throbber
Subaru of America, Inc., et. al
`v.
`Cruise Control Technologies LLC
`
`IPR2014‐00289
`Patent 6,324,463
`
`Petitioner Subaru of America, Inc.’s Demonstrative
`Exhibits DX‐1 through DX‐43 for March 24, 2015 Oral Argument
`
`Trial Hearing
`
`Subaru DX-1
`
`Petitioners' Exhibit 1016
`
`

`

`Brief Overview of the ’463 Patent
`
`Subaru DX-2
`
`

`

`U.S. Patent No. 6,324,463
`
`Filed:
`
`Issued:
`
`• May 12, 1999
`• November 27, 2001
`Independent: 1‐2, 12‐13,
`18, 25‐26, 34
`• Dependent: 3‐5, 14‐15, 19‐
`20, 27‐28, 35‐36
`
`Claims at issue:
`•
`
`Ex. 1001, ‘463 Patent
`
`Subaru DX-3
`
`

`

`U.S. Patent No. 6,324,463
`
`’463 Patent File History
`
`Ex. 1003,‘463 patent file history, at 105 (annotated); Pet. at 6‐7
`
`Subaru DX-4
`
`

`

`U.S. Patent No. 6,324,463
`
`•
`
`•
`
`“Figure 1 illustrates a digital speed
`display, while Figure 2 illustrates an
`analog speedometer.”
`“When a cruise control set button . . .
`is pressed, the vehicle speed is
`stored in digital memory . . . as a
`preset speed.”
`
`Paper 19, Board Decision, at 2‐3
`
`Subaru DX-5
`
`Ex. 1001, ‘463 Patent, Fig 1
`
`Ex. 1001, ‘463 Patent, Fig 2
`
`

`

`U.S. Patent No. 6,324,463
`
`David McNamara
`
`Ex. 1012 at 19‐20 ¶ 21; Pet. at 12
`
`Subaru DX-6
`
`

`

`Grounds for Unpatentability
`
`Subaru DX-7
`
`

`

`Grounds for Unpatentability
`
`Claims
`
`Section
`
`#
`
`A 13, 18, 25‐27 102(b)
`B 12‐13
`102(b)
`
`C 1‐2, 12, 14‐15, 27, 34‐36 103(a)
`D 19‐20
`103(a)
`E 1‐5, 14, 26‐
`103(a)
`28, 34‐36
`
`Reference(s)
`
`Yoshimitsu
`Yagihashi
`Yoshimitsu and 300zx
`Manual
`Yoshimitsu and
`Nagashima
`Yagihashiand
`Yoshimitsu
`
`Subaru DX-8
`
`

`

`Combination of Embodiments
`
`Grounds A‐C
`
`Subaru DX-9
`
`

`

`Grounds A‐C: Combination of Embodiments
`
`Patent Owner’s Resp. at 7; see also, e.g.,
`id.at 6, 8, 10, 13‐14, 17 (annotated)
`
`Subaru DX-10
`
`

`

`Grounds A‐C: Combination of Embodiments
`
`[T]hecourtmust,whilelookingatthereference as a whole,
`concludewhetherornotthatreferencedisclosesallelements
`oftheclaimedinventionarrangedasintheclaim.
`Reply at 2 (citing Net MoneyIn v. VeriSign, Inc., 545 F.3d 1359, 1369 n.5 (Fed. Cir. 2008)) (emphasis altered)
`Whenanalyzingthepriorart:
`[I]tispropertotakeintoaccountnotonlyspecificteachingsof
`thereferencebutalsotheinferenceswhichoneskilledinthe
`artwouldreasonablybeexpectedtodrawtherefrom
`Reply at 2 (citing In re Preda, 401 F.2d 825, 826 (CCPA 1968))
`
`Subaru DX-11
`
`

`

`Grounds A‐C: Combination of Embodiments
`
`Moreover,thepriorartreferenceisreadfromtheperspective
`ofonewithordinaryskillintheart. In re Graves,69F.3d1147,
`1152(Fed.Cir.1995)(“Areferenceanticipatesaclaimifit
`disclosestheclaimedinventionsuchthataskilledartisancould
`takeitsteachingsincombinationwithhisownknowledgeof
`theparticularartandbeinpossessionoftheinvention.”)
`Groupon, Inc. v. Blue Calypso, LLC, CBM2013‐00046, Paper 46, Final Written Decision, at 20 (also citing In re Preda, 401 F.2d
`at 826).
`
`Subaru DX-12
`
`

`

`Grounds A‐C: Combination of Embodiments – Yoshimitsu
`
`Overview of Yoshimitsu
`
`Ex. 1007 at AMH00571 (annotated); Pet. at 21‐23 (citing same)
`
`Subaru DX-13
`
`

`

`Grounds A‐C: Combination of Embodiments – Yagihashi
`
`Eleventh Embodiment
`
`Ex. 1007 at AMH00526 (annotated); Reply at 9 (citing same)
`
`Subaru DX-14
`
`

`

`Challenges to Yoshimitsu in Grounds A and C‐D
`
`A: Section 102(b) – Claims 13, 18, 25‐27 by
`Yoshimitsu
`C: Section 103 – Claims 1‐2, 12, 14‐15, 27,
`34‐36 by Yoshimitsu and the 300zx
`Manual
`D: Section 103 – Claims 19‐20 by
`Yoshimitsu and Nagashima
`
`Subaru DX-15
`
`

`

`Grounds A, C‐D: Yoshimitsu – Preset Speed
`
`Ex. 1007 at AMH00579;
`Pet. at 16 (citing same)
`
`Ex. 1007 at AMH00572 (annotated); Pet. at 23 (citing same)
`
`Subaru DX-16
`
`

`

`Grounds A, C‐D: Yoshimitsu – Preset Speed
`
`Mr. McNamara
`
`Ex. 1012 at AMH00796, ¶ 45; Pet. at 16
`
`Subaru DX-17
`
`

`

`Grounds A, C‐D: Yoshimitsu – Preset Speed
`
`Paper 13, Board Decision, at 11 (annotated)
`
`Subaru DX-18
`
`

`

`Grounds A, C‐D: Yoshimitsu – “Actual” Set Speed
`
`Patent Owner’s Argument:
`
`Patent Owner’s Resp. at 5 (annotated); see also, e.g., id. at 12, 19, 21, 25‐26
`
`Subaru DX-19
`
`

`

`Grounds A, C‐D: Yoshimitsu – “Actual” Set Speed
`
`The claim language at issue is: “displaying to the
`operator a symbol indicative ofthe preset speed.”
`Yoshimitsu:
`
`Ex. 1007 at AMH00575 (annotated);
`Pet. at 17 (citing same)
`
`Subaru DX-20
`
`

`

`Grounds A, C‐D: Yoshimitsu – “Actual” Set Speed
`
`Ex. 1007, Yoshimitsu, Fig. 3
`
`Ex. 1001, ’463 Patent, Fig. 2
`
`Ex. 1007 at AMH00572 (annotated); Pet. at 23 (citing same)
`
`Subaru DX-21
`
`

`

`Grounds A, C: Yoshimitsu – Accelerating the Vehicle
`to a Speed Above the Preset Speed
`
`Patent Owner’s Argument:
`
`Patent Owner’s Resp. at p. 9 (annotated)
`
`Subaru DX-22
`
`

`

`Grounds A, C: Yoshimitsu – Accelerating the Vehicle
`to a Speed Above the Preset Speed
`
`Claim Language at Issue:
`
`Ex. 1001, claim 25 (annotated)
`
`Subaru DX-23
`
`

`

`Grounds A, C: Yoshimitsu – Accelerating the Vehicle
`to a Speed Above the Preset Speed
`
`Ex. 1007, Fig. 3 (annotated);
`Pet. at 16 (citing same)
`
`Ex. 1007, Fig. 3
`(altered and annotated)
`
`Ex. 1007 at AMH00571 (annotated); Pet. at 21‐23 (citing same)
`
`Subaru DX-24
`
`

`

`Grounds A, C: Yoshimitsu – Accelerating the Vehicle
`to a Speed Above the Preset Speed
`
`David McNamara
`
`Ex. 1012, ¶ 45, AMH00796; Pet. at 22 (citing same)
`
`Subaru DX-25
`
`

`

`Grounds A, C: Yoshimitsu – Cancel Operation
`
`Patent Owner’s Argument:
`
`See, e.g., Patent Owner’s Resp. at 6 (annotated); see also, e.g., id.at 11, 20, 23
`
`Petition and Reply Explanation:
`
`Reply at 8 (annotated)
`
`Subaru DX-26
`
`

`

`Challenges to 300zx Manual in Ground C
`
`Section 103(a) –Claims 1‐2, 12, 14‐15, 27, 34‐
`36 by Yoshimitsu and 300zx Manual
`
`Subaru DX-27
`
`

`

`Ground C: Yoshimitsu/300zx – Enable/Disable Switch
`
`Relevant Disclosure
`
`Ex. 1008 at Fig. SC308, AMH00645(annotated);
`Pet. at 27 (citing same)
`
`Subaru DX-28
`
`

`

`Ground C: Yoshimitsu/300zx – Enable/Disable Switch
`
`David McNamara
`
`Ex. 1012 at AMH00800‐801, ¶ 54; Pet. at 28 (citing same)
`
`Ex. 1008 at Fig. SC308,
`AMH00645 (annotated);
`Pet. at 27 (citing same)
`
`Subaru DX-29
`
`

`

`Ground C: Yoshimitsu/300zx – Motivation to Combine
`
`Yoshimitsu
`(Ex. 1007 at AMH00579)
`
`300zx Manual
`(Ex. 1008 at AHM00645)
`
`Pet. at 26; Reply at 11 (citing same)
`
`Subaru DX-30
`
`

`

`Ground C: Yoshimitsu/300zx – Motivation to Combine
`
`David McNamara
`
`Ex. 1012 at AMH00800, ¶ 53 (annotated);
`Pet. at 26 (citing same)
`
`Subaru DX-31
`
`

`

`Challenges to Yagihashi in Grounds B and E
`
`B: Section 102(e) – Claims 12‐13 by
`Yagihashi
`
`E: Section 103(a) – Claims 1‐5, 14, 26‐28,
`34‐36 by Yagihashi and Yoshimitsu
`
`Subaru DX-32
`
`

`

`Grounds B, E: Motivation to Combine
`
`David McNamara
`
`Ex. 1012 at AMH00813‐814, ¶ 85; Pet. at 52 (citing same)
`
`Subaru DX-33
`
`

`

`Grounds B, E: Yagihashi – Digital Display
`
`Yagihashi Display
`
`Ex. 1005, AMH00515 (annotated); Pet. at 52, 54‐57 (citing same)
`
`Subaru DX-34
`
`

`

`Grounds B, E: Yagihashi – Digital Display
`
`Ex. 1005 at AMH00539 (annotated);
`Pet. at 54 (citing same)
`
`Ex. 1005 at AMH00538, FIG. 6 (annotated);
`Ex. 1012 at AMH00806, ¶ 67 (citing same).
`
`Ex. 1005, AMH00515 (annotated); Pet. at 52, 55 (citing same)
`
`Subaru DX-35
`
`

`

`Grounds B, E: Yagihashi – Digital Display
`
`Patent Owner’s Argument:
`
`Patent Owner’s Resp. at 27
`
`Subaru DX-36
`
`

`

`Ground E: Yagihashi –Enable/Disable Switch
`
`Ex. 1005 at AMH00538, FIG. 6 (annotated); Ex. 1012 at AMH00806, ¶ 67 (citing same)
`
`Subaru DX-37
`
`

`

`Challenges to Nagashima in Ground D
`
`Section 103(a) –Claims 19‐20 by
`Yoshimitsu and Nagashima
`
`Subaru DX-38
`
`

`

`Ground D: Nagashima – Indicators
`
`Ex. 1010 at AMH00759, ¶[0013] (annotated);
`Pet. at 40 (citing same)
`Ex. 1010 at AMH00751,
`Figure 1;
`Pet. at 43 (citing same)
`
`Ex. 1010 at AMH00761 (annotated); Pet. at 42‐43 (citing same)
`
`Subaru DX-39
`
`

`

`Ground D: Nagashima – Indicators
`
`Claim Language at Issue:
`
`Ex. 1001, claims 19‐20 (annotated)
`
`Subaru DX-40
`
`

`

`Ground D: Nagashima – Indicators
`David McNamara
`
`Ex. 1012 at AMH00804, ¶ 63‐64 (annotated); Pet. at 41 (citing same)
`Patent Owner does not substantively address this disclosure. Patent Owner’s Resp. at 26
`
`Subaru DX-41
`
`

`

`Ground D: Nagashima – Indicators
`
`Patent Owner’s Argument:
`
`Patent Owner’s Resp. at 26 (annotated)
`
`Ex. 1010 at AMH00751 (annotated);
`Ex. 1012 at AMH00804 (annotated),
`¶ 63‐64; Reply at 13‐14; Pet. at 43 (citing same)
`
`Subaru DX-42
`
`

`

`Ground D: Nagashima – Indicators
`
`Ex. 1010 at AMH00760, ¶ 20(annotated); Reply at 14 (citing same)
`
`Ex. 1010 at AMH00761, ¶ 24(annotated); Reply at 14 (citing same)
`
`Subaru DX-43
`
`

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket