`
`RECEIVED
`
`@004/019
`
`OFHGlAhMegENJ;
`
`_
`
`IN THE UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`
`APPLICANT:
`
`Roman ChistyakOv
`
`SERIAL NO.:
`
`lO/249,202
`
`GROUP NO.:
`
`2821
`
`FILING DATE:
`
`March 21, 2003
`
`EXAMINER:
`
`V0, Tuyet Thi
`
`TITLE:
`
`PLASMA GENERATION USING MULTI—STEP IONIZATlON
`
`Commissioner for Patents
`
`Alexandria, Virginia 22313-1450
`
`AMENDMENT AND RESPONSE
`
`Sir:
`
`The following amendments and remarks are responsive to the Office Action mailed on
`
`February 11, 2004 in the above-identified patent application. Entry and consideration of the
`
`following amendments and remarks, and allowance of the claims, as presented, are respectfully
`
`requested. The Commissioner is hereby authorized to charge the additional claims fee and any
`
`other proper fees to Attorney's Deposit Account No. 5 0121 1.
`
`Please enter the following amendments and consider the remarks that follow.
`
`PAGE 4l19 * RCVD AT 5l5l2004 10:19:39 PM [Eastern Daylight Time] * SVR:USPTO-EFXRF-1l0 * DNIS:8729305 ‘ CSID:781 271 1527 ‘ DURRTION (mm-ss):05-58
`
`'
`
`GILLETTE 1009
`
`GILLETTE 1009
`
`
`
`05/03/2004 THU 22204 FAX 781 271 1527 KURT RAUSCHENBACH
`
`.005/019
`
`Amendment and Response
`Applicant: Chistyakov
`Serial No_: 10/249,202
`Page 2 of 16
`
`Amendments to the Claims:
`
`Please amend claims 1, 6, 18, 22, 30, 33, and 40-42 and add new claims 43-46 as follows.
`
`1.
`
`(currently amended) A plasma generator that generates a plasma with a multi-step
`
`ionization process, the plasma generator comprising:
`
`a feed gas source comprising ground" state atoms;
`
`an excited atom source that is—eeep-leé—te receives gr_qund state at0m§ fiom the feed gas
`
`scurce, the excited atom source comprising a magnet that generates a magnetic field for
`
`substantially trapping electrons proximate to the ground gate atomg, the excited atom
`
`source generating excited atoms fiom the ground state atoms;
`
`a plasma chamber that is coupled to the excited atom source, the plasma chamber
`
`confming a volume of excited atoms generated by the excited atom source; and
`
`an energy source that is coupled to the volume of excited atoms confined by the plasma
`
`chamber, the energy source raising an energy of excited atoms in the volume of excited
`
`atoms so that at least a pertion of the excited atoms in the volume of excited atoms is
`
`ionized, thereby generating a plasma with a multi-step ionization process.
`
`2.
`
`I
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 1 wherein the feed gas source comprises ground
`
`state atoms that are chosen from the group comprising noble gas atoms, a mixture of
`
`different noble gas atoms, reactive gas atoms, a mixture of different reactive gas atoms,
`
`and a mixture ofnoble and reactive gas atoms.
`
`3.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 1 wherein the feed gas source comprises a
`
`volume of ground state argOn atoms.
`
`4.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 1 wherein the excited atom source comprises a
`
`metastable atom source that generates metastable atoms from the ground state atoms.
`
`PAGE 5119* RCVD AT 51672004 10:19:39 PM [Eastern Daylight llme]* SVR:USPTO£FXRF-110* DNIS:8729306 * 08101781 271 1527 * DURATION (mm-$513568
`
`
`
`05/08/2004 THU 22:04 FAX 781 271 1527 KURT RAUSCHENBACH
`
`'008/019
`
`Amendment and Response
`Applicant: Clustyakov
`Serial No.: 10/249,202
`Page 3 of 16
`
`5.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 1 wherein the excited atom source comprises a
`
`first electrode and a second electrode, the first electrode and the second electrode
`
`generating a discharge that excites the ground state atoms.
