Case4:13-cv-05933-CW Document140-2 Filele/27/14 Pagel of 20
`
`EXHIBIT B
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 1
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 1
`
`

`

`Case4:13-cv-05933-CW Document140-2 Filele/27/14 PageZ of 20
`
`A.
`
`U.S. Patent No. 5,838,551 (“the ’551 patent”)
`
`U.S. Patent No. 5,838,551
`
`Claim Term
`
`Rockstar’s Proposal
`
`Rockstar’s Support
`
`“a Faraday cage”
`
`“an enclosure formed on one side
`
`by the EMI shield and on the
`other side by the ground member
`which completely surrounds the
`electronic component”
`
`“the board”/Antecedent basis of
`“the board”
`
`“the substrate”
`
`“extending across substantially
`the whole area within the
`
`confines of the edges of the
`substrate”
`
`Plain and ordinary meaning
`
`B.
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,037,937 (“the ’937 patent”)
`
`Generally, the ’551 Patent and its
`File History; Specification at
`Col. 1 lines 59-62; Col. 4 lines
`14-20; Figures 1-6; Prosecution
`History, Office Action Response
`dated January 14, 1998 ;
`Newton’s Telecom Dictionary,
`25 Anniversary Edition,
`Copyright 2009, at page 462;
`Chambers Dictionary of Science
`and Technology, Copyright
`1999, at 431; American Heritage
`Science Dictionary, Copyright
`2005, at pa e 226
`Specification Abstract; Col. 1
`lines 20-34, 41-45, 52-53; C01. 2
`lines 61-64; Figures 1-6; Claims
`1, 9, 10, 12
`
`Generally, the ’551 Patent and its
`File History; Webster’s New
`20th Century Dictionary 1817
`
`(1 98 3)
`
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,037,937
`
`Rockstar’s Proposal
`
`Rockstar’s Support
`
`“physical Viewing area”
`
`Plain and ordinary meaning
`
`Generally, the ’937 Patent and its
`File History
`
`“manipulable area portion”
`
`“portion of the physical Viewing
`area including a touch screen
`panel where displayed content
`information is subject to
`manipulation”
`
`The specification of the ’937
`patent, including cols. 1:18-2:40;
`4:35-41; 4:56-5:8; 5:27-40; and
`6:35-8:11; and Figs 4-6; 8, and
`10-14, and corresponding text.
`
`The prosecution history of the
`‘937 patent, including Jan. 22,
`1999 Amendment &
`
`Remarks/Ar
`
`ents and June
`
`P.R. 4-3 EXHIBIT A CHART 0F DISPUTED TERMS
`McKool 1024230v1
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 2
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 2
`
`

`

`Case4:13-cv-05933-CW Document140-2 Filele/27/14 Page3 of 20
`
`US. Patent No. 6,037,937
`
`Rockstar’s Proposal
`
`Rockstar’s Support
`
`“control tool function”
`
`Plain and ordinary meaning
`
`
`
`16, 1999 Amendment &
`Remarks/Arguments.
`
`Generally, the ’937 Patent and its
`File History
`Webster’s New World, College
`Dictionary
`Third Edition, 1997
`(defining “input”)
`
`See above for “manipulable area
`portion”
`
`The specification of the ’937
`patent, including cols. 1:18-2:40;
`4:35-41; 4:56-6:24; and 6:35-
`
`8:11; and Figs 4-6; 8, 10, and 12-
`14, and corresponding text.
`
`The prosecution history of the
`‘937 patent, including Jan. 22,
`1999 Amendment &
`
`Remarks/Arguments and June
`16, 1999 Amendment &
`Remarks/Arguments.
`
`See above for “user input”
`
`The specification of the ’937
`patent,
`including cols. 2:5-40; 4:63-5:8;
`5:27-40; 6:35-63; 7:26-8:11 and
`Figs 4-6; 8, and 12-14, and
`corresponding text.
`
`The prosecution history of the
`’937 patent, including Jan. 22,
`1999 Amendment &
`
`Remarks/Arguments and June
`16, 1999 Amendment &
`Remarks/Arguments.
`
`See above for “user input”
`
`Generally, the ’937 Patent and its
`File History
`
`“user input”/ “receiving a user
`input to the physical viewing area
`corresponding to the manipulable
`area portion and the
`representation of the control
`tool”
`
`“determining if the user input
`selects the control tool”
`
`“user input”
`“information corresponding to
`a user’s touch”
`
`“receiving a user input to the
`physical viewing area
`corresponding to the
`manipulable area portion and
`the representation of the
`control tool”
`
`“receiving information
`corresponding to a user’s
`touch to the physical viewing
`area where the representation
`of the control tool overlays the
`manipulable area portion.”
`
`[“manipulable area portion”
`used as construed above]
`
`“determining if the information
`corresponding to a user’s touch is
`intended to select or ignore the
`control tool”
`
`“permitting the at least one
`control tool function to be
`
`activated when the user input
`does select the control tool”
`
`“permitting the at least one
`control tool function to be
`activated when the information
`
`corresponding to a user’s touch
`does select the control tool”
`
`P.R. 4-3 EXHIBIT A CHART 0F DISPUTED TERMS
`McKool 1024230v1
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 3
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 3
`
`

`

`Case4:13-cv-05933-CW Document140-2 Filele/27/14 Page4 of 20
`
`US. Patent No. 6,037,937
`
`Rockstar’s Proposal
`
`Rockstar’s Support
`
`“means for providing a
`manipulable area portion in a
`physical viewing area, said
`manipulable area portion having
`at least one manipulation
`function associated therewit ”
`
`[“user input” used as construed
`above].
`a
`providing
`Function:
`manipulable area portion in a
`physical
`viewing
`area
`and
`providing
`at
`least
`one
`manipulation
`function
`associated
`the
`
`with
`
`manipulable area portion
`
`[“manipulable area portion” used
`as construed above].
`
`Structure: Display module
`470, touch panel 474, LCD
`472, memory 440, feature
`processor 430, analog
`controller 460, program 510,
`and touchscreen program 520,
`as disclosed in Figs 4, 5, 6,
`and 8; col. 4:7-21; 4:36-41;
`
`4248-528; 5:27-33; 6:54-7:25;
`and 7:45-8:11, and equivalents
`thereto.
`
`Remarks/Arguments.
`
`See above for “manipulable area
`portion”
`
`The specification of the ’937
`patent,
`including cols. 4:7-21; 4:36-41;
`4:48-5:8; 6:54-7:25; and 7:45-
`8:11; and Figs 4-6 and 8 and
`corresponding text.
`
`The prosecution history of the
`’937 patent, including Jan. 22,
`1999 Amendment &
`
`Remarks/Arguments and June
`16, 1999 Amendment &
`
`Remarks/Arguments.
`
`See above for “manipulable area
`portion”
`
`The specification of the ’937
`patent,
`including cols. 4:7-21; 4:36-41;
`4:48-6:63; and Figs 4-8 and
`corresponding text.
`
`The prosecution history of the
`’937 patent, including Jan. 22,
`1999 Amendment &
`
`Remarks/Arguments and June
`16, 1999 Amendment &
`
`“means for displaying a
`representation of a control tool
`overlaying the manipulable area
`portion, said control tool having
`at least one control tool function
`associated therewith”
`
`a
`displaying
`Function:
`tool
`representation of a control
`overlaying the manipulable area
`portion, said control tool having
`at least one control tool fimction
`associated therewith
`
`[“manipulable area portion” used
`as construed above].
`
`Structure: Display module
`470, touch panel 474, LCD
`472, memory 440, feature
`processor 430, and program
`510, as disclosed in Figs 4, 5,
`6, 7, and 8; col. 4:7-21; 4:36-
`41; and 4:48-6:63, and all
`
`P.R. 4-3 EXHIBIT A CHART 0F DISPUTED TERMS
`McKool 1024230v1
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 4
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 4
`
`

`

`Case4:13-cv-05933-CW Document140-2 Filele/27/14 PageS of 20
`
`US. Patent No. 6,037,937
`
`Rockstar’s Proposal
`
`Rockstar’s Support
`
`_ equivalentsthereto. _
`
`“means for receiving a user input
`to the physical viewing area
`corresponding to the manipulable
`area portion and the
`representation of the control
`tool”
`
`receiving a user input
`Function:
`to the physical viewing area
`where the representation of the
`control
`tool
`overlays
`the
`manipulable area portion
`
`portion,”
`area
`[“manipulable
`“user input,” and “receiving a
`user input to the physical Viewing
`area
`corresponding
`to
`the
`manipulable area portion and the
`representation of
`the
`control
`tool” used as construed above].
`
`Structure: Touch panel 474,
`analog controller 460, LCD
`472, memory 440, feature
`processor 430, program 510
`and touchscreen program 520,
`as disclosed in Figs 4, 5, 6, 8,
`10, and 11; col. 4:7-21; 4:36-
`
`41; 4:48-6:63; and 7:45-8:11,
`and all equivalents thereto.
`
`See above for “manipulable area
`
`portion,” “user inpu ” and
`“receiving a user input to the
`physical viewing area
`corresponding to the manipulable
`area portion and the
`representation of the control
`tool”
`
`The specification of the ’937
`patent, including cols. 4:7—21;
`4:36-41; 4:48-6:63; 7:45-8:11;
`
`and Figs 4-6, 8, and 10-11 and
`corresponding text.
`
`The prosecution history of the
`’937 patent, including Jan. 22,
`1999 Amendment &
`
`Remarks/Arguments and June
`16, 1999 Amendment &
`Remarks/Arguments.
`
`
`
`“means for determining if the
`user input selects the control
`tool”
`
`determining if the
`Function:
`user input is intended to select or
`ignore the control tool
`
`See above for “user input” and
`“determining if the user input
`selects the control tool”
`
`[“user input” used as construed
`above].
`
`Structure: Touch screen panel
`474, analog controller 460,
`LCD 472, memory 440,
`feature processor 430,
`program 510 and touchscreen
`program 520, as disclosed in
`Figs. 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, 10, and 11;
`col. 427-21; 4:36-41; 4:48-
`5:40; 6:25-6:63; and 7:45-
`
`The specification of the ’937
`patent, including cols. 4:7-21;
`4:36-41; 4:48-5:40; 6:25-6:63
`
`7:45-8:11; and Figs 4-6 and 8-11
`and corresponding text.
`
`The prosecution history of the
`’937 patent, including Jan. 22,
`1999 Amendment &
`
`Remarks/Arguments and June
`16, 1999 Amendment &
`Remarks/Arguments.
`
`P.R. 4-3 EXHIBIT A CHART 0F DISPUTED TERMS
`McKool 1024230v1
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 5
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 5
`
`

`

`Case4:13-cv-05933-CW Document140-2 Filele/27/14 PageB of 20
`
`US. Patent No. 6,037,937
`
`Rockstar’s Proposal
`
`Rockstar’s Support
`
`“means for activating the at least
`one manipulation function when
`the user input does not select the
`control tool or permitting the at
`least one control tool function to
`
`be activated when the user input
`does select the control tool”
`
`“means for receiving a
`subsequent user input selecting a
`predetermined portion of the
`control tool, after at least one
`control tool function is permitted
`to be activated”
`
`
`
`8:11, and all equivalents
`thereto.
`
`at
`activating the
`Function:
`one
`manipulation
`least
`function when the user input
`does not select the control tool
`
`or permitting the at least one
`control
`tool
`function to be
`
`activated when the user input
`does select the control tool
`
`[“user input” and “permitting the
`at least one control tool function
`to be activated when the user
`
`input does select the control tool”
`used as construed above].
`
`Structure: Memory 440,
`feature processor 430,
`program 510 and touchscreen
`program 520, as disclosed in
`Figs. 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, 10, and 11;
`col. 4:7-21; 4:36-41; 4:48-
`
`6:63; and 7:45-8:11, and all
`equivalents thereto.
`
`receiving
`Function:
`input
`user
`subsequent
`predetermined
`a
`selecting
`portion of the control
`tool,
`after at least one control tool
`
`function is permitted to be
`activated
`
`[“user input” and “permitting the
`at least one control tool function
`to be activated when the user
`
`input does select the control tool”
`used as construed above].
`
`See above for “user inpu ” and
`“permitting the at least one
`control tool function to be
`
`activated when the user input
`does select the control tool”
`
`The specification of the ’937
`patent, including cols. 4:7—21;
`4:36-41; 4:48-6:63; 7:45-8:11;
`
`and Figs 4-6 and 8-11 and
`corresponding text.
`
`The prosecution history of the
`’937 patent, including Jan. 22,
`1999 Amendment &
`
`Remarks/Arguments and June
`16, 1999 Amendment &
`Remarks/Arguments.
`
`See above for “user input” and
`“permitting the at least one
`control tool function to be
`
`activated when the user input
`does select the control tool”
`
`The specification of the ’937
`patent,
`
`including cols. 4:7-21; 4:36-41;
`4:48-5:8; and 5:41-6:63; and Figs
`4-6 and 8-11 and corresponding
`text.
`
`The prosecution history of the
`’937 patent, including Jan. 22,
`1999 Amendment &
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 6
`
`Structure: Touch panel 474,
`
`PR. 4-3 EXHIBIT A CHART 0F DISPUTED TERMS
`McKool 1024230v1
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 6
`
`

`

`Case4:13-cv-05933-CW Document140-2 Filele/27/l4 Page? of 20
`
`US. Patent No. 6,037,937
`
`Rockstar’s Proposal
`
`Rockstar’s Support
`
`472, memory 440, feature
`processor 430, program 510
`and touchscreen program 520,
`as disclosed in Figs. 4, 5, 6, 8,
`9, 10 and 11; col. 4:7-21;
`
`thereto.-analogcontmller460’LCD
`
`
`
`Remarks/Arguments and June
`16, 1999 Amendment &
`Remarks/Arguments.
`
`See above for “user input”
`
`The specification of the ’937
`patent, including cols. 2:21-40;
`427-21; 4:36-41; 4:48-528; and
`5:41-6:63; and Figs 4-6 and 8-11
`and corresponding text.
`
`The prosecution history of the
`’937 patent, including Jan. 22,
`1999 Amendment &
`
`Remarks/Arguments and June
`16, 1999 Amendment &
`
`Remarks/Arguments.
`
`4:36-41; 4:48-5:8; and 5:41-
`6:63, and all equivalents
`
`“means for activating the
`function of changing a display of
`information in response to the
`subsequent user inpu ”
`
`the
`activating
`Function:
`function of changing a display
`of information in response to
`the subsequent user input.
`
`[“user input” used as construed
`above].
`
`Structure: Memory 440,
`feature processor 430,
`program 510 and touchscreen
`program 520, as disclosed in
`Figs. 4, 5, 6, 8, 9,10 and 11;
`col. 2:21-40; 4:7-21; 4:36-41;
`4:48-5:8; and 5:41-6:63, and
`all equivalents thereto.
`
`“wherein the means for
`
`displaying a representation of the
`control tool includes displaying
`arrows indicating direction”
`
`a
`displaying
`Function:
`representation of a control tool
`including
`arrows
`indicating
`direction
`overlaying
`the
`manipulable area portion and
`providing at least one control
`tool function associated with
`
`the overlayed control tool
`
`Structure: Display module
`470, touch panel 474, LCD
`472, memory 440, feature
`processor 430, and program
`510, as disclosed in Figs. 4, 5,
`
`See above for “user input”
`
`The specification of the ’937
`patent, including cols. 2:21-40;
`427-21; 4:36-41; 4:48-5226; 5:41-
`
`63; and 6:25-32; and Figs 4-11
`and corresponding text.
`
`The prosecution history of the
`’937 patent, including Jan. 22,
`1999 Amendment &
`
`Remarks/Arguments and June
`16, 1999 Amendment &
`Remarks/Arguments.
`
`PR. 4-3 EXHIBIT A CHART 0F DISPUTED TERMS
`McKool 1024230v1
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 7
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 7
`
`

`

`Case4:13-cv-05933-CW Document140-2 Filele/27/l4 PageB of 20
`
`US. Patent No. 6,037,937
`
`Rockstar’s Proposal
`
`Rockstar’s Support
`
`6, 7, 8, 9,10 and 11; col. 2:21-
`
`40; 4:7-21; 4:36-41; 4:48-
`
`5:26; 5:41-63; and 6:25-32,
`and all equivalents thereto.
`
`“wherein the means for
`
`displaying the representation of
`the control tool includes
`
`displaying an opaque
`representation of the control
`tool”
`
`an
`displaying
`Function:
`opaque
`representation of a
`control tool and providing at
`least one control tool function
`
`associated with the overlayed
`control tool
`
`Remarks/Arguments.
`
`The specification of the ’937
`patent, including cols. 2:21-40;
`427-21; 4:36-41; 4:48-5:26; and
`6:25-32; and Figs 4-6 and
`corresponding text.
`
`The prosecution history of the
`’937 patent, including Jan. 22,
`1999 Amendment &
`
`Remarks/Arguments and June
`16, 1999 Amendment &
`Remarks/Arguments.
`
`The specification of the ’937
`patent, including cols. 2:21-40;
`427-21; 4:36-41; 4:48-5:26; and
`
`6:25-34; and Figs 4-11 and
`corresponding text.
`
`The prosecution history of the
`’937 patent, including Jan. 22,
`1999 Amendment &
`
`Remarks/Arguments and June
`16, 1999 Amendment &
`
`Structure: Display module
`470, touch panel 474, LCD
`472, memory 440, feature
`processor 430, and program
`510, as disclosed in Figs. 4, 5,
`6; col. 2:21-40; 427-21; 4:36-
`
`41; 4:48-5:26; and 6:25-32,
`and all equivalents thereto.
`
`“wherein the means for
`
`displaying the representation of
`the control tool includes
`
`displaying a Virtually transparent
`representation of the control
`tool”
`
`Function: displaying a virtually
`transparent representation of a
`control tool and providing at least
`one control tool function
`
`associated with the overlayed
`control tool
`
`Function:
`
`a
`displaying
`Virtually
`transparent
`representation of a control tool
`and providing at
`least one
`control
`tool
`function
`
`associated with the overlayed
`control tool
`
`Structure: Display module
`470, touch panel 474, LCD
`472, memory 440, feature
`processor 430, and program
`510, as disclosed in Figs. 4, 5,
`
`PR. 4-3 EXHIBIT A CHART 0F DISPUTED TERMS
`McKool 1024230vl
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 8
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 8
`
`

`

`Case4:13-cv-05933-CW Document140-2 Filele/27/l4 PageQ of 20
`
`US. Patent No. 6,037,937
`
`Rockstar’s Proposal
`
`Rockstar’s Support
`
`equivalents thereto.
`
`6, 7, 8, 9,10 and 11; col. 2:21-
`
`40; 4:7-21; 4:36-41; 4:48-
`
`5:26; and 6:25-34, and all
`
`U. S. Patent No. 6, 128,298 (“the ’298 patent”)
`
`US. Patent No. 6,128,298
`
`Claim Term
`
`Rockstar’s Proposal
`
`Rockstar’s Support
`
`“means for receiving from the
`first network, a data packet
`having destination information,
`which includes a destination
`
`Function: receiving fiom the first
`network, a data packet having
`destination information, which
`includes a destination address
`
`See 7:65-8:6 and Fig. 2.
`
`See 5:37-60; 8:9-11 and Fig. 2.
`
`See 5:37-60; 829-11 and Fig. 2.
`
`address and a destination port,
`corresponding to a node in the
`second network and having
`source information, which
`includes a source address and a
`
`and a destination port,
`corresponding to a node in the
`second network and having
`source information, which
`includes a source address and a
`
`source port, corresponding to a
`node in the first networ ”
`
`source port, corresponding to a
`node in the first network
`
`“means for maintaining the
`source information taken from
`
`Structure: Packet Driver 30 and
`
`equivalents
`Function: maintaining the source
`information taken from the data
`
`the data packet in correlation
`with a unique value representing
`a port of the filter node”
`
`packet in correlation with a
`unique value representing a port
`of the filter node
`
`Structure: Software and/or
`
`hardware implementing
`translation table / Address
`
`Translation 40 and equivalents
`Function: replacing in the data
`packet the source address with an
`address of the filter node and the
`
`“means for replacing in the data
`packet the source address with an
`address of the filter node and the
`
`source port with the filter node
`port value”
`
`source port with the filter node
`port value
`
`Structure: Software and/or
`
`hardware implementing
`translation table / Address
`
`P.R. 4-3 EXHIBIT A CHART 0F DISPUTED TERMS
`McKool 1024230v1
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 9
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 9
`
`

`

`Case4:13-cv-05933-CW Document140-2 Filed10I27/l4 Page10 of 20
`
`US. Patent No. 6,128,298
`
`Rockstar’s Proposal
`
`Rockstar’s Support
`
`- Transmtion40andequivalents -
`
`See 7:65-8:6 and Fig. 2.
`
`“means for sending to the second
`network, the data packet having
`the replaced source information,
`whereby that packet is routed
`according to its destination
`information to the corresponding
`second network node”
`
`Function: sending to the second
`network, the data packet having
`the replaced source information,
`whereby that packet is routed
`according to its destination
`information to the corresponding
`second network node
`
`Structure: Packet Driver 32 and
`ecuivalents
`
`“means for receiving from the
`second network, a data packet
`having the address of the filter
`node as the destination address”
`
`Function: receiving from the
`second network, a data packet
`having the address of the filter
`node as the destination address
`
`See 7:65-8:6 and Fig. 2.
`
`“means for correlating the
`destination port of the destination
`information in the data packet to
`particular source information
`being maintained”
`
`Structure: Packet Driver 32 and
`
`equivalents
`Function: correlating the
`destination port of the destination
`information in the data packet to
`particular source information
`being maintained
`
`Structure: Software and/or
`
`hardware implementing
`translation table / Address
`Translation 40 and euivalents
`
`See 5:37-60; 829-11 and Fig. 2.
`
`“means for replacing, in the data
`packet, the destination
`information with the particular
`source information”
`
`Function: replacing, in the data
`packet, the destination
`information with the particular
`source information
`
`See 5:37-60; 829-11 and Fig. 2.
`
`See 7:65-8:6 and Fig. 2.
`
`Structure: Software and/or
`
`hardware implementing
`translation table / Address
`Translation 40 and e - uivalents
`
`“means for sending to the first
`network the data packet having
`the replaced destination
`information, whereby that packet
`is routed according to its
`destination information to the
`
`Function: sending to the first
`network the data packet having
`the replaced destination
`information, whereby that packet
`is routed according to its
`destination information to the
`
`PR. 4-3 EXHIBIT A CHART 0F DISPUTED TERMS
`McKool 1024230v1
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 10
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 10
`
`

`

`Case4:13-cv-05933-CW Document140-2 Filed10I27/14 Pagell of 20
`
`US. Patent No. 6,128,298
`
`Rockstar’s Proposal
`
`Rockstar’s Support
`
`See 3:22-24; 3:48-51; 5:37-60,
`
`and Fig. 2.
`
`See 7:65-8:6 and Fig. 2.
`
`See 5:37-60; 8:9-11 and Fig. 2.
`
`See 5:37-60; 829-11 and Fig. 2.
`
`corresponding first network
`node”
`
`“means for ignoring a data packet
`received from the second
`
`corresponding first network node
`
`Structure: Packet Driver 30 and
`
`equivalents
`Function: ignoring a data packet
`received from the second
`
`network, if the destination port of
`the destination information in
`
`network, if the destination port of
`the destination information in
`
`that data packet can not be
`correlated to the maintained
`source information”
`
`that data packet can not be
`correlated to the maintained
`source information
`
`Structure: Software and/or
`
`hardware implementing
`translation table / Address
`
`Translation 40 and equivalents
`Function: receiving fiom the first
`network, a data packet having a
`destination address
`
`corresponding to a node in the
`second network
`
`Structure: Packet Driver 30 and
`
`equivalents
`Function: maintaining the source
`address taken from the data
`
`“means for receiving from the
`first network, a data packet
`having a destination address
`corresponding to a node in the
`second network”
`
`“means for maintaining the
`source address taken from the
`
`data packet”
`
`packet
`
`Structure: Software and/or
`
`hardware implementing
`translation table / Address
`
`Translation 40 and equivalents
`Function: replacing, in the data
`packet, the source address with
`an address of the filter node,
`wherein the source address
`
`“means for replacing, in the data
`packet, the source address with
`an address of the filter node,
`wherein the source address
`
`includes a source port number
`and the address of the filter node
`
`includes a source port number
`and the address of the filter node
`
`includes a port number of the
`filter node”
`
`includes a port number of the
`filter node
`
`Structure: Software and/or
`
`hardware implementing
`translation table / Address
`
`“means for sending to the second
`
`Translation 40 and equivalents
`Function: sending to the second
`
`See 7:65-8:6 and Fig. 2.
`
`PR. 4-3 EXHIBIT A CHART 0F DISPUTED TERMS
`McKool 1024230v1
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 11
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 11
`
`

`

`Case4:13-cv-05933-CW Document140-2 Filed10I27/14 Page12 of 20
`
`US. Patent No. 6,128,298
`
`Rockstar’s Proposal
`
`Rockstar’s Support
`
`network the data packet having
`the replaced source address,
`whereby that packet is routed to
`the corresponding second
`network node”
`
`network the data packet having
`the replaced source address,
`whereby that packet is routed to
`the corresponding second
`network node
`
`See 7:65-8:6 and Fig. 2.
`
`See 5:37-60; 829-11 and Fig. 2.
`
`See 7:65-8:6 and Fig. 2.
`
`See 4:27-31 and Fig. 2.
`
`See 4:27-31 and Fig. 2.
`
`“means for receiving a return
`packet from the second network,
`responsive to the data packet
`having the replaced source
`information”
`
`“means for replacing, in the
`return packet, the destination
`address with the maintained
`source address”
`
`“means for sending to the first
`network the return packet having
`the replaced destination address,
`whereby that packet is routed to
`the corresponding the first
`network node”
`
`“means for buffering further data
`packets received from the first
`network while waiting for the
`return packet, and
`
`Structure: Packet Driver 32 and
`
`equivalents
`Function: receiving a return
`packet from the second network,
`responsive to the data packet
`having the replaced source
`information
`
`Structure: Packet Driver 32 and
`
`equivalents
`Function: replacing, in the return
`packet, the destination address
`with the maintained source
`address
`
`Structure: Software and/or
`
`hardware implementing
`translation table / Address
`
`Translation 40 and equivalents
`Function: sending to the first
`network the return packet having
`the replaced destination address,
`whereby that packet is routed to
`the corresponding the first
`network node
`
`Structure: Packet Driver 30 and
`
`equivalents
`Function: buffering further data
`packets received from the first
`network while waiting for the
`return packet
`
`Structure: at least one queue and
`associated hardware and/or
`software and euivalents
`
`means for controlling means (b)
`through (g) on an individual basis
`for processing the further
`packets, if any, that were
`
`Function: controlling means (b)
`through (g) on an individual basis
`for processing the further
`packets, if any, that were
`
`P.R. 4-3 EXHIBIT A CHART 0F DISPUTED TERMS
`McKool 1024230v1
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 12
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 12
`
`

`

`Case4:13-cv-05933-CW Document140-2 Filed10I27/14 Page13 of 20
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,128,298
`
`buffered”
`
`buffered
`
`Rockstar’s Proposal
`
`Rockstar’s Support
`
`Structure: at least one queue and
`associated hardware and/or
`software and e-uivalents
`
`Plain and ordinary meaning
`
`File History
`Generally, the ’298 Patent and its
`File Histo
`
`Generally, the ’298 Patent and its
`File Histo
`
`Generally, the ’298 Patent and its
`File History
`
`Generally, the ’298 Patent and its
`File Histo
`
`Generally, the ’298 Patent and its
`File History
`Generally, the ’298 Patent and its
`File History
`Generally, the ’298 Patent and its
`File History
`
`Generally, the ’298 Patent and its
`File History
`
`
`
`“in correlation with”
`
`“maintaining, by the filter node”
`
`“maintaining the source
`information taken from the
`outgoing data packet in
`correlation with a unique value
`representing a port of the filter
`node”
`
`“maintaining the source address
`taken from the data acket”
`
`“ignoring”
`
`Order of steps of claims 11, 14,
`15, 19, 23, 24
`Antecedent basis of “the source
`address taken from the data
`packet”
`Antecedent basis of “the
`[corresponding] public node
`network”
`
`No construction necessary.
`Antecedent basis exists in
`precedin limitation(s)
`“the corresponding node in the
`public networ ”
`
`D.
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,333,973 (“The ’973 patent”)
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,333,973
`
`of the notification messa es is
`
`Claim Term
`
`Rockstar’s Proposal
`
`Rockstar’s Support
`
`“means for automatically
`receiving notification messages
`corresponding to pending
`messages of different types, the
`notification messages including
`information regarding the source
`of each of the pending messages
`and the type of each of the
`pending messages, wherein each
`of the notification messa es is
`
`Function: automatically receiving
`notification messages
`corresponding to pending
`messages of different types, the
`notification messages including
`information regarding the source
`of each of the pending messages
`and the type of each of the
`pending messages, wherein each
`
`’973 Patent at 5:9-39 and Figs. 2-
`3 and accompanying text.
`
`’973 Patent File History,
`including all office actions and
`their responses, the interview
`summary, and the notice of
`allowability.
`
`P.R. 4-3 EXHIBIT A CHART 0F DISPUTED TERMS
`McKool 1024230v1
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 13
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 13
`
`

`

`Case4:13-cv-05933-CW Document140-2 Filed10I27/14 Page14 of 20
`
`US. Patent No. 6,333,973
`
`Rockstar’s Proposal
`
`Rockstar’s Support
`
`automatically sent to the user
`when one of the pending
`messages is initially received and
`wherein the notification
`
`automatically sent to the user
`when one of the pending
`messages is initially received and
`wherein the notification
`
`messages are received fiom an
`interface with independent
`connections with different
`bandwidths for the different
`
`messages are received from an
`interface with independent
`connections with different
`bandwidths for the different
`
`types of pending messages”
`
`types of pending messages
`
`
`
`“means for determining a
`message type of the pending
`messages from the information
`corresponding to the received
`notification messages”
`
`“means for associating a message
`type indicator with each of the
`received notification messages
`based on the determined message
`type”
`
`“means for receiving a selection
`of one of the pending messages
`based on the entries in the single
`selectable list”
`
`Structure: GSM Radio 3210, A/D
`and D/A 3235, and antenna 2200
`and 3100, including as recited
`and described in Figures 2 and 3,
`and equivalents
`Function: determining a message
`type of the pending messages
`from the information
`
`corresponding to the received
`notification messages
`
`Structure: Feature processor
`3300, memory 3400, and
`message center 6100, including
`as recited and described in
`
`Figures 3, 6, 7A, and 7B, and
`equivalents
`Function: associating a message
`type indicator with each of the
`received notification messages
`based on the determined message
`type
`
`Structure: Feature processor
`3300, memory 3400, and
`message center 6100, including
`as recited and described in
`
`Figures 3, 6, 7A, and 7B, and
`equivalents
`Function: receiving a selection of
`one of the pending messages
`based on the entries in the single
`selectable list
`
`Structure: Display 2400, feature
`processor 3300, sliding keypad
`3500, analo controller 3600, and
`
`’973 Patent at 2:32-40, 5:14-18,
`
`5250-62 and 8:27-9:5, and Figs.
`3, 6, 7A, and 7B and
`
`accompanying text.
`
`’973 Patent at 2:41-50, 5:14-18,
`
`5250-62 and 8:27-95, and Figs.
`3, 6, 7A, and 7B and
`accompanying text.
`
`’973 Patent 5:9-18, 5:50-6:2, and
`6:40-59, and Figs. 2 and 3 and
`accompanying text.
`
`PR. 4-3 EXHIBIT A CHART 0F DISPUTED TERMS
`McKool 1024230vl
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 14
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 14
`
`

`

`Case4:13-cv-05933-CW Document140-2 Filed10I27/14 Page15 of 20
`
`US. Patent No. 6,333,973
`
`Rockstar’s Proposal
`
`Rockstar’s Support
`
`“means for retrieving
`[manipulating] the selected
`pending message for viewing and
`manipulation by the user”
`
`“means for accessing an external
`mail server”
`
`“means for retrieving the selected
`pending message from the
`external mail server”
`
`display module 3700, including
`as recited and described in
`
`Figures 2 and 3, and equivalents
`Function: retrieving the selected
`pending message for viewing and
`manipulation by the user
`
`Structure: GUI manager 4100
`and message center 6100,
`including as recited and
`described in Figures 4, 6, 7A, and
`7B, and equivalents
`Function: accessing an external
`mail server
`
`Structure: Mobile telephone 1100
`and message center 6100,
`including as recited and
`described in Figures 2, 6, 7A, and
`7B, and equivalents
`Function: retrieving the selected
`pending message from the
`external mail server
`
`Structure: Mobile telephone
`1100, antenna 2200 and 3100,
`and message center 6100,
`including as recited and
`described in Figures 2, 3, 6, 7A,
`and 7B, and euivalents
`
`’973 Patent 2:41-50, 3:54-56,
`
`5:65-6:7 and 8:27-9:5, and Figs.
`4, 6, 7A, and 7B and
`accompanying text.
`
`’973 Patent 3:48-67, 5:9-31, and
`8:27-9:5, and Figs. 2, 6, 7A, and
`7B and accompanying text.
`
`’973 Patent 2:41-50, 3:48-67,
`
`529-31, and 8:27-9:5, and Figs. 2,
`3, 6, 7A, and 7B and
`accompanying text.
`
`File Histo .
`
`“means for associating a message
`type indicator with each of the
`received notification messages
`based on the message type of the
`corresponding pending message”
`
`Function: associating a message
`type indicator with each of the
`received notification messages
`based on the message type of the
`corresponding pending message
`
`’973 Patent at 5:14-18, 5:50-6:2
`
`and 8:27-9:5, and Figs. 3, 6, 7A,
`and 7B and accompanying text.
`
`Structure: Feature processor
`3300, memory 3400, and
`message center 6100, including
`as recited and described in
`
`Figures 3, 6, 7A, and 7B, and
`euivalents
`
`“pending message”
`
`Plain and ordinary meaning
`
`Generally, the ’973 Patent and its
`
`“notification message” (as used
`in the phrases “notification
`
`Plain and ordinary meaning
`
`Generally, the ’973 Patent and its
`File Histo .
`
`P.R. 4-3 EXHIBIT A CHART 0F DISPUTED TERMS
`McKool 1024230v1
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 15
`
`Google Ex. 1126, pg. 15
`
`

`

`Case4:13-cv-05933-CW Document140-2 Filed10I27/14 Page16 of 20
`
`US. Patent No. 6,333,973
`
`Rockstar’s Proposal
`
`Rockstar’s Support
`
`messages corresponding to
`pending messages”) (claims 1, 8,
`21)
`“wherein the notification
`messages are received fiom an
`interface with independent
`connections with different
`
`'
`5’
`bandwidths for [the] different
`1: es of n-endm
`“wherein the noification
`messages are received from an
`interface with independent
`connections with different
`bandwidths for the different
`
`types of the plurality of message
`senders”
`
`Plain and ordinary meaning
`
`Generally, the ’973 Patent and its
`File History.
`
`Plain and ordinary meaning
`
`Generally, the ’973 Patent and its
`File History.
`
`
`
`
`File Histo .
`
`File Histo .
`
`File History.
`
`File Histo .
`
`E.
`
`US. Patent No. 6,463,131 (“the ’131 patent”)
`
`US. Patent No. 6,463,131
`
`Claim Term
`
`Rockstar’s Proposal
`
`Rockstar’s Support
`
`“means for determining a
`characteristic of the
`communication event”
`
`Function: determining a
`characteristic of the
`communication event
`
`’ 131 Patent at 4:49-5-14 and Fig.
`1 and accompanying text.
`
`Structure: Processor 142 and
`
`memory 144, including as recited
`and described in Figure 1,