`
`
`
`January 31, 2020
`
`Via E-Filing
`The Honorable Leonard P. Stark
`J. Caleb Boggs Federal Building
`844 N. King Street
`Room 6124, Unit 26
`Wilmington, DE 19801-3556
`
`
`
`Re: Elm 3DS Innovations, LLC v. Samsung Elecs. Co. Ltd., et al.,
`C.A. No. 14-cv-1430-LPS
`
`
`Dear Chief Judge Stark,
`
`The parties in the above-referenced matter write to request the scheduling of a discovery
`teleconference.
`
`The following attorneys participated in a verbal meet and confer by telephone on December
`18, 2019:
`
`Delaware Counsel for Elm: Michael Farnan
`Lead Counsel for Elm: Nosson Knobloch
`Delaware Counsel for Samsung: Adam Poff
`Lead Counsel for Samsung: Phillip Citroen, Soyoung Jung and Allan Soobert
`
`
`
`In addition, the following attorneys participated in a verbal meet and confer by telephone on
`December 13, 2019:
`
`Delaware Counsel for Elm: Michael Farnan
`Lead Counsel for Elm: Nosson Knobloch
`Delaware Counsel for Samsung: Adam Poff
`Lead Counsel for Samsung: Soyoung Jung and Allan Soobert
`
`
`In addition, the following attorneys participated in a verbal meet and confer by telephone on
`December 9, 2019:
`
`Delaware Counsel for Elm: Brian Farnan
`Lead Counsel for Elm: Nosson Knobloch
`Delaware Counsel for Samsung: Adam Poff
`Lead Counsel for Samsung: Soyoung Jung and Phillip Citroen
`
`
`In addition, the following attorneys participated in a verbal meet-and-confer by telephone on
`October 24, 2019:
`
`
`Lead Counsel for Elm: Nosson Knobloch
`Lead Counsel for Samsung: Soyoung Jung and Phillip Citroen
`
`9 1 9 N . M A R K E T S T R E E T , 1 2 T H F L O O R , W I L M I N G T O N , D E 1 9 8 0 1
`P H O N E : ( 3 0 2 ) 7 7 7 – 0 3 0 0 · F A X : ( 3 0 2 ) 7 7 7 – 0 3 0 1 · W W W . F A R N A N L A W . C O M
`
`
`
`Case 1:14-cv-01430-LPS Document 244 Filed 01/31/20 Page 2 of 2 PageID #: 18082
`
`
`
`
`The following attorneys also participated in a verbal meet-and-confer by telephone on September 3,
`2019:
`
`
`Delaware Counsel for Elm: Michael Farnan
`Lead Counsel for Elm: Nosson Knobloch
`Delaware Counsel for Samsung: Adam Poff
`Lead Counsel for Samsung: Soyoung Jung and Phillip Citroen
`
`The above-named attorneys have also exchanged numerous emails and letters addressing these
`issues.
`
`There are three disputes requiring judicial attention:
`
`
`1. Samsung’s November 15, 2019 Objections and Responses to Elm’s Third Set of
`Common Interrogatories, and Elm’s efforts to obtain discovery about Samsung’s US
`and worldwide revenue.
`
`2. Samsung’s December 5, 2019 Objections and Responses to Elm’s Fourth Set of
`Interrogatories to Samsung, and Elm’s efforts to obtain discovery about Samsung’s
`revenue for components manufactured in or supplied from the United States.
`
`3. Whether issues 1 and 2 are mooted by Samsung’s commitment to produce the data
`and information responsive to them by no later than February 14.
`
`
`
`
`
`Counsel of Record (via E-File)
`
`
`cc:
`
`
`
`Respectfully submitted,
`
`/s/ Brian E. Farnan
`
`Brian E. Farnan
`
`2
`
`