throbber
1
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`Oral Hearing–September 15, 2015
`Rodney Carroll –Lead Counsel for Petitioner
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,484,035
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`Gordon * Howard Associates, Inc., 
`
`Petitioner
`
`Patent Owner
`Lunareye, Inc., 
`
`v.
`
`Before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board
`United States Patent and Trademark Office
`
`

`
`2
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`•Ground 3: Lewis,Oncore, and Mohan
`
`•Ground 2: Lewis and Mohan
`
`•Ground 1: Mohan, Oncore, and Roach
`
`•Second IPR–IPR2014‐01213: Claims 1‐24 Obvious 
`
`under 35 U.S.C §103(a) in view of:
`
`•Mohan and Oncore
`
`•First IPR –IPR2014‐00712: Claim 3 Obvious under 
`•Background of the ‘035 Patent
`Introduction
`
`35 U.S.C §103(a) in view of:
`
`

`
`3
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,484,035, Ex. 1002 at Fig. 1.
`
`Background of the ‘035 Patent
`
`

`
`4
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`‘035 Patent, Ex. 1002 at FIG. 2.
`
`“Enable/Disable” 
`
`Element
`
`The 
`
`Element
`The “GPS” 
`
`“Triggering” 
`
`Element
`
`The 
`
`The “Telemetry” 
`
`Element
`
`Background of the ‘035 Patent
`
`

`
`5
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`•Data Reordering element
`
`•Data Selecting element and
`
`•Data Selector performing data formatting functionalities:
`
`•Triggering element (undisputed), and
`
`•Enable/Disable element (undisputed), 
`
`•Telemetry element (undisputed),
`
`•GPS element (undisputed),
`
`comprising:
`Triggerablelocation‐reporting apparatus (undisputed), 
`Background of the ‘035 Patent
`
`

`
`6
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`sequences and are independently enabled & output
`•Reordering: NMEA sentences order data in different 
`
`•Selecting less than all: NMEA sentences contain different 
`
`location data sets
`
`•Data Selecting Device part of Oncore’sGPS device
`
`Broadest Claim
`
`Subject of related District Court Litigation
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•Limited to Claim 3
`First IPR: IPR2014‐00712
`
`

`
`7
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`•Oncorediscloses the “Data Selecting” and “Reordering” 
`
`Elements
`
`•Ground 3, Claims 3, 21: Lewis, Oncore, and 
`
`Mohan
`
`•Lewis discloses the “Data Selecting” and “Reordering” Elements
`
`•Ground 2, Claims 3‐24: Lewis and Mohan
`
`•Oncorediscloses the “Data Selecting” and “Reordering” 
`
`Elements
`
`•Ground 1, Claims 1, 2: Mohan,Oncore, and Roach
`Second IPR: IPR2014‐01213
`
`

`
`8
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`receiver
`receiver to yield recognized benefits associated with Oncore’sGPS 
`•Motivation to utilize Oncore’sGPS receiver in place of Mohan’s GPS 
`
`specific, known communication protocol (NMEA‐0183)
`receiver in order to utilize a GPS receiver that communicates via a 
`•Motivation to utilize Oncore’sGPS receiver in place of Mohan’s GPS 
`
`place of Mohan’s GPS receiver achieves a predictable result
`Simple substitution of Oncore’scommercially‐available GPS receiver in 
`
`•
`
`device
`recognized benefits associated with Roach’s cellular communications 
`•Motivation to utilize Roach’s cellular communications device to yield 
`
`transmitter/receiver achieves a predictable result
`communications device in place of Mohan’s communications 
`Simple substitution of Roach’s commercially available cellular 
`
`•
`
`Mohan, Oncore, and Roach
`Ground 1: A POSITA Would have Combined 
`
`

`
`9
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`arrange as desired for transmission. 
`available location data (e.g., only a desired subset of data) and 
`POSITA would have been motivated to use less than all of the 
`exceed  32 bits (for example, a GGA and/or GLL sentence), a 
`send location data and GPS data in a NMEA sentence could well‐
`Since Cellemetryused a 32 bit portion of a telemetry message to 
`
`•
`
`•Roach explains that Cellemetryused a 32 bit portion of a data 
`
`message (corresponding to the ESN) to transmit data.
`
`telemetry transmitter to send location data/GPS data for vehicles.  
`
`•Cellemetryliterature expressly taught and suggested using a 
`
`Mohan, Oncore, and Roach
`Ground 1: A POSITA Would have Combined 
`
`