`
`(currently amended) The plasma generator of claim 1 wherein the excited-atom
`
`fufiher—eempnses—a—magnet—that—generates—a magnetic field that substantially traps
`
`electrons pr0ximate to the ground state atoms—thereby—ineseasingincreases at least one of
`
`a rate at which the excited atoms are generated from the ground state atoms and a density
`of excited atoms.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 1 wherein the excited atom source comprises an
`
`electron gun that directs an electron beam into the ground state atoms, the electron beam
`
`exciting the ground state atoms.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 1 wherein a pressure differentialexists between
`
`a pressure in the excited atom source and a pressure in the plasma chamber, the pressure
`
`differential increasing at least one of a rate at which the excited atoms are generated From
`
`the ground state atoms and a density of the excited atoms.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 1 wherein the excited atom source comprises an
`
`, inductively coupled discharge source that generates a discharge that excites ground state
`atoms.
`
`10.
`
`ll.
`
`12.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 1 wherein the excited atom source is positioned
`
`inside the plasma chamber.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 1 wherein the excited atom source is positioned
`
`outside the plasma chamber.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 1 wherein the excited atoms generated by the
`
`excited atom source have a lower iomzation energy compared with an ionization energy
`
`of the ground state atoms.
`
`PAGE 6119 * RCVD AT 516l2004 10:19:39 PM [Eastern Daylight Tlme] * SVR1USPTO-EFXRF-110 * DNIS:8?29305 * CSID:?81 271 1527 ‘ DURATION (mm-ss):05-58
`
`
`
`05/06/2004 THU 22:04' FAX 781 271 1527 KURT RAUSCHENBACH
`
`.007/019
`
`Amendment and Response
`Applicant: Chistyakov
`Serial No.: 10/249,202
`Page 4 of 16
`
`13.
`
`14.
`
`15.
`
`16.
`
`17.
`
`18.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 1 wherein the energy source is chosen From the
`
`group comprising a DC discharge source, a radio frequency (RF) source, an X—ray source,
`
`an electron beam source, an ion beam source, an inductively coupled plasma (ICP)
`
`source, a capacitively coupled plasma (CCP) source, a microwave plasma source, an
`
`electron cyclotron resonance (ECR) plasma source, a helicon plasma source, a magnetron -
`
`source, and an AC discharge source.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim I wherein the energy source comprises a power
`
`supply.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 14 wherein the power supply is chosen From the
`
`group comprising a pulsed (DC) power supply, a RF power supply, an AC power supply,
`
`and a DC power supply.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 1 further comprising an electron/ion absorber
`
`that receives the excited atoms from the excited atom source, the electron/ion absorber
`
`trapping elections and ions.
`
`.. _
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim I wherein the plasma that is generated with the
`
`multi-step ionization process has a higher plasma density than a plasma that is generated
`
`by direct ionization of the ground state atoms.
`
`(currently amended) A plasma generator that generates a plasma with a multi—step
`
`ionization process, the plaSma generator comprising:
`
`a feed gas source comprising ground state atoms;
`
`a metastable atom source that is-ceupleé—te receives ground ‘state atoms from the Feed gas
`
`source, the metastable atom source comprising a magtet that generates a magnetic field
`
`for substantially trapping electrons proximate to thg gmund state atoms, the metastable
`
`atom source generating metastable atoms from the ground state atoms;
`
`PAGE "19 " RCVD AT 5l6l2004 10:19:39 PM [Eastern Daylight llme] * SVR:USPTO£FXRF-1l0 * DNIS:8?29306 " CSIDil81 271 152? ' DURATION (mm-ssllllS-Sll
`
`
`
`05/08/2004 THU 22:05 FAX 781 271 1527 KURT RAUSCHENBACH
`
`.008/019
`
`Amendment and Response
`Applicant: Chistyakov
`Serial No.: 10/249,202
`Page 5 of 16
`
`a plasma chamber that is Coupled to the metastable atom source, the plasma chamber
`
`confining a volume of metastable atoms generated by the metastable atom source; and
`
`a power supply that is electrically coupled to the volume of metastable atoms confined by
`
`the plasma chamber, the power supply generating a power that raises an energy of
`
`metastable atoms in the volume of metastable atoms so that at least a portion of the
`
`metastable atoms in the volume of metastable atoms is ionized, thereby generating a
`
`plasma with a multi-step ionization process.
`
`19.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 18 wherein the metastable atom source
`
`comprises a first electrode and a second electrode, the first electrode and the second
`
`electrode generating a discharge that excites the ground state atoms to a metastable state.
