EXHIBIT 2010
`
`EXHIBIT 2010
`
`

`
`Xqn/!88!
`Pq/!268!
`
`Vw gu fc {-!
`Cw i w u v!25-!31 23!
`
`Rc tv!X!
`
`Fgrc tvo gpv! qh! Eqo
`
`o gteg!
`
`Rc vgpv! c pf! Vtc fgo c tm ! Qhhkeg!
`48! EHT! Rc tv! 53!
`Qhhkeg! Rc vgpv! Vtkc n! Rtc evkeg! I w kfg=! Tw ng!
`
`XgtFc vg!O c t> 26@31 21 ! 28<37!Cw i !24-!31 23 L m v!3371 1 2 RQ!1 1 1 1 1
`
`Hto
`
`!1 1 1 1 2 Ho v!5828 Uho v!5828 G<^HT^HO ^25CWT6/UI O
`
`25CWT6
`
`utqdgtvu!qp!FUM6URVXP2RTQF!ykvj!TWNGU
`
`Patent Owner Exhibit 2010
`Petition for IPR Review of Patent No. 8,519,973
`Page 1
`
`

`
`59867!
`
`Hgfgtc n! Tgi kuvgt0 Xqn/! 88-! Pq/! 268 0 Vw gufc {-! Cw i w uv! 25-! 31 23 0 Tw ngu! c pf! Tgi w nc vkqpu!
`
`FGRCTVO GPV!QH!EQO O GTEG!
`
`Rc vgpv!c pf!Vtc fgo c tm !Qhhkeg!
`
`48!EHT!Rc tv!53!
`]Fqem gv!Pq/!RVQ— R— 31 22— 1 1 ; 5_!
`
`Qhhkeg!Rc vgpv!Vtkc n!Rtc evkeg!I w kfg!
`CI GPE[<!Wpkvgf!Uvc vgu!Rc vgpv!c pf!
`Vtc fgo c tm !Qhhkeg-!Eqo o gteg/!
`CEVKQP<!Pqvkeg!qh!rtc evkeg!i w kfg/!
`
`UWO O CT[<!Vjg!Ngc j{.Uo kvj!Co gtkec !
`Kpxgpvu!Cev!) CKC*!guvc dnkujgu!ugxgtc n!
`pgy !vtkc n!rtqeggfkpi u!vq!dg!eqpfw evgf!
`d{!vjg!Rc vgpv!Vtkc n!c pf!Crrgc n!Dqc tf!
`) Dqc tf*!kpenw fkpi !kpvgt!rc tvgu!tgxkgy -!
`rquv.i tc pv!tgxkgy -!vjg!vtc pukvkqpc n!
`rtqi tc o !hqt!eqxgtgf!dw ukpguu!o gvjqf!
`rc vgpvu-!c pf!fgtkxc vkqp!rtqeggfkpi u/!Kp!
`ugrc tc vg!tw ngo c m kpi u-!vjg!Wpkvgf!Uvc vgu!
`Rc vgpv!c pf!Vtc fgo c tm !Qhhkeg!) Qhhkeg!qt!
`WURVQ*!ku!tgxkukpi !vjg!tw ngu!qh!rtc evkeg!
`vq!ko rngo gpv!vjgug!rtqxkukqpu!qh!vjg!
`CKC!vjc v!rtqxkfg!hqt!vjg!vtkc n!
`rtqeggfkpi u!dghqtg!vjg!Dqc tf/!Vjg!
`Qhhkeg!rw dnkujgu!kp!vjku!pqvkeg!c !rtc evkeg!
`i w kfg!hqt!vjg!vtkc n!hkpc n!tw ngu!vq!c fxkug!
`vjg!rw dnke!qp!vjg!i gpgtc n!htc o gy qtm !qh!
`vjg!tgi w nc vkqpu-!kpenw fkpi !vjg!uvtw evw tg!
`c pf!vko gu!hqt!vc m kpi !c evkqp!kp!gc ej!qh!
`vjg!pgy !rtqeggfkpi u/!
`FCVGU<!Ghhgevkxg!Fc vg<!Vjku!rtc evkeg!
`i w kfg!c rrnkgu!vq!kpvgt!rc tvgu!tgxkgy -!
`rquv.i tc pv!tgxkgy -!c pf!eqxgtgf!dw ukpguu!
`o gvjqf!rc vgpv!tgxkgy !rtqeggfkpi u!
`eqo o gpekpi !qp!qt!c hvgt!Ugrvgo dgt!27-!
`31 23-!c u!y gnn!c u!fgtkxc vkqp!rtqeggfkpi u!
`eqo o gpekpi !qp!qt!c hvgt!O c tej!27-!31 24/!
`HQT HWTVJGT KPHQTO CVKQP EQPVCEV<!
`O kejc gn!Vkgtpg{-!Ngc f!Cfo kpkuvtc vkxg!
`Rc vgpv!Lw fi g-!Dqc tf!qh!Rc vgpv!Crrgc nu!
`c pf!Kpvgthgtgpegu!) y knn!dg!tgpc o gf!c u!
`Rc vgpv!Vtkc n!c pf!Crrgc n!Dqc tf!qp!
`Ugrvgo dgt!27-!31 23*-!d{!vgngrjqpg!c v!
`) 682*!383— ; 8; 8/!
`UWRRNGO GPVCT[ KPHQTO CVKQP<!
`Gzgew vkxg!Uw o o c t{<!Vjg!rc vgpv!vtkc n!
`tgi w nc vkqpu!nc {!qw v!c !htc o gy qtm !hqt!
`eqpfw evkpi !vjg!rtqeggfkpi u!c ko gf!c v!
`uvtgc o nkpkpi !c pf!eqpxgti kpi !vjg!kuuw gu!
`hqt!fgekukqp/!Kp!fqkpi !uq-!vjg!Qhhkeg“u!
`i qc n!ku!vq!eqpfw ev!rtqeggfkpi u!kp!c !
`vko gn{-!hc kt-!c pf!ghhkekgpv!o c ppgt/!
`Hw tvjgt-!vjg!Qhhkeg!jc u!fguki pgf!vjg!
`rtqeggfkpi u!vq!c nnqy !gc ej!rc tv{!vq!
`fgvgto kpg!vjg!rtghgttgf!o c ppgt!qh!
`rw vvkpi !hqty c tf!kvu!ec ug-!uw dlgev!vq!vjg!
`i w kfc peg!qh!lw fi gu!y jq!fgvgto kpg!vjg!
`pggfu!qh!c !rc tvkew nc t!ec ug!vjtqw i j!
`rtqegfw tc n!c pf!uw duvc pvkxg!tw nkpi u!
`vjtqw i jqw v!vjg!rtqeggfkpi u/!
`Dc em i tqw pf<!Vjg!Ngc j{.Uo kvj!
`Co gtkec !Kpxgpvu!Cev!guvc dnkujgu!ugxgtc n!
`pgy !vtkc n!rtqeggfkpi u!vq!dg!eqpfw evgf!
`d{!vjg!Dqc tf!kpenw fkpi <!) 2*!Kpvgt!rc tvgu!
`tgxkgy !) KRT*=!) 3*!rquv.i tc pv!tgxkgy !
`
`) RIT*=!) 4*!c !vtc pukvkqpc n!rtqi tc o !hqt!
`eqxgtgf!dw ukpguu!o gvjqf!rc vgpvu!
`) EDO *=!c pf!) 5*!fgtkxc vkqp!rtqeggfkpi u/!
`Vjg!CKC!tgsw ktgu!vjg!Qhhkeg!vq!
`rtqo w ni c vg!tw ngu!hqt!vjg!rtqeggfkpi u-!
`y kvj!vjg!RI T-!KRT-!c pf!EDO !tw ngu!vq!dg!
`kp!ghhgev!qpg!{gc t!c hvgt!CKC!gpc evo gpv!
`c pf!vjg!fgtkxc vkqp!tw ngu!vq!dg!kp!ghhgev!
`29!o qpvju!c hvgt!CKC!gpc evo gpv/!
`Eqpukuvgpv!y kvj!vjg!uvc vw vg-!vjg!Qhhkeg!
`rw dnkujgf!c !pw o dgt!qh!pqvkegu!qh!
`rtqrqugf!tw ngo c m kpi !kp!Hgdtw c t{!qh!
`31 23-!c pf!tgsw guvgf!y tkvvgp!eqo o gpvu!
`qp!vjg!Qhhkeg“u!rtqrqugf!
`ko rngo gpvc vkqp!qh!vjg!pgy !vtkc n!
`rtqeggfkpi u!qh!vjg!CKC/!Vjg!Qhhkeg!c nuq!
`jquvgf!c !ugtkgu!qh!rw dnke!gfw ec vkqpc n!
`tqc fujqy u-!c etquu!vjg!eqw pvt{-!
`tgi c tfkpi !vjg!rtqrqugf!tw ngu/!
`Cffkvkqpc nn{-!vjg!Qhhkeg!rw dnkujgf!c !
`rtc evkeg!i w kfg!dc ugf!qp!vjg!rtqrqugf!
