Case 1:14-cv-01430-LPS Document 329-1 Filed 09/01/20 Page 1 of 13 PageID #: 21395
`
`Exhibit 1
`
`

`

`Case 1:14-cv-01430-LPS Document 329-1 Filed 09/01/20 Page 2 of 13 PageID #: 21396
`
`Jung, Soyoung
`From:
`Sent:
`To:
`Cc:
`Subject:
`
`Alfonso Chan <achan@shorechan.com>
`Tuesday, August 25, 2020 7:40 AM
`Jung, Soyoung
`Nosson Knobloch; Patel, Anand; Soobert, Allan M.; Citroen, Phillip W.; Joseph DePumpo
`[EXT] RE: Elm 3DS v. Samsung
`
`Soyoung, 
` 
`
` is still considering the situation but in the meantime maintains its objection to production. 
`
` position on the issue by COB today if possible.  Any opposition to Elm’s letter is due 
`
` 
`If Elm is moving the court for an order to compel, why doesn’t Elm also ask for the court to sign the stipulation motion 
`for protective order? That would at least solve 
` issue. 
` 
`Sincerely, 
`Alfonso 
` 
`From: Jung, Soyoung <soyoungjung@paulhastings.com>  
`Sent: Monday, August 24, 2020 2:59 PM 
`To: Alfonso Chan <achan@shorechan.com> 
`Cc: Nosson Knobloch <nosson.knobloch@bartlitbeck.com>; Patel, Anand <anandpatel@paulhastings.com>; Soobert, 
`Allan M. <allansoobert@paulhastings.com>; Phillip Citroen <phillipcitroen@paulhastings.com> 
`Subject: RE: Elm 3DS v. Samsung 
` 
`Alfonso, 
` 
`Please let us know 
`tomorrow. 
` 
`Thanks, 
`Soyoung 
` 
`From: Alfonso Chan <achan@shorechan.com>  
`Sent: Friday, August 21, 2020 12:39 PM 
`To: Jung, Soyoung <soyoungjung@paulhastings.com> 
`Cc: Nosson Knobloch <nosson.knobloch@bartlitbeck.com>; Patel, Anand <anandpatel@paulhastings.com>; Soobert, 
`Allan M. <allansoobert@paulhastings.com>; Citroen, Phillip W. <phillipcitroen@paulhastings.com> 
`Subject: [EXT] RE: Elm 3DS v. Samsung 
` 
`Please circle back with me on Monday 8/24. 
` 
`From: Alfonso Chan  
`Sent: Friday, August 21, 2020 2:31 PM 
`To: Jung, Soyoung <soyoungjung@paulhastings.com> 
`Cc: Nosson Knobloch <nosson.knobloch@bartlitbeck.com>; Patel, Anand <anandpatel@paulhastings.com>; Soobert, 
`Allan M. <allansoobert@paulhastings.com>; Phillip Citroen <phillipcitroen@paulhastings.com> 
`Subject: RE: Elm 3DS v. Samsung 
` 
`
`1
`
`

`

`Case 1:14-cv-01430-LPS Document 329-1 Filed 09/01/20 Page 3 of 13 PageID #: 21397
`
`.  
`
`Please allow me to consult with my client 
` 
`From: Jung, Soyoung <soyoungjung@paulhastings.com>  
`Sent: Friday, August 21, 2020 1:53 PM 
`To: Alfonso Chan <achan@shorechan.com> 
`Cc: Nosson Knobloch <nosson.knobloch@bartlitbeck.com>; Patel, Anand <anandpatel@paulhastings.com>; Soobert, 
`Allan M. <allansoobert@paulhastings.com>; Phillip Citroen <phillipcitroen@paulhastings.com> 
`Subject: RE: Elm 3DS v. Samsung 
` 
`Alfonso, 
` 
`Please see attached Elm’s discovery letter to the Court asking for an order that Samsung produce confidential 
`documents subject to NDAs, third party objections or other restrictions.  In the letter, Elm refers to Samsung’s last 
`remaining license agreement with 
`, which we have not yet produced given 
` continued objection.  If 
` wishes to respond to Elm’s discovery motion and be heard by the Court on the issue, please feel free to submit 
`an opposition letter, which is due on August 25.  Otherwise, please let us know if we have 
` consent to produce 
`this agreement, so that this issue can be resolved before the discovery teleconference on September 1.   
` 
`Best, 
`Soyoung 
` 
`From: Alfonso Chan <achan@shorechan.com>  
`Sent: Friday, August 14, 2020 7:15 AM 
`To: Jung, Soyoung <soyoungjung@paulhastings.com> 
`Cc: Nosson Knobloch <nosson.knobloch@bartlitbeck.com>; Patel, Anand <anandpatel@paulhastings.com>; Soobert, 
`Allan M. <allansoobert@paulhastings.com>; Citroen, Phillip W. <phillipcitroen@paulhastings.com> 
`Subject: [EXT] RE: Elm 3DS v. Samsung 
` 
`Thanks for your letter. 
`
` I
`
` have not yet heard back from 
`
` but will check again and keep you posted. 
`
` 
`From: Jung, Soyoung <soyoungjung@paulhastings.com>  
`Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2020 6:31 PM 
`To: Alfonso Chan <achan@shorechan.com> 
`Cc: Nosson Knobloch <nosson.knobloch@bartlitbeck.com>; Patel, Anand <anandpatel@paulhastings.com>; Soobert, 
`Allan M. <allansoobert@paulhastings.com>; Phillip Citroen <phillipcitroen@paulhastings.com> 
`Subject: RE: Elm 3DS v. Samsung 
` 
`Thanks Alfonso.   I’ve attached for 
`agreement.  
` 
`Have you heard from 
` 
`From: Alfonso Chan <achan@shorechan.com>  
`Sent: Thursday, August 13, 2020 9:39 AM 
`To: Jung, Soyoung <soyoungjung@paulhastings.com> 
`Cc: Nosson Knobloch <nosson.knobloch@bartlitbeck.com>; Patel, Anand <anandpatel@paulhastings.com>; Soobert, 
`Allan M. <allansoobert@paulhastings.com>; Citroen, Phillip W. <phillipcitroen@paulhastings.com> 
`Subject: [EXT] RE: Elm 3DS v. Samsung 
` 
`
` records a PDF of the letter.  We will proceed with producing the license 
`
`?   
`
`2
`
`

`

`Case 1:14-cv-01430-LPS Document 329-1 Filed 09/01/20 Page 4 of 13 PageID #: 21398
`
`UNM concurs. 
` 
`From: Jung, Soyoung <soyoungjung@paulhastings.com>  
`Sent: Wednesday, August 12, 2020 11:33 PM 
`To: Alfonso Chan <achan@shorechan.com> 
`Cc: Nosson Knobloch <nosson.knobloch@bartlitbeck.com>; Patel, Anand <anandpatel@paulhastings.com>; Soobert, 
`Allan M. <allansoobert@paulhastings.com>; Phillip Citroen <phillipcitroen@paulhastings.com> 
`Subject: RE: Elm 3DS v. Samsung 
` 
`Alfonso, 
` 
`Please find attached a draft letter for 
` 
`Thanks, 
`Soyoung 
` 
`From: Alfonso Chan <achan@shorechan.com>  
`Sent: Friday, July 31, 2020 1:06 PM 
`To: Jung, Soyoung <soyoungjung@paulhastings.com> 
`Cc: Nosson Knobloch <nosson.knobloch@bartlitbeck.com>; Patel, Anand <anandpatel@paulhastings.com>; Soobert, 
`Allan M. <allansoobert@paulhastings.com>; Citroen, Phillip W. <phillipcitroen@paulhastings.com> 
`Subject: [EXT] RE: Elm 3DS v. Samsung 
` 
`
` review.    
`
` so I 
`
` has agreed in principle. Please send me a letter directed to 
`may obtain their final approval. 
`
` am still waiting to hear back from 
`
`.  
`
` I
`
` 
`From: Alfonso Chan  
`Sent: Thursday, July 30, 2020 10:58 AM 
`To: Jung, Soyoung <soyoungjung@paulhastings.com> 
`Cc: Nosson Knobloch <nosson.knobloch@bartlitbeck.com>; Patel, Anand <anandpatel@paulhastings.com>; Soobert, 
`Allan M. <allansoobert@paulhastings.com>; Phillip Citroen <phillipcitroen@paulhastings.com> 
`Subject: RE: Elm 3DS v. Samsung 
`
` I
`
` am waiting to hear back from 
`
`. I will update you as soon as I receive feedback. 
`
` 
`From: Jung, Soyoung <soyoungjung@paulhastings.com>  
`Sent: Friday, July 24, 2020 5:39 PM 
`To: Alfonso Chan <achan@shorechan.com> 
`Cc: Nosson Knobloch <nosson.knobloch@bartlitbeck.com>; Patel, Anand <anandpatel@paulhastings.com>; Soobert, 
`Allan M. <allansoobert@paulhastings.com>; Phillip Citroen <phillipcitroen@paulhastings.com> 
`Subject: RE: Elm 3DS v. Samsung 
` 
`Alfonso, 
` 
`Please find attached a draft letter pursuant to the parties’ discussion on the production of Samsung’s license agreement 
`with 
` in this litigation.  
` 
`Please let us know if have any comments.  If you approve, we can also prepare a similar letter for the production of your 
`client 
` license agreement, which you emailed me about last week.  
`
`3
`
`

`

`Case 1:14-cv-01430-LPS Document 329-1 Filed 09/01/20 Page 5 of 13 PageID #: 21399
`
` 
`Best, 
`Soyoung  
` 
`‐‐‐‐‐Original Appointment‐‐‐‐‐ 
`From: Patel, Anand <anandpatel@paulhastings.com>  
`Sent: Friday, June 26, 2020 12:14 PM 
`To: Nosson Knobloch; Alfonso Chan; Soobert, Allan M.; Citroen, Phillip W.; Jung, Soyoung 
`Subject: Elm 3DS v. Samsung 
`When: Monday, June 29, 2020 1:30 PM‐2:00 PM (UTC‐05:00) Eastern Time (US & Canada). 
`Where:  
` 
` 
` 
`-- Do not delete or change any of the following text. --    
`Join meeting in my PHMeet Personal Room
`
`Meeting number (access code): 928 672 424
`
`
`Join
`
`
`
`
`Join by phone
`Tap to call in from a mobile device (attendees only)
`+1‐415‐655‐0003 United States TOLL
`+1‐855‐282‐6330 United States TOLL FREE
`Access code: 928 672 424
`Global call‐in numbers | Toll‐free calling restrictions
`
`Join from a video conferencing system or application
`Dial anandpatel@phmeet.webex.com
`You can also dial 173.243.2.68 and enter your meeting number.
`If you are the host, you can also enter your host PIN in your video conferencing system or application to start
`the meeting.
`Join using Microsoft Lync or Microsoft Skype for Business
`Dial anandpatel.phmeet@lync.webex.com
`
`
`
`
`
`This meeting may be recorded. Need help? Go to http://help.webex.com
`
`
`
`
`
` 
`
`
`******************************************************************************************
`This message is sent by a law firm and may contain information that is privileged or confidential. If you received
`this transmission in error, please notify the sender by reply e-mail and delete the message and any attachments.
`If you reply to this message, Paul Hastings may collect personal information including your name, business name
`4
`
`

`

`Case 1:14-cv-01430-LPS Document 329-1 Filed 09/01/20 Page 6 of 13 PageID #: 21400
`
`and other contact details, and IP address. For more information about Paul Hastings’ information collection, privacy
`and security principles please click HERE. If you have any questions, please contact Privacy@paulhastings.com.
`
`******************************************************************************************
`This message is sent by a law firm and may contain information that is privileged or confidential. If you received
`this transmission in error, please notify the sender by reply e-mail and delete the message and any attachments.
`If you reply to this message, Paul Hastings may collect personal information including your name, business name
`and other contact details, and IP address. For more information about Paul Hastings’ information collection, privacy
`and security principles please click HERE. If you have any questions, please contact Privacy@paulhastings.com.
`
`******************************************************************************************
`This message is sent by a law firm and may contain information that is privileged or confidential. If you received
`this transmission in error, please notify the sender by reply e-mail and delete the message and any attachments.
`If you reply to this message, Paul Hastings may collect personal information including your name, business name
`and other contact details, and IP address. For more information about Paul Hastings’ information collection, privacy
`and security principles please click HERE. If you have any questions, please contact Privacy@paulhastings.com.
`
`******************************************************************************************
`This message is sent by a law firm and may contain information that is privileged or confidential. If you received
`this transmission in error, please notify the sender by reply e-mail and delete the message and any attachments.
`If you reply to this message, Paul Hastings may collect personal information including your name, business name
`and other contact details, and IP address. For more information about Paul Hastings’ information collection, privacy
`and security principles please click HERE. If you have any questions, please contact Privacy@paulhastings.com.
`
`******************************************************************************************
`This message is sent by a law firm and may contain information that is privileged or confidential. If you received
`this transmission in error, please notify the sender by reply e-mail and delete the message and any attachments.
`If you reply to this message, Paul Hastings may collect personal information including your name, business name
`and other contact details, and IP address. For more information about Paul Hastings’ information collection, privacy
`and security principles please click HERE. If you have any questions, please contact Privacy@paulhastings.com.
`
`5
`
`

`

`Case 1:14-cv-01430-LPS Document 329-1 Filed 09/01/20 Page 7 of 13 PageID #: 21401
`
`Exhibit 2
`
`