`
`20.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 18 wherein the metastable atom source
`
`comprises an electron gun that directs an electron beam into the ground state atoms, the
`
`electron beam exciting the ground state atoms to a metastable state.
`
`21.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 18 wherein the metastable atom source
`
`comprises an inductively coupled discharge source that generates a diScharge that excites
`
`the ground state atoms.
`
`22.
`
`(currently amended) The plasma generator of claim 18 wherein the metastable-atom
`
`WWHhet—generates—a magneticiii aid that substantially traps
`
`electrons proximate to the ground state atomsrfleeseby—inereasingtncreas sat least one of
`
`a rate at which the metastable atoms are generated from the ground state atoms and a
`
`density of the metastable atoms.
`
`23.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 18 wherein a pressure differential exists
`
`between a pressure in the metastable atom source and a pressure in the plasma chamber,
`
`the pressure differential increasing at least one of a rate at which the metastable atoms are
`
`generated from the ground state atoms and a density of the metastable atoms.
`
`PAGE 8119 " RCVD AT 51612004 10:19:39 PM [Eastern Daylight Time] * SVR:USPTO-EFXRF-1l0 * DNIS:8729306 * CSID:781 271 152? ‘ DURATION (mm-ss):05-58
`
`
`
`05/08/2004 THU 22:05 FAX 781 271 1527 KURT RAUSCHENBACH
`
`‘
`
`.009/019
`
`Amendment and ReSponsc
`Applicant: Chistyakov
`Serial No.: 10/249202
`Page 6 of 16
`
`24.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 18 wherein the metastable atom source is
`
`positioned inside the plasma chamber.
`
`25.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 18 wherein the metastable atom source is
`
`positioned outside the plasma chamber.
`
`26.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 18 wherein the metastable atOms generated by
`
`the metastable atom source have a lower ionization energy compared with an ionization
`
`energy of the ground state atoms.
`
`27.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 18 wherein the power supply is chosen from the
`
`group comprising a pulsed (DC) power supply, a RF power supply, an AC power supply,
`
`and a DC power Supply.
`
`28.
`
`(original) The plasma generator of claim 18 fiirther comprising an electrOn/iOn absorber
`
`that receives the metastable atoms from the metastable atom scurce, the electron/ion
`
`absorber trapping elections and ions.
`
`29.
`
`(original) The plaSma generator of claim 18 wherein the plasma that is generated with
`
`the multi-step ionization process has a higher plasma density than a plasma that is
`
`generated by direct ionization of the ground state stems.
`
`30.
`
`(currently amended) A method for generating a plasma with a multi-step ionization
`
`process, the method comprising:
`
`generating a magnetic field proximate to a volume of ggound state atoms to substantially
`
`trap electrons proximate to the volume 01' ground state atoms;
`
`generating a volume of metastable atoms from a gig volume of ground state atoms; and
`
`raising an energy of the metastable atoms so that at least a portion of the volume of
`
`metastable atoms is ionized, thereby generating a plasma with a multi-step ionization
`
`process.
`
`PAGE 9119 * RCVD AT 51612004 10:19:39 PM [Eastern Daylight Time] * SVR1USPTO-EFXRF-110" DNIS:8129306 " 6810:781 271 1521‘ DURATION (mm-ss):05-58
`
`
`
`05/06/2004 THU 22:05 FAX 781 271 1527 KURT RAUSCHENBACH
`
`.010/019
`
`Amendment and Response
`Applicant: Chistyakov
`Serial No.: 10/249,202
`Page 7 of 16
`
`31.
`
`32.
`
`33.
`
`(original) The method of claim 30 wherein the volume of ground state atoms comprises a
`
`volume of noble gas atoms.
`
`(original) The method of claim 30 wherein the generating the volume of metastable
`
`atoms comprises generating a discharge that excites at least a portion of the grOund state
`
`theme in the volume of groundstate atoms to a metastable state.
`
`(currently amended) The method of claim 3_Q SZ—fiirther-eempfisiag wherein the
`
`generating a th_e magnetic field proximate to the volumeof ground state atoms-Ase
`
`
`
`atemsrthereby—uaereasi-ng increases excitation of at least a the portion of the ground state
`
`atoms in the volume of the ground state atoms to a metastable state.
