Aiiismey Baezkei‘ N1). NEFN—imiffiliiffi 3E36i‘i392013
`
`FA'ETLNT
`
`{N THE {iNi’i‘EE} STATES PATENT AN?) TRABEMARK OFFECE
`
`In Re. Appiiwiia‘m of:
`
`SAMPAUS, Fciini
`
`Cmfirmaiim N49,:
`
`H67
`
`Sei‘iai Ne:
`
`"7
`133189“, 14
`
`Chimp Ar? Unit:
`
`1529
`
`Ei'iied:
`
`Juiy 25. EM i
`
`Examimr;
`
`POLANSKY, Gffigaé)
`
`F031:
`
`NA'E‘URAL
`
`MAR‘ENE
`
`SQIERCEC
`
`FHGS?HO¥,.EPEBS
`
`COMPRESENG
`
`PGLYENSATURATED FA'I‘T‘Q’ ACIDS AWE} THEER APPLE CAVHGNS
`
`Maii .‘Ei'ogi Bwiamiien
`Cenmiisaigmr for Patents
`
`Pi). Bax i450
`
`Aisxaiidria. VA 1’23 i 3» i 450
`
`
`
`i, Femidoon Shai‘iidij dad-arc as foiiiiwsg
`
`i.
`
`i am a iemn-ed Universiiy Rasmrch Profagsor at Mammiai Univarsiiy of Newi‘i’miidiam‘: in Si.
`
`John‘s. Canada. My appointn‘ism i.
`
`in the Departinam 0i" Biochamifiry. with a 53033--
`
`éippi_sini.meni wiih Lite AQUEEC-Llif‘iiffi ngmm, Bioiogy Department 9nd Ocean Sciences Cam‘s.
`
`i have, bfjfji’i
`
`.9. pmfessoi ai Marrwiiai Uiiivsisiiy sir-.02: 398?.
`
`am also an Harm-my Wei"3930:-
`
`at Chung Shari Medicai Univsrsiiy ii'i Taichung, Taiwan; 3 Chair Pmi’essor in the: Deparimem
`
`oi" Fan/id Sciencs at Nai’ia‘mai Chung i-iSing University in "E‘aiCLhLing Taiwan; and an Adjunct
`
`Profizgsm at Daihousie Universiiy iii Haiifzix. Nova Scmia. Canada and the "Nova Sec-Uzi
`
`Agi’icuiiumi Coiiege ii“: Trixie. Nova, Scotia, Canada. Prim to being at Memoriai; i was; in {he
`r.
`Depmimcrii 03" (iiii‘cti‘iiisii'y and the {apartment 1‘)? Chemicai Engine ring :1i the. Univei'siiy of
`
`Tammi").
`
`E earned a i3ii.j[:>. in i2??? in Physicai ()i‘ganic Chemistry from [his .‘Eéézpaiimeni of Chemistry ai
`
`McGiii Univergiiy in Moniréai. Canada. Prim is firm.) i earned a Bacheiors of Science. with
`
`5 1
`
`;.
`
`
`
`
`000001
`
`Petition for Inter Partes Review
`Of US. Patent 8,278,351
`Exhibit
`
`ENZYMOTEC-1059
`
`000001
`
`

