`
`
`
`
`UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`
`____________
`
`BEFORE THE PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`____________
`
`SKYHAWKE TECHNOLOGIES, LLC
`
`Petitioner,
`
`v.
`
`
`
`L&H CONCEPTS, LLC
`
`Patent Owner.
`
`____________
`
`Case IPR2014-00437
`
`U.S. Patent No. 5,779,566
`
`____________
`
`SUBMISSION OF PETITIONER’S DEMONSTRATIVE
`EXHIBITS FOR ORAL ARGUMENT
`
`
`
`
`

`

`SkyHawke Technologies, LLC
`v.
`L&H Concepts, LLC
`
`IPR2014-00437
`IPR2014-00438
`Patent 5,779,566
`
`Trial Hearing
`
`Petitioner SkyHawke Technologies, LLC’s Demonstrative
`Exhibits DX-1 through DX-58 for April 27, 2015 Oral Argument
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`Copyright © 2015 Oblon, McClelland, Maier & Neustadt, LLP
`
`SkyHawke DX-1
`
`

`

`Grounds of Institution
`
` Claims 1-3 are rendered obvious by Palmer and
`Vanden Heuvel (IPR2014-00438)
` Claims 4, 5, 13, and 17 are rendered obvious by
`Palmer, Vanden Heuvel, and Osamu (IPR2014-
`00438)
` Claims 8-11, 14, and 18 are rendered obvious by
`Palmer, Osamu, and Vanden Heuvel (IPR2014-
`00437)
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-2
`
`

`

`Grounds of Institution (438 IPR)
`
` Claims 1-3 are rendered obvious by Palmer and
`Vanden Heuvel
`
` Claims 4, 5, 13, and 17 are rendered obvious by
`Palmer, Vanden Heuvel, and Osamu
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-3
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 1
`An apparatus for recording and reporting golf information to increase a player’s ability to improve from experience, the apparatus
`comprising:
`
`[a] a self-contained computer unit having a memory, a power
`source and a display for selectively displaying a plurality of
`information screens and associated data stored in the memory,
`the information screens including screen-dependent data input
`fields for the associated data;
`
`[d] second screen-dependent field select key means for selecting
`a particular data input field of predefined data on a displayed
`screen, the second screen-dependent field select key means
`comprising two bi-directional tab keys for scrolling in opposite
`directions through the data input fields on a displayed information
`screen
`
`[b] key entry means for retrieving and selectively displaying the
`information screens from the memory on the display and for
`retrieving, selecting, and recording the associated data with each
`information screen,
`
`[e] and third screen-dependent value select key means for
`displaying and selectively recording or altering selected data in a
`selected data input field, the third screen-dependent value select
`key means comprising two bi-directional scroll keys for scrolling in
`opposite directions through the predefined data associated with
`the data input field on the displayed information screen.
`
`[c] wherein the key entry means includes first key means
`comprising one entry key for selectively displaying information
`screens
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-4
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006)
`Palmer maintains a club selection database, golf course
`database, “interactive training exercises, player
`performance analysis and/or score keeping.” (Ex. 1005
`at p. 5.)
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 1
`An apparatus for
`recording and
`reporting golf
`information to
`increase a player’s
`ability to improve from
`experience, the
`apparatus comprising:
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-5
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 1
`[a] a self-contained
`computer unit having a
`memory, a power source
`and a display for
`selectively displaying a
`plurality of information
`screens and associated
`data stored in the
`memory, the information
`screens including screen-
`dependent data input
`fields for the associated
`data;
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006)
`Palmer: Memory, power source, display for selectively
`displaying a plurality of information screens and associated
`data stored in the memory. (Ex. 1005 at pp. 6, 9-10.)
`
`Vanden Heuvel: Memory, power source, display for
`selectively displaying a plurality of information screens and
`associated data stored in the memory. (Ex. 1006 at Abstract.)
`
`Vanden Heuvel includes screen-dependent data input fields
`adjusted using entry keys and bi-directional scroll keys. (Ex.
`1006 at 9:5-26.)
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 71-81.
