IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
`FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF TEXAS
`MARSHALL DIVISION
`
`
`REMBRANDT WIRELESS
`TECHNOLOGIES, LP,
`
`
`Plaintiff,
`
`
`
`v.
`
`
`
`
`Case No. 2:13-cv-00213
`
`
`
`Jury Trial Requested
`
`
`
`
`
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`§
`
`
`SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO. LTD.;
`SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS AMERICA,
`INC.; SAMSUNG TELECOMMUNICATIONS
`AMERICA, LLC; SAMSUNG AUSTIN
`SEMICONDUCTOR, LLC; RESEARCH IN
`MOTION, CORP. and RESEARCH IN
`MOTION, LTD,
`
`
`Defendants.
`
`
`
`
`PLAINTIFF REMBRANDT WIRELESS TECHNOLOGIES, LP’S
`DISCLOSURE OF ASSERTED CLAIMS AND INFRINGEMENT
`CONTENTIONS AND ACCOMPANYING DOCUMENT PRODUCTION
`
`Pursuant to Local Patent Rules 3-1 and 3-2, Plaintiff Rembrandt Wireless Technologies,
`
`LP (“Rembrandt”) hereby provides its Disclosure of Asserted Claims and Infringement
`
`Contentions and accompanying Document Production to Defendants Samsung Electronics Co.
`
`Ltd. (“SEC”), Samsung Electronics America, Inc. (“SEA”), Samsung Telecommunications
`
`America, LLC (“STA”), Samsung Austin Semiconductor, LLC (“SAS”)1, Research in Motion
`
`Corp. (“RIM Corp.”), and Research in Motion Ltd. (“RIM Ltd.”)2 (collectively “Defendants”).
`
`Rembrandt contends that all Samsung and RIM products that practice Bluetooth Standard
`
`
`Collectively SEC, SEA, STA, and SAS are referred to herein as “Samsung”.
`1
`
`Collectively RIM Corp. and RIM Ltd. are referred to herein as “RIM”.
`
`1
`
`2
`
`
`
`Exhibit 1107 001/122
`
`

`

`Version 2.0 + EDR, Version 2.1 + EDR, Version 3.0 + HS, and Version 4.0 (“Defendants’
`
`Bluetooth Products”) fall within the scope of the asserted claims of United States Patent No.
`
`8,023,580 (“the ’580 Patent”) and the asserted claims of United States Patent No. 8,457,228
`
`(“the ’228 Patent”) as made, used, sold, offered for sale and/or imported by Defendants and/or
`
`Defendants’ customers.
`
`Rembrandt’s statements concerning Defendants’ Bluetooth Products are based on
`
`publicly available materials which identify Defendants’ products that practice Bluetooth
`
`Standards Version 2.0 + EDR, Version 2.1 + EDR, Version 3.0 + HS, and Version 4.0. At this
`
`time, Rembrandt has had no discovery to date from Defendants. Rembrandt expects that
`
`additional Defendants’ Bluetooth Products will be identified during discovery. Accordingly,
`
`Rembrandt reserves the right to supplement or alter its disclosure herein based on additional
`
`information obtained through formal discovery or other means concerning Defendants’ products.
`
`I.
`
`P.R. 3-1(a) - Asserted Claims
`
`Pursuant to P.R. 3-1(a), and based on the information presently available to it, Rembrandt
`
`contends that Samsung and RIM currently infringe and/or have infringed (directly and/or
`
`indirectly) the following Asserted Claims:
`
`• claims 1, 2, 4, 5, 10, 13, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 25, 29, 30, 32, 34, 38, 40, 41, 43, 44, 47,
`
`49, 52, 53, 54, 57, 58, 59, 61, 62, 66, 70, 76, 77, 78, 79 of the ’580 Patent; and
`
`• claims 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 25, 26,
`
`27, 28, 29, 31, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 43, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52 of the ’228 Patent.
`
`Rembrandt expressly reserves the right to augment and supplement its identification of Asserted
`
`Claims based on additional information obtained through discovery.
`
`
`
`
`
`2
`
`Exhibit 1107 002/122
`
`

`

`II.
`
`P.R. 3-1(b) - Accused Products
`
` Pursuant to P.R. 3-1(b), and based on information presently available to it, Rembrandt
`
`asserts that the Samsung Bluetooth Products listed in Exhibit A are marketed and sold as
`
`interoperable in accordance with Bluetooth Standard Version 2.0 + EDR, Version 2.1 + EDR,
`
`Version 3.0 + HS, and Version 4.0, and as a result satisfy each of the elements of the Asserted
`
`Claims. Moreover, Samsung sells or otherwise transfers its Accused Bluetooth Products to
`
`customers, actively encouraging them to use those Accused Bluetooth Products in a manner
`
`which induces and contributes to the infringement of the Asserted Claims.
`
`Based on information presently available to it, Rembrandt asserts that the RIM Bluetooth
`
`Products listed in Exhibit B are marketed and sold as interoperable in accordance with Bluetooth
`
`Standard Version 2.0 + EDR, Version 2.1 + EDR, Version 3.0 + HS, and Version 4.0, and as a
`
`result are believed to satisfy each of the elements of the Asserted Claims. Moreover, RIM sells
`
`or otherwise transfers its Accused Bluetooth Products to customers, actively encouraging them to
`
`use those Accused Bluetooth Products in a manner which induces and contributes to the
`
`infringement of the Asserted Claims.
`
`Defendants infringe the Asserted Claims as specified in the charts identified in section
`
`III, below. Rembrandt’s identification of accused products is merely exemplary, and
`
`Defendants’ forthcoming products with the same or similar functionality as that identified in the
`
`attached charts also infringe the Asserted Claims. Rembrandt expressly reserves the right to
`
`augment and supplement its identification of Asserted Claims and infringing products based on
`
`additional information obtained through formal discovery and as additional products are
`
`introduced.
`
`
`
`
`
`3
`
`Exhibit 1107 003/122
`
`

`

`III.
`
`P.R. 3-1(c) - Claim Charts
`
`Pursuant to P.R. 3-1(c), Rembrandt’s detailed infringement assertions with respect to the
`
`Asserted Claims are contained in the charts labeled Exhibits C-D.
`
`IV. P.R. 3-1(d) - Doctrine of Equivalents
`
`Pursuant to P.R. 3-1(d), Rembrandt asserts that the claims are literally infringed as
`
`reflected in attached Exhibit C and D. At this time, Rembrandt knows of no specific limitations
`
`of the asserted claims where infringement depends on the doctrine of equivalents. To the extent
`
`Defendants successfully argue that any of the limitations are not literally present in the Accused
`
`Bluetooth Products, the charts identify illustrative support for where the equivalent feature is
`
`found under the doctrine of equivalents. Rembrandt expressly reserves the right to modify,
`
`augment, and/or supplement its assertion of infringement under the doctrine of equivalents of
`
`any elements of any of the asserted claims after discovery from Defendants and/or third parties
`
`and/or after this Court has set forth its construction of the asserted claims.
`
`V.
`
`P.R. 3-1(e) - Priority Claim to an Earlier Application
`
`Pursuant to P.R. 3-1(e), each of the Asserted Claims is entitled to a filing date of
`
`December 5, 1997 because each is entitled to claim priority to U.S. Provisional Patent
`
`Application serial no. 60/067,562.
`
`V.
`
`P.R. 3-1(f) - Own Products That Practice Inventions
`
`Pursuant to P.R. 3-1(f), Rembrandt does not at this time intend to rely on the assertion
`
`that its apparatus, product, device, process, method, act, or other instrumentality practices any of
`
`the claimed inventions.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`4
`
`Exhibit 1107 004/122
`
`

`

`VI.
`
`P.R. 3-2(a) – Documents Evidencing Disclosures, Sales or Offers to Sell
`
`Pursuant to P.R. 3-2(a), Rembrandt is unaware of any documents that evidence any
`
`discussion with, disclosure to, or other manner of providing to a third party, or sale of or offer to
`
`sell, the claimed invention prior to the date of application for the patent in suit.
`
`VI.
`
`P.R. 3-2(b) – Documents Evidencing Conception, Reduction to Practice,
`Design and Development
`
`
`Pursuant to P.R. 3-2(b), the following documents evidence the conception, reduction to
`
`practice, design, and development of each claimed invention and were created on or before the
`
`December 5, 1997 priority date of the patents-in-suit: RIP00004310 – 4343
`
`VII. P.R. 3-2(c) – File Histories of Patents-In-Suit
`
`Pursuant to P.R. 3-2(c), the following documents are copies of the file histories of the
`
`patents-in-suit: RIP00000001 – 4309
`
`
`
`Date: July 25, 2013
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`
`
`
`
` /s/ Eric J. Enger
`Michael F. Heim (Texas Bar No. 09380923)
`mheim@hpcllp.com
`Eric Enger (Texas Bar No. 24045833)
`eenger@hpcllp.com
`Miranda Y. Jones (Texas Bar No. 24065519)
`mjones@hpcllp.com
`HEIM, PAYNE & CHORUSH, LLP
`600 Travis Street, Suite 6710
`Houston, Texas 77002-2912
`Telephone: (713) 221-2000
`Facsimile: (713) 221-2021
`
`Demetrios Anaipakos (Texas Bar No. 00793258)
`danaipakos@azalaw.com
`Amir Alavi (Texas Bar No. 00793239)
`aalavi@azalaw.com
`Steven J. Mitby (Texas Bar No. 24037123)
`smitby@azalaw.com
`Brian E. Simmons (Texas Bar No. 24004922)
`bsimmons@azalaw.com
`5
`
`Exhibit 1107 005/122
`
`

`

`AHMAD, ZAVITSANOS, ANAIPAKOS,
`ALAVI & MENSING, P.C.
`1221 McKinney Street, Suite 3460
`Houston, TX 77010
`Telephone: 713-655-1101
`Facsimile: 713-655-0062
`
`T. John Ward, Jr.
`Texas Bar No. 00794818
`jw@wsfirm.com
`WARD & SMITH LAW FIRM
`1127 Judson Road, Suite 220
`Longview, TX 75601
`Telephone: (903) 757-6400
`Facsimile: (903) 757-2323
`
`ATTORNEYS FOR REMBRANDT WIRELESS
`TECHNOLOGIES LP
`
`
`
`
`6
`
`Exhibit 1107 006/122
`
`

`

`
`
`CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
`
`The undersigned hereby certifies that all counsel of record are being served with a copy
`
`of this document by e-mail on July 25, 2013.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`/s/ Eric J. Enger
`Eric J. Enger
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`7
`
`Exhibit 1107 007/122
`
`

`

`EXHIBIT A
`SAMSUNG
`
`U.S. Patent Nos. 8,023,580 & 8,457,228
`
`
`The accused Samsung Bluetooth Products include those Samsung products practicing or
`
`implementing Bluetooth EDR, including Bluetooth Specifications Version 2.0 + EDR, Version
`
`2.1 + EDR, Version 3.0 + HS, and Version 4.0. Based on publicly available information
`
`currently available to Rembrandt, Rembrandt identifies Samsung Bluetooth Products as
`
`including the Samsung products described below, which are identified by product model or
`
`description. Information regarding which version of the Bluetooth Specifications is practiced or
`
`implemented by various Samsung products is information that is uniquely within the possession
`
`of Samsung. To the extent that any of the model numbers listed below identify Samsung
`
`products that do not practice or implement that Bluetooth EDR, those products are inadvertently
`
`included. Rembrandt reserves the right to amend or supplement these contentions in the course
`
`of discovery or further investigation.
`
`Galaxy S4
`Galaxy S III
`Galaxy S II
`Galaxy S II
`Skyrocket
`Galaxy Stellar
`Conquer 4G
`Focus 2
`Galaxy Nexus
`Galaxy Exhibit
`Galaxy Proclaim
`ATIV Odyssey
`Galaxy Note II
`Galaxy Note
`Nexus 10
`
`
`
`Galaxy Tab 2
`Galaxy Tab
`Galaxy Player 4.0
`Galaxy Player 5.0
`ES Series televisions
`with 3D support
`D Series televisions
`with 3D support
`AA-BK1NWBW
`AAET007NCK
`AWEP301JSE
`AWEP350JDE
`AWEP350JPE
`AWEP350JSE
`AWEP460JBE
`BHM1100NBAC
`
`BHM1200NBAC
`BHM1700NDAC
`BHM1700NPAC
`BHM7000NBAC
`BKB-10
`BKB-A
`BKC-1B1
`BKC-1B1USBG
`BKC-1C9
`CDMA SCI11
`CDMA_SCL21
`CL80
`DA-E550
`DA-E560
`DA-E570
`DA-E580
`
`1
`
`DA-E650
`DA-E651
`DA-E660
`DA-E661
`DA-E670
`DA-E680
`DA-E750
`DA-E751
`DA-E760
`DA-F560
`DA-F6**, DA-F7**
`DA-F60
`DP700A3B
`DP700A3D
`DP700A7D
`EI-CN10
`
`Exhibit 1107 008/122
`
`

`

`GT-C3260
`GT-C3262
`GT-C3300D
`GT-C3300i
`GT-C3303K
`GT-C3310
`GT-C3310R
`GT-C3312
`GT-C3312R
`GT-C3313T
`GT-C3322
`GT-C3322i
`GT-C3330
`GT-C3332
`GT-C3350
`GT-C3500
`GT-C3503
`GT-C3520
`GT-C3530
`GT-C3560
`GT-C3590
`GT-C3592
`GT-C3595
`GT-C3750
`GT-C3752
`GT-C3782
`GT-C5010B
`GT-C5010L
`GT-C5180
`GT-C5212i
`GT-C6712
`GT-E1232B
`GT-E1282T
`GT-E2152
`GT-E2152i
`GT-E2200L
`GT-E2202
`GT-E2220
`GT-E2222
`GT-E2222L
`
`EI-HH10
`EI-HS10
`EK-GC100
`EK-GC110
`EK-GC120
`EK-GN100
`EK-GN120
`EK-KC120K
`EK-KC120L
`EK-KC120S
`ESP-30
`ESP-70
`F750
`GT- S8500
`GT-B2100I
`GT-B2710
`GT-B2710D
`GT-B3310i
`GT-B3313i
`GT-B5330
`GT-B5330B
`GT-B5330L
`GT-B5722C
`GT-B6520
`GT-B6520L
`GT-B7350
`GT-B7350T
`GT-B7510
`GT-B7510B
`GT-B7510L
`GT-B7722i
`GT-B7810
`GT-B7810L
`GT-B9150
`GT-B9150WZKOO
`GT-B9388
`GT-C3011
`GT-C3222
`GT-C3222W
`GT-C3250
`
`
`
`GT-E2230
`GT-E2230L
`GT-E2232
`GT-E2250
`GT-E2252
`GT-E2260
`GT-E2262
`GT-E2330B
`GT-E2350B
`GT-E2370
`GT-E2530
`GT-E2600
`GT-E2652
`GT-E2652W
`GT-E3210
`GT-E3210B
`GT-E3210L
`GT-E3210O
`GT-E3213K
`GT-E3217B
`GT-E3217L
`GT-E3300
`GT-E3300I
`GT-E3300L
`GT-E3300V
`GT-E3309
`GT-E3309I
`GT-I5500M
`GT-I5503T
`GT-I5510
`GT-I5510 (GB)
`GT-I5510B
`GT-I5510L
`GT-I5510M
`GT-I5510T
`GT-I6420
`GT-I6712
`GT-I8150
`GT-I8150B
`GT-I8150T
`
`2
`
`GT-I8160
`GT-I8160L
`GT-I8160P
`GT-I8190
`GT-I8190L
`GT-I8190N
`GT-I8190T
`GT-I8250
`GT-I8258
`GT-I8260
`GT-I8260L
`GT-I8262
`GT-I8262B
`GT-I8262D
`GT-I8268
`GT-I8350
`GT-I8350T
`GT-I8530
`GT-I8550L
`GT-I8552
`GT-I8552B
`GT-I8558
`GT-I8700
`GT-I8703
`GT-I8730
`GT-I8730T
`GT-I9000
`GT-I9000M
`GT-I9001
`GT-I9003
`GT-I9003L
`GT-I9008
`GT-I9008L
`GT-I9010
`GT-I9018
`GT-I9020
`GT-I9020A
`GT-I9020T
`GT-I9023
`GT-I9070
`
`Exhibit 1107 009/122
`
`

`

`GT-I9300T
`GT-I9300X
`GT-I9305
`GT-I9305N
`GT-I9305T
`GT-I9306
`GT-I9308
`GT-I9500
`GT-I9502
`GT-I9505
`GT-I9505G
`GT-I9507
`GT-I9508
`GT-I9508C
`GT-N5100
`GT-N5105
`GT-N5110
`GT-N5120
`GT-N7000
`GT-N7005
`GT-N7100
`GT-N7100T
`GT-N7100X
`GT-N7102
`GT-N7102i
`GT-N7105
`GT-N7105T
`GT-N7108
`GT-N7108D
`GT-N8000
`GT-N8005
`GT-N8010
`GT-N8013
`GT-N8020
`GT-P1000
`GT-P1000L
`GT-P1000M
`GT-P1000N
`GT-P1000R
`GT-P1000T
`
`GT-I9080
`GT-I9080L
`GT-I9082
`GT-I9082i
`GT-I9082L
`GT-I9088
`GT-I9100
`GT-I9100G
`GT-I9100M
`GT-I9100P
`GT-I9100T
`GT-I9103
`GT-I9105
`GT-I9105P
`GT-I9108
`GT-I9128
`GT-I9128V
`GT-I9150
`GT-I9152
`GT-I9190
`GT-I9192
`GT-I9195
`GT-I9195L
`GT-I9195T
`GT-I9197
`GT-I9200
`GT-I9200X
`GT-I9205
`GT-I9208
`GT-I9210
`GT-I9228
`GT-I9250
`GT-I9250M
`GT-I9250T
`GT-I9250W
`GT-I9260
`GT-I9268
`GT-I9295
`GT-I9300
`GT-I9300_Tizen
`
`
`
`GT-P1010
`GT-P1010/W16
`GT-P1013
`GT-P3100
`GT-P3100B
`GT-P3108
`GT-P3110
`GT-P3113
`GT-P5100
`GT-P5110
`GT-P5113
`GT-P5200
`GT-P5210
`GT-P5220
`GT-P6200
`GT-P6200L
`GT-P6201
`GT-P6210
`GT-P6211
`GT-P6800
`GT-P6810
`GT-P6813
`GT-P7100
`GT-P7300
`GT-P7300B
`GT-P7310
`GT-P7320
`GT-P7320T
`GT-P7500
`GT-P7500D
`GT-P7500M
`GT-P7500R
`GT-P7500V
`GT-P7501
`GT-P7503
`GT-P7510
`GT-P7511
`GT-P8110
`GT-P8200
`GT-P8210
`
`3
`
`GT-P8220
`GT-P8510
`GT-S3332
`GT-S3333
`GT-S3350
`GT-S3353
`GT-S3570
`GT-S3572
`GT-S3710
`GT-S3770
`GT-S3770B
`GT-S3770K
`GT-S3770L
`GT-S3770M
`GT-S3770S
`GT-S3770Y
`GT-S3778
`GT-S3778V
`GT-S3802
`GT-S3850
`GT-S3970
`GT-S5220
`GT-S5220R
`GT-S5222
`GT-S5222R
`GT-S5250
`GT-S5260
`GT-S5260P
`GT-S5270K
`GT-S5270L
`GT-S5270S
`GT-S5270Y
`GT-S5273L
`GT-S5280
`GT-S5282
`GT-S5283B
`GT-S5301
`GT-S5301B
`GT-S5301L
`GT-S5303
`
`Exhibit 1107 010/122
`
`

`

`GT-S5303B
`GT-S5310
`GT-S5310B
`GT-S5310E
`GT-S5310G
`GT-S5310L
`GT-S5312
`GT-S5312B
`GT-S5312L
`GT-S5330
`GT-S5333
`GT-S5360
`GT-S5368
`GT-S5380
`GT-S5380B
`GT-S5380D
`GT-S5380E
`GT-S5380K
`GT-S5380L
`GT-S5511T
`GT-S5520
`GT-S5560i
`GT-S5570
`GT-S5570B
`GT-S5570L
`GT-S5571
`GT-S5578
`GT-S5580
`GT-S5610
`GT-S5610K
`GT-S5660
`GT-S5660B
`GT-S5660L
`GT-S5660M
`GT-S5660V
`GT-S5670
`GT-S5670B
`GT-S5670L
`GT-S5698
`GT-S5750E
`
`
`
`GT-S5780
`GT-S5820
`GT-S5830
`GT-S5830B
`GT-S5830C
`GT-S5830D
`GT-S5830F
`GT-S5830G
`GT-S5830L
`GT-S5830M
`GT-S5830T
`GT-S5830V
`GT-S5838
`GT-S5839i
`GT-S6010
`GT-S6010L
`GT-S6012
`GT-S6012B
`GT-S6108
`GT-S6310
`GT-S6310B
`GT-S6310L
`GT-S6310N
`GT-S6310T
`GT-S6312
`GT-S6313T
`GT-S6358
`GT-S6500
`GT-S6500D
`GT-S6500L
`GT-S6500T
`GT-S6810
`GT-S6810B
`GT-S6810E
`GT-S6810L
`GT-S6810M
`GT-S6810P
`GT-S6812
`GT-S6812B
`GT-S6812i
`
`GT-S6818
`GT-S6888
`GT-S7230
`GT-S7230B
`GT-S7230E
`GT-S7230L
`GT-S7233E
`GT-S7250
`GT-S7250D
`GT-S7270
`GT-S7270L
`GT-S7272
`GT-S7273T
`GT-S7275
`GT-S7500
`GT-S7500L
`GT-S7500T
`GT-S7508
`GT-S7530
`GT-S7530E
`GT-S7530L
`GT-S7560
`GT-S7560M
`GT-S7562
`GT-S7562i
`GT-S7562L
`GT-S7566
`GT-S7568
`GT-S7572
`GT-S7710
`GT-S7710L
`GT-S7898
`GT-S8500
`GT-S8530
`GT-S8530B
`GT-S8530L
`GT-S8600
`HF4000
`HM1100
`HM1200
`
`4
`
`HM1300
`HM1610
`HM1700
`HM1800
`HM1900
`HM3300
`HM3600
`HM3700
`HM5000
`HM5100
`HM6000
`HM6400
`HM6450
`HM7000
`HM7100
`HS3000
`HS6000
`HT-E5200
`HT-E5530
`HT-E5550
`HT-E5551
`HT-E6500
`HT-E6530
`HT-E6730WW
`HT-E6750W
`HT-E6759W
`HT-E8000
`HT-E8200
`HT-F5***
`HT-F5500W
`HT-F6***
`HT-F6500W
`HT-F9****
`HT-FM53
`HT-FM55WC
`HT-FS9***
`HW-E450
`HW-E450C
`HW-E550
`HW-E551
`
`Exhibit 1107 011/122
`
`

`

`NP355E7C
`NP355V5C
`NP365E5C
`NP470R5E
`NP500P4C
`NP510R5E
`NP520U4C
`NP530U3BI
`NP530U3C
`NP530U4BI
`NP530U4C
`NP535U3C
`NP535U4C
`NP540U3C
`NP540U4E
`NP550P5C
`NP600B4C
`NP680Z5E
`NP700G7C
`NP700Z3AH
`NP700Z3CH
`NP700Z5AH
`NP700Z5BH
`NP700Z5CH
`NP700Z7CH
`NP740U3E
`NP770Z7E
`NP780Z5E
`NP880Z5E
`NP900X1A
`NP900X1B
`NP900X3A
`NP900X3B
`NP900X3C
`NP900X3D
`NP900X3E
`NP900X3F
`NP900X4B
`NP900X4C
`NP900X4D
`
`HW-F355
`HW-F450
`HW-F550
`HW-F551
`HW-F750, HW-
`F850
`HW-FM45
`LG U+ LTE eNB
`RRH
`LG U+ LTE eNB
`RRH(SLS-
`2B014C0800)
`LP**A750/ A950
`MX-E630
`MX-E650
`MX-F830B
`MX-F730DB
`MX-F630DB
`MX-F630B
`MX-F830B
`MX-FS8000
`MX-FS9000
`NP270E4E
`NP270E5E
`NP275E5E
`NP300E4C
`NP300E5AI
`NP300E5C
`NP300U1A
`NP300V3AI
`NP300V4AI
`NP300V5AI
`NP305E5AI
`NP305U1A
`NP305V5AI
`NP350E5C
`NP350E7C
`NP350U2A
`NP350U2B
`NP350V5C
`NP355E5C
`
`
`
`NP-P560I
`NP-Q430E
`NP-Q530
`NP-QX411H
`NP-R780VE
`NP-RC512I
`NP-RF510E
`NP-RF511
`NP-RF710E
`NP-RF711
`NP-RV510I
`NP-RV515I
`NP-RV520I
`NP-SF310
`NP-SF511I
`OPT_NPC(PDCCE)
`OPT_VPC(PDCCE)
`PN**D49**
`PN**D5**
`PN**D6**
`PN**D7***
`PN**D8***
`PN51F5500AF
`PN51F8500AF
`PN60F5500AF
`PN60F8500AF
`PN64F5500AF
`PN64F8500AF
`RMCTPF1AP1
`RMCTPF1BP1
`RMCTPF2AP1
`RMCTPF2BP1
`SC-01C
`SC-01D
`SC-01E
`SC-02B
`SC-02C
`SC-02D
`SC-02E
`SC-03D
`
`5
`
`SC-03E
`SC-04D
`SC-04E
`SC-05D
`SC-06D
`SCH-5380C
`SCH-I100
`SCH-I200
`SCH-I225
`SCH-I339
`SCH-I400
`SCH-I405
`SCH-I405U
`SCH-I415
`SCH-I425
`SCH-I435
`SCH-I500
`SCH-i509
`SCH-I509U
`SCH-I510
`SCH-I515
`SCH-I519
`SCH-I520
`SCH-I535
`SCH-I535(HDP)
`SCH-I545
`SCH-I545L
`SCH-I559
`SCH-I569
`SCH-I579
`SCH-I579i
`SCH-I589
`SCH-I605
`SCH-I619
`SCH-I639
`SCH-I659
`SCH-I699
`SCH-I705
`SCH-I719
`SCH-I739
`
`Exhibit 1107 012/122
`
`

`

`SCH-I759
`SCH-I800
`SCH-I809
`SCH-I815
`SCH-I829
`SCH-I869
`SCH-I879
`SCH-I889
`SCH-I905
`SCH-I905U
`SCH-I909
`SCH-I909L
`SCH-I915
`SCH-I920
`SCH-I925
`SCH-I925U
`SCH-I929
`SCH-I930
`SCH-I939
`SCH-I939D
`SCH-I959
`SCH-L710
`SCH-M828C
`SCH-N719
`SCH-P709
`SCH-P729
`SCH-P739
`SCH-R100
`SCH-R210
`SCH-R220
`SCH-R250
`SCH-R260
`SCH-R261
`SCH-R270
`SCH-R270M
`SCH-R270U
`SCH-R270X
`SCH-R310
`SCH-R311
`SCH-R330
`
`
`
`SCH-R350
`SCH-R351
`SCH-R355
`SCH-R360
`SCH-R375C
`SCH-R380
`SCH-R390
`SCH-R390C
`SCH-R390X
`SCH-R420
`SCH-R430
`SCH-R450
`SCH-R451
`SCH-R455
`SCH-R455C
`SCH-R460
`SCH-R470
`SCH-R480
`SCH-R480C
`SCH-R520
`SCH-R530
`SCH-R530C
`SCH-R530M
`SCH-R530X
`SCH-R550
`SCH-R600
`SCH-R640
`SCH-R641
`SCH-R680
`SCH-R720
`SCH-R730
`SCH-R740C
`SCH-R760
`SCH-R760X
`SCH-R810
`SCH-R820
`SCH-R830
`SCH-R830C
`SCH-R850
`SCH-R860U
`
`SCH-R910
`SCH-R915
`SCH-R920
`SCH-R930
`SCH-R940
`SCH-R950
`SCH-R960
`SCH-R970
`SCH-R970C
`SCH-R970X
`SCH-S336C
`SCH-S380C
`SCH-S559
`SCH-S579
`SCH-S720C
`SCH-S735C
`SCH-S738C
`SCH-S759
`SCH-S950C
`SCH-S960L
`SCH-S968C
`SCH-U350
`SCH-U360
`SCH-U365
`SCH-U370
`SCH-U380
`SCH-U430
`SCH-U440
`SCH-U450
`SCH-U480
`SCH-U485
`SCH-U490
`SCH-U650
`SCH-U660
`SCH-U680
`SCH-U750
`SCH-U810
`SCH-W2013
`SCH-W279
`SCH-W289
`
`6
`
`SCH-W309
`SCH-W609
`SCH-W689
`SCH-W789
`SCH-W899
`SGH-5730G
`SGH-A177
`SGH-A187
`SGH-A207
`SGH-A217
`SGH-A667T
`SGH-A797
`SGH-A837
`SGH-A847D
`SGH-A847M
`SGH-A847R
`SGH-A867
`SGH-A997
`SGH-A997D
`SGH-A997M
`SGH-A997R
`SGH-C414
`SGH-C414M
`SGH-C414R
`SGH-C414V
`SGH-C414W
`SGH-C414Y
`SGH-I257
`SGH-I317
`SGH-I317M
`SGH-I337
`SGH-I337M
`SGH-I337Z
`SGH-I407
`SGH-I437
`SGH-I437P
`SGH-I437Z
`SGH-I467
`SGH-I467M
`SGH-I497
`
`Exhibit 1107 013/122
`
`

`

`SGH-I997
`SGH-I997R
`SGH-L400V
`SGH-M919
`SGH-M919N
`SGH-M919V
`SGH-R940
`SGH-S275G
`SGH-S275M
`SGH-S275R
`SGH-S390G
`SGH-S425G
`SGH-S730G
`SGH-S730M
`SGH-S959G
`SGH-T139
`SGH-T159
`SGH-T159V
`SGH-T189N
`SGH-T229
`SGH-T239
`SGH-T245G
`SGH-T249
`SGH-T249R
`SGH-T259
`SGH-T269
`SGH-T289
`SGH-T301G
`SGH-T330
`SGH-T330G
`SGH-T339
`SGH-T340G
`SGH-T349
`SGH-T359
`SGH-T369R
`SGH-T379
`SGH-T401G
`SGH-T404G
`SGH-T499
`SGH-T499W
`
`SGH-I527
`SGH-I527M
`SGH-I537
`SGH-I547
`SGH-I547C
`SGH-I570
`SGH-I577
`SGH-I617
`SGH-I627
`SGH-I667
`SGH-I677
`SGH-I717
`SGH-I717D
`SGH-I717M
`SGH-I717R
`SGH-I727
`SGH-I727R
`SGH-I747
`SGH-I747(HDP)
`SGH-I747M
`SGH-I747M(HDP)
`SGH-I748
`SGH-I748(HDP)
`SGH-I757
`SGH-I777
`SGH-I827
`SGH-I827D
`SGH-I847
`SGH-I857
`SGH-I896
`SGH-I897
`SGH-I917
`SGH-I917R
`SGH-I927
`SGH-I937
`SGH-I957
`SGH-I957D
`SGH-I957M
`SGH-I957R
`SGH-I987
`
`
`
`SGH-T499Y
`SGH-T528G
`SGH-T559
`SGH-T589
`SGH-T589R
`SGH-T589W
`SGH-T599
`SGH-T599N
`SGH-T599V
`SGH-T669V
`SGH-T669Y
`SGH-T679
`SGH-T679M
`SGH-T699
`SGH-T729
`SGH-
`T749TAKTMB
`SGH-T759
`SGH-T769
`SGH-T779
`SGH-T809
`SGH-T839
`SGH-T849
`SGH-T859
`SGH-T869
`SGH-T879
`SGH-T889
`SGH-T959
`SGH-T959D
`SGH-T959P
`SGH-T959V
`SGH-T959W
`SGH-T989
`SGH-T989D
`SGH-T999
`SGH-T999(HDP)
`SGH-T999L
`SGH-T999N
`SGH-T999V
`SGH-T999V(HDP)
`
`7
`
`SHC-Z100S
`SHC-Z160S
`SHV-E110S
`SHV-E120K
`SHV-E120L
`SHV-E120S
`SHV-E140K
`SHV-E140L
`SHV-E140S
`SHV-E150S
`SHV-E160K
`SHV-E160L
`SHV-E160S
`SHV-E170K
`SHV-E170K(HDP)
`SHV-E170L
`SHV-E170L(HDP)
`SHV-E170S
`SHV-E170S(HDP)
`SHV-E210K
`SHV-E210K(HDP)
`SHV-E210L
`SHV-E210L(HDP)
`SHV-E210S
`SHV-E210S(HDP)
`SHV-E220S
`SHV-E230K
`SHV-E230L
`SHV-E230S
`SHV-E250K
`SHV-E250L
`SHV-E250S
`SHV-E270K
`SHV-E270L
`SHV-E270S
`SHV-E275K
`SHV-E275S
`SHV-E300K
`SHV-E300L
`SHV-E300S
`
`Exhibit 1107 014/122
`
`

`

`SHV-E310K
`SHV-E310L
`SHV-E310S
`SHV-E330K
`SHV-E330L
`SHV-E330S
`SHV-E400K
`SHV-E400S
`SHW-A175S
`SHW-A280K
`SHW-A280L
`SHW-A280S
`SHW-A300K
`SHW-A300S
`SHW-A310S
`SHW-A330S
`SHW-A350K
`SHW-M110S
`SHW-M180K
`SHW-M180L
`SHW-M180S
`SHW-M180W
`SHW-M190S
`SHW-M200K
`SHW-M200S
`SHW-M210S
`SHW-M220L
`SHW-M240S
`SHW-M250K
`SHW-M250L
`SHW-M250S
`SHW-M290K
`SHW-M290S
`SHW-M300K
`SHW-M300S
`SHW-M300W
`SHW-M305W
`SHW-M340D
`SHW-M340K
`SHW-M340L
`
`
`
`SHW-M340S
`SHW-M380K
`SHW-M380S
`SHW-M380W
`SHW-M410K
`SHW-M410S
`SHW-M420K
`SHW-M420S
`SHW-M430W
`SHW-M440S
`SHW-M460D
`SHW-M480K
`SHW-M480S
`SHW-M480W
`SHW-M485W
`SHW-M486W
`SHW-M500W
`SHW-M550S
`SLS-2C304C0800
`SLS-2C304T0800
`SM-C101
`SM-G730A
`SMM-2LD04C1800
`SMM-2LD04T1800
`SMM-2LD04TC800
`SLS-2A504T0800
`SLS-2A504T0800
`SLS-2R02480800
`SM-T210
`SM-T2105
`SM-T210L
`SM-T210R
`SM-T211
`SM-T217S
`SM-T310
`SM-T311
`SM-T315
`SPH-A310
`SPH-D600
`SPH-D700
`
`SPH-D710
`SPH-D720
`SPH-L300
`SPH-L500
`SPH-L600
`SPH-L700
`SPH-L710
`SPH-L710(HDP)
`SPH-L720
`SPH-L900
`SPH-M220
`SPH-M260
`SPH-M330
`SPH-M360
`SPH-M370
`SPH-M380
`SPH-M390
`SPH-M400
`SPH-M550
`SPH-M570
`SPH-M575
`SPH-M580
`SPH-M580 BST
`SPH-M810
`SPH-M820
`SPH-M830
`SPH-M840
`SPH-M900
`SPH-M930
`SPH-M950
`SPH-P100
`SPH-P500
`SPH-P600
`SPH-Z400
`SSG-3050GB
`SSG-3500CR
`T999N
`UA**F****
`UN**D6***
`UN**D65**
`
`8
`
`UN**D8***
`UN**D9***
`UE**F****
`UN40F6400AF
`UN46F6400AF
`UN46F6800AF
`UN46F7100AF
`UN46F7500AF
`UN46F8000BF
`UN50F6400AF
`UN50F6800AF
`UN55F6400AF
`UN55F6800AF
`UN55F7050AF
`UN55F7100AF
`UN55F7450AF
`UN55F7500AF
`UN55F8000BF
`UN60F6400AF
`UN60F7050AF
`UN60F7100AF
`UN60F7500AF
`UN60F8000BF
`UN65F6400AF
`UN65F7050AF
`UN65F7100AF
`UN65F8000BF
`UN75F6400AF
`UN75F7100AF
`UN75F8000AF
`UN85S9AF
`VG-KBD1500
`VG-KBD2000
`WAM750
`WEP480
`WEP490
`XE500T1C
`XE700T1A
`XE700T1C
`YP-G1
`
`Exhibit 1107 015/122
`
`

`

`YP-G1CWY
`YP-G50
`YP-G70
`YP-G70C/NAW
`
`
`YP-GB1
`YP-GB70
`YP-GH1
`YP-GI1
`
`YP-GI1C/NA
`YP-GI2
`YP-GP1
`YP-
`
`GP1_KOR_LGU
`YP-GS1
`YP-GS1CB
`YP-S5JAB
`
`
`
`9
`
`Exhibit 1107 016/122
`
`

`

`EXHIBIT B
`RESEARCH IN MOTION
`
`U.S. Patent Nos. 8,023,580 & 8,457,228
`
`The accused RIM Bluetooth Products include those RIM products practicing or
`
`implementing Bluetooth EDR, including Bluetooth Specifications Version 2.0 + EDR, Version
`
`2.1 + EDR, Version 3.0 + HS, and Version 4.0. Based on publicly available information
`
`currently available to Rembrandt, Rembrandt identifies RIM Bluetooth Products as including the
`
`RIM products described below, which are identified by product model or description.
`
`Information regarding which version of the Bluetooth Specifications is practiced or implemented
`
`by various RIM products is information that is uniquely within the possession of RIM. To the
`
`extent that any of the model numbers listed below identify RIM products that do not practice or
`
`implement that Bluetooth EDR, those products are inadvertently included. Rembrandt reserves
`
`the right to amend or supplement these contentions in the course of discovery or further
`
`investigation.
`
`BlackBerry A10
`BlackBerry Z10
`BlackBerry Q10
`BlackBerry Q5
`BlackBerry Bold 9930
`BlackBerry Bold 9900
`BlackBerry Bold 9788
`BlackBerry Bold 9790
`BlackBerry Bold 9788
`BlackBerry Bold 9780
`BlackBerry Bold 9700
`BlackBerry Bold 9650
`BlackBerry Torch 9860
`BlackBerry Torch 9850
`BlackBerry Torch 9810
`BlackBerry Torch 9800
`BlackBerry Curve 9620
`BlackBerry Curve 9380
`
`Exhibit 1107 017/122
`
`

`

`BlackBerry Curve 9370
`BlackBerry Curve 9360
`BlackBerry Curve 9350
`BlackBerry Curve 9330
`BlackBerry Curve 9320
`BlackBerry Curve 9315
`BlackBerry Curve 9310
`BlackBerry Curve 9300
`BlackBerry Curve 9220
`BlackBerry Curve 8980
`BlackBerry Curve 8330
`BlackBerry Curve 8320
`BlackBerry PlayBook
`BlackBerry 8830
`BlackBerry Pearl 8110
`BlackBerry Music Gateway
`BlackBerry Wireless Headset HS-300
`BlackBerry Wireless Headset HS-700
`BlackBerry Universal Headset HS-250
`BlackBerry Style 9670
`BlackBerry Mini Stereo Speaker
`BlackBerry Mini Keyboard
`
`
`
`
`Exhibit 1107 018/122
`
`

`

`EXHIBIT C
`
`Infringement Claim Chart for U.S. Patent No. 8,023,580
`
`The accused products are Samsung Bluetooth Products listed in Exhibit A and RIM Bluetooth Products listed in Exhibit B (collectively
`
`
`
`referred to herein as “Accused Instrumentalities” or “Bluetooth EDR-Compliant Devices”). Pursuant to Local Patent Rule 3-1, Rembrandt is
`
`informed and believes that each of the Samsung Bluetooth Products and RIM Bluetooth Products contain circuitry, software and other features that
`
`perform or implement Bluetooth EDR through the implementation of Bluetooth Specifications Version 2.0 + EDR, Version 2.1 + EDR, Version 3.0,
`
`or Version 4.0.
`
`Based on the information presently available to it, Rembrandt contends that Samsung and RIM directly infringe United States Patent No.
`
`8,023,580 (“the ’580 Patent”) by making, using, selling or offering to sell within the United States, or importing into the United States, Bluetooth
`
`products that are EDR enabled. Rembrandt also contends that Samsung and RIM indirectly infringe the ‘580 Patent by actively inducing and
`
`contributing to its customers’ direct infringement of the asserted claims.
`
`Elements in Accused Instrumentality
`Bluetooth EDR-Compliant Devices are communication devices capable of communicating according to a master/slave relationship,
`as
`shown
`by
`the
`following
`excerpts
`from
`the
`Bluetooth
`2.0
`Specification
`(available
`at
`http://www.bluetooth.org/docman/handlers/DownloadDoc.ashx?doc_id=40560)1:
`
`“During typical operation a physical radio channel is shared by a group of devices that are synchronized to a common clock and
`
` •
`
`
`
`‘580 Claim 1
`1. [a] A communication
`device capable of
`communicating according
`to a master/slave
`relationship
`
`
`1 While these claim charts primarily rely on the Bluetooth 2.0 + EDR specification, the specifications for Bluetooth 2.1 + EDR, Version 3 and Version 4 are backwards compatible
` See Bluetooth Core Specification v4.0, available at
`with Bluetooth 2.0 + EDR and contain similar evidence as
`those provided
`in
`the chart.
`http://developer.bluetooth.org/TechnologyOverview/Pages/v4.aspx (“Each version of the core specification retains the functional characteristics of the previous version.”); see also
`Bluetooth 4.0 Specification, pp. 226-228/2302 (“No features were deprecated in v2.1+EDR”; “No features were deprecated in v3.0+HS”; “No features were deprecated in v4.0”).
`Accordingly, those specifications (and all addendums thereto) are incorporated by reference. Those specifications are available at https://www.bluetooth.org/en-
`us/specification/adopted-specifications.
`
`
`
`1
`
`
`
`Exhibit 1107 019/122
`
`

`

`‘580 Claim 1
`
`
`
`Elements in Accused Instrumentality
`frequency hopping pattern. One device provides the synchronization reference and is known as the master. All other devices are
`known as slaves. A group of devices synchronized in this fashion form a piconet. This is the fundamental form of
`communication in the Bluetooth wireless technology.” (p. 87/1230) 2
`
`“Piconet Master – The device in a piconet whose Bluetooth Clock and Bluetooth Device Address are used to define the piconet
`physical channel characteristics.
`Piconet Slave – Any device in a piconet that is not the Piconet Master, but is connected to the Piconet Master.” (p. 92/1230)
`
`“A piconet consists of two or more devices that occupy the same physical channel (which means that they are synchronized to a
`common clock and hopping sequence.) The common (piconet) clock is identical to the Bluetooth clock of one of the devices in
`the piconet, known as the master of the piconet, and the hopping sequence is derived from the master’s clock and the master’s
`Bluetooth device address. All other synchronized devices are referred to as slaves in the piconet. The terms master and slave are
`only used when describing these roles in a piconet.” (p. 125/1230)
`
`“One Bluetooth device acts as the master of the piconet, whereas the other device(s) act as slave(s). Up to seven slaves can be
`active in the piconet. Additionally, many more slaves can remain connected in a parked state. These parked slaves are not active
`on the channel, but remain synchronized to the master and can become active without using the connection establishment
`procedure. Both for active and parked slaves, the channel access is controlled by the master.” (p. 229/1230)
`
`“Each piconet only has a single master, however, slaves can participate in different piconets on a time-division multiplex basis.”
`(p. 229/1230)
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`
`2 All emphasis, including italicizing, underlining, highlighting and annotations, is added unless otherwise noted.
`
`
`
`2
`
`
`
`Exhibit 1107 020/122
`
`

`

`‘580 Claim 1
`
`Elements in Accused Instrumentality
`
`
`
`•
`
`•
`
`“
`
`“By definition, the device that initiates a connection by paging is the master. Once a piconet has been established, master-slave
`roles may be exchanged.” (p. 236/1230)
`
`” (p. 229/1230)
`
`
`Bluetooth EDR-Compliant Devices communicate such that a slave communication from a slave to a master occurs in response to a
`master communication from the master to the slave, as shown by the following excerpts from the Bluetooth 2.0 Specification
`(available at http://www.bluetooth.org/docman/handlers/DownloadDoc.ashx?doc_id=40560):
`
`“Each master transmission is a packet carrying information on one of the logical transports. Slave devices may transmit on the
`physical channel in response. The characteristics of the response are defined by the logical transport that is addressed.” (p.
`109/1230)
`
`“Only one device is the piconet master, all others being piconet slaves. All communication is between the master and slave
`devices. There is no direct communication between slave devices on the piconet channel.” (p. 110/1230)
`
`“The CONNECTION state starts with a POLL packet sent by the master to verify the switch to the master’s timing and channel
`frequency hopping. The slave may respond with any type of packet.” (p. 333/1230)
`
`“In the active mode, both master and slave actively participate on the channel. Up to seven slaves may be in the active mode at
`any given time. The master schedules the transmission based on traffic demands to and from the different slaves. In addition, it
`supports regular transmissions to keep slaves synchronized to the channel. Slaves in the active mode listen in the master-to-slave
`slots for packets. These devices are known as active slaves. If an active slave is not addressed, it may sleep until the next new
`master transmission. Slaves can derive the number of slots the master has reserved for transmission from TYPE field in the
`3
`
`
` •
`
`
`
`•
`
`•
`
`•
`
`[b] in which a slave
`communication from a
`slave to a master occurs
`in response to a master
`communication from the
`master to the slave, the
`device comprising:
`
`
`
`Exhibit 1107 021/122
`
`

`

`‘580 Claim 1
`
`•
`
`Elements in Accused Instrumentality
`packet header; during this time, the non-addressed slaves do not have to listen on the master-to-slave slots.” (p. 334/1230)
`
`“Only the slave that is addressed by one of its LT_ADDRs (primary or secondary) may return a packet in the next slave-to-
`master slot.” (p. 334/1230)
`
`
`
`
`Bluetooth