`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`
`
`
`BEFORE THE PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD
`
`TARGET CORPORATION,
`Petitioner
`v.
`
`DESTINATION MATERNITY CORPORATION,
`Patent Owner
`
`Case IPR2013-00530
`Case IPR2013-00531
`Case IPR2013-00532
`Case IPR2013-00533
`
`Before JENNIFER S. BISK, MICHAEL J. FITZPATRICK, and
`MITCHELL G. WEATHERLY Administrative Patent Judges.
`
`
`PETITIONER’S OBJECTIONS TO EVIDENCE
`
`PURSUANT TO 37 C.F.R. § 42.64(b)(1)
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`-1-
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`PETITIONER’S OBJECTIONS TO EVIDENCE
`
`Pursuant to 37 C.F.R. § 42.64(b)(1), petitioner Target Corporation
`
`(“Target”) hereby objects to the admissibility and/or status as evidence of the
`
`exhibits and items set forth in the below tables, and contends that they are
`
`inadmissible based on the Federal Rules of Evidence (“FRE”) and/or are not
`
`evidence, are inadmissible, and/or are entitled to no weight based on the provisions
`
`of 37 C.F.R. §§ 42.63 et seq. and 42.65 et seq.
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`2017 at ¶ 10 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`
`2017 at ¶ 11 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`
`2017 at ¶ 14 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 16 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 17 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`
`Objection
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 106, 402, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001,
`1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 106, 402, 403, 702, 703, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-2-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`2017 at ¶ 18 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 19 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`
`2017 at ¶ 20 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`
`2017 at ¶ 21 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 22 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 23 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 24 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`
`Objection
`FRE 702, 703
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 403, 702, 703, 802
`37 C.F.R. §§ 42.51(b)(1)(iii), 42.65 et seq.
`(purported expert testimony entitled to little or no
`weight due to non-disclosure or improper
`disclosure of underlying facts and/or data)
`FRE 106, 402, 403, 701, 702, 802, 901, 1001,
`1002
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 106, 402, 403, 701, 702, 802, 901, 1001,
`1002
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 106, 402, 403, 701, 702, 802, 901, 1001,
`1002
`
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-3-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`2017 at ¶ 28 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 29 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 32 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 33 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 34 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 35 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`
`2017 at ¶
`36(A)
`
`2017 at ¶
`36(B)
`
`Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 40 Declaration of
`David
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`Objection
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 106, 702, 703, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`FRE 403, 702, 703
`
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`-4-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 41 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`
`2017 at ¶ 42 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`
`2017 at ¶ 43 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`
`2017 at ¶ 44 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 45 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 46 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`
`Objection
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 403, 702, 703, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 403, 702, 703, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`FRE 403, 702, 703
`
`FRE 403, 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-5-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`2017 at ¶ 48 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 49 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 50 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 51 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 54 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 56 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`
`2017 at ¶ 58 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 59 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 62 Declaration of
`David
`
`Objection
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 403, 702, 703
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-6-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`Objection
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`FRE 403, 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 403, 702, 703
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`
`
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 63 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`
`2017 at ¶ 64 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 65 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`2017 at ¶ 66 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`
`2017, Ex. 2
`(as a whole);
`Ex. 2 at p. 1,
`2 (tables and
`information
`included
`therein); Ex.
`2 (all images
`purporting to
`be DMC
`Secret Fit
`Belly®
`products and
`AlvaForm);
`Ex. 2
`(microscopic
`images
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-7-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`and/or
`images of
`fine detail on
`pp. 12, 13,
`17-21, 49)
`2017,
`Referenced
`Material
`
`Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D.
`
`2018
`
`Deposition of
`Frances Harder
`2019, 2027 Deposition of
`Amy Brady
`2020, 2028 Deposition of
`Amy Brady,
`Exhibit 114
`7-17-2007
`Press Release
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`
`2021
`
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 2
`
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 9
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 10
`
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`
`2022 & 2029 Declaration of
`
`Objection
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 106, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`FRE 106
`Objections contained therein
`FRE 106
`Objections contained therein
`FRE 106, 403, 701, 702, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`
`FRE 106, 403, 701, 702, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 702, 703
`FRE 702, 703
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 403, 702, 703, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-8-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`at ¶ 11
`Philip Green
`
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 12
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 15
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 18
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 20
`
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 21
`
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 22
`
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`
`Objection
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`FRE 403, 702, 703
`
`FRE 403, 702, 703
`
`FRE 403, 702, 703
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-9-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 23
`
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 27
`
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 28
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 29
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 30
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 31
`
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 32
`
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`
`2022 & 2029 Declaration of
`
`Objection
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`Foundation
`FRE 403, 702, 703
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`FRE 403, 702, 703
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (testimony on U.S.
`patent law or patent examination practice is not to
`be admitted)
`FRE 403, 702, 703
`
`FRE 403, 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-10-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`at ¶ 33
`Philip Green
`
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 34
`
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 35
`
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`
`Objection
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001,1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`Foundation
`FRE 403, 702, 703
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`Foundation
`FRE 403, 702, 703, 802
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`2022 & 2029 Declaration of Foundation
`
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 36
`
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 37
`
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-11-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`at ¶ 38
`Philip Green
`
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 39
`
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 41
`
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`
`2022 & 2029
`at ¶ 42
`
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`
`2022 &
`2029,
`Exhibit A
`
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`
`Objection
`FRE 403, 702, 703
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 403, 702, 703
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 402, 403, 602, 701, 702, 703, 802, 901,
`1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-12-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`
`2022 &
`2029,
`Exhibit C
`
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`
`2022 &
`2029,
`Exhibit D
`
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`
`2022 &
`2029,
`Exhibit D-1
`
`Declaration of
`Philip Green
`
`2023
`
`2024
`
`Merriam-
`Webster’s
`Collegiate
`Dictionary, 11th
`Ed., 2007, p.
`1245
`Merriam-
`Webster’s
`Collegiate
`
`Objection
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`FRE 106, 402, 403, 901, 1001, 1002
`
`FRE 106, 402, 403, 901, 1001, 1002
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-13-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`Objection
`
`FRE 106, 402, 403, 901, 1001, 1002
`
`FRE 106, 402, 403, 701, 702, 802, 901, 1001,
`1002
`
`FRE 106, 402, 403, 701, 702, 802, 901, 1001,
`1002
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`
`
`2025
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`Dictionary, 11th
`Ed., 2007, p.
`679
`Merriam-
`Webster’s
`Collegiate
`Dictionary, 11th
`Ed., 2007, p.
`417
`2026 at ¶ 11 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 13 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 16 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-14-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 18 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 19 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 20 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 21 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`
`Objection
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-15-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`Objection
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`
`FRE 106, 402, 403, 701, 702, 802, 901, 1001,
`1002
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 22 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 23 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 24 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-16-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 25 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 26 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 28 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 29 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`
`Objection
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-17-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`Objection
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`FRE 702, 703, 802
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 30 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 33 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 38 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-18-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 39 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 40 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 41 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 42 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`
`Objection
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-19-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`Objection
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 106, 702, 703, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`
`FRE 403, 702, 703
`
`
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 43 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 44 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 45 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-20-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`2026 at ¶ 47 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 50 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶52 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶53 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`
`Objection
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 403, 702, 703, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 403, 702, 703, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-21-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`
`
`Objection
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 403, 702, 703, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶54 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 55 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 56 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 57 Declaration of FRE 702, 703
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-22-
`
`FRE 403, 702, 703
`
`
`FRE 403, 702, 703
`
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 60 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 62 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 63 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`
`Objection
`
`
`FRE 702, 703
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-23-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`
`
`Exhibit No. Title
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 64 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 65 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 66 Declaration of
`David
`Brookstein,
`Sc.D. in
`Support of
`Patent Owner’s
`Motion in the
`Alternative to
`Amend Claim
`1 of the ’563
`Patent
`2026 at ¶ 67 Declaration of
`David
`
`Objection
`underlying facts and/or data)
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`evidence not filed as an exhibit)
`Foundation
`FRE 106, 403, 702, 703, 802, 901, 1001, 1002
`37 C.F.R. § 42.65 et seq. (purported expert
`testimony entitled to little or no weight due to
`non-disclosure or improper disclosure of
`underlying facts and/or data)
`
`37 C.F.R. § 42.63 et seq. (not evidence in these
`proceedings before the PTAB; purported
`
`US.54180158.01
`
`-24-
`
`Target Corporation Exhibit 1152
`Target v. DMC
`IPR2013-00530, 531, 532, 533
`
`
`
`Objection
`