Case 4:18-cv-07229-YGR Document 42-4 Filed 02/10/20 Page 1 of 17
`
` 
`
` 
`
` 
`
` 
`
` 
`
` 
`
`Exhibit 3
`
`

`

`Case 4:18-cv-07229-YGR Document 42-4 Filed 02/10/20 Page 2 of 17
`Case 4:18-cv-O7229—YGR ”Ocumflfllmnflmmflflm"mum“ mm
`
`USGWMI 154132
`
`7777 United States Patent
`[388,141,154 B2
`szman at a}.
`
`(75) “Bate: 77f Patent: Mar. 20, 2731-2
`
`77777 7177777777 NIL:
`
`(54)
`
`SYE‘E‘EM AND METHOD FOR INSPECTING
`IWM‘WIICALLY GENERATED EXECUTABLE
`CODE
`
`‘75)
`
`17777777777777:
`
`11777776 Grumman. 7167777771 (737717 UL»);
`Yum} mil-ltzhak 1137175777777 (1L)
`
`
`
`73:7
`
`.53}
`
`Assignee: 17‘5an“, Inc. {11.)
`
`N77673:»:
`
`Subject 79 any (fisclaimeg the 77277717 0771773
`777776777 is 7777767771736 777 adjusted 77776737 35»
`11.5;.6 154073 by (3 71777777
`
`'27 7
`
`7379771. New 1 274814584
`
`22L}
`
`717777777:
`
`Jun. M, 2017}
`
`7757
`
`.75”
`
`52)
`‘53)
`
`m737.‘d
`
`Prim 777777777777777 7777777
`
`{33201667251 3737573
`
`37737. 3077 2-010
`
`77777 C].
`{26776.61 :7
`(707777 1mm
`
`$267927. 72 7.23: 726724:7132138
`13.3 (I!
`14field (7f f.1.775764177777711 Search.
`Name:
`$7272 67173673776077 6177 far 73677717177772 search 177577777:
`
`Rfiiemnces Cited
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`US RATENI' DOCUMENTE
`“33766“? 7737
`“1519794 Rum-77171777!
`»
`l67“!9‘99 7237777777
`1751.99.27
`57
`7.731000
`“17777770711
`72'3473700
`17777137777?
`875200}
`J?!
`.77
`7
`‘
`Barllamn 7:
`
`fwbmfl
`37777177777077 a: 77}.
`
`7367777779771 7277717
`7
`1227707
`33777771773177}:
`7,
`
`(7777777
`6.72261?) Hadmmil
`.7
`
`......................... R6914
`“3277316
`{71717777177}
`
`
`
`
`7277...»; 77.2
`7.37:7 22 772
`‘E‘flE‘Qfiifi-fi 1737*
`3.6367504 132 4“
`
` U)2730’?
`
`27701500735389 M ’9‘
`3&7327-‘01‘76635 7H
`20647073377796 A]
`EMMMMSfl-flii 5’71
`EQMWIEWEE) All
`200550170356" 7M
`EGMJ‘DMQV49 711“
`Ef}€)t‘3fflm5§§fl
`7‘“
`20067961611981 MR
`QLQWEWIEEWE AI
`
`
`
`6722067 Mbmchl
`151-31526}
`$752662
`837237777077
`726324
`
`7777777777 thm 731‘ 77!.
`..
`.. .7262'4
`7.7777377777677677»7“
`7 1713 7575
`Eif‘EQEM‘
`
`‘
`57152137114
`$27777
`57520057 K377777177 at 77!
`
`77
`_
`772065 35717113781167}!
`7777772
`17371106
`727771177 at 271.
`
`726722
`732606 Shcthet 777.
`777266? Dubmmkyetak
`.7 726.522
`
`
`6‘ 727166 by exaalamjnflr
`
`
`
`Fri77777717: 15.777777777777777
`7}; Pic-I1
`13777777777
`(74} 7477077773773 7736777. a?" firm -
`Dawn-Marie 77.737; King &
`Spaflding LLP
`
`75737
`
`77777777777777“
`
`7‘7 777367776 7:177 {77777776777777 :7 0177377! 73777777777767" 1777777 6177727 777773777777
`gmem‘ted 77727 17c} 77775 7207776177. inclu‘diflgmceiving777‘ 77 3777772777777};
`
`7.777777773777777 7:7777777777 heating 7;
`.1; 177 776773177 6077117777777 1677* 7.777777777—
`77773. the 72671777777 including 77:77“ 77:7 2777 9777777777 1777777367.“:77. and
`777.7 can 7777177717777; 2777 77739717, 777717717‘Iying the. 73017772717 7.77 the
`gateway 71671777777557;inclufling 78777777777177; 717777 7:77 I 70,7177: 7777377777777
`7777727777777 with :7 wrmwonding 7:777“ ‘77:) 77 27777777677777: 17777717777777, the
`77776777777777: 777777777777 77777 77177777766776"! 777 7777777 7117777777177 77)
`77
`3727377757737 mmpumr fur 77757372067771. 77677377777777.7717; 71777 75777767777277
`(2677mm 7777777 71777 gammy 73777713777777.3776 the 7: iem 77077777777777.
`77117767275 sing 7777: :mfl‘fiadmammn at 7176 721577777 9777173177767. 777777.77-
`7s.
`ni‘fling the input 76 mt? 577737777717“ cmnpm‘m furi 7573777367777 when
`3772: 3777757777777 7771777677177 77; 67777177777717 (76777777177665; 277 intramurity
`CGFWUW 777177761677 is 377717 7777777172 7777717777 73777771077777.7779 7777777177:
`1777 migimfl 6777667777 77ith the input transmfifl‘ng 27777 7777177327767
`77? 7771777777777 i7 is; 777717 for 77777 7317777777 7307777777777“ 77:7 inmke 77:77
`a
`777gum] [17777. 777777 7771' 7 71777777137177 1170777 7177‘ 7777677777y 42077777777777 777
`”:72 771777777 (77777777777777. 77nd. “awokmg 6777 0737777777 67777277677 77711773
`7717727717 0777771777767” Wit 7 7772 717777.773 07713 if71773; in 777777477: 7777777277776
`
`fmm 7173*
`707777757 73737777777767” 77771772777727 717277 771.7737 61777702777077 is
`
`7727772 A 77:77 773777 77777177 cam7putw-madahle muraga 771777677777 77777
`2717277 77757566777777 77.77717 632777717777.
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`12 (377777777. 5 thawing Shears
`
`
`MDIEAWRTOQEENT
`7
`;
`WP WNW
`
`
`
`
` |
`
`fll}fi§l’l‘¢kflmam 7
`
`7
`‘ mums-or
`
`szzzmnw 7377777735
`
`
`
`
`
`
`answmcmm
`SHE”?WWR
`
`
`
`oarmmmms
`0977772777
`cw.
`
`MMEE’Q
`53771333!
`
`FINJAN-QUALYS 004414
`
`

`

`Case 4:18-cv-07229-YGR Document 42-4 Filed 02/10/20 Page 3 of 17
`Case 4:18-cv-07229—YGR Document 42-4 Filed 02/10/20 Page 3 of 17
`
`LLS. Patent
`
`man 20,2012
`
`3mm M5
`
`US 33419154 132
`
`FIG.1(PRIORART)
`
`‘ mmmmwn ‘
`
`
`
` w
`
`umsm2mmgame":
`
`we
`
`‘
`;
`
`FINJAN-QUALYS 004415
`
`u
`x cm pammfi
`
`7 V
`‘ ‘fi
`
`: ammmmnamn ‘
`H
`‘
`
`3
`
`g
`
`I
`
`145
`
`
`
`1;
`
`i:
`
`
`
`1"
`w:
`_
`‘
`
`e:
`
`1
`cuemmma
`
`‘
`
`E
`
`'mesmm
`
`5'
`
`
`
`mammeaningmm”
`
`m
`
`mammamm”WEE?A.
`
`:23
`
`

`

`Case 4:18-cv-07229-YGR Document 42-4 Filed 02/10/20 Page 4 of 17
`Case 4:18-cv-07229—YGR Document 42-4 Filed 02/10/20 Page 4 of 17
`
`LLS. Patent
`
`man 20, mm
`
`3mm 2 m5
`
`US 33419154 132
`
`" ' ,
`
`w
`
`WfiU‘—;.,.VV.,_‘.‘.«\:.; a ._..A.\,_:.,.V. w ,2”; W .wwmm,w WM.""guard?“-
`
`wmmmmmm
`,,
`
`;
`
`.7
`
`‘
`,
`
`secumwnmmvzk
`
`'
`
`'
`
`2
`j
`
`
`
`233‘
`
`
`
`mmrmsmmn
`
`3‘
`
`
` A
`EMWfiffiifi
`
` smumfisewm
`
`{,m,‘,,-,.z_-r.w».,w~; y .... “Hwy.” 4 ‘3
`
`
`"
`'
`‘
`3
`
`3 marrmnmmn y
`
`g.
`
`23!!
`
`.
`
`. 4
`
`:-'
`
`z:
`
`cement emcmmn 3 3
`,
`
`m
`
`s
`
`3
`
`mm? me
`‘
`W U!”
`,
`WMPWR BF 5MBW
`l 1%anan
`
`1
`3
`
`'
`
`,7
`
`1
`"
`‘
`"
`ama‘mmm ,
`,
`7
`,
`‘
`‘3!
`IN
`
`wemfiqegflgfil,-
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`315
`
`FIG“2
`
`FINJAN-QUALYS 004416
`
`

`

`Case 4:18-cv-07229-YGR Document 42-4 Filed 02/10/20 Page 5 of 17
`Case 4:18-cv-07229—YGR Document 42-4 Filed 02/10/20 Page 5 of 17
`
`LLS. Patent
`
`Man If}? m 2
`
`3mm 3 M ,5
`
`US 331419154 132
`
`lo— mmmmm W»!
`
`{+— mmmmm ~44
`
`[e- smmm mama _+{
`
`
`mm cm W ‘
`
`‘ WW RHENDE‘B Fmemm
`WW!!!
`‘
`3
`
`
`
`‘ scmcumrmn #:192352ch 1
`cu: WNW mm
`
`' Fummm mwmumumm
`
`33.
`
`'
`
`
`
`
`
`
`meme-e mm ewnm' 3:
`cm are mm mm
`sum mm mus
`
`
`
`
`
`
`mmnwmmmw 1,,
`FUR pancsamum
`'
`
`
`7
`
`:11
`
`
`
`$333M wwmm mm
`WVWM‘ ’Cflwmfifl
`
`;
`
`“
`MNWT
`
`camm "TO PRGCESS
`
`WWW? SUEWW FUWR
`
`WWW0 1;:
`m mam gunman mm
`M$Ffimm
`
`0
`
`use
`
`newWm wmmmn my
`MGDIFIEL! um' mm Misunm ‘
`mwmm
`
`-
`
`
`
`mwmommuw
`
`m
`
`*3
`
`
`
`mVGKE WWW Funmm
`WI!" MDMMEW EWUT
`
`we
`
`-
`
`‘
`
`3m
`
`FIG” 3
`
`mmW- WP!)T MI} WEN!" Ill
`
`mum CMENT COMPUTER
`
`
`3%?! NWT we PWBEMCE BF
`PU MWQN WE
`
`
`
`:m
`
`FUNW10“ mm mm
`in mm
`
`
`
`‘
`
`‘ mmnmnmnmm ‘
`mammmwm
`mam mummwm v
`
`
`
`
`
`
`emu WM 1:: n'mmmr.
`mum mums
`
`kmrm swam mum" ma 3
`mewmm
`
`
`
`
`
`350
`W
`‘ WWW 17mm 56mm v
`MERLE W REEF” SEE-{MEN ‘
`mm?
`
`1
`
`m we PW mam meexa
`mzmnm SUMBNQM WITH
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`3W mmmrm ‘ WUE
`
`
`
`SET mmMTQR 1‘ FMfiE
`
`' msmmnmm mm
`WWW WW T0 mam
`
`CWFWTEE
`
`am
`
`FINJAN-QUALYS 004417
`
`

`

`Case 4:18-cv-07229-YGR Document 42-4 Filed 02/10/20 Page 6 of 17
`Case 4:18-cv-07229—YGR Document 42-4 Filed 02/10/20 Page 6 of 17
`
`US. Patent
`
`Mar. 20., 2012
`
`Sheet 4 ms
`
`US 8,141,154 B2
`
`
`
`cu EMT TRANSMI‘ITER
`
`AMD
`
`
`
`1 CQH‘I’ENT moeessaa
`
`
`
` UmamcaMPuTER
`
`
`
`CUENT REGEWER
`
`
`
`INPUT.gamma
`
`4811
`
`‘
`
` SEELEIT‘I’
`POLICIES
`
`M.
`
`aW 3
`
`:}m
`s:
`En
`
`\
`1
`
`ii
`
`1 1
`
`‘
`
`‘
`
`475'
`_
`
`mN"
`
`E!
`
`in
`
`‘‘
`
`
`
`meanness:swam
`
`
`
`’mamascfimem.
`
`
`
`ImptmmaTaCLiEfiT‘cameurgfiegSAFEmew
`
`I
`
`Gs
`
`r
`
`3:
`
`E
`
`e
`
`‘
`
`
`
`‘
`
`
`
`CONTENWINFUT
`momma:
`
`,
`
`
`‘
`h
`
`e
`‘
`
`’
`L
`f
`'
`mam maPEcmR
`
`i
`
`‘
`
`§
`
`‘—‘
`
`‘
`
`
`emewaw RECEIVER
`
`4335*“..5
`
` 4620
`
`goHTENT
`
`
`
`ORIGINALmomma
`
`
`
`41:A
`
`‘
`
`
`
`
`FIG.4
`
`FINJAN-QUALYS 004418
`
`

`

`Case 4:18-cv-07229-YGR Document 42-4 Filed 02/10/20 Page 7 of 17
`Case 4:18-cv-07229—YGR Document 42-4 Filed 02/10/20 Page 7 of 17
`
`US. Patent
`
`Mar-10,2012
`
`Sheets MS
`
`US 3,141,154 32
`
`3—.— mmwm sesame —+E
`
`i..— cuem mmwmm ——>{
`
`j warwmx mmmgm m3 mam: ‘ cmm‘mn
`
`‘
`
`macaw: mmm FRGM
`
`‘
`
`;
`
`3
`
`5mm
`
`‘
`_ em ab‘mfz'emm‘em my:
`‘
`7 PRESENCE QF FUNQ’HON GALW ‘
`
`-
`
`‘
`
`‘
`
`sea
`
`1‘ Ni.)
`‘
`
`_ m
`Emmet»: (mm mwm -
`
`‘
`
`mes
`
`52m
`
`REFUSE URQGWAL FHNG'HQN
`
`
`CALLfi WHH $UB$TFYUTE
`
`FUMCVQW mus
`x
`V
`
`515
`
`'
`
`‘
`
`
`REiEE NE QQMTEW FRGM
`
`fifiTQWA‘f CQMPUTER
`
`REZEENE‘ EMPUT ma CHEN? It?
`2':me mJENT (30M PUTTE-R
`
`MINI‘EMCT
`
`
`$13M WF‘U'? TO OET‘EHMHE
`SECUHSTY PRQW‘E
`
`{WM ‘EBMTWW‘E fiUMflTIBN
`
`. 1 3
`‘
`-
`M ,
`J.
`V
`a m mgfgfiggffmpfié‘gm m“ 3
`1
`‘
`
`‘
`1
`
`THANSWTWF’UTWD {:0qu m
`i; m GATEWM 3%me MR
`NSEIEBfiQf-J
`H
`
`‘ flmwaefi mm EMT eemmw ‘
`
`
`‘ warms mm {imam secumw 1
`
`
`x
`‘
`mm?
`
`
` _
`Em
`
`‘
`
`$511“ WWCATW G FNEE
`
`
`
`
`, QW‘EWM.FUNQTPQNWm ‘
`SME F65? CUENT Tfl-iWUKE
`
`
`.
`_
`INPUT?
`5 _
`
`was
`6“”
`
`
`SET WMEATGR ¢--?§§HE
`
`
`'
`
`
`
` ‘ wwmmr cemem m WENT :
`
`Fem Damaseem
`
` mmnmz‘m was 55
`
`
`
`
`
`
`REflEEWE SAFETV HNWCATOR
`
`
`FRGM SATEWM’ GQRI'RF’UTER
`
`‘
`
`
`‘
`
`
`‘
`
`L
`
`_
`
`a
`
`‘
`
`(KENDRA!QR TRUE?
`
`M.
`- M
`“.WWW mmm“w,m
`was
`
`
`LEN‘VCME Wifiiflgfl.‘ FUNETQM
`WWW MPH T
`
`
`
`3%
`
`FINJAN-QUALYS 004419
`
`

`

`Case 4:18-cv-07229-YGR Document 42-4 Filed 02/10/20 Page 8 of 17
`Case 4:18-cv-07229—YGR Document 42-4 Filed 02/10/20 Page 8 of 17
`
`US 811413-54 BEL
`
`
`
`1
`SYSTEM: AND METER“?! FDR INSPEIC‘I’ING
`DYNAMICALLY GENFKAIED EXEC UTALBILE
`CODE
`
`IIIIEIILLLI[Dill IIILIN‘.WIION
`
`11132: presem 11333323333931; mimes m tempura: 3533;311:333: mad
`11mm 3.333333313313310 pmwmim against lTliIIICIQ-‘I‘IIS emits: SLICINIS
`0013133333331" viruses,
`
`BACKGRCIIINI) 0F THIS INVENTION
`
`033133333332: 3‘3 mam: have heemfzmlpmu far was" lwn decades
`
`310w. Cmupumrvimsm gmeml‘ly mm: 333 the: J‘mrm Mamma-
`ahIe CEILIE‘ thatperlbrnm adwm: eyewationa 333033113 madil‘y-
`"mg .33 mmmpul‘er’: awaiting system m“ We 533333131,_ damnging .3
`cmmuter‘g hardwam or hardware im‘erlhces L): flmCrllmt-i<
`CELIIy lrmbmlimu.dawlWm «meCGHlelIEI m mmher Gamer.
`ally: 1333333331331“ 33?me am aanmlud I33 133‘634833: 331llfiflly. in
`LmiLr m LXpILJIt cmnpulcr vulnerabililim, Hammer: vimsm
`cm: £31.30 arise by accidem due m bug: in. seI‘iwam applimw
`00133
`
`Originally compmer 33133363; were mansmit‘lml as Lxmna
`XML" LmiL IHSLLTI‘LCI 313-... IIILL. ‘A3 mach 333.3: vim: was; L‘Iimch'
`emcL a signature) La!“ the virus was. wlleed by ami- vim);
`‘mmpmnieé. andlugedlli'um then m; LL) LILILecL {he virus and
`pmimt mmpmws 2133331133 ilr. [1533’s. 133.3313)": remind}? SLalmingfi
`leir file 3331333313 using aim-vim: mlli‘warfi, which regularly
`Expdamd its: sigmmm databaaa: as. each new vim: was 0333:3333
`eleL
`
`'4.
`
`l U
`
`2E1
`
`L)1!:
`‘
`
`30
`
`
`
`I
`ELL-L: hemhy inmmummd by mikmmce,
`cutizflems 33‘ WI‘IIEI’I
`dexcribc: gateway 142wa belmViL) mi aaaal3~fsia Bush helmviwmi
`3.31503535- 5123333: and. 33233333: mnmm remixed at a gmmmy a “I
`3373:1131-5331:233, a gammy pm‘file far the Lament. A $56.01;}?in pmfi‘le
`i5 :1 313mm Iisl {Jr delinemicm L)I' 33133336233315. m‘ pelefllia I};
`LLIELIiL-LimlsL 3333333133313 33‘... exLLuL‘LaIJlLL mmmu may 33031333333;
`Thederlw 3.2mm pmfilL 33.03613 campmed with a Acur‘ity
`pm‘lic3 fer thL Lampmm being pmleatml
`IL") detemli L:
`wlxmhLmrnm ilLL Lmtuu3" security pml‘iir: 330%:th me {.0111-
`333mm; mu r313v policy A swarm pL)liL;333. a gLanI EU :31"
`Simple m amalgam 333wa 31133333233 laeapplied lugma. 13an
`series L): inpamIIeL which datemime wheihemr 31m a speed it:
`mpemtim) is 'pemlitted (“If Ibrbidclen m be perlbmmd 1:331:30.
`Lament L‘m 3'32 (33333133331323 Tami 11g pmlecthXI,-SLLLLII 13’ pfiliuias are
`gmemlly amtlfigumblm and SLL by an m‘Iminlgtmmr ”Hm
`cemmltu Elm I3. liking 13:01.9de
`Assagnm 5 U L‘SL PM We 610520 emifleL-I SYSTILM
`AN [3 MI:IIIOI} FOR I’RGTECI INC”! A CLHSLNT DURING
`IIUNIIMEL lid-"(OM lVIDSIILl-i
`IDDWNILUAIDAIIILIL-EB, L L:
`mutants ml“ which are hamby inmrpomlcd by mfbrcmci
`[13:53:13th deskmp level beimvlfmal allmysis. 1332;331:303) IEVttI
`behavioral amIvsis l3)gammall}: impleand (hiring 31133
`[1111323 3333le :3 anpmcrs[awe-I) b33133 33m I: 3333.333:ng 33L?)
`mele rLLLLL’L-‘LXI war flu: 13313313.), As {he LOIIILWI l3 Ming
`pmcemd (11:33}:th seeuril'y app-Iiwficinas manila: mills; made:
`m whim] Sysmnns fif ’Lh‘L: mmpu‘ten such as Lheopermiflg
`Lyme-m, the me 33333333 and the neiwmlL Lyman. Defikmp
`security iipFIiIcaiIm‘IS use hawks IL) 3333234333“ calls: made IL)
`warming 333332331 limmitms, and 3313333 0)“ black 31.3 ml}: as
`appmpfima baaed cm the cmmpuferfi smurilj.“ pQILLLyL
`Each (31" 313.: varimm 3133343331313 Lechmfiegies, gateway vs;
`(Whom mamvevs. pmamivm hash-its pm: and mm, Ream-Live
`anti-vim: pmtmtluu i3: 00313331333335anally 3533313333:le 1133331; 3.3333»
`active vim: pm'femimz is campummmaliy inmmiw: and
`slewer. Reactive anti-virus pmmclfim cannot pretax: against
`new “firsHime” virtues, and 021315301 3mm: 3: war if his
`signature lileis um el‘dme; pmaLL‘lee maxiwims pmmm'io man
`pmtcm 313:3.me azaLw Wait-time” vimsas and d3) um quuirL:
`mgr)lax 5033331L‘mding ml" updaied signature HILL. Wilma}:
`mmpu‘l‘er viruses; :33 a greater distance
`lLle meLLLIm keeps
`33.3.3.1.) Meal mammal: L) '
`mam331119.33; deskmp level primec’siml is;
`mam acmmxw. fieskt’u
`3 IceveI puma-33ml is; gmwmlly availabilm
`In the mmuumr market It)!“ Malia-3 lL) ebulinL-aucl 3:3: susmpv
`Lihle LL) 333?me angiimmfmg; gateway level 3330thle i3; 313)!
`, generallyavailablem makers,
`Reference is new made I0 FIG. I, which is :3 shuplified
`black diagram DI prim art 333333333 ft): himking malicI-zms
`ULTIHIQJII,
`235 desmihc
`le-eimbmw. The. {manual
`333133333
`shew} 33:. FIG: I Must
`Limes 23333323733113: 1:33:33] 5330331313! applica-
`Lim). TILL: middle 53313113 slmwn in I’lfi‘i; I illumrmes- a deskmp
`lwel security appllLaL
`”3:313 and :13: lammm 3331611) 311333332 in
`
`‘1 i1] 1131:3333: a. mmlhimd 1;meaya-dmk’mp lLVLI maturity
`apleLaticm.
`‘I‘lw mpmmi $333331 .
`31133333) in FIG. 1 Includes a gateway
`m reLelwas 320313an from the 113me the
`(30333331333): I05 l‘I
`L‘Lmtem inimifiad 3mLIL
`LIWLQLLL LILLLILLmnpuLLrHD (3333:)-
`v.ay 20333333333): I 05 eriVLS the 3313313321111 mm 23 anmummmm
`0113mm] I20 211} gammy Cflmmer LLflflHfliDiauw with cli-
`Lm mmpum: “.0 033.: La mnnmmaicmimaLchannel125 Gmee
`my cmmpuier 105 ILLLILLLILS :3 Hem-333313 £41.23:le 135 and 23
`33.323333 Ira-3333331IILI,‘ 141}, (Slim: 32033133313323 Ill) incIudLs a
`client receiver 145, C
`Iimn‘ 60133131111er genermly 11133:.)
`I333)
`43
`which 53% not thMLL
`client tmaasnflue .
`at 110 Includes a cement 3330333355333 170.
`(Klimt mmpu
`Such as a 6.23133331130me we!) b‘mw set which pmces 541:3. bun-3:333:21
`mmmm and ma)
`
`83ml) aim-L-Firusp‘mmcfim 33: referred m as ‘Ireactim’l‘finm:
`it 3.3.1.3333 33mm: in reamiwm 331135.23. hat have already bmm
`disLL3‘3*‘e_rLX1.
`I
`W33}: Iiwadvmn mftlw lnmmm afldfl‘m abil 113' 133:: mu 32mm)»
`lgmwwm 33 new mm ..
`ab 6: cede such as. scrim within Interns: '
`OI" vim); I‘med; 3333133313,
`.3 virus Liam 3‘: 333233: 33 2013313133121" over
`the Internet .333an 333.0333. me cmnpu Lrs file SySEEIl). 33ml)
`In 61333213333333 can he embeddm M 13.3.. WLI: 33;: 32333 and mm
`web Lmuam. LmL‘I begiu executing 3331313 3) an lmmmi 1333mm):
`as Sflflfl 23:; they enter .3 mmpulm: Run fine file scans; are ml
`33b ‘4: IQ detect math 3033333353330 35:) 13:31:“me 30331353333433.3390
`3m Vi—Vims 1001:. had 3:. lac 13233313333331.
`
`‘I‘vm 33.3333: 13‘, 3:: 0f zilmiwims app Ic-Minng 113231. 2333': war-
`3633313 I wilahlc LL) 33mm against $11101”! 333mm) 33:33:33: am: (i)
`332) may aeLurii3 applicmimm. 23ml {limesflqmp 3330133333 23131313
`
`‘canam. Gate“: 3' 33:33:31.: applicsmiinns Shield web mute)“
`I33:cm. 3133; Lament IS 0603333361 in lis Intel-Mud LILLLIHMILHI
`cmnpmer. Giatemy security 33.313.133.333: 33.... 33.21:) 330311th
`and Hack the Lemma? from machimg the destinmitm 2611131303333!
`if he conmn i3 claimed by the security appliczstim m be
`e:33,l3il3 malicimzs. In Llistiflcficm. (jammy) smuxlty applb
`ca 5m): shield 333333333331 weal) 6:333)le 33331333 Lame-m mclms‘iis
`“1)thde demimmw 3.31.33.33.33,
`mewm l3: additim}, m macfim anti—vim:-applicmlmx
`‘lmt are banged on databaws ef lmnwn 3313):: sigmmmg.
`
`mmn‘ly “pmmctivL” mfivirua .2:
`lie-minus have Imus: deveIm
`wed. Prmzmllw anti-3311):; pmeclrimn 33:33-33
`:1 mafimdmlugy
`“11333333 233: “beimvinmI amalfilg” 33. 233150 menu?!)putt): Lemma
`It): [I16 prewar)»: Elf viruses-L Behavlm LLLLLILys-lg is used {0 mm)»
`mmimlly 5L3): 23310132333332 ExacumbIL-z content in mile: I.) detect
`which 32031133113421“ mmrmicms the 333311332331 may 1.3333333... As
`much. I‘JEIMVIQTHI 231330333; can. black virusw {hm have: 31:31 been
`Irwims‘ly detmtt‘ed :3le which. ch) 3301‘ have Li 33351331me cm
`mama, hence 0m 33:33:33.: “pmamive”.
`
`Asaigflee’s US, ”at. NC) GI‘IWLJW emified SYSTIFEM‘
`
`
`AND MI? ml} FOR PM;
`‘
`MCI)“. CLJMPUI" ‘ AND
`
`A NETWORK ”RUM 1930531 IILLl::- ITJ‘DWNILL‘JADABILLIISL the:
`
`
`
`4L?
`
`33L")
`
`{:37
`
`
`
`
`
`
`3333333333.: 8133:13le LL32 it Fer InwraclILNL-Lriawing L313): display
`
`m: at WILLIE-33131333: I): in the Imam L31“ ism-cub
`
`FINJAN-QUALYS 004420
`
`

`

`Case 4:18-cv-07229-YGR Document 42-4 Filed 02/10/20 Page 9 of 17
`Case 4:18-cv-07229—YGR Document 42-4 Filed 02/10/20 Page 9 of 17
`
`US 811413-54 BE,
`
`3
`able: mile,_ Javafiimm, VlRScripl, lava applets, Active}: cm—
`ll‘fllfis which are Sllpgflflfll by web blfflWSflI'S.
`Gatmmy elimpuler 1135- infilllclfifi a mutant inspectw 1:74
`which. may be reactive m garlmwliwg er a comblnmimn m”
`reactive anal mmwtlve imagining simian} is; analyzed by anti:
`mm iaispmlm ll 74 beliire being {mummified m client computer
`lll)‘. ll imnming Clllllléml is (IleBd in be maliclmis, llmn
`gateway template:- 195 prefErsllfily prevents; Elm mule-ill llom
`rmehing cllml mmpuler llll. Allerrrizliiwlys gatmvay mmr
`puller .105 may liamllfy llw milieu! am at; la Wildfllj‘ El lléll’fllltillfi,
`and mlbiamiwiill y mummii the mmli llm‘l matmim client cam-
`piiler llll.
`Cfll‘llfll‘ll impede-r1“ can be new it) inspect humming,
`cement (m its way in: client campmer .l ll} élfl its dalmatian,
`will alsm m lJlS-PECl Nitgmlmg clinil'lmlD 1&2ng 8613! Elam climl’
`mmwlar Mil a2; ill-3 (iriginl
`The llllildlc syslem Shawn in PM}; i includes 21 gateway
`Cifllllpfl‘lE-Y :1 {l5 and a clieiil mmpuler 1 il ill the cllmil climpliler
`1.10 lilcludiliga 601mm lnspeclm .176 ., Cement iiispecicar 176
`may live a caiivmlliional Signmum-hasml anilwimg amplifie-
`licmj mm 1m mvtiu‘ie bellzwimml baa 38d zipplical‘im‘i “(lam manimm
`rim-lime walls 5mech by minimal pmceizmr 170 m warming,
`syslmii, file-sysmmmid lialmhrk syslem fililclimm
`'llw hellonisysleln slkmm in FIG, 1 lmludes Emilia cement
`inspector 174 at gateway mammal? 10553 and ii militant inspec-
`li'ir l76 at cliem mmpmw llll‘ Such a system cam Sllppm‘l
`EQ‘llVellllt’mlll gamma}! level pmmctlmn, wimp: law! prams;
`Elam, reactiveamifivims: welt-3min“ and pmzicilve amiwimx
`prelemim.
`As the li‘ *lwrw. aimiwimi‘»; pmlccillmnlnall‘ mmimmmm
`
`
`Wage, a newer type: (if Vlfllfi has sprung llmvard; llzifiwly,
`dynamically generated finial-:53. 'l‘hem vi N585 are mange-he‘s
`gememmd (My at William, llmi; thwarting cmwenlimml ream
`rive-anzilyels and conwmimml gale- ray level proactive belww
`infill analgesia "Ilia-3e V'll‘llSBS lake advantage m“ l’mmuma all“
`dynamic l-‘lTl'l/ll; gnarl-alien: such as- executable wile. 0r
`scrlpls llml lire cil‘ibcdc‘led within HTML wages; to gmmram
`{hamselws mi. the fly al rumlnm
`Fm emmple «amides: llie lbllewing pm’llfifl (if a standard
`ll'l'ML page:
`
`
`
`fl
`
`”nil
`
`h:V:
`
`3t)
`
`41:!
`
`' M L l’EEBLliC‘. “»,e‘3’WECF.z’lTl"-D ll'l‘lvlll. 4.0
`filllilC'l‘Vl "-
`
`’l‘ymfiil i mm
`«mam
`M
`'
`'Klm’lificr‘ml”
`
`nlmwmeimwrl
`m that, is gnawed ai nul—l’imMih l 1*“):
`
`m 3CM???”
`
`
`
`llie mm within lliii <SCRlP'lTi? 1335 is: alnwficrlpt. Emil
`includes a call to the standard fillllllilm dumimmiwrlml )
`Jw‘14
`which genemlm dynamic l‘lTMl,,\. la": the example 313mm. line 3.
`liliicllmx clumnmntwriiel: 3 its“ used in gmmmle HTML header
`text, Willi a taxi string llml is; gmieralezl all mill-“llfllfil ll llm mil
`string gensmmd all rim—Kim: is fill llw farm
`fiSC? lill?’7l3~lllzilii:luus lava SgcrllalfifSCR.l_l3"l'fi
`than {the (lmumemwrlm ) llmcl’lau will insert mallcimis
`.lanSCrim mm l‘lie; ll'l‘Mli page lilml is currently lacing W311“
`dared by a web browser. ln mm when m: well brewer
`piecemeal tile instilled text, ll: will palm-111 iiizlllclmlsapema
`liens m llia cliem'wmpumr.
`Such clynmnicsilly generated mallcicam cede mnmi lie
`lime-med by muwmijmlal iizziszzilw: Clillllt‘flll lllgpecllfln and aim.
`ventiimiilggaleway level heliaviiiml aimlysii mmlmll inspec—
`
`61:)
`
`4
`
`ticm, Sinai»: llm maliC-imis :lavnficript l‘fi mil prawn in the con-
`l‘iam prim is.) mils-[lineal cement impale: wlll Gully delecnlm
`pres SERGE! Ufa will to likmimentwritq ) with input lexl; llml is
`yell uukmwn. ll' such a mmml lilifilflwl'l‘lf were ten black all
`CilllS in ljlmlllllfim.W-rllli( l liicli scriiiiina‘leljs, {hell immy' hemp
`less; scrimg will be liliuaizlmla sinmmcml all llie time Call; m
`ilfle‘mimentmfilial Jim: made fur dynamla clislilay‘ purpmms
`lmlyfl
`US. Elm“ Nesfiflhiflélgmid 6,2716%“ i Tamil :0 ll, describe
`reziciiw client level momleiil im'psxtlinm 111m limclifies dawn-
`lmded immutable cede within 3 deskmp level antiwims
`lippllcelllmn, However; mach impacting mm canly pml‘ecl
`against Static mziliillmis mmem, mill ‘ca‘llmel’ mmecl aigalufil
`
`dynamically gemmmll malls" iii; content.
`l‘flesltmp lcwal rim-lune bahzavlciiral ziimlysi s ‘ 1:38 a chance ml
`shielding :1 client mmpuiemigalml dynamically generaleil
`malleimm cflclej Since-such uncle will lillixmii‘ely mailm- {mall in
`an epemllmg gyrslwii fimcllmi llmveveri clea‘lmp zmllavims
`pmmmic‘n has a {limdmnmge Ofbfllllg w dalyma‘ilalfle lathe
`hacker mmmimliy, wliiell is ill aye eager-{i3 liml maliicnilmlli—
`ties}. lli llfililllifll’lm deflating: will ~vli'us pmmcl’im ”MS a CliSiiiClVEill"
`la gig: ml mam irliig imilz‘illmlim all client snllwzlra
`As such there.
`la a need fur a new lbml n1“ belmvlmal
`élllzllyfilfi, which can shield mummims; lliaial (ly mmiimliy gen-
`
`mii licltzms melt: Williom mwingmu the swimmer itself
`llial is: being shielded»
`
`SEUMMARE,’ OF 'l‘llllfi if} ilSClllP‘l" QN
`
`
`
`
`
`
`“l‘lie preaem inventlmi mneems syilems and imllmds liar
`implementing new behavioral analysis leclmnlmgyi ‘llil: new
`belilwimml auslysis tmlmmlegy 1%“)de pl‘flletliml agaimsl
`dyrlamlcté‘illy generated maliclmmriide, in adaliliim m mummy
`lineal swimmer Virusm llml ml: almically generated.
`The present lm’enllmi apemlizs llmugh fl seaurily mm~
`pillar llwl l5 prellzmlrrly mm‘em lam a elienl cempmm that is
`being shielded while: prizmssmg melw‘wk mmenl. [Juirlmg
`mil-lime, while- pmcegsll’ig llw Remark 52051101,“, builmlmm
`the client um'nplimr invent"; a lime lam call llml may mien-
`lially dymmlmlly generate iiiallcimm male the clieiil cam»
`purel- @3535 the 01mm to ll‘llli‘ llmfllm lathe securily mmputer
`lbw irifipmiimn and smpmds pmceaiing tlw Ramada ailment
`pending a reply back ‘li‘mn llm smuriiy mammal-:1: Since: llw
`input 10 the: llmmima is being pa sand ai mil-lime, it 11213 already
`been dynamically geilemled Mill is [ms reactlily inspected by
`all mammal; inspmmr. Kalb-axing m llm‘axample above, we re the
`input in lflL-‘f gamed m ll’m airmail}: minimum prim m mil—lime.
`ll wmiltl ism;- like Emmi ml indeterminate text; milligram the
`input; pegged during miHlm’le takes lie llelamiiiaaile {17mm
`{éSCRlP‘l‘kmailicimls .lavaScriplfiffiClllPlies
`which can madlly line inspecml. llpmii receipt Ufa: reply fmm
`llle‘ gmurily (:mnpulfll; the client mmpuwr resumes pmcess»
`ling; Elie nelwml: William 311le klmwa whether {:3 lly—pass llw
`llmmlmi call ilwmmlen.
`Te enable l‘he client cm'l‘miiler in pass» llmclli'm inning in me
`gfit‘lil‘ll}? cmmpuler and giispeml gamma-sing 1,)lmnt‘mi pending
`replies 1mm lhfi swurily Cilmplllifil’,
`ll“: present inwmlim
`(llflfim‘l‘m by replacing mlglml lumlleuicalls will} milmlimm
`llmmlma calls Wilfllll} llw-winmnl? m, a imam-“my mmpulm. prim
`i0, lhe mnlenl being .Fflfifitlv‘fld m lhe (illiml (Jammie:
`"l‘lw premm iiweiiliml also pmvllles piiitealicm against
`arbilmrily many lemmiw levels ml dynamic gmmmlinu ital“
`malicious male, whereby Such Cflilli' is; generated via a SEf‘lES
`ofsucwssive l’mmim Willaj mile within the: next.
`By upwelling lhmiigli ‘lllc—z medium walla gecllrlly mmpmm',
`lliepmixmil inventiaim iiiwmmum tilt-3 diml vantages nl‘iiiislciop
`anll-vlnm appliczilimmfl whim: are available in 11113 hacker
`
`FINJAN-QUALYS 004421
`
`

`

`Case 4:18-cv-07229-YGR Document 42-4 Filed 02/10/20 Page 10 of 17
`Case 4:18-cv-07229—YGR Document 42-4 Filed 02/10/20 Page 10 of 17
`
`US 8.141.154 BE.
`
`
`
`5
`2111111111111111 1111 11111111111. 326111113 2111111 1221111111: 21111111111111g 111:.
`1112:6111 11111211111111 11112-21111113111611 522111111}: 1111111111. 11151111111211
`13011111111213.
`11211111111111.1311 1111111 :1 19121211211
`Them 111 11111:. prmvided. 111
`111'1111111111112111’111'1112 111-1121113111 1111121111011 11 1111311111111 fur pmtmfiug
`11 21111111 1::11111}:111:r {11111.1 1131111111‘1‘101111)? 11121121111111 11.1111 1131111111 121.11%
`12111., 111211111113 12131311111511: 1: 111111211135: 8.011111111211111111121z1t1 being
`5:111 111 11111113111 2111111111121 1111 pfecesisi‘ng. 1111—: 13111112111 111211111111g
`a 1:111! 111 2111 1211111111 1111111111111, 111111 1111: 1:111] 1112111111112 2111 11111111,
`modifying 1111': 2111112111 :11 1111: gateway 21111111111111. induding
`1211122211131, 1111: 1:111] 111111.: 1111g111211 111112111111 111111111 :11:r::111111d.~
`mg 132111. 11:1 21 11111111111111: 111111111211. 111: submimw 1711116‘110111121113.
`01121111121121
`(1 5131111 1111:
`11111111 10 :1 :emrity 13211111111131
`1:11”
`
`11111111121112}. 1 1.1151111117111g 11.12 1112111111211 1:11.11
`1111. 1111.111 111: gm:-
`11.1113112111111111161 111 1111: 2112111 11111111111121; 11111121111111}; 1111: 111111111211
`13111112111 :11. 1.11.: #:1111111 12111211111111.1313 111111111111111'1‘1g 1112 11111111 1.11
`1’
`11'
`3221111111 211111 11111111111111 11151122111111 11111211 11113 311111111111: 1111121111111
`11; 11115111101313. 1 e12n11i11111g .111 111:: 322111111}: 11111111111121 11111211112171 1:
`3111': 121.1 111: 2112111 21.111111111121111 111111111: 11.11: 1111gi.11111 111112111111
`111111 111:. 11111111 11111181111115.1151 .2111 1111112211111 1.111121121111111 if is 112111:
`. 1.1: 1111:: 121121111 11011113111121 11;) 1111111111111: 1111311112111 1111113111111 111111 he
`11111111. 1111111 111;: 52:11:11; 13111111111113: 11111112113112111 magnum 11111.1
`he
`3111111211111, 1111: (1111;111:211 111112111111 :11 1111::112111 21111111111121 11111.1
`11.111111. 11111311 1111-: 11111111121111: 1222111.:‘1 1111111 1111: 51mm 1211112
`11.1111111111211 21111121115111111 11111121111111:
`111: safe.
`”17111-2112: 1':
`1111112: 1111111111211. 111 11201111121110:- with :1 prefer 211
`e111budi.111211‘ 1.111112 present 11112111113111 :1 3111312111 1111‘ 1111112121113.
`:1 2112111 211111 11112111111111 L 31112111111311.1111 gmczmmd 1112111211111: 1.11.111»
`11111, 1111111111113:
`21 gamma: 13111111111121. including :1 11111211211}!
`21313111111 for. 22:11ng cm112111be1'11g5m1111 : 611:111‘211111111 1:1
`1:11? 11111111332112 11121311 113111 including 21 C111]
`11:1 1111 1111211111
`‘
`'111c1'1111L 211111 [112 122111 i11011111111g 2111 11111111 11 2111112111 111111111113:
`
`
`111111111111 ' 11.1.1111. 12
`"2211 21111113111 by 11.111.11.111g1h1. 1211111 11:1 11:
`migimfl
`111112111111 with 2’: wwwpmnding 23.11 :11 .21 5111112111111:
`he .
`1111112111111. 11112 1111113111111: 1111131111111 111:21g. 11112251112113} 10 52111
`111111.11 111 11 5116111113.! 6111] 1311113 fur 11151166111111 11111111dgmfiway
`' 21151111111111.1111: 111111111111 111.3 11111 11111111111611 13111112111 11:11:11
`1111:
`11111211113: 11.131111111121111 111: 211211112111111111121. :1 9211111113; 1:11:11»-
`1111121. 11113111111111;
`:1 11211111137 112221112: 11.11 1212211122 111:1111111
`111111 1112 0111-3111 1111111111111:
`1111 11111111 11191113122101“ 1'11: 1113.12111111111111;
`11111121111117 it 11': $1111: [far 111.: 2111211112011qu113112 1111111112 the 11:13.1 .1111
`1111111313111 111 1‘1: 111:. 11111111. 211111 21 3111:1111 13: 11111131111112: 1'11:- 11:21:15.-
`mifiiagmn 11111113111111 1:111:11: (1212:1111111 11g. 121 1112 2112111 12111111111121",
`1.11111 :1 adieu! 12111111311111: 1:111’1111111111m1111g 11111111112 gamway 1:11 .11—
`.11101 31111 1111111 1112 3213111111411 2131111111121,
`1110111111111;
`:1
`21111111
`_ 2111:1161." 11111221211122 111;: 1110111111211 (3111112111 11.121111: 11:11: gammy
`13111111111121“, and £1.11 1:221’mg 11111 11111111111111 1111111 1112 152213131
`2111111111121;
`11 2111112111 1111112211111 1111 pamwssing 11:: 1111111113221
`
`11:11 111110111111 11111.3: 11'1 2*
`1121112111. and 1'11: 511111111111). 1111:1111;
`111111135111‘1’ 11111101112: 111111 1:11:11 inmcafim 1': safe; 111111 :1 211111111
`1111111111111 .11171111‘1111113117111111131‘112 1.1111111 10 111‘: :em1111y 13111111111 21’
`
`
`1'11: 1113p: 111111. 1211121111125111151111112 11111131111111: 11111111.
`'
`1131111311
`”151121 1: 1.: yet 11111112: 1111111111211 111 32:11:1131122 121111111 11‘:
`2111110211
`16111 111' 1111:: 11112311111
`11111111111111.
`.1 1:1111111‘111e1»m111121111:
`1111112111: 1111311111111 Haring pmgmm 1:11:11: 1111* 122111311111. :11 1:11:11 (1112
`22111p111111g (1:111:32 11.1 1121:2111: $211121“: including :1 2:111 111 £1.11
`1311511112111 1311112111111, and 1112 121111 1112111111111321111 11111111, 121111121: 1111:
`1:11.11 111 111: 11.11g111211 11:11:111111 1111111 11 13111121111111.11111121. 1:211} 11:1 11
`1111118131111: 1311112112111. 11112 31111311111121 111111;:11111‘112111g (1.1112121111111111
`111 1121111 1121111111 1111‘ 11121112011011. 1112.1:1151 generating 11:11.1:11 112:1.
`2111112111. 11111225: 1112111111111112212111112.1711, 11:11:11.1: 11:11»: 11111111 11:11
`1113;121:1111“. 11111211 1111: 3111151111111: 111112111111 11:
`1111112111211 111111121
`1111122112'11g 1111:111111111111112111112111,. 11111.1 suspend 11:11:251111111 (.11
`1112 11111
`1112121 201112111, 1121111111111: 111111211121“ 11 1: 3:111:11: 111111122:
`the. wig
`11111. 111118111111 1111111 1.11: input. 111111511111 1.1.11 1111111321161: 111'
`1111211111: 1115 1211': 11117: 1111111111112: 11:. 111111112: 111: 111111111211 111112.w
`111111 1111111 1112 1.1111111. and 112511111: 1111101131111: 1111111: 11111111111111
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`:11
`
`“111
`
`1.1an
`
`31.1
`
`41.]
`
`.1"V1
`..
`
`131'}
`
`15Ua
`
`6
`21111112111 11112111112211.1111; 11:: 1111111311101. 111111 11111111: 111:: 111111111111
`’ ' 11111111111 11/1111 1111: 1.1111111 11111311171111: 11111i221121 11111112511211 11.1111 1:111:11
`' 11111211111111 1:; 11111:
`
`T111211: '1': 21111111101121.1131 priwidflgi in. 1222111111121: 1111111 :1 3111:
`”211211 embodhnem 1111111: 11112112111 11111211111311 :1 11121111111 1'11:
`31111111111113,
`21 1:112:11.
`(11111111111121 1111111 11111111111111.2111}: 11111121111136
`111:1 111.11.111.13 13111112111. 111:111dingrec’e‘1ving 0111112111 11:111g112111 11.1 :1
`1:11:11: 2131111111121 1111‘p1112253111g. 1111: 12011113111 11111111111115:111111 I 111
`1111 111111111211111111111111 1111(1111221111111211111ng :11 inpm11111111111-
`
`11g 1111: 3111112111511112111111111: 1121111111113}; the 1:111] 111 1111: wig. :11
`11112111111111111 1: 131111251101111111’11 111111 111.231 1111113111111211111211011. 1.112
`31111311111121 ‘1111111111‘111112111g 11111131131111.1231 111 11:11.11 11112: 1111:1111
`1:1
`:1
`52:11:11); 12111111111121“ fm 11131111211211. 211.111 111111.:1111'1111’1g 1111:: 1114:1112
`112d women: 111 111:: 11112111 111111111111131 111117 precessing.
`
`T111212. 11: 1111112111111" 11111111111131.1111 112.1:11111211122 11.11111. 21 1.1 11211211
`
`
`21111111111111.2111 (11111.13 11121111111 11W 1.111111 :1 53113112111. 11111.1 1.1.161: 111g
`110112111c11111p11121110111 dymmicafly getwramd 11111111311111: c011:
`11:111. 1.111111111111g 1.1 12221121 1111‘ 1222111111 1311111121111 being. 112111 to :1
`2112111 2111111111121 1111' 11111192115111 1;. 1112 221112111 111:11111111g a 1:11 1 11:1
`1111 1111 11111.11 111111211011. 111111 1111-: 131111 incinding 1111 inpm. a C1111 1:111
`111111111121: 1'11: 1.111161131111111.1112 12013111211 1111111112111 111-1 mplac111g1111:
`131111 11.1 1112 11:1g1'11111 111111111011 1111111 21 1:111:25111111111113 1.1111] 111 21
`511115111111: 111112111111. 11112 5111131111112 1111112111111 1:12ng 111121.1111111111
`111 1121111 1111: 1111:1111 11.1 :1 11221111131 21111111111211111 11151122111111, 2111121 21
`11111151111021” 1'11}: 1.1211151111111111: 1111: 11111111111213 1301112111111 1111:. (1112111
`«21111111111121:
`T111311: is 111111121 1111111111311 111 amerdmlm: 1.111111 a prefermd
`1111111111111112111 11f 1111: 11112112111 111v211111111 a 2111111111113:'—1::111:1h1:
`5111111 1121112111 11111 5111:111g pmgrmn 1211112 111.1 11111151111: :1 6111111111:
`1113; 111211112: 111 12221112 1221116111; 1110111111111”: :1 13-2111 11’: 11111111111112}
`11111113111111, 211111. [1121:1111 11161111111121 :11 11.11.1111. 111111 1:111:12: 1:111: 1:111]
`11.11111: mf'giml 1111113111111 1111111 11 21111231111211111132311 121 :1 111.111.1111»
`111121 1111112111111. 1112 gubsfimm 1111112111111 111:1 11g. (11121111111113! 111 1121111
`11121111111111
`11:11 11131121311311.
`"17111-111: 1: 31121 1111111121”1111.111de 1.11 11.211111112111122: with :1 11121211211
`21111101111111.1111 {11111131311131.1111 1111121111 (.1 1.111 11121.11
`1131‘ [1111161311113
`:1. 11112111 1211111111112111211.1:1311121111ica11y