throbber
CYAN EXHIBIT 1034
`
`SCOTT BENNETT
`YALE UNIVERSITY LIBRARIAN EMERITUS
`
`DECLARATION
`
`I, Scott Bennett, am a retired academic librarian living at 711 South Race Street, Urbana, IL, 61801-4132.
`
`I was employed as a librarian as follows:
`
`0 University Librarian, Yale University, New Haven, CT., 1994-2001
`
`0 Director, The Milton S. Eisenhower Library, The Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, 1989-
`1994
`
`0 Assistant University Librarian for Collection Management, Northwestern University, Evanston, IL,
`1981-1989
`
`0
`
`Instructor, Assistant and Associate Professor of Library Administration, University of Illinois at
`Urbana-Champaign, Urbana, IL, 1974-1981
`
`During the course of this employment, and through graduate study of library science (University of
`
`Illinois, M.S., 1976), I have become well informed about the operations of academic libraries. Further
`
`information is available at my Web site, www.libraryspaceplanning.com.
`
`Standard operating procedures for books and serials. Given that the cataloging and shelving for use by
`readers of the items listed below occurred several decades ago, this Declaration describes standard
`
`procedures very widely used by academic libraries. Specific corroborating evidence is provided.
`
`Items 1 and 2 below are published doctoral theses and would normally have been cataloged as books
`
`and then made available to readers. Items 3 through 8 below are articles that appeared in serial
`
`publications to which libraries subscribe. A serial title is cataloged when the subscription is first
`
`established, which is often years or decades before a given issue of that title is added to the collection.
`
`Publishers identify individual issues by date upon publication. When individual issues are received by a
`
`library, they are checked in, added to library holdings records, and shelved for use by readers as soon
`
`after their arrival as possib|e—norma||y with a few days or (at most) a few weeks.
`
`Academic libraries sometimes use date stamps to mark one stage or another of the processing of both
`
`books and issues ofjournal titles.
`
`In the case of individual issues of journals, one can say with
`
`confidence that they would normally have been available to readers within a few days or (at most) a few
`weeks of the time indicated by the date stamp.
`
`The absence of a date stamp indicates nothing about processing.
`
`In the case of serials, dates stamps
`
`may have been placed on covers that were removed when several issues were gathered and
`
`permanently bound.
`
`Books relevant to this declaration
`
`Item 1: Grangaud, René, ”Recherches sur |’Astaxanthine, Nouveau Facteur, Vitaminique A”, 69 pp.
`(Editions Desoer, Liege, 1951).
`
`

`

`Item 2: Massonet, Reneé, ”Recherches sur la Biochemie de |’Astaxanthine”, 146 pp. (F.Fontana, Algiers,
`
`1960)
`
`Both titles are formally published theses. Wor|dCat (http:[[www.wor|dcat.org[) shows that three
`academic libraries in the United States and three European libraries hold and have cataloged Item 1.
`
`Wor|dCat shows that two academic libraries in the United States and four European libraries hold and
`
`have cataloged Item 2.
`
`The Yale University Library (”Ya|e”) holds both items 1 and 2. At Yale, item 1 was cataloged and
`classified as WG1506, while Item 2 was cataloged and classified as WG36959. Both classification
`
`numbers derive from a set of classification schedules, collectively known as ”O|d Yale,” in use until the
`
`Yale Library changed to the Library of Congress classification system in approximately 1970.
`
`Attachments 24-25 present information about the use of ”O|d Yale” classification numbers.
`
`Attachments 1-4 are copies of the online catalog records for items 1 and 2 from the Yale University
`
`Library and from the Center for Research Libraries (Chicago, IL). The ”O|d Yale” classification numbers
`for items 1 and 2 are highlighted in yellow in Attachments 1 and 3. Attachments 1-4 were retrieved
`
`online in the period from May 24 to June 3, 2013.
`
`The use of ”Old Yale” classification numbers for these books enables me to say, conclusively, that
`
`both Item 1 and Item 2 were cataloged and made available to readers after their publication in 1951
`and 1960, respectively, and prior to 1970.
`
`Serial titles relevant to this declaration
`
`Item 3: Grangaud, René, and Massonet, Reneé, ”Action de |'hui|e de Crevette (Penaeus foliaceus) sur le
`Rat blanc carence en vitamine A,” Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Seances de |'Academie
`
`des Sciences, Vol. 227, pp. 568-570 (1948).
`
`Item 4: Grangaud, René, and Massonet, Reneé, ”Activité antixérophtalmique du pigment caroténo'I'de
`
`d'Aristeomorpha foliacea (Penaeidae),” Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Seances de
`
`|'Academie des Sciences, Vol. 230, pp. 1319-1321 (March 27, 1950).
`
`Item 5: Grangaud, R., and Massonet, R., ”Activité antixérophtalmique des esters de |'astaxanthine,”
`
`Comptes Rendus des seances de la Societe de biologie et de ses filiales, Vol. 148, pp. 1392-1394
`
`(1954).
`
`Item 6: Massonet, R., Conquy, T., and Grangaud, R., ”Transformation in vitro de |'astaxanthine en
`
`vitamine A par le tissu oculaire du Rat,” Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des seances de la
`
`Societe de biologie et de ses filiales, Vol. 155, pp. 747-750 (1961).
`
`Item 7: Grangaud, René,‘ Massonet, Reneé,‘ Conquy Thérese; and Ridolfo, Jacqueline, ”Transformation
`de |'astaxanthine en vitamine A chez le Rat albinos: néoformation in vivo et in vitro,” Comptes
`
`Rendus Hebdomadaires des Seances de |'Academie des Sciences, Vol. 252, pp. 1854-1856 (1961)
`
`Item 8: Massonet, R., Conquy, T., and Grangaud, R.R. ”Etude de la transformation de |'astaxanthine en
`vitamine A chez le Rat albinos: Expériences ‘in vitro’,” Annales de la Nutrition et de
`
`|’A|imentation, Vol. 19 pp. pages C655—C658 (1965).
`
`2
`
`

`

`Attachments 5-10 are online catalog records for the three relevant serial titles from the Yale University
`
`Library and from the University of Illinois at Urbana—Champaign Library. Holdings information for the
`
`issues in which Items 3-8 appeared is highlighted in yellow. Note that the serial titles under which these
`
`six items will be found in individual libraries may vary somewhat. This is the result of long and complex
`
`publishing histories for these titles and the variety of cataloging codes in use, in North American, Canada,
`
`and Europe, during the years when they were published. Attachments 5-10 were retrieved online in the
`
`period from May 24 to June 3, 2013.
`
`Note further that while library catalogs list serial titles, it is indexing services that normally guide readers
`
`to individual articles published in a given issue of a serial. Items 1 and 3-8 were indexed shortly after
`
`they were published at least in Chemical Abstracts, which has been indexing scientific literature since
`
`about—cas cas—histor ). Attachment 19 shows the ChemicalAbstracts
`: www.cas.or
`1907 (see htt
`index entries for Items 1 and 3-8.
`
`I have examined print versions of Items 3-8 at the University of Illinois at Urbana Champaign Library;
`
`they bear the following date stamps (reproduced photographically in Attachments 20-23):
`
`Item 3 date stamp: none (issue bound without its covers)
`
`Item 4 date stamp: none (issue bound without its covers)
`
`Item 5 date stamp: 5 January 1955 (on cover, which was retained in binding)
`
`Item 6 date stamp: 30 November 1961 (on cover, which was retained in binding)
`Item 7 date stamp: 26 April 1961 (on cover, which was retained in binding)
`
`Item 8 date stamp: 9 June 1965 (on cover, which was retained in binding)
`
`0
`
`0
`
`The publisher's date on Item 5 is Aout—Septembre 1954, while the University of Illinois Library date
`stamp is 5 January 1955.
`
`The publisher's date on Item 7 is 20 Mars 1961, while the University of Illinois Library date stamp is
`
`26 April 1961.
`
`Similar dating patterns are evident in Items 6 and 8
`
`These dates suggest that it might take up to three months for these publications to reach Urbana from
`
`Paris and to be cataloged and shelved for public access at the library. Under normal operating
`
`procedures, newly arrived issues of a serial would have been on the shelves and available to readers
`
`within a few days or (at most) a few weeks of the date indicated by the stamp.
`
`Considering the standard operating procedures of academic libraries and the corroborating evidence
`
`of date stamps, where available, and considering the time required for trans-Atlantic mail, I am
`confident that each of the six serial publications listed above was available to readers within, at most,
`
`five months of its publication in 1948, 1950, 1954, 1961, and 1965, respectively.
`
`%
`
`Se|f—citation as regards Items 1 and 2. Items 5 to 8 each include a citation to Item 1, and Items 6-8 each
`include citations to both Items 1 and 2. Therefore, any reader of Item 5-8 would be directed to
`
`previously published Item 1, while readers of Items 6-8 would be directed to both Items 1 and 2.
`
`3
`
`

`

`In order to be confident that the items listed above were both available to readers
`Citation by others.
`and in actual use, I looked for evidence that they had been cited by persons other than Grangaud and
`
`Massonet. Relevant citation data are reported in Attachments 11-18, where the publication dates of
`
`the citing articles are highlighted in yellow. These data are summarized in the following table, where
`
`the last column disregards se|f—citation by counting only citing articles for which neither Grangaud nor
`Massonet was an author or co—author.
`
`Item/Publication date Citation index
`
`Total # of citations and their date
`
`# of citations before 1994 by
`persons other than
`
`Grangaud and/or Massonet
`
`1: Published 1951
`
`Web of Science
`
`4 citations, 1954-1981
`
`2: Published 1960
`
`Google Scholar
`
`3 citations, 1961-1969
`
`Web of Science
`
`3: Published 1948
`4: Published 1950
`5: Published 1954
`6: Published 1961
`7: Published 1961
`8: Published 1965
`
`Web of Science
`Web of Science
`Web of Science
`Web of Science
`Web of Science
`
`15 citations, 1949-1969
`
`The citation history of all eight publications demonstrates conclusively that one or more readers had
`found and used each of Items 1-7 before 1994. The absence of any but se|f—citation for Item 8 does not
`alter the fact, demonstrated above, that Item 8 was cataloged and available to readers prior to 1994.
`
`Summary
`
`Based on the standard operation procedures of academic libraries, the corroborating evidence of date
`
`stamps, the particularities of the classification scheme used at Yale University for Items 1 and 2, and
`
`relevant citation data, I am confident that all eight items listed above were cataloged and available to
`
`readers in one or more libraries before 1994, and that Items 1-7 were in actual use by readers prior to
`1994.
`
`

`

`I reserve the right to supplement my opinion in the future to respond to any arguments that the Patent
`Owner raises and to take into account new information as it becomes available.
`
`I declare that all statements made herein of my own knowledge are true and that all statements made
`on information and belief are believed to be true; and further that these statements were made with
`the knowledge that willful false statements and the like so made are punishable by fine or
`imprisonment, or both, under Section 1001 of Title 18 of the United States Code.
`
`Dated June 5, 2013.
`
`Sincerely,
`
`Scott Bennett
`
`Yale University Librarian Emeritus
`
`Attachments.
`
`The following 25 attachments are true and accurate representations of online catalog records and other documents,
`extracted as Word document for ease of use in this Declaration. Most holdings information forjournal issues published
`prior to Items 3-7 have been omitted from the catalog records as irrelevant. Attachment 19 is a true and accurate PDF
`copy of the results of a search for Items 1-8 in Chemical Abstracts. Attachments 20-23 are original and unretouched
`photographs taken by the person making this Declaration.
`
`0
`
`0
`
`0
`
`0
`
`-
`
`0
`
`0
`
`0
`
`0
`
`0
`
`0
`0
`0
`0
`
`Attachment 1: Catalog record for Item 1 (extracted as a Word document from the Yale University Library online
`catalog, with the Old Yale classification number highlighted in yellow)
`Attachment 2: Catalog record for Item 1 (extracted as a Word document from the Center for Research Libraries
`online catalog)
`Attachment 3: Catalog record for Item 2 (extracted as a Word document from the Yale University Library online
`catalog, with the Old Yale classification number highlighted in yellow)
`Attachment 4: Catalog record for Item 2 (extracted as a Word document from the Center for Research Libraries
`online catalog)
`
`Attachment 5: Catalog record for Items 3, 4, and 7 (extracted as a Word document from the Yale University Library
`online catalog, with the relevant volume holdings highlighted in yellow)
`Attachment 6: Catalog record for Items 3, 4, and 7 (extracted as a Word document from the University of Illinois at
`Urbana-Champaign Library online catalog, with the relevant volume holdings highlighted in yellow)
`Attachment 7: Catalog record for Items 5 and 6 (extracted as a Word document from the Yale University Library
`online catalog, with the relevant volume holdings highlighted in yellow)
`Attachment 8: Catalog record for Items 5 and 6 (extracted as a Word document from the University of Illinois at
`Urbana—Champaign Library online catalog, with the relevant volume holdings highlighted in yellow)
`Attachment 9: Catalog record for Item 8 (extracted as a Word document from the Yale University Library online
`catalog, with the relevant volume holdings highlighted in yellow)
`Attachment 10: Catalog record for Item 8 (extracted as a Word document from the University of Illinois at Urbana-
`Champaign Library online catalog, with the relevant volume holdings highlighted in yellow)
`Attachment 11: Results of a search for authors citing Item 1 (extracted as a Word document from the Web of Science)
`Attachment 12: Results of a search for authors citing Item 2 (extracted as a Word document from Google Scholar)
`Attachment 13: Results of a search for authors citing Item 3 (extracted as a Word document from the Web of Science)
`Attachment 14: Results of a search for authors citing Item 4 (extracted as a Word document from the Web of Science)
`
`5
`
`

`

`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`

`

`

`

`

`

`

`

`

`

`Attachment 6: Catalog record for Items 3, 4, and 7 (extracted as a
`
`Word document from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
`
`Library online catalog, with the relevant volume holdings highlighted
`
`in yellow)
`
`Title:
`Published:
`
`Comptes rendus hebdomadaires des séances de l‘Académie des sciences.
`Paris : Gauthier-Villars, 1835-1965.
`
`Physical Description:
`
`261 v.
`
`:
`
`ill., maps. ; 27-29 cm.
`
`Publication History:
`
`Tome 1, no. 1 (ao0t1835)-t. 261, no. 25 (20 déc. 1965).
`
`Frequency:
`Subject (LCSH):
`
`Subject (MeSH):
`Other Name:
`More about this Title:
`
`Indexed by:
`Indexes:
`
`Weekly
`Science --Periodicals.
`Science -- eriodicals
`
`Académie des sciences (France)
`
`The proceedings forthe period priorto 1835 are contained in: Académie des sciences
`(France). Proces-verbaux des séances de l‘Académie tenues depuis la fondation de
`l‘lnstitutjusqu‘au mois d‘ao0t 1835.
`Split into: Comptes rendus hebdomadaires des séances de |‘Académie des sciences.
`Series A, Sciences mathématiques et B, Sciences physiques; Comptes rendus
`hebdomadaires des séances de l‘Académie des sciences. Série C, Sciences
`chimiques; and: Comptes rendus hebdomadaires des séances de l‘Académie des
`sciences. Série D, Sciences naturelles.
`Mathematical reviews. 0025-5629
`
`Vols. 1-31, 1835-50. 1 V.; Vols. 32-61, 1851-65. 1 V.; Vols. 62-91, 1866-80. 1 V.; Vols.
`92-121, 1881-95. |V.; Vols. 122-151, 1896-1910. 1 V.; Vols. 212-241, 1941-55. 1 V.
`
`Notes:
`
`ISSN:
`
`In this library, the various groups of v. 260-261 (1965) were divided, bound and housed
`in the appropriate departmental libraries.
`0001-4036
`
`Persistent link to this page:
`
`https://i-share.carli.il|inois.edu/uiu/cgi-
`bin/Pwebrecon.cgi?DB=loca|&v1 =1 &BBRecl D=32022
`
`Institution:
`Location:
`
`University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign Library
`Main Stacks
`
`v.258:5-6 F(1964) c.1 Shelved At Oak Street Facility [request only]
`v.198(1934) c.1 Temporarily Shelved at Rare Book & Manuscript Library [non-
`circulating]
`v.177(1923) c.1 Temporarily Shelved at Rare Book & Manuscript Library [non-
`circulating]
`Q. 506 CR —»Text me this call number
`
`1 F
`
`or later Vols input 506CRSER.A-B, 506CRSER.C AND 506CRSER.D.
`
`v.258:5-6 F(1964) c.1 In Process 11-20-08 Find copies in other I-Share libraries.
`v.160(1915)-v.261:no.25(1965)
`
`V. 261223-25 D (1965)
`V. 261218-22 N (1965)
`V. 261:9-17 AG-O (1965)
`V. 261:1-8 JY-AG (1965)
`V. 260223-26 JE (1965)
`V. 260218-22 MY (1965)
`
`Call Number:
`
`Copy:
`Note:
`
`Status:
`
`Library Has (Summary):
`
`Library Has (Volumes):
`
`

`

`

`

`

`

`

`

`Attachment 7: Catalog record for Items 5 and 6 (extracted as a Word
`
`document from the Yale University Library online catalog, with the
`
`relevant volume holdings highlighted in yellow)
`
`o Author/Creator:Socie'te' de biologie gParis, France)
`- Title:Comptes rendus des seances de la Sociéte de biologie et de ses filiales.
`0
`ISSN:0037-9026
`
`Published/Created:Paris : Au bureau de la Gazette médicale, 1850-1998.
`o
`Physical Description:223 V.
`c
`: ill. ; 23-25 cm.
`- Linkszhttp://math-doc.ujf-grenoble.fr/RBSM/cr-gallica.html
`- Yale Holdings
`Location:LSF - Request for delivery to any Yale Library
`
`Call Number: QH301 S58
`Status:Not Checked Out
`
`Library Has: t. 164(1970)-t.192(1998)
`Location:LSF - Request for delivery to any Yale Library
`
`0 O
`
`OOO
`
`ser.3 :t. 1-2 1859-60 c.1 Shelved at LSF-Request for Use in Manuscripts and
`Archives
`
`ser.3 :t.5-ser.4:t.1 1863-64 c.1 Shelved at LSF-Request for Use in Manuscripts
`and Archives
`
`ser.8:t.1 1884 c.1 Shelved at LSF-Request for Use in Manuscripts and Archives
`ser.9:t.5 1893 c.1 Shelved at LSF-Request for Use in Manuscripts and Archives
`ser.11:t.1 1899 c.1 Shelved at LSF-Request for Use in Manuscripts and
`Archives
`
`t.53 1901 c.1 Shelved at LSF-Request for Use in Manuscripts and Archives
`t.54 1902 c.1 Shelved at LSF-Request for Use in Manuscripts and Archives
`t.[60] 1906 c.1 Shelved at LSF-Request for Use in Manuscripts and Archives
`t.69=annee 62:t.2 1910 c.1 Shelved at LSF-Request for Use in Manuscripts and
`Archives
`
`t.72=annee 64:t.1 1912 c.1 Shelved at LSF-Request for Use in Manuscripts and
`Archives
`
`t.74:annee 65:t.1 1913 c.1 Shelved at LSF-Request for Use in Manuscripts and
`Archives
`
`t.132=annee 91 :t.3 1939 c.1 Shelved at LSF-Request for Use in Manuscripts
`and Archives
`
`O
`
`Call Number: QH301 S58
`Status:Not Checked Out
`
`

`

`

`

`

`

`

`

`

`

`

`

`University of Library catalog record for Item 8
`
`Title:
`
`Annales de la nutrition et de l'alimentation.
`
`Date/Volume:
`
`V. 1-34; 1947-1980.
`
`Imprint:
`
`Description:
`
`Frequency:
`
`Merged into:
`
`Notes:
`
`Paris, Centre national de la recherche scientifique.
`
`34 V. ill. 23 cm.
`
`Bimonthly
`
`Nutrition and metabolism 0029-6678
`Annals of nutrition & metabolism 0250-6807
`
`Includes bibliographies.
`Biological abstracts
`Chemical abstracts
`
`Nuclear science abstracts
`
`Index medicus
`
`Bibliography of agriculture
`Merged with: Nutrition and metabolism, to form: Annals of
`nutrition & metabolism.
`
`Subjects:
`
`Nutrition -- Periodicals.
`Food -- periodicals.
`Nutrition -- periodicals.
`
`Other authors or contributors: Centre national de la recherche scientifigue gFrance1
`Other titles:
`Ann. nutr. aliment.
`
`0003-4037
`
`ANAIAF
`
`ISSN:
`
`CODEN:
`
`Crerar
`
`Location: Crerar, Bookstacks
`Call No.: QPl4l.AlA6
`
`Copy No.: c.l
`Notes: Shelved by journal title, Crerar, Floor 2.
`Library has: V. 1-34(1947-1980)
`
`

`

`

`

`

`

`v.7 (1953) c.1
`
`v.6 (1952) c.1
`
`v.5 (1951) c.1
`
`v.4 (1950) c.1
`
`v.3 (1949) c.1
`
`v.2 (1948) c.1
`
`v.1—3 (1947-1949) c.1
`
`v.1 (1947) c.1
`
`Status:
`
`v.19(1965) c.1 — Recently checked in
`
`

`

`Attachment 11: Results of a search for authors citing Item 1 (extracted
`
`as a Word document from the Web of Science)
`
`F
`
`1
`
`Title: INVESTIGATIONS OF CAROTENOPROTEIN COMPLEXES IN ANIMALS
`
`' .3. PRESENCE OF CRUSTACYANINS IN GAMMARUS-LACUSTRIS GO SARS
`
`Author(s): CZECZUGA; B; KRYWUTA; S
`Source: COMPARATIVE BIOCHEMISTRY AND PHYSIOLOGY B-
`
`BIOCHEMISTRY & MOLECULAR BIOLOGY Volume: 70 Issue: 3 Pages: 665-
`667 DOI: 10.1016/0305-O491(81)90318-7 Published: 2
`Times Cited: 2 (from Web of Science)
`wiLE"'
`1.: N
`
`Title: CAROTENOID PIGMENTS IN CRUSTACEA
`
`' Author(s): LENEL; R; NEGRESADARGUES; G; CASTILLO; R
`Source: ARCHIVES DE ZOOLOGIE EXPERIMENTALE ET GENERALE Volume:
`119 Issue: 2 Pages: 297-334 Published: 2
`Times Cited: Q (from Web of Science)
` \'ALE>I.INK5
`
`Title: STUDIES OF PIGMENTS IN SHRIMP CRANGON CRANGON gCRUSTACEA
`
`' - MALACOSTRACA)
`Author(s): CZERPAK; R; CZECZUGA; B
`Source: MARINE BIOLOGY Volume: 3
`10. 1007/BFOO3 53431 Published: 2
`Times Cited: Q (from Web of Science)
`
`\'ALE>I.INK5
`
`Issue: 2 Pages: 122-& DOI:
`
`Title: *ACTIVITE ANTIXEROPHTALMK )UE DES ESTERS DE
`' LASTAXANTHINE
`
`Author(s): GRANGAUD; R; MAS SONET; R
`Source: COMPTES RENDUS DES SEANCES DE LA SOCIETE DE BIOLOGIE ET
`DE SES FILIALES Volume: 148 Issue: 15-1 Pages: 1392-1394 Published: 2
`Times Cited: 3 (from Web of Science)
`\'ALE>1..I N K -3
`
`

`

`

`

`Attachment 13: Results of a search for authors citing Item 3 (extracted
`
`as a Word document from the Web of Science)
`
`Title: CURRENT DATA ON
`
`BIOGENESIS OF FAT-SOLUBLE
`
`VITAMINS
`
`Author(s): GRANGAUD; R; NICOL;
`M; MASSONET; R; et al.
`Source: ANNALES DE LA
`
`NUTRITION ET DE L
`
`ALIMENTATION Volume: 23 Issue:
`5 Pages: B81-& Published: 2
`Tims Cited: 1 (from Web of Science)
`
`V2.
`
`‘-3.
`
`:-
`
`Title: TRANSFORMATION IN VITRO DE
`
`LASTAXANTHINE EN VITAMINE A PAR LE
`
`TISSU OCULAIRE DU RAT
`
`Author(s): MASSONET, R; CONQUY; T;
`GRANGAUD; R
`Source: COMPTES RENDUS DES SEANCES DE LA
`
`SOCIETE DE BIOLOGIE ET DE SES
`
`FILIALES Volume: 155 Issue: 1 Pages: 747-
`& Published: 2
`Times Cited: 3 (from Web of Science)
`
`Title: TRANSFORMATION DE LASTAXANTHINE
`
`EN VITAMINE A CHEZ LE RAT ALBINOS -
`
`NEOFORMATION IN VIVO ET IN VITRO
`
`Author(s): GRANGAUD; R; RIDOLFO; J; CONQUY;
`T; et al.
`Source: COMPTES RENDUS HEBDOMADAIRES
`
`DES SEANCES DE L ACADEMIE DES
`
`SCIENCES Volume: 252 Issue: 12 Pages: 1854-
`& Published: 2
`Times Cited: § (from Web of Science)
`
`Title: VITAMINE-A ET PROGESTERONE
`
`Author(s): GRANGAUD; R; CONQUY; T
`Source: COMPTES RENDUS DES SEANCES DE LA
`
`SOCIETE DE BIOLOGIE ET DE SES
`
`FILIALES Volume: 152 Issue: 8-9 Pages: 1230-
`1234 Published: 2
`
`

`

`Tims Cited: 1_1 (from Web of Science)
`wlLE."'
`I
`.1 ‘.'-J K
`
`Title: RECHERCHES SUR LACTIVITE
`
`VITAMINIQ QUE-A DES HUILES DE PENEIDES
`Author(s): MASSONET, R
`Source: COMPTES RENDUS DES SEANCES DE LA
`
`SOCIETE DE BIOLOGIE ET DE SES
`
`FILIALES Volume: 150 Issue: 1 Pages: 170-
`173 Published: 2
`Times Cited: 1 (from Web of Science)
`
`Title: SOME ASPECTS OF VITAMIN-A
`
`METABOLISM
`
`Author(s): LOWE, J S; MORTON, RA
`Source: VITAMINS AND HORMONES-ADVANCES
`
`IN RESEARCH AND APPLICATIONS Volume:
`
`14 Pages: 97-137 DOI: 10.1016/S0083-
`6729(O8)60299-X Published: 2
`Times Cited: E (from Web of Science)
`
`
`Title: ACTIVITE ANTIXEROPHTALMIQ QUE DES
`CHROMOPROTEIDES DE CRUSTACES
`
`ADMINISTRES AU RAT BLANC CARENCE EN
`
`VITAMINE-A
`
`Author(s): MASSONET, R
`Source: COMPTES RENDUS DES SEANCES DE LA
`
`SOCIETE DE BIOLOGIE ET DE SES
`
`FILIALES Volume: 149 Issue: 21-2 Pages: 1971-
`1976 Published: 2
`Times Cited: 1 (from Web of Science)
`
`
`Title: *ACTIVITE ANTIXEROPHTALMIQ QUE DU
`PIGMENT CAROTENOIDE DE PENEIDES
`
`QARISTEOMORPHA-FOLIACEA, RIS SO ET
`
`ARISTEUS-ANTENNATUS, RISSO) - TECHNIQUE
`DE PREPARATION DES EXTRAITS ACTIFS
`
`Author(s): GRANGAUD, R; MAS SONET, R;
`SANSAC, A
`Source: COMPTES RENDUS DES SEANCES DE LA
`
`SOCIETE DE BIOLOGIE ET DE SES
`
`FILIALES Volume: 148 Issue: 5-6 Pages: 533-
`536 Published: 2
`Times Cited: § (from Web of Science)
`
`
`

`

`Title: ASPECTS OF VITAMIN-A DEFICIENCY IN
`
`RATS
`
`Author(s): LOWE, J S; MORTON; RA; HARRISON,
`RG
`
`Source: NATURE Volume: 172 Issue: 4381
`
`716-719 DOI: 10.1038/l727l6a0 Published:
`
`Paies:
`
`Times Cited: L01 (from Web of Science)
`
`Title: *RECHERCHES SUR LES FACTEURS
`
`VITAMINI UES-A DHUILES DE PENAEIDAE
`
`Author(s): GRANGAUD; R; CHECHAN; C;
`MASSONET; R; et al.
`Source: BULLETIN DE LA SOCIETE DE CHIMIE
`
`BIOLOGIQUE Volume: 32 Issue: 3-4 Pages: 245-
`249 Published: 2
`Times Cited: 8 (from Web of Science)
`
`
`Title: *ACTIVITE ANTIXEROPHTALMIQ QUE DHUILES DARISTEUS
`
`ANTENNATUS {PENAEIDAE}
`Author(s): MASSONET; R
`Source: COMPTES RENDUS DES SEANCES DE LA SOCIETE DE BIOLOGIE ET
`DE SES FILIALES Volume: 144 Issue: 15-1 Pages: 1028-1030 Published: 2
`Tims Cited: 3 (from Web of Science)
`
`Title: PREFORIVIED VITAMIN-A IN CRUSTACEA
`
`Author(s): KON; SK; THOMPSON; SY
`Source: ARCHIVES OF BIOCHEMISTRY Volume: 24 Issue: 1 Pages: 233-
`234 Published: 2
`Times Cited: fl (from Web of Science)
`‘u'ALE>I.|NK:1
`
`Title: ETUDE DES PROPRIETES VITAMINIQ QUES DE LHUILE DE CREVETTE
`
`1PENAEUS-FOLIACEUS 1 - EFFETS SUR LE RAT BLANC CARENCE EN
`VITAMINE-A
`
`Author(s): GRANGAUD; R; MAS SONET; R
`Source: BULLETIN DE LA SOCIETE DE CH]1\/IIE BIOLOGIQUE Volume:
`31
`Issue: 2 Pages: 231-234 Published: 2
`Times Cited: 8 (from Web of Science)
`‘mLE"'
`|.| mcs
`
`10.
`
`11.
`
`12.
`
`13.
`
`14.
`
`Title: *ACTIVITE VITAMINI§ QUE-A DHUILES DE PENAEIDAE
`Author(s): MASSONET; R
`Source: COMPTES RENDUS DES SEANCES DE LA SOCIETE DE BIOLOGIE ET
`DE SES FILIALES Volume: 143
`Issue: 17-1 Pages: 1178-1179 Published: 2
`Times Cited: 2 (from Web of Science)
`‘|’ALE:>I.IN1-UL
`
`

`

`I‘
`
`15 Title: *ACTIVITE ANTIXEROPHTALMIQUE ET CARACTERES SPECTRAUX
`' DHUILES DE PENAEIDAE
`
`Author(s): GRANGAUD, R; CHECHAN, C; MASSONET, R
`Source: CO1\/[PTES RENDUS DES SEANCES DE LA SOCIETE DE BIOLOGIE ET
`DE SES FILIALES Volume: 143
`Issue: 17-1 Pages: 1179-1181 Published: 2
`Times Cited: 1 (from Web of Science)
`YALE"
`I .| N K 5
`
`

`

`Attachment 14: Results of a search for authors citing Item 4 (extracted
`
`as a Word document from the Web of Science)
`
`Title: EFFECT OF
`
`ASTAXANTHINE ON
`
`ELECTRORETINO-GRAMS OF
`
`VITAMIN-A-DEFICIENT RATS
`
`Author(s): CARRICABP; TAYEBI,
`B; CHARDENO.P
`Source: COl\/IPTES RENDUS
`
`HEBDOMADAIRES DES
`
`SEANCES DE L ACADEMIE DES
`
`SCIENCES SERIE D Volume:
`
`270 Issue: 9 Pa es: 1282-
`
`& Published:
`
`Times Cited: 2 (from Web of
`Science)
`
`
`Title: OCCURRENCE DISTRIBUTION AND
`
`ABSORPTION OF PROVITAMINS A
`
`Author(s): THOMPSON, SY
`Source: PROCEEDINGS OF THE NUTRITION
`
`SOCIETY Volume: 24 Issue: 2 Pa es: 136-& DOI:
`
`10.1079/PNS19650026 Published:
`
`Times Cited: Q (from Web of Science)
`
`Title: TRANSFORMATION IN VITRO DE
`
`LASTAXANTHINE EN VITAMINE A PAR LE TISSU
`
`OCULAIRE DU RAT
`
`Author(s): MAS SONET, R; CONQUY, T; GRANGAUD,
`
`R S
`
`ource: COMPTES RENDUS DES SEANCES DE LA
`
`SOCIETE DE BIOLOGIE ET DE SES
`
`FILIALES Volume: 155 Issue: 1 Pages: 747-
`& Published: 2
`Times Cited: 3 (from Web of Science)
`YALEK I.l N K" 5
`
`Title: TRANSFORMATION DE LASTAXANTHINE EN
`
`VITAMINE A CHEZ LE RAT ALBINOS -
`
`NEOFORMATION IN VIVO ET IN VITRO
`
`Author(s): GRANGAUD, R; RIDOLFO, J; CONQUY, T;
`et al.
`
`