`vtkc n!tw ngu!kp!vjg!Hgfgtc n!Tgi kuvgt!vq!
`rtqxkfg!vjg!rw dnke!c p!qrrqtvw pkv{!vq!
`eqo o gpv/!Rtc evkeg!I w kfg!hqt!Rtqrqugf!
`Vtkc n!Tw ngu-!88!HT!7979!) Hgd/!; -!31 23*!
`) Tgsw guv!hqt!Eqo o gpvu*!) jgtgc hvgt!
`’’Rtc evkeg!Iw kfg!hqt!Rtqrqugf!Vtkc n!
`Tw ngu““!qt!’’Qhhkeg!Rc vgpv!Vtkc n!Rtc evkeg!
`Iw kfg““*/!Vjku!Qhhkeg!Rc vgpv!Vtkc n!
`Rtc evkeg!I w kfg!ku!kpvgpfgf!vq!c fxkug!vjg!
`rw dnke!qp!vjg!i gpgtc n!htc o gy qtm !qh!vjg!
`tw ngu-!kpenw fkpi !vjg!uvtw evw tg!c pf!vko gu!
`hqt!vc m kpi !c evkqp!kp!gc ej!qh!vjg!pgy !
`rtqeggfkpi u/!
`Kp!tgurqpug!vq!vjg!pqvkegu!qh!rtqrqugf!
`tw ngo c m kpi !c pf!vjg!Rtc evkeg!Iw kfg!
`pqvkeg-!vjg!Qhhkeg!tgegkxgf!362!
`uw do kuukqpu!qh!y tkvvgp!eqo o gpvu!htqo !
`kpvgnngevw c n!rtqrgtv{!qti c pk|c vkqpu-!
`dw ukpguugu-!nc y !hkto u-!rc vgpv!
`rtc evkvkqpgtu-!c pf!qvjgtu-!kpenw fkpi !c !
`Wpkvgf!Uvc vgu!ugpc vqt!y jq!y c u!c !
`rtkpekrc n!c w vjqt!qh!ugevkqp!29!qh!vjg!
`CKC/!Vjg!eqo o gpvu!rtqxkfgf!uw rrqtv!
`hqt-!qrrqukvkqp!vq-!c pf!fkxgtug!
`tgeqo o gpfc vkqpu!qp!vjg!rtqrqugf!
`tw ngu/!Vjg!Qhhkeg!c rrtgekc vgu!vjg!
`vjqw i jvhw n!eqo o gpvu-!c pf!jc u!
`eqpukfgtgf!c pf!c pc n{|gf!vjg!eqo o gpvu!
`vjqtqw i jn{/!Kp!nki jv!qh!vjg!eqo o gpvu-!
`vjg!Qhhkeg!jc u!o c fg!o qfkhkec vkqpu!vq!vjg!
`rtqrqugf!tw ngu!vq!rtqxkfg!enc tkv{!c pf!vq!
`dc nc peg!vjg!kpvgtguvu!qh!vjg!rw dnke-!
`rc vgpv!qy pgtu-!rc vgpv!ejc nngpi gtu-!c pf!
`qvjgt!kpvgtguvgf!rc tvkgu-!kp!nki jv!qh!vjg!
`uvc vw vqt{!tgsw ktgo gpvu!c pf!
`eqpukfgtc vkqpu-!uw ej!c u!vjg!ghhgev!qh!vjg!
`tgi w nc vkqpu!qp!vjg!geqpqo {-!vjg!
`kpvgi tkv{!qh!vjg!rc vgpv!u{uvgo -!vjg!
`ghhkekgpv!c fo kpkuvtc vkqp!qh!vjg!Qhhkeg-!
`c pf!vjg!c dknkv{!qh!vjg!Qhhkeg!vq!eqo rngvg!
`vjg!rtqeggfkpi u!vko gn{/!
`Hqt!vjg!ko rngo gpvc vkqp!qh!ugevkqpu!4-!
`7-!8-!c pf!29!qh!vjg!CKC!vjc v!c tg!tgnc vgf!
`vq!c fo kpkuvtc vkxg!vtkc nu!c pf!lw fkekc n!
`tgxkgy !qh!Dqc tf!fgekukqpu-!vjg!Qhhkeg!ku!
`rw dnkujkpi !vjg!hqnnqy kpi !hkpc n!tw ngu!kp!
`ugrc tc vg!pqvkegu!kp!vjg!Hgfgtc n!Tgi kuvgt<!
`) 2*!Tw ngu!qh!Rtc evkeg!hqt!Vtkc nu!dghqtg!vjg!
`
`Rc vgpv!Vtkc n!c pf!Crrgc n!Dqc tf!c pf!
`Lw fkekc n!Tgxkgy !qh!Rc vgpv!Vtkc n!c pf!
`Crrgc n!Dqc tf!Fgekukqpu!) TKP!1 762— !
`CE81 *=!) 3*!Ejc pi gu!vq!Ko rngo gpv!Kpvgt!
`Rc tvgu!Tgxkgy !Rtqeggfkpi u-!Rquv.I tc pv!
`Tgxkgy !Rtqeggfkpi u-!c pf!Vtc pukvkqpc n!
`Rtqi tc o !hqt!Eqxgtgf!Dw ukpguu!O gvjqf!
`Rc vgpvu!) TKP!1 762— CE82*=!) 4*!
`Vtc pukvkqpc n!Rtqi tc o !hqt!Eqxgtgf!
`Dw ukpguu!O gvjqf!Rc vgpvu˜ Fghkpkvkqpu!qh!
`Eqxgtgf!Dw ukpguu!O gvjqf!Rc vgpv!c pf!
`Vgejpqnqi kec n!Kpxgpvkqp!) TKP!1 762— !
`CE86*=!c pf!) 5*!Ejc pi gu!vq!Ko rngo gpv!
`Fgtkxc vkqp!Rtqeggfkpi u!) TKP!1 762— !
`CE85*/!Vjg!Qhhkeg!c nuq!rtqxkfgu!
`tgurqpugu!vq!vjg!rw dnke!y tkvvgp!
`eqo o gpvu!kp!vjgug!hkpc n!tw ngu!kp!vjg!
`Tgurqpug!vq!Eqo o gpvu!ugevkqpu!qh!vjg!
`pqvkegu/!
`Hw tvjgt-!vjg!Qhhkeg!tgxkugf!vjg!Qhhkeg!
`Rc vgpv!Vtkc n!Rtc evkeg!Iw kfg!dc ugf!qp!vjg!
`hkpc n!tw ngu/!Vjg!Qhhkeg!jc u!dggp!y qtm kpi !
`fknki gpvn{!vq!rw dnkuj!c nn!qh!vjg!hkpc n!tw ngu!
`tgnc vgf!vq!vjg!pgy !CKC!vtkc n!rtqeggfkpi u!
`c pf!vjg!Qhhkeg!Rc vgpv!Vtkc n!Rtc evkeg!
`Iw kfg!kp!vjg!Hgfgtc n!Tgi kuvgt!
`eqpew ttgpvn{/!Fw g!vq!egtvc kp!nko kvc vkqpu-!
`jqy gxgt-!vjg!Qhhkeg!Rc vgpv!Vtkc n!Rtc evkeg!
`c pf!vjg!urgekhke!hkpc n!tw ng!hqt!fgtkxc vkqp!
`rtqeggfkpi u!y knn!dg!rw dnkujgf!kp!vjg!
`Hgfgtc n!Tgi kuvgt!c hvgt!vjg!qvjgt!hkpc n!
`tw ngu/!Kp!rc tvkew nc t-!vjg!urgekhke!tw ngu!hqt!
`fgtkxc vkqp-!k/g/-!¤¤53/51 5!vjtqw i j!
`53/523-!y knn!dg!rw dnkujgf!c v!c !nc vgt!fc vg/!
`Uvc vw vqt{!Tgsw ktgo gpvu<!Vjg!CKC!
`rtqxkfgu!egtvc kp!o kpko w o !tgsw ktgo gpvu!
`hqt!gc ej!qh!vjg!pgy !rtqeggfkpi u/!
`Rtqxkfgf!dgnqy !ku!c !dtkgh!qxgtxkgy !qh!
`vjgug!tgsw ktgo gpvu/!
`Rtqeggfkpi u!dgi kp!y kvj!vjg!hknkpi !qh!c !
`rgvkvkqp!vq!kpuvkvw vg!c !vtkc n/!Vjg!rgvkvkqp!
`o w uv!dg!hkngf!y kvj!vjg!Dqc tf!eqpukuvgpv!
`y kvj!c p{!vko g!rgtkqf!tgsw ktgf!d{!uvc vw vg!
`c pf!dg!c eeqo rc pkgf!d{!vjg!gxkfgpeg!vjg!
`rgvkvkqpgt!uggm u!vq!tgn{!w rqp/!Ugg-!g/i /-!
`46!W/U/E/!246) c *!c pf!422) e*-!c u!
`c o gpfgf-!c pf!¤53/4!) tghgtgpegu!vq!
`¤53/z!qt!¤2/z!tghgt!vq!vkvng!48!qh!vjg!
