Case 5:18-cv-05198-BLF Document 14-3 Filed 10/04/18 Page 1 of 62
`Case 5:18—cv-05198—BLF Document 14-3 Filed 10/04/18 Page 1 of 62
`
`EXHIBIT 3
`EXHIBIT 3
`
`

`

`Case 5:18-cv-05198-BLF Document 14-3 Filed 10/04/18 Page 2 of 62
`
`I lilll ililil ilr ililr ililrlllll lllil llll lllll lillr il|il ililr ril illl llll
`us007802310B2
`
`(r2) United States Patent
`Farber et al.
`
`(ro) Patent No.:
`(+s) Date of Patent:
`
`us 7,802,310 B2
`*Sep. 21,2010
`
`(54)
`
`(7s)
`
`(73)
`
`(*)
`
`(21)
`(22)
`(65)
`
`(60)
`
`(s 1)
`
`Appl. No
`Filed:
`
`CONTROLLING ^{CCESS TO DATA IN A D.{TA
`PROCESSTNG SYSTEi\{
`Invcntors: David A. Farber. Ojai, CA (JS):
`Ronald D. Lachman, Northbrook, IL
`(rJS)
`Assignees: Kinetech, Inc.. Studio City, CA (JS);
`Level 3 Communicationso LLC,
`Broornfield, CO tiJS)
`Nolice: Subjecl to any disclaimer. lhe tenn of this
`patcnt is extendcd or adjustcd undcr 35
`U.S.C. 154O) by 79 days.
`This palent is subject 1o a tenuinal dis-
`clairner.
`11/980,687
`Oct.3L,2007
`Prior Publication Data
`US 200B/0066191A1 Mar. 13.2008
`Related U.S, Application l)ata
`Continuatiotr of application No. 11/724,232. filed on
`Mar. 15. 2007, r.r'iich is a continuation of application
`No. l11017,650. filed on Dec. 22,2004, which is a
`continnation of application No. 09/987,723, filed on
`Nov. 15. 2001, now Pat. No. 6,928,442. which is a
`contirnation of application No. 09/283,160, filed on
`Apr 1, 1999. non'Pat. No. 6.415,280. which is a divi-
`sion ofapplication No. 08/960,079, filed on Oct.24,
`1 997. now Pat. No. 5.97 8,7 9 1. u'hich is a continnation
`of application No. 08/425, 1 60. fi led on Apr. 1 1. 1 995.
`now abandoned, application No. I 1i980.687, rvhich is
`a corltirrration of application No . I0/7 42,972, filed on
`Dec.23,2003. u'hich is a division of application No.
`091987.723, filcd on Nov. 15, 2001, now Pat. No.
`6,928^442, which is a continuation of'application No.
`09i283.160, filed onApr I, 1999. Inrw Pa1. No. 6,415,
`280. n'hich is a division ofapplication No. 08/960.079.
`filed on Oct. 24. 1997 , nou' Pat. No. 5,978.791 , which
`is a continnation of applicationNo. 08/425.160, fi1ed
`on Apr. 1 1, 1 995, norv abaudoued.
`Int. Cl.
`H04L 29/06
`G06F 21/00
`
`(2006.01)
`(2006.01)
`
`(s2)
`(s8)
`
`u.s. ct.
`126/28:7 111163
`Field of Classifi cation Search ........... ........ 7 26128.
`726127,29; 7131181
`See application file for cornplete search history.
`
`(56)
`
`Refcrcnccs Citcd
`
`U.S. PATENT DOCUMENTS
`3,668,647 A
`
`6/1972 Evmgelistietal,
`
`(Contimred)
`
`EP
`
`FOREIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
`0 268 069 A2
`(Contimred)
`
`5/1988
`
`OTHER PUBLIC,{TIONS
`
`Cheriton, Dar.id R. and Mann, Tirnothy P, "Decentralizing a global
`naning seruice lbr irnprovedperlbnnmce md thult tolerzrnce", ACM
`Transactions on Cornputer Systerns, vol. 7, No. 2, May 1989. pp.
`147-l 83.
`
`(Continued)
`Prinnr)., Esanirer Gilbefio Barron. Jr.
`Assistant Exontirzer Samson B Letnma
`(7 4) Attontelt, Agent. or Finn-Davidson Berquist Jackson &
`Go'*'dev, LLP; Brian Siritztrry
`(57)
`
`ABSTRACT
`
`Access to and delivery oflicensed content is controlled using
`content nanes that were detennined based on the content. A
`name for a data iten is obtained, the name having beeu
`detemrined based at least in part on the data wlich courprise
`the contents of the data item. Access to the data iterrr is
`authorized based at least in part on the name. Once atttho-
`rizcd, access may be granted fron nore than oue corDputcr.
`Thenamernay have beendetermiued usinga hash ornessage
`digest fturction snch as MD4, MD5 or SHA. The data item
`rnay cornprise a lile, a portion ola lile, a page in lremor)'. a
`digilal rnessage, a digital irnage, a video signal or an andio
`sigral.
`
`87 Claims,31 Drawing Sheets
`
`STORAGE
`DEVICE
`
`Dn/lGE
`
`106
`
`J.00
`
`EXHIBIT 3 - 1
`
`

`

`Case 5:18-cv-05198-BLF Document 14-3 Filed 10/04/18 Page 3 of 62
`
`Hunter el al.
`Belsan et al,
`Konrad et al.
`Wyrnan
`Cato et al.
`Perelson et il. ............... 711,'21
`Cohn et al.
`Nelson et al.
`Dorfrnan ..................... 7 14,' 54
`Coppersrnith et al.
`Bulnett
`Winterbottom
`Badcr
`Fischer
`Squibb ............,.......... 107 i695
`Gopal et al.
`Friedrnan
`hisenberg et al.
`Krarvczl'k ...........,....... 7l3il 88
`Blickcnstaff ct al. ........ 707 l)05
`Neirnat et al,
`Ross et al.
`Grccnwood ct al.
`Stern
`Burnett
`Fitzgerald et al.
`Gardler et al.
`Neermn et al.
`IIou'ard
`Aziz
`Nuttall et al.
`Kindell et al.
`V'elissalopoulos et al.
`Stefik et al.
`Harnilton et al.
`Wbodhill et al.
`Blakley. III et al.
`Dockter et al.
`Cahill et al.
`Johnson et al. ............. 7l3i 189
`Carnpbell
`Alf'erness et al.
`Alley et al.
`Chmg et al,
`Taoda
`Masinter....
`Wyrm
`Bellare et a.l.
`Aucsrnith et a[.
`Haber et al,
`Balick ct al.
`Nguyen
`l)gata et al.
`Herz et al.
`Boebert et al.
`Davis
`Gudrnundson et al.
`Grisrvold
`Iruber et al.
`Gamy et al.
`Bnmett et al.
`Jones et al.
`Kahn et al.
`Farber et al.
`Hale et al.
`Squibb ...,...........
`Faber et al,
`Fuber et al.
`Lee et al.
`Lee et al.
`Lee et al,
`Lee et al.
`Fabcr ct al.
`
`............ 1i1
`
`707 il
`
`us 7,802,310 82
`Page 2
`
`2/ 199-5
`411995
`4t 1995
`8/ | 995
`8,1 995
`9r 1995
`91 1995
`9i 199-s
`9,1 995
`9t 1995
`101199-(
`I lr 1995
`I li t99,5
`l2t 1995
`1211995
`2i 1996
`311996
`4t 1996
`6i 1996
`7 i 1996
`7 ! t996
`9i I 996
`l0r1996
`12/ 1996
`12i 1996
`t2t 1996
`t2/ 1996
`I2t 1996
`2t 1997
`2/ l99i
`2/199',i
`511997
`5/ 1997
`6i199'i
`6i1997
`7t1997
`t0!199'7
`I0t199i
`10/ 1997
`1211991
`121 t997
`12! 1997
`1r 1 998
`3/1998
`311998
`4i 1998
`4i1998
`511998
`51 I 998
`7 t 1998
`gt 1998
`9r1998
`10r1998
`1 1/1998
`l1 1999
`5t1999
`5i 1999
`8ri999
`I l/1999
`I 1t1999
`12it999
`10r2000
`1 0/2000
`1/2002
`5/2004
`1 112004
`812005
`5i2002
`6t2002
`412003
`4t2003
`5/2003
`7/2004
`
`A
`
`A A A AA A AA AA AA AA A AA AA AA AA A AAAAA B
`
`1
`B1
`81 *
`B2
`AI
`AI
`AI
`A1
`AI
`AI
`
`s.394,5 55
`5,403.639
`5,404,508
`5,4i8,508
`5,442,343
`s,448,668
`5,448,718
`5,452,447
`5,454.000
`5,454,039
`5,459.860
`5,465,365
`5,467 ,471
`5,475.826
`5.479,654
`,{.491,817
`5,499.294
`,5,504,879
`-s,530.757
`5,5 37.585
`5,542.087
`-5,5 51.143
`s, s68.1 8 I
`5,5 81.615
`5,5 81,758
`5,s 8 I,764
`5,5 83.995
`s,5 88, I 47
`5,600,834
`5,604,803
`5,604,892
`5,630,067
`5,632,031
`5,638,443
`s,640,564
`5,649,196
`5,677 .952
`5,678,038
`5,678,046
`5.694,472
`5,694,s96
`s,701,3 16
`5.7 10922
`5;724,425
`5,',724.552
`5.i42,807
`s,7 45,879
`s 7s7ql3
`5,757,915
`5.781,629
`5,802,29 I
`5,809,494
`5.826.049
`5,815,087
`5,864,683
`s,907 ,619
`5,907 ,704
`5,940.504
`5,978,79 I
`s,991,414
`6,006,018
`6,134,603
`6.1 35,646
`6,4 15,280
`6,732,1 80
`6,8 I 6,872
`6,928,442
`2C)02i 0052884
`2002i0082999
`2003i 0078888
`2003i 0078889
`2003i 0095660
`?,004i0139097
`
`U.S. PAIENT DOCUMENTS
`3.835.260 A
`9i1974 Ptescheretal.
`4.096.568 A
`6.'1978 Bennefletal.
`4,215,402 A
`7i 1980 Mitchell et al.
`4.221.003 A
`9i 1980 Chargetal.
`4,290,105 A
`911981 Cichellietal.
`4,376,299 A
`3i 1983 Rivest
`4.405,829 A
`911983 fur'est et al.
`4.4i2.285 A
`10i1983 Nechesetal.
`4,414,624 A
`I li 1983 Sruuner, .rr. et al.
`4,441,155 A
`4i1984 Iiletcheretal.
`4.4(A,'713 A
`811984 Benhaseetal.
`4,490,782 A
`1211984 Dixon et al.
`4,558.413 A
`l2ll985 Schrnidtetal.
`4,571.700 A
`211986 Erruy. -lr. et al.
`4.577.293 A
`3,'1986 Matick et al.
`4.642,793 A
`2,'1987 Meaden
`4.658,093 A
`4,'1987 Helhnan
`4.675.810 A
`611987 Gruner et al.
`4.691,299 A
`9i1987 Rivest et al,
`4,725,945 A
`2/1988 Kronstadtelal.
`4,773,039 A
`9i1988 Zarnora
`4,821.184 A
`4/1989 Clmcy et al.
`4,887,235 A
`l2il989 Hollou'ayetal.
`4,888,681 A
`l2i 1989 Bunesetal.
`4,914,586 A
`4/1990 Su,inehattetal,
`4,922,414 A
`5i 1990 Hollou'ay et al.
`4,922,417 A
`5i 1990 Chuln et al.
`4.949,302 A
`8i 1990 Arnoldetal.
`4,972,367 A
`ll,'1990 Burke
`5.007,658 A
`4,'1991 Bendert et al.
`5.014,192 A
`5/1991 Mmsfield et al.
`5,025,421 A
`6i1991 Cho
`5,047,918 A
`9/1991 Schu'a1zetal,
`5.050,074 A
`9i1991 Milca
`5,050,212 A
`9i1991 Dyson
`5.057.837 A
`l0il991 Clolu'elletal.
`5.077,658 A
`12i1991 Bendefi
`I l9q2 Mrzario
`5.084.8 15 A
`5.117,351 A
`511992 Miller
`5,129,081 A
`7i1992 KobaYashietal.
`5.129.082 L
`7i1992 Tirfirgetal.
`5,144,66'7 A
`9i1992 Pogue, Jr. et al.
`5.163,147 A + 11i1992 Orita ............................. 707t9
`5.179.680 A
`lil993 Colwelletal.
`5.182.799 A
`lll993 Tarnuraetal.
`5,199.073 A
`311993 Scott
`5.202.982 A I 411993 Granlichetal. ................... li I
`5,204.897 A
`4,',1993 S/ynm
`5,204.958 A
`4i1993 Chcngctal.
`5.204,966 A
`4i 1993 Wittenberg et al.
`5,208,858 A
`5i1993 Vollerletal.
`5,247,620 A
`9i1993 Frtkuzauactal.
`5,260,999 A
`11i1993 S/ytnan
`5,276,869 A
`|i1994 Forestetal.
`5,276,901 A
`Li1994 I{owell et al.
`5,287,499 A
`2ii994 NeInes
`5.287,514 A
`211994 Gran
`5,297,279 A
`311994 Bannonetal.
`5,301,286 A
`4.1994 Raiani
`5,301,316 A
`4 1994 Hatnilton et al.
`5,317,693 A
`5i1994 Cttenod et al.
`5,341,477 A
`8i 1994 Pitkin et al.
`5,343.527 A
`8i1994 Moore
`5.347,653 A
`9t1994 Flynnctal.
`5.351,302 A
`9i1994 Leightonetal.
`5,357,440 A
`10"1994 Talbottetal.
`5,351,623 A
`l0i 1994 Megoty-Cohen
`5,359,523 A
`10i 1994 Talbott et al.
`5,361,356 A
`Ili1994 Claketal.
`5.371.897 A
`12 1994 Brcunetal.
`5.384.565 A
`1i1995 Cannon
`
`F,XHIBIT 3 - 2
`
`

`

`Case 5:18-cv-05198-BLF Document 14-3 Filed 10/04/18 Page 4 of 62
`
`us 7,802,310 82
`Page 3
`
`2005!0010792
`2005t0114296
`2007/01 85848
`200810065635
`2008/00661 9l
`20081007 I 855
`2008/00825 5 I
`
`Al8
`A1
`AI
`AI
`AI
`AI
`Ai
`
`t2005
`5,',2005
`8/2007
`3i 2008
`3i 2008
`3,'2008
`4t2008
`
`Carpentier et al. .......... 7 131193
`.Fuber et al.
`Farber et al.
`Farber et al-
`.Faber et al.
`Iarber et al.
`Farber et al.
`
`FOR F,] GN P,AIENT DOCUMENTS
`
`EP
`EP
`EP
`EP
`EP
`EP
`EP
`GB
`JP
`.rP
`JP
`JP
`.rP
`JP
`.IP
`wo
`wo
`WO
`wo
`WO
`
`A2
`A2
`
`AI
`A2
`A2
`A
`
`A2
`A
`
`0 315 425
`0 558 945
`0 566 967
`0 592045
`0631 226
`0 654 9ZO
`0 658 022
`2294132
`s90s85g
`63-106048
`63-273961
`2-1277 55
`05162529
`06 r 87384
`063485.58
`wo 92120021
`wo 94106087
`wo 94i 209 t3
`wo 95101599
`wo 97 !437 l7
`
`5i I 989
`911993
`10i 1993
`4t t994
`12t t994
`5/1995
`6i 1995
`4t t996
`4t 1984
`5i 1988
`1 lrl988
`5r 1990
`611993
`7 i 1994
`12/1994
`11i 1992
`3i 1994
`9t 1994
`1r1995
`11t 1997
`
`OTIIER PUBLICATIONS
`
`Request for Reexillination of U.S. Patent No. 6,928.442: Reexatn
`U.S, Appl. No. 901010.260, filed on Arrg. 29, 2008.
`'92 Workshop on the
`Advances in Cryptology-AUSCRYPT
`'l'heory md Application of Cryptographic 'lechnitlues Gold Coast,
`Queensland, Australia Dec. 13-16, 1992 Proceedings.
`Advarces in Cryptology-ETIROCRYPT '93. Workshop on the
`'lheory md Applicalion of Cr-wptographic lechniques Lofthus, \or-
`wzy. Mry 23-27.1993 Proceedings.
`Aildavit of Timothy P- Walker in Support of CWIS' Opening Mark-
`man Brief Construing the Terms at Issue il L.S. Patent No.
`6,415.280. dated .Iul. 25, 2003, frorn Civil .Action No. 02-ll43o
`RWZ.
`Akami and Ml l's Merlorandutn in Support of 'l'heil Clairn Con-
`stluction of USPAT 5.978,791, dated Aug. 31, 2001, frotn Civil
`Action No. 00-cv-l 185 IRWZ.
`,\kamai's Ansu'er. Affirtnative Defenses and Comterclaitns to
`Anended Complaint. filed Dec. 6, 2002, in Civil Aciion No. 02-CV-
`11430RW2.
`Aknmi's Brief on Claim Constmction. dated Aug. 8, 2003, frotn
`Civil Action No. 02-1 1430 RWZ.
`Alberl Langer (cmlt5l@anu,oz.au), http:r/groups.google.com/
`groups?selm:199i Aug7.225 I59.786o2640neu'shost,anu. edu.art
`&oe:IJTF-8&output:gplain. Aug. 7, 1 99 I .
`Alexander Dupuy (dupuy@snarts.coln), "MD5 md I-IFNs (uas:
`Misc Corrunents)". wu'w.acl. lanl. gor'/URliatchive"/ru i -94q2.rnes-
`sageslOO8l.htrnl, Apl 17 , 1994.
`Alexmder Dupuy (dupuy@slniuts.coln), "RE: MD5 md LIFNs
`(was: Misc Comrnents)", u'ww.acl.lanl.govrURliarchive.hri-94q2.
`rnessages/0 I I 3.html, Apr. 26, 199 4.
`Alswer of Defendant RIA.4 to FirstArnended Cornplaint and Coun-
`terclairn, datcd Feb. 8, 2005. froln Civil Action No. CV04-7456 JFW
`(CTx).
`Bemers-Lee. T. et al., "Hypertext Trmsl'er Protocol-HTTPi 1.0,"
`lvlay 1996, pp. 1-54.
`Bemers-Lee, T. etal., "UniformResoruceLocators (LIRL),"pp l -25.
`Dec.1994.
`Bemers-Lee, T.. "Universal Resoruce ldenti{iers in *1[-W," Jun.
`1994. pp. I -25.
`Bert dern Boer. et al., Collisiols for tle cornprcssion frtnction of
`N4D.sub.5 pp. 292 -304. 1994.
`
`Birgil Pfitzlnm, Sofing Out Signahrre Schemes. Nov. 1993. I .sttp.st
`Conf. Cornputer & Cornn. Sectuity '93. p. 74-85.
`Birgit Pfitznmn, Sorting Out Signattue Schernes, Nov. 1993. lst
`Conf. Cornpitler & CoInrn. Secruity'93 pp. 74-85.
`Bou'rnm. C. N'lic, et a[., "Hnvest: A Scalable. Custornizable Discor'-
`eryandAccess Systern."Aug. 4, 1994,pp. l-27.
`Bownan, C. Mic, et al.. "Harl'est: A Scalable. Custornizable Discov-
`ery mdAccess Systetn." Mat. 12. 1995, pp. 1-29.
`Brisco, T., "DNS Supporl for Load Balancing."Apr. 1995. pp. i-7.
`Blorvne, Shirley et al., "Location-Independent Nzuning for Vifual
`Distributed Software ltepositories," 1995, 7 pages.
`Brorvne. Shirley et al., "Location-Independent Naning for Virtual
`Distribrrtcd Soft u'arc Repo sitorics." 1 99 5, pt intcd fi orn http: /uum,.
`netlib.orgiutk/papersrlilhtnain.htrnl on Mar. 22, 2006, l8 pages.
`Carter. J. Lalvrence. et al. "Universal Classes of llash lunctions."
`Jorunal of Cornputer md Systern Sciences. vol. I 8, No. 2, Apr. 1 979,
`pp. 143-154.
`Chris Chrunes and .losef Pieprzky, Lineal Nonequivalence versus
`Nonlineality. Pieprzky, pp. 156-164, 1993.
`Civil Vinutcs Gcncraldatcd Jm.25,2005, fiunCivilAction No. CV
`04-7456-JFW (CTx).
`Clifford Lynch (Cahrr@;uccrnr.sa.bitnet), "ietf ru lr'uri oven'iev' drafl
`papcr (long)", mw.acl.lanl.goi,1llRlirchivciuri-93q1.rncssages,'
`001 5.html, Mar. 25, 1993.
`Cornplaint for Patent Infi'ingement. Pelnment lnjttnction, and Dan-
`ages, dated Sep. 8, 2004, frorn Civil Action No. CV 04-7456 .IFW
`(A.rwx).
`Cormen, thorms H.. et al. lntroductiol to Algoritluns, Ihe MI'i'
`Press. Canbridge, I\,fassachusetts, 1994. pp. 2 19 -243, 991-993.
`CWIS' Opening Mrkrm Bricf Constnring thc Tcnns at Isstrc in
`1..S. Patent No. 6,415,280, r'lated.lul. 25. 2003, liom Civil Action No.
`02-11430 RWZ.
`CWIS' Reply Malkrnm Brief Construing tle Teuns at Issue in U.S.
`Patent No. 6.415,280. dated Aug. 15. 2003. from Civil Action No.
`02-l1430 Rwz.
`Dmzig, PB., et al., ""Distributed Indexing: A Scalable Mechmisrn
`For Dishitmted Infonnation Retrieval,"" Proceedings of the 14th
`Almral International ACM SIGIR Conference on l{eseach and
`Developrnent in Infolnation Relrieral, pp. 220-229. Ocl. 13-16,
`1991.
`Davis, Jares R., 'A Server lbr aDistributed Digital lechrical l{eporl
`Library," Ja.n. 15. 199,1, pp. 1-8.
`Declalation of Robert B.K, Dewa: in Support of CWIS' Construction
`oftle lelns at lssue in LJ.S. Patent No. 6.415,280, dated Jul. 25.
`2003. florn Civil Action ),tro. 02-cv-11430RW2.
`Deering, Stephen, et al. "Multicast Routing in Datagaln
`Inte.rneftr'orks md Extended LANs." ACM 'limsactions on Clorn-
`putel Systems, vol. 8. No. 2. May 1990, pp. 85-1 10.
`Defendanl Digital Islmd's Opening Brief on Clairn Construction
`Issues dated Aug. 17, 2001, frotn Civil Action lJo, 00-c'-11851-
`RWZ.
`Defendant Lirne \tr/ire. LLC's Ans\^'er. Afilnative Defenses and
`Comterclaims dated Nor'. 15, 2007. fiom Civil Action No. 07-06161
`vBF (PLAx).
`Defendant Media Sentry, Inc.'s Reply Melnora.ndrun of Points and
`Authorities in !urther Suppott of Its Motion to Disrniss, dated Nov.
`15,2004, frorn Civil Action No. CV04-7456 JFW (CTx).
`Defendant MedraSentry Inc.'s Notice of Motion and Motion to Dis-
`miss First Arnended Cornplaint; Memorandrun of Points and
`Authorities in Support Thereof, dated Dec. 13, 2004, frorn Civil
`Action No. CV04-7456 .fFW.
`Defendant MediaSentry', Inc.'s Alswer to Plaintifl's' First Arnended
`Complaint and Counterclaims. dated Feb. 8. 2005, from Civil Action
`No. CV04-7456 JFW (CTx).
`Defendant RIAA's Notice of Motion and Motion to Disrliss First
`Arnended Cornplaint; I\4ernormdurn of Points a:rd Authorities in
`Support Thereo{ dated Dec. 13. 2004, frorn Civil Action No. CV04-
`7456 JFW (C lx).
`Defendants Loudeye Corp.'s and Overpeer, Inc.'s Answer to Plain-
`tiffs' First Arnended Cornplaint and Cotmtetclailn, d.lted Feb. 8,
`2005, llnrn CivilAction \lo. 04-7456 .lFW (AJWx).
`Defendants' Preliminay In alidity Contentions dated Dec. 14, 2006,
`from Civil Action No. CV 06-5086 SJO (Ex).
`
`EXHIBIT 3 - 3
`
`

`

`Case 5:18-cv-05198-BLF Document 14-3 Filed 10/04/18 Page 5 of 62
`
`us 7,802,310 B2
`
`Page 4
`
`Devine, Robert. "Design a:rd Irnplernentation of DDH: A Distributed
`Dynunic Hashing Algorithtn," In Proc. of 4th International Conl'er'
`ence on Foundations of Data Organizations ud Algorithms, 1993,
`pp. l0l-l 14.
`European Sealch Report issued Dec. 23, )004 in corepsondirtg
`European Application No. 969 107(12.2-220 1.
`Ixpert Report of Professor Ellis Ilorowitz. cleted Mar'. 6,2006, frorn
`Civil Action No. 04-7456 JFW (CTx).
`Expert Report of the Honorable Gerald.T. Mossinghoff. d,1ted \4rr'
`13. 2006, liom Civil Action No. 04-7456 JF\V (CTx).
`Faltstrorn. P. et al., "Hou'to Interact with a Whois++ Mesh." Feb.
`i996. pp, I -9.
`iieeley, Michael. et al. "Implernenting Global Memoiy Mmagernent
`in aWorkstation Clrtster." In Proc. of ihe l5th ACM Synp, on Oper-
`ating Systerns Principles. 1995. pp. 201-212.
`Fielding, R. et al., "Hypeltext Trmsl's Botocol-HTTPll.l," Jm.
`1997. pp. I-16-1,
`Irielding, R, et al.. "Hypertext Transfer Protocol IITTP/ I 1," Jrtn.
`1999. pp, l-1s7.
`Filst Arncldcd Colnplaint for Patcnt lnfringcrncnt, Pcnnancnt
`Injunction and Darnages, dated Nor'. 24, 2004, ilorn Civil Action No.
`Cv 04-7456 JFW (.CTx).
`Irloyd, Sally, et al. 'A reliable Multicast lirameuork fol Light-Wei€fit
`Sessions md Application Level lirzuring." In Proceeding of ACM
`SIGCO\4M'95. pp. 342-356.
`Fredrnan, Michael. et al. "Storing a Sparse Table with 0('1) Worst
`Case Access Tirne.".Tournal of the Association for Conputing
`\,Iachinery, r'ol.31, No.3, Jul. i984, pp. 538-544.
`G. L. Friedmm, Digital Canera With Apparzhrs for Authentication
`of Images Produced Frotn an Itnage File, NASA Case No. NPO-
`19108-l-CU, U.S. Appl. No. 08r159.9ti0, Nor'. 24. 1993.
`Grigni, Michelangelo, et al. "Irglrt Bounds on Vinirntun Broadcasts
`Networks." SIAM .Iounal of Discrete Matlerlatics, I'ol. 4, No. 2.
`lr4ay 1991. pp. 207 -222.
`Gwertzrnan. .l^lnes. et al. "The Case for Geographical Push-Cach-
`hg." Technical l{eport HU 1R 34-94 (excerpt), Hanard University,
`DAS, Canbridge, MA 02138, 1994. 2 pgs.
`H. Goodrnan, Ada, Object-Oriented Techniques, md Conctlrrency in
`Teaching Data Stntctrtres md File Managernent Report Documenta-
`tion p. Ad-A275 385-94-04277,
`H. Gooclnar, Feb. 9, 1994 Ada, Object-Oriented Techniques, and
`ConcurLency in 'Ieachrng Data Sructtues md lile Managernent
`Report Docurnentation P AD-A275 385-94-04277.
`Hauzeur, B. M.. 'A Model lor Naning, Addtessing, md Routing,"
`ACM Trms. Ini Syst. 4, OcL 4, 1986). 293-311.
`International Search Report dated Jun. 24. 1996 in correspondilg
`international application PCT,ltJS I 996/004733.
`K. Sollils md L. N{asinter, "Functional Reqrtirernents for Unifonn
`Resoruce Narnes", uuq,.w3,orgi Addressing/rfc I737.txt, Dec. 1994.
`pp.l-7.
`K-hale. R. md Lau'rence, S,, "Upgrading to'lLS Within H'Il'Pi 1.1,"
`N4ay 2000. pp. l-12.
`Kloshafiar, S. ),tr. et al. 1986, Object identity. In Conf. Proc On
`Object-Oriented Progratnning Systelns. Lmguages and Applica-
`tions (Pofiland. Oregon, United States, Sep. 29-Oct.2,1986). N.
`N4eyrorvitz. Ed, OOPLSA'86. ACM Press, NewYork, NY,406-416
`Kim et al., "Experiences with Tripwire: Using Integrity Checkers lbr
`Intmsion Detection", COAST Labs. Dept. of Cornpnter Sciences
`Purdrrc Llnivcrsity,Feb.22. 1995, pp. 1-i2,
`Kim et al., "The Desipn and hnplernentation of Tripwile: A file
`Systern Integrity Checker", COAST Labs. Dept. of Computer Sci-
`ences Purdue Uriversity, Feb, 23, 1995. pp. l-18.
`Kirn el al., "The Design and Lnplernentation of Tripu'ire: A lile
`Systern Inteplity Checker", COAST Labs. Dept. of Cotnputer Sci-
`cnccs Purdue Univcrsity, Nov. 19. 1993, pp. l-2 I .
`Kin. Gene H.. and SpalTord, Eugene H., "Writing, Supporting, md
`Evaluating Tripu,ire; A Publicly Available Security Tool." COAST
`Labs. Dept. of Cornpute| Sciences htrdue UniYersity, Mu. 12,1994,
`pp. l'23.
`Kmrth. Donald E., "The Art of Clomputer Programing." 1973, vol.
`3, Ch.6.4. pp 506-549
`
`Lantz, K. A., et al., "Tou'rds a universal directoly sen ice." In Proc.
`4th .Armral ACM Syrnp. on Principles of Distlibuted Cotnputing
`(Minaki. Ontario, Cmada). PODC '85. ACM Press. Neu'\brk, NY,
`250-260.
`Leach. P J,. et al,. The file systeln ofan integrated local network. In
`Proc. 1985 ACM l3thArnual Conf. on Cornp. Sci. CSC '85. ACM
`Prcss. ),1Y. NY. 309-324.
`Lcach, PJ., ct al., 't.IDs as lntcrnal Nancs in a Distributed Filc
`Systern," In Proc. l st ACM SIGACT-SIGOPS Syrnp. on Principles of
`Distlibuted Cornputing (Ottau/a, Canada. Aug. l8-20, 1982). PODC
`'82. ACM Prcss, Ncu'York, N\', 34-41.
`Ma. C. 1992. On building vcry lrugc naning systcrns. In Proc. -sth
`Workshop on,\CM SIGOPS European Workshop: Models and Pa:a-
`diguns For Distributed Systerns Sbllctluing (Frmce, Sep. 2l-23.
`1992). EW 5. ACV Press, NewYork, NY, 1-5.
`Mernorandtun of Points and Anthorities in Support of Loudeye's md
`Overpeer's Motion to Disniss the Fitst Arnended Cornplainl for
`Failue to State a Cllairn or. In the Alternative. for a More Definitive
`Staternent, dated Dec. 13, 2004, frorn Cir.il Action No. C\'-04-7456
`JFw{AIVX).
`Ming-Ling Lo et al., On Optirnal Processor Allocation to Stlpport
`Pipelined Hash.loins, ACM SIGMOD, pp.69-78. May 1993.
`Moats. R., "URN S,vntar." N{ay 1997, pp. l-ii,
`Mruiidhu Koushik, Dyna:nic Hashing With Disbibuted Overflorv
`Space: A Irile OrgalizationWith Good Insertion Perfolrnance. 1993,
`Info. Sys.. r'ol. 18. No. 5. pp. 299-317.
`Myers, J. and Rose, M., "The Content-MDs Header Field," Oct.
`1995, pp. 1-4.
`Naor. Moni, et al. 'The Load. Capacity and Availability of QuorLun
`Systerns." In Proceedings ofthe 35th IIEE Syrposiurn on Ironnda-
`tions of Cornputer Scicncc, Nov. 1994, pp. 214-225.
`Nisan. Noan. "Psuedorandorn Generators for Space-Botmded Com-
`putation." In Proceedings of the Twenty-Second Armral ACM Sym-
`posium on Theoty ol Computirg. May 1990. pp.204-212.
`Office Action in corresponding .lapanese Applicalion No. 53 1,073/
`1996 rnailed on ApL 25,2006.
`C)ffice Cornrlrmication in corresponding Eruopea:r Application No.
`969 101 62.2-1225 dated .Ian. 17. 2007 .
`Order Re Clairn Consuuction dat€d N<tr'. 8. 2001 , liom Civil Action
`No.00-11851-RWZ.
`PaLner'. Mak, et al. "Fido: A Cache that Lems to Fetch." In Pro-
`cccdings of the lTth Intcrnational Confcrencc on Vcry Lzuge Data
`Bases. Sep. 1991. pp. 255-264.
`Patent Abslracts of .Tapm, "Device for Generating Database and
`Method lor the Szune," Application No. 03-080504. Sm Microsyst.
`Inc., published Jun. 1993. 38 pages.
`Patent Abstracts ol.lapan, "Electronic N4ail Multiplexing Systern and
`Cornmunication Control Method in The System." Jun. 30. 1993, JP
`051625293.
`Patent Abstracts of.Iapan. "Method for Registering and Retrieving
`Data Base," Application No, 0l-i87303, Nippon'lelegr. & 'I'eleph.
`Corp.. published Feb. 1993, I I pages.
`Peleg, Dar.id, et al. "The Availability ofQuonun Systerns." Infolna-
`tion md Cornputation 123. 1995, 210-223.
`Peter Deutsch (peterd@bunyip.cotn). "Re: MD5 and LiFNs (u'as:
`Misc Cornnclts)". ulllv.acl.lml. gor'.tlRliarchivciuri-9.1q2.rncs-
`sages/O 1 06.hlrnl, Apl 26, 1994.
`Peterson, L. L. 1988. A yellou,-pages senice for a local-zuea net-
`wor*. In Proc. ACM Workshop on Flontiers in Cornputer Clorunu-
`nications Technology (Vennont. 1987). .L J. Garcia-Luna-Aceves,
`Ed. SI(rcOM\,I '87. ACM Press. NewYork, NY,235-242.
`Plaintiffs' Mcrnormdurn of Points md Authoritics in Opposition to
`Loudeye Del'endmts' Motion to Disniss, dated Nov. 8, 2004, liom
`Civil Action No. CV-04-7456 JFW (A.IW)().
`Plaintiffs' Opposition to Media Sentry's Motion to Disrnissi Metno-
`randrun of Points md Authorities il Support Thereof, dated Nov. 8,
`2004, frorn Civil Action No. CV 04-7456.TFW (CTx).
`Plaintiffs opposition to Rccording Industry Association olA:ncri-
`ca's Motion to Distniss; Memorandun of Points and Authorities in
`Support Thereof, dated Nov. 8, 2004, Ii'om Civil Action No. CV-04-
`7456 JFw (CTx).
`
`EXHIBIT 3 - 4
`
`

`

`Case 5:18-cv-05198-BLF Document 14-3 Filed 10/04/18 Page 6 of 62
`
`us 7,802,310 82
`Page 5
`
`Plaintilt s Reply to De1'endant Loudeye Cory.'s mrl Overpeer. Inc.'s
`Counterclairns, dated Mal. 3, 2005, lilorn Civil Action No. CV
`04-7456 JFW (CTx).
`Plaintiffs Reply to Defendant Mediasentty's Counterclaitns, dated
`N4ar'. 3, 2005, florn Civil Action No. CV 04-7456JFW (C1x).
`Plaintiffs Reply to Defendmt RIAA's Connterclairns, dated Va. 3.
`2005. fioln Civil Action No. 04-7456 .]FW (CTx).
`Proceedings ofthe 1993 ACM SIGMOD lntemational Conf'erence on
`\4magernent ofData, rol. 22, Issue 2. .hut. 1993.
`Rabin, Michael. "Ef8cient Dispersal of Information for Secr.uity.
`Load Balancing, md Fault lblermce." .lor.unal of the ACir4, vol 36.
`No.2, Apr. 1989, pp.335-348,
`Ravi, R., "Rapid Rurnor Ratnification: Approxirnating thc Minitmun
`Broadcast Tirne." In Proc. ofthe 35th IEEE Synp. on Fotndation ol'
`Cornprrter Science. Nov. I 994, pp. 202-213 .
`Ravindlan, K. and Rarnakrishnan, K. K. 1991. A naming systern for
`featlre-based sen'ice specification in dishibuted operating systelns.
`SIGSMALLIPC Notes 17,3-4 (Sep. 1991), 12-21.
`Reed Whde (u,ade@cs.utk.edu). "re: Dienst and BFD/LIFN docu-
`rncnt."' Au g. 8, I 994. printed frorn http: i./rw.u'cbhistoly.orgiu'uu'
`lists.iwwrvlalkI994q3/04I6.htrrl on Mat 22, 2006, (7 pages).
`Rivest, l{.. ".lhe MD5 Message-Digest Algorithrn." Apr. 1992, pp.
`I - 19 and errata sheet ( I page).
`Rose. M., "The Content-MD5 Ileader lield," Nor,. 1993. pp, 1-3.
`Ross, K., "Ilash-Routing fot' Collections of Shued Web Caches,"
`IEEE Netu'olk Magazine. pp. 37-44, Nor'.-Dec. 1997.
`Sakti Pramanik et al.. Multi-I)irmtory Hasing. 1993. Info. Sys.. rol.
`18, No. 1. pp.63-74.
`Schrnidt, .Teanetle, et al. "ChemolT-Hoelfding Bountls lbr Applica-
`tions with Limited Independence." In Proceedings of the 4th ACS-
`SIAM Symposirun on Discrete Algorithrns, 1 993. pp. 33 1 -340.
`Schncicr. Bnrcc. "Onc-Way Hash Functions, Llsing Crypographic
`Algorithrns lbr Hashing," 1991, printed liom http:r/202.179135.4i
`data./DD.I/articles t 1991 i9 109 /9 l919gi9l 099.httn on Mu. 22, 2006.
`Schwartz, M.. et al. 1987. A nane serwice for erolving heterogeneous
`systcrns. In Proc. i lth ACM Syrnp. on L)S Principlcs (Tcxas, Nor'.
`8-l l, 1987), SOSP '87. ACM Press, NY. l'a\' 52-62.
`Se:nch Re;nrt dated.Iun. 24, 1996.
`Shaheen-Gouda,A.And Loucks, L. 1992. Naneborders. ln Proc. 5th
`Workshop on ACM SIGOPS Europem Workshop: Vodels and Para-
`digrns For Distlibuted Systelns Sttucttuing (Vont Saint-Vichel.
`Frmce. Sep. 2l-23. 1992). EW 5. ACM Press, N\'. NY l-6.
`Stm Microsystems, Inc., "NFS: Netlvolk File Systern Protocol Speci-
`fication," Mzu. 1989, pp. l-25.
`Tar'1an, Robefi Endre, ct al. "Storing a Sprsc Tablc." Commtnica-
`tions ol'tJreACM, vol. 22. )Jo. 11, Nor,. 1979. pp.606-611.
`Terry D. B, 1984. Ar malysis of nzuning conventions lbr distributed
`cornputer systerns. In Ploc. ACM SICCOMM Synp. on Colnmmi-
`cations Achitcchtrcs ald Protocols: Trttorials & Sylnp. SIGCOMM
`'84. ACI4 Press. NY N\', 218-224.
`Thornm A. Berson. Differential Cryptmalysis Mod 2.sup.32 with
`Applications to MD5. pp. 69-81. 1992.
`Vijay Krnnm, A Concurrcncy Control Mechmistn Bascd on Extcnd-
`ible Hashing for Main Mernoty Database Systerns, ACM, l'ol. 3,
`1989. pp. 109-l 13.
`Vijay Krunar. .A concrurency Coltrol Mechanisrn based on Extend-
`iblc Hashing fbr Main Mernory Database Systctns, pp. 109-113,
`ACM. vol. 3, 1989.
`Vincenzetti, David md Courozz| MassiIno. "Anti Tanpering Pro-
`glan," Proceedings of the Fouth {USENIX} Security Sl'tnposiun,
`Santa Clara, CA, 1993. 1l pagcs,
`Vincenzetti, David md Cotnoz.zi, Massimo. 'Anti Tmpering Pro-
`grarn," Proceedings of the Fourth {USENIX} Secruity S;'mposiutn.
`Smta ClaIa, CA, undated, printed frorn http:iluuu'ja.net/CERlT
`Vincenzetti and-CotrozziiATP-Anti Tarnp on Mar. 22, 2006, 8
`pa8es.
`Vitter; Jeffrey Scott, et al. "Optirnal Prel'etching via Data Colnptes-
`sion." In Proceedings of32nd IEEE Synpositur on Foundations of
`Corlputer Science, Nor'. 199i, pp. l2l-130.
`W3C:ID. HTTP: A protocol for networked infonnation, "Basic
`HTTP as defured in 1992", uum'.u'3.org/Protocols/HTTP2.htrnl,
`1992.
`
`Wegrnan. Mark, et al. "Neu' Hash Functions andTheirllse in Authen-
`tication md Set Equality.".Tounal of Cotnpnter and Systern Sciences
`vol. 22..Tun. 1981. pp. 265-279.
`Willian Perrizo. et al., Distlibuted .Ioin Processing Perfbnnance
`Evalnation. I 994. Tu'enty-Seventl Hawnii International Conferetrce
`on Systern Sciences. vol. Il, pp. 236-244.
`Witold Litu,in et al., LH.sup. Lincar Hashing for Distribrttcd Filcs,
`HP Labs 'lech. Report \o. HPL-93-2 l. Jun. 1 993. pp. I -22.
`Witold Litu.in et al.. Linea:' Hashing for Distributed Files. ACM
`SIGMOD. May 1993, pp. 327 -336.
`Witold Litu,in, et al.. LH Linear Hashing fol Distribrrted Files, HP
`Labs Tech. Repof No. IIPL-93-21 .htn. 1993. pp. l-72.
`Yao. Aldleu, Chi-Chih. "Should Tables be Sorted?".Iounal ofthe
`Association lbr Cornputing Machinery. r,ol. 28. No. 3, Jul. 1981, pp.
`6 1 5-628
`Yuliang Zheng et a1., Haval A One-Way Hashing Algorithrn u'ith
`\miable Length ofOutput (Extended Abstlact). pp. 83-105.
`Yuliang Zheng, et al,. Har,al A One-Way Hashing Algorithrn u'ith
`Variable l-ength of Outpilt (Extended Abstract), pp. 83-105,
`Advmces ir Cryptology, AUSCRIPT '92, 1992.
`Zhiyl Tian, et al., A New Hashing Function: Statistical Behaviortr
`and Algolithn, pp. 3-13, SIGIR Fonrrn, 1993,
`ZhiynTian, eI al.. A New Hashing Function: Statistical Behaviortr
`md Algorithm, pp. 3- 13, SIGIR Fonun, Spring 1993.
`fProposed] Order Reguding Constluction of Telrns. filed Ma. 29,
`2007 in C.D. Cal. cme No. CV 06-5086 SJO (Ex) [9 pgs.l.
`Analysis of Plaintifl's' Claim Chat for the '280 Patent As Against
`Defendmt ir{edia Sentry, Inc. 11 pages.
`Analysis of PlaintifTs' Clailn Charl for thc '791 Patcnt As Against
`Defendant lr4edia Sentry. Inc. (11916.001.0150.a) pp. l-48.
`Alalysis of Plaintiffs' Claim Chat for the '791 Patent .As Against
`Defendant Over?eer pp. 140.
`Barbara, D., et al., "Exploiting sytnmetries for low-cost cornparison
`of file copies". Sth Int'l Conf. on Distributed Cornputing Systerns.
`.hrn, 1988, pp. 471-479, San .Iose. CA.
`Carnpbell, M., "The Design of Text Signatures lbr Text Retrieval
`Systcrns." Tech. Rcport. Scp. 5, 1994. Deakin L,nivcrsity, School of
`Computing & Math., Geelong, Australia.
`Chang, W, W et al.. 'A sigtratlre access Inethod for the Stuburst
`database systetn." in Proc. I 5th Int'1 Conl'. on Very Large Dafa Rases
`(Arnsterdar. The Netherlmds). pp, 145- 153.
`Changes to M2. 23, 2007 Deposition of Robert B. K. Dev'ro', in C.D
`Clal. case No. CV 06-5086 SJO (Ex) [3 pgs + cover letter,l.
`Cornmmication from EPO in Etuopean Application No. 96 910
`762.2-1225 datet{ May 8. 2009 [4 pgs.].
`Coruntmication pnrsuant to Article 96(2) EPC frorn EPO (Exulina-
`tion Repofi). .Im. 17, 2007, in Application No. EP 96 9 IO 762.2-1225
`[1 pg. with 5 pg. mex],
`Ciornplaint for Patent lntiingernent. Pertnanent lnjrmction and Dan-
`agcs. Aug. 8. 2006. in C,D, Cal. case No. CV 06-5086 SJO (Ex) [1 I
`pgs,l.
`Cornplaint lor Patent Infringernent, Penment Injunction md Dam-
`ages, filed Sep, 21, 2007 in C.D. Cal. Cme No. Cr, 07-06161 VBF
`(PLAx) [10 pgs.].
`Dcclaration of Charlcs S. Bakcrin Suppor of Dcl'cndant Litne Wirc's
`Motion to Stay Pending Reexmination of Patent md Retluest for
`Extension of Deadlines, Aug. 29, 2008, in C.D. Cal. Case No. CV
`07-06161VBF (PL.{x) [2 pgs.].
`Defendant Lime Wire, LLC's First Anended Answer^ Affinnative
`Defenses md Counterclairns, Oct. 2. 2008, Cl.D. Cal. case No.
`07-06161VBF (PL.d'<) [13 pgs.].
`Defendant I-irne Wire. I-LC's Secontl Arnended Ansu,er, Affinnative
`Defenses and Connterclairm. Oct. 27. 2008. From C.D. Cal. caseNo
`07-06161vBF (PLAx) !3 pgs.l.
`Defendant Michael Weiss's Ansu'er to Plaintiffs Complaint lbr
`Patent Infringcmcnt, Pcnnment Injunction and Dunagcs; Dclnand
`for Juy Trial, Sep. 15, 2006, cme No. CV 06-5086 SJO (Ex) [10
`pcs.l.
`Defcndmt Recording Industry Asmciation of Ancrica's Arncndcd
`Notice of Motion md Motion for Patial Sruunuy Jttdgrnent on
`Plaintiffs' Clairns for Patent Infringement md Inducing Patent
`Infringernent. Mernorandrun of Points md Authorities. May 22,
`2006, redacted. original confidential, filed mder seal, in C D. Cal.
`case No. CV 04-7456 .IFW (CTx) [19 pgs ].
`
`EXHIBIT 3 . 5
`
`

`

`Case 5:18-cv-05198-BLF Document 14-3 Filed 10/04/18 Page 7 of 62
`
`us 7,802,310 82
`
`Page 6
`
`Defendant Recording Indusby Associafion of Atnerica's and
`I\4ediasentry. Inc.'s )Jotice ofMotion and \4otion for Partial Srun-
`rnary Julgrnent Based on Itnplied License or. In the Allernalir'e.
`Based on Patert N4isuse and flnclem Hmds. May 22, 2006.
`l{edacted, in C.D, Cal. case No. CV 04-7456 .lFW (C lx) [21 pgs ].
`Defendant Recortling indttshy Association of Arnerica's and
`l\4ediasentry, Inc's Notice of Motion md Motion fbr Patial Siun-
`rnary.Tudgrnent Based on hnplied License or. In the Alternative.
`Based on Patent Misrtse and linclean Hmds. May 8, 2006, in C.D.
`Cal. case No. CY 04-7456 JFW (C't'x) [20 pgs.].
`Defendant Sbeatncast Nets'orks Inc.'s Arswer to Plaintiff s Corn-
`plaint for Patcnt Infiingcmcnt, Pctnancnt Injrrnction md Dalnagcs:
`Demmd Ibr Jury Trial, Sep. 5, 2006, C,D. Cal. case No. CV 06-5086
`SJO (Ex) [0 pgs,].
`Dcfcndarts' Ancndcd Prclirninary Clairn Consttlctions