`
`10
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,484,035, Ex. 1002 at Claim 1.
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`whereinthedataselectorreorderstheselectedGPSdata[the“reordering”Element].
`
`theenablecontrollerbeingconfiguredtodisabletheGPSreceiverandthecellularnetworktransmitter
`
`[the“enable/disable”Element];
`
`theenablecontrollerbeingconfiguredtoenabletheGPSreceiverandthecellularnetworktransmitter
`
`uponreceiptoftheenablesignalfromthetriggersignalreceiver;and
`
`anenablecontrollercoupledtotheGPSreceiver,thecellularnetworktransmitter,andthetriggersignal
`
`receiver;
`
`atriggersignalreceiverresponsivetothetriggersignalforproducinganenablesignal[the
`
`“triggering”Element”];
`
`[the“telemetry”Element];
`stationtosendaRegistrationNotificationInvokesignalincludingtheselectedGPSdatatothegateway
`bytheElectronicSerialNumberandaMobileIdentificationNumberthatwillcausethecellularbase
`enabled,aReverseControlChannelsignalincludingtheselectedGPSdataintheplacenormallyoccupied
`acellularnetworktransmittercoupledtothedataselectorforformattingandtransmitting,when
`
`adataselectorforselectinglessthanalloftheGPSdata,toproduceselectedGPSdata[the“data
`
`selecting”Element];
`
`aGPSreceiverresponsivetotheGPSsignalsforproducingGPSdatawhenenabled[the“GPS”
`
`Element];
`
`triggerablelocation-reportingapparatuscomprising[the“triggerablelocation-reporting”Preamble]:
`ControlChannelsignalincludingaMobileIdentificationNumberandanElectronicSerialNumber,the
`connectedthroughanetworktoagateway;thecellularbasestationbeingconfiguredtoexpectaReverse
`GlobalPositioningSatelliteSystem(GPS)signals;asourceofatriggersignal;acellularbasestation
`Atriggerablelocation-reportingapparatusforuseinanenvironmentincluding:asourceof
`1.
`
`Ground 1, Claims 1, 2: Claim 1 is illustrative:
`
`

`
`11
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`•The “Reordering” Element –Oncore
`•The “Enable/Disable” Element –Mohan
`•The “Triggering” Element –Mohan
`•The “Telemetry” Element –Roach
`•The “Data Selecting” Element –Oncore
`•The “GPS” Element –Oncore
`
`•The “TriggerableLocation‐Reporting” Preamble –
`
`Mohan
`
`•Ground 1, Claim 1: Mohan,Oncore, and Roach
`
`

`
`12
`
`Oncore, Ex. 1007 at 3.1.
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`PartesReview, Paper 11 at 8.
`Decision; Institution of Inter
`
`construe
`
`OncoreDiscloses a Data Selector:
`
`signal.”
`include
`location
`ofselectinglocationdatato
`device”as“devicecapable
`selector”and“dataselecting
`“data
`[W]e
`
`the
`
`in
`
`

`
`13
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`Oncore, Ex. 1007 at 5.15.
`
`“Reordering” Elements:
`OncoreDiscloses the “Data Selecting” and 
`
`

`
`14
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`Oncore, Ex. 1007 at 5.15.
`
`“Reordering” Elements:
`OncoreDiscloses the “Data Selecting” and 
`
`

`
`15
`
`Oncore, Ex. 1007 at 6.148-49.
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`Oncore, Ex. 1007 at 6.153.
`
`Coordinated
`Coordinated
`Coordinated
`Time
`Time
`Time
`
`3. Universal
`3. Universal
`3. Universal
`
`2. Longitude
`2. Longitude
`2. Longitude
`
`1. Latitude
`1. Latitude
`1. Latitude
`
`4. Height
`4. Height
`4. Height
`
`3. Longitude
`3. Longitude
`3. Longitude
`
`2. Latitude
`2. Latitude
`2. Latitude
`
`Coordinated
`Coordinated
`Coordinated
`Time
`Time
`Time
`
`1. Universal
`1. Universal
`1. Universal
`
`OncoreDiscloses Selecting Less Than All:
`
`

