`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/7/2014
`
`1
`
`
`UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`
`
`
`
`BEFORE THE PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`
` !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
`
`
`IICRO MOTION,
`INC.,
`
` "#$#$%&"'
`Petitioner,
`
`IPR2014-00167
`!()!*)" %) !
`
`IPR2014-0017O
` !
`
`
`
`
`
`at 4:25 p.m.
`
`IPR2014-00178
` !
`
` +
`,
`
`,
`
`
!-
`INVENSYS SYSTEMS,
`INC.,
`IPR2014-00179
`
`-
`
`Patent Owner.
`Volume II
` *#"&#.&"' +%/01"
`
` !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
`
`
`
` +$2"%3*1$&*#$%&%4
`
`INVENSYS SYSTEMS,
`INC.,
`IPR2014-00179
`
`-
`
`Patent Owner.
`Volume II
` *#"&#.&"' +%/01"
`
` !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
`
`
`
` +$2"%3*1$&*#$%&%4
`
`Video Examination of MICHAEL D. SIDMAN,
`
`
#*5"&*##"$&)#*&6"%4#"
*#"&#.&"'
0&2"'
`Ph.D.,
`taken at the instance of the Patent Owner, under
`
` *&270')0*&##%
`8*98989*&2
`and pursuant
`to 35 USC 316(a)(5)(A) and 37 C.F.R.
`
` 829
`Ph.D.,
`taken at the instance of the Patent Owner, under
`
` *&270')0*&##%
`8*98989*&2
`and pursuant
`to 35 USC 316(a)(5)(A) and 37 C.F.R.
`
` 829
:"4%'";
`
`
* "<$)#"'"2
`42.53(d), before JENNIFER L. SCHMALING,
`a Registered
`
` "'$# "7%'#"'
`42.53(d), before JENNIFER L. SCHMALING,
`a Registered
`
` "'$# "7%'#"'
"'#$4$"2 "*/#$1" "7%'#"'
"'#$4$"2
`Ierit Reporter, Certified Realtime Reporter, Certified
`
` '%*26*)#*7#$%&"'*&2 %#*'= 0:/$6$&*&24%'#"
`Broadcast Captioner and Notary Public in and for the
`
`-
`#*#"%4>$)6%&)$&
`Ierit Reporter, Certified Realtime Reporter, Certified
`
` '%*26*)#*7#$%&"'*&2 %#*'= 0:/$6$&*&24%'#"
`Broadcast Captioner and Notary Public in and for the
`
`-
`#*#"%4>$)6%&)$&
*# %/"=?*'2&"'
*)#
`State of Wisconsin, at Foley & Lardner, 777 East
`
` >$)6%&)$&("&0"
`State of Wisconsin, at Foley & Lardner, 777 East
`
` >$)6%&)$&("&0"
$/.*05""
>$)6%&)$&
%&
`isconsin Avenue, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, on
`
` 0<0)#
`isconsin Avenue, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, on
`
` 0<0)#
6%11"&6$&<*#-@* 1 *&26%&6/02$&<
`August 7, 2014, commencing at 9:07 a.m. and concluding
`
` *#@7 1
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`
`Invensys Ex. 2022
`713-653-7100
`Micro Motion v Invensys |PR2014-00393
`
`
`August 7, 2014, commencing at 9:07 a.m. and concluding
`
` *#@7 1
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`
`Invensys Ex. 2022
`713-653-7100
`Micro Motion v Invensys |PR2014-00393
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/7/2014
`
`2
`
`
`A P P E A R A N C E S
`
`
`
`
` ,?
:=
`FOLEY & LARDNER, by
` ; ,
`
`
`FOLEY & LARDNER, by
` ; ,
`
`
`IR.
`JEFFREY N. COSTAKOS,
`IS. KADIE M.
`JELENCHICK,
`
` ;
` *)#>$)6%&)$&("&0"
`777 East Wisconsin Avenue,
` $/.*05""
>$)6%&)$&
`Iilwaukee, Wisconsin 53202,
` *77"*'"2%&:"*/4%4#" "#$#$%&"'
`appeared on behalf of the Petitioner.
`
:=
`DLA PIPER LLP, by
` ;
` ]
`DLA PIPER LLP, by
` ;
` ]
`IR.
`JAMES M. HEINTZ,
` - '""2%1'$("
`0$#"
`11911 Freedom Drive, Suite 300,
` ")#%&
+$'<$&$*-!
`Reston, Virginia 20190-5602,
` *77"*'"2%&:"*/4%4#" *#"&#.&"'
`appeared on behalf of the Patent Owner.
`-
:=
`DLA PIPER LLP, by
` ; , ;
`
`DLA PIPER LLP, by
` ; , ;
`
`IR.
`JEFFREY L.
`JOHNSON,
` %0$)$*&*
`0$#"
`1000 Louisiana, Suite 2800,
` %0)#%&
"3*)
`Houston, Texas 77002,
` *77"*'"2%&:"*/4%4#" *#"&#.&"'
`appeared on behalf of the Patent Owner.
`
:=
`DLA PIPER LLP, by
` >
`
`
`DLA PIPER LLP, by
` >
`
`
`IR. EDWARD H. SIKORSKI,
`
`#'""#
`0$#"
`401 B Street, Suite 1700 ,
`
`*&$"<%
*/$4%'&$*-!-
`San Diego, California 92101-4297,
` *77"*'"2%&:"*/4%4#" *#"&#.&"'
`appeared on behalf of the Patent Owner.
`
`
`A L S O
`P R E S E N T
`
`
`
`
`
`
` ' ;%&
`7%&%/#^
+
`
`
+$2"%<'*7"'
`
`
` _____
`- `
`
`
`John Sponholtz, CLVS, Videographer.
`
`3*1$&*#$%&@ *<"
`
` = ' "$&#^
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
` _____
`- `
`
`
`John Sponholtz, CLVS, Videographer.
`
`3*1$&*#$%&@ *<"
`
` = ' "$&#^
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph. D.
`
`
`
`
`8/7/2014
`
`
`
` _____
`
` `
`
`
`
`
`
`3$:$# 2"&#$4$"2@ *<"
`
`Declaration Of Dr. Michael Sidman In
` % -!"6/*'*#$%&4' $6*"/
`$21*& &
`
`Connection With IPR2014-00170 Which
` %&&"6#$%&>$# !>$6
`
`24
`%&6"'&)
` *#"&#
`Concerns U.S. Patent 6,311,136 ..........
`
`24
` % !
` *#"&# %
`o. 2030 - U.S. Patent No. 6,311,136 ...............
`*
`*
`*
`*
`*
` _____
`
`goooqow
`
`3
`
` $)7%)$#$%&4'$<$&*/3$:$#)@
`Disposition Of Original Exhibits:
`
`- "#0'&"2 % $7"'
`Returned To DLA Piper LLP
`
`_____
`
`10
`
`
`11
`
`
`12
`
`
`13
`
`
`14
`
`
`15
`
`
`16
`
`
`17
`
`
`18
`
`
`19
`-
`
`20
`
`
`21
`
`
`22
`
`
`23
`
`
`24
`
`
`25
`
`
`U. S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/7/2014
`
`4
`
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
`
`
`
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` + @>"*'"%44$6$*//=%&
`THE VIDEOGRAPHER:
`We are officially on
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`#"'"6%'2*#-@* 1 %2*=a)2*#"$)
`the record at 9:07 a.m. Today's date is
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`0<0)##
$)$)$)5 %
+%/01" $&
`August 7th, 2014.
