`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/6/2014
`
`1
`
`
`UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`
`
`
`
`BEFORE THE PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`
` !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
`
`
`IICRO MOTION,
`INC.,
`
`
`
`
`
` "#$#$%&"'
`Petitioner,
`
`IPR2014-00167
`()" %) !
`
`IPR2014-OOl7O
` !*)! !
`
`IPR2014-00178
` !
`
`IPR2014-00179
` !+
`
` ,
`-
`
`-
`
`
`INVENSYS SYSTEMS,
`INC.,
`
`+
`
`Patent Owner.
` (#"&#.&"'
`
`!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
`
`at 5:49 p.m.
`
`
`
`
`
` ,$/"%0(1$&(#$%&%2
`
`Video Examination of MICHAEL D. SIDMAN,
`
`
#(3"&(##"$&)#(&4"%2#"
(#"&#.&"'
5&/"'
`Ph.D.,
`taken at the instance of the Patent Owner, under
`
` (&/65')5(&##%
`7(87878(&/
`and pursuant
`to 35 USC 316(a)(5)(A) and 37 C.F.R.
`
` 7/8
`Ph.D.,
`taken at the instance of the Patent Owner, under
`
` (&/65')5(&##%
`7(87878(&/
`and pursuant
`to 35 USC 316(a)(5)(A) and 37 C.F.R.
`
` 7/8
9"2%'":
`
`
( ";$)#"'"/
`42.53(d), before JENNIFER L. SCHMALING,
`a Registered
`
` "'$# "6%'#"'
`42.53(d), before JENNIFER L. SCHMALING,
`a Registered
`
` "'$# "6%'#"'
"'#$2$"/ "(<#$1" "6%'#"'
"'#$2$"/
`Ierit Reporter, Certified Realtime Reporter, Certified
`
` '%(/4()#(6#$%&"'(&/ %#('= 59<$4$&(&/2%'#"
`Broadcast Captioner and Notary Public in and for the
`
`+
`#(#"%2>$)4%&)$&
`Ierit Reporter, Certified Realtime Reporter, Certified
`
` '%(/4()#(6#$%&"'(&/ %#('= 59<$4$&(&/2%'#"
`Broadcast Captioner and Notary Public in and for the
`
`+
`#(#"%2>$)4%&)$&
(# %<"=?('/&"'
()#
`State of Wisconsin, at Foley & Lardner, 777 East
`
` >$)4%&)$&*"&5"
`State of Wisconsin, at Foley & Lardner, 777 East
`
` >$)4%&)$&*"&5"
$<.(53""
>$)4%&)$&
%&
`isconsin Avenue, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, on
`
` 5;5)#
`isconsin Avenue, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, on
`
` 5;5)#
4%11"&4$&;(#+@( 1 (&/4%&4<5/$&;
`August 6, 2014, commencing at 9:16 a.m. and concluding
`
` (#@+6 1
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`
`Invensys EX. 2021
`713-653-7100
`Micro Motion v Invensys |PR2014-00393
`
`
`August 6, 2014, commencing at 9:16 a.m. and concluding
`
` (#@+6 1
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`
`Invensys EX. 2021
`713-653-7100
`Micro Motion v Invensys |PR2014-00393
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/6/2014
`
`
`
`A P P E A R A N C E S
`
`
`
`
` -?
9=
`FOLEY & LARDNER, by
` : -
`
`
`FOLEY & LARDNER, by
` : -
`
`
`IR.
`JEFFREY N. COSTAKOS,
`()#>$)4%&)$&*"&5"
`777 East Wisconsin Avenue,
` $<.(53""
>$)4%&)$&
`Iilwaukee, Wisconsin 53202,
`(66"('"/%&9"(<2%2#" "#$#$%&"'
`appeared on behalf of the Petitioner.
`
`
`
`
9=
`DLA PIPER LLP, by
` >
`
`
`DLA PIPER LLP, by
` >
`
`
`IR. EDWARD H. SIKORSKI,
`
`#'""#
`5$#"
`401 B Street, Suite 1700,
`
`(&$";%
(<$2%'&$(+!+
`San Diego, California 92101-4297,
`(66"('"/%&9"(<2%2#" (#"&#.&"'
`appeared on behalf of the Patent Owner.
`
`
`
`
9=
`DLA PIPER LLP, by
`+ : - :
`
`DLA PIPER LLP, by
`+ : - :
`
`IR.
`JEFFREY L.
`JOHNSON,
`%5$)$(&(
`5$#"
`1000 Louisiana, Suite 2800,
` %5)#%&
"0()
`Houston, Texas 77002,
`(66"('"/%&9"(<2%2#" (#"&#.&"'
`appeared on behalf of the Patent Owner.
`
`
`
`
9=
`DLA PIPER LLP, by
` :
` _
`DLA PIPER LLP, by
` :
` _
`R.
`JAMES M. HEINTZ,
`+ '""/%1'$*"
`5$#"
`11911 Freedom Drive, Suite 300,
` ")#%&
,$';$&$(+!
`Reston, Virginia 20190-5602,
`(66"('"/%&9"(<2%2#" (#"&#.&"'
`appeared on behalf of the Patent Owner.
`
`
`A L S O
`P R E S E N T
`
`
`
` ' :%&
`6%&%<#`
,
`
`
,$/"%;'(6"'
`r.
`John Spohnholtz, CLVS, Videographer.
`
`
`aaaaa
`
`
`
`2
`
` b
`
`+
`Examination:
` 0(1$&(#$%&@ (;"
`Page
`......
`5
`Sikorski ..............................
` = '
`$3%')3$
`Heintz ................................
`...... 124
` = ' "$&#`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`r.
`John Spohnholtz, CLVS, Videographer.
`
`
`aaaaa
`
`
`
`2
`
` b
`
`+
`Examination:
` 0(1$&(#$%&@ (;"
`Page
`......
`5
`Sikorski ..............................
` = '
`$3%')3$
`Heintz ................................
`...... 124
` = ' "$&#`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`
`
`8/6/2014
`
`
`
` aaaaa
` b
`
`anNH
`
`
`
`3
`
`0$9$# /"&#$2$"/@ (;"
`Exhibit Identified:
`Page
`
`
`
`mm
`
`2014
` % ! %#$4"2"6%)$#$%& &d
`Notice Of Deposition In '178 ............
`2015
` % ! %#$4"2"6%)$#$%& &d+
`Notice Of Deposition In '179 ............
`2016
` % !
`511('=2<($1%&)#'54#$%&) '%1 "
`Summary Of Claim Constructions From The
`Various PTO Orders ......................
`,('$%5) '/"')
`2017
` % !%451"&# (#$)#) =(4 '/"'
`Document That Lists By Each IPR Order
`>(#'%5&/)>"'"44"6#"/ = "
`What Grounds Were Accepted By The
`+ (#"&# %('/ %' " 5'6%)"2 ")"
`Patent Board For The Purpose Of These
` )>$# (;" 519"')&/ ('(;'(6)
`IPRs With Page Numbers And Paragraphs
`10
` &/5#<$&"2 " (43;'%5&/
`"4#$%&)
`And Outline Of The Background Sections
`Of The IPRs
`2 " )
`11
`Dr. Sidman's Declaration To U.S. Patent
` % !'
`$/1(&d)"4<('(#$%& %
` (#"&#
` %
`No. 7,124,646 ...........................
`Dr. Sidman's Declaration To U.S. Patent
`12
` % +!'
`$/1(&d)"4<('(#$%& %
` (#"&#
` %
`No. 7,136,761 ...........................
`13
` % ! %/"< "#"'
`566<"1"&#
`<5; <%.&/
`Model D Meter Supplement, Slug Flow And
`%(/$&;&<%(/$&;
&)#'54#$%& (&5(<
`Loading/Unloading, Instruction Manual
`14
` (#"/
`"6#"19"'+
`Dated September 1987 ....................
` % !
` (#"&# %
`Loading/Unloading, Instruction Manual
`14
` (#"/
`"6#"19"'+
`Dated September 1987 ....................
` % !
` (#"&# %
%$&/"&9(51 +
`U.S. Patent No. 5,224,387 To Lindenbaum.
`15
` % !
` (#"&# %
`U.S. Patent No. 5,224,387 To Lindenbaum.
`15
` % !
` (#"&# %
+
+ % %1(&%
`U.S. Patent No. 4,934,196 To Romano .....
` % !'
`$/1(&d)06"'#"4<('(#$%&
`Dr. Sidman's Expert Declaration
`16
` %&4"'&$&; "d (#"&# & "
`Concerning The
`'854 Patent
`In The 167
`IPR .....................................
`
`17
` % ! &)#$#5#$%&"4$)$%&
`U.S. Patent No. 4,934,196 To Romano .....
` % !'
`$/1(&d)06"'#"4<('(#$%&
`Dr. Sidman's Expert Declaration
`16
` %&4"'&$&; "d (#"&# & "
`Concerning The
`'854 Patent
`In The 167
`IPR .....................................
`
`17
` % ! &)#$#5#$%&"4$)$%&
(6"' % &
`Institution Decision, Paper No.
`10 In
`IPR2014—00167 ...........................
` !
`18
` % !
` (#"&# %
`Institution Decision, Paper No.
`10 In
`IPR2014—00167 ...........................
` !
`18
` % !
` (#"&# %
+
+ % (<%#(=
`U.S. Patent No. 5,009,109 To Kalotay....
` % ! (#$"&# '$(<&/66"(< %('/d)
`Patient Trial And Appeal Board's
`19
`+ "4$)$%&>$# ")6"4# %
` (#"&#
`Decision With Respect To U.S. Patent
` %
`U.S. Patent No. 5,009,109 To Kalotay....
` % ! (#$"&# '$(<&/66"(< %('/d)
`Patient Trial And Appeal Board's
`19
`+ "4$)$%&>$# ")6"4# %
` (#"&#
`Decision With Respect To U.S. Patent
` %
&
!
`No. 6,311,136 In IPR2014—00170 .......... 138
`20
` % !
` (#"&# %
`No. 6,311,136 In IPR2014—00170 .......... 138
`20
` % !
` (#"&# %
% "&'=
`U.S. Patent No. 7,505,854 To Henry ...... 170
` % !
` (#"&# %
`U.S. Patent No. 7,505,854 To Henry ...... 170
` % !
` (#"&# %
+
+ % $<<"'
`U S. Patent No. 4,679,947 To Miller ..... 177
`
`21
`
`*
`*
`*
`*
`*
`22
` aaaaa
`23
` $)6%)$#$%&2'$;$&(<0$9$#)@
`Disposition Of Original Exhibits:
`24
` "#5'&"/ % $6"'
`Returned To DLA Piper LLP.
`25
` aaaaa
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`U S. Patent No. 4,679,947 To Miller ..... 177
`
`21
`
`*
`*
`*
`*
`*
`22
` aaaaa
`23
` $)6%)$#$%&2'$;$&(<0$9$#)@
`Disposition Of Original Exhibits:
`24
` "#5'&"/ % $6"'
`Returned To DLA Piper LLP.
`25
` aaaaa
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/6/2014
`
`4
`
`
`TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
`
`
`
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`(Exhibit Nos. 2014 and 2015 were marked.)
`70$9$# %) (&/."'"1('3"/ 8
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` , @>"('"%22$4$(<<=%&
`THE VIDEOGRAPHER:
`We are officially on
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`#"'"4%'/(#+@( 1 %/(=d)/(#"$)
`the record at 9:16 a.m. Today's date is
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`5;5)##
$)$)$)3 % $&#"
`August 6th, 2014.
`This is Disk No.
`1
`in the
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`/"6%)$#$%&%2' $4("<
`$/1(&
`deposition of Dr. Michael Sidman.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` $)/"6%)$#$%&$)9"$&;#(3"&$&#"
`This deposition is being taken in the
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`1(##"' $4'% %#$%&
`August 6th, 2014.
`This is Disk No.
`1
`in the
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`/"6%)$#$%&%2' $4("<
`$/1(&
`deposition of Dr. Michael Sidman.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` $)/"6%)$#$%&$)9"$&;#(3"&$&#"
`This deposition is being taken in the
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`1(##"' $4'% %#$%&
&4%'6%'(#"/
"#$#$%&"'
`matter Micro Motion,
`Incorporated, Petitioner,
`
`Edward Sikorski of DLA
`
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`*"')5) (#"&#.&"' &*"&)=)
`=)#"1)
&4%'6%'(#"/
`versus Patent Owner Invensys Systems,
`Incorporated.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` $)1(##"'$)6"&/$&;9"2%'"#" (#"&# '$(<(&/
`This matter is pending before the Patent Trial and
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`66"(< %('/
`versus Patent Owner Invensys Systems,
`Incorporated.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` $)1(##"'$)6"&/$&;9"2%'"#" (#"&# '$(<(&/
`This matter is pending before the Patent Trial and
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`66"(< %('/
&$#"/
`#(#") (#"&#(&/ '(/"1('3
`Appeal Board, United States Patent and Trademark
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`22$4"
`#(#") (#"&#(&/ '(/"1('3
`Appeal Board, United States Patent and Trademark
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`22$4"
()" %)
!+
!
!
`Office, Case Nos.
`IPR2014-169, 2014-170, 2014-178
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`and 2014-179.
`(&/!+
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` $)/"6%)$#$%&$)9"$&;#(3"&(##"
`This deposition is being taken at
`the
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`%22$4")%2 %<"=?('/&"'<%4(#"/(#()#
`offices of Foley & Lardner located at 777 East
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`>$)4%&)$&*"&5"
`Office, Case Nos.
`IPR2014-169, 2014-170, 2014-178
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`and 2014-179.
`(&/!+
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` $)/"6%)$#$%&$)9"$&;#(3"&(##"
`This deposition is being taken at
`the
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`%22$4")%2 %<"=?('/&"'<%4(#"/(#()#
`offices of Foley & Lardner located at 777 East
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`>$)4%&)$&*"&5"
$<.(53""
>$)4%&)$& =&(1"$)
`Wisconsin Avenue, Milwaukee, Wisconsin.
`My name is
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`:%&
`6%&%<#`
`Wisconsin Avenue, Milwaukee, Wisconsin.
`My name is
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`:%&
`6%&%<#`
*$/"%;'(6"'2%'
` ";(<
` ";(<
(&/
`John Spohnholtz, videographer for U.S. Legal, and
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`#"4%5'#'"6%'#"'$):"&&$2"'
`41(<$&; >$<<
`the court reporter is Jennifer Schmaling. Will
`
`+@@+
`
`+
`
`4%5&)"<6<"()")#(#"#"$'(66"('(&4")(&/.%1
`counsel please state their appearances and whom
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`#"='"6'")"&#
`John Spohnholtz, videographer for U.S. Legal, and
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`#"4%5'#'"6%'#"'$):"&&$2"'
`41(<$&; >$<<
`the court reporter is Jennifer Schmaling. Will
`
`+@@+
`
`+
`
`4%5&)"<6<"()")#(#"#"$'(66"('(&4")(&/.%1
`counsel please state their appearances and whom
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`#"='"6'")"&#
9";$&&$&;.$#6"#$#$%&"'d)
`they represent, beginning with petitioner's
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`4%5&)"<
`they represent, beginning with petitioner's
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`4%5&)"<
(&/#"&#"'"6%'#"'.$<<)."('$&#"
`counsel, and then the reporter will swear in the
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`witness.
`.$#&"))
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@:"22%)#(3%)
`counsel, and then the reporter will swear in the
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`witness.
`.$#&"))
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@:"22%)#(3%)
%<"=?
`MR. COSTAKOS:
`Jeff Costakos, Foley &
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`('/&"'
`MR. COSTAKOS:
`Jeff Costakos, Foley &
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`('/&"'
2%' $4'% %#$%&(&/2%'#".$#&"))
`Lardner,
`for Micro Motion and for the witness.
`
`+@@+
`
`
`
`MR. SIKORSKI:
`
`
` @/.('/
`$3%')3$%2
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`Lardner,
`for Micro Motion and for the witness.
`
`+@@+
`
`
`
`MR. SIKORSKI:
`
`
` @/.('/
`$3%')3$%2
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/6/2014
`
`5
`
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` $6"'%&9"(<2%2 &*"&)=)
`=)#"1)
&4
#"
`Piper on behalf of Invensys Systems, Inc.,
`the
`
`+@@
`
`+@@
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`
`
`6(#"&#%.&"'
`patent owner.
`
`
`
` _@:(1") "$&`
`Piper on behalf of Invensys Systems, Inc.,
`the
`
`+@@
`
`+@@
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`
`
`6(#"&#%.&"'
`patent owner.
`
`
`
` _@:(1") "$&`
(<)%2'%1
`MR. HEINTZ:
`James Heinz, also from DLA
`
`
`
` $6"'
`MR. HEINTZ:
`James Heinz, also from DLA
`
`
`
` $6"'
(<)%%&9"(<2%2 &*"&)=)
`=)#"1)
`=)#"1)
&4
`Piper, also on behalf of Invensys Systems, Inc.,
`
`
`
`#"6(#"&#%.&"'
`the patent owner.
`
`
`
` :
` @:"22'"=:%&)%&2'%1
`MR.
`JOHNSON:
`Jeffrey Johnson from DLA
`
`Just so I have them
`
`
`+@@
`
`+@@
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` $6"'
(<)%%&9"(<2%2 &*"&)=)
`=)#"1)
`=)#"1)
&4
`Piper, also on behalf of Invensys Systems,
`Inc.
`
`
`
`Piper, also on behalf of Invensys Systems,
`Inc.
`
`
`
4(<<"/()(
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D., called as a
`
`+ .$#&"))"'"$&
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D., called as a
`
`+ .$#&"))"'"$&
(*$&;9""&2$')#/5<=).%'&%&
`witness herein, having been first duly sworn on
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`%(#
`witness herein, having been first duly sworn on
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`%(#
.()"0(1$&"/(&/#")#$2$"/()2%<<%.)@
`oath, was examined and testified as follows:
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`EXAMINATION
`b
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`BY MR. SIKORSKI:
` -
`
` @
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e%%/1%'&$&;
`oath, was examined and testified as follows:
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`EXAMINATION
`b
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`BY MR. SIKORSKI:
` -
`
` @
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e%%/1%'&$&;
'
`$/1(&
`Q
`Good morning, Dr. Sidman.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`%%/1%'&$&;
`Good morning.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e d*"1('3"/2%'#"'"4%'/
`$/1(&
`Q
`Good morning, Dr. Sidman.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`%%/1%'&$&;
`Good morning.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e d*"1('3"/2%'#"'"4%'/
f5)#2%'2%'1(<$#=
`I've marked for the record,
`just for formality
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`)(3"
`I've marked for the record,
`just for formality
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`)(3"
#"2$')##.%"0$9$#)
"6%)$#$%&0$9$#)
`sake,
`the first two exhibits, Deposition Exhibits
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`(&/ "=d'"#" %#$4"%2"6%)$#$%&$&
`2014 and 2015. They're the Notice of Deposition in
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`#.%%2#"2%5' ) -%54(&;<(&4"(##"1
`two of the four IPRs.
`You can glance at
`them.
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`
`
`@%=%5(*"4%6$")2%'1"g
`MR. COSTAKOS:
`Do you have copies for me?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`MR. SIKORSKI:
`I do.
`
`
` @ /%
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@'"(# %##(# '"(<<=
`MR. COSTAKOS: Great. Not that
`I really
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`&""/#%)"6('#$45<('%&")
`sake,
`the first two exhibits, Deposition Exhibits
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`(&/ "=d'"#" %#$4"%2"6%)$#$%&$&
`2014 and 2015. They're the Notice of Deposition in
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`#.%%2#"2%5' ) -%54(&;<(&4"(##"1
`two of the four IPRs.
`You can glance at
`them.
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`
`
`@%=%5(*"4%6$")2%'1"g
`MR. COSTAKOS:
`Do you have copies for me?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`MR. SIKORSKI:
`I do.
`
`
` @ /%
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@'"(# %##(# '"(<<=
`MR. COSTAKOS: Great. Not that
`I really
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`&""/#%)"6('#$45<('%&")
95#!!
`need those particular ones, but --
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`
`
` @-%5()3"/2%'#"1
`need those particular ones, but --
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`
`
` @-%5()3"/2%'#"1
=%5
`MR. SIKORSKI:
`You asked for them, you
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`;"##"1 "'"=%5;%
`get
`them.
`There you go.
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`
`
`@3(= :5)#)% (*"#"1
`MR. COSTAKOS: Okay.
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`MR. SIKORSKI:
`You asked for them, you
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`;"##"1 "'"=%5;%
`get
`them.
`There you go.
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`
`
`@3(= :5)#)% (*"#"1
`MR. COSTAKOS: Okay.
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/6/2014
`
`6
`
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`4%''"4#<=
.$4%&"$).$4&%.g$)d
`correctly, which one is which now?
`2014 is '178.
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`3(= %#$#
`Okay. Got it.
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`BY MR. SIKORSKI:
` -
`
` @
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`e %'#"'"4%'/
`correctly, which one is which now?
`2014 is '178.
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`3(= %#$#
`Okay. Got it.
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`BY MR. SIKORSKI:
` -
`
` @
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`e %'#"'"4%'/
#")" %#$4")(&/ %#$4")2%'#"
`Q
`For the record,
`these Notices and Notices for the
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`%#"'#.% )."'"(<'"(/=$&#"659<$4
`other two IPRs were already in the public PTO
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`'"4%'/
`Q
`For the record,
`these Notices and Notices for the
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`%#"'#.% )."'"(<'"(/=$&#"659<$4
`other two IPRs were already in the public PTO
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`'"4%'/
)%."d<</$)6"&)".$#"&#"'$&;#"%#"'
`record,
`so we'll dispense with entering the other
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`#.% %#$4") '
`$/1(&
`record,
`so we'll dispense with entering the other
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`#.% %#$4") '
`$/1(&
&%#$4"/#(#4%5&)"<()
`two Notices. Dr. Sidman,
`I noticed that counsel as
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`."."'"6'"6('$&;2%'#"/"6%)$#$%&/'%66"/(
`we were preparing for the deposition dropped a
`
`+@+@
`
`+
`
`4%56<"%2/%451"&#)$&2'%&#%2=%5 %=%51$&/
`couple of documents in front of you.
`Do you mind
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`#"<<$&;1".(##%)"/%451"&#)('"g
`telling me what
`those documents are?
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`&"6(;"4%&)$)#)%2(<$)#%24<($1"/
`One page consists of a list of claimed
`
`MR. SIKORSKI: We'll mark that as 2016,
`
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`constructions that the --
`4%&)#'54#$%&)#(##"!!
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`Mind if I
`look at
`that?
`e $&/$2 <%%3(##(#g
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`Sure.
`
`5'"
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`
`
`@ (*"%&"$2=%5.(%'
`MR. COSTAKOS:
`I have one if you want for
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`your own copy.
`=%5'%.&4%6=
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
` >
`
`@
`"#2%'#9=#" (#"&#
`THE WITNESS:
`Set forth by the Patent
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`22$4"$&#"$''5<$&;)
`two Notices. Dr. Sidman,
`I noticed that counsel as
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`."."'"6'"6('$&;2%'#"/"6%)$#$%&/'%66"/(
`we were preparing for the deposition dropped a
`
`+@+@
`
`+
`
`4%56<"%2/%451"&#)$&2'%&#%2=%5 %=%51$&/
`couple of documents in front of you.
`Do you mind
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`#"<<$&;1".(##%)"/%451"&#)('"g
`telling me what
`those documents are?
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`&"6(;"4%&)$)#)%2(<$)#%24<($1"/
`One page consists of a list of claimed
`
`MR. SIKORSKI: We'll mark that as 2016,
`
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`constructions that the --
`4%&)#'54#$%&)#(##"!!
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`Mind if I
`look at
`that?
`e $&/$2 <%%3(##(#g
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`Sure.
`
`5'"
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`
`
`@ (*"%&"$2=%5.(%'
`MR. COSTAKOS:
`I have one if you want for
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`your own copy.
`=%5'%.&4%6=
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
` >
`
`@
`"#2%'#9=#" (#"&#
`THE WITNESS:
`Set forth by the Patent
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`22$4"$&#"$''5<$&;)
%'/"')%&#")"2%5'
)
`Office in their rulings, orders on these four IPRs.
`
`+@+@
`
`+
`
`BY MR. SIKORSKI:
` -
`
` @
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`e
`%#$))""#
`Office in their rulings, orders on these four IPRs.
`
`+@+@
`
`+
`
`BY MR. SIKORSKI:
` -
`
` @
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`e
`%#$))""#
())51"
(&/
4%5&)"<
=%5d'"2'""
`Q
`So this sheet,
`I assume, and, counsel, you're free
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`#%(&)."'$2=%5.(&#
`Q
`So this sheet,
`I assume, and, counsel, you're free
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`#%(&)."'$2=%5.(&#
#"=d'"()511('=%24<($1
`to answer if you want,
`they're a summary of claim
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`constructions from the various PTO orders?
`4%&)#'54#$%&)2'%1#"*('$%5) %'/"')g
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`MR. COSTAKOS: Yeah. That's what it's
`
`
`@-"( (#d).(#$#d)
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`meant
`to be.
`1"(&##%9"
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`
`
` @>"d<<1('3#(#()
`to answer if you want,
`they're a summary of claim
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`constructions from the various PTO orders?
`4%&)#'54#$%&)2'%1#"*('$%5) %'/"')g
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`MR. COSTAKOS: Yeah. That's what it's
`
`
`@-"( (#d).(#$#d)
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`meant
`to be.
`1"(&##%9"
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`
`
` @>"d<<1('3#(#()
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/6/2014
`
`7
`
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`6<"()"
`please.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`(Exhibit No. 2016 was marked.)
`70$9$# % .()1('3"/ 8
`
`+@@+
`
`
`
`BY MR. SIKORSKI:
` -
`
` @
`
`+@@+
`
`
`
`e "'"d)(&%#"'/%451"&#$&2'%&#%2=%5#(#
`Q
`There's another document
`in front of you that
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`4%5&)"<;(*"=%5g
`counsel gave you?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`&/#(#d)(/%451"&##(#4%&)$)#)%22%5'6(;")
`And that‘s a document that consists of four pages,
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`%&"6(;"6"'
#(#<$)#)9=#"!!"(4
`one page per IPR,
`that lists by the -- each IPR
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`%'/"'.(#;'%5&/)."'"(44"6#"/9=#" (#"&#
`order what grounds were accepted by the Patent
`
`+@@+
`
`+
`
` %('/2%'#"65'6%)"%2#")" )(&/;$*"5)
`Board for the purpose of these IPRs and give us
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`6(;"&519"')(&/6('(;'(6)
`page numbers and paragraphs.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e 9"<$"*"=%5)($/#(#=%5'4%6=$)2%5'6(;")
`I believe you said that your copy is four pages.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` "4%6=#(#4%5&)"<(&/"/1"$)2$*"
`The copy that counsel handed me
`is five.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`3(= &/#"2$2#6(;"
`one page per IPR,
`that lists by the -- each IPR
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`%'/"'.(#;'%5&/)."'"(44"6#"/9=#" (#"&#
`order what grounds were accepted by the Patent
`
`+@@+
`
`+
`
` %('/2%'#"65'6%)"%2#")" )(&/;$*"5)
`Board for the purpose of these IPRs and give us
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`6(;"&519"')(&/6('(;'(6)
`page numbers and paragraphs.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e 9"<$"*"=%5)($/#(#=%5'4%6=$)2%5'6(;")
`I believe you said that your copy is four pages.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` "4%6=#(#4%5&)"<(&/"/1"$)2$*"
`The copy that counsel handed me
`is five.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`3(= &/#"2$2#6(;"
'$;#
$)f5)#(!!(&
`Okay.
`And the fifth page, right,
`is just a --
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`%5#<$&"%2#"9(43;'%5&/)"4#$%&)%21= )
`outline of the background sections of my IPRs.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e
`%'#%2#(9<"%24%&#"&#)%'$&/"0
`Okay.
`And the fifth page, right,
`is just a --
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`%5#<$&"%2#"9(43;'%5&/)"4#$%&)%21= )
`outline of the background sections of my IPRs.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e
`%'#%2#(9<"%24%&#"&#)%'$&/"0
)%#%)6"(3g
`Sort of table of contents or index,
`so to speak?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`%''"4#
`Sort of table of contents or index,
`so to speak?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`%''"4#
%2#"$&#'%/54#%'=%29(43;'%5&/)"4#$%&)
`Correct, of the introductory of background sections
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`that were common to each of the four IPRs that
`#(#."'"4%11%&#%"(4%2#"2%5' )#(#
`
`Right.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`."d'"/$)45))$&;#%/(=
`we‘re discussing today.
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`e&/f5)#)% d14<"('
`Correct, of the introductory of background sections
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`that were common to each of the four IPRs that
`#(#."'"4%11%&#%"(4%2#"2%5' )#(#
`
`Right.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`."d'"/$)45))$&;#%/(=
`we‘re discussing today.
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`e&/f5)#)% d14<"('
#"2%5'
)'"4"$*"/2%5'
`And just so I'm clear,
`the four IPRs received four
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`)"6('(#""4<('(#$%&)2'%1=%5
`And just so I'm clear,
`the four IPRs received four
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`)"6('(#""4<('(#$%&)2'%1=%5
'$;#g
`separate Declarations from you, right?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`&"2%'"(4
`separate Declarations from you, right?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`&"2%'"(4
4%''"4#
`One for each, correct.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e&/#$)2$2#6(;"$))$16<=$/"&#$2=$&;#"
`And this fifth page is simply identifying the
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`6%'#$%&)%2#%)""4<('(#$%&)#(#('"4%11%&
`portions of those Declarations that are common
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`(1%&;!!(1%&;#"1g
`among -- among them?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` $;#
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`One for each, correct.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e&/#$)2$2#6(;"$))$16<=$/"&#$2=$&;#"
`And this fifth page is simply identifying the
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`6%'#$%&)%2#%)""4<('(#$%&)#(#('"4%11%&
`portions of those Declarations that are common
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`(1%&;!!(1%&;#"1g
`among -- among them?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` $;#
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/6/2014
`
`8
`
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@9f"4##%#"2%'1
`MR. COSTAKOS: Object
`to the form.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` >
`
`@ (#6"'#($&#%#"!!()
`THE WITNESS:
`That pertain to the -- as
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`$#)(=)
h "$&#'%/54#$%&%'9(43;'%5&/)"4#$%&) h
`it says,
`"The introduction or background sections."
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`
`
` @3(= >=/%&d#."1('3
`MR. SIKORSKI: Okay. Why don't we mark
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`=%5'4%6=%2#$)()0$9$#
`it says,
`"The introduction or background sections."
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`
`
` @3(= >=/%&d#."1('3
`MR. SIKORSKI: Okay. Why don't we mark
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`=%5'4%6=%2#$)()0$9$#
$2=%5/%&d#
`your copy of this as Exhibit 2017,
`if you don't
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`mind.
`1$&/
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`(Exhibit No. 2017 was marked.)
`70$9$# % .()1('3"/ 8
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`BY MR. SIKORSKI:
` -
`
` @
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`e'
`$/1(&
`your copy of this as Exhibit 2017,
`if you don't
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`mind.
`1$&/
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`(Exhibit No. 2017 was marked.)
`70$9$# % .()1('3"/ 8
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`BY MR. SIKORSKI:
` -
`
` @
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`e'
`$/1(&
=%5(*"(."9)$#"
'$;#g
`Q
`Dr. Sidman, you have a website, right?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` (*")$/1(& 4%1
`Q
`Dr. Sidman, you have a website, right?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` (*")$/1(& 4%1
=")
`I have sidman.com, yes.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e (#d)(."9)$#"/"/$4(#"/#%=%5'"&;$&""'$&;
`That‘s a website dedicated to your engineering
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`4%&)5<#$&;6'(4#$4"g
`consulting practice?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`That‘s a fair statement. Yes.
` (#d)(2($')#(#"1"&# -")
`
`You've been deposed how many times?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e&#(#."9)$#"
`I have sidman.com, yes.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e (#d)(."9)$#"/"/$4(#"/#%=%5'"&;$&""'$&;
`That‘s a website dedicated to your engineering
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`4%&)5<#$&;6'(4#$4"g
`consulting practice?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`That‘s a fair statement. Yes.
` (#d)(2($')#(#"1"&# -")
`
`You've been deposed how many times?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e&#(#."9)$#"
=%5<$)#!!"045)"1"!!=%5
`On that website, you list -- excuse me -- you
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`/"/$4(#"(6(;"#%"06"'#)"'*$4")2%'#"<";(<
`dedicate a page to expert services for the legal
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`6'%2"))$%& %=%5'"4(<<#(#g
`profession.
`Do you recall that?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` !! '"4(<<$# (*"&d#<%%3"/(#$#'"4"&#<=
`On that website, you list -- excuse me -- you
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`/"/$4(#"(6(;"#%"06"'#)"'*$4")2%'#"<";(<
`dedicate a page to expert services for the legal
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`6'%2"))$%& %=%5'"4(<<#(#g
`profession.
`Do you recall that?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` !! '"4(<<$# (*"&d#<%%3"/(#$#'"4"&#<=
`-
`I recall it.
`I haven't
`looked at it recently,
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`95#=")
`but yes.
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`e&/$#$&/$4(#")#(#=%5('"(&"06"'#2%'$'"%'
`And it indicates that you are an expert for hire or
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`2%'*('$%5)<";(<#%6$4))54()"06"'#'"6%'#)
`for various legal
`topics such as expert reports,
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`/"6%)$#$%&
#'$(<
"#4"#"'( %=%5'"4(<<#(#g
`deposition, trial, et cetera.
`Do you recall that?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`"&"'(<<=
`deposition, trial, et cetera.
`Do you recall that?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`"&"'(<<=
'"4(<<#(#
`Generally,
`I recall that.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e
`%=%5!!
`So you --
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` #d)&%#(4%16<"#")#(#"1"&#
`Generally,
`I recall that.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e
`%=%5!!
`So you --
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` #d)&%#(4%16<"#")#(#"1"&#
95#=")
`It‘s not a complete statement, but yes.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e-%5d*"9""&/"6%)"/%.1(&=#$1")g
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`It‘s not a complete statement, but yes.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e-%5d*"9""&/"6%)"/%.1(&=#$1")g
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/6/2014
`
`9
`+
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` 4(&d#;$*"=%5(&(445'(#"(&)."'#%#(#
95#
`I can‘t give you an accurate answer to that, but
`I
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`.%5</)(=1%'"#(&(/%`"&#$1")%*"'(!="('
`would say more than a dozen times over a 25-year
`
`+@@+
`
`
`
`6"'$%/
`period.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e%=%5'"4(<<."&=%5'2$')#/"6%)$#$%&.()
`I can‘t give you an accurate answer to that, but
`I
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`.%5</)(=1%'"#(&(/%`"&#$1")%*"'(!="('
`would say more than a dozen times over a 25-year
`
`+@@+
`
`
`
`6"'$%/
`period.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e%=%5'"4(<<."&=%5'2$')#/"6%)$#$%&.()
;$*"
`Do you recall when your first deposition was, give
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`or take?
`%'#(3"g
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` %&")#<=/%&d#
`I honestly don't.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e
`%)"*"'(<="(')(;%g
`So several years ago?
`
`+@@+
`
`
`
` #.()
`Do you recall when your first deposition was, give
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`or take?
`%'#(3"g
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` %&")#<=/%&d#
`I honestly don't.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e
`%)"*"'(<="(')(;%g
`So several years ago?
`
`+@@+
`
`
`
` #.()
d1)5'"
/"4(/")(;%
`It was,
`I'm sure, decades ago.
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`e (*"=%5#")#$2$"/(##'$(<g
`Have you testified at trial?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`I have.
` (*"
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e %.1(&=#$1")g
`How many times?
`
`that I testified at trial at, but that's -- maybe
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` d*"#")#$2$"/()(&"06"'#2$*"#$1")%*"'#"
`I've testified as an expert five times over the
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`6()#="(')
`It was,
`I'm sure, decades ago.
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`e (*"=%5#")#$2$"/(##'$(<g
`Have you testified at trial?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`I have.
` (*"
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e %.1(&=#$1")g
`How many times?
`
`that I testified at trial at, but that's -- maybe
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` d*"#")#$2$"/()(&"06"'#2$*"#$1")%*"'#"
`I've testified as an expert five times over the
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`6()#="(')
(66'%0$1(#"<=
`past 25 years, approximately.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e %.
`past 25 years, approximately.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e %.
=%5$&/$4(#"/#(#=%5#")#$2$"/()(&"06"'#
`Now, you indicated that you testified as an expert.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`>"'"#%)"(<<6(#"()")g
`Were those all patent cases?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`No.
` %
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e>$4."'"!!(&=%5f5)#9'"(3#"156
`Now, you indicated that you testified as an expert.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`>"'"#%)"(<<6(#"()")g
`Were those all patent cases?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`No.
` %
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e>$4."'"!!(&=%5f5)#9'"(3#"156
.$4
`Which were -- Can you just break them up, which
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`."'"6(#"&#)
`Which were -- Can you just break them up, which
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`."'"6(#"&#)
.$4."'")%1"#$&;"<)"g
`were patents, which were something else?
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`>"<<
`were patents, which were something else?
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`>"<<
(*"#%#$&3%22(&/ 5# 1"(&
`Well,
`I have to think offhand. But
`I mean,
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`;"&"'(<<=
$#d)!!#"4()") d1$&*%<*"/$&'"<(#"
`generally,
`it‘s -- the cases I'm involved in relate
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`#%6(#"&#/$)65#")%26(#"&#$&2'$&;"1"&#
`generally,
`it‘s -- the cases I'm involved in relate
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`#%6(#"&#/$)65#")%26(#"&#$&2'$&;"1"&#
`to patent disputes of patent
`infringement,
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`)%1"#$1")#'(/")"4'"#/$)65#")%'9'"(4%2
`sometimes trade secret disputes or breach of
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`contract.
`I can't -- I'd have to think about how
`4%&#'(4# 4(&d#!! d/(*"#%#$&3(9%5#%.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`#%(&)."'=%5'i5")#$%&)6"4$2$4(<<=2%'#"4()")
`to answer your question specifically for the cases
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`#(# #")#$2$"/(##'$(<(#
95##(#d)!!1(=9"
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/6/2014
`
`10
`
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`#(#)5$#)=%5'65'6%)"
`that suits your purpose.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e (#d)2$&" 2 &""/1%'"/"#($<
d<<'"*$)$#
`That‘s fine.
`If I need more detail, I'll revisit
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`$# (&3=%5 -%55&/"')#(&/#(##"6('#$")$&
`it.
`Thank you.
`You understand that the parties in
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`#$)4()"$&4<5/"&%#%&<=1"')%&<"4#'$495#
`this case include not only Emerson Electric but
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`(<)% $4'% %#$%&
`That‘s fine.
`If I need more detail, I'll revisit
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`$# (&3=%5 -%55&/"')#(&/#(##"6('#$")$&
`it.
`Thank you.
`You understand that the parties in
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`#$)4()"$&4<5/"&%#%&<=1"')%&<"4#'$495#
`this case include not only Emerson Electric but
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`(<)% $4'% %#$%&
&4 g
`also Micro Motion,
`Inc.?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`Yes.
`-")
`
`and scientists.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e'"=%52(1$<$('.$##%)"#.%4%16(&$")d&(1")g
`Are you familiar with those two companies' names?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`Yes.
`-")
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`
`
`@9f"4#$%&#%2%'1
`MR. COSTAKOS: Objection to form.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`BY MR. SIKORSKI:
` -
`
` @
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e (*"=%56'$%'#%#$)4()"
`also Micro Motion,
`Inc.?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`Yes.
`-")
`
`and scientists.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e'"=%52(1$<$('.$##%)"#.%4%16(&$")d&(1")g
`Are you familiar with those two companies' names?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`Yes.
`-")
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`
`
`@9f"4#$%&#%2%'1
`MR. COSTAKOS: Objection to form.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`BY MR. SIKORSKI:
` -
`
` @
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e (*"=%56'$%'#%#$)4()"
(&/ d<<65#(&
`Q
`Have you prior to this case, and I'll put an
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`519'"<<(%*"'#$)4()"
`Q
`Have you prior to this case, and I'll put an
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`519'"<<(%*"'#$)4()"
()#%#"45''"&#/$)65#"
`umbrella over this case, as to the current dispute,
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`#"6(#"&#/$)65#"9"#.""&#"6('#$")
/$/=%5/%
`the patent dispute between the parties, did you do
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`(&=6'"*$%5).%'32%'1"')%&<"4#'$4g
`any previous work for Emerson Electric?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@9f"4#$%&#%2%'1
`MR. COSTAKOS: Objection to form.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` >
`
`@ /%&d#'"4(<</%$&;(&=
`THE WITNESS:
`I don't recall doing any
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`6'"*$%5).%'32%'1"')%&<"4#'$4
`previous work for Emerson Electric.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`BY MR. SIKORSKI:
` -
`
` @
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`Q
`How about for Micro Motion?
`e %.(9%5#2%' $4'% %#$%&g
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`-")
`the patent dispute between the parties, did you do
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`(&=6'"*$%5).%'32%'1"')%&<"4#'$4g
`any previous work for Emerson Electric?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@9f"4#$%&#%2%'1
`MR. COSTAKOS: Objection to form.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` >
`
`@ /%&d#'"4(<</%$&;(&=
`THE WITNESS:
`I don't recall doing any
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`6'"*$%5).%'32%'1"')%&<"4#'$4
`previous work for Emerson Electric.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`BY MR. SIKORSKI:
` -
`
` @
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`Q
`How about for Micro Motion?
`e %.(9%5#2%' $4'% %#$%&g
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`-")
(*"/%&")%1".%'32%'#"1 #(5;#(
`Yes,
`I have done some work for them.
`I
`taught a
`
`+@@+
`
`
`
`#"4&$4(<4%5')"
`Yes,
`I have done some work for them.
`I
`taught a
`
`+@@+
`
`
`
`#"4&$4(<4%5')"
(&/
` #'($&$&;
` #'($&$&;
`technical course, MATLAB and SIMULINK training,
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`1%'"#(&="(')(;%#%#"$'/")$;&"&;$&""')$&
`more than 16 years ago to their design engineers in
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` %5</"' #d)(4%5')"#(# #"(4
(4%5')"#(#
`Boulder.
`It‘s a course that
`I
`teach,
`a course that
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` #"(4#%$&/5)#'=
`Boulder.
`It‘s a course that
`I
`teach,
`a course that
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` #"(4#%$&/5)#'=
;"&"'(<<=
#%/")$;&"&;$&""')
`I
`teach to industry, generally,
`to design engineers
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`(&/)4$"&#$)#)
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`I
`teach to industry, generally,
`to design engineers
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`(&/)4$"&#$)#)
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/6/2014
`
`11
`
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e %.$)$##(#=%5'"4(<<;$*$&;#$)6'%;'(1#%
`How is it that you recall giving this program to
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` $4'% %#$%&)%1"="(')(;%g
`Micro Motion some 16 years ago?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`Well --
`>"<<!!
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@9f"4#$%&#%2%'1
`MR. COSTAKOS: Objection to form.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` >
`
`@!!#"=d'"%9*$%5)<=(
`THE WITNESS:
`-- they're obviously a
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`6('#=#%#$)4()"
(&/ '"4(<<(*$&;#(5;##(#
`party to this case, and I recall having taught that
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`4%5')"(&/(*$&;/"*"<%6"/)6"4$2$4"0(16<")2%'
`course and having developed specific examples for
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`#"4%5')"9()"/%&%'$%<$)2<%.1"#"'#"4&%<%;=
`the course based on Coriolis flowmeter technology.
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`BY MR. SIKORSKI:
` -
`
` @
`
`a prior art patent that's associated with this
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e>"'"#"'"(&=)#5/"&#)$&#"4%5')"#(#=%5
`Q
`Were there any students in the course that you
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`recall from that time that are involved in the
`'"4(<<2'%1#(##$1"#(#('"$&*%<*"/$&#"
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`45''"&#/$)65#"g
`current dispute?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` d1&%#)5'"%.#%(&)."'#(#i5")#$%& 1"(&
`party to this case, and I recall having taught that
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`4%5')"(&/(*$&;/"*"<%6"/)6"4$2$4"0(16<")2%'
`course and having developed specific examples for
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`#"4%5')"9()"/%&%'$%<$)2<%.1"#"'#"4&%<%;=
`the course based on Coriolis flowmeter technology.
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`BY MR. SIKORSKI:
` -
`
` @
`
`a prior art patent that's associated with this
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e>"'"#"'"(&=)#5/"&#)$&#"4%5')"#(#=%5
`Q
`Were there any students in the course that you
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`recall from that time that are involved in the
`'"4(<<2'%1#(##$1"#(#('"$&*%<*"/$&#"
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`45''"&#/$)65#"g
`current dispute?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` d1&%#)5'"%.#%(&)."'#(#i5")#$%& 1"(&
`I'm not sure how to answer that question.
`I mean,
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`$2=%5."'"#%&(1"&(1")
1(=9" 4%5</'"4(<<
`if you were to name names, maybe I could recall.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e d1.%&/"'$&;
`if you were to name names, maybe I could recall.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e d1.%&/"'$&;
/%=%5'"4(<<."#"'#"'"."'"(&=
`I'm wondering, do you recall whether there were any
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` $4'% %#$%&"16<%="")%'%#"'6"%6<"(22$<$(#"/
`Micro Motion employees or other people affiliated
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`.$# $4'% %#$%&#(#=%5#(5;#="(')(;%#(#
`with Micro Motion that you taught 16 years ago that
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`=%5('"&%.)""$&;"$#"'$&6"')%&%'9=&(1"$&
`you are now seeing either in person or by name in
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`#"6'")"&#/$)65#"g
`the present dispute?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@9f"4#$%&#%2%'1
`MR. COSTAKOS: Objection to form.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` >
`
`@ (*"&d#!! $')#%2(<<
`I'm wondering, do you recall whether there were any
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` $4'% %#$%&"16<%="")%'%#"'6"%6<"(22$<$(#"/
`Micro Motion employees or other people affiliated
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`.$# $4'% %#$%&#(#=%5#(5;#="(')(;%#(#
`with Micro Motion that you taught 16 years ago that
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`=%5('"&%.)""$&;"$#"'$&6"')%&%'9=&(1"$&
`you are now seeing either in person or by name in
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`#"6'")"&#/$)65#"g
`the present dispute?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`
`
`@9f"4#$%&#%2%'1
`MR. COSTAKOS: Objection to form.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` >
`
`@ (*"&d#!! $')#%2(<<
`THE WITNESS:
`I haven't -- First of all,
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` (*"&d#)""&(&= $4'% %#$%&"16<%="")9=&(1"
`I haven't seen any Micro Motion employees by name
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`.$#'")6"4##%#"45''"&#/$)65#" %."*"'
/%
`with respect to the current dispute. However,
`I do
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`'"4%;&$`"(#<"()#%&"&(1"()9"$&;(&$&*"&#%'%2
`recognize at least one name as being an inventor of
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`(6'$%'('#6(#"&##(#d)())%4$(#"/.$##$)
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`with respect to the current dispute. However,
`I do
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`'"4%;&$`"(#<"()#%&"&(1"()9"$&;(&$&*"&#%'%2
`recognize at least one name as being an inventor of
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`(6'$%'('#6(#"&##(#d)())%4$(#"/.$##$)
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/6/2014
`
`12
`
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`case .
`4()"
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`BY MR. SIKORSKI:
` -
`
` @
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`Q
`e d1)5'"=%53&%..(#1=&"0#i5")#$%&$) >%$)
`I'm sure you know what my next question is. Who is
`
`to a couple of technologies involved in
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`that?
`#(#g
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` 9"<$"*"$)&(1".() $43 (;$&&$)(##"&/"/1=
`I believe his name was Rick Maginnis attended my
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`4%5')"="(')(;% #$&3$#.()$& ('4%2
`course 16 years ago.
`I
`think it was
`in March of
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`d+
(#'""!/(=4%5')"(# $4'% %#$%&
`'98,
`a three-day course at Micro Motion.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e (#d)i5$#"#"'"4%<<"4#$%& -%5$&/$4(#"/#(#
`That‘s quite the recollection.
`You indicated that
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`#"4%5')"#(#=%5#(5;#="(')(;%
`'98,
`a three-day course at Micro Motion.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e (#d)i5$#"#"'"4%<<"4#$%& -%5$&/$4(#"/#(#
`That‘s quite the recollection.
`You indicated that
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`#"4%5')"#(#=%5#(5;#="(')(;%
(;($&
`the course that you taught 16 years ago, again,
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`4%''"4#1"$2 1$)5&/"')#%%/
$&=%5'6'"6('(#$%&
`correct me if I misunderstood,
`in your preparation
`
`+@@+
`
`
`
`2%'#(#4%5')"
`correct me if I misunderstood,
`in your preparation
`
`+@@+
`
`
`
`2%'#(#4%5')"
=%54'"(#"/)%1")%'#%2"0(16<")
`for that course, you created some sort of examples
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`5)$&;%'$%<$)2<%.1"#"')j$)#(#'$;#g
`using Coriolis flowmeters;
`is that right?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`-") ;"&"'(<<=45)#%1$`"1= (&/
`
`Yes.
`I generally customize my MATLAB and SIMULINK
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`<(9%'(#%'=#'($&$&;4%5')")2%'"(4)"#%2
`laboratory training courses for each set of
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`4<$"&#)
`for that course, you created some sort of examples
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`5)$&;%'$%<$)2<%.1"#"')j$)#(#'$;#g
`using Coriolis flowmeters;
`is that right?
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`-") ;"&"'(<<=45)#%1$`"1= (&/
`
`Yes.
`I generally customize my MATLAB and SIMULINK
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`<(9%'(#%'=#'($&$&;4%5')")2%'"(4)"#%2
`laboratory training courses for each set of
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`4<$"&#)
)% /$/#(#2%'#")"!!#$);'%56%2
`clients,
`so I did that for these -- this group of
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`"&;$&""') #1(3")#$&;)1%'"'"<"*(%'#"1
`clients,
`so I did that for these -- this group of
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`"&;$&""') #1(3")#$&;)1%'"'"<"*(%'#"1
`engineers.
`It makes things more relevant for them,
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`(&/#"&#"=4(&$##";'%5&/'5&&$&;5)$&;
`and then they can hit the ground running using
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`MATLAB and SIMULINK.
` (&/
`
`
`+@+@
`
`+
`
`e )#"'"(6('#$45<('1%/"<&519"'%'4%11"'4$(<
`Is there a particular model number or commercial
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`identifier associated with the Coriolis flowmeter
`$/"&#$2$"'())%4$(#"/.$##"%'$%<$)2<%.1"#"'
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`#(#=%5<%%3"/(#="(')(;%g
`that you looked at 16 years ago?
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
` /%&d#'"1"19"'(&=#$&;)6"4$2$4<$3"#(# "
`I don't remember anything specific like that.
`The
`
`+@+@+
`
`
`
`#"4&%<%;=!! ""0(16<")#(# '"1"19"'%22(&/
`technology -- The examples that
`I
`remember offhand
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`/"*"<%6$&;2%'#"1'"<(#"/&%##%(&=)6"4$2$4
`developing for them related not
`to any specific
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`6'%/54#95##%(4%56<"%2#"4&%<%;$")$&*%<*"/$&
`product but
`
`U.S. LEGAL SUPPORT
`
`
`
`713.653.7100
`
`
`
`
`
`
`MICHAEL D. SIDMAN, Ph.D.
`
`
`8/6/2014
`
`13
`
`
`+@+@+
`
`
`
`%'$%<$)2<%.1"#"') %'"0(16<"
#"'")%&(&#
`Coriolis flowmeters.
`For example,
`the resonant
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`/=&(1$4)%2#.%/'$*"&*$9'(#%'=#59")4'"(#"/!!
`dynamics of two driven vibratory tubes created --
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`4'"(#"/(
` 1%/"<#(#&%#%&<=1%/"<"/#"
`created a SIMULINK model that not only modeled the
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`1"4(&$4(</=&(1$4)(&/#"!!(&/%.#"=%6"'(#"
`mechanical dynamics and the -- and how they operate
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`()9"$&;/'$*"&9=(2'"i5"&4=%')%5'4"#(#4%5</
`as being driven by a frequency or source that could
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`"04$#"1%'"#(&%&"2<"0$9<"1%/" &/(<)%
`Coriolis flowmeters.
`For example,
`the resonant
`
`+@+@
`
`
`
`/=&(1$4)%2#.%/'$*"&*$9'(#%'=#59")4'"(#"/!!
`dynamics of two driven vibratory tubes created --
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`4'"(#"/(
` 1%/"<#(#&%#%&<=1%/"<"/#"
`created a SIMULINK model that not only modeled the
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`1"4(&$4(</=&(1$4)(&/#"!!(&/%.#"=%6"'(#"
`mechanical dynamics and the -- and how they operate
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`()9"$&;/'$*"&9=(2'"i5"&4=%')%5'4"#(#4%5</
`as being driven by a frequency or source that could
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`"04$#"1%'"#(&%&"2<"0$9<"1%/" &/(<)%
`excite more than one flexible mode.
`And also,
`I
`
`+@@+
`
`
`
`'"4(<<(&"0(16<"#(#/"1%&)#'(#")#"%6"'(#$%&
`recall an example that demonstrates the operation
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`%2)=&4'%&%5)/"1%/5<(#%') "'"1(=9"%#"'
`of synchronous demodulators.
`There may be other
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`#$&;)
95##(#d).(# 4(&'"4(<<%22(&/
`things, but that's what
`I can recall offhand.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e d1)5'"=%5d'"(.('"#(#2%')%1"%2#")"
`I'm sure you‘re aware that for some of these
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` )!! d1)%''= %=%5&""/#%#(3"(9'"(3g
`IPRs -- I'm sorry.
`Do you need to take a break?
`
`+@@+
`
`
`
` d1f5)##'=$&;#%;"#4%12%'#(9<"
`things, but that's what
`I can recall offhand.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e d1)5'"=%5d'"(.('"#(#2%')%1"%2#")"
`I'm sure you‘re aware that for some of these
`
`+@@
`
`
`
` )!! d1)%''= %=%5&""/#%#(3"(9'"(3g
`IPRs -- I'm sorry.
`Do you need to take a break?
`
`+@@+
`
`
`
` d1f5)##'=$&;#%;"#4%12%'#(9<"
)%;%("(/
`I'm just trying to get comfortable,
`so go ahead.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`Don't mind me.
`%&d#1$&/1"
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e (#d)2$&" d<<;$*"=%5()"4%&/ d<<#$&3
`That‘s fine.
`I'll give you a second.
`I'll think
`
`flow document associated with that, yes.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`(9%5#1=&"0#i5")#$%&
`about my next question.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`Sure.
`
`5'"
`
`+@@+
`
`
`
`e-%55&/"')#(&/ -%5d*"9""&/"6%)"/"&%5; 2
`You understand. You've been deposed enough.
`If
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`=%5&""/#%#(3"(9'"(3
`I'm just trying to get comfortable,
`so go ahead.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`Don't mind me.
`%&d#1$&/1"
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e (#d)2$&" d<<;$*"=%5()"4%&/ d<<#$&3
`That‘s fine.
`I'll give you a second.
`I'll think
`
`flow document associated with that, yes.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`(9%5#1=&"0#i5")#$%&
`about my next question.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`Sure.
`
`5'"
`
`+@@+
`
`
`
`e-%55&/"')#(&/ -%5d*"9""&/"6%)"/"&%5; 2
`You understand. You've been deposed enough.
`If
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`=%5&""/#%#(3"(9'"(3
f5)#()31"
`you need to take a break,
`just ask me.
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`3(= (&3=%5
`Okay.
`Thank you.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e d1)5'"=%5d'"(.('"#(#2%')%1"%2#" )
`you need to take a break,
`just ask me.
`
`+@@
`
`+
`
`3(= (&3=%5
`Okay.
`Thank you.
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`e d1)5'"=%5d'"(.('"#(#2%')%1"%2#" )
`I'm sure you‘re aware that for some of the IPRs,
`
`+@@
`
`
`
`=%54$#"#%(65'6%'#"/<=4%11"'4$(</"*$4"#(#
`you cite to a purportedly commercial device that
`
`+@@+
`
`
`
` d<<f5)#'"2"'#%()#" %/"<2<%.1"#"' '"
`I'll just refer to as the Model D flowmeter. Are
`
`+@@
Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.
After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.
Accept $ Charge
Still Working On It
This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.
Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.
A few More Minutes ... Still Working
It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.
Thank you for your continued patience.
This document could not be displayed.
We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.
Your account does not support viewing this document.
You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.
Your account does not support viewing this document.
Set your membership
status to view this document.
With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll
get a whole lot more, including:
- Up-to-date information for this case.
- Email alerts whenever there is an update.
- Full text search for other cases.
- Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.
One Moment Please
The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.
Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.
Your document is on its way!
If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.
Sealed Document
We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.
If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.
Access Government Site
