throbber
Atterney Becket N n. NEE: PN—lNB/(lfitlel 313653—20} S (ARRIVE-32174}
`
`E’A'E‘EEN'E"
`
`EN l’HE UNETEH STA'E‘ES PA'H‘EN'E" ANH TRAHEMARH {EFFICE
`
`in Re Patent ef:
`
`SAMPALIS, Fotini
`
`Confirrnatien No:
`
`l 897
`
`Control No:
`
`95.:"00lfl74
`
`Group Art Unit:
`
`3991
`
`Filed:
`
`FOR:
`
`October l9fi 20M
`
`Examiner:
`
`CAMPELL Bruee R.
`
`INTER PARTES REEXAWE 0F U.S. PATENT 8,339,348: NATURAL MARINE
`SHUHCE ¥E§0$PHOLHHHS CQMMHSENG l’C’tLYUNSATUHA’E‘EH FATTY
`
`ACIDS AND THERE APPELJECATEGNS
`
`Mail Step Heelaratien
`Cernrnissinner fer Patents
`
`PO. Box lélSG
`
`Alexandria, VA 223 l 3-i45i)
`
`DECEAHATEGN (H7 FREEZE HGHN SHAH HH FHQH. UNHEH 37 QER. ’ 1.132
`
`
`
`l, Fereideon Shanirli, declare as teliriws:
`
`l.
`
`i am a tenured University Research Prefesser at Memorial University of Newleundland in St:
`
`.lehn’s, Canada. My appointment is in the Department of Biochemistry, with a eress—
`
`appointment with the Aquaculture Program, Biology Department and Ocean Sciences Centre.
`
`l have been a professor at Memorial University sinee l987i
`
`l am also an lI-lonerary Professer
`
`at Chung Shan Medical University in Taichung, Taiwan; a Chair Professor in the Department
`
`at Feed Science at National Chung Haing University in Taichung, Taiwan; and an Adjunct
`
`Professor at Dalhousie University in Halifax,“ Nova Scotia, Canada and the Nova Scotia
`
`Agricultural College in Trure, Nova Seotia, Canada. Prier to being at lylen'inriala l was in the
`
`Department of Chemistry and the Department of Chemical Engineering at the University of
`
`Tornnte.
`
`w l earned, a PhD. in l977 in Physical Qrganie Chemistry from the Department of Chemistry at
`
`lVleGill University in Montreal, Canada. Prier to that, l earned a Bachelors el‘ Science, with
`
`000001
`
`Petition for Inter Partes Review
`Of U.S. Patent 8,278,351
`
`ENZYMOTEC - 1056
`
`Exhibit
`
`000001
`
`

`

`Reexamination U , S .S N. 95/(it) l ,7?
`Declaration of Dr. Fereidoon Shahidi
`
`Honours, from the Department of Chemistry at Shiraz (Fahlavi) University in Shiraz, lran.
`
`Alter my doctoral work,
`
`l was a Postdoctoral Fellow in the Department of Chemistry at
`
`McGill University.
`
`[M
`
`9
`4
`.
`l have been a scientist for almost 40 fears as outlined in niv Curriculum Vitae (A endix
`
`A),
`
`l have been recognized with a variety of awards, including, for example: European Lipid
`
`Technology Award, Eurofed Lipid (2010); Fellow, American Chemical Society (20%);
`
`Distinguished Service Award, Agricultural and Food Chemistry Division, American
`
`Chemical Society {2308};
`
`l?’ellow, American Oil Chemists” Society (2088); Outstanding
`
`Division Member, Nutraceutical and Functional Food Division,
`
`lnstitute of Food
`
`Technologists (2008); Advancement of Application of Agricultural and Food Chemistry,
`
`American Chemical Society (EQW), Fellow, lnternational Academy of Food Science and
`
`Technology (2006); Stephen 8, Chang Award,
`
`lnstitute of Food Technologists (2095);
`
`Fellow, institute of Food "Technologists (2005); Fellow, Royal Society of Chemistry (UK)
`
`0998);, Farl F. McFee Award, Atlantic Fisheries Technological Society 0998);, Fellow,
`
`Chemical institute of Canada (i995); William J. Eva Award, Canadian institute of Food
`
`Science and Technology 0996); Fellow, Agricultural and Food Chemistry Division,
`
`American Chemical Society 0994); Platinum Award, American Chemical Society 0994);
`
`Fellow, Canadian institute of Food Science and, Technology (l993).
`
`(Jr
`
`l have published about 450 peer reviewed articles, about 2169 book chapters and conference
`
`proceedings, and about 60 books.
`
`l have been recognized as the till inost published author
`
`(lg) in the area of Food, Nutrition and Agricultural Science for the period of l99ti—2ll06; the
`
`lSl most cited (4th) author in Food, Nutrition and Agricultural Science for the period, of l997~
`
`2037'; the TST most cited (7th) author in the area of Food, Nutrition and Agricultural Science
`
`for the period of l 99692096; the lSl most cited {3”} author in the area of Agricultural Science
`
`for the period of ZillllQOl l; and, author of the American Oil Chemists Society, Best Paper
`
`Award for l995, l997, l998, l999, 2002, and 2003.
`
`l am the FditorwinmChiet‘ of the Journal (if-Fans {Tonal Foods.
`
`i am also an Editor of Food
`
`)a
`Chemise“! and,
`
`,,
`i am or have been on the Editorial Board of: Journal of Food Science,
`
`000002
`
`000002
`
`