`This is Disk No. 1, Volume II in
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`#"2"7%)$#$%&%4' $6*"/
`$21*&
`the deposition of Dr. Michael Sidman.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` $)2"7%)$#$%&$):"$&<#*5"&$&#"
`This deposition is being taken in the
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`1*##"' $6'% %#$%&
`August 7th, 2014.
`This is Disk No. 1, Volume II in
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`#"2"7%)$#$%&%4' $6*"/
`$21*&
`the deposition of Dr. Michael Sidman.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` $)2"7%)$#$%&$):"$&<#*5"&$&#"
`This deposition is being taken in the
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`1*##"' $6'% %#$%&
&6%'7%'*#"2
"#$#$%&"'
`matter Micro Motion,
`Incorporated, Petitioner,
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`("')0) *#"&#.&"' &("&)=)
`=)#"1)
&6%'7%'*#"2
`versus Patent Owner Invensys Systems,
`Incorporated.
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
` $)1*##"'$)7"&2$&<:"4%'"#" *#"&# '$*/*&2
`This matter is pending before the Patent Trial and
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`77"*/ %*'2
`versus Patent Owner Invensys Systems,
`Incorporated.
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
` $)1*##"'$)7"&2$&<:"4%'"#" *#"&# '$*/*&2
`This matter is pending before the Patent Trial and
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`77"*/ %*'2
&$#"2
`#*#") *#"&#*&2 '*2"1*'5
`Appeal Board, United States Patent and Trademark
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`44$6"
`#*#") *#"&#*&2 '*2"1*'5
`Appeal Board, United States Patent and Trademark
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`44$6"
*)") %
!-
!
!
`Office, Cases No.
`IPR2014-l69, 2014-170, 2014-178
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`*&2!- $)2"7%)$#$%&$):"$&<#*5"&*#
`and 2014-179.
`This deposition is being taken at
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`#"%44$6")%4 %/"=?*'2&"'/%6*#"2*#*)#
`the offices of Foley & Lardner located at 777 East
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`>$)6%&)$&("&0"
`Office, Cases No.
`IPR2014-l69, 2014-170, 2014-178
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`*&2!- $)2"7%)$#$%&$):"$&<#*5"&*#
`and 2014-179.
`This deposition is being taken at
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`#"%44$6")%4 %/"=?*'2&"'/%6*#"2*#*)#
`the offices of Foley & Lardner located at 777 East
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`>$)6%&)$&("&0"
$/.*05""
>$)6%&)$&
`Wisconsin Avenue, Milwaukee, Wisconsin.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` =&*1"$);%&
`7%&%/#^
`Wisconsin Avenue, Milwaukee, Wisconsin.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` =&*1"$);%&
`7%&%/#^
($2"%<'*7"'
`My name is John Spohnholtz, videographer
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4%'
` "<*/
`My name is John Spohnholtz, videographer
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4%'
` "<*/
*&2#"6%0'#'"7%'#"'$);"&&$4"'
`for U.S. Legal, and the court reporter is Jennifer
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`
`61*/$&< >$//6%0&)"/7/"*)")#*#"#"$'
`Schmaling. Will counsel please state their
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`*77"*'*&6")*&2.%1#"='"7'")"&#
`for U.S. Legal, and the court reporter is Jennifer
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`
`61*/$&< >$//6%0&)"/7/"*)")#*#"#"$'
`Schmaling. Will counsel please state their
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`*77"*'*&6")*&2.%1#"='"7'")"&#
:"<$&&$&<.$#
`appearances and whom they represent, beginning with
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`7"#$#$%&"'a)6%0&)"/ "&#"'"7%'#"'.$//)."*'
`petitioner‘s counsel.
`Then the reporter will swear
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`in the witness.
`$&#".$#&"))
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@;"44%)#*5%)
`appearances and whom they represent, beginning with
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`7"#$#$%&"'a)6%0&)"/ "&#"'"7%'#"'.$//)."*'
`petitioner‘s counsel.
`Then the reporter will swear
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`in the witness.
`$&#".$#&"))
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@;"44%)#*5%)
%/"=?
`MR. COSTAKOS:
`Jeff Costakos, Foley &
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`*'2&"'
`MR. COSTAKOS:
`Jeff Costakos, Foley &
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`*'2&"'
4%'
"#$#$%&"'
$6'% %#$%&
*&24%'#"
`Lardner,
`for Petitioner, Micro Motion, and for the
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`witness.
`.$#&"))
`
`Invensys Systems.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` ]@;*1") "$&^4'%1 $7"'
`MR. HEINTZ:
`James Heinz from DLA Piper
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4%' *#"&#.&"'
`Lardner,
`for Petitioner, Micro Motion, and for the
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`witness.
`.$#&"))
`
`Invensys Systems.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` ]@;*1") "$&^4'%1 $7"'
`MR. HEINTZ:
`James Heinz from DLA Piper
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4%' *#"&#.&"'
&("&)=)
`=)#"1)
`for Patent Owner,
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`=)#"1)
`for Patent Owner,
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/7/2014
`
`5
`
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`MR. SIKORSKI:
`Edward Sikorski of DLA
`
`
` @2.*'2
`$5%')5$%4
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` $7"'
*/)%4%' &("&)=)
`Piper, also for Invensys.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` ;
` @&2;"44'"=;%&)%&
`Piper, also for Invensys.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` ;
` @&2;"44'"=;%&)%&
`MR.
`JOHNSON:
`And Jeffrey Johnson, DLA
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` $7"'
*/)%4%' &("&)=)
`=)#"1)
`Piper, also for Invensys Systems.
`
`
`
`=)#"1)
`Piper, also for Invensys Systems.
`
`
`
6*//"2*)*
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D., called as a
`
` .$#&"))"'"$&
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D., called as a
`
` .$#&"))"'"$&
*($&<:""&4$')#20/=).%'&%&
`witness herein, having been first duly sworn on
`
` %*#
`witness herein, having been first duly sworn on
`
` %*#
.*)"3*1$&"2*&2#")#$4$"2*)4%//%.)@
`oath, was examined and testified as follows:
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`EXAMINATION
``
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`BY MR. HEINTZ:
` , ]@
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b%%21%'&$&<*<*$&
`oath, was examined and testified as follows:
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`EXAMINATION
``
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`BY MR. HEINTZ:
` , ]@
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b%%21%'&$&<*<*$&
'
`$21*&
`Good morning again, Dr. Sidman.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`%%21%'&$&<
`Good morning.
`
`BY MR. HEINTZ:
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b
`$'
`$21*&
`Good morning again, Dr. Sidman.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`%%21%'&$&<
`Good morning.
`
`BY MR. HEINTZ:
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b
`$'
*("=%0*2*&=)0:)#*&#$("6%&("')*#$%&)
`Sir, have you had any substantive conversations
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`)$&6"."/"4##"'%%1=")#"'2*=*:%0##"
`since we left the room yesterday about
`the
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`)0:)#*&6"%4#$)2"7%)$#$%&c
`substance of this deposition?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`No.
` %
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b *("=%0%("'"*'2*&=6%&("')*#$%&)*:%0##"
`Have you overheard any conversations about
`the
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`)0:)#*&6"%4#$)2"7%)$#$%&c
`substance of this deposition?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`No.
` %
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`b5*=
`$'
`Sir, have you had any substantive conversations
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`)$&6"."/"4##"'%%1=")#"'2*=*:%0##"
`since we left the room yesterday about
`the
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`)0:)#*&6"%4#$)2"7%)$#$%&c
`substance of this deposition?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`No.
