`
`
`By:
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Thomas Engellenner
`Pepper Hamilton LLP
`125 High Street
`19th Floor, High Street Tower
`Boston, MA 02110
`(617) 204-5100 (telephone)
`(617) 204-5150 (facsimile)
`
`UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`___________________
`
`BEFORE THE PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`___________________
`
`YAMAHA CORPORATION OF AMERICA
`Petitioner
`
`v.
`
`BLACK HILLS MEDIA, LLC
`Patent Owner
`___________________
`
`Case No. IPR2013-00594
`Patent 8,050,652
`___________________
`
`
`PATENT OWNER’S NOTICE OF
`SUBMISSION OF DEMONSTRATIVES
`
`

`

`
`
`IPR2013-00594
`U.S. Patent No. 8,050,652
`
`PATENT OWNER’S NOTICE OF
`SUBMISSION OF DEMONSTRATIVES
`
`Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. § 42.70, Patent Owner Black Hills Media, LLC
`
`(“Patent Owner”) hereby submits the attached demonstratives for the Oral Hearing
`
`scheduled for October 20, 2014.
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`Dated: October 16, 2014
`
`
`
`
`By: /Thomas Engellenner/
`Thomas Engellenner, Reg. No. 28,711
`Pepper Hamilton LLP
`125 High Street
`19th Floor, High Street Tower
`Boston, MA 02110
`(617) 204-5100 (telephone)
`(617) 204-5150 (facsimile)
`Attorney for Patent Owner
`
`-1-
`
`

`

`IPR2013-00594
`U.S. Patent No. 8,050,652
`
`CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
`
`
`I hereby certify that on October 16, 2014, a true and accurate copy of this
`
`paper, PATENT OWNER’S NOTICE OF SUBMISSION OF DEMONSTRATIVES, was served
`on the following counsel for Petitioner via email:
`
`David L. Fehrman
`Mehran Arjomand
`Morrison & Foerster LLP
`707 Wilshire Boulevard
`Los Angeles, CA 90017-3543
`Tel: (213) 892-5630
`Fax: (323) 210-1329
`
`
`Dated: October 16, 2014
`
`dfehrman@mofo.com
`marjomand@mofo.com
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`By:
`
` /Thomas Engellenner/
`Thomas Engellenner, Reg. No. 28,711
`Pepper Hamilton LLP
`125 High Street
`19th Floor, High Street Tower
`Boston, MA 02110
`(617) 204-5100 (telephone)
`(617) 204-5150 (facsimile)
`Attorney for Patent Owner
`
`
`
`

`

`Patent Owner Black Hills Media, LLC
`Trial Demonstratives
`
`1
`
`

`

`US PATENT 8,045,952
`METHOD AND DEVICE FOR
`OBTAINING PLAYLIST CONTENT
`OVER A NETWORK
`
`’
`
`’
`
`'
`United States Patent
`Qureshey 9‘ 31‘
`
`(It!) Patent No.:
`,
`[45) D9“ “f Patent.
`
`US 8,050,652 BZ
`,
`fiNm‘ 1s 20“
`
`'
`
`Nmm.
`
`.'
`.
`[Olmxnnrvu‘nFORM
`MI:
`R\I)l()('.\l‘ARI ‘
`)B '.\IVI\( PI.\YI
`( 0.
`..
`I
`V”;
`Imumm SaIioun-m
`1mm n. snépme um. m (US)
`shugnu:
`llIInhamEnlurpriwL,” :_
`WIIminglullJNiUJS)
`Sum
`.1 any disclmmur. lhu [L'rm m Ihis
`IuIIL'nt
`xlundod nr ndiuslnd IIIILJII! 35
`l) qr. l54(hlby 1374 my.
`‘I‘lm pawn L> aubjm In a Icmn‘nal div
`clninwt.
`“sum:
`No“ 212006
`Prim- l‘ullliniliun Data
`I 3
`.
`.
`\.
`.'
`”52°07’0le 2“
`"’r 1’ 2007
`“mm, U.s.r\
`”who“ um
`(.mmmmmn nl upphculmn Nu, (1013mm. [1ch1 m.
`12, 2“”. mm :IhimdnnL‘LL which
`Mar,
`I:
`I.
`,
`“T
`mm“ “mm." “r WWW M nwmmm.
`.
`-
`.
`J
`.
`(l
`I
`I
`,
`,
`.
`“MM ““ 12 ”)3 "W ‘m‘h‘w
`l’mviswml Mppl
`on N“. (EU/246.3542. mud un an'.
`3, 2000, pmvisioml ”Iguana“ Nu, (mm, I 27_ fim
`unlun 22.1998
`(200601)
`[RISK 11/!!!)
`InI.(:I.
`(2006.01)
`0'06!" 15/16
`(mum)
`[luvs/415
`“4,34 . 455155“: 455657;
`U“; (-1,
`,
`4.1
`55,4,
`709,2” 70%ij
`45
`mam-725:5
`,
`T
`'
`'
`.
`Held arnmimnon Search .
`Ii 1 :12
`»
`-
`.
`4554““ ”2‘ '501- 15"" '5] 2‘ IS-H.
`455154.2‘ lix‘l- 15“- 153‘4- IKGII-JH-
`‘
`JSSMIAH. “LE-150,1 556L557: 709/217.
`70‘}
`1*} 725/1‘JI45I1K
`
`
`
`US PATENT 8,050,652
`METHOD AND DEVICE FOR AN
`INTERNET RADIO CAPABLE OF
`OBTAINING PLAYLIST CONTENT
`FROM A CONTENT SERVER
`
` z
`
`(5(2)
`
`,
`
`'
`
`lurmmwzh
`
`‘
`
`IMI-rI-ncI-u'ned
`U S MllzN I' IXX'UMILNIS
`I
`.
`I
`7
`.
`,
`.
`“1"” "
`"”6" “h
`“
`“WWW”
`FORIIIGNl‘\['|,N'l'l)O(‘lJMl'
`992mm .\1
`3sz
`(c “mm”
`(TllilIR I’UBLI‘ZWI'JUNS
`I Suumlxcm '
`"A Music Rmvluuun I
`uwsc. 2 mm
`((‘Imlmumh
`I-rma- Wm Iummm.
`II7I4III:Iumm: 4ng m f‘mir Wllllmw a:
`(57)
`A155 TRACT
`.
`“Id” a mph.)
`A ncmnrk mm :Iudm duvlcu II
`um mm mm. \IIcuficr [a wlw playhu ni'numc much
`from I isk In».- (113.1.) mul “mummy, mum.» bmum
`ill‘lllll‘ nlll‘}
`\ilL'».LlndI]lhfl
`.“lllhlflillllCL‘v wnsmcullulw
`IiIx- In hux' dimmed. me use“:
`caulpmc pm) ‘sh
`”MIT Dam-d “fab hmddcabt I'mm K.
`lul'zu'aILz-bIlIHVch
`bmmlv.‘
`‘InaddII
`lhcnscr
`play Lunlzmimvdml‘] ‘I
`and MP3 enoudcd c1)
`audlmvmu I m l:
`:IlAMfl'M
`alumnus 1 unlIur, II|L‘ 50h
`llm I
`‘r colllmls and flu: HH-
`play me “warn-mm
`dam-L am nlpcrdhb' my
`figured “dcfllulCClCdSkIChEhdlth‘
`crcun IL‘
`'IIIopLIyII'
`‘
`mm Include m)" and nthur m
`m .I\ ma um
`,
`acrwrsilc
`.‘
`sI in a i
`mum chuusca pluI
`I cmhlaul
`Uf'lhcdwic
`Inwremmm
`AIId‘mNclwmk[JMN):IIIdeI:II
`‘nu-n: NIIIcludus
`I'IE’ANwrvu amp-\Nclicm.
`snlluiln. mm nIIIIIcm‘murL -n.uhw:nmmamcu.1I
`mt ulnmkrclwhluldudindmccpmwdt pcuplewhnarum