`
`7 34.
`
`(original) The method of claim 30 wherein the generating the volume 'of‘ metastable
`
`atoms comprises generating an electron beam that excites at least a portion of the ground
`
`state atoms in the volume of ground state atoms to a metastable state.
`\
`
`35.
`
`36.
`
`37.
`
`(original) The method of claim 30 wherein the raising the energy of the metastable atoms
`
`comprises exposing the metastable atoms to an electric field.
`
`.
`
`(Original) The method of claim 30 wherein the raising the energy of the metastable atoms
`
`comprises exposing the metastable atoms to X-ray radiation.
`
`(original) The method of claim 30 wherein the raising the energy of the metastable atoms
`
`comprises exposing the metastable atoms to a plasma.
`
`38.
`
`.
`
`(original) The method of claim 30 further comprising trapping electrons and ions in the
`
`volume ofmetastable atoms.
`
`39.
`
`(original) The method of claim 30 wherein the raising the energy of the metastable atoms
`
`comprises exposing the metastable atoms to an electron source.
`
`PAGE 10l19 ‘ RCVD AT {#612004 10:19:39 PM [Eastern Daylight Time] ‘ SVR1USPTO-EFXRF-1lll * DNIS:8729306 * CSID:781 271 1527 * DURATION (mm-ss):05-58
`
`
`
`05/06/2004 THU 22:06 FAX 781 271 1527 KURT RAUSCHENBACH
`
`I011/019
`
`Amendment and Response
`Applicant: Chi5tyakov
`Serial No.: 10/249,202
`Page 8 of 16
`
`40.
`
`.
`
`(currently amended) A method for generating a plasma with a multi-step ionization
`
`process, the method comprising:
`
`generating a maggetic field proximate to a volume of ground state molecules to
`
`substantially trap electrgns proximate to the volume of ground state molecules;
`
`generating a volume of metastable molecules from a E volume of ground state
`
`molecules; and
`
`raising an energy of the metastable molecules so that at least a pertion of the volume of
`
`metastable molecules is ionized, thereby generating a plasma with a multi-step ionization
`
`proccss.
`
`41.
`
`(currently amended) An apparatus for generating a plasma comprising:
`
`means for generating a magnetic field proximate to a volume of ggound state atoms to
`
`substantially trap electrons proximate to the volume of ggound state atoms;
`
`means for generating a volume of metastable atoms from a th_e volume of ground state
`
`atoms; and
`
`means for raj sing an energy of the metastable atoms so that at least a portion of the
`
`volume of metastable atoms is ionized, thereby generating a plasma with a multi-step
`
`ionization process.
`
`42.
`
`(cunently amended) The apparatus of claim 41 further comprising means for trapping
`
`electrons elections and ions in the volume of metastable atoms.
`
`43.
`
`(new) A plasma generator that generates a plasma with a multi—step ionization process,
`
`the plasma generator comprising:
`
`a feed gas source comprising ground state atoms;
`
`PAGE 11l19 " RCVD AT 5l61200410219139PM [Eastern Daylight Tlme] ‘ SVR:USPTO-EFXRF-1l0 * DNIS:8729306 * CSIDI781 271 1527 * DURATION (mm-ss):05-58
`
`
`
`05/06/2004 THU 22:06 FAX 781 271 1527 KURT RAUSCHENBACH
`
`.012/019
`
`Amendment and Response
`Applicant: Chistyakov
`Serial No.: 10/249,202
`Page 9 of 16
`
`an excited atom source that is coupled to the feed gas source, the excited atom source
`
`generating excited atoms from the ground state atoms;
`
`a plasma chamber that is coupled to the excited atom source, the plasma chamber
`
`confining a volume of excited atoms generated by the excited atom source, wherein a
`
`pressure differential exists between a pressure in the excited atom source and a pressure
`
`in the plasn‘la chamber, the pressure differential increasing at least one of a rate at which
`
`the excited atoms are generated from the ground state atoms and a density of the excited
`
`atoms; and
`
`an energy source that is coupled to the volume of excited atoms confined by the plasma
`
`chamber, the energy source raising an energy of excited atoms in the volume of excited
`
`atoms so that at least a portion of the excited atoms in the volume of excited atoms is
`
`ionized, thereby generating a plasma with a multi—step ionization process.
`
`44.
`
`(new) A plasma generator that generates a plasma with a multi-step ionization process,
`
`the plasma. generator comprising:
`
`_
`
`--
`
`a feed gas source comprising ground state atoms;
`
`an inductively coupled discharge source that is coupled to the feed gas source, the
`
`inductively coupled discharge source generating excited atoms fi-om the ground state
`
`atoms;
`
`a plasma chamber that is coupled to the inductively coupled discharge source, the plasma
`
`chamber confining a volume of excited atoms generated by the inductively coupled
`
`discharge source; and
`
`an energy source that is coupled to the voltunc of excited atoms confined by the plasma
`
`chamber, the energy source raising an energy of excited atoms in the volume of excited
`
`atoms so that at least a portion of the excited atoms in the volume of excited atoms is
`
`ionized, thereby generating a plasma with a multi—step ionization process.
`
`PAGE 12l19 ‘ RCVD AT “612004 10:19:39 PM [Eastern Daylight Time] * SVR:USPTO-EFXRF-1l0 ‘ DNIS:8729306 * CSID:?81 271 1527 * DURATION (mm-ss):05-58
`
`
`
`05/06/2004 THU 22:06 FAX 781 271 1527 KURT RAUSCHENBACH
`
`.013/019
`
`Amendment and Response
`Applicant: Chistyakov
`Serial N0.: 10/249,202
`Page 10 of 16
`
`45.
`
`(new) A plasma generator that generates a plasrna with a multi-step ionization process,
`
`the plasma generatOr camprising:
`
`a feed gas source cempn'siug ground state atoms;
`
`an excited atom source that is coupled to the feed gas source, the excited atom source
`
`generating excited atoms from the ground state atoms;
`
`an electron/ion absorber that receives the excited atoms generated by the excited atom
`
`scurce and then traps elections and ions;
`
`a plasma chamber that is coupled to the electron/ion absorber, the plasma chamber
`
`confining a volume of excited atoms generated by the excited atom source; and
`
`an energy source that is coupled to the volume of excited atoms confined by the plasma
`
`chamber, the energy source raising an energy of excited atoms in the volume of excited
`
`atoms so that at least a portion of the excited atoms in the volume of excited atoms is
`
`ionized, thereby generating a plasma with a multi-step ionization precess.
`
`46.
`
`(new) A method for generating a plasma with a multi-step iOnization process, the method
`
`comprising:
`
`, generating a volume of metastable atoms from a volume of ground state atoms;
`
`trapping electrons and ions in the volume of metastable atoms; and
`
`raising an energy of the metastable atoms so that at least a portion ofthe volume of
`
`metastable atoms is ionized, thereby generating a plasma with a multi-step ionization
`
`process.
`
`PAGE 13119 * RCVD 111' 51612004 10:19:39 PM [Eastern Daylight Time] ' SVR:USPTO-EFXRF-1l0 * DNIS:8729306 * CSID:?81 271 1527 * DURATION (mm-ss):05-58
`
`
`
`05/06/2004 THU 22:06 FAX 781 271 1527 KURT RAUSCHENBACH
`
`.014/019
`
`Amendment and Response
`Applicant: Chistyak0v
`SerialvNon 10/249,202
`Page 11 of 16
`
`Pending Claims:
`
`,
`
`q
`
`REMARKS
`
`Claims 1-46 are currently pending in the present application. Claims 1, 6. 18, 22, 30,
`
`33, and 40-42 are amended by the present Amendment. New claims 43-46 have been added.
`
`No new matter is added by these amendments. Upon entry of the present Amendment,
`
`reconsideration of claims 1-42 and consideration of new claims 43-46 is respectfully
`
`requested.
`
`Allowable Subject Matter:
`
`The Applicant acknowledges with appreciation the Examiner’s statement made in
`
`paragraph 7 ofthe Office Action dated February 11, 2004 that claims 6, 8, 9, 16, 21-23, 28, 33,
`
`and 38 would be allowable if rewritten ,in independent form including all of the limitations of the
`
`heme claim and any intervening claims. The'Applicant has amended independent claim 1 to
`
`include the limitation of dependent claim 6, which the Examiner has indicated is allowable. The
`Applicant has amended independent claim 18 to include the limitation of dependent claim 22,- I
`
`which the Examiner has also indicated is allowable. In addition, the Applicant has amended
`
`independent claim 30 to include the limitation of dependent claim 33, which the Examiner has
`
`also indicated is allowable. Therefore, the Applicant submits that independent claims 1, 18, and
`
`30 are now allowable as currently amended. In addition, the Applicant submits that dependent
`
`claims 2-17, 19-29, and 31-39 are now allowable as depending from allowable base claims.
`
`Dependent claim 8 was rewritten in independent form in new claim 43. The Examiner
`
`has indicated that dependent claim 8 is allowable. Therefore, the Applicant submits that new
`
`claim 43 is allowable over the prior art ol‘record. Dependent claim 9 was rewritten in
`independent form in new claim 44. The Examiner has indicated that dependent claim 9 is
`
`allowable. Therefore, the Applicant submits that new claim 44 is allowable over the prior art of
`
`record. Dependent claim 16 was rewritten in independent form in new claim 45. The Examiner
`
`has indicated that dependent claim 16 is allowable. Therefore, the Applicant submits that new
`
`claim 45 is allowable over the prior art of record. In addition, Dependent claim 38 was rewritten
`
`PAGE 14119 ’ RCVD AT {#612004 10:19:39 PM [Eastem Daylight Time] " SVR:USPTO-EFXRF-1!0 * DNIS:8729306 * CSID:781 271 152? * DURATION (mm-ss):05-58
`
`
`
`05/08/2004 THU 22:07 FAX 781 271 1527 KURT RAUSCHENBACH
`
`.015/019
`
`Amendment and Response
`Applicant Chistyakov
`SerialNo.: 10/249,202
`Page 12 of 16
`
`in independent form in new claim 46. The Examiner has indicated that dependent claim 38 is
`
`allowable. Thereibre, the Applicant submits that new claim 46 is allowable over the prior art of
`
`record.
`
`Drawing Obicctlons:
`
`Paragraph 1 of the Office Action dated February 11, 2004 states that the drawings are
`
`objected to under 37 C.F.R. §l.83(a). The drawings must show every feature of the invention
`
`specified in the claims. Specifically, the electron gun must be shown or removed from claims 7
`
`and 20. The Applicant respectfully submits that thc originally-filed FIG. 8 and the
`
`corresponding written detailed description explicitly illustrate the electron gun 604 (See, for
`
`example, FIG. 8 and paragraph 118). Therefore, the Applicant submits that the drawings as
`
`originally-filed are not objectionable under 37 C.F.R. §l.83(a).
`
`Claim Objections:
`
`Paragraph 2 ofthe Officc Action dated February 1 l, 2004 states that claim 42 is objected
`to bccausc of a typographical error. The Applicant has amended claim 42 to replace the word
`
`“elections” with the word “electrons” as suggested in paragraph 2 of the Office Action.
`
`Therefore, the Applicant submits that claim 42 as currently amended overcomes the objection.
`
`Rejections under 35 U.S.C. §1021e1 as Being Anticipated by Bertrand et aL:
`
`Claims 1-5, 7, 11-15, 17-20, 25—27, 29-32, 34, 35, 37, 39, and 40-42 are rejected under 35
`
`U.S.C. §102(c) as being anticipated by US. Patent No. 6,661,178 issued to Bertrand et a1.
`
`(hereinafter “B ertrand"). Independent claims 1, 18, 30, 40, and 41 are herein amended to more
`
`clearly recite the invention. No new matter is added by these amendments.
`
`To anticipate a claim under 35 U.S.C. §102, a single reference must teach every aspect of
`
`the claimed invention either explicitly or impliedly. Any feature not directly taught by the
`
`reference must be inherently present in the reference. Thus, a claim is anticipated by a reference
`
`only if each and every element of the claim is described, either expressly or inherently, in 21
`
`PAGE 15119 ’ RCVD AT 51612004 10:19:39 PM [Eastern Daylighl'l'lme] " SVR1USPTO-EFXRF-110 ‘ DNIS:8?29306 * CSID:?81 271 152? ‘ DURATION (mmss):05-58
`
`
`
`05/06/2004 THU 22:07 FAX 781 271 1527 KURT RAUSCHENBACH
`
`I016/019
`
`Amendment and Response
`Applicant: Chistyaltov
`Serial No.: 10/249,202
`Page 13 of 16
`
`single prior art reference.
`
`Independent Claim 1 and Dependent Claims 2—5, 7, 11-15, and 17
`
`The Applicant respectfully submits that Bertrand does not describe each and every
`
`element of independent claim 1 as currently amended. Independent claim 1 has been amended
`
`10
`
`include the limitation of dependent claim 6, which the Examiner has indicated is allowable.
`
`Therefore, as stated above, the Applicant submits that independent claim 1 is allowable and
`
`dependent claims 2-5, 7, 11-15, and 17 are allowable as depending from allowable baSe claim.
`
`Independent Claim 18 and Defindcnt Claims 19, 20, 25, 26, 27, and 29
`
`The Applicant respectfully submits that Bertrand does not describe each and every
`
`element of independent claim 18 as currently amended. Independent claim 18 has been amend
`
`ed.
`
`to include the limitation of dependent claim 22, which the Examiner has indicated is allowable.
`
`Thereibre, as stated above, the Applicant submits that independent claim 18 is allowable and
`
`dependent claims 19, 20, 25, 26, 27, and 29 are allowable as depending from allowable base
`
`claim.
`
`Independent Claim 30 and Dependent Claims 31, 32, 34, 35, 37, and 39
`
`The Applicant respectfully submits that Bertrand does not describe each and every
`
`element of independent claim 30 as currently amended. Independent claim 30 has been amended
`
`to include the limitation of dependent claim 33, which the Examiner has indicated is allowable.
`
`Therefore, as stated above, the Applicant submits that independent claim 30 is allowable and
`
`dependent claims 31, 32, 34, 35, 37, and 39 are allowable as depending from allowable base
`
`claim.
`
`Independent Claim 40
`
`The Applicant respectfiilly submits that Bertrand does not describe each and every
`
`element of independent claim 40 as currently am ended.
`
`independent claim 40 has been amended
`
`to include the limitation of dependent claim 33, which the Examiner has indicated is allowable.
`
`PAGE 16119 ‘ RCVD AT 51612004 10:19:39 PM [Eastern Daylight Time] “ SVR:USPTO-EFXRF-110 * DNIS:8?29396 * CSID:?81 271 1527* DURATION (mm-ss):05-58
`
`
`
`05/08/2004 THU 22:07 FAX 781 271 1527 KURT RAUSCHENBACH
`
`l21017/019
`
`Amendment and Response
`Applicant: Chistyakov
`Serial No.: 10/249,202
`Page 14 of 16
`
`Amended independent claim 40 recites a method for generating a plasma with a multi-step -
`
`ionization process that includes generating a magnetic field pmximate to a voltune of ground
`
`state atoms to substantiale trap electrons proximate to the volume of ground state atoms. This
`
`amendment to claim 40 is supported by the originally—filed specification. No new matter is
`
`added by this amendment.
`
`Paragraph 7 of the Office Action states that the prior art fails to disclose a magnet that
`
`generates a magnetic field for trapping electrons proximate to the ground state atoms as required
`
`by claims 6, 22. and 33. The Applicant submits that there is no disclosure in Bertrand of
`
`generating a magnetic field to trap electrons proximate to a volume of ground state atoms, and
`
`thus Bertrand does not describe each and every element of independent claim 40 as currently
`
`amended, either expressly or inherently. Therefore, the Applicant submits that Bertrand does not
`
`anticipate independent claim 40 as currently amended. Thus, the Applicant submits that
`
`amended independent claim 40 is allowable under 35 U.S.C. §102(e).
`
`In
`
`dent
`
`laim 4land De end
`
`a'
`
`The Applicant respectfully submits that Bertrand does not describe each and every
`
`element of independent claim 41 as currently amended. Independent claim 41 has also been
`amended to include the limitation of dependent claim 33, which the Examiner has indicated is
`allowable. Amended independent claim 41 recites a method for generating a plasma with a
`
`multi—step ionization process including a means for generating a magnetic field proximate to a
`
`volume of ground state. atoms to substantially trap electrons prOximate to the volume of ground
`state atoms. This amendment to claim 41 is supported by theoriginally-filed specification. No
`
`new matter is added by this amendment.
`
`The Applicant submits that there is no disclosure in Bertrand of a means for generating a
`
`magnetic field to trap electrons proximate to a volume of ground state atoms, and thus Bertrand
`
`does not describe each and every element of independent claim 41 as currently amended.
`
`Therefore, the Applicant submits that Bertrand does not anticipate independent claim 41 as
`
`PRGE 17119 ‘ RCVD AT 5i612004 10:19:39 PM [Eastern Daylight Time] * SVR:USPTO-EFXRF-1lfl " DNIS:8729306 * CSID:781 271 1527 * DURATION (mm-ss):05-58
`
`
`
`05/06/2004 THU 22:08 FAX 781 271 1527 KURT RAUSCHENBACH
`
`.018/019
`
`v
`
`Amendment and Response
`Applicant: Chistyakov
`_ Serial No.: 10/249,202
`Page 15 of 16
`
`currently amended, either expressly or inherently. Thus, the Applicant submits that amended
`
`independent claim 41 and dependent claim 42 are allowable under 35 U.S.C. §102(e).
`
`Reiectlons under 35 U.S.C. §103:
`
`Claims 10, 24, and 36 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. §103(a) as being unpatentable over
`
`Bertrand. The Applicant respectfully submits that Bertrand does not render dependent claims 10,
`
`24, and 36 obvious.
`
`Dependent Claims 10, 24, and 36 '
`
`Dependent claim 10 depends on independent claim 1. The Applicant respectfiilly
`
`submits that independent claim 1 as currently amended is allowable ever the prior art of record
`
`for the reasons stated above. Thus, the Applicant submits that dependent claim 10 is allowable
`
`as depending fmm an allowable base claim.
`
`Dependent claim 24 depends on independent claim 18. The Applicant respectfully
`
`submits that independent claim 18 as currently amended is allowable over the prior art of record
`
`for the reasons stated above. Thus, the Applicant submits that dependent claim 24 is allowable
`
`as depending from an allowable base claim.
`
`Dependent claim 36 depends on independent claim 30. The Applicant respectfully
`
`submits that independent claim 30 as currently amended is allowable over the prior art of record
`
`for the reasons stated above. Thus, the Applicant submits that dependent claim 36 is allowable
`
`as depending from an allowable base claim.
`
`CONCLUSION
`
`' Claims 1-46 are currently pending in the present application. Claims 1, 6, 18, 22, 30, 33,
`
`and 40-42 are amended by the present Amendment. New claims 43-46 are added. In view of the
`
`foregoing amendments and remarks, reconsideration and allowance of all pending claims (i.e.,
`
`claims 1-46) is respectfully requested.
`
`PAGE 18119 ' RCVD 111 {#612004 10:19:39 PM [Eastern Daylight Time] ‘ SVRIUSPTO-EFXRF-WDNIS:8729306*CSID:781 271 1527 * DURATION (mm-ss):05-58
`
`
`
`05/06/2004 THU 22:08 FAX 781 271 1527 KURT RAUSCHENBACH
`
`.019/019
`
`.
`
`Amendment and Response
`Applicant: Chistyakov
`Serial No.: 10/249,202
`Page 16 of 16
`
`The Commissioner is hereby authorized to charge the additional claims fee and any other
`
`proper fees to Attorney's Deposit Account No. 50121 1 .
`
`If, in the Examiner’s opinion, a telephonic interview would expedite'prosecution of the
`
`present application, the undersigned attorney would welcome the opportunity to discuss any
`
`outstanding issues, and to work with the Examiner toward placing the application in condition
`
`for allowance.
`
`Date: May 6, 2004
`Reg. No. 40.137
`
`Tel. No.: (781) 271-1503
`Fax No: (781) 271-1527
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`Kurt Rauschenbach, Ph.D.
`Attorney for Applicant
`Rauschenbach Patent Law Group, LLC
`Post Office Box 387
`Bedford, MA 01730
`
`PAGE 19119 * RCVD AT 51612004 10:19:39 PM [Eastern Daylight Time]? SVR:USPTO-EFXRF-110 " DNIS:8729396 * CSID2781 271 1527 * DURATION (mm-ss):05_58
`
`