`

`.41101'1163' [100111311310 E‘xiEE'NOOE(3211831’66m291
`1
`7
`
`Honours. from {he {31033011010111 01" Chemistry at 811112.: 1P3. 111111113 110111.151'11“: 81111213. 115111.
`
`After my 000101211 work.
`
`1 was a E’osidnctoz'a‘: ESEEOW 111 1110 13611311111011: {.1ECE1011115113:
`
`111
`
`1-.‘1/1CG'311 1.3111110121131.
`
`3. 111m: 00011 11 31210111151 for 311111101;: 40 3.1-2.1 1:. as 0111111150 111 my C111'1'1011111111 Vitae {01103113110111
`
`,1).
`
`4.
`
`1
`
`1111126 been 1130053111200 W10
`
`2: V3.1:'013' 01" awards 111011101::g, for 0113:1111': 1:: 131110116111: 1.11110
`
`Tachmbgy Award. E-1:.0:00 1.11310 {SEE-T1); FdEc-w.
`
`[4111101113051
`
`{3116111113131
`
`$013161)! {21"110‘1;
`
`D151111g111511120
`
`SEZFVECS Award.
`
`{1.131101131111211
`
`and 13000
`
`(3115111151131 Eva-:1. Amerman
`
`(3115111111211 30010151 {2008);
`
`E's-31213111.
`
`14.111131'1051“: 011 (3211 5:1:5’ Society {EC-{38);
`
`{31115111110111g
`
`173111151011
`
`111101111181. Nutracemical
`
`and
`
`F1111¢11onai E000
`
`9111151011,
`
`111511111113
`
`01" E7000
`
`Techmlggigtg (25198}; Adggymnr‘s (11’1111131001101 01' A‘YT10111111111 011d E000? 3110111151111
`
`1111151111311 {3110111113311 Socieiy ("2007). FCEEOW.
`
`11110171121110.1101 Academy 01" E70011 801121101: 0110
`
`'1'1':0111.10.10ogy (2006');
`
`5110011011 S. Chang Award,
`
`11151111110 01 E000 Fe.1114 ogi 5‘15
`
`(22005);
`
`Eefimv, 11131111119. of F000 ’EecE1n-310g1515 (2111115);
`
`1313110111, 11103101 8131310111 01° Chemistry (UK)
`
`{119E111}; 132.111? M01:13.0 K111111110, 0.0011111:
`
`7171511011135 "1001111010317? 8013101}: (1998'); 1%}an.
`
`{3113111102911 E1=51111116 OE {01110- (1911(1); $11: 115111: 3.131131 11.111141111301011 11151111110 0EE13-00
`
`8121011131:
`
`21110 E10311::01011y
`
`(MOE. E'eiiz'jw.
`
`14161110112111.1211
`
`and F000 131113.1111511'),1
`
`[101131011
`
`1111101101111 Chemicaé 541111.161}; {1994}; 1010111111111 4111:1110 1911110111'
`
`{-0131111ra1800101311994);
`
`Ewe 110,111 Canadian 1113311116 OEEL13.1 30113110021110 "EEC-11114.1'i0gy {1993).
`
`‘1.“
`
`have. 11111111511130 21110111 450 11150: 10111113111611 3.11”11011555. 32:10:11 21:31} 11001-5 $111016:5 11110"
`
`1211111131161101:
`
`p10130ed111g5. and about 6C1 1300115.
`
`E E10111: 2:166:11 rmognized .215 {he ESE 11105: 11111311311130 111111101
`
`(15") in the 21 ea (1'1“1-‘1'100. NUEE'EEEOK'J {1110 Aggie-111111121 Sc1e11ce E01 1111: 136110-11 01" 199633006; 11113
`
`1S111'1051 0111.10 (4"3211111101 111 E0110, 1111111111111“: 3110 11<f11€11=-111131Sci1.:0
`\
`2007; 1110 151 111051 11115{1 (7" 2101111101“ 111 Ehe 9:101“: 01'EE000 N1.11.111:- 01“: 1111001101111111511 S131“111:0
`
`11311110 1301100 01” 199?"
`
`'1'01'1‘1'10 1351100 01" 19962000; 11113 ESE mos: 131113111“;""1 .1111}101 111 1116: 21117: 3Ag1'101111111'al1: Science:
`
`for 1111'). 11011011 01" 2QGE~2€"EE;
`
`11110 51111110: 01'1‘1'10 1411110110211“: 011 {31151111515 Socimy. 8051 Paper
`
`.LXV'1101'01' 1995-. 1997.. 19913. 1999300111110 2003
`
`6.
`
`1 2101 11,10 E11111'11-111-C11113E 01'" 1110 Jvmnazf {11"}711055101111! £701,105
`
`E am 21150 2111 E0111:.1 1:"11r21...-'1
`
`C15111115111. 3.110 1 am or 11211613001“:
`
`01“:
`
`111-5
`
`13.131113 11211 802110 0f2.1011171ai':01 .3000? S1101:
`
`000902
`
`
`
`000002
`
`

