`Case 1:19-cv-11278—RGS Document 45-7 Filed 02/20/20 Page 1 of 8
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`EXHIBIT 1
`EXHIBIT 1
`
`
`
`Case 1:19-cv-11278-RGS Document 45-7 Filed 02/20/20 Page 2 of 8
`
`G^X]VZa M]Vbdh( J]*>* ) @ZWgjVgn -,( .,.,
`
`JV\Z -
`
`CH NB? OHCN?> MN;N?M >CMNLC=N =IOLN
`@IL NB? >CMNLC=N I@ G;MM;=BOM?NNM
`
`UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU
`OHCFI= .,-3( FF=
`
`JaV^ci^[[(
`
`PM*
`
`J;S=B?R( CH=*(
`
`>Z[ZcYVci*
`
`)))))))))))))))))))))))))))
`OHCFI= .,-3( FF=(
`
`JaV^ci^[[
`
`PM*
`
`;NB?H;B?;FNB( CH=*(
`
`&
`&
`&
`&
`&
`&
`&
`&
`&
`&
`&
`&
`&
`
`&&
`
`&&
`
`&&
`
`&
`>Z[ZcYVci*
`UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUU&
`
`>?JIMCNCIH
`I@
`GC=B;?F MB;GIM( J]*>*
`GdcYVn( @ZWgjVgn -,( .,.,
`56,3 V*b
`
`=^k^a ;Xi^dc Hd*
`-6-5)Xk)--.3.)LAM
`
`=^k^a ;Xi^dc Hd*
`-6-5)Xk)--.34)LAM
`
`>Zedh^i^dc d[ G^X]VZa M]Vbdh( J]*>*( V l^icZhh
`]ZgZ^c( iV‘Zc ^c VXXdgYVcXZ l^i] JZcchnakVc^V LjaZh
`d[ =^k^a JgdXZYjgZ Hd* 0,,3*-( Wn VcY WZ[dgZ
`>jiX]ZZc I* =VbZgdc( LZ\^hiZgZY GZg^i
`LZedgiZg)=Zgi^[^ZY LZVai^bZ LZedgiZg VcY HdiVgn
`JjWa^X ^c VcY [dg i]Z =dbbdclZVai] d[ JZcchnakVc^V(
`Vi i]Z d[[^XZh d[ LZZY Mb^i]( FF=( ..1 @^[i] ;kZcjZ(
`J^iihWjg\( JZcchnakVc^V( -1...( dc GdcYVn(
`@ZWgjVgn -,( .,.,( Vi 56,3 V*b*
`
`LZedgiZY Wn6 >jiX]ZZc I* =VbZgdc
`
`AgZ\dgn?YlVgYh( FF= p QdgaYl^YZ =djgi LZedgi^c\
`AgZ\dgn?YlVgYh*Xdb p 422)0NZVb A?
`
`-
`
`. /
`
`0
`
`1
`
`2
`
`3
`
`4
`
`5
`
`-,
`
`--
`
`-.
`
`-/
`
`-0
`
`-1
`
`-2
`
`-3
`
`-4
`
`-5
`
`.,
`
`.-
`
`..
`
`./
`
`.0
`
`.1
`
`
`
`Case 1:19-cv-11278-RGS Document 45-7 Filed 02/20/20 Page 3 of 8
`
`G^X]VZa M]Vbdh( J]*>* ) @ZWgjVgn -,( .,.,
`
`JV\Z 0/
`
`-
`
`.
`
`/
`
`0
`
`1
`
`2
`
`3
`
`4
`
`5
`
`-,
`
`--
`
`-.
`
`-/
`
`-0
`
`-1
`
`-2
`
`-3
`
`-4
`
`-5
`
`.,
`
`.-
`
`..
`
`./
`
`.0
`
`.1
`
`^h i]Vi ^c \ZcZgVa eVgaVcXZ( i]Z iZgb Veea^XVi^dc
`
`egd\gVb ^h jhZY id Y^hi^c\j^h] i]Z egd\gVb [gdb Vc
`
`deZgVi^c\ hnhiZb egd\gVb* Md Vc Veea^XVi^dc egd\gVb
`
`^h VWaZ id WZ ^ckd‘ZY Wn V jhZg id eZg[dgb [jcXi^dch
`
`[dg i]Z jhZg* Hdl( ndj XVc ]VkZ hiVcYVadcZ
`
`Veea^XVi^dch( [dg hjgZ* Sdj XVc Vahd ]VkZ
`
`Veea^XVi^dch i]Vi gjc ^c V WgdlhZg* ;cY i]ZgZ VgZ
`
`bVcn d[ i]dhZ* C$kZ gjc bVcn VeeaZih i]gdj\]
`
`WgdlhZgh( VcY i]dhZ VeeaZih XVc WZ kZgn ZmiZch^kZ ^c
`
`iZgbh d[ i]Z^g XVeVW^a^i^Zh hd i]Vi dcZ ldjaY gZ[Zg
`
`id i]Zb Vh Veea^XVi^dch* Hdl( ^[ ndj lVci id \Zi
`
`^cid i]Z [^cZ Y^hi^cXi^dc WZilZZc Vc VeeaZi VcY Vc
`
`Veea^XVi^dc( ^[ ndj lVci id bV‘Z i]Vi Y^hi^cXi^dc(
`
`i]^h ^h Vh YZhXg^WZY ^c ?m]^W^i 2( i]Vi ldjaY WZ V
`
`lVn d[ bV‘^c\ i]Z Y^hi^cXi^dc*
`
`K*
`
`;cY VXijVaan )) lZaa( ^hc$i i]Z YZhXg^ei^dc
`
`ZmXjhZ bZ )) hig^‘Z i]Vi*
`
`Chc$i i]Z Y^hi^cXi^dc WZ^c\ bVYZ ^c 1( 2
`
`VcY 3 )) ndj XVc gZVY Vh bjX] d[ i]ZhZ ndj lVci(
`
`i]Zn hVn WVh^XVaan i]Z hVbZ i]^c\ )) i]Vi Vc
`
`Veea^XVi^dc ^h V hiVcYVadcZ egd\gVb i]Vi ^h cdi Vc
`
`deZgVi^c\ hnhiZb VcY eZg[dgbh jhZ[ja ldg‘( l]^aZ Vc
`
`VeeaZi( ^c [VXi( ^hc$i V hiVcYVadcZ( ^i cZZYh id gjc
`
`^ch^YZ V WgdlhZg( VcY i]Vi ^h i]Z Y^hi^cXi^dc8
`
`;*
`
`QZaa( i]ZgZ$h cd fjZhi^dc i]Vi Vc VeeaZi ))
`
`AgZ\dgn?YlVgYh( FF= p QdgaYl^YZ =djgi LZedgi^c\
`AgZ\dgn?YlVgYh*Xdb p 422)0NZVb A?
`
`
`
`Case 1:19-cv-11278-RGS Document 45-7 Filed 02/20/20 Page 4 of 8
`
`G^X]VZa M]Vbdh( J]*>* ) @ZWgjVgn -,( .,.,
`
`JV\Z 13
`
`-
`
`.
`
`/
`
`0
`
`1
`
`2
`
`3
`
`4
`
`5
`
`-,
`
`--
`
`-.
`
`-/
`
`-0
`
`-1
`
`-2
`
`-3
`
`-4
`
`-5
`
`.,
`
`.-
`
`..
`
`./
`
`.0
`
`.1
`
`i]dj\]i hdbZi]^c\ ha^\]ian Y^[[ZgZci* Md aZi$h iVa‘
`
`VWdji i]dhZ hZeVgViZan*
`
`;*
`
`K*
`
`SZh*
`
`Q]Vi Y^Y ndj bZVc l]Zc ndj hV^Y "V eVX‘V\Z
`
`[^aZ lg^iiZc ^c DVkV"8
`
`;*
`
`Md i]Z iZgb i]Vi lZ$gZ iVa‘^c\ VWdji ]ZgZ
`
`^h [^aZ eVX‘Zi dg [^aZ eVX‘V\Z* QZ$gZ cdi iVa‘^c\
`
`VWdji di]Zg ‘^cYh d[ eVX‘V\Zh* Md V DVkV eVX‘V\Z ^h
`
`cdi cZXZhhVg^an i]Z hVbZ i]^c\ Vh V [^aZ eVX‘V\Z*
`
`Md l]Zc hdbZWdYn )) ^[ hdbZWdYn XVbZ je id bZ VcY
`
`hV^Y( ]Zn( C \di V DVkV eVX‘V\Z ^c bn edX‘Zi( ^i
`
`ldjaY WZ VbW^\jdjh* Ci XdjaY bZVc V XdjeaZ d[
`
`i]^c\h i]Vi C _jhi ZmeaV^cZY*
`
`K*
`
`I‘Vn* Md l]Zc ndj hVn V eVX‘V\Z lg^iiZc ^c
`
`DVkV( l]Vi Yd ndj bZVc Wn i]Vi8
`
`;*
`
`K*
`
`;*
`
`I‘Vn*
`
`Q]Vi ^h i]Vi ZmVbeaZ8
`
`Md [dg YZXVYZh eZdeaZ ]VkZ gZ[ZggZY id
`
`hd[ilVgZ eVX‘V\Zh* Md[ilVgZ eVX‘V\Z ^h \ZcZgVaan V
`
`XdaaZXi^dc d[ egd\gVbh i]Vi ^ciZgVXi l^i] dcZ
`
`Vcdi]Zg ^c dgYZg id eZg[dgb hdbZ [jcXi^dc* ;cY hd
`
`l]Zc lZ hVn )) ^[ lZ _jhi jhZ i]Z ldgY eVX‘V\Z( ^i
`
`bZVch Vc Veea^XVi^dc i]Vi Xdch^hih d[ V eVX‘V\Z( V
`
`hd[ilVgZ eVX‘V\Z* I‘Vn8 N]ZgZ VgZ bVcn lVnh d[
`
`Y^hig^Wji^c\ hd[ilVgZ eVX‘V\Zh* MdbZi^bZh i]Zn$gZ
`
`AgZ\dgn?YlVgYh( FF= p QdgaYl^YZ =djgi LZedgi^c\
`AgZ\dgn?YlVgYh*Xdb p 422)0NZVb A?
`
`
`
`Case 1:19-cv-11278-RGS Document 45-7 Filed 02/20/20 Page 5 of 8
`
`G^X]VZa M]Vbdh( J]*>* ) @ZWgjVgn -,( .,.,
`
`JV\Z 14
`
`-
`
`.
`
`/
`
`0
`
`1
`
`2
`
`3
`
`4
`
`5
`
`-,
`
`--
`
`-.
`
`-/
`
`-0
`
`-1
`
`-2
`
`-3
`
`-4
`
`-5
`
`.,
`
`.-
`
`..
`
`./
`
`.0
`
`.1
`
`hbVaa( hdbZi^bZh i]Zn$gZ kZgn( kZgn aVg\Z* Md
`
`eVX‘V\Z lVh V iZgb [dg V WjcX] d[ hij[[ i]Vi ndj
`
`]VkZ id eji id\Zi]Zg ^c dgYZg id gjc Vc Veea^XVi^dc*
`
`Md C$b kZgn [Vb^a^Vg l^i] GVi]ZbVi^XV( l]^X] ^h dcZ
`
`d[ i]Z egd\gVbh i]Vi =GO ]Vh a^XZchZY* ;cY ^i
`
`deZgViZh ^c ild Y^[[ZgZci lVnh7 dcZ ^h ^i gjch dc V
`
`cZildg‘ hZgkZg( dg ^[ ndj ]VkZ i]Z gZaZkVcXZ hiVijh
`
`Vi i]Z jc^kZgh^in( ndj XVc VXijVaan YdlcadVY i]Z
`
`[jaa Veea^XVi^dc id ndjg dlc Xa^Zci XdbejiZg VcY gjc
`
`^i adXVaan* C ]VkZ ^i dc i]^h aVeide* C Ydc$i ]VkZ
`
`id WZ XdccZXiZY id Vcn cZildg‘ ^c dgYZg id gjc
`
`GVi]ZbVi^XV*
`
`K*
`
`;*
`
`Q]Vi YdZh ^i ]VkZ id Yd l^i] V eVX‘V\Z8
`
`C$b \Zii^c\ i]ZgZ* Md GVi]ZbVi^XV ^h
`
`gZ[ZggZY id Vh V eVX‘V\Z* Ci$h V eVX‘V\Z i]Vi
`
`eZg[dgbh bVi]ZbVi^XVa deZgVi^dch* ;cY i]Z gZVhdc
`
`^i$h V eVX‘V\Z ^h ^i$h cdi _jhi dcZ i]^c\* N]ZgZ$h
`
`V GVi]ZbVi^XV XdYZ* N]ZgZ$h V GVi]ZbVi^XV aVjcX]Zg(
`
`VXijVaan* N]ZgZ VgZ bVi]ZbVi^XVa [^aZh ))
`
`GVi]ZbVi^XV [^aZh i]Vi VgZ gZfj^gZY Yjg^c\
`
`ZmZXji^dc* N]Z egd\gVb ^ihZa[ l^aa \d dji VcY gZVY
`
`[^aZh [gdb ndjg Y^hX i]Vi ^i cZZYh* N]^h l]daZ
`
`i]^c\ id\Zi]Zg( eji id\Zi]Zg ldjaY WZ gZ[ZggZY id Vh
`
`i]Z GVi]ZbVi^XV eVX‘V\Z* Ci$h V eVX‘V\Z d[
`
`hd[ilVgZ* C$b cdi iVa‘^c\ VWdji h]g^c‘lgVeeZY l^i]
`
`AgZ\dgn?YlVgYh( FF= p QdgaYl^YZ =djgi LZedgi^c\
`AgZ\dgn?YlVgYh*Xdb p 422)0NZVb A?
`
`
`
`Case 1:19-cv-11278-RGS Document 45-7 Filed 02/20/20 Page 6 of 8
`
`G^X]VZa M]Vbdh( J]*>* ) @ZWgjVgn -,( .,.,
`
`JV\Z 2.
`
`-
`
`.
`
`/
`
`0
`
`1
`
`2
`
`3
`
`4
`
`5
`
`-,
`
`--
`
`-.
`
`-/
`
`-0
`
`-1
`
`-2
`
`-3
`
`-4
`
`-5
`
`.,
`
`.-
`
`..
`
`./
`
`.0
`
`.1
`
`^hc$i i]Z [^aZ*
`
`K*
`
`Q]Vi VWdji V hXg^ei d[ hdbZ hdgi id V^Y ^c
`
`^chiVaaVi^dc8
`
`;*
`
`; hXg^ei ^h V [^aZ* MXg^eih VgZ hidgZY ^c
`
`[^aZh* N]Zn ]VeeZc id WZ hXg^eih gVi]Zg i]Vc
`
`gZ\jaVg egd\gVbb^c\ XdYZ*
`
`K*
`
`Q]Vi ^h ndjg jcYZghiVcY^c\ d[ )) cdl( aZi
`
`bZ WVX‘ je*
`
`Sdj jcYZghiVcY i]Vi i]ZgZ$h i]Z iZgb
`
`hZ\bZci ^c i]ZhZ XaV^bh8 L^\]i8 Ci$h V [^aZ eVX‘Zi
`
`l^i] V hZ\bZci*
`
`;*
`
`K*
`
`SZh*
`
`Ch i]Z iZgb hZ\bZci hdbZi]^c\ i]Vi ]Vh
`
`bZVc^c\ djih^YZ d[ i]ZhZ eViZcih( dg ^h i]Vi
`
`hdbZi]^c\ heZX^Va id i]ZhZ eViZcih8
`
`;*
`
`N]Z ldgY hZ\bZci ^ihZa[ ]Vh bZVc^c\* Ci$h
`
`cdi XaZVg i]Vi i]Vi$h i]Z bZVc^c\ i]Vi$h ^ciZcYZY ^c
`
`i]Z eViZci*
`
`K*
`
`Md l]Vi ^h ndjg jcYZghiVcY^c\ d[ i]Z
`
`bZVc^c\ d[ hZ\bZci l^i] gZ\VgY id i]^h XVhZ8 Ch ^i
`
`V [^aZ8 Ch ^i ))
`
`;*
`
`QZaa( C Ydc$i ‘cdl nZi* C ]VkZc$i de^cZY
`
`dc ^i*
`
`K*
`
`;*
`
`I‘Vn*
`
`C Ydc$i i]^c‘ C Y^hXjhhZY hZ\bZcih* C bVn
`
`AgZ\dgn?YlVgYh( FF= p QdgaYl^YZ =djgi LZedgi^c\
`AgZ\dgn?YlVgYh*Xdb p 422)0NZVb A?
`
`
`
`Case 1:19-cv-11278-RGS Document 45-7 Filed 02/20/20 Page 7 of 8
`
`G^X]VZa M]Vbdh( J]*>* ) @ZWgjVgn -,( .,.,
`
`JV\Z 2/
`
`-
`
`.
`
`/
`
`0
`
`1
`
`2
`
`3
`
`4
`
`5
`
`-,
`
`--
`
`-.
`
`-/
`
`-0
`
`-1
`
`-2
`
`-3
`
`-4
`
`-5
`
`.,
`
`.-
`
`..
`
`./
`
`.0
`
`.1
`
`bV‘Z bZci^dc d[ i]Z ldgY WZXVjhZ ^i bVn VeeZVg ^c V
`
`fjdiVi^dc* C XVc \d iV‘Z V add‘* C Ydc$i ‘cdl ^[
`
`C$b \d^c\ id WZ VWaZ id [dgbjaViZ Vc de^c^dc [dg ndj
`
`dc i]Z [an*
`
`K*
`
`I‘Vn* C XVc YZ[^c^iZan VhhjgZ ndj i]Vi C
`
`Vb cdi Vh‘^c\ ndj id [dgbjaViZ Vc de^c^dc dc i]Z
`
`[an*
`
`;*
`
`K*
`
`I‘Vn*
`
`C \jZhh( aZi bZ _jhi deZc i]^h je( dg Vh‘
`
`^i Y^[[ZgZcian*
`
`;h ndj h^i ]ZgZ idYVn( Yd ndj ]VkZ Vc
`
`de^c^dc dc i]Z bZVc^c\ d[ hZ\bZci Vh i]Vi iZgb ^h
`
`jhZY ^c i]Z XdciZmi d[ V [^aZ eVX‘Zi ^c i]ZhZ
`
`eViZcih8
`
`;*
`
`Hd( Wji C$aa iZaa ndj V fjZhi^dc i]Vi C$Y
`
`gVi]Zg VchlZg( l]^X] ^h( Y^Y C ]VkZ Vc jcYZghiVcY^c\
`
`d[ i]Z ldgY hZ\bZci l]Zc C lVh Yd^c\ bn ldg‘ ^c i]^h
`
`XVhZ* ;cY i]Z VchlZg id i]Vi ^h nZh( C ]VY Vc
`
`jcYZghiVcY^c\*
`
`K*
`
`;*
`
`I‘Vn* Q]Vi lVh ndjg jcYZghiVcY^c\8
`
`; hZ\bZci ^h V XdbedcZci( V e^ZXZ* N]ZgZ$h
`
`hdbZi]^c\ ^c i]ZgZ i]Vi YdZh l]ViZkZg i]Vi hZ\bZci
`
`^h hjeedhZY id WZ )) ^h XaV^bZY id WZ Yd^c\*
`
`K*
`
`;cY ^h ^i ndjg jcYZghiVcY^c\ i]Vi i]Vi
`
`hZ\bZci ]Vh id WZ V [^aZ dg bjai^eaZ [^aZh8
`
`AgZ\dgn?YlVgYh( FF= p QdgaYl^YZ =djgi LZedgi^c\
`AgZ\dgn?YlVgYh*Xdb p 422)0NZVb A?
`
`
`
`Case 1:19-cv-11278-RGS Document 45-7 Filed 02/20/20 Page 8 of 8
`
`G^X]VZa M]Vbdh( J]*>* ) @ZWgjVgn -,( .,.,
`
`JV\Z 20
`
`-
`
`.
`
`/
`
`0
`
`1
`
`2
`
`3
`
`4
`
`5
`
`-,
`
`--
`
`-.
`
`-/
`
`-0
`
`-1
`
`-2
`
`-3
`
`-4
`
`-5
`
`.,
`
`.-
`
`..
`
`./
`
`.0
`
`.1
`
`;*
`
`Ci$h Y^[[^Xjai [dg bZ id XdbegZ]ZcY ]dl ^i
`
`ldjaYc$i WZ( WZXVjhZ [^aZh VgZ ine^XVaan i]Z lVn ^c
`
`l]^X] ^c[dgbVi^dc ^h XdckZnZY* MXg^eih( l]ZgZ$h i]Z
`
`hXg^ei XdbZ [gdb8 C lg^iZ V hXg^ei VcY C hidgZ ^i
`
`^c V [^aZ( VcY i]Zc C Xden i]Z [^aZ ^cid l]ViZkZg
`
`i]^h eVX‘V\Z ^h i]Vi C$b hZcY^c\* N]Z hXg^ei
`
`^ihZa[( ^i$h cdi ]Vc\^c\ VgdjcY addhZ ^c i]ZgZ7
`
`di]Zgl^hZ( ndj ldjaYc$i ‘cdl l]ZgZ i]Z hXg^ei WZ\Vc
`
`VcY l]ZgZ i]Z hXg^ei ZcYZY* ;cY hd ^i$h V [^aZ*
`
`K*
`
`FZi$h iV‘Z o^e [^aZh( [dg ZmVbeaZ* >dc$i
`
`i]Zn XdciV^c ‘^cY d[ ]ZVYZg ^c[dgbVi^dc i]Vi VgZ cdi
`
`i]ZbhZakZh V [^aZ8
`
`;*
`
`SZh* Md( [dg ZmVbeaZ( jh^c\ i]Z e]nh^XVa
`
`eVX‘V\Z VcVad\n( ^[ C iV‘Z V WjcX] d[ i]^c\h VcY C
`
`eji lgVee^c\ eVeZg VgdjcY i]Zb( i]Z lgVee^c\ eVeZg
`
`^h cdi eVgi d[ i]Z i]^c\h* Ci$h l]Vi bV‘Zh i]Z
`
`eVX‘V\Z i]Z eVX‘V\Z* Ci$h ]daY^c\ i]Zb Vaa )) ^i$h
`
`]daY^c\ i]Zb Vaa id\Zi]Zg*
`
`K*
`
`<ji XVc$i i]Z lgVee^c\ eVeZg ^c ndjg
`
`ZmVbeaZ( ^[ lZ cdl h]^[i id i]Z hd[ilVgZ XdciZmi( ^[
`
`ndj$gZ ]Vk^c\ V [^aZ eVX‘Zi [dg i]Z ejgedhZ d[
`
`YZeadn^c\ hd[ilVgZ( XdjaYc$i i]Z lgVee^c\( hd id
`
`heZV‘( ^cXajYZ [jcXi^dcVa ^c[dgbVi^dc dc ]dl id
`
`jclgVe dg ^chiVaa i]Z hd[ilVgZ8
`
`;*
`
`SZh( C i]^c‘ i]Vi$h XVeijgZY Wn i]Z ldgY
`
`AgZ\dgn?YlVgYh( FF= p QdgaYl^YZ =djgi LZedgi^c\
`AgZ\dgn?YlVgYh*Xdb p 422)0NZVb A?
`
`