` %
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b *("=%0%("'"*'2*&=6%&("')*#$%&)*:%0##"
`Have you overheard any conversations about
`the
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`)0:)#*&6"%4#$)2"7%)$#$%&c
`substance of this deposition?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`No.
` %
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`b5*=
`$'
a1<%$&<#%*)5=%0#%#0'&#%=%0'
`Okay. Sir,
`I'm going to ask you to turn to your
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`"37"'#'"7%'#.$6*):""&1*'5"2*)3$:$#
`expert report which has been marked as Exhibit 2023
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`7'"($%0)/=*&2$&7*'#$60/*'#%#0'&#%7*'*<'*7)
`previously and in particular to turn to paragraphs
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`122 and 123.
`*&2
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`
`
`@$2=%0)*=ddc
`MR. COSTAKOS: Did you say "122"?
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
` ]@ 2$2
`Okay. Sir,
`I'm going to ask you to turn to your
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`"37"'#'"7%'#.$6*):""&1*'5"2*)3$:$#
`expert report which has been marked as Exhibit 2023
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`7'"($%0)/=*&2$&7*'#$60/*'#%#0'&#%7*'*<'*7)
`previously and in particular to turn to paragraphs
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`122 and 123.
`*&2
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`
`
`@$2=%0)*=ddc
`MR. COSTAKOS: Did you say "122"?
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
` ]@ 2$2
=")
`MR. HEINTZ:
`I did, yes.
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
` , ]@
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`MR. HEINTZ:
`I did, yes.
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
` , ]@
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/7/2014
`
`6
`
`
`
`
`b5*=
`$'
.%0/2=%0*<'""#*#.*#=%02")6'$:"
`Okay. Sir, would you agree that what you describe
`
`$&7*'*<'*7)*&2$)*)=&#")$)1%2"4%'
`in paragraphs 122 and 123 is a synthesis mode for
`
`<"&"'*#$&<#"2'$(")$<&*/)c
`generating the drive signals?
`
`
`
`@:e"6#$%& %'1
`MR. COSTAKOS: Objection.
`Form.
`
` >
`
`@
`%=%0*("&a#<$("&1"*
`THE WITNESS:
`So you haven't given me a
`
`
`
`0%
`0%
`40
`-@-@
`
`0%
`0%
`42
`-@-@
`
`47
`0%
`0%
`-@-@
`
`0%
`53
`-@-@
`
`0%
`Q5
`-@@
`
`0%
`Q7
`-@@
`
`0%
`Q8
`-@@
`
`0%
`Q8
`-@@
`
`0%
`Q9
`-@@-
`
`0%
`$0
`-@@
`
`0%
`$1
`-@@
`
`0%
`$3
`-@@
`
`0%
`$4
`-@@
`
`M5
`0%
`-@@
`
`0%
`M8
`-@@
`
`0%
`53
`-@@
`
`0%
`£6
`-@@
`
`0%
`59
`-@@-
`
`0%
`:m
`-@@
`
`0%
`$4
`-@@
`
`0%
`$5
`-@@
`
`0%
`$6
`-@@
`
`0%
`$8
`-@@
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`-
`
`
`
`11
`
`
`12
`
`
`13
`
`
`14
`
`
`15
`
`
`16
`
`
`17
`
`
`18
`
`
`19
`-
`
`20
`
`
`21
`
`
`22
`
`
`23
`
`
`6%7=%4 $//"'="#
`copy of Miller yet.
`
`BY MR. HEINTZ:
` , ]@
`
`b,%0)%0/2*("$#4'%1=")#"'2*=
`You should have it from yesterday.
`
`MR. COSTAKOS:
`I
`think it's in there.
`
`
`@ #$&5$#a)$&#"'"
`
` >
`
`@ #a))%1"7/*6"
`THE WITNESS:
`It's some place.
`
`BY MR. HEINTZ:
` , ]@
`
`b
`Okay. Sir, would you agree that what you describe
`
`$&7*'*<'*7)*&2$)*)=&#")$)1%2"4%'
`in paragraphs 122 and 123 is a synthesis mode for
`
`<"&"'*#$&<#"2'$(")$<&*/)c
`generating the drive signals?
`
`
`
`@:e"6#$%& %'1
`MR. COSTAKOS: Objection.
`Form.
`
` >
`
`@
`%=%0*("&a#<$("&1"*
`THE WITNESS:
`So you haven't given me a
`
`
`
`0%
`0%
`40
`-@-@
`
`0%
`0%
`42
`-@-@
`
`47
`0%
`0%
`-@-@
`
`0%
`53
`-@-@
`
`0%
`Q5
`-@@
`
`0%
`Q7
`-@@
`
`0%
`Q8
`-@@
`
`0%
`Q8
`-@@
`
`0%
`Q9
`-@@-
`
`0%
`$0
`-@@
`
`0%
`$1
`-@@
`
`0%
`$3
`-@@
`
`0%
`$4
`-@@
`
`M5
`0%
`-@@
`
`0%
`M8
`-@@
`
`0%
`53
`-@@
`
`0%
`£6
`-@@
`
`0%
`59
`-@@-
`
`0%
`:m
`-@@
`
`0%
`$4
`-@@
`
`0%
`$5
`-@@
`
`0%
`$6
`-@@
`
`0%
`$8
`-@@
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`-
`
`
`
`11
`
`
`12
`
`
`13
`
`
`14
`
`
`15
`
`
`16
`
`
`17
`
`
`18
`
`
`19
`-
`
`20
`
`
`21
`
`
`22
`
`
`23
`
`
`6%7=%4 $//"'="#
`copy of Miller yet.
`
`BY MR. HEINTZ:
` , ]@
`
`b,%0)%0/2*("$#4'%1=")#"'2*=
`You should have it from yesterday.
`
`MR. COSTAKOS:
`I
`think it's in there.
`
`
`@ #$&5$#a)$&#"'"
`
` >
`
`@ #a))%1"7/*6"
`THE WITNESS:
`It's some place.
`
`BY MR. HEINTZ:
` , ]@
`
`b
*&2#"=a'"$&%'2"'
)%$#)%0/2:"!!
`2028, and they're in order,
`so it should be --
`
` 7'%:*:/=#%%5$#%0#%4%'2"' 5*= %#$#
`I probably took it out of order. Okay. Got it.
`
`think that‘s a fair characterization.
`#$&5#*#a)*4*$'6*'*6#"'$^*#$%&
`
`b5*= )&a#$##'0"#*##"%&/=2$44"'"&6"
`Okay.
`Isn‘t it true that the only difference
`
`:"#.""&#".$2":*&24'"f0"&6=).""7*&2#"
`between the wide band frequency sweep and the
`
`&*''%.:*&2!!)%''=
`2028, and they're in order,
`so it should be --
`
` 7'%:*:/=#%%5$#%0#%4%'2"' 5*= %#$#
`I probably took it out of order. Okay. Got it.
`
`think that‘s a fair characterization.
`#$&5#*#a)*4*$'6*'*6#"'$^*#$%&
`
`b5*= )&a#$##'0"#*##"%&/=2$44"'"&6"
`Okay.