`

`.
`,
`1.
`Afiumsy 331255151 N1}. NEif‘N 00110211 *3 3
`85112111 No. 13118557123:
`
`{21152171211211.2135 $919991; 0.”?001’5 91’6319613258-1'. 117121251523121152115 and F1301,
`7-
`\.
`124053 851521522,
`
`[2'217‘1111'211/1.
`
`11-1111
`
`1115 ,J’flagr'naf (1f Aqua/1'1" F032;" 132125525.
`
`1173122125212 1911111512392/2 1222255
`
`.132251.22%?)gy amii
`
`(111 1115.
`
`1111111111111 .10‘"1£2::21}; 81.1.2111".
`
`211’ 111-. 1101122251! 21;
`
`.'-122.51.!1'212'121 11222: F1101? 17.112222221512112.
`
`1 was 1.115
`
`Ei1'11101'»111»(§31115f11 1113.10.21?“ «31.5.11;12117,1312% 12112111991121 200*).
`
`f»!
`
`1
`
`51m 1121'
`
`113115
`
`115511 5 11151111151
`
`1:11"
`
`1115.
`
`(01101111152; 5Y1121121.121
`
`311313 53100115.1 organizationg:
`
`111151'113111311211 301115.13; 1'011‘211111'13155111151115 212121 13112161101131 171121315. 11115. 115.1:01151 1.111101 521 E'ood
`
`81.15.1155 and I551111511 0g} 11115313111 1'11'1511 1315111115951“ 01'1 1951111211 17115211111 Precincts, Amarican
`
`(12113111211111; Society, Amerimn M13111 551.152.1235.
`
`”1.95.1.1 911111111.
`
`(311511115111 111311111113 1'1ECan211'1a.
`
`Groups 51.1311111511111 11115221111115.1151Canadian (11611132151155 AS511531111011.
`
`11131111112: of Food
`
`15511110103312. Canadian 11131111115. 51' 17111111 $151155.
`
`11112.1
`
`11:2:111'112152g32.
`
`.2‘21211121'1122221 ChemicaE
`
`Staci15.111, and 1.115. Rayad (3115111- C111 801325.12
`
`8.
`
`1111115 1.15511
`
`:1 {3155511151 1121' 25 121'1231--1-11001511'12'1 55110155/1535211'1311 5153.151211113/2135013111155 21212.1 50
`
`01521113515512“ 11115513 stud-31112.
`
`9.
`
`E
`
`113111: 135511 22
`
`1115121111.2' Of 22512113115 10051 $15111111111123 30111121112553.
`
`11151111111122 1.1511g '11 Expert
`
`131111130131 {30111111111523 11151115351 €131
`
`1115 US. 13113151550135121 {USP}. 17001.1 Ingrediéms (213-1;
`
`present); 11/1121111152. Expat Advisory P12111131. £15.3011 Canada, 81232111512511:5. of {112111521123 1005115511111
`
`(31312113101 102.1113 (1 9991301 053.1111 11151111151. 81211121111115 (323511511 0(15213111'1(2090—2010}.
`
`101 was
`
`5.
`
`1551111111.11
`
`1Xpm‘1
`
`11/11111sz
`
`111
`
`31
`
`13235111
`
`infréngcmcm 15112231111: concerning the
`
`33112111113515.11051111..1>\121:{a.11(11'11g1.1211511'111111‘C Cthy1e0'16:onng513 21.11yac111s,1111r 1213213141251
`
`and EPA {1321:1211}'11 [€151 r"1{11'21152 Marge x1551}.
`
`.1515211'2}:
`
`(T512311.
`
`1
`
`'09»CV~00304--SLR "MP’D.
`
`11.1 am an inventor 0'17 4 1.1.5.23. P3151115 (5.443.532. 5. "5.956. 5.230.915. and 4,55‘ .2341. a
`t:
`1
`2'42: 5'1
`Hair
`-1“
`.1...
`1
`.
`b 1/:
`.4
`1.).)
`)4.
`("S ‘
`”11.51.;
`.1.-
`1
`2w
`i 1..
`111 21125.11 1’31511110
`4
`8.3) 3
`12221 m 121151 p1 2111113121112 101%
`
`1
`
`12.111 Dew-3113151 01 2011
`
`was
`
`511gag51’1 by 501111351
`
`for
`
`1913131111113.
`
`"123:122111055153 and
`
`1711011332311
`
`r1353 (“1951311111571 11';
`
`1521215112 1.13. PAC 8,030,348 {“1115 53418 131.11.51'11”)
`
`91111.1
`
`3111331911315 pm 55.11:51011 21151011,»? 11:1:(:1111111'5.111.1.:5'11111-111'1 52581 E2111 '1 W11 11-5.; 1111'. 1-011551551
`
`1351111517111156121111113.1101": 111-511 by A:51 1311311151122151'“ A1151,75151521515 (1.8.8.51. 931001.114
`
`1115111231119. 1111. 35515141123'1 offM1“ Bjor=111§15 1111ng5?fijerd 212121 1115050151'3111311 of £31.:1111311353
`
`(3112111515511 and 920 ()(1/‘2‘3’14085'11121 1”); 511111 31191720111113: 521315112115, and '10 provide my
`
`000003
`
`
`
`000003
`
`