`Eqfg!qh!Hgfgtc n!Tgi w nc vkqpu*/!Hqt!KRT-!
`RIT-!c pf!EDO -!vjg!rc vgpv!qy pgt!ku!
`c hhqtfgf!c p!qrrqtvw pkv{!vq!hkng!c !
`rtgnko kpc t{!tgurqpug/!46!W/U/E/!424-!c u!
`c o gpfgf-!c pf!46!W/U/E/!434/!
`Vjg!Dqc tf!c evkpi !qp!dgjc nh!qh!vjg!
`Fktgevqt!o c {!kpuvkvw vg!c !vtkc n!y jgtg!vjg!
`rgvkvkqpgt!guvc dnkujgu!vjc v!vjg!uvc pfc tfu!
`hqt!kpuvkvw vkpi !vjg!tgsw guvgf!vtkc n!c tg!o gv!
`vc m kpi !kpvq!c eeqw pv!c p{!rtgnko kpc t{!
`tgurqpug!hkngf!d{!vjg!rc vgpv!qy pgt/!
`Eqpxgtugn{-!vjg!Dqc tf!o c {!pqv!
`c w vjqtk|g!c !vtkc n!y jgtg!vjg!kphqto c vkqp!
`rtgugpvgf!kp!vjg!rgvkvkqp-!vc m kpi !kpvq!
`c eeqw pv!c p{!rc vgpv!qy pgt!rtgnko kpc t{!
`tgurqpug-!hc knu!vq!o ggv!vjg!tgsw kukvg!
`uvc pfc tf!hqt!kpuvkvw vkpi !vjg!vtkc n/!Ugg!
`g/i /-!46!W/U/E/!425-!c u!c o gpfgf-!c pf!46!
`W/U/E/!435/!Y jgtg!vjgtg!c tg!o w nvkrng!
`o c vvgtu!kp!vjg!Qhhkeg!kpxqnxkpi !vjg!uc o g!
`rc vgpv-!vjg!Dqc tf!o c {!fgvgto kpg!jqy !
`
`XgtFc vg!O c t> 26@31 21 ! 28<37!Cw i !24-!31 23 L m v!3371 1 2 RQ!1 1 1 1 1
`
`Hto
`
`!1 1 1 1 3 Ho v!581 2 Uho v!581 1 G<^HT^HO ^25CWT6/UI O
`
`25CWT6
`
`utqdgtvu!qp!FUM6URVXP2RTQF!ykvj!TWNGU
`
`Patent Owner Exhibit 2010
`Petition for IPR Review of Patent No. 8,519,973
`Page 2
`
`

`
`Hgfgtc n! Tgi kuvgt0 Xqn/! 88-! Pq/! 268 0 Vw gufc {-! Cw i w uv! 25-! 31 23 0 Tw ngu! c pf! Tgi w nc vkqpu!
`
`59868!
`
`vjg!rtqeggfkpi u!y knn!rtqeggf-!kpenw fkpi !
`rtqxkfkpi !hqt!c !uvc {-!vtc puhgt-!
`eqpuqnkfc vkqp-!qt!vgto kpc vkqp!qh!c p{!
`uw ej!o c vvgt/!Ugg-!g/i /-!46!W/U/E/!426-!c u!
`c o gpfgf-!c pf!46!W/U/E/!436/!
`Vjg!CKC!tgsw ktgu!vjc v!vjg!Dqc tf!
`eqpfw ev!CKC!vtkc nu!c pf!vjc v!vjg!Fktgevqt!
`rtguetkdg!tgi w nc vkqpu!eqpegtpkpi !vjg!
`eqpfw ev!qh!vjqug!vtkc nu/!46!W/U/E/!7-!246-!
`c pf!427-!c u!c o gpfgf-!c pf!46!W/U/E/!
`437/!Hqt!gzc o rng-!hqt!KRT-!RIT-!c pf!
`EDO -!vjg!CKC!o c pfc vgu!vjg!
`rtqo w ni c vkqp!qh!tw ngu!kpenw fkpi !o qvkqpu!
`vq!ugc n-!rtqegfw tgu!hqt!hknkpi !
`uw rrngo gpvc n!kphqto c vkqp-!uvc pfc tfu!
`c pf!rtqegfw tgu!hqt!fkueqxgt{-!uc pevkqpu!
`hqt!ko rtqrgt!w ug!qh!vjg!rtqeggfkpi -!
`gpvt{!qh!rtqvgevkxg!qtfgtu-!c pf!qtc n!
`jgc tkpi u/!Ugg-!g/i /-!46!W/U/E/!427) c *-!c u!
`c o gpfgf-!c pf!46!W/U/E/!437/!
`Cffkvkqpc nn{-!vjg!CKC!o c pfc vgu!vjg!
`rtqo w ni c vkqp!qh!tw ngu!hqt!KRT-!RIT-!c pf!
`EDO !eqpegtpkpi !vjg!uw do kuukqp!qh!c !
`rc vgpv!qy pgt!tgurqpug!y kvj!uw rrqtvkpi !
`gxkfgpeg!c pf!c nnqy kpi !vjg!rc vgpv!qy pgt!
`c !o qvkqp!vq!c o gpf!vjg!rc vgpv/!Kf/!
`C!rgvkvkqpgt!c pf!c !rc vgpv!qy pgt!o c {!
`vgto kpc vg!vjg!rtqeggfkpi !y kvj!tgurgev!vq!
`vjg!rgvkvkqpgt!d{!hknkpi !c !y tkvvgp!
`c i tggo gpv!y kvj!vjg!Dqc tf-!w pnguu!vjg!
`Dqc tf!jc u!c ntgc f{!fgekfgf!vjg!o gtkvu!qh!
`vjg!rtqeggfkpi !dghqtg!vjg!tgsw guv!hqt!
`vgto kpc vkqp!ku!hkngf/!Ugg-!g/i /-!46!W/U/E/!
`428-!c u!c o gpfgf-!c pf!46!W/U/E/!438/!Kh!
`pq!rgvkvkqpgt!tgo c kpu!kp!vjg!rtqeggfkpi -!
`vjg!Dqc tf!o c {!vgto kpc vg!vjg!tgxkgy !qt!
`rtqeggf!vq!c !hkpc n!y tkvvgp!fgekukqp/!Hqt!
`fgtkxc vkqp!rtqeggfkpi u-!vjg!rc tvkgu!o c {!
`c tdkvtc vg!kuuw gu!kp!vjg!rtqeggfkpi -!dw v!
`pqvjkpi !rtgenw fgu!vjg!Qhhkeg!htqo !
`fgvgto kpkpi !vjg!rc vgpvc dknkv{!qh!vjg!
`enc ko gf!kpxgpvkqpu!kpxqnxgf!kp!vjg!
`
`rtqeggfkpi /!46!W/U/E/!246-!c u!c o gpfgf/!
`Y jgtg!c !vtkc n!jc u!dggp!kpuvkvw vgf!c pf!
`pqv!fkuo kuugf-!vjg!Dqc tf!y knn!kuuw g!c !
`hkpc n!y tkvvgp!fgekukqp!y kvj!tgurgev!vq!
`vjg!kpxqnxgf!rc vgpv!c pf0qt!c rrnkec vkqpu/!
`46!W/U/E/!246!c pf!46!W/U/E/!429-!c u!
`c o gpfgf-!c pf!46!W/U/E/!439/!
`Hqt!KRT-!RIT-!c pf!EDO -!vjg!CKC!
`tgsw ktgu!vjc v!vjg!Qhhkeg!eqpukfgt!vjg!
`ghhgev!qh!vjg!tgi w nc vkqpu!qp!vjg!geqpqo {-!
`vjg!kpvgi tkv{!qh!vjg!rc vgpv!u{uvgo -!vjg!
`ghhkekgpv!c fo kpkuvtc vkqp!qh!vjg!Qhhkeg-!
`c pf!vjg!c dknkv{!qh!vjg!Qhhkeg!vq!vko gn{!
`eqo rngvg!vjg!rtqeggfkpi u/!46!W/U/E/!
`427-!c u!c o gpfgf-!c pf!46!W/U/E/!437/!Kp!
`fgxgnqrkpi !vjg!i gpgtc n!vtkc n!tw ngu-!c u!
`y gnn!c u!vjg!urgekhke!tw ngu!hqt!vjg!
`kpfkxkfw c n!rtqeggfkpi u-!vjg!Qhhkeg!jc u!
`vc m gp!vjgug!eqpukfgtc vkqpu!kpvq!c eeqw pv/!
`Hw tvjgt-!vjg!urgekhke!tw ngu!hqt!vjg!
`kpfkxkfw c n!rtqeggfkpi u!vc m g!kpvq!
`c eeqw pv!vjg!lw tkufkevkqpc n!c pf!vko kpi !
`tgsw ktgo gpvu!hqt!vjg!rc tvkew nc t!
`rtqeggfkpi u/!
`I gpgtc n!Qxgtxkgy !qh!Rtqeggfkpi u<!
`Igpgtc nn{-!vjg!rtqeggfkpi u!dgi kp!y kvj!
`vjg!hknkpi !qh!c !rgvkvkqp!vjc v!kfgpvkhkgu!c nn!
`qh!vjg!enc ko u!ejc nngpi gf!c pf!vjg!
`i tqw pfu!c pf!uw rrqtvkpi !gxkfgpeg!qp!c !
`enc ko .d{.enc ko !dc uku/!Y kvjkp!vjtgg!
`o qpvju!qh!pqvkhkec vkqp!qh!c !hknkpi !fc vg-!
`vjg!rc vgpv!qy pgt!kp!c p!KRT-!RIT-!qt!
`EDO !rtqeggfkpi !o c {!hkng!c !rtgnko kpc t{!
`tgurqpug!vq!vjg!rgvkvkqp-!kpenw fkpi !c !
`uko rng!uvc vgo gpv!vjc v!vjg!rc vgpv!qy pgt!
`gngevu!pqv!vq!tgurqpf!vq!vjg!rgvkvkqp/!Vjg!
`Dqc tf!c evkpi !qp!dgjc nh!qh!vjg!Fktgevqt!
`y knn!fgvgto kpg!y jgvjgt!vq!kpuvkvw vg!c !
`vtkc n!y kvjkp!vjtgg!o qpvju!qh!vjg!fc vg!vjg!
`rc vgpv!qy pgt“u!rtgnko kpc t{!tgurqpug!
`y c u!fw g!qt!y c u!hkngf-!y jkejgxgt!ku!hktuv/!
`Kp!kpuvkvw vkpi !c !vtkc n-!vjg!Dqc tf!y knn!
`pc ttqy !vjg!kuuw gu!hqt!hkpc n!fgekukqp!d{!
`
`c w vjqtk|kpi !vjg!vtkc n!vq!rtqeggf!qpn{!qp!
`vjg!ejc nngpi gf!enc ko u!hqt!y jkej!vjg!
`vjtgujqnf!uvc pfc tfu!hqt!vjg!rtqeggfkpi !
`jc xg!dggp!o gv/!Hw tvjgt-!vjg!Dqc tf!y knn!
`kfgpvkh{-!qp!c !enc ko .d{.enc ko !dc uku-!vjg!
`i tqw pfu!qp!y jkej!vjg!vtkc n!y knn!rtqeggf/!
`Cp{!enc ko !qt!kuuw g!pqv!kpenw fgf!kp!vjg!
`c w vjqtk|c vkqp!hqt!tgxkgy !y knn!pqv!dg!rc tv!
`qh!vjg!vtkc n/!C!rc tv{!fkuuc vkuhkgf!y kvj!vjg!
`Dqc tf“u!fgvgto kpc vkqp!vq!kpuvkvw vg!c !vtkc n!
`o c {!tgsw guv!tgjgc tkpi !c u!vq!rqkpvu!
`dgnkgxgf!vq!jc xg!dggp!qxgtnqqm gf!qt!
`o kuc rrtgjgpfgf/!Ugg!¤53/82) f*!c pf!) e*/!
`Vjg!Dqc tf!y knn!gpvgt!c !Uejgfw nkpi !
`Qtfgt!) Crrgpfkz!C*!eqpew ttgpv!y kvj!vjg!
`fgekukqp!vq!kpuvkvw vg!c !vtkc n/!Vjg!
`Uejgfw nkpi !Qtfgt!y knn!ugv!fw g!fc vgu!hqt!
`vjg!vtkc n!vc m kpi !kpvq!c eeqw pv!vjg!
`eqo rngzkv{!qh!vjg!rtqeggfkpi !dw v!
`gpuw tkpi !vjc v!vjg!vtkc n!ku!eqo rngvgf!
`y kvjkp!qpg!{gc t!qh!kpuvkvw vkqp/!
`Hqt!gzc o rng-!c !Uejgfw nkpi !Qtfgt!hqt!
`c p!KRT!qt!RIT!o ki jv-!eqpukuvgpv!y kvj!
`¤¤53/231 !c pf!53/331 -!rtqxkfg!c !vjtgg!
`o qpvj!fgc fnkpg!hqt!rc vgpv!qy pgt!
`fkueqxgt{!c pf!hqt!hknkpi !c !rc vgpv!qy pgt!
`tgurqpug!c pf!o qvkqp!vq!c o gpf/!Qpeg!
`vjg!rc vgpv!qy pgt“u!tgurqpug!c pf!o qvkqp!
`vq!c o gpf!jc xg!dggp!hkngf-!vjg!
`Uejgfw nkpi !Qtfgt!o ki jv!rtqxkfg!vjg!
`rgvkvkqpgt!y kvj!vjtgg!o qpvju!hqt!
`fkueqxgt{!c pf!hqt!hknkpi !c !rgvkvkqpgt“u!
`tgrn{!vq!vjg!tgurqpug!c pf!vjg!
`rgvkvkqpgt“u!qrrqukvkqp!vq!vjg!
`c o gpfo gpv/!Vjg!Uejgfw nkpi !Qtfgt!
`o ki jv!vjgp!rtqxkfg!vjg!rc vgpv!qy pgt!
`y kvj!qpg!o qpvj!hqt!fkueqxgt{!c pf!hqt!
`hknkpi !c !rc vgpv!qy pgt!tgrn{!vq!
`rgvkvkqpgt“u!qrrqukvkqp!vq!c !rc vgpv!
`qy pgt!c o gpfo gpv/!C!tgrtgugpvc vkxg!
`vko gnkpg!ku!rtqxkfgf!dgnqy <!
`
`GT25CW23/111>0IRJ@
`
`Ugsw gpeg!qh!fkueqxgt{/!Qpeg!
`kpuvkvw vgf-!c dugpv!urgekc n!ektew o uvc pegu-!
`fkueqxgt{!y knn!rtqeggf!kp!c !ugsw gpegf!
`hc ujkqp/!Hqt!gzc o rng-!vjg!rc vgpv!qy pgt!
`
`o c {!dgi kp!fgrqukpi !vjg!rgvkvkqpgt“u!
`fgenc tc pvu!qpeg!vjg!rtqeggfkpi !ku!
`kpuvkvw vgf/!Chvgt!vjg!rc vgpv!qy pgt!jc u!
`hkngf!c !rc vgpv!qy pgt!tgurqpug!c pf!c p{!
`
`o qvkqp!vq!c o gpf!vjg!enc ko u-!vjg!
`rgvkvkqpgt!o c {!fgrqug!vjg!rc vgpv!
`qy pgt“u!fgenc tc pvu/!Uko knc tn{-!c hvgt!vjg!
`rgvkvkqpgt!jc u!hkngf!c !tgrn{!vq!vjg!rc vgpv!
`
`XgtFc vg!O c t> 26@31 21 ! 28<37!Cw i !24-!31 23 L m v!3371 1 2 RQ!1 1 1 1 1
`
`Hto
`
`!1 1 1 1 4 Ho v!581 2 Uho v!581 1 G<^HT^HO ^25CWT6/UI O
`
`25CWT6
`
`utqdgtvu!qp!FUM6URVXP2RTQF!ykvj!TWNGU
`
`Patent Owner Exhibit 2010
`Petition for IPR Review of Patent No. 8,519,973
`Page 3
`
`

`
`59869!
`
`Hgfgtc n! Tgi kuvgt0 Xqn/! 88-! Pq/! 268 0 Vw gufc {-! Cw i w uv! 25-! 31 23 0 Tw ngu! c pf! Tgi w nc vkqpu!
`
`qy pgt“u!tgurqpug!c pf!c p!qrrqukvkqp!vq!
`c p!c o gpfo gpv-!vjg!rc vgpv!qy pgt!o c {!
`fgrqug!vjg!rgvkvkqpgt“u!fgenc tc pvu!c pf!
`hkng!c !tgrn{!kp!uw rrqtv!qh!kvu!enc ko !
`c o gpfo gpvu/!Y jgtg!vjg!rc vgpv!qy pgt!
`tgnkgu!w rqp!pgy !fgenc tc vkqp!gxkfgpeg!kp!
`uw rrqtv!qh!kvu!c o gpfo gpvu-!vjg!
`rgvkvkqpgt!y knn!dg!c w vjqtk|gf!vq!fgrqug!
`vjg!fgenc tc pvu!c pf!uw do kv!qdugtxc vkqpu!
`qp!vjg!fgrqukvkqp/!Qpeg!vjg!vko g!hqt!
`vc m kpi !fkueqxgt{!kp!vjg!vtkc n!jc u!gpfgf-!
`vjg!rc tvkgu!y knn!dg!c w vjqtk|gf!vq!hkng!
`o qvkqpu!vq!gzenw fg!gxkfgpeg!dgnkgxgf!vq!
`dg!kpc fo kuukdng/!Cfo kuukdknkv{!qh!
`gxkfgpeg!ku!i gpgtc nn{!i qxgtpgf!d{!vjg!
`Hgfgtc n!Tw ngu!qh!Gxkfgpeg/!
`Ugsw gpeg!qh!hknkpi !tgurqpugu!c pf!
`o qvkqpu/!Cp!kpkvkc n!eqphgtgpeg!ec nn!y knn!
`dg!jgnf!c dqw v!qpg!o qpvj!htqo !vjg!fc vg!
`qh!kpuvkvw vkqp!vq!fkuew uu!vjg!o qvkqpu!vjc v!
`vjg!rc tvkgu!kpvgpf!vq!hkng!c pf!vq!
`fgvgto kpg!kh!c p{!c flw uvo gpv!pggfu!vq!dg!
`o c fg!vq!vjg!Uejgfw nkpi !Qtfgt/!Vjg!
`rc vgpv!qy pgt!o c {!hkng!c !rc vgpv!qy pgt“u!
`tgurqpug!c pf0qt!c !o qvkqp!vq!c o gpf!vjg!
`enc ko u!d{!vjg!vko g!ugv!kp!vjg!Uejgfw nkpi !
`Qtfgt/!Vjg!rgvkvkqpgt!y knn!vjgp!hkng!c !
`tgrn{!vq!vjg!rc vgpv!qy pgt“u!tgurqpug!c pf!
`c p{!qrrqukvkqp!vq!vjg!rc vgpv!qy pgt“u!
`c o gpfo gpv/!Dqvj!rc tvkgu!y knn!vjgp!dg!
`rgto kvvgf!c p!qrrqtvw pkv{!vq!hkng!o qvkqpu!
`vq!gzenw fg!c p!qrrqpgpv“u!gxkfgpeg!
`dgnkgxgf!vq!dg!kpc fo kuukdng/!Chvgt!c nn!
`o qvkqpu!jc xg!dggp!hkngf-!vjg!rc tvkgu!y knn!
`dg!c hhqtfgf!c p!qrrqtvw pkv{!vq!jc xg!c p!
`qtc n!c ti w o gpv!c v!vjg!Dqc tf/!
`Uw o o c t{!qh!vjg!Tw ngu<!Vjg!hqnnqy kpi !
`ku!c !i gpgtc n!uw o o c t{!qh!vjg!tw ngu!hqt!vjg!
`rtqeggfkpi u/!
`K/!I gpgtc n!Rtqegfw tgu!
`Vjg!tw ngu!c tg!vq!dg!eqpuvtw gf!uq!c u!vq!
`gpuw tg!vjg!lw uv-!urggf{-!c pf!kpgzrgpukxg!
`tguqnw vkqp!qh!c !rtqeggfkpi !c pf-!y jgtg!
`c rrtqrtkc vg-!vjg!tw ngu!o c {!dg!o qfkhkgf!
`vq!c eeqo rnkuj!vjgug!i qc nu/!¤53/2) d*=!
`¤53/6) c *!c pf!) d*/!
`C/!Lw tkufkevkqp!c pf!O c pc i go gpv!qh!vjg!
`Tgeqtf!
`2/!Lw tkufkevkqp<!46!W/U/E/!7) d*-!c u!
`c o gpfgf-!rtqxkfgu!vjc v!vjg!Dqc tf!ku!vq!
`eqpfw ev!fgtkxc vkqp!rtqeggfkpi u-!kpvgt!
`rc tvgu!tgxkgy u-!c pf!rquv.i tc pv!tgxkgy u/!
`Vjg!Dqc tf!c nuq!eqpfw evu!vjg!vtc pukvkqpc n!
`rtqi tc o !hqt!eqxgtgf!dw ukpguu!o gvjqf!
`tgxkgy u-!y jkej!c tg!uw dlgev!vq!Dqc tf!
`tgxkgy !w pfgt!46!W/U/E/!7) d*-!c u!
`c o gpfgf-!46!W/U/E/!437) e*-!c pf!Rw dnke!
`Nc y !223— 3; -!ugevkqp!29/!Vjg!Dqc tf!
`vjgtghqtg!y knn!jc xg!gzenw ukxg!
`lw tkufkevkqp!y kvjkp!vjg!Qhhkeg!qxgt!gxgt{!
`c rrnkec vkqp!c pf!rc vgpv!vjc v!ku!kpxqnxgf!
`kp!c !fgtkxc vkqp-!KRT-!RIT-!qt!EDO !
`rtqeggfkpi /!Gz!rc tvg!tggzc o kpc vkqp!
`rtqeggfkpi u!c pf!kpvgt!rc tvgu!
`tggzc o kpc vkqp!rtqeggfkpi u!c tg!pqv!
`’’kpxqnxgf““!rc vgpvu!) c u!fghkpgf!kp!¨53/3*!
`kp!fgtkxc vkqp-!KRT-!RIT-!c pf!EDO !
`
`rtqeggfkpi u!c pf!c tg!vjw u!vtgc vgf!
`ugrc tc vgn{!gzegrv!c u!qtfgtgf!d{!vjg!
`Dqc tf/!
`3/!Rtqjkdkvkqp!qp!Gz!Rc tvg!
`Eqo o w pkec vkqpu<!Cnn!uw duvc pvkxg!
`eqo o w pkec vkqpu!y kvj!vjg!Dqc tf!
`tgi c tfkpi !c !rtqeggfkpi !o w uv!kpenw fg!c nn!
`rc tvkgu!vq!vjg!rtqeggfkpi -!gzegrv!c u!
`qvjgty kug!c w vjqtk|gf/!¤53/6) f*/!Vjg!
`rtqjkdkvkqp!qp!gz!rc tvg!eqo o w pkec vkqpu!
`fqgu!pqv!gzvgpf!vq<!) 2*!O kpkuvgtkc n!
`eqo o w pkec vkqpu!y kvj!uw rrqtv!uvc hh!) hqt!
`kpuvc peg-!vq!c ttc pi g!c !eqphgtgpeg!ec nn*=!
`) 3*!eqphgtgpeg!ec nnu!qt!jgc tkpi u!kp!y jkej!
`qrrqukpi !eqw pugn!fgenkpgu!vq!
`rc tvkekrc vg=!) 4*!kphqto kpi !vjg!Dqc tf!kp!
`qpg!rtqeggfkpi !qh!vjg!gzkuvgpeg!qt!uvc vw u!
`qh!c !tgnc vgf!Dqc tf!rtqeggfkpi =!qt!) 5*!
`tghgtgpeg!vq!c !rgpfkpi !ec ug!kp!uw rrqtv!
`qh!c !i gpgtc n!rtqrqukvkqp!) hqt!kpuvc peg-!
`ekvkpi !c !rw dnkujgf!qrkpkqp!htqo !c !
`rgpfkpi !ec ug!qt!tghgttkpi !vq!c !rgpfkpi !
`ec ug!vq!knnw uvtc vg!c !u{uvgo ke!rtqdngo */!
`Cttc pi kpi !c !eqphgtgpeg!ec nn!y kvj!vjg!
`Dqc tf/!Vjg!Dqc tf!gpeqw tc i gu!vjg!w ug!qh!
`eqphgtgpeg!ec nnu!vq!tc kug!c pf!tguqnxg!
`kuuw gu!kp!c p!gzrgfkvgf!o c ppgt/!Vjg!
`Dqc tf!gpxkukqpu!vjc v!o quv!qh!vjg!
`rtqegfw tc n!kuuw gu!c tkukpi !fw tkpi !c !
`rtqeggfkpi !y knn!dg!jc pfngf!fw tkpi !c !
`eqphgtgpeg!ec nn!qt!ujqtvn{!vjgtgc hvgt-!k/g/-!
`kp!c !o c vvgt!qh!fc {u/!Y jgp!c ttc pi kpi !c !
`eqphgtgpeg!ec nn-!rc tvkgu!ujqw nf!dg!
`rtgrc tgf!vq!fkuew uu!y kvj!c !Vtkc n!Ugevkqp!
`rc tc ngi c n!y j{!vjg!ec nn!ku!pggfgf!c pf!
`y jc v!o c vgtkc nu!o c {!dg!pggfgf!fw tkpi !
`vjg!ec nn-!g/i /-!c !rc tvkew nc t!gzjkdkv/!
`Tghw uc n!vq!rc tvkekrc vg/!Vjg!Dqc tf!jc u!
`vjg!fkuetgvkqp!vq!rgto kv!c !jgc tkpi !qt!
`eqphgtgpeg!ec nn!vq!vc m g!rnc eg!gxgp!kh!c !
`rc tv{!tghw ugu!vq!rc tvkekrc vg/!Kp!uw ej!
`ec ugu-!vjg!Dqc tf!o c {!qtfgt!c u!c !
`eqpfkvkqp!hqt!vjg!ec nn!c ffkvkqpc n!
`uc hgi w c tfu-!uw ej!c u!vjg!tgeqtfkpi !qh!vjg!
`eqo o w pkec vkqp!c pf!vjg!gpvt{!qh!vjg!
`tgeqtfkpi !kpvq!vjg!tgeqtf/!
`D/!Eqw pugn!
`Pggf!hqt!ngc f!c pf!dc em .w r!eqw pugn/!C!
`rc tv{!tgrtgugpvgf!d{!eqw pugn!o w uv!
`fguki pc vg!dqvj!c !ngc f!c u!y gnn!c u!c !dc em .!
`w r!eqw pugn!y jq!ec p!eqpfw ev!dw ukpguu!
`qp!dgjc nh!qh!vjg!ngc f!eqw pugn-!c u!
`kpuvc pegu!o c {!c tkug!y jgtg!ngc f!eqw pugn!
`o c {!dg!w pc xc knc dng/!¤53/21 ) c */!
`Rqy gt!qh!c vvqtpg{/!C!rqy gt!qh!
`c vvqtpg{!o w uv!dg!hkngf!y kvj!vjg!
`fguki pc vkqp!qh!eqw pugn-!w pnguu!vjg!
`fguki pc vgf!eqw pugn!ku!c ntgc f{!eqw pugn!qh!
`tgeqtf/!¤53/21 ) d*/!
`Rtq!jc e!xkeg/!Vjg!Dqc tf!o c {!
`tgeqi pk|g!eqw pugn!rtq!jc e!xkeg!fw tkpi !c !
`rtqeggfkpi !w rqp!c !ujqy kpi !qh!i qqf!
`ec w ug-!c pf!uw dlgev!vq!vjg!tgsw ktgo gpv!
`vjc v!ngc f!eqw pugn!ku!c !tgi kuvgtgf!
`rtc evkvkqpgt/!¤53/21 ) e*/!Vjg!Dqc tf!o c {!
`ko rqug!qvjgt!eqpukfgtc vkqpu!c u!y gnn/!Kf/!
`Rtqeggfkpi u!dghqtg!vjg!Qhhkeg!ec p!dg!
`vgejpkec nn{!eqo rngz/!Hqt!gzc o rng-!kv!ku!
`
`gzrgevgf!vjc v!c o gpfo gpvu!vq!c !rc vgpv!
`y knn!dg!uqw i jv/!Vjg!i tc pv!qh!c !o qvkqp!vq!
`c rrgc t!rtq!jc e!xkeg!ku!c !fkuetgvkqpc t{!
`c evkqp!vc m kpi !kpvq!c eeqw pv!vjg!urgekhkeu!
`qh!vjg!rtqeggfkpi u/!Uko knc tn{-!vjg!
`tgxqec vkqp!qh!rtq!jc e!xkeg!ku!c !
`fkuetgvkqpc t{!c evkqp!vc m kpi !kpvq!c eeqw pv!
`xc tkqw u!hc evqtu-!kpenw fkpi !
`kpeqo rgvgpeg-!w py knnkpi pguu!vq!c dkfg!
`d{!vjg!Qhhkeg“u!Tw ngu!qh!Rtqhguukqpc n!
`Eqpfw ev-!c pf!kpekxknkv{/!
`Vjg!Qhhkeg!gzrgevu!vjc v!ngc f!eqw pugn!
`y knn-!c pf!dc em .w r!eqw pugn!o c {-!
`rc tvkekrc vg!kp!c nn!jgc tkpi u!c pf!
`eqphgtgpeg!ec nnu!y kvj!vjg!Dqc tf!c pf!y knn!
`uki p!c nn!rc rgtu!uw do kvvgf!kp!vjg!
`rtqeggfkpi /!Kp!c ffkvkqp-!vjg!tqng!qh!
`dc em .w r!eqw pugn!ku!vq!eqpfw ev!dw ukpguu!
`y kvj!vjg!Qhhkeg!qp!dgjc nh!qh!ngc f!eqw pugn!
`y jgp!ngc f!eqw pugn!ku!pqv!c xc knc dng/!
`Cevkqpu!pqv!eqpfw evgf!dghqtg!vjg!Qhhkeg!
`) g/i /-!vc m kpi !qh!fgrqukvkqp*!o c {!dg!
`eqpfw evgf!d{!ngc f!qt!dc em .w r!eqw pugn/!
`E/!Gngevtqpke!Hknkpi !
`
`Gngevtqpke!hknkpi !ku!vjg!fghc w nv!o c ppgt!
`kp!y jkej!fqew o gpvu!c tg!vq!dg!hkngf!y kvj!
`vjg!Dqc tf/!¤53/7) d*/!Gngevtqpke!hknkpi !qh!
`ngi c n!fqew o gpvu!ku!dgkpi !ko rngo gpvgf!
`c etquu!vjg!eqw pvt{!kp!uvc vg!c pf!hgfgtc n!
`eqw tvu/!Vjg!w ug!qh!gngevtqpke!hknkpi !c kfu!
`kp!vjg!ghhkekgpv!c fo kpkuvtc vkqp!qh!vjg!
`rtqeggfkpi -!ko rtqxgu!rw dnke!
`c eeguukdknkv{-!c pf!rtqxkfgu!c !o qtg!
`ghhgevkxg!fqew o gpv!o c pc i go gpv!u{uvgo !
`hqt!vjg!Qhhkeg!c pf!rc tvkgu/!Vjg!o c ppgt!
`qh!uw do kuukqp!y knn!dg!guvc dnkujgf!d{!vjg!
`Dqc tf/!Vjg!Dqc tf!y knn!rw dnkuj!
`gngevtqpke!uw do kuukqp!kphqto c vkqp!qp!kvu!
`Y gd!ukvg!) y y y /w urvq/i qx0RVCD*!kp!
`Cw i w uv!qh!31 23/!Fw g!vq!u{uvgo !
`eqpuvtc kpvu-!pq!ukpi ng!w rnqc fgf!hkng!o c {!
`gzeggf!361 !o gi c d{vgu!kp!uk|g/!
`Rc rgt!hknkpi !o c {!dg!w ugf!y jgtg!
`c rrtqrtkc vg-!dw v!o w uv!dg!c eeqo rc pkgf!
`d{!c !o qvkqp!gzrnc kpkpi !vjg!pggf!hqt!
`pqp.gngevtqpke!hknkpi /!¤53/7) d*/!Dc ugf!
`w rqp!gzrgtkgpeg!y kvj!eqpvguvgf!ec ugu-!
`vjg!Dqc tf!fqgu!pqv!gzrgev!vq!tgegkxg!
`o c p{!tgsw guvu!vq!hkng!rc rgt!uw do kuukqpu/!
`Ektew o uvc pegu!y jgtg!c !rc rgt!hknkpi !o c {!
`dg!y c ttc pvgf!kpenw fg!vjqug!qeec ukqpu!
`y jgtg!vjg!Qhhkeg“u!gngevtqpke!hknkpi !
`u{uvgo !ku!w pc dng!vq!c eegrv!hknkpi u/!
`Cnvgtpc vkxgn{-!kh!c !rtqdngo !y kvj!
`gngevtqpke!hknkpi !c tkugu!fw tkpi !pqto c n!
`dw ukpguu!jqw tu-!c !rc tv{!o c {!eqpvc ev!vjg!
`Dqc tf!c pf!tgsw guv!c !qpg.fc {!gzvgpukqp!
`qh!vko g!hqt!fw g!fc vgu!vjc v!c tg!ugv!d{!tw ng!
`qt!qtfgtu!qh!vjg!Dqc tf/!¤53/6/!Kp!vjg!
`w pnkm gn{!gxgpv!vjc v!c p!c fo kpkuvtc vkxg!
`rc vgpv!lw fi g!ku!pqv!c xc knc dng!vq!tw ng!qp!
`vjg!gzvgpukqp-!vjg!Dqc tf!o c {!i tc pv!c p!
`gzvgpukqp!vjg!fc {!c hvgt!vjg!rc rgt!ku!fw g-!
`y jkej!kpenw fgu!ukvw c vkqpu!y jgtg!
`gngevtqpke!hknkpi !rtqdngo u!c tg!ujqy p!vq!
`jc xg!qeew ttgf/!
`
`XgtFc vg!O c t> 26@31 21 ! 28<37!Cw i !24-!31 23 L m v!3371 1 2 RQ!1 1 1 1 1
`
`Hto
`
`!1 1 1 1 5 Ho v!581 2 Uho v!581 1 G<^HT^HO ^25CWT6/UI O
`
`25CWT6
`
`utqdgtvu!qp!FUM6URVXP2RTQF!ykvj!TWNGU
`
`Patent Owner Exhibit 2010
`Petition for IPR Review of Patent No. 8,519,973
`Page 4
`
`

`
`Hgfgtc n! Tgi kuvgt0 Xqn/! 88-! Pq/! 268 0 Vw gufc {-! Cw i w uv! 25-! 31 23 0 Tw ngu! c pf! Tgi w nc vkqpu!
`
`5986; !
`
`F/!O c pfc vqt{!Pqvkegu!
`Vjg!tw ngu!tgsw ktg!vjc v!rc tvkgu!vq!c !
`rtqeggfkpi !rtqxkfg!egtvc kp!o c pfc vqt{!
`pqvkegu-!kpenw fkpi !kfgpvkhkec vkqp!qh!vjg!
`tgc n!rc tvkgu.kp.kpvgtguv-!tgnc vgf!o c vvgtu-!
`ngc f!c pf!dc em .w r!eqw pugn-!c pf!ugtxkeg!
`kphqto c vkqp/!¤53/9/!Y jgtg!vjgtg!ku!c !
`ejc pi g!qh!kphqto c vkqp-!c !rc tv{!o w uv!hkng!
`c !tgxkugf!pqvkeg!y kvjkp!32!fc {u!qh!vjg!
`ejc pi g/!¤53/9) c *) 4*/!
`2/!Tgc n!Rc tv{.kp.Kpvgtguv!qt!Rtkx{<!Vjg!
`eqtg!hw pevkqpu!qh!vjg!’’tgc n!rc tv{.kp.!
`kpvgtguv““!c pf!’’rtkxkgu““!tgsw ktgo gpv!vq!
`c uukuv!o go dgtu!qh!vjg!Dqc tf!kp!
`kfgpvkh{kpi !rqvgpvkc n!eqphnkevu-!c pf!vq!
`c uuw tg!rtqrgt!c rrnkec vkqp!qh!vjg!
`uvc vw vqt{!guvqrrgn!rtqxkukqpu/!Vjg!nc vvgt-!
`kp!vw tp-!uggm u!vq!rtqvgev!rc vgpv!qy pgtu!
`htqo !jc tc uuo gpv!xkc !uw eeguukxg!
`rgvkvkqpu!d{!vjg!uc o g!qt!tgnc vgf!rc tvkgu-!
`vq!rtgxgpv!rc tvkgu!htqo !jc xkpi !c !
`’’ugeqpf!dkvg!c v!vjg!c rrng-““!c pf!vq!
`rtqvgev!vjg!kpvgi tkv{!qh!dqvj!vjg!WURVQ!
`c pf!Hgfgtc n!Eqw tvu!d{!c uuw tkpi !vjc v!c nn!
`kuuw gu!c tg!rtqo rvn{!tc kugf!c pf!xgvvgf/!
`Eh/!Hgf/!T/!Ekx/!R/!28) c *!) Cfxkuqt{!
`Eqo o kvvgg!Pqvg!vq!2; 77!Co gpfo gpv!vq!
`Tw ng!28) c **!) ’’]V_jg!o qfgtp!hw pevkqp!qh!
`vjg!tw ng!kp!kvu!pgi c vkxg!c urgev!ku!uko rn{!
`vq!rtqvgev!vjg!fghgpfc pv!c i c kpuv!c !
`uw dugsw gpv!c evkqp!d{!vjg!rc tv{!c evw c nn{!
`gpvkvngf!vq!tgeqxgt-!c pf!vq!kpuw tg!
`i gpgtc nn{!vjc v!vjg!lw fi o gpv!y knn!jc xg!kvu!
`rtqrgt!ghhgev!c u!tgu!lw fkec vc /““*/!Vjg!
`WURVQ!y knn!c rrn{!vtc fkvkqpc n!eqo o qp.!
`nc y !rtkpekrngu!y kvj!vjgug!i qc nu!kp!o kpf!
`c pf!rc tvkgu!y knn!dg!y gnn.ugtxgf!vq!hc evqt!
`kp!vjgug!eqpukfgtc vkqpu!y jgp!
`fgvgto kpkpi !y jqo !vq!kfgpvkh{/!
`Y jgvjgt!c !rc tv{!y jq!ku!pqv!c !pc o gf!
`rc tvkekrc pv!kp!c !i kxgp!rtqeggfkpi !
`pqpgvjgnguu!eqpuvkvw vgu!c !’’tgc n!rc tv{.kp.!
`kpvgtguv““!qt!’’rtkx{““!vq!vjc v!rtqeggfkpi !
`ku!c !jki jn{!hc ev.fgrgpfgpv!sw guvkqp/!Ugg!
`i gpgtc nn{!Vc {nqt!x/!Uvw ti gnn-!664!W/U/!
`991 !) 31 1 9*=!29C!Ejc tngu!Cnc p!Y tki jv-!
`Ctvjw t!T/!O knngt!’!Gfy c tf!J/!Eqqrgt-!
`Hgfgtc n!Rtc evkeg!’!Rtqegfw tg!¤¤555; -!
`5562!) 3f!gf/!31 22*!) jgtgkpc hvgt!’’Y tki jv!
`'!O knngt““*/!Uw ej!sw guvkqpu!y knn!dg!
`jc pfngf!d{!vjg!Qhhkeg!qp!c !ec ug.d{.ec ug!
`dc uku!vc m kpi !kpvq!eqpukfgtc vkqp!jqy !
`eqw tvu!jc xg!xkgy gf!vjg!vgto u!’’tgc n!
`rc tv{.kp.kpvgtguv““!c pf!’’rtkx{/““!Ugg-!g/i /-!
`Vc {nqt-!664!W/U/!c v!9; 4— 9; 6!c pf!9; 4!p/7!
`) pqvkpi !vjc v!’’]v_jg!nkuv!vjc v!hqnnqy u!ku!
`o gc pv!qpn{!vq!rtqxkfg!c !htc o gy qtm !]hqt!
`vjg!fgekukqp_-!pqv!vq!guvc dnkuj!c !
`fghkpkvkxg!vc zqpqo {““*/!Eqw tvu!kpxqm g!
`vjg!vgto u!’’tgc n!rc tv{.kp.kpvgtguv““!c pf!
`’’rtkx{““!vq!fguetkdg!tgnc vkqpujkru!c pf!
`eqpukfgtc vkqpu!uw hhkekgpv!vq!lw uvkh{!
`c rrn{kpi !eqpxgpvkqpc n!rtkpekrngu!qh!
`guvqrrgn!c pf!rtgenw ukqp/!Ceeqtfkpi n{-!
`eqw tvu!jc xg!c xqkfgf!tki kf!fghkpkvkqpu!qt!
`tgekvc vkqp!qh!pgeguuc t{!hc evqtu/!
`Uko knc tn{-!o w nvkrng!Hgfgtc n!Tw ngu!
`kpxqm g!vjg!vgto u!y kvjqw v!c vvgo rvkpi !vq!
`
`fghkpg!vjgo !qt!y jc v!hc evqtu!vtki i gt!vjgkt!
`c rrnkec vkqp/!Ugg-!g/i /-!Hgf/!T/!Ekx/!R/!28=!
`Hgf/!Ekt/!T/!58/5/!
`Vjg!v{rkec n!eqo o qp.nc y !gzrtguukqp!
`qh!vjg!’’tgc n!rc tv{.kp.kpvgtguv““!) vjg!rc tv{!
`’’y jq-!c eeqtfkpi !vq!vjg!i qxgtpkpi !
`uw duvc pvkxg!nc y -!ku!gpvkvngf!vq!gphqteg!
`vjg!tki jv““*!fqgu!pqv!hkv!fktgevn{!kpvq!vjg!
`CKC!vtkc n!eqpvgzv/!Ugg!7C!Ejc tngu!Cnc p!
`Y tki jv-!Ctvjw t!T/!O knngt-!O c t{!M c {!
`M c pg-!’!Tkejc tf!N/!O c tew u-!Hgfgtc n!
`Rtc evkeg!’!Rtqegfw tg!Ekxkn!ugevkqp!2654!
`) 4f!gf/!31 22*!) fkuew uukpi !Hgf/!T/!Ekx/!R/!
`28*/!Vjc v!pqvkqp!tghngevu!uvc pfkpi !
`eqpegrvu-!dw v!pq!uw ej!tgsw ktgo gpv!
`gzkuvu!kp!vjg!KRT!qt!RIT!eqpvgzv-!
`c nvjqw i j!kv!gzkuvu!kp!vjg!EDO !eqpvgzv/!Kp!
`c p!KRT!qt!RIT!rtqeggfkpi -!vjgtg!ku!pq!
`’’tki jv““!dgkpi !gphqtegf!ukpeg!c p{!gpvkv{!
`) qvjgt!vjc p!vjg!rc vgpv!qy pgt*!o c {!hkng!
`c p!KRT!qt!RIT!rgvkvkqp/!Jqy gxgt-!vjg!
`urktkv!qh!vjc v!hqto w nc vkqp!c u!vq!KRT!c pf!
`RIT!rtqeggfkpi u!o gc pu!vjc v-!c v!c !
`i gpgtc n!ngxgn-!vjg!’’tgc n!rc tv{.kp.kpvgtguv““!
`ku!vjg!rc tv{!vjc v!fguktgu!tgxkgy !qh!vjg!
`rc vgpv/!Vjw u-!vjg!’’tgc n!rc tv{.kp.kpvgtguv““!
`o c {!dg!vjg!rgvkvkqpgt!kvugnh-!c pf0qt!kv!
`o c {!dg!vjg!rc tv{!qt!rc tvkgu!c v!y jqug!
`dgjguv!vjg!rgvkvkqp!jc u!dggp!hkngf/!Kp!
`vjku!tgi c tf-!vjg!Qhhkeg“u!rtkqt!
`c rrnkec vkqp!qh!uko knc t!rtkpekrngu!kp!vjg!
`kpvgt!rc tvgu!tggzc o kpc vkqp!eqpvgzv!qhhgtu!
`c ffkvkqpc n!i w kfc peg/!Ugg!i gpgtc nn{!Kp!tg!
`I w c p!gv!c n/!Kpvgt!Rc tvgu!Tggzc o kpc vkqp!
`Rtqeggfkpi -!Eqpvtqn!Pq/!; 601 1 2-1 56-!
`Fgekukqp!Xc ec vkpi !Hknkpi !Fc vg!) Cw i /!36-!
`31 1 9*/!Uko knc t!eqpukfgtc vkqpu!c rrn{!vq!
`EDO !rtqeggfkpi u-!c nvjqw i j!vjg!uvc vw vg!
`i qxgtpkpi !vjqug!rtqeggfkpi u!c nuq!
`tgsw ktgu!vjc v!vjg!rc tv{!uggm kpi !vjg!
`rtqeggfkpi -!qt!kvu!tgc n!rc tv{.kp.kpvgtguv!
`qt!rtkx{-!jc xg!dggp!uw gf!hqt!kphtkpi kpi !
`vjg!uw dlgev!rc vgpv-!qt!dggp!ejc ti gf!y kvj!
`kphtkpi go gpv!w pfgt!vjc v!rc vgpv/!
`Vjg!pqvkqp!qh!’’rtkxkv{““!ku!o qtg!
`gzrc pukxg-!gpeqo rc uukpi !rc tvkgu!vjc v!fq!
`pqv!pgeguuc tkn{!pggf!vq!dg!kfgpvkhkgf!kp!
`vjg!rgvkvkqp!c u!c !’’tgc n!rc tv{.kp.kpvgtguv/““!
`Vjg!Qhhkeg!kpvgpfu!vq!gxc nw c vg!y jc v!
`rc tvkgu!eqpuvkvw vg!’’rtkxkgu““!kp!c !o c ppgt!
`eqpukuvgpv!y kvj!vjg!hngzkdng!c pf!
`gsw kvc dng!eqpukfgtc vkqpu!guvc dnkujgf!
`w pfgt!hgfgtc n!ec ugnc y /!Wnvko c vgn{-!vjc v!
`c pc n{uku!uggm u!vq!fgvgto kpg!y jgvjgt!vjg!
`tgnc vkqpujkr!dgvy ggp!vjg!rw trqtvgf!
`’’rtkx{““!c pf!vjg!tgngxc pv!qvjgt!rc tv{!ku!
`uw hhkekgpvn{!enqug!uw ej!vjc v!dqvj!ujqw nf!
`dg!dqw pf!d{!vjg!vtkc n!qw veqo g!c pf!
`tgnc vgf!guvqrrgnu/!Vjku!c rrtqc ej!ku!
`eqpukuvgpv!y kvj!vjg!ngi kunc vkxg!jkuvqt{!qh!
`vjg!CKC-!y jkej!kpfkec vgu!vjc v!Eqpi tguu!
`kpenw fgf!’’rtkxkgu““!y kvjkp!vjg!rc tvkgu!
`uw dlgev!vq!vjg!uvc vw vqt{!guvqrrgn!
`rtqxkukqpu!kp!c p!ghhqtv!vq!ec rvw tg!’’vjg!
`fqevtkpg“u!rtc evkec n!c pf!gsw kvc dng!
`pc vw tg-““!kp!c !o c ppgt!c m kp!vq!eqnnc vgtc n!
`guvqrrgn/!Kp!vjc v!tgi c tf-!vjg!ngi kunc vkxg!
`jkuvqt{!gpfqtugf!vjg!gzrtguukqp!qh!
`’’rtkx{““!c u!hqnnqy u<!
`
`Vjg!y qtf!’’rtkx{““!jc u!c esw ktgf!c p!
`gzrc pfgf!o gc pkpi /!Vjg!eqw tvu-!kp!vjg!
`kpvgtguv!qh!lw uvkeg!c pf!vq!rtgxgpv!gzrgpukxg!
`nkvki c vkqp-!c tg!uvtkxkpi !vq!i kxg!ghhgev!vq!
`lw fi o gpvu!d{!gzvgpfkpi !’’rtkxkgu““!dg{qpf!vjg!
`enc uukec n!fguetkrvkqp/!Vjg!go rjc uku!ku!pqv!qp!
`vjg!eqpegrv!qh!kfgpvkv{!qh!rc tvkgu-!dw v!qp!vjg!
`rtc evkec n!ukvw c vkqp/!Rtkxkv{!ku!guugpvkc nn{!c !
`ujqtvjc pf!uvc vgo gpv!vjc v!eqnnc vgtc n!guvqrrgn!
`ku!vq!dg!c rrnkgf!kp!c !i kxgp!ec ug=!vjgtg!ku!pq!
`w pkxgtuc nn{!c rrnkec dng!fghkpkvkqp!qh!rtkxkv{/!
`Vjg!eqpegrv!tghgtu!vq!c !tgnc vkqpujkr!dgvy ggp!
`vjg!rc tv{!vq!dg!guvqrrgf!c pf!vjg!w puw eeguuhw n!
`rc tv{!kp!vjg!rtkqt!nkvki c vkqp!y jkej!ku!
`uw hhkekgpvn{!enqug!uq!c u!vq!lw uvkh{!c rrnkec vkqp!
`qh!vjg!fqevtkpg!qh!eqnnc vgtc n!guvqrrgn/!
`265!Eqpi /!Tge/!U; ; 98!) fc kn{!gf/!Ugrv/!
`38-!31 1 9*!) uvc vgo gpv!qh!Ugp/!M {n*!) ekvkpi !
`Ec n/!Rj{ukekc pu“!Ugtx/!x/!Cqm k!Fkc dgvgu!
`Tgugc tej!Kpuv/-!274!Ec n/Crr/5vj!261 7!
`) Ec n/!Crr/!31 1 9**=!ugg!c nuq!268!Eqpi /!
`Tge/!U2487!) fc kn{!gf/!O c t/!9-!31 22*!
`) kpeqtrqtc vkpi !rtkqt!31 1 9!uvc vgo gpv*/!
`Uw dugsw gpv!ngi kunc vkxg!jkuvqt{!gzrc pfgf!
`qp!vjg!rtkqt!fkuew uukqp!qh!’’rtkx{““!d{!
`pqvkpi !vjc v!’’rtkxkv{!ku!c p!gsw kvc dng!tw ng!
`vjc v!vc m gu!kpvq!c eeqw pv!vjg!’rtc evkec n!
`ukvw c vkqp-“!c pf!ujqw nf!gzvgpf!vq!rc tvkgu!
`vq!vtc puc evkqpu!c pf!qvjgt!c evkxkvkgu!
`tgnc vkpi !vq!vjg!rtqrgtv{!kp!sw guvkqp/““!
`268!Eqpi /!Tge/!U2487!) fc kn{!gf/!O c t/!9-!
`31 22*!) uvc vgo gpv!qh!Ugp/!M {n*/!
`Vjgtg!c tg!o w nvkrng!hc evqtu!tgngxc pv!vq!
`vjg!sw guvkqp!qh!y jgvjgt!c !pqp.rc tv{!o c {!
`dg!tgeqi pk|gf!c u!c !’’tgc n!rc tv{.kp.!
`kpvgtguv““!qt!’’rtkx{/““!Ugg-!g/i /-!Vc {nqt-!
`664!W/U/!c v!9; 4— 9; 6!c pf!9; 4!p/7!) pqvkpi !
`vjc v!’’]v_jg!nkuv!vjc v!hqnnqy u!ku!o gc pv!qpn{!
`vq!rtqxkfg!c !htc o gy qtm !]hqt!vjg!
`fgekukqp_-!pqv!vq!guvc dnkuj!c !fghkpkvkxg!
`vc zqpqo {““*/!C!eqo o qp!eqpukfgtc vkqp!ku!
`y jgvjgt!vjg!pqp.rc tv{!gzgtekugf!qt!
`eqw nf!jc xg!gzgtekugf!eqpvtqn!qxgt!c !
`rc tv{“u!rc tvkekrc vkqp!kp!c !rtqeggfkpi /!
`Ugg-!g/i /-!kf/!c v!9; 6=!ugg!i gpgtc nn{!Y tki jv!
`’!O knngt!ugevkqp!5562/!Vjg!eqpegrv!qh!
`eqpvtqn!i gpgtc nn{!o gc pu!vjc v!’’kv!ujqw nf!
`dg!gpqw i j!vjc v!vjg!pqprc tv{!jc u!vjg!
`c evw c n!o gc uw tg!qh!eqpvtqn!qt!qrrqtvw pkv{!
`vq!eqpvtqn!vjc v!o ki jv!tgc uqpc dn{!dg!
`gzrgevgf!dgvy ggp!vy q!hqto c n!
`eqrc tvkgu/““!Y tki jv!'!O knngt!¨5562/!
`Eqw tvu!c pf!eqo o gpvc vqtu!c i tgg-!
`jqy gxgt-!vjc v!vjgtg!ku!pq!’’dtki jv.nkpg!
`vguv““!hqt!fgvgto kpkpi !vjg!pgeguuc t{!
`sw c pvkv{!qt!fgi tgg!qh!rc tvkekrc vkqp!vq!
`s