`

`Reexamination U , S .S N. 95/00 l ,774
`Declaration of Dr. Fereidoon Shahidi
`
`International Journal of Food Properties, Pv’tttraceuticals and Food, Current 1 I’zttritz‘on and
`
`Food Science, Defiant, and the Janina! of Aquatic Food Product Technology, and on the
`
`Editorial Advisory Board of the Joamai of‘x’lgrz‘cultztrai and Food Chemistry.
`
`I was the
`
`Iiditor-in-Chief of the Journal ofFood Lama’s Irorn l993 to 2009.
`
`I am or have been a member of the tollowing exemplary professional organizations:
`
`International Society for Nntraceutieals and Functional Foods, International Ilnion of Food
`
`Science and Technology, International Commission on, Natural Health Products, An'ierican
`
`Oil Cheniists’ Society, American Meat Science Association, Chemical Institute of Canada,
`
`Groupe Polyphenol International, Canadian Meat Science Association, Institute of Food
`
`Technologists, Canadian Institute of Food Science and Technology, American Chemical
`
`Society, and the Royal Chemical Society.
`
`I have been a preceptor for 25 post—doctoral fellows/research assistants/associates and 50
`
`graduatedevel thesis students.
`
`I have been a rnen'iber of various food standards committees, including being an Expert.
`
`Advisory Committee member for the IIS. Pharmacopeia (U813), Food Ingredients (20H)—
`
`present); Member, Expert Advisory Panel, Health Canada, Standards ofIEVidence for Health
`
`Claims for Foods (1999-30l0}; and Member, Standards Council of Canada (2000—2010).
`
`I was
`
`a technical expert witness
`
`in a patent
`
`intringenient
`
`lawsuit concerning the
`
`pharmaceutical Loyaza, a drug that contains ethyl esters ot‘oniega 3 fatty acids, namely DIIA
`
`and EPA (Putnam Bioi’harma Norge AS v. Apotex Corp, l:ll9cv4)0304—SLR WIPE").
`
`9.
`
`ll}.
`
`LI arn an inventor of 4 US. Patents (5,443,852, 5,'25,95ti, 5,230,9l5, and 4,559,234), a
`
`European Patent (0,554,283), as well as other patent applications.
`
`l2.
`
`In IZIeceniher of 20H,
`
`I was engaged by counsel
`
`tor Neptune Technologies and
`
`Bioressonrces (“Neptune”) to review US. Patent 8,030,348 (“the ‘348 patent”) and its
`
`substantive prosecution history, including the De “laration ot‘Dr. Earl I.“ White; the Corrected
`
`Request for Reexamination filed by Alger Bioniarine {“Aker”), listed, as IJSSN 95/00l ,7l4,
`
`including the
`
`eclaration of Mr. Bjorn Ole Hangsgierd and the Declaration of Dr. Thomas
`
`Gnndersen and WO (IO/23546 {“Beandoin I”); and supporting, materials, and to provide my
`
`000003
`
`000003
`
`

`

`Reexamination U , S .S N. 95/00 l ,774
`Declaration of Dr. f‘ereidoon Shahidi
`
`expert scientific opinion.
`
`1 have had no prior direct involvement with either Neptune or
`
`Alter.
`
`i am being compensated at my customary hourly rate for my time spent on
`
`developing, forming, and expressing the facts and opinions in this declaration.
`
`l have no
`
`personal interest in the ultimate outcome of the reexamination proceedings involving the
`
`‘348 patent.
`
`l3.
`
`l have carefully read the information provided. Below l provide my expert scientific opinion.
`
`
`'l‘he ‘348 Patent Biscloses and Claims a Blolocicallv Effective Amount of an Extract With a
`
`Phosphollpid Containing Two of ERA and Elli/ti.
`
`14. l have read the disclosure and claims of the ‘348 patent and understand them to he directed to
`
`a biologically effective amount of an extract containing a phospholipid composition hearing
`
`two of EPA and DltlA, That is, amounts of phospholipid compositions containing two of
`
`EPA and DE-lA that would allow these compositions to he active ingredients. ”therefore, it is
`
`my understanding that the ‘348 patent is not directed to nor encompasses do minimis amounts
`
`of the phospholipid composition,
`
`l5.
`
`Specifically, claim l
`
`includes the phrase “wherein the composition is suitable tor human
`
`consumption.” This strongly suggests that the claim is directed to a biologically effective
`
`amount of the composition. My reading of the ‘348 patents specification supports this point.
`
`Under “Field of the invention,” l’atentee states that “ltlhe present invention is directed to
`
`nutraceutical, pharmaceutical or cosmetic compositions.” ‘348 Patent, Column l, lines 22~
`
`25. Claim i would not cover “nutraceutical, pharmaceutical or cosmetic compositions” if it
`
`encompassed preparations containing dc minimis amounts of the recited composition.
`
`Further, Column 4, lines 345, states: “[tlhe composition .
`”)5
`
`.
`
`. [is] useful in the prevention or
`
`treatment of a variety of disease states.
`
`Again, biologically effective amounts of the
`
`composition, and not are mfm‘mz's levels, would he needed to have a medical effect with the
`
`claimed phospholipids as the active ingredient. Further, Examples 2 and 3 show the medical
`
`uses of this composition, underscoring the need for biologically effective quantities, This is
`
`also seen in Column l9, line 63 to Column 2i , line 3l, which recites, among others, various
`
`000004
`
`000004
`
`