`

`Aftoamy 306E161E‘1E0. \EEPN =33341021“.. .E 316153-20E3
`
`81:11:11 N11.'E31’389.TE'14
`
`6111:1611 SCECHEEE‘EC 0111111611.
`
`E E16116 116d 110 331101 13311661 1111‘0Ev21‘116111 with 6111116 63611111116. or
`
`AME.
`
`6.011166115311661
`
`I am E36E11g
`f
`113:1126101111111, farming. 511E 6xpr6ssing Ehé E61. 3 and11E3 1116.115 1:1 17111.5. d66E21ra‘1E.1111
`
`:11 my 615110111211}; howdy 1:516.
`
`for my EEm-rz
`
`3336.131
`
`1311
`
`E
`
`E1:-11115. 110
`
`11615011211 111616.91 En EEK: uEtEmaEe 0111-:01116 of.E11: 11.653111131811611 1311313660111133 11110Evi11f-j EE16
`
`‘11-'48 11616111 or 111131 1:0111E0112‘111011 applications E'EEcd from this pate-.111.
`
`E3.
`
`EE15.1-'61‘.:51‘6E1.1E1y16:11.1EE113111€01E112111611
`
`{EOE/REE:(E 1316 1'11»: 1.1014136. my EZXEQEE'E
`
`11:1flc 0131111011.
`
`T116 ‘348 31116111 E313656565 £1116 Claims. 21 BEOEEV‘EmEE 1' Effiectiw 31111111111101 1111 EXEK‘EEC’E WEEK;11
`
`
`
`E.4
`
`E115116 1621111116 $603351” and24211111 5 05-.“116 3413‘, 1.12116.111 and. 1111061913110 them 10 E113 0.1166160 10
`
`a E3113E11gicz11§y CfffiCtEVifi 6111011111 0E3. 11:111mrz111 1:131:13.1 111 11g 21
`
`11E11.1phoEEpEd 6.1311153051111311 136511119»,
`
`10213 01' EPA and LEE-EA.
`
`’EE16‘.
`
`is. 51110111115 01n phospheiipid COFFEE'EOB'EEEOUS 60111111111011, 115/0 13‘?
`
`EPA and DEEA 1E151wo11Ed Mow 1E1656 COE‘K'EpOSEEEQEES 10. E16 5611111: ingredients. T'E161‘6f01‘6, it 15
`
`my 111166151211113E11g 1E1911~1E163.488111116111 13. 1101 0111-.‘0160 :.-:. 1161‘ 6116011.515565 2:}.- 171111111. 511111031115
`
`0E'EE11‘: phospEmEEpEd CCE‘EEpOSEEEOEE.
`
`.SpecificaEEy,
`
`1.1211111
`
`1116E11d65 the phrase ”wherein the CGH'EDOSEEEOE Ess, ‘EEEZEE’JEEZ 101 23111116111
`
`CQHSLEUEQTEQEE." This 5110111333," 51656513 thai 1136.‘EaEm 15: 6111661611 113 0 E‘loEn‘amE 3. CE'E'QECEEVC
`
`1111113111110f11‘16 60111110516 011 EVE» 11.60E11g 011‘ “348 1.1.6155:
`
`011162111011 ‘011‘1111‘1 1E1115 {30011.
`
`Under ‘“FE6Ed 0E1E16 E11v61111011.“ P61611166 SE3E€S
`
`that "EEJE’EC 1011356111 En‘i6111i011 15 CEEFBCEEEE 11.1
`
`
`11111121661 111;;E, 1361611111661. E08] 01‘ 121151116110 0011‘11305E
`
`‘348 92116111. C0E1111111
`
`111165 3:3-
`
`25. 9.1111 E vvouEd 116-1 00
`
`11111156611116.5E. phamm‘xm 11(2-811? ICC-SITESEE C 91316005100115 11 11
`
`611613111pz‘1556d
`
`11161311111111.3115
`
`6011163111111;
`
`d9.
`
`1111111111175
`
`5111161111165. 01'
`
`1E16
`
`{SCEECCE
`
`6.11111111.1511. Eon.
`
`FEFEEV’ Caiumn 4. 111165 3—5., 515125:
`
`"EE'EE‘K‘. 60111131115115.1111 .
`
`.
`
`. E15} 11561'11E E11 11113 13161261111011 0-:
`
`116011116111 01'
`
`21 variety 011115621 631111125." Again. bEGEogicaEEy ‘1"..11116 21111011116
`
`01” 1.116
`
`£‘LOETEpOSEEEOE‘. and 1101 de 11111111111.E6635, would 3:11: 11-6060 10 E13116 a 11161‘EE66E 6E'E'601 with 1E1:-
`
`4211111611 phosphoEipEasE 5.5
`
`:-.1‘ RCEE‘JE ng16d16111.
`
`F1111E16r. ExampEcis 2 and 3 5E'113w SEES meEECfiE
`
`'31
`1156.3 131'EE‘1ES 1::61111E:1E:15EEE::111. 1111d6s‘5613rir1g 1E1:- 1166d {"01 bEOEO“EC3EE}-’ EE'E'EBCEEVQ 11112111111165. This 15
`
`"1150 3136113111 CoEumn E9, 51116 63 to C0E11111112E E1111. 3E. whit.1 1566116.3. 21111131135. 611E1615, 1*211‘111115
`
`000904
`
`
`000004
`
`

`

`anomoy 35352355525 NE’LNE PM. 00‘: f02US‘ 35366 3 3 3
`Soriai No. 51;, i239. 54
`
`pharme 5:53.535 ioai and modioai usos of 5hr; composition, based on has assni'ngtion 5hai
`
`iho
`
`oomposiiion is in biologicaiiy aciivo amounts. Thor 3056, iii va ogi hi on thaz-hispaiontis
`
`diremod ioa‘nooiogioaiiy oiiootivo amoumoi‘iiiocomposition.
`
`
`
`M......W,,,,,
`
`
`Bin?mogicsiiv 53'555552.55yiauéimonni of a___?hos§5h_9§iggmo TW 0 of EPA and EEK-55°55
`
`5
`5i.
`
`.f
`have road tho Deoiaraiion 53-5 Eari5. .Wh'i5e subn'iiiitod on Ma" 35, EOE '5
`
`in 351,-
`
`535"; of the
`
`'3454 piston-5 My scioniific opinion of this decimation is aha: Dr. Win55: pionoiiy concindod
`1-
`
`i'nai Boandoin I doos note omain s hioioogicaiii"1T5:(Lii‘l'fiamount ofa phosphoiipid containing
`
`We of EPA and DHA.
`
`i7.Thius nosiding is nooessitaiod by not oniy Dr. Whiio’s siaiomonis bui aiso a i'oasonahio
`
`in5orpr’o5ation by a sciomisi in tho field.
`
`C33
`
`As to the. ianon i do 2513.5, nor wo-iid any othor sci-o mist, inioi'groi Ur. "s’v’hiio's concinsion 55).
`
`moan dist 553525: amounis of die phosphoiii'nd containing two of EPA and Di-iA an: not prosoni‘
`
`in Boandoin 53-55. As a votoran sciomist, Dr. White wouid not mako such a definitive
`
`staioznoni, nor wouid a iypioai soiontist draw such a oonoiusion. On We contrary, a soiontisi
`
`wouid iooi: 255 5555': Whizo data and understand thati'iis co:io=nsion was ii:at on the who ° and
`
`iimimd by iiio insti'umomai casoais the.t como «‘2:'5h our» oxpcr imo:55 hi 53in giooiiv odoctivo
`
`amounts ofiho composition were, no: doioo ed.
`
`39. Dr.
`
`55555555. explicitly:rates this as ho ropoifs his “opinion {hat
`
`iiio Boandoin Qii Fi'aciions
`
`soaked and 5535;5on 53y i'Dr. Whi to} do 5505 contain PLS ipi'iosphoiigins] ahio h have. attached
`
`0 thorn DNA and BET-'95, EPA and EPA. DHA and EPA :35 JEEP/‘53mil3}.'"i2\_._ a5rhouioioci'g,
`’7
`
`iiaiiis do sori=“35-55 above in gaiaOgagig{ iouiiinirig {JG/MS and his/\Ii’s 'ooimiq snoi " White
`
`Dociaraiion oi'iviay 3i 205 i, “ii i3 {emphasis added}.
`
`In) Q Therefore, .‘ioi 0555 v roasonah io zeading ofiho Eari L, Whiio Dociaration of May 3i. 12051 is
`
`than Dr. Whi 5c ono:iudod that Boaudoin5 does not Contain a hioiogioaiiy oifoctivo amount of
`
`.2 nhospholipid containing iwo of EPA and {Iii-ii",
`
`000005C.)
`
`
`000005
`
`

`

`Aimmay BCCECCE NC. NEEPM (1111/
`)3, 3E663121113
`SC?EEE1 NC. EEC-’1 89.314
`
`'21.“
`.1118 {SUCCECECCEE DCCammo“;EEa.'ECEEng EEEC CCE:CCE--11810 23E DE V»'EEEEC it)»; CSSCEEEEEg that some
`
`amCunE C EEEE. gab-ECCEECEECEE‘E CCE’EECEEEEng EVVC CE EPA and DEA is CECCCE E in EEEC 868111301?) 011.
`.1
`,11-Eis {ECC EaEaEica dCCS not q=EaEEEE15'1» EEEC 3111mm: CECECCECEE and USES a V-CE'V' SCEESEEEVC
`L‘
`ECCEEEEQLEC (E‘s-”EERE‘V mass spCcErC-EEECE r3”) ECE {EEC- (1011.”1101’1 This ECCEEEEECEEEC CECEEC nggV-CEC that a
`
`How VC-
`
`V'Cz'»! sma11 amCEEEE CE EEEC CCEEECCSEF. Eon,
`
`11’ any, ES pf‘SS'C‘E‘EE in the BCCEECECEEE V’s-11, awarding EC
`
`GUDCECE‘SCIE. HCV'CVC a; EEC 5CEEEEC-JE above {EEC lcasanab1 C Erzading of WEEEEC as E101 112.2121{EEC
`
`BCCEECECEEEE 011 1211313 an»; CV-Cn d9 112111127215, Same-Cm: CE‘El‘C CCmpCSEEECn CfEEEC ‘348 "am but
`
`that EEECrC ES CCE a C1010gica11y CffCCEEVC amouaE V111 EEEC CCmpCsEEECEE.
`
`. By wa: CE aEE-aECgVV. in E'EEC United \EaECs VV-EECEE a Vitamin Cr 111111613113 mesa-CE in a prCEEuCE a1
`
`11355 Ehan 2% CE” RCCCmECCncECd 1.3.2111»! Intake (R131). such a V'a1EEC may EEC ECCCEECEE on a 1006
`
`0.:- w:1111 an asECEE Ck that Tea-31's EC- EEEC sEaECmCCE “CCCEE‘EEEES ECss than 2‘14; CftEEC
`11-333ij as “75.1: 1‘0
`.
`.
`.
`V
`..
`.31
`.
`.
`C
`.
`13a:1»- "Jaime CE Ehas {these} EEEEEEECCE 11311111613153}.
`AESC, as a SCCCEEC anaEC-gy, Akm‘, EnC
`
`quEEC-stoz'
`
`11E USSEV. 951001.774. has rCCCiV'C“CE a (.ECEECEa1‘ V RCC
`
`‘33?)
`Jon
`
`EzV-d as SafC1C-RASE
`
`CE‘EEE‘EEECEECEE from 111C E-‘EI‘EA 1118.1 states 11 a: a maximum331 % ECSEEEEECECEEEIEEECE Es: aCCCpEaCEC
`
`EES 131111011 perCCES E‘EECE'CECE‘C, such EEC )‘P‘Efi’z’iilfiifi‘ aEEECEEEEEs are View-Cd En [EEC food industry a:
`
`mEnESCEEEC CE‘EOUgE‘; EC be1m. ECvaEEE. As iECCE-dm ECCCEES an 011 CCECCEECEEV VV‘EEEE a smaEE
`
`amCEEm CfEhC CE‘ECSCEECEEpErEmtamw EV0 01 FL"1‘ a CC} E)1--1.”\ {E E2. about 0.1 EC 1%} E: E5 my
`
`opinion LEE-:11 this is CC? C bEE’JEQEEILaEEjvf‘CECE:EEVC amount As EEECC ..,'EEEEzs
`
`’E1EC 3481Vtem aE'C
`
`E’EErCCECd
`
`to CECECgECCEEV CE‘E‘CCE'VC army-ms Cf EEEES CCE'EEE'ECSEEECEE.
`
`1115:»!
`
`are:
`
`dEsEECCE from
`
`BCCVECECEEE.
`
`.En auramary,
`
`1E Es my CpEEEECEE that
`
`A.
`1111:
`
`J
`‘348 -EaECm CECSCE-EEC3 and Cam 2: CECECgECaEEv
`
`Crreciéve amount Cf a
`
`pEECspEEEQEEC? CCEEEEVS EECE: CCCtaEEEEE'Eg EPA and/Cr DHA.
`
`This
`
`EEEECECECECEECC Es CCEESESECCE 'VV'EE‘EEstan;Eard pEaCtECCS En EEEC mod Eudus‘EE‘y,
`
`FCEEEECE,
`
`1 read 1118
`
`DCCECECEECEE 011312131 L. WEEEEC. SEEEECEEEECEE Ma» 31, 3011. EC. CC1DHCL1::1EC hat the: RCaEEdCEa 011
`
`EECCS Egg: contain a EEECECECECaEEV CEECCEEV-C amaani 01' c‘11p11115;;116011151 d CCEVECEEEEng WC! 0111 A
`
`and DHA.
`
`AESC.
`
`in my expert CCECECEE.
`
`EEEC GEEEECECECCC
`
`dCCECraEECE‘E COE‘E‘OEX')1”31€S
`
`EEEC
`
`5‘ See eg- NJEEEEECCCE Labai .nsz and 1’6111C311«an ACE (NE-31 r’\)E<,i‘QLEE1‘t‘EEE€T‘-1§ 18/94 ~ 3’95}, US Food and Drug
`
` Admin EEECEE
`EmMEa’EL’“ul-Ef
`a'
`Ems: "EEV-ww. Eda. gang/1E 1-:£1.11EEspnCIKm/M'VCCCE CM EEEdCSJEJcmE ~198111m East
`3C0.“iscci Mme:-E 4,:.
`1,1 Appendix 13‘-
`
`? Seas- AEVCE‘ ORAL? NCEECC (:1 1314/2010, TatEEC 1 9:? page -’1 015313: Appendix C.
`
`000806
`
`
`000006
`
`

