UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`____________
`
`BEFORE THE PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`____________
`
`GOOGLE INC.
`Petitioner
`
`v.
`
`B.E. TECHNOLOGY, LLC
`Patent Owner
`____________
`
`Case IPR2014-00031
`Patent 6,771,290 B1
`____________
`
`PETITIONER GOOGLE’S DEMONSTRATIVES
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`Presentation of Petitioners
`
`IPR 2014-00029
`
`IPR 2014-00031
`
`IPR 2014-00040
`
`IPR 2014-00044
`
`US. Patent NO. 6,771,290
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 1
`
`1
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 1
`
`

`

`Principal Prior Art at Issue
`
`-
`
`PCT International Publication Number WO
`
`97209682 to Kikinis (“Kikinis”), published Mar.
`13, 1997 is prior art under § 102(b)
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 2
`
`2
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 2
`
`

`

`The ’290 Patent
`
`EI-I-Il-I-II-II-
`
`"“5933” 5m“ P" (12] Uflitfid States Patent
`Hoyle
`I‘-I‘I
`tll'llll "It I‘I'I'HIIMI MHZ
`III. 41.
`'-E'
`t.|_ HAM .:.u_-.4 Ian
`.WLI'II'JUH-‘lfl'l'i
`
`r_"“"" " '-" “'|'*""?'"¢1"-"
`n+- mm-
`Int-II.- bind Ila-i. warn. I 1.
`I t: “nu-t. .Ic... at.” w...- III-{I'- In.-.
`I.”
`(54) COMPUTER INTERFACE METHOD AND
`u
`~--- Wu”
`“h” mm
`I» t. A :- “P" APPARATUS WITH PORTABLE NETWORK
`“..:::.;T“
`QRGANIZATIUN SYSTEM AND TARGETED
`extra“
`ADVERTISING
`- : t
`II'HJJI.
`III-r lid-II
`IrulrII-I-
`I’I
`IIMI- M- “ii-HIM
`
`[Rn Patent NIL:
`[45) Date ef Patent:
`
`US 6,771,290 B1
`Aug. 3, 20614
`
`
`
`rrIgIrrIIhIIIM'I-Ilrnn hm Huh-"mm HI 1|!-
`~m~nwh~+4~m3
`"" F"!
`‘
`"
`
`”we MA...
`mtkjflliu-Ibld
`
`:‘E: 3'2"” A:
`
`I \ Hum nutmwu
`
`”I T;
`
`(7'5)
`
`Inventor: Martin David [{9er, Metairie, LA
`(us)
`
`Assignee: RE. Thehnnlugy, LLC, Beyr City, MI
`(US)
`
`Notice:
`
`{21) Appl. NO.:
`(22) PCTFiled:
`
`Subject In any disclaimer, the term of this
`patent is extended or adjusted under 35
`LLSL‘. 154(b) by 0 days.
`093744333
`Jul. 16, 1999
`
`‘29!) Patent at pg. 1.
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 3
`
`3
`
`
`
`.
`'-
`
`'
`
`——— —-—” ;'
`=
`i f'A—ge __;-__ __— ' e— .-—-—
`_i|:3 Li'lgflr-W:
`
`
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 3
`
`

`

`
`
`The ’290 Patent, Fig. 50
`
`II}:
`
` led Stale: Fulani
`IIng-
`
`II II IIII II I
`LNH-TI'ISIHII
`
`“III “I!“ Na:
`In: DI“ I! Fahd:
`
`L55 $511.1“ II.
`Afllm
`
`E
`
`'E
`
`”1|er I“. '11. M'flm
`I..m_ u_ Lug HI-‘* -- 1_ v.12 nu... I-m. g
`
`.
`
`View URI.
`--
`Deb“.
`
`Sh“!
`
`Last Visited:
`
`.
`'
`'
`‘
`TIMES! Vis' [Ed‘
`
`|
`
`I
`|
`|
`
`.
`
`’29" Patent Fig. 5!:
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 4
`
`4
`
`
`
`I‘ll: [IN-It'll] Mm] “Emil-ah!
`MHN 'I'I'I'II ”Til-ll mmmn
`IHIANMI'II‘H 5mm 41:: 1.113an-
`HI. 1". I: 'll. bL'W. IE-FL'Id-ID‘ m
`.Imumun:
`h-IIFII'I-I-H- ‘Flllfiw
`..
`“‘11..
`LII-Lh-
`“1...“
`.
`.
`m: mm m gnu-mun...” Inn...
`" M
`'
`'m 5“" UM It“
`I
`I
`v.1
`WIN-“1
`VIEW TIHE
`4n, n.1,.
`t:.:'..n.|.g.ln;_nru._u
`1. “.54 .a.| wan-u |.. [nu-1.. .- mun—hag.
`”uni-k hlhfl m-ulimunuwudmm-
`I
`' P
`"III-1| w! IUNII‘I-lflf-flkflfl'flfll
`umlgnm—y-qunufl-mvu-mw
`WQHW'!’ Iii-“HM“
`NIH-rill
`l'I-I ”ii-1n m‘hH-III “III!“ ! I'l-fll-
`“"- l‘thh'a‘l'l"
`hp‘b—JilMI um...” um dam-hum“
`.
`.
`muni- Ip-n Im'nl II- nr—unuuw—pqm.
`.21 H'I u..|
`Jul. mun
`. awn “In: Ina-r :1: man ”Ln... n.
`"'1 N!" h" mm
`u-l-u-d-n -nan-quhhnfl--—d—t
`flu-Lmhhuahul-‘ilh-
`—. IL
`I.“ “1'“
`hqlenm
`I-Iblln. Wu Jim-Ir III-gm h durum-n II.
`I .1. “I”-
`nvwn-munn-n w-n-nu-wpun um
`IflHH'I-I-
`“I: ll.“
`I-qufl-In"'l Ihl
`anal Inf-l I-u huh-1
`nrrh‘u—qJ-uu—I‘ an. .J_1.u.: uh‘n-l-i
`II '| N- lln um
`ul-Nhflmd Ih-umhlnlhwukuu-Ilnm-
`n I” mmn-
`mwlmfll h lllr IIIIr hin- In In will Dc IIII JII'III-
`“ rIIIpH-I II. i . I IrI-IIHIIII' rug-"2|. II NIH H pct-w
`hit-I thumb
`manna-I. Lyman... ..uu~.n..m..nu.n.|.
`HI' run—m
`.- 4...“ .. r... “. E“... a... ... M u. “,4 huh“... I 1h— m an nan-mu. mI-u- urp.“ .:
`1m.
`mun-w.
`an" lunar—gnaw Inland-inf I'm-111
`“H“.
`-m warm-u lull-Ir- p-pm-n. In mar-r- rI-u
` "I"
`-thI h. duh-II:- d u- n In. qu‘h n‘ m
`
`m ”h“ Mlhu’whu ”In h. uni-pun.- h:
`'5" ll“
`I”: “'- lfl-‘h -
`‘4'”; 7‘“ n-ulmmnm-un- I-nn umh nun-u
`14> MIN}; MlAuJM-L 11".:- 4“.w,.anruml_ "m”MH._.",
`“a... m... n. nI-II‘L Aug-mud“ ._. In...“
`“hi-Full
`m.
`.u Lulu-H .. ul- na...“ 4. n numL
`III-Infill: maul m -I I'll. H- Mic-I '1:
`L'\ HI'l-‘Ill I!” I'HLL'I"!
`[II-Inn. III
`III
`Ilfi
`lll-llfl'll on! II
`
`
`
`I'd-“dud“-
`IFL'J'W .I|.
`' D4- IilHI-l
`m1 —1 It...“
`'LW'IL'A.
`III“ Hon-Id
`II.1.-—nu-nnwu
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`lI--.|
`
`UM
`
`
`”Haitian-nth
`
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 4
`
`

`

`The ’290 Patent, Claim 1
`
`II.:- pflilfld SHE'S PBIEI'I'
`
`Il||- l'lllrnli‘ti-m':
`
`a.-."
`[:5 ET-TIJLW BI
`
`l‘ul n". I :u-ti.
`
`l. A computer-readable memory for use by a client
`computer to provide a user of the computer with an
`integrated, customized, graphical user interface to a pluralityr
`of computer resources, the computer-readable memory,»r com-
`prising:
`
`a non—volatile data storage device;
`
`a program stored on said non-volatile data storage device
`in a computer-readable format;
`
`said program being operable upon execution to displa},F a
`graphical user interface comprising an application win-
`dow separated into a number of regions,
`
`a first one of said regions including a number ofgraphical
`objects, at least some of which are each representative
`of a difi'erent software application and are selectable by
`the user via an input device, wherein said program is
`operable upon selection of one of said graphical objects
`to initiate execution of the software application asso-
`ciated therewith;
`
`fir—‘_—w—1
`
`a second one of said regions including a number of
`user-selectable items, at least some of which are each
`associated with a different data set, said data sets each
`
`comprising a number of links to different information
`resources, wherein said program is operable in
`response to selection of at least one of said items to
`provide the user with access to its associated data set;
`
`said program including a login module that is operable
`upon execution to identifyr the user of the computer;
`and
`
`said program being operable following execution of said
`login module to provide an identification of the user to
`the server and to receive from the server a user profile
`containing one or more user data sets and user lint-ts to
`information resources, with said program further being
`operable to displa}r
`in one of said regions a user-
`selectable item for each ol'said user data sets and each
`
`of said user links.
`
`".190 Patent at 33:29-15? {Clainfil
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 5
`
`5
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 5
`
`

`

`The ’290 Patent, Claims 2-3
`
`Hayseed states Patent
`
`tlllllggggpllm
`nu. l'llllrfll'im':
`cs coupler
`
`2. A computer-readable memory ['or use by a client
`computer in conjunction with a server that is accessible by
`the client computer via a network, the server storing a user
`profile and user library for each of a number of different
`users, with the user library containing one or more files and 5
`the user profile containing at least one user link that provides
`a, link to one of the files in the user library, the computer-
`readable Ingmar? cal-uprising:
`
`a non—volatile data storage device;
`
`a program stored on said non-volatile data storage device
`in a computer-readable format;
`
`to
`
`said program being operable upon execution to display a
`graphical user interface comprising an application win-
`'4;
`dow having a number of user-selectable items dis.
`played therein, whfircin each (1f said items has aggflcj— '
`ated with it a link to an information resource accessible
`
`via the network and wherein said program is operable
`upon execution and in response to selection by a user
`
`of one of said items to access the associated informa-
`[ion resume: [war the ngrwgrk;
`
`said program being operable upon execution to receive
`from server one of the user profiles and to display a
`userwselectable item for user links contained within the
`
`”5H profile, saitltprograrn further '33ng operable in
`response to selection by a user of one of the user links
`to access the file associated with the selected user link
`
`from the user library associated with the received user
`Pl'fifilfi.
`3. A computer-readable memory as defined in claim 2,
`
`wherein said program is operable upon execution and in
`response to selection by a user of one of said items to access
`the associated information resource over the network using
`at brotvser.
`
`as
`
`e
`
`e
`
`e
`e
`‘29!) Patent at 39:1-ifl:1fi{CInirns-?-3l
`
`
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 6
`
`5
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 6
`
`