`

`Reexamination U , S .S N. 95/00 l ,7?
`Declaration of Dr. Fereidoon Shahidi
`
`pharmaceutical and, medical uses of the composition, based on the assumption that the
`
`composition is in biologically active arnounts, Therefore, it is my opinion that this patent is
`
`directed to a biologically effective arnount of the composition.
`
`
`
`Biolo “icall " Effective Amount of 3. Fires holi
`
`
`
`id Containin Two ot‘EPA and DHA.
`
`
`
`
`lo.
`
`l7.
`
`l8
`
`l have read the Declaration of Earl la. White submitted on May 3],, Zhll in support of the
`
`‘348 patent. My scientific opinion of this declaration is that Dr. White properly concluded
`
`that Beaudoin 1 does not contain a biologically effective amount of a phospholipid containing
`
`two of EPA and Dill/fit
`
`This reading is necessitated by not only Dr. White’s statements but also a reasonable
`
`interpretation by a scientist in the field.
`
`As to the latter, l do not, nor would any other scientist, interpret Dr. 'Wliitels conclusion to
`
`mean that trace amounts of the ohospholipi d containing two ofEPA and Dl’lA are not present
`
`in Beaudoin oil. As a veteran scientist, Dr. White would not make such a definitive
`
`statement, nor would a typical scientist draw such a conclusion. On the contrary, a scientist
`
`would lool: at the White data and understand that his conclusion was that, on the whole, and
`
`limited by the instrumental caveats that come with every experiment, biologically effective
`
`amounts of the composition were not detected.
`
`19.
`
`Dr: White explicitly states this as he reports his “opinion that the Beaudoin {til Fractions
`
`received and tested by [Dr White] do not contain PLs [phospholipidsl which have attached
`
`to them DHA and DNA, EPA, and EPA, DltlA and EPA, or EPA and DHA, attire detection
`
`
`
`
`
`lirnits descri ted above in "rare ‘ra h 7 {outlining LC/lVlS and MS/MS techniquesj.” White
`
`Beclaration ofMay 31, 201 l, ‘5' l3 (emphasis added),
`
`. Therefore, the only reasonable reading of the Earl l ‘White Declaration of May 31, Mill is
`
`that Dr, White concluded that Beaudoin l does not contain a biologically effective amount of
`
`a phospholipid containing two of EPA and DHA.
`
`000005
`
`000005
`
`

`

`Reexamination U . S .S N. 95/00 l ,774
`Declaration of Dr. Fereidoon Shahidi
`
`El. The Gundersen Declaration challenges the conclusions of Dr. White by asserting that some
`
`amount of the phospholipid containing two of EPA and Di—lA is present in the Beaudoin oil.
`
`However. this declaration does not quantify the amount de ected and uses a very sensitive
`
`technique (MRM mass spectrometry) for the detection This technique alone suggests that a
`
`very small amount of the composition, if any, is present in the Beaudoin oil, according to
`
`Gundersen. However; as described above, the reasonable reading of White is not that the
`
`Beaudoin oil lacks any, even de minimis, amount of the composition of the “348 Patent, but
`
`that there is not a biologically effective amount of the composition.
`
`22. By way of analogy. in the United States. when a vitamin or mineral is present in a product at
`
`less than 2% of Recommended Daily lntalre (RIM), such a value may he reported on a food
`
`label as “zero” or with “an asterisk that refers to the statement “Contains less than 2% of the
`
`Daily Value of this (these) nutrient (nutrients)?! Also, as a second analogy, Alter, the
`
`requestor in USSN. 95/00l,774l, has received a Generally Recognized as Safe (GRAB)
`
`aftirn'iation from the FDA that states that a maximum of 3% residual ethanol is acceptable in
`
`its krill oil products.2 Therefore, such de minimis amounts are viewed in the food industry as
`
`miniscule enough to be irrelevant: As Beaudoin reports an oil potentially with a small
`
`amount of the phospholipid containing two of EPA and DHA (Le. about (til to l%}, it is my
`
`opinion that this is not a biologically effective amount. As the claims of the ‘348 patent are
`
`directed to biologically effective amounts of this composition,
`
`they are distinct from
`
`Beaudoin.
`
`23. ln summary,
`
`it is my opinion that the ‘348 patent describes and claims a biologically
`
`effective amount of a phospholipid composition containing EPA and/or Dl’lA.
`
`This
`
`interpretation is consistent with standard practices in the food industry. Further. l read the
`
`Declaration of Earl L. White, submitted May 3i, 3(3ll, to conclude that the Beaudoin oil
`
`does not contain a biologically effective amount of a phospholipid containing two of EPA
`
`and DHA. Also,
`
`in my expert opinion,
`
`the Gundersen declaration corroborates the
`
`1 See, 6g, Nutritional Labeling and Education Act (NLEA) Requirements (8/94 ~ 2/95), US. Food and Drug
`Administration
`(iatraz‘iable
`at
`http://www.fda.gov/lCECl/lnspections/lnspectionGuides/ucmll409hhtni,
`last
`accessed March 4, 201 l, Appendix B).
`
`2 See Alier (ERAS Notice of l2/l4/2010, Table l at page 4 of 38, Appendix C.
`
`000906
`
`000006
`
`