`2
`- ml mmlurlnNu “llh CulllpulL‘B (I \x
`k'
`'
`lmm mnm-wummd [mum 1qu m1 pim‘clurlixlcumg
`NI. mm mm: emhule‘IncnlleP ‘
`l(‘umplllcr(|’(‘
`‘
`mud-nu IIpmthL-playln
`bHIIIIL'H
`'
`lcmllilunm
`Hoyhs mklmllcruudlu “Irena-Mm“
`lg ith'r
`
`I
`-
`-
`.nuT \nnn uwm I
`
`USS,045,952 52
`(10) PaIent
`(I2) United States Patent
`
`Qureslley el al. “Oct. 25, 20]] (45) Dale of Pain":
`
`ME'l’EIUJ) \VI) I)F\‘]('l-'. “11:051wa NH
`Ikl'crum‘m l‘iII-d
`1"..‘VlJ-‘i1 (-0" ”‘v
`I ”VICRANLHVOR
`luwmun:
`'ufloun‘xhcy ‘4IIM.’\n.I.('.’\(l
`'
`{Ixmmm
`Danielllhmppird Hmu.(.\[lJ>)
`.\$:-Ig\\n.\l
`llu
`mhlk'rprlws.].].(:.
`unsuszu .\I
`11000
`I1)m-.JuNl'.\H-,N1Ixx‘uMhNIs
`Wilmmgmn IJJ'IIN)
`(E mum-x!)
`anim‘:
`Sumwl Io any diwlaimur. dw Imn m'IIIis
`.
`,
`[mum n menm m deHMnl mm" :5
`m III.R PUB] II.
`1151‘ 154(an I Mag-:2
`“\\¢!\n«lm
`imp: mwmhml
`rum.“
`.
`.
`.
`.
`.
`,
`.
`,
`mmzn Imam 1 “41m. LamlIngl
`1““ P-"HI'
`'- A“ '“ -' “mm-'1 "1"
`wmqirmmllm In. 1m“
`mum.
`(I unlmuud]
`Anal Nu; 111552.221
`f'riumrI Emuuw mm“ In...
`,
`.
`:Vgrm. M 1m» Wilkmm 52
`r74) . "mm-I
`”'“L
`5"“ 17' 2"“
`'
`I
`I ‘
`I'm..- Pullliuliun um
`(57)
`MN Hm 'I'
`[\mudtsI who
`1 m-nmmmImIL-d .m ”4mm I
`‘J52w7""‘”“”]‘5-‘l
`"1" 19.2007
`dm
`"nth:Wk‘cw'lilj‘IJIlizian'g run-m1:
`Ih-IIIIudU
`\PF“
`Iivnllulu
`-
`'
`"InhflsdudmhflWn-m
`(Imllnlmliunal‘nppLIL
`nNn (Imus-17». I'm-LI un
`-bh
`IL
`1'
`I
`I,
`,
`I2 mm. mm :IhauanML “h I.
`Mu:
`Is
`I:
`I‘IIIII 'I‘I’I‘IIII
`‘
`“:I\I]d':>l:!l\],llfl‘::“
`umIinuIIus
`rpull ut’apphmmn Nu. mamjm.
`m MManndodt'liR “.41“.
`F munma
`“M"“J'm'” 9%me
`"‘“ML
`-
`Ii» mun-
`urLIInIrI:]>..:IIdIln-dw
`Win“, ”WHEN,”N“.{mmmmwmNW mm ‘ l-urlhcr
`“"1," 21mm
`lkuurt m
`{I I‘m In
`K2mm.pmvmuml:Ipplmfllinn N\!.5U-’072.127II]]\)G
`"
`‘
`-
`III'IJI“: “tw'lmmfi
`I,
`I
`I
`""-
`'-
`wnLrMII:wnzI]‘(';|ndV|I|:]IIL:n\I:[.ImIlHl
`.
`”043 1/”
`(WWI)
`mtrnh
`Imm'mL-dewn IerIIL-IImL-nm Panama}
`”05" [UM
`'lUdil‘NLMiul‘k [l]'.\N)£I|’|d \\ mu songs (mam: [INN dIMI
`[2mm 0“
`I!“
`(”’6’ 15/16
`”VHF-\N includcsuu U‘.\N acn‘chm Il’,\N L‘Ii
`I’Hld Il’,\N
`[WOOD
`mum/445
`(11mm)
`mlm MINI”um.II-mvkqlmmmmm
`Im
`Imu,
`4551344‘4551102;455}U{ 455/4l-I‘L
`”NHL \urk-umhludun .udnwpxmmIpemI-wmm
`-
`Im: um cumlbnuhlc mm cnmgmw 'u - ul'mking m
`m 19; 7214:
`I’lpmnn-lminm.“mm.
`Immmn’nmmumnndpuuingIIiaum-Iu.
`tlhrlmc Hg
`.4554“.
`,55,.,(5_._ ”5.1. lam. 1.02.
`no. 142.
`plmum', III uuuuulbmlmxchhA' l’cvaIlel umpumrfl‘C) u
`455-4I5,L4|alml.556|,
`,
`‘ssx, ml“WWW”Wrifly'w-'“Il“w“wiwb'h‘|““w"'l‘
`7U‘).'2L7.2]‘): 72513a.4.<.m
`“"5"
`"‘d”"‘”"“““““m““‘”“"““*“‘B”'““"
`)IHIIL‘flVfllmplult‘ warm lIiuurg'
`2fi(‘luimu.‘fl “II-wing 511ml;
`
`Immm
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`’
`
`’
`
`OBTAINING PLAYLIST CONTENT
`
`V
`
`'
`
`'
`
`FROM A CONTENT SERVER
`
`
`
`2
`
`

`

`“While the industry was
`predominantly focused on the
`significance of the audio content
`distribution systems in November
`2000, the ‘952 Patent was focused
`on the role of playlists in managing
`audio content . . . The role of
`playlists in content distribution
`systems is one of the more
`significant innovations disclosed in
`the ‘952 patent. . .”
`- Zatkovich Decl. (593/Ex. 2012 at ¶31;
`594/Ex. 2011 at ¶31)
`
`3
`
`

`

`“Thus, the network-enabled audio device provides people who are or are not
`comfortable with computers a way of taking music from various sources and
`putting it into one place for listening pleasure.”
`- 593/Ex. 1001 at 3:19-23; 594/Ex. 1001 at 3:20-24
`
`4
`
`

`

`“FIG. 17E illustrates a scheduling window 1763 that opens in response to the
`pressing the schedule button 1710. The user can schedule playlists to be
`played at a particular time and on a particular device. The network-enabled
`audio device will automatically turn on at the scheduled time and play the
`given playlist. . . . For example, the user can choose to have a selected playlist
`played every Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday at 6 p.m.”
`- 593/Ex. 1001 at 3:19-23; 594/Ex. 1001 at 3:20-24
`
`5
`
`

`

`9. A method comprising:
`receiving, at an electronic device, a playlist assigned to
`the electronic device, the playlist identifying a plurality of
`songs, wherein ones of the plurality of songs are not
`stored on the electronic device;
`receiving, at the electronic device, information enabling
`the electronic device to obtain the ones of the plurality of
`songs from at least one remote source; and
`obtaining the ones of the plurality of songs from the at
`least one remote source.
`
`6
`
`

`

`1. An electronic device comprising:. . . a system enabling
`playback of audio content from a playlist . . . when the
`desired mode of operation is the playlist mode of
`operation:
`receive the playlist assigned to the electronic device
`from the central system, the playlist identifying a plurality
`of songs, wherein ones of the plurality of songs are not
`stored on the electronic device;
`receive information from the central system enabling
`the electronic device to obtain the ones of the plurality of
`songs from at least one remote source;
`obtain the ones of the plurality of songs from the at
`least one remote source; and
`play the audio content indicated by the playlist.
`
`7
`
`

`

` Board’s Preliminary Construction in 593/594:
`“a list of audio files or URLs of where the audio files were
`retrieved from”
`
`(593/Paper 22 at 13; 594/Paper 17 at 12)
` Board’s Preliminary Construction in 597:
`“a list of media selections”
`
`(597/Paper 15 at 9)
` BHM’s Proposed Construction in 593/594/597/598:
`“a list referencing media items arranged to be played in a
`sequence”
`(593/Paper 34 at 13; 594/Paper 27 at 13; 597/Paper 26 at 14; 598/Paper 31 at 15)
`◦ BHM’s construction is consistent with the specifications of the
`‘952, ‘652, ‘099, and ‘873 Patents and is supported by the
`declarations of Ivan Zatkovich (“Zatkovich Decl.,” 593/Ex. 2012
`at ¶¶54-84; 594/Ex. 2011at ¶¶55-86) and Dr. Gareth Loy (“Loy
`Decl.,” 597/Ex. 2011 at ¶¶38-59; 598/Ex. 2011 at at ¶¶44-52).
`
`8
`
`

`

`◦ TerraTec M3PO High Quality Audio Decoder Manual, dated May 18, 2000 (“TerraTec
`Manual,” 593/Ex. 2013; 594/Ex. 2012);
`◦ SIREN™ Jukebox, published in 2000 (“SIREN Jukebox Manual,” 593/Ex. 2014; 594/Ex.
`2013); and
`◦ Microsoft Windows Media™ Player 7 Handbook, published October 4, 2000, (“Microsoft
`Handbook,” 593/Ex. 2015; 594/Ex. 2013).
`
`- Zatkovich Decl. (593/Ex. 2012 at ¶55; 594/Ex. 2011 at ¶59)
`
`9
`
`

`

`A playlist references media items (e.g., by title, see Microsoft Handbook, 593/Ex.
`2015 at 49; 594/Ex. 2014 at 49) arranged to be played in a sequence (i.e., as a
`group, without having to select individual songs for playback):
`
`- SIREN Jukebox Manual (593/Ex. 2014 at 41; 594/Ex. 2013 at 41)
`
`- SIREN Jukebox Manual (593/Ex. 2014 at 45; 594/Ex. 2013 at 45)
`10
`
`

`

`- SIREN Jukebox Manual (593/Ex. 2014 at 41; 594/Ex. 2013 at 41)
`
`- TerraTec Manual (593/Ex. 2013 at 10; 594/Ex. 2012 at 10)
`
`- TerraTec Manual (593/Ex. 2013 at 20; 594/Ex. 2012 at 20)
`
`11
`
`

`

`- Microsoft Handbook (593/Ex. 2015 at 40; 594/Ex. 2014 at 40)
`
`- Zatkovich Decl. (593/Ex. 2012 at ¶¶56-57; 594/Ex. 2011 at ¶¶58-59)
`
`12
`
`

`

`The ‘952 and ‘652 Patents use the term “playlist” consistent with its plain
`and ordinary meaning. Zatkovich Decl. (593/Ex. 2012 at ¶¶60, 74;
`594/Ex. 2011 at ¶¶62, 76).
`
`- ‘952 Patent (593/Ex. 1001 at 24:31-43); ‘652 Patent (594/Ex. 1001 at 24:31-43)
`
`- Zatkovich Decl. (593/Ex. 2012 at ¶61; 594/Ex. 2011 at ¶63)
`13
`
`

`

`◦ The DAD486x Digital Audio Delivery System Operation Manual, June 30, 1995 (DAD486x
`Manual,” 597/Ex. 2022);
`◦ Microsoft Windows Media™ Player 7 Handbook, published October 4, 2000, (“Microsoft
`Handbook,” 597/Ex. 2024;
`“Playlist,” Broadcast Dictionary (Broadcast Educators, LLC), (“Broadcast Dictionary,”
`597/Ex. 2025); and
`
`◦
`
`- Loy Decl. (597/Ex. 2011 at ¶¶48-49)
`
`14
`
`

`

`The ‘099 and ‘873 Patents use the term “playlist” consistent with its plain
`and ordinary meaning. Loy Decl. (597/Ex. 2011 at ¶¶54, 74; 598/Ex.
`2011 at ¶47).
`
`- ‘099 Patent (597/Ex. 1001 at 1:45-52)
`
`- Loy Decl. (597/Ex. 2011 at ¶46)
`
`15
`
`

`

`As evidenced by above publications, PHOSITA understands that a playlist
`references media items arranged to be played in a sequence (i.e., as a group,
`without having to select individual songs for playback):
`
`- Microsoft Handbook (597/Ex. 2022 at 40)
`
`- DAD486x Manual” (597/Ex. 2024 at 3-13)
`
`- Broadcast Dictionary (597/Ex. 2025 at 2)
`
`16
`
`

`

` Petitioner’s Proposed Definition:
`“at least a bachelor’s degree in computer
`science or electrical engineering and at
`least one year of practical experience”
`(593/Ex. 1002 at ¶8; 594/Ex. 1002 at ¶8)
` BHM’s Proposed Construction:
`“a Bachelor’s degree in computer science
`or electrical engineering or its equivalent
`and 1-2 years of practical experience with
`media file sharing”
`
`(593/Ex. 2012 at ¶26; 594/Ex. 2011 at ¶26)
`
`17
`
`