`

`Case 1:14-cv-01430-LPS Document 329-1 Filed 09/01/20 Page 8 of 13 PageID #: 21402
`
`
`
`
`
`1(213) 683-6211
`soyoungjung@paulhastings.com
`
`
`July 24, 2020
`
`CONFIDENTIAL
`VIA EMAIL
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`Re:
`
`Elm 3DS Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Elecs. Co. Ltd., et al., No. 14-cv-1430
`
`Dear
`
`,
`
`We represent the parties in the above-captioned litigation in the District of Delaware.
`
`In connection with the litigation, and as discussed with your counsel, Samsung identified
`
` as a document responsive to Elm’s discovery requests.
`In compliance with its discovery obligations, Samsung would like to produce the license to Elm.
`
`
`
` has some concerns regarding the status of the protective order
`We understand that
`applicable to this dispute. As you might know, the parties proposed a protective order (D.I. 117,
`attached as Exhibit A), which the Court adopted by a docket-only order on May 6, 2016. The
`parties therefore understand that protective order to be effective and have been operating under
`that protective order since the Court’s adoption.
`
`For the avoidance of doubt, the parties understand the protective order to apply to third-party
`productions (see paragraph VI), including any production made by
`. As such, should
` decide to produce the Agreement, the parties will treat it as “Protected Information”
`under the protective order and will take all necessary steps to protect
` proprietary
`information.
` will be protected by all of the remedies and relief provided by the
`protective order, should any issues arise.
`
`Please let us know if this resolves your concerns.
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`Case 1:14-cv-01430-LPS Document 329-1 Filed 09/01/20 Page 9 of 13 PageID #: 21403
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`July 24, 2020
`Page 2
`
`
`Sincerely,
`
`/s/ Soyoung Jung
`
`Soyoung Jung
`of PAUL HASTINGS LLP
`
`Counsel for Samsung
`
`
`cc:
`
`Alfonso Chan
`Shore Chan Bragalone LLP
`901 Main St., Suite 3300
`Dallas, TX 75202
`
`
`
`/s/ Nosson D. Knobloch
`
`Nosson Knobloch
`of BARTLIT BECK LLP
`
`Counsel for Elm
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`Case 1:14-cv-01430-LPS Document 329-1 Filed 09/01/20 Page 10 of 13 PageID #: 21404
`
`Exhibit 3
`
`

`

`Case 1:14-cv-01430-LPS Document 329-1 Filed 09/01/20 Page 11 of 13 PageID #: 21405
`
`Jung, Soyoung
`From:
`Sent:
`To:
`Cc:
`Subject:
`
`Citroen, Phillip W.
`Monday, July 13, 2020 7:37 PM
`Nosson Knobloch; Soobert, Allan M.; ServicePH Samsung-ELM 3DS
`Mailing List - Leedy; Michael J. Farnan; Brian Farnan
`RE: Samsung Product Samples
`
`Nosson, 
`
`  
`Please see the table at the end of this email regarding memory products and our notes below. 
`
`  
`First, the last four products are packed, sealed, and sold in bulk using tape and reel. These products are not sold 
`individually. We are investigating what options exist, if any, for buying these products in smaller quantities. 
`
`  
`Second, Samsung believes the following products are subject to NDAs. Samsung is collecting the NDAs so we can 
`determine next steps. 
`  
`
`  
`
`Third, as you can see in the table, Samsung proposes alternatives for certain products. 
`
`  
`Fourth, we should have the inventory of image sensor products to you in another day or two. 
`
`  
`Thanks, 
`Phillip 
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` 
` 
` 
` 
`
` 
` 
`
`1
`
`

`

`Case 1:14-cv-01430-LPS Document 329-1 Filed 09/01/20 Page 12 of 13 PageID #: 21406
`
` 
`From: Nosson Knobloch <nosson.knobloch@bartlitbeck.com>  
`Sent: Sunday, July 5, 2020 3:00 PM 
`To: Citroen, Phillip W. <phillipcitroen@paulhastings.com>; Soobert, Allan M. <allansoobert@paulhastings.com>; Patel, 
`Anand <anandpatel@paulhastings.com>; ServicePH Samsung‐ELM 3DS <ServicePHSamsung‐
`ELM3DS@paulhastings.com> 
`Cc: Mailing List ‐ Leedy <leedy@bartlit‐beck.com>; Michael J. Farnan <mfarnan@farnanlaw.com>; Brian Farnan 
`<bfarnan@farnanlaw.com> 
`Subject: [EXT] Samsung Product Samples 
` 
`Counsel,
`
` I
`
` hope you are all enjoying this Holiday weekend. As discussed on our last call, I’ve pasted
`below a list of products for which Elm would like Samsung to produce samples as soon as
`possible. As discussed, we’d like at least 6 samples of each product.
`
`Please let me know when you can provide these samples to us.
`
`Thanks,
`
`-Nosson
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`2
`
`

`

`Case 1:14-cv-01430-LPS Document 329-1 Filed 09/01/20 Page 13 of 13 PageID #: 21407
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`3
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`BartlitBeck LLP
` 
`Nosson D. Knobloch | p: 303.592.3122 | c: 773.301.2851 | Nosson.Knobloch@BartlitBeck.com | 1801 Wewatta Street, 12th Floor, Denver, CO
`80202
`This message may contain confidential and privileged information. If it has been sent to you in error, please reply to advise the sender of the error and then immediately delete this
`message. 
` 
`
`
`
`
`
`