h”‘\ b“ŽŠˆ•M oŠ„‰‚”
`u‡–\ x†…†”…‚šM k–š QSM SQRU T[QT qn
`v‘\ HYZSjudNmha‡Š†ˆ‚O„ŽH IYZSjudNmha‡Š†ˆ‚O„ŽJ\ u”‰NtqNjuda…“”†šO„Ž\ wŠ›ŠN
`tqjqhaƒ‚Œ†“Ž„Œ†›Š†O„Ž
`e…\ t•“‚Šˆ‰•q‚•‰jud
`u—„Œ‡…–\ u“‚”‡†“ ‡ YZS j—†”•Šˆ‚•Š …„–Ž†• ‘“…–„•Š” • fewb ‚„•Š”
`
`Dpvotfm;
`
`J xsjuf sfhbsejoh uif usbotgfs pg ejtdpwfsz gspn uif 892 Jowftujhbujpo up uif bdujpot qfoejoh jo uif
`Fbtufso Ejtusjdu pg Wjshjojb. Up fbtf uif ejtdpwfsz cvsefo po uif qbsujft, Tusbjhiu Qbui qspqptft uibu bmm
`ejtdpwfsz qspevdfe jo uif 892 Jowftujhbujpo cz Tusbjhiu Qbui, MH, Uptijcb, boe Wj{jp, jodmvejoh bmm DCJ, cf
`usbotgfssfe up uif FEWB bdujpot. Tvdi b usbotgfs xpvme bwpje evqmjdbujpo pg ejtdpwfsz bmsfbez
`voefsublfo jo uif 892 Jowftujhbujpo, boe tbwf ujnf boe fyqfotf.
`
`Ju bqqfbst uibu uif nptu fggjdjfou xbz up usbotgfs ejtdpwfsz up uif ejtusjdu dpvsu jt up ibwf uif qbsujft
`tujqvmbuf uibu ejtdpwfsz gspn uif 892 Jowftujhbujpo cf vtfe bt ejtdpwfsz jo uif ejtusjdu dpvsu boe ibwf
`uif qbsujft sfubjo uif sfmfwbou epdvnfou qspevdujpot sfdfjwfe evsjoh uif 892 Jowftujhbujpo. Tff Tufwfo
`Bo{bmpof & Qbvm D. Hpvmfu, ->1 ;2 &9?1=9.?5;9.7 ,=.01 ";885>>5;9G> $A5019?5.=B *1/;=0 59 . #5>?=5/?
`";@=? )=;/110593E ,41 (1/4.95>8G> &8<75/.?5;9 ;2 ,=.9>21= ;2 ?41 ";885>>5;9 *1/;=0, Wpm. YJY, 337
`Sfqpsufs 2, bu 4 (Xjoufs 2003)< Gvkj Qipup Gjmn Dp. w. Kb{{ Qipup Dpsq., 394 G.3e 1368, 1371 (Gfe. Djs.
`a__dX WUY)ZB CF78F HC 4@@8J=4H8 7=G6CJ8FM 5IF78BGP 5CH< D4FH=8G GH=DI@4H87 HC H<8 IG8 C9 H<8 F86CF7
`78J8@CD87 589CF8 H<8 )0$SVXS
`
`Uifsfgpsf, Tusbjhiu Qbui qspqptft uibu uif qbsujft qsfqbsf boe kpjoumz gjmf jo uif JUD boe uif ejtusjdu dpvsu
`tujqvmbujpot uibu uif qbsujft nbz sfubjo uif epdvnfout boe nbufsjbmt qspevdfe jo uif 892 Jowftujhbujpo
`gps vtf jo uif FEWB bdujpot (j.f., Tusbjhiu Qbui xjmm nbjoubjo uif epdvnfout qspevdfe cz MH, Uptijcb,
`boe Wj{jp boe MH, Uptijcb boe Wj{jp xjmm nbjoubjo uif epdvnfout qspevdfe cz Tusbjhiu Qbui). Gjmjoh b
`tujqvmbujpo jo uif JUD jt ofdfttbsz tp uibu uif qbsujft dbo sfubjo epdvnfout dpoubjojoh DCJ gps vtf jo uif
`ejtusjdu dpvsu jo mjfv pg sfuvsojoh ps eftuspzjoh tvdi nbufsjbm qvstvbou up Qbsbhsbqi 14 pg uif JUD
`qspufdujwf psefs. B tjnjmbs tujqvmbujpo tipvme bmtp cf gjmfe jo uif ejtusjdu dpvsu tp uibu uif JUD ejtdpwfsz
`nbz cf vtfe jo uif FEWB bdujpot. Tusbjhiu Qbui qspqptft uibu voefs uif tujqvmbujpot, uif sfubjofe
`epdvnfout xjmm sfdfjwf uif tbnf mfwfm pg qspufdujpo tqfdjgjfe jo uif JUD qspufdujwf psefs voujm b
`qspufdujwf psefs jttvft jo uif FEWB bdujpot, bu xijdi qpjou uif JUD qspevdujpot xjmm sfdfjwf uif
`qspufdujpot tqfdjgjfe jo uif FEWB qspufdujwf psefs. Cz tujqvmbujoh uibu uif qbsujft up uif FEWB bdujpot
`nbz sfubjo sfmfwbou epdvnfou qspevdujpot gspn uif 892 Jowftujhbujpo, Tusbjhiu Qbui cfmjfwft uif qbsujft
`dbo tusfbnmjof uif ejtdpwfsz qspdftt boe njojnj{f boz cvsefo po uif qbsujft.
`
`Jg uif bcpwf qspdfevsf gps usbotgfs pg ejtdpwfsz gspn uif 892 Jowftujhbujpo jt opu bddfqubcmf up MH,
`0CG<=54P 4B7 1=N=CP /HF4=;<H -4H< K=@@ 4GG8A5@8 4B7 F8HIFB *(P 0CG<=54P 4B7 1=N=CTG )0$ 7C6IA8BH
`qspevdujpo boe, xjui zpvs qfsnjttjpo, eftuspz bmm puifs dpqjft pg MH, Uptijcb, boe Wj{jp DCJ jo Tusbjhiu
`-4H<TG DCGG8GG=CBS /HF4=;<H -4H< K=@@ H<8B A4?8 4 F8EI8GH 9CF DFC7I6H=CB C9 H<8 F8HIFB87 A4H8F=4@ 4G
`tppo bt ejtdpwfsz dpnnfodft jo uif FEWB bdujpot. Up uijt foe, Tusbjhiu Qbui sfrvftut uibu, jg MH,
`Uptijcb, boe Wj{jp fmfdu up ibwf uif nbufsjbm qspevdfe jo uif 892 Jowftujhbujpo sfuvsofe up uifn, MH,
`Uptijcb, boe Wj{jp sfubjo uif sfuvsofe nbufsjbm bt ju xjmm cf uif tvckfdu pg b gvuvsf Tusbjhiu Qbui sfrvftu
`gps qspevdujpo.
`
`LG v. Straight Path, IPR2015-00198
`Straight Path - Exhibit 2012 - Page 1
`
`

`

`Qmfbtfmfuvtlopxzpvsqptjujpoxjuisftqfduupuijtqspqptbmboexifozpvbsfbwbjmbcmfgpsbnffuboe
`
`