`

`
`
`PC]:
`
`mums;
`
`11 am
`
`N'I'IIHAWAL mm PIZUSHEJ mu: 'I‘II'E Ph_
`rlfilhr-l—J'fltflih "
`“hm—
`m "m
`M “slur-nut
`il'l'i—‘w-m “Mi"- “'5
`WWMM— Wmlmsflhfl-fiu
`
`-
`
`chum:
`
`w
`
`:.
`
`AI
`
`I'll] Immi Plflklflfll ”Ill:
`
`'3- Hnn'h I99? (13-0331]
`
`PCT
`
`Wat-tic mmscrth mmrr MANHATIDN
`mm Em
`WNAHONHLL mafia“ PUBLISHED {ME THE PATENT COOPERA'I‘IDN TREATY {PCT}
`{511' hmfinfll Plum-151mm 5 =
`:11} tum-sum Pnhflflflan Numb-er:
`WU 07109602
`G051? 17130
`
`Ila-Ill! Immunis- Ih-u-
`
`f’IHHHIF m Mm: t...“ “It...”
`71": rural
`
`“MI-:gmflsfiM-m NHL-W- I“ I-W 5*
`mat—nun hwmnfl_lqndw Illnl
`mmflqu-utmanmi-ima
`led-cl-
`
`""""'
`
`{21] Inlermliuul Applaus- Number:
`
`Pc'rrlamwuss
`
`its} Muted sum: EN. IF. Enema patent (AT. BE. «Cl-I, DE.
`DE, ES, FL FR. GB. GR. IE. IT. LU. MC. HI... FI'. 5E}.
`
`E11! Immune-I Fills: Bate:
`
`30 hug-tut I005 {30.00.00}
`
`[30.1 Prim": DIP-l:
`MEWS
`
`I Sfilfl'flbll' 199-5 (01.09.95;
`
`US
`
` 'Lil-i‘lHt- WWW WKWTHIW
`ie'nu-nn
`(54) Title: SERVICE INDEPENDENT ELECTRONIC DOCUMENT SERVER
`hunt-i flmwflfl'fl—M—l mwkflrm
`mmmwnmnnmimmm-flm
`dubs-mama Imp-aluminium My”
`maunmmmlmmmwuflm 1n-
`IMMIm-unflitmwmlhmnml
`.wnr-IH hwflrmnt-hnwrhfla-Hmflw-fi'
`lit
`
`(5?) Abstract.
`
`A retrieval and auditing system fur electronic dccurnents specificallyr addressed
`
`and forwarded ever an Internet connection, including email, uniccarnuil. and facsimile
`(FAX) dccumants. provides a gateway intei-face in a home page retrievable without
`regard to a particular Internet Service Provider granting access to the Internet.
`In a
`preferred embodiment a security prcmcc] is required to launch the gateway from a
`heme lieger ensuring that the persist-I granted access rc specifically-addressed electronic
`dDCuntents is the addressee.
`
`I ‘
`
`'
`
`I
`
`| —
`
`Hikinis nt pg. 1.
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 7
`
`T
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 7
`
`

`

`
`
`PCT
`
`harmwrnmunr.nun-.11 mmm a
`in“
`.
`.
`
`GB!”
`
`97
`11:”
`
`FPF’IE LIP
`
`User's Provider
`
`PFPJSLIF
`
`
`
`
`| —
`
`Hikinis. Fig. 2 '
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 8
`
`8
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 8
`
`

`

`“Him M11091 MIMI-ED Wm THE mmmm TREAT? m
`mum Hun—- all-hr.
`‘I'l'lil mun
`lemh IlmlflTHlfl‘fl'l
`
`nunmflmmmm nib-LUSH;
`mun—w.“ mm mnhflu.mhap—_mtfl.fllnl
`mmmhfi- Mmflflflfiid
`
`fill-kirk
`Mei-Jim
`
`IWIH‘JNIMH'I
`
`Ul-
`
`Inc—nl unnu—
`
`m-w m MmLhfl-rlmlm
`man-Hz:
`mil-ll KIWI-i! ”WWII-“Ell
`mflfll
`m_ma_.m-u~_w.m I
`hmih-Jl-Ht‘th-tmma
`IWIHJ
`
`d-l-i‘l'flt WNWWKWTHIW
`lift-m
`hmwwmwww mania-I’m
`mmF-nmmmm‘nm
`aniline—pm:- u—nJ-h—hrnn—u-p Mull-I
`WI-nmmm Minimum-nu" hi.
`“Mummumumhmfln-
`“#mflhwmmnwmflammk
`
`Hildnis,Fig.3 .
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 9
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 9
`
`

`

`.mm
`PCT
`mmmmmmmm
`
`
`
`nMH
`
`4m...H.E.
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 10
`
`‘10
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 10
`
`
`

`

`Grounds in This Trial
`
`Kikinis: Anticipates claims 1-3
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 11
`
`11
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 11
`
`

`

`The ’290 Patent, Claim 2 Preamble
`
`
`
`Ll'i'lHTi'IJ-vllll
`Irw- Melt Ki!
`IN INK "I F-IIIIIIF:
`
`Ilfi 6,111.19. R!
`Amhlfll
`
`.._-. United Stat-:5 Patent
`. "f?“
`lll'llLl. K'Hlll MINI":
`Ill-ll
`lmH-Il-I J'ITHIJME HHIHfl-‘L‘Ifl
`WEI- Il‘l11'II "link NI'I'IIII
`hm. u .Ln... Vela-.111" It new“... H...”
`IIIBLWAIIM Hal NH NIL! LWFLD
`
`
`moment-um
`H 11“.“.‘fi
`AMII‘I‘N‘H:
`film] L-r-r I'u 11m.“ hull. _
`
`|Hp tuna.-
`m III-ml I.|l._ hl.|..-_ I A
`.no u"... a... -p...-
`I.'|:'HI
`u._:..:ru
`
`
`m. 3...... annruu-snm
`“'7‘I
`Jim-TI
`|.la.-
`
`J. nit-.1 _I find-- III
`Nels: w—rmmfi-‘anII-IHIM
`wfi“ lulu-un- Ion-II
`g...“ Hm-“ .. up“ _a.. H
`qw‘m.1..-...rm.
`
`l' “I
`I‘I'H- I'll " slut
`.un-u-u l-‘h HIT-n m-
`n...— I-‘U s. m: .a...‘
`II'JILIIJ
`nu an: I».
`, qr—nt mi u n Inn-I
`
`Jew-HI- l'l-I'IJ Imu Im I
`lift
`PI
`| Fri-t M It. I.“
`“IMII‘H’H bran-In]
`{In n'rrL-
`rL't'LwI-Inm
`E-n'LLn—I-u .L. nun-d
`
`|.1-|._
`urn-u munch-q late-u- a.
`I “I
`Ann-u: nan-u nu .mu
`Hie-nu no ml Huh-I
`Apr. IL“!
`thrill-i:-
`
`""1- H'TM‘GI film
`M I.m H
`
`- n. I. .W H— ,. a.
`h'lhfl-iu. III-35.}-
`plum. in: m up up m
`«- r-rl- II-r.. lug-”Hm
`nu.- thrrlrfl-I M
`
`my. Idlbc Milan-IL |.
`he...” 1|— Fr. an“.
`ul'l-II-unn
`I\IIIII-'II
`seamen-"homuncu-
`|n1r Lui—aI-Id-Ilt-‘iha IIIIIII Ind-
`
`-.. “a...“ _|..|.. .—
`I‘II
`ll.l.l.'
`1” HI“
`-.m1 1.. Jump: i .1.
`t
`I‘ll
`ILL'L
`m‘l‘l'fi'
`annual-n ind “In-u I1
`.
`HFI fill! m .
`H'LTIl. "N‘.
`\l-HI‘M .IIIH n-IIILN --rH
`
`n: ML .5; n.1_l_ “L In. .-: r 13;-
`.4. .Inmluu-l u: - mad-d
`was" am he «um-1 a
`litre-1n til
`e." n unabl- .- u, .
`LIL [1.11311 ”HI 1'”! M5
`lI-hI-H II. III-II:- Ir-HI-
`
`fut-h lIIIIILI
`Inl- n-I
`1 I1L":‘! Jt
`" NI- —.
`r-IW‘W“.-I|‘I—r —I:
`Lulu: I.
`”fill lbw“:
`
`«Human—us...
`’1.“ III!
`
` the server storing a user
`
`profile and user library for each of a number of different
`users, with the user library containing one or more files and
`the user profile eontaining at least one user link that provides
`a, link to one of the files in the user library, the computer—
`readable memory comprising:
`
`l'hl
`
`290 Patflrtat claim 2, cited in 00029 Petition at 1?; 00031 Petition at 15-1fi; Hull-11] Petition 3113-14;
`"11044 Petition 81:12.
`
`.1—u
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 12
`
`12
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 12
`
`

`

`Anticipation by Kikinis Fig. 2 is a block diagram illustrating how Internet users may
`
`:5“:
`
`:53.
`
`pc'r
`1‘
`.
`.t
`1::- nonfat“;
`LiIJGI' non
`
`....-.m....
`.-::. kinda—I I
`
`51
`
`............_.....
`" ‘- ' “
`, w.
`
`L
`
`
`-'u|1'1|- LHI‘:
`
`
`
`.m-n.-.
`Ila—u.
`II.-'l|:\.r‘1'I'I-::;.1I_I
`.-. I...“ a. .u;.-..-.
`
`remotely access their e—meiI using the facilities ofthe Web independent
`of‘protfider. fleetirtiint;I to an embodiment of the present invention.
`"'
`5? It iltinient 0:T-'I0. oitetl in 0002-9 Petition at 1?; 00031 Petition M10. 43:
`
`00040 Petition at 'I 3: 11004-1 Petition at 1?.
`
`
`@
`
`
`
`User‘s Provider
`Lona]
`Provider
`
`F'FF'FSLIP
`
`PPP-’SLiP
`
`
`
`Bro weer
`
`_ .
`
`Fig. 2
`Hikinisat Fig. 2. eitetl in 00029 Petition M1113: 00031 Petition at 16: 00040 Petition at 13: 000-14 Petition at 111'.
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 13
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 13
`
`

`

`Anticipation by Kikinis
`
`an. M
`
`hum-Ilium
`Immune-un-
`Infill-HHG‘AIIH-I uttflfl.
`.
`fllflflflllfl. Hill-Hum
`
`In the system of Fig. 2. user station 53 comprises. a high-speed
`
`modem 61, and a computer system 63 having well-known elements of
`
`such a computer system mcluding a Web-browser 65 and PPP or SLIP
`
`
`"HM-"mm .
`mmmmmmmmmmmwm
`M'I-I-l-Hfl-I-lflhl-l-‘I
`"II—hummus
`“film
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`communication software (not shown). Also in the system. a kiosk 55
`
`H ildnis at E: '1 'I -'1 3, cited in [IDIJZB Petition at '1 T; 00031 Petition at 1533-2433“, 43; null-ll] Petition at 9,1 3,1 5; non“ Petition at '1 3.
`
`
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 14
`
`”i4
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 14
`
`

`

`The ’290 Patent, Claim 2
`
`l|-'| U‘itid ELI-“5 Paul“
`. eh
`
`Ilw M
`N.
`
`Ll'i'lHTI'IJ-IHL
`
`'N" - -..-..-
`
`F
`
`
`
`2. A computer-readable memory for use by a client
`computer in conjunction with a server that is accessible by
`the client corn uter via a network
`
`
`the compute r-
`[1 b1
`i.
`i.
`"
`1'63. a
`6 memory CUIIIPI1s1ng
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`IMHWAIIH‘I Fin-l NH NIL! LWJLH
`,t_._.
`mtttwetm‘tfifit-
`hurts-r
`Amllm'u:
`“*- W” "33::
`|.Lu
`minimisim..." en:
`g...“ Hm-“ .. up“ _a.. H
`“Mm-1;
`rs- nmshlum
`sun-u I'.
`II-‘JHJIJ
`‘rm':
`nu w I».
`litr
`PI
`| Fat-e M It. “H
`Inn-HI- II_
`in. an».
`n'r-Lwrlmu
`r'flfl
`lil‘uiilhl‘l: 1' mm
`::;'I::'
`In r-rrmw.
`'IIIIIIHH
`mini
`h'l - m- Jan-15.:-
`$.15:
`w rash-lun- m
`an:
`-
`uh emu-luau
`1.1-. IlfllILFI
`"""hl? E
`.
`r .. :~ _.m -
`ffi;
`I‘ll u.“
`hll' un- Hn" 1., m
`:2: infill-km
`.
`. Muir-i: “-3.11
`th an» cm;
`4M.
`Kin-anti!
`flirt:
`LIJL unm IHIIThflh'lh
`:‘zrl'l
`
`1st: .
`is m:
`r we
`-
`2'90 Patent at claim 2, cited in 00029 Petition at 1B; “0031 Petition 3115-1 6,21; 0004!] Petition at '14;
`
`J
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 15
`
`15
`
`00044 Petition H13.
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 15
`
`

`

`Anticipation by Kikinis
`
`h11'25a11uul_.tl-Inzm1rlx mm Ism'n l"1'.5f'|l ml “fin-r “DION-H.433"; I'll-JET mm.
`Illl Fir-IF” Filrl' L'-
`
`nmm
`Ill-hm“ mill-ml
`
`Web server 6'! runs unique control routines according to an
`
`cw-er-u- embodiment of the present invention that supports a set of data bases 7i.
`.Ju- hint-u M
`crypt-
`
`ITI'JipuI-Hnl rIt-u'x'm:
`“1'; ‘ul
`:I'fl
`":
`lily-Hal mum Du:
`was
`'4 Alt-Mu I'Fllll fiml
`til-.IL'I'VI'r'h HILI'
`
`I
`'lIE
`
`Each data base belongs to (or is assigned to or associated with) a
`
`different client. A single data base of set Til includes a home page 9'3,
`
`individualized to a specific client, that provides software links to various
`
`lower—order data bases maintained by electronic document server 69.
`
`
`-.,- m WW. Examples of such lower-order data bases are an e—mail data base 89 a
`.n. “In,“
`#
`
`may”; fax data base 9 1I a voice mail data base 93: and other electronic
`
`1791-?"419-‘v?’ documents in data base 95. Home page "F3 is created with hypertext
`
`markup language (HTML), as are other home pages, and provides access
`
`to data bases 89, 91, 93, and 95 as described belovv through software
`
`links. Those with skill in the art will recognize that the technology of
`Hiltinisat 1234—89, cited in 110029 Petition at 13: 011031 Petition at 1E-1?,?2; 00041} Petition at "M; 110044 Petition m13.
`
`.1. r
`
`“1‘3
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 16
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 16
`
`

`

`Anticipation by Kikinis
`
`PCT
`."i .'1 35* 11:15: ll
`
`c..._-..-..r-..-,-:-.r ".m-s .-. ,c-r-coo. @
`'
`'I.n |..
`J.I'I': J: J. I II I'\'
`I-‘I 'Iu! “HI I
`I
`I "1'2 k I1 'i
`I”. I 1 Hi I:'.'\I':|v'l H 4: I 'I 3";
`I11 I J- ' ‘I' 1" I -
`
`Fig. 3 shows an example set 11] of windows accessible in a
`'iliiiifillfl: '
`7 home page for accessing electronic documents by using the facilities of a
`.. wcc browser such as wcc browser 109 at kiosk 55 (Fig. 2) according to
`
`”iii-[21.35777"”71‘3-357‘77"7‘7'i
`
`an embodiment of the present invention. A user invokes browser 109
`
`
`
`”'
`
`
`7
`
`and enters a URL for his or her home page '33 in field 1 13 of browser
`
`109. An initiation signal then causes control to retrieve home page 7'3
`
`and display it as an interface to data and other Web destinations.
`
`Operation to this point are conventional. and well-known in the art.
`
`Home page 7'3. however. is different than conventional home pages. as
`
`described above with reference to Fig. 2. having on-screen links to
`
`electronic documents reserved for the home page “owner". such as e—
`
`Hikinia at 1:20-1: 30. citotl in 00020 Petition at 10: 00031 Petition at 10: 000-10 Petition at 15: 0004-1 Petition nt 10.
`
`'-1.
`‘1 "memos
`
`u 7 ~
`
`r
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 17
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 17
`
`

`

`Anticipation by Kikinis
`
`In a preferred embodiment of the present invention, an Internet
`
`home page interface is provided comprising indieia identifying the home
`
`page owner; and an on-screen active selection area for access to an
`
`ea:in“?
`Killinis at claim '1, cited in IPREM 4410029 Reply 9
`
`1. An Internet home page interface comprising:
`
`Hillinisn‘t 3:1-3, cited in mammalian: Reply ntii: 1111031 Replynt'll]: cum Replynt a; mum Reply at 11.
`
`indicia identifying the home page owner; and
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 18
`
`’18
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 18
`
`

`

`.-.-- United SIM-:5 Faun!
`. Heal:
`
`II llllgggflglllll
`.m mm n:
`ma unm- n!
`Hw- lhfi: "F Fell-EFF:
`ALF-.5. “I
`
`a link to one of the files in the user library,—
`
`The ’290 Patent, Claim 2
`
`
`
`
`200 Patient at claim 2, cited in 00020 Petition at 22; 00031 Petition 3110; 00040 Petition at 14—15;
`00044Petitiun at 13.
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 19
`
`19
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 19
`
`

`

`Anticipation by Kikinis
`
`"HM-"mm .
`mmmmmmmmmmmwm
`M'I-I-l-Hfl-I-lflhl-l-‘I
`"II—hummus
`“film
`
`an. M
`
`hummus-n
`Immune-un-
`Infill-HHG‘AIIH-I uttflfl.
`.
`Hill-Hum
`manna-1:“.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`' modem 61, and a computer system 63 having well-known elements of
`
`
`
`
`
`
`eommmflcation software (not shown). Also in the system, a kiosk 55
`
`In the system of Fig. 2. user station 53 comprises. a high-speed
`
`such a computer system mcluding a Web-browser 65 and PPP or SLIP
`
`II iIIinis it E: 'I "I -"I 3, cited in 0002!] Petition at "I T-"I B; 00031 Petition at "I 8; 000-00 Petition at "I 4—1 5; 00044 Petition at "I 3.
`
`
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 20
`
`2.3
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 20
`
`

`

`Anticipation by Kikinis
`
`Expert Declarations
`
`”well—known elements” of a computersvstem .
`
`.
`
`. would have
`
`included some form of non-volatile data storage devices
`
`1T.I:i cited in 00020 Petition at10-1T.
`-1000 at
`00020 E Iliiliit Sal
`
`
`browser software on a user’s computer 63 would necessarily be
`stored on a non—volatile data storage device00031 E Iliiliit G eagle—1004 at 11125. cited in 00031 Petition M13.
`
`a computersystem “having well-known elements of such a
`
`computer. .
`
`.” .
`
`.
`
`. thus describes “a non—volatile data storage
`
`-
`d e V| C e .
`
`H
`
`.
`
`.
`
`00040 EHIiiliit Mcrosoft-1003 at 1m 113. 103-041. citeil in 000441 Petition M15.
`
`the computersystem {63, 107) has well-known elements of such a
`
`computersvstem,which would necessarily include a nonvolatile
`
`d ata StO rage d EVi C e .
`
`0004-1E1tliiliitSanmiiig-1005at1Hfl. citetliii00044Petiti0Iiat13.
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 21
`21
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 21
`
`

`

`The ’290 Patent, Claim 2
`
`Ll'i'lHTI'IJ-IHL
`
`
`.-.-- United SIM-:5 Faun!
`um mu: n:
`ma 6.17mi n1
`Hun-1|:
`H~r lhk uI F-IIIrPF:
`101.5. Ml
`
`lil-ll
`lWH-Il-IJ'ITWMEHHIHfl-‘LH'I
`lll'llLAK'Hlll ”H50:
`mm“ \‘I11'II "link NII'II“
`
`
`-
`,
`5
`_
`_
`m-.M.Lm~emml-kmmw...n.
`Lfii‘fiffi” '”"'”""""“'""'"
`handhmmomu-uu
`II-cl.
`|...u.. mn.mu..l._uu..._u
`’rflrh-"r '"flml-Ilhuh-
`
`flm
`u-In- Dw-n-‘Inr— --r-- h-u-nhu-u- rIn-r-
`_
`u..L._:r-u
`m. 3...... H. In-
`LLM-
`
`I
`'
`I
`74-43::
`“II-pr!MM u
`
`I.'~I
`L
`Iv.
`nu w I».
`
`lltr
`PI
`| HI! M
`
`ill-I FIT IL-
`PL-
`. u. ..1:.._
`
`Jul
`(rm-mam-
`In n'rM‘. m:
`
`h'lN-iI-I- 11-!
`mm.
`
`Infil- IL-ul—a-u-l-ul
`H II I" -- r'hl
`I‘ll
`ll.l.l.'
`'I. .L I.'L
`.
`I‘ll
`HFI PI- II m .
`'III: 'I
`hill
`Ll.L I‘ll!
`1H!::‘I A
`I'I|\.II
`'.|J'.-L"- I.
`-.-I-
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`W 6113111 630 O 8&1
`ltfiIflS as 3.58001-
`
`I'm
`
`200 Patent at claim 2, cited in 00020 Petitiun at10;
`00031 Petition HUB-10; 00040 Petition at 15-10; 00044 Petition at 14w.
`
`
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 22
`
`22
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 22
`
`

`

`“pm;
`
`IL'IIh'r-I-II
`:3. LR:
`I|llJIflI—-lw-m rimmlll-ufl
`m‘hmlmm ”mllfirhuhl
`.hIHI-I
`In .-
`In.» I.
`u.-
`-—':
`
`Anticipation by Kikinis
`
`
`
`
`D E E D E
`Home Page
`
`73
`
`'
`
`1 i 7
`
`120
`
`122
`
`i!
`'i
`It :Jitlfiu-Hnl-llll‘:fl
`
`
`
`Hikinis at Fig. 3 [CI opp-ail}. cited in 00020 Paition at 2'0;
`000 31 Petition 31:19: 00040 Petition at 15; 0004-1 Petition at H.
`
`huh—w
`Tim-kl
`PC]: mm:
`mmm AMEM'IDN FIJLEH'ED m 1111: M!
`
`1'—l'l_I-l:Iflru—'l'IfllT—zltl'“.
`I m
`
`III
`
`Mimi-n.
`guinea-I.
`
`I may: Ila-35 on mm.
`
`H.
`
`ETD-0w mum: :u-l‘r'ltr tJI-dfl
`V": m- In:
`REL-Innu- [minim Julian-“lbw Ila-u l'a.
`map-n. rum: Am_nmnu_unu w nu- I
`menu:
`Ln.mh.)54-ILWI1Llr.llri-1lffl1fl
`noun-.31..
`
`'l-T-H'KT WWW" NWKWWIMH'EI
`I'.l'l| MIL-I
`
` .dA'Fdr
`
`
`HrmfldhwlnrN-Cnuflh‘ I-ruLIn-DI-Ifl fldflnflli
`0MH-rmar-1n-pnu Mrc-mnm-M
`fiflqdflnflgwmmflmwflflpm
`WlpuwmquMHfl—HWL‘HW .l
`”mulnmnmdnmhI-lhkmmi
`Hum: fl
`' If
`III-H Hr. «:LH w rm- r—Ii- mul- n- ImuI-rlr-Hn-w-rm-n
`
`!
`
`
`x.009 e 23 , Pg
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 23
`
`

`

`Anticipation by Kikinis
`
`mlmlmw—ILJ ”mm-.1 “fill-slat“ @
`pc'r
`inn-.11 1....
`'
`.u-H sumo: Pl'nl “In D H.131 u 111i
`l'hfi-‘fi (tun-warns I11 I'Af‘l' .111:
`:H1flfihfllhfifli
`IIIII "gal!” mzfilfll"
`I I:I.L|.|ul.l..l.l2h.h|.1.ul'.|allu
`“TI 97M!
`
`gateway to their information resources. A home page is a graphical
`
`interface unique to an individual user, and it functions in part as a table
`
`of contents. For example, a computer manufacturer may provide a home
`
`Hikinisat 2:3-5. cite-{I in 00029 Petition at 19: 00031 Petition at 2‘4: 00040 Petition at 15-16.
`
`T
`
`I
`
`r
`
`|'
`
`':'.-':.~ of contents. For example, a computer manufacturer may provide a home
`
`page on the Internet WWW with active selection areas (buttons)
`
`directing control and display to such as product information, prices,
`
`system product capabilities, and other web sites. Buttons and the like on
`
`Hiltinietlt 2: 5-1.. citetl in 00020 Petition at 10; 00031 Petition at 24; 00040 Petition M1510.
`F
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 24
`
`34
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 24
`
`

`

`The ’290 Patent, Claim 2
`
`Ll'i'lHTi'IJ-vllll
`
`In: 3......
`I'I NM:
`
`played therein,
`
`nu w I»...
`lift
`PI
`| F“
`{In FITIL-:
`I u. I|.'I|
`if; (I. III-
`In n'rnn
`N'I N!-
`M
`Infil- nun—I.-
`H II III
`I‘ll
`ll.l.l.'
`1. .L I.'L
`I‘ll
`Hfll fill! fl
`
`
`.-.-- United SIM-:5 Faun!
`ma unm- n!
`.m mm n:
`MI.
`ALF-.5. “I
`Hw- lhfi: "F Fell-EFF:
`
`II'I'IILl. Mull mm
`lWH-IHI J'I'fmut HIL'IIRID-JL'I-I'I
`HUI
`W
`[-1- I\‘I11'II "link NI'I'IIII
`-
`1.
`hm. ‘1.th Nag-mph a mun-w... m“.
`
`
`H “HI“. “ mom “4“
`10190055? >1. Imam nmru
`
`|Hp lumi-
`mn:ul..l._uu..._u M1 |---r I'uMI-uhu'n-
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`11d wherein said program is operable
`
`
`290 Patent at claim 2, cited in 00020 Petition flt19-20; 00031 Petition at
`25-20; 00040 Petition at1fi-1?: 00044 Petition at 14—15.
`
`I'm
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 25
`
`25
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 25
`
`

`

`Anticipation by Kikinis
`
`mmmmmmmmmmmwm
`M'I-I-l-Hfl-I-lflhl-l-‘I
`"II—hummus mm
`
`hum-mm
`Immune-un-
`H. M
`. Duh—dim“ m Infill-HHG‘AIIH-I uttflfl.
`unnudilmflmnm
`uu—I-n- mug-mulls:
`
`
` "HM-"mm .
`
`
`
`system product capabilities, and other web sites. Buttons and the like on
`one web page also can cause control to jump to another web page. A
`
`
`
`home page is created with the hypertext markup language.
`
`Hillinis 312:8-3, citfldjn 00023 Petition atle; 00931 Petition 3124i mum Petition 3115,15.
`
`
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 26
`
`25
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 26
`
`

`

`The ’290 Patent, Claim 2
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`.
`
`An:
`
`3-
`
`via the network and wherein said program is operable
`upon execution and in response to selection by a user
`
`of one of said items to access the associated informa-
`tion resource over the network;
`
`said program being operable upon execution to receive
`from server one of the user profiles and to display a
`user—selectable item for user links contained within the
`
`user profile, said program further being operable in
`
`
`
`
`29!] Patent at claim 2, cited in 00029 Petition at 20-21; 00031 Petition ”$19-20; lllllldfl Petition at1fi-1T;
`001144 Petition at 15.
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 27
`
`2?
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 27
`
`

`

`Anticipation by Kikinis
`
`tun-”twang“ ".m-t .-. ,t-p-u-o. @
`'
`-|-I Pd 'I.n|..
`a n..-. -_u I
`- u-.::: n :x-u u. nu Iu r1 u- .- .w-u us --.-.1. nu a-v n.-
`
`PCT
`_--._-1:.._n‘-s1-_;s_-.;,;_ r:-:-
`I51III'41JlI-ull'ilrrr LII
`HUN: l'-'.':|-IJ
`-— -
`- Home page 73, however. is different than conventional home pages, as
`IZI Elfin-aw! tau-um.
`:;-- shun... Ig-liu
`
`described above with reference to Fig. 2, having on-screen links to
`
`'I app-u
`'.'
`Ion-Hui LIM'H'I.
`
`:In'L
`
`electronic documents reserved for the home page “owner". such as e-
`
`'* “vi-ifgfzttsf mail and faxes.
`Hikinis at T: 353:1. cited in 0002‘0I Petition at 2'1: 00031 Petition at 1?: 00040 Petition at 15-10: 0004-1 Petition at 12-13.
`
`In a preferred embodiment of the present invention. an Internet
`
`home page interface is provided comprising indicia identifying the home
`
`page owner; and an on-screen active selection area for access to an
`
`electronic document data base containing electronic documents
`
`addressed specifically to the home page owner. Selecting the on-screen
`Hikinisat 3:1-0. citetl in IPR2014-00020 Reply at a: 00031 Reply at 10: 0mm Reply at 9—1:): 00044 Reply at 11.
`00 11mm "
`'Ilur
`'
`I
`a-ww-w-u
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 28
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 28
`
`

`

`
`
`The ’290 Patent, Claim 2
`
`Ll'i'lHTi'IJ-vllll
`
`“w- Mflt 51:
`W! ”I“ "I Fifi-IF:
`
`[IE 6,171.19. H!
`Jim}. “I
`
`I'm
`
`.._-. United Sui-:5 Faun!
`. "f?“
`
`
`lmH-Il-I J'ITHIJME HHIHfl-‘L‘Ifllil-ll lll'llLl. K'Hlll MINI":
`WEI- I\‘I11'II "link NI'I'IIII
`hm. ‘1.th Nag-mph a mun-w... m“.
`IIIBLWAIIM m-l NH NIL! mun:
`AMII‘I‘N‘H:
`m. mum-m momu-uu
`L.
`m1 1‘ “hi-"041:“. Hulll .
`IHI. Imu- “minim—HI.
`I.'|:'HI
`m. 3...... u.m :|._
`LLM-
`I'I NM: w—rmmfl:
`Mu “amu-
`['5'
`I‘I‘S-l'I-Ur
`Inlum
`nu w I».
`litr
`PI
`| HI! M It. I.“
`{In n'rrL-
`rL'r'LwI-Im:
`I u. ..1:.._
`(rumm-
`Apr. ILHIII
`In n'rM‘. film
`“1 N-iI-I- III-35.}-
`nu.- hxw
`IL-ul—a-u-l-A-u
`1..“
`Infil-
`u I' r-q. --n-
`nu:
`ll.l.l.'
`I‘ll
`1. .L I.'L
`I‘ll
`.
`w. rum m .
`m ML .5; .1.
`Kin-1n I.”
`Ll.L [111?“ IJHI'I'H-
`1IH.":‘! a.
`"NI- I-uu—.
`Lulu: I.
`”fill H.114:
`1|.nl "Milli-.1"
`
`user profile,
`
`
`290 Patent at claim 2, cited in 00029 Petition 31:21;
`00031 Petition at19-21],27-28; MIMI] Petition 3116-1 7; 00044 Petition at 16.
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 29
`
`29
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 29
`
`

`

`Anticipation by Kikinis
`
`__—
`-
`I 1“me Lnku
`
`A subscriber ma)»I use the facilities of the Web to access his or
`
`her home page on [SP 5? from anywhere on Earth, and then use the link
`
`'I *PIPH'“
`{13; features in the home page to access the electronic document data bases.
`'.' Purl-III
`l.
`'1 LM:
`1.;.'--.':‘..*'-"~ ‘1' At the access station, such as a kiosk, the subscriber can retrieve and
`
`read e-mail messages, faxes, listen to voice mail, and further receive
`
`., _ other sorts of electronic documents. such as videos or audio files. If the
`-|'- Mun-I
`
`..
`
`.r...1\-.'-I.r 'I'-'
`|::-.1-I'|'1- I
`l'lHT.” run-u m- “. 1...: 1.-
`.
`
`
`K iliinisat 1:11-10. cite-{l in 00020 Petition at 21: 000 31 Petition at 20: 00040 Petition at 10-1?: 0004-1 Petition at 10.
`
`”EL-.- p.51; -_|--
`.L_.:~.i""':__,'
`.m-:--— I
`
`As an example, home page 73 in Fig. 3 has a button 117 labeled
`
`v-mail, for voice mail. By selecting button 117 a user is linked to data
`
`base 93 (Fig. 2) through CGI 80 and voice mail program 87. This
`it iliinis at 3: 24. citetl in 00020 Ft only at 0: 00040 Petition at 10 iciting E ii. 1 003 [H ouh [I ecu at 1T 1 2?}.
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 30
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 30
`
`

