Case 3:17-cv-05659-WHA Document 346 Filed 12/21/18 Page 1 of 2
`
`NGBM>= LM9M>L =BLMKB<M <HNKM
`GHKMA>KG =BLMKB<M H? <9EB?HKGB9
`<9G= 102
`’<9G= KWh+ -(,/-.5(
`
`.S+ <HGM9<M I>KLHG ?HK MABL HK=>K
`
`Dana Hardy
`
`.T+ 9MMHKG>R G9F> ’[X V[XXWdW‘f(
`
`Maxwell C. McGraw
`
`0;52A5 @524 9=AB@C3B9>=A >= =5FB ?275(
`
`(
`
`/S+ <HGM9<M IAHG> GNF;>K
`
`(816) 559-0358
`
`/T+ 9MMHKG>R IAHG> GNF;>K
`
`(816) 474-6550
`
`0"+ <HGM9<M >F9BE 9==K>LL
`
`dehardy@shb.com
`
`0#+ 9MMHKG>R >F9BE 9==K>LL
`
`mmcgraw@shb.com
`
`< H N K M N L > H G E R
`
`1+ F9BEBG@ 9==K>LL ’BG<EN=> E9P ?BKF G9F>) B? 9IIEB<9;E>(
`Shook, Hardy & Bacon
`2555 Grand Boulevard
`Kansas City, MO 64108
`
`2+ <9L> G9F>
`
`Finjan, Inc. v. Juniper Network, Inc.
`
`3+ <9L> GNF;>K
`
`17-cv-05659
`
`5+ MABL MK9GL<KBIM HK=>K BL ?HK7
`
`4+ <HNKM K>IHKM>K G9F> ’ ?HK ?MK) E>9O> ;E9GD 9G= *-+*. )/1%G " ?MK
`
`Katherine Sullivan and Jo Ann Bryce
`
`" 9II>9E
`
`" <KBFBG9E
`
`" B‘ Xad_S bSgbWd[e ’GHM>7 <agdf adVWd Xad fdS‘eUd[bfe _gef TW SffSUZWV(
`
`" GHG*9II>9E
`
`4
`" <BOBE
`
`<C97 =a ‘af geW fZ[e Xad_8 geW ?ad_ <C9/1+
`
`6+ MK9GL<KBIM’L( K>JN>LM>= ’LbWU[Xk badf[a‘’e( S‘V VSfW’e( aX bdaUWWV[‘Y’e( Xad iZ[UZ fdS‘eUd[bf [e dWcgWefWV() Xad_Sf’e( & cgS‘f[fk S‘V VW^[hWdk fkbW7
`
`S+
`
`A>9KBG@’L( ’HK IHKMBHGL H? A>9KBG@L(
`
`T+
`
`L>E><M ?HKF9M’L( ’./1,) ,*- 2335AA 9A 9=3;C454
`E9B8 ?C@382A5 >6 0+-’ B5FB’ ?2?5@ >@ 3>=45=A54(&
`
`U +
`
`=>EBO>KR MRI> ’ <ZaaeW a‘W bWd ^[‘W(
`
`=9M>
`
`CN=@>
`’[‘[f[S^e(
`
`MRI>
`’W+Y+ <F<(
`
`IHKMBHG
`BX dWcgWef[‘Y ^Wee fZS‘ Xg^^ ZWSd[‘Y)
`ebWU[Xk badf[a‘ ’W+Y+ i[f‘Wee ad f[_W(
`
`I=?
`’W_S[^(
`
`M>QM,9L<BB
`’W_S[^(
`
`I9I>K
`
`<HG=>GL>=
`’W_S[^(
`
`><? 9<<>LL
`’iWT(
`
`HK=BG9KR
`’0-*VSk(
`
`.1*=Sk
`
`>QI>=BM>=
`’4*VSk(
`
`0*=9R
`
`=9BER
`’GWjf VSk(
`
`AHNKER
`’/ Zde(
`
`K>9EMBF>
`
`12/10/2018
`
`m
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`m
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`m
`"
`
`m
`"
`
`m
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`"
`
`m
`"
`
`m m
`
`"
`
`"
`
`12/11/2018
`
`12/12/2018
`
`12/14/2018
`
`WHA
`WHA
`WHA
`WHA
`
`Trial
`Trial
`
`Trial
`Trial
`
`.-+ 9==BMBHG9E <HFF>GML) BGLMKN<MBHGL) JN>LMBHGL) >M<7
`
`"
`
`"
`
`HK=>K & <>KMB?B<9MBHG ’..+ & ./+( ;k e[Y‘[‘Y TW^ai) B UWdf[Xk fZSf B i[^^ bSk S^^ UZSdYWe ’VWbae[f b^ge SVV[f[a‘S^(+
`
`..+ LB@G9MNK>
`
`/s/ Maxwell C. McGraw
`
`Clear Form
`
`./+ =9M>
`
`12/20/2018
`
`Save as new PDF
`
`

`

`Case 3:17-cv-05659-WHA Document 346 Filed 12/21/18 Page 2 of 2
`
`<9G= 102
`’KWh+ -(,/-.5(
`
`;WXadW Ua_b^Wf[‘Y fZ[e Xad_) b^WSeW h[e[f US‘V+geUagdfe+Yah,fdS‘eUd[bfe Xad Ua_b^WfW
`
`NeW fZ[e Xad_ fa adVWd fZW fdS‘eUd[bf[a‘ aX bdaUWWV[‘Ye+
`fdS‘eUd[bf adVWd[‘Y [‘Xad_Sf[a‘+
`.+
`<a_b^WfW S eWbSdSfW adVWd Xad_ Xad WSUZ USeW ‘g_TWd Xad iZ[UZ fdS‘eUd[bfe SdW adVWdWV+
`/+
`<a_b^WfW S eWbSdSfW adVWd Xad_ Xad WSUZ Uagdf dWbadfWd iZa dWbadfWV bdaUWWV[‘Ye [‘ fZW USeW+
`0+
`<a_b^WfW BfW_e .*./+ DWWb S Uabk aX kagd Ua_b^WfWV adVWd Xad_ Xad kagd dWUadVe+
`1+
`>*X[^W fZ[e Xad_ [‘ fZW N+L+ =[efd[Uf <agdf <F,><? ekefW_+
`7 ’S( eWS^WV USeWe,bdaUWWV[‘Ye8 ’T( ‘a‘*bSdf[We8 ’U( bda eW bSdf[We iZa SdW ‘af W*X[^Wde+
`B‘ egUZ USeWe) _S[^ ad ZS‘V*VW^[hWd S ZSdV Uabk SVVdWeeWV fa fZW Uagdf dWbadfWd U,a fZW <^Wd]me HXX[UW Sf fZW <agdf V[h[e[a‘ iZWdW fZW bdaUWWV[‘Y iSe ZW^V+
`>_S[^ fZW Uagdf dWbadfWd ’W_S[^ ^[ef ShS[^ST^W Sf US‘V+geUagdfe+Yah,UagdfdWbadfWdUa‘fSUf( bda_bf^k SXfWd fZ[e MdS‘eUd[bf HdVWd ?ad_ [e W*X[^WV fa aTfS[‘ fZW S_ag‘f aX
`fZW dWcg[dWV VWbae[f =W^[hWd bSk_W‘f fa fZW Uagdf dWbadfWd bda_bf^k+ Nba‘ dWUW[bf aX fZW VWbae[f) fZW Uagdf dWbadfWd i[^^ TWY[‘ iad] a‘ fZW fdS‘eUd[bf+
`’S( adVWde Xad ?MK fdS‘eUd[bfe S‘V ’T( VS[^k fd[S^ fdS‘eUd[bf adVWde+
`N‘^Wee bdWbSk_W‘f [e iS[hWV) VW^[hWdk f[_W [e Ua_bgfWV Xda_ fZW VSfW fZW Uagdf dWbadfWd dWUW[hWe fZW VWbae[f) SgfZad[lWV <C9 /1 ?ad_) SgfZad[lSf[a‘ Xda_ ?WVWdS^
`IgT^[U =WXW‘VWdme HXX[UW ad) Xad fdS‘eUd[bfe adVWdWV Tk fZW N+L+ YahWd‘_W‘f) Xda_ fZW VSfW aX dWUW[bf aX fZW =<G ‘g_TWd+
`MZW VWbae[f XWW [e S‘ Wef[_SfW+ 9‘k ahWdSYW i[^^ TW dWXg‘VWV8 S‘k eZadfSYW i[^^ TW VgW Xda_ kag+
`
`2+
`
`3+
`
`4+
`
`BfW_e .*0
`
`B‘ X[W^Ve .S) /S & 0S) b^WSeW bdah[VW fZW Ua‘fSUf ‘S_W S‘V [‘Xad_Sf[a‘ Xad fZW bWdea‘ dWeba‘e[T^W Xad adVWd[‘Y fZW fdS‘eUd[bf+ B‘ S ^Si aXX[UW) fZ[e [e gegS^^k S
`bSdS^WYS^ ad SV_[‘[efdSf[hW See[efS‘f) ‘af fZW Sffad‘Wk+ B‘ X[W^Ve .T) /T & 0T) bdah[VW fZW Sffad‘Wk ‘S_W S‘V Ua‘fSUf [‘Xa) [X fZW Sffad‘Wk [e ‘af fZW Ua‘fSUf bWdea‘+
`BfW_e 2*3+ H‘^k a‘W USeW ‘g_TWd _Sk TW ^[efWV bWd adVWd+
`BfW_ 4+
`O[e[f US‘V+geUagdfe+Yah,fdS‘eUd[bfe Xad [‘efdgUf[a‘e Xad VWfWd_[‘[‘Y fZW ‘S_W aX fZW Uagdf dWbadfWd iZa dWbadfWV fZW bdaUWWV[‘Y ad [X fZW bdaUWWV[‘Y iSe
`SgV[adWUadVWV+ BX _[‘gfWe ZShW ‘af TWW‘ X[^WV) Ua‘fSUf \gVYWme Uagdfdaa_ VWbgfk+
`<ZWU] SbbWS^ HK ‘a‘*SbbWS^ 9G= Ud[_[‘S^ HK U[h[^+
`7 S Uagdf adVWd ebWU[X[US^^k SgfZad[l[‘Y fdS‘eUd[bfe [e dWcg[dWV TWXadW fdS‘eUd[bfe _Sk TW
`adVWdWV 9= 6>@<2 ?2C?5@9A+
`E[ef ebWU[X[U VSfW’e( aX fZW bdaUWWV[‘Ye Xad iZ[UZ fdS‘eUd[bf [e dWcgWefWV+ 9 fdS‘eUd[bf aX a‘^k S badf[a‘ aX S bdaUWWV[‘Y _Sk TW adVWdWV) [X fZW VWeUd[bf[a‘ [e U^WSd^k
`id[ffW‘ fa XSU[^[fSfW bdaUWee[‘Y+ N‘VWd nfkbW)o [‘V[USfW Td[WX^k iZSf fkbW aX bdaUWWV[‘Y [f iSe) egUZ Se n_af[a‘)o neW‘fW‘U[‘Y)o ad n<F<+o
`LW^WUf VWe[dWV
`Xad fdS‘eUd[bf+ MZWdW [e S‘ SVV[f[a‘S^ UZSdYW Xad WSUZ Xad_Sf adVWdWV+ O[e[f US‘V+geUagdfe+Yah,fdS‘eUd[bfdSfWe Xad VWfS[^e+ N‘^aU] ><?,iWT
`SUUWee [e [‘U^gVWV Sf ‘a WjfdS UZSdYW i[fZ WSUZ aX fZW afZWd Xad_Sfe+
`7 ?g^^ bd[UW _Sk TW UZSdYWV a‘^k [X
`MZWdW SdW 4
`fa UZaaeW Xda_ ’f[_We SdW Ua_bgfWV Xda_ VSfW aX dWUW[bf aX fZW VWbae[f XWW ad =<G ‘g_TWd(+
`fZW fdS‘eUd[bf [e VW^[hWdWV i[fZ[‘ fZW dWcg[dWV f[_W XdS_W+ ?ad WjS_b^W) [X S‘ adVWd Xad WjbWV[fWV fdS‘eUd[bf [e ‘af Ua_b^WfWV S‘V VW^[hWdWV i[fZ[‘ 4 US^W‘VSd VSke)
`fZW .1*VSk 45;9D5@G dSfW iag^V TW UZSdYWV+
`
`BfW_ 5+
`
`BfW_ 6S+
`
`fW_ 6T+
`
`BfW_ 6U+
`
`#
`
`#
`
`#
`
`#
`
`#
`
`#
`
`#
`
`H 0- US^W‘VSd VSke+
`H .1 US^W‘VSd VSke+
`H 4 US^W‘VSd VSke+
`H 0 US^W‘VSd VSke
`H /> C85 32<5>42A 42F 6?<<?E9>7 A5359@C ?6 C85 ?A45A $9>3<D49>7 E55;5>4B " 8?<942FB%& @A9?A C? C85 >?A=2< ?@5>9>7 8?DA ?6 C85 3<5A;#B ?66935’
`H 0[fZ[‘ fia ’/( Zagde+
`H 9 VdSXf g‘WV[fWV) g‘UWdf[X[WV fdS‘eUd[bf bdaVgUWV Tk S UWdf[X[WV dWS^f[_W dWbadfWd Se S TkbdaVgUf aX dWS^f[_W fa TW VW^[hWdWV W^WUfda‘[US^^k Vgd[‘Y
`bdaUWWV[‘Ye ad [__WV[SfW^k Xa^^ai[‘Y A5359@C ?6 C85 ?A45A+
`
`BfW_ ..+
`BfW_ ./+
`
`L[Y‘ [‘ fZ[e ebSUW fa UWdf[Xk fZSf kag i[^^ bSk S^^ UZSdYWe ’fZW VWbae[f b^ge S‘k SVV[f[a‘S^ UZSdYWe+( 9‘ W^WUfda‘[U ad Ua‘Xad_WV ’,e,( e[Y‘SfgdW [e SUUWbfST^W+
`>‘fWd fZW VSfW aX e[Y‘[‘Y fZW adVWd S‘V UWdf[X[USf[a‘+
`
`