`Case 5:18—cv-05198—BLF Document 14-4 Filed 10/04/18 Page 1 of 61
`
`EXHIBIT 4
`EXHIBIT4
`
`
`
`Case 5:18-cv-05198-BLF Document 14-4 Filed 10/04/18 Page 2 of 61
`
`r lllll illlllll ilt ililr ilil illl llilt ]il ]llt ]til ]]t illlt llll tilll]
`us00794554482
`
`(r2) United States Patent
`Farber et al.
`
`(ro) Patent No.:
`1+sy Date of Patent:
`
`us 7,945,54482
`lilay l7,20ll
`
`(54) SIMILARTTY-BASEDACCBSS CONTROL OF
`D.{T-{ INA D:\Ii\ PROCESSING SYSTBM
`(75) Inventors: David A. Farber, Oiai. CA (JS):
`Ronald l). Lachman. Northbrook. II
`(US)
`
`(73) Assignees: Kinetech, Inc.. Studio City. CA (JS):
`Levcl 3 Communications, LLC.
`Broonfield. CO (uS)
`
`( o ) Notice: Subiect to any disclaimer, the term ofthis
`patent is extended or adjusted nnder 35
`U.S.C. 154(b) by 624 days.
`
`(21)
`
`(22)
`
`(65)
`
`App1. No.: 11/980,688
`Filed: Oct.31,200?
`
`Prior Publication Data
`tJS 200tifi)65635 Al
`
`Mar. 13. 200tt
`
`Related U.S. Application l)ata
`(60) Corrtinuation of application No. 11 724,232. filed on
`Mar. 15. 2007. n'hich is a contiur.ration of applicatiou
`No. i11017.650. filcd on Dec. 22.2004, wtich is a
`continnation of application No. 09i987.723. filed on
`Nov. 15, 2001, now Pat. No. 6,928.442, which is a
`continuation of application No. 09/283,160. filed on
`Apr. 1. 1999, mrw Pat. No. 6,415.2ft0, w{rich is a
`division of application No. 08/960,079. filcd on Oct.
`24, 1997, now Pat. No. 5.978,791. u'hich is a
`collinuation ofapplication No. 08i425,160, filed on
`Apr. 11. 1995, norv abaldoned, application No.
`I1/980.688, which is a continuationof applicationNo.
`lol'142,972, filed or Dec. 23. 2003, wtich is a division
`ofapplication No. O9I987.723,which is a contiuitation
`of application No. 09/283.160. whicli is a division of
`application No. 08/960,079. which is a cont.inuation of
`applicatiou No. 08/425.1 60.
`
`(51)
`
`(s2)
`(s8)
`
`(56)
`
`Int. Cl.
`(]06lr t7/00
`(2006.0r)
`U.S. Cl.
`7071698:7A'//821:'/01/822
`Field of Classification Search ............ ...... 7071609,
`707/821-828.697 698
`See application file for complete search history.
`
`References Cited
`
`U.S, PATENT DOCUMENTS
`3.668.647 A
`6t1972
`Evangelisti et al
`3.835,260 A
`9tt9i4
`Prescher et al.
`(Continr.red)
`
`EP
`
`FOREIGN PAIENT DOCUMENTS
`0 268 069 A2 5i 1988
`(Continr.rcd)
`
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`Fowler, et a[. "A I.Iser-Level Replicated File Systern," AT&T Bell
`Laboratories Tchnical \4ernoraldurn 0 1 1267 0 -9304 I 4 -05. Apr.
`1993, and USENIX 1993 Suruner tlonference Proceedings, Cincil-
`nati, OH, .Iun. 1993.
`
`((irntinued)
`
`Printary F)xaminer Khanh B Phanr
`(71) .4ttorne1,, Agent, or Finn Davidson Berquist Jackson
`& Gowdey. LLP: Brian Siritztrq,
`(57)
`ABSTI{{CT
`Similarit-v o1'data items is determined by analyzing corre-
`sponding scg1lrcnts of thc dala itcns. A flinction is applicd to
`each segment ofa data item and the ontput oftirat function is
`compared to the output of the sarne ftilction applied to a
`corresponding seglnent of another data item. A flinction may
`be applied ltr the oulput of the luuctions. 'l'he lunctions n:ry
`be lush or message digest liurctions.
`
`56 (Jlaims,3l l)rawing Sheets
`
`EEffi
`
`ailuhHcBlmflffi
`(0cpm0tranu!wq
`
`CBGEEfBqOI
`.FilS@Ell&
`
`SUMENDTCIILO6
`l@phsmruEW
`
`EXHIBIT 4. 1
`
`
`
`Case 5:18-cv-05198-BLF Document 14-4 Filed 10/04/18 Page 3 of 61
`
`rJS 7,945,544 82
`Page 2
`
`6,',1978
`7.', 1980
`g,',1980
`9rl98l
`3,',1983
`9,',1983
`10,'1983
`I 1,',1983
`4,',1984
`8r 1984
`I 2r 1984
`I 2/ 1985
`21 1986
`3i 1986
`2i 1987
`2i 1987
`4i 1987
`6i 1987
`9i 1987
`2/1988
`9,',1988
`4,',1989
`12,'1989
`12,'1989
`4i 1990
`4,1990
`5i1990
`_5i 1990
`6i 1990
`8/ 1990
`8i 1990
`I l,'1990
`5i 1991
`6i 1991
`7 i 1991
`91t991
`9i 199 I
`9,',tq9l
`10,'1991
`r2,'1991
`1,',1992
`-{i 1992
`7 i 199)
`7i 1992
`9i 1992
`I li 1992
`li t993
`l/ 1993
`3,'1993
`4i 1993
`4t 1993
`4t 1993
`4i t993
`5/1993
`6,',1993
`7,',1993
`8,',1993
`8/ 1993
`9i 1993
`tL1993
`lt 1994
`tl 1994
`2t 1994
`2i 1994
`3i 1994
`4i 1994
`4,',t994
`5,',1994
`6t 1994
`8t 1994
`8t 1994
`8i t994
`9i 1994
`9i 1994
`l0/ 1994
`10,'i994
`10,'t994
`l0t t994
`
`5.361.:i56 A
`5,371,897 A
`5,375,206 A
`-5.384.565 A
`5,394,555 A
`,5.401.639 A
`5.404.508 A
`5,438,508 A
`5,442.343 A
`5,448,668 A +
`5.448.718 A
`5.457.447 A
`5.454,000 A +
`5.454,039 A
`.5.459.860 A
`5.465,365 A
`5.467 .471 A
`5.475,826 A
`5.479.654 A *
`5.491.817 A
`5,499,294 A
`5.-s04.879 A
`5,530.757 A *
`5,537,585 A
`5,542.087 A
`5,548,724 A
`5,553.143 A
`,5.568.181 A
`5.581,615 A
`5,581,758 A
`5,581,764 A
`5.583,99-s A
`5.588.147 A
`5.596.744 A
`5.600.834 A
`5,604,803 A
`5,604,892 A
`5,630,067 -A
`5,612,031 A
`-5.638"443 A
`s.640.564 A
`5.649.196 A
`{ 677 O<f A
`5.678,038 A
`5,678.046 A
`5,694,472 A *
`,{,694.596 A
`_(,701.316 A
`5,710.922 A
`5,7244?5 A
`5,r'24,552 A
`5.742,407 A
`,s,745,879 A
`5.757.9t3 A
`s.757.915 A
`,5,781.629 A
`5,802,291 A
`5.809.494 A
`5,826,049 A
`5,835,087 A
`5,864,683 A
`-<.907.619 A
`5.q07 ,704 A
`5,940,504 A
`5,978,791 A
`5,991,414 A
`6,006,018 A
`6,134,603 A
`6,135.646 A
`6.415.280 Bl
`6.732.180 Bl
`6,816.872 Bl x
`6,928.442 B2
`2002i0052884 Al
`2002i0082999 At
`2003i007881i8 Al
`200ii0078889 Al
`2003.i0(.)95660 A1
`2004i0139097 A1
`
`.... . . 714'2t
`
`707 i695
`
`lltl994
`Clalk el al.
`Brown et al.
`l2t 1994
`t2t t994
`Hunter et al.
`Cannon
`1i I 995
`Huntcr ct al.
`2,199,5
`Relsan et al.
`4i 1995
`4t t995
`Komatl et al.
`Wyrnan
`811995
`Cato ct al.
`8/ I 995
`Perelson et al.
`911995
`Cohl et al.
`9:199-<
`Nelson et al,
`9r 1 99,<
`Dorfinm .......,
`............... 1 14, 54
`9/1q95
`911995 Coppersmith et al.
`l0/1995
`Burnett
`Wintelbottorn
`I 1/1995
`Ilader
`I 1/1995
`t2i 1995
`Fischer
`Squibb ..........
`12/1995
`Gopal et al.
`2t 1996
`Friedrnan
`3! 1996
`Eisenberg et al.
`4,,1996
`h1rwcz1,k ...........,.....,... 7 ll I 88
`6j 1996
`7 t t996
`Blickenstall'et al.
`Ncirnat ct al.
`7 i 1996
`Akizau'a et al.
`8r I 996
`Ross el al.
`9i 1996
`Grccnrvood ct al.
`10r1996
`I2t 1996
`Stern
`12i1996
`Brunett
`Fitzgcrald ct al.
`12/ 1996
`t2i 1.996
`Ciudner et al.
`12i t 996
`Neernan et al.
`li 199'7
`Dao et al.
`IIoq'ad
`2i 1997
`Aziz
`2t 1991
`Nuftall et al.
`2t199',7
`Kindell et al.
`5t t997
`!'eli sszu-opoulos et al.
`5i t997
`Stelik et al.
`6t 1997
`Harnilton ct al.
`6t 1997
`Woodhill et al.
`7.t 1997
`Blakley. ill et al.
`10,1997
`10i t99i
`Dockter et al.
`Cahill et al.
`l0t 1997
`t2t t99i
`.Iohnson et al. ............... 713,'189
`I2t t997
`Carnpbell
`l2i t997
`Allbrness et al.
`lrl998
`Alley et al.
`Chmg et al,
`:111998
`Taoda
`3i1998
`Masintcr
`4i 1998
`Wyrnan
`4i 1998
`5i 1998
`Be-llare et al.
`Aucsrnith et al.
`511998
`71998
`Habcl ct al.
`Balick et al.
`91 1998
`9/1998
`Nguyen
`Ogala er al.
`10/1998
`Herz et al.
`1 1i 1998
`Iit999
`Boebert et al.
`Davis
`511999
`Grrdrmrndson ct al.
`511999
`8/1999
`Grisrvold
`1 lt t999
`Fuber et al.
`I li 1999
`Garay et al.
`Bumett et al.
`12i 1999
`Jones et al.
`10i 2000
`Kahn ei al.
`1 012000
`Farber et al.
`712002
`Hale et al.
`5!2004
`Squibb ..................................
`1 1t2001
`Farber et al.
`812005
`Farber et al.
`612002
`62002
`I.ee et al.
`4t2003
`Lee et al.
`4t2003
`Lcc ct al.
`Lee et al.
`5r2003
`7!2004
`Falbcr ct al.
`
`l''1
`
`EXHIBIT 4 - 2
`
`U.S. P.{TENT DOCUMENI'S
`4.096.568 A
`Bennett et al.
`4.2t5,402 A
`Mitchell el al.
`Chmg et al.
`4.221,003
`Cichelli et al.
`4.290.105
`fuvest
`4.376,299
`Rivest e1 al.
`4,405,829
`Neches et al.
`4,412,285
`4,4\4,624
`Sruruner'. .lr. et al.
`Fletcher et al.
`4,441,155
`Bcnhasc ct al.
`4,464,713
`Dixon et al.
`4,490.782
`Schrnidt et al.
`4,558,413
`Erruy. .Ir. ct al.
`4,571.700
`Matick el al.
`4,57'7.293
`Ausl:rntler
`4,642,764
`Mcadcn
`4,642.793
`Ilelhnan
`4.658,093
`4.67s,8 t0
`Grunel el al.
`Rivest et al.
`4,69t,299
`Kronstadt et al,
`4,725.945
`Zatnotit
`4.773,039
`Clmcy et al.
`4.82 1, I 84
`Hollou,ay et al.
`4.887.235
`Bames et al.
`4.888.68 1
`Baratz et al.
`4,9 t4,57 t
`Su,inehart el al.
`4,914,586
`4,922,4t4
`Hollou,ay et al.
`Chturn et al.
`4,922,417
`Robelt et al.
`4,937,863
`tunold et al.
`4.949.302
`Ryder, Sr. et al.
`4.953
`^209
`Burkc
`4.972.367
`Mmsfield et al.
`5,014.192
`Cho
`5,025,421
`Hecht et al.
`5,032,979
`Schu'utz et al.
`s,047,918
`Mzuca
`5.O50,0'74
`Dyson
`5.050.212
`Colwell et al.
`5.057,837
`Benderl et al.
`5.077,658
`Mazzario
`5.084,815
`Miller
`5,i 17,35 I
`Kobayrohi et al.
`5,129.081
`'lrrfing et al.
`5.129,082
`Pogue, .Tr. et al.
`5,1.44.667
`Olita
`5.t 63,147
`5, I 79,680
`Colu'ell et al.
`Tumrra et al.
`5,182^799
`Scott
`5, I 99.073
`Granlich et al.
`s,202,982
`Siyrnu
`s,204,897
`Cheng et al.
`5,204,958
`Wittcnbcrg ct al.
`5,204,966
`Vollerl el al.
`5,208,858
`Waite et al.
`5,222,134
`5.230,05 I
`Quan
`Nukui
`5.239.648
`5,241,67 I
`Reed et al.
`Fukuzau'a et al.
`5.247,620
`}\/yrnm
`5,260.999
`Irorlest et al.
`5,276.869
`Howell et a[.
`5,276,901
`5,287,499
`Nernes
`Grnn
`5,287 .514
`( ro7 )?o
`Bannon et al.
`R.rjani
`5.301.286
`5.301,3 l6
`Harnilton et al.
`Cuenod et al.
`5.317.693
`East et al,
`5.321,841
`Parker
`5,339,403
`Pitkin ct al.
`5,341,477
`Moore
`5,343,527
`ll;nn et al,
`5,34'.7,653
`Leightol et al.
`5.3 51.302
`Talbott et al.
`5.357.440
`Megory-Cohen
`5,357 .623
`OprescLr et al.
`5.3-57,630
`Talbott et al.
`5,3 s9.523
`
`AA AA AAA A A A
`
`AA
`
`A AA AAA AA
`
`AAA AA
`
`AAA AAA AA A A
`
`
`
`Case 5:18-cv-05198-BLF Document 14-4 Filed 10/04/18 Page 4 of 61
`
`as 7,945,544B.2
`
`Page 3
`
`I i 2005
`5i2005
`812007
`3/2008
`3i 2008
`3,'2008
`3,',2008
`
`Carpentier et al.
`Fuber et al.
`Fuber et al.
`Fuber et al.
`Farbcr et al.
`Irarber et al.
`F'uber et al.
`
`200510010792 Al
`2005/01 14296 Al
`200710185848 Al
`200810065635 Al
`2008i0066191 Al
`2008/0071855 Al
`2008/0082551 Al
`FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
`0 315 425
`5r 1989
`0 558 945 .A2 9i 1993
`0 566967 A2 10i 1993
`0592045
`4i1994
`06:i1 226 At
`l2il994
`06549?0 A2
`5i1995
`0 658 022 .A2 6t1995
`22q4t32 A
`4,;1996
`590s8564 4il984
`63-t06048
`5i 1988
`63-273961 1li 1988
`2-127755
`5i 1990
`05162529
`611993
`06187384 A2 7i1994
`06348558 A
`l2il994
`wo 9220021
`r|i1992
`wo 94/06087
`3i1994
`wo 94120913 9i1994
`WO 95/01599
`lil995
`WO97143717 11t1997
`OTHER PUBLICATIONS
`
`EP
`F,P
`EP
`EP
`EP
`EP
`EP
`GB
`.IP
`JP
`JP
`JP
`JP
`.IP
`JP
`wo
`wo
`wc)
`wo
`wo
`
`Greene. D., et al., "Multilndex Hashing for Infonnation Retrieval".
`Nor'. 20-22, 1 994. Proceedings, 3 5th Arnual SyT np on Foundations of
`Cornprrter Science. IEEE. pp. 722-731.
`Hirano, el al. "Exten<lible hashing for concurrent insertions and
`ret'ievals," in Proc 4th Eruorniclo Workshop on Puallel and Distrib-
`uted Processing. 1996 (PDP '96). .Ian. 24, 1996 to.rar. 26, I 996. pp.
`235-242, Braga, Porhrgal.
`Prereel et al,. "The Cryptographic Hash Ftnction zuPEMD-160".
`appeaed in CryptoBytes RSA Laboratories. r,ol. 3, No. 2, pp. 9-14,
`Iiall. 199? (also Bosselaers et al., "The RIPLMD-160 Crlptogaphic
`Hash Fnnction". Jm. 1997, Dr. Dohb's Joumal, pp. 24-28).
`Pnrsker et al.. "The Siphon; Managing Distmt Replicaled Reposito-
`ries" Nor'. 8-9. 1990, Proc. Mmagernent of Replicated Data IEEE.
`Reply to Exarnination Repofi, Munich, Nor'. 1 8. 2009. in Application
`No. EP 96 910 762.2 !9 pgs.l.
`Rich. K. et al, 'Hobgoblin: A File md Directory .Auditof', Sep.
`30-Oct. 3, 1991, LisaV, Sm Diego. CA.
`USP'IO Final Office Action in LJ.S. Appl. No. 1rJi742,972,Dec.22,
`2009.
`USPTO. Advisory Action. Ma:: 23. 2010. in U,S. Appl. No.
`1 1/980.679.
`USPTO. Final Office Action in U.S. Reexan Control No.
`90/010.260. Jan. 29, 2010.
`USP I O. !'inal Office Action mailed Jan. 12, 2010 in L..S. Appl. No
`1I/980,679.
`USPTO, Final Office Acf ion tnailed Aug, t 8. 2009 in tl.S. Appl. No.
`I 1/017.650.
`LISPTO, Final Office Action rnailed Sep. 30. 2009 in Lt.S. Appl. No.
`I1t724,232.
`LISP'I'O. Final Office Action, N4ar'. 5, 2010 in U.S. Appl. No
`1 1/980.687.
`Cheriton, David R. and Mann. Tilnothy P, "Decentralizing a global
`neuning sen'icelbr improved per-tbnnarce and.fau1t tolerance", ACM
`Trmsactions on Cornputel'Systerns, tol. 7, No. 2, May 1989, pp.
`147-l 83.
`l{etpest for Reexunination of U.S. Patent No. 6,928.442: Reexam
`Control No. 90/010.260, filed on Aug. 29, 2008.
`[Proposed] Order Regading Constntction ofTertns, filed N4ar. 29,
`2007 in C.D. Cal. case no. CV 06-5086 SJO (Ex) [9 pgs.].
`Analysis of Plaintiffs' Clairn Chart for the'280 Patent As -{gainst
`Defendant Merlia Sentry Inc. 1l pages.
`Aralysis of Plaintill's' Clairn Clhzut lbr the '791 Patent As Against
`Defendant Media Sentry, lnc. ( I I 9 I 6.001.0 I 50.A) pp. I -48.
`
`Analysis of Plaintiffs'Clairn Charl for the'791 Patent As Against
`Det'endant C)verpeer pp. I -40.
`Barbma. D., et al., "Exploiting sytnnetries for lou,-cost cornpalison
`o[file copies," 8th Int'l Conl] on Dishibuted Computing Systerns.
`.Ttrn. 1988, pp.47l-479. San.lose. CA.
`Campbell. M.. "lhe Design of Iext Sipnahrres lbr'lext Retrieval
`Systenrs," Tech, Reporl, Sep. 5, 1994. Deakin University, School of
`Cornputilg & Ma1h.. Geelong, Australia.
`Chang. W. W et a[.. 'A sipnahue access rnethod for the Stalburst
`database systern." in Proc. l5th Int'1 Coni onVery Lar€{e DataBases
`(.Amsterdan. The Netherlmds). pp. 145-153.
`Changes to Ma'. 23, 2007 Deposition of Robef B. K. Dewar. in C.D.
`Cal. case No. CV 06-5086 SJO (Ex) [3 pgs + cover letter.l.
`Cornnunication fiom EPO in Europcal Application No, 96 910
`i62.2 1225 dated \4ay 8, 2009 [4 pgs.l.
`Cornmrnication pursuant to Articlc 96(2) EPC tiorn EPO (Exanina-
`tion Rcport). .Ian. 17, 2007, in Application No. EP q6 I n 762.2-1225
`I pg. u'ith 5 pg. annex].
`Cornplaint fol Patcnt Infringcrncnt, Pcrrnancnt Injnnction aad Dam-
`ages, Aug. 8, 2006. in C.D, Cal. case No. CV 06-5086 SJO (Ex) [ I I
`Pgs.l.
`Cornplaint for Patent Infringement, Pennanent Injiurction and Dam-
`ages, filed Sep.21. 2007 in C.D. Cal. CaseNo. CV 07-06161 VBF
`(PLAx) [10 pgs.].
`Declaation of Chaules S. Bakerin Support olDel'endmt LimeWire's
`Mo(ion to Slay Pending Reexiunination of Patent and Request lbr
`Extension of Deadlines, Aug. 29, 2008, in C.D. Cal, Case No. CV
`07-06161VBF tPLAx) l2 pe.s I.
`I)efendmt Lirne Wire. LLC's liirst Alended .Arsu'er, Affilnative
`Defenses and Counterclairns, Oct. 2, 2008, C.D, Clal. case No.
`07-0(r16l VBF (PLAr) [3 pgs.l.
`Delendmt Lirne Wire. LLC's SecontlAnendedArswer, Alfilnative
`Defenses and Connterclainrs, Oct. 27 ,2008, from C.D. Cal. case No.
`07-06161VBF (PLAx) [3 pgs,].
`Defendant Michael Weiss's Ansu,er to Plaintiffs Cornplaint for
`Patent Infiingement, Pennanent Injunction md Datlages, Dernand
`for.huy Trial, Sep. 15. 2C)06, case No. CV 06-5086 SJO (Ex) [t0
`pgs.l.
`Defendant Recordin g Indu stry Association of .\nedca's Arnended
`Notice of Votion and Motion lbr Pa:tial Sruunuy Judgment on
`Plaintiffs' Clairls for Patcnt Infringetncnt md Inducing Patcnt
`Infiingernent; Mernoranthun of Points and Authorities, Ma-y 22.
`2006, redacted. original confidential. filed rurder seal" in C,D. Ual.
`casc No. CV 04-7456 JFW (CTx t [19 pgs.].
`Defendant Recording Industty Association of Arnerica's and
`Mediasentry, Inc,"s Notice of Motion md Motion for Pafial Srun-
`rnary Judgment Based on Lnplied License ol, in the Alternative.
`Based on Patent Misuse and Llnclean Hands. May 22, 2006,
`Redacted. in C.D. Cal. case No. CV OO-tOtU rp'$r {CTx) [2] pgs.].
`Dcfcndant Rccording Industry Association of Amcrica's and
`Mediasentry, Inc's Notice of Motion md Motion lbr Parlial Surn-
`rnary Judgrnent Based on Lnplied License or. in the Alternative,
`Bascd on Patcni Misusc md Llnclcan Hards, Ir4ay 8. 2006. in C.D.
`Cal, case No. CV 04-7456 JFW (CTx) [20 pgs.],
`Defendant StreunCast Netu,olks Inc.'s Alsrver to Plaintifls Con-
`plaint for Patcnt Infringerncnt, Pcnnancnt Injttnction md Drunages;
`Dernand for Jury Trial. Sep. 5, 2006, C.D. Cal. case No. CV 065086
`sJo (Ex) [0 pgs.],
`Defendants' Arnelded Prelirninary Clairn Constntctions [Patent
`Rrrle 4-21. filed Feb. 7,2007 in C.D. Cal. case No. CV 06-5086 SJO
`(Ex) [t0 pgs.].
`Dcfcndmt's Sccond Arncndcd Prclirninary Claim Constutctions
`[Patent Rule 4-2], filed Feb. 9. 2007 in C.D. Cal. case No. CV
`06-5086 SJo (Ex) [0 pgs.].
`Dcx'fl. Rcbrlttal Expert Rcport of Robcrt B.K. Dcu'r. in C.D. Cal.
`case No. CV 04-7456 JFW (CTx). Apr. 10. 2006 [87 pgs].
`Faloutsos, C. 'Access methods for text," ACM Cornput. Sun. 17, I
`(N4r. 1985).49-74.
`Faloutsos, C. et al., "Description aad perfonnance analysis of signa-
`ture file rnethods for office filing," ACM Trars. Inf. Syst. 5. 3 (Jul.
`1987).23i -257 .
`
`EXHIBIT 4 - 3
`
`
`
`Case 5:18-cv-05198-BLF Document 14-4 Filed 10/04/18 Page 5 of 61
`
`rJS 7,945,544 B2
`Page 4
`
`Faloutsos. C. el al., "Signahrre files: m access tnethod fbrdocrnnenfs
`and its anallical perfolnance evaluation." ACM Trans. Inf. Syst. 2.
`4 (Oct 1984),267-288.
`Federal Inlonnation Processing Standlds (FIPS) Publication I80-l;
`Secure Hash StmtLud, Apr. 17, 1995 [17 pgs.].
`Feigenbarun. .1. et al., "Cryptographic protection oi databases ut{
`sofh,ae," rn Distlibuted Cornputing md Ciryptography: Proc.
`DIMACS Wblkshop. Apr 1991. pp. 161-172. Arnerican Mathernati-
`cal Society, Boston. N4ass.
`First Arnentled Ansu'er of Defendmt Mediasenhy 1o Second
`A.rnended Cornplaint and Cormterclairn, Apr'. 24.2006, in C.D. Cal.
`case No. CV 04-7456 JFW (CTx) [29 pgs.l.
`Filst Arnended Alsu'er of Defendmt RIAA to Second A.mended
`Cornplaint md Countcrclairn. Apr.24,2006. in C.D. Cal. Casc No.
`CV O4-7456JFw (CTx) [27 pgs.l.
`First Arncndcd Cornplaint for Patcnt Infringctncnt, Pennancnt
`Injunction md Darnage s, filcd Scp. 8. 2008 in C.D. Cal. Casc No. CV
`07-06161VBF (PLAx) !0 pgs.l.
`I'larrison. M. C., "Irnplernentation of thc snbstring tcst by hashing,"
`Cornrntrn. ACI\4 14. l2 (Dec. l97l),777-779.
`IEHE. 'the Authoritative Dictionary of IEEU Standards I'elns. 7th
`ed., Copyright 2000. pp. I 07, 17 6,209.240,241,432. 468. 505. 506,
`682. 1016, I I 13, 1266. md 1267.
`Ishikaw:r"Y, et al., "Evaluation ofsignature files as set access facili-
`ties in OODBs." In Proc. of the 1993 AC\4 SIGMOD Inter. Conf. on
`N4anagement of Data (Washington. D.C., U.S., May 1993). P Bune-
`rnan & S. Jajodia, Fds. SIGMOD '93. AC\4. NY, NY, 247-256.
`Joint Clairn Constmction md Prehearing Staternenl. \.D. Cal. Rttle
`4-3, feb. 12. 2007,in C.D. Cal. case ),tro. CV 06-5086 SJO (Ex) [20
`pgs.l.
`Karp. R. Ir{. ald Rabin, M. O., "Eiicient randomized pattetn-.tnatch-
`irg algoritlurs," IB\4 J. Res. Dev. 3I,2 (\4ar 1987). 249-260.
`List of Asscrtcd Clairns and Infringcmcnt Chart for Each Asseitcd
`Clairn. Jul. 28. 2008. in C.D. Cal, Case No. CV 07-06161 VBF
`(PLAX) [31 pcs.].
`N4cGregor D. R. And Mariani. J. A. "Fingeryrinting A technique
`for flle identificalion andrnaintenalce," Sofnvare: Practice and Expe-
`rience, vol. 12. No. 12, Dc. 19ti2, pp. 1165-1166.
`Notice of Intercsted Parties. filed Sep. 2l, 2007 in C.D. Cal. Case No.
`CV 07-06161 VBF (PLAx) [2 pgs.].
`Notice of Motion md N4otion of Del'endmt Litne Wire to Stay Liti-
`gation Pcnding Recxnnination of Patcnt and Reqncst for Extcnsion
`ofDeadlines, Sep. 22, 2008, C,D. Cal. Case No. CV 07-06161 VBF
`(PLAr) [1] pgs.]
`Noticc of Rclatcd Cases, filcd Scp. 21, 2007 in C.D. Cal. Casc No. CV
`07-06161VBF (PLAx) [2 pgs.].
`Panagopoulos, G., et al., "Bit-sliced signahrre files for \.ely lalge text
`databases on apaallel rnachine rchitectue," In Proc. ofthe4th Inter.
`Conf on Extending Database Technology (EDBT), Czunbridge,
`U.K., Mr. 1994,pp.379-392 (Proc. LNCS 779 Springer 1994.ISBN
`3-540-578l8-8) [4 pgs ].
`Patent Abstract. "Managernent Systeln for Plur:rlVersions." PLtb. No.
`63273961 A, published Noi,. I l, 1988. NEC Cotp.
`Patcnt Abstracts of Japan. "Data Proccssor." Appln. No. 05 I 35620,
`filed Jun, 7. 1993. Toshiba Corp.
`Plaintiff Kinetech. Inc.'s Responses to Defendmt Mediasentry's
`First sct of Intcnogatorics, May l. 2006. in C.D. Cal. Case No. CV
`04-7456 JFW (CTx) [a pgs,].
`Plaintiff-Counterclairn Def'endmt Altnet, Inc.'s Supplemental
`Responses to Defe.ndmt-Counterclaitn Plaintiff Overpeer Inc.'s Filst
`Set of Interogatories. Mar. 8, 2006, redacted. in C.D. Cal. case No.
`Cv 04-7456 JFW (C1x) [24 pgs.l.
`Plaintiff-Countcrclairn Dcfendant Brilliant Digital Entcrtaimcnt,
`Inc.'s Supplernental Responses to Delentlant-Coturterclairn Plaintill'
`Orerpeer Inc.'s First Set oflnt€rogatories, N4r, 8. 2006, redacted, in
`C.D. Cal. case No. CV 04-7456 JFW (.CTx) [24 pgs.].
`Plaintifl'-Counterclairn Defendant Kinetech, [nc.'s Supplernental
`Responsesto Defendant-Llounterclaitn Plaintiff Overyeer Inc,'s First
`Sct of Interrogatorics Mal. 8, 2006, rcdactcd. in C.D. Cal. cme No.
`CV 04-'/456.IFW (CTx) [24 pgs.].
`Plaintiffs Altnet, Inc.. Brillimt Digrtal. Inc., and Kinetech, Inc.'s
`Rcsponscs to Dcfcndmt Rccording Indusuy Association ofArncri-
`
`ca's First Set of Reqnests for Adrnissions, Jm. 6.2006, in C'.D. Cal.
`case No. CV 04-7456 JFW (CTx) [26 pgs.].
`Plaintiffs' Clairn Construction Opening Blief and Exhibits A-D. F. G;
`May 7. 2007. in C.D. Cal. case No. CV 06-5086 SJO (Ex) [1 12 pgs.].
`Plaintill's' Prelirninary Clairl Constructions mtl Extrinsic Evidence.
`Feb. (r, 2006, in case CV 06-5086 S.IO (Ex) [2U pgs.J,
`Plaintiffs Reply to Defendant Mediasentry's Corurterclairns in its
`Ansu'er to the Second Arnended Cornplaint. May l. 2006. in C.D.
`Cal. CaseNo. CV 04-7456.rFW(CTx) [1] pgs.].
`Plaintiffs Reply to Defen&mt RIAA's Cormterclairns in its Ansu'er
`to the Second Amerded Complaint, May 1. 2006. in C.D. Cal. case
`No. CV 04-7456 JFW (CTx) [ I pgs.l.
`Plaintiffs' Reply to Defendmts' Clairn Construction Brief. filed Apr.
`23.2001 in C.D. Cal. cmc No. CV 06-5086 OD$r (Ex) 115 pgs.l.
`Reply to Exunination Repofi. .Tul. 19, 2007, in Application No. EP 96
`910 762.2-1Ds 17 pgs.l.
`Rcsponsc to Non-Final Officc Action filcd May 19. 2009 in U.S.
`Appl. No. I I 017.(150 | l9 pgs.l.
`R.ivcst, R., RFC 1320. "Thc MD4 Mcssagc-Digcst Algorithm," Thc
`Internet Engineering T:r-sk Force 1.IFTF). Apr. 1992.
`Sacks-Davis. R.. et al., "Multikey access methotls based on superirn-
`posed coding techriques," ACM Trms. Database Syst. 12, 4 (Nor'.
`1987).655-696.
`Siegel, A.. et al.. "Deceit: a Flexible Distributed File Systern," Proc.
`Workshop on the Managelnent of Replicated Data. Honston. TX, pp.
`l5-17. Nov.8-9, 1990.
`Siegel, A., et al., "Deceit: a Flexible Distributed File Systern," Tech-
`nical lteport, lRS9-1042, Cornell University, Nov. 1989.
`Stipulation and Proposed order to (1) Arnend the Cotnplaint, 12)
`Arnendpretrial Schedule. and(3)Withdrau' N4otion to Stay, filed Sep.
`8, 2008 in C.D. Cal. Case No. CV 07-06161 VBF(PL.{x) [6 pgs.].
`Streancast Networks Inc.'s Supplemental Responses to Cettain of
`Plaintiffs' First Sct oflntcrrogatodcs, Apr. 16. 2007. in C.D. Cal. casc
`No. CV 06-5086 SJO (Ex) [61 pgs.].
`StreanCast's Brief Re C'lairn Clonstmction, Apr. 12, 200?. in C.D.
`Cal, caseNo. CV 06-5086 S.lO (Ex) ill pgs.l.
`Transcript olDeposition ofDavid Farber. Feb. 16. 2006. in C.D. Cal.
`case No. CV 04-7456.lFW (C'Ix) [94 pgs.l.
`Trmscdpt of Deposition of Robert B. K. Dewu. M2, 23, 2007. in
`C.D. Cal. case No, CV 06-5086 SJO (Ex) [61 pgs.].
`'lianscript ofDeposition ofltonald Lachrnan. Feb. l. 2006, C.D. Cal.
`casc No. CV 04-74-56 JFW (CTx) [96 pgs.].
`USPTO, Non-Final Office Action rnailed May 6. 2009 in U.S. Appl.
`No. 1ii980,679.
`L. SPTO, Non-Final Of6cc action tnailcd .Tun. 15, 2009 in LLS. Appl.
`No. I l;980.687,
`USPTO. Non-Filal Office action rnailed Jun. 18. 2009 in Reexam
`No. 90/010.260.
`Adrances in Cry?tology-AUSCR\?T '92 Workshop on the
`Theory and Application of Crlptogaphic Techiques Gold Coast,
`Quecrsland. Australia Dcc. 13-16. 1992 Procccdings,
`Advmces in Cr'yptology-EUROCR\?T '93, Workshop on the
`Theory and Application of Cryptoglaphic Techniques Lofthus, Nor-
`way,May 23-27, 1993 Procccdings.
`Alndavit of Tirnothy P Walker in Support of CWIS' Opening Mark-
`mm Brief Constnting the Telns at Issue in U.S. Patent No,
`6,415,280, datcd Jul. 25, 2003, frorn Civil Action No. 02-11430
`RWZ,
`Akarnai a.nd MIT's Memorandurn in Support of Their Claim Con-
`stnction of USPAf 5.978,791, dated Aug. 31, 2001, fiorn Civil
`Action No. 00-ci'-l l85lRWZ.
`Akanai's AlsweL Altrnnative Def-enses and Clounterclairns to
`Arncnded Complaint, filcd Dcc. 6. 2002. in Civil Action No. 02-CV-
`I l430RWZ,
`Akanai's Brief on Clairn Constmction, dated Aug. 8. 2003. liont
`Civil Action No. 02-11430 RWZ.
`Alberl Langer (crn135 l@:rnu.oz.au). http:i/g;roups.google.cotni
`groups?sell:I991.Au97.225I 59.7860lo40neu.shost.mu. edtt.att
`&oc:UTF-8&output:gplain, Aug. 7, 1991.
`Alexa:rder Dupuy ldupuy@srna:ts.corn), "MD5 and LIFNs (was:
`Misc Conxnents)". uuu,.acl.lanl.gor'.{JRI/archivetrui-94q2.rnes-
`sagcsiOO81.htrnl, Apr. 17 , 1994.
`
`EXHIBIT 4 - 4
`
`
`
`Case 5:18-cv-05198-BLF Document 14-4 Filed 10/04/18 Page 6 of 61
`
`us 7,9450544B.2
`Page 5
`
`Alexantler Dupuy idupuy@slnans.corn). "Re: MD5 md I-IFNs (uas:
`I\4isc Cornnents)", u.uu,.acl.lanl.gor,[IRliuchivertui-94q2.mes-
`sages/O1 l3.htrnl, t\pt. 26. 1994.
`Answer ol Del'endmt RLA.A to First Arnended Cornplaint imd Coun-
`terclairn, dated Feb. 8. 2005. Iiom Civil Action No. CVO4-'7456 JFW
`(C Ix).
`Berners-Lee, T. et al.. "H)Trerext Trmsfer hotocol-HTTPi 1.0,"
`May 1996, pp. i-54.
`Berners-Lee. T. et al., "Unifoln Resource Locators (URL)," pp. 1 -25,
`Dec.1994.
`Berners-Lee, T., "Universal Resource ldentifiers in S'fV\V," .hm.
`1994. pp. l -25 .
`Be{ dem Boer et al., Collisions for the cornpression fitnction of
`MD.srrb.5 pp. 292-304, 1994.
`Birgit Pfitzrm, Sorting Out Srgnanrre Schernes. Nor'. -l993, Lsup.st
`Conf. Computcr'& Cornn. SccuriS-'93, p. 74-85.
`Birgit Pfitzrnmn. Sorting Out Sipnahrrc Schcmcs. Nor'. 1993, lst
`Conf. Cornputer & Colnrn. Secruify'93 pp. 74-85.
`Bou'rnan, C. Mic, ct al., "Hancst: A Scalablc, Custotnizablc Discor-
`ery antl Access Systern," Aug. 4, I 994. pp. I -27.
`Borunan. C. Mic. et a1., "Han'est: A Scalable, Custolnizable Discor-
`ery and Access Systern," Mar. I 2, 1995, pp, I -29.
`Brisco. T., "DNS Support for Load Balarcing," Apr. 1995, pp. l-7.
`Broune. Shirley et al.. "Localion-lndependent Narning for Virtual
`Distributed Soliu,ae Repositories." 1995. 7 pages.
`Browne, Shirley et al.. "Location-lndependent Nuning lbr Virtual
`DistribuLed Soli wzu e Repo siiories." 1 995, printed liom http :,'u,u,u,.
`netlib.org/utkpapersilifnirnain.htrnl on Mm. 22, 2006, 18 pages.
`Cater. J. Lawrence. et al. "Universal Classes of Hash Frnctions."
`Jorulal of Corrputer md Systern Sciences, vol. I ti. No. 2. Apr. 1979.
`pp. 143-l 54.
`Chris Charnes and Josef Pieprzky, Lineu Nonequivalence versus
`Nonlineality, Pieprzky, pp. 156-164. 1993,
`Civil Mimrtes General dated Jm. 25. 2005. fion Cii'il Action No. CV
`OO-tOtU-.15v lCTx).
`Clifford Llnch (Calur@ucctnvsa.bitnet), "ietf url,'uri overvieu, draft
`paper ('long)". uw.acl.lml.gor,,'tlRlrachiveirui-9iql.rnessages/
`0015.htrnl. Mu. 25, 1993.
`Cornplaint for Patent Infiingernent. Pennment Injunction, a:rd Darn-
`ages. dated Sep. 8, 2004, frorn Civil Action No. CV 04-7456 .lFW
`(.AJWx).
`Connen. Thornas i-I., et al. Introduction to Algorithms, The MIT
`Press, Cambridge. Massachusetts, 1994, pp. 219-243, 99 I -993.
`CWIS' Opcning N4nknan Bricf Constming thc Tcrtns at Issuc in
`U.S. Patent No. 6.4i 5.280. dated.hrl. 25. 2003, frorn Civil Action No.
`02-t 1430 Rwz.
`CWIS' Reply Markrnan Brief Constming the Telns at Issue in LLS.
`Patent No. 6,415.280, dated Aug. i5. 2003. frorn Civil Action No.
`02-11430 RWZ,
`Danzig, P.B., ct al., ""Distlibutcd Indcxing: A Scalablc N{cchmistn
`for Distributed Inl'urrurtion Retrieval."" Proceedings of the 14th
`Amual Intemational AC\4 SIGIR Conference on Resealch and
`Dcvcloprnent in Infonnation Rctricral, pp. 220-229, Oct. 13-16.
`199 1,
`Davis. James R., "A Sen'er for aDistributed Digital Technical Report
`Libray," Jm. 1-s, 1994, pp. t-8.
`Declaralion of Robert B.K. De*'m in Sr.rppott of CWIS' Constntction
`ofthe Telns ar Issue in LI.S. Patent No. 6,415,280, dated Jul, 25,
`2003. from Civil Action No. 02-CV-l I430RWZ.
`Deering. Stephen. el al. "Multicast Routing il Datagrarn
`lntemetuorks and Extended LANs," ACM'Irmsactions on Corn-
`putcr Systclns, r'ol. 8, No. 2, May 1990, pp. 85-1 10.
`Del'endant Digital Islmd's Openirg Briel'on Clairr Conslluction
`Issues dated Aug, 17, 2001, fiom Civil Action No. 00-cv-11851-
`RWZ.
`Defendant Lirne Wire. LLC's ,\nswer. Affilnatir,e Defenses and
`Counterclairns dated Nov. I 5, 2007, {iotn Civil Action No. 07-06161
`VBF (PLA\).
`Defendant Media Sentry. Inc.'s Reply Mernorandrun of Points and
`Authorities in Fruther Supporl of Its Motion to Disrniss. dated Nov,
`15, 2004. frorn Civil Action No. CV04-7456 JFW (CTx).
`
`Defendant MediaSenhy Inc.'s Notice of Motion and Motion to Dis-
`miss Filst ,\rnended Cornplaint: Memorandrun of Points and
`Althorities in Supporl Thereof, dated Dec. 13, 2004, frorn Cit'it
`Action No. CV04-7.156 JFW,
`De1'endant l\4ediaSentry. Inc.'s Arsu,er to PlaintilTs' First Anended
`Cornplaint and Counterclaims. dated Feb. 8, 2005. frorn Civil Action
`No. CVCI4-7456 JFW (CTx).
`Defendant zuAA's Notice of Motion and Motion to Disrniss First
`A:nended Cornplaint: Mernormdrun of Points md Authorities in
`Support Thereof, dated Dec. 13. 2004. fiorn Civil Action No. CV04-
`7456.IFW (CTx).
`Defendants Loudeye Corp.'s md Overpeer, Inc.'s Arsu'er to Plain-
`tiffs' First Arnended Cornplaint md Colmterclairn, dated Feb. 8,
`2005. liorn Civil Action No. 04-7456 JFW (AJWx).
`Defendmts' Prelirrinuy lnvalidity Contentions dated Dec. 14,2006.
`frorn Cir.il Action No. CV 06-5086 SJO (Ex).
`Dcvinc. Roberr. "Dcsign a.nd hnplclncntation of DDH: A Distribritcd
`Dynarric Hashing Algorithrn." In Proc. of4th International Confer-
`cncc on lioundalions of Data Organizations md Algorithrns, 1993,
`pp. l0l-l 14.
`European Seach Report issned Dec. 23, 2004 in colepsontling
`luropem Application No. 96910762.2-2201 .
`Expcrt Repof olProfessor Ellis Hororvitz, datcd Ma. 6.2006, frorn
`Civil Action No. 04-7456.IFW (CTx).
`Expef Repofi of the Honorable Gerald .T. \4ossinghoff. rlated Ma.
`11, 2006, from Civil Action No. 04-7456JFW (CTx).
`Faltstrorn. P et al., "Horv to Interact rvith a Whois++ Vesh," Feb.
`1996. pp. l-9.
`Feeley. Michael, et al. "Ilnplementing Global lr4ernory Management
`in aWorkstation Cluster.'" In Proc. of the l5th ACM Syrp. on Oper-
`ating Systerns Principles. 1995, pp. 201-212.
`Fielding, R. et al., "Fly;rerlext Transfer Protocol HTTPrl.l." Jm.
`1997. pp. l-163
`Fielding, R. et al.. "Hypertext Transfer Protocol HTTP/1.1,".Iun.
`1999, pp. l-157.
`First Arnended Complaint for Patent Infringernent, Pe.nnanent
`Injunction and Damages. dated No\'. 24. 2004, from Civil Action No.
`Cv 04-7456 JFW (C'Ix).
`Floyd, Sally, et al. 'A reliable Multicast Frarnervork for Light-Wei€fit
`Sessions and Application Level Frarning,"' In Proceeding of ACM
`SIGCOMM '95, pp. 342-356.
`Frcdnan. Michacl. ct a1. "Storing a Sparsc Tablc rvith 0(l) Worst
`Case Access Tirne." Jorunal of the Association for Cornputing
`Machinerl. vol. 31. No. 3. .rul. 1984, pp. 538-544.
`G. L. Flicdrnaa, Digital Carncra With Appn'atus ForAuthcntication
`of Images Produced Frcrn an Lnage File, NAS.A Case No, NPO-
`19108-l-CU, U.S. Appl. No. 08r159,980. Nov.24. 1993.
`Grigni, Michelargelo. et al. "TipCrt Bounds on Minirmur Broadcasts
`Netw'orks." SIAM .'lorunal of Discrete Mathernatics. vol, 4. No. 2.
`May 1991, pp.207-222.
`Gu'eitzrnm, Jilncs, ct al. "Thc Casc for Gcographical Push-Cach-
`ing." Techrical Report HU TR 34-94 (excerpt), Havard University.
`DAS, Cambridge. MA 02138, 1994. 2 pgs.
`Goodrnal, Ada. Objcct-Oricntcd Techliqucs. and Concurrclcy in
`Teaching Data Stnrctures and File \4anagement Report Doctunenta-
`tion p. AD-A275 385-94-04217,
`H. Goodrnm, Fcb. 9, 1994 Ada, Obicct-Oricntcd Tcch-niques. md
`Concnrrency in Teaching Data Snlctr"ues and File Managernent
`Report Docurrrentation P .AD-A275 3a5-94-04277 ,
`Hauzeur. B. M., 'A Model for Narning. .Addessing. and Routing,"
`ACM Trms. Inf, Syst.4. Oct.4, 1986). 293-311.
`Intemational Search Report daled Jun. 24, 1996 in corresponding
`intcrnational application PCTTIIS 1996!0047 33.
`K. Sollins and L. Masinter. "Functional Requirernents lbr Unilbnn
`Resource Nnnes", um,.w3.orgiAddressinglrfclT3T.At. Dec. 1994,
`pp. 1-7.
`Khare, R. and Lawrence, S., "Upgrading to TLS Within HTTPrl.l,'"
`May 2000, pp. l-12.
`Khoshafiar, S. N. ct al. 1986. Obicct idcntity. In Conf. Proc. on
`Object-Oriented Prograrruning Systerns. Languages and Applica-
`tions (Poltland. t)regon, Llnited States, Sep. 29-Oct.2, 1986). N.
`Meyou'itz, Ed. OOPLSA '86. ACM Prcss. Ncu,York, lrY,406-416.
`
`EXHIBIT 4 . 5
`
`
`
`Case 5:18-cv-05198-BLF Document 14-4 Filed 10/04/18 Page 7 of 61
`
`us 7,945,544B.2
`Page 6
`
`Kirn et al., "Experiences wifh Tripu'ire: llsing Integrity Checkers for
`Intmsion Detection". COAST Labs. Dept. of Cornputer Sciences
`Pudue Llniversity, Feb.22. 1995. pp. l-12.
`Kirn et al., "The Design :rnd Itnplernentation of Tripu'ire: A iile
`Systern Integrity Checker"', COAST Labs. Dept. ol'Cornputer Sci-
`ences Pmdue University, Feb. 23.1995, pp. 1-1ti,
`Kirn et al., "The Desipn and Lnplernentation of Tripwire: A file
`Systeln Integity Checker", COAST Labs. Dept. of Colnputer Sci-
`ences Prudue Universityi Nov. 19. 1993. pp. 1-21.
`Kirn. Gene H.. md Spafford, Eugene H., "Writing. Supporting, and
`Evalrating Tripu'ire A Publicly Available Sectuity Tool." Coast
`Labs. Dept. of Cornputer Sciences l\rdue University, Mar. 1.2, 1994,
`pp. l-23.
`Knuth. Donald E., "Thc Arl of Cornprttcr Progrunning.." 1973, r'ol.
`3. Ch. 6.4, pp. 506-549
`Lantz^ K. A., ct al., "Tou'alds a univclsal directory scrvicc," In Proc.
`4th Armral ACM Syrnp. on Principles of Distributcd Cornputirg
`(Minaki. Ontario, Canada). PODC '85. ACV Pless, NewYork, NY,
`250-260.
`Leach, P .T., et al.. The file systeln ofan integrated local network. In
`Proc. 1985 ACM l3thArnual Conl-. on Clornp.