`Isn‘t it true that the only difference
`
`:"#.""&#".$2":*&24'"f0"&6=).""7*&2#"
`between the wide band frequency sweep and the
`
`&*''%.:*&2!!)%''=
#"&*''%.4'"f0"&6=:*&2
`narrow band -- sorry,
`the narrow frequency band
`
`).""7'"4"''"2#%$&7*'*<'*7$)#":*&2%4
`sweep referred to in paragraph 122 is the band of
`
`4'"f0"&6$")0)"2."&2'$($&<#"4/%.#0:"c
`$'
`narrow band -- sorry,
`the narrow frequency band
`
`).""7'"4"''"2#%$&7*'*<'*7$)#":*&2%4
`sweep referred to in paragraph 122 is the band of
`
`4'"f0"&6$")0)"2."&2'$($&<#"4/%.#0:"c
`$'
`frequencies used when driving the flowtube? Sir,
`
`1*= *)5=%0#%'"*2$&#%#"'"6%'2#"2%601"&#
`may I ask you to read into the record the document
`
`=%0a'"/%%5$&<*#'$<#&%.c
`you‘re looking at right now?
`
`MR. COSTAKOS:
`Read into the record?
`
`
`@ "*2$&#%#"'"6%'2c
`
`MR. HEINTZ: Yeah.
` ]@,"*
`
`0%
`$8
`-@@
`
`24
`
`
`MR. COSTAKOS:
`You mean the name of it?
`
`
`@,%01"*&#"&*1"%4$#c
`
` , ]@
`
`25 BY MR. HEINTZ:
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/7/2014
`
`7
`
`
`0%
`$9
`-@@-
`
`
`
`b ""3$:$#&01:"'
#"2%601"&#=%0a'"/%%5$&<*#
`The exhibit number,
`the document you're looking at
`
`
`
`0%
`M2
`-@@
`
`M5
`0%
`-@@
`
`0%
`M6
`-@@
`
`0%
`$3
`-@@
`
`0%
`$5
`-@@
`
`55
`0%
`-@@
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`'$<#&%.
`right now.
`
`2024.
`
`
`b *&5=%0
`Thank you.
`
`5*= %0/2 *("#*#f0")#$%&%&"1%'"#$1"
`The exhibit number,
`the document you're looking at
`
`
`
`0%
`M2
`-@@
`
`M5
`0%
`-@@
`
`0%
`M6
`-@@
`
`0%
`$3
`-@@
`
`0%
`$5
`-@@
`
`55
`0%
`-@@
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`'$<#&%.
`right now.
`
`2024.
`
`
`b *&5=%0
`Thank you.
`
`5*= %0/2 *("#*#f0")#$%&%&"1%'"#$1"
`Okay. Could I have that question one more time,
`
`7/"*)"c
`please?
`
`8 %//%.$&<f0")#$%&'"*2 9
`(Following question read.)
`
`
`
` b )&a#$##'0"#*##"%&/=
`Q
`Isn't it true that the only
`
`difference between the wide band
`- 2$44"'"&6":"#.""&#".$2":*&2
`
` 4'"f0"&6=).""7*&2#"&*''%.
`frequency sweep and the narrow
`
`11
` :*&2!!)%''=
#"&*''%.4'"f0"&6=
`band -- sorry,
`the narrow frequency
`
`12
` :*&2).""7'"4"''"2#%$&7*'*<'*7
`band sweep referred to in paragraph
`
`13
` $)#":*&2%44'"f0"&6$")0)"2
`122 is the band of frequencies used
`
`0%
`£6
`-@@
`
`0%
`56
`-@@
`
`0%
`:M
`-@@
`
`0%
`:H
`-@@
`
`0%
`Q0
`-@@
`
`0%
`Q4
`-@@
`
`0%
`$0
`-@@
`
`0%
`$6
`-@@
`
`0%
`M6
`-@@
`
`55
`0%
`-@@
`
`0%
`:M
`-@@
`
`
`
`14
`
`
`15
`
`
`16
`
`
`17
`
`
`18
`
`
`19
`-
`
`20
`
`
`21
`
`
`22
`
`
`23
`
`
`24
`
`
`."&2'$($&<#"4/%.#0:"c
`when driving the flowtube?
`
` >
`
`@>"//
`band -- sorry,
`the narrow frequency
`
`12
` :*&2).""7'"4"''"2#%$&7*'*<'*7
`band sweep referred to in paragraph
`
`13
` $)#":*&2%44'"f0"&6$")0)"2
`122 is the band of frequencies used
`
`0%
`£6
`-@@
`
`0%
`56
`-@@
`
`0%
`:M
`-@@
`
`0%
`:H
`-@@
`
`0%
`Q0
`-@@
`
`0%
`Q4
`-@@
`
`0%
`$0
`-@@
`
`0%
`$6
`-@@
`
`0%
`M6
`-@@
`
`55
`0%
`-@@
`
`0%
`:M
`-@@
`
`
`
`14
`
`
`15
`
`
`16
`
`
`17
`
`
`18
`
`
`19
`-
`
`20
`
`
`21
`
`
`22
`
`
`23
`
`
`24
`
`
`."&2'$($&<#"4/%.#0:"c
`when driving the flowtube?
`
` >
`
`@>"//
=")*&2&% %
`THE WITNESS: Well, yes and no.
`No
`
`:"6*0)"#"6%170#"'
`THE WITNESS: Well, yes and no.
`No
`
`:"6*0)"#"6%170#"'
%'#"1$6'%7'%6"))%'
`because the computer, or the microprocessor,
`
`6%%)")"$#"'*.$2":*&2%'*&*''%.:*&2).""7
`chooses either a wide band or a narrow band sweep
`
`2"7"&2$&<%&#")$#0*#$%&$#7"'6"$(")$&#"
`depending on the situation it perceives in the
`
`4/%.#0:"
`%#")$<&*/$)6%170#"2#.%2$44"'"&#
`flowtube.
`So the signal
`is computed two different
`
`.*=)2"7"&2$&<%&#"1%2"#*##"6%170#"'
`ways depending on the mode that the computer
`
`"17/%=)#%7"'4%'1#$))"*'6%')6*&%').""7
`employs to perform this search or scan or sweep.
`
`,"):"6*0)"#"!!#":*&2)*'":%#4'"f0"&6=
`Yes because the -- the bands are both frequency
`
`:*&2) &"$)"3#'*%'2$&*'$/=&*''%.
*&2%&"$)
`bands.
`One is extraordinarily narrow, and one is
`
`"3#'*%'2$&*'$/='")7"6#$("/=.$2"
`extraordinarily respectively wide.
`
`0%
`M6
`-@@
`
`
`
` , ]@
`
`25 BY MR. HEINTZ:
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`bands.
`One is extraordinarily narrow, and one is
`
`"3#'*%'2$&*'$/='")7"6#$("/=.$2"
`extraordinarily respectively wide.
`
`0%
`M6
`-@@
`
`
`
` , ]@
`
`25 BY MR. HEINTZ:
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/7/2014
`
`8
`
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`Is that it?
`b )#*#$#c
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`That‘s it.
` *#a)$#
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b5*=
`$'
."& *)5"2=%0*:%0#.*#=%0
`Okay. Sir, when I asked you about what you
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`2")6'$:"2$&7*'*<'*7%4=%0'"37"'#'"7%'#
`Okay. Sir, when I asked you about what you
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`2")6'$:"2$&7*'*<'*7%4=%0'"37"'#'"7%'#
`described in paragraph 122 of your expert report,
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`.=2$2=%04$&2$#&"6"))*'=#%/%%5*#3$:$#!!
`why did you find it necessary to look at Exhibit --
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`3$:$#
#" %*'2a)$&)#$#0#$%&2"6$)$%&4%'
`Exhibit 2024,
`the Board's institution decision for
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`#"a7*#"&#c
`the ‘854 patent?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@;0)#4%'#"'"6%'2
`Exhibit 2024,
`the Board's institution decision for
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`#"a7*#"&#c
`the ‘854 patent?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@;0)#4%'#"'"6%'2
`MR. COSTAKOS:
`Just for the record,
`I
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`#$&5=%0)*$2d7*'*<'*7)*&2 d
`think you said "paragraphs 122 and 123."
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`BY MR. HEINTZ:
` , ]@
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`Q
`b5*= *'*<'*7)*&2 >*#7'%17#"2=%0
`Okay.
`Paragraphs 122 and 123. What prompted you
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`to turn to the Board's institution decision to
`#%#0'&#%#" %*'2a)$&)#$#0#$%&2"6$)$%&#%
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`*&)."'#*#f0")#$%&c
`answer that question?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`;0)##%'"4'")1=)"/4*:%0##"!!#"$))0")#*#
`Just to refresh myself about
`the -- the issues that
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`1*=:"6%&#'%("')$*/.$#'")7"6##%#*##%.*#
`may be controversial with respect
`to that to what
`I
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`)#*#"2$&#%)"7*'*<'*7))% 6%0/2<"#!!4%60)
`stated in those paragraphs so I could get -- focus
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`1=*&)."'1%'"2$'"6#/=#%.*# #%0<#=%01$<#
`my answer more directly to what
`I
`thought you might
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`:"#'=$&<#%<"#*#
`be trying to get at.
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`b%")#"4*6##*##"$))0"1$<#:"6%&#'%("')$*/
`Does the fact that the issue might be controversial
`
`And
`
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`6*&<"=%0'*&)."'c
`change your answer?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`No.
` %
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b//'$<# %.
$&'")7%&)"#%#"f0")#$%&*:%0#
`All right.
`Now,
`in response to the question about
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`what
`the difference was between the wide band
`.*##"2$44"'"&6".*):"#.""&#".$2":*&2
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4'"f0"&6=).""7*&2#"&*''%.:*&24'"f0"&6=
`frequency sweep and the narrow band frequency
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`).""7
`All right.
`Now,
`in response to the question about
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`what
`the difference was between the wide band
`.*##"2$44"'"&6".*):"#.""&#".$2":*&2
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4'"f0"&6=).""7*&2#"&*''%.:*&24'"f0"&6=
`frequency sweep and the narrow band frequency
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`).""7
=%0<*("1"*d=")d*&2*d&%d*&)."' &2
`sweep, you gave me a "yes" and a "no" answer.
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`sweep, you gave me a "yes" and a "no" answer.
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/7/2014
`
`9
`-
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`#"d&%d7*'#*2#%2%
#$&5
.$#.*##"!!
`the "no" part had to do,
`I
`think, with what
`the --
`
`-@@
`
`-@@
`
`-@@
`
`-@@
`
`-@@
`
`-@@
`
`-@@
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`
`
`%.#"6%170#"'2"6$2"2.$61"#%2%4<"&"'*#$&<
`how the computer decided which method of generating
`
`
`
`#"2'$(")$<&*/#%0)"g$)#*#6%''"6#c
`the drive signal
`to use;
`is that correct?
`
`
`
` *#a)7*'#%4$#
`That‘s part of it.
`
`
`
`b5*= >*#a)#"%#"'7*'#c
`Okay. What's the other part?
`
`
`
` "%#"'7*'#$)$#)=&#")$^")*&"36$#*#$%&
`The other part is it synthesizes an excitation
`
`
`
`.*("4%'1$&#.%2$44"'"&#.*=)
`waveform in two different ways.
`
`
`
`b//'$<# &2$)&a#$##'0"#*##"%&/=
`All right.
`And isn't it true that the only
`
`-
`
`2$44"'"&6"$&#".*=)$&.$6#"2'$(")$<&*/$)
`difference in the ways in which the drive signal
`is
`
`
`
`)=&#")$^"2*)#%2%.$##"4'"f0"&6=:*&2)#*#
`synthesized has to do with the frequency bands that
`
`
`
`are used?
`*'"0)"2c
`
`band to sweep, and it sweeps a very narrow band
`
`-@@
`
`-@@
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@:e"6#$%& %'1
`MR. COSTAKOS: Objection.
`Form.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` >
`
`@ "'"a)*/%#<%$&<%&
`THE WITNESS: There's a lot going on
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`.$#$&#"6%170#"'#%7"'4%'1#$).%/"7'%6"))
`within the computer to perform this whole process.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` &$#$*//=
`the "no" part had to do,
`I
`think, with what
`the --
`
`-@@
`
`-@@
`
`-@@
`
`-@@
`
`-@@
`
`-@@
`
`-@@
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`
`
`%.#"6%170#"'2"6$2"2.$61"#%2%4<"&"'*#$&<
`how the computer decided which method of generating
`
`
`
`#"2'$(")$<&*/#%0)"g$)#*#6%''"6#c
`the drive signal
`to use;
`is that correct?
`
`
`
` *#a)7*'#%4$#
`That‘s part of it.
`
`
`
`b5*= >*#a)#"%#"'7*'#c
`Okay. What's the other part?
`
`
`
` "%#"'7*'#$)$#)=&#")$^")*&"36$#*#$%&
`The other part is it synthesizes an excitation
`
`
`
`.*("4%'1$&#.%2$44"'"&#.*=)
`waveform in two different ways.
`
`
`
`b//'$<# &2$)&a#$##'0"#*##"%&/=
`All right.
`And isn't it true that the only
`
`-
`
`2$44"'"&6"$&#".*=)$&.$6#"2'$(")$<&*/$)
`difference in the ways in which the drive signal
`is
`
`
`
`)=&#")$^"2*)#%2%.$##"4'"f0"&6=:*&2)#*#
`synthesized has to do with the frequency bands that
`
`
`
`are used?
`*'"0)"2c
`
`band to sweep, and it sweeps a very narrow band
`
`-@@
`
`-@@
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@:e"6#$%& %'1
`MR. COSTAKOS: Objection.
`Form.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` >
`
`@ "'"a)*/%#<%$&<%&
`THE WITNESS: There's a lot going on
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`.$#$&#"6%170#"'#%7"'4%'1#$).%/"7'%6"))
`within the computer to perform this whole process.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` &$#$*//=
#"6%170#"'
%'#"7'%6"))%'
).""7)
`Initially,
`the computer, or the processor,
`sweeps
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`%("'*("'=.$2"'*&<"%44'"f0"&6$") >$/"$#a)
`over a very wide range of frequencies. While it's
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`2%$&<)%
`Initially,
`the computer, or the processor,
`sweeps
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`%("'*("'=.$2"'*&<"%44'"f0"&6$") >$/"$#a)
`over a very wide range of frequencies. While it's
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`2%$&<)%
$#a)#'=$&<#%2"#"'1$&"#"1*<&$#02"%4
`doing so,
`it‘s trying to determine the magnitude of
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`#"2$)7/*6"1"&#)$&#"($:'*#$&<#0:"0)$&<#"
`the displacements in the vibrating tube using the
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`)#'*&<"<*#"!!)#'*$&<*0<")"&)%') ##"&
`strange gate -- strain gauge sensors.
`It then
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`needs to make a determination as to how it
`&""2)#%1*5"*2"#"'1$&*#$%&*)#%%.$#
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`&*''%.)!!$#)0:)"f0"&#/=&*''%.)#")"*'6:*&2
`doing so,
`it‘s trying to determine the magnitude of
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`#"2$)7/*6"1"&#)$&#"($:'*#$&<#0:"0)$&<#"
`the displacements in the vibrating tube using the
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`)#'*&<"<*#"!!)#'*$&<*0<")"&)%') ##"&
`strange gate -- strain gauge sensors.
