throbber
Case 2:20-cv-07872-GW-PVC Document 298-7 Filed 03/09/24 Page 1 of 29 Page ID
`#:10389
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`EXHIBIT E
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`

`

`Case 2:20-cv-07872-GW-PVC Document 298-7 Filed 03/09/24 Page 2 of 29 Page ID
`#:10390
`
`APPENDIX A
`
`Country
`
`Additional Prior Art
`
`Issue/
`Publication
`Date
`United States 3/26/1974
`United States Patent 3,800,082 to Fish
`United States 8/7/1990
`United States Patent 4,947,321 to Spence, et al.
`United States 2/5/1991
`United States Patent 4,991,008 to Nama
`United States 7/23/1991
`United States Patent 5,034,812 to Rawlings
`United States 8/31/1993
`United States Patent 5241671 to Reed, et al.
`United States 11/2/1993
`United States Patent 5259037 to Plunk
`United States 8/13/1996
`United States Patent 5,546,475 to Bolle, et al.
`United States 11/19/1996
`United States Patent 5497314 to Novak
`United States 11/26/1996
`United States Patent 5576950 to Tonomura, et al.
`United States 1/14/1997
`United States Patent 5,594,226 to Steger
`United States 1/14/1997
`United States Patent 5594806 to Colbert
`United States 3/25/1997
`United States Patent 5615324 to Kuboyama
`United States 4/29/1997
`United States Patent 5625765 to Ellenby, et al.
`United States 6/17/1997
`United States Patent 5640193 to Wellner
`United States 10/28/1997
`United States Patent 5682332 to Ellenby, et al.
`United States 3/3/1998
`United States Patent 5724579 to Suzuki
`United States 4/21/1998
`United States Patent 5742521 to Ellenby, et al.
`United States 4/21/1998
`United States Patent 5742815 to Stern
`United States 5/12/1998
`United States Patent 5751286 to Barber, et al.
`United States 6/16/1998
`United States Patent 5768633 to Allen, et al.
`United States 6/16/1998
`United States Patent 5768663 to Lin
`United States 6/23/1998
`United States Patent 5771307 to Lu, et al.
`United States 7/28/1998
`United States Patent 5787186 to Schroeder
`United States 9/29/1998
`United States Patent 5815411 to Ellenby, et al.
`United States 11/3/1998
`United States Patent 5,832,463 to Funk
`United States 11/3/1998
`United States Patent 5832464 to Hoevener, et al.
`United States 4/6/1999
`United States Patent 5893095 to Jain, et al.
`United States 4/13/1999
`United States Patent 5894323 to Kain, at el
`United States 4/27/1999
`United States Patent 5897625 to Gustin, et al.
`United States 6/15/1999
`United States Patent 5911827 to Heller
`United States Patent 5915038 to Abdel-Mottaleb, et al. United States 6/22/1999
`
`United States Patent 5917930 to Kayani, et al.
`United States Patent 5926116 to Kitano, et al.
`United States Patent 5933823 to Cullen, et al.
`United States Patent 5933829 to Durst, et al.
`
`United States 6/29/1999
`United States 7/20/1999
`United States 8/3/1999
`United States 8/3/1999
`
`1
`
`
`
`
`
`1
`2
`3
`4
`5
`6
`7
`8
`9
`10
`11
`12
`13
`14
`15
`16
`17
`18
`19
`20
`21
`22
`23
`24
`25
`26
`27
`28
`29
`30
`31
`
`32
`33
`34
`35
`
`
`
`

`

`Case 2:20-cv-07872-GW-PVC Document 298-7 Filed 03/09/24 Page 3 of 29 Page ID
`#:10391
`
`Country
`
`Issue/
`Publication
`Date
`United States 8/10/1999
`United States 8/10/1999
`United States 8/31/1999
`United States 10/26/1999
`United States 11/2/1999
`United States 11/9/1999
`United States 11/23/1999
`United States 11/30/1999
`United States 12/28/1999
`United States 2/29/2000
`United States 3/14/2000
`United States 3/14/2000
`United States 3/14/2000
`United States 3/14/2000
`United States 3/14/2000
`United States 3/14/2000
`United States 4/4/2000
`United States 4/25/2000
`
`United States 5/9/2000
`United States Patent 6061478 to Kanoh, et al.
`United States 5/16/2000
`United States Patent 6064398 to Ellenby, et al.
`United States 5/30/2000
`United States Patent 6069696 to McQueen, et al.
`United States 6/6/2000
`United States Patent 6072904 to Desai, et al.
`United States Patent 6081612 to Gutkowicz-Krin, et al. United States 6/27/2000
`
`United States Patent 6,097,834 to Krouse, et al.
`United States Patent 6097834 to Krouse
`United States Patent 6097834 to Krouse, et al.
`United States Patent 6098118 to Ellenby, et al.
`United States Patent 6108656 to Durst, et al.
`United States Patent 6134548 to Gottsman, et al.
`United States Patent 6144848 to Walsh, et al.
`United States Patent 6173239 to Ellenby
`United States Patent 6181817 to Zabih
`United States Patent 6182090 to Peairs
`United States Patent 6199048 to Hudetz, et al.
`United States Patent 6202055 to Houvener, et al.
`
`United States 8/1/2000
`United States 8/1/2000
`United States 8/1/2000
`United States 8/1/2000
`United States 8/22/2000
`United States 10/17/2000
`United States 11/7/2000
`United States 1/9/2001
`United States 1/30/2001
`United States 1/30/2001
`United States 3/6/2001
`United States 3/13/2001
`
`2
`
`
`
`Additional Prior Art
`
`United States Patent 5933923 to Catlos, et al.
`United States Patent 5937079 to Franke
`United States Patent 5945982 to Higashio, et al.
`United States Patent 5971277 to Cragun, et al.
`United States Patent 5978773 to Hudetz, et al.
`United States Patent 5982912 to Fukui, et al.
`United States Patent 5991827 to Ellenby, et al.
`United States Patent 5992752 to Wilz, et al.
`United States Patent 6009204 to Ahmad
`United States Patent 6031545 to Ellenby, et al.
`United States Patent 6,038,553 to Hyde
`United States Patent 6036086 to Sizer, et al.
`United States Patent 6037936 to Ellenby, et al.
`United States Patent 6037963 to Denton, et al.
`United States Patent 6038295 to Mattes
`United States Patent 6038333 to Wang
`United States Patent 6045039 to Stinson, et al.
`United States Patent 6055536 to Shimakawa, et al.
`
`36
`37
`38
`39
`40
`41
`42
`43
`44
`45
`46
`47
`48
`49
`50
`51
`52
`53
`
`54
`55
`56
`57
`58
`
`59
`60
`61
`62
`63
`64
`65
`66
`67
`68
`69
`70
`
`
`
`

`

`Case 2:20-cv-07872-GW-PVC Document 298-7 Filed 03/09/24 Page 4 of 29 Page ID
`#:10392
`
`
`
`71
`72
`
`73
`74
`75
`76
`77
`78
`
`Additional Prior Art
`
`Issue/
`Publication
`Date
`United States 3/27/2001
`United States Patent 6208353 to Ayer, et al.
`United States Patent 6208749 to Gutkowicz-Krin, et al. United States 3/27/2001
`
`Country
`
`United States 3/27/2001
`United States Patent 6208933 to Lazar
`United States 7/3/2001
`United States Patent 6256409 to Wang
`United States 8/21/2001
`United States Patent 6278461 to Ellenby, et al.
`United States 9/4/2001
`United States Patent 6286036 to Rhoads
`United States 10/23/2001
`United States Patent 6307556 to Ellenby, et al.
`United States Patent 6307957 to Gutkowicz-Krin, et al. United States 10/23/2001
`
`United States Patent 6317718 to Fano
`79
`United States Patent 6339651 to Tian, et al.
`80
`United States Patent 6,351,735 to Deaton, et al.
`81
`United States Patent 6393147 to Danneels, et al.
`82
`United States Patent 6396475 to Ellenby, et al.
`83
`United States Patent 6396537 to Squilla, et al.
`84
`United States Patent 6396963 to Shaffer, et al.
`85
`United States Patent 6404975 to Bopardikar, et al.
`86
`United States Patent 6405975 to Sankrithi, et al.
`87
`United States Patent 6411725 to Rhoads
`88
`United States Patent 6411953 to Ganapathy, et al.
`89
`United States Patent 6414696 to Ellenby, et al.
`90
`United States Patent 6430554 to Rothschild
`91
`United States Patent 6434561 to Durst, et al.
`92
`United States Patent 6445834 to Rising, et al.
`93
`United States Patent 6446076 to Burkey, et al.
`94
`United States Patent 6453361 to Morris
`95
`United States Patent 6,473,517 to Tyan, et al.
`96
`United States Patent 6490443 to Freeny, Jr.
`97
`United States Patent 6501854 to Konishi, et al.
`98
`United States Patent 6502756 to Fahraeus
`99
`100 United States Patent 6505776 to Wilz, et al.
`101 United States Patent 6510238 to Haycock
`102 United States Patent 6,512,919 to Ogasawara
`103 United States Patent 6522292 to Ellenby, et al.
`104 United States Patent 6522772 to Morrison, et al.
`105 United States Patent 6522889 to Aarnio
`
`
`
`3
`
`United States 11/13/2001
`United States 1/15/2002
`United States 2/26/2002
`United States 5/21/2002
`United States 5/28/2002
`United States 5/28/2002
`United States 5/28/2002
`United States 6/11/2002
`United States 6/18/2002
`United States 6/25/2002
`United States 6/25/2002
`United States 7/2/2002
`United States 8/6/2002
`United States 8/13/2002
`United States 9/3/2002
`United States 9/3/2002
`United States 9/17/2002
`United States 10/29/2002
`United States 12/3/2002
`United States 12/31/2002
`United States 1/7/2003
`United States 1/14/2003
`United States 1/21/2003
`United States 1/28/2003
`United States 2/18/2003
`United States 2/18/2003
`United States 2/18/2003
`
`

`

`Case 2:20-cv-07872-GW-PVC Document 298-7 Filed 03/09/24 Page 5 of 29 Page ID
`#:10393
`
`
`
`Additional Prior Art
`
`106 United States Patent 6526158 to Goldberg
`107 United States Patent 6532298 to Cambier, et al.
`108 United States Patent 6533392 to Koitabashi
`109 United States Patent 6535210 to Ellenby, et al.
`110 United States Patent 6542933 to Durst, et al.
`111 United States Patent 6563959 to Troyanker
`112 United States Patent 6567122 to Anderson, et al.
`113 United States Patent 6578017 to Ebersole, et al.
`114 United States Patent 6580385 to Winner, et al.
`115 United States Patent 6597818 to Kumar, et al.
`116 United States Patent 6601026 to Appelt, et al.
`117 United States Patent 6609103 to Kolls
`118 United States Patent 6651053 to Rothschild
`119 United States Patent 6658389 to Alpdemir
`120 United States Patent 6666377 to Harris
`121 United States Patent 6674923 to Shih, et al.
`122 United States Patent 6674993 to Tarouriech
`123 United States Patent 6675165 to Rothschild
`124 United States Patent 6689966 to Wiebe
`125 United States Patent 6690370 to Ellenby, et al.
`126 United States Patent 6691914 to Isherwood, et al.
`127 United States Patent 6711278 to Gu, et al.
`128 United States Patent 6714969 to Klein, et al.
`129 United States Patent 6722569 to Ehrhart, et al.
`130 United States Patent 6724914 to Brundage, et al.
`131 United States Patent 6738630 to Ashmore
`132 United States Patent 6744935 to Choi, et al.
`133 United States Patent 6748122 to Ihara, et al.
`134 United States Patent 6765569 to Neumann, et al.
`135 United States Patent 6766363 to Rothschild
`136 United States Patent 6771294 to Pulli, et al.
`137 United States Patent 6788800 to Carr, et al.
`138 United States Patent 6801657 to Cieplinski
`139 United States Patent 6804726 to Ellenby, et al.
`140 United States Patent 6842181 to Acharya
`141 United States Patent 6650794 to Aoki
`142 United States Patent 6853750 to Aoki
`
`
`
`4
`
`Country
`
`Issue/
`Publication
`Date
`United States 2/25/2003
`United States 3/11/2003
`United States 3/18/2003
`United States 3/18/2003
`United States 4/1/2003
`United States 5/13/2003
`United States 5/20/2003
`United States 6/10/2003
`United States 6/17/2003
`United States 7/22/2003
`United States 7/29/2003
`United States 8/19/2003
`United States 11/18/2003
`United States 12/2/2003
`United States 12/23/2003
`United States 1/6/2004
`United States 1/6/2004
`United States 1/6/2004
`United States 2/10/2004
`United States 2/10/2004
`United States 2/17/2004
`United States 3/23/2004
`United States 3/30/2004
`United States 4/20/2004
`United States 4/20/2004
`United States 5/18/2004
`United States 6/1/2004
`United States 6/8/2004
`United States 7/20/2004
`United States 7/20/2004
`United States 8/3/2004
`United States 9/7/2004
`United States 10/5/2004
`United States 10/12/2004
`United States 1/11/2005
`United States 2/8/2005
`United States 2/8/2005
`
`

`

`Case 2:20-cv-07872-GW-PVC Document 298-7 Filed 03/09/24 Page 6 of 29 Page ID
`#:10394
`
`
`
`Additional Prior Art
`
`143 United States Patent 6856965 to Stinson, et al.
`144 United States Patent 6865608 to Hunter
`145 United States Patent 6866196 to Rathus, et al.
`146 United States Patent 6868415 to Kageyama, et al.
`147 United States Patent 6882756 to Bober
`148 United States Patent 6885771 to Takahashi
`149 United States Patent 6912464 to Parker
`150 United States Patent 6925196 to Kass, et al.
`151 United States Patent 6,947,571 to Rhoads, et al.
`152 United States Patent 6947571 to Rhoads, et al.
`153 United States Patent 6950800 to McIntyre, et al.
`154 United States Patent 6956593 to Gupta, et al.
`155 United States Patent 6963656 to Pursuad, et al.
`156 United States Patent 6968453 to Doyle, et al.
`157 United States Patent 6974078 to Simon
`158 United States Patent 6,977,743 to Carlton
`159 United States Patent 6977743 to Carlton
`160 United States Patent 6985240 to Benke, et al.
`161 United States Patent 6990235 to Katsuyama
`162 United States Patent 6993573 to Hunter
`163 United States Patent 6996251 to Malone, et al.
`164 United States Patent 7002551 to Azuma, et al.
`165 United States Patent 7016532 to Boncyk, et al.
`166 United States Patent 7016889 to Bazoon
`167 United States Patent 7016899 to Stern, et al.
`168 United States Patent 7027652 to I'Anson
`169 United States Patent 7031496 to Shimano, et al.
`170 United States Patent 7031536 to Kijiwara
`171 United States Patent 7031875 to Ellenby, et al.
`172 United States Patent 7050653 to Edsoet, et al.
`173 United States Patent 7053916 to Kobayashi, et al.
`174 United States Patent 7062454 to Giannini
`175 United States Patent 7062456 to Riehl
`176 United States Patent 7072669 to Duckworth
`177 United States Patent 7103772 to Jorgensen
`178 United States Patent 7113867 to Stein
`179 United States Patent 7119831 to Ohto, et al.
`
`
`
`5
`
`Country
`
`Issue/
`Publication
`Date
`United States 2/15/2005
`United States 3/8/2005
`United States 3/15/2005
`United States 3/15/2005
`United States 4/19/2005
`United States 4/26/2005
`United States 6/28/2005
`United States 8/2/2005
`United States 9/20/2005
`United States 9/20/2005
`United States 9/27/2005
`United States 10/18/2005
`United States 11/8/2005
`United States 11/22/2005
`United States 12/13/2005
`United States 12/20/2005
`United States 12/20/2005
`United States 1/10/2006
`United States 1/24/2006
`United States 1/31/2006
`United States 2/7/2006
`United States 2/21/2006
`United States 3/21/2006
`United States 3/21/2006
`United States 3/21/2006
`United States 4/11/2006
`United States 4/18/2006
`United States 4/18/2006
`United States 4/18/2006
`United States 5/23/2006
`United States 5/30/2006
`United States 6/13/2006
`United States 7/4/2006
`United States 9/5/2006
`United States 9/12/2006
`United States 9/26/2006
`United States 10/10/2006
`
`

`

`Case 2:20-cv-07872-GW-PVC Document 298-7 Filed 03/09/24 Page 7 of 29 Page ID
`#:10395
`
`
`
`Additional Prior Art
`
`180 United States Patent 7121469 to Dorai, et al.
`181 United States Patent 7127094 to Elbaum, et al.
`182 United States Patent 7143949 to Hannigan
`183 United States Patent 7167164 to Ericson, et al.
`184 United States Patent 7175095 to Pettersson, et al.
`185 United States Patent 7190833 to Kagehiro, et al.
`186 United States Patent 7224995 to Rhoads
`187 United States Patent 7245273 to Eberl, et al.
`188 United States Patent 7254548 to Tannenbaum
`189 United States Patent 7266545 to Bergman, et al.
`190 United States Patent 7295718 to Park, et al.
`191 United States Patent 7296747 to Rohs
`192 United States Patent 7301536 to Ellenby, et al.
`193 United States Patent 7305354 to Rodriguez, et al.
`194 United States Patent 7309015 to Frantz, et al.
`195 United States Patent 7310605 to Janakiraman, et al.
`
`Country
`
`Issue/
`Publication
`Date
`United States 10/17/2006
`United States 10/24/2006
`United States 12/5/2006
`United States 1/23/2007
`United States 2/13/2007
`United States 3/13/2007
`United States 5/29/2007
`United States 7/17/2007
`United States 8/7/2007
`United States 9/4/2007
`United States 11/13/2007
`United States 11/20/2007
`United States 11/27/2007
`United States 12/4/2007
`United States 12/18/2007
`United States 12/18/2007
`
`196 United States Patent 7331523 to Meier, et al.
`197 United States Patent 7334728 to Williams
`198 United States Patent 7345673 to Ericson, et al.
`199 United States Patent 7353182 to Missinhoun, et al.
`
`United States 2/19/2008
`United States 2/26/2008
`United States 3/18/2008
`United States 4/1/2008
`
`200 United States Patent 7353184 to Kirshenbaum, et al.
`
`United States 4/1/2008
`
`201 United States Patent 7353990 to Elliot, et al.
`202 United States Patent 7356705 to Ting
`203 United States Patent 7362922 to Nishiyama, et al.
`204 United States Patent 7376645 to Bernard
`205 United States Patent 7383209 to Hudetz, et al.
`206 United States Patent 7410099 to Fukasawa, et al.
`207 United States Patent 7427980 to Partridge, et al.
`208 United States Patent 7430588 to Hunter
`209 United States Patent 7477909 to Roth
`210 United States Patent 7526440 to Walker, et al.
`211 United States Patent 7548915 to Ramer, et al.
`212 United States Patent 7558595 to Angelhag
`213 United States Patent 7555462 to Dutta, et al.
`
`United States 4/8/2008
`United States 4/8/2008
`United States 4/22/2008
`United States 5/20/2008
`United States 6/3/2008
`United States 8/12/2008
`United States 9/23/2008
`United States 9/30/2008
`United States 1/13/2009
`United States 4/28/2009
`United States 6/16/2009
`United States 7/7/2009
`United States 7/30/2009
`
`
`
`6
`
`

`

`Case 2:20-cv-07872-GW-PVC Document 298-7 Filed 03/09/24 Page 8 of 29 Page ID
`#:10396
`
`
`
`Additional Prior Art
`
`214 United States Patent 7580061 to Toyoda
`215 United States Patent 7595816 to Enright, et al.
`216 United States Patent 7599847 to Block, et al.
`217 United States Patent 7631336 to Diaz Perez
`218 United States Patent 7641342 to Eberl, et al.
`219 United States Patent 7680324 to Boncyk, et al.
`220 United States Patent 7696905 to Ellenby, et al.
`221 United States Patent 7707218 to Gocht, et al.
`222 United States Patent 7765126 to Hudetz, et al.
`223 United States Patent 7768534 to Pentenrieder, et al.
`
`224 United States Patent 7774283 to Das, et al.
`225 United States Patent 7797204 to Balent
`226 United States Patent 7845558 to Beemer, et al.
`227 United States Patent 7872669 to Darrell, et al.
`228 United States Patent 7889193 to Platonov, et al.
`229 United States Patent 7916138 to John, et al.
`230 United States Patent 8099332 to Lemay, et al.
`231 United States Patent 8,104,676 to Ramachandran
`232 United States Patent 8608055 to Carpenter, et al.
`233 United States Patent 7686222 to Ehrhart, et al.
`234 United States Patent 5594226 to Steger
`235 United States Patent 8090616 to Proctor, et al.
`236 United States Patent 8090657 to Mitchell, et al.
`237 United States Patent 8104676 to Ramachandran
`238 United States Patent 8626602 to George
`239 United States Patent 8559671 to Milanfar, et al.
`240 United States Patent 8550903 to Lyons, et al.
`241 United States Patent 8312168 to Rhoads, et al.
`242 United States Patent 8588527 to Boncyk, et al.
`243 United States Patent 5579471 to Barber
`244 United States Patent 8320615 to Hamza, et al.
`245 United States Patent 7843488 to Stapleton
`246 United States Patent 8577810 to Dalit, et al.
`247 United States Patent 7830417 to Liu, et al.
`248 United States Patent 8605141 to Dialameh, et al.
`249 United States Patent 8335351 to Boncyk, et al.
`
`
`
`7
`
`Country
`
`Issue/
`Publication
`Date
`United States 8/25/2009
`United States 9/29/2009
`United States 10/6/2009
`United States 12/8/2009
`United States 1/5/2010
`United States 3/16/2010
`United States 4/13/2010
`United States 4/27/2010
`United States 7/27/2010
`United States 8/3/2010
`
`United States 8/10/2010
`United States 9/14/2010
`United States 12/7/2010
`United States 1/18/2011
`United States 2/15/2011
`United States 3/29/2011
`United States 1/17/2012
`United States 1/31/2012
`United States 12/17/2013
`United States 3/30/3010
`United States 1/14/1997
`United States 1/3/2012
`United States 1/3/2012
`United States 1/31/2012
`United States 1/7/2014
`United States 10/15/2013
`United States 10/8/2013
`United States 11/13/2012
`United States 11/19/2013
`United States 11/26/1996
`United States 11/27/2012
`United States
`11/30/2010
`United States 11/5/2003
`United States 11/9/2010
`United States 12/10/2013
`United States 12/18/2012
`
`

`

`Case 2:20-cv-07872-GW-PVC Document 298-7 Filed 03/09/24 Page 9 of 29 Page ID
`#:10397
`
`
`
`Additional Prior Art
`
`Country
`
`Issue/
`Publication
`Date
`United States 12/2/2014
`250 United States Patent 8,903,430 to Sands, et al.
`United States 12/4/2012
`251 United States Patent 8326031 to Boncyk, et al.
`United States 2/12/2012
`252 United States Patent 8121944 to Norman, et al.
`United States 2/19/2008
`253 United States Patent 7333947 to Wiebe, et al.
`United States 2/26/2013
`254 United States Patent 8386918 to Do, et al.
`United States 3/1/2011
`255 United States Patent 7896235 to Ramachandran
`United States 3/24/2015
`256 United States Patent 8,990,235 to King, et al.
`United States 3/6/2012
`257 United States Patent 8130242 to Cohen
`United States 3/6/2012
`258 United States Patent 8131118 to Jing, et al.
`United States 3/6/2012
`259 United States Patent 8131595 to Lee, et al.
`United States 4/10/2007
`260 United States Patent 7201320 to Csulits, et al.
`261 United States Patent 9,311,635 to Ramachandran, et al. United States 4/12/2016
`
`262 United States Patent 8442500 to Gupta, et al.
`263 United States Patent 7720436 to Hamynen, et al.
`264 United States Patent 8447066 to King, et al.
`265 United States Patent 7222789 to Longacre, et al.
`266 United States Patent 8187045 to Tibodaux
`267 United States Patent 8189964 to Flynn, et al.
`268 United States Patent 8190645 to Bashaw
`269 United States Patent 8751316 to Fletchall, et al.
`270 United States Patent 7737965 to Alter, et al.
`271 United States Patent 8756659 to Ruckart
`272 United States Patent 7734507 to Ritter
`273 United States Patent 8218874 to Boncyk, et al.
`274 United States Patent 8219146 to Connors, et al.
`275 United States Patent 7756755 to Ghosh, et al.
`276 United States Patent 8477202 to Asano
`277 United States Patent 7564469 to Cohen
`278 United States Patent 7565008 to Boncyk, et al.
`279 United States Patent 8494274 to Badharudeen, et al.
`
`United States 5/14/2013
`United States 5/18/2010
`United States 5/21/2013
`United States 5/29/2007
`United States 5/29/2012
`United States 5/29/2012
`United States 5/29/2012
`United States 6/10/2014
`United States 6/15/2010
`United States 6/17/2014
`United States 6/8/2010
`United States 7/10/2012
`United States 7/10/2012
`United States 7/13/2010
`United States 7/2/2013
`United States 7/21/2009
`United States 7/21/2009
`United States 7/23/2013
`
`280 United States Patent 7764808 to Zhu, et al.
`281 United States Patent 7406445 to Silverbrook, et al.
`
`United States 7/27/2010
`United States 7/29/2008
`
`282 United States Patent 8497939 to Cuttner
`283 United States Patent 7751805 to Neven, et al.
`
`United States 7/30/2013
`United States 7/6/2010
`
`
`
`8
`
`

`

`Case 2:20-cv-07872-GW-PVC Document 298-7 Filed 03/09/24 Page 10 of 29 Page ID
`#:10398
`
`
`
`Additional Prior Art
`
`284 United States Patent 8483715 to Chen, et al.
`285 United States Patent 7775437 to Cohen
`286 United States Patent 5444794 to Ushland
`287 United States Patent 8255291 to Nair
`288 United States Patent 7769228 to Bahlmann, et al.
`289 United States Patent 8528818 to Ehrhart
`290 United States Patent 7104444 to Suzuki
`291 United States Patent 6942151 to Ehrhart
`292 United States Patent 8,838,477 to Moshfeghi
`293 United States Patent 8824738 to Boncyk, et al.
`294 United States Patent 8542906 to Persson, et al.
`295 United States Patent 8523075 to van der Merwe
`296 United States Patent 8831279 to Rodriguez, et al.
`297 United States Patent 8831677 to Villa-Real
`298 United States Patent 7711598 to Perkowski
`299 United States Patent 5870725 to Bellinger
`300 United States Patent Application 2002/0047867 to
`Mault, et al.
`301 United States Patent Application 2002/0047867A1 to
`Mault
`302 United States Patent Publication 2001/0011276 to
`Durst, et al.
`303 United States Patent Publication 2001/0032252 to
`Durst, et al.
`304 United States Patent Publication 2001/0044824 to
`Hunter, et al.
`305 United States Patent Publication 2001/0047426 to
`Hunter
`306 United States Patent Publication 2001/0053252 to
`Creque
`307 United States Patent Publication 2002/0001393A1 to
`Jones
`308 United States Patent Publication 2002/0001398 to
`Shimano, et al.
`309 United States Patent Publication 2002/0006602 to
`Masters
`310 United States Patent Publication 2002/0019819 to
`Sekiguchi, et al.
`
`
`
`9
`
`Country
`
`Issue/
`Publication
`Date
`United States 7/9/2013
`United States 8/17/2010
`United States
`8/22/1995
`United States 8/28/2012
`United States 8/3/2010
`United States 9/10/2013
`United States 9/12/2006
`United States 9/13/2005
`United States 9/16/2014
`United States 9/2/2014
`United States 9/24/2013
`United States 9/3/2013
`United States 9/9/2014
`United States 9/9/2014
`United States 5/2010
`United States
` TBD
`United States 4/25/2002
`
`United States 4/25/2002
`
`United States 8/2/2001
`
`United States 10/18/2001
`
`United States 11/22/2001
`
`United States 11/29/2001
`
`United States 12/2001
`
`United States 1/3/2002
`
`United States 1/3/2002
`
`United States 1/17/2002
`
`United States 2/14/2002
`
`

`

`Case 2:20-cv-07872-GW-PVC Document 298-7 Filed 03/09/24 Page 11 of 29 Page ID
`#:10399
`
`
`
`Additional Prior Art
`
`Country
`
`Issue/
`Publication
`Date
`United States 4/25/2002
`
`311 United States Patent Publication 2002/0048403 to
`Guerreri
`312 United States Patent Publication 2002/0055957 to
`Ohsawa
`313 United States Patent Publication 2002/0084328 to Kim United States 7/4/2002
`
`United States 5/9/2002
`
`314 United States Patent Publication 2002/0089524 to
`Ikeda
`315 United States Patent Publication 2002/0090132 to
`Boncyk, et al.
`316 United States Patent Publication 2002/0102966 to Lev,
`et al.
`317 United States Patent Publication 2002/0124188 to
`Sherman, et al.
`318 United States Patent Publication 2002/0140988 to
`Cheatle
`319 United States Patent Publication 2002/0150298 to
`Rajagopal, et al.
`320 United States Patent Publication 2002/0156866 to
`Schneider
`321 United States Patent Publication 2002/0163521 to
`Ellenbym et al.
`322 United States Patent Publication 2002/0167536 to
`Valdes, et al.
`323 United States Patent Publication 2002/0178112 to
`Goeller, et al.
`324 United States Patent Publication 2002/0187774 to
`Ritter, et al.
`325 United States Patent Publication 2002/0195485 to
`Polerleau, et al.
`326 United States Patent Publication 20020103813 to
`Frigon
`327 United States Patent Publication 2003/0064705 to
`Desiderio
`328 United States Patent Publication 2003/0095681 to
`Burg, et al.
`329 United States Patent Publication 2003/0116478 to
`Laskowski
`
`United States 7/11/2002
`
`United States 7/11/2002
`
`United States 8/1/2002
`
`United States 9/5/2002
`
`United States 10/3/2002
`
`United States 10/17/2002
`
`United States 10/24/2002
`
`United States 11/7/2002
`
`United States 11/14/2002
`
`United States 11/28/2002
`
`United States 12/12/2002
`
`United States 12/26/2002
`
`United States 8/1/2002
`
`United States 4/3/2003
`
`United States 5/22/2003
`
`United States 6/26/2003
`
`
`
`10
`
`

`

`Case 2:20-cv-07872-GW-PVC Document 298-7 Filed 03/09/24 Page 12 of 29 Page ID
`#:10400
`
`
`
`Additional Prior Art
`
`330 United States Patent Publication 2003/0164819 to
`Waibel
`331 United States Patent Publication 20030132974 to
`Bodin
`332 United States Patent Publication 2004/0208372 to
`Boncyk, et al.
`333 United States Patent Publication 2005/0015370 to
`Stavely, et al.
`334 United States Patent Publication 2005/0024501 to
`Ellenby, et al.
`335 United States Patent Publication 2005/0055281 to
`Williams
`336 United States Patent Publication 2005/0102233 to
`Park, et al.
`337 United States Patent Publication 2005/0162523 to
`Darrell, et al.
`338 United States Patent Publication 2005/0162532 to
`Toyoda
`339 United States Patent Publication 2005/0185060 to
`Neven
`340 United States Patent Publication 2005/0206654 to
`Vaha-Sipila
`341 United States Patent Publication 2005/0252966 to
`Kulas
`342 United States Patent Publication 2006/0008124 to
`Ewe, et al.
`343 United States Patent Publication 2006/0038833 to
`Mallinson, et al.
`344 United States Patent Publication 2006/0161379 to
`Ellenby, et al.
`345 United States Patent Publication 2006/0190812 to
`Ellenby, et ao
`346 United States Patent Publication 2006/0223635 to
`Rosenberg
`347 United States Patent Publication 2007/0109619 to
`Eberl, et al.
`348 United States Patent Publication 2007/0146391 to
`Pentenrieder, et al.
`
`
`
`11
`
`Country
`
`Issue/
`Publication
`Date
`United States 9/4/2003
`
`United States 7/17/2004
`
`United States 10/21/2004
`
`United States 1/20/2005
`
`United States 2/3/2005
`
`United States 3/10/2005
`
`United States 5/12/2005
`
`United States 7/28/2005
`
`United States 7/28/2005
`
`United States 8/25/2005
`
`United States 9/22/2005
`
`United States 11/17/2005
`
`United States 1/12/2006
`
`United States 2/23/2006
`
`United States 7/20/2006
`
`United States 8/24/2006
`
`United States 10/5/2006
`
`United States 5/17/2007
`
`United States 6/28/2007
`
`

`

`Case 2:20-cv-07872-GW-PVC Document 298-7 Filed 03/09/24 Page 13 of 29 Page ID
`#:10401
`
`
`
`Additional Prior Art
`
`Country
`
`Issue/
`Publication
`Date
`United States 8/9/2007
`
`349 United States Patent Publication 2007/0182739 to
`Plantonov, et al.
`350 United States Patent Publication 2008/0021953 to Gil United States 1/24/2008
`
`351 United States Patent Publication 2008/0133555 to
`Rhoads, et al.
`352 United States Patent Publication 2008/0157946 to
`Eberl, et al.
`353 United States Patent Publication 2008/0189185 to
`Matsuo, et al.
`354 United States Patent Publication 2008/0207296 to
`Lutnick, et al.
`355 United States Patent Publication 2008/0243721 to Joao United States 10/2/2008
`
`United States 6/5/2008
`
`United States 7/3/2008
`
`United States 8/7/2008
`
`United States 8/28/2008
`
`United States 11/13/2008
`
`356 United States Patent Publication 2008/0279481 to
`Ando
`357 United States Patent Publication 2009/0027337 to
`Hildreth
`358 United States Patent Publication 2009/0030900 to
`Iwasaki
`359 United States Patent Publication 2010/0045933 to
`Eberl, et al.
`360 United States Patent Publication 2010/0106720 to
`Chao, et al.
`361 United States Patent Publication 2010/0188638 to
`Eberl, et al.
`362 United States Patent Publication 2011/0131241 to
`Petrou, et al.
`363 United States Patent Publication 2011/0173100 to
`Boncyk, et al.
`364 United States Patent Publication 2011/0282785 to Chin United States 11/17/2011
`
`United States 1/29/2009
`
`United States 1/29/2009
`
`United States 2/25/2010
`
`United States 4/29/2010
`
`United States 7/29/2010
`
`United States 6/2/2011
`
`United States 7/14/2011
`
`365 United States Patent Publication 2012/0002872 to
`Boncyk, et al.
`366 United States Patent Publication 2012/0011119 to
`Baheti, et al.
`367 United States Patent Publication 2012/0011142 to
`Baheti, et al.
`
`United States 1/5/2012
`
`United States 1/12/2012
`
`United States 1/12/2012
`
`
`
`12
`
`

`

`Case 2:20-cv-07872-GW-PVC Document 298-7 Filed 03/09/24 Page 14 of 29 Page ID
`#:10402
`
`
`
`Additional Prior Art
`
`Country
`
`Issue/
`Publication
`Date
`United States 2/2/2012
`
`United States 3/22/2012
`
`United States 4/19/2012
`
`368 United States Patent Publication 2012/0027290 to
`Baheti, et al.
`369 United States Patent Publication 2012/0072353 to
`Boone, et al.
`370 United States Patent Publication 2012/0095857 to
`McKelvey, et al.
`371 United States Patent Publication 2012/0231887 to Lee,
`et al.
`372 United States Patent Publication 2012/0263388 to
`Vaddadi, et al.
`373 United States Patent Publication 2013/0013414 to Haff United States 1/10/2013
`
`United States 9/13/2012
`
`United States 10/18/2012
`
`374 United States Patent Publication 2013/0046602 to
`Grigg, et al.
`375 United States Patent Publication 2013/0181044A1 to
`Harris
`376 United States Patent Publication 2013/0265450 to
`Barnes
`377 United States Patent Publication 2013/0304609 to
`Keonorasak
`378 United States Patent Publication 2014/0006165 to
`Grigg, et al.
`379 United States Patent Publication 2014/0007012 to
`Govande, et al.
`380 United States Patent Publication 2014/0101048 to
`Gardiner, et al.
`381 United States Patent Publication 2014/0129942 to
`Rathod
`382 United States Patent Publication 2014/0162598 to
`Villa-Real
`383 United States Patent Publication 2015/0026785 to
`Soon-Shiong
`384 WO 1998/47100 to Jones, et al.
`385
`JP 1998091634 to Yuasa
`386
`JP 1998289243 to Yamakita
`387
`JP 2000029932 to Miyazaki
`388
`JP 2000341657 to Ogasawara
`389 Purposefully Blank
`
`
`
`13
`
`United States 2/21/2013
`
`United States 7/18/2013
`
`United States 10/10/2

This document is available on Docket Alarm but you must sign up to view it.


Or .

Accessing this document will incur an additional charge of $.

After purchase, you can access this document again without charge.

Accept $ Charge
throbber

Still Working On It

This document is taking longer than usual to download. This can happen if we need to contact the court directly to obtain the document and their servers are running slowly.

Give it another minute or two to complete, and then try the refresh button.

throbber

A few More Minutes ... Still Working

It can take up to 5 minutes for us to download a document if the court servers are running slowly.

Thank you for your continued patience.

This document could not be displayed.

We could not find this document within its docket. Please go back to the docket page and check the link. If that does not work, go back to the docket and refresh it to pull the newest information.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

You need a Paid Account to view this document. Click here to change your account type.

Your account does not support viewing this document.

Set your membership status to view this document.

With a Docket Alarm membership, you'll get a whole lot more, including:

  • Up-to-date information for this case.
  • Email alerts whenever there is an update.
  • Full text search for other cases.
  • Get email alerts whenever a new case matches your search.

Become a Member

One Moment Please

The filing “” is large (MB) and is being downloaded.

Please refresh this page in a few minutes to see if the filing has been downloaded. The filing will also be emailed to you when the download completes.

Your document is on its way!

If you do not receive the document in five minutes, contact support at support@docketalarm.com.

Sealed Document

We are unable to display this document, it may be under a court ordered seal.

If you have proper credentials to access the file, you may proceed directly to the court's system using your government issued username and password.


Access Government Site

We are redirecting you
to a mobile optimized page.





Document Unreadable or Corrupt

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket

We are unable to display this document.

Refresh this Document
Go to the Docket