`

`Aimmfiy Backei N0, NEPNMGGMIZU S
`Serial No, 13,5189 7’14
`
`_'
`
`.3
`
`A
`
`v
`
`‘-
`
`mnciufimn of Dr. White 353 it empleys a sensitive technique m wagediy etact a 51's mirzz’mig
`
`ammmt 5f the phosphoiipid swimming twa ~31" EPA and DHA A5 {ha ‘348 patent is diracied
`
`to biologicaiiy effective amounts; of this compcsition; and Beaudoin doas m3: contain these
`
`aa'nounis, my opir‘non is that Eht’: ciaims of the “348 pamm are digiinct fmm Beaudmn.
`
`[Russmincfier u: ix: page 131i isssr;'ssi§or.:3iiy blank]
`
`
`
`oooep7
`
`000007
`
`

`

`I further dcsciare that aEE smtrzmez'afs made keratin of my own mawiedge gar-3 true, and that a“
`
`statements» made an inflammation and baiief’ are beiievad m be, firm: and furihm‘, that
`,n
`—.
`
`ese
`
`staiemems uni-:m made, with the knowladga tha: wiiim: miss Stafements and the. Eikc‘: so made
`
`are puniahabirz by fine a: imprismmant or bah, undfir Section 1003 OfTiUt': 8 oft‘ne Unitesd
`
`SW53 Coda, and Elma: such miifui
`
`.“aise statements may jeoparaize ihe vaiidity a? me
`
`application 02' any patent issuing thareon.
`
`
`
`Dated: Kiwi“; 2 '3} 3
`
`
`
`
`
`000008
`
`000008
`
`