`It then
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`needs to make a determination as to how it
`&""2)#%1*5"*2"#"'1$&*#$%&*)#%%.$#
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`&*''%.)!!$#)0:)"f0"&#/=&*''%.)#")"*'6:*&2
`narrows -- it subsequently narrows the search band,
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4%'"3*17/"
#"'*#"*#.$6#":*&2$)
`for example,
`the rate at which the band is
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`&*''%."2 a1/%%5$&<"'"$&#"a-7*#"&#
`for example,
`the rate at which the band is
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`&*''%."2 a1/%%5$&<"'"$&#"a-7*#"&#
`narrowed.
`I'm looking here in the '947 patent,
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`6%/01&
/$&"%')% "&$#2"6$2").*#
`column 13,
`line 12 or so.
`Then it decides what
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`:*&2#%).""7
`column 13,
`line 12 or so.
`Then it decides what
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`:*&2#%).""7
*&2$#).""7)*("'=&*''%.:*&2
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/7/2014
`
`10
`
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`#"'"*4#"' ##"&*)#%#'*656*&<")$&#"
`thereafter.
`It then has to track changes in the
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`'")%&*'"f0"&6=%4#"($:'*#$&<#0:"
)%$#a)
`resonant frequency of the vibrating tube,
`so it's
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`&%#e0)#*1*##"'%4).$#6$&<:"#.""&*.$2"
`not just a matter of switching between a wide
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4'"f0"&6=:*&2*&2*&*''%.4'"f0"&6=:*&2
`frequency band and a narrow frequency band.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`BY MR. HEINTZ:
` , ]@
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`Q
`b5*=
`$'
`resonant frequency of the vibrating tube,
`so it's
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`&%#e0)#*1*##"'%4).$#6$&<:"#.""&*.$2"
`not just a matter of switching between a wide
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4'"f0"&6=:*&2*&2*&*''%.4'"f0"&6=:*&2
`frequency band and a narrow frequency band.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`BY MR. HEINTZ:
` , ]@
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`Q
`b5*=
`$'
$&=%0'*&)."'
=%0'"4"''"2#%#"
`Okay. Sir,
`in your answer, you referred to the
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`'*#"*#.$6#":*&2$)&*''%."2#*#*77"*')$&
`rate at which the band is narrowed that appears in
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`#")"&#"&6")#*'#$&<*#/$&"%46%/01& %
`the sentence starting at
`line 12 of column 13.
`Do
`
`-@@-
`
`-
`
`=%0'"6*//#*#c
`you recall that?
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`Yes.
`,")
`
`That‘s a very narrow band that the computer
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b5*= *&=%0"37/*$&.*##" $//"'7*#"&#$)
`Okay.
`Can you explain what
`the Miller patent
`is
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`#*/5$&<*:%0#."&$#!!."&$#0)")#"#"'1!!
`talking about when it -- when it uses the term --
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` a1)%''=
`Okay. Sir,
`in your answer, you referred to the
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`'*#"*#.$6#":*&2$)&*''%."2#*#*77"*')$&
`rate at which the band is narrowed that appears in
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`#")"&#"&6")#*'#$&<*#/$&"%46%/01& %
`the sentence starting at
`line 12 of column 13.
`Do
`
`-@@-
`
`-
`
`=%0'"6*//#*#c
`you recall that?
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`Yes.
`,")
`
`That‘s a very narrow band that the computer
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b5*= *&=%0"37/*$&.*##" $//"'7*#"&#$)
`Okay.
`Can you explain what
`the Miller patent
`is
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`#*/5$&<*:%0#."&$#!!."&$#0)")#"#"'1!!
`talking about when it -- when it uses the term --
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` a1)%''=
#"7'*)"d#"'*#"*#.$6#":*&2
`I'm sorry,
`the phrase "the rate at which the band
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`is narrowed"?
`$)&*''%."2dc
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`>"//
`I'm sorry,
`the phrase "the rate at which the band
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`is narrowed"?
`$)&*''%."2dc
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`>"//
$#)*=)$#a)*1*##"'%42")$<&6%$6"#%
`Well, it says it's a matter of design choice to
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`2"#"'1$&"#"'*#"*#.$6#":*&2$)&*''%."2
`Well, it says it's a matter of design choice to
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`2"#"'1$&"#"'*#"*#.$6#":*&2$)&*''%."2
`determine the rate at which the band is narrowed,
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`1"*&$&<%.f0$65/=#"'*&<"%4)6*&&"2
`meaning how quickly the range of scanned
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4'"f0"&6$")6*&:"&*''%."22%.&#%0/#$1*#"/=*
`frequencies can be narrowed down to ultimately a 20
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`"'#^:*&26%("'$&<*77'%3$1*#"/="'#^%&"*6
`hertz band covering approximately 10 hertz on each
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`)$2"%4#"40&2*1"&#*/4'"f0"&6=%4#")=)#"1
`side of the fundamental frequency of the system.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b5*= &2)%."&."#*/5*:%0##""'#^:*&2
`Okay.
`And so when we talk about
`the 20 hertz band,
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`$)#*##".$2":*&24'"f0"&6=).""7%'#"&*''%.
`is that the wide band frequency sweep or the narrow
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4'"f0"&6=:*&2).""7#*#=%0a'"'"4"''$&<#%$&
`frequency band sweep that you're referring to in
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`7*'*<'*7%4=%0'"6/*'*#$%&c
`paragraph 122 of your Declaration?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` *#a)*("'=&*''%.:*&2#*##"6%170#"'
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/7/2014
`
`11
`
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`0/#$1*#"/=
%7"40//=
*''$(")*#
`ultimately, hopefully, arrives at.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b
`%/"#1"*)5=%0#%"37/*$&*/$##/"1%'"*:%0#
`So let me ask you to explain a little more about
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`%.#$).%'5)
`%$&7*'*<'*7%4=%0'
`how this works.
`So in paragraph 122 of your
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`"6/*'*#$%&
`ultimately, hopefully, arrives at.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b
`%/"#1"*)5=%0#%"37/*$&*/$##/"1%'"*:%0#
`So let me ask you to explain a little more about
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`%.#$).%'5)
`%$&7*'*<'*7%4=%0'
`how this works.
`So in paragraph 122 of your
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`"6/*'*#$%&
=%0)#*#"
d $//"'2$)6/%)")d!! a1
`Declaration, you state, "Miller discloses" -
`I'm
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`)%''= %=%0*("$#c
`sorry.
`Do you have it?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`Yeah.
`Go ahead.
`,"* %*"*2
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b,%0)*=
`Declaration, you state, "Miller discloses" -
`I'm
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`)%''= %=%0*("$#c
`sorry.
`Do you have it?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`Yeah.
`Go ahead.
`,"* %*"*2
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b,%0)*=
d $//"'2$)6/%)")#.%1%2")%42'$("
`You say, "Miller discloses two modes of drive
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`)$<&*/<"&"'*#$%&2'$($&<#"4/%.#0:"%)6$//*#$%&
`signal generation driving the flowtube oscillation
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`.$#*.$2":*&24'"f0"&6=).""7
`You say, "Miller discloses two modes of drive
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`)$<&*/<"&"'*#$%&2'$($&<#"4/%.#0:"%)6$//*#$%&
`signal generation driving the flowtube oscillation
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`.$#*.$2":*&24'"f0"&6=).""7
$&6/02$&<*'*&<"
`with a wide band frequency sweep,
`including a range
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`%44'"f0"&6$")'"7'")"&#$&<"17#=4/%.#0:"#%40//
`of frequencies representing empty flowtube to full
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4/%.#0:"
`with a wide band frequency sweep,
`including a range
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`%44'"f0"&6$")'"7'")"&#$&<"17#=4/%.#0:"#%40//
`of frequencies representing empty flowtube to full
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4/%.#0:"
."&#"4'"f0"&6=!!)%''=
."&#"
`flowtube, when the frequency -- sorry, when the
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`'")%&*'"f0"&6=$)0&5&%.& d%=%0)""#*#c
`resonant frequency is unknown."
`Do you see that?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`I do.
` 2%
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b5*=
`%2%")#*#1"*&#*##"4/%.#0:"$)
`Okay.
`So does that mean that the flowtube is
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`2'$("&*#2$44"'"'"f0"&6$")#'%0<%0##$)
`driven at different frequencies throughout this
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`.$2"4'"f0"&6=:*&2).""7c
`wide frequency band sweep?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@:e"6#$%& %'1
`MR. COSTAKOS: Objection.
`Form.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` >
`
`@>"//
`flowtube, when the frequency -- sorry, when the
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`'")%&*'"f0"&6=$)0&5&%.& d%=%0)""#*#c
`resonant frequency is unknown."
`Do you see that?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`I do.
` 2%
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b5*=
`%2%")#*#1"*&#*##"4/%.#0:"$)
`Okay.
`So does that mean that the flowtube is
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`2'$("&*#2$44"'"'"f0"&6$")#'%0<%0##$)
`driven at different frequencies throughout this
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`.$2"4'"f0"&6=:*&2).""7c
`wide frequency band sweep?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@:e"6#$%& %'1
`MR. COSTAKOS: Objection.
`Form.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` >
`
`@>"//
20'$&<#").""7
#"
`THE WITNESS: Well, during the sweep,
`the
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`4'"f0"&6=$)6%&)#*&#/=6*&<$&<
`frequency is constantly changing.
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`BY MR. HEINTZ:
` , ]@
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`Q
`b&2$)#"'"*'*#"*))%6$*#"2.$##*#6*&<"%4
`And is there a rate associated with that change of
`
`frequency sweep?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4'"f0"&6=c
`frequency?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`Sure.
`
`0'"
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b5*= >*#a)#")#*'#4'"f0"&6=%4#$).$2":*&2
`Okay. What's the start frequency of this wide band
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4'"f0"&6=).""7c
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`THE WITNESS: Well, during the sweep,
`the
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`4'"f0"&6=$)6%&)#*&#/=6*&<$&<
`frequency is constantly changing.
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`BY MR. HEINTZ:
` , ]@
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`Q
`b&2$)#"'"*'*#"*))%6$*#"2.$##*#6*&<"%4
`And is there a rate associated with that change of
`
`frequency sweep?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4'"f0"&6=c
`frequency?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`Sure.
`
`0'"
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b5*= >*#a)#")#*'#4'"f0"&6=%4#$).$2":*&2
`Okay. What's the start frequency of this wide band
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4'"f0"&6=).""7c
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/7/2014
`
`12
`
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
` $//"'2$)6/%)")$&$)a-7*#"&##*##"
`Miller discloses in his '947 patent that the
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`$&$#$*/%'.$2").""7:*&2)7*&)#"'*&<"%4
`initial or wide sweep band spans the range of 2700
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`"'#^4%'/$f0$2.*#"'#%"'#^4%'*&
`hertz for liquid water to 4500 hertz for an
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`"(*60*#"2#0:" &2#*#a)'"4"'"&6$&<6%/01&
`evacuated tube.
`And that's referencing column 12,
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`line 55 and thereafter.
`/$&"*&2#"'"*4#"'
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b5*= &2)%.%0/2$#:"4*$'#%6*//#")#*'#$&<
`Okay.
`And so would it be fair to call the starting
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4'"f0"&6=*7*'*1"#"'c
`frequency a parameter?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@:e"6#$%&#%4%'1
`MR. COSTAKOS: Objection to form.
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
` >
`
`@>"//
$1*<$&"#*#a)%&"
`THE WITNESS: Well,
`I
`imagine that's one
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`.*=#%6*'*6#"'$^"$# %."("'
`THE WITNESS: Well,
`I
`imagine that's one
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`.*=#%6*'*6#"'$^"$# %."("'
2%&a#:"/$"("
`way to characterize it. However,
`I don't believe
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
` $//"'0)")#"#"'1d7*'*1"#"'d$&#"a-7*#"&#
`Miller uses the term "parameter" in the '947 patent
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`0&/"))=%05&%.)%1"#$&< 2%&a#
`unless you know something I don't.
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`BY MR. HEINTZ:
` , ]@
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`b5*=
`Q
`Okay.
`
`It depends on how it's conducted --
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
` 2%&a#'"1"1:"')""$&<#*##"'1."&'"($".$&<
`I don't remember seeing that term when reviewing
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`#"7*#"&#
`the patent.
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`b %&"#"/"))
`way to characterize it. However,
`I don't believe
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
` $//"'0)")#"#"'1d7*'*1"#"'d$&#"a-7*#"&#
`Miller uses the term "parameter" in the '947 patent
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`0&/"))=%05&%.)%1"#$&< 2%&a#
`unless you know something I don't.
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`BY MR. HEINTZ:
` , ]@
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`b5*=
`Q
`Okay.
`
`It depends on how it's conducted --
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
` 2%&a#'"1"1:"')""$&<#*##"'1."&'"($".$&<
`I don't remember seeing that term when reviewing
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`#"7*#"&#
`the patent.
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`b %&"#"/"))
$#.%0/2:"*6%''"6##"'1#%0)"#%
`Nonetheless, it would be a correct term to use to
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`6*'*6#"'$^"#*#f0*&#$#=
`Nonetheless, it would be a correct term to use to
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`6*'*6#"'$^"#*#f0*&#$#=
'$<#!!
`characterize that quantity, right --
`
`-@-@-
`
`-
`
`Well --
`>"//!!
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`b!!)#*'#$&<4'"f0"&6=c
`-- starting frequency?
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`>"//
`characterize that quantity, right --
`
`-@-@-
`
`-
`
`Well --
`>"//!!
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`b!!)#*'#$&<4'"f0"&6=c
`-- starting frequency?
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`>"//
#*#a)!!#*#a)=%0'6*'*6#"'$^*#$%&
`Well,
`that‘s -- that's your characterization.
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`That‘s not Miller's characterization.
` *#a)&%# $//"'a)6*'*6#"'$^*#$%&
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`b a1*)5$&<=%0$4#"6*'*6#"'$^*#$%&$)6%''"6#
`I'm asking you if the characterization is correct.
`
`-@-@-
`
`
`
` )$#$17'%7"'#%=%0#%0)"#*#6*'*6#"'$^*#$%&c
`Is it improper to you to use that characterization?
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
` #2"7"&2)%&%.$#a)6%&206#"2!!
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`Well,
`that‘s -- that's your characterization.
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`That‘s not Miller's characterization.
` *#a)&%# $//"'a)6*'*6#"'$^*#$%&
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`b a1*)5$&<=%0$4#"6*'*6#"'$^*#$%&$)6%''"6#
`I'm asking you if the characterization is correct.
`
`-@-@-
`
`
`
` )$#$17'%7"'#%=%0#%0)"#*#6*'*6#"'$^*#$%&c
`Is it improper to you to use that characterization?
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
` #2"7"&2)%&%.$#a)6%&206#"2!!
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/7/2014
`
`13
`
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`b// a1*)5$&<!!
`All I'm asking --
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`!!$&#"6%170#"'7'%<'*1
`-- in the computer program.
`
`-@-@-
`
`
`
`b// a1*)5$&<=%04%'$)."#"'#")#*'#
`All I'm asking you for is whether the start
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`4'"f0"&6=%4#$).$2":*&2).""7$)*7*'*1"#"'
`frequency of this wide band sweep is a parameter.
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
` #$&5$#!!"7"&2$&<%&%.#"6%170#"'1*=:"
`I
`think it -- Depending on how the computer may be
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`7'%<'*11"2
=%06%0/2!!$#6%0/2%'!!%'$#
`programmed, you could -- it could or -- or it
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`6%0/2&a#:"*7*'*1"#"'
`couldn‘t be a parameter.
`
`-@-@-
`
`
`
`b>=6*&a#$#!!
`Why can‘t it --
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`So --
`
`%!!
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b
`%''=
`Sorry.
`
`caveats you‘ve just applied to characterize the end
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` *#a)%5*=
`%
`programmed, you could -- it could or -- or it
`
`-@-@
`
`
`
`6%0/2&a#:"*7*'*1"#"'
`couldn‘t be a parameter.
`
`-@-@-
`
`
`
`b>=6*&a#$#!!
`Why can‘t it --
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`So --
`
`%!!
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b
`%''=
`Sorry.
`
`caveats you‘ve just applied to characterize the end
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` *#a)%5*=
`%
4%'"3*17/"
$4#"$&$#$*/
`That‘s okay.
`So,
`for example,
`if the initial
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4'"f0"&6=#*#=%06$#"2
`That‘s okay.
`So,
`for example,
`if the initial
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4'"f0"&6=#*#=%06$#"2
"'#^
$)*'26%2"2
`frequency that you cited, 2700 hertz,
`is hard coded
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`$&#%#"7'%<'*1
`frequency that you cited, 2700 hertz,
`is hard coded
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`$&#%#"7'%<'*1
2%&a##$&5#*#.%0/2:"*
`into the program,
`I don't think that would be a
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`7*'*1"#"' 4$#.*))%1"#$&<#*#7"'*7)
`parameter.
`If it was something that perhaps
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`'")$2"2$&*#*:/"#*##"7'%<'*1*66"))"2
`into the program,
`I don't think that would be a
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`7*'*1"#"' 4$#.*))%1"#$&<#*#7"'*7)
`parameter.
`If it was something that perhaps
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`'")$2"2$&*#*:/"#*##"7'%<'*1*66"))"2
`resided in a table that the program accessed,
`I
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`)077%)"=%06%0/2#$&5%4$#*)*7*'*1"#"'
`suppose you could think of it as a parameter.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` %."("'
#*#a)'"*2$&<$&:"#.""&#"/$&")
`However,
`that‘s reading in between the lines.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`That‘s not what Miller discloses.
`He discloses
` *#a)&%#.*# $//"'2$)6/%)") "2$)6/%)")
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`.$2":*&2
`However,
`that‘s reading in between the lines.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`That‘s not what Miller discloses.
`He discloses
` *#a)&%#.*# $//"'2$)6/%)") "2$)6/%)")
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`.$2":*&2
*&$&$#$*/)"*'6
%' #$&5%4$#*)
`wide band, an initial search, or I
`think of it as
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`*&$&(")#$<*#$%&*&2#"&*&*''%.:*&2*&2#"&!!
`an investigation and then a narrow band and then --
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`*&2#"&"(%/($&<$&#%*("'=&*''%.:*&2.$6$)
`and then evolving into a very narrow band which is
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`1%'"%4*#'*65$&<)$#0*#$%&#*#6%("')("'=)1*//
`more of a tracking situation that covers very small
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`6*&<")$&2"&)$#=
`changes in density.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b5*=
`%.%0/2$#:"*/)%6%''"6#.$##")*1"
`Okay.
`So would it be also correct with the same
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`6*("*#)=%0a("e0)#*77/$"2#%6*'*6#"'$^"#""&2
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`wide band, an initial search, or I
`think of it as
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`*&$&(")#$<*#$%&*&2#"&*&*''%.:*&2*&2#"&!!
`an investigation and then a narrow band and then --
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`*&2#"&"(%/($&<$&#%*("'=&*''%.:*&2.$6$)
`and then evolving into a very narrow band which is
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`1%'"%4*#'*65$&<)$#0*#$%&#*#6%("')("'=)1*//
`more of a tracking situation that covers very small
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`6*&<")$&2"&)$#=
`changes in density.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b5*=
`%.%0/2$#:"*/)%6%''"6#.$##")*1"
`Okay.
`So would it be also correct with the same
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`6*("*#)=%0a("e0)#*77/$"2#%6*'*6#"'$^"#""&2
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/7/2014
`
`14
`
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4'"f0"&6=%4#".$2":*&2).""7*)*7*'*1"#"'c
`frequency of the wide band sweep as a parameter?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@:e"6#$%& %'1
`MR. COSTAKOS: Objection.
`Form.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`THE WITNESS:
`I would answer the
` >
`
`@ .%0/2*&)."'#"!!#*#
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`f0")#$%&$&*)$1$/*'.*=
`question in a similar way.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`BY MR. HEINTZ:
` , ]@
`
`have a software function that performs this sweep,
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`b5*= &2.*#*:%0##"'*#"*#.$6#").""7
`Q
`Okay.
`And what about
`the rate at which the sweep
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`$)6%&206#"2c )#*#*/)%*7*'*1"#"'c
`is conducted?
`Is that also a parameter?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@:e"6#$%&#%4%'1
`MR. COSTAKOS: Objection to form.
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`THE WITNESS: Miller didn't disclose that
` >
`
`@ $//"'2$2&a#2$)6/%)"#*#
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`*):"$&<*7*'*1"#"'"$#"' %&"%4#%)"*'"
`as being a parameter either. None of those are
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`2")6'$:"2*):"$&<7*'*1"#"')
`described as being parameters.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`BY MR. HEINTZ:
` , ]@
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`Q
`Would it be incorrect to characterize
`b>%0/2$#:"$&6%''"6##%6*'*6#"'$^"$#*)*
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`7*'*1"#"'c
`parameter?
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@:e"6#$%&#%4%'1
`MR. COSTAKOS: Objection to form.
`
`-@@
`
`
`
` >
`
`@ %6*'*6#"'$^"*&=%4
`THE WITNESS:
`To characterize any of
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`#%)"#'""#$&<)."e0)#2")6'$:"2
:"<$&&$&<
`those three things we just described, beginning
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4'"f0"&6=
`those three things we just described, beginning
`
`-@@
`
`
`
`4'"f0"&6=
"&2$&<4'"f0"&6=*&2#"'*#"%4).""7
`frequency, ending frequency and the rate of sweep,
`
`-@@
`
`-
`
`I
`think reads an embodiment
`into the '947 that
` #$&5'"*2)*&"1:%2$1"&#$&#%#"a-#*#
`
`-@@-
`
`
`
`Miller doesn‘t disclose.
`And I
`think it narrows
` $//"'2%")
Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.
After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.
Accept $ Charge
Still Working On It
This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.
Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.
A few More Minutes ... Still Working
It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.
Thank you for your continued patience.
This document could not be displayed.
We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.
Your account does not support viewing this document.
You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.
Your account does not support viewing this document.
Set your membership
status to view this document.
With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll
get a whole lot more, including:
- Up-to-date information for this case.
- Email alerts whenever there is an update.
- Full text search for other cases.
- Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.
One Moment Please
The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.
Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.
Your document is on its way!
If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.
Sealed Document
We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.
If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.
Access Government Site
