Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-4 Filed 01/17/12 Page 3 of 5
`
`the CPU, memory, and applications provided by the Atrix smartphone. The Atrix Lapdock
`
`keyboard, touchpad, and other peripheral devices allow for manipulation and input to the
`
`software and hardware of the Atrix smartphone while the Atrix Lapdock screen and speakers
`
`provide the output. Additionally, the Atrix smartphone's screen goes dark and is no longer
`
`producing an output to the user and is not capable of receiving user input through the touch
`
`screen interface.
`
`10. Working with electrical engineers under my direct supervision, we disabled the
`
`touch screen on the Atrix smartphone by removing the battery and the smartphone housing,
`
`identifying and disconnecting the display connection, and replacing the housing and the battery.
`
`Once the touch screen was disabled, the screen of the Atrix smartphone went black and lacked
`
`any ability to receive input or provide output via the touch screen, its former touch keyboard,
`
`microphone, speakers, or buttons.
`
`11.
`
`Then, with the Atrix smartphone's touch screen disabled, we docked the Atrix
`
`smartphone with the Atrix Lapdock in accordance with the directions provided with the Atrix
`
`Lapdock. Once docked to the Atrix Lapdock, the Atrix Lapdock, which previously had been a
`
`non-functioning shell, then functioned to provide direct user interaction with the Atrix
`
`smartphone's hardware and software through manipulation of the keys on the Atrix Lapdock's
`
`keyboard, mouse, screen, microphone, and speakers. All the while, the disabled screen of the
`
`Atrix smartphone itself remained black and accordingly continued to lack input and output
`
`means. Thus, the Atrix Lapdock is capable of working with an Atrix smartphone that has its
`
`input and output means disabled such that the input and output means of the Atrix smartphone
`
`are not available either when connected or not connected to the Atrix Lapdock.
`
`3
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 26
`
`

`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-4 Filed 01/17/12 Page 4 of 5
`
`12.
`
`In addition, according to Motorola, eleven Motorola smartphones include an
`
`integrated Linux-based "Webtop App" and are designed to be used with one or more Motorola
`
`Lapdocks. See Declaration of McCabe, Exhibit D at ~ 7. The Webtop App is a secondary
`
`operating system that is initiated upon connecting the smartphone to a Lapdock. Id. at ~~ 5-6.
`
`Prior to connecting to a Lapdock, the smartphones operating as a standalone devices operate
`
`using the "Android" operating system (O/S), while the Webtop App is not available. See id.
`
`("The webtop application is always present on the device but is only available when you insert
`
`the device into a dock with a dedicated display (such as the lapdock.)"). For example,
`
`Motorola's Atrix 4G and DROID BIONIC smartphones each included versions of the Android
`
`DIS and both work with the Atrix Lapdock. See Exhibits E, F, and G. However, when these
`
`smartphones connected to a Motorola Lapdock with its display screen opened, the smartphones
`
`automatically cease to use the Android O/S and instead begin working as computers through the
`
`Webtop App. See Declaration of McCabe, Exhibit D at ~~ 5-6 ("Note that with the lapdock, the
`
`webtop application will launch automatically ifthe display is open."). When the Webtop
`
`application is launched in a Lapdock, the smartphones go into sleep mode and do not display the
`
`mobile phone's device's applications or any additional applications unique to the Webtop, such
`
`as the Firefox® web-browser. See, e.g., Exhibit C (phone is shown dark while Lapdock is
`
`operational). However, in Webtop mode, the software and applications on the smartphones are
`
`accessible via the input and output means provided with a Lapdock or high definition multi(cid:173)
`
`media dock.
`
`13.
`
`The foregoing technical descriptions of how Motorola's Atrix and DROID
`
`BIONIC smartphones lack input and output means once docked to an Atrix Lapdock except
`
`through a Lapdock itself is supported by Motorola's advertising and operating instructions.
`
`4
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 27
`
`

`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-4 Filed 01/17/12 Page 5 of 5
`
`Attached as Exhibit H is a page from Motorola's website describing "How to use the Lapdock
`
`100." It states that, once docked, "[y]our phone will automatically go to Webtop mode and your
`
`phone will appear to go into sleep mode."
`
`14.
`
`Further, in the Motorola advertisement for the Smartphone and Lapdock
`
`(Exhibit C), Motorola shows the Atrix 4G Smartphone screen as blank when docked to the
`
`operating Lapdock.
`
`15.
`
`In the advertisement attached as Exhibit I, Motorola states that its Motorola
`
`Lapdock "only comes to life when you dock your Smartphone."
`
`16.
`
`Based on my background and experience as an electrical engineer and familiarity
`
`with smartphones and their operating systems, the foregoing referenced sources, and the test I
`
`supervised as described in paragraphs 10 and 11, it appears as a matter of fact that Motorola's
`
`Lapdocks are configured to work with Motorola smartphones that have their input and output
`
`means disabled. It also appears as a matter of fact that the Motorola smartphones, whose input
`
`and output means are functional when unconnected to the Lapdock, lack input and output means
`
`once the smartphones are docked to the Lapdock.
`
`17.
`
`Further, ifnot established as an irrefutable fact, for the foregoing reasons it is my
`
`opinion to a reasonable degree of scientific certainty that the Motorola Lapdocks are configured
`
`to work with Motorola smartphones that lack input/output means.
`
`Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 1746, I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and
`correct.
`
`Dated: January 17, 2012
`
`4802934.6
`
`By:
`
`/s/ Daniel Gallic
`Daniel Gallic
`
`5
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 28
`
`

`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-5 Filed 01/17/12 Page 1 of 5
`
`EXHIBIT A
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 29
`
`

`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-5 Filed 01/17/12 Page 2 of 5
`
`Daniel Gallic, PP
`44 Hillcrest Rd.
`Warren, NJ 07059
`908-507-0156
`the~allics@yahoo.com
`
`Education
`
`BS in Applied Materials Engineering, Rutgers University, New Brunswick, NJ
`Minor: Electrical Engineering
`Licensed Professional Planner, New Jersey
`
`'90
`
`Qualifications
`
`CEO and Chairman ofseveral LLC's and Incorporation's over the last 20 years
`Full knowledge of manufacturing processes, analytics and efficiency tools
`Deep, first hand knowledge, of software structures and architectures
`In-depth understanding and experience in high tech products.
`Experienced in marketing and leveraging unearned media.
`Experienced in controlling multimillion dollar budgets.
`
`Experience
`
`Arnouse Digital Device, Corp, Delaware
`Chief Operating Officer
`
`Global Mobile Video, Inc.
`Managing Partner, CEO
`
`2010 - present
`
`2009 - present
`
`• Developed live streaming video resources to mobile devices.
`• Created products for US Army under several R&D contracts.
`• Managed groups of software engineer, architects and project managers.
`• Created authenticated, encrypted live video streaming solutions for Android OS
`• Created authenticated, encrypted live video streaming solutions for PC based computers.
`• Integrated Video/Audio I/O boards to trans code on-the-fly video IP streams.
`• Acquired several R&D contracts with CERDEC at CECOM, Fort Monmouth.
`
`Solar Development Group, LLC, Hawthorne, New Jersey
`Partner
`
`2008 - 2009
`
`• Responsible for new client acquisition.
`• Analyzed the best possible solutions to reduce dependency on electrical needs of businesses.
`• Created compelling data for solar investment for warehouses with large footprints.
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 30
`
`

`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-5 Filed 01/17/12 Page 3 of 5
`
`• Analyzed the various alternative energy options to create options for green conscience building
`owners.
`
`Warren HOV Consulting, LLC, Warren, New Jersey
`Partner
`
`1997 - present
`
`• Developed hundreds of acres of residential developments.
`• Expert in wetlands delineation and working within DEP regulations to maximize developments.
`• Consulted in overall planning of several multimillion dollar redevelopments for townships.
`• Expert in planning "green" real estate developments with zero-carbon footprints.
`• Expert in COAH tax and business impacts on local communities.
`• Responsible for farming hundred of acres over the last 13 years.
`
`Academy Publishing, LLC
`Managing Partner, CEO
`
`2007 - 2010
`
`• Responsible for the publication of three monthly newspapers with circulation of 40,000
`• Increased sale from $5,500/month to over $37,000/month
`• Lowered overhead by over 50% to reduce ad costs and increase margins.
`• Managed a sales force and created monthly incentives for our customers.
`• Managed writing staff and kept articles fresh and exciting.
`• Responsible for all newspaper layout and ads
`• Return a 50% profit increase for investors on a year over year basis.
`
`Gallic Consulting, SP
`Marketing and Public Relations Director, CEO
`
`1995 - 2008
`
`• Responsible for multimillion dollar media strategies
`• Managed between 6 and 600 volunteers each election cycle
`• Created and produced TV, Mail and Radio spots.
`• Responsible for all messaging for hundreds of political campaigns
`• Obtained the highest win percentage in New Jersey over the last ten years.
`
`Tymarc, Inc
`COO
`
`1991-1995
`
`• Designed and build automated computer controlled machines to reduce labor expense.
`• Managed over 1000 employees.
`• Maintained and increased profit margins on all product lines.
`• Developed product lines for children furniture.
`• Responsible for procuring large quantities of hardwood, plywood and other supplies.
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 31
`
`

`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-5 Filed 01/17/12 Page 4 of 5
`
`L'Oreal
`Packaging Engineer, Executive Training
`
`1988-1991
`
`• Member ofthe executive training program and met with the COO monthly.
`• Created a digital graphic tool to reconcile QA data with engineering and manufacturing dept.
`• Designed the L'Oreal designer fragrance division line of packaging.
`
`Other Talents, Activities and Interest:
`
`Licensed New Jersey Professional Planner
`Warren Township Planning Board, I 999-present (Chairman, 200 I - 2006)
`Warren Township Open Space Committee (1997-1999)
`Somerset County Board of Mental Health, 1997-2000
`Knights of Columbus, 1999 - present (currently GK Council #14675, Watchung, NJ)
`Warren Township Environmental Commission (2001-2007)
`Warren Township Open Space committee (1996 - 1999)
`Expert knowledge of programming languages: PHP, MySql, AJAX, HTML, and Javascript
`Expert knowledge of Microsoft Excel, Word and Paradox
`Expert knowledge ofAdobe TlIustrator, InDesign, Photoshop
`Intermediate programming level in Adobe Flash
`Knowledge ofDNS control, Apache 4.0, CentOS and LINUX
`
`References
`
`Vic Sordillo, Mayor
`Warren Township
`
`Bill Palatucci, Esq.
`
`Joe Pennacchio
`New Jersey State Senator
`
`Peter Gallic, CFO
`Absolute Life Solutions
`
`Stanely Fong
`Division Chief, Fort Monmouth
`
`Contact information and additional references available upon request.
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 32
`
`

`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-5 Filed 01/17/12 Page 5 of 5
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 33
`
`

`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-6 Filed 01/17/12 Page 1 of 7
`
`EXHIBITB
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 34
`
`

`
`Motorola ATRIXTM - dual-core phone - Android smartphone - Tech Specs - Motorola Mobility, I...
`
`http://www.lOOtorola.comiConswrers/XZ-ENIConswrer-Products-and-Services/Mobile-Phones/...
`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-6 Filed 01/17/12 Page 2 of 7
`
`.". ANDROID OPERATING
`
`SYSTEM
`Android 2.2 (FroYo)
`
`CANDY BAR
`
`MULTIPLE NETWORKS
`WCDMA 850/900
`11900/2100, GSM 850/900
`11800/1900, HSDPA 14.4
`Iv1bps (Category 10), HSUPA
`2.0 Mbps, eCorT'4lass/aGPS , Bluetooth
`Class 2, Version 2.1 +EDR,
`802.11 b/802.11 g/802.11 a/802. 11 n
`
`ESSAGIN
`
`EMAlL2
`Corporate Sync, Google Mail,
`POP3/1MAP (embedded), Corporate
`Directory Lookup (GAL)
`
`MULTIMEDIA MESSAGING (MMS)2
`
`PREDICTIVE TEXT
`Android and S\l\lYpe
`
`TEXT MESSAGING (SMS)2
`Yes
`
`INSTANT MESSAGING (IM)2
`Subject to availability: Windows®
`
`MOTOROLA ATRIX'M
`
`-"E
`
`•
`
`j
`
`..
`
`I
`
`,
`
`TALK TIME (CONTINUOUS)1
`WCDMA up to 540 min.; GSM up to 530
`min.
`
`BATIERYTYPE
`1930 mAh Li Ion Polymer
`STANDBY TIME1
`WCDMA up to 350 hrs.; GSM up to 400
`hrs.
`
`10f6
`
`12/29/2011 4:54 PM
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 35
`
`

`
`Motorola ATRIXTM - dual-core phone - Android smartphone - Tech Specs - Motorola Mobility, 1...
`
`http://www.motorola.com/Consumers/XZ-EN/Consumer-Products-and-Services/Mobile-Phones/...
`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-6 Filed 01/17/12 Page 3 of 7
`
`Messenger, Yahoo!® Messenger and
`Google Talk™
`
`VOICE MAIL
`Yes
`
`DLNA (DIGITAL LIVING NETWORK
`ALLIANCE)
`Stream, store and share content with
`compatible devices around the home like
`HDTVs, game consoles and PCs
`
`GPS AND LOCATION SERVICES5
`eCompass, aGPS (assisted) with Google
`Maps TM, Google Latitude TM, Google Maps
`Street View, eCompass
`
`HEADSET JACK
`3.5 mm
`
`DIGITAL ZOOM
`Yes
`
`FLASH
`LED
`
`FOCUS
`Automatic
`
`MEGAPIXELS
`5 MP
`
`WEB CAM
`Front and rear-facing web camera
`
`SYNCHRONISATION
`Corporate Sync, BOTA, OMA OM
`
`WIFI
`80211 a,b,g,n
`
`BLUETOOTH® TECHNOLOGY!
`Stereo Bluetooth® technology 2.1 +EOR
`(supports profiles A20P 1.2, AVRCP, HFP
`15AG, HID 1.0 Host, HSP 1.0, OPP,
`PBAP PSE)
`
`3G MOBILE HOTSPOT
`Be a mobile hot spot for up to 5 other
`WiFi-enabled devices
`
`CONNECTOR TYPE
`Micro USB
`
`DATA TRANSMISSION RATE4
`USB 2 0 (High Speed)
`
`20f6
`
`12/29/20] I 4:54 PM
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 36
`
`

`
`t\ilolorola ATRIArr~1 - dual-core phone - Android smarlphone - Tech Specs - Motoro!<I Mobility, J...
`
`hnp://www.01Olorola.comIConsLUners/XZ-ENfConsLUner-Products-and-$ervices/MobiJe-Phones/...
`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-6 Filed 01/17/12 Page 4 of 7
`
`OISE REDUCTION
`Yes
`
`PHONE BOOK
`MOTOBLUR synchs p"rsol1al and work
`contacts 3110 connected socI31 ne:!vllorks
`
`SPEED DIAL
`QUickslore Private IDs. QUlcl\Slore Pnone
`Book Group IDs, SDG Lists
`
`BRACALL
`
`OICE DIALLING
`VR N"IT-== dialing VR Dlgil dialing
`
`AIT AND PAUSE DIALLING
`
`EB BROWSER
`Anoroid H1ML NebKlt Acloce-c, Flash;!:;
`Player 10,'
`
`EBACCESS
`
`ANDROID MARKETT.
`
`BUSINESS READY
`
`CALLERID
`Rll1ger ID Or /min Jlsr..lz., Plclur" 10
`
`CALLER 10-
`i<lnger ID On OiClJ1 illspray. Picture If;
`SPEAKERPHONE
`
`mON
`
`AUTOMATIC ANSWER
`
`CALL TIMER
`CAlL TRANSFER
`CALL WAITING
`
`EMERGENCY DLll,
`UTE CALL
`
`Gooyle r.bps t'.'
`
`Guogle Taik T
`GOOGLEMAILI,.
`
`30f6
`
`12129120 II 4:54 Pt\ I
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 37
`
`

`
`Motorola ATRIXTM - dual-core phone - Android smartphone - Tech Specs - Motorola Mobility, I...
`
`http://www.lTJOtorola.comlConsumers/XZ-EN/Consumer-Products-and-Services/Mobile-Phones/...
`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-6 Filed 01/17/12 Page 5 of 7
`
`TEXT TO SPEECH
`Missed / received calls, Readout of new
`SMS messages, Readout of new email
`messages, Readout of dialed digits,
`Readout of phone book contacts. Readout
`of caller identification, Voicemail alerts
`
`TOUCH SCREEN
`
`VIRTUAL KEYBOARD
`
`VOICE COMMANDS
`
`BUSINESS
`Quickofflce 3.0, Vlingo Voice
`
`ENTERTAINMENT
`Connected Media Player, Need for
`Speed, Zinio
`
`BACKLIGHT
`Yes
`
`OPERATING SYSTEM
`Android 22 (FroYo)
`
`CUSTOM NAVIGATION
`Multiple, customizable home screens
`
`DEDICATED KEYS
`Back, Home, Volume control, Power/Lock,
`MenLl, Search
`
`KEYPAD LOCK
`
`LIGHT-RESPONSIVE DISPLAY
`
`PINCH TO ZOOM
`
`.-
`,~ ..
`
`L.r-,_,
`
`MOTOBLUR ENABLED
`
`CUSTOMIZABLE HOME SCREEN
`Widget ktinnen verschoben, vergrtil1ert
`oder verklell1ert werden urn den Home
`Screen noch weiter zu personalisieren
`
`MOTOBLUR MESSAGING
`Facebook™. MySpace and Twitter
`Direct Messaging
`
`PHONEBOOK
`Geschaftliche, private Lind Kontakte aus
`
`40f6
`
`1212912011 4:54 PM
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 38
`
`

`
`Motorola ATRIXTM - dual-core phone - Android smartphone - Tech Specs - Motorola Mobility, I...
`
`http://www.motorola.com/Conswners/XZ-EN/Consumer-Products-and-Services/Mobile-Phones/...
`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-6 Filed 01/17/12 Page 6 of 7
`
`den sozialen Netzwerken - aile an einem
`Platz und aile auf einem sicheren Server
`hinterlegt
`
`PHOTO SHARING
`MySpace, Photobucket, Picasa n "
`Facebook™
`
`MUSIC ENABLED6
`
`MUSIC PLAYER
`Connected Media Player
`
`VIDEO CAPABLE
`
`VIDEO CAPTURE
`HP nop capture
`
`PLAYABLE FORMATS
`AAC+, H.264, eAAC+, MP3, MPEG-4,
`AAC, WN1A9, AMR NB
`
`STREAMING MEDIA
`Audio, Video, Internet Radio
`
`VIDEO CAPTURE RATE
`30 fps
`
`RINGTONE FORMATS
`eAAC+,eAAC,AAC+,AAC, MP3
`RINGTONES2
`Preloaded and downloadable
`WALLPAPERS2
`Preloaded and downloadable
`
`VIDEO PLAYBACK RATE
`30 fps
`
`•
`
`,'HYSICAL
`
`DISPLAY TYPE
`Corning® Gorilla® Glass
`
`WEIGHT
`135 grams
`
`SIZE
`63.5 x 117.75 x 10.95 mm
`DISPLAY SIZE
`4.0-in.; qHD (960 x 540)
`
`ANTENNA TYPE
`Internal
`
`FORM FACTOR
`Candy bar
`
`5 of
`
`12129/20 II 4:54 Pi'. I
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 39
`
`

`
`Motorola ATRlXCM - dual-core phone - Android smartphone - Tech Specs - Motorola Mobility, I...
`
`http://www.motorola.comiConswners/XZ-EN/Consumer-Products-and-Services/Mobile-Phones/...
`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-6 Filed 01/17/12 Page 7 of 7
`
`CALCULATOR
`
`CALENDAR
`Synching with MOTOBLURTM
`
`CLOCK
`Alarm clock
`
`FLIGHT MODE
`
`MEMORy7
`Up to 16 GB on board
`
`PROCESSOR SPEED
`1GHz dual-core processor for 2x the
`pov..er, 2x the speed
`
`REMOVABLE MEMORyS
`Up to 32 GB microSD
`
`ACCELEROMETER
`Yes
`NETWORKS2
`WCDMA 850/900/1900/2100, 8SM
`850/900/1800/1900, HSDPA 14.4 Mbps
`(Category 10), HSUPA 2.0 Mbps,
`eCompass/aGPS , Bluetooth Class 2,
`Version 2.1+EDR, 802.11b/802.11g
`/802. 11a/802. 11n
`
`SENSORS
`Proximity, ambient light
`
`II;.:
`
`•
`
`._ -
`<,.••-••.."
`tliv ....~L..
`
`, ,p
`
`. 0"""
`~ V
`
`.~
`
`WEBTOP APPLICATION
`Learn more about our webtop application
`
`60f6
`
`12129120 II 4:54 PM
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 40
`
`

`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-7 Filed 01/17/12 Page 1 of 4
`
`EXHIBIT C
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 41
`
`

`
`Lapdock for MOTOROLA ATRIX 4G - Compatibility - Motorola Mobility, Inc. USA
`
`http://www.motorola.com'Comwners/US-EN/Comwner-Product-and-Services/Mobile+Phone+...
`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-7 Filed 01/17/12 Page 2 of 4
`
`o CONSLIMEAS
`
`MOBILE PHONES
`
`TABLETS
`
`ACCESSORIES
`
`ALL PRODUCTS
`
`SOFTWAA EIAPPS
`
`STORE
`
`GET HELP
`
`TM
`LapdoclC for MOTOROLA ATRIX '16
`
`T1tf
`
`COMPATIBILITY
`
`OWNER SUPPORT
`
`lof3
`
`1/12/20121:33 PM
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 42
`
`

`
`Lapdock for MOTOROLA ATRlX 40 - Compatibility - Motorola Mobility, Inc. USA
`
`http://www.rnotorola.com'Conswners/US-EN/CorL'iwner-Product-and-Services/Mobile+Phone+...
`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-7 Filed 01/17/12 Page 3 of 4
`
`'"\
`
`.',
`
`'..
`
`1
`
`---...
`
`~_ \ , . 4 ..
`!'l'aVlf..-;...£01..
`
`-
`
`1
`
`•
`
`'
`
`•
`
`Q
`
`~
`
`Q
`
`MOTOROLA ATRIXTM 4G
`
`MOTOROLA ATRIX 4G gives you dual-core
`processing power and the revolutionary webtop
`application. With webtop and a compatible
`Motorola docking station. sold separately, you can
`surf the Internet with a full Firefox browser, create
`and edit docs, or access multimedia on a large
`screen almost anywhere.
`
`Product Details ~
`
`Motorola Home > Consumer Product & Ser\oices > Accessories> Lapdock™ for MOTOROLA ATRIXTM 4G
`
`•Email
`
`Signup
`
`:.1:
`
`.:w.
`
`"tftE1lF-T.
`
`·-"'i~U·-..l:l.""':'''F-lIf:l'·
`
`:-:
`
`20fJ
`
`II:·"
`
`1/12120121:33 PM
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 43
`
`

`
`Uipdock: for MOTOROLA ATRIX 4G - Compatibility - Motorola Mobility, Inc. USA
`
`http://www.JOOtorola.com'Coffiumers/US-EN/Coffiumer-Product-and-Services/Mobile+Phone+...
`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-7 Filed 01/17/12 Page 4 of 4
`
`300
`
`1/12/20121:33 PM
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 44
`
`

`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-8 Filed 01/17/12 Page 1 of 14
`
`EXHIBITD
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 45
`
`

`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-8 Filed 01/17/12 Page 2 of 14
`
`UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
`FOR THE
`DISTRICT OF VERMONT
`
`Case No. 5:11-cv-155
`
`) )) ))))
`
`ARNOUSE DIGITAL DEVICES CORP.,
`Plaintiff,
`
`v.
`
`MOTOROLA MOBILITY, INC.,
`Defendant.
`
`DECLARATION OF JUSTIN McCABE IN SUPPORT OF
`PLAINTIFF'S OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANT'S MOTION
`TO DISMISS PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT
`
`1.
`
`My name is Justin McCabe. I am an attorney with Downs RacWin Martin PLLC,
`
`counsel of record for Plaintiff Arnouse Digital Devices Corporation (hereinafter "Amouse
`
`Digital"). I am over 18 years of age and understand the obligations of an oath. I make this
`
`declaration based upon my personal knowledge.
`
`2.
`
`As part of my research with respect to Defendant Motorola Mobility, Inc.'s
`
`("Motorola") Motion to Dismiss, I went on the Internet and visited Motorola's website,
`
`motorola.com.
`
`3.
`
`Once at motorola.com, I clicked on the tab labeled "SOFTWARE/APPS" in the
`
`website's top bar. By clicking on "SOFTWARE/APPS" I triggered a drop-down menu from
`
`which I selected the first option, "app picks."
`
`4.
`
`Once at the "app picks" page, I scrolled to the bottom of the page, where I clicked
`
`on a link labeled "MOTODEV." The "MOTODEV" link took me to separate website titled
`
`"MOTODEV: The Motorola developer network."
`
`5.
`
`Once at "MOTODEV: The Motorola developer network" I clicked on the link
`
`labeled "Android Technical Library." Once at the "Android Technical Library" page, I clicked
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 46
`
`

`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-8 Filed 01/17/12 Page 3 of 14
`
`on the link labeled "Webtop Application Overview" which can be found at
`
`http://developer.motorola.com/doc to Ls/library/webtop-application-overview/. A copy of the
`
`"Webtop Application Overview" page I saw is attached to this Declaration as Exhibit A.
`
`6.
`
`On that "Webtop Application Overview" page, Motorola states that (I) when
`
`connected to a Lapdock with its display screen opened, the smartphones automatically cease to
`
`use the Android Operating System and instead begin working as computers through an integrated
`
`Linux-based "Webtop" software application, (2) when the Webtop application is launched in a
`
`Lapdock, the smartphones go into sleep mode and do not display the mobile phone's device's
`
`applications, and (3) that once docked, "[y]our phone will automatically go to Webtop mode and
`
`your phone will appear to go into sleep mode." On that same page, I also saw a photograph of an
`
`Atrix Smartphone screen that was blank when docked to the operating Lapdock.
`
`7.
`
`For the Webtop Application Overview page I clicked the linked labeled "Show all
`
`devices with the webtop application", which can be found at
`
`htto://deveLoper.motorola.com/products/?fiLters= 1509#filter/. A copy of the "AndroidTM_
`
`Powered Devices" page I saw is attached to this Declaration as Exhibit B.
`
`Pursuant to 28 U.S.c. § 1746, I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and
`correct.
`
`Dated: January 17,2012
`
`4802934.2
`
`By: ----7"":..-f--=------------
`
`2
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 47
`
`

`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-8 Filed 01/17/12 Page 4 of 14
`
`Exhibit A
`
`3
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 48
`
`

`
`MOTODEV> Documentation & Tools> Android Technical Library> Webtop Application Overview
`
`hUp://developer.lOOtorola.com'docstoolsilibrary/webtop-application-overview/
`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-8 Filed 01/17/12 Page 5 of 14
`
`'11.~••U.11
`
`. . Print Document
`
`~c SHARE
`
`""_ :."_
`
`Table of Contents
`) What is the v..ebtop application?
`
`) Supported devices
`) Peripherals
`
`) Activating the v..ebtop application
`
`) Undocking and re-docking
`
`) The v..ebtop application desktop
`
`) Mobile View
`) Firefox brow.:;er
`) File manager
`
`) Webtop application types
`) Android app support
`) H1ML5 app support
`
`) App tray icons
`
`Webtop Application Overview
`
`Although there is little that an Android™ or HTML5 developer must do to tailor their apps to run \/\ell v.ith the \/\ebtop application. developers
`should be familiar wth the \/\ebtop application and how an end user interacts v.ith it. Accordingly, this article presents an introduction to the
`\/\ebtop application and points out those aspects that v.ill be of particular interest to developers.
`
`What is the webtop application?
`Webtop refers to a v..eb-based desktop environment that is presented by the v..ebtop
`application found on certain Android devices such as Motorola AlRlXTM 4G. The
`v..ebtop application is launched when you connect the device to a full-sized display
`and (optionally) a keyboard and mouse through one of the available docks,
`morphing the device into one better suited for a given situation:
`
`) The Lapdock™, v.ith its buitt-in 11.5" (1366 x 768 pixel) screen, keyboard, and
`trackpad. allow.:; you to use the \/\ebtop application while on the go.
`) The HD Multimedia Dock allow.:; you to use the device as an entertainment center (complete v.ith remote controQ and is suitable for office
`use; it can connect the device to an external monitor, keyboard, and mouse.
`
`The v..ebtop application presents a full Firefox desktop brow.:;er (version 4.0.1 on Gingerbread, version 3.6.13 on Froyo)--eomplete wth
`Adobe Flash 10.1. multiple wndow.:;, tabs, themes, and add-ons-along wth the "Mobile View': a v.indow wthin which the user can run
`Android apps and otherv.ise interact v.ith their mobile device. The v..ebtop application extends the rnuttitasking and computing experience of
`the mobile device v.ithout compromising on the device's mobile features.
`
`This ability of the device to readily adapt itself to differing situations means that users wit be able to leave their cornputers behind lIIk1i1e stiD
`enjoying an uncomprornised experience lIIk1ether at oork, at play, or on the go.
`
`Supported devices
`Show all devices v.ith the v..ebtop application
`
`Peripherals
`As befitting a desktop or laptop computer, Wlen the device is running the \/\ebtop application you have the option to connect a number of
`peripherals. The v..ebtop application includes support for standard HID keyboards and !'rice, either v.ired (through a dock's USB ports) or
`v.ireless (such as Bluetooth keyboards and mice). As v..ell, you can connect a wred or wreless headset (as you can V>tien the device is not
`running the v..ebtop application). Printers are supported (you can print from Firefox, from \/\eb apps. or from the PDF viev..er), but only if they
`are IP-accessible on the same wreless ne!'M:Jrk.
`
`Using one of the dock's USB ports you can connect a USB mass-storage device such as a flash drive. When you plug in a recognized
`mass-storage device it mounts automatically. Mounted USB storage is visible in both the v..ebtop application's File Manager and in the Mobile
`Views Files app, as is the device's internal storage and removable SO card (if one is present in the device). Android apps can access these
`various volumes asing their paths:
`
`) The device's internal storage (essentially, a "non-removable SO card") is mounted as sdCiird/
`
`lof7
`
`1/2/2012 12:57 PM
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 49
`
`

