`
`Exhibit 4
`
`
`
` ÿ ÿ
`
`
`
` ÿ ÿÿ ÿÿÿ ÿÿ !"#ÿ$ÿ ÿ%ÿ&ÿ' ÿ( )
`ghÿjklmnomlÿpmqnrsmlÿuvwxyÿz{|}}~|{yÿ|| ÿ~ÿ~ÿÿ|
`
`012ÿ45678294ÿ7::;45ÿ<2=5967ÿ2>ÿ?@955=A
`>29ÿB84ÿCD76ÿ82ÿE;7=9;CD5ÿFGHIJÿK7::B65
`:248LMNOPQRSTÿVPWWRXÿYZÿ[P\\P]T^\RSS\ÿPX_ÿ`RSRWÿVRM]TÿYZÿaRWbYXSÿ\Pc
`STPSÿ\TYS\ÿ]Y^M_ÿQR]YbRÿ^XPdYW_PQMRÿZYWÿ\YbRÿebRWN]PX\f
`wy |ÿxvÿÿ|x yÿzzÿÿÿzÿu
` ¡ÿ¡£¤¥¦§¨©ÿª«¬¥®£¦¯ÿ°¥¨¨£¤ÿ§±ÿ²¥©©¥³¯´©£¦¦©ÿ¥¤µÿ¶£¦£¨ÿ°£«³¯ÿ§±ÿ·£¨¸§¤¦ÿ¥¨£ÿ´¨¹¬¤¹
`²§µ£¨¤¥º©ÿ³¯¬£±ÿ£»£³´¦¬¼£ÿ¦§ÿ¨£³§¤©¬µ£¨ÿ¥ÿ½«¥¤ÿ¦§ÿ¾´¥µ¨´½«£ÿ¦¯£ÿ³§©¦ÿ§±ÿ¬¦©ÿ¿À·ÁÂÃÄÅ
`&
`
`Case 1:22-cv-00252-MSG Document 59-4 Filed 03/02/23 Page 2 of 6 PageID #: 1041
`
` -
`
`
`
`Case 1:22-cv-00252-MSG Document 59-4 Filed 03/02/23 Page 3 of 6 PageID #: 1042
`
`G:BB>D8IÿA:L>D6ÿ238ÿ9:;<=>?68ÿO>=;CAÿM6=88?Rÿ23=8:28DAÿ24ÿ;:N8ÿ238ÿA342Aÿ5D:OO4=?:<18ÿ24
`A4;8ÿ0;8=>B:DAQ
` ÿ ÿ
`
`
`
` ÿ ÿÿ ÿÿÿ ÿÿ !"#ÿ$ÿ ÿ%ÿ&ÿ' ÿ( )
`SDÿ:ÿO>=;1LÿJ4=?8?ÿ18228=ÿ24ÿ9UVÿW2XH3:D8ÿY:DB81Iÿ238ÿZ8;4B=:2>BÿA8D:24=Aÿ?8D45DB8?
`238ÿH=4H4A:1ÿ24ÿ[5:?=5H18ÿ238ÿH=>B8ÿO=4;ÿ:<452ÿ\]^ÿH8=ÿ?4A8ÿ24ÿ<82J88Dÿ\__`ÿ:D?ÿ\_a`Q
`T38LÿA:>?ÿ238ÿ<>428B3ÿ=8B8>G8?ÿ<>11>4DAÿ4Oÿ?411:=AÿO=4;ÿbWÿ2:cH:L8=AÿO4=ÿ=8A8:=B3I
`?8G814H;8D2ÿ:D?ÿ:?G:DB8ÿH5=B3:A8Aÿ:D?ÿ23:2ÿ238ÿB4;H:DLÿ3:Aÿ5A8?ÿ238ÿ=8A512>D6
`452A>d8?ÿH=4O>2Aÿ24ÿ=8J:=?ÿB4;H:DLÿ8c8B52>G8Aÿ:D?ÿA3:=8341?8=AQ
`01234563ÿ238ÿ9:;<=>?68@<:A8?ÿ<>428B3CAÿ;8AA8D68=ÿEF0ÿG:BB>D8ÿ3:Aÿ381H8?ÿ24ÿ2:;8ÿ238
`H:D?8;>BIÿ238ÿA8D:24=AÿJ=428ÿK8?D8A?:LIÿM23>AÿH=46=8AAÿ;:Lÿ<8ÿH52ÿ:2ÿ=>ANÿ<8B:5A8ÿ4O
`P4?8=D:CAÿ6=88?IÿJ3>B3ÿ3:Aÿ238ÿH428D2>:1ÿ24ÿ>DB=8:A8ÿG:BB>D:2>4DÿB4A2AÿO4=ÿ;>11>4DAÿ4Oÿ5D@
`:D?ÿ5D?8=>DA5=8?ÿ0;8=>B:DAQR
`SDÿ:ÿA2:28;8D2IÿP4?8=D:ÿA:>?ÿ>2AÿG:BB>D8Aÿ3:G8ÿA:G8?ÿ238ÿ1>G8Aÿ4Oÿ35D?=8?Aÿ4Oÿ;>11>4DAÿ4O
`H84H18ÿ:=45D?ÿ238ÿJ4=1?ÿ:D?ÿ23:2ÿ238>=ÿH=>B8Aÿ=8O18B2ÿ238>=ÿG:158QÿT38ÿO>=;ÿ:1A4ÿA:>?ÿ;4A2
`0;8=>B:DAÿJ4DC2ÿD42>B8ÿ238ÿ?>OO8=8DB8ÿ<8B:5A8ÿ>DA5=8=AÿJ>11ÿB4G8=ÿ238ÿB4A2Q
`
`&
`
` -
`
`
`
`Case 1:22-cv-00252-MSG Document 59-4 Filed 03/02/23 Page 4 of 6 PageID #: 1043
`2/24/23, 91@AWBE 1:22-cv-002babSéiaGis akasinavend GYrded’ follaGAWwOBeibie Rag~evécaleGoktayeliidstén GOES
`
` ÿ ÿ
`
`
`
`
`
` ÿ ÿÿ ÿÿÿ ÿÿ !"#ÿ$ÿ ÿ%ÿ&ÿ' ÿ( )
`
`https:/Avww.bostonglobe.com/2023/0 1/25/business/two-senators-accuse-moderna-greed-its-plan-quadruple-covid-vaccine-cost/?event=event12
`
`0123456ÿ89:;3<14=ÿ>36612?@ABC8DEFÿG@HIJFK@00LAJ@I8MÿNH800
`
`SenatorElizabeth Warren JACQUELYN MARTIN/ASSOCIATED PRESS
`
`&
`
` -
`
`
`
`Case 1:22-cv-00252-MSG Document 59-4 Filed 03/02/23 Page 5 of 6 PageID #: 1044
`
`lrghifsÿzrirsÿ{rmpjevÿl|}~~ÿzz{~ll}|~ ÿzll
`012ÿ45ÿ467892:;2ÿ28ÿ;82<ÿ2=:2>ÿ?78;ÿ29:;54248;ÿ28ÿ:ÿ@866<9@4:Aÿ6:9B<2ÿ:;Cÿ@8;5452<;2ÿD42=
`
` ÿ ÿÿ ÿÿÿ ÿÿ !"#ÿ$ÿ ÿ%ÿ&ÿ' ÿ( )
`
` ÿ ÿ
`
`79<E<;24E<ÿ5<9E4@<5ÿ@8E<9:F<ÿ9<G?49<6<;25>ÿH8C<9;:I5ÿJKL1MNOPÿE:@@4;<5ÿ:;CÿQ8852<95
`D4AAÿ@8;24;?<ÿ28ÿQ<ÿ:E:4A:QA<ÿ:2ÿ;8ÿ@852ÿR89ÿ2=<ÿE:52ÿ6:S8942Tÿ8Rÿ7<87A<ÿ4;ÿ2=<ÿU;42<C
`V2:2<5>Wÿ2=<ÿ@867:;Tÿ5:4CX
`Y:99<;ÿ:;CÿY<A@=ÿ5<;2ÿ:ÿ5464A:9ÿA<22<9ÿ28ÿZR4[<9ÿ@=4<Rÿ<\<@?24E<ÿ]AQ<92ÿ^8?9A:ÿA:52ÿ68;2=
`:R2<9ÿ=<ÿ5:4Cÿ2=<ÿ7=:96:@<?24@:AÿF4:;2ÿ7A:;;<Cÿ28ÿ9:45<ÿ2=<ÿ794@<ÿ8Rÿ425ÿ94E:Aÿ6_`]
`E:@@4;<ÿ28ÿ2=<ÿ5:6<ÿ9:;F<Xÿ]2ÿ:ÿ@8;R<9<;@<ÿ=852<CÿQTÿVa]aÿ4;ÿ`8E<6Q<9>ÿ^8?9A:ÿ5:4Cÿ2=<
`E:@@4;<ÿD4AAÿ524AAÿQ<ÿ0R9<<ÿR89ÿ:AAÿ]6<94@:;5WÿQ<@:?5<ÿ4;5?9<95ÿD4AAÿ74@Bÿ?7ÿ2=<ÿ@852Xÿ^?2
`@9424@5ÿ5:4Cÿ2=<ÿ=4F=<9ÿ@852ÿQ89;<ÿQTÿ4;5?9<95ÿD4AAÿQ<ÿ7:55<Cÿ8;ÿ4;ÿ2=<ÿR896ÿ8Rÿ=4F=<9
`79<64?65X
`1;ÿ2=<ÿ@:5<ÿ8RÿH8C<9;:>ÿ^:;@<Aÿ28ACÿa=<ÿY:AAÿV29<<2ÿb8?9;:Aÿ8;ÿb:;XÿPÿ2=:2ÿ=45ÿ@867:;T
`D:5ÿ@8;54C<94;Fÿ9:454;Fÿ2=<ÿ794@<ÿD=<;ÿ2=<ÿR<C<9:AÿF8E<9;6<;2I5ÿ@8;29:@2ÿ<;C5ÿ:;Cÿ2=<
`E:@@4;<ÿ5=4R25ÿ28ÿ@866<9@4:AÿC45294Q?248;Xÿa=<ÿF8E<9;6<;2ÿ@?99<;2ATÿC45294Q?2<5ÿ2=<ÿ5=825
`R89ÿR9<<X
`^:;@<AI5ÿ:;;8?;@<6<;2ÿ798672<Cÿ:ÿ5D4R2ÿC<;?;@4:248;ÿR986ÿL<968;2I5ÿ5<;489ÿ5<;:289>
`^<9;4<ÿV:;C<95>ÿ:;ÿ4;C<7<;C<;2ÿ:;Cÿ2=<ÿ4;@864;Fÿ@=:49ÿ8Rÿ2=<ÿV<;:2<I5ÿ=<:A2=
`@866422<<Xÿ1;ÿ:ÿA<22<9ÿ8Rÿ=45ÿ8D;ÿ28ÿH8C<9;:I5ÿ=<:C>ÿ=<ÿ5:4Cÿ^:;@<AI5ÿ7A:;ÿD:5
`08?29:F<8?5Wÿ:;Cÿ:68?;2<Cÿ28ÿ0?;:@@<72:QA<ÿ@89789:2<ÿF9<<CXW
`1;ÿ2=45ÿD<<BI5ÿA<22<9>ÿY:99<;ÿ:;CÿY<A@=ÿ:5B<Cÿ^:;@<Aÿ28ÿ9<578;Cÿ28ÿ:ÿ5<94<5ÿ8Rÿ;4;<
`G?<5248;5ÿQTÿc<QXÿd>ÿ4;@A?C4;FÿD=<2=<9ÿH8C<9;:ÿ<\<@?24E<5ÿ@8;5?A2<CÿZR4[<9ÿ<\<@?24E<5
`:Q8?2ÿ7A:;;4;Fÿ5464A:9ÿ794@<ÿ4;@9<:5<5>ÿ9:454;Fÿ2=<ÿ57<@2<9ÿ8Rÿ:ÿ78554QA<ÿ:;24N29?52
`E48A:248;X
`efghijhgÿlhminohgÿphgÿqrÿsrhpjrtÿhiÿufghijhgvwhminohgxymfqrvpfov
`&
`
` -
`
`
`
`Case 1:22-cv-00252-MSG Document 59-4 Filed 03/02/23 Page 6 of 6 PageID #: 1045
`2/24/23, 91@AWBE 1:22-cv-O02babSéiaGis abaeinavend GYrded’ follaGAwOBeibie Rag~evacaleGokayeliidstén GOES
`
`Show 51 comments
`
`
` ÿ ÿ
`
`0123ÿ56ÿ72889:;<
`
`
` ÿ ÿÿ ÿÿÿ ÿÿ !"#ÿ$ÿ ÿ%ÿ&ÿ' ÿ( )
`=>?>@ÿBCDECFÿGHCIJÿKJLMNÿONPEFJPDQÿRRS
`
`©2023 Boston Globe Media Partners, LLC
`
`https:/Avww.bostonglobe.com/2023/0 1/25/business/two-senators-accuse-moderna-greed-its-plan-quadruple-covid-vaccine-cost/?event=event12
`
`&
`
`5/5
`
`- -
`
`