`
`SkyHawke DX-6
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 1
`[b] key entry means for
`retrieving and selectively
`displaying the
`information screens from
`the memory on the
`display and for retrieving,
`selecting, and recording
`the associated data with
`each information screen,
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006)
`Keys 40a-g of Vanden Heuvel retrieve and selectively display
`information screens. (Ex. 1006 at 5:48 – 6:3.)
`
`Pressing 40b of Vanden Heuvel displays a function menu.
`Select 70c to edit fields shown on the screen. (Ex. 1006 at
`8:44 – 9:38.)
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 71-74.
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-7
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 1
`[c] wherein the key entry
`means includes first key
`means comprising one
`entry key for selectively
`displaying information
`screens
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006)
`Operation of key 40a of Vanden Heuvel, for example,
`selectively displays any one of the desired information
`screens 206a-206d. (Ex. 1006 at 5:61-6:3.)
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶ 72.
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-8
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006)
`Operation of bi-directional keys 40c-40f of Vanden Heuvel
`scroll in opposite directions through the data input fields
`(e.g., 400 and 416) on the displayed information screen. (Ex.
`1006 at 8:44 – 9:38, FIGS. 11 and 12.)
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 1
`[d] second screen-
`dependent field select key
`means for selecting a
`particular data input field of
`predefined data on a
`displayed screen, the second
`screen-dependent field
`select key means comprising
`two bi-directional tab keys
`for scrolling in opposite
`directions through the data
`input fields on a displayed
`information screen
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 73-74.
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-9
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 1
`[e] and third screen-
`dependent value select key
`means for displaying and
`selectively recording or
`altering selected data in a
`selected data input field, the
`third screen-dependent
`value select key means
`comprising two bi-
`directional scroll keys for
`scrolling in opposite
`directions through the
`predefined data associated
`with the data input field on
`the displayed information
`screen.
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006)
`Operation of bi-directional keys 40c and 40d of Vanden
`Heuvel scroll in opposite directions through the predefined
`data associated with the data input fields on the displayed
`information screen. (Ex. 1006 at 9:18-38, FIG. 12.)
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 73-74.
`
`SkyHawke DX-10
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 2
`Apparatus as defined in
`claim 1, wherein the first
`key means permits
`changing of the
`information screens in
`sequential fashion, and
`the first key means
`further includes choice
`means for non-sequential
`selection or changing of
`information screens.
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006)
`Vanden Heuvel describes displaying Quick View screens (206a
`– 206d) automatically, or in sequence, or manually and non-
`sequentially. (Ex. 1006 at 5:61 – 6:19.)
`
`Activating entry key 40b when on the screen of Fig. 2
`presents menu shown in Fig. 3. (Ex. 1006 at 5:23-37.)
`
`Activating entry key 40b when on the screen of Fig. 6
`presents menu shown in Fig. 7. (Ex. 1006 at 6:34-55.)
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 75-77.
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-11
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 3
`Apparatus as defined in
`claim 2 wherein the
`choice means is screen-
`dependent to provide a
`customized set of screen-
`changing options for a
`displayed information
`screen.
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006)
`Vanden Heuvel discloses that activating entry key 40b when
`on the screen of Fig. 2 presents the menu shown in Fig. 3.
`(Ex. 1006 at 5:23-37.)
`
`Vanden Heuvel discloses that activating entry key 40b when
`on the screen of Fig. 6 presents the menu shown in Fig. 7.
`(Ex. 1006 at 6:34-55.)
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-12
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 75-77.
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`and Osamu Disputed Claim Element
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 4
`
`Apparatus as defined in
`claim 1, wherein the
`information screens stored
`in the memory comprise one
`or more pre-game
`parameter recording
`information screens, one or
`more game-interactive
`recording information
`screens; and one or more
`post-game statistic report
`information screens.
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006) and
`Osamu (Ex. 1007)
`Pre-game screens: Palmer describes a personal database and a golf
`course database, also interactive training exercises. (Ex. 1005 at pp.
`10, 15, 17; pp. 12-13 (training exercises).)
`
`Game-interactive screens: Palmer describes a scorecard and club
`selection tips. (Ex. 1005 at pp. 10-11, 18-19.)
`
`Osamu describes a scorecard and a shot-tracker screen. (Ex. 1007 at
`pp. 18-19.)
`
`Post-game statistic report screens: Both Palmer and Osamu describe
`a variety of post-game performance analysis. (Ex. 1005 at p. 19; Ex.
`1007 at pp. 19-20.)
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-13
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 89-91.
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`and Osamu
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006)
`and Osamu (Ex. 1007)
`Palmer discloses “a detailed performance analysis of
`the round so far…” (Ex. 1005 at pp. 18-19.)
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶ 66.
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 5
`
`Apparatus as defined
`in claim 4,
`wherein the
`information screens
`further include one or
`more game-interactive
`fact report information
`screens.
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-14
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`and Osamu
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 13
`An apparatus for recording and reporting sports and game information to increase a player’s ability to improve from experience, the
`apparatus comprising:
`
`[a] a self-contained computer unit having a memory, a power
`source and a display for selectively displaying a plurality of
`information screens and associated data stored in the memory,
`the information screens including screen-dependent data input
`fields for the associated data;
`[b] a plurality of pre-game, game-interactive and post-game
`information screens stored in the memory of the computer unit;
`
`[c] means for displaying a pre-game information screen and
`prompting entry of data which defines parameters of an
`upcoming game, and means for subsequently displaying a game-
`interactive information screen corresponding to a game-
`interactive mode defined by the parameters selected in the pre-
`game information screen;
`[d] entry key means for changing information screens in
`sequential fashion, the entry key means comprising one entry key;
`
`[e] choice key means for non-sequential selection or changing of
`information screens the choice key means comprising one choice
`key;
`
`[f] field select key means for choosing a particular data input field
`on a displayed information screen, the field select key means
`comprising two bi-directional keys; and
`[g] value select key means for displaying and selectively recording
`data in the chosen data input field the value select key means
`comprising two bi-directional keys.
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-15
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`and Osamu
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 13 Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006)
`and Osamu (Ex. 1007)
`Palmer maintains a club selection database, golf course
`database, “interactive training exercises, player
`performance analysis and/or score keeping.” (Ex. 1005
`at p. 5.)
`
`An apparatus for
`recording and
`reporting sports and
`game information to
`increase a player’s
`ability to improve from
`experience, the
`apparatus comprising:
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-16
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`and Osamu
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 13
`
`[a] a self-contained
`computer unit having a
`memory, a power source
`and a display for
`selectively displaying a
`plurality of information
`screens and associated
`data stored in the
`memory, the information
`screens including screen-
`dependent data input
`fields for the associated
`data;
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006) and
`Osamu (Ex. 1007)
`Palmer: Memory, power source, display for selectively
`displaying a plurality of information screens and associated
`data stored in the memory. (Ex. 1005 at pp. 6, 9-10.)
`
`Vanden Heuvel: Memory, power source, display for
`selectively displaying a plurality of information screens and
`associated data stored in the memory. (Ex. 1006 at Abstract.)
`
`Vanden Heuvel includes screen-dependent data input fields
`adjusted using entry keys and bi-directional scroll keys. (Ex.
`1006 at 9:5-26.)
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 71-81.
`
`SkyHawke DX-17
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`and Osamu Disputed Claim Element
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 13
`
`[b] a plurality of pre-
`game, game-interactive
`and post-game
`information screens
`stored in the memory of
`the computer unit;
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006) and
`Osamu (Ex. 1007)
`Pre-game screens: Palmer describes a personal database and a golf
`course database, also interactive training exercises. (Ex. 1005 at pp.
`10, 15, 17; pp. 12-13 (training exercises).)
`
`Game-interactive screens: Palmer describes a scorecard and club
`selection tips. (Ex. 1005 at pp. 10-11, 18-19.)
`
`Osamu describes a scorecard and a shot-tracker screen. (Ex. 1007 at
`pp. 18-19.)
`
`Post-game statistic report screens: Both Palmer and Osamu describe
`a variety of post-game performance analysis. (Ex. 1005 at p. 19; Ex.
`1007 at pp. 19-20.)
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-18
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 89-91.
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`and Osamu
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 13
`
`[c] means for displaying a
`pre-game information
`screen and prompting entry
`of data which defines
`parameters of an upcoming
`game, and means for
`subsequently displaying a
`game-interactive
`information screen
`corresponding to a game-
`interactive mode defined by
`the parameters selected in
`the pre-game information
`screen;
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006) and
`Osamu (Ex. 1007)
`Pre-game screens: Palmer describes a personal database and a golf
`course database, also interactive training exercises. (Ex. 1005 at pp.
`10, 15, 17; pp. 12-13 (training exercises).)
`
`Game-interactive screens: Palmer describes a scorecard and club
`selection tips. (Ex. 1005 at pp. 10-11, 18-19.)
`
`Osamu describes a scorecard and a shot-tracker screen. (Ex. 1007 at
`pp. 18-19.)
`
`Vanden Heuvel discloses a plurality of user activated keys 40a-g that
`retrieve and selectively display information screens from the device’s
`memory. (Ex. 1006 at 5:48 – 6:33, 8:44 – 9:38.)
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 64-66, 72, 75-77.
`
`SkyHawke DX-19
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`and Osamu
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 13
`
`[d] entry key means for
`changing information
`screens in sequential
`fashion, the entry key
`means comprising one
`entry key;
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006) and
`Osamu (Ex. 1007)
`For example, operation of key 40a of Vanden Heuvel
`selectively displays any one of the desired information
`screens 206a-206d. (Ex. 1006 at 5:61-6:3.)
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶ 72.
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-20
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`and Osamu
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 13
`
`[e] choice key means for
`non-sequential selection
`or changing of
`information screens the
`choice key means
`comprising one choice
`key;
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006) and
`Osamu (Ex. 1007)
`Vanden Heuvel discloses that activating entry key 40b when
`on the screen of Fig. 2 presents the menu shown in Fig. 3.
`(Ex. 1006 at 5:23-37.)
`
`Vanden Heuvel discloses that activating entry key 40b when
`on the screen of Fig. 6 presents the menu shown in Fig. 7.
`(Ex. 1006 at 6:34-55.)
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-21
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 75-77.
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`and Osamu
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006) and
`Osamu (Ex. 1007)
`Operation of the bi-directional keys 40c-40f of Vanden Heuvel
`scroll in opposite directions through the data input fields
`(e.g., 400 and 416) on the displayed information screen. (Ex.
`1006 at 8:44 – 9:38, FIGS. 11 and 12.)
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 13
`
`[f] field select key means
`for choosing a particular
`data input field on a
`displayed information
`screen, the field select
`key means comprising
`two bi-directional keys;
`and
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-22
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 73-74.
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`and Osamu
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006) and
`Osamu (Ex. 1007)
`Operation of the bi-directional keys 40c and 40d of Vanden
`Heuvel scroll in opposite directions through the predefined
`data associated with the data input fields on the displayed
`information screen. (Ex. 1006 at 9:18-38, FIG. 12.)
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 13
`
`[g] value select key
`means for displaying and
`selectively recording
`data in the chosen data
`input field the value
`select key means
`comprising two bi-
`directional keys.
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-23
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 73-74.
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`and Osamu
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 17
`A handheld portable apparatus for recording and reporting golf information to increase a player’s ability to improve from
`experience, the apparatus comprising:
`
`[a] a self-contained computer unit having a memory, a
`power source and a display for selectively displaying a
`plurality of information screens and associated data stored
`in the memory, the information screens including screen-
`dependent data input fields for the associated data;
`[b] first key entry means for sequentially displaying one or
`more pre-game information screens in a pre-game mode of
`operation, and subsequently sequentially displaying one or
`more game-interactive information screens in a game-
`interactive mode of operation, the first key entry means
`comprising one entry key;
`[c] second key means for selecting a particular data field on
`a displayed information screen, the second key means
`comprising two bi-directional keys;
`
`[d] third key means for selectively recording or altering data
`in a selected data field, the third key means comprising two
`bi-directional keys; wherein,
`
`[e] the pre-game information screens include means for
`prompting the entry of data which defines parameters of an
`upcoming game, and means for selecting one of a plurality
`of game-interactive information screens representing
`different levels of data-recording detail in the game-
`interactive mode.
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-24
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`and Osamu
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 17 Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006)
`and Osamu (Ex. 1007)
`Palmer maintains a club selection database, golf course
`database, “interactive training exercises, player
`performance analysis and/or score keeping.” (Ex. 1005
`at p. 5.)
`
`A handheld portable
`apparatus for
`recording and
`reporting golf
`information to
`increase a player’s
`ability to improve from
`experience, the
`apparatus comprising:
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-25
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`and Osamu
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 17
`
`[a] a self-contained
`computer unit having a
`memory, a power source
`and a display for
`selectively displaying a
`plurality of information
`screens and associated
`data stored in the
`memory, the information
`screens including screen-
`dependent data input
`fields for the associated
`data;
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006) and
`Osamu (Ex. 1007)
`Palmer: Memory, power source, display for selectively
`displaying a plurality of information screens and associated
`data stored in the memory. (Ex. 1005 at pp. 6, 9-10.)
`
`Vanden Heuvel: Memory, power source, display for
`selectively displaying a plurality of information screens and
`associated data stored in the memory. (Ex. 1006 at Abstract.)
`
`Vanden Heuvel includes screen-dependent data input fields
`adjusted using entry keys and bi-directional scroll keys. (Ex.
`1006 at 9:5-26.)
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 71-81.
`
`SkyHawke DX-26
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`and Osamu Disputed Claim Element
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 17
`
`[b] first key entry means for
`sequentially displaying one
`or more pre-game
`information screens in a pre-
`game mode of operation,
`and subsequently
`sequentially displaying one
`or more game-interactive
`information screens in a
`game-interactive mode of
`operation, the first key entry
`means comprising one entry
`key;
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006) and
`Osamu (Ex. 1007)
`Pre-game screens: Palmer describes a personal database and a golf
`course database, also interactive training exercises. (Ex. 1005 at pp.
`10, 15, 17; pp. 12-13 (training exercises).)
`
`Game-interactive screens: Palmer describes a scorecard and club
`selection tips. (Ex. 1005 at pp. 10-11, 18-19.)
`
`Osamu describes a scorecard and a shot-tracker screen. (Ex. 1007 at
`pp. 18-19.)
`
`Vanden Heuvel discloses that operation of key 40a or 40b retrieves
`and selectively displays information screens from the device’s
`memory. (Ex. 1006 at 5:48 – 6:33, 8:44 – 9:38.)
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-27
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 64-66, 72, 75-77.
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`and Osamu
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 17
`
`[c] second key means for
`selecting a particular
`data field on a displayed
`information screen, the
`second key means
`comprising two bi-
`directional keys;
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006) and
`Osamu (Ex. 1007)
`Operation of the bi-directional keys 40c-40f of Vanden Heuvel
`scroll in opposite directions through the data input fields
`(e.g., 400 and 416) on the displayed information screen. (Ex.
`1006 at 8:44 – 9:38, FIGS. 11 and 12.)
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 73-74.
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-28
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`and Osamu
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006) and
`Osamu (Ex. 1007)
`Operation of the bi-directional keys 40c and 40d of Vanden
`Heuvel scroll in opposite directions through the predefined
`data associated with the data input fields on the displayed
`information screen. (Ex. 1006 at 9:18-38, FIG. 12.)
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 17
`
`[d] third key means for
`selectively recording or
`altering data in a
`selected data field, the
`third key means
`comprising two bi-
`directional keys;
`wherein,
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 73-74.
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-29
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Vanden Heuvel
`and Osamu
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 17
`
`[e] the pre-game
`information screens include
`means for prompting the
`entry of data which defines
`parameters of an upcoming
`game, and means for
`selecting one of a plurality
`of game-interactive
`information screens
`representing different levels
`of data-recording detail in
`the game-interactive mode.
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Vanden Heuvel (Ex. 1006) and
`Osamu (Ex. 1007)
`Pre-game screens: Palmer describes a personal database used in
`offering club suggestions and a golf course database used with the
`scorecard and performance analysis. (Ex. 1005 at pp. 10, 15, 17.)
`
`Game-interactive screens: Palmer describes a scorecard and club
`selection tips. (Ex. 1005 at pp. 10-11, 18-19.)
`
`Osamu describes a scorecard and a shot-tracker screen. (Ex. 1007 at
`pp. 18-19.)
`
`Vanden Heuvel discloses that operation of key 40a or 40b retrieves
`and selectively displays information screens from the device’s
`memory. (Ex. 1006 at 5:48 – 6:33, 8:44 – 9:38.)
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-30
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 89-98.
`
`

`

`Ground of Institution (437 IPR)
`
` Claims 8-11, 14, and 18 are rendered obvious by
`Palmer, Osamu, and Vanden Heuvel
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-31
`
`

`

`‘566 Patent – Claim 8
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 14
`
`A method for recording and reporting
`golf information to increase a player’s ability to improve from
`experience, comprising the following steps:
`[a] storing a plurality of pre-game, game-interactive and post-game
`information screens in a memory of a computer unit having a
`display for selectively displaying one or more of the information
`screens,
`[b] the information screens including screen-dependent data input
`fields for entry of data;
`[c] displaying in sequential fashion one or more pre-game
`information screens and prompting entry of data which defines
`parameters of an upcoming game;
`[d] providing a choice among a plurality of game-interactive
`information screens for recording data during the game defined by
`the parameters entered in the pre-game information screens;
`[e] displaying a chosen game-interactive information screen;
`
`A method for recording and reporting golf information to increase
`a player’s ability to improve from experience, comprising the
`following steps:
`[a] storing a plurality of pre-game, game-interactive and post-game
`information screens in a memory of computer unit having a display
`for selectively displaying one or more of the information screens,
`
`[b] the information screens including screen-dependent data input
`fields for entry of data;
`[c] displaying in sequential fashion one or more pre-game
`information screens and prompting entry of data which defines
`parameters of an upcoming game;
`[d] providing a choice among a plurality of game-interactive
`information screens for recording data during the game defined by
`the parameters entered in the pre-game information screens;
`[e] displaying a chosen game-interactive information screen;
`
`[f] entering data in the chosen game-interactive information screen
`corresponding to a game as the game is played, and simultaneously
`recording entered data in the memory of the computer unit;
`[g] providing post-game reports based on the data entered in the
`game-interactive information screen; and
`[h] providing one or more game-interactive advice/feedback
`information screens.
`
`[f] entering data in a chosen game-interactive information screen
`corresponding to a game as the game is played, and simultaneously
`recording the entered data in the memory of the computer unit;
`[g] providing post-game reports based on the data entered in the
`game-interactive information screen; wherein,
`[h] the game-interactive information screens comprise a first
`information screen with a first detail level of recording, and a
`second information screen with a second detail level of recording.
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-32
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Osamu and
`Vanden Heuvel
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 8
`
`A method for recording and
`reporting golf information to
`increase a player’s ability to
`improve from experience,
`comprising the following
`steps:
`‘566 Patent – Claim 14
`A method for recording and
`reporting golf information to
`increase a player’s ability to
`improve from experience,
`comprising the following
`steps:
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Osamu (Ex. 1006) and Vanden
`Heuvel (Ex. 1007)
`Palmer maintains a club selection database, golf course
`database, “interactive training exercises, player performance
`analysis and/or score keeping.” (Ex. 1005 at p. 5.)
`
`SkyHawke DX-33
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Osamu and
`Vanden Heuvel Disputed Claim Element
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 8
`
`[a] storing a plurality of pre-
`game, game-interactive and
`post-game information screens
`in a memory of a computer unit
`having a display for selectively
`displaying one or more of the
`information screens,
`‘566 Patent – Claim 14
`[a] storing a plurality of pre-
`game, game-interactive and
`post-game information screens
`in a memory of a computer unit
`having a display for selectively
`displaying one or more of the
`information screens,
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Osamu (Ex. 1006) and Vanden
`Heuvel (Ex. 1007)
`Pre-game screens: Palmer describes a personal database and a golf
`course database, also interactive training exercises. (Ex. 1005 at pp.
`10, 15, 17; pp. 12-13 (training exercises).)
`
`Game-interactive screens: Palmer describes a scorecard and club
`selection tips. (Ex. 1005 at pp. 10-11, 18-19.)
`
`Osamu describes a scorecard and a shot-tracker screen. (Ex. 1006 at
`pp. 18-19.)
`
`Post-game statistic report screens: Both Palmer and Osamu describe
`a variety of post-game performance analysis. (Ex. 1005 at p. 19; Ex.
`1006 at pp. 19-20.)
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 58-60.
`
`SkyHawke DX-34
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Osamu and
`Vanden Heuvel
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Osamu (Ex. 1006) and Vanden
`Heuvel (Ex. 1007)
`Vanden Heuvel includes screen-dependent data input fields
`adjusted using entry keys and bi-directional scroll keys. (Ex.
`1007 at 9:5-26.)
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 26-29, 68-74, 78-82.
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 8
`
`[b] the information
`screens including screen-
`dependent data input
`fields for entry of data;
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 14
`[b] the information
`screens including screen-
`dependent data input
`fields for entry of data;
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-35
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Osamu and
`Vanden Heuvel Disputed Claim Element
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 8
`
`[c] displaying in sequential
`fashion one or more pre-
`game information screens
`and prompting entry of data
`which defines parameters of
`an upcoming game;
`‘566 Patent – Claim 14
`[c] displaying in sequential
`fashion one or more pre-
`game information screens
`and prompting entry of data
`which defines parameters of
`an upcoming game;
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Osamu (Ex. 1006) and Vanden
`Heuvel (Ex. 1007)
`Pre-game screens: Palmer describes a personal database used
`in offering club suggestions and a golf course database used
`with the scorecard and performance analysis. (Ex. 1005 at pp.
`10, 15, 17.)
`
`Vanden Heuvel describes displaying Quick View screens (206a
`– 206d) automatically, or in sequence, or manually and non-
`sequentially. (Ex. 1007 at 5:61 – 6:19.)
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 75-82.
`
`SkyHawke DX-36
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Osamu and
`Vanden Heuvel
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 8
`
`[d] providing a choice among a
`plurality of game-interactive
`information screens for
`recording data during the game
`defined by the parameters
`entered in the pre-game
`information screens;
`‘566 Patent – Claim 14
`[d] providing a choice among a
`plurality of game-interactive
`information screens for
`recording data during the game
`defined by the parameters
`entered in the pre-game
`information screens;
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Osamu (Ex. 1006) and Vanden
`Heuvel (Ex. 1007)
`Game-interactive screens: Palmer describes a scorecard and
`club selection tips. (Ex. 1005 at pp. 10-11, 18-19.)
`
`Osamu describes a scorecard and a shot-tracker screen. (Ex.
`1006 at pp. 18-19.)
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 48-50, 55, 58-66.
`
`SkyHawke DX-37
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Osamu and
`Vanden Heuvel
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 8
`
`[e] displaying a chosen
`game-interactive
`information screen;
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 14
`[e] displaying a chosen
`game-interactive
`information screen;
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Osamu (Ex. 1006) and Vanden
`Heuvel (Ex. 1007)
`Game-interactive screens: Palmer describes a scorecard and
`club selection tips. (Ex. 1005 at pp. 10-11, 18-19.)
`
`Osamu describes a scorecard and a shot-tracker screen. (Ex.
`1006 at pp. 18-19.)
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 50 and 55.
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`SkyHawke DX-38
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Osamu and
`Vanden Heuvel
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 8
`
`[f] entering data in the chosen
`game-interactive information
`screen corresponding to a game
`as the game is played, and
`simultaneously recording entered
`data in the memory of the
`computer unit;
`‘566 Patent – Claim 14
`[f] entering data in a chosen
`game-interactive information
`screen corresponding to a game
`as the game is played, and
`simultaneously recording the
`entered data in the memory of
`the computer unit;
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Osamu (Ex. 1006) and Vanden
`Heuvel (Ex. 1007)
`Game-interactive screens: Palmer describes a scorecard and
`club selection tips. (Ex. 1005 at pp. 10-11, 18-19.)
`
`Osamu describes a scorecard and a shot-tracker screen. (Ex.
`1006 at pp. 18-19.)
`
`Ex. 1012 at ¶¶ 50 and 55.
`
`SkyHawke DX-39
`
`

`

`Palmer in view of Osamu and
`Vanden Heuvel
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 8
`
`[g] providing post-game
`reports based on the data
`entered in the game-
`interactive information
`screen; and
`
`‘566 Patent – Claim 14
`[g] providing post-game
`reports based on the data
`entered in the game-
`interactive information
`screen; wherein,
`
`IPR2014-00437/438
`
`Palmer (Ex. 1005) in view of Osamu (Ex. 1006) and Vanden
`Heuvel (Ex. 1007)
`Post-game report: Both Palmer and Osamu describe a variety
`of post-game performance analysis. (Ex. 1005 at