`
`MOTODEV> DOCluuentation & Tools> Android Technical Library> Webtop Application Overview
`
`http://developer.motorola.com!docstools/Ii brary/webtop-appl ication-overview/
`
`Case 5:11-cv-00155-cr Document 11-8 Filed 01/17/12 Page 6 of 14
`
`) 111e d\-;v:ce's 12i rKNuf)ie SD eLil d is I11CJL;lHed as
`) USB lnass ~I01 Zlge deV1C2S ate fliCJurned Ll~II'lg sonletl"l:ng a:oi-1fJ th>2liilcS OJ
`USE) dE;\iiCe c.t1d th(~ riUiYiber of..JC'Jil.2S Clii rellt~y rnoun~.-;d)
`
`llhe cX;jCI nanK:: ri~iclY vary depending upoJ] tilL:
`
`As IS Stoii,j3;O plactlce 02 SLlI:.3 tc LiilH'/Junl3iTj connected ni2;s~'-0lolagedeVices beic:;e J s\.. Jlin\:~cjj('if1
`
`[i';CI11
`
`At mlS Iirne Olll} keyDuerds, mice. 311d USB nl~~SS storage deVlces Celli b,.::--
`you 21tternpl to plug 1I12dl unrecognized USB OCVIC2,
`
`j-Jtugged into tile dock's USB pOll 3L tills tllTte You \i\11l be notIfied It
`
`Remote Control
`
`The HD Mullirnedi3 Dock includes a refTlutf; cunirul thEn provides d ir;e8SUI e of conlroi f(orn a dbt3nc(.'
`AitilOugrl it IS IntencieJ to zHovv a L1ser
`to fE:i1',(;tCI/ contrG! rnultimecii3 playtJ,Jck on a dOCf....0d cievlc2 cOl1necieci
`(0 their lele\;1S;Oi1 ClndJUi si2ieu c,PlJ dC\Jdo~2IS can lake aUVclJ1la:jE:: Dj the remOle hi thea Cipplic3.tions: ii they
`so ch00se f\lote that the relrloh.; \.\{)rks \i\1th (he:: dock, 1101 Ll1e de\,.'icE:: so th3l an app V~ljJ only be, able to
`12spund it die c.h.:vice IS dc)cked
`
`Tile Ml;;llU ~-jij!\\c~, CiIIL! Ba''::K bllU.Ul·~::: un Ulc'; !e1f\Jl2 (~CtJ:"'ISl ,ike 'tnt: COii-SSpOJKHi-lg u:.JLTuns on U-,e d~:;\/jC£;
`oti-ler rJurt0ns on lile IernGle c~u'S:; tli2 -I01JcYV\1I1Cj key' evt::::rlts [u b2 Cei k-;i atec
`
`lhe
`
`Key(s)
`
`5-vvay 113V1Q3iion cLnu-ol
`
`Event(s)
`
`Si.::rlds :1 .,j'
`
`Apps th:n 'e~:sttr for tile; lISI-2ci cv.;:;nts VJ1!i fccel\/c rhein Villel} tilS ussr PI8~ScS the Cippropriote t..UllOtiS Ut; [he
`riD [\/luHi'1:2Lli.2i Dock I ernotc conti oL
`
`AcrivaLin~ nld V'J20i:CP 3pplk:CltL~n
`
`Trie 'v'licbrop dprJ1ic,alloll ,$ a!V"'0yS pre-scI-Ii on trlc DeviCe but IS on:y available "iJ121l you lf1Scrt lhe U2\,'jCt: l! Itu a
`(Jock wil1'1 d dedIcated dLSP!d'Y (sue!') ciS tile L;::'fJdock) 01 \-",he!\ 'y'GLl dl-Op II il'i1O 3 dock to vvnlch dll exL-,:rilcd
`n ~cnilol !s connected "{Oil \~Jili the!l Dc gt\..en tile 0;J!lOli
`tG !ol:fiCii 1I1:~ \'vebtop app, run the Einen:il Ul\::-:=nl
`L;en k;'i E-qJp or do neil! Ie!. Note tnat v.-.tt; Ule L~~pdock, the v\r;~IJt(Jp 3ppjiCl::~liUi 1 V\~h 12.luncl1 aut'Jnl~Hjc.dlhl if the:
`C1isplay is opeil_
`
`!"ltll0Ugll e!l1 eXk:rnctl dis~tay IS requited inpUT d2\'1ces are optiollsd: the device itself stands Ii) for 2ilher 0;
`both ir neither d keyu03!d flor & mOlls,;~ is coni1ecled, the dE:=\/lcc'S toucllscrEen presenls bot!l violien thE; \i\rebtop 3pp!~c3tlon is runn~ng If cnlY
`2 keyb031d IS cuililected, the devIce display "cis as a large Irackp3d If oilly a mouse IS corlliectcd, till:' device presents a OWERfY
`keyboald th31 can be used for dali] input FilIally, 11 bolh a keyboaci 31id 3 mouse [ire connected tr,c; de\J1ce display shm~s Irie cLirrent (ilile
`Clncl elate and 1l1fol-rr\Zltlon about 211)' IflconHng C2&S it IS jrnpoltallt to be aViare Ihdt vVlleli the v"ebmp 2lppJiCCltiOil is rUI\nmg, tt-le Andro:d
`JevIce uls;Jiay is plesented on trtC connecten nK.Jilltu(
`in tn:.:: )\jiobile Vlev~l.
`
`Undocking and re-docking
`Tile \\l2blop c.pplicalion is (,1e519]12d so lf1at you can SJ!l;ply grab your deVice out of lhe dock \i'.hllout !13VilJij 10 take any aCllon (besides
`lit :illJlmting :j!1Y connect~d USB mass-stlJrE~g2 (jc-~vJC8S) Vviheil U12 ue\,1ce is unjocked, c,it VIICQCOP ?LlJpltcc;uun actl'vity is suspellded and the
`'iv0blCp ,app!ICJUOn ils2l! mO\ICS hJ iJlc t)oCj\~\f0Li;)(i Fa: 3 purloei ur lJrYr2 110\'.'2v21 lilE Flre10X Lr0V\i~ei rernams runnllig.
`to allo'.,,,, allY ZlutO-Scl\/i.::
`functionality'
`to trigger :or 'iI'~'2!J sites such as 8(1;011 (J1 f,l!lcrusort UIfiCE: LlI.lc /\fter [(1;::; pc::;jud OY lln-:c, ::-lre;Ox IS SUsfJe(lcle:d alld its priority IS
`
`2 of7
`
`112/201212:57 PM
`
`Petitioner Motorola Mobility LLC - Exhibit 1009 - Page 50