Filed on behalf of: Junior Party FAN
`
`Paper No.
`
`I
`
`By:
`
`R. Danny Huntington, Esq.
`Sharon E. Crane, Ph.D., Esq.
`ROTHWELL, FIGG, ERNST & MANBECK, RC.
`607 14th St., NW, Suite 800
`Washington, DC 20005
`dhuntington@rfem.com
`scrane@rfem.com
`Main Telephone: (202) 783-6040
`Main Facsimile: (202) 783-6031
`
`UNITED STATES PATENT AND TRADEMARK OFFICE
`
`BEFORE THE PATENT TRIAL AND APPEAL BOARD -
`
`HEI-MUN CHRISTINA FAN and STEPHEN QUAKE
`Junior Party
`(Patent 8,195,415),
`
`V.
`
`YUK-MING DENNIS L0, ROSSA WAI KWUN CHIU, and KWAN CHEE CHAN
`-
`Senior Party
`(Application 131070266),
`
`Patent Interference No. 105,922 (DK)
`(Technology Center 1600)
`
`FAN PRIORITY STATEMENT
`
`II
`
`SEQUENOM EXHIBIT 1100
`SEQUENOM EXHIBIT 1100
`Sequenom v. Stanford
`Sequenom V. Stanford
`IPR2013-00390
`IPR2013-00390
`
`‘
`
`SEQUENOM EXHIBIT 1100
`
`
`
`

`

`Interference No. 105,922
`
`MAIL STOP INTERFERENCE
`United States Patent and Trademark Office
`
`Patent Trial and Appeal Board
`Madison Building East
`600 Dulany Street
`Alexandria, Virginia 22313
`
`I Pursuant to Bd.R. 204(a)(1), Junior Party Fan (“Fan”) hereby sets forth the basis upon _
`
`which Fan intends to establish its entitlement to judgment on priority.
`
`Date and Location ofFan ’5 Earliest Corroborated Conception
`
`Pursuant to Bd.R. 204(a)(2)(i), Fan intends to prove a date of earliest corroborated
`
`conception in the United States of on or about December 18, 2007. Exhibit A is a copy of the
`
`earliest document upon which Fan will rely to show conception.
`
`Date and Location ofEarliest CorroboratedActaal Reduction to Practice
`
`Pursuant to Bd.R. 204(a)(2)(ii), Fan intends to prove a date of corroborated actual
`
`reduction to practice in the United States of on or about March 24, 2008.
`
`Earliest Corroborated Date on Which Diligence Began ‘
`
`Pursuant to Bd.R. 204(a)(2)(iii), Fan intends to prove diligence beginning on or about
`
`December 18, 2007.
`
`A Copy of the Eariiest Document Relied Upon to Show Conceptioa
`
`Pursuant to Bd.R. 204(a)(2)(iv), Fan hereby provides, as an attachment to this Priority
`
`~ Statement, a copy of the earliest document upon which Fan intends to rely to show conception.
`
`(Exhibit A).
`
`10
`
`11
`
`12
`
`13
`
`14
`
`15
`
`16
`
`17
`
`18
`
`19
`
`20
`
`21
`
`22
`
`23
`
`'24 -
`
`25
`
`26
`
`

`

`Interference No. 105,922
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`Date:
`
`July 31, 2013
`
`By:
`
`/s/ R. Danny Huntington
`R. Danny Huntington, Reg. No. 27,903
`Sharon E. Crane, Ph.D., Reg. No. 36,113
`Rothwell, Figg, Ernst & Manbeck, RC.
`607 14th St, N.W., Suite 800
`
`Washington, DC 20005
`
`Counselfor Junior Party Fan
`
`,_1
`
`OWOO‘JONMrh-LJJN
`
`._u
`
`|—I
`
`;_n
`
`

`

`EXHIBIT A
`
`

`

`7
`
`93:14pm PmdssMg .of pzasrm. 4%” P515200 20.28.30, 3039.35.34.32
`
`022.2 (g. a}
`
`[3/18/3000
`
`f'lle:l/IC:lDocurncnts%20311d%20Sailings/Yann/My%201)ocumems...
`
`w 0mm Well;
`
`
`
`
`"" a“ "-1.11- ""‘= h H "' 4;";H'
`Ellanallaall- 43944 44444 4 W348
`
`4 mwvmmmmmfigzgtm
`'
`h. W3“ '3'11'9"fiifi‘fi fl *1?“ User:Shared
`
`fifi‘“
`:3 aah: ‘ $4 ,3: Data File:C:\ Documents and SettingsWann‘. My Documents\ Down Syndrome
`
`54.4.5.1 Diagnostics‘1ReaI-Ttme P00120071210_P27-P37.tad
`‘9, 9 ’3" A
`10000000603255»...
`Active Dye: (HEX)
`
`C(T) Threshoid: 0.002010
`
`Threshold has been set manually.
`.
`(ex-514524221 fQ/[szaw
`80044391115413. _; 5931.2 801‘va
`.3542 104190042 50:40 444,103 r504.)
`
`Quantitation Graph
`
`HEX (04410124)
`3 2 {2m
`
`
`E9404 vole: C(T) Control Graph 17 = .3637): + 36.45: mg: a 0.993
`
`Fluorescence
`
`Set
`NTC
`
`Efficiency -w Avg 00) Max 0(1)
`NIA
`40.4
`NIA -- 9
`45.49
`30.42
`31.00
`
`
`
`
`
`31.32
`
`49.49
`30.29
`30.05
`.
`
`0(1) 00
`
`0.13
`030
`0.14
`
`0.0002502
`
`00.73
`
`44w .
`
`'Min copies copies SD
`0.0002502 0.0002592
`41.51
`25.02
`25.92
`41.93
`
`0.054
`2.021
`$463
`
`_
`
`39.25
`31.97
`45.00
`
`31.44
`54.42
`030 HEX
`.
`.
`P31 HEX 05.54
`30.40
`44.13
`30.47
`.3055
`142 HEX—m 0.35
`P35 HEX
`09.37
`31.00
`31.01
`30.50
`0.45
`P36 HEX
`73.04
`.
`30.79
`0.24_
`P37 HEX
`7750
`.
`30.50
`0.00
`
`20.24
`43.15
`
`31.13
`
`.
`
`3.1.79.
`129.37-
`«43.10
`
`.
`
`25.33
`43.13
`
`0.050 _
`4050
`
`4944‘
`
`
`
`1555/20 (N40441:?
`444,145.51 as
`{8 ‘o?.§,-LV’
`00410: M”: »
`.
`'2’
`F:
`6.52:193
`863.; WPI
`i
`1’0 «0514’
`069044144 001%.
`
`3
`
`
`21.331.3040‘1004
`-HEX 03.33
`0.00 13045-10041.304e+0041.304e+004
`21.53
`21.03
`
`502053642 25-07
`1361”
`_-.2.::-22 209.22.19.51--- 0.6.1:_..__.__ m---
`-
`
`
`
`wstdaHEXmGOfiB 20.13
`130
`g 20.10
`.
`.3730“ 0.10
`“W330
`130_
`3104 £4 47.07*-_1_3_._0
`32.00
`32.53
`31.51 0.30
`#___1_3‘._0__
`13.0%
`
`
`'5‘d5fl- 92-5?!
`1-35__ 35-47
`35.63 3217.-...E0“
`_.L35...._|
`..,L§§._.,..
`'
`:Jésmfilrimv
`4.
`. -.I
`s51;
`170-.
`1131‘ wfii’um’ 111W
`P6581
`91(39):? flapgpjfml
`I) {135101.04
`P362 :1'34 6013116251”?! Pkgjm'a,
`$2 5 J
`:
`i
`l 00 carI'E’S/MJ {14.104 0h—
`P 9);); 500 00045470! 17/615400
`.17 5,75 : 7—06 0219;111:1441 [210541.40
`P56
`3
`5L347- 0013105 [04! 12161501“
`VET : 3939 001?pr /011
`flame»
`
`I of]
`
`‘
`
`”15/2003 3:36 PM
`
`OUTSIDE ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
`
`'
`
`I VRNTA00002004
`
`

`

`7.: h
`
`
`
`
`
`
`file:///C:/Documents%20aucl%2(JSeltingsr‘Yanu/My%20Dm:uments..r
`
`5 A 4
`
`c
`
`V“. g.
`
`_
`
`
`
`,.
`.-
`.
`o
`l.Esizfi'o-Wfigfizmratzwzuavzfiz Uéér-Smfe?
`
`
`
`
`
`
`;-
`v I‘M-'5 . $9
`3%,, ‘45»; Data File.C.\ Ducumenls and uellmgm Yannl My Documenls\ Down Syndrome
`al 1-99
`$9.32, ¢ $.04
`Diagnostics\ Real-Time PCR\ 20071218_P2T-P37.1ad
`
`Active Dye: (FAM)
`1-
`I1?” "3?sz _m.~g€a€afi.§g mfigfig
`
`
`
`C(T) Threshold: 0.007589
`mm tramp . >33,
`
`
`Threshold has been set manually.
`fig; mag; 31:3“:
`
`
`MERLE): LEAW
`
`Quanlilation Graph
`
`C(T) Control Graph y = 1; r’\2 : o
`
`«a
`
`u.
`
`280 5
`
`% §
`
`_.-'
`
`'
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Max CU) Min C(t) C(1)SD Maxcopigs Min copies copies SD
`
`
`Nm ——"
`“
`-
`WA
`Nm
`NIA
`NrA '
`NJ'A
`
`' 32-24
`
`' 33.65
`32.26
`
`
`.
`0.00
`NM
`
`
`
`29.44
`
`
`
`
`MJ‘MP”GA{'¢C Lyme
`
`-[~v Show diAFMJ
`
`{fir
`
`ID‘KS'W» -1l\ 0019; +0 [9Q Called 'man’
`
`ml: 10%”:
`
`F925) ”3!?
`
`l of!
`
`1115120083:37PM
`
`OUTSIDE ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
`
`VRNTAOOOOZOOS
`
`

`

`...,[/W2008
`$11 nof-rhbfludad’
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`P42
`
`HE21—.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`13 3192 31.93
`
`m
`.
`P45
`5714
`33.30
`33.30 33.35
`70.33
`22:35
`33.30
`311311;:1 HEX
`31111111151212 HEX! 30.33
`male .
`
`
`6558
`dilution 3 __ __ .
`male
`_
`_
`48.40
`
`dilution4 H U‘
`31913
`HEX
`
`
`3011110115 __
`
`.ngpm 79mm...
`
`n;— 113.5“..109m._{1933m 31.333110. (3.1.1., <73, 9147 9S .
`
`.
`
`33119,,2991 _.
`
`1‘1le:l//C:fDocuments%2Gand%20$ellings/Yann/My%20Documcnts...
`
`at: waded 00611;
`
`5'3
`t.1 am
`‘1:
`i- User.Shared M3
`at???61 «13 Q ¢ ‘1"; Data File:C:1Documentsand Settings\YanmMyDocuments1DownSyndrome
`5‘5, " Diagnostics\ Real-Time PCR\ 20080114_P34P38-P45.tad
`51(31th Active Dye. (HEX)
`
`I HEX (61111711A) ‘
`
`Quantitafion Graph
`
`3191911 M
`
`gVOWfIamm ~5 9"“2 Bfifiaerflfi
`(676177231‘22! 27%- 01/9'4-7’2493’)
`5.) 5,2,4? Hmefll’e-(120191 @WFW 1.54%)
`
`C(T) Contra: Graph y.. 3.317;: 1 33.99; 112-2 1
`
`Note
`
`Av
`Min
`Av
`
`C(19)
`C(l)
`C(t)
`SD molecfltes
`-— ~11
`~11
`—_E25133—4 31.03 0.33
`.
`.
`32.593-2.73
`
`32.35 33.07 32. 39 0.30 _20:75~
`24.27
`
`3293
`32.48 0.39 :1-7229- _ 22.79
`
`33-52 33.34 3335 0.13 —11‘:121-_
`12.51
`
`Max
`‘C(1)
`
`Max
`molecules
`19.
`34‘?
`23.37
`
`21.33"
`
`3-303 33.13
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`FIQSAIADJW‘:
`CPPE’SLOW-'1“;
`.._....___
`550.5
`5317'-
`
`5,161
`4.32,
`23-3
`
`34,
`34]
`' g; 1;
`3531
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`____.
`
`15:31” r._#1681 7TH“ -
`35.252?“
`33.35..
`.
`
`om _—_32.«53~—_am
`0. 35
`13.29
`13.14
`'
`1011
`101133001
`2344120931004 23.45 2370-019 121331004 133731001
`2299134431004 2299 23.03 2295 004 1.344e+001
`1347131004 '13443-1004
`2337'
`1344
`23.37 23.45 23.33'009
`1311
`i
`2E).52
`164
`29.51
`20.76 29.09 i 0.30
`164
`
`3313
`16.4
`33.13 3340 32.93 0.20
`16.4
`
`39.79
`
`33.19
`
`.131
`
`33.25 3379 35.71
`
`__.___-._...__|.___.__.___
`
`1.64
`0.511
`.___._._____._
`
`
`
`02/ 1%1’14 mfg/mm?)
`1142(i»6{r‘1011‘10.1 1111343331717
`W147 = Qfliéjfih{131
`
`10 180191
`
`9016111071 50/12:
`
`101'!
`
`HIS/2008 3:36 PM
`
`OUTSIDE ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
`
`.
`
`VRNTAODOOZOOS
`
`

`

`'
`
`I'Ile:lI'/C:lDocu1110111596203nd0/n20Settings/Ya:mlMy%20D0011ments...
`
`-
`
`3'4 "1%
`-'* w -" User:Si1arad
`Data File:C:\ Decumenzs and Sellings‘. Yanm My Documents\ Down Syndrome
`
`_ Diagnostics\ Real-Time PCR\ 200801'14_P34P38-P45.lad
`
`'9‘ Active Dye: (FAM)
`
`bf: C(T) Threshold: 0.012355
`
`.' Threshold has been set manually.
`
`(.FAM I
`
`
`
`C(T) Conirol Graph y = ‘l; r"2 = U
`
`D4909 15 1
`
`Fluorescence
`
`L011
`
`Note
`
`.
`
`
`
`37.62 0.00
`37.92
`—-—-40.16 37.02
`MIA
`MIA
`MIA
`P34 FAM—_--35.59 34.26
`MIA
`MIA
`MIA
`pas -——--2_-95_ NA
`NA —~A
`114—“
`NA
`
`MIA
`P39
`FAM
`MIA
`MIA
`MIA
`MIA_ MIA __ MIA
`MIA
`MIA
`
`32.55 0.39
`MIA
`NIA
`NIA
`MIA.
`P40
`FAM 57.50
`32.95— MIA
`32.97
`33.52
`
`MIA
`MIA
`MIA
`MIA
`MIA
`MIA
`P41
`PAM—MIA
`MIA
`MIA
`MIA
`
`P42
`FAM 46.88
`34.14 __MLA___ 34.19
`.
`MIA
`'MIA
`34.59
`33.?3
`MIA
`MIA
`
`0.00 MIA_:“ MIA " _MIA
`'43.45 40.45_ 46.45
`MIA
`MIA
`MIA
`MIA
`
`MIA _. 41.0514234 40.49
`P44
`13.34 143.64
`1.19
`MIA WWI?— WWW—Emmi
`
`
`
`
`P45
`FAM 33.93 3339
`MIA _- 31.30
`32.33 31.25
`0.33 ._ MIA
`l
`MIA :l
`NI‘AMM‘
`NIAWh
`
`
`
`
`
`female
`MIA
`control
`
`0113:1121 l-19.35 MIA
`
`
`
`ma'e
`PAM 5919
`23.49
`MIA
`dilution 2
`
`MIA
`
`
`'NIA
`
`'
`w j
`I
`
`MIA
`MIA
`:
`
`MIA
`
`MIA
`
`MIA
`
`MIA
`
`19.93
`23.32
`
`19.34
`23.43
`
`MIA
`
`MIA
`__fi
`19.70
`22.22 0.50
`
`MIA
`.
`MIA
`NIAI
`
`
`NI'A
`
`
`MIA
`26.07 0.33
`20.93
`23.55
`MIA
`26.59
`-.”“?"9
`FAM 55.06
`
`
`.. _:'___________________ WW mwm‘w’
`dllulIDnS
`
`
`
`
`(1111111133: 4 FAM 39.00
`29.97
`29.31
`MIA
`29.32
`29.64
`0.13
`MIA
`_
`r... __..__
`___
`.m
`.
`
`film)?” FAM 30.5?
`133.43
`MIA
`33.40 0.03
`MIA
`
`
`33.43
`
`33.57
`
`MIA
`
`l"
`MIA
`._.______.......__.m-. _
`MIA
`'
`MIA
`2.2-
`MIA
`
`,.
`
`MIA
`
`l
`
`NM
`
`
`
`my 1213634117.: Mug-11> Alamo Mia-9442f»:
`
`'13‘1514 M wdgrlo foe 1mm: 51mg
`
`mi? 1391“;
`
`P3131740, P49, P91;
`
`lofl
`
`HIS/2008 3:36 PM
`
`OUTSIDE ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
`
`VRNTA00002007
`
`

`

`-. a. w
`
`‘
`
`_.
`J.
`7
`__.J”...—1...“...-_._.
`1:.
`"1"“
`
`i
`
`Ear/1.101241211111815 1.1.1.1191. o..1.-mhemco1.m__ f
`. mam/U.11, $1Mm£§m£e PCRPmfi‘qmnPw+oca(__TJ ‘
`i
`'ELM'W" .1. 10.11.17—1»,We.»
`.
`...
`
`
`
`'
`'
`
`'
`
`.
`
`81301112 ~9- ”30.119
`PIE
`"
`' E6
`follbwed .S‘MXA .fdzrnaa Cons’rrwhon:ErgPMprp‘fhcal
`
`.
`
`
`, _ ..
`
`'
`
`.
`
`[Om/WAT? 10w
`
`...-.11.
`
`.JDNA
`J’s/.1119
`.
`T1 DNA 119.111.1111.
`MrFmTX
`$1.1!
`’17? 1&fo Fatwa 541.2
`Fflfaow W [71913111133156
`T4- [WK 5411!
`
`[/1211
`
`309C ‘RJFI
`
`3017!!“
`
`€01 Mfiwm
`12111011161.
`12mm.” 33...)?
`155.
`
`110101 “14‘ Lam 4o 3'5401 neggmm:
`
`DNA
`
`33.1112
`
`{Cu/low 6W BN3
`01111117
`101412
`Wow/«13‘ 31M
`
`1s.» 10
`.2181
`9111111211119 Pcfl Pair-Rmfign
`
`16111112ch 11 Law. as
`
`OUTSIDE ATTORNEYS' EYES ONLY
`
`VRNTA00002008
`
`.
`.
`1
`waw-wr-rm nut-«r... «.... a.w»-.mm.-m.d-..u.-p .._.....
`
`M._._..... “......W. .. .
`
`..
`
`.-
`
`...-.5. _.1. ......3
`
`Prqoma(111110.113 J51? 3211121121 3111mm?
`
` '“ dampfe
`
`.
`:‘
`1
`I
`.1-
`
`.
`1
`I
`--.... _
`_i _
`
`_
`
`_
`
`1:111:11 M1113111/we
`.MnfimgxM1131. 10:11.;
`
`.
`
`-
`
`_- w
`
`_
`
`
`
`__8x100.112flaunt).DJM .11..11-1.0”0111111152. 111%..My'
`9 be.11.... E”
`P
`71(9111111015111
`_
`'M
`Qfl-LQ. @m_ -
`( 1145a..fiizm.gffléafl.fmm$
`
`« .
`
`

`

`
`
`.g'l
`E:
`...“.3...“fl.““.1.'“mm‘?"“""}""““_..__.E...H...
`
`
`
`_._§__._:___J._...J.__.L....
`L._..-I.____._|._._.,._i. .....E.A....:_...._..é...... _.........:-......._-..- .I.
`!
`! NA,
`row:
`i
`
`' .‘u.-.'....‘.u..:..h...,;m.,. ,.
`
`
`
`I‘m'wghflfix...,_..,..j........-1...“..-w......f...»....£..._..........'.
`
`.
`
`.. .. W.
`
`.....-..
`
`___..
`
`.
`
`--..:‘.._.....Jl.._-...:..........'-..__....:...
`
`.
`
`._..-.£_-.._.T..__...I..... -.€-.......:,_.._....>.
`
`L_;....
`l...
`
`__.i.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`.
`
`..
`
`.33 3
`
`L.
`__.f
`
`L- .
`
`.
`
`j.—
`5..... a
`
`g:
`'r.
`
`l-
`
`3
`
`’
`9
`
`.
`
`.
`.
`
`.
`
`.. DNA,,,
`4344.41.
`.
`.
`.PiquSibn--j)/J4:.PD(HW§L_ QM
`
`.
`
`‘
`
`-
`
`,
`
`.
`
`,
`
`‘
`
`,
`
`.
`..
`
`. _....
`
`..
`
`.
`
`.qu pm. :2 l
`
`(114.
`
`"3923.681
`H95“ 96'°C
`.303
`(éSpC } 13(5ng_
`
`30.8
`
`32°C
`
`.
`
`5mm #20C
`we.
`.0
`
`3m ((2qu 10m WW
`Hand (,4. 5m :55.
`
`.
`
`-
`
`.
`
`._
`
`.
`
`OUTSIDE ATTORNEYS" EYES ONLY
`
`'VRNTA00002009
`
`