`

`Source: COMPTES RENDUS HEBDOMADAIRES DES
`
`SEANCES DE L ACADEMIE DES
`
`SCIENCES Volume: 252 Issue: 12 Pages: 1854-
`& Published: 2
`Times Cited: § (from Web of Science)
`
`Title: VITAMINE-A ET PROGESTERONE
`
`Author(s): GRANGAUD, R; CONQUY, T
`Source: COMPTES RENDUS DES SEANCES DE LA
`
`SOCIETE DE BIOLOGIE ET DE SES
`
`FILIALES Volume: 152 Issue: 8-9 Pages: 1230-
`1234 Published: 2
`Times Cited: Q (from Web of Science)
`
`Title: RECHERCHES SUR LACTIVITE
`
`VITAMINIQ QUE-A DES HUILES DE PENEIDES
`Author(s): MASSONET, R
`Source: COMPTES RENDUS DES SEANCES DE LA
`
`SOCIETE DE BIOLOGIE ET DE SES
`
`FILIALES Volume: 150 Issue: 1 Pages: 170-
`173 Published: 2
`Times Cited: 1 (from Web of Science)
`
`YALE>l.l N1-{E-1
`Title: SOME ASPECTS OF VITAMIN-A
`
`METABOLISM
`
`Author(s): LOWE, JS; MORTON, RA
`Source: VITAMINS AND HORMONES-ADVANCES
`
`IN RESEARCH AND APPLICATIONS Volume:
`
`14 Pages: 97-137 DOI: 10. lOl6/SOO83-6729(O8)60299-
`X Published: 2
`Times Cited: E (from Web of Science)
`
`YALE>l.l N1-{E-L
`
`Title: ACTIVITE ANTIXEROPHTALMIQ QUE DES
`CHROMOPROTEIDES DE CRUSTACES
`
`ADMINISTRES AU RAT BLANC CARENCE EN
`
`VITAMINE-A
`
`Author(s): MASSONET, R
`Source: COMPTES RENDUS DES SEANCES DE LA
`
`SOCIETE DE BIOLOGIE ET DE SES
`
`FILIALES Volume: 149 Issue: 21-2 Pages: 1971-
`1976 Published: 2
`Times Cited: 1 (from Web of Science)
`wll.l3"
`1.1 N K 5;
`
`Title: *ACTIVITE ANTIXEROPHTALMI§ QUE DU
`PIGMENT CAROTENOIDE DE PENEIDES
`
`

`

`gARISTEOMORPHA-FOLIACEA; RIS SO ET
`
`ARISTEUS-ANTENNATUS, RISSOQ - TECHNIQ QUE
`DE PREPARATION DES EXTRAITS ACTIFS
`
`Author(s): GRANGAUD; R; MASSONET; R; SANSAC;
`
`A S
`
`ource: COMPTES RENDUS DES SEANCES DE LA
`
`SOCIETE DE BIOLOGIE ET DE SES
`
`FILIALES Volume: 148 Issue: 5-6 Pages: 533-
`536 Published: 2
`Times Cited: § (from Web of Science)
`‘mm 1-: ‘N K 5
`
`Title: *ACTIVITE ANTIXEROPHTALMIQ QUE DES
`ESTERS DE LASTAXANTHINE
`
`Author(s): GRANGAUD; R; MAS SONET; R
`Source: COMPTES RENDUS DES SEANCES DE LA
`
`SOCIETE DE BIOLOGIE ET DE SES
`
`FILIALES Volume: 148 Issue: 15-1 Pages: 1392-
`1394 Published: 2
`Times Cited: 3 (from Web of Science)
`YALE"
`l.l N K 5-:
`
`10.
`
`11
`
`Title: *CHROMATOGRAPHIE DE PARTAGE DES CAROTENOIDES .1.
`
`' SEPARATION DE LASTAXANTHINE
`
`Author(s): GRANGAUD; R; GARCIA; I
`Source: BULLETIN DE LA SOCIETE DE CH]1\/[IE BIOLOGIQUE Volume:
`34 Issue: 7-8 Pages: 754-760 Published: 2
`Times Cited: 1 (from Web of Science)
`‘l'ALE\
`|.| N1-{E-i
`
`12.
`
`Title: SAUMONISATION DE SALMO IRIDEUS GIBB PAR ADMINISTRATION
`
`DASTAXANTHINE
`
`Author(s): GRANGAUD; R; DIEUZEIDE; R; MAS SONET; R; et al.
`Source: COMPTES RENDUS HEBDOMADAIRES DES SEANCES DE L
`
`ACADEMIE DES SCIENCES Volume: 235 Issue: 2 Pages: 213-214 Published:
`
`Tims Cited: 2 (from Web of Science)
`YALE‘.
`I.| was
`
`Title: VITAMIN-A AND CAROTENOIDS IN CERTAIN INVERTEBRATES .1.
`
`' MARINE CRUSTACEA
`
`Author(s): FISHER; LR; KON, SK; THOMPSON, SY
`Source: JOURNAL OF THE MARINE BIOLOGICAL ASSOCIATION OF THE
`UNITED KINGDOM Volume: 31
`Issue: 2 Pages: 229-258 Published: 2
`Times Cited: Q (from Web of Science)
`YALE-"
`I .| :4 K 5
`
`Title: FAT-SOLUBLE VITAMINS
`
`14
`
`' Author(s): DAM; H
`Source: ANNUAL REVIEW OF BIOCHEMISTRY Volume: 20 Pages: 265-
`
`

`

`I"
`
`J“
`
`304 DOI: lO.l146/annureV.bi.2O.O7Ol51.001405 Published: 2
`Times Cited: § (from Web of Science)
`
`‘|’ALE:'>|.|Nl-if-‘s
`
`15 Title: CAROTENOIDS IN FISH .5.
`' Author(s): GOODWIN, TW
`Source: BIOCHEMICAL SOCIETY SSHVIPOSIUM Volume: 6 Pages: 63-
`82 Published: 2
`Tims Cited: Q (from Web of Science)
`‘mLE"'
`1.: N K
`
`16 Title: VITAMIN-A-ACTIVE SUBSTANCES
`' Author(s): GOODWIN, TW
`Source: BRITISH JOURNAL OF NUTRITION Volume: 5
`100 DOI: 10.1079/BINl95100ll Published:
`Times Cited: 1 (from Web of Science)
` ‘u'ALE>|.|NK5
`
`Issue: 1 Pages: 94-
`
`

`

`Attachment 15: Results of a search for authors citing Item 5 (extracted
`
`as a Word document from the Web of Science)
`
`1.
`
`Title: Effects of Astaxanthin on Human Blood Rheology
`Author(s): Miyawaki, Hiromi; Takahashi, Jiro; Tsukahara, Hiroki; et al.
`Source: JOURNAL OF CLINICAL BIOCHEMISTRY AND NUTRITION Volume:
`43 Issue: 2 Pages: 69-74 DOI: 10.3164/jcbn.2008048 Published: SEP 2
`Times Cited: Q (from Web of Science)
`YALE '> I .| N K
`[ E'“'View abstract]
`
`I“
`
`Title: FAT-SOLUBLE VITAMINS
`
`' Author(s): KODICEK, E
`Source: ANNUAL REVIEW OF BIOCHEMISTRY Volume: 25 Pages: 497-536 DOI:
`10.1146/annureV.bi.25.O7Ol56.002433 Published: 2
`Times Cited: 1 (from Web of Science)
`YALE,‘
`I .| N K
`
`F
`
`3 Title: ACTIVITE VITAMINI§ QUE DES ESTERS DE LASTAXANTHINE ET
`' TROUBLES DE LA REPRODUCTION CHEZ LE RAT BLANC CARENCE EN
`
`VITAMINE-A
`
`Author(s): MASSONET, R
`Source: COMPTES RENDUS DES SEANCES DE LA SOCIETE DE BIOLOGIE ET
`DE SES FILIALES Volume: 150 Issue: 3 Pages: 529-531 Published: 2
`Times Cited: g (from Web of Science)
`YALE"
`I .I N K :1
`
`

`

`Attachment 16: Results of a search for authors citing Item 6 (extracted
`
`as a Word document from the Web of Science)
`
`Title: BIOSYNTHESIS + METABOLISM OF
`
`CAROTENOIDS + RETINOL 1 VITAMIN A )
`Author(s): OLSON, JA
`Source: JOURNAL OF LIPID RESEARCH Volume:
`5
`Issue: 3 Pages: 281-& Published: 2
`Times Cited: Q (from Web of Science)
` \'ALEi>l .| N F." 5
`Title: FAT-SOLUBLE VITAMINS
`
`Author(s): PITT; GAJ; MORTON, RA
`Source: ANNUAL REVIEW OF
`
`BIOCHEMISTRY Volume: 31 Pages: 491-& DOI:
`10. 1 146/annureV.bi.3 1.070162.002423 Published: 2
`Times Cited: Q (from Web of Science)
`
`
`Title: CURRENT DATA ON
`
`BIOGENESIS OF FAT-SOLUBLE
`
`VITAMINS
`
`Author(s): GRANGAUD; R;
`NICOL, M; MASSONET, R; et al.
`Source: ANNALES DE LA
`
`NUTRITION ET DE L
`
`ALIMENTATION Volume:
`
`23 Issue: 5 Pa es: B81-
`
`& Published:
`
`Times Cited: I (from Web of
`Science)
`
` F
`
`F
`
`

`

`Attachment 17: Results of a search for authors citing Item 7 (extracted
`
`as a Word document from the Web of Science)
`
`Title: Retinol-deficient rats can
`
`convert a pharmacological dose of
`astaxanthin to retinol: antioxidant
`
`potential of astaxanthin, lutein, and
`beta-carotene
`
`Author(s): Sangeetha, R. K;
`Baskaran, V.
`Source: CANADIAN JOURNAL OF
`
`PHYSIOLOGY AND
`
`PHARMACOLOGY Volume:
`
`88 Issue: 10 Pages: 977-985 DOI:
`10.1139/YlO-O74 Published: OCT
`
`Tims Cited: Q (from Web of Science)
`
`[ E""View abstract]
`
`Title: EFFECT OF ASTAXANTHINE ON
`
`ELECTRORETINO-GRAMS OF VITAMIN-A-
`
`DEFICIENT RATS
`
`Author(s): CARRICABP; TAYEBI,

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket