Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 1 of 29
`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page1 of 29
`
`EXHIBIT A-2
`EXHIBIT A-2
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 2 of 29
`5/28/2021
`LT - 228544
`
`Invoice:
`228544 (pending 0 days)
`
`TAX
`FEES EXPENSES
`TOTAL
`Billed $3,659.50 $3,659.50
`$0.00 $0.00
`Adjustments
`$0.00
`$0.00
`$0.00 $0.00
`Discounts
`$0.00
`$0.00
`$0.00 $0.00
`Total
` Co Matter: REALTIME DATA LLC dba
`Invoice Tracker ID: 1515586 Vendor: Wheeler Trigg O'Don (Denver)
` Co Matter ID: 2018-00243 LF Matter: RealTime Data Country:
`IXO adv. DISH Network Corporation et al
`United States
`
`FY MATTER
`$3,659.50 $3,659.50
`$0.00
`$0.00
`
`BUDGET
`Spend.
`Var.
`
`Inv. date: 05/28/21
`Inv. period: 04/07/21 - 04/30/21
`AP: --
`Inv. paid: --
` P.O.:
`Inv. Reference: --
`
`Comments: to Firm (0) Show comments
`Description: April 2021 Services
`
`APPROVERS & APPROVAL HISTORY
`
`Inv. posted: 05/28/21
`
`Inv. approved: --
`
`
`
`Inv. sent to
`
`Action Name
`
`Status
`
`Total
`
`Fees Expenses Comment
`
`Nancy
`Castilleja
`
`Posted(Uploaded By)
`05/28/2021
`
`$3,659.50 $3,659.50
`
`$0.00
`
`--
`
`INVOICE ANALYSIS
`
`Taxes
`Amount Not Taxed: $3,659.50
`
`OTHER INVOICE AND FIRM INFORMATION
`
`Matter ID:
`
`2018-00243
`
`Firm Internal Matter Name: RealTime Data
`
`Firm Client # | Matter #:
`
`06353 | 06353.0015
`
`Vendor Tax ID:
`
`20-0697269
`
`VAT ID:
`
`GST ID:
`
`HST ID:
`
`PST ID:
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`https://us.legaltracker.thomsonreuters.com/tracker/Invoice/Info?id=1515586
`
`1/3
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 3 of 29
`5/28/2021
`LT - 228544
`
`Sales Tax ID:
`
`QST ID:
`
`Withholding Tax ID:
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`Invoice Type:
`
`LEDES 1998B
`
`Tax Point Date:
`
`Regulatory Statement:
`
`Engagement Letter:
`
`Tax Rules Enforced:
`
`Fee Arrangements:
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`none
`
`--
`
`FIRM REMITTANCE ADDRESS
`
`Street 1:
`
`Street 2:
`
`Street 3:
`
`Street 4:
`
`Street 5:
`
`Street 6:
`
`City:
`
`State:
`
`PO Box 17782
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`Denver
`
`Colorado
`
`Zip/Postal Code: 80217-0782
`
`Country:
`
`United States
`
`BILLED TO
`
`Tax ID:
`
`Name:
`
`Street 1:
`
`Street 2:
`
`City:
`
`State:
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`https://us.legaltracker.thomsonreuters.com/tracker/Invoice/Info?id=1515586
`
`2/3
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 4 of 29
`
`
`
`370 17th Street, Suite 4500
`Denver, CO 80202-5647
`Telephone: (303) 244-1800
`
`Lawrence R. Katzin Esq.
`Vice President and Associate General Counsel
`DISH Network L.L.C.
`PO Box 6655
`Englewood, CO 80155
`
`Tax ID# 20-0697269
`Please remit to:
`P.O. Box 17782
`Denver, CO 80217-0782
`
`Invoice No:
`
`Matter ID:
`
`May 28, 2021
`228544
`
`06353.0015
`
`CONFIDENTIAL/PRIVILEGED
`ATTORNEY/CLIENT COMMUNICATION
`
`For professional services rendered through April 30, 2021
`
`Regarding: Realtime Adaptive Streaming LLC
`Claim No.: 2018-00243
`
`DATE
`
`04/07/21
`
`04/07/21
`
`04/08/21
`
`04/08/21
`
`04/10/21
`
`04/13/21
`
`04/13/21
`
`TIMEKEEPER
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Prepare for and participate in telephone conference with client and co-
`counsel regarding case status and strategy.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with Messrs. L. Katzin and R. Cordell regarding new
`matter.
`
`S. Gottesfeld
`Preparation of initial deadline chart after review of court order concerning
`deadlines and review of judge's practice standards.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review docket and courtroom minutes.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Email to Mr. L. Katzin regarding conflict issue and meeting.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with Mr. L. Katzin regarding conflict waiver.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with Mr. J. Day regarding conflict waiver.
`
`HOURS
`
`AMOUNT
`
`0.70
`
`479.50
`
`0.30
`
`205.50
`
`1.00
`
`220.00
`
`0.40
`
`0.20
`
`0.10
`
`0.20
`
`274.00
`
`137.00
`
`68.50
`
`137.00
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 5 of 29
`
`Wheeler Trigg O’Donnell LLP
`May 28, 2021
`Page: 2
`
`Invoice:
`Matter ID:
`
`228544
`06353.0015
`
`DATE
`04/14/21
`
`04/14/21
`
`04/14/21
`
`04/16/21
`
`04/21/21
`
`04/26/21
`
`04/28/21
`
`04/29/21
`
`04/30/21
`
`04/30/21
`
`TIMEKEEPER
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with Mr. L. Katzin regarding case background.
`
`HOURS
`0.20
`
`AMOUNT
`137.00
`
`S. Gottesfeld
`Revise litigation timeline and calendar to reflect current deadlines.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Prepare for and participate in weekly status call with Fish Richardson.
`
`S. Gottesfeld
`Review court's docket sheet to determine pertinent pleadings needed for
`attorney review and analysis.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Prepare for and participate in weekly status call with defense team.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review email and documents from A. Shartzer.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Prepare for and participate in weekly defense counsel call.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Emails with A. Shartzer and L. Matheo regarding mock trial.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Email to co-counsel regarding mock trial.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with Ms. L. DeCaro of Courtroom Performance
`regarding mock trial.
`
`0.60
`
`0.50
`
`0.40
`
`0.70
`
`0.30
`
`0.40
`
`0.30
`
`0.20
`
`0.20
`
`132.00
`
`342.50
`
`88.00
`
`479.50
`
`205.50
`
`274.00
`
`205.50
`
`137.00
`
`137.00
`
`TIMEKEEPER
`
`RANK
`
`Hugh Q. Gottschalk
`
`Sharon A. Gottesfeld
`
`Total All Timekeepers
`
`Partner
`
`Paralegal
`
`Sub-Total Fees:
`
`3,659.50
`
`TIMEKEEPER SUMMARY
`
`HOURS
`WORKED
`
`BILLED PER
`HOUR
`
`BILL
`AMOUNT
`
`4.70
`
`2.00
`
`6.70
`
`Total Current Charges:
`Previous Balance Due:
`Total Due for this Matter:
`
`685.00
`
`220.00
`
`$
`
`$
`
`$
`
`$
`$
`$
`
`3,219.50
`
`440.00
`
`3,659.50
`
`3,659.50
`0.00
`3,659.50
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 6 of 29
`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page6 of 29
`
`Wheeler Trigg O’Donnell LLP
`May28, 2021
`
`Page: 3
`
`Invoice:
`Matter ID:
`
`228544
`06353.0015
`
`ACH/Wire Instructions — Please Remit in US Dollars
`
`
`Wheeler Trigg O’Donnell LLP Operating Account
`UMBBankColorado,n.a.
`ABA
`1010 Grand Bivd.
`Acct
`Kansas City, MO 64106
`Please include invoice #228544 on paymen
`
`
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 7 of 29
`6/22/2021
`LT - 229119
`
`Invoice:
`229119 (pending 0 days)
`
`TAX
`FEES EXPENSES
`TOTAL
`Billed $3,966.50 $3,966.50
`$0.00 $0.00
`Adjustments
`$0.00
`$0.00
`$0.00 $0.00
`Discounts
`$0.00
`$0.00
`$0.00 $0.00
`Total
` Co Matter: REALTIME DATA LLC dba
`Invoice Tracker ID: 1543915 Vendor: Wheeler Trigg O'Don (Denver)
` Co Matter ID: 2018-00243 LF Matter: RealTime Data Country:
`IXO adv. DISH Network Corporation et al
`United States
`
`FY MATTER
`$7,626.00 $7,626.00
`$0.00
`$0.00
`
`BUDGET
`Spend.
`Var.
`
`Inv. date: 06/22/21
`Inv. period: 05/04/21 - 05/31/21
`AP: --
`Inv. paid: --
` P.O.:
`Inv. Reference: --
`
`Comments: to Firm (0) Show comments
`Description: May 2021 Services
`
`APPROVERS & APPROVAL HISTORY
`
`Inv. posted: 06/22/21
`
`Inv. approved: --
`
`
`
`Inv. sent to
`
`Action Name
`
`Status
`
`Total
`
`Fees Expenses Comment
`
`Nancy
`Castilleja
`
`Posted(Uploaded By)
`06/22/2021
`
`$3,966.50 $3,966.50
`
`$0.00
`
`--
`
`INVOICE ANALYSIS
`
`Taxes
`Amount Not Taxed: $3,966.50
`
`OTHER INVOICE AND FIRM INFORMATION
`
`Matter ID:
`
`2018-00243
`
`Firm Internal Matter Name: RealTime Data
`
`Firm Client # | Matter #:
`
`06353 | 06353.0015
`
`Vendor Tax ID:
`
`20-0697269
`
`VAT ID:
`
`GST ID:
`
`HST ID:
`
`PST ID:
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`https://us.legaltracker.thomsonreuters.com/tracker/Invoice/Info?id=1543915
`
`1/3
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 8 of 29
`6/22/2021
`LT - 229119
`
`Sales Tax ID:
`
`QST ID:
`
`Withholding Tax ID:
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`Invoice Type:
`
`LEDES 1998B
`
`Tax Point Date:
`
`Regulatory Statement:
`
`Engagement Letter:
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`Tax Rules Enforced:
`
`none
`
`Fee Arrangements:
`
`Fee Arrangement
`Standard hourly rates
`
`Fee Comment Details
`
`FIRM REMITTANCE ADDRESS
`
`Street 1:
`
`Street 2:
`
`Street 3:
`
`Street 4:
`
`Street 5:
`
`Street 6:
`
`City:
`
`State:
`
`PO Box 17782
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`Denver
`
`Colorado
`
`Zip/Postal Code: 80217-0782
`
`Country:
`
`United States
`
`BILLED TO
`
`Tax ID:
`
`Name:
`
`Street 1:
`
`Street 2:
`
`City:
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`https://us.legaltracker.thomsonreuters.com/tracker/Invoice/Info?id=1543915
`
`2/3
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 9 of 29
`
`
`
`370 17th Street, Suite 4500
`Denver, CO 80202-5647
`Telephone: (303) 244-1800
`
`Lawrence R. Katzin Esq.
`Vice President and Associate General Counsel
`DISH Network L.L.C.
`PO Box 6655
`Englewood, CO 80155
`
`Tax ID# 20-0697269
`Please remit to:
`P.O. Box 17782
`Denver, CO 80217-0782
`
`Invoice No:
`
`Matter ID:
`
`June 22, 2021
`229119
`
`06353.0015
`
`CONFIDENTIAL/PRIVILEGED
`ATTORNEY/CLIENT COMMUNICATION
`
`For professional services rendered through May 31, 2021
`
`Regarding: Realtime Adaptive Streaming LLC
`Claim No.: 2018-00243
`
`DATE
`
`05/04/21
`
`05/04/21
`
`05/05/21
`
`05/05/21
`
`05/07/21
`
`05/19/21
`
`05/24/21
`
`TIMEKEEPER
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Prepare for and participate in telephone conference with defense counsel
`regarding mock trial planning.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review Notice letters to Judge Jackson regarding Motions to Dismiss.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Send background materials to co-counsel.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with Ms. L. DeCaro of Courtroom Performance
`regarding mock trial.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Prepare for and participate in Zoom meeting with Ms. L. DeCaro and co-
`counsel regarding mock trial exercise.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Prepare for and participate in telephone conference with co-counsel
`regarding mock trial and trial preparation.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Emails with co-counsel and Ms. C. Cheng regarding Judge Jackson motion
`procedures.
`
`HOURS
`
`AMOUNT
`
`1.00
`
`685.00
`
`0.40
`
`0.20
`
`0.40
`
`274.00
`
`137.00
`
`274.00
`
`0.60
`
`411.00
`
`0.80
`
`548.00
`
`0.30
`
`205.50
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 10 of 29
`
`Wheeler Trigg O’Donnell LLP
`June 22, 2021
`Page: 2
`
`Invoice:
`Matter ID:
`
`229119
`06353.0015
`
`DATE
`05/24/21
`
`05/25/21
`
`05/25/21
`
`05/26/21
`
`05/26/21
`
`05/26/21
`
`05/26/21
`
`TIMEKEEPER
`C. Cheng
`Correspond with Mr. A. Shartzer and Mr. D. Tishman regarding local
`practice for submission of attorney declarations and other local practice for
`summary judgment.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Emails with co-counsel and Ms. C. Cheng regarding motion in limine
`procedures.
`
`C. Cheng
`Review case deadlines and operative pleadings.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding motions in limine.
`
`S. Gottesfeld
`Review court's docket sheet and pull all LOIs and responses to LOIs, as
`well as all other recent filings, and send same to Ms. C. Cheng for her
`review and analysis.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with client and co-counsel regarding motions to
`dismiss and trial planning.
`
`C. Cheng
`Correspond and conference with Fish Richardson team regarding motions
`in limine practice.
`
`05/27/21
`
`C. Cheng
`Analyze dispositive motions filings and letters of intent.
`
`HOURS
`0.10
`
`AMOUNT
`45.50
`
`0.30
`
`205.50
`
`0.30
`
`0.30
`
`0.50
`
`136.50
`
`205.50
`
`110.00
`
`0.40
`
`274.00
`
`0.80
`
`364.00
`
`0.20
`
`91.00
`
`TIMEKEEPER SUMMARY
`
`Sub-Total Fees:
`
`3,966.50
`
`TIMEKEEPER
`
`RANK
`
`HOURS
`WORKED
`
`BILLED PER
`HOUR
`
`BILL
`AMOUNT
`
`Hugh Q. Gottschalk
`
`CiCi Cheng
`
`Sharon A. Gottesfeld
`
`Total All Timekeepers
`
`Partner
`
`Associate
`
`Paralegal
`
`4.70
`
`1.40
`
`0.50
`
`6.60
`
`Total Current Charges:
`Previous Balance Due:
`
`685.00
`
`455.00
`
`220.00
`
`$
`
`$
`
`$
`
`$
`
`$
`$
`
`3,219.50
`
`637.00
`
`110.00
`
`3,966.50
`
`3,966.50
`3,659.50
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 11 of 29
`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 11 of 29
`
`Wheeler Trigg O’Donnell LLP
`June 22, 2021
`
`Page: 3
`
`Invoice:
`MatterID:
`
`229119
`06353.0015
`
`Total Due for this Matter:
`
`$
`
`7,626.00
`
`ACH/Wire Instructions — Please Remit in US Dollars
`
`
`UMBBankColorado,n.a.
`Wheeler Trigg O'Donnell LLP Operating Account
`ABA
`1010 Grand Bivd.
`Kansas City, MO 64106
`Acct
`Please include invoice #229119 on paymen
`
`
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 12 of 29
`7/14/2021
`LT - 229489
`
`Invoice:
`229489 (pending 0 days)
`
`TAX
`FEES EXPENSES
`TOTAL
`Billed $24,941.50 $24,941.50
`$0.00 $0.00
`Adjustments
`$0.00
`$0.00
`$0.00 $0.00
`Discounts
`$0.00
`$0.00
`$0.00 $0.00
`Total
` Co Matter: REALTIME DATA LLC dba
`Invoice Tracker ID: 1565427 Vendor: Wheeler Trigg O'Don (Denver)
` Co Matter ID: 2018-00243 LF Matter: RealTime Data Country:
`IXO adv. DISH Network Corporation et al
`United States
`
`MATTER
`FY
`$32,567.50 $32,567.50
`$0.00
`$0.00
`
`BUDGET
`Spend.
`Var.
`
`Inv. date: 07/14/21
`Inv. period: 06/01/21 - 06/30/21
`AP: --
`Inv. paid: --
` P.O.:
`Inv. Reference: --
`
`Comments: to Firm (0) Show comments
`Description: June 2021 Services
`
`APPROVERS & APPROVAL HISTORY
`
`Inv. posted: 07/14/21
`
`Inv. approved: --
`
`
`
`Inv. sent to
`
`Action Name
`
`Status
`
`Total
`
`Fees Expenses Comment
`
`Nancy
`Castilleja
`
`Posted(Uploaded By)
`07/14/2021
`
`$24,941.50 $24,941.50
`
`$0.00
`
`--
`
`INVOICE ANALYSIS
`
`Taxes
`Amount Not Taxed: $24,941.50
`
`OTHER INVOICE AND FIRM INFORMATION
`
`Matter ID:
`
`2018-00243
`
`Firm Internal Matter Name: RealTime Data
`
`Firm Client # | Matter #:
`
`06353 | 06353.0015
`
`Vendor Tax ID:
`
`20-0697269
`
`VAT ID:
`
`GST ID:
`
`HST ID:
`
`PST ID:
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`https://us.legaltracker.thomsonreuters.com/tracker/Invoice/Info?id=1565427
`
`1/3
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 13 of 29
`7/14/2021
`LT - 229489
`
`Sales Tax ID:
`
`QST ID:
`
`Withholding Tax ID:
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`Invoice Type:
`
`LEDES 1998B
`
`Tax Point Date:
`
`Regulatory Statement:
`
`Engagement Letter:
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`Tax Rules Enforced:
`
`none
`
`Fee Arrangements:
`
`Fee Arrangement
`Standard hourly rates
`
`Fee Comment Details
`
`FIRM REMITTANCE ADDRESS
`
`Street 1:
`
`Street 2:
`
`Street 3:
`
`Street 4:
`
`Street 5:
`
`Street 6:
`
`City:
`
`State:
`
`PO Box 17782
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`Denver
`
`Colorado
`
`Zip/Postal Code: 80217-0782
`
`Country:
`
`United States
`
`BILLED TO
`
`Tax ID:
`
`Name:
`
`Street 1:
`
`Street 2:
`
`City:
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`https://us.legaltracker.thomsonreuters.com/tracker/Invoice/Info?id=1565427
`
`2/3
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 14 of 29
`
`
`
`370 17th Street, Suite 4500
`Denver, CO 80202-5647
`Telephone: (303) 244-1800
`
`Lawrence R. Katzin Esq.
`Vice President and Associate General Counsel
`DISH Network L.L.C.
`PO Box 6655
`Englewood, CO 80155
`
`Tax ID# 20-0697269
`Please remit to:
`P.O. Box 17782
`Denver, CO 80217-0782
`
`Invoice No:
`
`Matter ID:
`
`July 14, 2021
`229489
`
`06353.0015
`
`CONFIDENTIAL/PRIVILEGED
`ATTORNEY/CLIENT COMMUNICATION
`
`For professional services rendered through June 30, 2021
`
`Regarding: Realtime Adaptive Streaming LLC
`Claim No.: 2018-00243
`
`DATE
`
`06/01/21
`
`06/02/21
`
`06/02/21
`
`06/02/21
`
`06/08/21
`
`06/09/21
`
`06/09/21
`
`TIMEKEEPER
`
`S. Gottesfeld
`Revise litigation timeline to reflect response to DISH's summary judgment
`motion.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with clients regarding participation in mock trial.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Email to co-counsel regarding filing and priority of pretrial motions.
`
`C. Cheng
`Email with Mr. A. Shartzer regarding summary judgment motions and
`strategy for refiling.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with Mr. A. Shartzer and Ms. L. DeCaro regarding
`mock trial presentation.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review and finalize entry of appearance.
`
`S. Gottesfeld
`Preparation of entry of appearance for Mr. H. Gottschalk.
`
`HOURS
`
`AMOUNT
`
`0.10
`
`22.00
`
`0.20
`
`0.20
`
`0.20
`
`137.00
`
`137.00
`
`91.00
`
`0.40
`
`274.00
`
`0.10
`
`0.20
`
`68.50
`
`44.00
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 15 of 29
`
`Wheeler Trigg O’Donnell LLP
`July 14, 2021
`Page: 2
`
`Invoice:
`Matter ID:
`
`229489
`06353.0015
`
`DATE
`06/09/21
`
`06/09/21
`
`06/09/21
`
`06/11/21
`
`06/11/21
`
`06/11/21
`
`06/14/21
`
`06/14/21
`
`06/15/21
`
`06/17/21
`
`06/17/21
`
`06/17/21
`
`06/17/21
`
`06/18/21
`
`06/18/21
`
`TIMEKEEPER
`H. Gottschalk
`Prepare for and participate in weekly defense call.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Schedule mock trial prep meeting with Mr. A. Shartzer.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review motion to exclude damages.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Initial review of expert reports.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Prepare for and participate in telephone conference with Mr. A. Shartzer
`regarding mock trial damages presentation and Judge Jackson trial
`procedures.
`
`C. Cheng
`Emails and call with Mr. A. Shartzer and with Mr. D. Tishman regarding trial
`strategy, birfurcation issues, and other pre-trial practices for Judge Jackson.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with Mr. D. Tishman regarding initial damages
`PowerPoint.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review initial damages PowerPoint for mock trial.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review and revise damages declaration for mock trial.
`
`S. Gottesfeld
`Revise notice of USPTO reexamination to comport with court rules.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Email to Mr. A. Shartzer regarding revisions to damages presentation.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review and revise PowerPoint damages presentation.
`
`C. Cheng
`Analyze and revise notice of non-final PTO action for filing.
`
`S. Gottesfeld
`Revise litigation timeline triggered by recent filings.
`
`HOURS
`0.40
`
`AMOUNT
`274.00
`
`0.10
`
`0.20
`
`1.00
`
`1.20
`
`68.50
`
`137.00
`
`685.00
`
`822.00
`
`1.30
`
`591.50
`
`0.10
`
`68.50
`
`0.30
`
`0.80
`
`0.20
`
`0.30
`
`1.30
`
`0.30
`
`0.20
`
`205.50
`
`548.00
`
`44.00
`
`205.50
`
`890.50
`
`136.50
`
`44.00
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review response to motion in limine to exclude Meyer and review Meyer
`expert report.
`
`1.50
`
`1,027.50
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 16 of 29
`
`Wheeler Trigg O’Donnell LLP
`July 14, 2021
`Page: 3
`
`Invoice:
`Matter ID:
`
`229489
`06353.0015
`
`DATE
`06/18/21
`
`06/18/21
`
`06/18/21
`
`06/21/21
`
`06/21/21
`
`06/23/21
`
`06/23/21
`
`06/23/21
`
`06/23/21
`
`06/23/21
`
`06/24/21
`
`06/24/21
`
`06/24/21
`
`06/24/21
`
`06/25/21
`
`TIMEKEEPER
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with Ms. C. Cheng regarding Notice regarding Re-
`examination.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review Notice regarding Re-examination and approve for filing with Court.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review email from Mr. A. Shartzer regarding revisions to PowerPoint
`presentation for mock trial.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review and revise damages presentation for mock trial.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with Mr. D. Tishman regarding damages
`presentation for mock trial.
`
`S. Gottesfeld
`Revise litigation timeline to reflect changes triggered by recent filings.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review Mr. D. Tishman damages PowerPoint for Realtime.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding mock trial.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Work on damages presentations for mock trial.
`
`C. Cheng
`Review stipulation regarding motions in limine, opposing to motion for
`partial summary judgment on affirmative defenses, and other dispositive
`motions filings.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review mock trial presentations.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with Mr. R. Cordell regarding jury trial issues.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conferences with Messrs. D. Tishman and L. Matheo regarding
`mock trial presentations and mock trial schedule.
`
`C. Cheng
`Telephone conference with Fish Richardson team regarding bifurcation and
`other pre-trial issues.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with Messrs. L. Matheo and D. Tishman regarding
`Tishman damages presentation for mock trial.
`
`HOURS
`0.20
`
`AMOUNT
`137.00
`
`0.20
`
`0.70
`
`137.00
`
`479.50
`
`1.50
`
`1,027.50
`
`0.70
`
`479.50
`
`0.20
`
`0.40
`
`0.60
`
`0.70
`
`0.40
`
`0.50
`
`0.40
`
`0.70
`
`44.00
`
`274.00
`
`411.00
`
`479.50
`
`182.00
`
`342.50
`
`274.00
`
`479.50
`
`0.70
`
`318.50
`
`0.40
`
`274.00
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 17 of 29
`
`Wheeler Trigg O’Donnell LLP
`July 14, 2021
`Page: 4
`
`Invoice:
`Matter ID:
`
`229489
`06353.0015
`
`DATE
`06/25/21
`
`06/27/21
`
`06/27/21
`
`06/28/21
`
`06/28/21
`
`06/28/21
`
`06/28/21
`
`06/28/21
`
`06/29/21
`
`06/29/21
`
`06/29/21
`
`06/30/21
`
`06/30/21
`
`TIMEKEEPER
`H. Gottschalk
`Observe D. Tishman damages presentation for mock trial.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with Mr. D. Tishman regarding PowerPoint
`presentation for mock trial.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review and revise PowerPoint presentation for mock trial.
`
`S. Gottesfeld
`Review multiple recent filings and revise litigation timeline to reflect
`changes triggered by same.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with Mr. L. Matheo regarding mock trial schedule.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Prepare for preparation of damages video for mock trial.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Participate in taping of damages video for mock trial and observe validity
`presentations.
`
`C. Cheng
`Review oppositions to motions in limine.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Observe mock trial presentation videos.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with Mr. L. Matheo regarding mock trial logistics.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with Mr. L. Katzin regarding mock trial logistics.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Attend and participate in mock trial.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Prepare for mock trial.
`
`HOURS
`0.80
`
`AMOUNT
`548.00
`
`0.70
`
`479.50
`
`2.50
`
`1,712.50
`
`0.30
`
`66.00
`
`0.40
`
`274.00
`
`1.50
`
`1,027.50
`
`4.50
`
`3,082.50
`
`0.30
`
`136.50
`
`1.50
`
`1,027.50
`
`0.40
`
`0.30
`
`274.00
`
`205.50
`
`4.20
`
`2,877.00
`
`2.00
`
`1,370.00
`
`Sub-Total Fees:
`
`24,941.50
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 18 of 29
`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 18 of 29
`
`Wheeler Trigg O’Donnell LLP
`July 14, 2021
`
`Page: 5
`
`Invoice:
`Matter ID:
`
`229489
`06353.0015
`
`TIMEKEEPER SUMMARY
`
`TIMEKEEPER
`
`RANK
`
`HOURS
`WORKED
`
`BILLED PER
`HOUR
`
`Hugh Q. Gottschalk
`
`Partner
`
`CiCi Cheng
`
`Associate
`
`Sharon A. Gottesfeld
`
`Paralegal
`
`33.90
`
`3.20
`
`1.20
`
`685.00
`
`455.00
`
`220.00
`
`$
`
`$
`
`$
`
`BILL
`AMOUNT
`
`23,221.50
`
`1,456.00
`
`264.00
`
`
`Total All Timekeepers
`38.30
`$
`24,941.50
`
`Total Current Charges:
`Previous Balance Due:
`Total Due for this Matter:
`
`$
`$
`$
`
`24,941.50
`7,626.00
`32,567.50
`
`ACH/Wire Instructions — Please Remit in US Dollars
`
`
`Wheeler Trigg O’Donnell LLP Operating Account
`UMBBankColorado, n.a.
`ABA
`1010 Grand Bivd.
`Acct
`Kansas City, MO 64106
`Please include invoice #229489 on paymen
`
`
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 19 of 29
`8/6/2021
`LT - 230015
`
`Invoice:
`230015 (pending 0 days)
`
`TAX
`FEES EXPENSES
`TOTAL
`Billed $71,419.00 $71,419.00
`$0.00 $0.00
`Adjustments
`$0.00
`$0.00
`$0.00 $0.00
`Discounts
`$0.00
`$0.00
`$0.00 $0.00
`Total
` Co Matter: REALTIME DATA LLC dba
`Invoice Tracker ID: 1591728 Vendor: Wheeler Trigg O'Don (Denver)
` Co Matter ID: 2018-00243 LF Matter: RealTime Data Country:
`IXO adv. DISH Network Corporation et al
`United States
`
`MATTER
`FY
`$103,986.50 $103,986.50
`$0.00
`$0.00
`
`BUDGET
`Spend.
`Var.
`
`Inv. date: 08/05/21
`Inv. period: 07/01/21 - 07/31/21
`AP: --
`Inv. paid: --
` P.O.:
`Inv. Reference: --
`
`Comments: to Firm (0) Show comments
`Description: August 2021 Services
`
`APPROVERS & APPROVAL HISTORY
`
`Inv. posted: 08/06/21
`
`Inv. approved: --
`
`
`
`Inv. sent to
`
`Action Name
`
`Status
`
`Total
`
`Fees Expenses Comment
`
`Nancy
`Castilleja
`
`Posted(Uploaded By)
`08/06/2021
`
`$71,419.00 $71,419.00
`
`$0.00
`
`--
`
`INVOICE ANALYSIS
`
`Taxes
`Amount Not Taxed: $71,419.00
`
`OTHER INVOICE AND FIRM INFORMATION
`
`Matter ID:
`
`2018-00243
`
`Firm Internal Matter Name: RealTime Data
`
`Firm Client # | Matter #:
`
`06353 | 06353.0015
`
`Vendor Tax ID:
`
`20-0697269
`
`VAT ID:
`
`GST ID:
`
`HST ID:
`
`PST ID:
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`https://us.legaltracker.thomsonreuters.com/tracker/Invoice/Info?id=1591728
`
`1/3
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 20 of 29
`8/6/2021
`LT - 230015
`
`Sales Tax ID:
`
`QST ID:
`
`Withholding Tax ID:
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`Invoice Type:
`
`LEDES 1998B
`
`Tax Point Date:
`
`Regulatory Statement:
`
`Engagement Letter:
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`Tax Rules Enforced:
`
`none
`
`Fee Arrangements:
`
`Fee Arrangement
`Standard hourly rates
`
`Fee Comment Details
`
`FIRM REMITTANCE ADDRESS
`
`Street 1:
`
`Street 2:
`
`Street 3:
`
`Street 4:
`
`Street 5:
`
`Street 6:
`
`City:
`
`State:
`
`PO Box 17782
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`Denver
`
`Colorado
`
`Zip/Postal Code: 80217-0782
`
`Country:
`
`United States
`
`BILLED TO
`
`Tax ID:
`
`Name:
`
`Street 1:
`
`Street 2:
`
`City:
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`--
`
`https://us.legaltracker.thomsonreuters.com/tracker/Invoice/Info?id=1591728
`
`2/3
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 21 of 29
`
`
`
`370 17th Street, Suite 4500
`Denver, CO 80202-5647
`Telephone: (303) 244-1800
`
`Lawrence R. Katzin Esq.
`Vice President and Associate General Counsel
`DISH Network L.L.C.
`PO Box 6655
`Englewood, CO 80155
`
`Tax ID# 20-0697269
`Please remit to:
`P.O. Box 17782
`Denver, CO 80217-0782
`
`Invoice No:
`
`Matter ID:
`
`August 5, 2021
`230015
`
`06353.0015
`
`CONFIDENTIAL/PRIVILEGED
`ATTORNEY/CLIENT COMMUNICATION
`
`For professional services rendered through July 31, 2021
`
`Regarding: Realtime Adaptive Streaming LLC
`Claim No.: 2018-00243
`
`DATE
`
`07/01/21
`
`07/01/21
`
`07/01/21
`
`07/02/21
`
`07/02/21
`
`07/02/21
`
`07/02/21
`
`TIMEKEEPER
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review and organize mock materials for trial.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Prepare for and participate in mock trial.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with clients regarding mock trial.
`
`C. Cheng
`Telephone conference with Mr. H. Gottschalk regarding pre-trial conference
`issues and other pre-trial strategy.
`
`C. Cheng
`Correspond with Fish & Richardson trial team regarding jury instructions
`and other pre-trial considerations.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with Mr. D. Tishman and Ms. C. Cheng regarding
`Judge Jackson trial procedures.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with Mr. D. Tishman regarding damages
`presentation at mock trial.
`
`HOURS
`
`AMOUNT
`
`1.20
`
`822.00
`
`5.70
`
`3,904.50
`
`0.80
`
`0.30
`
`548.00
`
`136.50
`
`0.20
`
`91.00
`
`0.50
`
`342.50
`
`0.80
`
`548.00
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 22 of 29
`Wheeler Trigg O’Donnell LLP
`August 5, 2021
`Page: 2
`
`Invoice:
`Matter ID:
`
`230015
`06353.0015
`
`DATE
`07/02/21
`
`07/02/21
`
`07/06/21
`
`07/06/21
`
`07/07/21
`
`07/07/21
`
`07/07/21
`
`07/07/21
`
`07/07/21
`
`07/07/21
`
`07/07/21
`
`07/08/21
`
`07/08/21
`
`07/08/21
`
`TIMEKEEPER
`H. Gottschalk
`Review mock trial report and data.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review and respond to co-counsel emails regarding Judge Jackson trial
`procedures.
`
`C. Cheng
`Analyze replies regarding motions in limine, Daubert and summary
`judgment motions.
`
`C. Cheng
`Correspond with trial team regarding void dire and other trial preparation
`questions.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review and respond to emails with co-counsel regarding witness
`preparation schedule.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Prepare for and attend weekly status meeting with co-counsel.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with J. Hanft regarding presentation of damages
`case at trial.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Prepare for and participate in trial planning meeting with D. Tishman.
`
`C. Cheng
`Correspond with trial team regarding void dire and other trial preparation
`strategy and practices for Judge Jackson.
`
`C. Cheng
`Analyze draft notice and request for bench trial.
`
`C. Cheng
`Correspond with Mr. D. Tishman regarding draft notice and request for
`bench trial.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review mock trial materials, and organize case materials for trial.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Prepare for and participate in debrief with Courtroom Performance
`regarding mock trial results.
`
`C. Cheng
`Correspond with trial team regarding trial preparation strategy and practices
`for Judge Jackson.
`
`HOURS
`0.80
`
`AMOUNT
`548.00
`
`0.50
`
`342.50
`
`0.40
`
`182.00
`
`0.30
`
`136.50
`
`0.50
`
`342.50
`
`1.60
`
`1,096.00
`
`0.80
`
`548.00
`
`1.50
`
`1,027.50
`
`0.30
`
`136.50
`
`0.20
`
`0.30
`
`91.00
`
`136.50
`
`1.00
`
`685.00
`
`2.60
`
`1,781.00
`
`0.30
`
`136.50
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 23 of 29
`Wheeler Trigg O’Donnell LLP
`August 5, 2021
`Page: 3
`
`Invoice:
`Matter ID:
`
`230015
`06353.0015
`
`DATE
`07/08/21
`
`07/09/21
`
`07/09/21
`
`07/09/21
`
`07/09/21
`
`07/09/21
`
`07/11/21
`
`07/11/21
`
`07/11/21
`
`07/11/21
`
`07/12/21
`
`07/12/21
`
`07/12/21
`
`07/12/21
`
`TIMEKEEPER
`C. Cheng
`Review stipulation on trial issues and Realtime's reply in support of its
`Daubert motion.
`
`S. Gottesfeld
`Email communications with Ms. A. DeVan concerning logistics for hosting
`Fish Richardson trial team and equipment needed during trial.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review and revise PowerPoint presentation for P. Meyer.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Prepare for and participate in telephone conference with co-counsel
`regarding trial planning and witness preparation schedule.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review key pleadings, request for bench trial and Minnick declaration and
`support materials.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review emails regarding trial and prep schedule and review pending
`motions.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review P. Meyer report.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review Dell report and deposition and identify key issues for trial.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Emails with Mr. D. Tishman regarding trial preparation process and
`logistics.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review mock trial exhibits.
`
`S. Gottesfeld
`Telephone conference with and email communications to Ms. A. Afful and
`Ms. C. Mason concerning trial logistics and support.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with Mr. D. Tishman regarding damages
`examination outlines and trial exhibits.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review mock trial juror videos.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review key pleadings and pending motions, including replies regarding
`Daubert motions and motions in limine.
`
`HOURS
`0.30
`
`AMOUNT
`136.50
`
`0.20
`
`44.00
`
`1.00
`
`685.00
`
`2.20
`
`1,507.00
`
`1.80
`
`1,233.00
`
`1.20
`
`822.00
`
`0.60
`
`1.40
`
`0.80
`
`411.00
`
`959.00
`
`548.00
`
`1.60
`
`1,096.00
`
`1.00
`
`220.00
`
`0.60
`
`411.00
`
`1.30
`
`890.50
`
`2.00
`
`1,370.00
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 24 of 29
`Wheeler Trigg O’Donnell LLP
`August 5, 2021
`Page: 4
`
`Invoice:
`Matter ID:
`
`230015
`06353.0015
`
`DATE
`07/12/21
`
`07/12/21
`
`07/12/21
`
`07/13/21
`
`07/13/21
`
`07/13/21
`
`07/14/21
`
`07/14/21
`
`07/14/21
`
`07/14/21
`
`07/14/21
`
`07/15/21
`
`07/15/21
`
`07/15/21
`
`07/15/21
`
`TIMEKEEPER
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with Mr. D. Tishner regarding replies regarding
`Daubert motions and motions in limine.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review emails regarding demonstrative exhibits and Bench trial request.
`
`C. Cheng
`Correspond with trial team regarding void dire and other trial preparation
`strategy and practices for Judge Jackson.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Email communications with Messrs. D. Tishman and P. Meyer regarding
`damage analysis and trial prep plan.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review expert reports.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Meeting with Mr. D. Tishman regarding extranet site and trial outline
`preparation.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Begin preparation of initial Dell cross examination outline.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Prepare for and participate in trial preparation meeting with co-counsel.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review and revise initial PowerPoint from Mr. P. Meyer.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review deposition excerpts for trial from Mr. D. Tishman.
`
`C. Cheng
`Correspond with trial team and telephone conference with Mr. D. Tishman
`regarding void dire and other trial preparation strategy and practices for
`Judge Jackson.
`
`C. Cheng
`Review joint proposed jury instructions and analyze comments from Judge
`Jackson.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review motion in limine regarding S. Dell opinions.
`
`S. Gottesfeld
`Internal emails concerning logistics for hosting of co-counsel during trial.
`
`S. Gottesfeld
`Email communications with Ms. A. Afful concerning trial logistics.
`
`HOURS
`1.00
`
`AMOUNT
`685.00
`
`0.60
`
`0.50
`
`411.00
`
`227.50
`
`1.30
`
`890.50
`
`1.60
`
`1,096.00
`
`0.50
`
`342.50
`
`2.00
`
`1,370.00
`
`2.10
`
`1,438.50
`
`1.20
`
`822.00
`
`1.50
`
`1,027.50
`
`0.80
`
`364.00
`
`1.20
`
`546.00
`
`1.00
`
`0.20
`
`0.20
`
`685.00
`
`44.00
`
`44.00
`
`

`

`Case 1:17-cv-02097-RBJ Document 308-4 Filed 08/13/21 USDC Colorado Page 25 of 29
`Wheeler Trigg O’Donnell LLP
`August 5, 2021
`Page: 5
`
`Invoice:
`Matter ID:
`
`230015
`06353.0015
`
`DATE
`07/15/21
`
`07/15/21
`
`07/15/21
`
`07/15/21
`
`07/15/21
`
`07/16/21
`
`07/16/21
`
`07/16/21
`
`07/16/21
`
`07/16/21
`
`07/16/21
`
`07/16/21
`
`07/16/21
`
`07/19/21
`
`07/19/21
`
`TIMEKEEPER
`H. Gottschalk
`Review and revise demonstrative exhibits from T. Shelin.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with T. Shelin and D. Tishman regarding
`demonstrative exhibits.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review Judge Jackson edits and comments to jury instructions.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Email to co-counsel regarding Judge Jackson edits and comments to jury
`instructions.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review and revise outline of S. Dell cross examination and create
`PowerPoint slides for Dell cross.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Continue work on Meyer direct examination PowerPoint.
`
`S. Gottesfeld
`Multiple emails and telephone conferences with co-counsel concerning
`various trial logistics.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Emails with co-counsel regarding Judge Jackson jury instruction comments.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Telephone conference with co-counsel regarding Judge Jackson jury
`instruction comments and pretrial conference.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Prepare for and participate in final pretrial conference with Court and all
`counsel.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review Meyer motion in limine.
`
`C. Cheng
`Correspond with trial team regarding joint proposed jury instructions and
`comments from Judge Jackson.
`
`C. Cheng
`Review courtroom minutes from pretrial conference and DISH's notice on
`prior art references.
`
`H. Gottschalk
`Review emails with opposing counsel regarding bench trial.
`
`S. Gottesfeld
`Review minute order issued from trial preparation conference.
`
`HOURS
`1.20
`
`AMOUNT
`822.00
`
`0.60
`
`411.00
`
`0.70
`
`0.50
`
`479.50
`
`342.50
`
`2.20
`
`1,507.00
`
`1.80
`
`1,233.00
`
`0.50
`
`110.00
`
`0.70
`
`0.50
`
`479.50
`
`342.50
`
`2.80
`
`1,918.00
`
`0.60
`
`0