`
` %,i%}%u;artehnan
`
`g L‘
`
`L
`
`EMC/VMware v. PersonalWeb
`
`V IVP_R2013-00083
`’ LJEMCVMW 1053
`
`
`
` M
`
`V
`
`§etr1eval§5ys-
`9‘r»e-‘id
`hai/;“icaLA/iph6tocopyir1g,
`
`: Theféiluwing fl}4
`a_te: £igure legéndsi:
`
`are pruned’ pex1§i11s‘e‘éio'r‘\:Vfréfin th‘e aut\ho%zs féferehcéd in the approi:ri~
`‘
`
`_
`
`M
`
`M
`
`A
`
`V
`
`11- ,1f12::~1V-13,-V 11;4;;:11:.5}L11-.£;}1~1.7; u.3;‘.1,1.9; 11.10; 11.11;
`11.
`,
`‘
`.19; i1,I.'20;~1«—1;2.1. 2.1;*1;2.2:1 2.3;~12.4; 125; 12.6;
`
`' p.cm, '
`‘
`’ 1.IIC1Pd°53“de><«..
`{ISBN 1;ss55sV4o33-5
`
`
`
`
`
`..s9;-;1a92 " A
`«;c11j
`2
`~-
`
`
`
` ‘
`
`,
`
`> ‘V Worjldwide Networks
`
`235
`
`‘ is
`or V} rm
`
`CUVMB.BITNET.
`ff,'ware‘and,.documenta-
`A
`fx-om’a1l over the
`\
`‘ refurfi“ a response in the
`
`
`
`
`
`L
`
`L
`
`‘
`
`_
`
`15I*NET in the United States, Net~
`srae1,_and »Gu1fNet in the Persian
`
`A
`
`and thus pné CfAt_};1Veb oldest cooperative networks
`
`" i~'TQktida'?.e'Yt-ai 198§].j It isalso one of the
`i
`V
`V
`mgasuire; Vhav;i;;gA u—:.:265,000 users and
`—
`,,.
`—s
`'w'r} in
`i"ur‘e§1O.1;andVranging from
`
`
`__.,ersities. In fact,
`){ia:1yonVeV and any
`_
`n ’:’U§e r’s Network.”
`
`
`
`service.
`lyg assodafed network LIUCP
`
`L’
`
`‘
`
`V
`
`‘
`
`‘
`
`V 811». a new machine
`V
`unicate. with
`hé gérjéral /maps is
`fiete1jmmesa.cc:é:ss. There is also
`‘eac'~:h;V/Lhost pays for its own
`tr
`fi>"o'1-iiginatingat other
`L
`?'"l<u§eV‘of the net-
`;u§uaHy‘permitted, but
`‘
`}
`3? ¥d~i€flfo1fCe~« su3;h«
`directly.
`d-air
`tccmpfaints: anyone posting
`bout iffand will see
`‘p1ejth‘inV!<'tL1\:e o17igjnalpost~
`V
`.
`evan do fipa jé[s‘don’f,t-V generally like bad
`H .p
`‘ga on;?byLv/their COflleagl1éS_ and customers, this usually
`fcases, fpeople h_ave?’proiposLed putting pressure on the
`
`
`
`7
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`. Worldwide, Networks
`
`237
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`.
`
`n;‘*i€w‘1«i¢h
`the
`sting machine
`oneg.
`fa fis’.found in the
`onsists ofxthe ma-
`hes’: éosts; (The V
`hafp‘tefr13V.> ‘since
`Vse
`L
`V
`_
`
`
`
`,ey mdenvéf’ en twork, their administrators
`fthese ~os s- ea_ m ch 0 ;
`tend to take}-£1 sLtro:1g;intére‘st\in the state:of thevnetwork, The exact influence
`V of [the backbone i
`L
` ear,But~it*is,in_‘vo1vecl Vin/the organization of both the
`t» u
`‘
`>14:
`1:
`s3
`A
`?a_aba%:kbOLn,e'on each con-
`
`‘
`L
`I’
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`one q‘n,.the,?nétwork
`ey
`mt
`Us’e‘d~for:new users’ ‘of»the<network
`
`
`that are
`
` These are botlierribdéfated new,S_group s:;that is,’
`
`aVL‘1Vs e:r,pho3ts an article,
`
`'
`
`the asis of con-
`gy.
`of the net-
`
`c?al:iLe d énafLti;cIe.V: Its format, as given in
`V-19873 modeled ajfdter that of ARPANET
`
`
`
`
`
`
`» “ munjnayn-r. vfiwcdmp
`
`
`
`,
`
`
`
`
`
`mnetfi)r_..utzoo
`, ‘ii "
`
`
`
`
`
`
`%
`
`‘V r‘e dLjointly:with
`¥ ively, and thére
`a LI.jOu]tsideiV:of7 Europe or
`an Vthestructure of
`
`and software systems
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`3%:23:33..22.3%:3.3%..22%:.2:2:33%:23:33..22.3%:3.3%..22%:.2:2:3
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`,
`
`‘Distfibufidn: Gebgraplyy
`
`
`
`“'
`
`V
`
`'is<'rrgflected ~t):1r;$ughout the world. No explicit igatewaying is
`‘
`’ osta zirtiicléurtlhatiwill, travg-:I‘5~to~‘vafiouéparts of the world
`
`he
`L
`L
`"
`r9:?‘eeIIé1°;an,L~i»and
`
`‘when mi distribution is
`5fEI\K7[EjT,Ck10€S,-, Acciden—
`
`L
`
`~
`
`‘.
`
`VV
`
`‘
`
`L
`
`
`
`
`
`M . ‘V w,md;mu.;Networks
`
`241
`
`
`
`A
`
`egj
`
`/alvgoyithmz each hosfsends each article
`a
`V,hiwh;iyt*c:d xnutxiééges. 7I‘her‘g are»two»mechanisms
`each‘irivplyifigésfheadéijlinein each article as well as
`
`L
`
`Path: header is
`h[ich t‘he artic1e was just
`traveled from the
`
`
`‘a;nge’dV
`V
`is?,;$u}5pbsedi:to vbevuniquefthroughout
`V
`- usually acéomp1ish’ed.by having it include the host
`L
`L
`ame and;a;séquenceVnumberVfor ~art1‘c1.esgposted -from that host, or the time
`’
`V
`"
`“
`V
`L
`.V
`heaj;1erA11neLisVj1sedL«to constructa his-
`?
`!f‘e;:'e_ivje_:c1*o:n.ithaf host‘. If an article with
`isseen, ibis considered to be a
`
`
`
`‘
`
`ifcommunicates with and of the
`O se:\d"'to¢-each‘ of those hosts. If
`p» and distribution are not
`
`om raiher short period, by
`d ’f;';om ~the histQry- file. It
` i'fhlt:he Expires: header
`ff Lt iC1‘€5- 7
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`<;:fr:is to=be avoided by tuning
`host. ‘ Iris alsqpossible to reject
`
`specified‘ ago, on the
`ssgcjmg fxojm‘%,hosts‘,that have
`,fimf¢L1s‘1_Jsua1ly the same as
`"aj
`xpxra on : ec use’ expired‘ articles are also
`
`
`
`V
`
`;us
`
`g
`3151 .does < thjeé
`and; l1SENET'nféw§g_roi1psV‘
`bvax
`
`Vb‘etwéen Internet
`isknownfas uclwax on
`erInternet,
`It bursts’ di-
`
`
`yedgwfith BITNET
`maclfinvéwthathdqes
`
`10
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`_ :16 L 5, eat‘ D‘u1<e University
`£r<m1979s [Spafford 1988c].
`01;, ’’A goal of USENET
`[nity to join and benefit
`«ifyou. will.” The
`oremanss
`fU?a_S with the newly released
`Bell Laboratories.’ Access was limited to
`
`ilwhoecould legally have
`thee nl
`L
`aii notfbeen [thought of
`S_e{7ehfth Editieh Ld1's‘tribution—
`Vgrsaduateestudent at the
`‘first two hosts
`ddey:11by{198O; it was
`partitgipatedr ‘in the late 1979
`the
`shell script
`
`Mskzéax, and he,
`1;,
`g"-the fnehflork. Many
`‘ ahdesmailjreplies were
`e :recent example, in
`V
`I
`:own_bac1<bone‘host administra-
`itselfafovgery.
`
`q
`
`'
`
`
`
`.a we *
`it
`
`V
`
`’ ;’s'c}ffWa1‘e_~ packages,
`guse of the use of
`out ,the“network.
`
`V
`
`
`
`
`
`flVv‘IV‘f~'¢¢-‘):a‘*4“$7‘;3V\.%1:\:¥d’/A(l4Vm»V«<l¢,;.,...,-.».r,/.s«.>m:a/:
`
`V
`
`
`
`V11
`
`‘
`
`Lswarmwide Networks L
`
`243
`
`ntis‘ ‘gmany of. them organ-
`others.are~mo1fe\genera;1 than that. At
`1?
`_ s';prodi.\c,edVssaL series=—of_ convenfions of its partici-
`n‘t’-sh‘irts.s There are even feuds between newsgroups,
`V _
`V mug attempts of some soawomene participants to ban all
`'
`V
`_
`H “Lo1;;Lp}§this hasrLin¢:1uVded the tactic of creating
`am
`tyL'w0'm,e1fI.haa‘béent:reated*as-a moderated
`
`without mention of
`Essderiyed from the
`ysedetectable by a
`
` K
`
`
`
`
`
`
`1e,:
`everything gbur newsgroupsLwitLh fplay asthev
`
`7
`
`L
`"
`
`V
`
`1“:
`.0
`7
`\ that: was added
`V ;"A
`laLyL,'T ineaxjin
`
`12 ..
`
`
`
`Worldwide Networks
`
`V245
`
`
`
`V
`
`_¢}r5rmerv Tniecent years.
`sgroupsl, articles, and data
`L
`dricg1r;—;prOb1em with this
`
`
`[W8 50 ;. are:rewrites.to cope with growth of the
`ydonye in}/lja/flmtrthé Urfiversity of California at Berkeley (UCB)
`fuderit M‘a_rk'Hc“rton.and high school student*Matt Glickman.
`
`‘bIic._aS—B»n‘ews 2.1 in 1982. Mark
`‘\
`‘
`‘ first “ I
`" 4* d.tO.f1i’ "
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`blferrfafter a great deal
`ft
` fi*om-’t‘h‘e moderated‘ mailing lists that had
`V
`eri
`L
`V
`_ V
`7
`for many years. The first moderated newsgroup
`existed on re
`. was modrznnozmceg whichrwasryzan 1a1ternative,to ynetgeneral, a newsgroup
`
`V u.fo,r7mer
`V ténded arr.
`"nera dis" ssionsrthroughoujtthe network, but that
`
`K
`
`_
`
`\
`
`
`
`
`
`
`01, the last version
`/
`«element of a
`
`7‘as ‘released by
`Virginia,
`code that handled
`o'_d,.l’<yeyword on 15 Sep-
`86 Horton and Adams
`an hjewfsgroupsrwas not in
`urpfcsje13isL.to allow users to
`.
`,
`:,ap1ueal\Vareas appropriate td them, while
`sgroupsapprbpfiate to their general topics.
`. voliredxzhan ’
`Ttl/1e namgs of news
`_e' "amés bfull news»
`“
`V was the only
`main top level
`rcéted distribu-
`
`.
`
`W13
`
`
`
`
`
`1.
`
`_W0rIdzz)ide Networks
`
`2417
`
`V
`
`V héifipaign (UIUC) by
`"tad, nstarting in 1979 {Kol-
`5fPLATO1NGTES system.
`L1bliC‘at thelanuary 1982
`'Lareqo.?rigina11y spread
`different interchange
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`,
`
`e ahfe dy in:use onsqme links: some backbone hosts
`’
`”'th,e'ffe¢tive'L
`eds10f‘4OKbps or more.
`L
`"
`"
`6. measure, but numbers of
`W S; Have been estimated
`V
`:14’ These—are shown
`@9135 ‘sources [Frey
`thin recent years are
`are7,basjed, on" actual readers,
`
`r,7 the\A‘usual method of
`
`’NV w's°'Tr’ansfer Protocol
`
`reader Overload, old
`,
`L.
`
`an hjxgmand unevenly carried costs of
`10 p pagahoneeespee
`‘
`raised _e po‘ss,ibi;1Aity of using, theexperience gained in
`7
`lo
`.rep1a_ce'it;‘ ”’~I~’2heSe problemsehave been
`
`'
`
`45
`I
`
`K
`
`
`
`
`
`may ecL—nw<.{erat19h
`flaws’ 2.10.2
`
`_ ,awbone
`_
`
`1 —3y_ NE'I‘,"newsgroup
`vreoxfganx ation completed
`’
`‘
`’ Telébii Trai1b1a7.ers
`
`
`
`
`
`"V1 /
`
`.,
`
`'
`_'
`’
`12000
`
`1x,
`..
`3.;5>< ’
`
`
`
`i we éé.;.t1L1at the
`A.
`exceeded the capa-
`
`
`
`:'do*
`’
`‘
`V
`_ d,rapiC1€ly,fhOwe\'er, and with developments such
`as 80OMbyi halfiheight Winéhester drives for a [few thousand’ dollars
`< expectedfby 1989, »ar'1fIiBM‘PC-icould easily have enough space for the
`C’1\<13?F'e:¥It;:}{f§ffi_E. T
`I
`5%
`L
`»
`.
`.
`M
`
`
`
` 16
`
`
`
`
`
`§0
`
`0-.).,».,~.u.:.~.m).0.~.«.r0«~;..,,,,..‘~f'Jb./)<<d4
`
`
`
`
`»
`
`1
`
`0347
`362
`398
`
`",'Wat'lflz0ide Netwdrks
`
`249
`
`
`I V‘Sa’zr‘1— l Reader
`User
`‘
`ple
`est.
`est.
`
`V
`
`
`380,000
`7 53,000
`249
`420,000
`59,000
`296
`500,000
`75,000
`~*293_
`640,000
`95,000
`6320
`351 6- 70,000, 630,000
`320
`82,000
`660,000
`.028;
`88,000
`640,000
`3546 688,000
`590,000
`84,000;
`620,000
`79,000
`570,000
`90,000
`590,000
`90.000
`550,000
`06,000
`570,000
`.435 105,000
`550,000
`5.4525
`120,000
`530,000
`1476
`n;s,0000 640,000
`0497
`125,000
`720,000
`* 0,134,000
`810,000
`
`770,000
`730,000
`770,000
`0,840,000
`050,000
`,
`, 9910.000
`080,000
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`‘
`
`V1’,
`
`groups»§h5t‘had‘»n0n'zer0}raffic during the measmement interval.
`k5,Pex.:m‘0m’h:.
`,
`.
`0
`,
`*
`e:’:'hos¥ count."
`lmés _lnlthe,p'ast, 12 months.
`*l'me_s«in, the past 3 months‘
`«_
`esin the past 80 days.
`
`,
`«if:
`izth
`
`store 7news, there is
`’ “tfansfez:
`up ,with,ma.s$es,,of material
`
`
`
`written by
`nentedimterface c7alled«vnéws
`,‘<??3“I,i1’1€_?)3\,.‘}AlIi\?C1l1,1is?t\,andxeleasedl.in,1983.
`It is similar to the interface to the
`notesfifles software, ,andsi‘tT allows moving among several menus, can list
`
`17
`
`
`
`capéd ha
`
`’
`
`since
`
`V
`1;1FeL
`‘ -1,a‘k..et Lal;
`
`A
`
`K
`
`V
`
`g
`
`‘
`
`V
`
`‘.
`‘
`
`;
`
`‘
`
`V
`
`«V
`
`‘
`
`L
`
`‘
`
`[Dur-
`_o $urV1vLe;a’é
`ed in an Vupdatedy form as
`is:;dis<:ussed' elsewhere in
`
`
`
`
` ‘ef7*c£RNVfse¢tsonVm
`
`,,,,
`A 19.5
`iBibz»zogr;:phic Notes
`
`
`
`
`
`‘
`
`
`
`.VLn*fo,nVacma1 V
`nbaurn.:1988 and I’ar~
`
`L 3::
`
` E‘,rex1tiCe%fI‘ia11,-
`
`fechn L
`
`V
`
`iidgn‘-d,»"‘IP'NA,St. Louis,
`
`‘P1 kige x=[;GeLr;a¢rd,.LJ~M Lord, 13., and
`"‘
`‘twopki1\g:A
`5.~PP%»83V*9?—:
`
`.,V.91:~
`
`
`
`,~.—-,.,7—\»_..»<‘£r¥I.‘2¢‘7‘_h$
`
`
`
`tephen, 11i$;JameS»and Tnxscott.;Tcm,?‘USENE1‘~A
`80: Da
`,ani
`Network," Duke,‘Uni've:si‘t ; Durham, NC, Summer
`T
`G4ex_\era1_"Acce'ss
`T980“.
`'I'his.is a slightly modifi'ed'copy‘oi—ithe or_igina_ flyer of ]anuary'1980.
`:
`,
`
`r:De‘x:nco"1988.' Dér7nco,».,
`‘ Person cemmunicafidns, A—ggu§t'1988,
`',
`.\__‘
`‘
`er
`0
`
`
`
`
`
`
`'
`
`«
`
`~
`
`1,9’
`
`
`
` ,
`
`
`
`
`
`Worldwide Networks
`
`2'73
`
`
`”USENET: Death by
`ey J¥d€hi§,",Ric1<;
`’ ,l;lNIX~‘REVJE«W) V91». 5, no. 8, pp. 55 +60, August 1987.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`’ and Hartman, '1‘. C., "Evolution of
`ms
`umal, vol; .18,.no. 1, p. 111, 1979.
`‘ om utfer ~Networking, Report of
`En’ergy,’Washingto_n, DC,
`
`'
`
`
`
`
`‘
`
`fiw-‘:l%r'Be1lovin,‘ Steven M.,
`“ o‘1c1rjes.ses,/" Proceedings of the
`[mg ‘1986), pp. 126- 141,
`V
`I
`V
`of fhfé Summer 1983
`
`71) V1‘
`‘
`June 1984), pp. 368-372,
`
`
`7H0Ijt'Dh/198
` ‘»’1n§e;change Format Standard;
`:1
`for Comments, February 1986.
`1*. Van gg dams~,,Rick, ”Standard for Inter-
`RFC1_()36;"
`Workingcroup Requests
`
`sagg
`
`
`
`
`{fort Europe,” Nature, vol.
`Transfer Pro-
`
` ‘
`
`(3
`Sep,t¢mfb9I\1983.
`‘
`,
`o
`‘c_tiufgs}" IFNA, St. Louis, MO,
`, _Ne¢"i‘E1e‘c:tfOnic"Mail F'rotoco1,” IFNA, St.
`
` :Kantcx?,‘ Brian—,-oryxd —I.apsley, Phil, ”Network News
`RFC977,” iARPANET¢Working Group Requests for Comments,
`‘}k.ADiré¢ta;y,,vg1; i, no. 2, Spring 1986.
`
`.4§)0i;andV‘rRFC822; RFC987,” ARPANET
`em?»-Iurieoo1986: I “
`L
`L
`V
`7 (Maj)pk1g;between X.400 and RFC-
`oes‘
`fooor,Comments, September
`
`
`
`jr,chf198,9.».
`_
`'7 Inside Autono-
`V, gs,— g‘
`
`ne onseeifhejlnteroperubility Report,
`uting Eriviroximents, Mountain View,
`
`
`
`20
`
`
`
`ASh<?é5s79ri
`‘urtiflatidizs,
`
`Peter?
`‘
`'\
`‘ E11 ' eetifig
`
`V
`
`”¥~’Spt1'”ng
`
`‘V
`
`‘
`
`?are:F—1'Vowing (or
`pp.'6-'_8,,-ACM srcsorrr.
`
`
`
`Worldwide Networks
`
`275
`
`
`
`Thompson, K., The UNIX Time-
`V éisfl Ritchié; D
`¢?1Ch(1ict1I»,]auz:naZ;'_'vo1. 57, no. 6, part 2,
`‘
`'
`’
`’
`*
`*
`\
`i
`a Sysimli
`, Auggst 1978.. «This version describes Seventh Edition
`
`
`
`
`,sA:htc$
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`V
`
`_
`
`ctiyef‘New§sgrQups (Updated: 2~Apri1
`n_p1mct.new_uStrS,,USENET, 3 April 1988.
`V
`_;
`_
`_
`,
`_ _fie,—‘..",USEN£T Softwatei __History and Sources
`’
`'
`min,"nezus.a,n'§zou'ncemewusers, USENET, 3
`
` xie, "1UsI~:NET,'f {Err Prcibéeiiings, IETF, Washington,
`
`"ACcessibi Mafuing Lists (Updated: 14
`'
`'
`,
`T; 17 April 1988.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`,
`
`k
`
`on,"B;er|<,eley;-C._’,1987.
`_
`,
`j
`,
`_ erswltidrton, Karen, and Horton, Mark,
`orton198S; - Su,
`_‘
`‘
`W
`Sumnie, _
`!'s§gjtus,of‘thé’USENIX UUCP1Project,”'Proceedings of the Winter 1985 USENIX
`\
`’
`(Dallas, T_e:;as, ,2,3-. ,
`,
`1985), _p.1,83,,USENIX Association,
`
`
`
`,
`
`’netwc;:rl§ community we mezashite),”
`its,
`p; %,22,j1.986;‘_Transcript-[of a panel discussion, in
`. ,
`ry 1988.
`V
`,_gP}jaceed1'ngs 0f the Summer
`f—_-I4 Iune I985), pp. 79-80,
`;
`V
`~
`,
`‘ CA,,19a5.,
`
`iiren, ’f«P3,-oject Starga¢e,?‘ EUlIG»‘5pring '86 Conference
`W13}? 21
`-2f4"Apr:z'l':'1986),‘Euiropégin UNIX systems User
`
`
`
`
`
`.
`.,
`gputez,vo1;;17,-no.:6;}PP:-8-1
`
`., »“PHYSi"iet
`/,HBPnet/NRAO/SPAN-
`»
`V
`J3_ECn<;tjMai1,?? Data, orijiiiiunication and Network Ser-
`Iifornia at Berkélf.§y,:14:Sept§ixiberV1987.
`‘and SPAN,” infa-
`“
`"I
`‘
`._
`’
`
`
`
`‘