`

`v.
`
`Environmental Designs Ltd v. Union Oil
`713 F.2d 693 (Fed. Cir. 1983)
`593/Paper 34 at 12
`594/Paper 27 at 12
`
`18
`
`Bove Depostion Transcript
`593/Ex. 2016 at 50:12-51:22
`594/Ex. 2015 at 50:12-51:22
`
`

`

` The ‘952 Patent (IPR2013-00593):
`
`◦ Claims 9, 10, and 14 as anticipated by Berman;
`◦ Claim 13 as obvious over Berman; and
`◦ Claims 9, 10, and 14 as anticipated by Wolff.
`
`19
`
`

`

` The ‘652 Patent (IPR2013-00594):
`◦ Claims 1-4, 6, 7, 13, 21, 22, 24, 25, 27, 28, 34,
`42-45, 47, and 48 as obvious over White;
`◦ Claims 1-4, 6-8, 10, 13, 21, 22, 24-29, 31, 42-
`45, 47-50, and 52 as obvious over Qureshey and
`Berman; and
`◦ Claims 11, 32, and 53 as obvious over Qureshey,
`Berman, and Leeke.
`
`20
`
`

`

`The playback unit [100] communicates over a network, such as the Internet
`102, to request digital audio material from one or more audio material servers
`104. The playback unit receives audio material from an audio material server
`and provides it to a conventional home audio system 106 for playback. . . .
`Access to the audio material and authority for distribution rights are preferably
`controlled by a directory and user list (DUL) server 107 . . . . The playback
`unit includes a network interface 110 that provides a communication channel
`with the Internet 102 and to the audio material server 104.
`- Berman at 4:53-5:14 (593/Ex. 1012; 594/Ex. 1012)
`
`21
`
`

`

`Ierman’s Song List
`
`302
`
`i 304
`
`301
`
`
`
`POWER ON.
`
`USER SELECTS ARTIST,
`TITLE, ALBUM, GENRE,
`ETC.
`
`SEND CURRENT SONG LIST
`VERSION T0 DUL SERVER.
`
`310
`
`
` 306
`NO
`SON
`G LIST
`DUL SENDS UPDATED
`RENT7
`SONG LIST TO
`' a PLAVBACK UNIT.
`USER SELECTS
`
`ARTIST AND SONG
`TITLE,
`
`30
`
`
`
`
`USER SELECTS ARTIST.
`
`TITLE, ALBUM, GENRE,
`
`CURRENT? . PLAYBACK UNIT.
`
`SONG LIST
`
`DUL SENDS UPDATED
`
`SONG LIST TO
`
`CUR
`
`
`
`
`DUL SERVER SENDS URL OF
`AUDIO MATERIAL SERVER
`
`
`AT WHICH SONG DATA IS
`STORED.
`
`312
`
`314
`
`USER SELECTION
`SENT TO DUL
`SERVER.
`
`
`
`
`
`22
`
`

`

`“U.S. Patent No. 7,472,353 of Wolff et al. (“Wolff”),
`entitled “Remote Console for Network Application
`Servers,” discloses a method and system for
`organizing and retrieving multimedia objects such as
`“Moving Picture Expert Group (MPEG) video's,
`MPEG audio Layer-3 (MP3), music compact discs
`(CD), etc.” Wolff, Abstract and 3:21-25. As shown in
`Figure 1 of Wolff, a remote controller (130), which can
`be a Personal Digital Assistant (PDA), allows the user
`to select a media object to be played by a network
`access appliance (NAA) that is coupled to a network
`from which the NAA can retrieve the media objects.
`Wolff, 3:20-32.”
`- Zatkovich Decl., 593/Ex. 2012 at ¶112
`
`23
`
`

`

`Petitioner’ Position:
`“Periodically, the media objects
`indicated by the playlist can be
`accessed and cached by the
`appropriate network access
`appliance. This is done “by
`examining stored play lists.”
`Therefore, the NAA will receive
`the playlist from the personalized
`server, examine it and obtain
`media objects not already stored
`in its cache.
`
`- 593/Paper 1 at 31
`
`“[T]here is no indication in Wolff that its play
`list that is stored in the personalized server
`(110) is transferred to or received by the
`NAA, for the purpose of examination or
`otherwise. Contrary to the ‘952 Petition’s
`assertions, the process of “examining” a
`stored play list to allow indicated media
`objects to “eventually be accessed and
`cached by the appropriate NAA” does not
`involve or require receipt of the stored play
`list itself. In fact, Wolff provides that the NAA
`“periodically accesses the personalized
`server 110 and update [sic] the local cache
`in the NAA with the appropriate media
`objects based on the resource identifiers
`stored in the personalized server 110.”
`Thus, the “examining stored play lists”
`passage cited by the ‘952 Petition merely
`indicates that the URLs are used to cache
`the media objects—not that a playlist is
`received.”
`- Zatkovich Decl., 593/Ex. 2012, ¶ 123
`
`24
`
`

`

`“[D]igital engine 101 may be used in
`association with an Internet website
`configured to provide access to selectable
`information.” (White ‘947 Patent, Ex. 1014,
`col. 4, lines 63-65). “During operation, audio
`information may be selected by a user
`utilizing a personal computer or other
`devices operable to communicate with an
`information network. Digital engine 102 [sic]
`is operable to maintain information
`associated with the selected audio
`information.” (Id., 4:42-46). “System 100,
`utilizing communication engine 102, may
`wirelessly communicate data or information
`associated with the selected audio
`information to electronic device 103 thereby
`providing wireless communication of
`selected information to an electronic device
`operable to receive wireless
`communications.” (Id., 4:56-62).
`
`“White, however, teaches an approach that
`is fundamentally different from the
`approach recited in claims 1, 21, and 42 of
`the ‘652 Patent by indicating that the
`server, using the URLs associated with
`selected audio material, obtains and
`assembles the audio material for
`transmission to the user’s device.”
`- Zatkovich Decl., 594/Ex. 2011 at ¶147
`
`25
`
`

`

`“White does not disclose that URLs or any other information enabling an electronic device
`(103/300) to obtain the songs are received by the electronic device (103/300). To the
`contrary, White discloses that “audio information” (i.e., the audio file itself) is sent to the
`playback device directly, without the playback device having to access the location or
`source to retrieve the audio file.”
`
`– Zatkovich Decl. (594/Ex. 2011 at ¶149)
`
`26
`
`

`

`Petitioner’s Expert:
`“White discloses numerous
`embodiments that include various
`features. It is my opinion that each
`of the elements of the claims is
`disclosed in White as set forth in the
`claim chart contained in the '652
`Petition. It is also my opinion that it
`would have been obvious to one of
`ordinary skill in the art that the
`features of the various
`embodiments could be
`implemented in a single device, as
`it is apparent that such features
`could be combined as deemed
`necessary or desirable.”
`- 594/Ex. 1002 at ¶28
`
`Patent Owner’s Expert:
`“One skilled in the art would have no
`motivation to replace White’s scheme with the
`approach taught in the ‘652 Patent, and the
`‘652 Petition and the Bove Report fail to
`explain why one skilled in the art would be
`taught or motivated, explicitly or implicitly, to
`replace White’s scheme at all.
`Thus, whereas the ‘652 Patent provides that
`information enabling the device to obtain
`songs (e.g., URLs) is used by the electronic
`device to obtain the audio content for
`streaming or downloading, White merely
`describes a system in which “audio
`information” (i.e., an audio file) can be
`selected by a user and the selected audio
`information (i.e., an audio file) is
`communicated to an electronic device.”
`- Zatkovich Decl. 594/Ex. 2011 at ¶¶147-148
`
`27
`
`

`

`“Referring back to FIG. 2, the second display region 222 can be used to
`provide auxiliary information about music content. The auxiliary information
`is displayed in response to receiving a user-initiated selection of the
`information control 220, which includes the text "ALBUM INFO" for music
`content. The auxiliary information can include specific information for the
`current title such as album cover graphics, liner notes, tray back images,
`images of the artist(s), producer and writer credits, and distribution label
`information, for example.”
`
`- 594/Ex. 1010 at 20:64-21:6
`
`28
`
`

`

`“There is no reason to assume that Leeke’s auxiliary information
`is obtained by sending a request to a remote server in real-time
`while a song is playing. It is plausible (and far more likely) that
`Leeke envisioned retrieval of additional information, such as the
`song name, artist, etc. from the audio file itself or local storage.”
`- Zatkovich Decl. (594/Ex. 2011 at ¶127)
`
`29
`
`