`

`The ’290 Patent, Claim 3
`
`Ll'i'lIiITI'IJ-IIHL
`
`.-.-- United SIM-:5 Pauul
`Hun-1|:
`
`um mu: m IIII unm- n1
`IN ”I“ "I F-IIIrIIF:
`M15. Ml
`
`IlilI MWHII-i-l'ruqu. HIL'IIHID-JL'I- I'l
`MIA-“11“"IIIIIIII It
`
`'IIII. K'IIIII ”II”I“:
`
`hm tweak-am lu“.u... .M
`”grammesmImh'ILFIHWFI—H
`I“. “Wman-u
`I...u.. mn.ml..l._uu..._u Mr II---r I'n'n-M-uhu
`Jw
`I:I1_h-_w:n-'In-r—-r--Inc-Eli:nqd- II-r_-n_.
`
`II-Il.
`
`
`
`
`i....-...
`3. A computer-readable memory as defined in claim 2,
`.
`wherein said program is operable upon execution and in
`response to selection by a user of one of said items to access
`the associated information resource over the network
`
`
`
`
`5555m-
`I'InI
`LI'
`1Hu:‘r I.
`I_
`'.IJ'.- L'
`1L
`
`200 Patent at claim 2, cited in 00020 Petition $0.22; 00031 Petition at 20-30; 00040 Petition at "IT-10;
`00044 Petition at 1 '.|"-1 0.
`
`
`
`
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 31
`
`31
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 31
`
`

`

`Anticipation by Kikinis
`
`I—___ Mini-"Hm
`
`“Haulw “film".
`fllflfltflllfl.rfllflnfi.flh
`
`Fig. 3 shows an example set 111 of windows accessible in a
`
`
`
`"HM-"mm 0
`rcr
`
`mmmmmmmmmmmwm
`
`
`
`home page for accessing electronic documents by using the facilities of a
`
`
`Web browser such as Web browser 109 at kiosk 55 (Fig. 2) according to
`
`an embodiment ofthe present invention. A user invokes browser 109
`
`
`
`Hillinisat 1:20-20, cited in 00020 Petition 31:22; 00031 Petition 3120-30; 00040 Petitinn 31.11110; 00044 Fetitinn 31.11
`
`
`
`
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 32
`
`32
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 32
`
`

`

`
`
`IJNI'E'l-IIII H'I'J‘T'I'l-IS I’A'I'IW'I' ENE} "I'll-"kl lI-IMJ'THK {HiFltll-I
`
`I
`
`KIKINIS DOES NOT DISCLOSE “A PROGRAM STORED ON SAID
`
`N ON—VOLATILE DATA STORAGE DEVICE” THAT PERFORMS
`
`THE FUNCTIONS CLAIMED IN CLAIMS 1 AND 2.
`
`
`J’utunl fiJNJ‘Jl]
`I
`
`Patart I‘aner Reqmnsesat 'u'
`
`THE '290 PATENT TEACHES A “ONE-CLICK" SYSTEM
`
`Patent flwner Rflfilflllfiflflt VI [011041] at 1ulll}
`
`
`PATENT OWNER‘S RESPDNSE To PETmcm
`m GER. § 42.121”
`
`I
`
`KIKINIS DOES NOT DISCLOSE A USER PROFILE.
`
`
`
`Patent UWI'IEI' Rmonma‘t VII {011040 at 'UIII]:
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 33
`
`33
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 33
`
`

`

`
`
`| INI'F'JiIJ H'I'J‘fl'lifi I’A'J'H‘J'I' AME} 'I'Ilhl lliMJ‘THK (ll-'HL'l-I
`
`
`[3| E FOR] '1 TE 1| I Pn'l'l INT TI? | M . AN] 3| M‘E‘J if“ T I'H JAR”
`
`
`KIKINIS DOES NOT DISCLOSE “A PROGRAM STORED ON SAID
`
`NON-VOLATILE DATA STORAGE DEVICE” THAT PERFORMS
`
`THE FUNCTIONS CLAIMED IN CLAIMS 1 AND 2.
`
`
`L'I'NNl': If. I’fi'["E'Ii}]{I':W. sidmimlsl'nun-T Pan-m .J'iuigu's.
`
`Patent UMIHHESIJOIISEES at U
`
`PISTJTGREEW. sldmrmsrmflw Prmurhfrm‘gv.
`
`
`
`PATENT OWNER‘S RESPONSE To PETITION
`
`m GER. § 42.121”
`
`Mail Slop l‘uiunl ihmnl
`PHIL'III.
`'[II'I'EIJ and Amwul: E'Sd'tau‘d
`Unilcd final-:5 Patcnl and 'I'radmmri-z { It'l'icu:
`PI 1. Hum 145“
`Newlruirin. ‘v'r'i. 22.“ 3-145”
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 34
`
`34
`
`Google Ex. 1018, pg 34
`
`

`

`
`
`| INl'l'l'iIJ H'I'J‘fl'lifi l’fi'l'lt'l‘l'l' AME} 'I'Ih‘tl lliMJ‘tHK (ll-'l’lL'l-I
`
`
`A.
`
`Kikinis Teaches Remotely Stored Programs.
`
`Kikinis generally discloses a system that provides remote indirect access to
`
`electronic documents, such as e-mail. See Ex. 1005, Col. 1:1-3 (“The present
`
`00020 Patent Ownerfleeuone-eat 0; 00031 Patent 0 wnerR-emoneeat 0;
`00040 Patelrt fl'INIlflI' Response at 11; 00044 Patent Owner Reepolleeet 10.
`
`
`lie-IEIrLL‘rMI‘YFL'hEEDI :Ii‘f'.‘ KIA-IXAN K. DEESJIIE‘i-“ILNIJ'l-I. and
`
`mail”). But unlike the system claimed in the i290 patent, Kikinis requires
`
`remotely stored programs to access the remotely stored electronic documents.
`
`00020 Patent OwnerReeuoneeat 0; 00031 Patent 0 W'I'IBI'RBBIJDIISIEH'I 0;
`00040 Patent GMIeI'R Jone-e at 11; 00