`
`16
`
`Oncore, Ex. 1007 at 6.148-49.
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`Oncore, Ex. 1007 at 6.153.
`
`Coordinated
`Coordinated
`Coordinated
`Time
`Time
`Time
`
`3. Universal
`3. Universal
`3. Universal
`
`2. Longitude
`2. Longitude
`2. Longitude
`
`1. Latitude
`1. Latitude
`1. Latitude
`
`4. Height
`4. Height
`4. Height
`
`3. Longitude
`3. Longitude
`3. Longitude
`
`2. Latitude
`2. Latitude
`2. Latitude
`
`Coordinated
`Coordinated
`Coordinated
`Time
`Time
`Time
`
`1. Universal
`1. Universal
`1. Universal
`
`Location Data:
`OncoreDiscloses Reordering The Selected 
`
`

`
`17
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`power management scheme
`in the same way and obtain those benefits associated with Mohan’s 
`Lewis’s vehicle tracking unit to improve Lewis’s vehicle tracking unit 
`
`•Application of Mohan’s known power management schemeto 
`
`•Motivation to utilize Mohan’s power management scheme within 
`Lewisand Mohan
`Ground 2: A POSITA Would have Combined 
`
`of preserving and conserving power
`Lewis’s vehicle tracking unit in order to obtain the predictable result 
`
`

`
`18
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,484,035, Ex. 1002 at Claim 4.
`
`whereinthedataselectingdevicereorderstheselectedlocationdata[the“reordering”Element].
`
`“enable/disable”Element];
`deviceandthetelemetrytransmitterafterthetelemetrytransmittertransmitsthelocationsignal[the
`transmitterwhenthecontrollerreceivesatriggersignalandtodisablethelocation-signalgenerating
`anenablecontrollerconfiguredtoenablethelocation-signalgeneratingdeviceandthetelemetry
`
`atelemetrytransmittercoupledtothedataselectingdeviceconfiguredtotransmitthelocationsignal
`
`whenenabled[the“telemetry”Element];and
`
`adataselectingdeviceforselectinglessthanallofthederivedlocationdatatoincludeinthelocation
`
`signal[the“dataselecting”Element];
`
`alocation-signalgeneratingdeviceconfiguredtoproducealocationsignalincludingderivedlocation
`
`datawhenenabled[the“GPS”Element];
`
`Atriggerablelocation-reportingapparatuscomprising[the“triggerablelocation-reporting”
`
`Preamble]:
`4.
`
`Ground 2, Claims 3‐24: Claim 4 is illustrative:
`
`

`
`19
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`•The “Reordering” Element –Lewis 
`•The “Enable/Disable” Element –Mohan
`•The “Telemetry” Element –Lewis
`•The “Data Selecting” Element –Lewis
`•The “GPS” Element –Lewis
`
`•The “TriggerableLocation‐Reporting” Preamble –
`
`Lewis
`
`•Ground 2: Lewis and Mohan
`
`

`
`20
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`Record of Oral Hearing, IPR2014-00712, Notice 42, at 23:5-25:25 (emphasis added).
`
`location signals.
`construed location signal and did it in such a way that there are essentially two
`integrated with these…it's a District Court claim construction, but the District Court
`
`And there's a third, I believe, claim construction dispute that is more or less
`
`explained, I think, at length that reorder implies an initial order.…
`
`The second dispute is about the reorders.And I think that patent owner has
`
`selecting device....
`major claim construction disputes. The first is…the location of the data-
`MR. COMPTON: Yes, there are, Your Honor. There are probably three, I think,
`
`construction disputes in this case and what are they?
`JUDGE LEE: You mention claim construction, Mr. Compton. Are there claim
`
`Ground 2: Claim Construction “Disputes”
`
`

`
`21
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`•BRI Standard applies: construction offered by the Board 
`
`is a reasonable interpretation
`
`data
`“Chip” within Oncore’sGPS selects less than all and reorders location data/GPS 
`
`absent a clear disclaimer
`Limitations should not be imported from preferred embodiments into the claims 
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•Petitioner strongly disagrees for the reasons set forth in 
`
`the First IPR and in Petitioner’s Reply Brief:
`
`Claim 3 is broadest claim
`
`•
`
`•Claim Construction Disputes arose from Claim 3
`Ground 2: Claim Construction “Disputes”
`
`

`
`22
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`Decision; Institution of Inter PartesReview, Paper 11 at9.
`
`for
`Consequently,weconstrue“reorders”inthecontextofthe
`
`intothedesiredorder
`
`transmission.”
`challengedclaimsas“arranges
`
`Decision; Institution of Inter PartesReview, Paper 11 at8.
`
`thelocationsignal.”
`device”as“devicecapableofselectinglocationdatatoincludein
`Therefore,weconstrue“dataselector”and“dataselecting
`
`Board’s Broadest Reasonable Interpretation
`
`

`
`23
`
`IPR2014-00712, Ex. 2031 at 6.
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`is directed to a preferred embodiment:
`Patent Owner’s narrow claim construction 
`
`

`
`24
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`order)
`receiver produces a NMEA sentence having a defined 
`•An initial order is present in the first data signal (GPS 
`
`•Second data signal having less than all GPS data and 
`
`reordered is produced by the data selecting device
`
`•First data signal with GPS data is produced by GPS 
`
`receiver and received by data selecting device
`
`•Data Selecting Device is separate from GPS receiver
`nonetheless taught by Lewis and Mohan:
`construction was proper, all elements are 
`Even if, arguendo, the Patent Owner’s 
`
`

`
`25
`
`Lewis, Ex. 1009 at FIG. 2A.
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`(emphasis added).
`Lewis, Ex. 1009 at col. 10, lines 53-56
`
`overlines51aand51brespectively.
`telephonesignalstransmittedandreceived
`thecellulartransceiver52forformattingthe
`[GPS]receiver48throughamodem74to
`Theswitchingjunction50interconnectsthe
`
`Data Selecting
`
`Device
`
`GPS Receiver
`
`Device:
`Lewis Discloses a separate Data Selecting 
`
`

`
`26
`
`Lewis, Ex. 1009 at FIG. 2A.
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`(emphasis added).
`Lewis, Ex. 1009 at col. 10, lines 53-56
`
`overlines51aand51brespectively.
`telephonesignalstransmittedandreceived
`cellulartransceiver52forformattingthe
`receiver48throughamodem74tothe
`Theswitchingjunction50interconnectsthe
`
`Second Location
`
`Signal
`
`First Location
`
`Signal
`
`signal:
`Lewis Discloses a first and second location 
`
`

`
`27
`Lewis, Ex. 1009 at 9:25-58 (emphasis added).
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`expressedinknotsandthevehiclespeedexpressedinkilometersperhour.
`vehicle16ismovingindegreeswithregardtotruenorthandtomagneticnorth,thevehiclespeed
`identifiedbythe$GPVTG(VehicleTrackmadeGood)addressfieldandincludesthedirectionthatthe
`inprovidingthedifferentialcorrectiondata.Thereceiveroutputmayalsoincludeanotherblockwhichis
`anidentifierindicatingwhichofthepluralityofpotentiallyavailabledifferentialstations40wasinvolved
`time(orage)expressedinsecondsthatthepresentdifferentialGPScorrectiondatahasnotchanged,and
`SVs),thealtitudeoftheantennaabovemeansealevel,theellipsoidseparationbetweensatellites12,the
`fixdata,thehorizontaldilutionofprecision(HDOP/3-SVs)orpositiondilutionofprecisiondata(PDOP/4-
`indicatingadifferentialGPSfix),thenumberofsatellites12whosesignalswerereceivedtocalculatethe
`indicatordescribingthelocationorfixdata(0indicatinganinvalidfix,1indicatingavalidGPSand2
`eastorwestlongitude,thenumberofsatellites(either3or4)participatinginthefix,adataquality
`GGAaddressfieldandincludetheuniversaltimecoordinated(UTC)time,thenorthorsouthlatitude,the
`MarineElectronicsAssociation.ThosesentencesareablockoftheGPSFixData($GPGGA)withinthe
`receiver48iscapableofoutputtingatleasttwosentencesinthe0183standardestablishedbytheNational
`0183,StandardforInterfacingMarineElectronicDevices,Version2.00,Jan.1,1992”….Illustratively,sucha
`thatformatestablishedbytheDepartmentofDefenseanddescribedin“NationalMarineElectronicsAssociation
`Thereceiver48isinanillustrativeembodimentofthisinventionadaptedtoreceiveandprocessGPSsignalsin
`
`Lewis’sGPS produces NMEA sentences:
`
`

`
`28
`
`Oncore, Ex. 1007 at 6.148-49.
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`Ref. Station ID.
`Age of Diff. Data
`Geoidal Sep.
`
`Height
`H.D.O.P.
`H.D.O.P.
`H.D.O.P.
`
`Number of Sat.
`
`GPS Quality
`
`Longitude
`Longitude
`Longitude
`
`Latitude
`Latitude
`Latitude
`Coordinated
`Coordinated
`Coordinated
`Universal Time
`Universal Time
`Universal Time
`
`order:
`NMEA sentences have a defined initial 
`
`

`
`29
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`•Lewis’s Illustrative Data Message: Location (e.g., 
`
`Latitude, Longitude), Time
`
`•GGA Sentence: Time, Latitude, Longitude, Height, etc.
`
`Lewis, Ex. 1009 at 11:19-56 (emphasis added).
`
`The switching network routes the packet of data to its destination node.
`command, the message text in the form of the vehicle location and time data, and an end-of-text suffix.
`
`…Illustratively, the data message would include a start-of-header preamble, a start-of-text
`
`the mobile telephone system 22….
`dual purpose antenna 20, which functions to receive and transmit data messages to and from its cell 24 of
`
`The transceiver 52 is coupled via a suitable coaxial cable 53 and an AM-FM/cellular splitter 54 to a
`
`the NMEA sentences:
`Lewis selects less than all of the data from 
`
`

`
`30
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`(emphasis added).
`Deposition of Joseph McAlexander, Ex. 1023 at 94:17-96:6
`
`it.
`Itismorethanadequateforapersonofordinaryskillintheouttoknow--arttoknowhowtodo
`alreadyknown.Theinventiongoestothepointofdoingthisanditshowsyouthebenefitsofit.
`oruseonlyportionsofdataandtakeinputsandchangethereformattingtotheoutput.Thatis
`alreadyknown.Andthat’showtousemicroprocessorsto--tocaptureonlyportionsofdata
`--there’sanyrequirementthattheinventorneededtogothroughalengthyexplanationofwhatis
`microprocessorart,howtodothat.Itisnotrequiredthat--Idon’tthinkit’sin--thattherehas
`thereisnotaninfinitenumberbutthereareanumberofwaysthatpeopleknow,inthe
`A.…Apersonskilledintheartknowshowtodothat.Thereareanumberofdifferent--
`reorders?....
`Q.Doesthespecificationdiscloseexactlyhowthedataselectorselectslessthanallandthen
`
`than all of the data:
`The POSITA would know how to select less 
`
`

`
`31
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,484,035, Ex. 1002 at Fig. 6, Fig. 7.
`
`remaining data:
`Patent; discarding data & compressing the 
`The meaning of “reorders” from the ‘035 
`
`

`
`32
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`added).
`Deposition of Joseph McAlexander, Ex. 1023 at 24:10-25:1 (emphasis
`
`puttingtheminadifferentarrangement.
`besideeachothernow,thatisreordering.RearrangingsaysIamtakingthemand
`andfour.IfItakeone,threeandfiveandwheretherewasaspaceandIputthem
`selectedthedata,Ihave--Ihavepositionsone,threeandfive.SoIhaveleftofftwo
`Let'ssayit's--let'ssayIhadpositionsone,two,three,fourandfive.AndthenwhenI
`thatfourofthosepositions,thenifItakethosefourpositions--let's--let's--example.
`A.Well,iftheorderhad--iftheorderwas,let'ssay,sixpositionslongandIextractedfrom
`Q.Andwhatisreordering?
`A.Changingtheposition.
`Q.Whatisrearranging?
`reorderingisbroaderthanrearranging.
`rearranginghastobeawayinwhichreorderingcanbedonebutnottheonlyway.So
`data.Claim21saysthereorderingoftheselecteddatacomprisesrearranging.So
`A.The--theclaimthreerequiresthedataselectingdevicereorderstheselectedlocation
`Q.Inthisproposedreadingofclaim21,wouldreorderingbebroaderthanrearranging?
`
`and reordering:
`and compressing is selecting less than all 
`Patent Owner’s Expert agrees; discarding 
`
`

`
`33
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`Rearranged
`
`Discard & Compressed
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•Lewis’s Illustrative Data Message: Location (e.g., Latitude, 
`
`Longitude), Time
`
`•GGA Sentence: Time, Latitude, Longitude, Height, etc.
`
`Lewis, Ex. 1009 at 11:19-56 (emphasis added).
`
`The switching network routes the packet of data to its destination node.
`command, the message text in the form of the vehicle location and time data, and an end-of-text suffix.
`
`…Illustratively, the data message would include a start-of-header preamble, a start-of-text
`
`the mobile telephone system 22….
`dual purpose antenna 20, which functions to receive and transmit data messagesto and from its cell 24 of
`
`The transceiver 52 is coupled via a suitable coaxial cable 53 and an AM-FM/cellular splitter 54 to a
`
`Lewis reorders the selected data:
`
`

`
`34
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`(emphasis added).
`Deposition of Joseph McAlexander, Ex. 1023 at 94:17-96:6
`
`it.
`Itismorethanadequateforapersonofordinaryskillintheouttoknow--arttoknowhowtodo
`alreadyknown.Theinventiongoestothepointofdoingthisanditshowsyouthebenefitsofit.
`useonlyportionsofdataandtakeinputsandchangethereformattingtotheoutput.Thatis
`alreadyknown.Andthat’showtousemicroprocessorsto--tocaptureonlyportionsofdataor
`--there’sanyrequirementthattheinventorneededtogothroughalengthyexplanationofwhatis
`microprocessorart,howtodothat.Itisnotrequiredthat--Idon’tthinkit’sin--thattherehas
`thereisnotaninfinitenumberbutthereareanumberofwaysthatpeopleknow,inthe
`A.…Apersonskilledintheartknowshowtodothat.Thereareanumberofdifferent--
`reorders?....
`Q.Doesthespecificationdiscloseexactlyhowthedataselectorselectslessthanallandthen
`
`the selected data:
`The POSITA would know how to reorder 
`
`

`
`35
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`•Application of Mohan’s known power management schemeto Lewis’s 
`
`management scheme
`same way and obtain those benefits associated with Mohan’s power 
`vehicle tracking unit to improve Lewis’s vehicle tracking unit in the 
`
`•Motivation to utilize Mohan’s power management scheme within Lewis’s 
`
`preserving and conserving power
`vehicle tracking unit in order to obtain the predictable result of 
`
`receiver by recognized benefits associated with Oncore’sGPS receiver
`
`•Motivation to utilize Oncore’sGPS receiver in place of Lewis’s GPS 
`
`specific, known communication protocol (NMEA‐0183)
`receiver in order to utilize a GPS receiver that communicates via a 
`•Motivation to utilize Oncore’sGPS receiver in place of Lewis’s GPS 
`
`place of Lewis’s GPS receiver achieves a predictable result
`Simple substitution of Oncore’scommercially‐available GPS receiver in 
`
`•
`
`Lewis, Oncore, and Mohan
`Ground 3: A POSITA Would have Combined 
`
`

`
`36
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,484,035, Ex. 1002 at Claim 21.
`
`…whereinthedataselectingdevicereorderstheselectedlocationdatacomprisesrearrangingthe
`
`locationdata.
`21.
`
`U.S. Patent No. 6,484,035, Ex. 1002 at Claim 3.
`
`whereinthedataselectingdevicereorderstheselectedlocationdata[the“reordering”Element].
`
`Element];
`telemetrytransmitterafterthetelemetrytransmittertransmitsthelocationsignal[the“enable/disable”
`transmitterwhenitreceivesatriggersignalandtodisablethelocation-signalgeneratingdeviceandthe
`anenablecontrollerconfiguredtoenablethelocation-signalgeneratingdeviceandthetelemetry
`
`atelemetrytransmittercoupledtothedataselectingdeviceconfiguredtotransmitthelocationsignal
`
`whenenabled[the“telemetry”Element];and
`
`adataselectingdeviceforselectinglessthanallofthelocationdatatoincludeinthelocationsignal
`
`[the“dataselecting”Element];
`
`alocation-signalgeneratingdeviceconfiguredtoproducealocationsignalincludinglocationdata
`
`whenenabled[the“GPS”Element];
`
`Atriggerablelocation-reportingapparatuscomprising[the“triggerablelocation-reporting”
`
`Preamble]:
`3.
`
`Ground 3, Claims 3, 21: Claim 21 is illustrative:
`
`

`
`37
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`•The “Reordering” Element –Oncore
`•The “Enable/Disable” Element –Mohan
`•The “Telemetry” Element –Lewis
`•The “Data Selecting” Element –Oncore
`•The “GPS” Element –Oncore
`
`•The “TriggerableLocation‐Reporting” Preamble –
`
`Lewis
`
`•Ground 3: Lewis, Oncore, and Mohan
`
`

`
`38
`
`IPR2014‐001213
`
`order
`Thus, rearranging must encompass initial/1storder, followed by a changed/2nd
`
`says I am taking them and putting them in a different arrangement”
`Patent Owner’s Expert: rearranging is “changing the position”; “rearranging 
`
`Patent Owner’s Expert: “…reordering is broader than rearranging”
`
`§112, Fourth Paragraph: dependent claim specifies a “further limitation”
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•Claim 21: reordering “comprises” rearranging the 
`
`location data
`
`•Claim 20: data selecting device “discards” leaving 
`Construction of generic term “reorders”
`
`selected and “reordered” data; Figures 6 & 7
`
`

`
`39
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`transmission.”
`construction: “arranges into a desired order for 
`generic term “reorders” as recited in Claim 3 is the PTAB’s 
`Accordingly, the Broadest Reasonable Interpretation of the 
`
`‘035 Patent, Ex. 1002 at 7:15-20 (emphasis added).
`
`datatobetransmittedandarrangesitintothedesiredorder.
`desirabletosendtheheadingportionfirst.Thedataselectorselectsthe
`portionsoftheinformationaretransmitted.Forexample,itmaybe
`itmaybedesirabletochangetheorderthatthevarious
`Further,
`
`data:
`‘035 Patent discloses “ordering” of location 
`
`

`
`40
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`Petitioner’s Reply
`receiver is consistent with the redacted portion of 
`encompass formation of a NMEA sentence by the GPS 
`•Construing “selecting less than all” and “reorders” to 
`
`•Arranges the selected location data into a desired order (e.g., a requested NMEA 
`
`sentence) for transmission
`
`Selects less than all location data (GLL and GGA have different location data)
`
`•
`
`includes a data selecting device that:
`In producing NMEA sentences, Oncore’sGPS receiver 
`Oncore“selects less than all” and “reorders”
`
`•
`
`

`
`41
`
`IPR2014‐01213
`
`•Ground 3: Lewis, Oncore, and Mohan
`
`•Ground 2: Lewis and Mohan
`
`•Mohan and Oncoreneed not be physically combined in:
`
`•Oncore’suse of the NMEA standard does not teach away 
`
`POSITA would not be lead away by Oncore’soff‐the‐shelf aspect
`
`POSITA would not be lead away by Mohan’s miniaturized aspects
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•Neither Mohan nor OncoreTeaches Away from Their Combination in 
`POSITA
`Oncorewould have been obvious to the 
`The Combinations employing Mohan and/or 
`
`Ground 1
`
`

`
`IPR2014-01213
`
`
`Petitioner’s Demonstrative Exhibits
`
`CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
`
`
`
`Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. §§42.6(e) and 42.105, this is to certify that I caused a
`
`true and correct copy of the PETITIONER’S DEMONSTRATIVE EXHIBITS
`
`to be served via electronic service by e-mail, in its entirety, to the counsels for the
`
`patent owner on this 10th day of September, 2015:
`
`Matthew S. Compton, Jr., mcompton@pfalawfirm.com
`
`PREBEG, FAUCETT & ABBOTT, PLLC
`
`Stephen W. Abbott, sabbott@pfalawfirm.com
`
`PREBEG, FAUCETT & ABBOTT, PLLC
`
`Christopher M. Faucett, cfaucett@pfalawfirm.com
`
`PREBEG, FAUCETT & ABBOTT, PLLC
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`By:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`/s/Rodney B. Carroll
`Rodney B. Carroll (Reg. No. 39,624)
`Jerry C. Harris, Jr. (Reg. No. 66,822)
`Ryan D. Jenlink (Reg. No. 72,907)
`J. Robert Brown, Jr. (Reg. No. 45,438)
`Conley Rose, P.C.
`5601 Granite Parkway, Suite 500
`Plano, TX 75024
`rcarroll@dfw.conleyrose.com
`jcharris@dfw.conleyrose.com
`rjenlink@dfw.conleyrose.com
`rbrown@dfw.conleyrose.com
`Telephone: 972-731-2288
`Facsimile: 972-731-2289
`
`1

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket