Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 39 Filed 05/29/12 Page 1 of 10
`
`
`
`
`
`IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
`FOR THE DISTRICT OF VERMONT
`
`Arnouse Digital Devices Corp.
`
`Plaintiff,
`
`v.
`
`Motorola Mobility, Inc.
`
`Defendant.
`
`
`Civil Action No.: 5:11-cv-155-CR
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`JOINT CLAIM CONSTRUCTION AND PREHEARING STATEMENT
`
`Pursuant to the partially stipulated Markman scheduling order (D.I. 24), Plaintiff Arnouse
`
`Digital Devices, Corp. (“Arnouse”) and Defendant Motorola Mobility, Inc. (“MMI”) submit the
`
`following Joint Claim Construction and Prehearing Statement.
`
`
`
`
`US2008 3521033.1
`
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1013 - Page 1
`
`

`

`
`
`Disputed Claims with
`Disputed Terms
`Highlighted within U.S.
`Patent No. 7,516,484
`
`Claim 1:
`Preamble of claim 1
`
`Claim 1:
`A reader configured to interact
`with a portable computer
`without input and output means
`for interacting directly
`therewith, the reader comprising:
`
`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 39 Filed 05/29/12 Page 2 of 10
`
`MMI’s Construction
`
`Arnouse’s Construction
`
`MMI’s Intrinsic
`Evidence
`
`Arnouse’s Intrinsic
`Evidence
`
`Court’s Construction
`
`The preamble of claim 1 is
`limiting
`
`
`
`The preamble of claim 1 is
`limiting, and claim 1 is
`directed to a reader, not
`the combination of a
`reader and a portable
`computer.
`
`An electronic device that is
`designed to be connected to a
`portable computer that by itself is
`not capable of receiving
`information from or providing
`information to a user because it
`lacks input and output means, as
`those terms are defined below. In
`other words, the portable
`computer needs the reader for the
`user to interact with the computer.
`
`An electronic device that is
`designed to be connected to a
`portable computer, wherein the
`portable computer lacks input and
`output means, as those terms are
`defined below, but includes a
`processor, a memory, and an
`operating system. In other words,
`the portable computer needs the
`reader for the user to interact with
`the programs, hardware, and user
`information of the portable
`computer.
`
`Office Action mailed January
`13, 2009.
`
`Response to Office Action
`mailed January 13, 2009, pg. 9.
`
`‘484 patent, Abstract.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 3, ll. 14-16.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 3, ll. 54-62.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 4, ll. 44-48.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 4-21.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 22-31.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 52-58.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 33-35.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 37-38.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 45-57.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Any intrinsic evidence relied
`upon by MMI and
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 4-6
`
`‘484 patent, col. 3, ll. 10-11
`
`‘484 patent, col. 4, ll. 66 to
`col.5, ll. 50
`
`‘484 patent, col. 5, ll. 63 to
`col.6, ll. 8
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 22-31
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 36-45
`
`‘484 patent, col. 5, ll. 66 to col.
`6, ll. 3
`
`
`
`
`
`
`US2008 3521033.1
`
`
`1
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1013 - Page 2
`
`

`

`
`
`Disputed Claims with
`Disputed Terms
`Highlighted within U.S.
`Patent No. 7,516,484
`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 39 Filed 05/29/12 Page 3 of 10
`
`MMI’s Construction
`
`Arnouse’s Construction
`
`MMI’s Intrinsic
`Evidence
`
`Arnouse’s Intrinsic
`Evidence
`
`Court’s Construction
`
`Claim 1:
`A reader configured to interact
`with a portable computer without
`input and output means for
`interacting directly therewith, the
`reader comprising
`
`Any component that allows a
`portable computer to receive
`information from or provide
`information to a user, including
`but not limited to, a keyboard,
`keypad, button, display, touch
`screen, speaker, webcam,
`microphone, or headphone jack.
`
`
` Any component that allows a
`portable computer to interact
`directly with the programs,
`hardware, and user information of
`the portable computer by
`receiving information from or
`providing information to a user,
`including but not limited to, a
`keyboard, keypad, button, display,
`touch screen, speaker, webcam,
`microphone, or headphone jack.
`
`
`
`
`US2008 3521033.1
`
`
`2
`
`
`
`Any intrinsic evidence relied
`upon by MMI and
`
`‘484 patent, col. 4, ll. 66 to
`col.5, ll. 50
`
`‘484 patent, col. 5, ll. 63 to col.
`6, ll 8
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 22 -28
`
`
`
`‘484 patent, col. 9, ll. 11-21.
`
`‘484 patent, claim 3.
`
`‘484 patent, claim 19.
`Office Action mailed January
`13, 2009.
`
`Response to Office Action
`mailed January 13, 2009, pg. 9.
`
`‘484 patent, Abstract.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 3, ll. 14-16.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 3, ll. 54-62.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 4, ll. 44-48.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 4-21.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 22-31.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 52-58.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 33-35.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 37-38.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 45-57.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 9, ll. 11-21.
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1013 - Page 3
`
`

`

`
`
`Disputed Claims with
`Disputed Terms
`Highlighted within U.S.
`Patent No. 7,516,484
`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 39 Filed 05/29/12 Page 4 of 10
`
`MMI’s Construction
`
`Arnouse’s Construction
`
`MMI’s Intrinsic
`Evidence
`
`Arnouse’s Intrinsic
`Evidence
`
`Court’s Construction
`
`Claim 1: a housing that is at least
`one of an input or an output
`device; and.
`
`
`Any component that allows the
`reader to receive information from
`or provide information to a user,
`including but not limited to, a
`keyboard, keypad, button,
`display, touch screen, speaker,
`webcam, microphone, or
`headphone jack.
`
` Any component that allows the
`reader to interact directly with the
`programs, hardware, and user
`information of the portable
`computer by receiving
`information from or providing
`information to a user, including
`but not limited to, a keyboard,
`keypad, a display, touch screen,
`speaker, webcam, microphone, or
`headphone jack.
`
`Claim 1: wherein the reader is
`configured to be a non-
`functioning shell when not
`connected to the portable
`
`non-working device
`
` means that the reader can access
`the programs, hardware, and user
`information stored on the portable
`
`3
`
`
`
`
`US2008 3521033.1
`
`
`
`‘484 patent, claim 3.
`
`‘484 patent, claim 19.
`
`‘484 patent, Abstract.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 3, ll. 14-16.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 3, ll. 54-62.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 4, ll. 44-48.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 4-21.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 22-31.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 52-58.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 33-35.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 37-38.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 45-57.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 9, ll. 11-21.
`
`‘484 patent, claim 3.
`
`‘484 patent, claim 19.
`‘484 patent, Abstract.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 1, ll. 48-67.
`
`
`Any intrinsic evidence relied
`upon by MMI and
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 6-8
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll.22-28
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 36-45
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Any intrinsic evidence relied
`upon by MMI and
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 10-12
`
`
`
`
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1013 - Page 4
`
`

`

`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 39 Filed 05/29/12 Page 5 of 10
`
`MMI’s Construction
`
`Arnouse’s Construction
`
`MMI’s Intrinsic
`Evidence
`
`Arnouse’s Intrinsic
`Evidence
`
`Court’s Construction
`
`computer when connected thereto,
`and ceases to function and does
`not retain any user information
`when not connected to the
`portable computer.
`
`wherein the reader is designed to
`operate with only a portable
`computer that does not have input
`and output means. In other words,
`the portable computer needs the
`reader for the user to interact with
`the computer.
`
`means that the reader has a non-
`universal design that limits the
`types of portable computers that
`may be used with the reader
`
`
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 10-21.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 7-24.
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 36-45.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 46-58.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 8, l. 66 – col.
`9, l. 4.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 9, ll. 9-11.
`
`Third Revised Accelerated
`Examination Support
`Document, pg. 6.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 1, ll. 40-44.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 16-21.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 38-42.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 46-50.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 8, ll. 7-8.
`
`No construction needed.
`
`
` A portable computer is a readily
`mobile device that includes a
`processor, storage, an operating
`system, and a connector.
`
`
`
`4
`
`
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 7-45
`
`
`
`
`Any intrinsic evidence relied
`upon by MMI and
`
` ‘484 patent, col.5, ll. 45-62
`
`
`
` U.S. Provisional Application
`No. 61/028,373 at ¶8.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 3, ll. 51-53
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 22-31
`
`
`
`
`
`Any intrinsic evidence relied
`upon by MMI and
`
`‘484 patent, col. 3, ll. 10-11
`
`‘484 patent, col. 4, ll. 66 to
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Disputed Claims with
`Disputed Terms
`Highlighted within U.S.
`Patent No. 7,516,484
`
`computer, and.
`
`Claim 15: wherein the reader is
`configured to be a non-
`functioning shell when not
`connected to the portable
`computer.
`
`Claim 1:
`wherein the readers are
`configured so that they will not
`operate with a computer other
`than a portable computer of the
`system
`
`
`Claim 15:
`wherein the readers are
`configured so that they will not
`operate with a computer other
`than a portable computer of the
`system
`
`Claim 15:
`at least one portable computer,
`each comprising: storage; and at
`least one connector for connecting
`to at least one reader;
`
`
`
`
`US2008 3521033.1
`
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1013 - Page 5
`
`

`

`
`
`Disputed Claims with
`Disputed Terms
`Highlighted within U.S.
`Patent No. 7,516,484
`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 39 Filed 05/29/12 Page 6 of 10
`
`MMI’s Construction
`
`Arnouse’s Construction
`
`MMI’s Intrinsic
`Evidence
`
`Arnouse’s Intrinsic
`Evidence
`
`Court’s Construction
`
`Claim 15:
`at least one reader, each
`comprising: an input device; an
`output device; and a connector for
`connecting to the at least one
`portable computer,
`
`Any component that allows the
`reader to receive information from
`a user, including but not limited
`to, a keyboard, keypad, button,
`touch screen, webcam, or
`microphone.
`
`Anything that allows the reader to
`interact directly with the
`programs, hardware, and user
`information of the portable
`computer by receiving
`information from a user, including
`but not limited to, a keyboard,
`keypad, touch screen, webcam, or
`microphone.
`
`Claim 15:
`at least one reader, each
`comprising: an input device; an
`
`Any component that allows the
`reader to provide information to a
`user, including but not limited to,
`
` Anything that allows the reader to
`interact directly with the
`
`5
`
`
`
`
`US2008 3521033.1
`
`
`col.5, ll. 50
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Any intrinsic evidence relied
`upon by MMI and
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 6-8
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 22-28
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 36-45
`
`
`
`Any intrinsic evidence relied
`upon by MMI and
`
`‘484 patent, Abstract.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 3, ll. 14-16.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 3, ll. 54-62.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 4, ll. 44-48.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 4-21.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 22-31.
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 52-58.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 33-35.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 37-38.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 45-57.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 9, ll. 11-21.
`
`‘484 patent, claim 3.
`
`‘484 patent, claim 19.
`‘484 patent, Abstract.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 3, ll. 14-16.
`
`
`
`
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1013 - Page 6
`
`

`

`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 39 Filed 05/29/12 Page 7 of 10
`
`MMI’s Construction
`
`Arnouse’s Construction
`
`MMI’s Intrinsic
`Evidence
`
`Arnouse’s Intrinsic
`Evidence
`
`Court’s Construction
`
`
`
`Disputed Claims with
`Disputed Terms
`Highlighted within U.S.
`Patent No. 7,516,484
`
`output device; and a connector
`for connecting to the at least one
`portable computer,
`
`a display, touch screen, speaker,
`or headphone jack.
`
`programs, hardware, and user
`information of the portable
`computer by providing
`information to a user, including
`but not limited to, a display, touch
`screen, speaker, or headphone
`jack.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 6-8
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 22-28
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 36-45
`
`
`
`Any intrinsic evidence relied
`upon by MMI and
`
`‘484 patent, col. 5, ll. 66 to
`col.6, ll. 3
`
`
`
`
`
`
`‘484 patent, col. 3, ll. 54-62.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 4, ll. 44-48.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 4-21.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 22-31.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 52-58.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 33-35.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 37-38.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 45-57.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 9, ll. 11-21.
`
`‘484 patent, claim 3.
`
`‘484 patent, claim 19.
`Office Action mailed January
`13, 2009.
`
`Response to Office Action
`mailed January 13, 2009, pg. 9.
`
`‘484 patent, Abstract.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 3, ll. 14-16
`
`‘484 patent, col. 3, ll. 54-62.
`
`Claim 15:
`wherein the portable computer
`excludes means for a user to
`interact directly with the
`portable computer
`
`
`By itself the portable computer
`cannot provide information to a
`user or receive information from a
`user. In other words, the portable
`computer needs the reader for the
`user to interact with the computer.
`
`
` By itself the portable computer
`cannot provide information to a
`user or receive information from a
`user. In other words, the portable
`computer needs the reader for the
`user to interact with the programs,
`hardware, and user information of
`the portable computer.
`
`6
`
`
`
`
`US2008 3521033.1
`
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1013 - Page 7
`
`

`

`
`
`Disputed Claims with
`Disputed Terms
`Highlighted within U.S.
`Patent No. 7,516,484
`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 39 Filed 05/29/12 Page 8 of 10
`
`MMI’s Construction
`
`Arnouse’s Construction
`
`MMI’s Intrinsic
`Evidence
`
`Arnouse’s Intrinsic
`Evidence
`
`Court’s Construction
`
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 4-21.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 22-31.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 52-58.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 33-35.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 37-38.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 45-57.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 9, ll. 11-21.
`
`‘484 patent, claim 3.
`
`‘484 patent, claim 19.
`‘484 patent, Abstract.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 1. ll. 64-67.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 3, ll. 54-65.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 4-21.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 22-31.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 17-24.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 7, ll. 33-50.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 9, ll. 11-21.
`
`Any intrinsic evidence relied
`upon by MMI and
`
`‘484 patent, col. 6, ll. 13-16
`
`
`
`
`
`Claim 15:
`wherein the reader and
`portable computer are
`configured to become a fully
`functioning computer when
`connected,
`
`The reader and portable computer
`are designed so that, when they
`are connected, the combination
`has the following components: a
`memory, an input device, an
`output device, a processor, and an
`operating system; neither the
`reader nor the portable computer
`has all of those components by
`itself.
`
` The reader and portable computer
`are designed so that, when they
`are connected, the combination
`has the following components: a
`storage, an input device, an output
`device, a processor, an operating
`system, and complementary
`connectors.
`
`
`
`
`US2008 3521033.1
`
`
`7
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1013 - Page 8
`
`

`

`
`
`Disputed Claims with
`Disputed Terms
`Highlighted within U.S.
`Patent No. 7,516,484
`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 39 Filed 05/29/12 Page 9 of 10
`
`MMI’s Construction
`
`Arnouse’s Construction
`
`MMI’s Intrinsic
`Evidence
`
`Arnouse’s Intrinsic
`Evidence
`
`Court’s Construction
`
`
`‘484 patent, col. 9, ll. 43-45.
`
`‘484 patent, col. 11, ll. 60-66.
`
`‘484 patent, claim 3.
`
`
`
`
`US2008 3521033.1
`
`
`8
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1013 - Page 9
`
`

`

`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 39 Filed 05/29/12 Page 10 of 10
`
`
`
`
`
`
`US2008 3521033.1
`
`
`
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1013 - Page 10
`
`