Ex. GOOG 1009
`
`EX. GOOG 1009
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`EX. GOOG 1009
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`PATENT
`Attomey Docket Na; 3384,01t5~oo
`
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEI\IIARK QFFlCE.
`
`RECE\\IEO
`J~N ·2. 6 \9~~:
`a.rnup Z700
`.
`..
`=tflt)fi
`·Gro'UP Ad· Umt; 277Y
`Examinen Thomas Nguyen 0 0~
`l -d.")- q
`
`).
`)
`)
`}
`).
`)
`)
`)
`)
`);
`)
`
`Brhm BEATON et.al.
`
`Ser1~1 No,:. 06/965.265
`
`Fll~d; December 4, 1997
`
`For: NAVIGATION TOOL FOR
`'GRAPHICAL USER
`'JNTERFACb
`
`· Assistant Commissioner for Patent$
`Washington, o.c, 20231
`
`Sir:
`
`AMENDMENT UNbER37C.f.R.§ 1.111
`
`In reply to the OffiCi1'!1 Acti.on.dated .October 23, ·1998~ for which the period for
`
`reply ends on January 23, 1999 (a Saturd$y), please -amend the application as follows:
`
`0112a11 m NROSE1 ®000001 ~n. ~.~
`01
`i~fHE SPECIFICATION:
`
`FC;iOJ
`
`Please am\d th.e specification as follows:
`Pag~ 1, li~ ~· change "08/_. _,_. _.~to ..;oe/985,264--;
`lin\7, change "No. OS/_._. ,_"to -No. 08/985,261~-;
`
`Une 24, after "with" insert-a-.
`
`LA.,W Of'PI0£8
`Fil'JNECIIN, HENDERSON,
`FAI).A9DW1 C(\RRETT,
`·s ouMJtR,'L.L.P.
`!lPC? J ~TRtlti N:. ~-~
`WASHINGfONj p. Co 2000!5
`~92.-~8· ... 900;
`
`l
`j
`
`j
`
`·~ j:
`
`. 'l'
`
`Ex. GOOG 1009
`
`
`
`1
`h f 1
`I
`•
`'""2·· . .,.
`•
`b.
`\
`'· pleS$.e msertt e· QriPW ng new p<!ragraph:
`Page 4, efore lm.e
`------~~------------~--------------------------------~--]
`/9. t•
`~igs, 14A and 148 are gr~phs showing the. touch characteristics of a
`~Q:.Q
`n1 ;f'_~l\/EO
`, pen afld a·ftnger, respectively."'
`' ·;It 2 6 1999
`P~ge 5, "\~ 1 o, ehange ":11 O" ro ·~21(),.; ~nd
`
`Group 2:700
`\
`line 1\change "2.10" to - 310-.
`Page e, line 25, chal']ge "310 (Fig. 4)" to -21 0_(fig. $A)- and change h21Q!'to
`~ •~310-; and
`\ lin·~, after "contacts" Insert -(Fig . 4)~.
`
`Page 7, line 11, .change ;'210" _to -310-,.
`
`IN THE CLAIMS;
`
`Please arnend citaims 1-22, wlthouf prejudice, and add new claims 23 and 24 as
`
`follows:
`
`1. (Amended) A method of actlvatjngJi.mctlons responsive to <i user input,
`
`[eontrolling display of content informe~tion in a physic;ii viewing -area] comprising [the
`
`steps of]:
`
`provjdtng a manipull~ble .area portion [displaying the. content information] in (the]
`
`~· phyalcal viewing area, sajd manipulable ·area portion having at least~:me manipulation
`
`function associated therewith;
`
`displaying a representation of a control tool overlayihg the.manipulable area
`
`portion, said-control tool having at least one contrel tool function associated therewith
`
`[over the .display of ~cm;tent inform~tionJ;
`
`-2-
`
`L~w 0'1"'1~,;:1
`FrNNEC..,N, Hrno~l\.lON, .
`fAilAIIOW.o CM!l£TT,
`II 0UNNU;L.V.
`ISUO 1 1:5'TIIIr:,.tr·1 M,'!ft'•
`~ I'I I HO T ON f o.c. iiOOO!I
`tOJ · 40B · .... ooo
`
`..
`
`{
`·. ;
`
`Ex. GOOG 1009
`
`
`
`receiving a user input [selecting the control :toolJtQ. the pby'sie@l VIewing areij
`
`corresponding to the manibulable area portion and the representation of'the control
`
`detennininq ifthe user jonut selects the control ·tool; ;;~nCI
`
`acithtatiog the at least one manip.ulatjon.function when the user input does not
`
`select the control tool or permitting the at least one control tool function to be activated·
`
`when the user input does select the corjt[ol top I [contrplling tl')e display of cont~;mt
`
`inforti'lation according· fu. the user. input},
`
`•
`A
`.
`.
`2\ (Amended) The method -of clairn 1, wherein the at least one control tool
`
`function includes a function of changing a display oflnformatlon in the manipulable area
`
`portion, the method further including~ [the steps of]
`
`after at least one control tool function is pellT!itted tQ be_ activated. reeeiving a
`
`subsequent user input selecting a predetermined portion of the c.ontroltool~[.] and
`
`activating the function ofchang!ng a display of infwmatjon [the control fool] in
`
`response to the subsequent user input[; and wherein the controlling step includes the
`
`s_upstep of changing the display to a differ¢~ht portion of t.he content inforri'latlon].
`
`3. (Amended) Th~ method of cla.im ~ {1 ], wherein the {qontrolling step) function
`
`of chanqjng a display of information io~h.!<:les [the,sul;lstep of] shifting [the content]
`
`information in the manipulable a tea pOrtion [physical viewing ateaJ.
`
`LA"" ornc~:a
`FINNECII.N, H!NDEIUON1
`f"-llA~OW,GAI'.l\En,
`I!" DUNNER, L.L.r.
`iJPO l';,al'n'E.r.'!'1·M, VI.•
`N.\sHINOTqN1 D:.: c. Ze·ooo.
`~OZ·406•. 40.00
`
`- 3-
`
`' .
`
`Ex. GOOG 1009
`
`
`
`4, (Amended) The metMd of claim 3,wherein the shifting [step} includes [the
`
`substep of] scrolling [to a dlfferent portion of the c.ontent information].
`
`5. (Amended) The method of claJm 3, wherein the shifting [step] includes [the
`
`substep of] jumpin9 {to a different portion of the coritentinformation].
`
`6. (Amended) The method ·of claim "[1], wherein the function of cbangfng a
`
`display of information [controlling step] includes control ofthe speed oftbe change of
`
`the di~play of information based on th.e subsequent user input [the substep of shifting
`
`the display of content Information at .~ speed determined by to the user input].
`
`7. (Amended) The method of claim 2. [1], wherein the Changing [control
`
`information] includes [a plurality of pages, and wherein the controlling step incl.udes the
`
`substep of] displaying ·a different on:e of a plurality of {the] pages of [the content]
`
`information.
`
`B. (Amended) The method of claim 1, wherein the [step oij displaying i!.
`
`.reoresentation of the control tool includes [the substep o~ displaying [the control tool
`
`containing] arrows. Indicating direction.
`
`9. (Amended) The method of claim 1, wherein the [control] information displayed
`
`jn the manipulable area portion includes. a ~ortion of a document and wherein the [step
`
`-4-
`
`' .
`
`....,.w al"r'tc:.E.•
`FINJ<fGIIN, HlNDEI\SON;
`fiiP.IIBOW, (:;llltRHT,
`II DUNNE!t, L.L,f.
`1300 1 SJII.r:tr1 H. W.
`WA..I-HINCITO'N1 0. Co 1()00!1
`1:0I:· .. b8•400.0
`
`Ex. GOOG 1009
`
`
`
`of displaying the control tool! at least one control tool function includes [the substep of
`
`displaying the control tool indicating various functions] a function related to the
`
`document.
`
`10. (Amended) The method of claim 1, wherein the [step oij displaying the
`
`representation or the cohtrol tool includes [the substf:!p of] displaying a virtually
`
`transparent representation of the control tool.
`
`11. (Amended) The method o1 claim 1, wherein the [step of] displaying the
`
`representation of tbe control tool includes [the substep of) displaying an opaque
`
`representation of the control tool.
`
`13,
`)&.. (Amended) An apparatus for activating functions responsive to a user input.
`
`(controlling display of content information in a physical viewing area] comprising:
`
`means for providing a manipulable area portion !displaying the· content
`
`information} in [the]~ physical viewing area. sajd manipulable area portion haying at
`
`least one manipulation function associated therewith:
`
`means for displaying a representation of a control tool overlaying the
`
`manipulable area portion. said control tool having at least one control tool function
`
`associated therewith [over the display of content information);
`
`"""""o,.,c.-.a
`FrNHEGIIN, HEND~II.ION,
`FIIII.,-BOW, c.\11.1\I!TT,
`& D~tNllER,L.l.P.
`UOO l 5f,.CP1 ,.. , w.
`WA.I•U NOTOH1 O.t;. ZO.OO•
`I:Ot• • OO• 4000
`
`- 5-
`
`..
`
`.·· (
`
`Ex. GOOG 1009
`
`
`
`means for receiving_ a user Input [selecting the c.ontrol tool] to the physical
`
`vjewjng area .ccmespondlng to the manioulable area _portion and tbe representation of
`
`the control tool:
`
`rneaMs for determining if the user Input seiects the control tool; and
`
`rne.ans for activating the at l~ast on~ mahlpulation function when the user input
`
`does not select the control tool or permitting the at least one control tool function to be
`
`activated when the user Input does select the control .tool [contrblling the display of
`
`content information atcording to the user input].
`
`Jt
`u
`'1i, (Amended) The apparatus of claim~ wherein the aoeast one control tool
`function includes a function of changing a display of lnfonnatjon in the maojpulable-area
`
`portion. the apparatus further including~
`
`means for receiving a subsequent user input selecting a predetermined portion
`
`of the control tool. after at least one control tool function is permitted to be activated,
`
`and
`
`means for activating the fvnctlon of changing a display oflnfonnatjon [the control
`
`tool] in response to the suL?segyent user Input[. and wherein the controlling means
`
`includes means for changing the display to a different portion of the content
`
`information}.
`
`\.~"Y CF"f"l,::ll:~
`Ftl-IHECAN, HeNDEI\5oN,
`fARABOW;.GARKfTT,
`ll :OUNNER,L.L.~.
`llOO 1 UU;ET1 H,W,
`w-"sHINGrort1 o~ c, .aooos
`.ao),.: .. oit-4ooo
`
`-6-
`
`(
`
`Ex. GOOG 1009
`
`
`
`lb',
`~~
`~ (Amended) ihe apparatus of cl~tlm :ti [12l, wherein the [controlling means]
`
`function of changing a djsplay of infonnation includes {means for] sl')lftlng· ftbe content)
`
`information in the manipulable area portion [physical viewing ar~aJ.
`
`''·
`-~
`t5.. (Amended) The apparatus of claim X wherein the shifting [means] includes,
`[means for] scrolling [to a different portipn of the content information].
`
`.
`
`t7.
`l.t
`'(Amended) The 'appar~tu~ of,elaim 't4, whe,teirt the shifting {nieans] includes
`
`[meari::rfor] jumping [to a-different portion .of the :content infor.triation].
`
`JY
`~~.
`~ (Amended) The !'lpparatus of· claim ~J12], wherein the function .of chang ina:
`
`a display of lnfortnation [controlling means]jndudes i:iontrol ofthe speed offhe Change
`
`of tbe display of Information based on the subsegue[]t user input Jmeans for shifting the
`
`display of content information ala ·!)peed .determined .by the user input].
`
`J,y
`/~.
`~(Amended)· The .apriaratus of claim ~[12]; wherein the (content information]
`
`changing includes [a plurality of pages, and wherein the controlling means includes
`
`means for] displaying a different [ones] one of [the] a plurality of pages of [th~ content]
`
`information.
`
`6·
`•
`'1:9.. (Amended} The apparatus of claim ~wherein the means for displaying :!.!
`
`representation of the control tool Includes [means for] displaying [the control tool
`
`~AW O't'liC: a=.s
`FINNECA!-1, H ~N D!~$0N,
`FARAI!OW, GA!lll.IITT,
`& 0UNN~R,l.L .P.
`I;JQ-Q , ) &,1t t i!T1 H,W,
`.WASl1 l HO,O'"f1 0 . C. ZOOO tl
`10:1:• <tOO· .... OO O
`
`~7-
`
`Ex. GOOG 1009
`
`
`
`containing] arrows indicating direction.
`
`.
`•.3·
`.
`21.
`·'2Q.. (Amended) The apparatus of claim ~~ wheteln the [content] information
`
`displayed in the manipulable area. portion includes. a portion of a document, and
`
`wnetein the [means fqr qisplayirig th~ pOntrol too:l] at least one controltool function
`
`"
`includes [means for displaying the centro! tool Jndic~ating ,various functions] a function
`
`related td the document.
`
`~.
`Jj
`'
`~ (Amended) The apparatus of claim~ wherein the means for displaying the
`
`.representation ofthe control tqol includes ,[means for] displaying a: virtually transparent
`
`represe.ntatiol1' of1h~ control tool.
`
`!,3
`:,a,
`)i (Amended) The apparafiJS of claim~· wherein the means for displaying the
`
`representation of the control tool includes [means for] displaying an opaque
`
`representation of the contra. I tool.
`
`.1. _ .•
`
`Please add the following ·new claims:
`f:t.
`-'2-3,. The method according to claim 1, wherein the at least ohE! manipulation
`
`function inclUdes an editing function for a doc;ument.-
`
`IJ .
`-24. The apparaii,Js a.ccordiog to clai.m ~ wherein lhe ~t J~ast one
`
`mahipt.ilation function. includes an editing function for a docume.nt.-~
`
`FINNtCAN, HENDE.R:SON,
`l'AA1JDOW, Chl\RUT,
`.e· DONNER, L;L.~ • .
`llOO 1 !ITRE.£T1 N, Wo
`WA~I11N~H.ON.1 ~~. c;o iii:OQp,~
`
`ZP2--40S,.."tO~:::I.Q
`
`- 8 ·-
`
`; .J
`
`,.
`
`Ex. GOOG 1009
`
`
`
`IN THE DRAWINGS:
`
`Subject to the approval of the Examiner, please amend Figs. 3A, 1 OA, at1d 11 B
`
`in accordance with the' red~marked changes in the l~equestfor Approval of Drawing
`
`Changes address~ to the draft~perS,on.
`
`REMARkS
`
`In the Office· Action, the Office objected to the specification because the related
`
`applications were not identified by application number. Regarding rejections based on
`
`art, the Office rejected claims 1"7, 9·18. ·eu1d 2.0,~2 - !Jnl]er 35 U.S.G. § 1 02(e) as being
`
`anticipated by U.S. Patent 5i 7361982. to BetmaN etaL (Berman). The Office rejected
`tlaims 8 and 19 under 35 U.s.c. § 103(a:)as being unpatentable over Berman .ln view
`
`of U.S. Patent $,745,116 tQ Pis!iltha-Amond,
`
`The ~pacification hal! been f:!ITiehded to .address the Offic.e'~ 6~Jection 't_o the
`
`speCificati_on, .and otherwise to place this application in better condition for Issue.
`
`A separate Request for Approval of Drawing Changes is being filed concurrently
`
`to correct minor errors appearii:JQ in the drawings.
`
`Without acceding to the outstanding rejections and solely to :advance.
`
`prosecution, Applicant f:'las amended claims 1-22. Claims 23~24 have b.een added to
`
`proVide more comprehensive patent protection for the invention·.
`
`Independent ,clairns 1 and 12, as amended,_distingtJish patentably from the prior
`
`art of record.
`
`FINN£CAN, H~N D EiUON1
`FAI\ ABQW, C Ail.Rf.TTj
`8 O U~I>lf lt, ~. L .P.
`u oc I srncn, .. . w.
`WA.StfiNGTotr1 D. C.. toOO&
`a,oa .. ..a a ~ "coo
`
`-9-
`
`Ex. GOOG 1009
`
`
`
`Specifically, independent c.laim 1 recites a method qf activating f~nctlons
`
`responsive lo. a user input including, lriter alia, providing a manipulable area portion in ·a
`
`physical viewing area, the manipulable area portion having at least cme manipulation
`
`function associated thereWith, and displaying a· representation of a control tool
`
`oveilaying the manipulable area portion, the control te>ol having at least one control tool
`
`function associated .therewith.
`
`Claim 1 further r:ecites receiving a user input to the physical viewing area
`
`corresponding to the manipuh:ible area portion and the representation of the control tool
`
`and determining if the user input sel~cts the control toot Also, claim 1 recites ·activating
`
`the at least one manipulation function when th~ user input does not select the control
`
`tool or permitting the at. least one control tool function to be activated when the user
`
`input does sele<;:t the control tool.
`
`Independent clair:n 12 rec~es' an apparatus fqt activating functions responsive to
`
`a user input including, ibt~r alia. means Jor providing a manipulable area portion ln a
`
`physical viewing area. the manipulable area portion having at least one manipulation
`
`function associated therewith, and rneans for displaying a representation .of a control
`
`tool overlaying the manipulable area portion, the control tool having at lea.st one control
`
`tool function associated therewith.
`
`Claim 12 further recites means for receiving.a user input to the physical vie~ing
`
`area corresponding to the -manipulable area portion an·d thE! representation of the
`
`control tool and means for determining if the user input selects the control tool. Also;
`
`claim 12 recites means for activat!ng the at least one manipulation function When the
`
`IA'W 0f' f' IC~
`Fll-lNECAI-1, H!NOEMON,
`f:ARI\IIOW, CA'~kETt,
`6 0UNN£R,l.lo.P.
`1:1 00 t stn t £1, N. w.
`ljiJ,.'!IMnf,:tTON/ D. E;- '1.000'"'
`!:O'i•<4qB • ..t~OOO
`
`-10-
`
`.,
`
`' .
`
`.·. [·
`
`Ex. GOOG 1009
`
`
`
`user Input does not select the control tool or permitting· thei at IE!ast one control tool
`
`function to be activated when the u~er input does select the· control tool.
`
`Berman, relied upon to reject independent cle~ims 1 and 1'2, falls to dlsclose or
`
`suggest-a combination offeatures as claimed in claims 1 and 12. The action handles
`
`of Berman, previo.usly indicated by the Office to correspond to (he recited control tool,
`
`"always provide a place where the stylus always acts as a pointing device rather than a
`
`pen (that is, no digital ink Is created when touching an action handre) :~ See col. 5, lines
`
`64-67 of Berman.
`
`Accordingly, Bannan teaches the antithesis of'provldlng a manipulable area
`
`portion in a physical viewing area, the manip:ulable area portion halilng at least one
`
`manipulation funetion assoctated therewith, and displaying ;a' ~presentation of a control
`
`.tool overlaying the manipulable area portion, tile control tool hewing at least one control
`
`tool function associated therewith; as recited in combination in method claim 1 and
`
`apparatus claim 12. Further, it necessarily follows that Berman also tails to disclose or
`
`suggest activating the at least one manipulation function when the user input does not
`
`select the control tool or permitting tt;e-at least one cohtrQI tool function to be activated
`
`when the user input does select the eontrol tool, as claimed.
`
`Therefore, Berman does not render claims t and 12 invalid Wider 35 U.S.C.
`
`§§ 102 and 10$, and those claims, as well as dependent ciEiims, 2;-11 and 13~24 are
`
`allowable over Berman.
`
`1-AWC<rP:t<:.a.S
`fli<NECIIN, !-1ENDER50N1
`FN>.AWW; GliRRETT,
`II DUNilEk,~.~.P.
`1300 1 STR.£tT, N. '!J.
`w.-_SHINGTO~I b.~ 2000!1
`202·408•4000
`
`·11 -
`
`I
`
`•
`
`Ex. GOOG 1009
`
`
`
`Pisutha~Amond clearly fails to remedy the deficiencies .of Berman noted above.
`
`fn view of the foregoing amendments and remari<s, Applicant respectfuliy
`
`requests the reconsideration and reexamination of this application and the timely
`
`allowance of the pending claims.
`
`To the .. extent any extension at time under 37 C.F.R. §.1 .136 is required to obtain
`
`entry of this response, sueh extension Is hereby respectfully requested . If there are any
`
`fees due under 37 C.F.R. §§ 1.16 or 1.17 whleh are hot~nclosed hereWith, Including
`
`any fees required for an extension of time under 37 C.F.R. § 1.136, please charge such
`
`fees to our Deposit Account No. 06-0916.
`
`Respectfully s.ubmitted,
`
`FINNEGAN, HENDERSON, FARABOW,
`GARRETT & DUNNER, L.L.P.
`
`\ By:._¥'1>"<.!..!.1:11""':'-:-:i!r.-"-'-.:&...::'---- - -
`
`Dated: January 22, 1999
`
`u.·H Orf"ICC11
`fiNNfCAN, HF.NDEMON,
`FAI\ABOW, GAI\I\ETT,
`8 0UNNEP.1 L, L.P.
`1100. 1 STREU1 N, W,
`Wo"'&HINQTON1 D, c:;:. 2000~
`IOZ·•o8• ... 000
`
`- 12-
`
`I
`
`•
`
`.·
`
`(
`
`Ex. GOOG 1009
Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.
After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.
Accept $ Charge
Still Working On It
This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.
Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.
A few More Minutes ... Still Working
It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.
Thank you for your continued patience.
This document could not be displayed.
We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.
Your account does not support viewing this document.
You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.
Your account does not support viewing this document.
Set your membership
status to view this document.
With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll
get a whole lot more, including:
- Up-to-date information for this case.
- Email alerts whenever there is an update.
- Full text search for other cases.
- Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.
One Moment Please
The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.
Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.
Your document is on its way!
If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.
Sealed Document
We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.
If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.
Access Government Site