`

`Reexamination U a S .S N. 95/00} ,774
`Declaration Of Dr. Feteideen Shahidi
`
`CGflCiuSiOn ef Dr. White as it employs a sensitive technique to allegedly detect a de minimis
`
`ameunt 0f the phespheiipid centaining twe et‘ZEEPA and DE-EAH As the “348 patent is directed
`
`t0 bioiegiealiy effective ameunts ef this eompositien, and Beaudein (tees not centain these
`
`amounts, my epinion is that the cieirns 0f the $348 patent are distinct fmm Beendein.
`
`{Remainder of the page left intentimtafly biankj
`
`000007
`
`000007
`
`

`

`Rwammamm JJC(J 8N9"3:UJJ 3’74
`JZJecJaJaILJm OJ UL?<3::0:((3J: nShathz
`
`'24.
`
`J further (JecJare that aJJ gtaternaz'xts made. herein of my own Jirmeedge aria mm, and that (3J1
`
`gtabzments mafia on information and J36,Jief arc:
`
`J'}:JJEVE:(J 30 be flue and further {bat
`
`these
`
`statemsmf': v(if: mada w:Jib tbs Fra-qurzdge-JJbai W1JJJuJ fa Jse 3-"(item ems and tbs“; JJkL 50 made
`
`are. punishabie by fine :32" imprisommm. 0r bath, under Section JDGJ (VJ
`
`iJi‘: J8 (JJb sink imd
`
`SJEJGS {IQ-:18, and (hat such wiJJfiJJ faJs(‘1
`
`Jaiemaémg mavjeoparid3353 {Jis WJJ J:.JJJ.3) DJ J;a. Patent
`
`3036.:48;
`
`
`
`
`
`000908
`
`000008
`
`

`

`USSN, 95/003 ,774
`Declaration Of Dr. P'ereidfion Shahidi
`
`Ammmdix A
`
`Cumming} Vims 9f Di”: Femidwm Shahidi
`
`000009
`
`000009
`
`

`

`ElSfiahhfi
`
`Engelifl'lfifi
`
`CURRICULUM V1 ME UP”
`
`Fernitinnn Shahitti
`
`E’OSE'I'ION:
`
`ADDRESS:
`
`University Research Professor; Department ot‘Bioehernistw
`(Crosswappointed with Aqnaeuitnre Program, Bioiogy Department and
`Ocean Sciences Centre)
`
`Department of Bioehemistw
`Mernotiai University of Newfoundland
`St John's, NE.” Canada
`A18 3X9
`
`'E‘ELE?H(}NE:
`
`{709) 864—8552
`
`FAX:
`
`(709) 8644000
`
`E~MA£L2
`
`f5hahidi@rnun.ea
`
`:
`
`Chemistry“ biochemistry and nutrition of food components; Natural antioxidants; Phytoeheinieais
`and phytophan'naceutieais; Nutraeeutieais and fonetionai
`foods; Mechanisms of action of
`antioxidants at eeiiniar and subceiinlar ieveis; Antinnti‘itionai factors in plant foods; Food and
`flavour chemistry; Functional prnperties nfprotein preparatinns; Seafood processing and utilization
`0f processing ‘byqn‘oduets; Nutraceutieai and Feed Eipids; Lipid biotechnology; Sea? research;
`Oniegam3 fatty acids and seafoods; Lipid oxidation and, its prevention; Process—induced chemical and
`biochemical changes in foods; Aquaeuitnre.
`
`Edaeat‘ina:
`
`1977
`
`1973
`
`A wards:
`
`Phi). (Physical Organic Chemistry), Department of (:Tireinistry, Met’iiii
`University, Montreal, Canada.
`Thesis Titie: Soivem and Cent’nrmanonal Ffiéci‘s on Malecular Vaitmzes.
`
`338e, (Honours) Department of Chemistry, Shiraz {Pahiavi} University
`Shiraz, Eran.
`
`i’rojeet 'E‘itie: Synthesis of Tetracycline Analogs
`
`0000010
`
`0000010
`
`

`

`F. Shahidi
`
`Pa £20105}
`
`20l0
`
`20l0
`
`2008
`
`2008
`
`2008
`
`2007
`
`2007
`
`2007
`
`2006
`
`2006
`
`2006
`
`2006
`
`2005
`
`2003
`
`2002
`
`2002
`
`European Lipid Technology Award, Eurofed Lipid
`
`Fellow, Arnerican Chemical Society
`
`Distinguished Service Award, Agricultural and Food Chemistw Division,
`An'ieri can Chemical Society
`
`Fellow, An'ierican Oil Chentists’ Society
`
`Outstanding Division Member, Nutraceutical and Functional Food,
`Division, institute of Food Technologists
`
`Advancement of Application of Agricultural and Food Chernistw,
`American Chemical Society
`
`Outstanding Division Member Awards, Nutraceutical and Functional Food
`Division, lnstitute of Food Technologists
`
`lSl Most cited (4th) author in Food, Nutrition and Agricultural Science for
`the period ot‘199'fl2007
`
`TS}, Most cited (7111) author in the area of Food, Nutrition and Agricultural
`Science for the period of l996—2006
`
`in the area of Food, Nutrition and
`181 Most published author (is?)
`Agricultural Science for the period, of 1996~2006
`
`Fellow, lnteinational Acaderny ofFood Science and Technology
`
`Outstanding Division Meniher Award, Nutraceutical and Functional Food
`Division, lnstitute of Food Technologists
`
`Stephen S. Chang Award, Tnstitute of Food Technologists
`
`Fellow, institute ofFood Technologists
`
`AQCS, hest paper award, Kansas City, MO
`
`lSl Most highly cited Recognition Award (top l5) in the discipline of
`Agriculture, Plant and Animal Sciences for l99l,~200l decade
`
`ADM Award. Protein and Co—product Division ofAmerican Oil Chemists’
`Society.
`
`0000011
`
`0000011
`
`

`

`ElSfiahhfi
`
`Engefitfl'ldfi
`
`1998-
`
`1998
`
`1998
`
`1996
`
`1996
`
`University Research Prefewor, Meinoriai University of Newtbnndiand,
`St. John’s, NL
`
`Feiiow, Royal Society of Chemistry {UK}
`
`Earl 1’. McFee Award, Atiantic Fisheries Technological Society
`
`i?’eiiow, Chemical institute 0f Canada
`
`Wi iiiani 1. Eva Award, Canadian 1 nsti tate of}?end Science and, Technolegy
`
`1995—2002
`
`Best Paper Award, AOCS for 1995, 1997, 1998, 1999 and 20023
`
`1994
`
`1994
`
`1993
`
`Fedow, Agri cu1tura1 and Food, Chemistry Division, Atnericai'i Chernicai
`Society
`
`Piatinnin Award, American Chernica} Society
`
`19‘eliow, Canadian 1nstitute of 17nod Science and Technology
`
`19754976
`
`T. Sterry Hunt Prize.
`Montreal, Canada
`
`for Teaching Exceitence, McGiit University,
`
`19734 976
`
`Max Binz Schoiarship, McGiii University, Montreai, Canada
`
`1973-1978
`
`Schoiarsiiip, Ministry of Science and, higher Education 0f Eran
`
`1973
`
`Gold Medah Shiraz (Paiiiavi) Ui'iiyersity, Shiraz, Tran
`
`1970—1973
`
`Schoiarship, Shiraz (Paiiiavi) Ui'iiyersity, Shiraz, Tran
`
`Exgerience:
`
`Jan. 2011—
`
`Honorary Professor, Chung Shari Medicai University, Taichung, Taiwan
`
`3111. 2010—
`
`Visiting Professor, King Sand Ti’niyersity, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia
`
`Aug. 2009—
`
`Chair Professor, Department of Food Science, Nationai Chung Hsing
`University, Taichung, Taiwan
`
`0000012
`
`0000012
`
`

`

`F. Simhidi
`
`Pa £40105}
`
`Aug 2999-
`
`Adjunct Professor, Graduate Studies, Dainonsie University, Halifax, NS,
`Canada
`
`Aug. 2009—
`
`Adjunct Professor, Nova Seotia A grienitnrai College, THEN), N 8, Canada
`
`3ni.~i\"ov. 2000
`
`Visiting Professor, Uepartnrent of Chemistry, National University of
`Singapore, Singapore
`
`May 1998-
`
`Sep. 1992—
`
`University Research Professor, Department of Biochemistry, Memoriai
`University of Newioundiand, St. John’s, Newfoundland, Canada.
`
`Professor, Department of Biochemistry, Mernoriai University of
`Newfoundland, St, John's, Newfoundland, Canada.
`
`i‘via,r.—Ang.
`
`i 996
`
`Visiting Professor, Department ot‘Systemic Botany, Aarhns University and
`international Food Science Centre, Aarhns, Denmark.
`
`.Eaaneb. 1996
`
`Sep. 1994—
`
`May 1994—
`
`Jan. 19934 996
`
`Jan. 1991—
`
`Visiting Professor, Department ofFood Science, ()ehanon’rizn University
`by invitation of Japan Society for Promotion of Science, Tokyo, Japan.
`
`Cross—Appointment, Department of Biology, Mentoriai University of
`Nevvfonndiarni, St. John’s, Nevvfonndiarni, Canada.
`
`Aquacnitnre Committee, M ernoriai University ot‘Ney‘t/foundiand, St, John’s,
`Newfoundiand, Canada,
`
`Crossfippointnient, Department of (ifhernistry, Mernoriai University of
`Newfoundland, St. John's, Newfoundland, Canada.
`
`i‘yienioriai University of
`CrossmAppointnient, Ocean Sciences Centre,
`Newfoundland, St, John's, Newfoundland, Canada.
`
`Sept. 19884997
`
`CrossmAppointinent, Sehooi of Pharniaey, Memorial University of
`Newfoitndiand, St. John's, Newfoundland, Canada.
`
`Jan. 1987-Ang. 1992
`
`Associate Professor, Department of Biochemistry, i‘vternoriai University of
`Newfoundland, St. John’s, Newfoundland, Canada.
`
`Jul. i984—Dee. i986
`
`Adjunct Professor of Food Engineering, Department of Citernieai
`Engineering and Applied Chemistry, University of Toronto, Toronto,
`Canada.
`
`0000013
`
`0000013
`
`

`

`F. Sitahidi
`
`Page 5 (if 109'}
`
`Sep. 1978—,lnn. 1984
`
`Research Assnciate/Lecturer of Chemistry and Food Engineering,
`Departments of Chemistry as well as Chemical Engineering antl Applied
`Chemistry, University of Teronto, Toronto, Canada.
`
`NoV i976~Ang 1978
`
`Postdnctor‘al Fellow, Department of Chemistry, McGill University, Mon—
`treal, Canada.
`
`
`
`
`
`2008-
`
`l9???“
`
`Lecturer, Bieenergetics, EC 4200.
`
`Lecturer, Food Chemistry, BC 3402; Feed, Biochemistry, BC 6530;1nstru—
`mental Metheds of Feed Analysis, EC4400 (ended 1996}; Food Science
`Topics, BC 4501 (ended, 1996), Science and Technology of Marine Feeds,
`BC 4650/6650 (BC4650 ended 1996). Marine Biochemistry, BC 6630.
`Binchemical Techniques, BC 42l l.
`
`198-44986
`
`Lecturer, industrial Bielegical Processes CHE 448E anti CHE 1132H;
`Fundamentals of Bietechnoiogy CHE 335$;
`li‘nndamentals of Feed
`Engineering CHE 4625 and CHE ilSSH; Organic Chemistry CHE 203?.
`
`1978—1983
`
`Lecturer/"later, General Chemistry CHM l 35; Organic Chemistry CHM
`240.
`
`1976— l 978
`
`Lecturer/Tutor, Organic Chemistry CHEM 212 and, 222.
`
`l975—Dec. 1976
`
`instructer/Tntor, Advanced Organic Chemistry CHEM 362 antl 392.
`
`1974—1975
`
`leaching Assistant/’l‘ntor, Analytical Chemistry CHEM 257
`
`1972-1975
`
`Teaching Assistant, Organic Chemistry CHEM 212 and 222.
`
`Pm essinnai ertniearimts r’txfemhersizir
`
`2008',—
`1995—
`1995-
`
`1992-
`1989—
`
`1988*
`
`l988—
`
`lnternational Seciety for Nutracenticals and Functional Feeds
`Assnciate Member, international Union ef Food Science and 'l'echneingy
`Associate Member, international Con'rmissicn on Natural ltiealtlr Products
`
`American Oil Chemists’ Seciety
`Arnerican Meat Science Association
`
`Chemical lnstitnte ef Canada
`
`Group Pelyphennl international
`
`0000014
`
`0000014
`
`

`

`ElSfiahhfi
`
`1985—
`
`198:3—
`1981—
`1976—
`1974—
`
`Canadian Meat Science Associatien
`
`i’nstitnte of Food, 'i'eciinniogists
`Canadian institute of Food Science and Technology
`American Cheniieai Society
`Royal Chemical Society
`
`Engeéifl'lfifi
`
`
`mi {70mm '
`‘
`‘
`
`Extensive administrative experience as executive/chair/CEQ in severai scientific organizations and
`major national and internationai committees/events or large companies.
`
`2008—
`
`2008—
`
`2005—
`
`2005—
`
`2004—
`
`2004-
`
`2004—
`
`2003
`
`2003—
`
`2003—
`
`2003—
`
`Appointed Editcr—in—Chief of the Jean; at ot‘Funetionai Foods
`
`Asscciate Editor, journal of Food Science
`
`Editoriai Beard Member, inform
`
`Past Chair and Newsletter Editor, Lipid, Oxidation and Quality Division of
`the American ()ii Cheniists’ Society
`
`Past Chair, Agricidtarai and, Food Chemistry Division of the Aniefican
`Chemical Society
`
`North American Editer of Food Chemistry journai
`
`Eiiditoriai Board Member of Current Nutritien (Si; Food Science journal
`
`Chair, USDA—ARS review panei on Functional Foods and, Phytocheniicais
`
`Advisory Board Member, Journal ot‘Agricidtarai Feed Ci’iernistry
`
`Editorial Board Member, Journal of Feed Science
`
`Editorial Beard Member, international Jetirnai of Fond Properties
`
`2003—2007
`
`Counciiior (Alternate), Functional Food and Nnti‘aceuticai Division of
`institute ochod Technologists (EFT)
`
`2003—2003
`
`Chair, Functinnai Food, and Nutraeeutiea} Division of institute of Food,
`
`'fi‘echnoiogists.
`
`2001-2003
`
`Chair, Lipid, ()xidatinn and Quality Division oftne American ()ii (:iiiei‘fliSES’
`Society.
`
`0000015
`
`0000015
`
`

`

`F. Simhidi
`
`2001-2002
`
`2000—
`
`2000—
`
`2000-
`
`1999—
`
`2392-
`
`2000—2001
`
`1999—2001
`
`1999—2000
`
`1999-2000
`
`1999—2000
`
`1997—2000
`
`1997-1998
`
`1997—2000
`
`1996298
`
`Pa £70109?
`
`Chair, Agriculturai and Food Chemistry Division ofthe American Chemica}
`Society
`
`Member, Canadian Functional Foods Network
`
`Member, Standards Council of Canada
`
`Member, Expert Committee on Piant Products, Agricuitnre and Agri—Ei‘ood
`Canada
`
`Member, Expert Advisory Panei, Health Canada, Standards of Evidence for
`Health, Claims for Foods
`
`Editoriai Board Member oi“ the journai ofNatracenticais and Food
`
`and,
`Institute of Food Technoiogists, Functional Foods
`Vice Chair,
`Nutraceuticais Division ~ The Division was co—founded by 1“. Shahidi and
`colleagues.
`
`Vice Chair, American Oii Chemists‘ Society, Lipid Oxidation and Qnaiity
`Divi sion
`
`Vice Chair, American Chemical Society, Food and Agricnitnrai Chemistry
`Division
`
`Chair, American Chemical Society, Flavor Subdivision ongricniturai and
`Food Chemistry
`
`Chair, American Oi1 Ciiemists’ Society, Young Scientist Award Committee
`
`Member, NSERC Strategic Committee on Biotechnoiogy
`
`Vice Chair, American Chemieai Society, F iavor Subdivision ofA gricuitnrai
`and Food, Chemistry
`
`Executive Committee Member, American Oi1 Chemists Society, Lipid
`Oxidation and, Quality Division as well as Protein and Co—Product Division
`
`President, Canadian
`Newfoundland Section
`
`institute of Food Science
`
`and Technology,
`
`0000016
`
`0000016
`
`

`

`FlSfiahhfi
`
`Ew§e8ifl'lfifi
`
`1994—
`
`President and/or Executive. Committee Member, At1antic Fisheries
`
`'i'ecnnoiogy Society
`
`1993—2009
`
`EESditor-in-Cnief, Journal of Food Lipids
`
`1994—2004
`
`Fditoriai Board ot‘Food Chemistry
`
`1998—
`
`Editoi‘iai Board of international jouma} ofFood Properties
`
`1992—2006
`
`Network Member, Meat Focus international
`
`1995—2001
`
`Past—President and Board Member—at—Large, Protein and Co—Prodnct
`Division, American Oii Chemists’ Society
`
`1995—1996
`
`Secretary, Fiavor Chemistry Subdivision, American Oii Chernists’ Society
`
`1995—1996
`
`President—Pied, Newfoundland and Labrador, Canadian institute of Food,
`
`Science and 'i'echnoiogy
`
`1994-1995
`
`President, Protein and (Io—product Division, American Di} Chemists Society
`
`1993—1994
`
`Vice—President and President—fleet, Protein and (So—Product Division,
`
`American Oi1 Chemists’ Society
`
`inn. 1992—1995
`
`National Secretary, Canadian institute of Food Science and 'fi‘ecimoiogy
`
`Jan. 1990—Dec. 1992 Editoriai Board of .Eonrnai of Mascie Foods, .ianoary i990—Decemher 1992
`
`1989—1993
`
`Membership Chairman and Past President, Newtonnd1and and Labrador,
`Canadian 1nstitote of Food Science and Technology
`
`May1989—1992
`
`National Education Committee Chairman, Canadian 1nstitnte of Food
`Science and, Technology
`
`1989—1992
`
`National Sea1in I Adviser ' Committee of the Deiartrnent of Fisheries and,
`iv
`'3
`1
`
`()ceans
`
`1988—89
`
`President, Newfound1and and Labrador, Canadian institute of Food Science
`
`and Technology
`
`1988
`
`Chair, Conference in Newfoundiand, Atiantic Fisheries ’i‘echnoiogy Society
`
`0000017
`
`0000017
`
`

`

`F. Shahidi
`
`Page 9 of 109'}
`
`1987— l 988
`
`Director, Newfoundland and Labrador, Canadian institute of Food Science
`
`and "l‘echnology
`
`(Mast regent)
`
`20“
`
`Expert adviser, Cliile F unctional Food evaluation for CRQEEAS (Creation and
`Continuity Projects), Santiego, Chile
`
`20l 0
`
`Expert Advisory Committee member, US Rliamiacopea, Food ingredients
`
`2009, 201 l
`
`Review Fanel for EC grant applications
`
`2008
`
`Executive Committee Member and Founder of international Society for
`Nutraceuticals and Functional Foods
`
`2006 and 2008
`
`Chair, CFl Review Panel for Nutrition as well as infrastructure funds
`
`2008
`
`2008—
`
`2008
`
`2007
`
`Reviewer, Life Sciences, Scientific Foundation of lreiand
`
`Reviewer, Danish Agency for Science
`
`Program Review, NCE, lE-Eo irai do University, Japan
`
`Reviewer, FAD
`
`Con area cc: Qrgan izetions:
`
`
`
`20l l
`
`20l0
`
`20l0
`
`20l 0
`
`2009
`
`2009
`
`(So—organizer of20ll ESNFF Sapporo conference
`
`Co~organizer of 20l0 lSNFF Bali Conference
`
`Conorganizer oftwo symposia in Paciticliern Conference in Honolulu
`
`Organizer of several symposia in American Chemical Society, institute of Food
`Technologists and American Gil Chemists’ Society
`
`Qrganizer oi‘several symposia for American Chemical Society, institute ofFood
`"E‘echnologists and, American ()il Chemist” Society
`
`Co—organizer of the 12Eh international Flavor Conference, Siriathos, Greece
`
`0000018
`
`0000018
`
`

`

`F. Siiahidi
`
`Pa Fe 100 '105}
`
`2009
`
`2008*
`
`2008—
`
`2008-
`
`2007
`
`2007
`
`2007—
`
`2006
`
`200:3
`
`2005
`
`2004
`
`20021
`
`2001
`
`2000
`
`Qrganizer of an international Forum on Nutraeeutieals and Functional Foods in
`Skiathos, Greece
`
`{To—organizer ofthe Meeting ot‘the lnternational Society for Nutraeeutieals and
`Functional Foods.
`
`Organizer of a symposium at the American Oil Clieinists’ Society.
`
`{)rganizer of a symposium at the institute of Food 'l‘eennologists.
`
`()rganizer of 5 syrnposia at institute of Food Technologist
`
`Organizer of one symposium at the American Oi l Chernists Society
`
`Qrganizer of one syrnposiuin at the American Chernieal Society,
`
`1
`.
`,
`.
`.
`.
`international Conference and,
`Organizer of 6 syrnposia and coworganizer, 7
`Exhibition for Nutraeeutieais anti Functional Foods, Reno, NV
`
`[h
`
`a
`.‘
`.
`.1}
`.
`,
`,
`,
`{)rganizer ol‘" 5 syrnposta and eel—organizer, s ‘ international Lonterenee and
`Exhibition for Nutraeeutioals and Functional Foods, Anaheim, CA
`
`Organizer of a symposium at Faeifiehem Conference in Honolulu
`
`()rganizer of 6 syniposia anti/or conferences in the ACS, AGES and lFl‘, and co
`organizer, 51h lnternational Conference and Exhibition on Nutraeeutieals and
`Functional Foods 18 syinposia,
`
`Qrganizer of? syrn posia and/or conferences in the ACS, AOCS and lFT, and co—
`organizer of the 43‘ international Conference ancl Exhibition on Nutraeeutieals
`and Function al Foods.
`
`Qrganizer ofo symposia in the ACS. AOCS, lFT, and ACCS international. Also
`organizer oftlie Third international Conference and Exhibition on Nutraceutieals
`and Functional Foods.
`
`Organizer of 7 symposia in the ACS, EFT, AQCS, and lUFoS’l", among others.
`Also eo~organizer of the Second lntemational Conference and Exhibition on
`Nutraoeutieal and Functional Food.
`
`Co~organizer of 2 syniposia on “Funetional Foods: lngredients and Fi‘ospeets”
`and “Quality of Fresh and Processed Foods”, Faeiliehern 2000, Honolulu,
`
`0000019
`
`0000019
`
`

`

`F. Siiahidi
`
`Pa is H a '100
`
`eeeinher 141—19. A1so coworganizer of the First 1nternationa1 Conference and
`Exhibition on Nutraeentieai and Functional Foods.
`
`2000/2001 /’2002
`
`()rganizer, 1nternationa1 Conference and Exhibition on 1?’nnetiona1 Foods and
`2003 Nutraeeutieais, Houston, 1X, September 13—17, 2000; November 2001
`Portland, 0R, November 2002, San Diego, CA, and, Septenrher/Uetoher 2003,
`Las Vegas, NV .
`
`2000
`
`2000
`
`2000
`
`1999
`
`1999
`
`1999
`
`1999
`
`1999
`
`1998
`
`1998
`
`{,osorgamzer, 10 ’ 1nternatrona1iiiavortonterenee, Paros, tx'reeee, .1u1y 4-7.
`
`{To—organizer, Symposia on “Phytosterois: Chemistry, Sources and
`Nutraceuticai Applications”, American Oi1 Chemists? Society, April 2529,
`2000, San Diego, CA
`
`Co~organizer, Symposium on “Free Radicals in Foods”, American Chernicai
`Society, March 26—3 1 , San Francisco, CA
`
`Chair, symposia on Recent 'fi‘rends in struet'urai Antioxidants, 2nd 1nternationa1
`Conference on Food Factors: Chemistry and Hea1t1i Effects, December 12—17,
`Kyoto, ,1apan.
`
`Member, Qrganizing Committee, Attantie Fisheries Teetinoiogieai Conterenee,
`November 10— 1 4, N’ewbern, NC
`
`“Functiona1 Foods and Heaitn C1airns” and
`{To—organizer, 2 syrnposia on
`“Seafoods Qua1ity and Nutrition”, 10m1UFoST, Sydney, Aastraiia, October 3—8.
`
`Conorganizer, Symposium on “antioxidants”, American Git Chemists” Society,
`May 3—8, Qriando, 17L.
`
`Co—organizer of a symposium on Higtiiy Unsaturated Fatty Acids: Chemistry
`and Nutrition. American Cheniicai Society, Spring Meeting, March EEK—April
`2, Anaheim, CA.
`
`Conorganizer of a. symposium on Meat Qaaiity. American Chemieai Society,
`Spring, Meeting, March 26—Apri1 2, Daiias, 1X
`
`Conference Chairperson, Atiantie Fisheries Teehnoiogy Conference, to he held in

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket