispataim5
`filed.
`
`A. any.
`0. Sammie: Dmmempabrrl
`WWWaMafiM
`smwmmm
`A. Mn,fldoesn1.llifimhmere.
`MR.BOYLF_' Immineqlesfimas
`wage.
`THEWITIESS: Saw.
`EWMR.HEIIRICH:
`
`[Meshe'i'fldpataidisdnsea
`Q.
`distribllecl “alumina! (htabase all IP Mm?
`
`A. Mn,ildoesn'l. lldmflgninmlhe
`WWWMM lldesuilxnille
`Wmhsnflashwflhusedm
`
`Wish 3 Writ wmnunicafim, IImi'lil:l'| is
`mflisspmificpataiifideaiuwih.
`
`Ebay_Ne12Phone
`
`Page 206-209
`
`Page 8 of 29
`
`

`

`210
`
`Maltaway, Shane v. 2 91012007 9:00:00 AM
`212
`
`mm-mlmm-th-L
`
`.5.-in
`
`Q. ‘l'reumnafimsewerwuamu‘afis
`desaibedhflempataiwasmemflmym
`mumdmrmleaglmatmmewmmme
`amewnnmasdsmbermmgfi;
`mat?
`
`IIIBOYLE 0hiecfim,cal5lnralegal
`0mm. llisahnarmmeflafive.
`TIEWITNESE lwm‘tevmamm
`
`me.‘l1‘alissily_
`BYNIlI'EINRICH:
`Q. Ymmmmmmat
`A Nuldm't llisaridulwsqlflsfim.
`lmeanjlwasmebesllaymis'besl'?
`Defin'bestmy.‘
`0. Ymmmm‘bfil'n'ems?
`A Wm'besl'meanilmml
`
`—|—|—|—|0|th
`NEEEE-fia mom? I mam, flis—uflyfimetelsmat
`
`m,ldm'twamtobemfliue,bmmefad
`iafismmdfimhmt ll
`defimmatllefllmtfmemcfimsewer
`
`mmmhmummamm
`mafim. Yuuhmflsflmehfitmfim
`
`Q. asafmpterrberztifl'l, 1995,1nerewualae
`afabefiermmamkmwflmm
`
`wastischsedinme'm-Ipdent?
`
`211
`
`EBOYLE ltisvamemdmare
`Wham
`THEWITNESE ldreadyexphindmyw,
`miswilbemeflirdaldhsttirelexphh
`mismyul,flnmnufinserverhhere,fle
`mydauifimisflslmcfimasaholmp
`mmmmmammm
`numn‘ln-afierhwmeumnecfim
`
`misshuchMfidmn‘ln-afleruuly
`mniaimmfladjdoesn'lmif
`mereisumoramiimmrm, lm‘l
`rnalterimeyaeumnmedmmgla
`fienchimlmfihodurastarpaltemma
`kxaluwideamanummmefadisjis
`pelfixmhgahohlpfilflmtfmle
`IjvmanmLmdmemnplehhemis
`menfiladdlesa
`
`Sn,ynulum,mrquafimsmgnmafl
`mandan. Tmradismeuflymiumis
`paterflisdnigasfarasamncfimsenmr
`isomuemedissrmhgmmemmzfim
`serverisfulfilingasakmhpsystemto
`esuiishamfl-h-pdntm_1hatis
`it ltdoesrfldmcrbehmywayjrmeor
`ftxmfl'lea'chixuwedlhemncfimsenmr
`
`NEE!
`
`mm-qmm-hwn-L
`dd—hd—h—h—h
`CIUIhUN-hfi
`NEEINEEEES
`
`.- HI
`
`{HG-‘nlelLfl-th-I
`Baaaaaaaazan:a
`
`lflfi-dafimhuN-I
`d—hd—L—h—h—h—hHamburg-La
`
`1B
`
`ornuliuememnnm. Tom;
`
`MR. I-EIIRJCH: l'mgnhgtomuuehsh‘le
`mmmmnmmm
`MR.BOYLF_' ‘l'hatlnnsenfirely—
`MR. I-EIIRICH: lm‘tcalemmmrarm
`
`WEMUGW.MLM
`MR.BOYLF_' Ywd’lmld. Ymsluld.
`
`MR. I-EIIRJCH: l'mguhgtobeaskiumy
`queslimaga'n.
`MR.BOYLF_' rmqnpnsiglmtn'nfim
`bemfllmselirelymmiue.
`EWMRHEIIRICH:
`
`Q. Mymesfinnistiflarat rmjustaslirg
`mmmaymitmatflmafllymmfiumwu
`maymflflisinelmtfl‘misulm.
`a. LetmeheariL
`
`Q. Mymesfinntowuis: Weleynumrein
`Sqiernlnr—asofWZSfl'lJMofabflnr
`WWWMIreMIasdiscbsedh
`
`0112mm
`MR.BOYLF_' Washedmdmma‘l.
`mummmmmmmm
`wudnn'llitehismm.
`THEVHTMESS: lwilmflaga‘n.
`
`mmispatanmtmm
`mechm' mamcum' Snanrnetireh
`
`mummmmflismfiednrm,
`mulmlemmmnmngme
`patemsdmistimweradamme
`Mupmdmnmmmmmu‘e
`mechm' server.
`
`Mfldidn'lapflytollispatertm
`Iiismnishinygmndescfibig
`mafimserfimaumflymdflfile
`Mermdeaingmmmnnecfimm
`andNett-indcaflflre.
`Schmmrmmqmism
`mbauydflqum,mardflecuIm
`mrfl'emewunsewiuem‘uemwgflms
`gommheflnmhmptenberMSem—
`mlerefleasmmeflpraamflflmtim_
`Mlismtdelmtsuahdfiesuibedhuis
`spedficpaient
`BYMRHEIIRJCH:
`
`Q. Somdm‘twudscmmeacufl
`Wmemnmrammhlfis
`patent?
`a. mmmJliljJstmrm
`mm.
`
`213
`
`Ebay_Ne12Phone
`
`Page 210—213
`
`Page 9 of 29
`
`

`

`21:1
`
`Mattaway. Shane v. 2 91'10l'200? 9:00:00 AM
`21B
`
`It is not
`MR. BOYLE. Objedion. vague.
`intellagible es lo your but you can answer.
`THE WITNESS: When dealing with Bruce
`Jobsi -
`
`MR. BOYLE: Also, F’nl irislructing you not
`to answer about your allorney-cliei1t
`cornmunicalions will1 —-
`
`THE WITNESS: Well. I'm not going lo
`discuss specifics. out me leol is. Bruce Joosi
`is also a very intelligent man with some
`engineering background When dealing wilh
`Bmce Jobsi. I would basically give him
`documents. go on the while board. describe in
`doleil what we are doing and say. 'Bmce. 01
`this. what can we patent?”
`Okay”? And he would 1elI me. “Okay. we
`have gol lliis. this, this. and Iliis. 1131M:
`have gol lo lake this inorernenlely You just
`
`REDACTED
`
`waafl in here. And that is why you do have
`more than one patent in your rcponoire o1
`documenlo ove' mere.
`BY MR. HEINRICH:
`
`D. 50 to understand the invention perIaining
`lo the cunnecllori server architecture. you have 10
`look at other parents?
`MR. BOYLE: Obiedion: calls tore legal
`conclusion. And it is vague.
`THE WITNESS Frosm'iaoly. yes.
`MR. HEINRICH: Why {1001 we 1alre a snarl
`bredr now. we are getting imo an hour.
`THE VIDEOG RAPHER. We are oil the record.
`
`{Thereuporh a recess was iakeri. after
`which the iollowing proceedings were he|cl:]
`YHE VIDEDGRAPHER: We are on Ihe reoud.
`BY MR. HEINRICH:
`0. And now I'rri going to marl: as Maitaway 6 US
`Paisni No. 6.131.121.
`lThereupori, Ihe referred-lo mmentwas
`marked by the coun reporier lor ioeilifioalion
`as Mafia-way Exhibit 6.}
`
`Dw‘imo‘é-CI’N—L
`rhUN—‘O
`
`15
`
`16
`l?
`18
`
`no:
`
`W'h-Imu'
`
`11
`12
`13
`1-1
`15
`16
`1?
`1s
`19
`20
`21
`22
`23
`2-1
`25
`
`BY MR. HEINRICH.
`Q,
`Is lh'rs another patient. Mr. Maltawey. on
`which you are named as a co-invenlror'.’
`A. Yes.
`
`Q. Wmld you please Iun'i to the claims.
`beginning at column 41. which I5 Ille seoond-lo-Iast
`page 01 1119 paheni? And flyou could midlo
`your-soil claim 1.
`A. Okay.
`Q. Are you an 'rmentor of claim? of the '121
`patent?
`MR. BOYLE: Objection. calls fora legal
`conclusion.
`
`I mean. I would
`THE WITNESS: Well. yeah.
`have to say this is oasioolly lho oamo claim 1
`as in the eaten, the fl'iOI' patent “181 WU
`showed me oririing in 701-. whee. yui know. I
`basically told you lhal Glenn Hullzon and IWEI'E
`coinvenm Of this ned'naiism described in
`claim 1.
`BY MR. HEINRICH:
`G. With relcrence to claim 1 of lhe '121
`patent. which elements of this claim old you
`contribute lo?
`
`MR. BOYLE: Obleclion, lacks foundation.
`
`THE WITNESS: Again. it is Ihs same answer
`as I gave you for oats!“ "1'04. The connection
`service using the POP server mechanism was
`Glenn's. and then subsequeni to that. using
`another more proprietary mechanism was
`co—invsniisd by Giana and I. and 111m Domains
`loHiereslofclaim 1.
`So you are looking at Glenn Hunon. Shane
`Moflawey co4nvontlon in claim 1.
`BY MR. HEINRICH:
`0. 50 claim I is directed lo the more
`propneiary connection somos mechanism thal you
`nope-o --
`It
`It Is generlc‘eegeneflc can be.
`A. No.
`is — well. no. no1 necessarily. Wait a minute.
`is saying it is lrsnsmitting an email simal from
`[he first — soil is really perlain'l'ig Io lhe POP.
`I believe the PCIP server riiecl'lfl'liam. Seeing “is is
`the program oode for transmilling an email signal
`from the lust processor to the server processor
`over the computer network.
`50 thus is slill relemng ho Ina POF'3
`server mechanism.
`
`II
`
`Q. So let me restate my mostion. Are you an
`huenlor oi olain'i 1 of the “I21 patent?
`
`maneuver-x».-
`
`AI:
`12
`13
`I4
`
`18
`IT
`18
`10
`2t)
`21
`22
`23
`2:1
`25
`
`wm-aaaogcom‘
`
`4c:
`12
`13
`14
`15
`16
`1?
`18
`19
`
`21
`
`23
`24
`25
`
`215
`
`211"
`
`Ebay_Net2Phone
`
`Page 214 — 217
`
`Page 10 of 29
`
`

`

`218
`
`Maltaway, Shane v. 2 91012007 9:00:00 AM
`220
`
`IRBOYIE Calsllxalegalmnclminn.
`TI‘EWITNEEE Didn‘lymjlstaskmat?
`BYNIlI'EINRICH:
`
`0. Ymdarficafimheremfusedn'e,“
`l'nllmder'l‘gif—
`A Wisuanfmhg? lmiilsmnt—
`TI‘EWITNEEE meupleasemaflbadtm
`mmhflnsamquesfimheafiedbefiuem
`g'verimlmtarmel?
`BYNIlI'EINRICH:
`
`Q. Snlwilmllymmlaflnedflflagah,
`bemlmiflynujlsthasfliedflfllfl‘e
`mafimserviceusingfl‘ePOPselwrmdanism
`wasGMflea.
`
`A Yesjllas.
`Q. Arldmywmfldfl'flmisdainhlf
`M'121pataimrta'l15tolmPOPm
`mecl‘anisrn.
`
`A Wesaiimemmhgflidn'lwe?
`Q. Snmmwmlddymmfliblhmasa
`mddainw
`EBOYLE Wmdmmed
`BYNIlI'EINRICH:
`Q.
`lffllisisdra‘hxltolmPOPm
`mm?
`
`A mnyhBB—hremmflm,
`lglmslwmldmmsayflfllflismelem's
`dain1hem,seehgre'sdealhgwimmemai
`signl.1hisisGlerlfsPOP59wern'ectaism,am
`mlwasnmmewiwumraflfisspmific
`dain1. lapnlmize. lhaflbl‘eadlilgreater
`detail.
`
`0. Calmfleaseteln'eirwua'em
`imminrulcla'miioflhe'ifipdent?
`IIIBOYLE Sa'neubjecimwlsfora
`mm
`TI‘EWITNESE Wherei53?
`
`WmhissumYuuhmJ
`mean—lmldravemsaymlfisumis—
`mismiswiwhdbyGlerna'ldl.
`BYNIlI'EINRICH:
`
`Q. mmadmmmme)
`IIIBOYLE Sa'neubjacim.
`TI‘EWITNESE Evalyflirgafllerflnnlhe
`POPsenler. lmlifi—flifidfiu‘ibifl,
`finmfllatlmgaflnrfiunmishguagga
`amnecfimmuimysewicepmcess
`Misprmidmmemmmlyas
`m—asflePOPmrmiunhcfimt
`ifl'mmdetstamigmismrmfly.
`
`mm-mlmm-th-L
`8200283333333n:a
`mm-qmm-hwn-L
`NEEINEBEE-fiaaififiia
`
`{HG-‘nlelLfl-th-I
`Baaaaaaaazan:a
`
`lflfi-dafimhuN-I
`d—hd—L—h—h—h—hHamburg-La
`
`1B
`
`Midlifilhmmmmiamesfim
`mmmmsismmu
`plmlid'ngammcfimsewilmoflerflmfl'e
`POPSmectmismaldmatismeflingflm
`Glemamld'liumsedm,m,atflnmlset
`heiremeumstakadmism,asa
`possiblealm'fliue. Snlfl'l'llklmtisflm
`aisdesuibinghere.
`EWMR.HEIIRICH:
`
`Q. Sodla‘fi'lgymrfltafimwelemntD
`ofda'm3,1’mg'ammflemlfiglledmesuli5ha
`pnii—b—poiflwmmimfimwfla’nflerpm
`munwmm‘dnwuseemat?
`A. Yeah.
`
`Q. Lethnflfl‘elPhohlprnedmismaside
`furamument
`
`A. Allrimt
`Q. “.maremflfl'eflslmmwlflm
`aprogla'nwdehratablishigapnfl—b—poi’fl
`unmicafiunlimmmuessmerlhemnulter
`”NEW“?
`A. mymsay'mmlicafinnfplme
`deinei.
`Q. Tmmissimafthta.
`A. Mmrmnd.
`
`Q. meohmmflmmuimnul
`mummmwasmatfiMOnmemdfln
`lntenlfl?
`
`MR.BOYLF_' Hapelesslyvame.
`THEWITIESS: Ongmrmnda
`hishximaf,y11lhlow,fl‘enmlcsmd
`multerscimue. Immciwis
`Immfimmmmm,
`mmufimnmrflmmeMmE
`mfimmmwuaetalingabwl
`havilgmepmcessflktoatfller,mhm,
`yeah, mnemaslmgasmswemm
`flmyuIrHIUimflcimIflsaflwumd
`pain—mmmmlimMasamb
`mummmauehaewenmruurmle.
`Yes. Smlrnemjlereislnlsd
`amicafimsmefl'flummcfmiflm
`pain, which I hopefully emailed wayearier
`inmisdqmsflinnflsimflxlmmmmr
`Mmicehreaime,mdmatism
`lfisisalam
`EWMR.HEIIRJCH:
`
`Q. Mmflirtflflmwefl‘efimm
`mmelpwimpnfltopnirlmmmricafinmdwice
`am?
`
`219
`
`221
`
`Ebay_Ne12Phone
`
`Page 213—221
`
`Page 11 of 29
`
`

`

`Maltaway, Shane v. 2 91012007 9:00:00 AM
`224
`
`{HG-‘nlelLfl-th-I
`Baaaaaaaazan:a
`
`lflfi-dafimhuN-I
`d—hd—L—h—h—h—hHamburg-La
`
`1B
`
`[Ill alplex system, it mum "animate the
`data. flmdnmhuhtemethtasofl'fli
`Mademtalingmpwfiesmuube
`head bylhe mlerparlies isten'ng. That
`MSMamndjmtmlayingflmmta,
`Mammmammmm
`daHHflreSHKirgfl‘muatammedler
`parliainlhemom.
`“.matieinflmflmmit Endd
`amulet
`EWMR.HEIIRJCH:
`
`Q. Okay.mirymuwlduntommm21
`oflle'121mlLAmlluuldliewubrealL
`startigatlhaSfiafwlIImZLalldgnmm
`murmZZl'neZL
`A. mmmflmmmaflaflkxld?
`Q. Mmmmmrselfmlease.
`A. Wednmwaimhleadnm
`
`Q. Cullmn22,ine21_
`A. No. mmameredoymnIImem
`remtomfl'alim?
`Q. UneZ1.
`A.
`(July. Okay.
`Q. Duesmispamgglhefiflpatat
`
`descfibeNHSpeak‘smcfimseweramfitecum?
`A. Asdlflen?
`
`Q. Wellefssh'lata'wti'ne.
`A. hmmrfimyeah. lnilsenti'eiy,
`
`nn.
`
`0. Sommamdmln
`NHSpeak'smcfimsenerarcfitecum?
`A. WIJHIIIJMrnemstarlatfifijis
`basicdlytel'ngyml um. illhis Manama
`meaninghhisexanflemichweaegdngmcjve
`wuinlhefallmuhg umpleofpa'aglaphs, H's
`infighe a mmberofghbd sewem, all rmmg their
`owndahbase,amlbeing—medatwaseisbeing
`rqiimtedfwfalll—tuletaimdhafl-m
`mm. mamwamemmm
`tomaflflisduwnjwwlddmrrpflnmd
`Midlanmdmenifinmemiflflnmetf
`mmmmmdlmsaysmm‘ywhmj
`flmedsmmmdflcaflpmuideanmm,
`flm—flreimmeWemeciemhgnm
`misgubalsewer,aflmmalfleem:lfflnday,
`fialelseHRyIm-Ifalmnl'mgnhg
`toselflwuanennilmsagemmmyl’adm
`givemeaml. Michwelumisduwlxnismore
`hflnufllerofureaffl‘elistirplementafimsof
`
`A Yes.
`
`Q. Snwumfixmemieramcaled
`VocaTer.
`A Yuln'flfilndeaflier.
`
`0. Dnymmflmeflpmdlm
`immMad poinHalHni'll mmrnu'liufiun (twice data?
`A Dnlkrmfllm‘? Now? Badtlhen?
`
`0. WelLsnlefsshtmlm. Dnywkrm
`ifVmarl'ec'spmmdsiwnhedmii-ln-pdm
`mmmmirafimnfvniuedata?
`
`A Lfimmrmismesflmilmmh:
`wrmlmmMIWTehmmCmm,
`erermedmNetSpeflJwasW
`In Vmal'l'ec by Glenn, saying, 'Sl'rme, decklhis
`uuL'
`
`AndMlenliwefligatedehyedwihi.
`ldidli‘alresearchlmldmlaldmenl
`mlmmmdflhflnm
`mmuhadbmnmdfnrmmm
`mmm—medbyfihaflbfllflilbnam
`
`m H
`
`ymatmefimewasmeymmmt
`usiuamii—b-pdntn'ecrHiSHIjrflunme
`mnhaymmeywemefiedivetyushgmatwumld
`callkxlayaslteamnfnrermseuw. lllas—
`
`Mwmjufiashundflmmlasbeing
`rehmflcaslmltomeparfimfl'flmeuser
`washmesamevimflmnin.
`
`Snbydefinimaslhaueam
`definamillhmimfllasnotapflrl—m-poin
`system. llwasnflmflfleaffutfiulig'nlhe
`realmrldas,wuhluw,agnbalvniaemerlP
`syshanlnbeirflematedmmemfld.
`Q. Snwuuirlfl'flmelRCSewerwasused
`mmhmwmmmhmfl
`would?
`EBOYLE Ohiecfimmame.
`TIEWITNESE waaimdefineynurwd
`Tehrbmauseusedinauaielydumcqfls,
`ImamjtermrehyapackeLMay? all
`nmmmmmmm. Hm
`mdedsinmmflw‘erflmflhlmmfl‘e
`
`rmdlufierlhasmgntobmmflsgdm
`leflsafimisisfl‘emmlDfieris
`
`AanCctfllserverMfihmdnmre
`”Hijlflrelay. llhasmmfl'e
`packdsofihmafimflwlicatmaflsafl
`”mofimeachcramelmrwlemmMaL
`
`ltn'aydsomixfl'ealflin. llilwasa
`
`mm-mlmm-th-L
`8200283333333n:a
`mm-qmm-hwn-L
`NEEINEBEE-fiaaififiia
`
`Ebay_Ne12Phone
`
`Page 222-225
`
`Page 12 of 29
`
`

`

`lhePOPflsenlermdm
`asdesaibedherej'sbaeicalysaying,
`asmemruehmdnseiamislnmat—me
`mummserveramritechIeMInswmahw
`implemented? llishfl'flllheghbalsewetsare
`malymdservemaflmatmemncelfld
`rediectiuaWebPrulemmoflermewunsewer,
`okay? Euenfl'mg'lflisnotneumsailyexphim
`inhel'easbeiummerparemormnavem
`Wehu‘ehiermfl'wjnflmmme
`mmdmmmmmm
`mmumidemmlhelPaddmswua'e
`lonlighjflismfldmthhele.
`mummmmmomu
`mlfiuemmzfimsewersaua‘hbletomedto
`ismidefl'nflispassage.
`Snisflmeemclandfilal
`
`implementafim oflhe mnneclim mnriee plums
`implementedwNetSIm? No. Isilapnrlim
`WYfiMasnfllmffim,hflinfleedfl
`shmsmnetfhelmcfimdflydflnynuhmmf
`Mimermhfinnflntmsfimllynninm
`mm
`0. Mhternmofmefllmiyfl'flm
`lilalyplliltoplaflicealdismtedherein
`
`M'121patelihl1esafimfl'flljlflrefimed
`mummmllatllncfinmflypflim
`WWW?
`A erqlesfimldnn'llitebecalseym
`nudeanasalfllfimhmestatelmflflichis
`ianTed. szaidmatmispassagewaslmlwe
`lilalyplliltoatlinflen‘erlflljnflflfllwasmfl
`mlsaid,a'ldfl'flismtflncase.