`  
`          
`
`
` $ ( 44 *$* %4 6,670,905
`
` @?A5>>@B>
`
`"3
`
` ))+3
`
`June 14, 2000
`December 30, 2003
`
` $,$*%(3 *,$
`4 ((    
`
`
`
`
`
`
`  AE 444 < B@4D:;
`))$3 )%(* $4
`
`*"3 Radar Warning Receiver With Position and Velocity Sensitive Functions
`
`
`

" *%&   1  :AE 444 < B@4D:;:@;;
`%##))%$( %( *$*)
`44 %. ?BC>
`".$(1  @@A?A5?BC>
`
`
`
` !#  !' !" !#& ''
`
` 1 () (*%$1 "( ) %""%-)3
`
`    
`
`'
`
`
`
`?4
`
` ($  "%( % )$ ( $ "*("
`
`$$($ (%#  $$)/",$ ** $,()*/ $ ?GFA -* $
`
`#&)) $ "*(%#$*)1 %##+$*%$)1 $ $*$$)4 ")%
`
`($ 

)*() $ "*(" $$($ (%#  ," %)*(+*
`
`Page 1 of 6
`
`K40 Exhibit 1021, pg. 1
`IPR2013-00240
`
`

`

`%%" $ ?GFE -*  )&"0*%$ $ %##+$*%$) $$($4
`School in 1987 with a specialization in communications engineering.
`I
`
`")% ($  %*%(" ( $ "*(" $$($ (%# %
`also earned a doctoral degree in electrical engineering from Ohio
`
`$,()*/ $ ?GGF4
`University in 1998.
`
`@4
`2.
`
` , %,( @G /() % .&($ -* %##+$*%$1
`I have over 29 years of experience with communication,
`
`$,*%$ $ )+(,""$ )/)*#)4
`navigation and surveillance systems.
`
`A4
`3.
`
` # +(($*"/  &(%))%( $ * %%" % "*("
`I am currently a professor in the School of Electrical
`
`$$($ $ %#&+*( $ * % $,()*/4 , *+*
`Engineering and Computer Science at Ohio University.
`I have taught
`
`+$((+* $ (+* %+()) $ (( $ 4
`undergraduate and graduate courses in radar and GPS.
`
`B4
`4.
`
`  ")*$ % #/ &+"*%$) $ ()( ) $"+ $ #/
`A listing of my publications and research is included in my
`
`+((+"+# ,*1  %&/ % - ) ** ) &&$. 4
`curriculum vitae, a copy of which is attached as Appendix A.
`
`I.

% ##$" "   # !#
`I.
`My Status as an Independent Declarant
`
`C4
`5.
`
` , $ (*$ $ *) #**( /
`B> "*(%$) 4
`I have been retained in this matter by K40 Electronics LLC.
`
`:8**%$(9; *% &(%, $ $"/)) % * )%& $ %$*$* % *-%
`("Petitioner”) to provide an analysis of the scope and content of two
`
`&(%( (* (($) ** .)* &(%(1 * (")* &*$* &&"*%$
`prior art references that existed prior, the earliest patent application
`
`+$("/$ 44 *$* %4 E1GGG1E@? :8* 6E@? &*$*9;4 $ &(*+"(1
`underlying U.S. Patent No. 7,999,721 ("the ‘721 patent”). In particular, I
`
`$"/0 -*( (*$ "#$*) % * "#) % * 6E@? &*$* (
`analyzed whether certain elements of the claims of the ‘721 patent are
`
`)( $ * *-% &(%( (* (($)4
`described in the two prior art references.
`
`D4
`6.
`
` # $ %#&$)* %( #/ -%(!4

/  ) $%*
`I am being compensated for my work. My fee is not
`
`%$*$$* %$ * %+*%# % $/ #**( %( %$ $/ % * *$"
`contingent on the outcome of any matter or on any of the technical
`
`Page 2 of 6
`Page 2 of 6
`
`K40 Exhibit 1021, pg. 2
`|PR2013-00240
`
`K40 Exhibit 1021, pg. 2
`IPR2013-00240
`
`

`

`&%)*%$) .&"$ $ *) "(*%$4 , $% $$" $*()* $
`positions I explain in this declaration.
`I have no financial interest in
`
`**%$(4
`Petitioner.
`
`E4
`7.
`
` , $ $%(# ** )%(* $41 :($*( (((
`I have been informed that Escort Inc., (hereinafter referred
`
`*% ) 8*$*9; %-$) * 6E@? &*$*4 , $% $$" $*()* $ *
`to as "Patentee”) owns the ‘721 patent.
`I have no financial interest in the
`
`*$* %( * 6E@? &*$*4
`Patentee or the ‘721 patent.
`
`II.
`11.
`
` !"  !# " "
`Comparison of Certain Basic Files
`
`F4
`8.
`
` *(+ $ %((* %&/ % *   )%+( % $"+
`A true and correct copy of the BASIC source code included
`
`$ .* @>FD ) ** ) &&$. 4 -"" (( *% ** )%+(
`in Exhibit 2086 is attached as Appendix B.
`I will refer to that source
`
`% ) BD>>!4)4
`code as TST4600k.bas.
`
`G4
`9.
`
` *(+ $ %((* %&/ % *   )%+( % $"+
`A true and correct copy of the BASIC source code included
`
`$ .* @>G?7) (&@4) " ) ** ) &&$. 4 -"" ((
`in Exhibit 2091’s graph2.bas file is attached as Appendix C.
`I will refer
`
`*% ** )%+( % ) (&@4)4
`to that source code as graph2.bas.
`
`?>4  *(+ $ %((* %&/ % *   )%+( % $"+
`10.
`A true and correct copy of the BASIC source code included
`
`$ .* @>G?7) (&A4) " ) ** ) &&$. 4 -"" ((
`in Exhibit 2091’s graph3.bas file is attached as Appendix D.
`I will refer
`
`*% ** )%+( % ) (&A4)4
`to that source code as graph3.bas.
`
`??4 *"0$

(%)%* %(1 (*  %#&()%$ %
`11. Utilizing Microsoft Word, I created a comparison of
`
`BD>>
`4) $ (&@4)4  *(+ $ %((* %&/ % **
`TST46OOK.bas and graph2.bas. A true and correct copy of that
`
`%#&()%$ ) ** ) &&$. 4 $ &&$. 1 * )%+( %
`comparison is attached as Appendix E. In Appendix E, the source code
`
`** ) &()$* $ (&@4) +* ) $%* &()$* $ BD>>!4) )
`that is present in graph2.bas but is not present in TST4600k.bas is
`
`Page 3 of 6
`Page 3 of 6
`
`K40 Exhibit 1021, pg. 3
`|PR2013-00240
`
`K40 Exhibit 1021, pg. 3
`IPR2013-00240
`
`

`

`)&"/ $ $ +$("$ %$*4 $ &&$. 1 * )%+( % ** )
`displayed in an underlined font. In Appendix E, the source code that is
`
`&()$* $ BD>>!4) +* ) $%* &()$* $ (&@4) ) )&"/
`present in TST4600k.bas but is not present in graph2.bas is displayed
`
`+)$  )*(!%+* %$*4
`using a strikeout font.
`
`?@4

(%)%* %( $*) ** *( ( GD (,)%$)
`
`12. Microsoft Word indicates that there are 96 revisions
`
`*-$ (&@4) $ BD>>!4)4
`between graph2.bas and TST4600k.bas.
`
`?A4 *"0$

(%)%* %(1 (*  %#&()%$ %
`13. Utilizing Microsoft Word, I created a comparison of
`
`BD>>
`4) $ (&A4)4  *(+ $ %((* %&/ % **
`TST46OOK.bas and graph3.bas. A true and correct copy of that
`
`%#&()%$ ) ** ) &&$. 4 $ &&$. 1 * )%+( %
`comparison is attached as Appendix F. In Appendix F, the source code
`
`** ) &()$* $ (&A4) +* ) $%* &()$* $ BD>>!4) )
`that is present in graph3.bas but is not present in TST4600k.bas is
`
`)&"/ $ $ +$("$ %$*4 $ &&$. 1 * )%+( % ** )
`displayed in an underlined font. In Appendix F, the source code that is
`
`&()$* $ BD>>!4) +* ) $%* &()$* $ (&A4) ) )&"/
`present in TST4600k.bas but is not present in graph3.bas is displayed
`
`+)$  )*(!%+* %$*4
`using a strikeout font.
`
`?B4

(%)%* %( $*) ** *( ( GD (,)%$)
`
`14. Microsoft Word indicates that there are 96 revisions
`
`*-$ (&A4) $ BD>>!4)4
`between graph3.bas and TST4600k.bas.
`
`?C4  *%$) %$ & @ % .*)  $  %&$  "
`15.
`The additions on page 2 of Exhibits E and F open a file
`
`$# 8%!449  *%$) ( $ "**+ $ "%$*+
`named "Locked.LOC.” The additions read in latitude and longitude
`
`%%($*)1 #%$ %*( $%(#*%$1 (%# * 8%!49 "4 
`coordinates, among other information, from the “Locked.LOC” file. The
`
`*%$) ")% %&$ *-% 

&%(*)4 ) 

&%(*) ( +) *%
`additions also open two COM ports. These COM ports are used to
`
`(, * (%#   (,( $  (( **%(4  *%$)
`receive data from a GPS receiver and a radar detector. The additions
`
`")% "+"*  )*$1 80)*91 +)$ * %,5)+)) "**+ $
`also calculate a distance, "zdist", using the above-discussed latitude and
`
`Page 4 of 6
`Page 4 of 6
`
`K40 Exhibit 1021, pg. 4
`|PR2013-00240
`
`K40 Exhibit 1021, pg. 4
`IPR2013-00240
`
`

`

`"%$*+ %%($*) $ * +(($* &%)*%$ % *  (,(4 
`
`*%$) *$ %#&( ** )*$ *% 4@C4  * )*$ ) ")) *$
`
`4@C1 *$ * ,(" 8"%!9 ) )* *% ?1 %*(-) * ,(" 8"%!9
`
`) >4
`
`?D4  *%$) %$ & A % .*)  $  ($  "" -$
`
` (( )$" ) **  8"%!9 ) '+" *% > +* %) $%* ($  ""
`
` 8"%!9 ) '+" *% ?4
`
`?E4 +)1 * *%$) *% .*)  $   * +$*%$"*/
`
`*% &(%(# location-based police radar signal processing.
`
`?F4
`
` +$()*$ ** (4 ($%$ ) *)* ** *)
`
`*%$) -( 8"(" $ $*+(94 )(4 !$ $*% %+$* **
`
`* 6E@? *$* %#$ % * )" "#$*) : 41 1 ((
`
`**%(1 $ %#&+*(;1 *) (,)%$) (&()$* ,(/*$ **

(4
`
`(( -%+" , """/  *% &(%(# location-based police radar
`
`signal processing4
`
`?G4 ) +&%$ #/ +$()*$$ ** (&@4) $
`
`(&A4) -( (* %$ %( *( @>?>1 $ #/ (,- % *
`
`*%$) # *% BD>>!4) *% (* (&@4) $ (&A4)1
`
`) $% ,$ **

r. Orr has demonstrated location-based police radar
`
`signal processing &(%( *% @>?>4
`
`Page 5 of 6
`
`K40 Exhibit 1021, pg. 5
`IPR2013-00240
`
`

`

`@>4
`20.
`
` "( ** "" )**#$*) # ($ % #/ %-$
`I declare that all statements made herein of my own
`
`!$%-" ( *(+ $ ** "" )**#$*) # %$ $%(#*%$ $
`knowledge are true and that all statements made on information and
`
`" ( ", *%  *(+2 $ +(*( ** *) )**#$*) -(
`belief are believed to be true; and further that these statements were
`
`# -* * !$%-" ** -""+" ") )**#$*) $ * "! )%
`made with the knowledge that willful false statements and the like so
`
`# ( &+$)" / $ %( #&()%$#$*1 %( %*1 +$( *%$
`made are punishable by fine or imprisonment, or both, under Section
`
`?>>? % *" ?F % * $* **) %4
`1001 of Title 18 of the United States Code.
`
`@?4
`21.
`
` "( +$( &$"*/ % &( +(/ ** * %(%$ ) *(+
`I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true
`
`$ %((*4
`and correct.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`a-
`=====================================
`’--,.
`.'
`.
`""‘L-
`(4 () (*%$1 44
`Dr. Chris Bartone. P.E.
`
` =
`
`l--
`_
`_-
`.
`'.
`===========================
`':-.e
`,- UL
`
`*3
`
`
`
`Date:
`
`Page 6 of 6
`Page 6 of 6
`
`K40 Exhibit 1021, pg. 6
`|PR2013-00240
`
`K40 Exhibit 1021, pg. 6
`IPR2013-00240
`
`

`

`
`
`

`
` 
`xhibit A
`
` E
`
`
`
`Exhibit A to K40 Exhibit 1021, pg. 1
`|PR2013-00240
`
`Exhibit A to K40 Exhibit 1021, pg. 1
`IPR2013-00240
`
`

`

`Chris G. Bartone, Ph.D., P.E.
`
`
`
`APPENDIX A
`
`
`
`CURRICULUM VITAE
`
`
`CONTACT INFORMATION
`
`
`Chris Gregory Bartone, Ph.D., P.E.
`Professor, School of EECS, Ohio University
`President, GNSS Solutions® Ltd.
`Athens, Ohio 45701
`Office: 740-593-9573 (school)
`Mobile: 740-591-1660
`Fax: 740-205-4123
`E-mail: bartone@ohio.edu, bartone@GNSSsolutions.com
`
`
`EDUCATIONAL DEGREES/CERTIFICATES
`
`P.E. in State of Ohio, Registration Number PE 66926, since June 2002
`
`Ph.D. Electrical Engineering, Ohio University, Athens, Ohio, Fall 1994 to Spring 1998, awarded
`in June 1998. Dissertation Title: “Ranging Airport Pseudolite for Local Area Augmentation
`Using the Global Positioning System”.
`
`M.S. Electrical Engineering, The Naval Postgraduate School, Monterey, CA, Fall 1986 to
`Summer 1987, awarded in August 1987; specialized in Communications Engineering. Thesis
`Title: “Measured Noise Performance of a Direct-Sequence Spread-Spectrum System and a
`Comparison of Single-vice Dual-Channel Delay-Lock Loops”.
`
`B.S. Electrical Engineering, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA, Fall 1979
`to Spring 1983, awarded in June 1983; emphasis in electromagnetics, communications, and
`antennas.
`
`ACADEMIC EXPERIENCE
`
`Ohio University, School of Electrical Engineering and Computer Science, Athens, OH
`Professor (6/2009-Present)
`Associate Professor (5/2004-6/2009)
`Assistant Professor, (3/1999-5/2004)
`Visiting Assistant Professor, (9/1998-3/1999)
`Graduate Instructor, (3/1998-6/1998)
`
`Research:
`x Differential Global Positioning System (GPS) Performance Analysis task for Northrop-
`Grumman Corporation, El Segundo, CA for engineering services and white paper.
`2/27/2009 to 6/12/2009. Principle Investigator for this task.
`x GPS Long Range Navigation (LORAN)-C Analysis and Support, sponsored by the FAA,
`Contract: DTFA01-01-C-00071, Technical Task Description 2.1, 10/1/07 to 12/30/07; new
`work from 1/1/08 to 09/26/08, then with contract extension to 04/30/09. I am the Principle
`
`
`
`1
`
`Exhibit A to K40 Exhibit 1021, pg. 2
`IPR2013-00240
`
`

`

`Chris G. Bartone, Ph.D., P.E.
`
`
`
`
`
`Investigator for Loran-C support to FAA on all aspects. Coordinate all development
`including King Air flight tests, Loran Propagation Model (LPM) development and
`validation, ASF measurement and validation studies, legacy performance assessments for
`GPS non-precision approach, H-field antenna specification.
`x Ohio University Shielded Antenna Anechoic Chamber, used in research for the following
`projects:
`o Spectral Systems Incorporated/Sierra Nevada Corporation microwave antenna
`development (2.4 GHz band)
`o FAA Instrumented Landing System (ILS) antenna (300MHz band)
`o Stanford University, Joint Precision Approach and Landing System Controlled
`Reception Pattern Array measurement (L band)
`o USCG NDGPS Antenna Performance Analysis (L band)
`o FAA GPS interference work (L band)
`I am the Principle Investigator for development, testing, and coordination of all projects.
`All results were provided back to program sponsors.
`x Development of a Prototype NDGPS High Performance Architecture Enhancement. Lead
`agency was the U.S. Department of Transportation (DOT) Federal Railroad Administration
`(FRA) funded through DOT/Volpe Center. Contract DTRS57-04-C-10026 Base Period
`from 10/20/05 to 04/20/06 and Options 1 until 10/20/06 to 10/20/07. This was essentially a
`follow-on contract to the Prototype NDGPS contract shown below. I was the Principle
`Investigator for all development and research efforts.
`x Combat Sent System Passive Ranging for high accuracy bearing determination to locations
`off the aircraft body. Issued under contract FA8620-05-G-3015-0002, Subcontract 301502-
`OU-01, from U.S. Air Force, via Spectral Systems Incorporated/Sierra Nevada Corporation,
`from 8/1/05-4/15/06. (Co-PI with Frank van Graas); asked co-PI for advice occasionally.
`Contribution Level: High (~30%). I was the Principle Investigator for all development and
`research efforts including DC-3 flight tests.
`x Analysis and Evaluation on Impact of the Wide Area Augmentation System (WAAS) on
`Maritime Radio Navigation Users, from Volpe. Contract DTRT57-05-P-80171 from
`6/17/05-3/17/06. I was the Principle Investigator for all development and research efforts.
`x Development of a Prototype Nationwide Differential Global Positioning System (NDGPS)
`and High Performance Architecture Demonstration. Lead agency was the U.S. Department
`of Transportation (DOT) Federal Railroad Administration (FRA) funded
`through
`DOT/Volpe Center. Contract DTRS57-04-C-10026 Base Period from 03/30/04 to 09/30/04
`and Options 2 until 09/30/06. I was the Principle Investigator for all development and
`research efforts. (This was the original DOT/FRA/Volpe contracts, which led to the follow-
`on contract shown earlier.)
`x Missile Range Safety Technology (BMRST), Eastern Range, Command Destruct System
`(CDS) Testing Flight Test Support, supported by Florida Air National Guard (FLANG),
`Contract W911YN-06-P-002, from 10/06/05-07/06/05. I was the Principle Investigator for
`all development and research efforts.
`x Antenna Baseline and Attitude Measurement Systems (ABAMS) Feasibility Study for
`UAVs, Lead agency is the U.S. Naval Research Laboratory, via ITT Industries, from
`9/29/2004 to 8/5/2005. (co-PI with Tom Arthur)
`x Antenna Performance Analysis for the U.S. Coast Guard NDGPS sites. New effort awarded
`
`
`
`2
`
`Exhibit A to K40 Exhibit 1021, pg. 3
`IPR2013-00240
`
`

`

`Chris G. Bartone, Ph.D., P.E.
`
`
`
`
`
`from U.S. DOT Volpe Center, Contract DTRS57-04-P-80285, from 8/16/04-04/29/05. I was
`the Principle Investigator for all development and research efforts.
`x Antenna Baseline Measurement System (ABMS) for high accuracy bearing determination to
`locations off the aircraft body. Contract F33657-02-G-4036-0004, Subcontract 4.3604-OU-
`01. Issued from U.S. Air Force, via Spectral Systems Incorporated/Sierra Nevada
`Corporation, from 9/1/03-10/31/04. (Co-PI with Frank van Graas) I was the Principle
`Investigator for the development and research efforts including DC-3 flight tests.
`x Anti-Jam Navigation Terminal System (ANTS) for the Air Force Research Laboratory,
`Space Vehicle, Ballistic Missile Technology Program Office. Contract F29601-00-C-0212,
`Anti-Jam Navigation Terminal System Using the Global Positioning System. Multi-year
`contract:
`o Base Year, from 09/07/00 to 2/29/02
`o Option Year One Awarded on 8/14/01 for 12 months:
`x Task 3.1 GPS Transceiver Development
`x Task 3.2 AZMLA Development; extended to 7/31/03.
`I was the Principle Investigator for all development and research efforts.
`x GPS-based Range Safety System to meet the Air Force Research Laboratory, Space
`Vehicle, Ballistic Missile Technology Program Office requirements. Research for the
`establishment, licensing, and certification of a GPS-based range safety system to eliminate
`ground-based radars. Contract F29601-99-C-0176, GPS Range Safety Technology System,
`from 10/1/99 to 9/30/00; then, from 1/17/01-1/31/03. I was the Principle Investigator for all
`development and research efforts.
`
`
`Teaching:
`I taught the following electrical engineering courses at Ohio University, Athens, OH:
`1. EE 605 Satellite-Based Navigation Systems, F00-01, F01-02, F03-04, W04-05, F06-07,
`F07-08, F08-09, F09-10, F10-11.
`2. EE 613/690 High-Accuracy Satellite Navigation Systems, S00-01, S01-02, W03-04, S06-
`07, W07-08, W08-09, W09-10, S10-11.
`3. EE395B Intermediate Laboratory Experimentation II, W08-09, S08-09, W09-10, S09-10,
`F10-11,W10-11.(Electromagnetics/Motors part).
`4. EE 395C Intermediate Electrical and Computer Engineering Design Experience, S02-03,
`F03-04, F06-07, S07-08, S09-10, F10-11, S10-11.
`(Electromagnetics/Antennas/Communications).
`5. EE 602/690 Radar Systems, S99-00, W10-11.
`6. EE 601/690, Electromagnetic Wave Propagation in Electronic Navigation Systems, F99-
`00, F04-05.
`7. EE 690 Satellite Navigation Systems for Automobiles Seminar (Independent Study),
`S06-07.
`8. EE 321 Electromagnetics and Materials I, W99-00, W01-02, W02-03.
`9. EE 495A/B/C Electrical and Computer Engineering Capstone Design I, II, & III, Design
`Project Leader for a GPS Antenna, 2002-2003 and 2003-2004. Used EECS Antenna
`Anechoic Chamber in design evaluation.
`10. EE 490 Electromagnetics Experimentation Design, F02-03, superseded by EE395C.
`11. EE 690 Antenna Pattern Measurement Seminar (Independent Study), W00-01, F06-07.
`12. EE 371 Applied Probability and Statistics for Electrical Engineers, S97-98, S98-99.
`
`
`
`3
`
`Exhibit A to K40 Exhibit 1021, pg. 4
`IPR2013-00240
`
`

`

`Chris G. Bartone, Ph.D., P.E.
`
`
`
`
`
`13. EE 441/541, Antennas I, W98-99.
`14. EE 312 Linear Systems and Networks II, W98-99.
`15. EE 310 Linear Systems and Networks I, F98-99.
`
`Graduate Student Summary:
`The following lists are for the Theses/Dissertations Directed (Graduated and Current):
`Graduated Students:
`1. Ravi Varma Komarabathuni, MSEE, “Performance Assessment of a 77 GHz Automotive
`Radar for Various Obstacle Avoidance Applications”, Ohio University, Spring 2010-
`2011.
`2. Raghunath Viswanatha, MSEE, “A Multi-channel RF Front End for Global Navigation
`Satellite System Receiver”, Ohio University, November 2008.
`3. Tim Needham, MSEE, “A Low Rate Data Link for a High Performance Differential
`Global Positioning System”, Ohio University, June 2008.
`4. Jeff Dickman, Ph.D.EE, “Single Platform Relative Positioning for Sensor Stabilization”,
`Ohio University, June 2008.
`5. Luyi Chen, MSEE, “Dual Frequency Patch Antenna Design for Global Navigation
`Satellite System”, Ohio University, June 2007.
`6. Ian Barton, MSEE, “Antenna Performance Analysis for the Nationwide Differential
`Global Positioning System”, November 2005.
`7. Yujie Zhang, Ph.D.EE, “High Performance Differential Global Positioning System (HP-
`DGPS) For Long Range Baseline Application”, Ohio University, August 2005.
`8. Sumit Bhattacharya, MSEE, “A Real-time Bi-directional Differential Global Positioning
`System Data Link over Internet Protocol”, Ohio University, March 2005.
`9. Sidharth Nair, MSEE, “A Multiple Antenna Global Positioning System Configuration
`For Enhanced Performance”, Ohio University, June 2004.
`10. Sai Kiran, Ph.D.EE, “A Wideband Airport Pseudolite for LAAS”, Ohio University,
`November 2003.
`11. Ranjeet Shetty, MSEE, “A Real-Time Bi-Directional Differential Global Positioning
`System”, Ohio University, November 2002.
`12. Jeff Dickman, MSEE, “Multipath Limiting Antenna Design Considerations for Ground
`Based Pseudolite Ranging Sources”, Ohio University, November 2001.
`Current Graduate Students:
`1. Tom Arthur, MSEE, “Closed Traverse Loop Analysis for Flight Test Validation, with
`RTK Application”, Ohio University, graduation planned Fall 2011-2012.
`2. Mahesh Katragadda, MSEE, “Broadband Planar Antennas for GNSS”, graduation
`planned Fall 2011-2012.
`3. Sumit Bhattacharya, Ph.D.EE, Ohio University, “A GPS-based Augmentation Navigation
`System Augmented with Multi-Vision Sensors”, graduation planned Spring 2011-2012.
`4. Kiran Kumar, “Intelligent Ground Vehicle Control using the Global Positioning
`Systems” graduation planned Spring 2011-2012.
`5. Gangula Rohan Sai, MSEE, “Multi-frequency GNSS Antennas Using a Slotted Feed
`Structure”, graduation planned Winter 2011-2012.
`6. Zach Bauer, MSEE, “CRPA measurements with a Software Radio”, Fall 2011-2012.
`7. Christian Sagardia, MSEE, “Ubiquitous UWB-based Positioning for Personnel/Asset
`Tracking and Navigation in an Indoor Environment”, graduation planned Spring 2011-
`
`
`
`4
`
`Exhibit A to K40 Exhibit 1021, pg. 5
`IPR2013-00240
`
`

`

`Chris G. Bartone, Ph.D., P.E.
`
`
`
`
`
`2012.
`8. Tim Needham, Ph.D. EE, “Integrated Navigation System for Land Navigation, Ph.D
`graduation planned Spring 2013-2014.
`
`
`School Committee Service Summary:
`
`Department Committees:
`1. Curriculum Committee, Review and oversee all changes to curriculums and courses,
`2010-2010, Committee Member.
`2. Graduate, School of EECS, 2004-2006, Committee Member.
`3. Assessment and Accreditation, School of EECS, 2002-2004, Committee Member.
`4. EE Senior Focus for the School of EECS, 2003-2006, Committee Member.
`5. EE Intermediate Courses for the School of EECS, 2003-2006, Committee Member.
`6. EE Design Courses for the School of EECS, 2003-2006, Committee Member.
`7. Matlab® Ad Hoc, February 2004, For discussion on adding additional MATLAB into the
`EECS curriculum. Outcome was to add Matlab® in EE103, Committee Member.
`8. Intermediate Curriculum Committee, Overseeing Development of new EE333/EE334
`Intermediate I/II, EE321 Electromagnetic, and EE371 Probability and Statistics Courses in
`new EECS Curriculum. 1999-2003, Head of Committee.
`9. Stocker Research Award, School of EECS, 1999-2000, Committee Member.
`
`
`College Committees:
`1. Dean’s Evaluation Committee, for 2008-2010, Faculty Senate Appointed, Committee
`Member.
`2. College Professional Ethics Committee, Russ College of Engineering and Technology,
`2008-2011, Faculty Senate Appointed, Committee Member.
`3. Auto ID 5-year Review Committee. 2005, Committee Member.
`4. College Professional Ethics Committee, Russ College of Engineering and Technology,
`2004-2007, Dean Appointed, Committee Member.
`
`
`University Committees:
`1. Faculty Senate, Ohio University for 2006-2009 and from 2009-2010. Faculty Senator,
`elected by and represent Russ College of Engineering and Technology.
`2. Facilities and Finances Committee (FFC), Ohio University, sub-committee of Faculty
`Senate, 2007-2011, Committee Member.
`3. Professional Relations Committee (PRC), Ohio University, sub-committee of Faculty
`Senate, 2006-2007, Committee Member.
`4. Budget Planning Council, Ohio University; Sept 2004-Sept 2005, committee advises Ohio
`University President and Provost on university wide budget issues. Appointed by Provost,
`Committee Member.
`
`
`Consulting and Seminars Experience
`The follow lists consulting and seminars performed.
`• President for GNSS Solutions® Ltd, founded April 2006, outgrowth of CNS Seminars &
`Consultants, Ltd., www.GNSSsolutions.com
`• Offered 24 tutorials on the two days preceding the ION GNSS 2010 Conference,
`
`
`
`5
`
`Exhibit A to K40 Exhibit 1021, pg. 6
`IPR2013-00240
`
`

`

`Chris G. Bartone, Ph.D., P.E.
`
`
`
`
`
`Portland, OR, on September 20-21, 2010.
`• Offered 24 tutorials on the two days preceding the ION GNSS 2009 Conference,
`Savannah, GA, on September 21-22, 2009.
`• Offered 24 tutorials on the two days preceding the ION GNSS 2008 Conference,
`Savannah, GA, on September 15-16, 2008.
`• Offered 25 tutorials on the two days preceding the ION GNSS 2007 Conference, Fort
`Worth, TX, on September 24-25, 2007.
`• Offered 10 tutorials on the two days preceding the ION GNSS 2006 Conference, Fort
`Worth, TX, on September 25-26, 2006.
`• Seminar Instructor for GNSS Solutions® Ltd
`• Two seminar classes in Singapore in cooperation with EEM Advancement Seminars
`Ltd. In 2010 and 2007:
`o Fundamentals of Antennas for Communication, Navigation and Surveillance
`(CNS) Systems
`ƒ 6 - 8 December 2010, Copthorne Orchid Singapore
`ƒ 3
` 5 December 2007, York Hotel Singapore
`o Fundamentals of Global Navigation Satellite Systems (GNSS)
`ƒ 9
` 10 December 2010, Copthorne Orchid Singapore
`ƒ 1
` 2 December 2007, York Hotel Singapore
`• Two days prior to the Institute of Navigation (ION) Global Navigation Satellite
`System (GNSS) 2010 Conference, Portland, OR, September 20-21, 2010, taught the
`following tutorials:
`• Fundamentals of GNSS I & II, September 20, 2010
`• GNSS Antenna I-Fundamentals, September 21, 2010
`• GNSS Antenna II-Special Topics, (taught first of three hours), September 21,
`2010
`• At Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)/ION Position Location
`and Navigation Symposium
`(PLANS),
`taught GPS Error Characterization,
`Mitigation, and Analysis, May 3, 2010, Palm Springs/Indian Wells, CA,
`• At IEEE Military Communications (MILCOM) Conference, taught Fundamentals of
`GNSS Tutorial, Boston, MA, October 20, 2009,
`• Two days prior to the Institute of Navigation (ION) Global Navigation Satellite
`System (GNSS) 2009 Conference, Savannah, GA, September 21-22, 2009, taught the
`following tutorials:
`• Fundamentals of GNSS I & II, September 21, 2009
`• Fundamentals of Antenna for GNSS, September 22, 2009
`• Two days prior to the ION GNSS 2008 Conference, Savannah, GA, September 15-16,
`2008, taught the following tutorials:
`• Fundamentals of GNSS I & II, September 15, 2008
`• Fundamentals of Antenna for GNSS, September 16, 2008
`• At Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE)/ION Position Location
`and Navigation Symposium (PLANS), May 15, 2008, Monterey, CA, taught
`Fundamentals of Satellite Navigation Systems Using GPS Tutorial.
`In cooperation with EEM Advancement Centre Pte Ltd, December 3-7, 2007, taught
`the following tutorials:
`• Fundamentals of GNSS, December 6-7, 2007, York Hotel, Singapore
`
`•
`
`
`
`6
`
`Exhibit A to K40 Exhibit 1021, pg. 7
`IPR2013-00240
`
`

`

`Chris G. Bartone, Ph.D., P.E.
`
`
`
`
`
`• Fundamentals of Antennas for Communications, Navigation and Surveillance
`(CNS) Systems, December 3-5, 2007, York Hotel, Singapore
`• Two days prior to the ION GNSS 2007 Conference, Fort Worth, TX, September 24-
`25, 2007, taught the following tutorials:
`• Fundamentals of GNSS I & II, September 24, 2007
`• Fundamentals of Antenna for GNSS, September 25, 2007.
`• Two days prior to the ION GNSS 2006 Conference, Fort Worth, TX, September 24-
`25, 2006, taught the following tutorials:
`• Fundamentals of GNSS I & II, September 25, 2006
`• GNSS Signal Propagation: Theory & Practice, September 25, 2006
`• Fundamentals of DGNSS, September 26, 2006
`• Fundamentals of Antenna for GNSS, September 26, 2006.
`• At IEEE/ION PLANS, San Diego, CA, April 24, 2006, taught Fundamentals of
`Satellite Navigation Systems Using GPS Tutorial.
`• Technical Expert Legal Consultant with GNSS Solutions® Ltd, June 2005-Present.
`• Ongoing Patent Infringement Case in the area of GPS and inertial navigation
`technologies for marine autopilots, International Trade Commission Case. Nov 2010-
`Present; awaiting trial date.
`o Expert Report on Infringement,
`o Expert Report on Rebuttal,
`o One full day of deposition.
`• Ongoing Patent Infringement Case in the area of GPS and radar detection commercial
`products, District Course Case, Idaho. Aug 2010-Present; awaiting trial date.
`o Expert Report on Infringement,
`o Expert Report on Rebuttal,
`o One full day of deposition.
`• Ongoing Patent Infringement Case in the area of Wireless Communications. District
`Court Case, Ohio. Expert Reports completed in Oct 2009 through Aug 2010; awaiting
`trial date.
`o Expert Report on Infringement,
`o Expert Report on Rebuttal,
`o Expert Report
` Supplemental,
`o Expert Report - Declaration supporting Motion of Summary Judgment,
`o Expert Report - Declaration supporting Opposition to Defendants Motion of
`Summary Judgment,
`o One full-days deposition.
`• Patent Review in the area of GPS receiver chip, wireless, and telematics technology
`for patent infringement to assess market potential of various patents. Dec 2009-Jan
`2010.
`• Civil Action Case in the area of differential GPS and radio technologies, US District
`Court, In matters of Honeywell International, Inc., vs Raytheon. Civil Action No. 08-
`cv-03952-SRC-MAS. Jan 2009 Nov 2009.
`• Contract Protest Case: In matters of Honeywell International, Inc., vs Raytheon. File:
`B400417, Agency: Naval Air Systems Command involving GPS-based precision
`approach and landing system technology under Solicitation No. N00019-07-R-0044,
`August 8, 2008 through September 6, 2008. (Case settled prior to court).
`
`
`
`7
`
`Exhibit A to K40 Exhibit 1021, pg. 8
`IPR2013-00240
`
`

`

`Chris G. Bartone, Ph.D., P.E.
`
`
`
`
`
`• Patent Infringement Case: U.S. International Trade Commission, Investigation No.
`337-TA-596, SiRF Technologies vs. Global Locate. In Matters of Certain GPS Chips,
`Associated Software and Systems, and Products Containing Same.
`o Expert Report on Infringement,
`o Expert Report on Rebuttal,
`o Expert Declaration supporting Motion of Summary Judgment,
`o Five full-days deposition,
`o Three full-days testifying in International Trade Commission (ITC) Federal
`Court.
`January 4, 2007 to April 30, 2008. (signed protective order on 6/18/07 (estimated))
`• Patent Infringement Case in the area of GPS chip technology and receiver design.
`U.S. District Court Case No. SACV05-773 CJC (ANx), in SiRF Technology, Inc., vs
`u-NAV Microelectronics Corporation. June 3, 2005 to January 10, 2007. (Case
`settled prior to court.)
`• Technical Expert Engineering Consultant with GNSS Solutions® Ltd
`• Supported Global Cooling Incorporate of Athens, Ohio
`in electromagnetic
`compatibility, interference emissions product development for European CE testing.
`(July-Aug 2010).
`• Supported Spectracom Corporation for the development of advanced products. (June-
`Aug 2010)
`• Design Consultant for ANTCOM on a Combined Ku/X-band Antenna Array for Land
`Navigations, Conceptual Design, May, 2005.
`• Seminar Instructor for CNS Seminars & Consultants, Ltd. Taught the following:
`• Fundamentals of Antennas, Spectral Systems Incorporated (SSI), Dayton, OH,
`October 19-20, 2005.
`• Fundamentals of Antennas for CNS Systems, National Aeronautics and Space
`Administration (NASA), NASA John Glenn Research Center, Cleveland, OH,
`September 26-28, 2005.
`• Fundamentals of Navigation I, July 28-30, 2003, Florida Air National Guard, Cape
`Canaveral, FL.
`• Seminar Instructor for Navtech GPS Seminars. Taught the following:
`• Pseudolites in Navigation and their Augmentation to GPS/GNSS, ION GNSS 2004
`Tutorial, September 20, 2004, Portland, OR.
`• GPS Antenna Fundamentals and Details, ION GNSS 2004